WorksPhysics and Astronomy
+2SOSEX self-energy made positive semi-definite
Abstract
The formulation of vertex corrections beyond the approximation within the framework of perturbation theory is a subtle and challenging task, which accounts for the wide variety of schemes proposed over the years. Exact self-energies are required to satisfy the mathematical condition of positive semi-definiteness. The self-energy fulfills this property, but the vast majority of the vertex-corrected self-energy approximations do not. In this study, we devise a positive semi-definite extension to the +2SOSEX self-energy that we name +2SOSEX-psd. To reach this goal, we demonstrate the cancellation of the bare energy poles that are contained in the fully dynamic second-order in self-energy (). We then demonstrate on molecular examples the correct positive semi-definiteness of the proposed self-energy approximation and its good accuracy in predicting accurate quasiparticle energies for valence and core states.
Introduction
Over the years, Green’s functions have proven to be insightful and efficient tools for addressing the many-electron problem in both extended and finite systems.[1, 2, 3, 4] In this approach, the central unknown object is the self-energy operator that governs the equation-of-motion of the Green’s function (GF) . On this road, Hedin’s approximation to the self-energy[5] represents a unique milestone: it is an appealing combination of simplicity and accuracy.[6, 7, 8]
In contrast with regular perturbation theory based on the bare Coulomb interaction ,[9, 10] the approximation is obtained as the first-order expansion in terms of the screened Coulomb interaction .
Producing approximations beyond the term, often referred to as “vertex corrections”, is not a straightforward task. An order-by-order expansion in terms of is unique and well-defined, as illustrated by the early results by Cederbaum[1, 10, 11] with perturbation theory to second order (PT2), third order (PT3) etc. Electron screening effects represent a problem on their own. Using the dynamically screened interaction systematically, as a building block of perturbative expansions, is much more difficult, both conceptually[12, 13] and numerically. For this reason, following some early attempts in the 90s[14, 15, 16, 17, 18] we have witnessed a blooming of vertex correction proposals for extended[19, 20, 21, 22, 23, 24, 25, 26, 27] and finite[23, 28, 29, 30, 31, 32, 33, 34, 35, 36, 37, 38, 39, 40, 41] systems. These many propositions come from the difficult task of truncating the 3-point vertex equation, and many different choices can be made.[2] The vertex can be included in only,[19, 22, 26, 32, 33] in the self-energy only,[24, 29, 36, 42] or in both.[20, 21, 23, 25, 27, 28, 30, 31, 34, 37, 38, 39, 40, 41] At least for molecules, many works have shown the latter strategy to be rather successful.[31, 37, 38, 39, 40, 41] These advanced strategies are beyond the scope of this work, and we only consider a vertex correction in the self-energy, keeping at the level of random phase approximation (RPA).
Very often, the focus is placed on the main peaks of the imaginary part of the Green’s function , the so-called spectral function :
where the integration contour goes infinitesimally above and below the real axis for , and , respectively, with being the chemical potential of the system. These peaks mark the ionization or affinity energies of electrons in an interacting electron system and can be compared to results of actual photoemission and inverse-photoemission experiments. When the peaks are well defined, they are named quasiparticle () peaks. However, the spectral function often exhibits additional complexity beyond the main peaks, in the form of the so-called satellite structures. They are well-known spectral features in the homogeneous electron gas, [43, 44] bulk materials, [45, 46, 47] and molecules. [35, 48, 49]
Both effects, the renormalization of the peaks and the emergence of satellites in the spectral function, is encoded in the electron self-energy (SE) , which can, in turn, be recast in terms of its spectral function :
where is the frequency-independent exchange part of the self-energy, and is the correlation part. The function is sometimes referred to as a rate function due to its physical interpretation—it describes the rate at which various scattering processes influence the many-body state of the system following the removal or addition of a particle (electron). A fundamental requirement is that this rate must be non-negative for all energy transfers and for all combinations of initial and final states. This leads to the mathematical requirement that must be a positive semi-definite (PSD) matrix () admitting a Lehmann (i.e., sum over states) representation. [13, 50, 51] For the time-ordered self-energy, the PSD condition translates to the constraints:
for any state onto which we project. A PSD self-energy implies two key consequences: (i) it gives rise to a PSD spectral function —ensuring a positive electron density as expected, and (ii) it preserves the correct causal structure: the self-energy is derived from via the Kramers-Krönig relation (Eq. (2)), and is determined as the imaginary part of . The fact that the exact self-energy admits a Lehmann representation has been known since the early work of Winter. [52] However, it was largely overlooked that, starting from third order in the bare interaction, some self-energy diagrams violate this property, [53] a point that only gained attention through early calculations for the homogeneous electron gas by Minnhagen[54] and through Almbladh’s analysis of photoemission processes.[55]
Let us check out whether common approximations fulfill the PSD property with the example of a single neon atom in Figure 1. The two simplest approximations are presented in the upper row: a -based expansion (PT2) in panel (a) and a -based expansion () in panel (b). Both approximations appear as PSD, and we will recall in this article that it is a general mathematical result. However, when trying to include higher-order terms in panel (c) with PT3 (Ref. 10) or in panel (d) with the fully dynamic term (Refs. 36,54), large negative parts show up.

Figure 1. Imaginary part of selected time-ordered correlation self-energies for the Ne atom. We plot the HOMO diagonal expectation value for PT2, in the first row, and PT3, in the second row.
These observations can be readily rationalized using the method introduced in Ref. 13, based on the non-equilibrium Green’s function (NEGF) formalism, as illustrated in Figure 2, panels (a) and (b). Below, we sketch the idea, and we will provide more detailed arguments in the subsequent sections. To this end, consider the partitions (diagrams with pluses and minuses assigned to vertices indicating the branches of the Keldysh contour on which the corresponding time arguments lie) of the lesser self-energy (SE). Since there can be no isolated islands of pluses or minuses, the diagrams naturally split into two half-diagrams (as indicated by dashed lines), with time arguments residing exclusively on either the forward (minus) or backward (plus) branches. It is important to note then, that one half-diagram in panel (a) contains one interacting line, whereas the other contains two interacting lines. Conversely, SE diagrams are obtained by gluing half-diagrams (possibly with permutation of the dangling lines). Only when the plus and minus half-diagrams are equivalent can
Figure 2. Diagrammatic proof why some diagrams of the PT3 approximation are not PSD (a), whereas the approximation is PSD (b). Decomposition of the screened interaction into the bare Coulomb and a polarizable part , viz. Eq. (7) (c). The full second-order in SE diagram (d). Representation of the lesser RPA component in terms of the time-ordered (), electron-hole bubble, and anti-time-ordered components (e).
the glued expression be recast as a sum of squares (in the form of the Fermi golden rule), which is then manifestly positive definite. For the diagram in panel (a), this condition is not fulfilled due to the differing number of interaction lines, and hence the diagram is not PSD. Remedying this would require the addition of two more diagrams of second and fourth order in the bare interaction.
In contrast, the diagram in panel (b) is PSD because its two constituent half-diagrams are topologically equivalent. A subtle point here is the representation of its constituent lesser screened interaction in terms of the time-ordered () and anti-time-ordered () components, as depicted in panel (e). We will present a more explicit positivity proof in Sec. 2.3.
We also note that the full diagram shown in Figure 2, panel (d), contains the non-PSD diagram from panel (a) as a subset. This suggests (we are cautious here because one non-PSD part can, in principle, be compensated by another, more positive part) that the full diagram may also fail to be PSD, a conclusion supported by the numerical results shown in Figure 1, panel (d). We will return to this example in § 2.4 explicitly demonstrating the non-positivity of its specific term. This is a serious shortcoming for the approximation that calls for improvements.
