WorksPhysics and Astronomy
Electromagnetically driven flow in unsupported electrolyte layers: lubrication theory and linear stability of annular flow
Abstract
We consider a thin horizontal layer of a non-magnetic electrolyte containing a bulk solution of salt and carrying an electric current. The layer is bounded by two deformable free surfaces loaded with an insoluble surfactant and is placed in a vertical magnetic field. The arising Lorentz force drives the electrolyte in the plane of the layer. We employ the long-wave approximation to derive general two-dimensional hydrodynamic equations describing symmetric pinching-type deformations of the free surfaces. These equations are used to study the azimuthal flow in an annular film spanning the gap between two coaxial cylindrical electrodes. In weakly deformed films, the base azimuthal flow and its linear stability with respect to azimuthally invariant perturbations are studied analytically. For relatively thick layers and weak magnetic fields, the leading mode with the smallest decay rate is found to correspond to a monotonic azimuthal velocity perturbation. The Marangoni effect leads to further stabilisation of the flow while perturbations of the solute concentration in the bulk of the fluid have no influence on the flow stability. In strongly deformed films in the diffusion-dominated regime, the azimuthal flow becomes linearly unstable with respect to an oscillatory mixed mode characterised by the combination of radial and azimuthal velocity perturbations when the voltage applied between electrodes exceeds the critical value.
Introduction
Electromagnetically driven flows in shallow layers and channels of electrically conducting fluids in the presence of deformable interfaces attracted much attention due to their importance in plasma physics [14, 26] and various microfluidic applications including contactless manipulation of flow in magnetohydrodynamic networks [2], liquid channels embedded into carrier fluids [12], droplet microfluidics [43] and electromagnetic stirring [41] [1].
The comprehensive theoretical description of magnetohydrodynamic (MHD) flows of magnetic fluid films in arbitrary strong magnetic fields is technically challenging as the hydrodynamic equations must be coupled with Maxwell’s equations in the presence of deformable moving boundaries. However, in the case of non-magnetic electrically conducting fluids, the description can be greatly simplified. For this class of fluids, which comprises electrolyte solutions and liquid metals with weak magnetic properties, the additional stresses that typically appear at the interfaces due to externally applied magnetic fields can be neglected. For relatively weak magnetic fields of the order of , which can be created using conventional permanent magnets, the magnetic Reynolds number associated with the flow of fluid with the magnetic diffusivity in the domain of a characteristic size with velocity , is typically small, . In this regime, the magnetic field induced by the electric current flowing through the fluid can be neglected compared to the external field [36]. With this simplification, the MHD equations have been successfully applied to study flows of electrolytic solutions and non-magnetic liquid metals such as mercury in various geometries. These include liquid metal layers confined between two parallel insulating walls [47] and in thin horizontal films [46] and electrolyte solutions in annular channels [15, 28, 29, 39, 48].
Geometric parameters of the system such as the depth and the aspect ration of the layer have been shown to have the major influence on the flow characteristics. In shallow horizontal layers of electrolyte solutions with a depth of several millimetres and a small depth-to-width aspect ratio placed between two coaxial vertical electrodes the flow was found to be essentially three-dimensional even for relatively weak currents [15, 28, 39, 48]. The quasi-two-dimensional approximation, developed in [15, 39] by using the depth-averaging method, could capture some of the main features of the base azimuthal flow but was shown to be inadequate when describing toroidal flows that lead to the formation of the experimentally observable free-surface vortices [48].
As the depth of a horizontal layer and the aspect ratio of the system are further decreased, the vertical component of the flow velocity is impeded by the boundaries and the horizontal component of the flow becomes dominant. The two-dimensional nature of the flow in very thin liquid layers was used to study two-dimensional turbulence as pioneered around four decades ago by [6, 7] in experiments with soap films that were mechanically stirred by the array of rods to produce turbulent flow. At around the same time [46] studied effectively two-dimensional flows in thin mercury films with a free upper surface and supported from below by an array of conducting electrodes. Instead of a mechanical stirring, a contactless electromagnetic Lorentz forcing was used to drive the flow in the presence of highly non-uniform magnetic fields. Later, similar contactless electromagnetic forcing was used to gain a deeper understanding of the scaling properties of the velocity correlation function in turbulent regimes [3, 27, 50]. A comprehensive review of two-dimensional turbulence can be found in [24 e.g.].
Historically, electromagnetic driving was extensively used in supported liquid layers, but not in unsupported systems such as soap films. This, perhaps, was due to the intrinsic instability of soap-type films and the difficulty of controlling their curvature. In fact, to the best of our knowledge, the first attempt to use Lorentz force in unsupported free films was made almost 20 years after [6, 7] pioneered the film turbulence studies. It used a soap film containing chloride salt spanning a region between two parallel conducting electrodes placed above an array of permanent magnets [42]. The main advantage of using an unsupported film when studying two-dimensional turbulence is the elimination of energy leakage at the no-slip bottom of the container. In a recent experimental study [9] investigated the flow dynamics in an electromagnetically forced film in the case of a localised source of electric current. A series of experiments with soap films spanning the gap between two coaxial electrodes placed in an external magnetic field is currently underway [10].
The theoretical description and modelling of electromagnetically driven flows in supported films with a free interface are now well developed [16, 17, 19, 20, 26, 31, 32, 33, 34, 35] and continue to attract attention mainly due to applications in plasma flows and tokamaks. In the absence of the Lorentz force, the pure hydrodynamic description of the flow in unsupported liquid films was initiated in [40, 45] and later received a huge boost because of its relevance to nonlinear film rupture and two-dimensional turbulence problems [5, 8, 13, 18, 44, 49, 51] as reviewed in [24, 37]. In unsupported thin viscous films, the hydrodynamic equations are simplified using two main assumptions. Firstly, the long-wave approximation is applied by taking into account large-scale flow patterns and film deformations the wavelength of which is much larger than the average film thickness. Secondly, deformations of the free interfaces are assumed to be mirror-symmetric with respect to the centre plane of the layer, which corresponds to a varicose-type pinching deformation mode. Under these assumptions, the effective two-dimensional dynamic equations were derived at the leading order of the lubrication approximation for curved soap films in the presence of a surfactant [21, 30] and for horizontally stretched free films in the presence of solute and surfactant [4]. So far, the application of the lubrication approximation to describe MHD flows in unsupported free films of electrolyte solutions in external magnetic fields has not been reported.
