betaFeedback

WorksPhysics and Astronomy

Inclusive αα Production for 6^{6}Li+51^{51}V System

Abstract

Measurement of angular distributions and energy spectra of αα and deuterons through breakup, transfer and incomplete fusion processes to dis-entangle their relative contributions and to investigate relative importance of breakup-fusion compared to transfer. Inclusive αα production cross-sections have been measured for 6^6Li + 51^{51}V system near Coulomb barrier energies. Theoretical calculations for estimation of various reaction channels contributing to αα production have been performed with finite range coupled reaction method using FRESCO code. The cross-sections from non-capture breakup (NCBU) (αα + d) and 1n, 1p, and 1d transfer channels, compound nuclear decay channel and incomplete fusion (ICF) leading to αα production were estimated to get the cumulative production cross-sections. Contributions from breakup, transfer and incomplete fusion channels could reproduce the integral direct αα production cross-sections and their angular distributions quite well. The direct αα production cross-sections are in agreement with other targets. The αα production cross-sections are higher compared to the deuteron production. Kinematic analysis of the energy spectra of αα particles and deuterons suggest that αα particle spectra is dominated by breakp-fusion and deuteron spectra have contribution of breakup and transfer reactions. A systematic study of direct αα production with various targets follow a universal behavior on average but noticeable differences are observed for different targets. A ratio of αα and deuteron yields for a wide mass range of targets shows a saturation above barrier and an increasing production of αα particles relative to deuteron around Coulomb barrier.

I Introduction

The transfer and breakup reactions induced by weakly bound projectiles are important reaction channels around Coulomb barrier. The breakup of weakly bound light nuclei such as 6Li{}^{6}\mathrm{Li} with cluster structure (α+d\alpha+d) is a well established phenomenon while moving in the proximity to the field of target nucleus [1–5]. Numerous observations exist for larger yield of α\alpha particles in comparison to its complementary constituent and the mechanism lying behind is still the current interest of investigation for projectiles with cluster structures like 6,8He{}^{6,8}\mathrm{He}, 6,7Li{}^{6,7}\mathrm{Li}, 7,9Be{}^{7,9}\mathrm{Be} [1, 6–8]. Large yield of inclusive α\alpha particles compared to complimentary deuteron cluster implies existence of several processes apart from breakup [1, 4, 9–12]. A systematic understanding of inclusive α\alpha production and the different reaction channels contributing to it, have not been yet clearly identified by inclusive and exclusive measurement, and theoretical estimations [13–16]. Three types of measurements are performed to understand reaction mechanism with weakly bound nuclei; a) elastic scattering: to get reaction cross-section and understand potential behavior near Coulomb barrier, effect of breakup and transfer on it. b) exclusive measurement: particle-particle or particle-γ\gamma coincidence to get the cross-sections of the major channels. c) inclusive measurement: to get contribution from all major and minor channels.

A large number of studies were performed with weakly bound projectile 6Li{}^{6}\mathrm{Li} to have better understanding of breakup influences on elastic scattering and fusion [1, 6, 7, 17, 18]. The yield of α\alpha particles is significantly higher than that of deuterons which indicates deuteron transfer and breakup-fusion is favored over α\alpha, and there are many more reaction channels that produce α\alpha particles as compared to deuterons. Inclusive α\alpha production incorporates distinct reaction mechanisms, right from breakup to compound nuclear evaporation along with nucleon transfer trailed by breakup; incomplete fusion or transfer of a cluster. The complete fusion (CF) is found to be suppressed by ≈30%\approx30\% for mid to heavy mass targets [18] but less suppression was reported for light mass targets [19–23]. The suppression is due to breakup, transfer and incomplete fusion processes although, there is a difficulty in separation of CF and ICF channels for light mass targets and the conclusions are model dependent. As α\alpha production is the main channel in all direct reactions (transfer and ICF) other than breakup, it is interesting to understand if direct α\alpha production also gets suppressed in light mass region like 51V{}^{51}\mathrm{V}.

The α\alpha energy spectrum from an exclusive measurement for 7Li+93Nb{}^{7}\mathrm{Li}+{}^{93}\mathrm{Nb} system [24] suggested that transfer is dominant while other studies have suggested a mechanism of breakup-fusion to be more important [25]. In the case of transfer, the QQ value is shared and contributes to high energy α\alpha production for positive QQ value reactions but in the case of breakup-fusion the α\alpha particles do not get extra energy from the positive QQ value. Theoretical studies could explain α\alpha production from cluster transfer mechanism for 7Li{}^{7}\mathrm{Li} case [1, 26]. In the case of 6Li{}^{6}\mathrm{Li} projectile neutron transfer was suggested to be responsible for ≈50%\approx50\% direct α\alpha production [10], transfer was assumed to be responsible without distinguishing different transfer channels [27]. Presently, none of the coupled channel codes are competent enough to include breakup and transfer in a comprehensive calculation. Several reports [5, 14, 28, 29] manifest this aspect to define breakup cross section and have done exclusive and inclusive measurements to find the solution of this open question of various contributions to inclusive α\alpha production.