In this work, we analyze the PSD behavior of approximations in the family, namely second-order exchange (SOX), second-order screened exchange (SOSEX), [29, 42] complete second-order screened exchange (2SOSEX), [36] and full . These approximations are obtained by replacing one or two in by the static . This will allow us to propose a PSD-compliant self-energy approximation that comprises the 2SOSEX terms. In doing so, we identify the role of poles in the self-energy that combine 3 bare energies and show how these contributions can be rigorously discarded. The proposed self-energy approximations will be tested on finite systems for valence and core excitations using the established benchmarks GW100[56] and CORE65.[57]
Diagnosing PT2, , self-energies
Since the article focuses on finite systems, we will employ notations commonly used in quantum chemistry. Let us state that we will limit our discussion to a non-self-consistent Green’s function using a so-called one-shot approach and to the RPA to . Hartree atomic units are used everywhere in the text.
Notations
We use the usual convention where the indices , , run over virtual molecular orbitals (MO), , , over occupied MO, and , , , over all the MO. stands for a small positive real number that enforces the proper location of the poles in the complex plane: above the real axis for occupied states () and below the real axis for virtual states (). Note that we assume real wavefunctions without loss of generality for finite systems.
With this, the non-interacting time-ordered Green’s function that comes from a previous generalized Kohn-Sham calculation is spin-diagonal and reads
Along with the time-ordered and the anti-time-ordered components, the lesser and greater components of GF will be useful:
It is common practice to split the screened Coulomb interaction into a static part and a polarizable part (see Figure 2 panel c for diagrammatic representation):
The polarizable part has a Lehmann representation:
where the Lehmann amplitudes and the system’s neutral excitation energies can be obtained from the solution of Casida’s equation (or Bethe–Salpeter equation) within the RPA.[58, 59] Note that incorporates the spin degeneracy factor. Here and in the following the index (and later also ) runs over the pairs of states (occupied virtual). Along with the time-ordered component of , the lesser and greater components of the screened interaction will be useful:
From the orbital/neutral excitation basis representation of (Eq. 5) and (Eq. 8), it is evident that the corresponding matrices are diagonal. This is advantageous, as it renders the diagrammatic technique akin to that used for periodic systems, where each propagator carries a momentum. However, in contrast to systems such as the electron gas, where performing the spatial integration over each vertex enforces momentum conservation, the integration here yields a nontrivial matrix element, given by the following integral:
In the following, we will work on the correlation part of self-energy that is dynamic . The static part accounting for the exchange (and possibly for the corrections to the one-body reduced density-matrix [1, 60]) will be added.
PT2 is PSD
The second-order approximation to the self-energy, also named GF2 or the second Born approximation, is the sum of two terms (Figure 3): the 1-ring term and the SOX term.[61]
Figure 3. Diagrammatic representation of the two terms contributing to the PT2 approximation. Vertices are labeled by / depending on the branch of Keldysh contour they reside on. Since GFs are diagonal in orbital basis, each fermionic line is labeled by the orbital index. Frequencies (e.g. , ) associated with some propagators are also indicated; the others follow from the energy conservation at each vertex.
For convenience, we split the terms according to the location of the pole with respect to the real axis of the complex plane. Notation vov stands for virtual-occupied-virtual, which will result in a pole in the fourth quadrant, whereas ovo for occupied-virtual-occupied generates a pole in the second quadrant.
These terms read
and
where Coulomb integrals in the chemists’ notation were introduced.
The nonequilibrium Green’s function formalism provides a fast way to derive these equations. It can be illustrated by the computation of the lesser SE according to the diagrams in Figure 3, where state indices on fermionic lines and frequencies associated with some propagators are indicated. For the ring diagram, standard diagrammatic rules (App. § 11) yield
Using definitions (5), and performing the two frequency integrals we obtain
For the second-order exchange, the diagrammatic rules yield
Again, by performing the two frequency integrals, we obtain
For unoccupied states, we verify that , as expected.
We note in passing that there is a correspondence between the nature of intermediate electronic states (occupied or virtual) in the diagrams in Figure 3 and the partition type (determined by the distribution over the internal vertices). In this example, this is a one-to-one correspondence because here only the lesser () and the greater () GFs are involved. Since the Coulomb interaction is instantaneous, no other partitions are possible. However, we will see examples involving time-ordered () or anti-time-ordered () GFs. These contain contributions from both occupied and virtual states, and thus the correspondence between partitions and the nature of intermediate states is no longer one-to-one. A useful rule of thumb is that partitions uniquely determine the scattering mechanisms, but not the character of the intermediate states.
The sum of the 1-ring and SOX terms is PSD because they are formed by gluing a single half-diagram with itself, without and with permutation of two fermionic lines, respectively (the argument is detailed in Ref. 13). We remind the reader that the half-diagrams contain vertices on the same branch of the Keldysh contour, and they are obtained by dissecting the original diagrams along the dashed blue lines, Figure 3. Independent of the diagrammatic argument, a direct proof of positive definiteness can be given. To this end, we manipulate the terms in Eqs. (10a) and (14) using a symmetry and obtain.
where we introduced the antisymmetrized Coulomb matrix elements . Now it is not difficult to verify that a projection of on an arbitrary state yields a PSD rate:
with and . In the derivation, we used the Sokhotski–Plemelj formula
Analogously, it can be shown that . This mathematical derivation confirms the numerical observation drawn from the Neon atom in Figure 1.
Note that the poles of 1-ring, SOX, and therefore PT2, are located at the bare energies or . Since we will refer to these poles later, we assign names to them here: h-(h-p) and p-(p-h) poles.
GW is PSD
Demonstrating that the one-shot self-energy is PSD is straightforward once the analytic expressions of and are inserted in the convolution integral. After the residue theorem is applied, the correlation part of the self-energy is expressed as the sum of the two following terms: [62, 63, 64]
and
It is instructive to derive these equations with NEGF formalism. By diagrammatic rules, we have
where is defined by Eq. (8). Performing the frequency integral, we obtain
Now, taking a projection on an arbitrary state , we obtain a positive rate:
where . The contribution of virtual states can be treated similarly, and one shows that . Thus, is a PSD approximation. Furthermore, putting the explicit expression (20) in correspondence with the diagram 2(b), it becomes clear that its constituent half-diagrams are represented by the and matrix elements. In the next example, we will see that they also appear as a part of more complicated diagrams.
Note the specific location of the poles, and , that include RPA excitation energies , instead of bare electron-hole excitations in the case of PT2 and SOX.
+ is not PSD
Now turning to the correction beyond , the analytic expression confirms the PSD-violation we observed in Figure 1.
Let us focus on a specific term in . If this term is non-PSD and if it is not compensated by another term in the expression, this is sufficient to show the non-PSD behavior of the overall approximation. We then scrutinize the only term in that involves three occupied states and, therefore, cannot be compensated [Eq. (13a) in Ref. 36]:
This expression involving three intermediate occupied states was obtained using the time-ordered formalism. Turning to the corresponding lesser SE component, further insights into the scattering mechanisms can be gained. There are three possible diagram partitions 1) , 2) , and 3) , where we traverse the diagram’s vertices from left to right (App. § 11). Note that the partition, familiar from the analysis of the SOX diagram in § 2.2, is excluded by the choice of intermediate states, and conversely, none of the present partitions are possible for the SOX diagram because they involve connecting different branches of the Keldysh contour (in contrast to , is time non-local). Partitions 1 and 3 correspond to the hole scattering mechanism involving one neutral excitation (one fermionic and one bosonic line crossing the half-diagram border), whereas partition 2 corresponds to a higher-order process in which a hole scatters, emitting two neutral excitations (one fermionic and bosonic lines crossing the border). The mechanisms can also be identified by inspecting the three terms in the denominator of Eq. (21).