Here we build upon earlier theoretical studies [4, 21, 30] to derive the leading order dynamic equations for an electromagnetically driven two-dimensional flow in a thin free horizontal layer of electrolyte solution the free surfaces of which are loaded with an insoluble surfactant. The flow is driven by the Lorentz force generated by the electric current flowing through the electrolyte in the presence of a homogeneous external magnetic field normal to the layer. We show that at the leading order of the lubrication approximation the product of the current density and the local thickness of the layer is divergence-free reflecting the condition of no accumulation of electric charge in the bulk. The complete set of the derived dynamic equations is written in an invariant vector form suitable for applications in arbitrary geometries. It consists of the dynamic equation for the two-dimensional flow field depending on the solute concentration in the bulk, surfactant concentration, symmetric film deformations and the electric potential. As an example, we apply the derived equations to study the azimuthal flow and its linear stability in annular free films spanning the gap between two coaxial conducting electrodes.
The paper is organised as follows. In section we present the derivation of the leading order equations in the lubrication approximation using the systematic expansion technique suggested earlier in [4, 13]. The derived equations correctly reflect the conservation of the total mass of the surfactant and solute as well as the continuity of electric current under the condition of no accumulation of the electric charge in the fluid. In section we rewrite the derived equations in polar coordinates to study the flow in annular free films. In section we study the linear stability of the annular azimuthally invariant steady-state with respect to perturbations that depend only on the radial coordinate. We present analytical results for the linear stability of a flat film and vanishingly small flow velocities first. Subsequently, we use the numerical continuation method [11, 25] to study the stability of a strongly deformed layer. The obtained theoretical and computational results are summarised in section .
Lubrication theory of electrically conducting free films in an external magnetic field
Consider a horizontal free film of an electrolyte solution, which can be created by supporting the weight of the film by the pressure difference between the regions below and above the film. Following [4, 13] we exclude film bending and only consider symmetric pinching-type surface deformation modes with each surface being a mirror image of the other at all times as schematically shown in Figure 1(a). Here, and are the coordinates in the horizontal plane, is a vertical coordinate and is time. The local thickness of the film is and the average film thickness is

Figure 1. (a) Symmetric deformation mode in a horizontal free liquid film with two deformable surfaces located at . The flow field is mirror symmetric with respect to the centre-plane . (b–e) The top view of the system: four possible topological configurations of a free film spanning space between two electrodes (1, 2). The surface of each electrode represents a no-slip equipotential boundary impenetrable for surfactant and electrolyte solution.
where denotes the area of the centre plane . Each surface of the film is loaded with an insoluble surfactant with local concentration . The addition of surfactants is particularly important in soap films that contain fatty acid carboxylates, which are typically found at the surface. The electrolyte solution is composed of a solvent fluid (typically pure water) and dissociated salt molecules with bulk concentration . In what follows we assume that salt is completely soluble and does not form a molecular surface layer. Two electrodes are immersed in the fluid so that the electric current can flow between them through the film when external voltage is applied. One may consider at least four possible topological configurations of a free film spanning space between two electrodes as shown in Figure 1(b–Figure 1e). The surface of the electrodes is assumed to be chemically inert and impenetrable to the surfactant and the solute in the film. In addition, the flow field vanishes at .
The electrical conductivity of the electrolyte solution generally depends on . The solution density and dynamic viscosity (kinematic viscosity ) are assumed to be constant and independent of . The externally applied magnetic field is assumed to be significantly stronger than that induced by the motion of the fluid. In what follows we neglect gravity effects anticipating that hydrostatic pressure in a sub-micrometre thin free film is negligible as compared to the Laplace pressure. The motion of the incompressible fluid with three-dimensional velocity is described by the continuity and Navier-Stokes equations with the added Lorentz force term [36]
where is the pressure in the fluid and represents the disjoining pressure due to intermolecular forces that become important when the film thickness is approximately 100 nm or less [22, 38]. Because of the symmetry of the pinching mode, the horizontal flow velocity components and the vertical velocity component should be even and odd function of , respectively.
The current density is related to the electric potential via Ohm’s law
For electrolyte solutions, we assume linear dependence between conductivity and
where is an empirical constant specific to a particular salt and solvent. Under the condition of no accumulation of electric charge in the bulk, the electric potential is found from
which must be solved instantaneously for any given velocity field . Additionally, the current continuity condition 6 must be supplemented with the boundary conditions for that correspond to the equipotential surfaces of the conducting electrodes.
Note that for a magnetic field orthogonal to the layer , and . The normal component of the electric current vanishes at the film surfaces. Thus, at we require
where is the unit normal vector to the upper film surface directed away from the fluid.
At , the kinematic boundary condition applies
where is the horizontal gradient. Note that 8 can also be written in the equivalent form as .
To describe the dynamics of surfactant and the concentration of salt in the bulk of the fluid, we follow [23]. The bulk concentration is described by the advection-diffusion equation
where is the bulk diffusion coefficient, is the advective flux and is the diffusive flux.
The advection-diffusion equation for the surfactant concentration at the upper film surface is given by
where is the surface diffusivity of the surfactant and is the surface gradient.
At the diffusive flux normal to the film surface must vanish
It can be shown that 11 supplemented with the condition that the flow velocity and the normal diffusive fluxes of surfactant and solute vanish at the surface of the electrodes leads to the conservation of the total mass of the solute and the surfactant.
