betaFeedback

WorksPhysics and Astronomy

Cartan geometry and the Hamiltonian analysis of gravitational actions in terms of forms

Abstract

The purpose of the paper is to review the Hamiltonian formulation for several actions related to general relativity that can be written in terms of differential forms. As we will show the powerful ideas of Cartan geometry can be used to simplify the Hamiltonian analysis and arrive at a coherent and comprehensive geometrical understanding of it.

Key Words: Cartan geometry; Gravitational actions; Hamiltonian formulation

Introduction

The Hamiltonian approach to the dynamics of gravitational theories has received a lot of attention since the initial work by Dirac [1] and the subsequent development of the ADM formalism [2, 3]. One reason for this is that Hamiltonians can be used as a first step toward quantization. In fact, Loop Quantum Gravity (LQG) started as a novel Hamiltonian description of General Relativity (GR) formulated in terms of Yang-Mills variables instead of the traditional geometrodynamical ones [4, 5].

All the known actions for GR are defined in terms of singular Lagrangians. The Hamiltonian analysis of this type of Lagrangians is not straightforward and requires some care. The first comprehensive approach to dealing with them was developed by Dirac [6] who proposed a celebrated “algorithm” for this purpose. His approach relies on the identification of the so called primary constraints and the introduction of a total Hamiltonian HTH_{T} involving arbitrary objects—multipliers in the usual parlance—that must be fixed by requiring that the dynamics given by HTH_{T} be consistent. In the process of finding these multipliers by solving the relevant equations, extra secondary constraints may appear, in which case additional consistency checks are needed. Although the whole procedure may get quite involved, if followed to the letter, it provides a consistent way to arrive at the sought for Hamiltonian description. It is important to bear in mind that Dirac’s method guarantees that this formulation describes precisely the dynamics given by the Euler-Lagrange equations.

There are other possible ways to handle singular Lagrangian systems. An interesting one, formulated in a geometric language in stark contrast with that of Dirac (see, however, [7]), was developed by Gotay, Nester and Hinds (GNH) [8, 9]. There the emphasis was on the geometrical meaning of the constraints and the consistency requirements, which were phrased as tangency conditions. The most important difference between the Dirac and GNH points of view is that Dirac’s method provides a description in the full phase space of the theory under consideration whereas the GNH approach gives a formulation on the primary constraint submanifold M0M_{0}. A relevant consequence of working with these different descriptions is that, although we have the canonical symplectic form in phase space with a simple expression in terms of conjugate variables, on M0M_{0} we are usually forced to work with a complicated, presymplectic form. This notwithstanding, it is sometimes possible to find new variables in terms of which this presymplectic form is simple. In fact, the Ashtekar formulation for GR can by found in this way.

Despite the conceptual clarity that the GNH method provides, it must be said that it is almost as hard to implement as Dirac’s algorithm. At this point, it is important to understand what the main sources of difficulties are in both approaches. In Dirac’s method, the conditions that fix the value of the Dirac multipliers (collectively denoted as uu) are linear, inhomogeneous equations of the form A⋅u=BA \cdot u = B where the matrix AA generically depends on the canonical variables and, hence, has a rank that also depends on them. In practice, at least in the examples that we will consider here, the form of the solutions obtained by solving these equations directly is very complicated. This precludes an easy interpretation of their solutions, makes it difficult to simplify them by using the constraints and, as a consequence, to carry out some necessary consistency checks. Something similar happens if one uses the GNH method. In this case, the most difficult step is the resolution of the equations for the components of the Hamiltonian vector fields that, ultimately, contain the information on the dynamics of the system. Also, as in Dirac’s case, if these solutions are not appropriately simplified by using the available constraints, checking the consistency requirements (i.e., the tangency of the Hamiltonian vector field to the full constraint submanifold) becomes a hard and unforgiving task.

In this paper we will consider a parametric family of actions for Euclidean and Lorentzian GR that includes the Cartan-Palatini and the Holst ones as well as their Carrollian (c→0c \to0) limit. These actions are written in terms of differential forms and lead to first order field equations. These two facts suggest a different approach to find the corresponding Hamiltonian descriptions. On one hand, as many differential forms operators interact neatly with pullbacks, it is straightforward to rewrite the field equations in 3+13 + 1 form once a suitable foliation of space time is introduced. On the other, the fact that the equations are first order naturally leads to “projected equations” in 3+13 + 1 form, that must be the same as those obtained by the more complicated Dirac or GNH methods. For this reason, the main part of the paper will be a unified, concise, streamlined—but complete—derivation of the Hamiltonian description for all these models.