Since 1 and 3 correspond to the same mechanism, they give rise to a double pole when and . This destroys the Lehmann decomposition of the self-energy, [52, 53] which is a fundamental property. The second problem becomes evident when we perform a partial fraction decomposition of Eq. (21) and focus, for instance, on the term proportional to . Introducing a new matrix element
it can be written as
It is clear that this expression is not PSD, as contains a product of terms without a definite sign. Diagrammatically, corresponds to a half-diagram with a single interaction vertex (which already appeared in the analysis of self-energy in § 2.3), whereas is built of three interaction vertices. To ensure the PSD property, one would need, in addition to cross-terms , to include the products and .
Design of a PSD-compliant 2SOSEX self-energy
Figure 4. Diagrammatic representation of the four terms contributing to the approximation. Thin wavy lines stand for bare Coulomb interaction , whereas double wavy lines—for the frequency-dependent part of the screened interaction . We therefore have .
We just saw in the previous section that the correction to induces undesirable non-PSD terms in the self-energy. Moreover, some of them contain double poles. Leaving the multiple-pole issues aside, [65] we focus here on the positivity constraint. In a recent series of works, [13, 50, 51] it was shown how the inclusion of higher-order terms could restore the PSD behavior of any approximation to the self-energy. We will focus here on the 2SOSEX approximation to , which is free of double poles and therefore easier to handle mathematically. Moreover, in previous work it was shown [36] that 2SOSEX avoids many of the numerical difficulties of while giving similar results. The proof will be made in two main steps: 1. all the p-(p-h) and h-(h-p) poles in compensate; 2. all the other poles in 2SOSEX can be complemented so to yield a PSD expression.
Let us recap the SOSEX and 2SOSEX approximations. It is customary to split the static and dynamic interactions following Eq. (7). Introducing this decomposition in gives rise to 4 terms:
where the indices have been dropped for simplicity. The first term in Eq. (24) is nothing else but the SOX self-energy of Eqs. (11a-11b). The first two terms form the SOSEX approximation of Ren and coworkers. [29] The three first terms were named 2SOSEX in our previous work [36] and finally, the four terms are the fully dynamic expression.
The argument in favor of introducing 2SOSEX is the observation that there is no reason to select the first term and not the second one . As a matter of fact, for diagonal expectation values, they are equal.
In the following, we will introduce the analytic expression of SOSEX and show how the p-(p-h) and h-(h-p) poles compensate.
Analytic expression of the SOSEX self-energies
Let us begin with the introduction of the SOSEX term in the self-energy. We will use the same strategy as in Ref. [36]. The terms will be grouped by occupied or virtual molecular orbitals for the 3 Green’s function in . The static imposes that the first two occupations differ. Then, instead of the 8 contributions present in , only 4 will survive.
The energy convolutions can be performed with the application of the residue theorem. Symbolic calculators, such as the open-source Wolfram Engine, can be of help to obtain the following expressions:
Though these equations were already used in our previous work, [36] the analytic expressions were not written out explicitly. To form 2SOSEX, one should consider the alternate term whose analytic expression is the same as SOSEX in Eqs. (20a–20d) but with swapped indices .
The expressions in Eq. (20a) and Eq. (20b) contain products of two poles. To disentangle these, one can apply partial fraction decomposition, and after some tedious manipulations or using a symbolic calculator, one reaches these factorized expressions:
These expressions have the advantage to show that contributions with h-(h-p) and p-(p-h) poles can be treated separately from those with RPA excitation energies. And indeed, we will show in the next subsection that the contributions with h-(h-p) and p-(p-h) poles vanish in the full self-energy.
Compensation of bare energy p-(p-h) and h-(h-p) poles
In order to show the cancellation of h-(h-p) and p-(p-h) poles in , we will make use of an analytic formula that is not obvious at first sight. The RPA elements and fulfill the following equality:
for any molecular orbital indices and any occupied-empty pair of MOs . This mathematical relation is demonstrated in Appendix § 8. In words, this relation expresses that the poles of the non-interacting susceptibility correspond to zeroes of the interacting RPA susceptibility .
With this relation, we identify that the first term in Eq. (21a), is precisely the opposite of the SOX term, in Eq. (11a). This can be written as
Symmetrically, we observe the analogous relation between the first term in and in Eq. (11b).
This shows that in the SOSEX approximation, which is , the SOX self-energy is completely canceled out. In other words, in the SOSEX approximation, there is no pole located at bare energy differences. The only poles that survive are located at or , exactly those contained in standard .
Now, one can be worried about the 2SOSEX approximation we proposed in Ref. 36. Indeed, we can show following the exact same steps as above, that the left-screened self-energy SOSEX also contains a contribution. This may look pathological at first sight. Fortunately, we show now that this term is also cancelled out by a contribution in the dynamic self-energy.
Starting from the analytic formulas for in Ref. 36, one can apply the partial fraction decomposition technique to separate the poles. We focus on the term [Eq. (17) in Ref. 36]. This permits us to isolate different kinds of poles, and in particular a h-(h-p) pole:
This equation contains the only h-(h-p) pole in the complete term. Let us single out this contribution and discard the rest. Applying twice the relation in Eq. (31), one can reach the desired result:
Of course, the same manipulations can be done for the particle scattering part, yielding the term. In total, this proves that the contains a SOX contribution.
This derivation teaches us that the 2SOSEX approximation proposed in our previous work[36] retains some h-(h-p) and p-(p-h) contributions, but G3W2 would have none. It would then make sense to construct a semi-static approximation to G3W2 that also incorporates the SOX contribution in the dynamic part . That is why we introduce now an “augmented” version of 2SOSEX that we name “2SOSEX-aug” and that is defined as
This expression differs from 2SOSEX only by the factor 2 scaling the term . So far, the derivation was purely algebraic, and it seems hopeless to associate a diagrammatic form with it. However, the diagrammatic analysis is simple.
Let us return to the explicit SOSEX expressions (20). To analyze hole scattering mechanisms, it is natural to look at the rate function associated with the lesser self-energy .
Taking the imaginary part of Eqs. (20a and 20c), we see that there are two scattering mechanisms at play: involving RPA neutral excitations giving rise to , and involving bare particle-hole excitations giving rise to the frequency dependence. The particle scattering processes are classified analogously by analyzing .
Just as the time-ordered SE, can be analyzed diagrammatically. For we have to remember that outer vertices are situated on the branches, respectively, whereas internal vertices can take position at either Keldysh branch ( or ), provided that i) there should be no isolated islands of certain sign, ii) bare Coulomb interaction is time-instantaneous, and therefore can only connect vertices on the same branch. Given these constraints, it turns out that the lesser SOSEX self-energy consists of just two partitions as depicted in Figure 5. It is not difficult to verify that they have distinct functional forms—they describe different physical mechanisms. The first partition involves 2 lesser and 1 greater GFs. Integrating over the intermediate times yields the dependence. Moreover, as was shown in § 3.2, this partition is exactly canceled by the SOX term. The second partition involves 1 lesser GF and 1 lesser line. Integrating over the intermediate times yields the dependence. Summarizing, Eq. (36) can be depicted diagrammatically as in Figure 6. It is then obvious, considering the constituent half-diagrams, that this expression cannot be written as a sum of squares. Thus, this approximation is not manifestly PSD. We will improve upon this approximation in the next section.
