WorksPhysics and Astronomy
Mode coupling, bi-stability, and spectral broadening in buckled nanotube resonators
Abstract
Bi-stable mechanical resonators play a significant role in various applications, such as sensors, memory elements, and quantum computing. While carbon nanotube (CNT) based resonators have been widely investigated as promising nano electro-mechanical devices, a bi-stable CNT resonator has never been demonstrated. Here, we report a new class of CNT resonators in which the nanotube is buckled upward. We show that a small upward buckling yields record electrical frequency tunability, whereas larger buckling can achieve Euler-Bernoulli (EB) bi-stability, the smallest mechanical resonator with two stable configurations to date. We believe that these recently discovered CNT devices will open new avenues for realizing nano-sensors, mechanical memory elements and parametric amplifiers. Furthermore, we present a three-dimensional theoretical analysis revealing significant nonlinear coupling between the in-plane and out-of-plane static and dynamic modes of motion, and a unique three-dimensional EB snap-through transition. We utilize this coupling to provide a conclusive explanation for the low quality factor in CNT resonators at room temperature, key in understanding dissipation mechanisms at the nano scale.
Main text
A bi-stable system is the underlying operation principle of modern technology. It is the basic building block for computing, memories, and digital electronics. In micro electromechanical systems (MEMS) technology[1], bi-stability is achieved by an arch shaped beam with two symmetric possible configurations: either buckled up (or right) or down (or left). The transition between the two buckled configurations, named Euler-Bernoulli (EB) snap-through (ST) bi-stability[2], is a fascinating example for non-linear behavior where the compression of the beam decreases its effective spring constant until it vanishes. The transition between the two configurations is controlled by an external force (usually electrostatic) and near this critical transition point, any small force perturbation results in a significant mechanical response, utilized for the realization of ultra-sensitive force, acceleration, and position sensors. Reducing the dimensions of a MEMS resonator to the nano scale improves its performance[3, 4, 5, 6] and enables observation of quantum effects that are not accessible via MEMS devices[7].
Carbon nanotube (CNT) based resonators have been widely investigated for sensing[8] [9], signal processing10, and quantum research11–15. However, a bi-stable CNT resonator has never been demonstrated. In this work, we realize for the first time, the EB snap-through buckling instability in novel suspended CNT resonators and investigate, both theoretically and experimentally, the static and the dynamic behavior of the system, and visualize the complete three-dimensional CNT motion. In fact, we present the first devices in which the CNT is initially buckled upward. This new configuration enables unique out-of-plane static motion which results in completely different behavior than traditional CNT resonators. The realization of this new type of devices opens new avenues, some of which we report here: robust bi-stability for long-term endurance of the device, 10-fold enhancement over the best electrical frequency tunability reported, and strong mode coupling explaining the anomalous dissipation of CNTs at room temperature.
An important characteristic of CNT resonators is the emergence of nonlinear behavior even at a nanometric vibrational amplitude16,17. In devices exhibiting EB buckling, the geometric nonlinearity18,19 becomes more significant since we can observe the transition from compression to stretching. This transition is accompanied by large modulation of the resonance frequencies and strong nonlinear coupling between different modes via the built-in strain. We utilize this induced coupling by the axial strain between the in- and out-of-plane mechanical motions to provide decisive explanation for the long-standing problem of low quality factor of CNT resonators at room temperature, in agreement with the fluctuation broadening theory20.
Device fabrication and results
Figure 1a presents the geometric structure of our devices. The fabrication is based on the technique developed recently for self-aligned local gate suspended CNT devices21. Briefly, CNTs are grown by chemical vapor deposition (CVD) to create a contact between the source and drain (SD) electrodes, while suspended above a local-gate electrode (Figure 1a, see methods section and supplementary information for fabrication details).