A very important tool for our analysis will be Cartan geometry because it provides a conceptual framework that illuminates the meaning of the geometric objects in terms of which our actions are written (interesting discussions about the applications of Cartan geometry to the interpretation and understanding of gravity theories in three and four dimensions can be found in [10, 11]). It also tells us a big deal about the structure of the Hamiltonian vector fields and their interpretation, especially with regard to the symmetries of the dynamics. In fact, the insights gained by relying on Cartan geometry can also be used to simplify the computations if the Dirac or GNH methods are employed.

The paper is organized as follows. After this introduction, we review in § 2 the main geometric ideas that we use in the paper. § 3 is devoted to discuss the family of actions that we study, their symmetries and the equations of motion in covariant (i.e. spacetime) form. The geometric ideas discussed in § 2 play a relevant role here. § 4 is devoted to find the Hamiltonian formulation for these actions by introducing a spacetime foliation and an appropriate projection procedure. The implementation of the time gauge and the introduction of Ashtekar variables is the purpose of § 5. § 6 provides a discussion on how the ideas of Cartan geometry can be used to facilitate the computations if the Dirac or GNH approaches are followed. We will not give too many details but we will provide the crucial information to complete the Hamiltonian analysis in these frameworks. We end the paper with our conclusions and some comments in § 7. Auxiliary material has been compiled in the appendices, in particular, our notation and some useful mathematical results are explained in Appendix § 9. Some results on top-forms, frame dualities and the simplification of the field equations are given in Appendix § 10.

Cartan Geometry

General properties of a Cartan geometry

Let GG be a Lie group and H≤GH \leq G a closed subgroup, with corresponding Lie algebras h≤g\mathfrak{h} \leq\mathfrak{g}. A Cartan geometry of type (G,H)(G,H) on a smooth manifold MM [11, 12] is a principal HH-bundle

πP:P→M\pi_P : P \to M

endowed with a g\mathfrak{g}-valued one-form

ω∈Ω1(P,g),\omega\in\Omega^1(P,\mathfrak{g}),

called the Cartan connection, satisfying the following axioms:

C1: HH-equivariance:

(Rh)∗ω=Ad⁡(h−1)ω,∀h∈H;(R_h)^*\omega= \operatorname{Ad}(h^{-1})\omega,\qquad\forall h \in H;

C2: Reproduction of fundamental vector fields:

ω(X∗)=X,∀X∈h,\omega(X^*) = X,\qquad\forall X \in\mathfrak{h},

where X∗X^* denotes the fundamental vector field on PP generated by XX, namely

X∗(p)=ddt∣t=0pexp⁡(tX);X^*(p) = \left.\frac{\mathrm{d}}{\mathrm{d}t}\right|_{t=0}p\exp(tX);

C3: Absolute parallelism: for every p∈Pp \in P, the linear map

ωp:TpP→g\omega_p : T_pP \to\mathfrak{g}

is an isomorphism with inverse ωp−1:g→TpP\omega_p^{-1} : \mathfrak{g} \to T_pP. Notice that

TphRh−1∘ωph−1=ωp−1∘Ad⁡(h)∀h∈H,∀p∈P;T_{ph}R_{h^{-1}} \circ\omega_{ph}^{-1} = \omega_p^{-1} \circ\operatorname{Ad}(h)\qquad\forall h \in H,\qquad\forall p \in P;

The homogeneous model of a Cartan geometry of type (G,H)(G,H) is the canonical principal bundle

H→G→G/HH \to G \to G/H

endowed with the left Maurer–Cartan form

ωG∈Ω1(G,g).\omega_G \in\Omega^1(G,\mathfrak{g}).

Thus, the homogeneous model of a Cartan geometry of type (G,H)(G,H) is precisely the corresponding Klein geometry [12].