Figure 5. Diagrammatic representation of the SOSEX self-energy.
Figure 6. Diagrammatic representation of Eq. (36). The transformation is performed with the help of Eqs. (23), which originate from the identity (31).
Half-diagrams in Figure 6 have a clear diagrammatic meaning, analytic expressions can be derived using standard rules. However, it is of interest to support these derivations by transforming the time-ordered expressions. Now that we have shown that the h-(h-p) and p-(p-h) poles disappear in 2SOSEX-aug, we focus on a scattering mechanism involving RPA neutral excitations. For occupied states, we therefore inspect terms corresponding to the poles . They originate from the term given in Eq. (14a), Eq. (20c) and the non-SOX term in Eq. (23a), and the corresponding terms from the symmetric self-energy . Relabeling the indices and using the symmetry of , we finally arrive at a compact expression analogous to :
where
In agreement with diagrammatic form in Figure 6, Eq. (27a) contains three terms.
For virtual states the analysis is analogous, it starts from Eqs. (14b), (23b), and (23b) and their counterparts and yields the following expression:
where
, have the meaning of the first-order (in ) correction to hole-neutral excitation, particle-neutral excitation scattering processes, respectively.
Final expression: -psd
Equations (37) and (39) are already very useful. They correspond directly to the diagrams in Figure 6, and they are easy to evaluate numerically. Moreover, they clearly demonstrate that and are responsible for the overall non-PSD behavior. In fact, due to the energy differences in the denominators, these matrix elements do not have a definite sign. But adding extra terms quadratically proportional to allows us to complete a square in the numerators of Eqs. (27a) and (39) and yields manifestly PSD expressions:
A critical reader, however, would demand that correction terms should not be added ad hoc, but rather have a clear diagrammatic meaning. Such interpretation, which involves, as expected, a partition of a certain third-order diagram, indeed exists and in depicted in Figure 7. In this figure, we consider the lesser SE component describing scattering of occupied states and corresponding to Eq. (28a). The bottom row illustrates its complete square form.
Figure 7. Diagrammatic representation of the lesser SE component corresponding to Eq. (28a).
Let us conclude this section with Table 1 that recapitulates the analytic properties of the different approximations beyond that we discussed in this work. As shown above, standard is devoid of h-(h-p) and p-(p-h) poles and PSD and we were looking for vertex corrections that are as mathematically sound as . SOX and 2SOSEX corrections fail with respect to these two criteria. +2SOSEX-aug only fixes the no-p-(p-h)-h-(h-p) pole property and finally +2SOSEX-psd fixes both. Going too far and adding all the contributions of destroys again the PSD constraint.
| Approximation | Free of p-(p-h), h-(h-p) poles | Positive semi-definite |
| Yes | Yes | |
| No | No | |
| Yes | No | |
| No | No | |
| -aug | Yes | No |
| -psd | Yes | Yes |
| Yes | No |
Table 1. Summary of the self-energy approximations considered in this work with their properties.
Connection to effective Hamiltonians
Another way to look at PSD self-energies is through the lens of effective Hamiltonians of the general form
Here, is the Fock or generalized Kohn–Sham Hamiltonian with matrix elements , and is a diagonal matrix with the matrix elements , describing auxiliary states to which the single-particle states are coupled through with matrix elements . Equation (43) can be downfolded onto the single-particle space, resulting in the self-energy
Since any matrix is PSD, any self-energy which can be obtained through downfolding from an effective Hamiltonian is PSD. Conversely, since any PSD self-energy admits a Lehmann representation, [53] it can be represented as an effective single-particle Hamiltonian of the form in Eq. (43). Indeed, with , the self-energy from Eq. (14) [66, 67, 68] is obtained, and setting , the -psd self-energy in Eq. (28) is recovered. Replacing the RPA neutral excitation energies with the bare particle-hole pairs and modifying the couplings accordingly, one obtains the Hamiltonian corresponding to the PT2 self-energy.[69] On the other hand, none of the non-PSD self-energy expressions presented in this work correspond to an effective Hamiltonian of the form of Eq. (43). Though not numerically competitive, this alternate form is worth mentioning since it could help deriving exact properties in the future.
Numerical results for molecular systems
The new self-energies we have introduced in the previous section, namely -aug and -psd, have appealing formal properties. However, the true test is the actual accuracy of these approximations on real electronic systems. In the following, we focus on molecular systems for valence and core electron energies. All results shown are obtained with MOLGW.[64]
In the course of this study, we also evaluated the complete spectral functions, but we found that the satellite structures in the spectral functions were very sensitive to the technical details, basis set, mean-field starting point. In our opinion, they are not conclusive pieces of information.
Imaginary part of the self-energy of molecular examples
Let us first illustrate the approximations gathered in Table 1 with the Ne atom that we used in the introduction in Figure 1.
Figure 8 reports the imaginary part of 6 self-energy approximations starting from and complementing it with vertex corrections. SOX is the worst of all with strong non-PSD weight. This confirms the known statement that SOX is not producing accurate quasiparticle energies.[33, 70] SOSEX, which is devoid of p-(p-h) and h-(h-p) poles, shows improved performance with respect to the PSD criterion, even though it is not perfect. GW+2SOSEX has a strong positive contribution around -68 eV, which comes from the contribution. Then in GW+2SOSEX-aug, this contribution is eliminated. Remember that the only difference between GW+2SOSEX and GW+2SOSEX-aug is the addition of an extra .

Figure 8. Imaginary part of time-ordered correlation self-energies for the Ne atom. We plot the HOMO diagonal expectation value for GW, GW+SOX, GW+SOSEX in the first row, and GW+2SOSEX, GW+2SOSEX-aug, GW+2SOSEX-psd in the second row. Self-energies are evaluated as one-shot correction on top of HF.
Finally, our GW+2SOSEX-psd self-energy is perfectly PSD as expected. Its overall shape is much more similar to the original GW than any one of the other approximations. With the knowledge of the performance of GW for molecules, it is a very positive sign that GW+2SOSEX-psd stays rather similar to GW.
Second, in Figure 9, we show imaginary parts of self-energies for a more complicated example, benzene, where the poles almost form a continuum. The conclusions we drew on the Neon case are confirmed, except that the non-PSD peaks are less pronounced. Notice once again the similarity between and -psd: the peaks are the same, just their intensity was modified. This is consistent with the Eqs. (28) that only differ from their counterpart Eqs. (14) by the numerators.
Figure 9. Imaginary part of time-ordered correlation self-energies for the benzene molecule, . We plot the HOMO diagonal expectation value for , , in the first row, and , , -PSDized in the second row. A broadening Ha was used.
GW100 ionization potentials benchmark
Thanks to the reference coupled-cluster ionization potentials from Refs. [71] and [33], the GW100 set[56] of 100 small- and medium-sized molecules can serve as a fair measure of the quality of a self-energy approximation for HOMO quasiparticle energies. In the following, we use the same Gaussian basis set as in the reference calculations, namely Def2-TZVPP,[72] to mitigate the basis set effect on the conclusions.
Sticking to one-shot evaluation of the self-energy as assumed in our equations, there always exists a starting point dependence in the results and this may obscure the conclusions. Therefore, we proceed in two steps. In a first step, we evaluate the self-energies using Hartree-Fock (HF) as a starting point, as is standard in quantum chemistry. In a second step, we use improved starting points for selected self-energy approximations, as the community often do.