Figure 1. Suspended CNT based bi-stable NEMS device. (a) Schematic layout of the device, coordinates system and experimental setup for the resonance frequency measurement. Note that our coordinates system is such that the positive direction points downward. Inset: SEM image of a typical device, displaying initial upward buckling. Scale bar - . (b) Theoretical 2D model for the midpoint static deflection (red dot in a) as a function of the DC gate voltage. The blue line represents a stable solution while the gray is unstable. Inset is the corresponding theoretical resonance frequency dependence on the DC gate voltage. (c) Resonance frequency measurement of device I, displaying continuous transition via an inflection point (IP), exhibiting MHz/V (dashed yellow line). (d) Upward (right) and downward (left) sweeps measurement of device II, exhibiting the snap-through and release phenomena, resulting in a "jump" of nearly 80 MHz in the resonance frequency.
All measurements were conducted in a vacuum chamber under a constant pressure of Torr at room temperature. For the resonance frequencies measurements, the actuation of the CNT is done electrostatically by the local-gate, and the detection is done by the frequency mixing technique22, as illustrated in Figure 1a.
Figure 1c and Figure 1d present resonance frequency measurements of two devices (devices I and II, respectively), revealing a qualitative different behavior from previously reported suspended CNT resonators22,23. The “classical” suspended CNT resonance frequency increases with the gate voltage due to increase in tension. In our devices, however, the resonance frequency exhibits a substantial decrease until a noticeable minimum. The transition from “fall” to “rise” appears either in the form of a sharp dip via an inflection point (IP, Figure 1c) or by a large "jump" in the resonance frequency ( in Figure 1d). The IP in Figure 1c is characterized by extremely high tunability (marked by the dashed line) with a slope of 100 MHz/V, the highest electrostatic tunability to date of any NEMS/MEMS device22,24. High ratio is essential for achieving ultrasensitive nano-sensors[3], realizing nanomechanical computing25, and for obtaining high-gain parametric amplification and self-oscillation.
Figure 1b presents results from a standard 2D theoretical model that should predict the static response of a buckled beam exhibiting ST phenomenon. Initially, the CNT is buckled upward. Applying a DC gate voltage attracts the CNT towards the local-gate, generating compression and therefore softening the CNT spring constant, which causes the decrease in the resonance frequency (point A in Figure 1b-Figure 1d). If the initial buckling is above a critical instability, an unstable solution is formed (marked in gray, Figure 1b). Then, the transition between the two stable configurations (in our case, from initial upward buckling to downward buckling) occurs through an abrupt mechanical transition, known as the snap-through Euler-Bernoulli buckling transition19,26. This mechanical "jump" causes a change in the spring constant, which translates into a discontinuity in the resonance frequency (B B in Figure 1b,Figure 1d). After the snap, decreasing the applied voltage, a second critical point is reached (D) resulting in an abrupt transition back to the original geometric configuration, known as release (). The ST and release points may occur for different static loads (as is depicted in Figure 1b) which then translates into a hysteretic response, evidenced in both the DC conductance measurement (see supplementary text) and the resonance frequency measurement (Figure 1d).
Discussion
We divide our devices into four different categories (Figure 2 and S3). In the first category (device III, see Figure 2a), the CNT is initially buckled downward (), thus exhibiting the common behavior of CNT resonators which has been widely studied22,24,27.

