betaFeedback

WorksMathematics

The cohomology of finite simple groups is unbounded

Abstract

In every fixed positive degree, we show that the cohomology of finite simple groups, algebraic groups and quantum groups, with coefficients in simple modules, can have arbitrarily large dimension. In particular, we disprove Guralnick's conjecture.

Introduction

1.1.

Cohomology in topology and geometry is rarely bounded, even in a single degree with coefficients of rank one. A smooth projective complex curve of genus gg has first cohomology of dimension 2g2g in singular, de Rham and ℓ\ell-adic cohomology, and of dimension gg for the structure sheaf. In 1984, Guralnick conjectured [18 Conjecture 2] that the first cohomology of finite groups behaves very differently:

Conjecture (Guralnick). There is an absolute constant CC such that

dim⁡kH1(G,V)≤C\dim_k H^1(G,V) \le C

for every finite group GG, every field kk, and every faithful absolutely irreducible finite-dimensional kGkG-module VV.

Guralnick’s conjecture concerns degree one. In higher degrees the analogous statement fails for arbitrary finite groups: Guralnick, Kantor, Kassabov and Lubotzky showed that the dimensions of Hn(G,V)H^n(G,V) are unbounded for every n≥2n \ge2 as GG ranges over all finite groups and VV over faithful absolutely irreducible modules [20 Theorems 12.3 and 12.6]. Their examples use wreath products to build large cohomology, and they pose the following question concerning simple groups:

Question I. [20 Question 12.1] For which n≥1n \ge1 is there an absolute constant CnC_n such that

dim⁡kHn(G,V)≤Cn\dim_k H^n(G,V) \le C_n

for every finite simple group GG, every field kk, and every faithful absolutely irreducible finite-dimensional kGkG-module VV.

We show that no such constant CnC_n exists for any n≥1n \ge1, answering Question I. The case n=1n = 1 disproves Guralnick’s conjecture. Before stating our results, we recall the developments that sustained interest in the conjecture for more than forty years.

1.2.

Despite its audacity, the conjecture looked safe for almost two decades. Guralnick and Hoffman even suggested that C=2C = 2 might suffice [19 Conjecture 2]. Only in 2003 did Scott find modules with dim⁡H1=3\dim H^1 = 3, for PSL6\mathrm{PSL}_6 in large defining characteristic [33] (see also [8]), and six years later 3 was still the largest known value [13 Introduction]. Meanwhile, a sustained programme of positive results gave bounds increasingly independent of the module. Early bounds depended on dim⁡V\dim V [3, 19]. For finite groups of Lie type in defining characteristic, Cline, Parshall and Scott bounded dim⁡H1\dim H^1 in terms of the root system alone, uniformly in the characteristic [13]. In the algebraic group setting, Parshall and Scott obtained analogous bounds for Ext⁡1\operatorname{Ext}^1 between arbitrary irreducible rational modules [30 Theorem 5.1]. Explicit bounds for finite groups of Lie type were obtained by Guralnick and Tiep in cross characteristic [21] and by Parker and Stewart in defining characteristic [29]. Moreover, a universal bound for finite simple groups would imply one for all finite groups with faithful absolutely irreducible coefficients [20 Lemma 5.2].

At the 2012 AIM workshop Cohomology bounds and growth rates, Scott and Sprowl, using a new algorithm for computing individual Kazhdan–Lusztig basis elements [34], reached 5 for PSL7\mathrm{PSL}_7 (see [28 §4]), and then Lübeck, running the Kazhdan–Lusztig algorithm at scale, found

dim⁡H1(PSLN,V)=3, 16, 469, 36672(N=6,7,8,9)\dim H^1(\mathrm{PSL}_N,V) = 3,\ 16,\ 469,\ 36672 \qquad(N = 6,7,8,9)

in sufficiently large defining characteristic, and 3,537,142 in type E6E_6 [28 §4.1 and Theorem 4.7]. In light of these examples Guralnick, Hodge, Parshall, and Scott concluded their AIM workshop saying that Guralnick’s conjecture ‘could no longer be believed’ [17]. The theory has advanced since, with Guralnick and Tiep’s bounds in terms of sectional rank [22, 23] and the characteristic-free bounds of [4, 5]; but the question of a uniform bound has remained open for a further fourteen years. Our first main result settles it, thus proving that Guralnick’s conjecture is false.

