betaFeedback

WorksPhysics and Astronomy

Effect of invisible neutrino decay on neutrino oscillation at long baselines

Abstract

In this article, we study the effect of invisible neutrino decay of the third neutrino state for accelerator neutrino experiments at two different baselines, 1300 km with a liquid argon time projection chamber (LArTPC) detector (similar to DUNE) and 2588 km with a water Cherenkov detector (similar to P2O). For such baselines, the matter effect starts to become important. Our aim is to ascertain the sensitivity to mass hierarchy and octant of θ23θ_{23} in these two experiments in the presence of a decaying neutrino state. We compare and contrast the results of the two experimental setups. We find that, in general, hierarchy sensitivity decreases in the presence of decay. However, if we consider decay only in the opposite hierarchy (test scenario), in the 2588 km setup, the hierarchy sensitivity with the true hierarchy as IH is larger than the no decay case. We also study the dependence of hierarchy sensitivity with true θ23θ_{23}. We find that the dominant muon background in P2O plays an important role in how the hierarchy sensitivity depends on θ23θ_{23}. The octant sensitivity for both setups increases in the presence of decay except for the LArTPC setup in case true θ23=49∘θ_{23}=49^\circ. To understand the octant sensitivity results in the two setups, we check the synergy in sensitivity between electron and muon channels as a function of test θ23θ_{23}. We also study the degeneracies in the test θ23−δCPθ_{23}-δ_{CP} plane and find that combined analysis of the two setups removes all the degeneracies in the test θ23−δCPθ_{23}-δ_{CP} plane at 5σ5σ significance.

Prepared for submission to JHEP

Introduction

Neutrino oscillations, which involve the conversion of one neutrino flavor into another, have been detected across various neutrino sources, including the sun, the atmosphere, reactors, and accelerators, utilizing a diverse range of detection techniques in terrestrial experiments[1, 2, 3, 4, 5]. These findings conclusively establish the three-neutrino oscillation paradigm, with a substantial portion of the parameter space governing the phenomenon accurately established. However, there are still open challenges and unanswered questions, namely, the ordering of neutrino masses (mass hierarchy), the exact value (i.e., octant) of the mixing angle θ23\theta_{23}, and the value of the CP phase. Many ongoing, upcoming, and proposed experiments are expected to address these issues. Although neutrino oscillation is established as a leading solution to the solar and atmospheric neutrino anomalies corroborated by reactor and accelerator experiments, imprints of physics beyond the standard model can appear as sub-leading effects. Many studies have been performed to explore a multitude of new physics scenarios. Neutrino decay is one such solution.

Massive neutrinos can decay in general. Neutrino decay was first proposed as a solution to the solar neutrino problem[6, 7] and has since been thoroughly explored in scientific research. Neutrino decay in the Standard Model, whether radiative or non-radiative, is constrained by cosmological observations due to precise measurements of the cosmic microwave background.[8, 9]

In contrast, processes involving neutrino decay in physics beyond the Standard Model (BSM) such as νi→νf+Xf\nu_i \to\nu_f + X_f are much less constrained. Here νi\nu_i denotes the mass states (i=1,2,3i=1,2,3), and νf\nu_f and XfX_f are the final state particles. From a phenomenological perspective, there are two types of neutrino decay: visible decay and invisible decay. In visible decay, the neutrinos in the final state are active and can be detected. This type of decay would result in the observable event rates at the detector being impacted by the decay products, which would have lower energies than the parent particle. A typical signature of visible neutrino decay would be a concentration of events at low energies[10, 11, 12, 13, 14]. In invisible decay, the neutrino in the final state is not observable in the detector. This could occur if the neutrino in the final state is a light sterile neutrino (lighter than the active ones, allowing for the decay kinematically). Another possibility is that the decay product involves an active neutrino, which, due to its low energy, is unobservable. We are interested in discussing the phenomenon of invisible neutrino decay. In this particular scenario, a beam of relativistic neutrinos (νi\nu_i) with a lifetime of τi\tau_i and mass mim_i is subject to depletion as a consequence of invisible decay by a factor of

ξ(L,E)=exp⁡(−αiLE)=exp⁡(−κi)(1)\xi(L,E)=\exp\left(-\alpha_i\frac{L}{E}\right)=\exp(-\kappa_i) \tag*{(1)}

where E is the neutrino energy, L is the distance between the source and the detector and

αi=miτi; κi=αiLE(2)\alpha_i=\frac{m_i}{\tau_i};\ \kappa_i=\alpha_i\frac{L}{E} \tag*{(2)}

is the decay parameter. It is evident that, for a given ratio of L/E, neutrino decay is only sensitive when αi≥L/E\alpha_i \ge L/E, and the no decay limit is αi→0\alpha_i \to0.

Constraints on τi\tau_i have been established using various neutrino sources. Neutrino decay as a possible explanation for the decrease in solar neutrinos has been explored early on[11, 15, 16]. Subsequently, many studies have investigated the combination of neutrino oscillation and decay as a solution to the solar neutrino problem, setting limits on the lifetime of the unstable state[17, 18, 19, 20, 21]. These studies assumed that ν2\nu_2 is the unstable state and derived constraints on τ2\tau_2. The possibility of decay of Dirac/Majorana neutrino to a pseudo scaler has been studied from solar neutrino appearance in [22]. A recent study[23] has established constraints on both τ1\tau_1 and τ2\tau_2 using low-energy solar neutrino data. Additional bounds have been obtained from the observation of SN1987A data [24, 25]. On the other hand, atmospheric neutrinos or long-baseline neutrino data have been used so far to bound the τ3/m3\tau_3/m_3[26, 27, 28, 29, 30, 31, 32]. The combined analysis of Super-Kamiokande data together with long-baseline data from K2K and MINOS provides a lower bound on the decay parameter τ3/m3≥9.3×10−11 s/eV\tau_3/m_3 \ge9.3 \times10^{-11}\ {\rm s/eV} at 99% C.L[33]. Recent analysis[34] of the MINOS (using the full charged-current and neutral-current data sample) and T2K (charged-current data) imply τ3/m3>2.8×10−12 s/eV\tau_3/m_3 > 2.8 \times10^{-12}\ {\rm s/eV} at 90% C.L. bound on τ3/m3≥1.5×10−12 s/eV\tau_3/m_3 \ge1.5 \times10^{-12}\ {\rm s/eV} was obtained from combined analysis of NOν\nuA and T2K data [35]. However, adding MINOS data with T2K and NOν\nuA leads to τ3/m3≥2.4×10−11 s/eV\tau_3/m_3 \ge2.4 \times10^{-11}\ {\rm s/eV} [36] at 90% C.L. for both mass hierarchy.

The decay of ultrahigh energy astrophysical neutrinos has been considered by many authors[37, 38, 39]. The IceCube experiment, as shown in [40], can reach a sensitivity of τ/m>10 s/eV\tau/m > 10\ {\rm s/eV} for both hierarchies for 100 TeV neutrinos coming from a source at a distance of 1 Gpc. Moreover, in [41], the invisible neutrino decay with τ/m>102\tau/m > 10^{2} s/eV has been shown to explain the discrepancy seen in the track and cascade data set of high-energy neutrinos. The implications of invisible neutrino decay for future experiments like JUNO[42], RENO-50[43], DUNE [44], T2HK, and T2HKK [45, 46] have been investigated. In DUNE, the bound of 5.1×10−115.1 \times10^{-11} s/eV is shown to be obtained [47] in 90% C.L. The sensitivity to lifetimes of all neutrino mass states has been discussed in [48] using solar, supernova and DSNB neutrinos in upcoming neutrino observatories.

