Introduction
The Ryu–Takayanagi (RT) formula translates the entanglement entropy of a boundary region into the area of a bulk minimal surface [1 , 2 ] . On a static bulk slice, the bit-thread formulation replaces this minimal surface by a maximal flow [3 , 4 ] ,
S ( A ) = max v ∫ A v i n i d A E , ∇ i E v i = 0 , ∣ v ∣ E ≤ 1 4 G N , (1) S(A) = \max_{v} \int_A v^i n_i \, dA_E, \qquad\nabla^E_i v^i = 0, \qquad|v|_E \le\frac{1}{4G_N}, \tag*{(1)} S ( A ) = v max ∫ A v i n i d A E , ∇ i E v i = 0 , ∣ v ∣ E ≤ 4 G N 1 , (1)
where the metric, norm, and area element in this expression are in the Einstein frame. Conservation makes the flux invariant under deformations among homologous cuts, while the norm bound limits the entropy flux through each unit area. The RT surface is the bottleneck at which the maximal flow saturates this bound. This formulation has led to geometric constructions of holographic flows [5 ] and direct proofs of entropy inequalities [3 , 6 ] , as well as extensions to thermal states [7 , 8 ] .
The flow v i v^i v i , however, is normally introduced as the dual variable of a convex optimization problem. Its integral curves may be represented as threads, but the variational problem by itself does not identify a spacetime charge or a physical object whose equations of motion select those curves. A stringy realization should therefore answer two separate questions. First, what fixes the local entropy capacity that appears in the norm bound? Second, can a current carried by physical strings realize a maximal flow and reproduce entanglement entropy?
Our previous work identified the spatial projection of the Kalb–Ramond string charge density with an entropy flow and used it to reproduce black hole entropies in three- and ten-dimensional backgrounds [9 , 10 , 11 ] . For certain extremal black holes, Tseytlin [12 ] obtained the entropy microscopically by counting string oscillator states in a conformal sigma model. A subsequent construction related the string-frame capacity to the genus-zero off-shell closed string action and exhibited stationary on-shell F1 flows for black hole entropy [13 ] . The present paper addresses the corresponding interval problem. We construct explicit families of on-shell F1 worldsheets in the A d S 3 \mathrm{AdS}_3 AdS 3 vacuum and in planar BTZ, derive their spacetime currents directly from the F1 source action, and show that their spatial projections reproduce the vacuum and thermal entanglement entropies of a single C F T 2 \mathrm{CFT}_2 CFT 2 interval. The probe limit is used throughout: the F1 embeddings solve their complete worldsheet equations in fixed background fields, while their backreaction is neglected. The previous string and worldsheet based analyses of entanglement and black hole entropy include Refs. [14 , 15 , 16 , 17 , 18 , 19 , 20 ] .
We briefly recall the string-frame normalization obtained in [13 ] . At genus zero and two-derivative order, the regulated closed-string sphere gives the Euclidean curvature term [16 , 17 ]
I c l o s e d = − 1 16 π G N ( 3 ) ∫ d 3 x g e − 2 ϕ R [ g ] . (2) I_{\mathrm{closed}}=-\frac{1}{16\pi G_N^{(3)}}\int\mathrm{d}^3x\sqrt{g}e^{-2\phi}R[g]. \tag*{(2)} I closed = − 16 π G N ( 3 ) 1 ∫ d 3 x g e − 2 ϕ R [ g ] . (2)
For a replica cone of opening angle 2 π n 2\pi n 2 π n around a curve m m m , the singular curvature gives [21 ]
( I n − n I 1 ) ∣ t i p = ( n − 1 ) ∫ m ρ S d A S + O ( ( n − 1 ) 2 ) , ρ S = e − 2 ϕ 0 4 G N ( 3 ) , (3) \left.(I_n-nI_1)\right|_{\mathrm{tip}}=(n-1)\int_m \rho_S \mathrm{d}A_S+O\left((n-1)^2\right),\qquad\rho_S=\frac{e^{-2\phi_0}}{4G_N^{(3)}}, \tag*{(3)} ( I n − n I 1 ) ∣ tip = ( n − 1 ) ∫ m ρ S d A S + O ( ( n − 1 ) 2 ) , ρ S = 4 G N ( 3 ) e − 2 ϕ 0 , (3)
for constant ϕ = ϕ 0 \phi=\phi_0 ϕ = ϕ 0 . The smooth NS–NS matter terms do not add a localized tip contribution at this order. The Brown–Henneaux central charge, expressed in the string frame, is [22 ]
c = 3 ℓ A d S 2 G e f f ( 3 ) = 6 ρ S ℓ A d S , G e f f ( 3 ) = G N ( 3 ) e 2 ϕ 0 . (4) c=\frac{3\ell_{\mathrm{AdS}}}{2G_{\mathrm{eff}}^{(3)}}=6\rho_S\ell_{\mathrm{AdS}},\qquad G_{\mathrm{eff}}^{(3)}=G_N^{(3)}e^{2\phi_0}. \tag*{(4)} c = 2 G eff ( 3 ) 3 ℓ AdS = 6 ρ S ℓ AdS , G eff ( 3 ) = G N ( 3 ) e 2 ϕ 0 . (4)
The replica construction and flow–cut duality then give [3 , 4 , 13 , 23 ]
S A ( 0 ) = min m ∼ A r e g ∫ m ρ S d A S = max v Φ A [ v ] , ∇ i v i = 0 , ∣ v ∣ ≤ ρ S , (5) S_A^{(0)}=\min_{m\sim A_{\mathrm{reg}}}\int_m\rho_S\mathrm{d}A_S=\max_v\Phi_A[v],\qquad\nabla_i v^i=0,\qquad|v|\leq\rho_S, \tag*{(5)} S A ( 0 ) = m ∼ A reg min ∫ m ρ S d A S = v max Φ A [ v ] , ∇ i v i = 0 , ∣ v ∣ ≤ ρ S , (5)
where all geometric quantities in the last expression are defined using the spatial string-frame metric. This closed string result fixes the capacity. The on-shell F1 current fixes a physical direction for the entropy flow.
Our first result concerns the vacuum interval A = ( − R , R ) A=(-R,R) A = ( − R , R ) in Poincare A d S 3 \mathrm{AdS}_3 AdS 3 . We obtain a one-parameter family of F1 worldsheets whose time-zero profiles obey
( x − R ) 2 + ( z − z 0 ) 2 = z 0 2 (6) (x-R)^2+(z-z_0)^2=z_0^2 \tag*{(6)} ( x − R ) 2 + ( z − z 0 ) 2 = z 0 2 (6)
The worldsheets satisfy both the embedding equations, including the Kalb–Ramond force, and the worldsheet metric constraints. We select an ensemble of strings whose spatial profiles at t = 0 t=0 t = 0 intersect the regulated RT surface at equal intervals of proper length along the surface. We then coarse-grain the discrete F1 current and project it onto the t = 0 t=0 t = 0 slice. We normalize the projected string charge density to have norm ρ S \rho_S ρ S within the string bundle. The resulting flow is conserved and equals ρ S \rho_S ρ S times the oriented unit normal along the entire regulated RT surface. It therefore attains the maximal flux,
S A ( 0 ) = Φ A = 2 ρ S ℓ A d S arc cosh R ε = c 3 log 2 R ε + O ( ε 2 R 2 ) . (7) S_A^{(0)}=\Phi_A=2\rho_S\ell_{\mathrm{AdS}}\operatorname{arc\,cosh}\frac{R}{\varepsilon}=\frac{c}{3}\log\frac{2R}{\varepsilon}+O\left(\frac{\varepsilon^2}{R^2}\right). \tag*{(7)} S A ( 0 ) = Φ A = 2 ρ S ℓ AdS arc cosh ε R = 3 c log ε 2 R + O ( R 2 ε 2 ) . (7)
This gives the standard vacuum interval entropy [24 , 25 ] directly from physical F1 probes.
Classical string propagation in BTZ, including probes in the NS–NS background, has been studied in Refs. [26 , 27 ] . We next construct the corresponding worldsheets in planar BTZ for an interval A = ( x 1 , x 2 ) A=(x_1,x_2) A = ( x 1 , x 2 ) of length L A L_A L A . The full embedding, its current, and the string spacing are derived independently in the thermal coordinates. On the t B = 0 t_B=0 t B = 0 slice, the normalized F1 current again saturates the RT surface normally. Its regulated flux is 2 ρ S ℓ A d S U β , ε 2\rho_S\ell_{\mathrm{AdS}}U_{\beta,\varepsilon} 2 ρ S ℓ AdS U β , ε , and the continuum limit gives [25 ]
S A ( 0 ) = Φ β , A = c 3 log [ β π ε sinh π L A β ] + o ( 1 ) . (8) S_A^{(0)}=\Phi_{\beta,A}=\frac{c}{3}\log\left[\frac{\beta}{\pi\varepsilon}\sinh\frac{\pi L_A}{\beta}\right]+o(1). \tag*{(8)} S A ( 0 ) = Φ β , A = 3 c log [ π ε β sinh β π L A ] + o ( 1 ) . (8)
We verify that the complete thermal worldsheet and spacetime current reduce to the vacuum construction as β → ∞ \beta\to\infty β → ∞ . For L A / β → ∞ L_A/\beta\to\infty L A / β → ∞ , the entropy slope approaches
∂ S A ( 0 ) ∂ L A ∣ β ⟶ π c 3 β = ρ S ℓ A d S z h , (9) \left.\frac{\partial S_A^{(0)}}{\partial L_A}\right|_{\beta}\longrightarrow\frac{\pi c}{3\beta}=\frac{\rho_S\ell_{\mathrm{AdS}}}{z_h}, \tag*{(9)} ∂ L A ∂ S A ( 0 ) β ⟶ 3 β π c = z h ρ S ℓ AdS , (9)
which is the BTZ horizon entropy per unit boundary length [2 , 28 ] .
These explicit solutions reveal additional information that is not contained in the value of the RT entropy. In the pure NS–NS background, the F1 profiles starting on A A A reach only a bounded part B h i t ⊂ A ‾ B_{\mathrm{hit}}\subset\overline{A} B hit ⊂ A of the regulated complement, even though their flux computes the entropy of the reduced state on A A A , which is defined using the full complement. To understand this feature, we vary the NS–NS fraction η \eta η in a classical mixed-flux background [29 , 30 ] . The F1 equation selects the stationary profile
θ η ( r ) = θ h + ℓ A d S r h log ( 1 + η ) r D η ( r ) + η r h , D η 2 ( r ) = ( 1 − η 2 ) r 2 + η 2 r h 2 . (10) \theta_\eta(r)=\theta_h+\frac{\ell_{\mathrm{AdS}}}{r_h}\log\frac{(1+\eta)r}{D_\eta(r)+\eta r_h},\qquad D_\eta^2(r)=(1-\eta^2)r^2+\eta^2r_h^2. \tag*{(10)} θ η ( r ) = θ h + r h ℓ AdS log D η ( r ) + η r h ( 1 + η ) r , D η 2 ( r ) = ( 1 − η 2 ) r 2 + η 2 r h 2 . (10)
At η = 0 \eta=0 η = 0 , the strings follow the geodesics normal to the RT surface, as in the bit-thread construction [5 , 7 , 8 ] . At η = 1 \eta=1 η = 1 , Eq. (10) becomes the pure NS–NS profile and all complementary cutoff contacts lie on one side.
In vacuum, writing ϑ = arc tanh η \vartheta=\operatorname{arc\,tanh}\eta ϑ = arc tanh η and U ε = arc cosh ( R / ε ) U_\varepsilon=\operatorname{arc\,cosh}(R/\varepsilon) U ε = arc cosh ( R / ε ) , the fraction of the entropy flux reaching the left complement is
Φ L S A ( 0 ) = [ U ε − ϑ ] + 2 U ε , η c r i t = tanh U ε = 1 − ε 2 R 2 . (11) \frac{\Phi_L}{S_A^{(0)}}=\frac{[U_\varepsilon-\vartheta]_+}{2U_\varepsilon},\qquad\eta_{\mathrm{crit}}=\tanh U_\varepsilon=\sqrt{1-\frac{\varepsilon^2}{R^2}}. \tag*{(11)} S A ( 0 ) Φ L = 2 U ε [ U ε − ϑ ] + , η crit = tanh U ε = 1 − R 2 ε 2 . (11)
Thus the F1 dynamics predict the precise finite-cutoff threshold at which the left flux vanishes.
In planar BTZ, we identify which strings connect the two exteriors by where they cross the regulated RT surface on the time-zero slice. We denote the crossing coordinate by θ h \theta_h θ h , the signed proper distance from the midpoint of the RT surface in units of ℓ A d S \ell_{\mathrm{AdS}} ℓ AdS . The string ensemble spans θ h ∈ [ − U , U ] \theta_h \in[-U,U] θ h ∈ [ − U , U ] , where U = U β , ϵ U = U_{\beta,\epsilon} U = U β , ϵ . For 0 ≤ η < 1 0 \le\eta< 1 0 ≤ η < 1 , the strings that connect the two exteriors are those with − d − ϑ < θ h < d − ϑ -d-\vartheta< \theta_h < d-\vartheta − d − ϑ < θ h < d − ϑ , where d = L A / ( 2 z h ) d = L_A/(2z_h) d = L A / ( 2 z h ) . Their signed flux through the BTZ bifurcation line is therefore proportional to the length of the overlap:
Φ h o r n e t = ρ S ℓ A d S Length ( [ − U , U ] ∩ [ − d − ϑ , d − ϑ ] ) . (12) \Phi_{\mathrm{hor}}^{\mathrm{net}} = \rho_S \ell_{\mathrm{AdS}}\operatorname{Length}\left([-U,U] \cap[-d-\vartheta,d-\vartheta]\right). \tag*{(12)} Φ hor net = ρ S ℓ AdS Length ( [ − U , U ] ∩ [ − d − ϑ , d − ϑ ] ) . (12)
When U ≥ d + ϑ U \ge d+\vartheta U ≥ d + ϑ , this becomes
Φ h o r n e t = 2 d ρ S ℓ A d S = s t h L A = π c L A 3 β . (13) \Phi_{\mathrm{hor}}^{\mathrm{net}} = 2d\rho_S\ell_{\mathrm{AdS}} = s_{\mathrm{th}}L_A = \frac{\pi c L_A}{3\beta}. \tag*{(13)} Φ hor net = 2 d ρ S ℓ AdS = s th L A = 3 β π c L A . (13)
At fixed cutoff the overlap in Eq. (12) eventually shrinks to zero as η \eta η increases. At the pure NS–NS point, the net horizon flux vanishes although the interval entropy and thermal entropy density are unchanged. Some F1 profiles enter the second exterior and return, and their two bifurcation-line crossings have opposite orientations and cancel in the signed string charge, while each profile crosses the interval RT surface only once. This exhibits the main distinction between the entropy and its physical F1 realization: the RT surface fixes the total maximal flux, whereas the worldsheet dynamics determine where that flux is routed.
Finally, we clarify two aspects of this interpretation. First, a positive reweighting of the string ensemble over the same range of RT crossing points changes the Kalb–Ramond charge density and the density of cutoff contacts, but in the pure NS–NS construction it does not change the normalized entropy flow or its maximal flux. Second, B h i t B_{\mathrm{hit}} B hit characterizes the support of one particular F1 maximizer. In other words, it is not the subsystem traced out in the definition of ρ A \rho_A ρ A . Indeed, in the vacuum we exhibit an interval C 0 C_0 C 0 outside B h i t B_{\mathrm{hit}} B hit for which
I ( 0 ) ( A : C 0 ) = c 3 log 16 9 > 0. (14) I^{(0)}(A:C_0) = \frac{c}{3}\log\frac{16}{9} > 0. \tag*{(14)} I ( 0 ) ( A : C 0 ) = 3 c log 9 16 > 0. (14)
Thus the absence of F1 contacts from this maximizer does not imply the absence of leading boundary correlations.
The paper is organized as follows. In § 2 , we review the F1 worldsheet equations, the Kalb–Ramond current, and its conserved spatial projection. § 3 constructs the vacuum worldsheets and derives the vacuum interval entropy. § 4 repeats the construction independently in planar BTZ, derives the thermal interval entropy, and checks the vacuum and long-interval limits. § 5 studies the mixed-flux family and derives the vacuum routing threshold and the net horizon flux. § 6 summarizes the results and discusses string reweighting, cutoff contacts, and their relation to the boundary reduced state.
Worldsheet equations and the spatial F1 current
In this paper, we consider Poincare AdS3 _3 3 and planar BTZ supported by pure NS–NS flux, with constant dilaton ϕ = ϕ 0 \phi= \phi_0 ϕ = ϕ 0 [28 , 31 , 32 ] . We first summarize how an on-shell F1 probe defines the spatial current used below.
We work in the probe limit, keeping g a b g_{ab} g ab , B a b B_{ab} B ab , and ϕ \phi ϕ fixed. The F1 sources therefore do not backreact on the background at the order considered. The action for one F1 probe is [33 , 34 , 35 ]
S F 1 = − 1 4 π α ′ ∫ d 2 σ ( − γ γ m n ∂ m X a ∂ n X b g a b + ϵ m n ∂ m X a ∂ n X b B a b ) , (15) S_{\mathrm{F1}}=-\frac{1}{4\pi\alpha'}\int d^2\sigma\left(\sqrt{-\gamma}\gamma^{mn}\partial_mX^a\partial_nX^b g_{ab}+\epsilon^{mn}\partial_mX^a\partial_nX^b B_{ab}\right), \tag*{(15)} S F1 = − 4 π α ′ 1 ∫ d 2 σ ( − γ γ mn ∂ m X a ∂ n X b g ab + ϵ mn ∂ m X a ∂ n X b B ab ) , (15)
where γ m n \gamma_{mn} γ mn is the worldsheet metric and γ \gamma γ its determinant. We choose ϵ τ σ = + 1 \epsilon^{\tau\sigma}=+1 ϵ τ σ = + 1 , with B B B specified in each background. In conformal gauge, variation of the F1 action with respect to X a X^a X a gives the embedding equations
E a − H b c a ∂ τ X b ∂ σ X c = 0 , (16) \mathcal{E}^a-H^a_{\ bc}\partial_\tau X^b\partial_\sigma X^c=0, \tag*{(16)} E a − H b c a ∂ τ X b ∂ σ X c = 0 , (16)
where
E a = − ∂ τ 2 X a + ∂ σ 2 X a + Γ b c a ( − ∂ τ X b ∂ τ X c + ∂ σ X b ∂ σ X c ) . (17) \mathcal{E}^a=-\partial_\tau^2X^a+\partial_\sigma^2X^a+\Gamma^a_{\ bc}\left(-\partial_\tau X^b\partial_\tau X^c+\partial_\sigma X^b\partial_\sigma X^c\right). \tag*{(17)} E a = − ∂ τ 2 X a + ∂ σ 2 X a + Γ b c a ( − ∂ τ X b ∂ τ X c + ∂ σ X b ∂ σ X c ) . (17)
The independent worldsheet-metric equation also imposes
g a b ∂ τ X a ∂ σ X b = 0 , g_{ab}\partial_\tau X^a\partial_\sigma X^b=0, g ab ∂ τ X a ∂ σ X b = 0 ,
g a b ( ∂ τ X a ∂ τ X b + ∂ σ X a ∂ σ X b ) = 0. (18) g_{ab}\left(\partial_\tau X^a\partial_\tau X^b+\partial_\sigma X^a\partial_\sigma X^b\right)=0. \tag*{(18)} g ab ( ∂ τ X a ∂ τ X b + ∂ σ X a ∂ σ X b ) = 0. (18)
For N \mathcal{N} N strings, variation of the total Kalb–Ramond coupling defines the normalized source current in the convention of Refs. [9 , 13 ]
δ B S F 1 = − 1 4 π α ′ ∫ d 3 x − g j a b δ B a b , \delta_B S_{\mathrm{F1}}=-\frac{1}{4\pi\alpha'}\int d^3x\sqrt{-g}\,j^{ab}\delta B_{ab}, δ B S F1 = − 4 π α ′ 1 ∫ d 3 x − g j ab δ B ab ,
j a b ( x ) = 1 − g ∑ k = 1 N ∫ d τ d σ ϵ m n ∂ m X k a ∂ n X k b δ ( 3 ) ( x − X k ( τ , σ ) ) . (19) j^{ab}(x)=\frac{1}{\sqrt{-g}}\sum_{k=1}^{\mathcal{N}}\int d\tau d\sigma\,\epsilon^{mn}\partial_mX_k^a\partial_nX_k^b\delta^{(3)}\left(x-X_k(\tau,\sigma)\right). \tag*{(19)} j ab ( x ) = − g 1 k = 1 ∑ N ∫ d τ d σ ϵ mn ∂ m X k a ∂ n X k b δ ( 3 ) ( x − X k ( τ , σ ) ) . (19)
The current is conserved in the bulk, ∇ a j a b = 0 \nabla_a j^{ab}=0 ∇ a j ab = 0 , for worldsheets without interior endpoints.
With vanishing shift, let N A D M N_{\mathrm{ADM}} N ADM be the lapse and n μ = ( − N A D M , 0 , 0 ) n_\mu=(-N_{\mathrm{ADM}},0,0) n μ = ( − N ADM , 0 , 0 ) the future-directed unit normal covector to a constant-time slice. Its spatial current is
q μ = − n ν j ν μ , q 0 = 0 , q i = N A D M j 0 i . (20) q^\mu=-n_\nu j^{\nu\mu},\qquad q^0=0,\qquad q^i=N_{\mathrm{ADM}}j^{0i}. \tag*{(20)} q μ = − n ν j ν μ , q 0 = 0 , q i = N ADM j 0 i . (20)
Since − g = N A D M h \sqrt{-g}=N_{\mathrm{ADM}}\sqrt{h} − g = N ADM h and j 00 = 0 j^{00}=0 j 00 = 0 , the time component of bulk current conservation gives
0 = ∂ i ( − g j i 0 ) = − ∂ i ( h q i ) . (21) 0=\partial_i\left(\sqrt{-g}j^{i0}\right)=-\partial_i\left(\sqrt{h}q^i\right). \tag*{(21)} 0 = ∂ i ( − g j i 0 ) = − ∂ i ( h q i ) . (21)
Thus ∇ i q i = 0 \nabla_iq^i=0 ∇ i q i = 0 on each slice, including when j i j ≠ 0 j^{ij}\ne0 j ij = 0 .
In both interval calculations, ∣ q ∣ |q| ∣ q ∣ is constant and nonzero inside the bundle on the slice used to compute the entropy. We then use the constant rescaling
v p h y s i = ρ s q ^ i = ρ S ∣ q ∣ q i , (22) v_{\mathrm{phys}}^i=\rho s\hat{q}^i=\frac{\rho S}{|q|}q^i, \tag*{(22)} v phys i = ρ s q ^ i = ∣ q ∣ ρS q i , (22)
on the bundle, with zero flow outside. This preserves conservation and saturates the norm bound inside the bundle.
Single-interval entanglement entropy from physical F1 sources
In this section, we compute the leading entanglement entropy of a single interval in the C F T 2 \mathrm{CFT}_2 CFT 2 vacuum using on-shell F1 probes in Poincare A d S 3 \mathrm{AdS}_3 AdS 3 . We first construct a family of F1 worldsheets and choose an ensemble whose intersections with the regulated RT surface are equally spaced in proper length. We then coarse-grain the discrete string current, project it onto a constant-time slice, and evaluate the spatial current at t = 0 t=0 t = 0 . Finally, we normalize this current using the string-frame entropy capacity and show that the resulting flow saturates the flux bound on the RT surface, reproducing the standard vacuum single-interval entropy.