In the present work, the energy and angular distributions of inclusive α\alpha, deuteron, and the integral cross sections for the 6Li+51V{}^{6}\mathrm{Li}+{}^{51}\mathrm{V} system are reported. Kinematic analysis of α\alpha and deuteron energy spectra was performed to understand dominant process between transfer and breakup-fusion. Theoretical calculations for breakup and various transfer channels are performed to interpret the experimental data. The results manifest contribution from breakup and transfer channels. Systematics of direct α\alpha cross-section and its relation with deuteron cross-sections were performed. The article contains following outline. Sec. II is dedicated to experimental details. Sec. III describes the data reduction procedure and brief discussion. Kinematic disentanglement for origin of α\alpha particles and deuterons by different processes is discussed in sec. IV. Theoretical analysis using statistical model, CDCC, coupled reaction calculation of 1n1n, 1p1p and 1d1d transfer using FRESCO are described in Sec. V. Systematic study of direct α\alpha production cross-section, ratio of α\alpha and deuteron cross-sections are described in sec. VI. Summary is given in sec. VII.

Experimental details

Details of the experimental setup are given in our earlier publication [17] where breakup threshold anomaly was reported and only a short summary is given here for completeness. The experiment was performed at 14-UD BARC-TIFR Pelletron-Linac accelerator facility, Mumbai, India with 6Li3+{}^{6}\mathrm{Li}^{3+} beam at energies 14, 20, 23 and 26 MeV. The beam current was ranging between 5-28 nA. The beam was incident on a self-supported 51V{}^{51}\mathrm{V} target of thickness 1.17 mg/cm2^{2}. Beam energies were corrected for the energy loss in the target (13.6, 19.7, 22.7 and 25.7 MeV). The detection system was consisting of a set of four solid state silicon surface barrier telescope detectors in ΔE+E\Delta E + E arrangement and two monitors at ±10∘\pm10^\circ for absolute normalization. The angles covered by telescope detectors were 14∘14^\circ to 170∘170^\circ in lab. frame.

A typical measured ΔE\Delta E - ETotalE_{Total} 2D-plot at Elab=19.7E_{lab}=19.7 MeV and θlab=30∘\theta_{lab}=30^\circ is given in Figure 1. The statistical errors were ≈1%\approx1\% at forward angles which gradually increase up to ≈10%\approx10\% above θlab=70∘\theta_{lab}=70^\circ for 19.7, 22.7 and 25.7 MeV energies. In the case of 13.6 MeV energy, the statistical errors were less than 5% at all angles. The data were recorded using the Linux based data acquisition system, LAMPS [30].

Figure 1. The typical bi-parametric ΔE\Delta E - ETotalE_{Total} plot for the 6Li+51V{}^{6}\mathrm{Li}+{}^{51}\mathrm{V} system at Elab=19.7E_{lab}=19.7 MeV, θlab=30∘\theta_{lab}=30^\circ.

Experimental energy and angular distributions

The energy spectra of α\alpha particles at various angles are shown in Figure 2 and Figure 3 for 25.7 MeV and 19.7 MeV, respectively. The experimental energy spectra include α\alpha particles originating from direct and compound nuclear reactions. The calculated values from compound nuclear reaction have dominant contribution well above grazing angles while the direct contributions peaks around grazing angles. The grazing angles for 25.7, 22.7, 19.7 and 13.6 MeV are ≈31∘\approx31^\circ, 36∘36^\circ, 45∘45^\circ, and 91∘91^\circ, respectively which were obtained from elastic scattering data [17]. The direct contribution is deduced by subtracting the calculated compound nuclear contribution from measured α\alpha production. The experimental energy and angular distributions are matching well with compound nuclear contributions at higher angles (70° and above for 25.7 MeV and above 100° for 19.7 MeV) to offer the only contribution from complete fusion process above these angles. Direct α\alpha is dominated around grazing angles. The energy integrated α\alpha particle yields were obtained at different angles. The energy integrated measured differential angular cross sections were obtained [5] using the following equation

Energy spectra of α particles at $E_{\mathrm{lab}}=25.7$ MeV for various laboratory angles

Figure 2. Energy spectra of α particles at Elab=25.7E_{\mathrm{lab}}=25.7 MeV and for various lab. angles for 6Li+51V{}^{6}\mathrm{Li}+{}^{51}\mathrm{V} system. The experimental data for total and direct α production are presented by filled circles and hollow triangles, respectively. The compound nuclear contribution from PACE is represented by solid line.

Energy spectra of α particles at $E_{\mathrm{lab}}=19.7$ MeV for various laboratory angles

Figure 3. Same as given in Figure 2. but at Elab=19.7E_{\mathrm{lab}}=19.7 MeV.

dσαdΩ=YαYeldσeldΩ(1)\frac{d\sigma_{\alpha}}{d\Omega}=\frac{Y_{\alpha}}{Y_{\mathrm{el}}}\frac{d\sigma_{\mathrm{el}}}{d\Omega} \tag*{(1)}

Here, YαY_{\alpha}, YelY_{\mathrm{el}} are α particle and elastic scattering yields, dσel/dΩd\sigma_{\mathrm{el}}/d\Omega is the elastic scattering cross section, as reported in Ref. [17]. Angular distributions of α particle production cross sections are shown in Figure 4. It is clear that the cross-sections well above grazing angles are dominated by evaporation through the compound nuclear or complete fusion reaction whereas breakup and transfer following α particles are peaking near grazing angles.

