Introduction
At low densities, hadrons as composite particles are useful effective degrees of freedom for describing many-body systems governed by quantum chromodynamics (QCD). As the density increases, however, their quark and gluon substructure becomes increasingly relevant to the interactions among hadrons and eventually to the bulk properties of the system. The change from a hadronic description to one in terms of quarks and gluons need not be sharp, since the same underlying quark and gluon dynamics is responsible both for the internal structure of hadrons and for their interactions [1 ] . At vanishing baryon density, lattice QCD with physical quark masses has established that the finite-temperature transition is an analytic crossover [2 , 3 ] . At low temperatures and high baryon densities, smooth hadron–quark crossover or continuity has also been explored theoretically [4 , 5 ] and phenomenologically in neutron-star matter [6 , 7 , 8 , 9 , 10 ] .
Recently, several approaches have incorporated the composite quark structure of baryons and quark-level Pauli constraints into descriptions of dense baryonic matter [11 , 12 , 13 , 14 , 15 , 16 ] . In a class of such approaches, these constraints are formulated directly in terms of quark occupation probabilities. As density increases, low-momentum quark states eventually reach unit occupation, a phenomenon referred to here as quark saturation [17 , 18 , 19 , 20 , 21 , 22 ] . Beyond quark saturation, a quark Fermi sea begins to develop. Somewhat surprisingly, quark-saturation effects can become important already around 2 2 2 –3 n 0 3n_{0} 3 n 0 , where n 0 = 0.16 f m − 3 n_{0}=0.16\ \mathrm{fm}^{-3} n 0 = 0.16 fm − 3 is the nuclear saturation density. This density is substantially lower than the naive geometric scale at which baryons with radii of order 0.5 f m 0.5\ \mathrm{fm} 0.5 fm would strongly overlap.1 The detailed estimate of the onset of quark saturation, however, is sensitive to the size and internal wave function of the baryons.
In this work, we study electrically neutral d d u ddu dd u baryonic matter in uniform and static magnetic fields with ∣ e B ∣ ∼ Λ Q C D 2 ∼ ( 200 − 300 M e V ) 2 \lvert eB\rvert\sim\Lambda_{\mathrm{QCD}}^2 \sim(200-300\ \mathrm{MeV})^2 ∣ e B ∣ ∼ Λ QCD 2 ∼ ( 200 − 300 MeV ) 2 , corresponding to B ∼ 10 19 G B \sim10^{19}\ \mathrm{G} B ∼ 1 0 19 G , or larger. In this strong-field regime, the spectra and internal structure of baryons are substantially reorganized [26 , 27 , 28 , 29 , 30 , 31 , 32 , 33 , 34 ] . For comparison, the surface dipole fields of magnetars are typically of order 10 14 10^{14} 1 0 14 –10 15 G 10^{15}\ \mathrm{G} 1 0 15 G [35 , 36 , 37 ] , while global equilibrium considerations suggest an upper bound on the average internal magnetic field of order 10 18 G 10^{18}\ \mathrm{G} 1 0 18 G [38 , 39 ] (although local fields may be substantially stronger than the large-scale field [40 ] ). Microscopically, possible spontaneous magnetization in quark matter has also been discussed, with the field strength reaching up to ∼ 10 16 G \sim10^{16}\ \mathrm{G} ∼ 1 0 16 G in some model studies [41 , 42 , 43 ] . Thus, even allowing for such exotic mechanisms, the field strengths considered here are substantially larger than conventional estimates for magnetars, and hence the direct phenomenological applications of our results may be limited. We believe, however, that this study is valuable because our setup poses conceptually interesting questions about the interplay between hadronic structure and quark saturation, and also provides a useful setting for exploring how dense matter evolves toward the strong-field regime, which may in turn offer qualitative insight into the behavior at more realistic field strengths.
We use a simple non-relativistic constituent-quark model [44 , 45 ] to describe individual baryons and construct an ideal baryon gas in magnetic fields. The applicability of this non-relativistic framework to low-lying states in strong magnetic fields, as well as the approximation of a B B B -independent constituent-quark mass [46 ] , was discussed in detail in Ref. [47 ] . Fields of ∣ e B ∣ ∼ Λ Q C D 2 \lvert eB\rvert\sim\Lambda_{\mathrm{QCD}}^2 ∣ e B ∣ ∼ Λ QCD 2 substantially modify the baryon energy spectra, including their dependence on the baryon pseudomomentum, as well as the spin-flavor structure and spatial quark wave functions [26 ] . The resulting baryonic Fermi sea becomes highly anisotropic.
The onset of quark saturation is estimated through the following simple sum rule. At B = 0 B=0 B = 0 , the quark occupation probability in baryonic matter is schematically obtained by convoluting the baryon distribution f b f_b f b with the quark distribution ϕ q / b \phi_{q/b} ϕ q / b inside a baryon (b = n ↑ , n ↓ , Δ 0 , ⋯ b=n_{\uparrow},n_{\downarrow},\Delta^0,\cdots b = n ↑ , n ↓ , Δ 0 , ⋯ and q = u ↑ , u ↓ , d ↑ , ⋯ q=u_{\uparrow},u_{\downarrow},d_{\uparrow},\cdots q = u ↑ , u ↓ , d ↑ , ⋯ )
f q ( p ) = ∑ b N q b ∫ K f b ( K ) ϕ q / b ( p ; K ) . (1) f_q(p)=\sum_b N_q^b\int_K f_b(K)\phi_{q/b}(p;K). \tag*{(1)} f q ( p ) = b ∑ N q b ∫ K f b ( K ) ϕ q / b ( p ; K ) . (1)
Here N q b N_q^b N q b specifies the quark spin-flavor content in a given baryon b b b . The baryon distribution f b f_b f b should in general be determined from the many-body dynamics of baryons. In this work, we generalize this relation to finite B B B . We first formulate the internal quark distribution using the one-body reduced density matrix constructed from the single baryon wave function, and then construct the corresponding quark occupation probabilities in the Landau-level basis. For simplicity, we restrict ourselves to an ideal baryon gas. Within this framework, one can determine the density at which quark saturation occurs and the purely baryonic description reaches its limit of applicability.
This paper is structured as follows. In § 2 we discuss the properties of single baryons within a non-relativistic constituent quark model. In § 3 we construct a density matrix from a baryon wave function and derive one-body reduced density matrix for a quark. We then derive a quark distribution function for a given baryon. In § 4 we compute the quark distribution in dense baryonic matter and estimate the density at which quark saturation occurs. § 5 is devoted to summary.
Neutral baryons in magnetic fields
We first clarify the relation between particle labels and flavor labels. Since the color wave function of a color-singlet baryon is totally antisymmetric, the remaining space-spin-flavor wave function is totally symmetric. For the d d u ddu dd u sector, we introduce a reference component,
∣ Ψ r e f d d u ⟩ = ∑ s 1 , s 2 , s 3 ∑ r 1 , r 2 , r 3 ∫ ψ r e f d d u ( r 1 , r 2 , r 3 ) ∣ d , ξ 1 ; d , ξ 2 ; u , ξ 3 ⟩ , ξ j = ( r j , s j z ) (2) \left|\Psi_{\mathrm{ref}}^{ddu}\right\rangle= \sum_{s_1,s_2,s_3}\sum_{r_1,r_2,r_3} \int\psi_{\mathrm{ref}}^{ddu}(r_1,r_2,r_3) |d,\xi_1;d,\xi_2;u,\xi_3\rangle,\qquad\xi_j=(r_j,s_j^z) \tag*{(2)} Ψ ref dd u ⟩ = s 1 , s 2 , s 3 ∑ r 1 , r 2 , r 3 ∑ ∫ ψ ref dd u ( r 1 , r 2 , r 3 ) ∣ d , ξ 1 ; d , ξ 2 ; u , ξ 3 ⟩ , ξ j = ( r j , s j z ) (2)
and construct the physical state as
∣ Ψ d d u ⟩ = N S 3 ∣ Ψ r e f d d u ⟩ , S 3 = 1 3 ! ∑ P ∈ S 3 P . (3) \left|\Psi^{ddu}\right\rangle= \mathcal{N}S_3\left|\Psi_{\mathrm{ref}}^{ddu}\right\rangle,\qquad S_3=\frac{1}{3!}\sum_{P\in S_3}P. \tag*{(3)} Ψ dd u ⟩ = N S 3 Ψ ref dd u ⟩ , S 3 = 3 ! 1 P ∈ S 3 ∑ P . (3)
where N \mathcal{N} N is the normalization constant and P \mathcal{P} P is the permutation operator. Thus, the assignment ( d 1 , d 2 , u 3 ) (d_1,d_2,u_3) ( d 1 , d 2 , u 3 ) refers only to the reference component; in the fully symmetrized state, flavor is not tied to a fixed particle slot. Accordingly, the Hamiltonian should be regarded as an operator acting also in flavor space. We introduce the flavor projectors
P f ( j ) = ∣ f ⟩ j j ⟨ f ∣ , f = u , d , (4) \mathcal{P}_f^{(j)}=|f\rangle_j{}_j\langle f|,\qquad f=u,d, \tag*{(4)} P f ( j ) = ∣ f ⟩ j j ⟨ f ∣ , f = u , d , (4)
and write the one-body Hamiltonian associated with particle slot j j j as
h ^ j = ∑ f = u , d P f ( j ) h f ( j ) , (5) \hat{h}_j=\sum_{f=u,d}\mathcal{P}_f^{(j)}h_f(j), \tag*{(5)} h ^ j = f = u , d ∑ P f ( j ) h f ( j ) , (5)
where [ Π f ( j ) ≡ p j − e f A ( r j ) ] [\boldsymbol{\Pi}_f(j)\equiv\mathbf{p}_j-e_f\mathbf{A}(r_j)] [ Π f ( j ) ≡ p j − e f A ( r j )]
h f ( j ) = m f + Π f 2 ( j ) 2 m f − e f 2 m f σ j ⋅ B , (6) h_f(j)=m_f+\frac{\boldsymbol{\Pi}_f^2(j)}{2m_f}-\frac{e_f}{2m_f}\boldsymbol{\sigma}_j\cdot\mathbf{B}, \tag*{(6)} h f ( j ) = m f + 2 m f Π f 2 ( j ) − 2 m f e f σ j ⋅ B , (6)
where we set g = 2 g=2 g = 2 for the constituent-quark magnetic moment, as in the standard non-relativistic constituent-quark model [44 , 45 ] . The corresponding neutron magnetic moment will be used below to fix the constituent-quark mass. For instance, acting on the flavor state ∣ d d u ⟩ |ddu\rangle ∣ dd u ⟩ , we obtain
h ^ 1 ∣ d d u ⟩ = h d ( 1 ) ∣ d d u ⟩ , h ^ 2 ∣ d d u ⟩ = h d ( 2 ) ∣ d d u ⟩ , h ^ 3 ∣ d d u ⟩ = h u ( 3 ) ∣ d d u ⟩ . (7) \hat{h}_1|ddu\rangle=h_d(1)|ddu\rangle,\qquad\hat{h}_2|ddu\rangle=h_d(2)|ddu\rangle,\qquad\hat{h}_3|ddu\rangle=h_u(3)|ddu\rangle. \tag*{(7)} h ^ 1 ∣ dd u ⟩ = h d ( 1 ) ∣ dd u ⟩ , h ^ 2 ∣ dd u ⟩ = h d ( 2 ) ∣ dd u ⟩ , h ^ 3 ∣ dd u ⟩ = h u ( 3 ) ∣ dd u ⟩ . (7)
Since the full one-body Hamiltonian ∑ j = 1 3 h ^ j \sum_{j=1}^{3}\hat{h}_j ∑ j = 1 3 h ^ j is symmetric under permutations of the particle slots j = 1 , 2 , 3 j=1,2,3 j = 1 , 2 , 3 , the eigenvalue equations for ∣ d d u ⟩ |ddu\rangle ∣ dd u ⟩ , ∣ d u d ⟩ |dud\rangle ∣ d u d ⟩ , and ∣ u d d ⟩ |udd\rangle ∣ u dd ⟩ are related simply by relabeling the particle indices j j j . Hence, the eigenvalues are unchanged under such permutations. For the wave functions, once the wave function is obtained for a specific flavor ordering, those for the other orderings follow by the corresponding permutations of the particle indices j j j .
The full Hamiltonian is then written as
H ^ = ∑ j = 1 3 h ^ j + V c o n f + V s h o r t . (8) \hat{H}=\sum_{j=1}^{3}\hat{h}_j+V_{\mathrm{conf}}+V_{\mathrm{short}}. \tag*{(8)} H ^ = j = 1 ∑ 3 h ^ j + V conf + V short . (8)
For the confining potential, we consider the sum of the harmonic oscillators
V c o n f = α ∑ i > j r i j 2 + C 0 , α ∼ Λ Q C D 3 . (9) V_{\mathrm{conf}}=\alpha\sum_{i>j}r_{ij}^{2}+C_0,\qquad\alpha\sim\Lambda_{\mathrm{QCD}}^{3}. \tag*{(9)} V conf = α i > j ∑ r ij 2 + C 0 , α ∼ Λ QCD 3 . (9)
The constant C 0 C_0 C 0 represents a B B B -independent contribution to the baryon energy and does not affect the wave functions. We treat the confining potential at leading order, while the short-range potential
V s h o r t = ∑ i > j ( v i j E + v i j M σ i ⋅ σ j ) (10) V_{\mathrm{short}}=\sum_{i>j}\left(v_{ij}^{E}+v_{ij}^{M}\boldsymbol{\sigma}_{i}\cdot\boldsymbol{\sigma}_{j}\right) \tag*{(10)} V short = i > j ∑ ( v ij E + v ij M σ i ⋅ σ j ) (10)
is regarded as a perturbation. The explicit forms of the color-electric and magnetic interactions are given in § 2.2 .
The interaction terms considered below are also symmetric under permutations of particle slots j = 1 , 2 , 3 j=1,2,3 j = 1 , 2 , 3 . The full Hamiltonian therefore satisfies
P H ^ P − 1 = H ^ , P ∈ S 3 . (11) P\hat{H}P^{-1}=\hat{H},\qquad P\in S_{3}. \tag*{(11)} P H ^ P − 1 = H ^ , P ∈ S 3 . (11)
For practical calculations, we may work with the reference d 1 d 2 u 3 d_{1}d_{2}u_{3} d 1 d 2 u 3 component. Acting on this component, the flavor projectors simply select
h ^ 1 + h ^ 2 + h ^ 3 ⟶ h d ( 1 ) + h d ( 2 ) + h u ( 3 ) . (12) \hat{h}_{1}+\hat{h}_{2}+\hat{h}_{3}\longrightarrow h_{d}(1)+h_{d}(2)+h_{u}(3). \tag*{(12)} h ^ 1 + h ^ 2 + h ^ 3 ⟶ h d ( 1 ) + h d ( 2 ) + h u ( 3 ) . (12)
Therefore, within the reference component we may use
e 1 = e 2 = e d , e 3 = e u , m 1 = m 2 = m d , m 3 = m u , (13) e_{1}=e_{2}=e_{d},\qquad e_{3}=e_{u},\qquad m_{1}=m_{2}=m_{d},\qquad m_{3}=m_{u}, \tag*{(13)} e 1 = e 2 = e d , e 3 = e u , m 1 = m 2 = m d , m 3 = m u , (13)
while the full physical state is obtained by symmetrization.