Figure 2. Influence of initial buckling on the dynamic response. (a-d) Representative resonance frequency measurements of devices III-VI for the different categories, where (a) , (b) , (c) , and (d) . The insets are schematics of the initial shape of the CNT (solid arch) illustrating the different classes relative to the critical value (dashed arch). (e-h) Modelling the dynamic response of the same devices in (a-d), respectively. The solid lines are the theoretical fitting to the experimental data (black dots). The initial CNT heights extracted from the fit are: (e) for device III, (f) for device IV, (g) for device V, and (h) for device VI, in agreement with our qualitative interpretation.
The other categories, however, deal with the case of initial upward buckling (), a regime never explored before in CNT resonators. These classes are characterized by the ratio between and the critical initial buckling, , for which the ST instability is formed.
In the second group, the initial height is still minor compared to the critical value, meaning . The resonance frequency gate dependence in this regime is characterized by a mild dip in the resonance frequency measurement (device IV, Figure 2b). As increases, we enter the third category, in which the mild dip sharpens (devices V and I, Figure 2c and Figure 1c, respectively), but the transition is still continuous. When increases above the critical value, we enter the fourth type (), characterized by a hysteretic static and dynamic response. As a result, a noticeable "jump" in the resonance frequency is observed (devices II and VI in Figure 1d and Figure 2d, respectively).
Unlike previous CNT bi-stable devices that relied only on pull-in[4], which deteriorate after only several switches28, our ST transition is extremely robust. The snap-through transition occurs in every DC gate sweep. Hence, during a resonance frequency measurement, it is repeated hundreds of times. For example, we extracted an average ST voltage from the measurement in Figure 1d of =4.39V and a standard deviation of = 0.02V. The relative deviation in the snap-through voltage ( = 0.46%) in our CNT resonators is significantly smaller than in previous mentioned bistable nanobeams (~50V, = >10%)29. This shows that the ST transition in our CNT resonators is extremely sharp and requires significantly lower power consumption.
While these results are highly encouraging, they leave us with a puzzle. According to the 2D model (Figure 1b), the ST transition occurs at extremum points, which symbolize zero spring constant and hence zero resonance frequency (=0). However, looking closer at Figure 1d and Figure 2d (of devices in the fourth category), we note that the "jump" does not take place at =0, but at 20-60MHz above zero. In addition, for the down sweep in Figure 1d (left) we observe a negative jump, which cannot be explained by the naïve model. To solve this puzzle, we had to realize that the model in Figure 1b assumes that the CNT movement is constrained to the xz-plane (in-plane), where in fact, there is a "hidden" out-of-plane component responsible for our observations.
In order to understand the origin of the different classes of devices and their characteristics, we model our devices as doubly clamped beams19,26,30. Since the CNT cross section is circular, we must consider the out-of-plane as well as the in-plane motion16,31. The out-of-plane motion and the electrostatic force towards the local-gate impose torque along the CNT axis30, forming a gate-dependent torsion. Thus, the tube develops a twist during its static motion towards the local-gate. As a result, we formulated a 3D theoretical model in which the Euler-Bernoulli equations of motion are solved considering all three degrees of freedom: in-plane (), out-of-plane () and twist () (see supplementary text). We should emphasize the fundamental difference whether the CNT is slacked downward (type I) or buckled upward (types III-V), since only the latter can result in static out-of-plane motion. While many CNT studies took into account out-of-plane dynamics16, we are the first to consider out-of-plane initial and static deflection. This type of motion is new both for suspended CNTs analysis (traditionally slacked downward) as well as for buckled beams analysis, in which the (width) and (thickness) beam dimensions are usually different, restricting the motion to be solely in-plane (widththickness). Our simulations yielded excellent agreement with the experimental results (Figure 2e-Figure 2h and Figure 3c-Figure 3d) and allowed us to visualize the complete and unique CNT motion (Figure 3e-Figure 3f).

Figure 3. Hybrid in-plane and out-of-plane motion. (a) Resonance frequency measurement of device VII, revealing both the out-of-plane (lower, marked by the arrows) and in-plane (second) modes where . (b) Resonance frequency measurement of device VIII, in which . Only the lowest in-plane mode is detected. Inset is a close-up on the "jump" area marked by the dashed line. (c,d) Modelling the dynamic response of the same devices as in (a) and (b), respectively. The solid lines are the theoretical fitting to the experimental data (black dots\squares). (e) and (f) are the CNT static movement when increasing the gate voltage corresponding to the theoretical fitting in (c) and (d), respectively.
Regarding the puzzle raised earlier, as to why does the “jump” occur at finite frequency, the theoretical analysis predicts that the lowest out-of-plane mode () is always lower than its in-plane counterpart (, see Figure 3c,Figure 3d), while the torsional vibrational modes () are several orders of magnitude higher (, where and are the tube radius and length, respectively). Therefore, the mode that reaches zero frequency and dictates the ST transition is actually the out-of-plane mode. Accordingly, the lowest in-plane mode, which is usually the only mode we can observe in our measurements, will automatically exhibit a "jump" in the resonance frequency even before reaching zero (device VII, Figure 3b and 3d). We shall also note that without twist, a negative jump (as in Figure 1d left) cannot be accounted for. Occasionally, due to the rotational motion near the inflection point (representing the transition from up to down), we are able to detect evidence for the out-of-plane resonance frequency (marked by the arrows in Figure 3a). Examining the CNT shape development (Figure 3e-Figure 3f) reveals how the in-plane and out-of-plane motions are strongly intertwined.
Broadening analysis
Lastly, with the new experimental data at hand and having a model that reproduces the physical motion of the CNT, we address a long-standing question in the field of CNT resonators. The energy dissipation mechanisms of micro and nano resonators are an important characteristic of the device, commonly represented by their quality factor, , a quantity indicating how much energy dissipates in one period of oscillation. Unfortunately, the quality factor of CNT resonators at room temperature () is much lower than anticipated () when considering known dissipation mechanisms20,22,23,32–34.
An important experimental study showed that spectral broadening due to geometrical symmetry breaking can account for the low values at room temperature23. However, theoretical simulations suggest another possible mechanism (“fluctuation broadening”), in which thermal fluctuations should cause strong coupling between the in-plane and out-of-plane modes of motion, resulting from the dynamic built-in strain along the CNT20. This effect has never been proved experimentally due to the problematic estimation of the built-in strain in standard CNT resonators.
To study the dissipation mechanisms of the system, we calculate the quality factor according to , where is the full width at half maximum (FWHM) and is the resonance frequency (example of device IX in Figure 4a). We compare the extracted from the data with a theoretical estimation of based on the fluctuation broadening theory (Figure 4b, see supplementary text for details). In the supplementary text we also examine the broadening due to symmetry breaking23,30, which has been previously shown to explain the low at room temperature. We show that symmetry breaking cannot account by itself for the spectral broadening evidenced in our measurements (supplementary text).