Energy integrated angular distributions of $\alpha$ particles and deuterons

Figure 4. Energy integrated angular distribution of α\alpha particles at different energies a) 25.7 MeV, b) 22.7 MeV, c) 19.7 MeV and d) 13.6 MeV for 6Li+51V^{6}\mathrm{Li}+^{51}\mathrm{V} system. The solid circles represent total α\alpha cross section, solid line is contribution from compound nuclear reaction, and direct or non-compound (total - compound) are depicted by hollow triangles. Total deuteron cross-sections are shown by hollow squares.

The angle integrated direct α cross sections at each energy were obtained by fitting the Gaussian shape to (dσ/dΩ)×2πsin⁡θ(d\sigma/d\Omega)\times2\pi\sin\theta distribution and an integral α cross section was deduced using equation

σα=∫02πdϕ∫0πdσα(θ)dΩsin⁡θdθ(2)\sigma_{\alpha}=\int_{0}^{2\pi}d\phi\int_{0}^{\pi}\frac{d\sigma_{\alpha}(\theta)}{d\Omega}\sin\theta d\theta \tag*{(2)}

The deduced experimental direct α cross sections along with errors are given in Table I. The errors were obtained

ElabE_{\mathrm{lab}} (MeV)σαdirect\sigma_{\alpha}^{\mathrm{direct}} (mb)σd\sigma_d (mb)σαCN\sigma_{\alpha}^{\mathrm{CN}} (mb)σpaceCF\sigma_{\mathrm{pace}}^{\mathrm{CF}} (mb)σαNCBU\sigma_{\alpha}^{\mathrm{NCBU}} (mb)σ1−nTC\sigma_{1-n}^{\mathrm{TC}} (mb)σ1−pTC\sigma_{1-p}^{\mathrm{TC}} (mb)σ1−dTC\sigma_{1-d}^{\mathrm{TC}} (mb)σαICF\sigma_{\alpha}^{\mathrm{ICF}} (mb)σαcal.\sigma_{\alpha}^{\mathrm{cal.}} (mb)
25.7510±46510 \pm46136±27136 \pm27387105662431661277459
22.7490±68490 \pm68144±38144 \pm3830496358361661253424
19.7403±11403 \pm1123082652251556217365
13.6239±8239 \pm836±736 \pm7542792524104273174

Table I. Experimental direct α\alpha production (σαdirect\sigma_{\alpha}^{\mathrm{direct}}) and total deuteron production cross-sections (σdtotal\sigma_d^{\mathrm{total}}) deduced from integral of measured angular distributions, calculated cross sections for α\alpha production by compound nuclear reactions σαCN\sigma_{\alpha}^{\mathrm{CN}}, non-capture breakup (σαNCBU\sigma_{\alpha}^{\mathrm{NCBU}}), 1n-transfer (σ1−nTC\sigma_{1-n}^{\mathrm{TC}}), 1p-transfer (σ1−pTC\sigma_{1-p}^{\mathrm{TC}}), 1d-transfer (σ1−dTC\sigma_{1-d}^{\mathrm{TC}}), ICF (σαICF\sigma_{\alpha}^{\mathrm{ICF}}) and total calculated direct α\alpha production (σαcal.\sigma_{\alpha}^{\mathrm{cal.}}). Transfer calculations are performed using FRESCO and compound nuclear calculations are done with PACE code. The complete fusion cross-sections given by PACE are denoted by σpaceCF\sigma_{\mathrm{pace}}^{\mathrm{CF}}.

due to fitting errors in the three parameters (strength, mean, and width) of the Gaussian distributions. Maximum and Minimum cross-sections were obtained by adding these errors to the mean values of the parameters, and thus errors were deduced in the cross-sections. The angular range of measurements was very well covered around grazing angles for 19.7 and 13.6 MeV energies hence, the errors in the data were less. The angular distributions for 22.7 and 25.7 MeV energies were very much forward peaked and the measurements were done from 14° onward, hence, the deduced errors were relatively higher at these energies.