Physical F1 strings in Poincare AdS3
Now, we consider the boundary interval A = ( − R , R ) A=(-R,R) A = ( − R , R ) at t = 0 t=0 t = 0 in the string-frame background
d s A d S 2 = ℓ A d S 2 z 2 ( − d t 2 + d x 2 + d z 2 ) , B = − ℓ A d S 2 z 2 d t ∧ d x , ϕ = ϕ 0 , (23) ds_{\mathrm{AdS}}^2=\frac{\ell_{\mathrm{AdS}}^2}{z^2}\left(-dt^2+dx^2+dz^2\right),\qquad B=-\frac{\ell_{\mathrm{AdS}}^2}{z^2}dt\wedge dx,\qquad\phi=\phi_0, \tag*{(23)} d s AdS 2 = z 2 ℓ AdS 2 ( − d t 2 + d x 2 + d z 2 ) , B = − z 2 ℓ AdS 2 d t ∧ d x , ϕ = ϕ 0 , (23)
where ℓ A d S \ell_{\mathrm{AdS}} ℓ AdS is the AdS radius and z > 0 z>0 z > 0 . In particular,
H = d B = 2 ℓ A d S 2 z 3 d t ∧ d x ∧ d z , H t x z = 2 ℓ A d S 2 z 3 . (24) H=dB=\frac{2\ell_{\mathrm{AdS}}^2}{z^3}dt\wedge dx\wedge dz,\qquad H_{txz}=\frac{2\ell_{\mathrm{AdS}}^2}{z^3}. \tag*{(24)} H = d B = z 3 2 ℓ AdS 2 d t ∧ d x ∧ d z , H t x z = z 3 2 ℓ AdS 2 . (24)
To construct a simple family centered on the right endpoint ( 0 , R , 0 ) (0,R,0) ( 0 , R , 0 ) of the interval, we introduce the dimensionless worldsheet coordinates
τ = t z , σ = R − x z . (25) \tau=\frac{t}{z},\qquad\sigma=\frac{R-x}{z}. \tag*{(25)} τ = z t , σ = z R − x . (25)
This ansatz reduces the three embedding functions t ( τ , σ ) t(\tau,\sigma) t ( τ , σ ) , x ( τ , σ ) x(\tau,\sigma) x ( τ , σ ) and z ( τ , σ ) z(\tau,\sigma) z ( τ , σ ) to the one undetermined function z ( τ , σ ) z(\tau,\sigma) z ( τ , σ ) :
t = τ z , x = R − σ z . (26) t=\tau z,\qquad x=R-\sigma z. \tag*{(26)} t = τ z , x = R − σ z . (26)
The differentials give
d t = z d τ + τ d z , d x = − z d σ − σ d z . (27) dt=z\,d\tau+\tau\,dz,\qquad dx=-z\,d\sigma-\sigma\,dz. \tag*{(27)} d t = z d τ + τ d z , d x = − z d σ − σ d z . (27)
Substituting this gauge into d s A d S 2 ds_{\mathrm{AdS}}^2 d s AdS 2 , its induced line element is
d s w s 2 = ℓ A d S 2 ( − d τ 2 + d σ 2 + D z d z + D z 2 d z 2 ) . (28) ds_{\mathrm{ws}}^2=\ell_{\mathrm{AdS}}^2\left(-d\tau^2+d\sigma^2+\frac{\mathcal{D}}{z}dz+\frac{\mathcal{D}}{z^2}dz^2\right). \tag*{(28)} d s ws 2 = ℓ AdS 2 ( − d τ 2 + d σ 2 + z D d z + z 2 D d z 2 ) . (28)
where D ≡ 1 + σ 2 − τ 2 \mathcal{D} \equiv1+\sigma^2-\tau^2 D ≡ 1 + σ 2 − τ 2 . The last two terms can be rewritten as
d D z d z + D z 2 d z 2 = d z z 2 d ( D z ) . (29) \frac{d\mathcal{D}}{z}dz+\frac{\mathcal{D}}{z^2}dz^2=\frac{dz}{z^2}d(\mathcal{D}z). \tag*{(29)} z d D d z + z 2 D d z 2 = z 2 d z d ( D z ) . (29)
We select the nonconstant branch with a flat induced metric,
d s w s 2 = ℓ A d S 2 ( − d τ 2 + d σ 2 ) , (30) ds_{\mathrm{ws}}^2=\ell_{\mathrm{AdS}}^2(-d\tau^2+d\sigma^2), \tag*{(30)} d s ws 2 = ℓ AdS 2 ( − d τ 2 + d σ 2 ) , (30)
This is a convenient conformal-gauge solution of the worldsheet metric constraints. The embedding equations must still be checked independently. On the branch d z ≠ 0 dz\ne0 d z = 0 , the required cancellation is equivalent to
d ( D z ) = 0 (31) d(\mathcal{D}z)=0 \tag*{(31)} d ( D z ) = 0 (31)
Writing the positive integration constant as 2 z 0 2z_0 2 z 0 , so that D z = 2 z 0 \mathcal{D}z=2z_0 D z = 2 z 0 , and restricting to z 0 > 0 z_0>0 z 0 > 0 and D > 0 \mathcal{D}>0 D > 0 , we obtain
X t ( τ , σ ) = 2 z 0 τ D , X x ( τ , σ ) = R − 2 z 0 σ D , X z ( τ , σ ) = 2 z 0 D . (32) X^t(\tau,\sigma)=\frac{2z_0\tau}{\mathcal{D}},\qquad X^x(\tau,\sigma)=R-\frac{2z_0\sigma}{\mathcal{D}},\qquad X^z(\tau,\sigma)=\frac{2z_0}{\mathcal{D}}. \tag*{(32)} X t ( τ , σ ) = D 2 z 0 τ , X x ( τ , σ ) = R − D 2 z 0 σ , X z ( τ , σ ) = D 2 z 0 . (32)
The conditions z 0 > 0 z_0>0 z 0 > 0 and D > 0 \mathcal{D}>0 D > 0 place the solution in the Poincare patch z > 0 z>0 z > 0 . This verifies the constraints in Eq. (18) . Choosing the Weyl representative in which the independent metric equals the induced metric gives
γ m n = g a b ∂ m X a ∂ n X b = ℓ A d S 2 diag ( − 1 , 1 ) , − det γ = ℓ A d S 2 , − γ γ m n = diag ( − 1 , 1 ) . (33) \gamma_{mn}=g_{ab}\partial_mX^a\partial_nX^b=\ell_{\mathrm{AdS}}^2\operatorname{diag}(-1,1),\qquad
\sqrt{-\det\gamma}=\ell_{\mathrm{AdS}}^2,\qquad
\sqrt{-\gamma}\gamma^{mn}=\operatorname{diag}(-1,1). \tag*{(33)} γ mn = g ab ∂ m X a ∂ n X b = ℓ AdS 2 diag ( − 1 , 1 ) , − det γ = ℓ AdS 2 , − γ γ mn = diag ( − 1 , 1 ) . (33)
To identify the target space surface swept out by this embedding, use Eq. (26) :
t 2 = τ 2 z 2 , ( x − R ) 2 = σ 2 z 2 . (34) t^2=\tau^2z^2,\qquad(x-R)^2=\sigma^2z^2. \tag*{(34)} t 2 = τ 2 z 2 , ( x − R ) 2 = σ 2 z 2 . (34)
Combining them and adding z 2 z^2 z 2 to both sides gives
( x − R ) 2 + z 2 − t 2 = z 2 ( 1 + σ 2 − τ 2 ) . (35) (x-R)^2+z^2-t^2=z^2(1+\sigma^2-\tau^2). \tag*{(35)} ( x − R ) 2 + z 2 − t 2 = z 2 ( 1 + σ 2 − τ 2 ) . (35)
Using (32) , we have
( x − R ) 2 + z 2 − t 2 = 2 z 0 z . (36) (x-R)^2+z^2-t^2=2z_0z. \tag*{(36)} ( x − R ) 2 + z 2 − t 2 = 2 z 0 z . (36)
Equivalently,
( x − R ) 2 + ( z − z 0 ) 2 − t 2 = z 0 2 , (37) (x-R)^2+(z-z_0)^2-t^2=z_0^2, \tag*{(37)} ( x − R ) 2 + ( z − z 0 ) 2 − t 2 = z 0 2 , (37)
This equation is the target space image of the string worldsheet described by t ( τ , σ ) t(\tau,\sigma) t ( τ , σ ) , x ( τ , σ ) x(\tau,\sigma) x ( τ , σ ) and z ( τ , σ ) z(\tau,\sigma) z ( τ , σ ) .
Now, we can check whether this configuration (32) satisfies the complete F1 equations (16) and reproduces (37) . Substituting the solution (32) ,
X t ( τ , σ ) ≡ t ( τ , σ ) = 2 z 0 τ D , X x ( τ , σ ) ≡ x ( τ , σ ) = R − 2 z 0 σ D , X z ( τ , σ ) ≡ z ( τ , σ ) = 2 z 0 D , (38) X^t(\tau,\sigma)\equiv t(\tau,\sigma)=\frac{2z_0\tau}{\mathcal{D}},\qquad X^x(\tau,\sigma)\equiv x(\tau,\sigma)=R-\frac{2z_0\sigma}{\mathcal{D}},\qquad X^z(\tau,\sigma)\equiv z(\tau,\sigma)=\frac{2z_0}{\mathcal{D}}, \tag*{(38)} X t ( τ , σ ) ≡ t ( τ , σ ) = D 2 z 0 τ , X x ( τ , σ ) ≡ x ( τ , σ ) = R − D 2 z 0 σ , X z ( τ , σ ) ≡ z ( τ , σ ) = D 2 z 0 , (38)
into the equations of motion E a − H b c a ∂ τ X b ∂ σ X c \mathcal{E}^{a}-H^{a}_{\ bc}\partial_{\tau}X^{b}\partial_{\sigma}X^{c} E a − H b c a ∂ τ X b ∂ σ X c , we find
E a − H b c a ∂ τ X b ∂ σ X c = − 2 z z 0 ( t , x − R , z − z 0 ) a + 2 z z 0 ( t , x − R , z − z 0 ) a = 0. (39) \mathcal{E}^{a}-H^{a}_{\ bc}\partial_{\tau}X^{b}\partial_{\sigma}X^{c}=-\frac{2z}{z_{0}}(t,x-R,z-z_{0})^{a}+\frac{2z}{z_{0}}(t,x-R,z-z_{0})^{a}=0. \tag*{(39)} E a − H b c a ∂ τ X b ∂ σ X c = − z 0 2 z ( t , x − R , z − z 0 ) a + z 0 2 z ( t , x − R , z − z 0 ) a = 0. (39)
The embedding therefore satisfies the complete F1 equations and the worldsheet metric constraints. Moreover, at t = 0 t=0 t = 0 , we have
( x − R ) 2 + ( z − z 0 ) 2 = z 0 2 , (40) (x-R)^{2}+(z-z_{0})^{2}=z_{0}^{2}, \tag*{(40)} ( x − R ) 2 + ( z − z 0 ) 2 = z 0 2 , (40)
which is a circle tangent to the ideal boundary at ( R , 0 ) (R,0) ( R , 0 ) . The same family of curves appears in the geometric construction of maximal flows in Ref. [6 ] . In this paper, it arises as the time-zero section of on-shell F1 worldsheets. The RT surface is [1 , 2 ]
γ A : x 2 + z 2 = R 2 . (41) \gamma_{A}: \qquad x^{2}+z^{2}=R^{2}. \tag*{(41)} γ A : x 2 + z 2 = R 2 . (41)
At their intersection in the bulk, Eq. (35) implies z 0 z = R ( R − x ) z_{0}z=R(R-x) z 0 z = R ( R − x ) . Their Euclidean normal vectors obey
( x , z ) ⋅ ( x − R , z − z 0 ) = R 2 − R x − z 0 z = 0. (42) (x,z)\cdot(x-R,z-z_{0})=R^{2}-Rx-z_{0}z=0. \tag*{(42)} ( x , z ) ⋅ ( x − R , z − z 0 ) = R 2 − R x − z 0 z = 0. (42)
Since the spatial string-frame metric is conformal to d x 2 + d z 2 dx^{2}+dz^{2} d x 2 + d z 2 , the curves also intersect orthogonally in the physical metric.
The physical string current and vacuum interval entropy
To define the spacing between adjacent strings, we use a geometric regulator that keeps the ideal endpoints ± R \pm R ± R fixed and truncates their surface at z = ε z=\varepsilon z = ε :
a ε = R 2 − ε 2 < R , A ε = { z = ε , − a ε ≤ x ≤ a ε } , 0 < ε < R . (43) a_{\varepsilon}=\sqrt{R^{2}-\varepsilon^{2}}<R,\qquad A_{\varepsilon}=\{z=\varepsilon,\ -a_{\varepsilon}\le x\le a_{\varepsilon}\},\qquad0<\varepsilon<R. \tag*{(43)} a ε = R 2 − ε 2 < R , A ε = { z = ε , − a ε ≤ x ≤ a ε } , 0 < ε < R . (43)
At t = 0 t=0 t = 0 , each string attached to A ε A_{\varepsilon} A ε satisfies (36) :
( x − R ) 2 + ε 2 = 2 z 0 ε . (44) (x-R)^{2}+\varepsilon^{2}=2z_{0}\varepsilon. \tag*{(44)} ( x − R ) 2 + ε 2 = 2 z 0 ε . (44)
Thus, the string passing through the cutoff point x x x has integration constant
z 0 ( x ) = ( x − R ) 2 + ε 2 2 ε . (45) z_{0}(x)=\frac{(x-R)^{2}+\varepsilon^{2}}{2\varepsilon}. \tag*{(45)} z 0 ( x ) = 2 ε ( x − R ) 2 + ε 2 . (45)
Using a ε 2 + ε 2 = R 2 a_{\varepsilon}^{2}+\varepsilon^{2}=R^{2} a ε 2 + ε 2 = R 2 , we have
z 0 , min = ( R − a ε ) 2 + ε 2 2 ε = R ( R − a ε ) ε , z 0 , max = ( R + a ε ) 2 + ε 2 2 ε = R ( R + a ε ) ε . (46) \begin{aligned}
z_{0,\min} &=\frac{(R-a_{\varepsilon})^{2}+\varepsilon^{2}}{2\varepsilon}=\frac{R(R-a_{\varepsilon})}{\varepsilon},\\
z_{0,\max} &=\frac{(R+a_{\varepsilon})^{2}+\varepsilon^{2}}{2\varepsilon}=\frac{R(R+a_{\varepsilon})}{\varepsilon}. \tag*{(46)}
\end{aligned} z 0 , m i n z 0 , m a x = 2 ε ( R − a ε ) 2 + ε 2 = ε R ( R − a ε ) , = 2 ε ( R + a ε ) 2 + ε 2 = ε R ( R + a ε ) . (46)
The endpoint values determine the logarithmic size of the range:
z 0 , max z 0 , min = R + a ε R − a ε = ( R + a ε ) 2 ε 2 , (47) \frac{z_{0,\max}}{z_{0,\min}}=\frac{R+a_{\varepsilon}}{R-a_{\varepsilon}}=\frac{(R+a_{\varepsilon})^{2}}{\varepsilon^{2}}, \tag*{(47)} z 0 , m i n z 0 , m a x = R − a ε R + a ε = ε 2 ( R + a ε ) 2 , (47)
due to ( R − a ε ) ( R + a ε ) = R 2 − a ε 2 = ε 2 (R-a_{\varepsilon})(R+a_{\varepsilon})=R^2-a_{\varepsilon}^2=\varepsilon^2 ( R − a ε ) ( R + a ε ) = R 2 − a ε 2 = ε 2 . Therefore, we can define the notation
U ε ≡ 1 2 log z 0 , max z 0 , min = log R + R 2 − ε 2 ε = arc cosh R ε . (48) U_{\varepsilon}\equiv\frac{1}{2}\log\frac{z_{0,\max}}{z_{0,\min}}=\log\frac{R+\sqrt{R^2-\varepsilon^2}}{\varepsilon}=\operatorname{arc\,cosh}\frac{R}{\varepsilon}. \tag*{(48)} U ε ≡ 2 1 log z 0 , m i n z 0 , m a x = log ε R + R 2 − ε 2 = arc cosh ε R . (48)
Since z 0 , min z 0 , max = R 2 z_{0,\min}z_{0,\max}=R^2 z 0 , m i n z 0 , m a x = R 2 , the endpoints can equivalently be expressed as
z 0 , min = R e − U ε , z 0 , max = R e U ε . (49) z_{0,\min}=Re^{-U_{\varepsilon}},\qquad z_{0,\max}=Re^{U_{\varepsilon}}. \tag*{(49)} z 0 , m i n = R e − U ε , z 0 , m a x = R e U ε . (49)
Since R R R is the geometric mean of z 0 , min z_{0,\min} z 0 , m i n and z 0 , max z_{0,\max} z 0 , m a x , we use it as the reference scale for the dimensionless string label
u = log z 0 R , − U ε ≤ u ≤ U ε . (50) u=\log\frac{z_0}{R},\qquad-U_{\varepsilon}\leq u\leq U_{\varepsilon}. \tag*{(50)} u = log R z 0 , − U ε ≤ u ≤ U ε . (50)
Thus U ε U_{\varepsilon} U ε is the half-width of the allowed range of u u u . The F1 equations determine the string profile for each u u u . To form the ensemble, we choose equally spaced values of u u u . This places the intersections of the strings with the RT surface at equal intervals of proper length.
The RT surface and an F1 profile satisfy
R T : x 2 + z 2 = R 2 , F 1 : ( x − R ) 2 + z 2 = 2 z z 0 . (51) \mathrm{RT}:\quad x^2+z^2=R^2,\qquad\mathrm{F1}:\quad(x-R)^2+z^2=2zz_0. \tag*{(51)} RT : x 2 + z 2 = R 2 , F1 : ( x − R ) 2 + z 2 = 2 z z 0 . (51)
Solving Eqs. (36) and (41) at t = 0 t=0 t = 0 gives the bulk intersection of the F1 string profile with the RT surface:
x = R R 2 − z 0 2 R 2 + z 0 2 , z = 2 R 2 z 0 R 2 + z 0 2 . (52) x=R\frac{R^2-z_0^2}{R^2+z_0^2},\qquad z=\frac{2R^2z_0}{R^2+z_0^2}. \tag*{(52)} x = R R 2 + z 0 2 R 2 − z 0 2 , z = R 2 + z 0 2 2 R 2 z 0 . (52)
Substituting z 0 = R e u z_0=Re^u z 0 = R e u , we obtain
x = − R tanh u , z = R sech u . (53) x=-R\tanh u,\qquad z=R\operatorname{sech}u. \tag*{(53)} x = − R tanh u , z = R sech u . (53)
Since d x 2 + d z 2 = R 2 sech 2 u d u 2 = z 2 d u 2 dx^2+dz^2=R^2\operatorname{sech}^2u\,du^2=z^2du^2 d x 2 + d z 2 = R 2 sech 2 u d u 2 = z 2 d u 2 , the proper line element along the RT curve is
d A S = ℓ A d S z d x 2 + d z 2 = ℓ A d S z R 2 sech 2 u d u 2 = ℓ A d S ∣ d u ∣ . (54) dA_S=\frac{\ell_{\mathrm{AdS}}}{z}\sqrt{dx^2+dz^2}=\frac{\ell_{\mathrm{AdS}}}{z}\sqrt{R^2\operatorname{sech}^2u\,du^2}=\ell_{\mathrm{AdS}}|du|. \tag*{(54)} d A S = z ℓ AdS d x 2 + d z 2 = z ℓ AdS R 2 sech 2 u d u 2 = ℓ AdS ∣ d u ∣. (54)
Thus, the equal spacing in u u u gives equal proper spacing along the RT curve. This parallels the BTZ construction in our previous work [13 ] , where equal angular spacing gives equal proper spacing along the horizon. Based on this observation, we can follow the notation of the angular separation θ s = 2 π / N \theta_s=2\pi/N θ s = 2 π / N in the BTZ case and define the separation between adjacent strings by
u s = 2 U ε N . (55) u_s=\frac{2U_{\varepsilon}}{N}. \tag*{(55)} u s = N 2 U ε . (55)
Divide [ − U ε , U ε ] [-U_{\varepsilon},U_{\varepsilon}] [ − U ε , U ε ] into N N N equal cells and place one string at the midpoint of each cell:
u k = − U ε + ( k + 1 2 ) u s , k = 0 , … , N − 1. (56) u_k=-U_{\varepsilon}+\left(k+\frac{1}{2}\right)u_s,\qquad k=0,\ldots,N-1. \tag*{(56)} u k = − U ε + ( k + 2 1 ) u s , k = 0 , … , N − 1. (56)
The corresponding integration constants are
z 0 , k = R e u k = z 0 , min exp [ ( k + 1 2 ) u s ] . (57) z_{0,k}=Re^{u_k}=z_{0,\min}\exp\left[\left(k+\frac{1}{2}\right)u_s\right]. \tag*{(57)} z 0 , k = R e u k = z 0 , m i n exp [ ( k + 2 1 ) u s ] . (57)
and the adjacent strings satisfy
log z 0 , k + 1 z 0 , k = u s . (58) \log\frac{z_{0,k+1}}{z_{0,k}} = u_s . \tag*{(58)} log z 0 , k z 0 , k + 1 = u s . (58)
The regulator selects this ensemble through its intersections with A ε A_{\varepsilon} A ε at t = 0 t=0 t = 0 . Each u k u_k u k is then a fixed label of a complete on-shell worldsheet at all times. Figure 1 shows the limiting values of z 0 z_0 z 0 at the two cutoff endpoints and how midpoint sampling gives equal proper spacing between F1 crossings along the regulated RT surface.
Figure 1. The regulated vacuum RT surface in Poincaré AdS3 _3 3 at t = 0 t=0 t = 0 is shown on the left and unfolded onto the arclength ruler on the right. The left and right cutoff endpoints map to + U ε +U_{\varepsilon} + U ε and − U ε -U_{\varepsilon} − U ε , corresponding to z 0 , max z_{0,\max} z 0 , m a x and z 0 , min z_{0,\min} z 0 , m i n , respectively. The dots on the ruler mark F1 crossings at the cell midpoints. The same two adjacent crossings are highlighted in gold in both panels. Their label separation u s u_s u s corresponds to a proper distance ℓ A d S u s \ell_{\mathrm{AdS}}u_s ℓ AdS u s along the surface.