In this paper, our focus is on investigating invisible neutrino decay of the third neutrino state for long baseline experiments. Toward this goal, we choose two setups: (i) A water Cerenkov detector at a distance of 2588 km from an accelerator beam. This baseline is proposed to be realized by the Protvino to ORCA (P2O) experiment; (ii) A liquid Argon time projection chamber (LArTPC) detector at a distance of 1300 km from a beam source of neutrinos, similar to the upcoming DUNE experimental setup. For these baselines, the matter effect starts becoming important. We include this in our study. Note that the 2588 km baseline of the P2O experiment closely corresponds to the bi-magic baseline of 2540 km [49, 50, 51]. We examine how the bi-magic condition [50], which implies near-independence of the probabilities on δCP\delta_{CP} for a particular hierarchy at specific energies, gets affected in the presence of neutrino decay. Furthermore, we seek to investigate how the three-neutrino oscillation phenomenology is modified in the presence of neutrino decay. Our particular interest lies in understanding the impact of the decay of the third mass state (ν3\nu_{3}) on the determination of both neutrino mass hierarchy and the octant of θ23\theta_{23}. In addition to studying the mass hierarchy, octant of θ23\theta_{23}, the study also probes the degeneracies in θ23−δCP\theta_{23}-\delta_{CP} plane to determine if combining the results from the two baselines can resolve these ambiguities.

The paper is organized as follows. To start with, in section 2, we have discussed the analytical framework for neutrino oscillation in the presence of decay and the oscillation probabilities. Then, in section 3, we study the effects of decay in PμeP_{\mu e}, PμμP_{\mu\mu} in the context of determining mass hierarchy and octant of θ23\theta_{23}. The details of experimental setups have been written in section 4. Next, in section 5, we discuss the results of sensitivity to mass hierarchy and octant of θ23\theta_{23}. Finally, we summarize our findings in section 6.

Neutrino oscillations in the presence of neutrino decay

In the presence of decay of neutrino states, the total Hamiltonian is non-Hermitian due to the contribution of decay,

Hm=Hmstd−i2Γm,(3)\mathcal{H}_{m}=\mathcal{H}_{m}^{std}-\frac{i}{2}\Gamma_{m}, \tag*{(3)}

In the presence of neutrino decay of the third mass state ν3\nu_{3}, the total Hamiltonian of the system is given by,

H=12EU[(0000Δ21000Δ31)+(00000000−iα3)]U†+12E(A00000000),(4)H=\frac{1}{2E}U\left[\begin{pmatrix}0&0&0\\0&\Delta_{21}&0\\0&0&\Delta_{31}\end{pmatrix}+\begin{pmatrix}0&0&0\\0&0&0\\0&0&-i\alpha_{3}\end{pmatrix}\right]U^{\dagger}+\frac{1}{2E}\begin{pmatrix}A&0&0\\0&0&0\\0&0&0\end{pmatrix}, \tag*{(4)}

where UU is the PMNS matrix, Δij=mi2−mj2\Delta_{ij}=m_i^2-m_j^2 are mass-squared differences and A=22GFNeEA=2\sqrt{2}G_F N_e E is the matter potential of neutrino. Because of the non-Hermitian nature of the Hamiltonian, the calculation of the probabilities in the presence of decay in matter is not straightforward. It has been discussed in [52] that in matter, the decay and mass eigenstates are necessarily different, and even if one starts with one decaying state in a vacuum, other states eventually also develop decaying components. Three generation probabilities in the presence of decay have been discussed in [53]. The probability in the presence of decay can be written as [53],

Pμe=s132s232(1+e−4κ3−2e−2κ3+4e−2κ3sin⁡2[(A^−1)Δ])α32+Δ312Δ312(A^−1)2+α32+βs13sin⁡2θ12sin⁡2θ23sin⁡A^ΔA^×[(sin⁡[(A^−1)Δ+δCP−Δ]e−2κ3+sin⁡[A^Δ−δCP])Δ312(A^−1)−α32Δ312(A^−1)2+α32+(cos⁡[A^Δ−δCP]−cos⁡[(A^−1)Δ+δCP−Δ]e−2κ3)Aα3Δ312(A^−1)2+α32].(5)\begin{aligned} P_{\mu e}={}&s_{13}^{2}s_{23}^{2}\left(1+e^{-4\kappa_{3}}-2e^{-2\kappa_{3}}+4e^{-2\kappa_{3}}\sin^{2}\left[(\hat{A}-1)\Delta\right]\right)\frac{\alpha_{3}^{2}+\Delta_{31}^{2}}{\Delta_{31}^{2}(\hat{A}-1)^{2}+\alpha_{3}^{2}}\\ &+\beta s_{13}\sin2\theta_{12}\sin2\theta_{23}\frac{\sin\hat{A}\Delta}{\hat{A}}\times\\ &\left[\left(\sin\left[(\hat{A}-1)\Delta+\delta_{CP}-\Delta\right]e^{-2\kappa_{3}}+\sin\left[\hat{A}\Delta-\delta_{CP}\right]\right)\frac{\Delta_{31}^{2}(\hat{A}-1)-\alpha_{3}^{2}}{\Delta_{31}^{2}(\hat{A}-1)^{2}+\alpha_{3}^{2}}\right.\\ &\left.\quad+\left(\cos\left[\hat{A}\Delta-\delta_{CP}\right]-\cos\left[(\hat{A}-1)\Delta+\delta_{CP}-\Delta\right]e^{-2\kappa_{3}}\right)\frac{A\alpha_{3}}{\Delta_{31}^{2}(\hat{A}-1)^{2}+\alpha_{3}^{2}}\right]. \tag*{(5)} \end{aligned}
Pμμ=1−12sin⁡22θ23[1+2sin⁡2Δe−2κ3−e−2κ3]−s232(1−e−4κ3)−κ3(4s234+sin⁡22θ23cos⁡2Δ)−2A^−1s132sin⁡22θ23(sin⁡Δcos⁡[A^Δ]sin⁡[(A^−1)Δ]A^−A^2Δsin⁡[2Δ])−4s132s232sin⁡2[(A^−1)Δ](A^−1)2+βc122sin⁡22θ23Δsin⁡[2Δ]+κ32(8s234+sin⁡22θ23cos⁡2Δ).(6)\begin{aligned} P_{\mu\mu}={}&1-\frac{1}{2}\sin^{2}2\theta_{23}\left[1+2\sin^{2}\Delta e^{-2\kappa_{3}}-e^{-2\kappa_{3}}\right]-s_{23}^{2}\left(1-e^{-4\kappa_{3}}\right)-\kappa_{3}\left(4s_{23}^{4}+\sin^{2}2\theta_{23}\cos2\Delta\right)\\ &-\frac{2}{\hat{A}-1}s_{13}^{2}\sin^{2}2\theta_{23}\left(\sin\Delta\cos[\hat{A}\Delta]\frac{\sin[(\hat{A}-1)\Delta]}{\hat{A}}-\frac{\hat{A}}{2}\Delta\sin[2\Delta]\right)\\ &-4s_{13}^{2}s_{23}^{2}\frac{\sin^{2}[(\hat{A}-1)\Delta]}{(\hat{A}-1)^{2}}+\beta c_{12}^{2}\sin^{2}2\theta_{23}\Delta\sin[2\Delta]+\kappa_{3}^{2}\left(8s_{23}^{4}+\sin^{2}2\theta_{23}\cos2\Delta\right). \tag*{(6)} \end{aligned}

where A^=A/Δ31\hat{A}=A/\Delta_{31}, β=Δ21/Δ31\beta=\Delta_{21}/\Delta_{31}, and Δ=Δ31L/E\Delta=\Delta_{31}L/E. Now, for the bi-magic baseline, putting sin⁡[(A^−1)Δ]=0\sin[(\hat{A}-1)\Delta]=0 in the above equations will lead to,

