betaFeedback

WorksMathematics

A description of the space with no separable quotient presented by OpenAI

Abstract

OpenAI recently presented a remarkable solution to the longstanding separable quotient problem in Banach space theory. The result establishes its independence from ZFC, relative to the consistency of ZFC with a measurable cardinal. Under the continuum hypothesis, the paper constructs a nonseparable Banach space XX with no separable infinite-dimensional quotient. The present paper offers an alternative exposition of the mechanism leading to XX and its properties. Our aim is to make the methods and results more accessible and to offer a clearer understanding of this exotic space.

Introduction

The separable quotient problem asks whether every infinite-dimensional Banach space admits a separable infinite-dimensional quotient. Equivalently, given an infinite-dimensional Banach space XX, does there exist a closed subspace YY of XX such that X/YX/Y is separable and infinite dimensional? One of the attractive features of this problem is that its formulation is accessible to anyone who has completed a first course in functional analysis. Every infinite-dimensional Banach space contains a separable infinite-dimensional closed subspace, obtained by taking the closed linear span of a countable linearly independent set. The corresponding question for quotients has proved much more difficult.

Traditionally associated with Banach and Mazur, the problem has occupied a central place in the structural theory of Banach spaces. Among the positive results preceding the work discussed here, Johnson and Rosenthal [14] proved in 1972 that every separable infinite-dimensional Banach space has an infinite-dimensional quotient with a Schauder basis. In 2008, Argyros, Dodos and Kanellopoulos [3] established that every infinite-dimensional dual Banach space has a separable infinite-dimensional quotient.

The nontrivial case of the separable quotient problem concerns nonseparable spaces, since a separable infinite-dimensional space is already a quotient of itself. In the separable setting, a related question asks whether there exists a separable infinite-dimensional Banach space such that every infinite-dimensional quotient has a nonseparable dual. This question, posed by Johnson and Rosenthal [14], has a positive answer. Such a space is supplied by the construction of Argyros, Arvanitakis and Tolias in [1 Section 6]; the quotient property is explicitly established by Argyros and Beanland in [2 Section 5, Corollary 22]. Thus nonseparability of the dual may persist in every infinite-dimensional quotient of a separable space.

In the preprint Relative independence of the separable quotient problem, dated 23 September 2026, OpenAI [15] establishes two opposite conclusions under additional set-theoretic assumptions. If the continuum cc is real-valued measurable, every infinite-dimensional Banach space has a separable infinite-dimensional quotient. Under the continuum hypothesis, however, there exists a Banach space XX of density ℵ1\aleph_{1} which has no separable infinite-dimensional quotient. Together with the relative consistency of a real-valued measurable continuum from a measurable cardinal, these results yield the independence of the separable quotient problem from ZFC, relative to the consistency of ZFC with a measurable cardinal.

The aim of the present paper is to describe the mechanism leading to the space XX and to offer an alternative access to its definition and the proof of its properties. We separate the functional-analytic argument from the construction of the auxiliary space EE, and organize the latter in two stages. This makes it possible to see how the different properties of EE enter the definition of XX before considering the norming sets which produce them.

The paper is organized into four sections. In Section 1, we state and prove the following criterion, which is Theorem 1.2 below.

Theorem 1.2. Assume that a Banach space EE has a transfinite Schauder basis (eα)α<ω1(e_{\alpha})_{\alpha<\omega_{1}} and satisfies the following conditions.

(i) Setting

X0=span⁡‾{eα∗:α<ω1}⊂E∗,X_{0}=\overline{\operatorname{span}}\{e_{\alpha}^{*}:\alpha<\omega_{1}\}\subset E^{*},

the canonical evaluation map identifies EE with X0∗X_{0}^{*}.

(ii) The space EE contains no isomorphic copy of ℓ1\ell_{1}, and every infinite-dimensional closed subspace of EE has nonseparable dual.

(iii) There exists a closed subspace X⊂E∗X\subset E^{*} such that

X+X0‾∥⋅∥=E∗\overline{X+X_{0}}^{\|\cdot\|}=E^{*}

and the canonical restriction map

R:E⟶X∗,(Re)(x)=x(e),R:E\longrightarrow X^{*},\qquad(Re)(x)=x(e),

is an onto isomorphism.

Then XX has no infinite-dimensional separable quotient.

As W. B. Johnson pointed out, the existence of spaces satisfying all the assumptions of this theorem implies CH. Thus CH is necessary for this particular construction of XX; the auxiliary space EE itself is constructed in ZFC. The proof of the criterion is comparatively short. What we find remarkable in the AI contribution is the identification of the assumptions which make this argument possible.