Pseudomomentum
In a uniform magnetic field, the ordinary canonical momentum is not the most convenient quantity for characterizing translational motion. To separate the collective motion from the internal dynamics, it is useful to introduce the pseudomomentum [48 , 49 , 50 ]
K j = Π j + e j B × r j . (14) \mathcal{K}_{j}=\boldsymbol{\Pi}_{j}+e_{j}\mathbf{B}\times\mathbf{r}_{j}. \tag*{(14)} K j = Π j + e j B × r j . (14)
The commutation rules among Π \boldsymbol{\Pi} Π and K \mathcal{K} K are
[ Π i x , Π j y ] = i e i δ i j B z = − [ K i x , K j y ] , (15) [\Pi_{i}^{x},\Pi_{j}^{y}]=\mathrm{i}e_{i}\delta_{ij}B^{z}=-[\mathcal{K}_{i}^{x},\mathcal{K}_{j}^{y}], \tag*{(15)} [ Π i x , Π j y ] = i e i δ ij B z = − [ K i x , K j y ] , (15)
and all the other commutators are zero; in particular, [ Π i , K j ] = 0 [\boldsymbol{\Pi}_{i},\mathcal{K}_{j}]=0 [ Π i , K j ] = 0 .
For a translationally invariant Hamiltonian, the total pseudomomentum K R ≡ ∑ j K j \mathcal{K}_{R}\equiv\sum_{j}\mathcal{K}_{j} K R ≡ ∑ j K j commutes with the Hamiltonian, [ K R , H ] = 0 [\mathcal{K}_{R},H]=0 [ K R , H ] = 0 . Meanwhile, in general the x , y x,y x , y components of K R \mathcal{K}_{R} K R do not commute with each other,
[ K R x , K R y ] = − i B ∑ j e j = − i e R B , e R ≡ ∑ i e i . (16) [\mathcal{K}_{R}^{x},\mathcal{K}_{R}^{y}]=-\mathrm{i}B\sum_{j}e_{j}=-\mathrm{i}e_{R}B,\qquad e_{R}\equiv\sum_{i}e_{i}. \tag*{(16)} [ K R x , K R y ] = − i B j ∑ e j = − i e R B , e R ≡ i ∑ e i . (16)
However, for charge neutral states as we discuss in this paper, this commutation relation vanishes. Hence, the eigenstates of the Hamiltonian can be labelled by ( E , K R ) (E,\mathcal{K}_{R}) ( E , K R ) .
For a three-particle system, we choose Jacobi coordinates
R = ∑ j m j r j M , ρ = r 2 − r 1 , λ = r 3 − m 1 r 1 + m 2 r 2 m 12 , (17) R=\frac{\sum_{j}m_{j}r_{j}}{M},\qquad\rho=r_{2}-r_{1},\qquad\lambda=r_{3}-\frac{m_{1}r_{1}+m_{2}r_{2}}{m_{12}}, \tag*{(17)} R = M ∑ j m j r j , ρ = r 2 − r 1 , λ = r 3 − m 12 m 1 r 1 + m 2 r 2 , (17)
where m 12 = m 1 + m 2 m_{12}=m_{1}+m_{2} m 12 = m 1 + m 2 and M = m 1 + m 2 + m 3 M=m_{1}+m_{2}+m_{3} M = m 1 + m 2 + m 3 . Then we note
∑ j e j r j = R ∑ j e j + e 2 m 1 − e 1 m 2 m 12 ρ + e 3 m 12 − ( e 1 + e 2 ) m 3 M λ ≡ e R R + e ρ ρ + e λ λ . (18) \sum_{j}e_{j}r_{j}=R\sum_{j}e_{j}+\frac{e_{2}m_{1}-e_{1}m_{2}}{m_{12}}\rho+\frac{e_{3}m_{12}-(e_{1}+e_{2})m_{3}}{M}\lambda\equiv e_{R}R+e_{\rho}\rho+e_{\lambda}\lambda. \tag*{(18)} j ∑ e j r j = R j ∑ e j + m 12 e 2 m 1 − e 1 m 2 ρ + M e 3 m 12 − ( e 1 + e 2 ) m 3 λ ≡ e R R + e ρ ρ + e λ λ . (18)
For neutrons and Δ 0 \Delta_0 Δ 0 , taking the particle slots to be ordered as d d u ddu dd u , we set q ≡ e / 3 q \equiv e/3 q ≡ e /3 , e d = − q e_d=-q e d = − q , and e u = 2 q e_u=2q e u = 2 q , and m 1 = m 2 = m 3 = m m_1=m_2=m_3=m m 1 = m 2 = m 3 = m , for which e R = 0 = e ρ e_R=0=e_\rho e R = 0 = e ρ and e λ = 2 e / 3 = 2 q e_\lambda=2e/3=2q e λ = 2 e /3 = 2 q .
Now, choosing the symmetric gauge, A = B × r / 2 A=\mathbf{B}\times\mathbf{r}/2 A = B × r /2 , one can write (B q ≡ q B B_q\equiv qB B q ≡ q B )
K R = P R + ∑ j e j B × r j 2 = P R + e λ B × λ 2 = P R + B q × λ . (19) \mathcal{K}_R=\mathbf{P}_R+\sum_j\frac{e_j\mathbf{B}\times\mathbf{r}_j}{2}=\mathbf{P}_R+\frac{e_\lambda\mathbf{B}\times\boldsymbol{\lambda}}{2}=\mathbf{P}_R+\mathbf{B}_q\times\boldsymbol{\lambda}. \tag*{(19)} K R = P R + j ∑ 2 e j B × r j = P R + 2 e λ B × λ = P R + B q × λ . (19)
We consider the eigenfunction of the eigenvalue problem K R Φ K = K Φ K \mathcal{K}_R\Phi_K=K\Phi_K K R Φ K = K Φ K whose solution takes the form
Φ K ( R , ρ , λ ) = e i Θ ( R , λ ) ϕ K ( ρ , λ ) , Θ ( R , λ ) = R ⋅ ( K − B q × λ ) . (20) \Phi_K(R,\rho,\lambda)=e^{i\Theta(R,\lambda)}\phi_K(\rho,\lambda),\qquad\Theta(R,\lambda)=R\cdot\left(K-\mathbf{B}_q\times\lambda\right). \tag*{(20)} Φ K ( R , ρ , λ ) = e i Θ ( R , λ ) ϕ K ( ρ , λ ) , Θ ( R , λ ) = R ⋅ ( K − B q × λ ) . (20)
The unitary transformation of the Hamiltonian, H → H ′ = e − i Θ H e i Θ H\to H'=e^{-i\Theta}He^{i\Theta} H → H ′ = e − i Θ H e i Θ , factorizes the center-of-mass coordinate, leaving the pseudomomentum K \mathbf{K} K as a parameter in the internal Hamiltonian. The resulting Hamiltonian takes the form H ′ = H 0 ′ + V s h o r t H'=H'_0+V_{\mathrm{short}} H ′ = H 0 ′ + V short , where
H 0 ′ = M + K 2 2 M + H 0 z + H 0 ⊥ + H Z e e m a n . (21) H'_0=M+\frac{K^2}{2M}+H_0^z+H_0^\perp+H_{\mathrm{Zeeman}}. \tag*{(21)} H 0 ′ = M + 2 M K 2 + H 0 z + H 0 ⊥ + H Zeeman . (21)
Here the orbital terms in the z z z -direction are
H 0 z = ( p ρ z ) 2 m + 3 α 2 ρ z 2 + 3 ( p λ z ) 2 4 m + 2 α λ z 2 . (22) H_0^z=\frac{(p_\rho^z)^2}{m}+\frac{3\alpha}{2}\rho_z^2+\frac{3(p_\lambda^z)^2}{4m}+2\alpha\lambda_z^2. \tag*{(22)} H 0 z = m ( p ρ z ) 2 + 2 3 α ρ z 2 + 4 m 3 ( p λ z ) 2 + 2 α λ z 2 . (22)
The orbital terms in the transverse direction are
H 0 ρ ⊥ = ( p ρ ⊥ ) 2 m + ( B q 2 16 m + 3 α 2 ) ρ ⊥ 2 + 1 2 m B q ⋅ L ρ . (23) H_{0\rho}^\perp=\frac{(p_\rho^\perp)^2}{m}+\left(\frac{B_q^2}{16m}+\frac{3\alpha}{2}\right)\rho_\perp^2+\frac{1}{2m}\mathbf{B}_q\cdot\mathbf{L}_\rho. \tag*{(23)} H 0 ρ ⊥ = m ( p ρ ⊥ ) 2 + ( 16 m B q 2 + 2 3 α ) ρ ⊥ 2 + 2 m 1 B q ⋅ L ρ . (23)
for ρ \rho ρ modes, and, for λ \lambda λ modes,
H 0 λ ⊥ = 3 ( p λ ⊥ − p ρ ⊥ ) 2 4 m + ( 3 B q 2 4 m + 2 α ) ( λ ⊥ − λ ⊥ 0 ) 2 − B q ⋅ L ~ λ 2 m − B q 2 K ⊥ 2 6 m ( B q 2 + 3 m α ) . (24) H_{0\lambda}^\perp=\frac{3(p_\lambda^\perp-p_\rho^\perp)^2}{4m}+\left(\frac{3B_q^2}{4m}+2\alpha\right)(\lambda_\perp-\lambda_\perp^0)^2-\frac{\mathbf{B}_q\cdot\widetilde{\mathbf{L}}_\lambda}{2m}-\frac{B_q^2K_\perp^2}{6m(B_q^2+3m\alpha)}. \tag*{(24)} H 0 λ ⊥ = 4 m 3 ( p λ ⊥ − p ρ ⊥ ) 2 + ( 4 m 3 B q 2 + 2 α ) ( λ ⊥ − λ ⊥ 0 ) 2 − 2 m B q ⋅ L λ − 6 m ( B q 2 + 3 m α ) B q 2 K ⊥ 2 . (24)
where L ~ λ = ( λ ⊥ − λ ⊥ 0 ) × ( p λ ⊥ − p ρ ⊥ ) \widetilde{\mathbf{L}}_\lambda=(\lambda_\perp-\lambda_\perp^0)\times(p_\lambda^\perp-p_\rho^\perp) L λ = ( λ ⊥ − λ ⊥ 0 ) × ( p λ ⊥ − p ρ ⊥ ) and p ρ 0 p_\rho^0 p ρ 0 and λ ⊥ 0 \lambda_\perp^0 λ ⊥ 0 and the constant shifts are
λ ⊥ 0 = K ⊥ × B q 2 ( B q 2 + 3 m α ) , p ρ 0 = B q × λ ⊥ 0 3 = B q 2 6 ( B q 2 + 3 m α ) K ⊥ . (25) \lambda_\perp^0=\frac{\mathbf{K}_\perp\times\mathbf{B}_q}{2(B_q^2+3m\alpha)},\qquad\mathbf{p}_\rho^0=\frac{\mathbf{B}_q\times\lambda_\perp^0}{3}=\frac{B_q^2}{6(B_q^2+3m\alpha)}\mathbf{K}_\perp. \tag*{(25)} λ ⊥ 0 = 2 ( B q 2 + 3 m α ) K ⊥ × B q , p ρ 0 = 3 B q × λ ⊥ 0 = 6 ( B q 2 + 3 m α ) B q 2 K ⊥ . (25)
These shifts generate a quadratic term proportional to K ⊥ 2 K_\perp^2 K ⊥ 2 in Eq. (24) , which partially cancels K ⊥ 2 / 2 M K_\perp^2/2M K ⊥ 2 /2 M . The Zeeman terms are
H Z e e m a n = − B q 2 m ⋅ [ 2 σ 3 − ( σ 1 + σ 2 ) ] . (26) H_{\mathrm{Zeeman}}=-\frac{B_q}{2m}\cdot[2\sigma_3-(\sigma_1+\sigma_2)]. \tag*{(26)} H Zeeman = − 2 m B q ⋅ [ 2 σ 3 − ( σ 1 + σ 2 )] . (26)
Below we use the notations
B ρ 2 ≡ B q 2 + 24 m α , B λ 2 ≡ B q 2 + 8 m α / 3. (27) B_\rho^2\equiv B_q^2+24m\alpha,\qquad B_\lambda^2\equiv B_q^2+8m\alpha/3. \tag*{(27)} B ρ 2 ≡ B q 2 + 24 m α , B λ 2 ≡ B q 2 + 8 m α /3. (27)
We define B ρ B_\rho B ρ and B λ B_\lambda B λ to be positive, B ρ ≡ ∣ B ρ ∣ B_\rho\equiv|B_\rho| B ρ ≡ ∣ B ρ ∣ and B λ ≡ ∣ B λ ∣ B_\lambda\equiv|B_\lambda| B λ ≡ ∣ B λ ∣ .
Baryon dispersion relations
Diagonalizing the unperturbed Hamiltonian H 0 H_0 H 0 and evaluating the short-range interaction to first order in perturbation theory, the Hamiltonian in a given orbital state takes the form
E n , { s } ( K ) = M + K z 2 2 M + 2 α K ⊥ 2 4 ( B q 2 + 3 m α ) + 6 α m ( n ρ z + n λ z + 1 ) + B ρ 2 m ( 2 n ρ ⊥ + ∣ L ρ z ∣ + B q B ρ L ρ z + 1 ) + B λ 2 m ( 6 n λ ⊥ + 3 ∣ L λ z ∣ − B q B λ L λ z + 3 ) + H Z e e m a n + ∑ i > j ( ⟨ v i j E ⟩ n K + ⟨ v i j M ⟩ n K σ i ⋅ σ j ) , (28) \begin{aligned}
E_{n,\{s\}}(\mathbf{K})={}&M+\frac{K_z^2}{2M}+\frac{2\alpha K_\perp^2}{4(B_q^2+3m\alpha)}+\sqrt{\frac{6\alpha}{m}}\left(n_\rho^z+n_\lambda^z+1\right)\\
&+\frac{B_\rho}{2m}\left(2n_\rho^\perp+\lvert L_\rho^z\rvert+\frac{B_q}{B_\rho}L_\rho^z+1\right)+\frac{B_\lambda}{2m}\left(6n_\lambda^\perp+3\lvert L_\lambda^z\rvert-\frac{B_q}{B_\lambda}L_\lambda^z+3\right)\\
&+H_{\mathrm{Zeeman}}+\sum_{i>j}\left(\langle v_{ij}^{E}\rangle_n^{K}+\langle v_{ij}^{M}\rangle_n^{K}\boldsymbol{\sigma}_i\cdot\boldsymbol{\sigma}_j\right), \tag*{(28)}
\end{aligned} E n , { s } ( K ) = M + 2 M K z 2 + 4 ( B q 2 + 3 m α ) 2 α K ⊥ 2 + m 6 α ( n ρ z + n λ z + 1 ) + 2 m B ρ ( 2 n ρ ⊥ + ∣ L ρ z ∣ + B ρ B q L ρ z + 1 ) + 2 m B λ ( 6 n λ ⊥ + 3 ∣ L λ z ∣ − B λ B q L λ z + 3 ) + H Zeeman + i > j ∑ ( ⟨ v ij E ⟩ n K + ⟨ v ij M ⟩ n K σ i ⋅ σ j ) , (28)
where n i z n_i^z n i z and n i ⊥ n_i^\perp n i ⊥ (i = ρ , λ i=\rho,\lambda i = ρ , λ ) are radial excitations while L i z L_i^z L i z are azimuthal angular-momentum around the z z z -axis. Below we focus on the states with minimal orbital excitations and set these quantum numbers to zero,
E 0 , { s } ( K ) = E 0 ( K ) + H Z e e m a n + ∑ i > j ⟨ v i j M ⟩ 0 K σ i ⋅ σ j (29) E_{0,\{s\}}(\mathbf{K})=E_0(\mathbf{K})+H_{\mathrm{Zeeman}}+\sum_{i>j}\langle v_{ij}^{M}\rangle_0^{K}\boldsymbol{\sigma}_i\cdot\boldsymbol{\sigma}_j \tag*{(29)} E 0 , { s } ( K ) = E 0 ( K ) + H Zeeman + i > j ∑ ⟨ v ij M ⟩ 0 K σ i ⋅ σ j (29)
where the spin-independent part is
E 0 ( K ) = M + K z 2 2 M + 2 α K ⊥ 2 4 ( B q 2 + 3 m α ) + 6 α m + B ρ + 3 B λ 2 m + ∑ i > j ⟨ v i j E ⟩ 0 K . (30) E_0(\mathbf{K})=M+\frac{K_z^2}{2M}+\frac{2\alpha K_\perp^2}{4(B_q^2+3m\alpha)}+\sqrt{\frac{6\alpha}{m}}+\frac{B_\rho+3B_\lambda}{2m}+\sum_{i>j}\langle v_{ij}^{E}\rangle_0^{K}. \tag*{(30)} E 0 ( K ) = M + 2 M K z 2 + 4 ( B q 2 + 3 m α ) 2 α K ⊥ 2 + m 6 α + 2 m B ρ + 3 B λ + i > j ∑ ⟨ v ij E ⟩ 0 K . (30)
We note that the K ⊥ K_\perp K ⊥ dependence arises from the potential terms: the confining potential generates the explicit quadratic term, while the short-range matrix elements also depend on K ⊥ K_\perp K ⊥ through the shifted internal wave function.