PμeBM=s132s232(1+e−4κ3−2e−2κ3)α32+Δ312Δ312(A^−1)2+α32+βs13sin⁡2θ12sin⁡2θ13sin⁡A^ΔA^×[(sin⁡[δCP−Δ]e−2κ3+sin⁡[A^Δ−δCP])Δ312(A^−1)−α32Δ312(A^−1)2+α32+(cos⁡[A^Δ−δCP]−cos⁡[δCP−Δ]e−2κ3)Aα3Δ312(A^−1)2+α32].(7)\begin{aligned} P_{\mu e}^{\mathrm{BM}}={}&s_{13}^{2}s_{23}^{2}\left(1+e^{-4\kappa_{3}}-2e^{-2\kappa_{3}}\right)\frac{\alpha_{3}^{2}+\Delta_{31}^{2}}{\Delta_{31}^{2}(\hat{A}-1)^{2}+\alpha_{3}^{2}}+\beta s_{13}\sin2\theta_{12}\sin2\theta_{13}\frac{\sin\hat{A}\Delta}{\hat{A}}\times\\ &\left[\left(\sin[\delta_{CP}-\Delta]e^{-2\kappa_{3}}+\sin[\hat{A}\Delta-\delta_{CP}]\right)\frac{\Delta_{31}^{2}(\hat{A}-1)-\alpha_{3}^{2}}{\Delta_{31}^{2}(\hat{A}-1)^{2}+\alpha_{3}^{2}}\right.\\ &\left.\quad+\left(\cos[\hat{A}\Delta-\delta_{CP}]-\cos[\delta_{CP}-\Delta]e^{-2\kappa_{3}}\right)\frac{A\alpha_{3}}{\Delta_{31}^{2}(\hat{A}-1)^{2}+\alpha_{3}^{2}}\right]. \tag*{(7)} \end{aligned}
PμμBM=1−12sin⁡22θ23[1+2sin⁡2Δe−2κ3−e−2κ3]−s232(1−e−4κ3)−κ3(4s234+sin⁡22θ23cos⁡2Δ)+A^A^−1s132sin⁡22θ23(Δsin⁡[2Δ])+βc122sin⁡22θ23Δsin⁡[2Δ]+κ32(8s234+sin⁡22θ23cos⁡2Δ).(8)\begin{aligned} P_{\mu\mu}^{\mathrm{BM}}={}&1-\frac{1}{2}\sin^{2}2\theta_{23}\left[1+2\sin^{2}\Delta e^{-2\kappa_{3}}-e^{-2\kappa_{3}}\right]-s_{23}^{2}\left(1-e^{-4\kappa_{3}}\right)-\kappa_{3}\left(4s_{23}^{4}+\sin^{2}2\theta_{23}\cos2\Delta\right)\\ &+\frac{\hat{A}}{\hat{A}-1}s_{13}^{2}\sin^{2}2\theta_{23}\left(\Delta\sin[2\Delta]\right)+\beta c_{12}^{2}\sin^{2}2\theta_{23}\Delta\sin[2\Delta]+\kappa_{3}^{2}\left(8s_{23}^{4}+\sin^{2}2\theta_{23}\cos2\Delta\right). \tag*{(8)} \end{aligned}

To retrieve the no decay limit, we put α3→0\alpha_{3} \to0 in the above equations to get,

PμeSM=4s132s232sin⁡2[(A^−1)Δ](A^−1)2+2βs13sin⁡2θ12sin⁡2θ23cos⁡[Δ−δCP]sin⁡A^ΔA^sin⁡[(A^−1)Δ](A^−1)(9)P_{\mu e}^{\mathrm{SM}} = 4s_{13}^{2}s_{23}^{2}\frac{\sin^{2}[(\hat{A}-1)\Delta]}{(\hat{A}-1)^{2}} + 2\beta s_{13}\sin2\theta_{12}\sin2\theta_{23}\cos[\Delta-\delta_{\mathrm{CP}}]\frac{\sin\hat{A}\Delta}{\hat{A}}\frac{\sin[(\hat{A}-1)\Delta]}{(\hat{A}-1)} \tag*{(9)}
PμμSM=1−sin⁡22θ23sin⁡2Δ+A^A^−1s132sin⁡22θ23Δsin⁡[2Δ]−4s132s232sin⁡2[(A^−1)Δ](A^−1)2−2A^−1s132sin⁡22θ23sin⁡Δcos⁡[A^Δ]sin⁡[(A^−1)Δ]A^+βc122sin⁡22θ23Δsin⁡[2Δ](10)\begin{aligned} P_{\mu\mu}^{\mathrm{SM}} ={}& 1-\sin^{2}2\theta_{23}\sin^{2}\Delta+\frac{\hat{A}}{\hat{A}-1}s_{13}^{2}\sin^{2}2\theta_{23}\Delta\sin[2\Delta]-4s_{13}^{2}s_{23}^{2}\frac{\sin^{2}[(\hat{A}-1)\Delta]}{(\hat{A}-1)^{2}}\\ &-\frac{2}{\hat{A}-1}s_{13}^{2}\sin^{2}2\theta_{23}\sin\Delta\cos[\hat{A}\Delta]\frac{\sin[(\hat{A}-1)\Delta]}{\hat{A}}+\beta c_{12}^{2}\sin^{2}2\theta_{23}\Delta\sin[2\Delta] \tag*{(10)} \end{aligned}

Probability level Analysis

In this section, we present the probabilities PμeP_{\mu e} (top panel) and PμμP_{\mu\mu} (bottom panel) for both the baselines of 2588 km (left) and 1300 km (right) in Figure 1. The red (NH) and blue (IH) colored solid shaded bands correspond to decay, while the hatched area is for no decay. The width of these curves is due to the variation of δCP\delta_{\mathrm{CP}} in the range −180∘:180∘-180^\circ:180^\circ.

Image not extracted

Figure 1. PμeP_{\mu e} (top) and PμμP_{\mu\mu} (bottom) as a function of energy EE at 2588 km (left) and 1300 km (right) without decay (hatched band) and with decay (solid band) for NH (red) and IH (blue).

The separation between NH and IH probability bands can give an idea about the hierarchy sensitivity. We observe the following points from these figures

  • The shaded probability bands for different hierarchies are lower in the presence of decay than the standard scenario with no decay. Comparing the dominant first terms in eq. (5) and eq. (9), the e−2κ3e^{-2\kappa_3} term leads to the lowering of PμeP_{\mu e} in the presence of decay. Similarly, PμμP_{\mu\mu} is affected due to the presence of e−2κ3e^{-2\kappa_3} in the second term in eq. (6) relative to eq. (10).

  • In the appearance channel, decay affects NH more than IH as the shift in bands of NH is greater than that of the bands of IH. This can lead to lower hierarchy sensitivity in the presence of decay.

  • The width of the bands is narrower in the disappearance channel than the appearance channel as there is no dependence on δCP\delta_{CP} in leading terms as seen from eq. (6), but higher order terms show δCP\delta_{CP} dependence [54]. The probability bands in the disappearance channel get lower when decay is present. However, there is no noticeable change in separation between the NH and IH bands near maxima in the decay case as compared to no decay. This can be understood more clearly from the insets in the lower panels.

  • Near the minima of appearance probability curves, there are points where δCP\delta_{CP} dependence vanishes in the standard scenario. However, the inclusion of decay introduces dependence to δCP\delta_{CP} in these energies, e.g., 2 GeV, 3.5 GeV at 2588 km baseline, as can be seen from the inset of the plots in the upper panel. Thus, decay induces a slight dependence on δCP\delta_{CP} at the energies corresponding to the bimagic condition for 2588 km. Similar signatures can also be observed in 1300 km at 1.1 GeV and 1.5 GeV. The broadening of bands at minima can be explained by the dependence of the second term in eq. (7) on δCP\delta_{CP} only in the presence of decay.

Now, we discuss the change in the appearance and disappearance probabilities for different values of θ23\theta_{23} for two different setups. In figure 2, the probability curves are depicted for no decay (red) and with decay using α3=2×10−11\alpha_3 = 2 \times10^{-11} s/eV (red) with different values of θ23=41∘\theta_{23} = 41^\circ(solid), 45∘45^\circ(dotted), 49∘49^\circ(dashed) while considering both NH and IH. We also show an enlarged view of the first oscillation maximum of PμμP_{\mu\mu} in the bottom panel. We can infer the following from the above plots:

  • Both decay and θ23\theta_{23} can lower the probability amplitude near oscillation maxima. Thus, the effect of decay can mimic the effect of a lower θ23\theta_{23} and no decay near oscillation maxima.

  • In the appearance channel (PμeP_{\mu e}), the differences between probabilities corresponding to different θ23\theta_{23} are almost similar for decay and no decay scenarios near maxima.