Section 2 explains a second remarkable step. For an auxiliary space EE with the stated properties, let

Q:E∗⟶W=E∗/X0Q:E^{*}\longrightarrow W=E^{*}/X_{0}

be the quotient map. We show that if a bounded operator B:E∗→WB:E^{*}\to W satisfies

B(X0)‾=W,∥B∥<110,B∗(W∗)⊂JE(E),\overline{B(X_{0})}=W,\qquad\|B\|<\frac{1}{10},\qquad B^{*}(W^{*})\subset J_{E}(E),

then X=ker⁡(Q−B)X=\ker(Q-B) satisfies the assumptions of Theorem 1.2 and hence has no separable infinite-dimensional quotient. Here JE:E⟶E∗∗J_{E}:E\longrightarrow E^{**} is the canonical embedding. The adjoint range condition follows from a norm-convergence property of BB on the finite initial sums of the special functionals. Informally, BB may be viewed as an anti-QQ operator: whereas QQ annihilates X0X_0, the operator BB maps X0X_0 onto a norm-dense subspace of WW. The construction exploits these contrasting behaviours by considering the subspace on which QQ and BB agree.

In Section 3, we present the properties of EE which yield the existence of BB. In contrast with the single construction of the auxiliary space in [15], our description proceeds in two stages. First we consider spaces Ep,rE_{p,r}, where 1<r<p<∞1<r<p<\infty. For parameters

1<r2<p2<r1<p1<∞1<r_2<p_2<r_1<p_1<\infty

put Ei=Epi,riE_i=E_{p_i,r_i} and Wi=Ei∗/X0,iW_i=E_i^*/X_{0,i}, with quotient maps Qi:Ei∗→WiQ_i:E_i^*\to W_i. Under CH, Proposition 3.2 constructs a contraction B2,1:E2∗→W1B_{2,1}:E_2^*\to W_1 such that

B2,1eα(2)∗=Q1ϕσ(α)(1)B_{2,1}e_\alpha^{(2)*}=Q_1\phi_{\sigma(\alpha)}^{(1)}

where σ\sigma bijectively pairs the biorthogonal functionals of E2E_2 with the indices of the special functionals of E1E_1. In particular, B2,1(X0,2)B_{2,1}(X_{0,2}) is norm dense in W1W_1. Moreover, B2,1B_{2,1} maps the finite initial sums of every special functional of E2E_2 to a sequence converging in norm to the image of that functional. Its boundedness follows from the ℓp2\ell_{p_2} estimate for the scalar families (f(eα(2)))α(f(e_\alpha^{(2)}))_\alpha, the upper ℓr1\ell_{r_1} estimate in W1W_1, and the inclusion ℓp2⊂ℓr1\ell_{p_2}\subset\ell_{r_1}.

In the second stage we choose

2>s>p1>r1>p2>r2>⋯>12>s>p_1>r_1>p_2>r_2>\cdots>1

and describe the space

E=(⨁n=1∞Epn,rn)2,s.E=\left(\bigoplus_{n=1}^{\infty}E_{p_n,r_n}\right)_{2,s}.

Its dual is generated in norm by the biorthogonal functionals, the vertical special functionals belonging to the component spaces, and an additional family of horizontal special functionals. For n≥1n\geq1, the preceding construction gives contractions Bn+1,n:En+1∗→WnB_{n+1,n}:E_{n+1}^*\to W_n because pn+1<rnp_{n+1}<r_n. The inequality p1<sp_1<s similarly gives a contraction B1,0:E1∗→WB_{1,0}:E_1^*\to W whose images of the biorthogonal functionals generate the horizontal special cosets. Writing ρn:E∗→En∗\rho_n:E^*\to E_n^* for restriction and jn:Wn→Wj_n:W_n\to W for the natural isometric embedding, the global operator is

Bf=τ0B1,0(ρ1f)+∑n=1∞τnjnBn+1,n(ρn+1f),τn=2−n−5.Bf=\tau_0B_{1,0}(\rho_1f)+\sum_{n=1}^{\infty}\tau_nj_nB_{n+1,n}(\rho_{n+1}f),\qquad\tau_n=2^{-n-5}.