Theorem A. For every integer r≥2r \ge2 and every sufficiently large prime pp, the finite simple group PSL⁡2r+1(Fp)\operatorname{PSL}_{2r+1}(\mathbb{F}_p) has a faithful absolutely irreducible module Vr,pV_{r,p} over Fp\mathbb{F}_p such that

dim⁡FpH1(PSL⁡2r+1(Fp),Vr,p)=r.\dim_{\mathbb{F}_p} H^1(\operatorname{PSL}_{2r+1}(\mathbb{F}_p), V_{r,p}) = r.

The module Vr,pV_{r,p} is obtained by first restricting the simple SL⁡2r+1(F‾p)\operatorname{SL}_{2r+1}(\overline{\mathbb{F}}_p)-module labelled by the weight

λr,p=2ϖr−1+(p−2)(ϖr+ϖr+1)+2ϖr+2\lambda_{r,p} = 2\varpi_{r-1} + (p - 2)(\varpi_r + \varpi_{r+1}) + 2\varpi_{r+2}

to the finite subgroup SL⁡2r+1(Fp)\operatorname{SL}_{2r+1}(\mathbb{F}_p), and then descending to the projective quotient.

The computed examples reached dimension in the millions, but they did not lead to a uniform family that could be proven unbounded. Theorem A supplies such a family with an explicit highest weight and an exact dimension formula. Theorem A goes beyond unboundedness: it implies that every nonnegative integer occurs as the dimension of first cohomology of a finite simple group with faithful absolutely irreducible coefficients. This solves an inverse problem in the spirit of constructing varieties with prescribed Hodge numbers [32 Theorem 1].

1.3.

Our approach to Theorem A is through Kazhdan–Lusztig combinatorics. Let WW be the affine Weyl group of SL⁡N\operatorname{SL}_N, acting on weights by the dot action x⋅λx \mathbin{\cdot} \lambda with translations scaled by pp, and let w0w_0 be the longest element of its finite Weyl subgroup. We write

hy,w(v)=vℓ(w)−ℓ(y)Py,w(v−2)h_{y,w}(v) = v^{\ell(w)-\ell(y)}P_{y,w}(v^{-2})

for the Kazhdan–Lusztig polynomials in Soergel’s normalization, and μ(y,w)\mu(y,w) for the coefficient of vv in hy,wh_{y,w}. For pp large and x⋅0x \mathbin{\cdot} 0 pp-restricted,

μ(w0,w0x)=dim⁡H1(SL⁡N(Fp),L(x⋅0)),\mu(w_0,w_0x) = \dim H^1(\operatorname{SL}_N(\mathbb{F}_p), L(x \mathbin{\cdot} 0)),

by results of Andersen and of Bendel, Nakano and Pillen (see § 2.5). As H1≠0H^1 \ne0 forces the centre to act trivially, L(x⋅0)L(x \mathbin{\cdot} 0) is not faithful for SL⁡N(Fp)\operatorname{SL}_N(\mathbb{F}_p); it descends to a faithful module for the simple group PSL⁡N(Fp)\operatorname{PSL}_N(\mathbb{F}_p) with the same H1H^1, so showing that these coefficients are unbounded would disprove Guralnick’s conjecture. This combinatorial formulation is also what allowed Lübeck to attack the conjecture by computer: his values are coefficients μ(w0,w0x)\mu(w_0,w_0x), computed by machine for N≤9N \le9. The following is the technical heart of the paper.