  • In the disappearance channel (PμμP_{\mu\mu}), the blue curves (decay) for different values of θ23\theta_{23} are more dispersed than the red curves in no decay case. This effect is relevant near

Image not extracted

Figure 2. PμeP_{\mu e} (first row), PμμP_{\mu\mu} (second row) as a function of energy for γ3=2×10−11\gamma_3 = 2 \times10^{-11} s/eV (blue), no decay (red) in 2588 km (left) and 1300 km (right) baseline for NH. The solid, dotted, and dashed lines refer to values of θ23\theta_{23} of 41∘41^\circ (LO), 45∘45^\circ, and 49∘49^\circ (HO).

both the first and second maxima of PμμP_{\mu\mu}. This indicates that including decay may lead to higher octant sensitivity with a bigger contribution coming from PμμP_{\mu\mu}.

Experiment and Simulation details

To facilitate the simulation of the neutrino beams in LArTPC and P2O setups at 1300 km and 2588 km, we have employed the GLoBES [55] software package. We have described two different experimental setups used for this analysis below.

A water Cherenkov detector configuration (2588 km)

The Protvino accelerator facility, situated in the Moscow region, Russia, can be utilized as a robust platform for conducting extensive experimental research in the realm of neutrino physics. At its core is the U-70 synchrotron, with a circumference of 1.5 km, capable of accelerating protons up to 70 GeV and delivering a substantial annual proton-on-target (POT) yield of 4×10204 \times10^{20}. This proton beam serves as the foundation for generating a neutrino beam with a power of 90 kW [56].

The directed neutrino beam can be aimed at the ORCA detector, a component of the KM3NeT collaboration, strategically positioned 2588 km away from the Protvino accelerator facility. The ORCA detector, with a fiducial target mass of 4 Mton, is assumed to be operating in an environment characterized by an average matter density of 3.4 g/cc.

The experiment is envisioned to span three years each in the neutrino and antineutrino modes, leading to a total exposure of 2160 MW.Kton.yr. The energy resolution is modeled as a Gaussian distribution with a width of 30%. This setup enables an exploration of neutrino oscillation phenomena in the presence of matter effects. The rules representing different (anti)neutrino channels along with the corresponding signal and background coefficients are listed in Table 1.

RuleSignal CoefficientBackground Coefficients
νe\nu_e Appearance0.9ντ\nu_\tau Appearance: 0.78; νμ\nu_\mu Disappearance: 0.45; Neutrino Beam: 0.9; Neutrino Misidentification: 0.2; Neutral-Current Background: 0.9
νμ\nu_\mu Disappearance0.7ντ\nu_\tau Appearance: 0.22; Neutral-Current Background: 0.18; νe\nu_e Appearance: 0.15
νˉe\bar{\nu}_e Appearance0.9ντ\nu_\tau Appearance: 0.78; νμ\nu_\mu Disappearance: 0.45; Antineutrino Beam: 0.9; Antineutrino Misidentification: 0.2; Neutral-Current Background: 0.9
νˉμ\bar{\nu}_\mu Disappearance0.7Neutral-Current Background: 0.18; ντ\nu_\tau Appearance: 0.22; νe\nu_e Appearance: 0.15

Table 1. Signal and Background coefficient for different rules in GLoBES file for P2O.

A liquid Argon detector setup (1300 km)

The experimental setup under consideration consists of a megawatt-scale muon neutrino beam source, a near detector (ND), and a far detector(FD). The ND will be placed close to the beam’s source, while the FD, comprising a 40 Kton LArTPC detector, will be placed at a distance of 1300 km away from the neutrino source. In our study, we have considered events from FD only. The large LArTPC at an underground observatory can also observe atmospheric neutrinos. The proposed DUNE experiment has a similar experimental configuration[57]. In this analysis, a beam-power of 1.2 MW leading to a total exposure of 1×10211 \times10^{21} POT/yr has been implemented for the numerical analysis. The energy resolutions, efficiency, and systematic errors are taken as per the .glb file in [57]. We assume the experiment will run for five years each in the neutrino and antineutrino modes, corresponding to a total exposure of 480 MW.Kton.yr. We have considered a constant matter density of 2.85 g/cc. The various background channels for different rules have been mentioned in Table 2, and each of these backgrounds is listed in files as a function of energy.

RuleBackground Channels
νe\nu_e Appearanceνe\nu_e, νˉe\bar{\nu}_e, νμ\nu_\mu, νˉμ\bar{\nu}_\mu, ντ\nu_\tau, νˉτ\bar{\nu}_\tau, ν\nu NC, νˉ\bar{\nu} NC
νμ\nu_\mu Disappearanceντ\nu_\tau, νˉτ\bar{\nu}_\tau, ν\nu NC, νˉ\bar{\nu} NC
νˉe\bar{\nu}_e Appearanceνe\nu_e, νˉe\bar{\nu}_e, νμ\nu_\mu, νˉμ\bar{\nu}_\mu, ντ\nu_\tau, νˉτ\bar{\nu}_\tau, ν\nu NC, νˉ\bar{\nu} NC
νˉμ\bar{\nu}_\mu Disappearanceντ\nu_\tau, νˉτ\bar{\nu}_\tau, ν\nu NC, νˉ\bar{\nu} NC

Table 2. Background channels for different GLoBES rules in LArTPC detector.

The table 3 provides a summary of the true and test values of various oscillation parameters used in the simulation. The true and test values of θ12\theta_{12} and θ13\theta_{13} are fixed at 33.4∘33.4^\circ and 8.42∘8.42^\circ respectively along with Δ21\Delta_{21} at 7.53×10−57.53 \times10^{-5} eV2^2. In this analysis, both the true and test values of δCP\delta_{CP} have been varied in a range from −180∘-180^\circ to 180∘180^\circ with a step size of 15∘15^\circ. The exploration of α3−1\alpha_3^{-1} extends from 1.0×10−111.0 \times10^{-11} s/eV to 3.0×10−113.0 \times10^{-11} s/eV, with the true value set at 2.0×10−112.0 \times10^{-11} s/eV. For hierarchy sensitivity, the sign of Δ31\Delta_{31} is reversed, whereas, for octant sensitivity analyses, the test value is varied in the opposite octant in the range as specified in Table 3 for a true value of θ23\theta_{23}.

ParametersTrue valuesTest values
θ12\theta_{12}33.4∘33.4^\circ33.4∘33.4^\circ
θ13\theta_{13}8.42∘8.42^\circ8.42∘8.42^\circ
θ23\theta_{23} (Hierarchy)41∘41^\circ, 45∘45^\circ, 49∘49^\circ39∘:51∘39^\circ: 51^\circ
θ23\theta_{23} (Octant)41∘41^\circ (49∘49^\circ)45∘:51∘45^\circ: 51^\circ (39∘:45∘39^\circ: 45^\circ)
δCP\delta_{CP}−180∘:180∘-180^\circ: 180^\circ−180∘:180∘-180^\circ: 180^\circ
δCP\delta_{CP} (CP discovery)−90∘-90^\circ, 0∘0^\circ, 90∘90^\circ−180∘-180^\circ, 0∘0^\circ, 180∘180^\circ
Δ21\Delta_{21}7.53×10−57.53 \times10^{-5} eV2^27.53×10−57.53 \times10^{-5} eV2^2
Δ31\Delta_{31} (Hierarchy)±2.45×10−3\pm2.45 \times10^{-3} eV2^2∓[2.35:2.6]×10−3\mp[2.35 : 2.6] \times10^{-3} eV2^2
Δ31\Delta_{31} (Octant)±2.45×10−3\pm2.45 \times10^{-3} eV2^2±[2.35:2.6]×10−3\pm[2.35 : 2.6] \times10^{-3} eV2^2
α3−1\alpha_3^{-1}2.0×10−112.0 \times10^{-11} s/eV[1.0:3.0]×10−11[1.0 : 3.0] \times10^{-11} s/eV

Table 3. True and test values of oscillation parameters.

Results

In this section, we evaluate the sensitivity of the two above-mentioned experiments regarding the determination of the mass hierarchy, the octant of θ23\theta_{23}, and CP violation within scenarios involving potential invisible decay of the ν3\nu_3 state. Initially, we examine the ability of these experiments to detect such decay by assessing its sensitivity under the assumption of no decay.