Next, we consider the balance of the normal and tangential forces at the upper surface
where is the viscous stress tensor, is the local mean curvature of the surface defined as , is the local surface tension, is the tensor product and the superscript denotes transposed quantities. In what follows we assume that the liquid is non-magnetic and the applied magnetic field is relatively weak so that the Maxwell component in the stress tensor can be completely neglected.
The gradient of the surface tension along the interface is induced by the distribution of the surfactant according to the soluto-Marangoni effect
where is the reference surface tension in the absence of a surfactant and is assumed to be constant. The balance of forces at the lower surface is automatically achieved for symmetric deformation modes.
The horizontal length scale of the flow in submicrometre thin films is several orders of magnitude larger than the average film thickness . The long-wave approximation theory of one-dimensional free films in the absence of a surfactant and an electric current has been developed some thirty years ago [13] using systematic expansion of the Navier-Stokes equations for small lubrication parameter . Subsequently, the theory was generalised to describe two-dimensional flat and curved free films loaded with soluble and insoluble surfactant agents [4, 21, 30]. Here we extend earlier results to derive the leading-order equations for long-wave symmetric deformations of a free electrically conducting film placed in an external magnetic field.
We scale horizontal coordinates with and the vertical coordinate and the local interface deflection with . The horizontal fluid velocity is scaled with some reference velocity , the vertical velocity with , time with and the pressure and the disjoining pressure with . The magnetic field is non-dimensionalised using some reference value while the scaling for the electric potential is . The bulk salt and the surface surfactant concentrations are scaled using arbitrary reference concentrations and , respectively, so that the conductivity is scaled with . The dimensionless bulk equations 2, 3, 6 and 9 then become
where we used the same notations for the dimensionless quantities and introduced the Reynolds (), Hartmann (), Peclet (), and Schmidt () numbers
From equation (12), the dimensionless normal and the tangential balances of stresses at are given by
with the capillary () and Marangoni () numbers defined as
The scaled boundary condition for the electric current 7, the kinematic condition 8, the surfactant equation 10 and 11 multiply by are given by
Crucial for further analysis is to determine the order of magnitude of all dimensionless parameters appropriate for the physical regime of interest. Following [4] we assume that for free liquid films the inertial effects play an essential role implying that . The leading contribution to pressure in the fluid is anticipated to come from the Laplace pressure, which implies that . Note that, for example, for slipper bearing flows and liquid films on a solid substrate, the capillary number scales as [37]. We assume that the Marangoni effect is weak so that at the leading order the film surfaces can be considered stress-free [4]. This can be achieved by setting . An additional assumption must be made regarding the strength of the magnetic field and the induced electric current. Here we consider weakly conducting electrolytes in weak magnetic fields and assume that the Lorentz force is of the same order of magnitude as the viscous force in the absence of vertical shear, i.e. . This implies that .
All fields in equations (14)–(28) are then expanded into a series in powers of , e.g. with , and the leading zero-order equations are derived by following the procedure outlined in [13] and [4]. At the zeroth order, the equations for , , , , , and are identical to those derived in [4] as the Lorentz force enters the equations only at the next order. Therefore, , and are independent of and .
At the leading order, from equations (18) and (19) we obtain for the electric potential and the bulk concentration
Since at , from (25) and (28) we conclude that both and are independent of .
The surfactant concentration satisfies the two-dimensional advection-diffusion equation
where is the leading order horizontal velocity. The kinematic equation 26 together with yield the evolution equation for the local film deformation
At the next order, the Navier-Stokes equations for the horizontal flow contain the Lorentz force terms
where the electric potential satisfies the equation
The boundary condition for at the film surface obtained from equation (25) is
Equation (34) shows that is a quadratic function of
Since for symmetric deformations the potential must be an even function of , we set and determine from the boundary condition 35 to obtain
Finally, substituting 37 into 34 we obtain
Multiplying equation 38 by and introducing the current we rewrite equation 38 in an invariant vector form
(39) represents the continuity equation for the electric current per unit length of the cross-section of the film.
Next, we eliminate and from equations 33 by taking into account the boundary conditions for the tangential and normal components of the stress tensor at . Because the electromagnetic component of the viscous stress tensor is neglected here, the result of the elimination procedure is identical to that of [4]. Consequently, we arrive at the leading-order dynamic equation for including the Lorentz force
where we replaced the vector with and introduced an additional flow field
that can be associated with the so-called extensional Trouton viscosity.
To close the system of leading order dynamic equations we derive the equation for the bulk concentration . At the leading order, from 29 we see that is independent of . At the next order, from 19 we obtain
The boundary condition at following from 28 reads
For a symmetric mode and according to 42 the field is a quadratic function of :
Applying 43 we write
Substituting 44 into 42 we obtain
Multiplying 45 by and using the kinematic condition 31 we arrive at
Equation 46 is identical to the transport equation for the solute concentration obtained at the leading order of the lubrication approximation after averaging over the film cross-section that was derived in [23]. It generalises the leading order equation for the bulk concentration derived in [4] to the case of large film deformations.
We summarise our results by writing the complete set of dimensional governing equations using physical variables and parameters
where we introduced function and dropped subscript 0. Note that equations 47 are written in a compact vector form, which is invariant with respect to the choice of a coordinate system. This is especially important in applications with non-rectangular geometry as exemplified in the next section.
Azimuthal flow in an annular free film between two coaxial cylinders
Electromagnetically driven flows of electrolytes in annular bounded by cylindrical vertical electrodes and a solid bottom have been extensively studied experimentally and theoretically [28, 39, 48 e.g.] It was found that the steady azimuthal flow may become unstable giving rise to free-surface vortices developing close to the outer cylindrical wall. The steady flow field has a three-dimensional toroidal structure while the deformation of the upper free surface is negligible.
However, in thin liquid layers the film deformation can no longer be neglected as has demonstrated in [51] using a mechanically driven flow in an unsupported soap film spanning the gap between two thin coaxial discs. If the outer disc is fixed and the inner one is rotated, the fluid is set in motion in an azimuthal direction similar to a Couette cell flow. Centrifugal forces push the liquid towards the outer disc making the film thinner near the inner disc. Rather unexpectedly, the flow was found to be laminar and the onset of turbulence was not observed even at the linear rotation speed of up to 3 .