For later use, we give the explicit lowest-orbital wave function. With the phase Θ \Theta Θ defined in Eq. (20) , it is
Φ K ( R , ρ , λ ) = N B e i Θ ( R , λ ) e i p ⊥ 0 ⋅ λ ⊥ × exp [ − ( λ ⊥ − λ ⊥ 0 ) 2 2 β λ ⊥ − ρ ⊥ 2 2 β ρ ⊥ − λ z 2 2 β λ z − ρ z 2 2 β ρ z ] , (31) \Phi_{\mathbf{K}}(\mathbf{R},\boldsymbol{\rho},\boldsymbol{\lambda})=N_B e^{i\Theta(\mathbf{R},\boldsymbol{\lambda})}e^{i\mathbf{p}_\perp^0\cdot\boldsymbol{\lambda}_\perp}\times\exp\left[-\frac{(\boldsymbol{\lambda}_\perp-\boldsymbol{\lambda}_\perp^0)^2}{2\beta_\lambda^\perp}-\frac{\rho_\perp^2}{2\beta_\rho^\perp}-\frac{\lambda_z^2}{2\beta_\lambda^z}-\frac{\rho_z^2}{2\beta_\rho^z}\right], \tag*{(31)} Φ K ( R , ρ , λ ) = N B e i Θ ( R , λ ) e i p ⊥ 0 ⋅ λ ⊥ × exp [ − 2 β λ ⊥ ( λ ⊥ − λ ⊥ 0 ) 2 − 2 β ρ ⊥ ρ ⊥ 2 − 2 β λ z λ z 2 − 2 β ρ z ρ z 2 ] , (31)
where
β λ ⊥ = 1 B λ , β ρ ⊥ = 4 B ρ , β λ z = 3 8 m α , β ρ z = 2 3 m α , (32) \beta_\lambda^\perp=\frac{1}{B_\lambda},\qquad\beta_\rho^\perp=\frac{4}{B_\rho},\qquad\beta_\lambda^z=\sqrt{\frac{3}{8m\alpha}},\qquad\beta_\rho^z=\sqrt{\frac{2}{3m\alpha}}, \tag*{(32)} β λ ⊥ = B λ 1 , β ρ ⊥ = B ρ 4 , β λ z = 8 m α 3 , β ρ z = 3 m α 2 , (32)
and N B N_B N B is the normalization constant.
Short-range interactions
To evaluate the matrix elements, it is useful to introduce
β d d ⊥ = β ρ ⊥ , β d d z = β ρ z , (33) \beta_{dd}^\perp=\beta_\rho^\perp,\qquad\beta_{dd}^z=\beta_\rho^z, \tag*{(33)} β dd ⊥ = β ρ ⊥ , β dd z = β ρ z , (33)
and
β u d ⊥ = β λ ⊥ + 1 4 β ρ ⊥ , β u d z = β λ z + 1 4 β ρ z . (34) \beta_{ud}^\perp=\beta_\lambda^\perp+\frac{1}{4}\beta_\rho^\perp,\qquad\beta_{ud}^z=\beta_\lambda^z+\frac{1}{4}\beta_\rho^z. \tag*{(34)} β u d ⊥ = β λ ⊥ + 4 1 β ρ ⊥ , β u d z = β λ z + 4 1 β ρ z . (34)
We characterize the typical scale of the short-distance interaction by
Q i j 2 ≡ Q 0 2 + ( β i j z ) − 1 + ( β i j ⊥ ) − 1 , Q 0 2 ≡ 2 m 2 (35) Q_{ij}^2\equiv Q_0^2+(\beta_{ij}^z)^{-1}+(\beta_{ij}^\perp)^{-1},\qquad Q_0^2\equiv2m^2 \tag*{(35)} Q ij 2 ≡ Q 0 2 + ( β ij z ) − 1 + ( β ij ⊥ ) − 1 , Q 0 2 ≡ 2 m 2 (35)
which reflects the typical inverse size of the corresponding quark pair. For the running coupling, we use
α s ( Q ) = 4 π β 0 ln ( Q 2 / Λ N P 2 ) , β 0 = 11 − 2 N f 3 . (36) \alpha_s(Q)=\frac{4\pi}{\beta_0\ln(Q^2/\Lambda_{\mathrm{NP}}^2)},\qquad\beta_0=11-\frac{2N_f}{3}. \tag*{(36)} α s ( Q ) = β 0 ln ( Q 2 / Λ NP 2 ) 4 π , β 0 = 11 − 3 2 N f . (36)
We take N f = 3 N_f=3 N f = 3 and Λ N P = 0.25 \Lambda_{\mathrm{NP}}=0.25 Λ NP = 0.25 GeV. The renormalization scale Q i j Q_{ij} Q ij is chosen to reflect the typical inverse size of the corresponding quark pair ( i j ) (ij) ( ij ) .
For the short-range interactions, we use the color-electric and color-magnetic potentials inspired by one-gluon exchange [44 , 45 ] . The color-electric potential is
v i j E ( r ) = − 2 3 α s ( Q i j ) r . (37) v_{ij}^{E}(r)=-\frac{2}{3}\frac{\alpha_s(Q_{ij})}{r}. \tag*{(37)} v ij E ( r ) = − 3 2 r α s ( Q ij ) . (37)
The additional factor 1 / 2 1/2 1/2 relative to the corresponding q q ˉ q\bar q q q ˉ interaction reflects the color factor for a quark pair in the 3 ˉ \bar{3} 3 ˉ channel. For the color-magnetic interaction, we upgrade the standard non-relativistic form of the vertex as α s / m i m j ⟶ α s / E i E j \alpha_s/m_i m_j \longrightarrow\alpha_s/E_i E_j α s / m i m j ⟶ α s / E i E j , with m i = m j = m m_i=m_j=m m i = m j = m and p i = p j = q / 2 p_i=p_j=q/2 p i = p j = q /2 . We then take the Fourier transform to get [see Appendix § 6 for details]
v i j M ( r ) = C M 4 α s ( Q i j ) 9 e − 2 m r r , (38) v_{ij}^{M}(r)=C_M\frac{4\alpha_s(Q_{ij})}{9}\frac{e^{-2mr}}{r}, \tag*{(38)} v ij M ( r ) = C M 9 4 α s ( Q ij ) r e − 2 m r , (38)
where C M C_M C M is a phenomenological parameter used for fine-tuning.
The short-range contributions are evaluated perturbatively as
⟨ v i j E , M ⟩ 0 K ⊥ = ∫ d 3 r 1 d 3 r 2 d 3 r 3 ∣ Φ K ( R , ρ , λ ) ∣ 2 v i j E , M ( r i j ) . (39) \left\langle v_{ij}^{E,M}\right\rangle_0^{K_\perp}=\int d^3r_1d^3r_2d^3r_3\,\left|\Phi_K(R,\rho,\lambda)\right|^2v_{ij}^{E,M}(r_{ij}). \tag*{(39)} ⟨ v ij E , M ⟩ 0 K ⊥ = ∫ d 3 r 1 d 3 r 2 d 3 r 3 ∣ Φ K ( R , ρ , λ ) ∣ 2 v ij E , M ( r ij ) . (39)
For the Gaussian ground-state wave function used here, these matrix elements can be reduced analytically to closed expressions, except for a one-dimensional integral in the displaced Coulomb matrix element. The explicit formulas are collected in Appendix § 6 .
Here we only note that, at small K ⊥ K_\perp K ⊥ , the matrix element can be expanded in powers of K ⊥ 2 K_\perp^2 K ⊥ 2 . The d d dd dd matrix elements are independent of K ⊥ K_\perp K ⊥ , while the K ⊥ K_\perp K ⊥ dependence of the u d ud u d matrix elements enters through ( λ ⊥ 0 ) 2 ∝ K ⊥ 2 / B 2 (\lambda_\perp^0)^2\propto K_\perp^2/B^2 ( λ ⊥ 0 ) 2 ∝ K ⊥ 2 / B 2 . Thus, for small K ⊥ K_\perp K ⊥ ,
⟨ v u d E , M ⟩ 0 K ⊥ = ⟨ v u d E , M ⟩ 0 K ⊥ = 0 + c u d E , M ( B ) K ⊥ 2 + O ( K ⊥ 4 ) , (40) \left\langle v_{ud}^{E,M}\right\rangle_0^{K_\perp}=\left\langle v_{ud}^{E,M}\right\rangle_0^{K_\perp=0}+c_{ud}^{E,M}(B)K_\perp^2+O(K_\perp^4), \tag*{(40)} ⟨ v u d E , M ⟩ 0 K ⊥ = ⟨ v u d E , M ⟩ 0 K ⊥ = 0 + c u d E , M ( B ) K ⊥ 2 + O ( K ⊥ 4 ) , (40)
where the coefficient of the transverse term scales at large B B B as
c u d E , M ( B ) ∼ α s Λ Q C D ∣ B ∣ . (41) c_{ud}^{E,M}(B)\sim\frac{\alpha_s\Lambda_{\mathrm{QCD}}}{\lvert B\rvert}. \tag*{(41)} c u d E , M ( B ) ∼ ∣ B ∣ α s Λ QCD . (41)
As in mesonic cases, the transverse kinetic energy term is suppressed by the factor 1 / B 1/B 1/ B .
Spin-flavor structure
For the lowest orbital state, the reference spatial wave function is symmetric under the interchange of the two d d d quarks [ Φ K \Phi_K Φ K was defined in Eq. (20) ],
ψ r e f d d u ( r 1 , r 2 , r 3 ) = Φ K ( R , ρ , λ ) . (42) \psi_{\mathrm{ref}}^{ddu}(r_1,r_2,r_3)=\Phi_K(R,\rho,\lambda). \tag*{(42)} ψ ref dd u ( r 1 , r 2 , r 3 ) = Φ K ( R , ρ , λ ) . (42)
which satisfies ψ r e f d d u ( r 1 , r 2 , r 3 ) = ψ r e f d d u ( r 2 , r 1 , r 3 ) \psi_{\mathrm{ref}}^{ddu}(r_1,r_2,r_3)=\psi_{\mathrm{ref}}^{ddu}(r_2,r_1,r_3) ψ ref dd u ( r 1 , r 2 , r 3 ) = ψ ref dd u ( r 2 , r 1 , r 3 ) . For S z = − 1 / 2 S_z=-1/2 S z = − 1/2 , we introduce the two normalized fully symmetric states
∣ χ 0 ⟩ = 3 S 3 ∣ χ ~ 0 ⟩ , ∣ χ − 1 ⟩ = 3 S 3 ∣ χ ~ − 1 ⟩ , (43) \lvert\chi_0\rangle=\sqrt{3}\mathcal{S}_3\lvert\widetilde{\chi}_0\rangle,\qquad\lvert\chi_{-1}\rangle=\sqrt{3}\mathcal{S}_3\lvert\widetilde{\chi}_{-1}\rangle, \tag*{(43)} ∣ χ 0 ⟩ = 3 S 3 ∣ χ 0 ⟩ , ∣ χ − 1 ⟩ = 3 S 3 ∣ χ − 1 ⟩ , (43)
with
∣ χ ~ 0 ⟩ = ∫ r 1 , r 2 , r 3 ψ r e f d d u ∣ d ↑ , r 1 ; d ↓ , r 2 ; u ↓ , r 3 ⟩ + ∣ d ↓ , r 1 ; d ↑ , r 2 ; u ↓ , r 3 ⟩ 2 , (44) \lvert\widetilde{\chi}_0\rangle=\int_{r_1,r_2,r_3}\psi_{\mathrm{ref}}^{ddu}\frac{\lvert d_{\uparrow},r_1;d_{\downarrow},r_2;u_{\downarrow},r_3\rangle+\lvert d_{\downarrow},r_1;d_{\uparrow},r_2;u_{\downarrow},r_3\rangle}{\sqrt{2}}, \tag*{(44)} ∣ χ 0 ⟩ = ∫ r 1 , r 2 , r 3 ψ ref dd u 2 ∣ d ↑ , r 1 ; d ↓ , r 2 ; u ↓ , r 3 ⟩ + ∣ d ↓ , r 1 ; d ↑ , r 2 ; u ↓ , r 3 ⟩ , (44)
∣ χ ~ − 1 ⟩ = ∫ r 1 , r 2 , r 3 ψ r e f d d u ∣ d ↓ , r 1 ; d ↓ , r 2 ; u ↑ , r 3 ⟩ . (45) \lvert\widetilde{\chi}_{-1}\rangle=\int_{r_1,r_2,r_3}\psi_{\mathrm{ref}}^{ddu}\lvert d_{\downarrow},r_1;d_{\downarrow},r_2;u_{\uparrow},r_3\rangle. \tag*{(45)} ∣ χ − 1 ⟩ = ∫ r 1 , r 2 , r 3 ψ ref dd u ∣ d ↓ , r 1 ; d ↓ , r 2 ; u ↑ , r 3 ⟩ . (45)
At finite magnetic field, the spatial wave function is not in general symmetric under permutations involving the u u u quark. Therefore, the spin-flavor part does not factorize into a state of definite isospin and total spin.