Figure 10 presents the GW100 HOMO energy (negative of the ionization potential) error distributions for all the approximations reported in Table 1, plus the initial HF mean-field result. HF is not a particularly good starting point for HOMO energies as we can see from the broad violin and the large mean absolute error (MAE). based on HF is rather good, with an MAE of 0.30 eV. The subsequent additions to , namely +SOX, +SOSEX, +2SOSEX, are not as accurate as the plain approximation. Through the elimination of the bare energy p-(p-h) and h-(h-p) poles, +2SOSEX-aug choice performs noticeably worse than +2SOSEX. This is quite unexpected. Quite the opposite, +2SOSEX-psd shows a reliability that is very comparable to with an MAE of 0.29 eV and a narrow distribution. For completeness, we also included the result from our previous work [36]. This last approximation shows serious outliers. Note that the analytic formula of SOSEX-psd is way faster to evaluate than that of with a much improved accuracy.
Figure 10. Error distribution of the HOMO energies with respect to a reference CCSD(T) SCF evaluation for the 100 molecules contained in the GW100 set. Different self-energies are evaluated as one-shot perturbations on top of HF.
Figure 11 demonstrates that the above conclusions are preserved when using improved starting points. Here we propose two mean-field approximations, PBEh(0.75) that was highlighted as a very good starting point in Ref. [33] and optimally-tuned range-separated hybrid [73] (OTRSH) that is also known to be excellent when combined with .[74] Both starting points are confirmed to have narrow distributions around zero by Figure 11. is excellent with very low MAE and SOSEX-psd performs equally well. Again, the numerically more involved approximation is detrimental to the accuracy.
Figure 11. Error distribution of the HOMO energies with respect to a reference CCSD(T) SCF evaluation for the 100 molecules contained in the GW100 set. The mean absolute errors (MAE) are given for each self-energy approximation. Self-energies are evaluated as one-shot perturbations on top of PBEh(0.75) (left-hand panel) or on top of optimally-tuned range-separated hybrid (OTRSH) (right-hand panel).
CORE65 benchmark for core electron binding energies
The self-energy formulas we derived are analytic and therefore can be evaluated accurately at any frequency. It is therefore straightforward to consider core ionization energies here, without the need to perform tedious numerical integrations.[75]
We employ a basis set dedicated to core excitations, pcSseg-3, [76] as prescribed in Ref. 77.
To allow for a fair comparison, we used the functional with different fractions of exact-exchange as the starting point. Golze et al.[57] identified as the best starting point for . However, this might not be the case for other self-energy approximations.
In Figure 12, we report the MAE of the binding energies of 53 core states in the CORE65 set[57] as a function of the content of exact-exchange in the starting mean-field. While we confirm that work best with , +2SOSEX-psd performs even slightly better for which is precisely the functional that works best. It is indeed a desirable feature that the accuracy of the final approximation does not rely on a sub-optimal starting point in combination with error compensations.
Figure 12. Binding energy mean absolute error for a subset of 53 out of 65 core state energies of organic molecules from the CORE65 benchmark. [57] The MAEs are presented as functions of the amount of exact-exchange in the starting mean-field .
Conclusion
Many-body perturbation theory is a standard tool in the arsenal of computational quantum chemistry. Despite years of intensive research, the question of which approximation works best for a given system can only be answered empirically. One approach to make this knowledge more systematic is to restrict to approximations that a priori satisfy a number of physical constraints.
This idea has been very fruitful, for example, in the development of exchange-correlation functionals, where incorporating as many known constraints as possible has led to significant accuracy improvements. [78] In many-body perturbation theory, the concept of conserving approximations is another well-known and extensively studied constraint. [79] This constraint has frequently been used to support the use of one-shot methods, as partially self-consistent approaches typically do not satisfy conservation laws. [80]
However, there are additional constraints within the framework of many-body perturbation theory. In this work, we focused on the constraint of positive semi-definiteness (PSD) of the electronic spectral function, which corresponds to the same property in the scattering rate function, i.e., the spectral function of the electron self-energy. This condition has a clear physical interpretation: it ensures that the probability of finding an electron at a given energy is always non-negative.
The formalism to construct PSD approximations, i.e., approximations that yield manifestly positive semi-definite spectral functions, has been known for over a decade. It is based on nonequilibrium Green’s function techniques and was initially applied to translationally invariant systems. In this work, we extended the approach to molecular systems. Starting from a subset of second-order diagrams, specifically second-order screened exchange (SOSEX), we observed that this approximation is not PSD. We then constructed a PSD version by including a higher-order diagram. The resulting approximation, which we call GW+2SOSEX-psd, not only satisfies the positivity constraint but also leads to a highly efficient numerical scheme with computational cost comparable to that of the analytic approach to the GW approximation. This efficiency is due to our discovery of a cancellation between the static and frequency-dependent components of the screened interaction in certain classes of self-energy diagrams. The effect is pronounced in finite systems and takes place under some conditions at higher orders, as we have demonstrated.
A natural question is how well the new approximation performs relative to existing methods. We conducted extensive numerical tests of ionization potentials and core-level binding energies using the established GW100 and CORE65 benchmarks using the MOLGW code. [64]
The main conclusion is that consistently outperforms its non-PSD counterparts like , , and , although the improvement over itself is modest for valence states and more pronounced for core states.
Acknowledgement
Part of this work was performed using HPC resources from GENCI–TGCC (Grant 2024-gen6018).
Supporting Information Available
Individual results for each molecule in the GW100 and CORE65 benchmarks are provided as Supporting information.
A handy relation
In this appendix, we demonstrate the relation given in Eq. (31). It is not obvious at first sight and was not known to us. It is valid for RPA energies and RPA eigenvectors and , where are any MO and where is an occupied-empty pair of MO.
Within RPA, the irreducible polarizability is obtained from the non-interacting polarizability with a Dyson-like equation (space indices are omitted):
Let us symmetrize the expression by multiply with on both sides:
In practice we use an auxiliary basis to represent and . This is not necessary for the proof but makes the derivation compact and follows closely what we actually have in the code.
Labeling the auxiliary basis with capital letter , , etc., reads
where are 3-center Coulomb integrals. After solving the Casida equations [58, 59, 64] in the RPA, we have an expression for :
Note that the spin degeneracy factor 2 is included by scaling coefficients with .
Introducing the spectral decompositions of and in the Dyson-like equation, Eq. (46), we obtain
When taking the limit , the left-hand side of Eq. (49) smoothly tends to a finite value, whereas its right-hand side contains diverging terms.
Therefore, the divergent terms in the right-hand side of Eq. (49) should cancel out. For simplicity, let us assume that energy difference is not degenerate.
Then for each pair , we have
Here we take the limit of vanishing , which induces a real part and an imaginary part by virtue of the Sokhotski–Plemelj formula. The imaginary part is a sum of delta functions . For finite systems with discrete excitation energies, we can safely assume that the delta function arguments are always non-zero and then that the imaginary part vanishes.
The remaining real part yields
Multiplying by expressed in any pair of MO , i.e. , we finally obtain the desired expression:
which is nothing else but the condition on the time-ordered screened interaction:
Note that our notation for the matrix elements of the screened interaction is analogous to that of the bare Coulomb interaction; that is, the same index ordering is used. Symmetries , and give rise to more conditions.