Inspired by these experiments, we consider an electromagnetically driven flow in an unsupported free film between two conducting coaxial cylindrical electrodes with radii and and placed in a vertical uniform magnetic field as schematically shown in Figure 2. The potential difference between the inner and outer electrodes is .

Figure 2. The top (left) and side (right) views of the radial cross-section of an annular free film of electrically conducting fluid spanning the gap between two coaxial cylindrical electrodes with radii and . The film is placed in a vertical uniform magnetic field . Electric current flowing through the film between the two electrodes generates Lorentz force that drives the flow azimuthally.
In what follows we scale the radial coordinate with , the film thickness with its average value and choose the flow velocity scale in such a way that in 20, that is . With used as the magnetic field scaling, the Hartmann number becomes , where is the average solute concentration in the bulk. The electric potential is scaled with , the pressure with and all other dimensionless parameters , , , and are obtained from 20 by setting . The dimensionless inner and outer radii are given by and , respectively, where . The concentration of a surfactant is scaled using the average value . Using the same symbols for non-dimensionless fields, we convert the invariant form of equations 47 to polar coordinates and obtain
with
The dynamic equations for the salt and surfactant concentrations and the kinematic condition are given by
The system is completed by the continuity equation for the electric current
System of equations 49–55 admits a steady solution that corresponds to the azimuthal flow field , induced by axisymmetric electric potential in a film with axisymmetric profile containing uniformly dissolved salt with constant bulk concentration and covered by a uniformly distributed surfactant with surface concentration . The functions , and are found from
where primes denote the radial derivative .
Equation 58 is integrated once to yield
where constant is linked to the potential difference between the electrodes via
The term in equation 59 represents the radial current density
The total steady current through the vertical cylindrical section of the film at any radial location is independent of the radius of a cross-section and is given by .
Eliminating from equation 57 we obtain two coupled equations for and
Fluid velocity vanishes at the surface of the electrodes leading to .
The boundary condition for the film deformation must be compatible with the long-wave approximation used here, which only takes into account relatively small film slopes .
In what follows we assume .
We are looking for a solution of the boundary value problems 62 and 63 that corresponds to a given average film half-thickness
and satisfies additional integral condition 60 for any given value of the applied voltage .
For reference, we derive the approximate analytic solution that corresponds to the flow in a flat undeformed film. By setting and neglecting the centrifugal acceleration we find from equations (63) and (60)
where , and .
To find non-trivial solutions of the boundary value problem 62, 63 with the integral condition 64 we use a numerical continuation package AUTO [11, 25]. The trivial solution and that exists for is used as a starting point for numerical continuation with being gradually increased.
In the absence of the disjoining pressure, that is for , the boundary value problem 62, 63 has an important scaling property. Namely, it contains three dimensionless parameters, , and , but only one of them, , depends explicitly on the dimensional layer thickness via . This implies that for any fixed and there exists a universal branch of solutions parameterised by . A solution that corresponds to an arbitrary value of the average film half-thickness and an arbitrary applied voltage is found on the universal branch for .
Taking into account the above scaling property we consider a free film with an arbitrary average half-thickness spanning the gap between cylindrical electrodes with radii and (). As an example we chose fluid properties and magnetic field strength similar to those used in [39, 48]: , , , . Additionally, we use for the surface tension coefficient. These correspond to . As the solution measure we take the maximum flow velocity and the minimum film thickness attained at the inner cylinder (). The numerically obtained maximum velocity is shown in Figure 3(a) by the solid line while the value found from the flat-film approximation 65 is depicted by the dashed line. The minimum film thickness is shown in the log-log scale in Figure 3(b) indicating that asymptotically approaches zero as a power law function .
Figure 3. (a) Maximum fluid velocity in a free annular film as a function of the applied voltage for and . The dashed and solid lines correspond to the flat film approximation 65 and the numerical solution, respectively. (b) Minimum film thickness at the inner cylinder as a function of the applied voltage. The dashed line depicts the power law function . (c) Film thickness for the values of at points 1 and 2 labelled in panel (a). (d) Velocity for solutions at points 1 and 2 in panel (a) (solid lines) and corresponding to the flow in the flat-film approximation 65 (dashed lines).
This implies that the solution exists for any fixed value of no matter how large it is. However, the film thickness becomes vanishingly small at the inner electrode indicating that the film is likely to rapture there. The film profile and the flow velocity at points 1 and 2 are shown in Figure 3(c) and Figure 3(d), respectively. The dashed line in Figure 3(d) corresponds to the approximate solution 65.
Linear stability of the azimuthal flow
In this section, we study the linear stability of the base azimuthal flow in a free film with the half-thickness in the absence of the disjoining pressure . It is anticipated that the least stable perturbations are azimuthally invariant due to the stabilising effect of the surface tension. Indeed, any perturbation that varies azimuthally must be periodic in and, consequently, be proportional to , . Therefore, the magnitude of the stabilising surface tension terms in equation (49) increases as and is the smallest for .
Equations (49)–(55) are linearised about the base flow by writing
where is the perturbation growth rate, is the steady film profile and the tilded variables represent small-amplitude perturbations, substituting these in the equations and neglecting the products of perturbations. After dropping the tildas we obtain
The flow velocity vanishes at and so that there. This leads to the automatic conservation of the total volume of the fluid
Additionally, we require , which with the help of 69 and conditions and translates into two boundary conditions for the radial velocity
Integrating the equation for the perturbation of the electric potential 72 once we obtain
where is some constant. Integrating 75 and imposing the condition we find
Multiplying equations (67) and (68) by , using equations (69) and (75) to eliminate and and, subsequently, differentiating 70 and 71 with respect to the radius we arrive at a nonlinear eigenvalue problem
that must be solved in conjunction with the integral condition 76. The set of boundary conditions 74 and must be extended with
which accounts for the chemically passive impenetrable boundaries of the two electrodes. Note that unlike 62 and 63 the eigenvalue problem 79 contains the average film thickness as a part of the capillary number .