For later convenience, we introduce the spin basis with S z = − 1 / 2 S_z=-1/2 S z = − 1/2 ,
∣ Ψ 1 / 2 ⟩ ≡ 1 3 ∣ χ 0 ⟩ − 2 3 ∣ χ − 1 ⟩ , (46) \lvert\Psi_{1/2}\rangle\equiv\frac{1}{\sqrt{3}}\lvert\chi_0\rangle-\sqrt{\frac{2}{3}}\lvert\chi_{-1}\rangle, \tag*{(46)} ∣ Ψ 1/2 ⟩ ≡ 3 1 ∣ χ 0 ⟩ − 3 2 ∣ χ − 1 ⟩ , (46)
∣ Ψ 3 / 2 ⟩ ≡ 2 3 ∣ χ 0 ⟩ + 1 3 ∣ χ − 1 ⟩ . (47) \lvert\Psi_{3/2}\rangle\equiv\sqrt{\frac{2}{3}}\lvert\chi_0\rangle+\frac{1}{\sqrt{3}}\lvert\chi_{-1}\rangle. \tag*{(47)} ∣ Ψ 3/2 ⟩ ≡ 3 2 ∣ χ 0 ⟩ + 3 1 ∣ χ − 1 ⟩ . (47)
In the zero-field limit, where the usual spin-flavor classification is recovered, these states continuously connect to the neutron and Δ 0 \Delta^0 Δ 0 , respectively. At finite B B B , they are used simply as a convenient basis for diagonalizing the spin-dependent Hamiltonian.
We now evaluate the spin-dependent part
H s p i n = H Z e e m a n + ∑ i < j ⟨ v i j M K ⟩ 0 σ i ⋅ σ j . (48) H_{\rm spin}=H_{\rm Zeeman}+\sum_{i<j}\langle v_{ij}^{M K}\rangle_0\,\boldsymbol{\sigma}_i\cdot\boldsymbol{\sigma}_j. \tag*{(48)} H spin = H Zeeman + i < j ∑ ⟨ v ij M K ⟩ 0 σ i ⋅ σ j . (48)
In the spin basis introduced above, the color-magnetic interaction is diagonal,
⟨ Ψ 1 / 2 ∣ ∑ i < j ⟨ v i j M K ⟩ 0 σ i ⋅ σ j ∣ Ψ 1 / 2 ⟩ = ⟨ v d d M K ⟩ 0 − 4 ⟨ v u d M K ⟩ 0 ≡ V 1 / 2 M , (49) \langle\Psi_{1/2}\rvert\sum_{i<j}\langle v_{ij}^{M K}\rangle_0\,\boldsymbol{\sigma}_i\cdot\boldsymbol{\sigma}_j\lvert\Psi_{1/2}\rangle=\langle v_{dd}^{M K}\rangle_0-4\langle v_{ud}^{M K}\rangle_0\equiv V_{1/2}^{M}, \tag*{(49)} ⟨ Ψ 1/2 ∣ i < j ∑ ⟨ v ij M K ⟩ 0 σ i ⋅ σ j ∣ Ψ 1/2 ⟩ = ⟨ v dd M K ⟩ 0 − 4 ⟨ v u d M K ⟩ 0 ≡ V 1/2 M , (49)
⟨ Ψ 3 / 2 ∣ ∑ i < j ⟨ v i j M K ⟩ 0 σ i ⋅ σ j ∣ Ψ 3 / 2 ⟩ = ⟨ v d d M K ⟩ 0 + 2 ⟨ v u d M K ⟩ 0 ≡ V 3 / 2 M , (50) \langle\Psi_{3/2}\rvert\sum_{i<j}\langle v_{ij}^{M K}\rangle_0\,\boldsymbol{\sigma}_i\cdot\boldsymbol{\sigma}_j\lvert\Psi_{3/2}\rangle=\langle v_{dd}^{M K}\rangle_0+2\langle v_{ud}^{M K}\rangle_0\equiv V_{3/2}^{M}, \tag*{(50)} ⟨ Ψ 3/2 ∣ i < j ∑ ⟨ v ij M K ⟩ 0 σ i ⋅ σ j ∣ Ψ 3/2 ⟩ = ⟨ v dd M K ⟩ 0 + 2 ⟨ v u d M K ⟩ 0 ≡ V 3/2 M , (50)
while the off-diagonal matrix element vanishes,
⟨ Ψ 1 / 2 ∣ ∑ i < j ⟨ v i j M K ⟩ 0 σ i ⋅ σ j ∣ Ψ 3 / 2 ⟩ = 0. (51) \langle\Psi_{1/2}\rvert\sum_{i<j}\langle v_{ij}^{M K}\rangle_0\,\boldsymbol{\sigma}_i\cdot\boldsymbol{\sigma}_j\lvert\Psi_{3/2}\rangle=0. \tag*{(51)} ⟨ Ψ 1/2 ∣ i < j ∑ ⟨ v ij M K ⟩ 0 σ i ⋅ σ j ∣ Ψ 3/2 ⟩ = 0. (51)
The Zeeman interaction, on the other hand, mixes the two basis states. For S z = − 1 / 2 S_z=-1/2 S z = − 1/2 , its matrix elements are
⟨ Ψ 1 / 2 ∣ H Z e e m a n ∣ Ψ 1 / 2 ⟩ = − B q m , (52) \langle\Psi_{1/2}\rvert H_{\rm Zeeman}\lvert\Psi_{1/2}\rangle=-\frac{Bq}{m}, \tag*{(52)} ⟨ Ψ 1/2 ∣ H Zeeman ∣ Ψ 1/2 ⟩ = − m B q , (52)
⟨ Ψ 3 / 2 ∣ H Z e e m a n ∣ Ψ 3 / 2 ⟩ = 0 , (53) \langle\Psi_{3/2}\rvert H_{\rm Zeeman}\lvert\Psi_{3/2}\rangle=0, \tag*{(53)} ⟨ Ψ 3/2 ∣ H Zeeman ∣ Ψ 3/2 ⟩ = 0 , (53)
⟨ Ψ 1 / 2 ∣ H Z e e m a n ∣ Ψ 3 / 2 ⟩ = 2 B q m . (54) \langle\Psi_{1/2}\rvert H_{\rm Zeeman}\lvert\Psi_{3/2}\rangle=\sqrt{2}\frac{Bq}{m}. \tag*{(54)} ⟨ Ψ 1/2 ∣ H Zeeman ∣ Ψ 3/2 ⟩ = 2 m B q . (54)
In the zero-field limit, these matrix elements are related to the neutron and Δ 0 \Delta^0 Δ 0 magnetic moments and to the n n n –Δ 0 \Delta^0 Δ 0 transition magnetic moment. With q = e / 3 q=e/3 q = e /3 , the nonrelativistic quark model gives
μ n = − e 3 m , μ Δ 0 = 0 , ∣ μ n Δ 0 ∣ = 2 e 3 m . (55) \mu_n=-\frac{e}{3m},\qquad\mu_{\Delta^0}=0,\qquad\lvert\mu_{n\Delta^0}\rvert=\frac{\sqrt{2}e}{3m}. \tag*{(55)} μ n = − 3 m e , μ Δ 0 = 0 , ∣ μ n Δ 0 ∣ = 3 m 2 e . (55)
Here μ n \mu_n μ n is defined in the conventional S z = + 1 / 2 S_z=+1/2 S z = + 1/2 convention. The experimental value of the neutron magnetic moment motivates our choice m ≃ 0.33 m\simeq0.33 m ≃ 0.33 GeV.
The spin-dependent Hamiltonian in the basis { ∣ Ψ 1 / 2 ⟩ , ∣ Ψ 3 / 2 ⟩ } \{\lvert\Psi_{1/2}\rangle,\lvert\Psi_{3/2}\rangle\} {∣ Ψ 1/2 ⟩ , ∣ Ψ 3/2 ⟩} is therefore
H s p i n ( ↓ ) = ( V 1 / 2 M − B q / m 2 B q / m 2 B q / m V 3 / 2 M ) . (56) H_{\rm spin}^{(\downarrow)}=
\begin{pmatrix}
V_{1/2}^{M}-B_q/m & \sqrt{2}B_q/m\\
\sqrt{2}B_q/m & V_{3/2}^{M}
\end{pmatrix}. \tag*{(56)} H spin ( ↓ ) = ( V 1/2 M − B q / m 2 B q / m 2 B q / m V 3/2 M ) . (56)
Its eigenvalues are
V ± M ↓ = V 3 / 2 M + V 1 / 2 M − B q / m 2 ± 1 2 ( V 3 / 2 M − V 1 / 2 M + B q / m ) 2 + 8 ( B q m ) 2 . (57) V^{M\downarrow}_{\pm}=\frac{V^M_{3/2}+V^M_{1/2}-B_q/m}{2}\pm\frac{1}{2}\sqrt{\left(V^M_{3/2}-V^M_{1/2}+B_q/m\right)^2+8\left(\frac{B_q}{m}\right)^2}. \tag*{(57)} V ± M ↓ = 2 V 3/2 M + V 1/2 M − B q / m ± 2 1 ( V 3/2 M − V 1/2 M + B q / m ) 2 + 8 ( m B q ) 2 . (57)
For the S z = + 1 / 2 S_z=+1/2 S z = + 1/2 sector, the sign of the Zeeman interaction is reversed. The corresponding spin-dependent Hamiltonian is
H s p i n ( ↑ ) = ( V 1 / 2 M + B q / m − 2 B q / m − 2 B q / m V 3 / 2 M ) , (58) H^{(\uparrow)}_{\mathrm{spin}}=\begin{pmatrix} V^M_{1/2}+B_q/m & -\sqrt{2}B_q/m \\ -\sqrt{2}B_q/m & V^M_{3/2} \end{pmatrix}, \tag*{(58)} H spin ( ↑ ) = ( V 1/2 M + B q / m − 2 B q / m − 2 B q / m V 3/2 M ) , (58)
with eigenvalues
V ± M ↑ = V 3 / 2 M + V 1 / 2 M + B q / m 2 ± 1 2 ( V 3 / 2 M − V 1 / 2 M − B q / m ) 2 + 8 ( B q m ) 2 . (59) V^{M\uparrow}_{\pm}=\frac{V^M_{3/2}+V^M_{1/2}+B_q/m}{2}\pm\frac{1}{2}\sqrt{\left(V^M_{3/2}-V^M_{1/2}-B_q/m\right)^2+8\left(\frac{B_q}{m}\right)^2}. \tag*{(59)} V ± M ↑ = 2 V 3/2 M + V 1/2 M + B q / m ± 2 1 ( V 3/2 M − V 1/2 M − B q / m ) 2 + 8 ( m B q ) 2 . (59)
Below we analyze the weak- and strong-field limits.
For weak magnetic fields, the eigenvalues can be expressed directly in terms of the magnetic moments. Defining
Δ M ( B ) = V 3 / 2 M ( B ) − V 1 / 2 M ( B ) , (60) \Delta_M(B)=V^M_{3/2}(B)-V^M_{1/2}(B), \tag*{(60)} Δ M ( B ) = V 3/2 M ( B ) − V 1/2 M ( B ) , (60)
we find
V − ↓ = V 1 / 2 M − ∣ μ n ∣ B − ∣ μ n Δ 0 ∣ 2 Δ M ( 0 ) B 2 + O ( B 3 ) , (61) V_{-\downarrow}=V^M_{1/2}-|\mu_n|B-\frac{|\mu_{n\Delta^0}|^2}{\Delta_M(0)}B^2+O(B^3), \tag*{(61)} V − ↓ = V 1/2 M − ∣ μ n ∣ B − Δ M ( 0 ) ∣ μ n Δ 0 ∣ 2 B 2 + O ( B 3 ) , (61)
V − ↑ = V 1 / 2 M + ∣ μ n ∣ B − ∣ μ n Δ 0 ∣ 2 Δ M ( 0 ) B 2 + O ( B 3 ) , (62) V_{-\uparrow}=V^M_{1/2}+|\mu_n|B-\frac{|\mu_{n\Delta^0}|^2}{\Delta_M(0)}B^2+O(B^3), \tag*{(62)} V − ↑ = V 1/2 M + ∣ μ n ∣ B − Δ M ( 0 ) ∣ μ n Δ 0 ∣ 2 B 2 + O ( B 3 ) , (62)
V + ↓ = V 3 / 2 M + ∣ μ n Δ 0 ∣ 2 Δ M ( 0 ) B 2 + O ( B 3 ) , (63) V_{+\downarrow}=V^M_{3/2}+\frac{|\mu_{n\Delta^0}|^2}{\Delta_M(0)}B^2+O(B^3), \tag*{(63)} V + ↓ = V 3/2 M + Δ M ( 0 ) ∣ μ n Δ 0 ∣ 2 B 2 + O ( B 3 ) , (63)
V + ↑ = V 3 / 2 M + ∣ μ n Δ 0 ∣ 2 Δ M ( 0 ) B 2 + O ( B 3 ) . (64) V_{+\uparrow}=V^M_{3/2}+\frac{|\mu_{n\Delta^0}|^2}{\Delta_M(0)}B^2+O(B^3). \tag*{(64)} V + ↑ = V 3/2 M + Δ M ( 0 ) ∣ μ n Δ 0 ∣ 2 B 2 + O ( B 3 ) . (64)
Thus, at weak magnetic fields, the neutron magnetic moment produces the linear Zeeman splitting between the two neutron-like branches, while the n n n –Δ 0 \Delta^0 Δ 0 transition magnetic moment produces the quadratic level repulsion. The latter lowers both neutron-like branches and raises both Δ 0 \Delta^0 Δ 0 -like branches.
At large B B B , the four eigenvalues behave as
V − ↓ ⟶ − 2 B q m + V 3 / 2 M + 2 V 1 / 2 M 3 , (65) V^{\downarrow}_{-}\longrightarrow-2\frac{B_q}{m}+\frac{V^M_{3/2}+2V^M_{1/2}}{3}, \tag*{(65)} V − ↓ ⟶ − 2 m B q + 3 V 3/2 M + 2 V 1/2 M , (65)
V − ↑ ⟶ − B q m + 2 V 3 / 2 M + V 1 / 2 M 3 , (66) V^{\uparrow}_{-}\longrightarrow-\frac{B_q}{m}+\frac{2V^M_{3/2}+V^M_{1/2}}{3}, \tag*{(66)} V − ↑ ⟶ − m B q + 3 2 V 3/2 M + V 1/2 M , (66)
V + ↓ ⟶ B q m + 2 V 3 / 2 M + V 1 / 2 M 3 , (67) V^{\downarrow}_{+}\longrightarrow\frac{B_q}{m}+\frac{2V^M_{3/2}+V^M_{1/2}}{3}, \tag*{(67)} V + ↓ ⟶ m B q + 3 2 V 3/2 M + V 1/2 M , (67)
V + ↑ ⟶ 2 B q m + V 3 / 2 M + 2 V 1 / 2 M 3 . (68) V^{\uparrow}_{+}\longrightarrow2\frac{B_q}{m}+\frac{V^M_{3/2}+2V^M_{1/2}}{3}. \tag*{(68)} V + ↑ ⟶ 2 m B q + 3 V 3/2 M + 2 V 1/2 M . (68)
The spin composition of this lowest branch also becomes particularly simple. For B > 0 B>0 B > 0 ,
∣ n ~ ↓ ⟩ ⟶ ∣ χ − 1 ⟩ ∼ ∣ d ↓ d ↓ u ↑ ⟩ , B → ∞ . (69) \lvert\widetilde n_{\downarrow}\rangle\longrightarrow\lvert\chi_{-1}\rangle\sim\lvert d_{\downarrow}d_{\downarrow}u_{\uparrow}\rangle,\qquad B\to\infty. \tag*{(69)} ∣ n ↓ ⟩ ⟶ ∣ χ − 1 ⟩ ∼ ∣ d ↓ d ↓ u ↑ ⟩ , B → ∞. (69)
Table 1. Parameter sets used for the numerical calculations. The constituent-quark mass is fixed to m = 0.33 m = 0.33 m = 0.33 GeV. For each set, the confinement parameter α \alpha α is chosen to reproduce the specified zero-field baryon-number rms radius r B ( 0 ) r_B(0) r B ( 0 ) , while C M C_M C M and C 0 C_0 C 0 are adjusted to reproduce M N = 0.939 M_N = 0.939 M N = 0.939 GeV and M Δ = 1.232 M_\Delta= 1.232 M Δ = 1.232 GeV at B = 0 B = 0 B = 0 .