We now return to the normalized current of N \mathcal{N} N equally oriented strings:
j a b ( x ) = 1 − g ∑ k = 0 N − 1 ∫ d τ d σ ( ∂ τ X k a ∂ σ X k b − ∂ σ X k a ∂ τ X k b ) δ ( 3 ) ( x − X k ) . (59) j^{ab}(x)=\frac{1}{\sqrt{-g}}\sum_{k=0}^{\mathcal{N}-1}\int d\tau d\sigma\left(\partial_\tau X_k^a\partial_\sigma X_k^b-\partial_\sigma X_k^a\partial_\tau X_k^b\right)\delta^{(3)}(x-X_k). \tag*{(59)} j ab ( x ) = − g 1 k = 0 ∑ N − 1 ∫ d τ d σ ( ∂ τ X k a ∂ σ X k b − ∂ σ X k a ∂ τ X k b ) δ ( 3 ) ( x − X k ) . (59)
This source current comes entirely from the Kalb–Ramond coupling and is independent of the chosen Weyl representative of the auxiliary worldsheet metric. To simplify this current, we recall the embedding (32) , before restricting to t = 0 t=0 t = 0 :
X k t = 2 z 0 , k τ D , X k x = R − 2 z 0 , k σ D , X k z = 2 z 0 , k D , D = 1 + σ 2 − τ 2 > 0. (60) X_k^t=\frac{2z_{0,k}\tau}{D},\qquad X_k^x=R-\frac{2z_{0,k}\sigma}{D},\qquad X_k^z=\frac{2z_{0,k}}{D},\qquad D=1+\sigma^2-\tau^2>0. \tag*{(60)} X k t = D 2 z 0 , k τ , X k x = R − D 2 z 0 , k σ , X k z = D 2 z 0 , k , D = 1 + σ 2 − τ 2 > 0. (60)
The inverse map of the embedding family is
τ ∗ = t z , σ ∗ = R − x z , u = log Δ A 2 R z , (61) \tau_*=\frac{t}{z},\qquad\sigma_*=\frac{R-x}{z},\qquad u=\log\frac{\Delta_A}{2Rz}, \tag*{(61)} τ ∗ = z t , σ ∗ = z R − x , u = log 2 R z Δ A , (61)
where Δ A = ( x − R ) 2 + z 2 − t 2 \Delta_A=(x-R)^2+z^2-t^2 Δ A = ( x − R ) 2 + z 2 − t 2 is a spacetime function. On the k k k th worldsheet, Δ A = 2 z 0 , k z \Delta_A=2z_{0,k}z Δ A = 2 z 0 , k z , so the inverse map returns u = u k = log ( z 0 , k / R ) u=u_k=\log(z_{0,k}/R) u = u k = log ( z 0 , k / R ) . The quantities τ ∗ \tau_* τ ∗ and σ ∗ \sigma_* σ ∗ are the worldsheet coordinates of the event ( t , x , z ) (t,x,z) ( t , x , z ) on that string. The target space delta distribution of (59) fixes τ = τ ∗ \tau=\tau_* τ = τ ∗ and σ = σ ∗ \sigma=\sigma_* σ = σ ∗ . Allowing u u u to vary between different members of the family, and using z 0 = R e u z_0=Re^u z 0 = R e u and z = 2 z 0 / D z=2z_0/D z = 2 z 0 / D , we have
d z z = d u − d D D . (62) \frac{dz}{z}=du-\frac{dD}{D}. \tag*{(62)} z d z = d u − D d D . (62)
Combining with Eq. (26) gives
d t = z d τ + τ d z , d x = − z d σ − σ d z . (63) dt = z\,d\tau+ \tau\,dz,\qquad dx = -z\,d\sigma- \sigma\,dz. \tag*{(63)} d t = z d τ + τ d z , d x = − z d σ − σ d z . (63)
or equivalently,
d t ∧ d x ∧ d z = − z 2 d τ ∧ d σ ∧ d z = − z 3 d τ ∧ d σ ∧ d u . (64) dt \wedge dx \wedge dz = -z^{2}d\tau\wedge d\sigma\wedge dz = -z^{3}d\tau\wedge d\sigma\wedge du. \tag*{(64)} d t ∧ d x ∧ d z = − z 2 d τ ∧ d σ ∧ d z = − z 3 d τ ∧ d σ ∧ d u . (64)
Therefore the absolute Jacobian is z 3 z^{3} z 3 , and the target space delta distribution becomes
δ ( 3 ) ( x − X k ) = 1 z 3 δ ( τ − τ ∗ ) δ ( σ − σ ∗ ) δ ( u − u k ) . (65) \delta^{(3)}(x-X_k) = \frac{1}{z^{3}}\delta(\tau-\tau_{*})\delta(\sigma-\sigma_{*})\delta(u-u_k). \tag*{(65)} δ ( 3 ) ( x − X k ) = z 3 1 δ ( τ − τ ∗ ) δ ( σ − σ ∗ ) δ ( u − u k ) . (65)
Thus, the N \mathcal{N} N equally oriented strings can be simplified as
j a b = 1 − g z 3 ( ∂ τ X a ∂ σ X b − ∂ σ X a ∂ τ X b ) ∗ ∑ k = 0 N − 1 δ ( u − u k ) , (66) j^{ab} = \frac{1}{\sqrt{-g}z^{3}}\left(\partial_{\tau}X^{a}\partial_{\sigma}X^{b}-\partial_{\sigma}X^{a}\partial_{\tau}X^{b}\right)_{*}\sum_{k=0}^{\mathcal{N}-1}\delta(u-u_k), \tag*{(66)} j ab = − g z 3 1 ( ∂ τ X a ∂ σ X b − ∂ σ X a ∂ τ X b ) ∗ k = 0 ∑ N − 1 δ ( u − u k ) , (66)
where subscript ∗ * ∗ denotes that the worldsheet derivatives are taken at fixed u u u and then evaluated at ( τ ∗ , σ ∗ , u ( x ) ) (\tau_{*},\sigma_{*},u(x)) ( τ ∗ , σ ∗ , u ( x )) . Substituting the embedding solution (32) ,
∂ τ X t ∂ σ X x − ∂ σ X t ∂ τ X x = z 2 ( D − 2 ) D , \partial_{\tau}X^{t}\partial_{\sigma}X^{x}-\partial_{\sigma}X^{t}\partial_{\tau}X^{x}=\frac{z^{2}(\mathcal{D}-2)}{\mathcal{D}}, ∂ τ X t ∂ σ X x − ∂ σ X t ∂ τ X x = D z 2 ( D − 2 ) ,
∂ τ X t ∂ σ X z − ∂ σ X t ∂ τ X z = − 2 σ z 2 D , \partial_{\tau}X^{t}\partial_{\sigma}X^{z}-\partial_{\sigma}X^{t}\partial_{\tau}X^{z}=-\frac{2\sigma z^{2}}{\mathcal{D}}, ∂ τ X t ∂ σ X z − ∂ σ X t ∂ τ X z = − D 2 σ z 2 ,
∂ τ X x ∂ σ X z − ∂ σ X x ∂ τ X z = 2 τ z 2 D . (67) \partial_{\tau}X^{x}\partial_{\sigma}X^{z}-\partial_{\sigma}X^{x}\partial_{\tau}X^{z}=\frac{2\tau z^{2}}{\mathcal{D}}. \tag*{(67)} ∂ τ X x ∂ σ X z − ∂ σ X x ∂ τ X z = D 2 τ z 2 . (67)
Using Eq. (61) , D = Δ A / z 2 \mathcal{D}=\Delta_{A}/z^{2} D = Δ A / z 2 and − g = ℓ A d S 3 / z 3 \sqrt{-g}=\ell_{\mathrm{AdS}}^{3}/z^{3} − g = ℓ AdS 3 / z 3 , the nonvanishing discrete current becomes
j 0 x = z 2 [ ( x − R ) 2 − z 2 − t 2 ] ℓ A d S 3 Δ A ∑ k = 0 N − 1 δ ( u − u k ) , j^{0x}=\frac{z^{2}\left[(x-R)^{2}-z^{2}-t^{2}\right]}{\ell_{\mathrm{AdS}}^{3}\Delta_{A}}\sum_{k=0}^{\mathcal{N}-1}\delta(u-u_k), j 0 x = ℓ AdS 3 Δ A z 2 [ ( x − R ) 2 − z 2 − t 2 ] k = 0 ∑ N − 1 δ ( u − u k ) ,
j 0 z = 2 z 3 ( x − R ) ℓ A d S 3 Δ A ∑ k = 0 N − 1 δ ( u − u k ) , j^{0z}=\frac{2z^{3}(x-R)}{\ell_{\mathrm{AdS}}^{3}\Delta_{A}}\sum_{k=0}^{\mathcal{N}-1}\delta(u-u_k), j 0 z = ℓ AdS 3 Δ A 2 z 3 ( x − R ) k = 0 ∑ N − 1 δ ( u − u k ) ,
j x z = 2 t z 3 ℓ A d S 3 Δ A ∑ k = 0 N − 1 δ ( u − u k ) . (68) j^{xz}=\frac{2tz^{3}}{\ell_{\mathrm{AdS}}^{3}\Delta_{A}}\sum_{k=0}^{\mathcal{N}-1}\delta(u-u_k). \tag*{(68)} j x z = ℓ AdS 3 Δ A 2 t z 3 k = 0 ∑ N − 1 δ ( u − u k ) . (68)
Next, we need to coarse-grain the discrete sum. Since u u u is nonperiodic, we use ordinary delta functions and write
∑ k = 0 N − 1 δ ( u − u k ) = 1 u s [ u s ∑ k = 0 N − 1 δ ( u − u k ) ] = N 2 U ϵ [ u s ∑ k = 0 N − 1 δ ( u + U ϵ − ( k + 1 2 ) u s ) ] . (69) \begin{aligned}
\sum_{k=0}^{\mathcal{N}-1}\delta(u-u_k)=\frac{1}{u_s}\left[u_s\sum_{k=0}^{\mathcal{N}-1}\delta(u-u_k)\right] \\
&=\frac{\mathcal{N}}{2U_{\epsilon}}\left[u_s\sum_{k=0}^{\mathcal{N}-1}\delta\left(u+U_{\epsilon}-\left(k+\frac{1}{2}\right)u_s\right)\right]. \tag*{(69)}
\end{aligned} k = 0 ∑ N − 1 δ ( u − u k ) = u s 1 [ u s k = 0 ∑ N − 1 δ ( u − u k ) ] = 2 U ϵ N [ u s k = 0 ∑ N − 1 δ ( u + U ϵ − ( k + 2 1 ) u s ) ] . (69)
For a smooth test function f f f , the term in brackets satisfies
u s ∑ k = 0 N − 1 f ( u k ) ⟶ ∫ − U ε U ε f ( u ) d u , (70) u_s\sum_{k=0}^{\mathcal{N}-1} f(u_k) \longrightarrow\int_{-U_\varepsilon}^{U_\varepsilon} f(u)\,du, \tag*{(70)} u s k = 0 ∑ N − 1 f ( u k ) ⟶ ∫ − U ε U ε f ( u ) d u , (70)
by the midpoint Riemann-sum limit. Its coarse-grained value is therefore one inside the range of string labels. Consequently,
∑ k = 0 N − 1 δ ( u − u k ) ⟶ coarse-graining N 2 U ε , − U ε < u < U ε . (71) \sum_{k=0}^{\mathcal{N}-1}\delta(u-u_k)\mathop{\longrightarrow}^{\text{coarse-graining}} \frac{\mathcal{N}}{2U_\varepsilon}, \qquad-U_\varepsilon<u<U_\varepsilon. \tag*{(71)} k = 0 ∑ N − 1 δ ( u − u k ) ⟶ coarse-graining 2 U ε N , − U ε < u < U ε . (71)
Substituting this coarse-grained density into the discrete current gives the smooth current at general target-space time:
j 0 x = N z 2 [ ( x − R ) 2 − z 2 − t 2 ] 2 U ε ℓ A d S 3 Δ A , j 0 z = N z 3 ( x − R ) U ε ℓ A d S 3 Δ A , j x z = N t z 3 U ε ℓ A d S 3 Δ A , (72) j^{0x}=\frac{\mathcal{N}z^2\left[(x-R)^2-z^2-t^2\right]}{2U_\varepsilon\ell_{\mathrm{AdS}}^3\Delta_A}, \qquad
j^{0z}=\frac{\mathcal{N}z^3(x-R)}{U_\varepsilon\ell_{\mathrm{AdS}}^3\Delta_A}, \qquad
j^{xz}=\frac{\mathcal{N}tz^3}{U_\varepsilon\ell_{\mathrm{AdS}}^3\Delta_A}, \tag*{(72)} j 0 x = 2 U ε ℓ AdS 3 Δ A N z 2 [ ( x − R ) 2 − z 2 − t 2 ] , j 0 z = U ε ℓ AdS 3 Δ A N z 3 ( x − R ) , j x z = U ε ℓ AdS 3 Δ A N t z 3 , (72)
which hold for Δ A > 0 \Delta_A>0 Δ A > 0 and − U ε < u < U ε -U_\varepsilon<u<U_\varepsilon − U ε < u < U ε .
We now project onto a constant-t t t slice. The lapse and spatial metric are
N A D M = ℓ A d S z , h i j d x i d x j = ℓ A d S 2 z 2 ( d x 2 + d z 2 ) , h = ℓ A d S 2 z 2 . (73) N_{\mathrm{ADM}}=\frac{\ell_{\mathrm{AdS}}}{z}, \qquad
h_{ij}dx^idx^j=\frac{\ell_{\mathrm{AdS}}^2}{z^2}(dx^2+dz^2), \qquad
\sqrt{h}=\frac{\ell_{\mathrm{AdS}}^2}{z^2}. \tag*{(73)} N ADM = z ℓ AdS , h ij d x i d x j = z 2 ℓ AdS 2 ( d x 2 + d z 2 ) , h = z 2 ℓ AdS 2 . (73)
The future-directed unit normal has covariant components n μ = ( − ℓ A d S / z , 0 , 0 ) n_\mu=(-\ell_{\mathrm{AdS}}/z,0,0) n μ = ( − ℓ AdS / z , 0 , 0 ) . Thus
q μ = − n ν j ν μ , q 0 = 0 , q i = N A D M j 0 i , i = x , z , (74) q^\mu=-n_\nu j^{\nu\mu}, \qquad q^0=0, \qquad q^i=N_{\mathrm{ADM}}j^{0i}, \qquad i=x,z, \tag*{(74)} q μ = − n ν j ν μ , q 0 = 0 , q i = N ADM j 0 i , i = x , z , (74)
which yields
q x = N z [ ( x − R ) 2 − z 2 − t 2 ] 2 U ε ℓ A d S 2 Δ A , q z = N z 2 ( x − R ) U ε ℓ A d S 2 Δ A . (75) q^x=\frac{\mathcal{N}z\left[(x-R)^2-z^2-t^2\right]}{2U_\varepsilon\ell_{\mathrm{AdS}}^2\Delta_A}, \qquad
q^z=\frac{\mathcal{N}z^2(x-R)}{U_\varepsilon\ell_{\mathrm{AdS}}^2\Delta_A}. \tag*{(75)} q x = 2 U ε ℓ AdS 2 Δ A N z [ ( x − R ) 2 − z 2 − t 2 ] , q z = U ε ℓ AdS 2 Δ A N z 2 ( x − R ) . (75)
The current is conserved on every constant time slice:
∂ x ( h q x ) = − ∂ z ( h q z ) = 2 N z ( x − R ) U ε Δ A 2 , ∇ i q i = 0. (76) \partial_x\left(\sqrt{h}q^x\right)=-\partial_z\left(\sqrt{h}q^z\right)=\frac{2\mathcal{N}z(x-R)}{U_\varepsilon\Delta_A^2}, \qquad\nabla_iq^i=0. \tag*{(76)} ∂ x ( h q x ) = − ∂ z ( h q z ) = U ε Δ A 2 2 N z ( x − R ) , ∇ i q i = 0. (76)
Its norm at general time is
∣ q ∣ 2 = ℓ A d S 2 z 2 [ ( q x ) 2 + ( q z ) 2 ] = ( N 2 ℓ A d S U ε ) 2 [ ( x − R ) 2 − z 2 − t 2 ] 2 + 4 z 2 ( x − R ) 2 Δ A 2 = ( N 2 ℓ A d S U ε ) 2 ( 1 + 4 t 2 z 2 Δ A 2 ) , (77) \begin{aligned}
|q|^2&=\frac{\ell_{\mathrm{AdS}}^2}{z^2}\left[(q^x)^2+(q^z)^2\right]\\
&=\left(\frac{\mathcal{N}}{2\ell_{\mathrm{AdS}}U_\varepsilon}\right)^2
\frac{\left[(x-R)^2-z^2-t^2\right]^2+4z^2(x-R)^2}{\Delta_A^2}\\
&=\left(\frac{\mathcal{N}}{2\ell_{\mathrm{AdS}}U_\varepsilon}\right)^2\left(1+\frac{4t^2z^2}{\Delta_A^2}\right), \tag*{(77)}
\end{aligned} ∣ q ∣ 2 = z 2 ℓ AdS 2 [ ( q x ) 2 + ( q z ) 2 ] = ( 2 ℓ AdS U ε N ) 2 Δ A 2 [ ( x − R ) 2 − z 2 − t 2 ] 2 + 4 z 2 ( x − R ) 2 = ( 2 ℓ AdS U ε N ) 2 ( 1 + Δ A 2 4 t 2 z 2 ) , (77)
where the final equality uses
[ ( x − R ) 2 − z 2 − t 2 ] 2 + 4 z 2 ( x − R ) 2 = Δ A 2 + 4 t 2 z 2 . (78) \left[(x-R)^2-z^2-t^2\right]^2+4z^2(x-R)^2=\Delta_A^2+4t^2z^2. \tag*{(78)} [ ( x − R ) 2 − z 2 − t 2 ] 2 + 4 z 2 ( x − R ) 2 = Δ A 2 + 4 t 2 z 2 . (78)
Note that the ADM projection gives a spatial current on each constant-t t t slice, with t t t labeling the slice. Since the boundary interval A = ( − R , R ) A = (-R, R) A = ( − R , R ) is defined at t = 0 t = 0 t = 0 and its RT surface lies on the same slice, we now set t = 0 t = 0 t = 0 to compute the entropy flux. On this slice, the projected current has constant norm and crosses the RT surface orthogonally. We utilize the notation
D A ≡ Δ A ∣ t = 0 = ( x − R ) 2 + z 2 . (79) D_A \equiv\Delta_A|_{t=0} = (x-R)^2 + z^2. \tag*{(79)} D A ≡ Δ A ∣ t = 0 = ( x − R ) 2 + z 2 . (79)
The nonvanishing spatial charge density and its norm reduce to
q x = N z [ ( x − R ) 2 − z 2 ] 2 U ϵ ℓ A d S 2 D A , q z = N z 2 ( x − R ) U ϵ ℓ A d S 2 D A , ∣ q ∣ = N 2 ℓ A d S U ϵ . (80) q^x = \frac{\mathcal{N}z\left[(x-R)^2-z^2\right]}{2U_\epsilon\ell_{\mathrm{AdS}}^2D_A}, \qquad q^z = \frac{\mathcal{N}z^2(x-R)}{U_\epsilon\ell_{\mathrm{AdS}}^2D_A}, \qquad|q| = \frac{\mathcal{N}}{2\ell_{\mathrm{AdS}}U_\epsilon}. \tag*{(80)} q x = 2 U ϵ ℓ AdS 2 D A N z [ ( x − R ) 2 − z 2 ] , q z = U ϵ ℓ AdS 2 D A N z 2 ( x − R ) , ∣ q ∣ = 2 ℓ AdS U ϵ N . (80)
Figure 2 shows representative profiles of the regulated F1 bundle on the t = 0 t = 0 t = 0 slice and their crossings of the RT surface γ A \gamma_A γ A . Thus, the outward unit normal and proper line element on the cutoff are
Figure 2. The red curves are the t = 0 t = 0 t = 0 profiles ( x − R ) 2 + z 2 = 2 z 0 z (x-R)^2+z^2=2z_0z ( x − R ) 2 + z 2 = 2 z 0 z , sampled at equal intervals of u = log ( z 0 / R ) u=\log(z_0/R) u = log ( z 0 / R ) . They cross the RT surface γ A \gamma_A γ A (navy) orthogonally, with successive intersections equally spaced in proper length. The left panel enlarges the region around the interval and its RT surface. The right panel shows how the same profiles continue outside that region. Cyan marks the regulated interval A ϵ A_\epsilon A ϵ , and violet marks the part of its complement reached by the string bundle at z = ϵ z=\epsilon z = ϵ . Arrows indicate the F1 charge orientation from the complement toward A ϵ A_\epsilon A ϵ . The plot uses R = 1 R=1 R = 1 and ϵ / R = 0.25 \epsilon/R=0.25 ϵ / R = 0.25 .
n c u t = − ϵ ℓ A d S ∂ z , d A S = ℓ A d S ϵ d x . (81) n_{\mathrm{cut}}=-\frac{\epsilon}{\ell_{\mathrm{AdS}}}\partial_z,\qquad dA_S=\frac{\ell_{\mathrm{AdS}}}{\epsilon}dx. \tag*{(81)} n cut = − ℓ AdS ϵ ∂ z , d A S = ϵ ℓ AdS d x . (81)
The charge flux through the full regulated interval is therefore
Φ A [ q ] ≡ ∫ A ϵ q ⋅ n c u t d A S = N U ϵ ∫ − a ϵ a ϵ R − x ( R − x ) 2 + ϵ 2 d x = N 2 U ε log ( R + a ε ) 2 + ε 2 ( R − a ε ) 2 + ε 2 = N , (82) \begin{aligned}
\Phi_A[q]\equiv\int_{A_\epsilon}q\cdot n_{\mathrm{cut}}\,dA_S=\frac{\mathcal{N}}{U_\epsilon}\int_{-a_\epsilon}^{a_\epsilon}\frac{R-x}{(R-x)^2+\epsilon^2}\,dx \\
&= \frac{\mathcal{N}}{2U_{\varepsilon}}\log\frac{(R+a\varepsilon)^2+\varepsilon^2}{(R-a\varepsilon)^2+\varepsilon^2}=\mathcal{N}, \tag*{(82)}
\end{aligned} Φ A [ q ] ≡ ∫ A ϵ q ⋅ n cut d A S = U ϵ N ∫ − a ϵ a ϵ ( R − x ) 2 + ϵ 2 R − x d x = 2 U ε N log ( R − a ε ) 2 + ε 2 ( R + a ε ) 2 + ε 2 = N , (82)
where the last step follows from Eq. (48) .
Following our previous method [13 ] , we next define the unit-normalized spatial current inside the bundle by
q ^ i = q i ∣ q ∣ , q ^ = z ℓ A d S D A ( [ ( x − R ) 2 − z 2 ] ∂ x + 2 z ( x − R ) ∂ z ) . (83) \hat{q}^{i}=\frac{q^{i}}{|q|},\qquad\hat{q}=\frac{z}{\ell_{\mathrm{AdS}}D_{A}}\left(\left[(x-R)^2-z^2\right]\partial_x+2z(x-R)\partial_z\right). \tag*{(83)} q ^ i = ∣ q ∣ q i , q ^ = ℓ AdS D A z ( [ ( x − R ) 2 − z 2 ] ∂ x + 2 z ( x − R ) ∂ z ) . (83)
Since ∣ q ∣ |q| ∣ q ∣ is constant on this slice,
∣ q ^ ∣ = 1 , ∇ i q ^ i = ∇ i q i ∣ q ∣ = 0. (84) |\hat{q}|=1,\qquad\nabla_i\hat{q}^{i}=\frac{\nabla_iq^{i}}{|q|}=0. \tag*{(84)} ∣ q ^ ∣ = 1 , ∇ i q ^ i = ∣ q ∣ ∇ i q i = 0. (84)
Using Eqs. (82) and (48) , its flux is
Φ A [ q ^ ] = Φ A [ q ] ∣ q ∣ = 2 ℓ A d S U ε = 2 ℓ A d S arccosh R ε . (85) \Phi_A[\hat{q}]=\frac{\Phi_A[q]}{|q|}=2\ell_{\mathrm{AdS}}U_{\varepsilon}=2\ell_{\mathrm{AdS}}\operatorname{arccosh}\frac{R}{\varepsilon}. \tag*{(85)} Φ A [ q ^ ] = ∣ q ∣ Φ A [ q ] = 2 ℓ AdS U ε = 2 ℓ AdS arccosh ε R . (85)
Thus the normalized geometric flux is independent of N \mathcal{N} N . We now recall the string-frame norm bound obtained from the off-shell sphere and replica construction [13 ] ,
ρ S = e − 2 ϕ 0 4 G N ( 3 ) . (86) \rho_S=\frac{e^{-2\phi_0}}{4G_N^{(3)}}. \tag*{(86)} ρ S = 4 G N ( 3 ) e − 2 ϕ 0 . (86)
Since the dilaton is constant, ρ S \rho_S ρ S is constant. Combining this capacity with the unit current gives the physical entropy flow
v p h y s i ≡ ρ S q ^ i = ρ S q i ∣ q ∣ , v_{\mathrm{phys}}^{i}\equiv\rho_S\hat{q}^{i}=\rho_S\frac{q^{i}}{|q|}, v phys i ≡ ρ S q ^ i = ρ S ∣ q ∣ q i ,
v p h y s = ρ S z ℓ A d S D A ( [ ( x − R ) 2 − z 2 ] ∂ x + 2 z ( x − R ) ∂ z ) . (87) v_{\mathrm{phys}}=\frac{\rho_S z}{\ell_{\mathrm{AdS}}D_A}\left(\left[(x-R)^2-z^2\right]\partial_x+2z(x-R)\partial_z\right). \tag*{(87)} v phys = ℓ AdS D A ρ S z ( [ ( x − R ) 2 − z 2 ] ∂ x + 2 z ( x − R ) ∂ z ) . (87)
Consequently,
∇ i v p h y s i = ρ S ∇ i q ^ i = 0 , ∣ v p h y s ∣ = ρ S ∣ q ^ ∣ = ρ S , (88) \nabla_i v_{\mathrm{phys}}^{i}=\rho_S\nabla_i\hat{q}^{i}=0,\qquad|v_{\mathrm{phys}}|=\rho_S|\hat{q}|=\rho_S, \tag*{(88)} ∇ i v phys i = ρ S ∇ i q ^ i = 0 , ∣ v phys ∣ = ρ S ∣ q ^ ∣ = ρ S , (88)
throughout the string bundle. Its entropy flux is
Φ A ≡ Φ A [ v p h y s ] = ρ S Φ A [ q ^ ] = 2 ρ S ℓ A d S arccosh R ε . (89) \Phi_A\equiv\Phi_A[v_{\mathrm{phys}}]=\rho_S\Phi_A[\hat{q}]=2\rho_S\ell_{\mathrm{AdS}}\operatorname{arccosh}\frac{R}{\varepsilon}. \tag*{(89)} Φ A ≡ Φ A [ v phys ] = ρ S Φ A [ q ^ ] = 2 ρ S ℓ AdS arccosh ε R . (89)
With central charge c = 6 ρ S ℓ A d S = 3 ℓ A d S e − 2 ϕ 0 / ( 2 G N ( 3 ) ) c=6\rho_S\ell_{\mathrm{AdS}}=3\ell_{\mathrm{AdS}}e^{-2\phi_0}/(2G_N^{(3)}) c = 6 ρ S ℓ AdS = 3 ℓ AdS e − 2 ϕ 0 / ( 2 G N ( 3 ) ) , this becomes
S A ( 0 ) = Φ A = c 3 arccosh R ε = c 3 log 2 R ε + O ( ε 2 R 2 ) . (90) S_A^{(0)}=\Phi_A=\frac{c}{3}\operatorname{arccosh}\frac{R}{\varepsilon}=\frac{c}{3}\log\frac{2R}{\varepsilon}+O\left(\frac{\varepsilon^2}{R^2}\right). \tag*{(90)} S A ( 0 ) = Φ A = 3 c arccosh ε R = 3 c log ε 2 R + O ( R 2 ε 2 ) . (90)
The finite-cutoff terms refer to the geometric regulator in Eq. (43) . In the continuum limit, this agrees with the vacuum interval entanglement entropy of CFT2 _2 2 [24 , 25 ] , now obtained from physical F1 sources. This is the vacuum entanglement entropy between A A A and its full complement A ˉ \bar{A} A ˉ . At finite cutoff, the F1 profiles connect A ε A_\varepsilon A ε only to a subinterval B h i t , ε B_{\mathrm{hit},\varepsilon} B hit , ε of the regulated complement. In Section 5, we show how the F1 equations determine which parts of the complement are reached as the NS-NS flux fraction varies, even though the total RT flux remains fixed.
Finally, it remains to verify maximality. The RT surface and its unit normal pointing into the interval homology region are
γ A : x 2 + z 2 = R 2 , n A = − z ℓ A d S R ( x ∂ x + z ∂ z ) . (91) \gamma_A: x^2+z^2=R^2,\qquad n_A=-\frac{z}{\ell_{\mathrm{AdS}}R}(x\partial_x+z\partial_z). \tag*{(91)} γ A : x 2 + z 2 = R 2 , n A = − ℓ AdS R z ( x ∂ x + z ∂ z ) . (91)
Substitution into Eq. (87) gives
v p h y s ∣ γ A = ρ S n A . (92) v_{\mathrm{phys}}\big|_{\gamma_A}=\rho_S n_A. \tag*{(92)} v phys γ A = ρ S n A . (92)
The flow is therefore normal to the bottleneck and saturates its capacity. The source intersections with this surface also satisfy
x = R R 2 − z 0 2 R 2 + z 0 2 , z = 2 R 2 z 0 R 2 + z 0 2 , d A S = ℓ A d S ∣ d z 0 ∣ z 0 . (93) x=R\frac{R^2-z_0^2}{R^2+z_0^2},\qquad z=\frac{2R^2z_0}{R^2+z_0^2},\qquad dA_S=\ell_{\mathrm{AdS}}\frac{|dz_0|}{z_0}. \tag*{(93)} x = R R 2 + z 0 2 R 2 − z 0 2 , z = R 2 + z 0 2 2 R 2 z 0 , d A S = ℓ AdS z 0 ∣ d z 0 ∣ . (93)
Thus Length ( γ A , ϵ ) = 2 ℓ A d S U ϵ \operatorname{Length}(\gamma_{A,\epsilon})=2\ell_{\mathrm{AdS}}U_\epsilon Length ( γ A , ϵ ) = 2 ℓ AdS U ϵ , and the ensemble is uniform per proper RT length. For any admissible flow w i w^i w i in the same regulated homology region,
∇ i w i = 0 , ∣ w ∣ ≤ ρ S . (94) \nabla_i w^i=0,\qquad|w|\leq\rho_S. \tag*{(94)} ∇ i w i = 0 , ∣ w ∣ ≤ ρ S . (94)
Flux conservation and the weighted flow–cut bound [4 , 13 ] then give
Φ A [ w ] = ∫ γ A , ϵ w ⋅ n A d A S ≤ ∫ γ A , ϵ ∣ w ∣ d A S ≤ ρ S Length ( γ A , ϵ ) = 2 ρ S ℓ A d S U ϵ = Φ A [ v p h y s ] . (95) \begin{aligned}
\Phi_A[w]=\int_{\gamma_{A,\epsilon}}w\cdot n_A\,dA_S\leq\int_{\gamma_{A,\epsilon}}|w|dA_S \\
&\leq\rho_S\operatorname{Length}(\gamma_{A,\epsilon})=2\rho_S\ell_{\mathrm{AdS}}U_\epsilon=\Phi_A[v_{\mathrm{phys}}]. \tag*{(95)}
\end{aligned} Φ A [ w ] = ∫ γ A , ϵ w ⋅ n A d A S ≤ ∫ γ A , ϵ ∣ w ∣ d A S ≤ ρ S Length ( γ A , ϵ ) = 2 ρ S ℓ AdS U ϵ = Φ A [ v phys ] . (95)
This proves that the entropy flux calculated from the physical string current is maximal.