Linear stability of a flat film with no applied voltage
In this section, we consider the stability of a flat film in the absence of an electric current. With , and the eigenvalue problem 77–79 and the integral condition 76 reduce to three decoupled eigenvalue problems: one for the azimuthal velocity perturbations , one for the radial velocity and surfactant perturbations and one for the perturbation of the solute concentration :
where .
The eigenvalue problem 81–84 can be solved analytically in terms of the auxiliary eigenvalue problem for the operator
which coincides with Bessel’s differential equation. The solution of 85 that satisfies the Dirichlet boundary conditions exists only for real positive and is given by
where and are arbitrary constants and and are the Bessel functions of order one of the first and second kind, respectively. Applying the boundary conditions we obtain the solvability condition for constants and that determines the entire spectrum of discrete eigenvalues
It follows from equations (85)–(87) that the spectrum of eigenvalues of the bulk solute concentration perturbations 84 is real and negative
and the corresponding eigenfunction is given by
where is an arbitrary constant.
The eigenvalue problem 82 and 83 for and can be solved in a similar way using the eigenfunctions of the operator . The solution that satisfies and is given by
where and are some constants.
Substituting 90 into 82 and 83 we obtain
and then eliminating from 91 we arrive at a cubic equation for
where characterises the strength of the Marangoni flow. For any admissible value of from 87 one needs to solve 93 to find the eigenvalue . Then the corresponding eigenfunctions 90 only contain one arbitrary scaling factor with . Here we consider two physically distinct situations: the diffusion-dominated regime, when the surface diffusivity is large, i.e. , and the advection-dominated regime, when . Since the Hartmann number , the capillary number and parameter in equation 93 do not depend on , the diffusion-dominated regime corresponds to with , and remaining finite. In this case equation 93 has three distinct solutions
where . Note that is real and negative and its magnitude is always much larger than . Since is real and positive, we conclude that the real parts of are always negative. Moreover, become complex if implying that the radial perturbation mode undergoes the transition from a monotonic to oscillatory decay. In physical variables, the condition for the oscillatory decay of the radial mode is
where the electric conductivity is and depends on the ratio of the radii via parameter . It is instructive to compare condition 96 with the linear stability of an unbounded flat free layer in the absence of the magnetic field. Neglecting the disjoining pressure, the growth rate of the least stable mode with the wave vector in an unbounded horizontal free film can be obtained from equation (30) in [13]:
It follows from 97 that the critical thickness of the layer above which the relaxation dynamics is oscillatory is given by
This coincides with our result 96 for .
It is seen from equations (94) that in the absence of the Marangoni flow, that is when , the eigenvalue of the radial velocity perturbation with the largest real part is given by
The perturbation of the surfactant is decoupled from that of the radial flow and has a negative real eigenvalue . In this regime, any perturbation of the surfactant distribution relaxes on the time scale , which is much shorter than the characteristic decay time of fluid motion. In the presence of the Marangoni flow when , the perturbations of the radial velocity and surfactant concentrations are coupled and their dynamics is characterised by the leading eigenvalues . The Marangoni flow leads to a further stabilisation of the leading perturbation mode as follows from equation (94). Indeed, by analysing the real parts of the leading eigenvalues we conclude that
regardless of the sign of . As a consequence, the characteristic decay time of the flow perturbation decreases in the presence of Marangoni effect.
As follows from equation (83), in the advection-dominated regime the dynamics of the surfactant perturbation is governed by the radial flow . Indeed in this limit , which shows that the surfactant plays the role of an active scalar field advected by the flow while its gradient influences the stability of the flow. By letting in 92 and then substituting in equation (91) we obtain
From 100 we see that the Marangoni flow has no effect on the stability of the base flow if the expression under the radical is negative. However, if
the leading eigenvalue becomes real and negative, and the presence of surfactant has a stabilising effect since . These analytical results extend an earlier study on the linear stability of planar soap films [30] by including the Lorentz force effects. The observation of the stabilising role of the Marangoni flow in the limit of diffusion-dominated and advection-dominated regimes is in agreement with [30], where it was also found that for long-wavelength perturbations the presence of the Marangoni flow decreases the growth rate of the dominant perturbation mode.
To illustrate the structure of the oscillatory radial mode we consider the diffusion-dominated regime in a film with the average thickness and take all other parameters as in Figure 3. For , the leading eigenvalue of the operator is , which corresponds to the complex leading eigenvalue of the radial mode . The corresponding eigenfunction is shown in Figure 4(a). Figure 4(b) depicts the instantaneous streamlines of the corresponding flow field in a vertical cross-section of the film . The streamlines are obtained by recalling that the vertical flow velocity is given by so that the kinematic equation 69 can be written in the form . The film interface oscillates about with a decreasing amplitude while the fluid flows from the inner to the outer cylinder and back.
Figure 4. (a) Leading eigenfunction of the radial perturbation mode for the same parameters as in figure 3. (b) Streamlines of the radially perturbed flow field in a vertical crosssection of the film.
The eigenvalue problem (81) for the azimuthal velocity perturbation can only be found analytically for a weak magnetic field at . When , the spectrum of the azimuthal velocity perturbations is real and is given by
Comparing 101 with 94 we observe that in the absence of the Marangoni flow () and when the absolute value of the eigenvalue of the monotonically stable azimuthal velocity perturbation is exactly half of the real part of the eigenvalue of the radial velocity mode.
Linear stability of a deformed film in the presence of electric current
In this section, we study the linear stability of the azimuthal flow in a deformed film in the diffusion-dominated regime, when perturbations of the surfactant and solute fields relax instantaneously. The azimuthal and radial velocity perturbation modes discussed in the previous section become coupled in the presence of an electric current. This implies that for any infinitesimal applied voltage the spectrum of the generalised eigenvalue problem 79 is discrete and contains the eigenvalues that originate from each of the possible radial and azimuthal velocity modes existing in the absence of current.