The Cartan connection ω\omega of (H→P→M,ω)(H \to P \to M,\omega) generalizes the Maurer–Cartan form on GG and, in particular, provides a natural parallelization of PP

TP→ ω P×g.TP \xrightarrow{\ \omega\ } P \times\mathfrak{g}.

More explicitly,

P×g∋(p,X)↦ωp−1(X)∈TP,TP∋v↦(πP(v),ω(v))∈P×g.P \times\mathfrak{g} \ni(p,X) \mapsto\omega_p^{-1}(X) \in TP,\qquad TP \ni v \mapsto(\pi_P(v),\omega(v)) \in P \times\mathfrak{g}.

and then, the vertical subbundle Ver⁡pP⊂TP\operatorname{Ver}_pP \subset TP is defined by

Ver⁡pP=ωp−1(h).\operatorname{Ver}_pP=\omega_p^{-1}(\mathfrak{h}).

Notice, however that, in general ω\omega does not provide an HH-invariant definition of Hor⁡pP\operatorname{Hor}_pP (this is only true for the reductive geometries discussed below). Moreover, for each X∈gX \in\mathfrak{g}, one defines the associated constant vector field

ω−1(X)∈X(P)\omega^{-1}(X) \in\mathfrak{X}(P)

by

p↦ωp−1(X).p \mapsto\omega_p^{-1}(X).

This vector field satisfies

ω(ω−1(X))=X,\omega(\omega^{-1}(X))=X,

where XX is regarded as a constant g\mathfrak{g}-valued function on PP, and

(Rh)∗ω−1(X)=ω−1(Ad⁡(h−1)X).(R_h)_*\omega^{-1}(X)=\omega^{-1}(\operatorname{Ad}(h^{-1})X).

Notice that, when X∈hX \in\mathfrak{h}, ω−1(X)=X∗\omega^{-1}(X)=X^* are just the fundamental (vertical) vector fields on PP.

In the homogeneous model

(H→G→G/H,ωG),(H \to G \to G/H,\omega_G),

one recovers

ωG−1(X)=LX,\omega_G^{-1}(X)=L_X,

where LXL_X denotes the left-invariant vector field on GG generated by XX.

Two (G,H)(G,H)-Cartan geometries (H→P1→M1,ω1)(H \to P_1 \to M_1,\omega_1) and (H→P2→M2,ω2)(H \to P_2 \to M_2,\omega_2) are isomorphic if and only if there exists a diffeomorphism f:M1→M2f:M_1 \to M_2 covered by a HH-bundle isomorphism f~:P1→P2\widetilde{f}:P_1 \to P_2 such that f~∗ω2=ω1\widetilde{f}^{*}\omega_2=\omega_1.

A (G,H)(G,H)-Cartan geometry is called reductive is there exists a Ad⁡H\operatorname{Ad}H-module decomposition

g=h⊕m\mathfrak{g}=\mathfrak{h}\oplus\mathfrak{m}

i.e., Ad⁡(h)(m)⊆m\operatorname{Ad}(h)(\mathfrak{m}) \subseteq\mathfrak{m} for all h∈Hh \in H [13]. For reductive geometries, due to the Ad⁡(H)\operatorname{Ad}(H)-invariance,

Hor⁡p(P)=ωp−1(m).\operatorname{Hor}_p(P)=\omega_p^{-1}(\mathfrak{m}).

At the infinitesimal level, this implies the bracket relations [h,h]⊆h[\mathfrak{h},\mathfrak{h}] \subseteq\mathfrak{h} and [h,m]⊆m[\mathfrak{h},\mathfrak{m}] \subseteq\mathfrak{m}.

If, in addition, the reductive geometry satisfies

[h,h]⊂h,[h,m]⊂m,[m,m]⊂h[\mathfrak{h},\mathfrak{h}] \subset\mathfrak{h},\qquad[\mathfrak{h},\mathfrak{m}] \subset\mathfrak{m},\qquad[\mathfrak{m},\mathfrak{m}] \subset\mathfrak{h}

then it is called symmetric. Many interesting examples in relativity—though not all—are symmetric. In the symmetric case, the linear map θ:g→g\theta:\mathfrak{g}\to\mathfrak{g} defined by