Thermal entanglement entropy from physical F1 sources
In this section, we extend the construction to a single interval in a thermal state of the CFT2 _2 2 on the infinite line, described holographically by planar BTZ. We construct on-shell F1 worldsheets in this background and choose their labels so that the crossings are equally spaced in proper length along the regulated thermal RT surface. After coarse-graining the string current and projecting it onto the t B = 0 t_B=0 t B = 0 slice, we apply the same string-frame normalization as in the vacuum case. The flow again saturates the RT flux bound, yielding the standard single-interval entanglement entropy at inverse temperature β \beta β .
Physical F1 strings in planar BTZ
We now consider the boundary interval A = ( x 1 , x 2 ) A=(x_1,x_2) A = ( x 1 , x 2 ) at t B = 0 t_B=0 t B = 0 in the thermal state on an infinite line. The string-frame planar BTZ background is [28 , 32 ]
d s B T Z 2 = ℓ A d S 2 z B 2 ( − f B d t B 2 + d x B 2 + d z B 2 f B ) , f B = 1 − z B 2 z h 2 . ds_{\mathrm{BTZ}}^2=\frac{\ell_{\mathrm{AdS}}^2}{z_B^2}\left(-f_Bdt_B^2+dx_B^2+\frac{dz_B^2}{f_B}\right),\qquad f_B=1-\frac{z_B^2}{z_h^2}. d s BTZ 2 = z B 2 ℓ AdS 2 ( − f B d t B 2 + d x B 2 + f B d z B 2 ) , f B = 1 − z h 2 z B 2 .
B B = − ℓ A d S 2 ( 1 z B 2 − 1 z h 2 ) d t B ∧ d x B , ϕ = ϕ 0 , β = 2 π z h . (96) B_B=-\ell_{\mathrm{AdS}}^2\left(\frac{1}{z_B^2}-\frac{1}{z_h^2}\right)dt_B\wedge dx_B,\qquad\phi=\phi_0,\qquad\beta=2\pi z_h. \tag*{(96)} B B = − ℓ AdS 2 ( z B 2 1 − z h 2 1 ) d t B ∧ d x B , ϕ = ϕ 0 , β = 2 π z h . (96)
The right exterior has x B ∈ R x_B\in\mathbb{R} x B ∈ R and 0 < z B < z h 0<z_B<z_h 0 < z B < z h . The Kalb–Ramond potential is regular at the horizon, and its field strength has the same orientation as in the vacuum construction:
H = d B B = 2 ℓ A d S 2 z B 3 d t B ∧ d x B ∧ d z B , H t B x B z B = 2 ℓ A d S 2 z B 3 . (97) H=dB_B=\frac{2\ell_{\mathrm{AdS}}^2}{z_B^3}dt_B\wedge dx_B\wedge dz_B,\qquad H_{t_Bx_Bz_B}=\frac{2\ell_{\mathrm{AdS}}^2}{z_B^3}. \tag*{(97)} H = d B B = z B 3 2 ℓ AdS 2 d t B ∧ d x B ∧ d z B , H t B x B z B = z B 3 2 ℓ AdS 2 . (97)
To simplify the calculation, we introduce the notation
L A = x 2 − x 1 , x c = x 1 + x 2 2 , d = L A 2 z h , h B = f B , L_A=x_2-x_1,\qquad x_c=\frac{x_1+x_2}{2},\qquad d=\frac{L_A}{2z_h},\qquad h_B=\sqrt{f_B}, L A = x 2 − x 1 , x c = 2 x 1 + x 2 , d = 2 z h L A , h B = f B ,
T = t B z h , ξ = x B − x c z h , p = x B − x 2 z h = ξ − d . (98) T=\frac{t_B}{z_h},\qquad\xi=\frac{x_B-x_c}{z_h},\qquad p=\frac{x_B-x_2}{z_h}=\xi-d. \tag*{(98)} T = z h t B , ξ = z h x B − x c , p = z h x B − x 2 = ξ − d . (98)
where we use z h = β / ( 2 π ) z_h=\beta/(2\pi) z h = β / ( 2 π ) as the thermal length scale, so that T T T , ξ \xi ξ , p p p , and the interval half-width d d d are dimensionless. The coordinate ξ \xi ξ is centered at x c x_c x c , making the symmetry of the RT surface explicit, while p p p is measured from x 2 x_2 x 2 , the reference point for the F1 embeddings. Using p = ξ − d p=\xi-d p = ξ − d , we express the string profiles in terms of ξ \xi ξ , the coordinate used for the RT surface.
As in the vacuum case, we use the right endpoint ( 0 , x 2 , 0 ) (0,x_2,0) ( 0 , x 2 , 0 ) as the reference point and choose dimensionless worldsheet coordinates. To construct the embedding, let W = z h / z B W=z_h/z_B W = z h / z B and use
τ = W h B sinh T , σ = − W sinh p . (99) \tau=Wh_B\sinh T,\qquad\sigma=-W\sinh p. \tag*{(99)} τ = W h B sinh T , σ = − W sinh p . (99)
Introduce the auxiliary combinations
P = W cosh p , Q = W h B cosh T , P 2 − σ 2 = W 2 , Q 2 − τ 2 = W 2 − 1. (100) P=W\cosh p,\qquad Q=Wh_B\cosh T,\qquad P^2-\sigma^2=W^2,\qquad Q^2-\tau^2=W^2-1. \tag*{(100)} P = W cosh p , Q = W h B cosh T , P 2 − σ 2 = W 2 , Q 2 − τ 2 = W 2 − 1. (100)
These are functions of the target coordinates. Their differentials give
− d P 2 + d σ 2 = − d W 2 + W 2 d p 2 , -dP^2+d\sigma^2=-dW^2+W^2dp^2, − d P 2 + d σ 2 = − d W 2 + W 2 d p 2 ,
d Q 2 − d τ 2 = W 2 W 2 − 1 d W 2 − ( W 2 − 1 ) d T 2 . (101) dQ^2-d\tau^2=\frac{W^2}{W^2-1}dW^2-(W^2-1)dT^2. \tag*{(101)} d Q 2 − d τ 2 = W 2 − 1 W 2 d W 2 − ( W 2 − 1 ) d T 2 . (101)
Based on these transformations, the BTZ line element pulled back to the worldsheet therefore takes the form
d s w s 2 = ℓ A d S 2 [ − d τ 2 + d σ 2 − d ( P − Q ) d ( P + Q ) ] . (102) ds_{\mathrm{ws}}^2=\ell_{\mathrm{AdS}}^2\left[-d\tau^2+d\sigma^2-d(P-Q)d(P+Q)\right]. \tag*{(102)} d s ws 2 = ℓ AdS 2 [ − d τ 2 + d σ 2 − d ( P − Q ) d ( P + Q ) ] . (102)
We choose the branch d ( P − Q ) = 0 d(P-Q)=0 d ( P − Q ) = 0 , for which the induced metric is flat and the worldsheet metric constraints are automatic. The embedding equations will be checked separately as vacuum case. Writing the positive integration constant as η \eta η , we have
P η − Q η = η , − P η 2 − τ 2 + σ 2 + Q η 2 = − 1. (103) P_\eta-Q_\eta=\eta,\qquad-P_\eta^2-\tau^2+\sigma^2+Q_\eta^2=-1. \tag*{(103)} P η − Q η = η , − P η 2 − τ 2 + σ 2 + Q η 2 = − 1. (103)
Using the notation D = 1 + σ 2 − τ 2 \mathcal{D}=1+\sigma^2-\tau^2 D = 1 + σ 2 − τ 2 , these two relations yield
P η = D + η 2 2 η , Q η = P η − η , W η = P η 2 − σ 2 . (104) P_\eta=\frac{\mathcal{D}+\eta^2}{2\eta},\qquad Q_\eta=P_\eta-\eta,\qquad W_\eta=\sqrt{P_\eta^2-\sigma^2}. \tag*{(104)} P η = 2 η D + η 2 , Q η = P η − η , W η = P η 2 − σ 2 . (104)
The solution for the embedding is thus
X t B ( τ , σ ) = z h arctanh τ Q η , X x B ( τ , σ ) = x 2 − z h arctanh σ P η , X z B ( τ , σ ) = z h W η , (105) X^{t_B}(\tau,\sigma)=z_h\operatorname{arctanh}\frac{\tau}{Q_\eta},\qquad X^{x_B}(\tau,\sigma)=x_2-z_h\operatorname{arctanh}\frac{\sigma}{P_\eta},\qquad X^{z_B}(\tau,\sigma)=\frac{z_h}{W_\eta}, \tag*{(105)} X t B ( τ , σ ) = z h arctanh Q η τ , X x B ( τ , σ ) = x 2 − z h arctanh P η σ , X z B ( τ , σ ) = W η z h , (105)
where Q η > ∣ τ ∣ Q_\eta>|\tau| Q η > ∣ τ ∣ and P η > ∣ σ ∣ P_\eta>|\sigma| P η > ∣ σ ∣ . In this domain W η 2 = 1 + Q η 2 − τ 2 > 1 W_\eta^2=1+Q_\eta^2-\tau^2>1 W η 2 = 1 + Q η 2 − τ 2 > 1 , so the embedding lies in the right exterior. Since d P η = d Q η dP_\eta=dQ_\eta d P η = d Q η at fixed η \eta η , Eq. (102) gives
d s w s 2 = ℓ A d S 2 ( − d τ 2 + d σ 2 ) . (106) ds_{\mathrm{ws}}^2=\ell_{\mathrm{AdS}}^2\left(-d\tau^2+d\sigma^2\right). \tag*{(106)} d s ws 2 = ℓ AdS 2 ( − d τ 2 + d σ 2 ) . (106)
We now choose the same Weyl representative as in the vacuum calculation:
γ m n = g a b ∂ m X a ∂ n X b = ℓ A d S 2 diag ( − 1 , 1 ) , − det γ = ℓ A d S 2 , − γ γ m n = diag ( − 1 , 1 ) . (107) \gamma_{mn}=g_{ab}\partial_mX^a\partial_nX^b=\ell_{\mathrm{AdS}}^2\operatorname{diag}(-1,1),\qquad\sqrt{-\det\gamma}=\ell_{\mathrm{AdS}}^2,\qquad\sqrt{-\gamma}\gamma^{mn}=\operatorname{diag}(-1,1). \tag*{(107)} γ mn = g ab ∂ m X a ∂ n X b = ℓ AdS 2 diag ( − 1 , 1 ) , − det γ = ℓ AdS 2 , − γ γ mn = diag ( − 1 , 1 ) . (107)
The worldsheet metric constraints are then satisfied.
To identify the surface swept out by the embedding in target space, we eliminate the worldsheet coordinates ( τ , σ ) (\tau,\sigma) ( τ , σ ) . Define
Δ β ≡ cosh p − h B cosh T . (108) \Delta_\beta\equiv\cosh p-h_B\cosh T. \tag*{(108)} Δ β ≡ cosh p − h B cosh T . (108)
By Eq. (100) , we have W Δ β = P − Q W\Delta_\beta=P-Q W Δ β = P − Q . Since P − Q = η P-Q=\eta P − Q = η on the chosen branch and W = z h / z B W=z_h/z_B W = z h / z B , the embedding obeys
Δ β = cosh ( x B − x 2 z h ) − 1 − z B 2 z h 2 cosh ( t B z h ) = η z B z h . (109) \Delta_\beta=\cosh\left(\frac{x_B-x_2}{z_h}\right)-\sqrt{1-\frac{z_B^2}{z_h^2}}\cosh\left(\frac{t_B}{z_h}\right)=\eta\frac{z_B}{z_h}. \tag*{(109)} Δ β = cosh ( z h x B − x 2 ) − 1 − z h 2 z B 2 cosh ( z h t B ) = η z h z B . (109)
For fixed η > 0 \eta>0 η > 0 , this equation gives the target space image of the string worldsheet in the right exterior 0 < z B < z h 0<z_B<z_h 0 < z B < z h . The worldsheet coordinates of a point on this surface are recovered from Eq. (99) .
We next verify the complete F1 equations, E a − H a b c ∂ τ X b ∂ σ X c = 0 \mathcal{E}^a-H^a{}_{bc}\partial_\tau X^b\partial_\sigma X^c=0 E a − H a b c ∂ τ X b ∂ σ X c = 0 , with E a \mathcal{E}^a E a the metric contribution in conformal gauge. Substituting Eq. (105) into the metric and NS–NS terms separately gives
E t B = H t B b c ∂ τ X b ∂ σ X c = − 2 z B 2 sinh T z h h B Δ β , \mathcal{E}^{t_B}=H^{t_B}{}_{bc}\partial_\tau X^b\partial_\sigma X^c=-\frac{2z_B^2\sinh T}{z_hh_B\Delta_\beta}, E t B = H t B b c ∂ τ X b ∂ σ X c = − z h h B Δ β 2 z B 2 sinh T ,
E x B = H x B b c ∂ τ X b ∂ σ X c = − 2 z B 2 sinh p z h Δ β , \mathcal{E}^{x_B}=H^{x_B}{}_{bc}\partial_\tau X^b\partial_\sigma X^c=-\frac{2z_B^2\sinh p}{z_h\Delta_\beta}, E x B = H x B b c ∂ τ X b ∂ σ X c = − z h Δ β 2 z B 2 sinh p ,
E z B = H z B b c ∂ τ X b ∂ σ X c = 2 z B h B Δ β ( h B cosh p − cosh T ) . (110) \mathcal{E}^{z_B}=H^{z_B}{}_{bc}\partial_\tau X^b\partial_\sigma X^c=\frac{2z_Bh_B}{\Delta_\beta}\left(h_B\cosh p-\cosh T\right). \tag*{(110)} E z B = H z B b c ∂ τ X b ∂ σ X c = Δ β 2 z B h B ( h B cosh p − cosh T ) . (110)
Note that E a \mathcal{E}^a E a is given by Eq. (17) . The metric and NS–NS contributions therefore agree component by component, so Eq. (105) describes on-shell F1 worldsheets.
To compare the string with the RT surface, we restrict the worldsheet surface in Eq. (109) to the t B = 0 t_B=0 t B = 0 slice. At t B = 0 t_B=0 t B = 0 , we use
D β ≡ Δ β ∣ t B = 0 = cosh p − h B . (111) D_\beta\equiv\left.\Delta_\beta\right|_{t_B=0}=\cosh p-h_B. \tag*{(111)} D β ≡ Δ β ∣ t B = 0 = cosh p − h B . (111)
The spatial F1 profile is D β = η z B / z h D_\beta=\eta z_B/z_h D β = η z B / z h . We now compare it with the RT surface [2 , 7 , 8 ] . For a curve z B = z B ( x B ) z_B=z_B(x_B) z B = z B ( x B ) , its spatial length functional and first integral are
L γ = ℓ A d S ∫ d x B z B 1 + z B ′ 2 f B , 1 z B 1 + z B ′ 2 / f B = 1 z ∗ , z B ′ ≡ d z B d x B , (112) \mathcal{L}_\gamma=\ell_{\mathrm{AdS}}\int\frac{dx_B}{z_B}\sqrt{1+\frac{z_B'^2}{f_B}},\qquad\frac{1}{z_B\sqrt{1+z_B'^2/f_B}}=\frac{1}{z_*},\qquad z'_B\equiv\frac{dz_B}{dx_B}, \tag*{(112)} L γ = ℓ AdS ∫ z B d x B 1 + f B z B ′2 , z B 1 + z B ′2 / f B 1 = z ∗ 1 , z B ′ ≡ d x B d z B , (112)
where z ∗ z_* z ∗ is the turning point at x B = x c x_B=x_c x B = x c . Integrating from z B z_B z B to z ∗ z_* z ∗ gives
∣ x B − x c ∣ = ∫ z B z ∗ z ~ d z ~ ( 1 − z ~ 2 / z h 2 ) ( z ∗ 2 − z ~ 2 ) = z h arccosh h B 1 − z ∗ 2 / z h 2 , (113) |x_B-x_c|=\int_{z_B}^{z_*}\frac{\tilde{z}\,\mathrm{d}\tilde{z}}{\sqrt{(1-\tilde{z}^{2}/z_h^{2})(z_*^{2}-\tilde{z}^{2})}}=z_h\operatorname{arc cosh}\frac{h_B}{\sqrt{1-z_*^{2}/z_h^{2}}}, \tag*{(113)} ∣ x B − x c ∣ = ∫ z B z ∗ ( 1 − z ~ 2 / z h 2 ) ( z ∗ 2 − z ~ 2 ) z ~ d z ~ = z h arccosh 1 − z ∗ 2 / z h 2 h B , (113)
where z ~ \tilde{z} z ~ is a dummy radial integration variable, whereas z B z_B z B is the radial coordinate of the point on the surface. At the ideal endpoints, ∣ x B − x c ∣ = L A / 2 |x_B-x_c|=L_A/2 ∣ x B − x c ∣ = L A /2 and h B = 1 h_B=1 h B = 1 . Hence
γ β , A : cosh ξ = h B cosh d , z ∗ = z h tanh d . (114) \gamma_{\beta,A}:\qquad\cosh\xi=h_B\cosh d,\qquad z_*=z_h\tanh d. \tag*{(114)} γ β , A : cosh ξ = h B cosh d , z ∗ = z h tanh d . (114)
To check orthogonality, let F γ = cosh ξ − h B cosh d F_\gamma=\cosh\xi-h_B\cosh d F γ = cosh ξ − h B cosh d and F F 1 = D β − η z B / z h F_{F1}=D_\beta-\eta z_B/z_h F F 1 = D β − η z B / z h denote the two curve equations. At their intersection the contraction of their normal covectors in the spatial string-frame metric is
h i j ∂ i F γ ∂ j F F 1 = z B 2 ℓ A d S 2 z h 2 [ sinh ξ sinh p + cosh d ( z B 2 z h 2 − η z B z h h B ) ] = z B 2 ℓ A d S 2 z h 2 [ cosh d − cosh ( ξ − p ) ] = 0. (115) \begin{aligned}
h^{ij}\partial_iF_\gamma\partial_jF_{F1}
&=\frac{z_B^2}{\ell_{\mathrm{AdS}}^2z_h^2}\left[\sinh\xi\sinh p+\cosh d\left(\frac{z_B^2}{z_h^2}-\eta\frac{z_B}{z_h}h_B\right)\right]\\
&=\frac{z_B^2}{\ell_{\mathrm{AdS}}^2z_h^2}\left[\cosh d-\cosh(\xi-p)\right]=0. \tag*{(115)}
\end{aligned} h ij ∂ i F γ ∂ j F F 1 = ℓ AdS 2 z h 2 z B 2 [ sinh ξ sinh p + cosh d ( z h 2 z B 2 − η z h z B h B ) ] = ℓ AdS 2 z h 2 z B 2 [ cosh d − cosh ( ξ − p ) ] = 0. (115)
where we used η z B / z h = cosh p − h B \eta z_B/z_h=\cosh p-h_B η z B / z h = cosh p − h B , h B 2 + z B 2 / z h 2 = 1 h_B^2+z_B^2/z_h^2=1 h B 2 + z B 2 / z h 2 = 1 , and h B cosh d = cosh ξ h_B\cosh d=\cosh\xi h B cosh d = cosh ξ . The spatial F1 profiles therefore cross the thermal RT surface orthogonally.
The physical string current and thermal interval entropy
To coarse-grain the discrete string current, we first determine the string spacing with the thermal analogue of the vacuum regulator. Keeping x 1 x_1 x 1 and x 2 x_2 x 2 fixed, we truncate the RT surface of Eqs. (112) –(114) at z B = ϵ z_B=\epsilon z B = ϵ , with 0 < ϵ < z ∗ 0<\epsilon<z_* 0 < ϵ < z ∗ . We denote the truncated curve by γ β , A , ϵ \gamma_{\beta,A,\epsilon} γ β , A , ϵ . Eq. (114) gives
f ϵ = 1 − ϵ 2 z h 2 , ξ ϵ = arccosh ( f ϵ cosh d ) , a β , ϵ = x c − z h ξ ϵ , b β , ϵ = x c + z h ξ ϵ , (116) f_\epsilon=1-\frac{\epsilon^2}{z_h^2},\qquad\xi_\epsilon=\operatorname{arc cosh}\left(\sqrt{f_\epsilon}\cosh d\right),\qquad a_{\beta,\epsilon}=x_c-z_h\xi_\epsilon,\qquad b_{\beta,\epsilon}=x_c+z_h\xi_\epsilon, \tag*{(116)} f ϵ = 1 − z h 2 ϵ 2 , ξ ϵ = arccosh ( f ϵ cosh d ) , a β , ϵ = x c − z h ξ ϵ , b β , ϵ = x c + z h ξ ϵ , (116)
with A β , ϵ = { z B = ϵ , a β , ϵ ≤ x B ≤ b β , ϵ } A_{\beta,\epsilon}=\{z_B=\epsilon,a_{\beta,\epsilon}\leq x_B\leq b_{\beta,\epsilon}\} A β , ϵ = { z B = ϵ , a β , ϵ ≤ x B ≤ b β , ϵ } . At t B = 0 t_B=0 t B = 0 , the string passing through a cutoff point x B x_B x B has integration constant
η ( x B ) = z h ϵ [ cosh x B − x 2 z h − f ϵ ] . (117) \eta(x_B)=\frac{z_h}{\epsilon}\left[\cosh\frac{x_B-x_2}{z_h}-\sqrt{f_\epsilon}\right]. \tag*{(117)} η ( x B ) = ϵ z h [ cosh z h x B − x 2 − f ϵ ] . (117)
Since ξ ϵ < d \xi_\epsilon<d ξ ϵ < d , one has p < 0 p<0 p < 0 on the regulated interval and d η / d x B = sinh p / ϵ < 0 \mathrm{d}\eta/\mathrm{d}x_B=\sinh p/\epsilon<0 d η / d x B = sinh p / ϵ < 0 . The minimum and maximum therefore occur at b β , ϵ b_{\beta,\epsilon} b β , ϵ and a β , ϵ a_{\beta,\epsilon} a β , ϵ , respectively:
η min = z h ϵ [ cosh ( d − ξ ϵ ) − f ϵ ] , η max = z h ϵ [ cosh ( d + ξ ϵ ) − f ϵ ] . (118) \eta_{\min}=\frac{z_h}{\epsilon}\left[\cosh(d-\xi_\epsilon)-\sqrt{f_\epsilon}\right],\qquad\eta_{\max}=\frac{z_h}{\epsilon}\left[\cosh(d+\xi_\epsilon)-\sqrt{f_\epsilon}\right]. \tag*{(118)} η m i n = ϵ z h [ cosh ( d − ξ ϵ ) − f ϵ ] , η m a x = ϵ z h [ cosh ( d + ξ ϵ ) − f ϵ ] . (118)
Using cosh ξ ϵ = f ϵ cosh d \cosh\xi_\epsilon=\sqrt{f_\epsilon}\cosh d cosh ξ ϵ = f ϵ cosh d , these can be rewritten as
η min , max = z h sinh d ϵ ( f ϵ sinh d ∓ sinh ξ ϵ ) , f ϵ sinh 2 d − sinh 2 ξ ϵ = ϵ 2 z h 2 . (119) \eta_{\min,\max}=\frac{z_h\sinh d}{\epsilon}\left(\sqrt{f_\epsilon}\sinh d\mp\sinh\xi_\epsilon\right),\qquad f_\epsilon\sinh^2d-\sinh^2\xi_\epsilon=\frac{\epsilon^2}{z_h^2}. \tag*{(119)} η m i n , m a x = ϵ z h sinh d ( f ϵ sinh d ∓ sinh ξ ϵ ) , f ϵ sinh 2 d − sinh 2 ξ ϵ = z h 2 ϵ 2 . (119)
Each value of the integration constant η \eta η specifies one F1 profile. The strings that meet the regulated interval A β , ϵ A_{\beta,\epsilon} A β , ϵ have η ∈ [ η min , η max ] \eta\in[\eta_{\min},\eta_{\max}] η ∈ [ η m i n , η m a x ] . We define the half-width of this range in log η \log\eta log η by
U β , ε ≡ 1 2 log η max η min = log [ z h ℓ ( f ε sinh d + sinh ξ ε ) ] = arccosh ( z h ℓ f ε sinh d ) . (120) U_{\beta,\varepsilon} \equiv\frac{1}{2}\log\frac{\eta_{\max}}{\eta_{\min}}=\log\left[\frac{z_h}{\ell}\left(\sqrt{f_\varepsilon}\sinh d+\sinh\xi_\varepsilon\right)\right]=\operatorname{arccosh}\left(\frac{z_h}{\ell}\sqrt{f_\varepsilon}\sinh d\right). \tag*{(120)} U β , ε ≡ 2 1 log η m i n η m a x = log [ ℓ z h ( f ε sinh d + sinh ξ ε ) ] = arccosh ( ℓ z h f ε sinh d ) . (120)
Since η min η max = sinh 2 d \eta_{\min}\eta_{\max}=\sinh^2d η m i n η m a x = sinh 2 d , the endpoints can be written as
η min = sinh d e − U β , ε , η max = sinh d e U β , ε . (121) \eta_{\min}=\sinh d e^{-U_{\beta,\varepsilon}},\qquad\eta_{\max}=\sinh d e^{U_{\beta,\varepsilon}}. \tag*{(121)} η m i n = sinh d e − U β , ε , η m a x = sinh d e U β , ε . (121)
We now explain why the ensemble is uniform in log η \log\eta log η . Introduce the dimensionless notation
u β = log η sinh d , − U β , ε ≤ u β ≤ U β , ε . (122) u_\beta=\log\frac{\eta}{\sinh d},\qquad-U_{\beta,\varepsilon}\leq u_\beta\leq U_{\beta,\varepsilon}. \tag*{(122)} u β = log sinh d η , − U β , ε ≤ u β ≤ U β , ε . (122)
On the RT surface, D β = − tanh d sinh p D_\beta=-\tanh d\sinh p D β = − tanh d sinh p . Solving the F1 and RT curve equations together then gives
( η sinh d ) 2 = tanh d − tanh ξ tanh d + tanh ξ , tanh ξ = − tanh d tanh u β , z B z h = sinh d cosh 2 u β + sinh 2 d . (123) \left(\frac{\eta}{\sinh d}\right)^2=\frac{\tanh d-\tanh\xi}{\tanh d+\tanh\xi},\qquad\tanh\xi=-\tanh d\tanh u_\beta,\qquad\frac{z_B}{z_h}=\frac{\sinh d}{\sqrt{\cosh^2u_\beta+\sinh^2d}}. \tag*{(123)} ( sinh d η ) 2 = tanh d + tanh ξ tanh d − tanh ξ , tanh ξ = − tanh d tanh u β , z h z B = cosh 2 u β + sinh 2 d sinh d . (123)
In particular, differentiating x B = x c + z h ξ x_B=x_c+z_h\xi x B = x c + z h ξ along this curve gives ∣ d x B / d u β ∣ = z B 2 / z ∗ \lvert dx_B/du_\beta\rvert=z_B^2/z_* ∣ d x B / d u β ∣ = z B 2 / z ∗ . Combining this relation with Eq. (112) gives
d A S = ℓ A d S z B 1 + z B ′ 2 f B ∣ d x B ∣ = ℓ A d S z ∗ z B 2 ∣ d x B ∣ = ℓ A d S ∣ d u β ∣ . (124) dA_S=\frac{\ell_{\mathrm{AdS}}}{z_B}\sqrt{1+\frac{z_B^{\prime2}}{f_B}}\lvert dx_B\rvert=\frac{\ell_{\mathrm{AdS}}z_*}{z_B^2}\lvert dx_B\rvert=\ell_{\mathrm{AdS}}\lvert du_\beta\rvert. \tag*{(124)} d A S = z B ℓ AdS 1 + f B z B ′2 ∣ d x B ∣ = z B 2 ℓ AdS z ∗ ∣ d x B ∣ = ℓ AdS ∣ d u β ∣ . (124)
Therefore, the equal spacing in u β u_\beta u β gives equal proper spacing on the RT surface, just as in the vacuum case. The bundle also covers the regulated homology region: at fixed z B z_B z B , u β u_\beta u β decreases with x B x_B x B and its values between the two branches of the RT surface lie between the labels on those branches. We then divide the range into N \mathcal{N} N equal cells and put one string at each midpoint:
u β , s = 2 U β , ε N , u β , k = − U β , ε + ( k + 1 2 ) u β , s , u_{\beta,s}=\frac{2U_{\beta,\varepsilon}}{\mathcal{N}},\qquad u_{\beta,k}=-U_{\beta,\varepsilon}+\left(k+\frac{1}{2}\right)u_{\beta,s}, u β , s = N 2 U β , ε , u β , k = − U β , ε + ( k + 2 1 ) u β , s ,
η k = sinh d e u β , k = η min exp [ ( k + 1 2 ) u β , s ] , k = 0 , … , N − 1. (125) \eta_k=\sinh d e^{u_{\beta,k}}=\eta_{\min}\exp\left[\left(k+\frac{1}{2}\right)u_{\beta,s}\right],\qquad k=0,\ldots,\mathcal{N}-1. \tag*{(125)} η k = sinh d e u β , k = η m i n exp [ ( k + 2 1 ) u β , s ] , k = 0 , … , N − 1. (125)
The adjacent strings satisfy log ( η k + 1 / η k ) = u β , s \log\left(\eta_{k+1}/\eta_k\right)=u_{\beta,s} log ( η k + 1 / η k ) = u β , s . Figure 3 shows the corresponding midpoint sampling for the thermal interval: the left and right cutoff endpoints carry the labels η max \eta_{\max} η m a x and η min \eta_{\min} η m i n , respectively, and the F1 crossings are equally spaced in u β u_\beta u β .