Kinematic disentanglement of α particle energy spectra

Detailed analysis of the energy spectra was carried out and energy centroids were calculated using kinematics for different processes and are given in Table II. The elastic or non-capture breakup contribution is in general very well reproduced by CDCC calculations using FRESCO and is ≈ 10 % of direct α cross-section as given in Table I. In the case of transfer reactions, if fusion followed by breakup takes place then energy from QQ value is not shared with the out going fragments like α\alpha, 5He^{5}\mathrm{He} and 5Li^{5}\mathrm{Li} for deuteron, proton and neutron transfer, respectively. The centroid energies in Table II are given for the cluster transfer where the energy from QQ value is not shared with the outgoing fragment. Neutron transfer has only one value as optimum QQ value (QoptQ_{\mathrm{opt}}) is zero. In the case of sharing of QQ value with the outgoing α\alpha particles, following possibilities are there for the present study at 25.7 MeV beam energy

(a) deuteron transfer: the α\alpha particles from ground state transfer should peak around 25 MeV; for transfer to lower states of the target but sufficient to emit one neutron, should peak at ≈22\approx22 MeV and transfer to higher

states of the target but sufficient to emit two neutrons, should peak at ≈19\approx19 MeV. (b) neutron transfer: the α\alpha particles from ground state transfer should peak around ≈21\approx21 MeV. (c) proton transfer: the α\alpha particles from ground state transfer should peak around ≈17\approx17 MeV. The calculations (Table I) suggest this process to be very small compared to other two processes.

In all three cases of the transfer reactions if QQ value is shared with the outgoing fragments then there should be a peak around 20 MeV. The energy spectra were fitted with two Gaussians with all free parameters. The contributions were estimated using areas under Gaussian peaks as shown in Figure 5. The relative peak area around 20 MeV was estimated to be ≈10\approx10 % which corresponds to deuteron, proton and neutron transfer, altogether. Other contributions to α\alpha production are from breakup fusion and NCBU which are under the major peak. The NCBU is ≈10\approx10 % of direct α\alpha cross-section as shown in Table I and the remaining α\alpha particles seem to originate from breakup fusion where QQ value does not boost the α\alpha particle energy. Small contribution of such boosted α\alpha particles perhaps indicates that breakup-fusion is the dominant process for 6Li{}^{6}\mathrm{Li} projectile compared to transfer while the transfer was reported to be dominant in the case of 7Li+93Nb{}^{7}\mathrm{Li}+{}^{93}\mathrm{Nb} [24].

Alpha-energy and deuteron spectra

Figure 5. α\alpha-energy spectra at θlab=30∘\theta_{\mathrm{lab}}=30^\circ for a) 25.7 and b) 19.7 MeV. Deutron spectra are given at c) θlab=30∘\theta_{\mathrm{lab}}=30^\circ and d) 70∘70^\circ degrees for 25.7 MeV beam energy. Non-capture breakup (NCBU), breakup-fusion are shown by shaded region (cyan) and nn, pp, dd and α\alpha transfers are shown by red shaded area (see § 4 for details).

Ec.m.E_{\mathrm{c.m.}} (MeV)dd trans. (MeV)pp trans. (MeV)nn trans. (MeV)breakup (MeV)
23.0 QggQ_{gg}14.76.11.65-1.47
QoptQ_{opt}-7.1-7.10.0
E‾α\overline{E}_{\alpha}16.013.421.214.3
20.3 QoptQ_{opt}-6.3-6.30.0
E‾α\overline{E}_{\alpha}14.111.919.112.6
17.6 QoptQ_{opt}-5.5-5.50.0
E‾α\overline{E}_{\alpha}12.310.416.910.8

Table 2. Kinematic parameters for α\alpha transfer channel for 6Li+51V{}^{6}\mathrm{Li}+{}^{51}\mathrm{V} system. QggQ_{gg} represent transfer to ground state, optimum QQ value (QoptQ_{opt}) is calculated at leading order according to Ref. [32], centroid energy of the direct-α\alpha for the respective channels in the c.m. system (Eα=Ec.m.+QoptE_{\alpha}=E_{\mathrm{c.m.}}+Q_{opt}). 5Li→α+p{}^{5}\mathrm{Li}\rightarrow\alpha+p and 5He→α+n{}^{5}\mathrm{He}\rightarrow\alpha+n are assumed to be broken giving α\alpha particles. The energies of breakup constituents are calculated as per mass ratio.

An estimate of the α\alpha particles from breakup fusion or incomplete fusion has been made as suggested by Jha et al. [31] and mentioned here. As the complete fusion is suppressed by ≈35\approx35% for 6Li{}^{6}\mathrm{Li} induced reactions and 75% of this is originated from deuteron capture reaction producing ICF α\alpha. The cross-sections for ICF α\alpha particles were estimated using complete fusion cross-sections given in Table I. The ICF α\alpha and other direct α\alpha cross-sections estimated from different reaction channels are given in Section V and are close to the experimental values as shown in Figure 8. It was not possible to separate ICF α\alpha and breakup α\alpha particles as both peaks are in the same region. In the case of deuteron energy spectra, it has mixture of breakup and α\alpha transfer. The breakup cross-sections and integral deuteron production suggest that both processes have almost equal share of it.

The contribution from different possible reaction channels contributing to direct alpha production

Figure 8. The contribution from different possible reaction channels contributing to direct α\alpha production i.e. non-capture breakup (dark yellow short-long dashed line), 1p1p transfer (blue dashed line), 1n1n transfer (cyan long-short dashed line), 1d1d transfer (green dotted line), Transfer + NCBU (black short dashed line), and ICF + Transfer + NCBU is represented by solid line. Experimental inclusive direct α\alpha cross-section data are represented with red solid circles. ICF-α\alpha is estimated as described in § 4.