Another example of a vanishing diagram
Cancellation of diagrams due to the identity (31) also takes places at higher orders. Consider, for instance, one out of six possible third-order SE diagrams, and take a specific partition such as illustrated in Figure 13 (there are in total partitions). Following the diagrammatic rules we obtain
Figure 13. Example of a vanishing third order partition
Performing frequency integrals we obtain
Thus, the partition vanishes in view of the identity (53).
Scattering amplitudes involving bare excitations
After considering the example in Sec. B, one may wonder whether diagrammatic expansions in terms of the RPA-screened interaction ever generate terms with bare particle-hole poles. An equivalent statement would be: *A general form of a lesser self-energy expansion contains contributions proportional to
whereas the greater self-energies contain contributions proportional to
A possible approach for proving such statement would be: Start with a lesser SE term and partition it into two half-diagrams along the boundary. For concreteness, consider one of them with vertices on the ””-branch. At the half-diagram boundary, it contains incoming fermionic lines associated with the lesser GFs and outgoing fermionic lines associated with the greater GFs. On the exit, it contains a single fermionic line. Internally, fermionic lines are connected by interacting lines associated with time-ordered interaction , so that there is no dangling edges. If there is an interaction line connected to an external particle–hole pair (as shown in Figure 14, panel (a)), one can immediately verify that the corresponding contribution vanishes. To see this, let be the frequency associated with and the frequency of the incoming lesser Green’s function, and manipulate the corresponding expression as follows:
Figure 14. (a) Time-ordered screened interaction connected to a bare particle–hole excitation. (b) A partition of the fourth-order (in ) self-energy diagram with a non-vanishing scattering amplitude that involves the generation of a bare particle–hole excitation.
In the last step, the identity Eq. (53) is used. Thus, contributions of this type always vanish.
One can verify that for diagrams of second and third order such argument always works.
This represents a great reduction of the number of partitions. For instance a third-order SE diagram depicted in Figure 13 consists in total of 16 partitions, but only 5 of them, namely −−−−−+, −−−−++, −−−+++, −−++++, −+++++, are non-vanishing.
In general, however, the argument does not hold. There are indeed fourth-order examples—such as the one shown in Figure 14, panel (b)—that yield a non-vanishing contribution proportional to , indicating the presence of a bare particle–hole excitation. The diagram was constructed specifically to avoid any or lines connecting to the particle–hole pairs crossing the border, which makes it impossible to apply the argument discussed above. An explicit expression can be derived using the diagrammatic rules (App. § 11):
where the leading sign is due to one fermionic loop. Considering that are proportional to the -functions, and that there is an additional energy conserving condition , the frequency integrals over , and immediately yield the overall dependence . However, the pre-factor cannot be made zero by virtue of Eq. (53) as it equals to
Thus, the scattering amplitude associated with the generation of bare particle-hole pairs is, in general, non-vanishing.
Diagrammatic rules
In this work we use diagrammatic rules as detailed in Ref. 4 chapter 10. For completeness, we include a summary of these rules in this appendix. Diagrams in bare and screened interactions have the same pre-factors. The pre-factor of a self-energy diagram is , where is the number of interacting lines and is the number of loops. This yields, for instance, for the 1-ring diagram in Figure 3 the pre-factor , while the SOX diagram has a negative pre-factor due to the absence of loops.
Each vertex in a diagram is associated with a time argument. For physical times and normal time ordering (i.e. on the forward () branch of the Keldysh contour) we obtain the time-ordered diagrams. For general contour times, i.e., on both and branches of the Keldysh contour, we obtain diagrams of nonequilibrium Green’s function theory. It is often useful to indicate explicitly the branch () on which each vertex lies. This labeling helps identify the explicit components of the Green’s function and the screened interaction , such as , or representing the time-ordered component, and so on.
For systems at equilibrium, the diagrams are typically evaluated in frequency space, by assigning frequencies to propagators. The sum of frequency arguments of the ingoing lines at each vertex has to be equal to the sum of the frequency arguments of the outgoing lines to satisfy energy conservation. This has been used in Figure 3, where some of the frequency arguments have been omitted for brevity. In evaluating each diagram, one has to integrate over all internal vertices, which includes integrations over space, spin, and time/frequency. When integrating over frequencies, each integral contributes a factor .
In diagrammatic representations of the lesser self-energy, the outgoing external vertex (typically on the left side of the diagram) carries a minus label, and the incoming vertex carries a plus. Diagrams with assigned labels are referred to as partitions. A single diagram generally corresponds to several partitions; however, not all are physically meaningful. Partitions with isolated islands of pluses or minuses vanish, as demonstrated in Ref. 13.
We do not propose a general scheme for ordering or numbering the partitions for the diagram in Figure 14(b). Nevertheless, the other diagrams considered in this work are relatively simple, with vertices arranged along a single line. In such cases, a partition can be indicated by listing the vertex labels from the outgoing () to the incoming () vertex. For the SOX diagram, this corresponds to the configuration .
References
TOC Graphic
Figure 15 (PDF p. 48).
References
- [1]Cederbaum, L. S.; Domcke, W. In Theoretical aspects of ionization potentials and photoelectron spectroscopy: A Green’s function approach; Prigogine, I., Rice, S. A., Eds.; Advance in Chemical Physics; Wiley-Interscience: New York, 1977; Vol. 36; p 205.DOI
- [2]Strinati, G. Application of the greens-functions method to the study of the optical-properties of semiconductors. Riv. Nuovo Cimento 1988, 11, 1.DOI
- [3]Mahan, G. D. Many-Particle Physics, 3rd ed.; Kluwer Academic/Plenum Publishers, 2000.
- [4]Stefanucci, G.; van Leeuwen, R. Nonequilibrium Many-Body Theory of Quantum Systems: A Modern Introduction; Cambridge University Press: Cambridge, 2013.
- [5]Hedin, L. New Method for Calculating the One-Particle Green’s Function with Application to the Electron-Gas Problem. Phys. Rev. 1965, 139, A796–A823.DOI
- [6]Reining, L. The GW approximation: content, successes and limitations. Wiley Interdisciplinary Reviews: Computational Molecular Science 2018, 8, e1344.DOI
- [7]Golze, D.; Dvorak, M.; Rinke, P. The GW Compendium: A Practical Guide to Theoretical Photoemission Spectroscopy. Frontiers in Chemistry 2019, 7, 377.DOI
- [8]Marie, A.; Ammar, A.; Loos, P. F. The GW approximation: A quantum chemistry perspective. Adv. Quantum Chem. 2024, 90, 157–184.arxiv.org/abs/2311.05351
- [9]Møller, C.; Plesset, M. S. Note on an Approximation Treatment for Many-Electron Systems. Phys. Rev. 1934, 46, 618–622.