Figure 4. Spectral broadening at room temperature. (a) Resonance frequency measurement of device IX in the third category, where . The yellow lines represent the frequency cross sections from which the data in (b) were extracted. Inset is an example taken at the yellow solid line. Blue dots are the data, orange solid line is a Lorentzian shape fit. (b) Quality factor (left) and spectral broadening (FWHM, right) extracted from (a) vs the static gate load (blue dots). The orange solid line is the theoretical calculation based on Eq. (1). The excellent fit implies that fluctuation broadening is the most significant mechanism to cause the low evidenced at room temperature.
The broadening due to the in-plane and out-of-plane coupling is estimated according to equation S33 in Ref. 20:
where is the out-of-plane component of the CNT movement with thermal fluctuations given by , in which represents the lowest out-of-plane resonance mode.
The peak width is then estimated according to .
As evidenced in Figure 4b, the fluctuation broadening theory yields remarkable compatibility to the experimental data. This is the most significant experimental evidence to date supporting this theory as the primary cause for low in CNT resonators at room temperatures. Moreover, we can show that the other modes' fluctuations contribution to the broadening is negligible and that the lowest out-of-plane mode dominates (see supplementary information). To further examine this theory, we present a similar analysis on device IV at varying temperatures in the supplementary information (Figure S9), also showcasing excellent agreement between the theoretical prediction and the experimental data.