Theorem B. Let r≥2r \ge2, put N=2r+1N = 2r + 1, and let WW be the affine Weyl group of type A~2r\widetilde{A}_{2r}, realized by affine permutations of period NN. For the affine permutation with window

βr=[N+1,…,N+r−1,1−r,r+1,N+r,2−r,…,0]\beta_r = [N+1,\ldots,N+r-1,1-r,r+1,N+r,2-r,\ldots,0]

one has

μ(w0,w0βr)=r.\mu(w_0,w_0\beta_r) = r.

More generally, the elements y0,…,yr−1y_0,\ldots,y_{r-1} of § 2.3, with y0=βry_0 = \beta_r, satisfy

hw0,w0ys(v)=rvs+1+O(vs+3)(0≤s≤r−1).h_{w_0,w_0y_s}(v) = r v^{s+1} + O(v^{s+3}) \qquad(0 \le s \le r-1).

Remark 1.1. Scott and Xi constructed unbounded μ(y,w)\mu(y,w) with both endpoints varying, so that they govern Ext⁡1\operatorname{Ext}^1 between two simple modules rather than H1H^1. They asked whether the coefficients can still be unbounded when the lower endpoint is required to be w0w_0 (as in the formula for first cohomology above) and proposed explicit candidates [35 Section 4]. Theorem B gives an affirmative answer using a different family of upper endpoints, namely the elements w0βrw_0\beta_r.

The higher-degree coefficients in Theorem B have consequences for the cohomology of finite simple groups in every degree. Taking s=n−1s = n - 1 in that theorem gives a coefficient of vnv^n equal to rr whenever 1≤n≤r1 \le n \le r. This is the dimension of the corresponding rational cohomology group in sufficiently large characteristic. The comparison with finite groups in § 2.6 then gives the following result.

Theorem C. Let n≥1n \ge1 and r≥max⁡{2,n}r \ge\max\{2,n\}. For every sufficiently large prime pp and every sufficiently large integer aa, the finite simple group PSL⁡2r+1(Fpa)\operatorname{PSL}_{2r+1}(\mathbb{F}_{p^a}) has a faithful absolutely irreducible module VV over Fp\mathbb{F}_p such that

dim⁡FpHn(PSL⁡2r+1(Fpa),V)≥r.\dim_{\mathbb{F}_p} H^n(\operatorname{PSL}_{2r+1}(\mathbb{F}_{p^a}),V) \ge r.

1.4.

The natural home for our results is the quantum group setting. Let UζU_\zeta be Lusztig’s quantum group of slN(C)\mathfrak{sl}_N(\mathbb{C}) at a primitive root of unity ζ\zeta of odd order ℓ>N\ell> N, and let ⋅ℓ\cdot_\ell denote the dot action of the affine Weyl group with translations scaled by ℓ\ell. Here Lusztig’s character formula holds [40], and its cohomological interpretation [11, 30] expresses hw0,w0xh_{w_0,w_0x} as the generating function of the dimensions of Hj(Uζ,Lζ(x⋅ℓ0))H^j(U_\zeta,L_\zeta(x\mathbin{\cdot_\ell}0)). The corresponding statement for algebraic groups in characteristic pp is deduced from the quantum case: Lusztig’s character formula was proved for large pp by comparison with the quantum group [2]. Our results for finite groups (Theorems A and C) therefore pass through the quantum group, and Theorem D below states the quantum result directly.

Parshall and Scott bounded the dimensions of cohomology groups for quantum groups in terms of the degree and the root system [30 Corollary 6.7], and asked whether the dependence on the root system could be removed [30 Remark 6.6]. Theorem D shows that it cannot, even in a fixed positive degree.