Theoretical Analysis

Statistical Model Calculations

The contribution from compound nuclear reaction for α\alpha production cross section was calculated using statistical model PACE [33]. The angular distributions and energy spectra show resemblance well above grazing angles with experimental data. The Ignatyuk prescription [34] of level density with parameter (a~=A/10 MeV−1\tilde{a}=A/10\ \mathrm{MeV}^{-1}, A=A= mass number) was used.

The optical potentials used in PACE are from C. M. Perey and F. G. Perey [35] for neutron and proton, and from J. R. Huizenga and G. Igo [36] for the α\alpha particles. The angular distributions of α\alpha production due to compound nucleus evaporation reaction are given in Figure 4 and energy spectra at different angles for 25.7 MeV and 19.7 MeV are given in Figure 2 and Figure 3, respectively which are represented by solid lines. The calculated angular distributions and energy spectra well above grazing angles match with the experimental data at 25.7, 22.7 and 19.7 MeV energies where the contribution is only from compound nuclear evaporation process.

Continuum Discretized Coupled Channel Calculations

The non-capture or elastic breakup cross-sections are calculated with CDCC using the code FRESCO version 3.1 [37, 38]. 6Li{}^{6}\mathrm{Li} nucleus was assumed as a two body α+d\alpha+d cluster. The continuum above the breakup threshold of 6Li→α+d{}^{6}\mathrm{Li}\rightarrow\alpha+d were discretized into momentum bins of width Δk=0.1 fm−1\Delta k=0.1\ \mathrm{fm}^{-1}. The continuum momentum bins were truncated at ϵmax⁡=9.25\epsilon_{\max}=9.25 MeV. Each continuum or resonance state was further binned into 40 equal kk-bins. The relative orbital angular momentum L=0L=0, 1, 2 and 3 were included in the calculations. In addition, the 1+1^{+}, 2+2^{+} and 3+3^{+} resonances for L=2L=2 with experimental widths at 2.186 MeV, 4.312 MeV and 5.65 MeV respectively, were also included. The binding potential for the α\alpha and dd clusters were taken from Ref. [39]. The resonance potentials were included from Ref. [40]. The cluster folding potentials for α+51V\alpha+{}^{51}\mathrm{V} and d+51Vd+{}^{51}\mathrm{V} at respective energies as per mass (2/3 of ElabE_{lab} for α\alpha and 1/3 of ElabE_{lab} for deuteron) were generated from Ref. [41, 42]. The breakup cross-sections at different energies are given in Table I and angular distributions are plotted in Figure 8.

Coupled Reaction Channel Calculations

Transfer and inelastic reactions are studied to explore the internal properties of nuclei, the arrangement of nucleons somewhere inside the nucleus. Therefore, for this purpose, transfer reactions are used to calculate single particle structure of nuclei and extraction of spectroscopic factors. In this section, we estimate the contribution of 1n, 1p and 1d direct transfer cross-section for the reactions 51V(6Li,5Li)52V{}^{51}\mathrm{V}({}^{6}\mathrm{Li},{}^{5}\mathrm{Li}){}^{52}\mathrm{V}, 51V(6Li,5He)52Cr{}^{51}\mathrm{V}({}^{6}\mathrm{Li},{}^{5}\mathrm{He}){}^{52}\mathrm{Cr} and 51V(6Li,4He)53Cr{}^{51}\mathrm{V}({}^{6}\mathrm{Li},{}^{4}\mathrm{He}){}^{53}\mathrm{Cr}, respectively. The parent and daughter nucleus incorporates coupling from different possible bound and excited states. To perform the coupled channel calculations, we need structural information of participating nuclei. In addition to this, other important physical input parameters are (1) optical potentials for incoming and outgoing distorted waves; (2) a peculiar identification of the overlap functions which typically represent single particle states in a Wood-Saxon potential with an intention to reproduce a bound state by re-adjusting depth of the binding potential; (3) spectroscopic factors corresponding to probability of finding core state within the composite state.

An incoming wave has both elastic and inelastic components. The wave function can be represented as

ψ=ϕα(r)χα(R)+ϕα′(r)χα′(R)(3)\psi= \phi_{\alpha}(r)\chi_{\alpha}(R) + \phi_{\alpha'}(r)\chi_{\alpha'}(R) \tag*{(3)}

Here ϕα(R)\phi_{\alpha}(R) and ϕα′(r)\phi_{\alpha'}(r) are the ground and excited state wave functions of projectile. The α\alpha represents incoming partition with projectile aa and target AA. The functions χα(R)\chi_{\alpha}(R) and ϕα′(r)\phi_{\alpha'}(r) represent relative motion between projectile and target in numerous internal states. Of course the total wave function ψ\psi satisfies the Schrodinger equation (E−H)ψ=0(E-H)\psi= 0. A set of two equations is obtained by projecting this equation onto different internal states:

(E−ϵα−Kα−Uαα)χα(R)=Uαα′χα′(R)(E−ϵα′−Kα′−Uα′α′)χα′(R)=Uα′αχα(R)(4)\begin{aligned} (E-\epsilon_{\alpha}-K_{\alpha}-U_{\alpha\alpha})\chi_{\alpha}(R) &= U_{\alpha\alpha'}\chi_{\alpha'}(R) \\ (E-\epsilon_{\alpha'}-K_{\alpha'}-U_{\alpha'\alpha'})\chi_{\alpha'}(R) &= U_{\alpha'\alpha}\chi_{\alpha}(R) \tag*{(4)} \end{aligned}

where UααU_{\alpha\alpha} and Uαα′U_{\alpha\alpha'} are the coupling potentials. In a typical approach for calculation of coupled reaction channel (CRC), these two equations in Eq. (4) are solved ‘exactly’ to obtain χα(R)\chi_{\alpha}(R) and χα′(R)\chi_{\alpha'}(R). In many cases, the inelastic component of the wave function is weakly coupled to ground state and thus this virtue opens the door for the approximated solution for the above equation. This can be obtained by making its inelastic component part to zero i.e.

(E−ϵα−Kα−Uαα)χα(R)≈0(5)(E-\epsilon_{\alpha}-K_{\alpha}-U_{\alpha\alpha})\chi_{\alpha}(R) \approx0 \tag*{(5)}

The resulting function χα(R)\chi_{\alpha}(R) is then inserted into the second equation to calculate χα′(R)\chi_{\alpha'}(R). This is called 1-step Distorted Wave Born Approximation (DWBA) calculation. Further, this calculated χα′(R)\chi_{\alpha'}(R) can again be inserted into 1st1^{st} part of Eq. (4) to have an iterative solution for χα(R)\chi_{\alpha}(R). In all the upcoming theoretical calculations by FRESCO we have used iterative method for full CRC calculations till the absolute difference between successive s-matrix elements becomes less than 0.01%. The coupling to few discrete channels or continuum channels depends on the excitation energy for the particular channel. The direct deuteron transfer to lower discrete states is insignificant due to higher positive QQ value thus continuum coupling is important. Other transfer channels have contribution of discrete as well as continuum channels. The optical potentials for the incoming channel were obtained from elastic scattering data [17] and is same for all transfer channels.

1n Transfer

The 1n1n transfer followed by breakup of 6Li⇒5Li(p+α)+n{}^{6}\mathrm{Li} \Rightarrow{}^{5}\mathrm{Li}(p+\alpha)+n can contribute to α\alpha production. The CRC calculations of 1n1n transfer resulted in considerable contribution to inclusive α\alpha cross section by the reaction 51V(6Li,5Li)52V{}^{51}\mathrm{V}({}^{6}\mathrm{Li},{}^{5}\mathrm{Li}){}^{52}\mathrm{V}. The Woods–Saxon form factors were used with reduced radii r0=1.25r_{0}=1.25 fm and diffuseness a=0.65a=0.65 fm for projectiles as well as target bound state potentials. The spin-orbit interaction was included with standard depth of 6 MeV. The depth of the real potential was allowed to vary to reproduce experimental neutron binding energies. The finite range transfer approximation in FRESCO [37] was used for the calculations in post form. Full complex remnant term were used with two way coupling scheme. The other important parameter, spectroscopic factor for the projectile was taken from Ref. [43]. The spectroscopic factors for target were incorporated from the work of O. Karban et. al. [44]. The calculations were performed for nn transfer to the 2p3/22p_{3/2}, 1f5/21f_{5/2}, 2p1/22p_{1/2} and 1g9/21g_{9/2} orbits of available model space of 52V{}^{52}\mathrm{V} with the assumption of closure of 1f7/21f_{7/2} subshell in the ground state. The continuum coupling above neutron bound state was considered with angular momentum of L=0→5ℏL=0\to5\hbar and using equal linear momentum bins up to ≈15\approx15 MeV of energies. The schematic picture of target overlaps and discrete states for coupling are shown in Figure 6 which were part of the calculations. The contribution of 1n1n transfer is mentioned in Table I. The total angular distribution for 1n1n transfer having sum of all participating states including continuum states in calculation, is presented in Figure 8.

Figure 6. Schematic diagram of coupling of different levels used in calculation for 1n1n transfer.

1p Transfer

In order to study the 1p1p stripping or transfer contribution through 51V(6Li,5He)52Cr^{51}\mathrm{V}(^{6}\mathrm{Li},^{5}\mathrm{He})^{52}\mathrm{Cr} reaction, CRC calculations have been performed. The calculations were performed for pp transfer to the 1f7/21f_{7/2}, 2p3/22p_{3/2} orbits in the model space of 52Cr^{52}\mathrm{Cr}. The schematic picture of target overlaps and states for coupling is shown in Figure 7. The spectroscopic factors for target were taken from Ref. [45]. The spectroscopic factors were taken as one to get the contribution of higher states up to 9.5 MeV. The continuum couplings upto 12 MeV above bound state was included which give rise to small contribution. The 1p1p transfer cross-section is mentioned in Table I. The total angular distribution for 1p1p stripping having sum of all participating states is presented in Figure 8.