Thus the strong magnetic field polarizes the spin-flavor composition toward the configuration d ↓ d ↓ u ↑ d_{\downarrow}d_{\downarrow}u_{\uparrow} d ↓ d ↓ u ↑ . As will be discussed below, this polarization plays an important role in determining which quark state first reaches saturation in baryonic matter.
Combining the spin-dependent eigenvalues with the spin-independent orbital energy, the four branches are defined as (s = ↑ , ↓ s = \uparrow,\downarrow s =↑ , ↓ )
E ~ 0 s n ~ ( K ) ≡ E 0 ( K ) + V − s , E ~ 0 s Δ 0 ( K ) ≡ E 0 ( K ) + V + s . (70) \widetilde{E}^{\tilde{n}}_{0s}(\mathrm{K}) \equiv E_0(\mathrm{K}) + V^s_{-}, \qquad\widetilde{E}^{\Delta^0}_{0s}(\mathrm{K}) \equiv E_0(\mathrm{K}) + V^s_{+}. \tag*{(70)} E 0 s n ~ ( K ) ≡ E 0 ( K ) + V − s , E 0 s Δ 0 ( K ) ≡ E 0 ( K ) + V + s . (70)
Here n ~ \tilde{n} n ~ and Δ ~ 0 \widetilde{\Delta}^0 Δ 0 denote the branches adiabatically connected to the neutron and Δ 0 \Delta^0 Δ 0 states at B = 0 B = 0 B = 0 , respectively.
At large B B B , the lowest branch behaves as
E ~ 0 ↓ n ~ ( K ) → M + K z 2 2 M + α K ⊥ 2 2 B q 2 + 6 α m + ∑ i > j ⟨ v i j E ⟩ 0 K + V 3 / 2 M + 2 V 1 / 2 M 3 . (71) \widetilde{E}^{\tilde{n}}_{0\downarrow}(\mathrm{K}) \to M + \frac{K_z^2}{2M} + \frac{\alpha K_\perp^2}{2B_q^2} + \sqrt{\frac{6\alpha}{m}} + \sum_{i>j}\langle v^E_{ij}\rangle_0 \mathrm{K} + \frac{V^M_{3/2} + 2V^M_{1/2}}{3}. \tag*{(71)} E 0 ↓ n ~ ( K ) → M + 2 M K z 2 + 2 B q 2 α K ⊥ 2 + m 6 α + i > j ∑ ⟨ v ij E ⟩ 0 K + 3 V 3/2 M + 2 V 1/2 M . (71)
The leading O ( B q ) O(B_q) O ( B q ) contribution from the transverse zero-point energy is canceled by the Zeeman energy in this branch. The other three branches are separated from the lowest branch as
E ~ 0 ↑ n ~ ( K ) − E ~ 0 ↓ n ~ ( K ) → B q m + Δ M ( B ) 3 , (72) \widetilde{E}^{\tilde{n}}_{0\uparrow}(\mathrm{K}) - \widetilde{E}^{\tilde{n}}_{0\downarrow}(\mathrm{K}) \to\frac{B_q}{m} + \frac{\Delta_M(B)}{3}, \tag*{(72)} E 0 ↑ n ~ ( K ) − E 0 ↓ n ~ ( K ) → m B q + 3 Δ M ( B ) , (72)
E ~ 0 ↑ Δ 0 ( K ) − E ~ 0 ↓ n ~ ( K ) → 3 B q m + Δ M ( B ) 3 , (73) \widetilde{E}^{\Delta^0}_{0\uparrow}(\mathrm{K}) - \widetilde{E}^{\tilde{n}}_{0\downarrow}(\mathrm{K}) \to3\frac{B_q}{m} + \frac{\Delta_M(B)}{3}, \tag*{(73)} E 0 ↑ Δ 0 ( K ) − E 0 ↓ n ~ ( K ) → 3 m B q + 3 Δ M ( B ) , (73)
E ~ 0 ↓ Δ 0 ( K ) − E ~ 0 ↓ n ~ ( K ) → 4 B q m . (74) \widetilde{E}^{\Delta^0}_{0\downarrow}(\mathrm{K}) - \widetilde{E}^{\tilde{n}}_{0\downarrow}(\mathrm{K}) \to4\frac{B_q}{m}. \tag*{(74)} E 0 ↓ Δ 0 ( K ) − E 0 ↓ n ~ ( K ) → 4 m B q . (74)
Since Δ M ( B ) > 0 \Delta_M(B) > 0 Δ M ( B ) > 0 , the n ~ ↓ \tilde{n}_{\downarrow} n ~ ↓ branch is the lowest of the four branches in the strong-field regime.
The results above determine the orbital and spin-flavor structure of the low-lying neutral baryon states in a magnetic field. We next illustrate the resulting spectra for representative parameter sets.
Numerical illustration
For the numerical illustrations, we first fix the constituent-quark mass using the neutron magnetic moment as a guide. In the present nonrelativistic quark model,
μ n = − e 3 m . (75) \mu_n = -\frac{e}{3m}. \tag*{(75)} μ n = − 3 m e . (75)
The experimental value,
μ n = − 1.91304276 ( 45 ) μ N , μ N ≡ e 2 M N , (76) \mu_n = -1.91304276(45)\,\mu_N, \qquad\mu_N \equiv\frac{e}{2M_N}, \tag*{(76)} μ n = − 1.91304276 ( 45 ) μ N , μ N ≡ 2 M N e , (76)
corresponds to
m ≃ 0.327 G e V . (77) m \simeq0.327\ \mathrm{GeV}. \tag*{(77)} m ≃ 0.327 GeV . (77)
We therefore fix m = 0.33 G e V m=0.33\ \mathrm{GeV} m = 0.33 GeV throughout the numerical analysis and examine the sensitivity to the spatial size of the baryon. We define
⟨ r B 2 ⟩ ≡ 1 3 ∑ i = 1 3 ⟨ ( r i − R ) 2 ⟩ (78) \langle r_{B}^{2}\rangle\equiv\frac{1}{3}\sum_{i=1}^{3}\langle(r_i-R)^2\rangle \tag*{(78)} ⟨ r B 2 ⟩ ≡ 3 1 i = 1 ∑ 3 ⟨( r i − R ) 2 ⟩ (78)
and consider three values of the zero-field baryon radius,
r B ( 0 ) ≡ ⟨ r B 2 ⟩ = 0.50 , 0.60 , 0.70 f m , (79) r_B(0)\equiv\sqrt{\langle r_B^2\rangle}=0.50,\ 0.60,\ 0.70\ \mathrm{fm}, \tag*{(79)} r B ( 0 ) ≡ ⟨ r B 2 ⟩ = 0.50 , 0.60 , 0.70 fm , (79)
which define parameter sets A, B, and C, respectively. For the Gaussian wave function for the ground state at B = 0 B=0 B = 0 , the baryon radius is related to the confinement parameter by
α = 1 6 m r B 4 ( 0 ) . (80) \alpha=\frac{1}{6m r_B^4(0)}. \tag*{(80)} α = 6 m r B 4 ( 0 ) 1 . (80)
Thus, once m m m and r B ( 0 ) r_B(0) r B ( 0 ) are specified, the confinement parameter α \alpha α is fixed. For each set, the confinement parameter α \alpha α is determined from the chosen value of r B ( 0 ) r_B(0) r B ( 0 ) , while C M C_M C M and C 0 C_0 C 0 are adjusted to reproduce
M N = 0.939 G e V , M Δ = 1.232 G e V (81) M_N=0.939\ \mathrm{GeV},\qquad M_\Delta=1.232\ \mathrm{GeV} \tag*{(81)} M N = 0.939 GeV , M Δ = 1.232 GeV (81)
at B = 0 B=0 B = 0 .
Figure 1 shows the magnetic-field dependence of the four low-lying neutral d d u ddu dd u baryon branches for the representative parameter set B. At B = 0 B=0 B = 0 , the two lower and two upper branches reduce to the spin-degenerate neutron and Δ 0 \Delta^{0} Δ 0 states, respectively. As the magnetic field increases, the spin degeneracy is lifted and the n ~ ↓ \tilde{n}_{\downarrow} n ~ ↓ branch becomes the lowest-energy state. Its relatively weak variation at strong fields reflects the cancellation between the transverse orbital contribution and the Zeeman energy discussed in Eq. (71) . The remaining branches are pushed upward relative to n ~ ↓ \tilde{n}_{\downarrow} n ~ ↓ , consistently with the strong-field behavior derived above.
Figure 1. Magnetic-field dependence of the four low-lying neutral d d u ddu dd u baryon branches at K = 0 K=0 K = 0 for parameter set B. The branches denoted by n ~ \tilde{n} n ~ and Δ 0 \Delta^{0} Δ 0 are adiabatically connected to the neutron and Δ 0 \Delta^{0} Δ 0 states at B = 0 B=0 B = 0 , respectively. The magnetic field lifts the spin degeneracy, and the n ~ ↓ \tilde{n}_{\downarrow} n ~ ↓ branch becomes the lowest-energy state as ∣ e B ∣ \lvert eB\rvert ∣ e B ∣ increases.
In the following, we focus mainly on the lowest n ~ ↓ \tilde{n}_{\downarrow} n ~ ↓ branch, which provides the relevant single-baryon state for the many-body analysis.
Figure 2 shows the transverse size r B , ⊥ r m s ≡ ⟨ r ⊥ 2 ⟩ r^{\mathrm{rms}}_{B,\perp}\equiv\sqrt{\langle r_{\perp}^{2}\rangle} r B , ⊥ rms ≡ ⟨ r ⊥ 2 ⟩ and the ground-state energy of the lowest n ~ ↓ \tilde{n}_{\downarrow} n ~ ↓ branch for parameter sets A–C. As the magnetic field increases, the baryon is compressed in the transverse direction, reflecting the magnetic localization of the internal quark motion. Although the quantitative behavior depends on the zero-field baryon size, the same trend is observed for all three parameter sets.
Figure 2. Magnetic-field dependence of the transverse size and ground-state energy of the lowest n ~ ↓ \tilde{n}_{\downarrow} n ~ ↓ branch for parameter sets A–C. (Left panel) Transverse rms baryon radius, r B , ⊥ r m s r^{\mathrm{rms}}_{B,\perp} r B , ⊥ rms . The magnetic field compresses the baryon in the transverse direction, with the three curves corresponding to the different zero-field baryon radii. (Right panel) Ground-state energy E n ~ ↓ ( K = 0 ) E_{\tilde{n}_{\downarrow}}(K=0) E n ~ ↓ ( K = 0 ) . Solid curves show the full results including the running short-range coupling α s ( Q ) \alpha_s(Q) α s ( Q ) , while dotted curves show the corresponding results with the short-range interaction switched off, α s = 0 \alpha_s=0 α s = 0 , without refitting the model parameters. The black dashed line indicates the weak-field behavior M n − ∣ μ n ∣ B M_n-\lvert\mu_n\rvert B M n − ∣ μ n ∣ B .
The right panel of Figure 2 shows the corresponding ground-state energy. Its sizable decrease with increasing B B B originates from the cancellation between the transverse orbital energy and the Zeeman energy in the lowest branch. This mechanism is particularly transparent when the short-range interaction is switched off. The full results including the running short-range coupling α s ( Q ) \alpha_s(Q) α s ( Q ) exhibit the same qualitative behavior, with additional modifications associated with the magnetic-field dependence of the short-range interactions. As shown explicitly in Eq. (71) , the leading O ( B q ) O(B_q) O ( B q ) contribution from the transverse zero-point motion is canceled by the Zeeman term at large B B B . Consequently, a substantial part of the transverse zero-point energy present at B = 0 B=0 B = 0 is effectively removed from the lowest branch.
This effect is more pronounced for baryons than for mesons because a three-quark system contains two independent internal transverse modes, associated with the Jacobi coordinates ρ \rho ρ and λ \lambda λ , whereas a meson has only one relative transverse mode. For comparison, at ∣ e B ∣ ≃ 1 G e V 2 \lvert eB\rvert\simeq1\ \mathrm{GeV}^{2} ∣ e B ∣ ≃ 1 GeV 2 the ground-state energy of a neutral meson decreases by about 200–300 MeV [47 , 51 ] , while the present baryon calculation gives a reduction of about 400–600 MeV. The approximately factor-of-two difference is therefore qualitatively consistent with the number of independent transverse internal modes.
To characterize the magnetic-field dependence of the transverse baryon motion, we define the transverse effective mass M ⊥ ( B ) M_{\perp}(B) M ⊥ ( B ) from the small-K ⊥ K_{\perp} K ⊥ dispersion of the lowest n ~ ↓ \tilde{n}_{\downarrow} n ~ ↓ branch,
E n ~ ↓ ( K ⊥ , 0 ) − E n ~ ↓ ( 0 , 0 ) = K ⊥ 2 2 M ⊥ ( B ) + O ( K ⊥ 4 ) . (82) E_{\tilde{n}_{\downarrow}}(K_{\perp},0)-E_{\tilde{n}_{\downarrow}}(0,0)=\frac{K_{\perp}^{2}}{2M_{\perp}(B)}+O(K_{\perp}^{4}). \tag*{(82)} E n ~ ↓ ( K ⊥ , 0 ) − E n ~ ↓ ( 0 , 0 ) = 2 M ⊥ ( B ) K ⊥ 2 + O ( K ⊥ 4 ) . (82)
At B = 0 B=0 B = 0 , rotational invariance restores the isotropic dispersion, giving M ⊥ ( B = 0 ) = M = 3 m M_{\perp}(B=0)=M=3m M ⊥ ( B = 0 ) = M = 3 m .