- [10]Cederbaum, L. Direct calculation of ionization potentials of closed-shell atoms and molecules. Theoret. Chim. Acta 1973, 31, 239.DOI
- [11]Cederbaum, L. S. One-body Green’s function for atoms and molecules: theory and application. Journal of Physics B: Atomic and Molecular Physics 1975, 8, 290.DOI
- [12]Holm, B.; von Barth, U. Fully self-consistent GW self-energy of the electron gas. Phys. Rev. B 1998, 57, 2108–2117.DOI
- [13]Stefanucci, G.; Pavlyukh, Y.; Uimonen, A.-M.; van Leeuwen, R. Diagrammatic expansion for positive spectral functions beyond GW: Application to vertex corrections in the electron gas. Phys. Rev. B 2014, 90, 115134.DOI
- [14]Mahan, G. D.; Sernelius, B. E. Electron-Electron Interactions and the Bandwidth of Metals. Phys. Rev. Lett. 1989, 62, 2718–2720.pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/10040070
- [15]Del Sole, R.; Reining, L.; Godby, R. W. GWF approximation for electron self-energies in semiconductors and insulators. Phys. Rev. B 1994, 49, 8024–8028.pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/10009565
- [16]Shirley, E. L. Self-consistent GW and higher-order calculations of electron states in metals. Phys. Rev. B - Condens. Matter Mater. Phys. 1996, 54, 7758–7764.pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/9984448
- [17]de Groot, H.; Ummels, R.; Bobbert, P.; Haeringen, W. V. Lowest-order corrections to the RPA polarizability and GW self-energy of a semiconducting wire. Phys. Rev. B - Condens. Matter Mater. Phys. 1996, 54, 2374–2380.
- [18]Schindlmayr, A.; Godby, R. W. Systematic vertex corrections through iterative solution of Hedin’s equations beyond the GW approximation. Phys. Rev. Lett. 1998, 80, 1702–1705.DOI
- [19]Shishkin, M.; Marsman, M.; Kresse, G. Accurate quasiparticle spectra from self-consistent GW calculations with vertex corrections. Phys. Rev. Lett. 2007, 99, 246403.pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/18233465
- [20]Grüneis, A.; Kresse, G.; Hinuma, Y.; Oba, F. Ionization Potentials of Solids: The Importance of Vertex Corrections. Phys. Rev. Lett. 2014, 112, 096401.pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/24655265
- [21]Kutepov, A. L. Electronic structure of Na, K, Si, and LiF from self-consistent solution of Hedin’s equations including vertex corrections. Phys. Rev. B 2016, 94, 155101.DOI
- [22]Schmidt, P. S.; Patrick, C. E.; Thygesen, K. S. Simple vertex correction improves GW band energies of bulk and two-dimensional crystals. Phys. Rev. B 2017, 96, 205206.DOI
- [23]Ma, H.; Govoni, M.; Gygi, F.; Galli, G. A Finite-Field Approach for GW Calculations beyond the Random Phase Approximation. J. Chem. Theory Comput. 2019, 15, 154–164.DOI
- [24]Pavlyukh, Y.; Stefanucci, G.; van Leeuwen, R. Dynamically screened vertex correction to GW. Phys. Rev. B 2020, 102, 045121.
- [25]Tal, A.; Chen, W.; Pasquarello, A. Vertex function compliant with the Ward identity for quasiparticle self-consistent calculations beyond GW. Phys. Rev. B 2021, 103, 161104.DOI
- [26]Cunningham, B.; Grüning, M.; Pashov, D.; Van Schilfgaarde, M. QSG Ŵ: Quasiparticle self-consistent GW with ladder diagrams in W. Phys. Rev. B 2023, 108, 165104.
- [27]Rohlfing, M. Approximate spatiotemporal structure of the vertex function Γ(1, 2;3) in many-body perturbation theory. Phys. Rev. B 2023, 108, 195207.DOI
- [28]Romaniello, P.; Guyot, S.; Reining, L. The self-energy beyond GW: Local and nonlocal vertex corrections. J. Chem. Phys. 2009, 131, 154111.DOI
- [29]Ren, X.; Marom, N.; Caruso, F.; Scheffler, M.; Rinke, P. Beyond the GW approximation: A second-order screened exchange correction. Phys. Rev. B 2015, 92, 081104.
- [30]Kuwahara, R.; Noguchi, Y.; Ohno, K. GW Γ + Bethe-Salpeter equation approach for photoabsorption spectra: Importance of self-consistent GW Γ calculations in small atomic systems. Phys. Rev. B 2016, 94, 121116(R).DOI
- [31]Vlček, V. Stochastic Vertex Corrections: Linear Scaling Methods for Accurate Quasiparticle Energies. J. Chem. Theory Comput. 2019, 15, 6254–6266.arxiv.org/abs/1904.05524
- [32]Lewis, A. M.; Berkelbach, T. C. Vertex Corrections to the Polarizability Do Not Improve the GW Approximation for the Ionization Potential of Molecules. J. Chem. Theory Comput. 2019, 15, 2925–2932, PMID: 30933508.DOI
- [33]Bruneval, F.; Dattani, N.; van Setten, M. J. The GW Miracle in Many-Body Perturbation Theory for the Ionization Potential of Molecules. Frontiers in Chemistry 2021, 9, 749779.DOI
- [34]Mejuto-Zaera, C.; Vlček, V. Self-consistency in GW Γ formalism leading to quasiparticle-quasiparticle couplings. Phys. Rev. B 2022, 106, 165129.
- [35]Loos, P. F.; Marie, A.; Ammar, A. Cumulant Green’s function methods for molecules. Faraday Discuss. 2024, 254, 240–260.arxiv.org/abs/2402.16414
- [36]Bruneval, F.; Förster, A. Fully Dynamic G3W2 Self-Energy for Finite Systems: Formulas and Benchmark. Journal of Chemical Theory and Computation 2024, 20, 3218–3230, PMID: 38603811.
- [37]Vacondio, S.; Varsano, D.; Ruini, A.; Ferretti, A. Going Beyond the GW Approximation Using the Time-Dependent Hartree-Fock Vertex. J. Chem. Theory Comput. 2024, 20, 4718–4737.DOI
- [38]Förster, A.; Bruneval, F. Why Does the GW Approximation Give Accurate Quasiparticle Energies? The Cancellation of Vertex Corrections Quantified. J. Phys. Chem. Lett. 2024, 15, 12526–12534, PMID: 39670751.arxiv.org/abs/2410.17843
- [39]Patterson, C. H. Molecular Ionization Energies from GW and Hartree–Fock Theory: Polarizability, Screening, and Self-Energy Vertex Corrections. Journal of Chemical Theory and Computation 2024, 20, 7479–7493, PMID: 39189378.DOI
- [40]Patterson, C. H. Erratum: Molecular Ionization Energies from GW and Hartree-Fock Theory: Polarizability, Screening and Self-Energy Vertex Corrections. J. Chem. Theory Comput. 2024, 20, 9267.DOI
- [41]Förster, A. Beyond Quasi-Particle Self-Consistent GW for Molecules with Vertex Corrections. J. Chem. Theory Comput. 2025, 21, 1709–1721.DOI
- [42]Romaniello, P.; Bechstedt, F.; Reining, L. Beyond the GW approximation: Combining correlation channels. Phys. Rev. B 2012, 85, 155131.DOI
- [43]Holm, B.; Aryasetiawan, F. Self-consistent cumulant expansion for the electron gas. Phys. Rev. B 1997, 56, 12825–12831.DOI
- [44]Takada, Y. Low-energy peak in the one-particle spectral function of the electron gas at metallic densities. Phys. Rev. B 2024, 110, 085132.DOI
- [45]Caruso, F.; Lambert, H.; Giustino, F. Band Structures of Plasmonic Polarons. Phys. Rev. Lett. 2015, 114, 146404.DOI
- [46]Zhou, J. S.; Gatti, M.; Kas, J. J.; Rehr, J. J.; Reining, L. Cumulant Green’s function calculations of plasmon satellites in bulk sodium: Influence of screening and the crystal environment. Phys. Rev. B 2018, 97, 035137.DOI
- [47]Riley, J. M.; Caruso, F.; Verdi, C.; Duffy, L. B.; Watson, M. D.; Bawden, L.; Volckaert, K.; van der Laan, G.; Hesjedal, T.; Hoesch, M.; Giustino, F.; King, P. D. C. Crossover from lattice to plasmonic polarons of a spin-polarised electron gas in ferromagnetic EuO. Nat. Commun. 2018, 9, 2305.DOI
- [48]Mejuto-Zaera, C.; Weng, G.; Romanova, M.; Cotton, S. J.; Whaley, K. B.; Tubman, N. M.; Vlček, V. Are multi-quasiparticle interactions important in molecular ionization? J. Chem. Phys. 2021, 154, 121101.