Figure S9. Resonance frequency measurement of device IV in the second category, obtained at . Inset is a frequency cross section obtained at , from which the left-most data mark in was extracted. Black dots are the data, blue solid line is a Lorentzian shape fit. Modelling the dynamic response of the measurement in , from which the left-most theoretical mark in was calculated. The solid lines are the theoretical fitting to the experimental data (black dots). Comparison between the experimental spectral broadening (FWHM) extracted from resonance peaks measured at varying
Conclusions
To conclude, thanks to a high quality fabrication process we were able to identify that there exist several types of carbon nanotube based resonators and that the main differentiating attribute is the shape of the as-fabricated buckled beam. We found that, unlike previous common-knowledge, it is possible to fabricate a CNT based resonator exhibiting Euler-
Bernoulli snap-through bi-stability. The technological implication of the new classification is that while type A CNT resonators (Figure 2a) are the standard, the highest electrical frequency tunability is reached in type C (Figure 2c). In addition, type D devices present a new double-well potential CNT resonator, where in both of the stable states the CNT is fully suspended with no physical contact to any surface. We speculate that this would open the possibility for fabricating integrated mechanical-resonator circuits for advanced computing as well as fast, durable and energy-efficient memory elements. On the theory side, we found that the existence of the snap-through bi-stability is associated with all three degrees of freedom of the CNT. Having a good experiment-model agreement, we also addressed the issue of anomalously low quality factor at room temperature and showed that nonlinear mode coupling accounts well for the spectral broadening in our devices, in agreement with the fluctuation broadening theory.
Methods
Fabrication
The geometric structure of our devices is presented in Figure 1a. As a substrate, we used a silicon wafer with a layer of 500 nm silicon oxide on top. All patterning stages were done by standard photolithography or electron beam lithography procedures. We evaporated Cr/Pt 5nm/35nm for the source and drain (SD) electrodes, after which we etched the using buffer oxide etchant (BOE) to create the local-gate trench (see supplementary text for details). Then, another step of Cr/Pt 5nm/35nm evaporation was performed to create the self-aligned local gate. Finally, we deposited patterned ferritin catalyst near the SD electrodes for the CNT growth. The CNTs were grown by chemical vapor deposition (CVD) under a constant flow of 0.5/0.5 SLPM at C for 20min, utilizing the fast heating growth technique35.
Resonance Frequency Measurements
The resonance frequency measurements were conducted using the mixing technique22, presented schematically in Figure 1a. The actuation of the CNT is done by applying an electrostatic force from the local gate:
where is the capacitance between the CNT and the local-gate electrode, is the local-gate voltage, which is a combination of a DC voltage superimposed with a driving voltage excited at frequency .
For the mixing, we apply a second driving voltage between the SD electrodes, :
where is the driving voltage, and is the offset frequency (in our experiments, few kHz). Utilizing the fact that the CNT serves as a mixer, we can actuate it at and detect its resonance frequencies through the current at the offset frequency :
where is the DC conductance of the CNT and is the time dependent vibrational motion of the CNT.
Data availability
The data that support the findings of this study are available from the corresponding author upon reasonable request.
Acknowledgements. This study was supported by the ISF (Grant No. 1854/19), and the Russell Berrie Nanotechnology Institute. The work made use of the Micro Nano Fabrication Unit at the Technion. S.R. acknowledges support by the Council for Higher Education and the Russel Berrie scholarships.
Author contributions. S.R. and T.T. have equal contribution to this work. S.R., T.T., and Y.E.Y. designed the experiment. S.R. and T.T. took part in device fabrication, performed the experiments and analysis. M.S. developed the fabrication process. S.S. assisted in the theoretical modelling and performed finite element simulations. S.R., T.T., and Y.E.Y. wrote the manuscript, with input from all authors.
Competing interests. The authors declare no competing interests.
Additional Information
Supplementary Information is available for this paper.
Correspondence and requests for materials should be addressed to Yuval E. Yaish.
Mode coupling, bi-stability, and spectral broadening in buckled nanotube resonators
S. Rechnitz; T. Tabachnik; M. Shlafman; S. Shlafman; Y. E. Yaish
Supplementary information
Fabrication and control of buckled CNT resonators
The fabrication process is detailed in the Methods section. The BOE etching is isotropic. Therefore, in addition to creating the trench between the source and drain electrodes, it also creates a small undercut underneath them. Then, another step of evaporation is performed, such that the final SD electrodes consist of a Cr/Pt/Cr/Pt 5nm/35nm/5nm/35nm heterostructure, with suspended edges. At the final stage of the CVD growth, the sample is heated to a temperature of 900°C, and thus the suspended metallic parts of the heterostructure will deform at the edges, due to thermal expansion coefficient mismatch. We believe that this deformation causes the CNT to favor upward buckling during the growth. To support our hypothesis, we examined the BOE etch depth vs the device classification (Figure S1) and the device classification vs SD deformation (Fig. S2). Although the yield is not 100%, both graphs together with Figure S3 demonstrate that we can control the initial buckling relatively well by the BOE etch step of the fabrication.

Figure S1. The effect of the BOE etching depth (depth measured via AFM, reflecting on the etch time) on the classification of the device, for upward buckled CNT resonators. Data taken from all fabricated devices, most of which are not presented in the article.

Figure S3. Initial midpoint elevation extracted from the fitting for the devices presented in Fig. 2, divided by their classification.

Figure S2.
Figure S2 (PDF p. 25). The effect of Source and Drain deformation (measured in AFM, normalized by the device length) on the classification of the device for upward buckled CNT resonators.
Influence of initial buckling
As explained in the main text (Figure 2), the initial configuration of the CNT determines which type of behavior is to be expected. To support this claim, Figure S3 presents the fitted vs classification for the devices in Figure 2. One can clearly observe that as decreases (absolute value increases), the classification changes according to our qualitative explanation in the main text (Figure 2).
Furthermore, to establish that the extracted initial buckling from the fitted data agrees with the real initial CNT displacement, we present a comparison of the theoretical with the SEM images of two devices in the third category (Figure S4). From the SEM image in Figure S4 we extracted initial midpoint elevation of nm, and from the theoretical fitting (Figure S4) we extracted initial midpoint elevation of nm. From the SEM image in Figure S4 we extracted initial midpoint elevation of nm, and from the theoretical fitting (Figure S4) we extracted initial midpoint elevation of nm. We shall point out that the typical buckling heights are less than 5% of the tube length and are hence hard to notice in the SEM images.