Figure 3 shows the magnetic-field dependence of M ⊥ M_{\perp} M ⊥ together with the transverse dispersion of the lowest branch. The left panel shows M ⊥ ( B ) / M M_{\perp}(B)/M M ⊥ ( B ) / M for parameter sets A–C. With increasing ∣ e B ∣ \lvert eB\rvert ∣ e B ∣ , M ⊥ M_{\perp} M ⊥ grows rapidly for all three parameter sets, indicating a strong suppression of the transverse baryon motion. The same qualitative behavior is found with and without the short-range interaction, although the latter modifies the quantitative behavior of M ⊥ M_{\perp} M ⊥ . The right panel shows the transverse excitation energy
Figure 3. Transverse dispersion and effective mass of the lowest n ~ ↓ \tilde{n}_{\downarrow} n ~ ↓ branch. (Left panel) Transverse effective-mass ratio M ⊥ ( B ) / M M_{\perp}(B)/M M ⊥ ( B ) / M for parameter sets A–C, extracted from the small-K ⊥ K_{\perp} K ⊥ dispersion, E n ~ ↓ ( K ⊥ , 0 ) − E n ~ ↓ ( 0 , 0 ) = K ⊥ 2 / [ 2 M ⊥ ( B ) ] + O ( K ⊥ 4 ) E_{\tilde{n}_{\downarrow}}(K_{\perp},0)-E_{\tilde{n}_{\downarrow}}(0,0)=K_{\perp}^{2}/[2M_{\perp}(B)]+O(K_{\perp}^{4}) E n ~ ↓ ( K ⊥ , 0 ) − E n ~ ↓ ( 0 , 0 ) = K ⊥ 2 / [ 2 M ⊥ ( B )] + O ( K ⊥ 4 ) . Solid curves show the full results including the short-range interaction, while dashed curves show the corresponding results with α s = 0 \alpha_s=0 α s = 0 . The rapid increase of M ⊥ M_{\perp} M ⊥ reflects the suppression of the transverse baryon kinetic energy at strong magnetic fields. (Right panel) Transverse excitation energy E n ~ ↓ ( K ⊥ , 0 ) − E n ~ ↓ ( 0 , 0 ) E_{\tilde{n}_{\downarrow}}(K_{\perp},0)-E_{\tilde{n}_{\downarrow}}(0,0) E n ~ ↓ ( K ⊥ , 0 ) − E n ~ ↓ ( 0 , 0 ) for parameter set B at several magnetic fields. With increasing ∣ e B ∣ \lvert eB\rvert ∣ e B ∣ , the transverse dispersion becomes progressively flatter.
E n ~ ↓ ( K ⊥ , 0 ) − E n ~ ↓ ( 0 , 0 ) (83) E_{\tilde{n}_{\downarrow}}(K_{\perp},0)-E_{\tilde{n}_{\downarrow}}(0,0) \tag*{(83)} E n ~ ↓ ( K ⊥ , 0 ) − E n ~ ↓ ( 0 , 0 ) (83)
for parameter set B at several magnetic fields. As the magnetic field increases, the dispersion becomes progressively flatter, directly illustrating the increase of M ⊥ M_{\perp} M ⊥ seen in the left panel. In the strong-field limit and α s = 0 \alpha_s=0 α s = 0 , the explicit orbital contribution in Eq. (71) is suppressed as K ⊥ 2 / B q 2 K_{\perp}^{2}/B_{q}^{2} K ⊥ 2 / B q 2 . The short-range interactions generate additional K ⊥ K_{\perp} K ⊥ -dependent terms that decrease more slowly with B B B , as discussed in Eq. (40) and Eq. (41) . A similar suppression of the transverse kinetic energy and flattening of the dispersion has been found in mesonic systems [47 , 51 , 52 , 53 ] .
Quark distribution in a baryon: Density matrix
In this section, we characterize the single-quark distribution starting from the one-body reduced density matrix. We first keep the finite-volume normalization factors explicit, so that matrix elements in individual momentum and Landau states can be interpreted as probabilities for discrete one-particle states. We later define the corresponding volume-independent distributions by factoring out these normalization factors.
One-body reduced density matrix
We now construct the single-quark density matrix starting from the fully symmetrized baryon state. For the S z = − 1 / 2 S_z=-1/2 S z = − 1/2 sector, we write the baryon state as
∣ Ψ K ( d d u ) ↓ ⟩ = c 0 ∣ χ 0 ; K ⟩ + c − 1 ∣ χ − 1 ; K ⟩ , ∣ c 0 ∣ 2 + ∣ c − 1 ∣ 2 = 1 (84) \left|\Psi_{K}^{(ddu)\downarrow}\right\rangle=c_0\left|\chi_0;K\right\rangle+c_{-1}\left|\chi_{-1};K\right\rangle,\qquad\lvert c_0\rvert^2+\lvert c_{-1}\rvert^2=1 \tag*{(84)} Ψ K ( dd u ) ↓ ⟩ = c 0 ∣ χ 0 ; K ⟩ + c − 1 ∣ χ − 1 ; K ⟩ , ∣ c 0 ∣ 2 + ∣ c − 1 ∣ 2 = 1 (84)
where the orbital dependence of the states is specified by the reference wave function ψ r e f d d u \psi_{\mathrm{ref}}^{ddu} ψ ref dd u obtained in the previous section. The corresponding baryon density operator is
ρ ^ B = ∣ Ψ K ( d d u ) ↓ ⟩ ⟨ Ψ K ( d d u ) ↓ ∣ (85) \hat{\rho}_B=\left|\Psi_{K}^{(ddu)\downarrow}\right\rangle\left\langle\Psi_{K}^{(ddu)\downarrow}\right| \tag*{(85)} ρ ^ B = Ψ K ( dd u ) ↓ ⟩ ⟨ Ψ K ( dd u ) ↓ (85)
The reduced density matrix associated with particle slot i i i is
ρ ^ i = Tr j ≠ i ρ ^ B , i = 1 , 2 , 3. (86) \hat{\rho}_i = \operatorname{Tr}_{j\ne i}\hat{\rho}_B,\qquad i=1,2,3. \tag*{(86)} ρ ^ i = Tr j = i ρ ^ B , i = 1 , 2 , 3. (86)
Because the full baryon state is totally symmetric under permutations of particle slots, the three reduced density matrices are equivalent, ρ ^ 1 = ρ ^ 2 = ρ ^ 3 \hat{\rho}_1=\hat{\rho}_2=\hat{\rho}_3 ρ ^ 1 = ρ ^ 2 = ρ ^ 3 . We therefore define the number-normalized one-body density operator
Γ ^ ≡ ∑ i = 1 3 ρ ^ i , Tr Γ ^ = 3. (87) \hat{\Gamma}\equiv\sum_{i=1}^{3}\hat{\rho}_i,\qquad\operatorname{Tr}\hat{\Gamma}=3. \tag*{(87)} Γ ^ ≡ i = 1 ∑ 3 ρ ^ i , Tr Γ ^ = 3. (87)
To extract the distribution of a given flavor and spin, we introduce the projector
P f s = ∣ f , s ⟩ ⟨ f , s ∣ , f = u , d , s = ↑ , ↓ , (88) \mathcal{P}_{fs}=\lvert f,s\rangle\langle f,s\rvert,\qquad f=u,d,\qquad s=\uparrow,\downarrow, \tag*{(88)} P f s = ∣ f , s ⟩ ⟨ f , s ∣ , f = u , d , s =↑ , ↓ , (88)
and define the corresponding one-body kernel by
Γ f s ( r , r ′ ) = ⟨ f , s , r ∣ Γ ^ ∣ f , s , r ′ ⟩ . (89) \Gamma_{fs}(\boldsymbol{r},\boldsymbol{r}')=\langle f,s,\boldsymbol{r}\lvert\hat{\Gamma}\rvert f,s,\boldsymbol{r}'\rangle. \tag*{(89)} Γ f s ( r , r ′ ) = ⟨ f , s , r ∣ Γ ^ ∣ f , s , r ′ ⟩ . (89)
For the two basis states introduced in § 2.3 , the spin-flavor components of the one-body density matrix are
Γ u ↓ ( r , r ′ ) = ∣ c 0 ∣ 2 R u ( r , r ′ ) , Γ u ↑ ( r , r ′ ) = ∣ c − 1 ∣ 2 R u ( r , r ′ ) , Γ d ↑ ( r , r ′ ) = ∣ c 0 ∣ 2 R d ( r , r ′ ) , Γ d ↓ ( r , r ′ ) = ( ∣ c 0 ∣ 2 + 2 ∣ c − 1 ∣ 2 ) R d ( r , r ′ ) . (90) \begin{aligned}
\Gamma_{u\downarrow}(\boldsymbol{r},\boldsymbol{r}')&=\lvert c_0\rvert^2R_u(\boldsymbol{r},\boldsymbol{r}'),\\
\Gamma_{u\uparrow}(\boldsymbol{r},\boldsymbol{r}')&=\lvert c_{-1}\rvert^2R_u(\boldsymbol{r},\boldsymbol{r}'),\\
\Gamma_{d\uparrow}(\boldsymbol{r},\boldsymbol{r}')&=\lvert c_0\rvert^2R_d(\boldsymbol{r},\boldsymbol{r}'),\\
\Gamma_{d\downarrow}(\boldsymbol{r},\boldsymbol{r}')&=\left(\lvert c_0\rvert^2+2\lvert c_{-1}\rvert^2\right)R_d(\boldsymbol{r},\boldsymbol{r}'). \tag*{(90)}
\end{aligned} Γ u ↓ ( r , r ′ ) Γ u ↑ ( r , r ′ ) Γ d ↑ ( r , r ′ ) Γ d ↓ ( r , r ′ ) = ∣ c 0 ∣ 2 R u ( r , r ′ ) , = ∣ c − 1 ∣ 2 R u ( r , r ′ ) , = ∣ c 0 ∣ 2 R d ( r , r ′ ) , = ( ∣ c 0 ∣ 2 + 2 ∣ c − 1 ∣ 2 ) R d ( r , r ′ ) . (90)
Γ u ↑ ( r , r ′ ) = ∣ c − 1 ∣ 2 R u ( r , r ′ ) . (91) \Gamma_{u\uparrow}(\boldsymbol{r},\boldsymbol{r}')=\lvert c_{-1}\rvert^2R_u(\boldsymbol{r},\boldsymbol{r}'). \tag*{(91)} Γ u ↑ ( r , r ′ ) = ∣ c − 1 ∣ 2 R u ( r , r ′ ) . (91)
Γ d ↑ ( r , r ′ ) = ∣ c 0 ∣ 2 R d ( r , r ′ ) . (92) \Gamma_{d\uparrow}(\boldsymbol{r},\boldsymbol{r}')=\lvert c_0\rvert^2R_d(\boldsymbol{r},\boldsymbol{r}'). \tag*{(92)} Γ d ↑ ( r , r ′ ) = ∣ c 0 ∣ 2 R d ( r , r ′ ) . (92)
Γ d ↓ ( r , r ′ ) = ( ∣ c 0 ∣ 2 + 2 ∣ c − 1 ∣ 2 ) R d ( r , r ′ ) . (93) \Gamma_{d\downarrow}(\boldsymbol{r},\boldsymbol{r}')=\left(\lvert c_0\rvert^2+2\lvert c_{-1}\rvert^2\right)R_d(\boldsymbol{r},\boldsymbol{r}'). \tag*{(93)} Γ d ↓ ( r , r ′ ) = ( ∣ c 0 ∣ 2 + 2 ∣ c − 1 ∣ 2 ) R d ( r , r ′ ) . (93)
The spatial kernels are
R u ( r , r ′ ) = ∫ r 1 , r 2 ψ r e f d d u ( r 1 , r 2 , r ) ψ r e f d d u ∗ ( r 1 , r 2 , r ′ ) , (94) R_u(\boldsymbol{r},\boldsymbol{r}')=\int_{\boldsymbol{r}_1,\boldsymbol{r}_2}\psi_{\mathrm{ref}}^{ddu}(\boldsymbol{r}_1,\boldsymbol{r}_2,\boldsymbol{r})\psi_{\mathrm{ref}}^{ddu*}(\boldsymbol{r}_1,\boldsymbol{r}_2,\boldsymbol{r}'), \tag*{(94)} R u ( r , r ′ ) = ∫ r 1 , r 2 ψ ref dd u ( r 1 , r 2 , r ) ψ ref dd u ∗ ( r 1 , r 2 , r ′ ) , (94)
R d ( r , r ′ ) = ∫ r 2 , r 3 ψ r e f d d u ( r , r 2 , r 3 ) ψ r e f d d u ∗ ( r ′ , r 2 , r 3 ) , (95) R_d(\boldsymbol{r},\boldsymbol{r}')=\int_{\boldsymbol{r}_2,\boldsymbol{r}_3}\psi_{\mathrm{ref}}^{ddu}(\boldsymbol{r},\boldsymbol{r}_2,\boldsymbol{r}_3)\psi_{\mathrm{ref}}^{ddu*}(\boldsymbol{r}',\boldsymbol{r}_2,\boldsymbol{r}_3), \tag*{(95)} R d ( r , r ′ ) = ∫ r 2 , r 3 ψ ref dd u ( r , r 2 , r 3 ) ψ ref dd u ∗ ( r ′ , r 2 , r 3 ) , (95)
where the equality of the two d d d -quark kernels follows from the 1 ↔ 2 1\leftrightarrow2 1 ↔ 2 symmetry of the reference orbital wave function. The interference terms between ∣ χ 0 ⟩ \lvert\chi_0\rangle ∣ χ 0 ⟩ and ∣ χ − 1 ⟩ \lvert\chi_{-1}\rangle ∣ χ − 1 ⟩ vanish in the spin-diagonal one-body density matrix after tracing over the other two quarks.