Figure 3. The regulated thermal RT surface in planar BTZ at t B = 0 t_B = 0 t B = 0 is shown on the left and unfolded onto the arclength ruler on the right. The left and right cutoff endpoints map to + U β , ε +U_{\beta,\varepsilon} + U β , ε and − U β , ε -U_{\beta,\varepsilon} − U β , ε , corresponding to η max \eta_{\max} η m a x and η min \eta_{\min} η m i n , respectively. The open circle marks the turning point ( x c , z ∗ ) (x_c,z_*) ( x c , z ∗ ) . The dots on the ruler mark F1 crossings at the cell midpoints. The gold dots identify the same pair of adjacent crossings in both panels, with proper separation ℓ A d S u β , s \ell_{\mathrm{AdS}}u_{\beta,s} ℓ AdS u β , s along the surface.
We now return to the normalized current of N \mathcal{N} N equally oriented strings. Writing x = ( t B , x B , z B ) x=(t_B,x_B,z_B) x = ( t B , x B , z B ) for the observation event, we have
j a b ( x ) = 1 − g ∑ k = 0 N − 1 ∫ d τ d σ ( ∂ τ X k a ∂ σ X k b − ∂ σ X k a ∂ τ X k b ) δ ( 3 ) ( x − X k ) . (126) j^{ab}(x)=\frac{1}{\sqrt{-g}}\sum_{k=0}^{\mathcal{N}-1}\int d\tau d\sigma\left(\partial_\tau X_k^a\partial_\sigma X_k^b-\partial_\sigma X_k^a\partial_\tau X_k^b\right)\delta^{(3)}(x-X_k). \tag*{(126)} j ab ( x ) = − g 1 k = 0 ∑ N − 1 ∫ d τ d σ ( ∂ τ X k a ∂ σ X k b − ∂ σ X k a ∂ τ X k b ) δ ( 3 ) ( x − X k ) . (126)
where X k X_k X k denotes the embedding in Eq. (105) with η = η k \eta=\eta_k η = η k . Before setting t B = 0 t_B=0 t B = 0 , we invert the embedding family using Eqs. (99) and (109) :
τ ∗ = z h h B z B sinh T , σ ∗ = z h z B sinh p , u β = log z h Δ β z B sinh d . (127) \tau_*=\frac{z_hh_B}{z_B}\sinh T,\qquad\sigma_*=\frac{z_h}{z_B}\sinh p,\qquad u_\beta=\log\frac{z_h\Delta_\beta}{z_B\sinh d}. \tag*{(127)} τ ∗ = z B z h h B sinh T , σ ∗ = z B z h sinh p , u β = log z B sinh d z h Δ β . (127)
This inverse is defined for Δ β > 0 \Delta_\beta> 0 Δ β > 0 in the right exterior. On the k k k th worldsheet, the inverse map gives u β = u β , k u_\beta= u_{\beta,k} u β = u β , k , while τ ∗ \tau_* τ ∗ and σ ∗ \sigma_* σ ∗ are the worldsheet coordinates of the observation event.
Allowing u β u_\beta u β to vary across the family, differentiation of the inverse map in ( T , p , W ) (T,p,W) ( T , p , W ) , with W = z h / z B W = z_h/z_B W = z h / z B , gives
d τ = W h B cosh T d T + sinh T h B d W , d σ = − W cosh p d p − sinh p d W , d u β = − h B sinh T d T + sinh p d p Δ β + cosh p − cosh T / h B W Δ β d W . (128) \begin{aligned}
d\tau&= W h_B \cosh T\,dT + \frac{\sinh T}{h_B}\,dW,\\
d\sigma&= -W\cosh p\,dp-\sinh p\,dW,\\
du_\beta&= \frac{-h_B\sinh T\,dT+\sinh p\,dp}{\Delta_\beta}+\frac{\cosh p-\cosh T/h_B}{W\Delta_\beta}\,dW. \tag*{(128)}
\end{aligned} d τ d σ d u β = W h B cosh T d T + h B sinh T d W , = − W cosh p d p − sinh p d W , = Δ β − h B sinh T d T + sinh p d p + W Δ β cosh p − cosh T / h B d W . (128)
Using cosh 2 p − sinh 2 p = cosh 2 T − sinh 2 T = 1 \cosh^2 p-\sinh^2 p=\cosh^2 T-\sinh^2 T=1 cosh 2 p − sinh 2 p = cosh 2 T − sinh 2 T = 1 , the wedge product reduces to
d τ ∧ d σ ∧ d u β = W d T ∧ d p ∧ d W = − 1 z B 3 d t B ∧ d x B ∧ d z B . (129) d\tau\wedge d\sigma\wedge du_\beta=W\,dT\wedge dp\wedge dW=-\frac{1}{z_B^3}\,dt_B\wedge dx_B\wedge dz_B. \tag*{(129)} d τ ∧ d σ ∧ d u β = W d T ∧ d p ∧ d W = − z B 3 1 d t B ∧ d x B ∧ d z B . (129)
The absolute Jacobian is therefore z B 3 z_B^3 z B 3 , and
δ ( 3 ) ( x − X k ) = 1 z B 3 δ ( τ − τ ∗ ) δ ( σ − σ ∗ ) δ ( u β − u β , k ) . (130) \delta^{(3)}(x-X_k)=\frac{1}{z_B^3}\delta(\tau-\tau_*)\delta(\sigma-\sigma_*)\delta(u_\beta-u_{\beta,k}). \tag*{(130)} δ ( 3 ) ( x − X k ) = z B 3 1 δ ( τ − τ ∗ ) δ ( σ − σ ∗ ) δ ( u β − u β , k ) . (130)
The first two delta functions perform the two worldsheet integrations. On the support of the remaining delta function, one may set u β , k = u β ( x ) u_{\beta,k}=u_\beta(x) u β , k = u β ( x ) in the derivative products, giving
j a b = 1 − g z B 3 ( ∂ τ X a ∂ σ X b − ∂ σ X a ∂ τ X b ) ∗ ∑ k = 0 N − 1 δ ( u β − u β , k ) , (131) j^{ab}=\frac{1}{\sqrt{-g z_B^3}}\left(\partial_\tau X^a\partial_\sigma X^b-\partial_\sigma X^a\partial_\tau X^b\right)_*\sum_{k=0}^{N-1}\delta(u_\beta-u_{\beta,k}), \tag*{(131)} j ab = − g z B 3 1 ( ∂ τ X a ∂ σ X b − ∂ σ X a ∂ τ X b ) ∗ k = 0 ∑ N − 1 δ ( u β − u β , k ) , (131)
where the subscript ∗ * ∗ also indicates that the worldsheet derivatives are taken at fixed u β u_\beta u β and then evaluated at ( τ ∗ , σ ∗ , u β ( x ) ) (\tau_*,\sigma_*,u_\beta(x)) ( τ ∗ , σ ∗ , u β ( x )) .
Substitution of the embedding into the three independent derivative products gives
( ∂ τ X t B ∂ σ X x B − ∂ σ X t B ∂ τ X x B ) ∗ = z B 2 ( h B cosh p − cosh T ) h B Δ β , \left(\partial_\tau X^{t_B}\partial_\sigma X^{x_B}-\partial_\sigma X^{t_B}\partial_\tau X^{x_B}\right)_*=\frac{z_B^2\left(h_B\cosh p-\cosh T\right)}{h_B\Delta_\beta}, ( ∂ τ X t B ∂ σ X x B − ∂ σ X t B ∂ τ X x B ) ∗ = h B Δ β z B 2 ( h B cosh p − cosh T ) ,
( ∂ τ X t B ∂ σ X z B − ∂ σ X t B ∂ τ X z B ) ∗ = z B 3 sinh p z h Δ β , ( ∂ τ X x B ∂ σ X z B − ∂ σ X x B ∂ τ X z B ) ∗ = z B 3 h B sinh T z h Δ β . (132) \left(\partial_{\tau}X^{t_B}\partial_{\sigma}X^{z_B}-\partial_{\sigma}X^{t_B}\partial_{\tau}X^{z_B}\right)_{*}=\frac{z_B^3\sinh p}{z_h\Delta_{\beta}},
\\
\left(\partial_{\tau}X^{x_B}\partial_{\sigma}X^{z_B}-\partial_{\sigma}X^{x_B}\partial_{\tau}X^{z_B}\right)_{*}=\frac{z_B^3h_B\sinh T}{z_h\Delta_{\beta}}. \tag*{(132)} ( ∂ τ X t B ∂ σ X z B − ∂ σ X t B ∂ τ X z B ) ∗ = z h Δ β z B 3 sinh p , ( ∂ τ X x B ∂ σ X z B − ∂ σ X x B ∂ τ X z B ) ∗ = z h Δ β z B 3 h B sinh T . (132)
With − g = ℓ A d S 3 / z B 3 \sqrt{-g}=\ell_{\mathrm{AdS}}^3/z_B^3 − g = ℓ AdS 3 / z B 3 , the discrete current is
j 0 x B = z B 2 ( h B cosh p − cosh T ) ℓ A d S h B Δ β ∑ k = 0 N − 1 δ ( u β − u β , k ) , j^{0x_B}=\frac{z_B^2(h_B\cosh p-\cosh T)}{\ell_{\mathrm{AdS}}h_B\Delta_{\beta}}\sum_{k=0}^{\mathcal{N}-1}\delta(u_{\beta}-u_{\beta,k}), j 0 x B = ℓ AdS h B Δ β z B 2 ( h B cosh p − cosh T ) k = 0 ∑ N − 1 δ ( u β − u β , k ) ,
j 0 z B = z B 3 sinh p ℓ A d S 3 z h Δ β ∑ k = 0 N − 1 δ ( u β − u β , k ) , j^{0z_B}=\frac{z_B^3\sinh p}{\ell_{\mathrm{AdS}}^3z_h\Delta_{\beta}}\sum_{k=0}^{\mathcal{N}-1}\delta(u_{\beta}-u_{\beta,k}), j 0 z B = ℓ AdS 3 z h Δ β z B 3 sinh p k = 0 ∑ N − 1 δ ( u β − u β , k ) ,
j x B z B = z B 3 h B sinh T ℓ A d S 3 z h Δ β ∑ k = 0 N − 1 δ ( u β − u β , k ) . (133) j^{x_Bz_B}=\frac{z_B^3h_B\sinh T}{\ell_{\mathrm{AdS}}^3z_h\Delta_{\beta}}\sum_{k=0}^{\mathcal{N}-1}\delta(u_{\beta}-u_{\beta,k}). \tag*{(133)} j x B z B = ℓ AdS 3 z h Δ β z B 3 h B sinh T k = 0 ∑ N − 1 δ ( u β − u β , k ) . (133)
Next, we coarse-grain the discrete sum. Since u β u_{\beta} u β is nonperiodic, the delta functions are ordinary delta functions. We write
∑ k = 0 N − 1 δ ( u β − u β , k ) = 1 u β , s [ u β , s ∑ k = 0 N − 1 δ ( u β − u β , k ) ] = N 2 U β , ε [ u β , s ∑ k = 0 N − 1 δ ( u β + U β , ε − ( k + 1 2 ) u β , s ) ] . (134) \sum_{k=0}^{\mathcal{N}-1}\delta(u_{\beta}-u_{\beta,k})
=\frac{1}{u_{\beta,s}}\left[u_{\beta,s}\sum_{k=0}^{\mathcal{N}-1}\delta(u_{\beta}-u_{\beta,k})\right]
=\frac{\mathcal{N}}{2U_{\beta,\varepsilon}}\left[u_{\beta,s}\sum_{k=0}^{\mathcal{N}-1}\delta\left(u_{\beta}+U_{\beta,\varepsilon}-\left(k+\frac{1}{2}\right)u_{\beta,s}\right)\right]. \tag*{(134)} k = 0 ∑ N − 1 δ ( u β − u β , k ) = u β , s 1 [ u β , s k = 0 ∑ N − 1 δ ( u β − u β , k ) ] = 2 U β , ε N [ u β , s k = 0 ∑ N − 1 δ ( u β + U β , ε − ( k + 2 1 ) u β , s ) ] . (134)
For a smooth test function f f f , the expression in brackets acts as the midpoint Riemann sum
u β , s ∑ k = 0 N − 1 f ( u β , k ) ⟶ ∫ − U β , ε U β , ε f ( u β ) d u β , (135) u_{\beta,s}\sum_{k=0}^{\mathcal{N}-1}f(u_{\beta,k})\longrightarrow\int_{-U_{\beta,\varepsilon}}^{U_{\beta,\varepsilon}}f(u_{\beta})\,du_{\beta}, \tag*{(135)} u β , s k = 0 ∑ N − 1 f ( u β , k ) ⟶ ∫ − U β , ε U β , ε f ( u β ) d u β , (135)
as N → ∞ \mathcal{N}\to\infty N → ∞ at fixed U β , ε U_{\beta,\varepsilon} U β , ε . Its weak limit is one inside the range of string labels and zero outside. Hence
∑ k = 0 N − 1 δ ( u β − u β , k ) ⟶ coarse-graining N 2 U β , ε , − U β , ε < u β < U β , ε . (136) \sum_{k=0}^{\mathcal{N}-1}\delta(u_{\beta}-u_{\beta,k})
\underset{\text{coarse-graining}}{\longrightarrow}
\frac{\mathcal{N}}{2U_{\beta,\varepsilon}},\qquad-U_{\beta,\varepsilon}<u_{\beta}<U_{\beta,\varepsilon}. \tag*{(136)} k = 0 ∑ N − 1 δ ( u β − u β , k ) coarse-graining ⟶ 2 U β , ε N , − U β , ε < u β < U β , ε . (136)
Substituting this density into the discrete current gives the smooth current at general target-space time:
j 0 x B = N z B 2 ( h B cosh p − cosh T ) 2 U β , ε ℓ A d S h B Δ β , j 0 z B = N z B 3 sinh p 2 U β , ε ℓ A d S 3 z h Δ β , j x B z B = N z B 3 h B sinh T 2 U β , ε ℓ A d S 3 z h Δ β , (137) j^{0x_B}=\frac{\mathcal{N}z_B^2(h_B\cosh p-\cosh T)}{2U_{\beta,\varepsilon}\ell_{\mathrm{AdS}}h_B\Delta_{\beta}},\qquad
j^{0z_B}=\frac{\mathcal{N}z_B^3\sinh p}{2U_{\beta,\varepsilon}\ell_{\mathrm{AdS}}^3z_h\Delta_{\beta}},\qquad
j^{x_Bz_B}=\frac{\mathcal{N}z_B^3h_B\sinh T}{2U_{\beta,\varepsilon}\ell_{\mathrm{AdS}}^3z_h\Delta_{\beta}}, \tag*{(137)} j 0 x B = 2 U β , ε ℓ AdS h B Δ β N z B 2 ( h B cosh p − cosh T ) , j 0 z B = 2 U β , ε ℓ AdS 3 z h Δ β N z B 3 sinh p , j x B z B = 2 U β , ε ℓ AdS 3 z h Δ β N z B 3 h B sinh T , (137)
where Δ β > 0 \Delta_{\beta}>0 Δ β > 0 and ∣ u β ∣ < U β , ε \lvert u_{\beta}\rvert<U_{\beta,\varepsilon} ∣ u β ∣ < U β , ε . The densitized components − g ( j 0 x B , j 0 z B , j x B z B ) \sqrt{-g}\left(j^{0x_B},j^{0z_B},j^{x_Bz_B}\right) − g ( j 0 x B , j 0 z B , j x B z B ) are proportional to ( − ∂ z B u β , ∂ x B u β , − ∂ t B u β ) \left(-\partial_{z_B}u_{\beta},\partial_{x_B}u_{\beta},-\partial_{t_B}u_{\beta}\right) ( − ∂ z B u β , ∂ x B u β , − ∂ t B u β ) , so the spacetime current is conserved.
We now project onto the constant-t B t_B t B slices. The lapse, spatial metric, and spatial volume density are
N A D M = ℓ A d S h B z B , h i j d x i d x j = ℓ A d S 2 z B 2 ( d x B 2 + d z B 2 f B ) , h = ℓ A d S 2 z B 2 h B . (138) N_{\mathrm{ADM}}=\frac{\ell_{\mathrm{AdS}}h_B}{z_B},\qquad
h_{ij}dx^idx^j=\frac{\ell_{\mathrm{AdS}}^2}{z_B^2}\left(dx_B^2+\frac{dz_B^2}{f_B}\right),\qquad
\sqrt{h}=\frac{\ell_{\mathrm{AdS}}^2}{z_B^2\sqrt{h_B}}. \tag*{(138)} N ADM = z B ℓ AdS h B , h ij d x i d x j = z B 2 ℓ AdS 2 ( d x B 2 + f B d z B 2 ) , h = z B 2 h B ℓ AdS 2 . (138)
The future-directed unit normal has covariant components n μ = ( − N A D M , 0 , 0 ) n_\mu=(-N_{\mathrm{ADM}},0,0) n μ = ( − N ADM , 0 , 0 ) . Thus q μ = − n ν j ν μ q^\mu=-n_\nu j^{\nu\mu} q μ = − n ν j ν μ , q 0 = 0 q^0=0 q 0 = 0 , and q i = N A D M j 0 i q^i=N_{\mathrm{ADM}}j^{0i} q i = N ADM j 0 i for i = x B , z B i=x_B,z_B i = x B , z B , which yields
q x B = N z B ( h B cosh p − cosh T ) 2 U β , ε ℓ A d S 2 Δ β , q z B = N z B 2 h B sinh p 2 U β , ε ℓ A d S 2 z h Δ β . (139) q^{x_B}=\frac{\mathcal{N}z_B\left(h_B\cosh p-\cosh T\right)}{2U_{\beta,\varepsilon}\ell_{\mathrm{AdS}}^2\Delta_\beta},\qquad q^{z_B}=\frac{\mathcal{N}z_B^2h_B\sinh p}{2U_{\beta,\varepsilon}\ell_{\mathrm{AdS}}^2z_h\Delta_\beta}. \tag*{(139)} q x B = 2 U β , ε ℓ AdS 2 Δ β N z B ( h B cosh p − cosh T ) , q z B = 2 U β , ε ℓ AdS 2 z h Δ β N z B 2 h B sinh p . (139)
At fixed t B t_B t B the projected current is conserved:
∂ x B ( h q x B ) = − ∂ z B ( h q z B ) = N z B cosh T sinh p 2 U β , ε z h 3 h B Δ β 2 , ∇ i q i = 0. (140) \partial_{x_B}\left(\sqrt{h}q^{x_B}\right)=-\partial_{z_B}\left(\sqrt{h}q^{z_B}\right)=\frac{\mathcal{N}z_B\cosh T\sinh p}{2U_{\beta,\varepsilon}z_h^3h_B\Delta_\beta^2},\qquad\nabla_iq^i=0. \tag*{(140)} ∂ x B ( h q x B ) = − ∂ z B ( h q z B ) = 2 U β , ε z h 3 h B Δ β 2 N z B cosh T sinh p , ∇ i q i = 0. (140)
The current is tangent to the level sets of u β u_\beta u β on each slice. Its string-frame norm is
∣ q ∣ 2 = ℓ A d S 2 z B 2 [ ( q x B ) 2 + ( q z B ) 2 f B ] = ( N 2 ℓ A d S U β , ε ) 2 ( h B cosh p − cosh T ) 2 + ( z B 2 / z h 2 ) sinh 2 p Δ β 2 = ( N 2 ℓ A d S U β , ε ) 2 ( 1 + z B 2 sinh 2 T z h 2 Δ β 2 ) . (141) \begin{aligned}
|q|^2=\frac{\ell_{\mathrm{AdS}}^2}{z_B^2}\left[\left(q^{x_B}\right)^2+\frac{\left(q^{z_B}\right)^2}{f_B}\right] \\
&=\left(\frac{\mathcal{N}}{2\ell_{\mathrm{AdS}}U_{\beta,\varepsilon}}\right)^2\frac{\left(h_B\cosh p-\cosh T\right)^2+\left(z_B^2/z_h^2\right)\sinh^2p}{\Delta_\beta^2} \\
&=\left(\frac{\mathcal{N}}{2\ell_{\mathrm{AdS}}U_{\beta,\varepsilon}}\right)^2\left(1+\frac{z_B^2\sinh^2T}{z_h^2\Delta_\beta^2}\right). \tag*{(141)}
\end{aligned} ∣ q ∣ 2 = z B 2 ℓ AdS 2 [ ( q x B ) 2 + f B ( q z B ) 2 ] = ( 2 ℓ AdS U β , ε N ) 2 Δ β 2 ( h B cosh p − cosh T ) 2 + ( z B 2 / z h 2 ) sinh 2 p = ( 2 ℓ AdS U β , ε N ) 2 ( 1 + z h 2 Δ β 2 z B 2 sinh 2 T ) . (141)
The last equality follows from h B 2 + z B 2 / z h 2 = 1 h_B^2+z_B^2/z_h^2=1 h B 2 + z B 2 / z h 2 = 1 .