Decay sensitivity of the two experimental setups

First, we have evaluated the sensitivity of the detectors to decay. The simulated true data is generated assuming no decay scenario, while decay is introduced in the test. All the oscillation parameters are kept fixed in true and test as in table 3 while θ23=45∘\theta_{23}=45^\circ, δCP=0∘\delta_{\mathrm{CP}}=0^\circ. Our findings indicate that a 3σ3\sigma sensitivity level can be achieved at a decay rate of approximately 2.9×10−112.9 \times10^{-11} s/eV (3.3×10−113.3 \times10^{-11} s/eV) and a 5σ5\sigma sensitivity level at around 1.7×10−111.7 \times10^{-11} s/eV (1.9×10−111.9 \times10^{-11} s/eV) for LArTPC (P2O) setup Sensitivity for NH and IH, as given by red and blue curves, are almost identical.

Image not extracted

Figure 3. Sensitivity of LArTPC (left), P2O (right) setups to detect decay as a function of decay parameter α3−1=τ3/m3\alpha_3^{-1}=\tau_3/m_3 in test for θ23=45∘\theta_{23}=45^\circ, δCP=0∘\delta_{\mathrm{CP}}=0^\circ for NH (red) and IH (blue).

Mass Hierarchy Sensitivity

In the figure 4, the sensitivity to the mass hierarchy has been depicted considering θ23=41∘\theta_{23}=41^\circ (left), 45∘45^\circ (middle) and 49∘49^\circ (right) for true hierarchy taken as normal (top) and inverted (bottom). The green curve shows the mass hierarchy sensitivity for a standard scenario without decay. We consider two different decay scenarios: the blue curve shows the same in the presence of decay in both the true and test, while the orange curve shows sensitivity in the presence of decay only in the test, i.e., in the opposite hierarchy. The observations from the plots in figure 4, are as follows,

  • In the presence of decay (decay is considered in true and test), there is a decrease in hierarchy sensitivity for both NH and IH compared to the standard scenario. However, when decay is considered only in the test, for true IH, the hierarchy sensitivity is more than the no decay case. This is because the decay affects NH more as seen in the probability plots in figure 1.

  • If we compare the plots in the first row for NH, hierarchy sensitivity is seen to rise with the true value of θ23\theta_{23} for all the cases. But, while considering IH as the true hierarchy, the highest sensitivity is observed for the maximal value of θ23=45∘\theta_{23}=45^\circ.

Image not extracted

Figure 4. Sensitivity to mass hierarchy as a function of true δCP\delta_{\mathrm{CP}} for true values of θ23=41∘\theta_{23}=41^\circ (top), 45∘45^\circ (middle), 49∘49^\circ (bottom) considering α3−1=2.0×10−11\alpha_3^{-1}=2.0\times10^{-11} s/eV at 2588 km for NH (top), IH (bottom). The green curves correspond to the standard without decay scenario. The blue and orange curves are for decay present in both true and test, and only in the test, respectively.

In figure 5, the sensitivity to mass hierarchy as a function of δCP\delta_{\mathrm{CP}} is depicted for the LArTPC detector setup for true values of θ23=41∘\theta_{23}=41^\circ (left), 45∘45^\circ (middle) and 49∘49^\circ (right). In this case, δCP\delta_{\mathrm{CP}} affects the sensitivity to mass hierarchy more than it does in the case of P2O. The variation of sensitivity is around 10σ10\sigma between the maxima and minima of the plots in LArTPC compared to around 4σ4\sigma variation in P2O. The sensitivity with decay (blue curves) in true and test cases is lowest, while the w/o decay scenario and Decay[Test] scenarios have higher sensitivity. The sensitivity for all three scenarios increases with θ23\theta_{23}, i.e., from the left panel to the right panel in NH. In the case of IH, the sensitivity is higher for θ23=45∘\theta_{23}=45^\circ than 41∘41^\circ but is similar for 45∘45^\circ and 49∘49^\circ. We probe further into dependence on true value of θ23\theta_{23} in figures 6,7.

Image not extracted

Figure 5. Sensitivity to mass hierarchy as a function of true δCP\delta_{\mathrm{CP}} for true values of θ23=41∘\theta_{23}=41^\circ (top), 45∘45^\circ (middle), 49∘49^\circ (bottom) considering α3−1=2.0×10−11\alpha_3^{-1}=2.0\times10^{-11} s/eV at 1300 km for NH (top), IH (bottom). The green curves correspond to the standard without decay scenario. The blue and orange curves are for decay present in both true and test, and only in the test, respectively.

In Figure 6, the sensitivity to MH in the presence of decay (dashed) in both true and test along with standard no decay scenario (solid) are plotted as a function of the true value of θ23\theta_{23} with the red (blue) curves corresponding to sensitivity for the true hierarchy of NH (IH) at P2O (top) and LArTPC (bottom) setups. We see that both with and without decay scenarios, the sensitivity gradually increases with θ23\theta_{23} for NH, whereas, for IH, the sensitivity falls on both sides of some θ23\theta_{23} value for P2O and remains almost constant for θ23=(44∘,48∘)\theta_{23} = (44^\circ, 48^\circ) for LArTPC setup. To understand this behavior, we have plotted the sensitivity from νe\nu_e (νμ\nu_\mu) channels in second (third) column in Figure 6. The sensitivity of νe\nu_e channel for P2O is mostly similar to total sensitivity in IH, but in NH, sensitivity at first decreases till θ23=42∘\theta_{23} = 42^\circ and then increases slowly. The contribution from νμ\nu_\mu channel is similar in both NH and IH, with a sudden decrease at first and then slightly rising before further decreasing with θ23\theta_{23}. In the case of the LArTPC detector, sensitivity from the νe\nu_e channel rises linearly with θ23\theta_{23} in both NH and IH. However, the sensitivity in the νμ\nu_\mu channel shows an oscillatory nature for NH, while in IH, the sensitivity attains a minima around θ23=45∘\theta_{23} = 45^\circ.

Image not extracted

Figure 6. Sensitivity to mass hierarchy as a function of θ23\theta_{23} for without decay scenario (solid) and with decay (dotted) in 2588 km (top) and 1300 km (bottom) for NH (red), IH (blue).

To inspect this different kind of behavior of sensitivity for IH, we have further plotted the contribution from electron and muon channels in Figure 7 without background (b/g) contributions mentioned in Table 1, 2 and no marginalization in the test scenario. We see from Figure 7 that without the b/g contributions, in the electron channel, the sensitivity increases with θ23\theta_{23} that can be explained by the leading term in PμeP_{\mu e} varies with sin⁡2θ23\sin^{2}\theta_{23} in eq. (5). While, in the muon channel, the sensitivity decreases with θ23\theta_{23} after initially increasing, and this nature can be understood from the leading terms in PμμP_{\mu\mu} in eq. (6) depending on sin⁡22θ23\sin^{2}2\theta_{23}. It shows that the muon background present in the electron channel is the reason why the sensitivity in IH is only rising till θ23∼46∘\theta_{23} \sim46^{\circ} and then decreasing in 2588 km and is constant for θ23=[44∘,48∘]\theta_{23} = [44^{\circ}, 48^{\circ}] in 1300 km. This background effect is also present in the true NH scenario; however, in that case, sensitivity w/o background in the electron channel is smaller compared to the muon background.

Image not extracted

Figure 7. Sensitivity to mass hierarchy as a function of θ23\theta_{23} for the electron (left) and muon (right) channels without background and marginalization at 2588 km (top) and 1300 km (bottom).

Octant Sensitivity

In this section, we discuss the results of octant sensitivity in the presence of invisible decay.