- [49]Kockläuner, J.; Golze, D. GW Plus Cumulant Approach for Predicting Core-Level Shakeup Satellites in Large Molecules. J. Chem. Theory Comput. 2025, 21, 3101–3119.DOI
- [50]Uimonen, A.-M.; Stefanucci, G.; Pavlyukh, Y.; van Leeuwen, R. Diagrammatic expansion for positive density-response spectra: Application to the electron gas. Phys. Rev. B 2015, 91, 115104.DOI
- [51]Pavlyukh, Y.; Uimonen, A.-M.; Stefanucci, G.; van Leeuwen, R. Vertex Corrections for Positive-Definite Spectral Functions of Simple Metals. Phys. Rev. Lett. 2016, 117, 206402.DOI
- [52]Winter, J. Study of core excitations in one-particle and one-hole nuclei by means of the six-point Green function. Nucl. Phys. A 1972, 194, 535–551.DOI
- [53]Cederbaum, L. S. Non-single-particle excitations in finite Fermi systems. J. Chem. Phys. 1975, 62, 2160–2170.DOI
- [54]Minnhagen, P. Vertex correction calculations for an electron gas. J. Phys. C: Solid State Phys. 1974, 7, 3013.DOI
- [55]Ambladh, C.-O. On the Theory of Photoemission. Phys. Scr. 1985, 32, 341.
- [56]van Setten, M. J.; Caruso, F.; Sharifzadeh, S.; Ren, X.; Scheffler, M.; Liu, F.; Lischner, J.; Lin, L.; Deslippe, J. R.; Louie, S. G.; Yang, C.; Weigend, F.; Neaton, J. B.; Evers, F.; Rinke, P. GW100: Benchmarking G0W0 for Molecular Systems. J. Chem. Theory Comput. 2015, 11, 5665–5687, PMID: 26642984.DOI
- [57]Golze, D.; Keller, L.; Rinke, P. Accurate Absolute and Relative Core-Level Binding Energies from GW. J. Phys. Chem. Lett. 2020, 11, 1840–1847. PMID: 32043890.DOI
- [58]Casida, M. E. In Recent Advances in Density Functional Methods, Part I; Chong, D., Ed.; World Scientific: Singapore, 1995; p 155.DOI
- [59]Casida, M. E. Time-dependent density-functional theory for molecules and molecular solids. J. Mol. Struct. THEOCHEM 2009, 914, 3–18.
- [60]Bruneval, F. Improved density matrices for accurate molecular ionization potentials. Phys. Rev. B 2019, 99, 041118(R).DOI
- [61]Szabó, A.; Ostlund, N. S. Modern quantum chemistry : introduction to advanced electronic structure theory; Dover Publications: Mineola (N.Y.), 1996.
- [62]Tiago, M. L.; Chelikowsky, J. R. Optical excitations in organic molecules, clusters, and defects studied by first-principles Green’s function methods. Phys. Rev. B 2006, 73, 205334.DOI
- [63]van Setten, M. J.; Weigend, F.; Evers, F. The GW-Method for Quantum Chemistry Applications: Theory and Implementation. J. Chem. Theory Comput. 2013, 9, 232–246, PMID: 26589026.
- [64]Bruneval, F.; Rangel, T.; Hamed, S. M.; Shao, M.; Yang, C.; Neaton, J. B. Molgw 1: Many-body perturbation theory software for atoms, molecules, and clusters. Comput. Phys. Commun. 2016, 208, 149 – 161.
- [65]Pavlyukh, Y. Padé resummation of many-body perturbation theories. Sci. Rep. 2017, 7, 504.DOI
- [66]Bintrim, S. J.; Berkelbach, T. C. Full-frequency GW without frequency. J. Chem. Phys. 2021, 154, 041101.DOI
- [67]Monino, E.; Loos, P.-F. Unphysical Discontinuities, Intruder States and Regularization in GW Methods. J. Chem. Phys. 2022, 156, 231101.DOI
- [68]Tölle, J.; Chan, G. K.-L. Exact relationships between the GW approximation and equation-of-motion coupled-cluster theories through the quasi-boson formalism. J. Chem. Phys. 2023, 158, 124123.DOI
- [69]Backhouse, O. J.; Nusspickel, M.; Booth, G. H. A wave function perspective and efficient truncation of renormalised second-order perturbation theory. J. Chem. Theory Comput. 2020, 16, 1090–1104.DOI
- [70]Marom, N.; Caruso, F.; Ren, X.; Hofmann, O. T.; Körzdörfer, T.; Chelikowsky, J. R.; Rubio, A.; Scheffler, M.; Rinke, P. Benchmark of GW methods for azabenzenes. Phys. Rev. B 2012, 86, 245127.DOI
- [71]Krause, K.; Harding, M. E.; Klopper, W. Coupled-cluster reference values for the GW27 and GW100 test sets for the assessment of GW methods. Mol. Phys. 2015, 113, 1952–1960.DOI
- [72]Weigend, F.; Ahlrichs, R. Balanced basis sets of split valence, triple zeta valence and quadruple zeta valence quality for H to Rn: Design and assessment of accuracy. Phys. Chem. Chem. Phys. 2005, 7.
- [73]Refaely-Abramson, S.; Sharifzadeh, S.; Govind, N.; Autschbach, J.; Neaton, J. B.; Baer, R.; Kronik, L. Quasiparticle Spectra from a Nonempirical Optimally Tuned Range-Separated Hybrid Density Functional. Phys. Rev. Lett. 2012, 109, 226405.
- [74]McKeon, C. A.; Hamed, S. M.; Bruneval, F.; Neaton, J. B. An optimally tuned range-separated hybrid starting point for ab initio GW plus Bethe-Salpeter equation calculations of molecules. J. Chem. Phys. 2022, 157, 074103.DOI
- [75]Golze, D.; Wilhelm, J.; van Setten, M. J.; Rinke, P. Core-Level Binding Energies from GW: An Efficient Full-Frequency Approach within a Localized Basis. Journal of Chemical Theory and Computation 2018, 14, 4856–4869, PMID: 30092140.DOI
- [76]Jensen, F. Segmented Contracted Basis Sets Optimized for Nuclear Magnetic Shielding. Journal of Chemical Theory and Computation 2015, 11, 132–138, PMID: 26574211.DOI
- [78]Kaplan, A. D.; Levy, M.; Perdew, J. P. The Predictive Power of Exact Constraints and Appropriate Norms in Density Functional Theory. Annu. Rev. Phys. Chem. 2023, 74, 193–218.DOI
- [79]Amblardh, C.-O.; Barth, U. V.; Leeuwen, R. V. Variational Total Energies from Φ- and Ψ-Derivable Theories. International Journal of Modern Physics B 1999, 13, 535–541.
- [80]von Barth, U.; Holm, B. Self-consistent results for the electron gas: Fixed screened potential within the random-phase approximation. Phys. Rev. B - Condens. Matter Mater. Phys. 1996, 54, 8411–8419.