Figure 7. Schematic diagram of coupling of different levels used in calculation for 1p1p transfer.

d-Cluster Transfer

The CRC calculations were performed for 1d1d transfer contribution which leads to direct α\alpha production through 51V(6Li,4He)53Cr^{51}\mathrm{V}(^{6}\mathrm{Li},^{4}\mathrm{He})^{53}\mathrm{Cr} reaction. The spectroscopic factors for the projectile and target were taken as one. As the QQ value for this channel is quite high (14.745 MeV), the contribution of transfer to low lying discrete states was negligible. Thus, the transfer to continuum coupling of 53Cr^{53}\mathrm{Cr} states up to ≈12\approx12 MeV energies above deuteron binding energy with equal momentum bins of bin width Δk=0.1 fm−1\Delta k = 0.1\ \mathrm{fm}^{-1} and angular momentum of L=0L = 0 to 7ℏ7\hbar were considered. The cross-section contribution of dd transfer is reported in Table I. The angular distribution for 1d1d transfer with sum of all continuum states in calculation is presented in Figure 8.

The angular distributions in Figure 8 show individual contributions from NCBU and transfer channels and their addition is represented by Tr + NCBU. The ICF α\alpha contributions were added by multiplying the Tr + NCBU spectra with a factor of (σαcal./(σαcal.−σαICF))(\sigma_{\alpha}^{cal.}/(\sigma_{\alpha}^{cal.}-\sigma_{\alpha}^{ICF})) where cross-sections are given in Table I and σαICF\sigma_{\alpha}^{ICF} calculations are described in § 4. An overall agreement with experimental data is good and small difference might be due to uncertainties in spectroscopic factors and inclusion of limited number of states in transfer calculations.

Systematic Study

The direct α\alpha cross sections for 6^{6}Li projectile with various targets have been compared in Figure 9 along with present work. A reduction approach to obliterate the effect of the Coulomb barrier for different targets at varying energies [46] was adopted. The energy is reduced to scale Ec.m.(AP1/3+AT1/3)/ZPZTE_{c.m.}(A_{P}^{1/3}+A_{T}^{1/3})/Z_{P}Z_{T}, where PP and TT stand for projectile and target respectively, ZZ and AA stand for charge and mass of involved nuclei. The direct contributions presented here show an overall universal trend and saturation above barrier energies with a noticeable difference for different targets. As the contribution to direct α\alpha particles is from many transfer channels; these have an influence of nuclear structure. The reduced cross-sections do not show suppression for light and mid mass targets compared with heavy mass targets.

Experimental direct alpha particle cross-section data for 6Li projectile with different targets

Figure 9. Experimental direct α\alpha particle cross-section data for 6Li{}^{6}\mathrm{Li} projectile with different targets. The cross-sections for various targets are taken from literature 58Ni{}^{58}\mathrm{Ni}, 118Sn{}^{118}\mathrm{Sn}, 120Sn{}^{120}\mathrm{Sn} [12], 59Co{}^{59}\mathrm{Co} [4], 65Cu{}^{65}\mathrm{Cu} [47], 90Zr{}^{90}\mathrm{Zr} [5], 159Tb{}^{159}\mathrm{Tb} [15], 208Pb{}^{208}\mathrm{Pb} [48] [9], 209Bi{}^{209}\mathrm{Bi} [13]. The present work for 6Li+51V{}^{6}\mathrm{Li} + {}^{51}\mathrm{V} is represented with black hollow circles.

A systematic study of α\alpha and deuteron production cross-sections was carried out and ratio of these cross-sections is plotted in Figure 10. The cross-section for 51V{}^{51}\mathrm{V}

A ratio of alpha production cross-section to deuteron production cross-section for different targets around Coulomb barrier

Figure 10. A ratio of α\alpha production cross-section to deuteron production cross-section for different targets around Coulomb barrier. Experimental data are taken from Ref. 6Li+238U{}^{6}\mathrm{Li} + {}^{238}\mathrm{U} [11], 6Li+124Sn{}^{6}\mathrm{Li} + {}^{124}\mathrm{Sn} [49], 6Li+159Tb{}^{6}\mathrm{Li} + {}^{159}\mathrm{Tb} [15], 6Li+59Co{}^{6}\mathrm{Li} + {}^{59}\mathrm{Co} [4], 6Li+118Sn{}^{6}\mathrm{Li} + {}^{118}\mathrm{Sn} [12].

(present study), 59Co{}^{59}\mathrm{Co} [4], 118Sn{}^{118}\mathrm{Sn} [12] and 238U{}^{238}\mathrm{U} [11] are from direct observation of these particles but for 124Sn{}^{124}\mathrm{Sn} [49] and 159Tb{}^{159}\mathrm{Tb} [15] the data are taken from ICF residue cross-sections. The ratio suggests many more reaction channels for α\alpha production (breakup, nn, pp transfer followed by breakup, dd transfer and breakup fusion etc.) compared to deuteron production (breakup, α\alpha transfer, and breakup fusion etc.). We have to also consider the effect of lower deuteron binding leading to its split into p+np+n particles.