Theorem D. Let r≥2r \ge2, put N=2r+1N = 2r + 1, and let ℓ>N\ell> N be odd. Let UζU_\zeta be Lusztig’s quantum group of slN(C)\mathfrak{sl}_N(\mathbb{C}) at a primitive ℓ\ellth root of unity ζ\zeta. For 0≤s≤r−10 \le s \le r - 1, put λr,s=ys⋅ℓ0\lambda_{r,s} = y_s\mathbin{\cdot_\ell}0. Then the irreducible modules Lζ(λr,s)L_\zeta(\lambda_{r,s}) satisfy

dim⁡CHs+1(Uζ,Lζ(λr,s))=r.\dim_{\mathbb{C}} H^{s+1}(U_\zeta,L_\zeta(\lambda_{r,s})) = r.

Moreover, Hj(Uζ,Lζ(λr,s))=0H^j(U_\zeta,L_\zeta(\lambda_{r,s})) = 0 for 0≤j<s+10 \le j < s + 1, so the prescribed dimension occurs in the first nonzero cohomological degree.

1.5.

Our group-theoretic constructions require the characteristic to be sufficiently large relative to the rank, and therefore leave open the possibility that Guralnick’s conjecture holds in a given fixed characteristic p>0p > 0. For the same reason, the bounds sought in Question I may still hold in every degree, with constants depending on the degree and the characteristic. This leads us to formulate the following fixed-characteristic version of Question I.

Question II. Fix a prime pp and an integer n≥1n \ge1. Does there exist a constant Cn,pC_{n,p} such that

dim⁡Hn(G,V)≤Cn,p\dim H^n(G,V) \le C_{n,p}

for every finite simple group GG and every absolutely irreducible module VV in characteristic pp?

Keeping the characteristic fixed while the rank grows takes us beyond the regime where ordinary Kazhdan–Lusztig polynomials control cohomology. The modular phenomena reflected in the pp-canonical basis, which is substantially harder to compute than the ordinary Kazhdan–Lusztig basis, suggest that extending our approach to these questions would require considerably deeper control of modular representation theory.

AI statement

This project began while CB, NL, and DP were participating in the 2025 ICERM Semester Program on Categorification and Computation in Algebraic Combinatorics. Our starting point was the observation that, within the parallelepiped of alcoves corresponding to pp-restricted weights, Lübeck’s examples lie in the regions farthest from the identity. Direct computations using Sage within this region were impractical in higher ranks, and the available values showed no recognizable pattern to guide a proof. At this point DF joined the project, using MAGMA calculations to conduct a more detailed investigation of this region. This led us to ask whether more tractable examples might exist closer to the identity.

We turned to GPT-6 Astra and asked it to explore this region. From the data it provided, we identified the elements βr\beta_r as a promising family exhibiting a uniform growth pattern. However, the obstacle remained: although these elements are closer to the identity, and we could compute individual cases in small ranks, the usual Kazhdan–Lusztig algorithm gave no way to directly calculate the entire infinite family.

We therefore asked GPT-6 Astra to find a nearby auxiliary element X0X_0 whose Kazhdan–Lusztig basis element could be computed more directly, and from which βr\beta_r could be reached using only simple reflections of the finite Weyl group. The strategy of the proof was ours: we asked for a computable element in a prescribed region, together with a factorization of βr\beta_r through simple reflections along which the Kazhdan–Lusztig coefficients remain manageable. Following our instructions, the model produced a proof of Theorem B. All arguments were checked, rewritten, and completed by the authors, who take full responsibility for the results.