After summing over spin, the flavor-resolved one-body kernels are
Γ u ( r , r ′ ) = R u ( r , r ′ ) , Γ d ( r , r ′ ) = 2 R d ( r , r ′ ) , (96) \Gamma_u(\boldsymbol{r},\boldsymbol{r}')=R_u(\boldsymbol{r},\boldsymbol{r}'),\qquad\Gamma_d(\boldsymbol{r},\boldsymbol{r}')=2R_d(\boldsymbol{r},\boldsymbol{r}'), \tag*{(96)} Γ u ( r , r ′ ) = R u ( r , r ′ ) , Γ d ( r , r ′ ) = 2 R d ( r , r ′ ) , (96)
and hence
Tr Γ u = 1 , Tr Γ d = 2. (97) \operatorname{Tr}\Gamma_u=1,\qquad\operatorname{Tr}\Gamma_d=2. \tag*{(97)} Tr Γ u = 1 , Tr Γ d = 2. (97)
For the analysis of the momentum distribution of a single quark, it is convenient to introduce density matrices normalized to unity,
ρ K u ( r , r ′ ) ≡ Γ u ( r , r ′ ) = R u ( r , r ′ ) , (98) \rho_K^u(\boldsymbol{r},\boldsymbol{r}')\equiv\Gamma_u(\boldsymbol{r},\boldsymbol{r}')=R_u(\boldsymbol{r},\boldsymbol{r}'), \tag*{(98)} ρ K u ( r , r ′ ) ≡ Γ u ( r , r ′ ) = R u ( r , r ′ ) , (98)
and
ρ K d ( r , r ′ ) ≡ 1 2 Γ d ( r , r ′ ) = R d ( r , r ′ ) , (99) \rho_K^d(\boldsymbol{r},\boldsymbol{r}')\equiv\frac{1}{2}\Gamma_d(\boldsymbol{r},\boldsymbol{r}')=R_d(\boldsymbol{r},\boldsymbol{r}'), \tag*{(99)} ρ K d ( r , r ′ ) ≡ 2 1 Γ d ( r , r ′ ) = R d ( r , r ′ ) , (99)
so that
Tr ρ K u = Tr ρ K d = 1. (100) \operatorname{Tr}\rho_K^u=\operatorname{Tr}\rho_K^d=1. \tag*{(100)} Tr ρ K u = Tr ρ K d = 1. (100)
Wave functions and single-quark momentum distributions
Using the explicit reference orbital wave function Eq. (31) , we now evaluate the normalized single-quark density matrices ρ K i \rho_K^i ρ K i . For ρ K i \rho_K^i ρ K i (i = u , d i=u,d i = u , d ), explicit calculations yield
ρ K i ( r ; r ′ ) = ∣ N i ∣ 2 e i Ξ K i ( r ⊥ , r ⊥ ′ ) e i k ⊥ i ⋅ ξ ⊥ − A ⊥ i ξ ⊥ 2 ⊗ e i k z i ξ z − A z i ξ z 2 = ρ K ⊥ i ρ K z i , (101) \rho_K^i(\boldsymbol{r};\boldsymbol{r}')=\lvert\mathcal{N}_i\rvert^2 e^{i\Xi_K^i(\boldsymbol{r}_{\perp},\boldsymbol{r}'_{\perp})}e^{i\boldsymbol{k}_{\perp}^i\cdot\boldsymbol{\xi}_{\perp}-A_{\perp}^i\xi_{\perp}^2}\otimes e^{ik_z^i\xi_z-A_z^i\xi_z^2}=\rho_{K_{\perp}}^i\rho_{K_z}^i, \tag*{(101)} ρ K i ( r ; r ′ ) = ∣ N i ∣ 2 e i Ξ K i ( r ⊥ , r ⊥ ′ ) e i k ⊥ i ⋅ ξ ⊥ − A ⊥ i ξ ⊥ 2 ⊗ e i k z i ξ z − A z i ξ z 2 = ρ K ⊥ i ρ K z i , (101)
where ξ = r − r ′ \boldsymbol{\xi}=\boldsymbol{r}-\boldsymbol{r}' ξ = r − r ′ and N i = ( L z S ⊥ ) − 1 / 2 \mathcal{N}_i=(L_zS_{\perp})^{-1/2} N i = ( L z S ⊥ ) − 1/2 , with L z L_z L z the size in z z z -direction and S ⊥ S_{\perp} S ⊥ the transverse area, so that tr [ ρ K i ] = 1 \operatorname{tr}[\rho_K^i]=1 tr [ ρ K i ] = 1 . Accordingly, the transverse and longitudinal parts scale as ρ K i ∝ 1 / S ⊥ \rho_K^i\propto1/S_{\perp} ρ K i ∝ 1/ S ⊥ and ρ K i ∝ 1 / L z \rho_K^i\propto1/L_z ρ K i ∝ 1/ L z , respectively. The density matrix factorizes into the transverse and longitudinal parts. Functions in the exponent are (i = u , d i=u,d i = u , d )
Ξ K i ( r ⊥ , r ⊥ ′ ) = − e i B 2 ⋅ ( r ⊥ × r ⊥ ′ ) , k i = ( m α B q 2 + 3 m α K ⊥ , K z 3 ) , \Xi_K^i(\boldsymbol{r}_{\perp},\boldsymbol{r}'_{\perp})=-\frac{e_i\boldsymbol{B}}{2}\cdot(\boldsymbol{r}_{\perp}\times\boldsymbol{r}'_{\perp}),\qquad\boldsymbol{k}^i=\left(\frac{m\alpha}{B_q^2+3m\alpha}\boldsymbol{K}_{\perp},\frac{K_z}{3}\right), Ξ K i ( r ⊥ , r ⊥ ′ ) = − 2 e i B ⋅ ( r ⊥ × r ⊥ ′ ) , k i = ( B q 2 + 3 m α m α K ⊥ , 3 K z ) ,
A z i = m α 6 , A ⊥ u = 1 4 ( B λ + B q 2 B λ ) , A ⊥ d = 1 16 ( B ρ + B λ + B q 2 B ρ + B q 2 B λ ) . (102) A_z^i=\sqrt{\frac{m\alpha}{6}},\qquad A_{\perp}^u=\frac{1}{4}\left(B_{\lambda}+\frac{B_q^2}{B_{\lambda}}\right),\qquad A_{\perp}^d=\frac{1}{16}\left(B_{\rho}+B_{\lambda}+\frac{B_q^2}{B_{\rho}}+\frac{B_q^2}{B_{\lambda}}\right). \tag*{(102)} A z i = 6 m α , A ⊥ u = 4 1 ( B λ + B λ B q 2 ) , A ⊥ d = 16 1 ( B ρ + B λ + B ρ B q 2 + B λ B q 2 ) . (102)
The density matrix is not diagonal for ( r , r ′ ) (\boldsymbol{r},\boldsymbol{r}') ( r , r ′ ) .
The one-body density matrix contains the complete information on the single-quark distribution. For an arbitrary normalized one-particle state ∣ a ⟩ \lvert a\rangle ∣ a ⟩ , the diagonal matrix element ⟨ a ∣ ρ ^ K i ∣ a ⟩ \langle a\lvert\hat{\rho}_K^i\lvert a\rangle ⟨ a ∣ ρ ^ K i ∣ a ⟩ gives the probability for the quark to occupy that state. It is therefore useful first to diagonalize ρ ^ K i \hat{\rho}_K^i ρ ^ K i ,
ρ ^ K i = ∑ b F b ; K i ∣ b ; K ⟩ ⟨ b ; K ∣ , (103) \hat{\rho}_K^i=\sum_b F_{b;K}^i\lvert b;K\rangle\langle b;K\rvert, \tag*{(103)} ρ ^ K i = b ∑ F b ; K i ∣ b ; K ⟩ ⟨ b ; K ∣ , (103)
where ∣ b ; K ⟩ \lvert b;K\rangle ∣ b ; K ⟩ denotes an eigenstate of the one-body density matrix. Then,
⟨ a ∣ ρ ^ K i ∣ a ⟩ = ∑ b F b ; K i ∣ ⟨ a ∣ b ; K ⟩ ∣ 2 . (104) \langle a\lvert\hat{\rho}_K^i\lvert a\rangle=\sum_b F_{b;K}^i\lvert\langle a\lvert b;K\rangle\rvert^2. \tag*{(104)} ⟨ a ∣ ρ ^ K i ∣ a ⟩ = b ∑ F b ; K i ∣⟨ a ∣ b ; K ⟩ ∣ 2 . (104)
Thus, the eigenstates ∣ b ; K ⟩ \lvert b;K\rangle ∣ b ; K ⟩ form the natural one-particle basis, and the corresponding eigenvalues F b ; K i F_{b;K}^i F b ; K i give the occupation probabilities in that basis. The distribution in any other basis, with basis states denoted by ∣ a ⟩ \lvert a\rangle ∣ a ⟩ , is obtained by projecting ρ ^ K i \hat{\rho}_K^i ρ ^ K i onto that basis. We will subsequently express these probabilities in the momentum basis along the magnetic field and in a fixed Landau basis in the transverse plane.
The natural-state label b b b introduced above is resolved here into transverse and longitudinal quantum numbers. Since ρ K i \rho_K^i ρ K i factorizes into transverse and longitudinal parts, the corresponding eigenvalue problems can be solved independently:
∫ r ⊥ ρ K ⊥ i ( r ⊥ , r ⊥ ′ ) ψ n ⊥ ; K ⊥ i ( r ⊥ ′ ) = F n ⊥ ; K ⊥ i S ⊥ ψ n ⊥ ; K ⊥ i ( r ⊥ ) , \int_{\boldsymbol{r}_{\perp}}\rho_{K_{\perp}}^i(\boldsymbol{r}_{\perp},\boldsymbol{r}'_{\perp})\psi_{n_{\perp};K_{\perp}}^i(\boldsymbol{r}'_{\perp})=\frac{F_{n_{\perp};K_{\perp}}^i}{S_{\perp}}\psi_{n_{\perp};K_{\perp}}^i(\boldsymbol{r}_{\perp}), ∫ r ⊥ ρ K ⊥ i ( r ⊥ , r ⊥ ′ ) ψ n ⊥ ; K ⊥ i ( r ⊥ ′ ) = S ⊥ F n ⊥ ; K ⊥ i ψ n ⊥ ; K ⊥ i ( r ⊥ ) ,
∫ z ′ ρ K z i ( z − z ′ ) ψ n z ; K z i ( z ′ ) = F n z ; K z i L z ψ n z ; K z i ( z ) . (105) \int_{z'}\rho_{K_z}^i(z-z')\psi_{n_z;K_z}^i(z')=\frac{F_{n_z;K_z}^i}{L_z}\psi_{n_z;K_z}^i(z). \tag*{(105)} ∫ z ′ ρ K z i ( z − z ′ ) ψ n z ; K z i ( z ′ ) = L z F n z ; K z i ψ n z ; K z i ( z ) . (105)
These eigenfunctions, ψ n ⊥ ; K ⊥ i \psi_{n_{\perp};K_{\perp}}^i ψ n ⊥ ; K ⊥ i and ψ n z ; K z i \psi_{n_z;K_z}^i ψ n z ; K z i , are the coordinate-space representations of the natural one-particle states ∣ b ; K ⟩ \lvert b;K\rangle ∣ b ; K ⟩ introduced above. For each flavor i = u , d i=u,d i = u , d , the transverse problem is formulated in the Landau basis associated with the charge e i e_i e i , while the longitudinal problem is diagonal in the momentum basis. We discuss the two sectors in turn.
The z-component
The z z z -component is relatively simple because ρ K z i ( z − z ′ ) \rho^i_{K_z}(z-z') ρ K z i ( z − z ′ ) depends only on the coordinate difference. For such cases the natural one-particle eigenstates are the momentum eigenstates,
ψ p z ; K z i ( z ) = e i p z z . (106) \psi^i_{p_z;K_z}(z)=e^{ip_z z}. \tag*{(106)} ψ p z ; K z i ( z ) = e i p z z . (106)
Indeed, substituting this function into Eq. (105) , we obtain
∫ z ′ ρ K z i ( z − z ′ ) e i p z z ′ = [ ∫ z ′ ρ K z i ( z − z ′ ) e − i p z ( z − z ′ ) ] e i p z z = F p z ; K z i L z e i p z z . (107) \int_{z'}\rho^i_{K_z}(z-z')e^{ip_z z'}=\left[\int_{z'}\rho^i_{K_z}(z-z')e^{-ip_z(z-z')}\right]e^{ip_z z}=\frac{F^i_{p_z;K_z}}{L_z}e^{ip_z z}. \tag*{(107)} ∫ z ′ ρ K z i ( z − z ′ ) e i p z z ′ = [ ∫ z ′ ρ K z i ( z − z ′ ) e − i p z ( z − z ′ ) ] e i p z z = L z F p z ; K z i e i p z z . (107)
Thus, after factoring out the finite-volume normalization 1 / L z 1/L_z 1/ L z , the corresponding longitudinal distribution is
F p z , K z i = π A z i exp [ − 1 4 A z i ( p z − K z 3 ) 2 ] ≡ φ i ( p z − K z / 3 ) . (108) F^i_{p_z,K_z}=\sqrt{\frac{\pi}{A^i_z}}\exp\left[-\frac{1}{4A^i_z}\left(p_z-\frac{K_z}{3}\right)^2\right]\equiv\varphi^i\left(p_z-K_z/3\right). \tag*{(108)} F p z , K z i = A z i π exp [ − 4 A z i 1 ( p z − 3 K z ) 2 ] ≡ φ i ( p z − K z /3 ) . (108)
The transverse component
Solving the eigenvalue equation in Eq. (105) for the transverse direction is more complicated than in the z z z direction. Unlike in the z z z direction, ordinary translational invariance is lost, and the momentum basis does not diagonalize the density matrix. There is, however, magnetic translation symmetry [54 , 55 , 56 ] , which allows us to identify a natural basis for the transverse motion.
In the current context, magnetic translation symmetry follows from the conservation of the total pseudomomentum K ^ R \hat{\boldsymbol{K}}_R K ^ R . The full baryon wave function Φ K \Phi_K Φ K and the corresponding density matrix ρ ^ K B \hat{\rho}^B_K ρ ^ K B satisfy
e i K ^ R ⋅ a Φ K = e i K ⋅ a Φ K → e i K ^ R ⋅ a ρ ^ K B e − i K ^ R ⋅ a = e i K ⋅ a ρ ^ K B e − i K ⋅ a = ρ ^ K B . (109) e^{i\hat{\boldsymbol{K}}_R\cdot\boldsymbol{a}}\Phi_K=e^{i\boldsymbol{K}\cdot\boldsymbol{a}}\Phi_K\quad\rightarrow\quad e^{i\hat{\boldsymbol{K}}_R\cdot\boldsymbol{a}}\hat{\rho}^B_K e^{-i\hat{\boldsymbol{K}}_R\cdot\boldsymbol{a}}=e^{i\boldsymbol{K}\cdot\boldsymbol{a}}\hat{\rho}^B_K e^{-i\boldsymbol{K}\cdot\boldsymbol{a}}=\hat{\rho}^B_K. \tag*{(109)} e i K ^ R ⋅ a Φ K = e i K ⋅ a Φ K → e i K ^ R ⋅ a ρ ^ K B e − i K ^ R ⋅ a = e i K ⋅ a ρ ^ K B e − i K ⋅ a = ρ ^ K B . (109)
This invariance of the baryon density matrix is inherited by the one-body reduced density matrix. To see this, we write the total magnetic translation operator as
T a = ∏ j = 1 3 T a ( j ) , T a ( j ) = e i K ^ j ⋅ a , (110) T_{\boldsymbol{a}}=\prod_{j=1}^{3}T_{\boldsymbol{a}}^{(j)},\qquad T_{\boldsymbol{a}}^{(j)}=e^{i\hat{\boldsymbol{K}}_j\cdot\boldsymbol{a}}, \tag*{(110)} T a = j = 1 ∏ 3 T a ( j ) , T a ( j ) = e i K ^ j ⋅ a , (110)
where j = 1 , 2 , 3 j=1,2,3 j = 1 , 2 , 3 denotes the particle slot. For instance, the reduced density matrix for particle slot 1 satisfies
ρ ^ K ( 1 ) = Tr 2 , 3 [ ρ ^ K B ] = Tr 2 , 3 [ T a ρ ^ K B T a † ] = T a ( 1 ) Tr 2 , 3 [ ρ ^ K B ] T a ( 1 ) † , (111) \hat{\rho}^{(1)}_K=\operatorname{Tr}_{2,3}\left[\hat{\rho}^B_K\right]=\operatorname{Tr}_{2,3}\left[T_{\boldsymbol{a}}\hat{\rho}^B_KT_{\boldsymbol{a}}^\dagger\right]=T_{\boldsymbol{a}}^{(1)}\operatorname{Tr}_{2,3}\left[\hat{\rho}^B_K\right]T_{\boldsymbol{a}}^{(1)\dagger}, \tag*{(111)} ρ ^ K ( 1 ) = Tr 2 , 3 [ ρ ^ K B ] = Tr 2 , 3 [ T a ρ ^ K B T a † ] = T a ( 1 ) Tr 2 , 3 [ ρ ^ K B ] T a ( 1 ) † , (111)
where the unitary transformations acting on the traced-out particle slots drop out by the invariance of the partial trace. Thus,
T a ( j ) ρ ^ K ( j ) T a ( j ) † = ρ ^ K ( j ) . (112) T_{\boldsymbol{a}}^{(j)}\hat{\rho}^{(j)}_K T_{\boldsymbol{a}}^{(j)\dagger}=\hat{\rho}^{(j)}_K. \tag*{(112)} T a ( j ) ρ ^ K ( j ) T a ( j ) † = ρ ^ K ( j ) . (112)
Since the one-particle magnetic translation operator is diagonal in flavor space, we may project this relation onto a definite flavor i = u , d i=u,d i = u , d . Restricting further to the transverse sector, we obtain
T a i ρ ^ K i T a i † = ρ ^ K i , (113) T^i_{\boldsymbol{a}}\hat{\rho}^i_K T^{i\dagger}_{\boldsymbol{a}}=\hat{\rho}^i_K, \tag*{(113)} T a i ρ ^ K i T a i † = ρ ^ K i , (113)
where T a i T^i_{\boldsymbol{a}} T a i is the one-particle magnetic translation operator for a quark of charge e i e_i e i .