To visualise how the stability of the azimuthal flow changes with the applied voltage we choose and keep all other parameters as in Figure 3. The numerical continuation method is then employed to track each mode and the corresponding eigenvalue using as the continuation parameter. To this end, the generalised eigenvalue problem 79 is solved simultaneously with equations (62) and (63). To quantify the relative coupling strength between the perturbations of the radial and the azimuthal velocity we introduce the parameter
Thus, corresponds to the pure radial and to pure azimuthal modes, respectively.
The real parts of the first three leading eigenvalues labelled by , and are shown in Figure 5(a). At the leading mode is the azimuthal velocity mode with the real eigenvalue . The second least stable mode corresponds to the radial velocity. It has the complex eigenvalues . The third mode is again the azimuthal velocity mode with the real eigenvalue . As increases, the two leading azimuthal velocity modes remain monotonically stable until the branching point bp is reached, where the two modes form a complex conjugate pair with a negative real part collide. A further increase of leads to the destabilisation of the leading radial mode , which becomes neutrally stable at the point ns, where . The corresponding film thickness profile and the base azimuthal flow are shown in Figure 5(c,Figure 5d), respectively.

Figure 5. (a) Real part of the first three leading eigenvalues as a function of the applied voltage for the same parameters as in Figure 3. The solid (dashed) lines correspond to complex (purely real) eigenvalues, respectively. Labels bp and ns mark the loci of the branching point of the azimuthal velocity mode and the point of neutral stability of the radial velocity mode, respectively; (b) the relative strength of the radial to azimuthal velocity mode ; (c) the neutrally stable film profile at point ns in panel (a); (d) the azimuthal velocity in a neutrally stable film; the magnitudes of the neutrally stable radial (e) and azimuthal (f) velocity perturbations.
Oscillatory neutrally stable perturbation is a mixture of radial and azimuthal flows as quantified by in Figure 5(b). Since the perturbation fields and are both complex, the real physical radial and azimuthal perturbations of the base flow are given by the real and imaginary parts of and with spatially varying phase shifts and . The spatially varying amplitudes of the neutrally stable radial and azimuthal velocity perturbations and are shown in Figure 5(e,Figure 5f).
To gain a deeper understanding of how the stability of the base flow changes with other parameters we plot neutral stability curves in Figure 6(a) for three selected values of in the plane , where is the critical value of the applied voltage above which the base flow is linearly unstable. It is noteworthy that for each value of there exists a finite limiting value of as . Such a limiting behaviour of the neutral stability curves confirms the dynamic nature of the flow instability. Indeed, with the scaling used here the capillary number is given by and the physical value of the applied voltage is
Figure 6. (a) Neutral stability curves in the plane for , and . (b) Neutral stability curve in the plane for . The dashed line corresponds to the power law function .
For the fixed , viscosity and density the limit of corresponds to a large surface tension . The existence of a finite value of implies that regardless of the strength of stabilising surface tension forces the instability can always be induced if the applied voltage exceeds .
We set and trace the locus of the neutral stability in the plane in Figure 6(b). The dashed line corresponds to and is obtained by fitting the lower part of the curve (small ) with a power law function. This simple power law relationship between and represents a universal stability threshold in the limit of small capillary and Hartmann numbers. Reintroducing dimensional variables we obtain the critical value of the applied voltage
The asymptotic result 103 is valid for the selected radii ratio and . At the critical value of the film is strongly deformed and has a shape similar to the solution (2) in figure 3(c). The minimum value of the film thickness is attained at the inner cylinder and is approximately 6% of .
Conclusions
We derived a set of leading order equations in the lubrication approximation that describe the electromagnetically driven flow of electrolyte solutions and/or non-magnetic liquid metals in a thin horizontal free layer with deformable surfaces placed in a uniform magnetic field normal to the layer. The equations are written in a generic coordinate-invariant form and can be used to study electromagnetically driven flows in an arbitrary geometry dictated by the shape and size of the deployed electrodes. The equations account for the presence of surfactants and chemical species dissolved in the bulk of the fluid. Inspired by recent studies of the electromagnetically driven flows in supported shallow annular layers between two coaxial cylinders [15, 28, 39, 48], we choose a similar geometry and apply the derived model to investigate the flow and its stability in annular free film spanning the gap between two coaxial cylindrical electrodes.
Similar to mechanically driven flows in soap films [51], a steady azimuthal electromagnetically driven flow can only exist in a deformed layer, where the radial component of the gradient of the Laplace pressure balances the centrifugal force. This is in contrast to supported thicker layers, where the free-surface deformation is typically negligible compared to the thickness of the layer while the flow speed does not exceed several centimetres per second. The other important feature distinguishing the flows in free layers and films from those in supported layers is that in the former the Laplace pressure dominates while in the latter the hydrostatic pressure gradient defines the fluid trajectory in the plane of the layer.
If the intermolecular forces are neglected, the azimuthally invariant steady-state flow can be found for an arbitrarily large electric current flowing through the film. The minimal film thickness is achieved at the inner electrode. It decreases as a power law function of the applied voltage remaining non-zero so that the point of a true film rupture is never reached.
We determined that the azimuthal flow in approximately flat free films with a small velocity is linearly unconditionally stable. For relatively weak magnetic fields of the order of T and fluid parameters corresponding to a weak electrolyte solution used in the experiments of [15, 39], we found that the azimuthal velocity perturbations decay monotonically while the decay of radial velocity perturbations of the base flow in layers with the average thickness in the micrometre range is oscillatory. However, as the film thickness is decreased below a certain critical value given by condition 96 ( nm for a film existing between coaxial cylinders with the inner and outer radii of 1 and 2 cm, respectively), the relaxation dynamics is found to be dominated by viscous damping with a monotonic decay of a radial flow and the associated surface deformation. This result contrasts the observations of instabilities in supported thicker annular layers, where the primary flow becomes unstable with respect to three-dimensional perturbations of the velocity without a noticeable variation of the layer depth. The fluctuations of the solute concentration in the bulk has no effect on the growth rate of the leading modes. In the presence of a surfactant, the Marangoni effect leads to further stabilisation of the base flow, which is in agreement with earlier studies of planar soap films in the absence of magnetic fields [30].