The ADM projection defines a spatial current on each slice, with t B t_B t B labeling the slice. Since A A A is defined at t B = 0 t_B=0 t B = 0 and its RT surface lies on the same slice, we now set t B = 0 t_B=0 t B = 0 to compute the entropy flux. On this slice Δ β = D β \Delta_\beta=D_\beta Δ β = D β , j x B z B = 0 j^{x_Bz_B}=0 j x B z B = 0 , and
q x B = N z B ( h B cosh p − 1 ) 2 U β , ε ℓ A d S 2 D β , q z B = N z B 2 h B sinh p 2 U β , ε ℓ A d S 2 z h D β . (142) q^{x_B}=\frac{\mathcal{N}z_B\left(h_B\cosh p-1\right)}{2U_{\beta,\varepsilon}\ell_{\mathrm{AdS}}^2D_\beta},\qquad q^{z_B}=\frac{\mathcal{N}z_B^2h_B\sinh p}{2U_{\beta,\varepsilon}\ell_{\mathrm{AdS}}^2z_hD_\beta}. \tag*{(142)} q x B = 2 U β , ε ℓ AdS 2 D β N z B ( h B cosh p − 1 ) , q z B = 2 U β , ε ℓ AdS 2 z h D β N z B 2 h B sinh p . (142)
with ∣ q ∣ = N 2 ℓ A d S U β , ε |q|=\frac{\mathcal{N}}{2\ell_{\mathrm{AdS}}U_{\beta,\varepsilon}} ∣ q ∣ = 2 ℓ AdS U β , ε N . Figure 4 shows representative profiles of the regulated F1 bundle on the t B = 0 t_B=0 t B = 0 slice in planar BTZ and their crossings of the thermal RT surface. The outward unit normal and proper line element on the cutoff are
Figure 4. The red curves are the t B = 0 t_B=0 t B = 0 profiles cosh p − h B = η z B / z h \cosh p-h_B=\eta z_B/z_h cosh p − h B = η z B / z h , sampled uniformly in u β = log ( η / sinh d ) u_\beta=\log(\eta/\sinh d) u β = log ( η / sinh d ) . They cross the thermal RT surface γ β , A \gamma_{\beta,A} γ β , A (navy) orthogonally and at equal proper intervals along it. Panel (a) shows the right exterior in the original BTZ coordinates, with an expanded vertical scale. Panel (b) shows the same profiles on a regular two-sided conformal slice, where physical angles are preserved and strings that reach the horizon continue across the bifurcation line. Cyan marks A β , ε A_{\beta,\varepsilon} A β , ε , and violet marks the subset of its regulated complement reached by this bundle. The plot uses L A / ( 2 z h ) = 0.8 L_A/(2z_h)=0.8 L A / ( 2 z h ) = 0.8 and ε / z h = 0.15 \varepsilon/z_h=0.15 ε / z h = 0.15 .
n c u t = − ε f ε ℓ A d S ∂ z B , d A S = ℓ A d S ε d x B . (143) n_{\mathrm{cut}}=-\frac{\varepsilon\sqrt{f_\varepsilon}}{\ell_{\mathrm{AdS}}}\partial_{z_B},\qquad dA_S=\frac{\ell_{\mathrm{AdS}}}{\varepsilon}dx_B. \tag*{(143)} n cut = − ℓ AdS ε f ε ∂ z B , d A S = ε ℓ AdS d x B . (143)
The charge flux through the full regulated interval is
Φ β , A [ q ] ≡ ∫ A β , ε q ⋅ n c u t d A S = − N 2 U β , ε z h ∫ a β , ε b β , ε sinh [ ( x B − x 2 ) / z h ] cosh [ ( x B − x 2 ) / z h ] − f ε d x B = N 2 U β , ε log η max η min = N , (144) \begin{aligned}
\Phi_{\beta,A}[q]\equiv\int_{A_{\beta,\varepsilon}}q\cdot n_{\mathrm{cut}}dA_S \\
&=-\frac{\mathcal{N}}{2U_{\beta,\varepsilon}z_h}\int_{a_{\beta,\varepsilon}}^{b_{\beta,\varepsilon}}\frac{\sinh\left[(x_B-x_2)/z_h\right]}{\cosh\left[(x_B-x_2)/z_h\right]-\sqrt{f_\varepsilon}}dx_B \\
&=\frac{\mathcal{N}}{2U_{\beta,\varepsilon}}\log\frac{\eta_{\max}}{\eta_{\min}}=\mathcal{N}, \tag*{(144)}
\end{aligned} Φ β , A [ q ] ≡ ∫ A β , ε q ⋅ n cut d A S = − 2 U β , ε z h N ∫ a β , ε b β , ε cosh [ ( x B − x 2 ) / z h ] − f ε sinh [ ( x B − x 2 ) / z h ] d x B = 2 U β , ε N log η m i n η m a x = N , (144)
where the last equality uses Eq. (120) .
Following the vacuum calculation, define the unit-normalized spatial current inside the bundle by
q ^ i = q i ∣ q ∣ , q ^ = z B ℓ A d S D β [ ( h B cosh p − 1 ) ∂ x B + z B z h h B sinh p ∂ z B ] . (145) \hat{q}^{i}=\frac{q^{i}}{|q|},\qquad
\hat{q}=\frac{z_B}{\ell_{\mathrm{AdS}}D_\beta}\left[(h_B\cosh p-1)\,\partial_{x_B}+\frac{z_B}{z_h}h_B\sinh p\,\partial_{z_B}\right]. \tag*{(145)} q ^ i = ∣ q ∣ q i , q ^ = ℓ AdS D β z B [ ( h B cosh p − 1 ) ∂ x B + z h z B h B sinh p ∂ z B ] . (145)
Since ∣ q ∣ |q| ∣ q ∣ is constant on this slice inside the bundle, ∣ q ^ ∣ = 1 |\hat{q}|=1 ∣ q ^ ∣ = 1 and ∇ i q ^ i = ∇ i q i / ∣ q ∣ = 0 \nabla_i\hat{q}^{i}=\nabla_i q^i/|q|=0 ∇ i q ^ i = ∇ i q i /∣ q ∣ = 0 . The resulting flux is
Φ β , A [ q ^ ] = Φ β , A [ q ] ∣ q ∣ = 2 ℓ A d S U β , ε . (146) \Phi_{\beta,A}[\hat{q}]=\frac{\Phi_{\beta,A}[q]}{|q|}=2\ell_{\mathrm{AdS}}U_{\beta,\varepsilon}. \tag*{(146)} Φ β , A [ q ^ ] = ∣ q ∣ Φ β , A [ q ] = 2 ℓ AdS U β , ε . (146)
As in the vacuum case, we use the string-frame entropy capacity from the off-shell sphere and replica construction,
ρ S = e − 2 ϕ 0 4 G N ( 3 ) . (147) \rho_S=\frac{e^{-2\phi_0}}{4G_N^{(3)}}. \tag*{(147)} ρ S = 4 G N ( 3 ) e − 2 ϕ 0 . (147)
The constant dilaton makes ρ S \rho_S ρ S constant. Combining this capacity with the unit current gives the physical entropy flow
v p h y s i ≡ ρ S q ^ i = ρ S q i ∣ q ∣ , v_{\mathrm{phys}}^{i}\equiv\rho_S\hat{q}^{i}=\rho_S\frac{q^{i}}{|q|}, v phys i ≡ ρ S q ^ i = ρ S ∣ q ∣ q i ,
v p h y s = ρ S z B ℓ A d S D β [ ( h B cosh p − 1 ) ∂ x B + z B z h h B sinh p ∂ z B ] . (148) v_{\mathrm{phys}}=\frac{\rho_S z_B}{\ell_{\mathrm{AdS}}D_\beta}\left[(h_B\cosh p-1)\,\partial_{x_B}+\frac{z_B}{z_h}h_B\sinh p\,\partial_{z_B}\right]. \tag*{(148)} v phys = ℓ AdS D β ρ S z B [ ( h B cosh p − 1 ) ∂ x B + z h z B h B sinh p ∂ z B ] . (148)
It satisfies ∇ i v p h y s i = 0 \nabla_i v_{\mathrm{phys}}^{i}=0 ∇ i v phys i = 0 and ∣ v p h y s ∣ = ρ S |v_{\mathrm{phys}}|=\rho_S ∣ v phys ∣ = ρ S inside the string bundle. Its flux is
Φ β , A ≡ Φ β , A [ v p h y s ] = ρ S Φ β , A [ q ^ ] = 2 ρ S ℓ A d S U β , ε . (149) \Phi_{\beta,A}\equiv\Phi_{\beta,A}[v_{\mathrm{phys}}]=\rho_S\Phi_{\beta,A}[\hat{q}]=2\rho_S\ell_{\mathrm{AdS}}U_{\beta,\varepsilon}. \tag*{(149)} Φ β , A ≡ Φ β , A [ v phys ] = ρ S Φ β , A [ q ^ ] = 2 ρ S ℓ AdS U β , ε . (149)
The physical F1 current thus realizes the maximal entropy flux, and the entropy with the geometric regulator is
S A ( 0 ) = Φ β , A = 2 ρ S ℓ A d S U β , ε = 2 ρ S ℓ A d S arccosh [ z h ε f ε sinh L A 2 z h ] . (150) S_A^{(0)}=\Phi_{\beta,A}=2\rho_S\ell_{\mathrm{AdS}}U_{\beta,\varepsilon}=2\rho_S\ell_{\mathrm{AdS}}\operatorname{arccosh}\left[\frac{z_h}{\varepsilon}\sqrt{f_\varepsilon}\sinh\frac{L_A}{2z_h}\right]. \tag*{(150)} S A ( 0 ) = Φ β , A = 2 ρ S ℓ AdS U β , ε = 2 ρ S ℓ AdS arccosh [ ε z h f ε sinh 2 z h L A ] . (150)
Using central charge c = 6 ρ S ℓ A d S = 3 ℓ A d S e − 2 ϕ 0 / ( 2 G N ( 3 ) ) c=6\rho_S\ell_{\mathrm{AdS}}=3\ell_{\mathrm{AdS}}e^{-2\phi_0}/(2G_N^{(3)}) c = 6 ρ S ℓ AdS = 3 ℓ AdS e − 2 ϕ 0 / ( 2 G N ( 3 ) ) and β = 2 π z h \beta=2\pi z_h β = 2 π z h , we obtain, at fixed L A L_A L A and β \beta β ,
S A ( 0 ) = 2 ρ S ℓ A d S log [ 2 z h ε sinh L A 2 z h ] + o ( 1 ) = c 3 log [ β π ε sinh π L A β ] + o ( 1 ) , (151) S_A^{(0)}=2\rho_S\ell_{\mathrm{AdS}}\log\left[\frac{2z_h}{\varepsilon}\sinh\frac{L_A}{2z_h}\right]+o(1)=\frac{c}{3}\log\left[\frac{\beta}{\pi\varepsilon}\sinh\frac{\pi L_A}{\beta}\right]+o(1), \tag*{(151)} S A ( 0 ) = 2 ρ S ℓ AdS log [ ε 2 z h sinh 2 z h L A ] + o ( 1 ) = 3 c log [ π ε β sinh β π L A ] + o ( 1 ) , (151)
with the limit ε → 0 \varepsilon\to0 ε → 0 . The finite-cutoff terms refer to the regulator in Eq. (116) . Therefore, the continuum result reproduces the well-known thermal interval entanglement entropy on an infinite line [25 ] , obtained here from physical F1 sources.
Finally, to verify maximality, choose the RT unit normal pointing toward the interval homology region:
n β , A = − z B ℓ A d S sinh d ( sinh ξ ∂ x B + z B z h h B cosh d ∂ z B ) . (152) n_{\beta,A}=-\frac{z_B}{\ell_{\mathrm{AdS}}\sinh d}\left(\sinh\xi\partial_{x_B}+\frac{z_B}{z_h}h_B\cosh d\partial_{z_B}\right). \tag*{(152)} n β , A = − ℓ AdS sinh d z B ( sinh ξ ∂ x B + z h z B h B cosh d ∂ z B ) . (152)
On γ β , A \gamma_{\beta,A} γ β , A , we have D β = − tanh d sinh p D_\beta=-\tanh d\sinh p D β = − tanh d sinh p and h B cosh p − 1 = sinh ξ sinh p / cosh d h_B\cosh p-1=\sinh\xi\sinh p/\cosh d h B cosh p − 1 = sinh ξ sinh p / cosh d . Substitution into Eq. (148) gives
v p h y s ∣ γ β , A , ε = ρ S n β , A . (153) \left.v_{\mathrm{phys}}\right|_{\gamma_{\beta,A,\varepsilon}}=\rho_S n_{\beta,A}. \tag*{(153)} v phys ∣ γ β , A , ε = ρ S n β , A . (153)
The flow therefore saturates the capacity normally on the entire regulated RT surface. Eq. (124) gives Length ( γ β , A , ε ) = 2 ℓ A d S U β , ε \operatorname{Length}(\gamma_{\beta,A,\varepsilon})=2\ell_{\mathrm{AdS}}U_{\beta,\varepsilon} Length ( γ β , A , ε ) = 2 ℓ AdS U β , ε . For any admissible flow w i w^i w i on the same regulated homology region, with ∇ i w i = 0 \nabla_iw^i=0 ∇ i w i = 0 and ∣ w ∣ ≤ ρ S \lvert w\rvert\le\rho_S ∣ w ∣ ≤ ρ S , flux conservation and the weighted flux bound [4 , 13 ] of the off-shell construction give
Φ β , A [ w ] = ∫ γ β , A , ε w ⋅ n β , A d A S ≤ ∫ γ β , A , ε ∣ w ∣ d A S ≤ ρ S Length ( γ β , A , ε ) = 2 ρ S ℓ A d S U β , ε = Φ β , A [ v p h y s ] . (154) \begin{aligned}
\Phi_{\beta,A}[w]=\int_{\gamma_{\beta,A,\varepsilon}}w\cdot n_{\beta,A}dA_S\le\int_{\gamma_{\beta,A,\varepsilon}}\lvert w\rvert dA_S \\
&\le\rho_S\operatorname{Length}(\gamma_{\beta,A,\varepsilon})=2\rho_S\ell_{\mathrm{AdS}}U_{\beta,\varepsilon}=\Phi_{\beta,A}[v_{\mathrm{phys}}]. \tag*{(154)}
\end{aligned} Φ β , A [ w ] = ∫ γ β , A , ε w ⋅ n β , A d A S ≤ ∫ γ β , A , ε ∣ w ∣ d A S ≤ ρ S Length ( γ β , A , ε ) = 2 ρ S ℓ AdS U β , ε = Φ β , A [ v phys ] . (154)
Vacuum limit and thermal extensivity
We finally check that the thermal construction reduces to the vacuum worldsheet and current, and that its long-interval flux reproduces the horizon entropy density.
For the vacuum limit, take x c = 0 x_c=0 x c = 0 , L A = 2 R L_A=2R L A = 2 R , and let z h → ∞ z_h\to\infty z h → ∞ with z 0 = z h η z_0=z_h\eta z 0 = z h η and the cutoff ε \varepsilon ε fixed. At fixed ( τ , σ ) (\tau,\sigma) ( τ , σ ) with D > 0 \mathcal{D}>0 D > 0 ,
P η , Q η , W η = z h D 2 z 0 + O ( z h − 1 ) . (155) P_\eta,\ Q_\eta,\ W_\eta=\frac{z_h\mathcal{D}}{2z_0}+O\left(z_h^{-1}\right). \tag*{(155)} P η , Q η , W η = 2 z 0 z h D + O ( z h − 1 ) . (155)
The thermal embedding consequently tends to
( X B t , X B x , X B z ) ⟶ ( 2 z 0 τ D , R − 2 z 0 σ D , 2 z 0 D ) , (156) \left(X_B^t,X_B^x,X_B^z\right)\longrightarrow\left(\frac{2z_0\tau}{\mathcal{D}},R-\frac{2z_0\sigma}{\mathcal{D}},\frac{2z_0}{\mathcal{D}}\right), \tag*{(156)} ( X B t , X B x , X B z ) ⟶ ( D 2 z 0 τ , R − D 2 z 0 σ , D 2 z 0 ) , (156)
which is the vacuum embedding after identifying ( t B , x B , z B ) (t_B,x_B,z_B) ( t B , x B , z B ) with ( t , x , z ) (t,x,z) ( t , x , z ) . At fixed bulk coordinates, the combinations in the current obey
Δ β = Δ A 2 z h 2 + O ( z h − 4 ) , Δ A = ( x B − R ) 2 + z B 2 − t B 2 (157) \Delta_{\beta}=\frac{\Delta_A}{2z_h^2}+O\left(z_h^{-4}\right),\qquad\Delta_A=(x_B-R)^2+z_B^2-t_B^2 \tag*{(157)} Δ β = 2 z h 2 Δ A + O ( z h − 4 ) , Δ A = ( x B − R ) 2 + z B 2 − t B 2 (157)
and
h B cosh p − cosh T = ( x B − R ) 2 − z B 2 − t B 2 2 z h 2 + O ( z h − 4 ) . (158) h_B\cosh p-\cosh T=\frac{(x_B-R)^2-z_B^2-t_B^2}{2z_h^2}+O\left(z_h^{-4}\right). \tag*{(158)} h B cosh p − cosh T = 2 z h 2 ( x B − R ) 2 − z B 2 − t B 2 + O ( z h − 4 ) . (158)
The label u β = log [ z h Δ β / ( z B sinh d ) ] u_\beta=\log[z_h\Delta_\beta/(z_B\sinh d)] u β = log [ z h Δ β / ( z B sinh d )] tends to u = log [ Δ A / ( 2 R z B ) ] u=\log[\Delta_A/(2Rz_B)] u = log [ Δ A / ( 2 R z B )] . The regulated half-width satisfies U β , ϵ → arccosh ( R / ϵ ) = U ϵ U_{\beta,\epsilon}\to\operatorname{arccosh}(R/\epsilon)=U_\epsilon U β , ϵ → arccosh ( R / ϵ ) = U ϵ , so the uniform distribution over u β u_\beta u β reduces to the vacuum distribution over u u u . Inside the string bundle, these expansions, together with sinh p = p + O ( p 3 ) \sinh p=p+O\left(p^3\right) sinh p = p + O ( p 3 ) and sinh T = T + O ( T 3 ) \sinh T=T+O\left(T^3\right) sinh T = T + O ( T 3 ) , give
\begin{pmatrix}
j^{0x_B}\\
j^{0z_B}\\
j^{x_Bz_B}
\end{pmatrix}
\longrightarrow
\frac{\mathcal{N}}{2U_\epsilon\ell_{\mathrm{AdS}}\Delta_A}
\begin{pmatrix}
z_B^2\left[(x_B-R)^2-z_B^2-t_B^2\right]\\
2z_B^3(x_B-R)\\
2t_Bz_B^3
\end{pmatrix}. \tag*{(159)}\end{pmatrix}
Thus the full spacetime current, including its spatial component at nonzero time, tends to the vacuum current. The regulated entropy flux likewise tends to 2 ρ S ℓ A d S U ϵ 2\rho_S\ell_{\mathrm{AdS}}U_\epsilon 2 ρ S ℓ AdS U ϵ .
To check thermal extensivity, we ask how much entropy is added when the interval is enlarged at fixed inverse temperature β = 2 π z h \beta=2\pi z_h β = 2 π z h . The L A L_A L A -dependent term in the continuum entropy is ( c / 3 ) log sinh d (c/3)\log\sinh d ( c /3 ) log sinh d , with d = L A / ( 2 z h ) = π L A / β d=L_A/(2z_h)=\pi L_A/\beta d = L A / ( 2 z h ) = π L A / β . Its slope is
∂ S A ( 0 ) ∂ L A ∣ β = c 3 cosh d sinh d 1 2 z h = c 6 z h coth d . (160) \left.\frac{\partial S_A^{(0)}}{\partial L_A}\right|_\beta
=\frac{c}{3}\frac{\cosh d}{\sinh d}\frac{1}{2z_h}
=\frac{c}{6z_h}\coth d. \tag*{(160)} ∂ L A ∂ S A ( 0 ) β = 3 c sinh d cosh d 2 z h 1 = 6 z h c coth d . (160)
For L A / β → ∞ L_A/\beta\to\infty L A / β → ∞ , we have d → ∞ d\to\infty d → ∞ and coth d → 1 \coth d\to1 coth d → 1 . Thus, using c = 6 ρ S ℓ A d S c=6\rho_S\ell_{\mathrm{AdS}} c = 6 ρ S ℓ AdS , we obtain
lim L A / β → ∞ ∂ S A ( 0 ) ∂ L A ∣ β = c 6 z h = π c 3 β = ρ S ℓ A d S z h . (161) \lim_{L_A/\beta\to\infty}\left.\frac{\partial S_A^{(0)}}{\partial L_A}\right|_\beta
=\frac{c}{6z_h}=\frac{\pi c}{3\beta}
=\frac{\rho_S\ell_{\mathrm{AdS}}}{z_h}. \tag*{(161)} L A / β → ∞ lim ∂ L A ∂ S A ( 0 ) β = 6 z h c = 3 β π c = z h ρ S ℓ AdS . (161)
The entropy therefore grows linearly at large L A L_A L A , with this limiting slope giving the entropy added per unit length. On the BTZ horizon, d A S = ( ℓ A d S / z h ) d x B dA_S=(\ell_{\mathrm{AdS}}/z_h)\,dx_B d A S = ( ℓ AdS / z h ) d x B . Multiplying the proper length per unit x B x_B x B by ρ S \rho_S ρ S gives the same entropy density. The F1 flux thus reproduces the horizon entropy per unit boundary length in the long-interval limit [2 , 25 ] .
F1 connectivity at fixed RT entropy
In both the vacuum and thermal constructions of § 3 and § 4 , the F1 strings that cross the interval RT surface connect A A A only to a restricted contact interval B h i t B_{\mathrm{hit}} B hit in the regulated complement A ˉ \bar{A} A ˉ . Their flux nevertheless gives S A ( 0 ) S_A^{(0)} S A ( 0 ) , the leading von Neumann entropy of the reduced state on A A A . In the vacuum this is the bipartite entanglement entropy between A A A and A ˉ \bar{A} A ˉ ; in the thermal case it is not an entanglement measure for A A A and A ˉ \bar{A} A ˉ alone. In neither case is it the entropy of the pair A A A and B h i t B_{\mathrm{hit}} B hit . To understand the restricted contact region, we vary the NS–NS fraction η \eta η . The complementary R–R flux in the classical type IIB solution preserves the metric [13 , 29 , 30 ] . Thus the RT surface and its capacity are fixed, while the force from B B B on the probe F1 changes. We use the stationary string equation and current prescription of our previous work [13 ] to follow this change from the bit-thread flow at η = 0 \eta= 0 η = 0 to the one-sided contacts at η = 1 \eta= 1 η = 1 . The resulting on-shell currents interpolate from the two-sided geodesic routing at η = 0 \eta= 0 η = 0 to the pure NS–NS routing at η = 1 \eta= 1 η = 1 , where the complementary contacts lie only in B h i t B_{\mathrm{hit}} B hit . Every member of the family gives the same leading RT entropy.
The stationary F1 profile at mixed flux
We first solve for the F1 string that crosses the RT surface at a specified point. To use a static worldsheet gauge, we introduce coordinates ( t R , r , θ ) (t_R, r, \theta) ( t R , r , θ ) adapted to the interval Killing boost and seek strings stationary with respect to t R t_R t R . The coordinate t R t_R t R is the interval modular (Rindler) time, not the planar-BTZ time t B t_B t B , although their time-zero slices coincide in the region used below. In the wedge containing A A A , r > r h r > r_h r > r h , and the RT surface is the bifurcation curve of the interval Killing horizon at r = r h r = r_h r = r h [36 ] . Along the RT surface, the coordinate θ ∈ R \theta\in\mathbb{R} θ ∈ R increases toward the right endpoint. We set r h = ℓ A d S r_h = \ell_{\mathrm{AdS}} r h = ℓ AdS by a choice of coordinate normalization. In planar BTZ, the black hole horizon is the distinct surface z B = z h z_B = z_h z B = z h . In this section, η \eta η denotes the background NS–NS flux fraction. When the worldsheet integration constant of § 4.1 is needed below, we denote it by η w s \eta_{\mathrm{ws}} η ws . Where the charts overlap, the t R = 0 t_R = 0 t R = 0 slice agrees with t = 0 t = 0 t = 0 in the vacuum and with t B = 0 t_B = 0 t B = 0 in planar BTZ. With the flux orientation of Ref. [13 ] , the metric and the external two-form potentials are
d S S 2 = − f d t R 2 + d r 2 f + r 2 d θ 2 , f ( r ) = r 2 − r h 2 ℓ A d S 2 , dS_S^2 = -f\,dt_R^2 + \frac{dr^2}{f} + r^2d\theta^2,\qquad f(r) = \frac{r^2-r_h^2}{\ell_{\mathrm{AdS}}^2}, d S S 2 = − f d t R 2 + f d r 2 + r 2 d θ 2 , f ( r ) = ℓ AdS 2 r 2 − r h 2 ,
B = − b η d t R ∧ d θ , b η ( r ) = η ( r 2 − r h 2 ) ℓ A d S , B = -b_\eta dt_R \wedge d\theta,\qquad b_\eta(r) = \frac{\eta(r^2-r_h^2)}{\ell_{\mathrm{AdS}}}, B = − b η d t R ∧ d θ , b η ( r ) = ℓ AdS η ( r 2 − r h 2 ) ,
C ( 2 ) = − c η d t R ∧ d θ , c η ( r ) = e − ϕ 0 1 − η 2 ( r 2 − r h 2 ) ℓ A d S , 0 ≤ η ≤ 1. (162) C^{(2)} = -c_\eta dt_R \wedge d\theta,\qquad c_\eta(r) = \frac{e^{-\phi_0}\sqrt{1-\eta^2}(r^2-r_h^2)}{\ell_{\mathrm{AdS}}},\qquad0 \le\eta\le1. \tag*{(162)} C ( 2 ) = − c η d t R ∧ d θ , c η ( r ) = ℓ AdS e − ϕ 0 1 − η 2 ( r 2 − r h 2 ) , 0 ≤ η ≤ 1. (162)
In particular, H = d B = ( 2 η / ℓ A d S ) r d t R ∧ d r ∧ d θ H = dB = (2\eta/\ell_{\mathrm{AdS}})r\,dt_R \wedge dr \wedge d\theta H = d B = ( 2 η / ℓ AdS ) r d t R ∧ d r ∧ d θ . In the classical type IIB solution, the relative NS–NS and R–R contributions to the curvature sum to η 2 + ( 1 − η 2 ) = 1 \eta^2 + (1-\eta^2) = 1 η 2 + ( 1 − η 2 ) = 1 . The two-form potentials are written in a gauge that vanishes at the interval horizon. The bosonic F1 action [15 ] couples to B B B and the probe remains at fixed internal coordinates.