Figure S4. SEM images of initially buckled upward CNTs (devices X and V, respectively), retrieved at a and (respectively) angle from the perpendicular to the surface. Resonance frequency measurements of the same devices as in and , respectively, typical of the third category (obtained prior to the SEM measurements). Measurement is the same as Figure 2c. Theoretical fitting (red line) to the data (black dots) extracted from the resonance measurement in , respectively.
Snap-Through Buckling Evidence in Conductance Measurements
The physical configuration of the CNT directly affects the capacitance between the CNT and the local-gate. Therefore, the snap-through (ST) and release transitions should be accompanied by capacitance modification. This change in the capacitance will modulate the charge on the CNT, translating into a change in the CNT conductance. Hence, at the unstable ST point, the abrupt mechanical transition causes a noticeable discontinuity in the conductance measurements, characterized also by hysteresis. Figure S5 presents the transfer characteristics curve of device II. Along with the common small band gap behavior, we observe additional features of discontinuities and hysteresis (marked by the dashed lines), corresponding to the resonance "jumps" in Figure 1d.

Figure S5. Conductance measurement of device II, exhibiting the snap-through and release phenomena. Insets: Zoom-in on areas marked by dashed rectangles.
Theoretical Modelling
To analyze the static response of the system, we begin from the following relations of the force moment, :1
where is the CNT Young's modulus, is the moment of inertia, is the unit vector tangential to the CNT (), is the shear modulus, is the polar moment of inertia, and where is the moment of the forces acting on a cross section of the tube, thus is the twisting component in the tangential direction and is the twist angle along the tube.
Taking the second derivative results in:
Substituting , where the external force (acting in the direction only), assuming (shallow arch) and separating into x,y,z components yields the following set of equations which describe the CNT static motion:
where we substituted , the tension along the tube, in which is the initial axial tension at . are the in-plane and out-of-plane deflections along the beam, respectively, and is the twist angle along the tube.
is the CNT cross-section area, is the horizontal distance between the clamped ends of the suspended CNT, is the CNT radius and is the electrostatic force exerted by the local-gate.
For the dynamic response analysis, we add the acceleration term to the equations to receive the Euler-Bernoulli beam equations. For the torsional vibrations we use the first derivative . Finally, we can describe the dynamic motion of the CNT by the following set of equations:
where is time, is the torsional moment of inertia, is the mass density, and is the tension, given by , as before.
We define the tube's deflection as a superposition of the initial buckling (subscript 0), the static deflection due to the DC voltage (subscript s) and the dynamic oscillation due to the AC actuation (subscript d), as illustrated for the in-plane component in Figure S6:

Figure S6. Schematic illustration for a doubly clamped suspended CNT with in-plane movement, represented by the superposition of the initial buckling (), static deflection () and dynamic deflection ().
Doubly clamped boundary conditions were imposed.
Eqs. (7) and (8) are nonlinear integro-differential equations, and therefore finding an exact analytical solution is difficult. However, by discretizing the system into finite degrees of freedom using a reduced order model (ROM) instead of solving a continuous system, an approximated solution can be found. For this task, we chose the Galerkin method2, in which the beam deflection is approximated as a linear combination of eigenmodes of the linear Euler-Bernoulli equation for a doubly clamped straight beam, noted by :
The discretization is therefore realized by taking a finite number of eigenmodes. Specifically, by comparing with a finite element method solution, we find that only the first two modes suffice:
This process transforms Eqs. (7) and (8) into a set of algebraic equations, which are solved numerically. We solve Eqs. (7) for the initial buckling and static motion () and only then solve Eqs. (8) for the resonance frequencies (i.e., the eigenvalues of the homogeneous system of equations) at the specific static position.
We shall emphasize that the CNT initial configuration is not restricted to be solely in-plane. We allow initial out-of-plane deflection by taking . Nonetheless, our SEM images and theoretical fitting reveal that the out-of-plane initial buckling is much smaller compared to the in-plane buckling (). Hence, the qualitative differentiation between device types based solely on the in-plane in Figure 2 is sufficient. Quantitatively, in order to achieve the good fitting, we must include non-zero out-of-plane deflection, even if it is small. Figure S7 presents a SEM image of the same device as Figure S4, taken perpendicular to the surface (from above), in which the CNT appears nearly straight, meaning that the out-of-plane component of the initial beam shape () is very small compared to the in-plane component () apparent in Figure S4.