By following the branch of steady-state solutions into the regime of large applied voltage and, consequently, large electric currents, we find that the steady azimuthal flow eventually becomes unstable with respect to a mixture of oscillatory azimuthal and radial velocity perturbations at a certain critical value of the applied voltage, at which the deformation amplitude of the layer is of the order of the average film thickness. This suggests that electromagnetically driven flows in free films may not be ideal candidates for studying two-dimensional turbulence since the primary instability of the base flow sets in only when the film is already strongly deformed. We note that a similar conclusion was made earlier in [42], where it was hypothesised that strong damping caused by the interactions of the flow within a film with a surrounding gas layer that are enhanced by the surface deformation may be the cause for the energy leakage responsible for stronger than expected decays of the velocity correlation function.
Finally, we briefly mention the action of intermolecular forces characterised by the disjoining pressure. They play a major role in the instability and subsequent stabilisation of free soap films that are thinner than nm. It is well known [22, 38] that long-range van der Waals forces destabilise free layers sandwiched between dielectric media with identical properties. These forces alongside the gravity-induced drainage of the fluid constitute the primary source of film instability. As the film thickness decreases below 10–50 nm, an electric double layer is typically formed consisting of the monolayers of soap ions adsorbed at each interface. Strong electric double-layer forces lead to the repulsion between the film surfaces and the formation of highly stable black soap films with a thickness under 50 nm. Therefore, it is important to study the role of the disjoining pressure on the steady azimuthal flow and its stability in the strong-current regimes when the deformation of the layer is significant. Intermolecular forces, black soap films and film rupture will become the topic of our future investigations.
References
References
- [2]Bau, H. H., Zhu, J., Qian, S. & Xiang, Y. 2003 A magneto-hydrodynamically controlled fluidic network. Sens. Actuators, B 88 (2), 205–216.DOI
- [3]Cardoso, O., Marteau, D. & Tabeling, P. 1994 Quantitative experimental study of the free decay of quasi-two-dimensional turbulence. Phys. Rev. E 49, 454–461.pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/9961233
- [4]Chomaz, J.-M. 2001 The dynamics of a viscous soap film with soluble surfactant. J. Fluid Mech. 442, 387–409.DOI
- [5]Chomaz, J. M. & Cathalau, B. 1990 Soap films as two-dimensional classical fluids. Phys. Rev. A 41, 2243–2245.pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/9903345
- [6]Couder, Y. 1981 The observation of a shear flow instability in a rotating system with a soap membrane. J. Phys. Let. 42 (19), 429–431.DOI
- [7]Couder, Y. 1984 Two-dimensional grid turbulence in a thin liquid film. J. Phys. Let. 45, 353–360.DOI
- [8]Couder, Y., Chomaz, J.-M. & Rabaud, M. 1989 On the hydrodynamics of soap films. Physica D 37 (1), 384–405.DOI
- [9]Cruz Gómez, R. 2016 Response of a soap film to a continuous electromagnetic forcing. J. Visualization 20, 87–95.DOI
- [10]Cuevas, S. & Figueroa, A. 2023 Personal communication.
- [11]Doedel, E. J., Wang, X. & Fairgrieve, T. 1994 AUTO94: Software for continuation and bifurcation problems in ordinary differential equations. Applied Mathematics Report. California Institute of Technology, Pasadena, U.S.A.
- [12]Dunne, P., Adachi, T., Dev, A. A., Sorrenti, A., Giacchetti, L., Bonnin, A., Bourdon, C., Mangin, P. H., Coey, J. M. D., Doudin, B. & Hermans, T. M. 2020 Liquid flow and control without solid walls. Nature 581, 58–62.DOI
- [13]Erneux, T. & Davis, S. H. 1993 Nonlinear rupture of free films. Phys. Fluids A 5 (5), 1117–1122.DOI
- [14]Fiflis, P., Christenson, M., Szott, M., Kalathiparambil, K. & Ruzic, D. N. 2016 Free surface stability of liquid metal plasma facing components. Nucl. Fusion 56 (10), 106020.DOI
- [15]Figueroa, A., Demiaux, F., Cuevas, S. & Ramos, E. 2009 Electrically driven vortices in a weak dipolar magnetic field in a shallow electrolytic layer. J. Fluid Mech. 641, 245–261.DOI
- [16]Gao, D. & Morley, N. B. 2002 Equilibrium and initial linear stability analysis of liquid metal falling film flows in a varying spanwise magnetic field. Magnetohydrodynamics 38 (4), 359–375.DOI
- [17]Gao, D., Morley, N. B. & Dhir, V. 2002 Numerical study of liquid metal film flows in a varying spanwise magnetic field. Fusion Eng. Des. 63, 369–374.
- [18]Gharib, M. & Derango, P. 1989 A liquid film (soap film) tunnel to study two-dimensional laminar and turbulent shear flows. Physica D 37 (1), 406–416.
- [19]Giannakis, D., Fischer, P. F. & Rosner, R. 2009 A spectral Galerkin method for the coupled Orr–Sommerfeld and induction equations for free-surface MHD. J. Comp. Phys. 228 (4), 1188–1233.DOI
- [20]Giannakis, D., Rosner, R. & Fischer, P. F. 2009 Instabilities in free-surface Hartmann flow at low magnetic Prandtl numbers. J. Fluid Mech. 636, 217–277.DOI
- [21]Ida, M. P. & Miksis, M. J. 1998 The dynamics of thin films I: General theory. SIAM J. Appl. Math. 58 (2), 456–473.DOI
- [22]Israelachvili, J. N. 2011 Intermolecular and Surface Forces, 3rd edn. Elsevier Science.