This series converges in operator norm and gives ∥B∥≤1/16\lVert B\rVert\leq1/16. Every vertical and horizontal special coset occurs, up to a nonzero scalar, as the image of a biorthogonal functional. Consequently B(X0)=WB(X_0)=W. Proposition 3.6 also proves the required convergence on special functionals, and hence completes the definition of X=ker⁡(Q−B)X=\ker(Q-B).

Finally, § 5 defines the norming sets Gp,rG_{p,r} and GG. An essential ingredient is the σρ\sigma_\rho coding of [6 Sections 2.3–2.4], based on the ρ\rho function of [19]. In the separable setting an injective coding of finite rational data is available. On ω1\omega_1, this is replaced by coding the data after transporting suitable finite ρ\rho-closures to finite subsets of N\mathbb{N}. Although σρ\sigma_\rho is not injective, coinciding codes give agreement on the common initial part and ρ\rho-separation outside it. We explain how this yields the eventual disjointness of the weight sets of two distinct infinite special sequences. This property controls the interaction of special functionals and is central to the definitions of the norming sets.

We prove directly several consequences of these definitions, including bounded completeness and the estimates used in constructing BB. The remaining structural results, notably the assertions about nonseparable duals of block subspaces and norm generation of the duals by the biorthogonal and special functionals, are stated explicitly. Their lengthy proofs use techniques from the theory of hereditarily indecomposable Banach spaces and are outside the scope of this paper. They may be presented separately if necessary.

Throughout the note the scalar field is R\mathbb{R}. All subspaces described as Banach spaces are norm closed, and, unless another topology is explicitly specified, separability of a subset of a dual space refers to the norm topology. The assertion that a space has no separable quotient means that it has no infinite-dimensional separable Banach quotient.

The structure of XX and two questions

The space XX has a peculiar structure. Its definition as ker⁡(Q−B)\operatorname{ker}(Q-B) gives an implicit description of its vectors, and even nonzero elements are obtained indirectly through the lifting argument. Its subspaces and possible decompositions are therefore not transparent. On the other hand, its dual is canonically isomorphic to the WCG space EE, with its explicitly defined transfinite basis and component projections πJ\pi_J. This contrast recalls the Argyros–Haydon space [5], which is hereditarily indecomposable and solves the scalar-plus-compact problem, while its dual is isomorphic to ℓ1\ell_1.

Question 1. Is the space XX indecomposable?

Here indecomposability means that XX cannot be written as a topological direct sum of two infinite-dimensional closed subspaces. The space XX has no infinite-dimensional separable complemented subspace, since a bounded projection onto such a subspace would give a separable infinite-dimensional quotient. Thus any decomposition into two infinite-dimensional summands would necessarily involve two nonseparable spaces. It is unclear whether such a decomposition is possible. To obtain projections on XX from those on EE, one needs the latter to be weak-star continuous for the duality induced by XX.

Question 2. Does there exist, under CH, a nonseparable closed subspace of ℓ∞(N)\ell_\infty(\mathbb{N}) with no separable infinite-dimensional quotient?

A sufficient condition for an affirmative answer can be formulated in terms of EE. In what follows, the weak-star topology on EE is σ(E,X)\sigma(E,X), induced by the canonical isomorphism R:E→X∗R:E\to X^*; it is the topology coming from the predual XX. Suppose that there is an infinite-dimensional weak-star closed subspace Y⊂EY\subset E whose closed unit ball BYB_Y, with the norm inherited from EE, is weak-star separable. Set

M=Y⊥={x∈X:x(y)=0 for every y∈Y},Z=X/M.M=Y_\perp=\{x\in X:x(y)=0\text{ for every }y\in Y\},\qquad Z=X/M.

Weak-star closedness gives M⊥=R(Y)⊂X∗M^\perp=R(Y)\subset X^*, so that Z∗Z^* is canonically identified with R(Y)R(Y). In particular, ZZ is infinite dimensional. Choose a countable weak-star dense family (yn)n∈N⊂BY(y_n)_{n\in\mathbb{N}}\subset B_Y and define

T:Z⟶ℓ∞(N),T(x+M)=(x(yn))n∈N.T:Z\longrightarrow\ell_\infty(\mathbb{N}),\qquad T(x+M)=(x(y_n))_{n\in\mathbb{N}}.

This map is well defined, and weak-star density gives

∥T(x+M)∥∞=sup⁡n∈N∣x(yn)∣=sup⁡y∈BY∣x(y)∣.\|T(x+M)\|_{\infty}=\sup_{n\in\mathbb{N}}|x(y_n)|=\sup_{y\in B_Y}|x(y)|.