Figure S7. Top view SEM image of the same CNT as in Fig. S4a, retrieved perpendicular to the sample surface. The beam appears straight, implying that the out-of-plane component of the initial beam shape () is much smaller than the in-plane curvature () apparent in Fig. S4a.
Calculation of the resonance frequencies and spectral broadening
As explained in the main text, the built-in strain along the nanotube affects its resonance frequencies. Since the resonance frequencies of the out-of-plane modes are always lower than the in-plane modes, we expect that the thermal fluctuations of the out-of-plane modes will affect both the in-plane resonance frequencies, , and their spectral broadening, [3]. Throughout the mode coupling discussion, we shall neglect the coupling to the torsional modes since, as explained in the main text, their resonance frequencies are much higher and therefore their effect on the in-plane modes is negligible.
It is customary to transform equations (7) and (8) to be dimensionless. We normalize the equations according to , , , , , where is the trench depth and , so the out-of-plane motion is represented by the dimensionless parameter . The dimensionless algebraic in-plane equations include coupling between the in-plane and out-of-plane modes in the form of , expressing the built-in strain resulting from the vibrations of the out-of-plane modes.
Barnard et al. show in Ref. 3 that for a buckled beam, the in-plane resonance fluctuations, , are related to the thermal fluctuations of the out-of-plane mode, , according to:
where is the Boltzmann constant, is temperature and is the effective spring constant of the out-of-plane mode.
Our theoretical model allows us to calculate both the out-of-plane resonance frequencies, and the derivative for every static load, according to
Substituting these results into Eq. (9) and using the relation yields the excellent fit for device IX in Figure 4. Another example of a good fit for a second CNT (device I, Figure 1c) is presented in Figure S11.

Figure S11. Peak width (left) and quality factor (right) calculated for device I according to the fluctural broadening theory (Eq. 1, orange line) and according to the symmetry breaking theory (Eq. S14, yellow dots) vs. the experimental data (blue dots).
One should wonder how dominant is the lowest out-of-plane mode compared to higher out-of-plane modes as well as higher in-plane modes[4]. To take into account an additional out-of-plane mode, we simply sum their contributions according to:
It turns out that the contribution of the second mode is negligible (Figure S8). This result is not surprising since the lowest out-of-plane resonance frequency is very close to the lowest in-plane mode, whereas the second out-of-plane and second in-plane resonance frequencies are significantly higher. For example, at , and , and at the inflection point () and .

Figure S8. Fig. S8. *Spectral broadening (FWHM, left) and quality factor (right) extracted from Figure 4a vs the static gate load (blue dots). The orange solid line is the theoretical calculation based on Eq. (1), considering only the 1{sup}st out-of-plane mode. The dashed yellow line is the theoretical calculation, considering only the 2{sup}nd
out-of-plane mode. And the dashed purple line is the theoretical calculation summing the contribution of both the 1{sup}st and 2{sup}nd out-of-plane modes. The excellent fit implies that fluctuation broadening is the most significant dissipation mechanism in the system, and the similarity between the orange and purple lines implies that the coupling to the first mode governs the broadening.
Fluctural broadening calculation at varying temperatures
Since fluctuation broadening is based on the equipartition theorem, the broadening depends on temperature. Hence, to further investigate this theory, we decided to repeat the same measurements and spectral broadening analysis at varying temperatures. At each temperature, we performed a resonance frequency measurement vs gate voltage (example obtained at is presented in Figure S9). From the theoretical fitting to this data (Figure S9), we calculated the strain gate voltage dependence at the different temperatures. Then we used the same methodology for calculating the theoretical broadening due to the first out-of-plane mode using Eq. (1). The experimental spectral broadening was extracted from a general Lorentzian fit to the resonance peak measured at each temperature (Figure S9 inset). The comparison between the broadening extracted directly from the measurement and the broadening estimated according to the theory at the same gate voltage and temperature is presented in Figure S9. The compatibility between experiment and theory is quite remarkable.
temperatures from device IV (orange marks) vs. the theoretical prediction according to Eq. (1) (blue marks).
Nonlinear oscillator equation and symmetry breaking
For this discussion, we shall take only the first in-plane mode and neglect the out-of-plane and torsion coupling terms. In this case, if we add the damping term, , the dynamic beam equation for the in-plane modes is:
where is the dynamic force exerted by the local-gate.
Substituting , , , multiplying the equation by and integrating over the beam length results in:
Rearranging the terms in (11) to the powers of and its derivatives will lead to the following equation:
By defining and the following coefficients:
Eq. Eq. (11) becomes:
By examining carefully the coefficients of Eq. (14), it is noticeable that introducing initial curvature to the beam has double impact, as it shifts the value of the linear spring constant (i.e. ) and at the same time creates quadratic nonlinearity (i.e. ). This explains why the behavior of arch shaped bi-stable systems is dictated by the quadratic nonlinearity, which always results in softening of the natural frequency3.
Experimentally, when the actuation power is small, the nonlinear terms in Eq. (14) are negligible and the linear response of the dynamic problem (Figure 1-Figure 4) is mostly dictated by , as described in the main text. Raising the actuation power and thus increasing the mechanical vibration at a given DC gate voltage, we observe the anticipated softening behavior as well as hysteresis, both before and after the ST transition (Figure S10). This phenomenon is different from previous results which usually observe hardening at low static loads, and softening at higher gate voltages[6, 7].