As in the full horizon construction [13 ] , take the static worldsheet gauge X t R = τ X^{t_R} = \tau X t R = τ , X r = σ = r X^r = \sigma= r X r = σ = r , X θ = θ η ( r ) X^\theta= \theta_\eta(r) X θ = θ η ( r ) with ϵ τ σ = + 1 \epsilon^{\tau\sigma} = +1 ϵ τ σ = + 1 . The induced metric is γ τ τ i n d = − f \gamma^{\mathrm{ind}}_{\tau\tau} = -f γ τ τ ind = − f , γ σ σ i n d = f − 1 + r 2 θ η ′ 2 \gamma^{\mathrm{ind}}_{\sigma\sigma} = f^{-1} + r^2\theta_\eta^{\prime2} γ σ σ ind = f − 1 + r 2 θ η ′2 , and γ τ σ i n d = 0 \gamma^{\mathrm{ind}}_{\tau\sigma} = 0 γ τ σ ind = 0 , where a prime denotes d / d r d/dr d / d r . Eliminating the auxiliary worldsheet metric gives the reduced F1 action
S F 1 = − 1 2 π α ′ ∫ d t R d r ( 1 + f r 2 θ η ′ 2 − b η θ η ′ ) . (163) S_{\mathrm{F1}} = -\frac{1}{2\pi\alpha'}\int dt_Rdr\left(\sqrt{1+fr^2\theta_\eta^{\prime2}}-b_\eta\theta_\eta'\right). \tag*{(163)} S F1 = − 2 π α ′ 1 ∫ d t R d r ( 1 + f r 2 θ η ′2 − b η θ η ′ ) . (163)
The angular coordinate is cyclic, so its equation has a first integral, with the squared equation useful for isolating the slope:
f r 2 θ η ′ 1 + f r 2 θ η ′ 2 − b η = k θ , θ η ′ 2 = ( b η + k θ ) 2 f r 2 [ f r 2 − ( b η + k θ ) 2 ] . (164) \frac{fr^2\theta_\eta'}{\sqrt{1+fr^2\theta_\eta^{\prime2}}}-b_\eta= k_\theta,\qquad\theta_\eta^{\prime2} = \frac{(b_\eta+k_\theta)^2}{fr^2\left[fr^2-(b_\eta+k_\theta)^2\right]}. \tag*{(164)} 1 + f r 2 θ η ′2 f r 2 θ η ′ − b η = k θ , θ η ′2 = f r 2 [ f r 2 − ( b η + k θ ) 2 ] ( b η + k θ ) 2 . (164)
For a regular branch reaching r h r_h r h , both b η b_\eta b η and the first term in the first equation vanish at the horizon, so k θ = 0 k_\theta= 0 k θ = 0 . On this branch, define the positive effective width
D η 2 ( r ) ≡ r 2 − b η 2 f = ( 1 − η 2 ) r 2 + η 2 r h 2 . (165) \mathcal{D}_\eta^2(r) \equiv r^2 - \frac{b_\eta^2}{f} = (1-\eta^2)r^2+\eta^2r_h^2. \tag*{(165)} D η 2 ( r ) ≡ r 2 − f b η 2 = ( 1 − η 2 ) r 2 + η 2 r h 2 . (165)
the radial slope and induced determinant take the form
θ η ′ = b η f r D η = η ℓ A d S r D η , 1 + f r 2 θ η ′ 2 = r D η . (166) \theta'_\eta= \frac{b_\eta}{fr\mathcal{D}_\eta} = \frac{\eta\ell_{\mathrm{AdS}}}{r\mathcal{D}_\eta}, \qquad\sqrt{1+fr^2\theta_\eta'^2} = \frac{r}{\mathcal{D}_\eta}. \tag*{(166)} θ η ′ = f r D η b η = r D η η ℓ AdS , 1 + f r 2 θ η ′2 = D η r . (166)
The transverse equation and the auxiliary metric equation imply the remaining embedding equations by worldsheet reparametrization invariance. Using the ingoing time t i n = t R + ∫ d r / f t_{\mathrm{in}} = t_R + \int dr/f t in = t R + ∫ d r / f , the induced metric can be written as − f d t i n 2 + 2 d t i n d r + r 2 θ η ′ 2 d r 2 -fdt_{\mathrm{in}}^2+2dt_{\mathrm{in}}dr+r^2\theta_\eta'^2dr^2 − f d t in 2 + 2 d t in d r + r 2 θ η ′2 d r 2 and has determinant − 1 -1 − 1 at r h r_h r h . The pullback of B B B is regular in these coordinates.
We therefore parameterize each string by its RT crossing coordinate θ h = θ η ( r h ) \theta_h=\theta_\eta(r_h) θ h = θ η ( r h ) . Integrating the slope yields
θ η ( r ) = θ h + ℓ A d S r h log ( 1 + η ) r D η ( r ) + η r h . (167) \theta_\eta(r) = \theta_h + \frac{\ell_{\mathrm{AdS}}}{r_h}\log\frac{(1+\eta)r}{\mathcal{D}_\eta(r)+\eta r_h}. \tag*{(167)} θ η ( r ) = θ h + r h ℓ AdS log D η ( r ) + η r h ( 1 + η ) r . (167)
At η = 0 \eta=0 η = 0 this gives θ 0 ( r ) = θ h \theta_0(r)=\theta_h θ 0 ( r ) = θ h , so the time-zero strings follow geodesics normal to the cut. At η = 1 \eta=1 η = 1 the angular shift is ( ℓ A d S / r h ) log ( r / r h ) (\ell_{\mathrm{AdS}}/r_h)\log(r/r_h) ( ℓ AdS / r h ) log ( r / r h ) , which recovers the pure NS–NS profiles. For η < 1 \eta<1 η < 1 its limiting value is ( ℓ A d S / r h ) arctanh η (\ell_{\mathrm{AdS}}/r_h)\operatorname{arctanh}\eta ( ℓ AdS / r h ) arctanh η as r → ∞ r\to\infty r → ∞ .
To follow the other end of each string, we introduce a signed coordinate ρ \rho ρ on the time-zero slice by r = r h cosh ρ r=r_h\cosh\rho r = r h cosh ρ , with ρ > 0 \rho>0 ρ > 0 on the side containing A A A and ρ < 0 \rho<0 ρ < 0 on the opposite side of the RT surface. In this notation, we define the quantity
W η ( ρ ) ≡ D η ( r h cosh ρ ) r h = 1 + ( 1 − η 2 ) sinh 2 ρ . (168) W_\eta(\rho)\equiv\frac{\mathcal{D}_\eta(r_h\cosh\rho)}{r_h}=\sqrt{1+(1-\eta^2)\sinh^2\rho}. \tag*{(168)} W η ( ρ ) ≡ r h D η ( r h cosh ρ ) = 1 + ( 1 − η 2 ) sinh 2 ρ . (168)
On the unit A d S 3 \mathrm{AdS}_3 AdS 3 hyperboloid − Y − 1 2 − Y 0 2 + Y 1 2 + Y 2 2 = − 1 -Y_{-1}^2-Y_0^2+Y_1^2+Y_2^2=-1 − Y − 1 2 − Y 0 2 + Y 1 2 + Y 2 2 = − 1 , the two boost wedges have
( Y 1 , Y 0 ) = sinh ρ ( cosh t R ℓ A d S , sinh t R ℓ A d S ) , ( Y − 1 , Y 2 ) = cosh ρ ( cosh θ , sinh θ ) . (169) (Y_1,Y_0)=\sinh\rho\left(\cosh\frac{t_R}{\ell_{\mathrm{AdS}}},\sinh\frac{t_R}{\ell_{\mathrm{AdS}}}\right), \qquad(Y_{-1},Y_2)=\cosh\rho(\cosh\theta,\sinh\theta). \tag*{(169)} ( Y 1 , Y 0 ) = sinh ρ ( cosh ℓ AdS t R , sinh ℓ AdS t R ) , ( Y − 1 , Y 2 ) = cosh ρ ( cosh θ , sinh θ ) . (169)
With r h = ℓ A d S r_h=\ell_{\mathrm{AdS}} r h = ℓ AdS , the profile in Eq. (167) is the intersection of the hyperboloid with the plane
( 1 + η ) e θ h ( Y − 1 − Y 2 ) − ( 1 − η ) e − θ h ( Y − 1 + Y 2 ) = ( W η + η ) − ( W η − η ) = 2 η . (170) (1+\eta)e^{\theta_h}(Y_{-1}-Y_2)-(1-\eta)e^{-\theta_h}(Y_{-1}+Y_2)=(W_\eta+\eta)-(W_\eta-\eta)=2\eta. \tag*{(170)} ( 1 + η ) e θ h ( Y − 1 − Y 2 ) − ( 1 − η ) e − θ h ( Y − 1 + Y 2 ) = ( W η + η ) − ( W η − η ) = 2 η . (170)
The projected plane normal in the tangent space of A d S 3 \mathrm{AdS}_3 AdS 3 has squared norm 4 ( 1 − η 2 ) + ( 2 η ) 2 = 4 4(1-\eta^2)+(2\eta)^2=4 4 ( 1 − η 2 ) + ( 2 η ) 2 = 4 . The section is therefore smooth and timelike across the boost horizons. Analytically continuing this regular solution also continues the local F1 equations. This fixes the two branches for each θ h \theta_h θ h and charge orientation.
String current and its total RT flux
We now compute the current of the stationary solutions derived above. At η = 1 \eta= 1 η = 1 , these solutions recover the pure NS-NS worldsheets of § 3 and § 4 . We keep the same cutoff and RT crossing points as we vary η \eta η , so that we can compare the boundary contacts at fixed total RT flux.
We first derive the current before counting its boundary contacts. The RT surface has d A S = r h d θ h dA_S = r_h d\theta_h d A S = r h d θ h for increasing θ h ∈ [ − U , U ] \theta_h \in[-U,U] θ h ∈ [ − U , U ] , where U = U ε U = U_\varepsilon U = U ε in vacuum and U = U β , ε U = U_{\beta,\varepsilon} U = U β , ε in planar BTZ. Thus r h = ℓ A d S r_h = \ell_{\mathrm{AdS}} r h = ℓ AdS makes θ h \theta_h θ h the signed RT proper distance from the midpoint in units of ℓ A d S \ell_{\mathrm{AdS}} ℓ AdS . To match the earlier conventions, we choose θ h = − u \theta_h = -u θ h = − u in vacuum and θ h = − u β \theta_h = -u_\beta θ h = − u β in planar BTZ, because the earlier coordinates increase to the left. For N \mathcal{N} N equally oriented sources, set θ s = 2 U / N \theta_s = 2U/\mathcal{N} θ s = 2 U / N and place the RT crossings at θ h , k = − U + ( k + 1 2 ) θ s \theta_{h,k} = -U + (k + \frac{1}{2})\theta_s θ h , k = − U + ( k + 2 1 ) θ s , k = 0 , … , N − 1 k = 0,\ldots,\mathcal{N} - 1 k = 0 , … , N − 1 . The function θ η , k ( r ) \theta_{\eta,k}(r) θ η , k ( r ) is given by Eq. (167) with θ h = θ h , k \theta_h = \theta_{h,k} θ h = θ h , k . Note that θ η , k ( r h ) = θ h , k \theta_{\eta,k}(r_h) = \theta_{h,k} θ η , k ( r h ) = θ h , k at r = r h r = r_h r = r h since D η ( r h ) = r h \mathcal{D}_\eta(r_h) = r_h D η ( r h ) = r h . The static gauge in the normalized source current (19) supplies δ ( t R − τ ) δ ( r − σ ) \delta(t_R - \tau)\,\delta(r - \sigma) δ ( t R − τ ) δ ( r − σ ) . Integrating those two delta functions and using − g = r \sqrt{-g} = r − g = r gives
j η 0 r = 1 r ∑ k = 0 N − 1 δ ( θ − θ η , k ( r ) ) , j η 0 θ = θ η ′ j η 0 r , j η r θ = 0. (171) j_\eta^{0r} = \frac{1}{r}\sum_{k=0}^{\mathcal{N}-1}\delta\left(\theta-\theta_{\eta,k}(r)\right),\qquad j_\eta^{0\theta} = \theta'_\eta j_\eta^{0r},\qquad j_\eta^{r\theta}=0. \tag*{(171)} j η 0 r = r 1 k = 0 ∑ N − 1 δ ( θ − θ η , k ( r ) ) , j η 0 θ = θ η ′ j η 0 r , j η r θ = 0. (171)
At fixed r r r the label θ h = θ − [ θ η ( r ) − θ η ( r h ) ] \theta_h = \theta- [\theta_\eta(r) - \theta_\eta(r_h)] θ h = θ − [ θ η ( r ) − θ η ( r h )] differs from θ \theta θ by a common shift, so the delta functions carry a unit Jacobian. In the large N \mathcal{N} N limit, the weighted sum of delta functions θ s ∑ k δ ( θ h − θ h , k ) \theta_s\sum_k\delta(\theta_h-\theta_{h,k}) θ s ∑ k δ ( θ h − θ h , k ) gives a uniform density of one on [ − U , U ] [-U,U] [ − U , U ] and zero outside, as seen by integrating it against any smooth function.
The slice metric is h i j d x i d x j = d r 2 / f + r 2 d θ 2 h_{ij}dx^idx^j = dr^2/f + r^2d\theta^2 h ij d x i d x j = d r 2 / f + r 2 d θ 2 and N A D M = f N_{\mathrm{ADM}} = \sqrt{f} N ADM = f . The projected components and their norm inside the bundle are
q η r = N A D M j η 0 r = N f 2 U r , q η θ = N A D M j η 0 θ = θ η ′ q η r . (172) q_\eta^r = N_{\mathrm{ADM}}j_\eta^{0r} = \frac{\mathcal{N}\sqrt{f}}{2Ur},\qquad q_\eta^\theta= N_{\mathrm{ADM}}j_\eta^{0\theta} = \theta'_\eta q_\eta^r. \tag*{(172)} q η r = N ADM j η 0 r = 2 U r N f , q η θ = N ADM j η 0 θ = θ η ′ q η r . (172)
Their norm is
∣ q η ∣ 2 = ( N 2 U r ) 2 ( 1 + f r 2 θ η ′ 2 ) = ( N 2 U D η ) 2 . (173) |q_\eta|^2 = \left(\frac{\mathcal{N}}{2Ur}\right)^2\left(1+fr^2\theta_\eta^{\prime2}\right)=\left(\frac{\mathcal{N}}{2U\mathcal{D}_\eta}\right)^2. \tag*{(173)} ∣ q η ∣ 2 = ( 2 U r N ) 2 ( 1 + f r 2 θ η ′2 ) = ( 2 U D η N ) 2 . (173)
Since h = r / f \sqrt{h}=r/\sqrt{f} h = r / f , h q η r \sqrt{h}q_\eta^r h q η r is constant and h q η θ \sqrt{h}q_\eta^\theta h q η θ is independent of θ \theta θ in the bundle. Its sides are profiles of constant θ h \theta_h θ h , so there is no normal flux across the sides and the extension by zero preserves ∇ i q η i = 0 \nabla_iq_\eta^i=0 ∇ i q η i = 0 . On a segment of fixed r r r spanning the populated labels, the outward unit normal is f ∂ r \sqrt{f}\partial_r f ∂ r and the line element is r d θ r d\theta r d θ . Its charge density flux is given by
Φ [ q η ] = ∫ − U U q η r f r d θ h = N 2 U ∫ − U U d θ h = N . (174) \Phi[q_\eta]=\int_{-U}^{U}\frac{q_\eta^r}{\sqrt{f}}r\,d\theta_h=\frac{\mathcal{N}}{2U}\int_{-U}^{U}d\theta_h=\mathcal{N}. \tag*{(174)} Φ [ q η ] = ∫ − U U f q η r r d θ h = 2 U N ∫ − U U d θ h = N . (174)
Here d θ = d θ h d\theta=d\theta_h d θ = d θ h at fixed r r r , and the formula also gives the flux at the RT cut by continuity.
For η < 1 \eta<1 η < 1 the charge norm varies along each string. A pointwise rescaling to norm ρ S \rho_S ρ S would give
∇ i ( ρ S q η i ∣ q η ∣ ) = ρ S f r D η ′ = ρ S ( 1 − η 2 ) f D η . (175) \nabla_i\left(\rho_S\frac{q_\eta^i}{|q_\eta|}\right)=\frac{\rho_S\sqrt{f}}{r}\mathcal{D}'_\eta=\frac{\rho_S(1-\eta^2)\sqrt{f}}{\mathcal{D}_\eta}. \tag*{(175)} ∇ i ( ρ S ∣ q η ∣ q η i ) = r ρ S f D η ′ = D η ρ S ( 1 − η 2 ) f . (175)
in the bundle of the A A A wedge. Instead, as in Ref. [13 ] , we use a single constant C g e o m C_{\mathrm{geom}} C geom and fix it by the local capacity:
C g e o m = inf r ≥ r h ρ S ∣ q η ∣ = 2 U r h ρ S N . (176) C_{\mathrm{geom}}=\inf_{r\ge r_h}\frac{\rho_S}{|q_\eta|}=\frac{2Ur_h\rho_S}{\mathcal{N}}. \tag*{(176)} C geom = r ≥ r h inf ∣ q η ∣ ρ S = N 2 U r h ρ S . (176)
This uses D η 2 − r h 2 = ( 1 − η 2 ) ( r 2 − r h 2 ) ≥ 0 \mathcal{D}_\eta^2-r_h^2=(1-\eta^2)(r^2-r_h^2)\geq0 D η 2 − r h 2 = ( 1 − η 2 ) ( r 2 − r h 2 ) ≥ 0 and the presence of the cut r = r h r=r_h r = r h in the support. The resulting entropy flow in the A A A wedge is
v p h y s , η i = C g e o m q η i = ρ S r h f r ( 1 , η ℓ A d S r D η ) . (177) v_{\mathrm{phys},\eta}^{i}=C_{\mathrm{geom}}q_\eta^{i}=\rho_S\frac{r_h\sqrt{f}}{r}\left(1,\frac{\eta\ell_{\mathrm{AdS}}}{r\mathcal{D}_\eta}\right). \tag*{(177)} v phys , η i = C geom q η i = ρ S r r h f ( 1 , r D η η ℓ AdS ) . (177)
It is easy to check that
∇ i v p h y s , η i = 0 , ∣ v p h y s , η ∣ = ρ S r h D η ≤ ρ S . (178) \nabla_i v_{\mathrm{phys},\eta}^{i}=0,\qquad|v_{\mathrm{phys},\eta}|=\rho_S\frac{r_h}{\mathcal{D}_\eta}\leq\rho_S. \tag*{(178)} ∇ i v phys , η i = 0 , ∣ v phys , η ∣ = ρ S D η r h ≤ ρ S . (178)
The total RT flux is therefore
S A ( 0 ) = C g e o m N = 2 ρ S r h U = 2 ρ S ℓ A d S U . (179) S_A^{(0)}=C_{\mathrm{geom}}\mathcal{N}=2\rho_Sr_hU=2\rho_S\ell_{\mathrm{AdS}}U. \tag*{(179)} S A ( 0 ) = C geom N = 2 ρ S r h U = 2 ρ S ℓ AdS U . (179)
The total is independent of η \eta η .
Vacuum: from two-sided to one-sided contact
Now, we fix the cutoff and the RT crossing points while varying η \eta η . Each profile has one cutoff contact x A x_A x A in A ϵ A_\epsilon A ϵ . We ask whether its other contact x o u t x_{\mathrm{out}} x out lies to the left or right of A ϵ A_\epsilon A ϵ .
For 0 ≤ η < 1 0\leq\eta<1 0 ≤ η < 1 , write ϑ = arctanh η \vartheta=\operatorname{arctanh}\eta ϑ = arctanh η and w = θ h + ϑ w=\theta_h+\vartheta w = θ h + ϑ . At t = 0 t=0 t = 0 , the Poincare coordinates give Y − 1 = ( R 2 + x 2 + z 2 ) / ( 2 R z ) Y_{-1}=(R^2+x^2+z^2)/(2Rz) Y − 1 = ( R 2 + x 2 + z 2 ) / ( 2 R z ) and Y 2 = x / z Y_2=x/z Y 2 = x / z . Eq. (170) becomes
sinh w R 2 + x 2 + z 2 2 R z − cosh w x z = sinh ϑ . (180) \sinh w\frac{R^2+x^2+z^2}{2Rz}-\cosh w\frac{x}{z}=\sinh\vartheta. \tag*{(180)} sinh w 2 R z R 2 + x 2 + z 2 − cosh w z x = sinh ϑ . (180)
At z = ϵ z=\epsilon z = ϵ , this is a quadratic in x x x for w ≠ 0 w\neq0 w = 0 . The sum of its roots is 2 R coth w 2R\coth w 2 R coth w . Since ∣ x A ∣ < R |x_A|<R ∣ x A ∣ < R and ∣ coth w ∣ > 1 |\coth w|>1 ∣ coth w ∣ > 1 , we have
x o u t = 2 R coth w − x A ⟹ { x o u t < − R , w < 0 , x o u t > R , w > 0. (181) x_{\mathrm{out}}=2R\coth w-x_A\quad\Longrightarrow\quad
\begin{cases}
x_{\mathrm{out}}<-R, & w<0,\\
x_{\mathrm{out}}>R, & w>0.
\end{cases} \tag*{(181)} x out = 2 R coth w − x A ⟹ { x out < − R , x out > R , w < 0 , w > 0. (181)
For a string with fixed θ h \theta_h θ h , increasing η \eta η increases w w w . When a string switches sides, x o u t x_{\mathrm{out}} x out tends to − ∞ -\infty − ∞ as w → 0 − w\to0^- w → 0 − and to + ∞ +\infty + ∞ as w → 0 + w\to0^+ w → 0 + . The profile with w = 0 w=0 w = 0 reaches Poincare infinity. A single crossing point contributes no flux in the continuum limit.
The dividing point on the RT surface is at θ h = − ϑ \theta_h=-\vartheta θ h = − ϑ . Strings crossing at smaller θ h \theta_h θ h connect to the left of A ϵ A_\epsilon A ϵ , whereas those crossing at larger θ h \theta_h θ h connect to the right. As η \eta η increases, the dividing point moves left from the midpoint of the fixed range [ − U ϵ , U ϵ ] [-U_\epsilon,U_\epsilon] [ − U ϵ , U ϵ ] . The left flux fraction is therefore the length of the part of this range below − ϑ -\vartheta − ϑ , divided by the total length:
Φ L S A ( 0 ) = [ U ϵ − ϑ ] + 2 U ϵ , U ϵ = arccosh R ϵ , [ y ] + = max ( y , 0 ) . (182) \frac{\Phi_L}{S_A^{(0)}}=\frac{[U_\epsilon-\vartheta]_+}{2U_\epsilon},\qquad U_\epsilon=\operatorname{arccosh}\frac{R}{\epsilon},\qquad[y]_+=\max(y,0). \tag*{(182)} S A ( 0 ) Φ L = 2 U ϵ [ U ϵ − ϑ ] + , U ϵ = arccosh ϵ R , [ y ] + = max ( y , 0 ) . (182)
At η = 0 \eta= 0 η = 0 , half the flux goes to each side. The left flux vanishes when the dividing point reaches θ h = − U ε \theta_h = -U_\varepsilon θ h = − U ε , at
η c r i t = tanh U ε = 1 − ε 2 / R 2 . (183) \eta_{\rm crit} = \tanh U_\varepsilon= \sqrt{1-\varepsilon^2/R^2}. \tag*{(183)} η crit = tanh U ε = 1 − ε 2 / R 2 . (183)
At this value the profile through the left endpoint of the regulated RT curve still reaches infinity. For η > η c r i t \eta> \eta_{\rm crit} η > η crit , all complementary contacts lie in a bounded interval on the right. In the pure NS–NS case η = 1 \eta= 1 η = 1 , the profiles obey Eq. (36) with z 0 = R e − θ h z_0 = R e^{-\theta_h} z 0 = R e − θ h . Their two cutoff contacts are related by reflection about x = R x = R x = R :
x o u t = 2 R − x A . (184) x_{\rm out} = 2R - x_A. \tag*{(184)} x out = 2 R − x A . (184)
The interval of complementary contacts is then B h i t , ε B_{\rm hit,\varepsilon} B hit , ε . Eq. (182) also shows that the limits do not commute: at any fixed η < 1 \eta< 1 η < 1 , removing the cutoff sends U ε → ∞ U_\varepsilon\to\infty U ε → ∞ and restores one half of the flux on each side, whereas taking η → 1 \eta\to1 η → 1 first gives the one-sided pure NS–NS routing.
For the cutoff used in Figure 5 , η c r i t ≃ 0.968 \eta_{\rm crit} \simeq0.968 η crit ≃ 0.968 . The middle panel at η = 1 / 2 \eta= 1/2 η = 1/2 therefore still has contacts on both sides, but more flux goes to the right. The total RT flux is the same in all three panels.