θ(Xh+Xm)=Xh−Xm,\theta(X_{\mathfrak{h}}+X_{\mathfrak{m}})=X_{\mathfrak{h}}-X_{\mathfrak{m}},

for Xh∈hX_{\mathfrak{h}}\in\mathfrak{h} and Xm∈mX_{\mathfrak{m}}\in\mathfrak{m}, is a Lie algebra involution of g\mathfrak{g}. One has h={X∈g:θ(X)=X}\mathfrak{h}=\{X\in\mathfrak{g}:\theta(X)=X\} and m={X∈g:θ(X)=−X}\mathfrak{m}=\{X\in\mathfrak{g}:\theta(X)=-X\}. Under mild assumptions on (G,H)(G,H), it can be shown that θ=Teσ\theta=T_e\sigma, where σ\sigma is an involutive automorphism of order two of GG, although typically not an inner automorphism, as illustrated in the examples given below. In any case, the infinitesimal definition in the Lie algebra recovers the standard geometric definition.

Cartan geometry in GR

We discuss now the Cartan geometries most commonly used in GR. Let 1+n1+n be the spacetime dimension and Λ\Lambda the value of the cosmological constant. For each κ=2Λ(n−1)(n−2)∈R\kappa=\frac{2\Lambda}{(n-1)(n-2)}\in\mathbb{R} let us define the Lie group GκG_\kappa by

Gκ={O++(1,n+1)if κ>0,O++(1,n)⋉R1,nif κ=0,O++(2,n)if κ<0.G_\kappa= \begin{cases} O^{++}(1,n+1) & \text{if }\kappa>0,\\ O^{++}(1,n)\ltimes\mathbb{R}^{1,n} & \text{if }\kappa=0,\\ O^{++}(2,n) & \text{if }\kappa<0. \end{cases}

and Hκ≤GκH_\kappa\leq G_\kappa with Hκ≃O++(1,n)H_\kappa\simeq O^{++}(1,n), embedded in the natural way dictated by the algebra described below. Its Lie algebra gκ=h⊕mκ\mathfrak{g}_\kappa=\mathfrak{h}\oplus\mathfrak{m}_\kappa, where h=o(1,n)\mathfrak{h}=\mathfrak{o}(1,n), can be described in terms of matrices of the form

gκ=h⊕mκ∋(000X)+(0−κxtηx0),X∈o(1,n),x∈R1,n,\mathfrak{g}_\kappa=\mathfrak{h}\oplus\mathfrak{m}_\kappa\ni \begin{pmatrix} 0 & 0\\ 0 & X \end{pmatrix} + \begin{pmatrix} 0 & -\kappa x^t\eta\\ x & 0 \end{pmatrix}, \qquad X\in\mathfrak{o}(1,n),\quad x\in\mathbb{R}^{1,n},