Figure S10. Duffing-type behavior. (a) Resonance frequency measurement of device I (same as Figure 1c) in the linear regime. (b) and (d) present examples of two out of the five frequency cross sections marked in (a) before (at ) and after (at ) the IP transition, respectively, for a series of increasing excitations, revealing non-linear dynamic response of the system, governed by softening. Dots are the sampled data and lines are the theoretical fit
The solution of Eq. (13) is given by[2, 8]:
where and are the frequency and amplitude of the excitation , respectively, and
is the effective nonlinear coefficient. We can extract from the resonance shift vs. at a constant DC voltage, according to the relation[7]:
where is the driving frequency for which we detect maximum current, corresponding to maximum deflection. The amplitude of the vibration is extracted from the maximum current in the frequency response, according to[6]:
linearly depends on the CNT static midpoint displacement . Therefore, near the ST point, when the deflection is small, the quadratic nonlinearity is negligible and . However, farther from the snap (either before or after), is expected to be dominant, resulting in softening behavior () at both low and high static loads. For example, at V (Figure S10), we receive an effective nonlinear coefficient of , in agreement with the observed softening behavior.
Using the and coefficients retrieved from the data, we calculated the anticipated response of the system and obtained excellent fit of Eq. (14) to the measured Duffing-like behavior (Figure S10 and Figure S10).
This analysis also allows us to estimate the spectral broadening due to symmetry breaking, which has been proposed as an alternative mechanism responsible for the low Q of CNT resonators at room temperature[7]. This geometric symmetry breaking actually refers to the geometric quadratic nonlinearity, . We calculate this effect according to equation (17) of Ref. 6:
For example, substituting and measured at into Eq. (17) results in and , which is 28% smaller than the measured broadening of and yielding nearly four times larger than . A similar result is achieved for all five gate voltages marked in Figure S10 and is plotted in Figure S11, implying that although characterized by substantial geometric nonlinearity, symmetry breaking is not the major broadening mechanism in our devices.
from solving equation (15). (c) Gate voltage cross sections in low and high excitations (marked by the green line in (a)), also displaying softening behavior.
References
- [1]Landau, L. D. & Lifshits, E. M. Theory of Elasticity. Oxford: Pergamon. Print. (1986).
- [2]N Nayfeh, A. H. & Mook, D. T. Nonlinear Oscillations. Weinheim, Germany: Wiley-VCH. Print. (2004).
- [3]Barnard, A. W., Sazonova, V., Van Der Zande, A. M. & McEuen, P. L. Fluctuation broadening in carbon nanotube resonators. Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. U. S. A. 109, 19093–19096 (2012).
- [4]Zhang, Y. & Dykman, M. I. Spectral effects of dispersive mode coupling in driven mesoscopic systems. Phys. Rev. B - Condens. Matter Mater. Phys. 92, 1–16 (2015).DOI
- [5]Younis, M. I., Ouakad, H. M., Alsaleem, F. M., Miles, R. & Cui, W. Nonlinear dynamics of MEMS arches under harmonic electrostatic actuation. J. Microelectromechanical Syst. 19, 647–656 (2010).DOI
- [6]Sazonova, V. et al. A tunable carbon nanotube electrochemical oscillator. Nature 431, 284–287 (2004).pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/15372026
- [7]Eichler, A., Moser, J., Dykman, M. I. & Bachtold, A. Symmetry breaking in a mechanical resonator made from a carbon nanotube. Nat. Commun. 4, 1–7 (2013).DOI
- [8]Dykman, M. I. & Krivoglaz, M. A. Classical theory of nonlinear oscillators interacting with a medium. Phys. Status Solidi 48, 497–512 (1971).DOI