Summary

In summary, inclusive α\alpha production cross-sections have been measured for 6Li+51V{}^{6}\mathrm{Li} + {}^{51}\mathrm{V} system around Coulomb barrier over a wide angular range and large α\alpha particle yields were observed. Statistical model calculations have been performed to separate the compound nuclear contributions in the α\alpha particle spectra and to get the direct α\alpha contributions. Non-capture break-up calculations using CDCC method, CRC calculations for nn, pp and dd transfers and ICF α\alpha estimations using fusion cross-sections were performed to disentangle the contribution from these channels to α\alpha production. Addition of all these channel cross-sections leading to α\alpha production reproduce angular and energy distributions, and integral cross-sections reasonably well. Deuteron cluster transfer gives negligible contribution to discrete states due to high QQ value and transfer to continuum gives significant contribution. Transfer to continuum enhances nn and pp transfer along with discrete state contributions, marginally. ICF α\alpha cross-sections were deduced from fusion cross-sections. The total calculated direct α\alpha cross-sections are in good agreement with the experimental data. The kinematic disentanglement of α\alpha particles suggest that breakup fusion is dominant over transfer as the positive QQ value boosted α\alpha particles are not significant. The dominance of breakup process and breakup fusion contributions over the direct transfer process in the production of α\alpha particles could be perhaps related to 6Li{}^{6}\mathrm{Li} having a smaller binding energy when compared to that of 7Li{}^{7}\mathrm{Li}. More experiments of particle-γ\gamma coincidence are required with suitable targets where disentanglement is irrefutable. Direct α\alpha particle cross-sections show a universal trend on average with a noticeable difference with different targets possibly due to structure effects in transfer channels contributing to α\alpha production but no suppression was observed in reduced direct α\alpha cross-section for light mass targets compared to heavy mass targets. Ratio of α\alpha and deuteron production cross-sections for various targets shows much higher cross-section for α\alpha production close to barrier compared to deuteron production due to difference in Coulomb barrier and more reaction channels for α\alpha production. The ratio saturates above barrier energies perhaps due to saturation of number of open channels.

Acknowledgments

The authors thank to BARC/TIFR Pelletron staff for excellent delivery of the beam and the support of the Department of Atomic Energy, Government of India, under project No. 12P-R&D-TFR-5.02-0300. One of the author (CJ) would like to acknowledge Department of Science and Technology (DST), Government of India for awarding her Inspire Fellowship. The authors V.V.P. and S.K. acknowledge the financial support from Young Scientist Research grant and Senior Scientist program, respectively, from the Indian National Science Academy (INSA), Government of India, in carrying out these investigations.

References

References

  1. [41]H. An and C. Cai, Phys. Rev. C 73, 054605 (2006).
  2. [42]V. Avrigeanu and M. Avrigeanu, EPJ Web of Conf. 2, 02003 (2010).
  3. [43]S. Cohen and D. Kurath, Nucl. Phys. A 101, 1 (1967).
  4. [44]O. Karban, J. England, D. Barker, M. Mannion, J. Nelson, C. Ogilvie, L. Potvin, L. Zybert, R. Zybert, N. Clarke, et al., Nucl. Phys. A 472, 189 (1987).
  5. [45]F. Pellegrini, I. Filosofov, M. I. El Zaiki, and I. Gabrielli, Phys. Rev. C 8, 1547 (1973).
  6. [46]P. R. S. Gomes, M. D. Rodríguez, G. V. Martí, I. Padron, L. C. Chamon, J. O. Fernández Niello, O. A. Capurro, A. J. Pacheco, J. E. Testoni, A. Arazi, et al., Phys. Rev. C 71, 034608 (2005).
  7. [47]A. Shrivastava, A. Navin, N. Keeley, K. Mahata, K. Ramachandran, V. Nanal, V. V. Parkar, A. Chatterjee, and S. Kailas, Phys. Lett. B 633, 463 (2006).
  8. [48]C. Signorini, M. Mazzocco, G. F. Prete, F. Soramel, L. Stroe, A. Andrighetto, I. J. Thompson, A. Vitturi, A. Brondi, M. Cinausero, et al., Eur. Phys. J. A 10, 249 (2001).
  9. [49]V. V. Parkar, S. K. Pandit, A. Shrivastava, R. Palit, K. Mahata, V. Jha, K. Ramachandran, S. Gupta, S. Santra, S. K. Sharma, et al., Phys. Rev. C 98, 014601 (2018).

Paper details

vlnc:W_jzndut4w
Version
v1 · latest
Published
Fresh — added to the Hub within the last 30 days
Added
License
CC BY 4.0
Usage

views · 0

downloads · 0

A view counts once per browser per day, a download each time the PDF is requested.

  • Physics and Astronomy

Not recorded for this paper

View statement
Looking for related papers…
Contents