with the Lie bracket

References

  1. [1]P. A. M. Dirac, The Theory of Gravitation in Hamiltonian Form, Proc. R. Soc. Lond. A Math. Phys. Sci. 246 (1958) 333DOI
  2. [2]R. L. Arnowitt, S. Deser and C. W. Misner, The Dynamics of general relativity, in Gravitation: An Introduction to Current Research, L. Witten Ed., John Wiley & Sons (New York, London), (1962) Chapter 7, 227–265.
  3. [3]R. L. Arnowitt, S. Deser and C. W. Misner, The Dynamics of general relativity, Gen. Rel. Grav. 40 (2008) 1997
  4. [4]A. Ashtekar, New Variables for Classical and Quantum Gravity, Phys. Rev. Lett. 57 (1986) 2244pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/10033673
  5. [5]A. Ashtekar, New Hamiltonian Formulation of General Relativity, Phys. Rev. D 36 (1987) 1587pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/9958340
  6. [6]P. A. M. Dirac Lectures on Quantum Mechanics (New York: Dover) 2001.
  7. [7]J. F. Barbero G., B. Díaz, J. Margalef-Bentabol and E. J. S. Villaseñor, Dirac’s algorithm in the presence of boundaries: a practical guide to a geometric approach, Class. Quant. Grav. 36 (2019) 205014
  8. [8]M. J. Gotay, J. M. Nester and G. Hinds, Presymplectic Manifolds and the Dirac–Bergmann Theory of Constraints, J. Math. Phys. 19 (1978) 2388DOI
  9. [9]M. J. Gotay, Presymplectic Manifolds, Geometric Constraint Theory and the Dirac-Bergmann Theory of Constraints, Ph.D. thesis, Center for Theoretical Physics of the University of Maryland, 1979.
  10. [10]D. K. Wise, Symmetric space Cartan connections and gravity in three and four dimensions, SIGMA 5 (2009) 080DOI
  11. [11]D. K. Wise, MacDowell-Mansouri gravity and Cartan geometry, Class. Quant. Grav. 27 (2010) 155010DOI
  12. [12]R. W. Sharpe, Differential geometry: Cartan’s generalization of Klein’s Erlangen program, vol. 166, Springer Science & Business Media, 2000.
  13. [13]J.-H. Eschenburg Lecture Notes on Symmetric Spaces, University of Augsburg
  14. [14]D. S. Freed, Classical Chern-Simons theory. Part 1, Adv. Math. 113 (1995) 237
  15. [15]C. Tejero Prieto, Variational formulation of Chern-Simons theory for arbitrary Lie groups, J. Geom. Phys. 50 (2004) 138DOI
  16. [16]J. Figueroa-O’Farrill, E. Have, S. Prohazka, and J. Salzer, The gauging procedure and Carrollian gravity, JHEP, 09 (2022) 243
  17. [17]J. Margalef-Bentabol and E. J. S. Villaseñor, Geometric formulation of the Covariant Phase Space methods with boundaries, Phys. Rev. D 103 (2021) 025011
  18. [18]J. Margalef-Bentabol and E. J. S. Villaseñor, Proof of the equivalence of the symplectic forms derived from the canonical and the covariant phase space formalism, Phys. Rev. D 105 (2022) L101701
  19. [19]J. Margalef-Bentabol, Towards general relativity through parametrized theories, Ph.D. thesis (2018), Universidad Carlos III de Madrid
  20. [20]N. Barros e Sá, Hamiltonian analysis of general relativity with the Immirzi parameter, Int. J. Mod. Phys. D 10 (2001) 261DOI
  21. [21]S. Alexandrov, SO(4, C) covariant Ashtekar-Barbero gravity and the Immirzi parameter, Class. Quant. Grav. 17 (2000) 4255DOI
  22. [22]J. F. Barbero G., B. Díaz, J. Margalef-Bentabol and E. J. S. Villaseñor, Concise symplectic formulation for tetrad gravity, Phys. Rev. D 103 (2021) 024051
  23. [23]J. F. Barbero G., J. Margalef-Bentabol, V. Varo and E. J. S. Villaseñor, From Holst to Carroll Gravity: a Hamiltonian point of view, Phys. Rev. D 114 (2026) 065024DOI
  24. [24]J. F. Barbero G, M. Basquens, V. Varo and E. J. S. Villaseñor, Three Roads to the Geometric Constraint Formulation of Gravitational Theories with Boundaries, Symmetry 13 (2021) 1430DOI
  25. [25]J. F. Barbero G., B. Díaz, J. Margalef-Bentabol and E. J. S. Villaseñor, Hamiltonian Gotay-Nester-Hinds analysis of the parametrized unimodular extension of the Holst action, Phys. Rev. D 103 (2021) 064062
  26. [26]J. F. Barbero G., M. Basquens and E. J. S. Villaseñor, Euclidean self-dual gravity: Ashtekar variables without gauge fixing, Phys. Rev. D 109 (2024) 064047
  27. [27]S. Capriotti, Dirac constraints in field theoryand exterior differential systems, J. Geom. Mech. 2(1) (2010) 1DOI
  28. [28]A. Ashtekar, Lectures on nonperturbative canonical gravity, World Scientific (1991)
  29. [29]P. Peldán, Actions for gravity, with generalizations: A Review, Class. Quant. Grav. 11 (1994) 1087DOI
  30. [30]S. Sengupta, Hamiltonian form of Carroll gravity, Phys. Rev. D 107 (2023) 024010DOI

Paper details

vlnc:W_k45v597x
Version
v1 · latest
Published
Fresh — added to the Hub within the last 30 days
Added
License
CC BY 4.0
Usage

views · 0

downloads · 0

A view counts once per browser per day, a download each time the PDF is requested.

  • Physics and Astronomy

Not recorded for this paper

View statement
Looking for related papers…
Contents