- [23]Jensen, O. E. & Grotberg, J. B. 1993 The spreading of heat or soluble surfactant along a thin liquid film. Phys. Fluids A 5 (1), 58–68.DOI
- [24]Kellay, H. & Goldburg, W. I. 2002 Two-dimensional turbulence: a review of some recent experiments. Rep. Prog. Phys. 65 (5), 845–894.DOI
- [25]Krauskopf, B., Osinga, H. M. & Galan-Vioque, J. 2014 Numerical Continuation Methods for Dynamical Systems: Path following and boundary value problems. Springer Netherlands.
- [26]Lunz, D. & Howell, P. D. 2019 Flow of a thin liquid-metal film in a toroidal magnetic field. J. Fluid Mech. 867, 835–876.DOI
- [27]Marteau, D., Cardoso, O. & Tabeling, P. 1995 Equilibrium states of two-dimensional turbulence: An experimental study. Phys. Rev. E 51, 5124–5127.pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/9963230
- [28]McCloughan, J. & Suslov, S. A. 2020 Linear stability and saddle-node bifurcation of electromagnetically driven electrolyte flow in an annular layer. J. Fluid Mech. 887, A23.DOI
- [29]Messadek, K. & Moreau, R. 2002 An experimental investigation of MHD quasi-two-dimensional turbulent shear flows. J. Fluid Mech. 456, 137–159.DOI
- [30]Miksis, M. J. & Ida, M. P. 1998 The dynamics of thin films II: Applications. SIAM J. Appl. Math. 58 (2), 474–500.DOI
- [31]Miloshevsky, G. V. & Hassanein, A. 2010 Modelling of Kelvin-Helmholtz instability and splashing of melt layers from plasma-facing components in tokamaks under plasma impact. Nucl. Fusion 50 (11), 115005.DOI
- [32]Morley, N. B. & Abdou, M. A. 1995 Modeling of fully-developed, liquid metal, thin film flows for fusion divertor applications. Fusion Eng. Des. 30 (4), 339–356.
- [33]Morley, N. B. & Abdou, M. A. 1997 Study of fully developed, liquid-metal, open-channel flow in a nearly coplanar magnetic field. Fusion Technol. 31 (2), 135–153.DOI
- [34]Morley, N. B. & Roberts, P. H. 1996 Solutions of uniform, open-channel, liquid metal flow in a strong, oblique magnetic field. Phys. Fluids 8 (4), 923–935.
- [35]Morley, N. B., Smolentsev, S. & Gao, D. 2002 Modeling infinite/axisymmetric liquid metal magnetohydrodynamic free surface flows. Fusion Eng. Des. 63–64, 343–351.DOI
- [36]Müller, U. & Bühler, L. 2013 Magnetofluiddynamics in Channels and Containers. Springer Berlin, Heidelberg.
- [37]Oron, A., Davis, S. H. & Bankoff, S. G. 1997 Long-scale evolution of thin liquid films. Rev. Mod. Phys. 69, 931–980.DOI
- [38]Overbeek, J. Th. G. 1960 Black soap films. J. Phys. Chem. 64 (9), 1178–1183.
- [39]Pérez-Barrera, J., Ortiz, A. & Cuevas, S. 2016 Analysis of an annular MHD stirrer for microfluidic applications. In Recent advances in fluid dynamics with environmental applications (ed. J. Klapp, L. D. G. Sigalotti, A. Medina Ovando, A. López Villa & G. Ruíz Chavarría), pp. 275–288. Springer.DOI
- [40]Prévost, M. & Gallez, D. 1986 Nonlinear rupture of thin free liquid films. J. Chem. Phys. 84 (7), 4043–4048.DOI
- [41]Qian, S. & Bau, H. H. 2005 Magneto-hydrodynamic stirrer for stationary and moving fluids. Sens. Actuators, B 106, 859–870.DOI
- [42]Rivera, M. & Wu, X. L. 2000 External dissipation in driven two-dimensional turbulence. Phys. Rev. Let. 85, 976–979.pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/10991453
- [43]Shang, L., Cheng, Y. & Zhao, Y. 2017 Emerging droplet microfluidics. Chem. Rev. 117 (12), 7964–8040.DOI
- [44]Sharma, A., Kishore, C. S., Salaniwal, S. & Ruckenstein, E. 1995 Nonlinear stability and rupture of ultrathin free films. Phys. Fluids 7 (8), 1832–1840.DOI
- [45]Sharma, A. & Ruckenstein, E. 1988 Effects of surfactants on wave-induced drainage of foam and emulsion films. Colloid Polym. Sci. 266, 60–69.DOI
- [46]Sommeria, J. 1986 Experimental study of the two-dimensional inverse energy cascade in a square box. J. Fluid Mech. 170, 139–168.DOI
- [47]Sommeria, J. & Moreau, R. 1982 Why, how, and when, mhd turbulence becomes two-dimensional. J. Fluid Mech. 118, 507–518.
- [48]Suslov, S. A., Pérez-Barrera, J. & Cuevas, S. 2017 Electromagnetically driven flow of electrolyte in a thin annular layer: axisymmetric solutions. J. Fluid Mech. 828, 573–600.DOI
- [49]Van De Fliert, B. W., Howell, P. D. & Ockenden, J. R. 1995 Pressure-driven flow of a thin viscous sheet. J. Fluid Mech. 292, 359–376.DOI
- [50]Williams, B. S., Marteau, D. & Gollub, J. P. 1997 Mixing of a passive scalar in magnetically forced two-dimensional turbulence. Phys. Fluids 9 (7), 2061–2080.
- [51]Wu, X.-L., Martin, B., Kellay, H. & Goldburg, W. I. 1995 Hydrodynamic convection in a two-dimensional Couette cell. Phys. Rev. Let. 75, 236–239.pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/10059643