References

  1. [1]H. H. Andersen. An inversion formula for the Kazhdan–Lusztig polynomials for affine Weyl groups. Adv. Math., 60(2):125–153, 1986.DOI
  2. [2]H. H. Andersen, J. C. Jantzen, and W. Soergel. Representations of quantum groups at a pth root of unity and of semisimple groups in characteristic p: independence of p. Astérisque, 220, 1994.
  3. [3]M. Aschbacher and R. Guralnick. Some applications of the first cohomology group. J. Algebra, 90(2):446–460, 1984.DOI
  4. [4]C. P. Bendel, B. D. Boe, C. M. Drupieski, D. K. Nakano, B. J. Parshall, C. Pillen, and C. B. Wright. Bounding the dimensions of rational cohomology groups.
  5. [5]C. P. Bendel, D. K. Nakano, B. J. Parshall, C. Pillen, L. L. Scott, and D. Stewart. Bounding cohomology for finite groups and Frobenius kernels. Algebr. Represent. Theory, 18(3):739–760, 2015.DOI
  6. [6]C. P. Bendel, D. K. Nakano, and C. Pillen. On comparing the cohomology of algebraic groups, finite Chevalley groups and Frobenius kernels. J. Pure Appl. Algebra, 163(2):119–146, 2001.DOI
  7. [7]A. Björner and F. Brenti. Combinatorics of Coxeter Groups, volume 231 of Graduate Texts in Mathematics. Springer, Berlin, 2005.DOI
  8. [8]J. Bray and R. Wilson. Examples of 3-dimensional 1-cohomology for absolutely irreducible modules of finite simple groups. J. Group Theory, 11(5):669–673, 2008.DOI
  9. [9]B. Casselman. Notes on Kazhdan–Lusztig polynomials, 2016. Sections 5–6.
  10. [10]E. Cline, B. Parshall, L. Scott, and W. van der Kallen. Rational and generic cohomology. Invent. Math., 39(2):143–163, 1977.DOI
  11. [11]E. Cline, B. J. Parshall, and L. L. Scott. Abstract Kazhdan–Lusztig theories. Tôhoku Math. J. (2), 45(4):511–534, 1993.DOI
  12. [12]E. T. Cline, B. J. Parshall, and L. L. Scott. Detecting rational cohomology of algebraic groups. J. London Math. Soc. (2), 28(2):293–300, 1983.DOI
  13. [13]E. T. Cline, B. J. Parshall, and L. L. Scott. Reduced standard modules and cohomology. Trans. Amer. Math. Soc., 361(10):5223–5261, 2009.DOI
  14. [14]B. Elias and H. Ko. A singular Coxeter presentation. Proc. Lond. Math. Soc. (3), 126(3):923–996, 2023.arxiv.org/abs/2105.08563
  15. [15]B. Elias and G. Williamson. The Hodge theory of Soergel bimodules. Ann. of Math. (2), 180(3):1089–1136, 2014.
  16. [16]P. Fiebig. An upper bound on the exceptional characteristics for Lusztig’s character formula. J. Reine Angew. Math., 673:1–31, 2012.arxiv.org/abs/0811.1674
  17. [17]R. Guralnick, T. Hodge, B. Parshall, and L. Scott. AIM workshop counterexample to Wall’s conjecture. American Institute of Mathematics.
  18. [18]R. M. Guralnick. The dimension of the first cohomology group. In Representation Theory II (Ottawa, 1984), volume 1178 of Lecture Notes in Mathematics, pages 94–97. Springer, 1986.DOI
  19. [19]R. M. Guralnick and C. Hoffman. The first cohomology group and generation of simple groups. In Groups and Geometries (Siena, 1996), Trends in Mathematics, pages 81–89. Birkhäuser, Basel, 1998.DOI
  20. [20]R. M. Guralnick, W. M. Kantor, M. Kassabov, and A. Lubotzky. Presentations of finite simple groups: profinite and cohomological approaches. Groups Geom. Dyn., 1(4):469–523, 2007.arxiv.org/abs/0711.2817
  21. [21]R. M. Guralnick and P. H. Tiep. First cohomology groups of Chevalley groups in cross characteristic. Ann. of Math. (2), 174(1):543–559, 2011.DOI