In Figure 8 and 9, the octant sensitivity with and without decay scenarios have been shown as a function of true δCP\delta_{\rm CP} for true θ23=41∘\theta_{23}=41^\circ (left), 49∘49^\circ (right) for NH (top) and IH (bottom) for the detector setups at 2588 km and 1300 km respectively. We present two scenarios: one where decay is present in the true and test scenario (blue dashed), and in another case, the decay is absent in both true and test, i.e., the standard scenario (green solid). In all the cases, the marginalization has been done in θ23\theta_{23} in opposite octant, ∣Δ31∣\lvert\Delta_{31}\rvert, δCP\delta_{\rm CP} and α3\alpha_3 (in the presence of decay). The main observed features are;

Image not extracted

Figure 8. Sensitivity to octant of θ23\theta_{23} as a function of true δCP\delta_{\mathrm{CP}} considering true θ23=41∘\theta_{23} = 41^{\circ} (left), 49∘49^{\circ} (right) for without decay (green) and with decay (blue) considering true α3−1=2.0×10−11\alpha_{3}^{-1} = 2.0 \times10^{-11} s/eV for NH (top) and IH (bottom) at 2588 km baseline.

  • For 2588 km (Figure 8), in the presence of decay (blue), the sensitivity is higher than that of the standard no decay scenarios (green). The increase in sensitivity is higher for θ23\theta_{23} in LO (41∘41^\circ) as compared to HO (49∘49^\circ).

  • In the case of 1300 km (Figure 9), the octant sensitivity in the presence of decay (blue) is lower for θ23true\theta_{23}^{true} in HO and higher for θ23true\theta_{23}^{true} in LO relative to the no-decay scenario.

Image not extracted

Figure 9. Sensitivity to octant of θ23\theta_{23} as a function of true δCP\delta_{\rm CP} considering true θ23=41∘\theta_{23}=41^\circ (left), 49∘49^\circ (right) for without decay (green) and with decay (blue) considering true α3−1=2.0×10−11\alpha_3^{-1}=2.0\times10^{-11} s/eV for NH (top) and IH (bottom) at 1300 km baseline.

Since the synergy between electron and muon channel is the main contributor in enhancing the octant sensitivity, in order to understand the nature of curves in Figure 8, Figure 9, we have plotted the contributions from these two channels along with total sensitivity in the test θ23\theta_{23} plane in Figure 10 for 2588 km (top) and 1300 km (bottom). In Figure 10, the sensitivity without decay and with decay is shown by solid and dashed curves, respectively. For the PμeP_{\mu e} channel (c.f. eq. (9),(5)), the leading contribution goes as sin⁡2θ23\sin^2\theta_{23}, and the chi-square in the opposite octant increases with θ23\theta_{23} as can be seen from the bottom-left panel in Figure 10 for the LArTPC setup. However, for the P2O setup (c.f. the top-left panel), due to the presence of 45% muon background (c.f. Table 1), the nature of the chi-square curve in the electron channel gets modified, and it’s not a monotonic function of sin⁡2θ23\sin^2\theta_{23} any longer. For the muon channel (c.f. eq. (10),(6)), the leading term in the probability proportional to sin⁡22θ23\sin^2 2\theta_{23} doesn’t offer octant sensitivity. However, due to the matter effect at large baselines like 1300 km and 2588 km, the contribution from the term proportional to sin⁡2θ23\sin^2\theta_{23} becomes significant, and some octant sensitivity comes from this channel as well. The position of the minima of the total sensitivity curve is governed mainly by the PμμP_{\mu\mu} channel, but there is an octant sensitive contribution coming from PμeP_{\mu e} channel, enhancing

Figure 10. Octant sensitivity as a function of test θ23\theta_{23} showing contribution from νe\nu_e (orange) and νμ\nu_\mu (green) and total (blue) events for θ23\theta_{23} in LO (left) and HO (right) in 2588 km (top) and 1300 km (bottom). The solid (dashed) curves signify no decay (decay) scenarios.

the chi-square. Since the chi-square from PμeP_{\mu e} channel at P2O is flatter, this octant sensitive contribution is less, and thus, the overall sensitivity is more for the DUNE-like setup, as can be seen from Figure 10. In addition, from the top-left panel, it is seen that in the presence of decay, the minima of the total chi-square shifts from 49.5∘49.5^\circ to 50.5∘50.5^\circ where the value of chi-square is higher in both νμ,νe\nu_\mu,\nu_e channels as compared to the no decay case, leading to an elevated total sensitivity. Similarly, from the top-right panel (θ23true\theta_{23}^{\mathrm{true}} in HO), the minima of the total sensitivity shifts from 42.5∘42.5^\circ to 44∘44^\circ, where the contribution of νμ\nu_\mu is similar but νe\nu_e is slightly more than no decay scenario, leading to a smaller increase in total sensitivity. In the case of 1300 km also, we can see enhanced sensitivity due to the synergy between νe\nu_e and νμ\nu_\mu channels for both decay and no decay scenarios. For θ23\theta_{23} in LO (the bottom-left panel), in the presence of decay, the minima of νμ\nu_\mu channel shifts to larger θ23\theta_{23} with the value of chi-square higher than that of no decay, resulting in enhanced total sensitivity. However, in 1300 km for HO (the bottom-right panel), it is observed in the presence of decay that minima of the combined sensitivity shifts to a higher θ23\theta_{23} (towards 45∘45^\circ) driven by the νμ\nu_\mu channel. For such values, the contribution from the νe\nu_e channel is lower, resulting in a reduced total sensitivity as compared to the no decay case.

Sensitivity in θ23−δCP\theta_{23} - \delta_{CP} Plane

In this section, we explore the degenerate solutions in the presence of decay in the test θ23−δCP\theta_{23} - \delta_{CP} plane for fixed mass hierarchy in the case of the LArTPC detector (DUNE-like) and the water Cherenkov detector (P2O) as well the combination of these setups. In Figure 11 and Figure 12, we have plotted regions of [3σ3\sigma, 5σ5\sigma] sensitivity in θ23−δCP\theta_{23} - \delta_{CP} plane for no-decay (decay) scenarios by shaded contours (contour lines) in P2O [dark red and light red], DUNE-like [blue and cyan] setup and the combined analysis [dark green and light green] of these two setups, respectively. We considered different combinations of true values in the case of both NH (first and second rows) and IH (third and fourth rows) as the true hierarchy. In case of decay, the true value of α3−1\alpha_3^{-1} is 2×10−112 \times10^{-11} s/eV and marginalization is over [1:3]×10−11[1 : 3] \times10^{-11} s/eV. The main observations from Figure 11, Figure 12 are as follows,

Figure 11. Sensitivity in the test θ23\theta_{23}–δCP\delta_{CP} plane for true values of θ23=41∘,49∘\theta_{23}=41^\circ,49^\circ, and δCP=−90∘,0∘,90∘\delta_{CP}=-90^\circ,0^\circ,90^\circ for both normal and inverse hierarchy. The shaded contours are for the decay case, and the contours encompassed by curves are for the no-decay case. The dark red and light red correspond to 3σ,5σ3\sigma,5\sigma contours in P2O, while blue and cyan stand for 3σ,5σ3\sigma,5\sigma contours in LArTPC.

Figure 12. Sensitivity in the test θ23\theta_{23} − δCP\delta_{CP} plane for true values of θ23=41∘,49∘\theta_{23}=41^\circ,49^\circ, and δCP=−90∘,0∘,90∘\delta_{CP}=-90^\circ,0^\circ,90^\circ for both normal and inverse hierarchy. The shaded contours are for the decay case, and the contours encompassed by curves are for the no-decay case. The dark green and light green correspond to 3σ3\sigma, 5σ5\sigma contours in the combined analysis of P2O+LArTPC setups.

  • The allowed contours are larger for P2O, signifying a lower sensitivity in θ23\theta_{23} and δCP\delta_{CP} than the DUNE-like setup for both decay and no-decay cases.

  • Comparing the decay and no-decay scenarios, for P2O, allowed regions in θ23\theta_{23} are seen to be more restrictive in the presence of decay. This is consistent with the earlier observation that octant sensitivity is enhanced in the presence of decay in P2O. This also leads to the removal of wrong octant solutions at 3σ3\sigma in some cases, e.g., θ23=49∘\theta_{23} = 49^\circ, δCP=0∘\delta_{CP} = 0^\circ, and θ23=41∘\theta_{23} = 41^\circ, δCP=−90∘\delta_{CP} = -90^\circ.