References

  1. [1]S. A. Argyros, A. D. Arvanitakis, and A. G. Tolias, Saturated extensions, the attractors method and hereditarily James tree spaces, in Methods in Banach Space Theory (J. M. F. Castillo and W. B. Johnson, eds.), London Math. Soc. Lecture Note Ser. 337, Cambridge University Press, Cambridge, 2006, pp. 1–90.DOI
  2. [2]S. A. Argyros and K. Beanland, On spaces admitting no ℓₚ or c₀ spreading model, Positivity 17 (2013), no. 2, 265–282.
  3. [3]S. A. Argyros, P. Dodos, and V. Kanellopoulos, Unconditional families in Banach spaces, Math. Ann. 341 (2008), no. 1, 15–38.DOI
  4. [4]S. A. Argyros and V. Felouzis, Interpolating hereditarily indecomposable Banach spaces, J. Amer. Math. Soc. 13 (2000), no. 2, 243–294.arxiv.org/abs/math/9712277
  5. [5]S. A. Argyros and R. G. Haydon, A hereditarily indecomposable ℒ∞-space that solves the scalar-plus-compact problem, Acta Math. 206 (2011), no. 1, 1–54.
  6. [6]S. A. Argyros, J. López-Abad, and S. Todořcević, A class of Banach spaces with few non-strictly singular operators, J. Funct. Anal. 222 (2005), no. 2, 306–384.DOI
  7. [7]S. A. Argyros and T. Raikofstalis, Banach spaces with a unique nontrivial decomposition, Proc. Amer. Math. Soc. 136 (2008), no. 10, 3611–3620.DOI
  8. [8]A. Avilés, G. Plebanek, and J. Rodríguez, A weak* separable C(K)* space whose unit ball is not weak* separable, Trans. Amer. Math. Soc. 366 (2014), no. 9, 4733–4753.
  9. [9]I. Deliyanni and A. Manoussakis, Asymptotic ℓ_p hereditarily indecomposable Banach spaces, Illinois J. Math. 51 (2007), no. 3, 767–803.
  10. [10]T. Figiel and W. B. Johnson, A uniformly convex Banach space which contains no ℓ_p, Compositio Math. 29 (1974), no. 2, 179–190.
  11. [11]W. T. Gowers, A Banach space not containing c₀, ℓ₁ or a reflexive subspace, Trans. Amer. Math. Soc. 344 (1994), 407–420.
  12. [12]W. T. Gowers and B. Maurey, The unconditional basic sequence problem, J. Amer. Math. Soc. 6 (1993), no. 4, 851–874.
  13. [13]R. C. James, A separable somewhat reflexive Banach space with nonseparable dual, Bull. Amer. Math. Soc. 80 (1974), 738–743.DOI
  14. [14]W. B. Johnson and H. P. Rosenthal, On w*-basic sequences and their applications to the study of Banach spaces, Studia Math. 43 (1972), 77–92.
  15. [15]OpenAI, Relative independence of the separable quotient problem, preprint dated 23 September 2026, especially Sections 5, 8 and 9. https://github.com/openai/math/blob/main/preprints/Relative-independence-of-the-separable-quotient-problem-September-23-2026/paper.pdf.
  16. [16]G. Petsoulas and T. Raikofstalis, A Gowers tree like space and the space of its bounded linear operators, Studia Math. 190 (2009), no. 3, 233–281.DOI
  17. [17]Th. Schlumprecht, An arbitrarily distortable Banach space, Israel J. Math. 76 (1991), nos. 1–2, 81–95.arxiv.org/abs/math/9201225
  18. [18]C. Stegall, The Radon–Nikodym property in conjugate Banach spaces, Trans. Amer. Math. Soc. 206 (1975), 213–223.DOI
  19. [19]S. Todořcević, Partitioning pairs of countable ordinals, Acta Math. 159 (1987), 261–294.DOI
  20. [20]B. S. Tsirel’son, Not every Banach space contains an imbedding of ℓ_p or c₀, Funct. Anal. Appl. 8 (1974), no. 2, 138–141; Russian original: Funktsional. Anal. i Prilozhen. 8 (1974), no. 2, 57–60.DOI

Paper details

vlnc:W_k5gfp79v
Version
v1 · latest
Published
Fresh — added to the Hub within the last 30 days
Added
License
CC BY 4.0
Usage

views · 0

downloads · 0

A view counts once per browser per day, a download each time the PDF is requested.

  • Mathematics

GPT-6 Astra

View statement
Looking for related papers…
Contents