Figure 5. Vacuum F1 profiles for η = 0 \eta= 0 η = 0 , 1 2 \frac{1}{2} 2 1 , 1 1 1 at t = 0 t = 0 t = 0 and ε / R = 0.25 \varepsilon/R = 0.25 ε / R = 0.25 . The same RT surface γ A , ε \gamma_{A,\varepsilon} γ A , ε (navy) and crossing points θ h , k \theta_{h,k} θ h , k are used in all panels. Violet dots mark the complementary cutoff contacts, and cyan marks A ε A_\varepsilon A ε . The contacts lie on both sides at η = 0 \eta= 0 η = 0 and η = 1 / 2 \eta= 1/2 η = 1/2 , and only on the right at η = 1 \eta= 1 η = 1 . Some sampled arcs leave the plotted window.
Planar BTZ: from inter-exterior flux to one-sided contact
As in vacuum, we follow each string from A A A to its other end. In BTZ, that end can lie to the left or right of A A A in the original exterior, or it can reach the second exterior of the extended geometry [38 ] .
Let us keep d = L A / ( 2 z h ) d = L_A/(2z_h) d = L A / ( 2 z h ) , ξ = ( x B − x c ) / z h \xi= (x_B-x_c)/z_h ξ = ( x B − x c ) / z h , and W = z h / z B W = z_h/z_B W = z h / z B . On the extended time-zero slice, Q = ± W 2 − 1 Q = \pm\sqrt{W^2-1} Q = ± W 2 − 1 is positive in the exterior which contains A A A , negative in the second exterior, and zero on the BTZ bifurcation line. The coordinate transformation is given by
Q = Y − 1 + cosh d Y 1 sinh d , Y 2 = W sinh ξ , Y − 1 = W cosh d cosh ξ − Q sinh d . (185) Q = \frac{Y_{-1}+\cosh d Y_1}{\sinh d}, \qquad Y_2 = W\sinh\xi, \qquad Y_{-1} = \frac{W\cosh d\cosh\xi-Q}{\sinh d}. \tag*{(185)} Q = sinh d Y − 1 + cosh d Y 1 , Y 2 = W sinh ξ , Y − 1 = sinh d W cosh d cosh ξ − Q . (185)
In the original exterior, Q = W h B \mathcal{Q}=W h_B Q = W h B , so Y 1 = 0 Y_1=0 Y 1 = 0 gives the thermal RT curve cosh ξ = h B cosh d \cosh\xi=h_B\cosh d cosh ξ = h B cosh d . For η < 1 \eta<1 η < 1 , the angular coordinate in Eq. (167) approaches w = θ h + ϑ w=\theta_h+\vartheta w = θ h + ϑ at the other end, where ϑ = arctanh η \vartheta=\operatorname{arctanh}\eta ϑ = arctanh η as in vacuum. Taking ρ → − ∞ \rho\to-\infty ρ → − ∞ in the first relation of Eq. (185) gives
lim ρ → − ∞ Q cosh ρ = cosh w − cosh d sinh d . (186) \lim_{\rho\to-\infty}\frac{\mathcal{Q}}{\cosh\rho}=\frac{\cosh w-\cosh d}{\sinh d}. \tag*{(186)} ρ → − ∞ lim cosh ρ Q = sinh d cosh w − cosh d . (186)
This limit is negative for ∣ w ∣ < d |w|<d ∣ w ∣ < d , so the string reaches the second exterior. For ∣ w ∣ > d |w|>d ∣ w ∣ > d , it ends in the original exterior, where Y 2 = W sinh ξ Y_2=W\sinh\xi Y 2 = W sinh ξ gives sinh ξ → sinh d sinh w / ( cosh w − cosh d ) \sinh\xi\to\sinh d\sinh w/(\cosh w-\cosh d) sinh ξ → sinh d sinh w / ( cosh w − cosh d ) . Therefore ∣ ξ ∣ > d |\xi|>d ∣ ξ ∣ > d there, and the sign of w w w determines the side of A A A . The other end lies
{ to the left of A in the original exterior , w < − d , in the second exterior , − d < w < d , to the right of A in the original exterior , w > d . (187) \begin{cases}
\text{to the left of }A\text{ in the original exterior}, & w<-d,\\
\text{in the second exterior}, & -d<w<d,\\
\text{to the right of }A\text{ in the original exterior}, & w>d. \tag*{(187)}
\end{cases} ⎩ ⎨ ⎧ to the left of A in the original exterior , in the second exterior , to the right of A in the original exterior , w < − d , − d < w < d , w > d . (187)
The two values w = ± d w=\pm d w = ± d correspond to two individual string profiles and therefore do not affect the continuum flux.
Net horizon flux and extensive thermal entropy
The endpoint criterion tells us which strings connect the two exteriors. To determine how much of the total flow into A A A is carried by strings connecting the two exteriors, we evaluate the same F1 current across the BTZ bifurcation line on the t B = 0 t_B=0 t B = 0 slice.
The definition of the string current supplies the required signed counting rule [37 ] . Eq. (174) gives Φ [ q η ] = N \Phi[q_\eta]=\mathcal{N} Φ [ q η ] = N on the regulated RT curve, where all N \mathcal{N} N strings cross once with the same orientation. On a general oriented curve the count is signed: two crossings with opposite orientations contribute + 1 +1 + 1 and − 1 -1 − 1 in string charge units. The same rule applies to two crossings of a single string. Since v p h y s , η i = C g e o m q η i v_{\mathrm{phys},\eta}^{i}=C_{\mathrm{geom}}q_\eta^{i} v phys , η i = C geom q η i with constant C g e o m C_{\mathrm{geom}} C geom , the entropy flow inherits this counting rule. We therefore define
Φ h o r n e t ≡ ∫ H B v p h y s , η i n i d s , H B = { Q = 0 } , (188) \Phi_{\mathrm{hor}}^{\mathrm{net}}\equiv\int_{\mathcal{H}_B}v_{\mathrm{phys},\eta}^{i}n_i\,ds,\qquad\mathcal{H}_B=\{\mathcal{Q}=0\}, \tag*{(188)} Φ hor net ≡ ∫ H B v phys , η i n i d s , H B = { Q = 0 } , (188)
where n i n_i n i is the unit normal pointing from the second exterior toward the one containing A A A , and d s ds d s is the proper length element along the line.
A string that joins the two exteriors has one net crossing toward A A A . If both ends are in the original exterior, any passage into the second exterior is paired with a passage back. The same conserved charge crosses in opposite directions, so the two contributions to Φ h o r n e t \Phi_{\mathrm{hor}}^{\mathrm{net}} Φ hor net cancel. Figure 6 illustrates the cancellation for a single on-shell F1 string. It crosses the BTZ bifurcation line twice and the interval RT curve only once.
Figure 6. A returning F1 string at η = 1 \eta= 1 η = 1 , with d = 0.80 d = 0.80 d = 0.80 , ε / z h = 0.15 \varepsilon/z_h = 0.15 ε / z h = 0.15 , and θ h = − U β ε , ℓ / 12 \theta_h = -U\beta_{\varepsilon,\ell}/12 θ h = − U β ε , ℓ /12 . The left panel shows its single RT crossing and the two intersections H 1 , H 2 H_1,H_2 H 1 , H 2 with the BTZ bifurcation line. The right panel uses the signed coordinate Q Q Q to show the segment joining H 1 H_1 H 1 and H 2 H_2 H 2 in the second exterior. The original exterior is below the line in both panels. The arrows trace the profile from A. The two horizon crossings carry equal and opposite flux.
The strings in the ensemble cross the regulated RT curve at θ h ∈ [ − U , U ] \theta_h\in[-U,U] θ h ∈ [ − U , U ] , with U = U β , ϵ U=U_{\beta,\epsilon} U = U β , ϵ . We follow their full profiles without imposing a separate cutoff in the second exterior. For η < 1 \eta<1 η < 1 the endpoint criterion ∣ w ∣ < d |w|<d ∣ w ∣ < d is equivalent to − d − ϑ < θ h < d − ϑ -d-\vartheta<\theta_h<d-\vartheta − d − ϑ < θ h < d − ϑ . Each such string contributes its RT flux to the net horizon flux, and all other strings give zero net contribution. The net flux is therefore
Φ h o r n e t = ρ s ℓ A d Length ( [ − U , U ] ∩ [ − d − ϑ , d − ϑ ] ) , U = U β , ϵ . (189) \Phi_{\mathrm{hor}}^{\mathrm{net}}=\rho s\ell A_d\operatorname{Length}\left([-U,U]\cap[-d-\vartheta,d-\vartheta]\right),\qquad U=U_{\beta,\epsilon}. \tag*{(189)} Φ hor net = ρ s ℓ A d Length ( [ − U , U ] ∩ [ − d − ϑ , d − ϑ ] ) , U = U β , ϵ . (189)
For U > d U > d U > d , the overlap length is explicitly
Length = { 2 d , 0 ≤ ϑ ≤ U − d , U + d − ϑ , U − d < ϑ < U + d , 0 , ϑ ≥ U + d . (190) \operatorname{Length} =
\begin{cases}
2d, & 0 \leq\vartheta\leq U-d,\\
U+d-\vartheta, & U-d < \vartheta< U+d,\\
0, & \vartheta\geq U+d.
\end{cases} \tag*{(190)} Length = ⎩ ⎨ ⎧ 2 d , U + d − ϑ , 0 , 0 ≤ ϑ ≤ U − d , U − d < ϑ < U + d , ϑ ≥ U + d . (190)
If U ≥ d + ϑ U \geq d+\vartheta U ≥ d + ϑ , the entire range of crossings leading to the second exterior lies within [ − U , U ] [-U,U] [ − U , U ] , so the overlap has length 2 d 2d 2 d . Using 2 d = L A / z h 2d = L_A/z_h 2 d = L A / z h , β = 2 π z h \beta= 2\pi z_h β = 2 π z h , and c = 6 ρ s ℓ A d S c = 6\rho_s\ell_{\mathrm{AdS}} c = 6 ρ s ℓ AdS , we obtain
Φ h o r n e t = 2 d ρ s ℓ A d S = s t h L A = π c L A 3 β , s t h = π c 3 β . (191) \Phi_{\mathrm{hor}}^{\mathrm{net}} = 2d\rho_s\ell_{\mathrm{AdS}} = s_{\mathrm{th}}L_A = \frac{\pi cL_A}{3\beta}, \qquad s_{\mathrm{th}} = \frac{\pi c}{3\beta}. \tag*{(191)} Φ hor net = 2 d ρ s ℓ AdS = s th L A = 3 β π c L A , s th = 3 β π c . (191)
The horizon has proper length ℓ A d S / z h \ell_{\mathrm{AdS}}/z_h ℓ AdS / z h per unit boundary length, giving the thermal entropy density s t h = ρ s ℓ A d S / z h s_{\mathrm{th}} = \rho_s\ell_{\mathrm{AdS}}/z_h s th = ρ s ℓ AdS / z h . The net flux in this regime therefore reproduces the extensive thermal entropy of a segment of length L A L_A L A . At η = 0 \eta= 0 η = 0 it agrees with the bit-thread construction [7 , 8 ] .
The standard bit-thread flow is also signed, so opposite passages through an auxiliary curve cancel for a conserved flow [3 ] . A general bit-thread flow can have a returning profile. The geodesic construction in planar BTZ excludes such a return because the bifurcation line is itself a geodesic and two distinct geodesics on this slice meet at most once. The string charge density gives a physical origin to the signed count and ties each counted profile to the F1 equation. At fixed metric and dilaton the bit-thread constraints have no η \eta η dependence. The Kalb–Ramond coupling in the probe equation, by contrast, predicts how the string connections change with η \eta η .
As η \eta η rises, w = θ h + ϑ w = \theta_h + \vartheta w = θ h + ϑ increases at each fixed θ h \theta_h θ h . A string whose complementary end is to the left can come to reach the second exterior and then end to the right. At fixed cutoff and U > d U > d U > d , the range [ − d − ϑ , d − ϑ ] [-d-\vartheta,d-\vartheta] [ − d − ϑ , d − ϑ ] moves to smaller θ h \theta_h θ h . Its full length contributes until its left endpoint reaches − U -U − U at η = tanh ( U − d ) \eta= \tanh(U-d) η = tanh ( U − d ) . Although the identities of the strings reaching the second exterior have changed, their total signed flux remains equal to Eq. (191) . Beyond this point, the overlap has length U + d − ϑ U+d-\vartheta U + d − ϑ until its right endpoint also reaches − U -U − U , at η = tanh ( U + d ) \eta=\tanh(U+d) η = tanh ( U + d ) . The net flux thus vanishes. Above this threshold, for η < 1 \eta<1 η < 1 , every complementary end is to the right of A A A in the original exterior.
At the pure NS–NS point η = 1 \eta=1 η = 1 , the profile is θ = θ h + log cosh ρ \theta=\theta_h+\log\cosh\rho θ = θ h + log cosh ρ . The growth of Y − 1 Y_{-1} Y − 1 as cosh 2 ρ \cosh^2\rho cosh 2 ρ at large ∣ ρ ∣ |\rho| ∣ ρ ∣ makes Q Q Q positive at both ends. In the original exterior, Eq. (170) becomes W [ cosh ( ξ − d ) − h B ] = sinh d e − θ h W[\cosh(\xi-d)-h_B]=\sinh d e^{-\theta_h} W [ cosh ( ξ − d ) − h B ] = sinh d e − θ h . This is the pure NS–NS surface (109) at t B = 0 t_B=0 t B = 0 with η w s = sinh d e − θ h \eta_{\mathrm{ws}}=\sinh d e^{-\theta_h} η ws = sinh d e − θ h , where η w s \eta_{\mathrm{ws}} η ws is the integration constant called η \eta η in § 4.1 . The two cutoff contacts have the same W W W and h B h_B h B . Since cosh ( ξ − d ) \cosh(\xi-d) cosh ( ξ − d ) is even about ξ = d \xi=d ξ = d , the contacts are reflected about x 2 x_2 x 2 , and both ends are in the same exterior:
x B , o u t = 2 x 2 − x B , A , Φ h o r n e t = 0. (192) x_{B,\mathrm{out}}=2x_2-x_{B,A},\qquad\Phi_{\mathrm{hor}}^{\mathrm{net}}=0. \tag*{(192)} x B , out = 2 x 2 − x B , A , Φ hor net = 0. (192)
All complementary cutoff contacts are then in B h i t , ε β B_{\mathrm{hit},\varepsilon}^{\beta} B hit , ε β .
The pure NS–NS profile also specifies which strings pass into the second exterior and return. Setting s = − sinh ρ > 0 s=-\sinh\rho>0 s = − sinh ρ > 0 on the ρ < 0 \rho<0 ρ < 0 branch, Eq. (185) gives
2 sinh d Q = e θ h s 2 − 2 s cosh d + e θ h + e − θ h . (193) 2\sinh d\,\mathcal{Q}=e^{\theta_h}s^2-2s\cosh d+e^{\theta_h}+e^{-\theta_h}. \tag*{(193)} 2 sinh d Q = e θ h s 2 − 2 s cosh d + e θ h + e − θ h . (193)
The discriminant is 4 ( sinh 2 d − e 2 θ h ) 4(\sinh^2d-e^{2\theta_h}) 4 ( sinh 2 d − e 2 θ h ) , so there are two positive roots if θ h < log sinh d \theta_h<\log\sinh d θ h < log sinh d . Between them the string is in the second exterior, with one crossing in each direction. Both roots lie beyond its single RT crossing at ρ = 0 \rho=0 ρ = 0 . Figure 7 compares how the boundary connections change as η \eta η increases, with the same regulated RT curve throughout.
Figure 7. Thermal F1 sources in the original planar BTZ exterior at t B = 0 t_B=0 t B = 0 for η = 0 , 1 2 , 1 \eta=0,\frac{1}{2},1 η = 0 , 2 1 , 1 . All panels use d = 0.80 d=0.80 d = 0.80 , ε / z h = 0.15 \varepsilon/z_h=0.15 ε / z h = 0.15 , and the same crossing points θ h , k \theta_{h,k} θ h , k on γ β , A , ε \gamma_{\beta,A,\varepsilon} γ β , A , ε . Blue strings reach the boundary of the second exterior. Red strings have both ends in the original exterior. Panels (a) and (b) have net horizon flux s t h L A s_{\mathrm{th}}L_A s th L A , although different crossing points connect the two exteriors. In panel (c), every complementary cutoff contact lies in B h i t , ε β B_{\mathrm{hit},\varepsilon}^{\beta} B hit , ε β and the net horizon flux is zero. The two highlighted branches in (c) belong to one string that crosses the bifurcation line and returns.
Removing the cutoff at fixed η < 1 \eta<1 η < 1 sends U U U to infinity and recovers Eq. (191) . Taking η → 1 \eta\to1 η → 1 first at fixed cutoff gives zero net horizon flux instead. The total RT flux still gives the same interval entropy (151) for every η \eta η . The η \eta η dependence is a property of the physical F1 current: it specifies which parts of the complement receive the fixed RT flux. In particular, the pure NS–NS contacts lie in B h i t , ε β B_{\mathrm{hit},\varepsilon}^{\beta} B hit , ε β , while the partial trace defining the entropy of A A A includes its full complement.
Conclusion and discussion
In this paper, we constructed families of on-shell F1 probes for a single interval in the AdS3 _3 3 vacuum and in planar BTZ. On the time-zero slice, the entropy flow obtained from their conserved spatial Kalb–Ramond current saturates the string-frame capacity ρ S \rho_S ρ S in the normal direction along the RT surface. Its total flux therefore reproduces the standard leading vacuum and thermal interval entropies. The worldsheet embeddings also specify where the strings carrying this flux meet the cutoff boundary.
The mixed-flux calculation then separates the total RT flux from the string connections. At fixed metric and dilaton, the geometric bit-thread constraints are independent of the NS–NS fraction η \eta η . The Kalb–Ramond coupling in the F1 equation changes with η \eta η and, in the boost-invariant sector, selects a regular stationary profile for each RT crossing. At η = 0 \eta= 0 η = 0 these profiles give the geodesic bit-thread flow. In vacuum, the flux to the left of A A A vanishes at the finite-cutoff threshold η c r i t = tanh U ε \eta_{\mathrm{crit}} = \tanh U_{\varepsilon} η crit = tanh U ε .
In planar BTZ, the net flux through the bifurcation line equals s t h L A s_{\mathrm{th}}L_A s th L A when η < 1 \eta< 1 η < 1 and U β , ε ≥ d + ϑ U_{\beta,\varepsilon} \ge d+\vartheta U β , ε ≥ d + ϑ , where ϑ = arctanh η \vartheta= \operatorname{arctanh}\eta ϑ = arctanh η . This condition is eventually satisfied when the cutoff is removed at any fixed η < 1 \eta< 1 η < 1 . At fixed cutoff, the overlap of RT crossings that connect the two exteriors vanishes at η = tanh ( U β , ε + d ) \eta= \tanh(U_{\beta,\varepsilon}+d) η = tanh ( U β , ε + d ) . At the pure NS–NS point, η = 1 \eta= 1 η = 1 , both cutoff contacts lie in the original exterior and the net horizon flux is zero, while the thermal entropy density and total RT flux remain unchanged. A spatial profile can still enter the second exterior and return: the two horizon crossings contribute with opposite signs, while the string crosses the interval RT surface only once.
The total entropy flux is thus fixed by the RT surface, while the F1 dynamics determine how that flux is distributed among complementary regions. We now distinguish the density of cutoff contacts from their support, and explain what the support means for the boundary subsystem.
String ensemble and attachment density
We now clarify whether the normalized F1 flow depends on how the strings are distributed along the RT surface. Keeping the string profiles and the range of crossing points fixed, we examine how reweighting the ensemble affects two quantities: the entropy flux through the interval and the density of string contacts at the cutoff.
Let χ 0 \chi_0 χ 0 denote the RT crossing label, with χ 0 = u \chi_0 = u χ 0 = u in vacuum and χ 0 = u β \chi_0 = u_\beta χ 0 = u β in planar BTZ. The RT length element is d A S = ℓ A d S ∣ d χ 0 ∣ dA_S = \ell_{\mathrm{AdS}}|d\chi_0| d A S = ℓ AdS ∣ d χ 0 ∣ . Replacing the uniform string density with a smooth positive density ν ( χ 0 ) \nu(\chi_0) ν ( χ 0 ) on the same label range multiplies the projected current by ν ( χ 0 ) / ν u n i f o r m \nu(\chi_0)/\nu_{\mathrm{uniform}} ν ( χ 0 ) / ν uniform . This factor is constant along each string profile, so the reweighted current is still conserved. In pure NS–NS flux, the factor cancels in q ^ i = q i / ∣ q ∣ \hat{q}^{\,i} = q^i/|q| q ^ i = q i /∣ q ∣ , leaving v p h y s i = ρ S q ^ i v_{\mathrm{phys}}^{\,i} = \rho_S\hat{q}^{\,i} v phys i = ρ S q ^ i and its maximal flux unchanged.
Reweighting the ensemble changes the density of cutoff contacts on the regulated interval. Writing x ∂ = x x_{\partial}=x x ∂ = x in vacuum and x ∂ = x B x_{\partial}=x_B x ∂ = x B in planar BTZ, the number of contacts per unit cutoff coordinate is
d N A d x ∂ = ν ( χ 0 ( x ∂ ) ) ∣ d x 0 d x ∂ ∣ . (194) \frac{dN_A}{dx_{\partial}}=\nu\left(\chi_0(x_{\partial})\right)\left|\frac{dx_0}{dx_{\partial}}\right|. \tag*{(194)} d x ∂ d N A = ν ( χ 0 ( x ∂ ) ) d x ∂ d x 0 . (194)
Even a uniform density of strings along the RT surface gives a nonuniform contact density when this Jacobian varies. In vacuum, the normalized flow carries ρ S ℓ A d S ∣ d u ∣ \rho S\ell_{\mathrm{AdS}}|du| ρS ℓ AdS ∣ d u ∣ per label interval. Evaluating Eq. (61) at t = 0 t=0 t = 0 and z = ε z=\varepsilon z = ε therefore gives
d Φ A d x A = ρ S ℓ A d S 2 ( R − x A ) ( R − x A ) 2 + ε 2 , − a ε ≤ x A ≤ a ε . (195) \frac{d\Phi_A}{dx_A}=\rho S\ell_{\mathrm{AdS}}\frac{2(R-x_A)}{(R-x_A)^2+\varepsilon^2},\qquad-a_{\varepsilon}\le x_A\le a_{\varepsilon}. \tag*{(195)} d x A d Φ A = ρS ℓ AdS ( R − x A ) 2 + ε 2 2 ( R − x A ) , − a ε ≤ x A ≤ a ε . (195)
This is the entropy flux per unit cutoff coordinate of the chosen normalized F1 maximizer. Positive reweighting changes the unnormalized string-contact density but cancels from q i / ∣ q ∣ q^i/|q| q i /∣ q ∣ , so this normalized entropy-flux density remains unchanged.
We now turn from how densely the strings meet the cutoff to which parts of the complement they reach. Does the region reached by the chosen F1 current coincide with the region traced out to obtain ρ A \rho_A ρ A ? To clarify what the contact region tells us about boundary correlations, we examine whether A A A can have nonzero mutual information with a region that receives no flux from this current.
In pure NS–NS flux, the reflection maps (184) and (192) give the complementary cutoff contacts in vacuum and planar BTZ, respectively:
B h i t , ε = [ 2 R − a ε , 2 R + a ε ] , B h i t , ε β = [ 2 x 2 − b β , ε , 2 x 2 − a β , ε ] . (196) B_{\mathrm{hit},\varepsilon}=[2R-a_{\varepsilon},2R+a_{\varepsilon}],\qquad B^\beta_{\mathrm{hit},\varepsilon}=[2x_2-b_{\beta,\varepsilon},2x_2-a_{\beta,\varepsilon}]. \tag*{(196)} B hit , ε = [ 2 R − a ε , 2 R + a ε ] , B hit , ε β = [ 2 x 2 − b β , ε , 2 x 2 − a β , ε ] . (196)
These intervals specify where the chosen F1 current reaches the regulated complement. The reduced state ρ A = Tr A ˉ ρ \rho_A=\operatorname{Tr}_{\bar A}\rho ρ A = Tr A ˉ ρ is defined using the full complement A ˉ \bar A A ˉ on the boundary line. In the vacuum, that complement purifies A A A . In the thermal case, the second boundary in the two-sided description purifies the thermal state on the original boundary line [38 ] . Starting from that purified state, one traces over both the second boundary and A ˉ \bar A A ˉ to obtain ρ A \rho_A ρ A . The contact intervals are supports of this current, not physical boundaries of the CFT. They therefore impose no conformal boundary condition and introduce no boundary entropy log g \log g log g [25 , 39 , 40 ] .
The vacuum provides a direct example of the distinction. The interval C 0 = ( − 7 R / 2 , − 3 R / 2 ) C_0=(-7R/2,-3R/2) C 0 = ( − 7 R /2 , − 3 R /2 ) lies outside B h i t , ε B_{\mathrm{hit},\varepsilon} B hit , ε and receives no flux from this F1 maximizer. For A ∪ C 0 A\cup C_0 A ∪ C 0 , the disconnected and connected RT pairings give products of endpoint separations 4 R 2 4R^2 4 R 2 and 9 R 2 / 4 9R^2/4 9 R 2 /4 , respectively. The connected pairing has the smaller length in the continuum limit [41 ] , so
I ( 0 ) ( A : C 0 ) = c 3 log 16 9 > 0. (197) I^{(0)}(A:C_0)=\frac{c}{3}\log\frac{16}{9}>0. \tag*{(197)} I ( 0 ) ( A : C 0 ) = 3 c log 9 16 > 0. (197)
Thus A A A can share leading boundary correlations with a region that receives no flux from the chosen F1 current. The cutoff contacts describe how this current realizes S A ( 0 ) S_A^{(0)} S A ( 0 ) , and the full complement determines the trace that defines ρ A \rho_A ρ A .
Acknowledgements HW is supported by NSFC Grant No.12105191. SY is supported by NSFC Grant No.12105031 and No.12547101.