  • For the DUNE-like setup, the allowed regions are almost identical for decay and no-decay cases at 3σ3\sigma, and there are no wrong octant solutions. However, at 5σ5\sigma, the sensitivity of θ23\theta_{23} decreases for θ23=49∘\theta_{23} = 49^\circ in the presence of decay, and in some cases, the regions extend to opposite octant.

  • The wrong octant and wrong δCP\delta_{CP} solutions are removed with combined analysis as seen from light green contours in Figure 12 even at 5σ5\sigma in decay and no-decay scenarios.

  • The CP sensitivity is more for LArTPC setup as compared to P2O. Moreover, in the case of P2O, the sensitivity for IH is less than that of NH. For P2O, the red-dashed regions cover the entire parameter space of δCP\delta_{CP} in most of the panels in Figure 12, signifying no sensitivity to δCP\delta_{CP} at 5σ5\sigma. But for a combined analysis of the two setups, the wrong δCP\delta_{CP} solutions are excluded even at 5σ5\sigma significance.

Conclusions

In this work, we have studied the effects of invisible decay of the third neutrino state on the determination of mass hierarchy and octant of θ23\theta_{23} in the context of two different long baseline experimental setups: a LArTPC setup (similar to DUNE) at 1300 km and a water Cherenkov setup (proposed by P2O) at 2588 km. For mass hierarchy sensitivity, we explored two scenarios in the presence of decay: (i) decay in both true and test cases and (ii) no decay in true and decay in the test case for the opposite hierarchy. We find that the mass hierarchy sensitivity is reduced in the first case compared to the no-decay scenario in both setups. However, the sensitivity increases in the second case compared to the first case. In the water Cherenkov setup, the mass hierarchy sensitivity is seen to be increasing steadily with θ23\theta_{23} for true NH but peaks at θ23∼46∘\theta_{23} \sim46^\circ for true IH. This nature of sensitivity is due to a higher muon background of 45% in P2O in the electron channel. We also noticed the mass hierarchy sensitivity to be flat between θ23=44∘−46∘\theta_{23} = 44^\circ- 46^\circ for true IH in the LArTPC setup in 1300 km, which can be attributed to the presence of muon backgrounds.

In the study of the sensitivity to octant of θ23\theta_{23}, we have only considered the presence of decay (in both true and test) and compared it with the no-decay scenario. It is observed that in the presence of decay, the sensitivity is increased for both the setups for true values of θ23\theta_{23} in LO due to enhanced contribution from the νμ\nu_\mu channel. For θ23\theta_{23} in HO, we see reduced sensitivity in the P2O setup as compared to θ23\theta_{23} in LO but still higher than the no-decay scenario. In the LArTPC setup, the sensitivity in presence decay for θ23\theta_{23} in HO is lower than the no decay. These features are explained by the synergy between electron and muon channels.

We also explore the degeneracies present in the test θ23−δCP\theta_{23} - \delta_{CP} plane for various combinations of true values in the presence of decay in both true and test and compare with the no decay scenario. In the P2O setup, the wrong octant solutions exist at 3σ3\sigma (for certain combinations of true values) and 5σ5\sigma in no-decay scenarios. However, the inclusion of decay elevates the octant sensitivity, resulting in the removal or reduction of wrong octant solutions. The 3σ3\sigma contours of DUNE-like setups are similar for the decay and no-decay cases, and there is no wrong octant solution in 3σ3\sigma. In the case of a DUNE-like setup, the sensitivity is lower in the presence of decay for θ23\theta_{23} in HO, leading to enlarged contours extending to opposite octant at 5σ5\sigma. When we do the combined analysis of these setups, the wrong solutions disappear even at 5σ5\sigma.

Acknowledgments

AC acknowledges the Ramanujan Fellowship (RJF/2021/000157), of the Science and Engineering Research Board of the Department of Science and Technology, Government of India, and CERN EP-Nu group. SG acknowledges the J.C. Bose Fellowship (JCB/2020/000011) of the Science and Engineering Research Board of the Department of Science and Technology, Government of India. It is to be noted that this work has been done solely by the authors and is not representative of the DUNE collaboration. SP appreciates the guidance of Dr. Monojit Ghosh regarding the writing of the glb file for the P2O experiment.