  22. [22]R. M. Guralnick and P. H. Tiep. Sectional rank and cohomology. J. Algebra, 558:434–452, 2020.
  23. [23]R. M. Guralnick and P. H. Tiep. Sectional rank and cohomology II, 2020.arxiv.org/abs/2005.02543
  24. [24]A. Henderson. Nilpotent orbits of linear and cyclic quivers and Kazhdan–Lusztig polynomials of type A. Represent. Theory, 11:95–121, 2007.arxiv.org/abs/math/0501054
  25. [25]D. Kazhdan and G. Lusztig. Representations of Coxeter groups and Hecke algebras. Invent. Math., 53:165–184, 1979.DOI
  26. [26]Hankyung Ko. Cohomology in singular blocks for a quantum group at a root of unity. Algebras and Representation Theory, 22:1109–1132, 2019.DOI
  27. [27]T. Lam, L. Lapointe, J. Morse, and M. Shimozono. Affine insertion and Pieri rules for the affine Grassmannian. Mem. Amer. Math. Soc., 208(977), 2010.arxiv.org/abs/math/0609110
  28. [28]F. Lübeck. Computation of Kazhdan–Lusztig polynomials and some applications to finite groups. Trans. Amer. Math. Soc., 373(4):2331–2347, 2020.
  29. [29]A. E. Parker and D. I. Stewart. First cohomology groups for finite groups of Lie type in defining characteristic. Bull. Lond. Math. Soc., 46(2):227–238, 2014.
  30. [30]B. J. Parshall and L. L. Scott. Bounding Ext for modules for algebraic groups, finite groups and quantum groups. Advances in Mathematics, 226(3):2065–2088, 2011.arxiv.org/abs/0909.5207
  31. [31]A. Petrov. Non-decomposability of the de Rham complex and non-semisimplicity of the Sen operator, 2025. arXiv:2302.11389v2.arxiv.org/abs/2302.11389
  32. [32]S. Schneider. On the construction problem for Hodge numbers. Geometry & Topology, 19(1):295–342, 2015.
  33. [33]L. L. Scott. Some new examples in 1-cohomology. Journal of Algebra, 260(1):416–425, 2003.DOI
  34. [34]L. L. Scott and T. Sprowl. Computing individual Kazhdan–Lusztig basis elements. J. Symbolic Comput., 73:244–249, 2016.arxiv.org/abs/1309.7265
  35. [35]L. L. Scott and N. Xi. Some non-trivial Kazhdan–Lusztig coefficients of an affine Weyl group of type Ãₙ. Science China Mathematics, 53(8):1919–1930, 2010.
  36. [36]Romyar Sharifi. Group and Galois cohomology. Lecture notes.
  37. [37]W. Soergel. Kazhdan–Lusztig polynomials and a combinatoric for tilting modules. Represent. Theory, 1:83–114, 1997.DOI
  38. [38]R. P. Stanley. Enumerative Combinatorics, Volume 1, volume 49 of Cambridge Studies in Advanced Mathematics. Cambridge University Press, Cambridge, 2 edition, 2012.
  39. [39]R. Steinberg. Representations of algebraic groups. Nagoya Math. J., 22:33–56, 1963.DOI
  40. [40]T. Tanisaki. Character formulas of Kazhdan–Lusztig type. In Representations of finite dimensional algebras and related topics in Lie theory and geometry, volume 40 of Fields Inst. Commun., pages 261–276. Amer. Math. Soc., Providence, RI, 2004.DOI
  41. [41]G. Williamson. Singular Soergel bimodules. Int. Math. Res. Not. IMRN, 2011(20):4555–4632, 2011.arxiv.org/abs/1010.1283

Paper details

vlnc:W_jw6akbxh
Version
v1 · latest
Published
Fresh — added to the Hub within the last 30 days
Added
License
CC BY 4.0
Usage

views · 0

downloads · 0

A view counts once per browser per day, a download each time the PDF is requested.

  • Mathematics

Not recorded for this paper

View statement
Looking for related papers…
Contents