References

  1. [1]Arthur B. McDonald. Nobel Lecture: The Sudbury Neutrino Observatory: Observation of flavor change for solar neutrinos. Rev. Mod. Phys., 88(3):030502, 2016.DOI
  2. [2]Takaaki Kajita. Nobel Lecture: Discovery of atmospheric neutrino oscillations. Rev. Mod. Phys., 88(3):030501, 2016.DOI
  3. [3]K. Abe et al. The T2K Experiment. Nucl. Instrum. Meth. A, 659:106–135, 2011.
  4. [4]P. Adamson et al. Measurement of Neutrino Oscillations with the MINOS Detectors in the NuMI Beam. Phys. Rev. Lett., 101:131802, 2008.pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/18851439
  5. [5]Xinheng Guo et al. A Precision measurement of the neutrino mixing angle θ₁₃ using reactor antineutrinos at Daya-Bay. 1 2007.
  6. [6]John N. Bahcall, N. Cabibbo, and A. Yahil. Are neutrinos stable particles? Phys. Rev. Lett., 28:316–318, 1972.
  7. [7]S. Pakvasa and K. Tennakone. Neutrinos of Non-zero Rest Mass. Phys. Rev. Lett., 28:1415, 1972.
  8. [8]Alessandro Mirizzi, Daniele Montanino, and Pasquale D. Serpico. Revisiting cosmological bounds on radiative neutrino lifetime. Phys. Rev. D, 76:053007, 2007.DOI
  9. [9]Kaustubh Agashe, Roberto Franceschini, and Doojin Kim. Using Energy Peaks to Measure New Particle Masses. JHEP, 11:059, 2014.DOI
  10. [10]C. W. Kim and W. P. Lam. Some remarks on neutrino decay via a Nambu-Goldstone boson. Mod. Phys. Lett. A, 5:297–299, 1990.DOI
  11. [11]Andy Acker, Anjan Joshipura, and Sandip Pakvasa. A Neutrino decay model, solar anti-neutrinos and atmospheric neutrinos. Phys. Lett. B, 285:371–375, 1992.
  12. [12]Manfred Lindner, Tommy Ohlsson, and Walter Winter. A Combined treatment of neutrino decay and neutrino oscillations. Nucl. Phys. B, 607:326–354, 2001.
  13. [13]Pilar Coloma and Orlando L. G. Peres. Visible neutrino decay at DUNE. 5 2017.arxiv.org/abs/1705.03599
  14. [14]Alberto M. Gago, Ricardo A. Gomes, Abner L. G. Gomes, Joel Jones-Perez, and Orlando L. G. Peres. Visible neutrino decay in the light of appearance and disappearance long baseline experiments. JHEP, 11:022, 2017.DOI
  15. [15]Z. G. Berezhiani, G. Fiorentini, M. Moretti, and Anna Rossi. Fast neutrino decay and solar neutrino detectors. Z. Phys. C, 54:581–586, 1992.DOI
  16. [16]Zurab G. Berezhiani, Mauro Moretti, and Anna Rossi. Matter induced neutrino decay and solar anti-neutrinos. Z. Phys. C, 58:423–428, 1993.
  17. [17]Sandhya Choubey, Srubabati Goswami, and Debasish Majumdar. Status of the neutrino decay solution to the solar neutrino problem. Phys. Lett. B, 484:73–78, 2000.DOI
  18. [18]John F. Beacom and Nicole F. Bell. Do Solar Neutrinos Decay? Phys. Rev. D, 65:113009, 2002.DOI
  19. [19]Anjan S. Joshipura, Eduard Masso, and Subhendra Mohanty. Constraints on decay plus oscillation solutions of the solar neutrino problem. Phys. Rev. D, 66:113008, 2002.DOI
  20. [20]Abhijit Bandyopadhyay, Sandhya Choubey, and Srubabati Goswami. Neutrino decay confronts the SNO data. Phys. Lett. B, 555:33–42, 2003.
  21. [21]R. Picoreti, M. M. Guzzo, P. C. de Holanda, and O. L. G. Peres. Neutrino Decay and Solar Neutrino Seasonal Effect. Phys. Lett. B, 761:70–73, 2016.
  22. [22]Lena Funcke, Georg Raffelt, and Edoardo Vitagliano. Distinguishing Dirac and Majorana neutrinos by their decays via Nambu-Goldstone bosons in the gravitational-anomaly model of neutrino masses. Phys. Rev. D, 101(1):015025, 2020.DOI
  23. [23]Jeffrey M. Berryman, Andre de Gouvea, and Daniel Hernandez. Solar Neutrinos and the Decaying Neutrino Hypothesis. Phys. Rev. D, 92(7):073003, 2015.DOI
  24. [24]Joshua A. Frieman, Howard E. Haber, and Katherine Freese. Neutrino Mixing, Decays and Supernova Sn1987a. Phys. Lett. B, 200:115–121, 1988.
  25. [25]R. M. Bionta et al. Observation of a Neutrino Burst in Coincidence with Supernova SN 1987A in the Large Magellanic Cloud. Phys. Rev. Lett., 58:1494, 1987.
  26. [26]J. M. LoSecco. What the atmospheric neutrino anomaly is not. 9 1998.DOI
  27. [27]Vernon D. Barger, J. G. Learned, S. Pakvasa, and Thomas J. Weiler. Neutrino decay as an explanation of atmospheric neutrino observations. Phys. Rev. Lett., 82:2640–2643, 1999.DOI
  28. [28]Paolo Lipari and Maurizio Lusignoli. On exotic solutions of the atmospheric neutrino problem. Phys. Rev. D, 60:013003, 1999.DOI
  29. [29]Gian Luigi Fogli, E. Lisi, A. Marrone, and G. Scioscia. Super-Kamiokande data and atmospheric neutrino decay. Phys. Rev. D, 59:117303, 1999.
  30. [30]Sandhya Choubey and Srubabati Goswami. Is neutrino decay really ruled out as a solution to the atmospheric neutrino problem from Super-Kamiokande data? Astropart. Phys., 14:67–78, 2000.
  31. [31]Vernon D. Barger, J. G. Learned, P. Lipari, Maurizio Lusignoli, S. Pakvasa, and Thomas J. Weiler. Neutrino decay and atmospheric neutrinos. Phys. Lett. B, 462:109–114, 1999.
  32. [32]Y. Ashie et al. Evidence for an oscillatory signature in atmospheric neutrino oscillation. Phys. Rev. Lett., 93:101801, 2004.
  33. [33]M. C. Gonzalez-Garcia and M. Maltoni. Status of Oscillation plus Decay of Atmospheric and Long-Baseline Neutrinos. Phys. Lett. B, 663:405–409, 2008.
  34. [34]R. A. Gomes, A. L. G. Gomes, and O. L. G. Peres. Constraints on neutrino decay lifetime using long-baseline charged and neutral current data. Phys. Lett. B, 740:345–352, 2015.DOI
  35. [35]Sandhya Choubey, Debajyoti Dutta, and Diptyaman Pramanik. Invisible neutrino decay in the light of NOvA and T2K data. JHEP, 08:141, 2018.DOI
  36. [36]Christoph A. Termes and Giulia Pagliaroli. Invisible neutrino decay at long-baseline neutrino oscillation experiments. Phys. Rev. D, 109(7):L071701, 2024.
  37. [37]John F. Beacom, Nicole F. Bell, Dan Hooper, Sandip Pakvasa, and Thomas J. Weiler. Decay of High-Energy Astrophysical Neutrinos. Phys. Rev. Lett., 90:181301, 2003.pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/12785996
  38. [38]Michele Maltoni and Walter Winter. Testing neutrino oscillations plus decay with neutrino telescopes. JHEP, 07:064, 2008.
  39. [39]Sandip Pakvasa, Anjan Joshipura, and Subhendra Mohanty. Explanation for the low flux of high energy astrophysical muon-neutrinos. Phys. Rev. Lett., 110:171802, 2013.
  40. [40]G. Pagliaroli, A. Palladino, F. L. Villante, and F. Vissani. Testing nonradiative neutrino decay scenarios with IceCube data. Phys. Rev. D, 92(11):113008, 2015.DOI
  41. [41]Peter B. Denton and Irene Tamborra. Invisible Neutrino Decay Could Resolve IceCube’s Track and Cascade Tension. Phys. Rev. Lett., 121(12):121802, 2018.DOI
  42. [42]Miao He. Jiangmen Underground Neutrino Observatory. Nucl. Part. Phys. Proc., 265-266:111–113, 2015.arxiv.org/abs/1412.4195
  43. [43]Soo-Bong Kim. New results from RENO and prospects with RENO-50. Nucl. Part. Phys. Proc., 265-266:93–98, 2015.arxiv.org/abs/1412.2199
  44. [44]R. Acciarri et al. Long-Baseline Neutrino Facility (LBNF) and Deep Underground Neutrino Experiment (DUNE): Conceptual Design Report, Volume 2: The Physics Program for DUNE at LBNF. 12 2015.arxiv.org/abs/1512.06148
  45. [45]K. Abe et al. Hyper-Kamiokande Design Report. 2 2016.
  46. [46]K. Abe et al. Physics potentials with the second Hyper-Kamiokande detector in Korea. PTEP, 2018(6):063C01, 2018.
  47. [47]Anish Ghoshal, Alessio Giarnetti, and Davide Meloni. Neutrino Invisible Decay at DUNE: a multi-channel analysis. J. Phys. G, 48(5):055004, 2021.DOI
  48. [48]Pablo Martínez-Miravé, Irene Tamborra, and Mariam Tórtola. The Sun and core-collapse supernovae are leading probes of the neutrino lifetime. JCAP, 05:002, 2024.
  49. [49]Sushant K. Raut, Ravi Shanker Singh, and S. Uma Sankar. Magical properties of 2540 Km baseline Superbeam Experiment. Phys. Lett. B, 696:227–231, 2011.DOI
  50. [50]Amol Dighe, Srubabati Goswami, and Shamayita Ray. 2540 km: Bimagic baseline for neutrino oscillation parameters. Phys. Rev. Lett., 105:261802, 2010.
  51. [51]Amol Dighe, Srubabati Goswami, and Shamayita Ray. Optimization of the baseline and the parent muon energy for a low energy neutrino factory. Phys. Rev. D, 86:073001, 2012.DOI
  52. [52]Dibya S. Chattopadhyay, Kaustav Chakraborty, Amol Dighe, Srubabati Goswami, and S. M. Lakshmi. Neutrino Propagation When Mass Eigenstates and Decay Eigenstates Mismatch. Phys. Rev. Lett., 129(1):011802, 2022.DOI
  53. [53]Dibya S. Chattopadhyay, Kaustav Chakraborty, Amol Dighe, and Srubabati Goswami. Analytic treatment of 3-flavor neutrino oscillation and decay in matter. JHEP, 01:051, 2023.DOI
  54. [54]Jesper Grönroos, Tommy Ohlsson, and Sampsa Vihonen. Revisiting series expansions of neutrino oscillation and decay probabilities in matter. 1 2024.DOI
  55. [55]Patrick Huber, M. Lindner, and W. Winter. Simulation of long-baseline neutrino oscillation experiments with GLoBES (General Long Baseline Experiment Simulator). Comput. Phys. Commun., 167:195, 2005.
  56. [56]Sandhya Choubey, Monojit Ghosh, and Dipyaman Pramanik. Sensitivity study of Protvino to ORCA (P2O) experiment: effect of antineutrino run, background and systematics. Eur. Phys. J. C, 79(7):603, 2019.DOI
  57. [57]T. Alion et al. Experiment Simulation Configurations Used in DUNE CDR. 6 2016.arxiv.org/abs/1606.09550

Paper details

vlnc:W_jq34awsg
Version
v1 · latest
Published
Fresh — added to the Hub within the last 30 days
Added
License
CC BY 4.0
Usage

views · 0

downloads · 0

A view counts once per browser per day, a download each time the PDF is requested.

  • Physics and Astronomy

Not recorded for this paper

View statement
Looking for related papers…
Contents