Since ρ ^ K i \hat{\rho}^i_K ρ ^ K i commutes with every magnetic translation T a i T^i_{\boldsymbol{a}} T a i , one might try to diagonalize the density matrix together with the magnetic translations. This is, however, not possible for all transverse translations simultaneously, because the magnetic translation operators do not commute with each other. For a charged quark of flavor i i i , they satisfy
T a i T b i = e i e i B ⋅ ( a × b ) T b i T a i . (114) T^i_{\boldsymbol{a}}T^i_{\boldsymbol{b}}=e^{ie_i\boldsymbol{B}\cdot(\boldsymbol{a}\times\boldsymbol{b})}T^i_{\boldsymbol{b}}T^i_{\boldsymbol{a}}. \tag*{(114)} T a i T b i = e i e i B ⋅ ( a × b ) T b i T a i . (114)
Therefore, one cannot construct a common eigenbasis of all transverse magnetic translations. Instead, Eq. (113) constrains the structure of the one-body density matrix through the irreducible representation of the magnetic-translation group.
The transverse one-particle Hilbert space can be separated into two independent sectors,
H ⊥ = H c y c ⊗ H g c . (115) \mathcal{H}_{\perp}=\mathcal{H}_{\mathrm{cyc}}\otimes\mathcal{H}_{\mathrm{gc}}. \tag*{(115)} H ⊥ = H cyc ⊗ H gc . (115)
Here H g c \mathcal{H}_{\mathrm{gc}} H gc is the Hilbert space carrying an irreducible representation of the magnetic-translation algebra, while H c y c \mathcal{H}_{\mathrm{cyc}} H cyc describes the remaining cyclotron degree of freedom, which is invariant under magnetic translations. Hence magnetic translations may be written as
T a i = 1 c y c ⊗ T a , g c i . (116) T_{a}^{i}=1_{\mathrm{cyc}}\otimes T_{a,\mathrm{gc}}^{i}. \tag*{(116)} T a i = 1 cyc ⊗ T a , gc i . (116)
Since the set of operators T a , g c i T_{a,\mathrm{gc}}^{i} T a , gc i forms an irreducible representation on the guiding-center Hilbert space, Schur’s lemma, together with Eq. (113) , implies
ρ ^ K ⊥ i = [ ρ ^ K ⊥ i ] c y c ⊗ 1 g c . (117) \hat{\rho}_{K_{\perp}}^{i}=\left[\hat{\rho}_{K_{\perp}}^{i}\right]_{\mathrm{cyc}}\otimes1_{\mathrm{gc}}. \tag*{(117)} ρ ^ K ⊥ i = [ ρ ^ K ⊥ i ] cyc ⊗ 1 gc . (117)
Thus, each eigenvalue of the one-body density matrix is independent of the guiding-center quantum number. The nontrivial eigenvalue problem resides entirely in the cyclotron sector.
Diagonalizing the matrix ρ ^ K ⊥ i \hat{\rho}_{K_{\perp}}^{i} ρ ^ K ⊥ i is still a nontrivial problem for a general K ⊥ K_{\perp} K ⊥ , but at K ⊥ = 0 K_{\perp}=0 K ⊥ = 0 the problem is much simpler. At K ⊥ = 0 K_{\perp}=0 K ⊥ = 0 , we use the standard Landau basis
∣ n , n ~ ⟩ i = ∣ n ⟩ i c y c ⊗ ∣ n ~ ⟩ i g c . (118) |n,\tilde{n}\rangle_i=|n\rangle_i^{\mathrm{cyc}}\otimes|\tilde{n}\rangle_i^{\mathrm{gc}}. \tag*{(118)} ∣ n , n ~ ⟩ i = ∣ n ⟩ i cyc ⊗ ∣ n ~ ⟩ i gc . (118)
As shown below, this basis also diagonalizes ρ ^ 0 ⊥ i \hat{\rho}_{0\perp}^{i} ρ ^ 0 ⊥ i . Here, n n n is the Landau-level (cyclotron) index, while n ~ \tilde{n} n ~ labels the guiding-center states. We then relate ρ ^ K ⊥ i \hat{\rho}_{K_{\perp}}^{i} ρ ^ K ⊥ i and ρ ^ 0 ⊥ i \hat{\rho}_{0\perp}^{i} ρ ^ 0 ⊥ i via a unitary transformation
ρ ^ K ⊥ i = U i ( K ⊥ ) ρ ^ 0 ⊥ i U i † ( K ⊥ ) , (119) \hat{\rho}_{K_{\perp}}^{i}=U_i(K_{\perp})\hat{\rho}_{0\perp}^{i}U_i^{\dagger}(K_{\perp}), \tag*{(119)} ρ ^ K ⊥ i = U i ( K ⊥ ) ρ ^ 0 ⊥ i U i † ( K ⊥ ) , (119)
where U i ( K ⊥ ) U_i(K_{\perp}) U i ( K ⊥ ) is the momentum-shift operator
U i ( K ⊥ ) = exp [ i κ ⊥ i ( K ) ⋅ r ^ ⊥ ] , ⟨ p ⊥ ∣ U i ( K ⊥ ) = exp [ − κ ⊥ i ( K ) ⋅ ∂ ∂ p ⊥ ] ⟨ p ⊥ ∣ . (120) U_i(K_{\perp})=\exp\left[i\kappa_{\perp}^{i}(K)\cdot\hat{r}_{\perp}\right],\qquad\langle p_{\perp}|U_i(K_{\perp})=\exp\left[-\kappa_{\perp}^{i}(K)\cdot\frac{\partial}{\partial p_{\perp}}\right]\langle p_{\perp}|. \tag*{(120)} U i ( K ⊥ ) = exp [ i κ ⊥ i ( K ) ⋅ r ^ ⊥ ] , ⟨ p ⊥ ∣ U i ( K ⊥ ) = exp [ − κ ⊥ i ( K ) ⋅ ∂ p ⊥ ∂ ] ⟨ p ⊥ ∣. (120)
Since r ^ ⊥ \hat{r}_{\perp} r ^ ⊥ contains both the cyclotron and guiding-center coordinates, U i ( K ⊥ ) U_i(K_{\perp}) U i ( K ⊥ ) acts on both sectors. The explicit computations for the momentum shift are worked out in the next section.
Now we diagonalize ρ ^ 0 ⊥ i \hat{\rho}_{0\perp}^{i} ρ ^ 0 ⊥ i . First we note that the density matrix is diagonal for n ~ \tilde{n} n ~ ,
ρ ^ 0 ⊥ i = [ ρ ^ 0 ⊥ i ] c y c ⊗ 1 g c = ∑ n , n ′ , n ~ [ ρ ^ 0 ⊥ i ] n n ′ ∣ n , n ~ ⟩ i i ⟨ n ′ , n ~ ∣ . (121) \hat{\rho}_{0\perp}^{i}=\left[\hat{\rho}_{0\perp}^{i}\right]_{\mathrm{cyc}}\otimes1_{\mathrm{gc}}=\sum_{n,n',\tilde{n}}\left[\hat{\rho}_{0\perp}^{i}\right]^{nn'}|n,\tilde{n}\rangle_i{}_i\langle n',\tilde{n}|. \tag*{(121)} ρ ^ 0 ⊥ i = [ ρ ^ 0 ⊥ i ] cyc ⊗ 1 gc = n , n ′ , n ~ ∑ [ ρ ^ 0 ⊥ i ] n n ′ ∣ n , n ~ ⟩ i i ⟨ n ′ , n ~ ∣. (121)
since 1 g c = ∑ n ~ ∣ n ~ ⟩ ⟨ n ~ ∣ 1_{\mathrm{gc}}=\sum_{\tilde{n}}|\tilde{n}\rangle\langle\tilde{n}| 1 gc = ∑ n ~ ∣ n ~ ⟩ ⟨ n ~ ∣ .
The last step is to diagonalize the matrix [ ρ ^ 0 ⊥ i ] n n ′ = i ⟨ n , 0 ∣ ρ ^ 0 ⊥ i ∣ n ′ , 0 ⟩ i \left[\hat{\rho}_{0\perp}^{i}\right]^{nn'}={}_i\langle n,0|\hat{\rho}_{0\perp}^{i}|n',0\rangle_i [ ρ ^ 0 ⊥ i ] n n ′ = i ⟨ n , 0∣ ρ ^ 0 ⊥ i ∣ n ′ , 0 ⟩ i where we chose n ~ = 0 \tilde{n}=0 n ~ = 0 as a representative. In the symmetric gauge which we are taking, a state ∣ n , n ~ ⟩ i |n,\tilde{n}\rangle_i ∣ n , n ~ ⟩ i has the angular momentum L z = sgn ( e i B ) ( n ~ − n ) L_z=\operatorname{sgn}(e_iB)(\tilde{n}-n) L z = sgn ( e i B ) ( n ~ − n ) . For fixed n ~ \tilde{n} n ~ , states with different n n n carry different angular momenta. Since ρ ^ 0 ⊥ i \hat{\rho}_{0\perp}^{i} ρ ^ 0 ⊥ i is rotationally invariant, matrix elements between states with different L z L_z L z must vanish. Hence, the matrix is nonzero only for n = n ′ n=n' n = n ′ ,
[ ρ ^ 0 ⊥ i ] n n ′ = δ n n ′ [ ρ ^ 0 ⊥ i ] n n ≡ F n i S ⊥ . (122) \left[\hat{\rho}_{0\perp}^{i}\right]^{nn'}=\delta_{nn'}\left[\hat{\rho}_{0\perp}^{i}\right]^{nn}\equiv\frac{F_n^{i}}{S_{\perp}}. \tag*{(122)} [ ρ ^ 0 ⊥ i ] n n ′ = δ n n ′ [ ρ ^ 0 ⊥ i ] nn ≡ S ⊥ F n i . (122)
Finally, defining ∣ n , n ~ ; K ⊥ ⟩ i ≡ e i K ⊥ ⋅ r ^ i ∣ n , n ~ ⟩ i \lvert n,\tilde n;K_\perp\rangle_i \equiv e^{iK_\perp\cdot\hat r_i}\lvert n,\tilde n\rangle_i ∣ n , n ~ ; K ⊥ ⟩ i ≡ e i K ⊥ ⋅ r ^ i ∣ n , n ~ ⟩ i , we obtain the spectral decomposition
ρ ^ K ⊥ i = 1 S ⊥ ∑ n , n ~ F n i ⊥ ∣ n , n ~ ; K ⊥ ⟩ i i ⟨ n , n ~ ; K ⊥ ∣ . (123) \hat\rho^i_{K_\perp}=\frac{1}{S_\perp}\sum_{n,\tilde n}F^{i\perp}_n\lvert n,\tilde n;K_\perp\rangle_i{}_i\langle n,\tilde n;K_\perp\rvert. \tag*{(123)} ρ ^ K ⊥ i = S ⊥ 1 n , n ~ ∑ F n i ⊥ ∣ n , n ~ ; K ⊥ ⟩ i i ⟨ n , n ~ ; K ⊥ ∣ . (123)
Here, we emphasize that F n i ⊥ / S ⊥ F^{i\perp}_n/S_\perp F n i ⊥ / S ⊥ is an eigenvalue of the one-body density matrix, whose corresponding eigenstate ∣ n , n ~ ; K ⊥ ⟩ i \lvert n,\tilde n;K_\perp\rangle_i ∣ n , n ~ ; K ⊥ ⟩ i depends on K ⊥ K_\perp K ⊥ and it is the superposition of various ∣ m , m ~ ⟩ \lvert m,\tilde m\rangle ∣ m , m ~ ⟩ defined at K ⊥ = 0 K_\perp=0 K ⊥ = 0 . Hence, the quark occupation probability for the Landau bases, i ⟨ n , n ~ ∣ ρ ^ K ⊥ i ∣ n , n ~ ⟩ i {}_i\langle n,\tilde n\lvert\hat\rho^i_{K_\perp}\rvert n,\tilde n\rangle_i i ⟨ n , n ~ ∣ ρ ^ K ⊥ i ∣ n , n ~ ⟩ i , does not correspond to F n i ⊥ / S ⊥ F^{i\perp}_n/S_\perp F n i ⊥ / S ⊥ ; for the former, we need to compute i ⟨ n , n ~ ∣ m , m ~ ; K ⊥ ⟩ i = i ⟨ n , n ~ ∣ U i ( K ⊥ ) ∣ m , m ~ ⟩ i {}_i\langle n,\tilde n\lvert m,\tilde m;K_\perp\rangle_i={}_i\langle n,\tilde n\lvert U_i(K_\perp)\rvert m,\tilde m\rangle_i i ⟨ n , n ~ ∣ m , m ~ ; K ⊥ ⟩ i = i ⟨ n , n ~ ∣ U i ( K ⊥ )∣ m , m ~ ⟩ i , and the matrix element manifestly depends on K ⊥ K_\perp K ⊥ .
The coefficient F n i ⊥ F^{i\perp}_n F n i ⊥ can be explicitly computed as
F n i ⊥ = S ⊥ ∫ r , r ′ ϕ n , 0 i ∗ ( r ) ρ ⊥ i ( r , r ′ ) ϕ n , 0 i ( r ′ ) = 4 π 4 A ⊥ i + ∣ e i B ∣ ( 4 A ⊥ i − ∣ e i B ∣ 4 A ⊥ i + ∣ e i B ∣ ) n , (124) F^{i\perp}_n=S_\perp\int_{r,r'}\phi^{i*}_{n,0}(r)\rho^i_\perp(r,r')\phi^i_{n,0}(r')=\frac{4\pi}{4A^i_\perp+\lvert e_iB\rvert}\left(\frac{4A^i_\perp-\lvert e_iB\rvert}{4A^i_\perp+\lvert e_iB\rvert}\right)^n , \tag*{(124)} F n i ⊥ = S ⊥ ∫ r , r ′ ϕ n , 0 i ∗ ( r ) ρ ⊥ i ( r , r ′ ) ϕ n , 0 i ( r ′ ) = 4 A ⊥ i + ∣ e i B ∣ 4 π ( 4 A ⊥ i + ∣ e i B ∣ 4 A ⊥ i − ∣ e i B ∣ ) n , (124)
where ϕ n , 0 i ( r ) = ⟨ r ∣ n , n ~ = 0 ⟩ i \phi^i_{n,0}(r)=\langle r\lvert n,\tilde n=0\rangle_i ϕ n , 0 i ( r ) = ⟨ r ∣ n , n ~ = 0 ⟩ i is the n n n -th wave function. In the large B B B limit, only the n = 0 n=0 n = 0 component survives, as A ⊥ i ∼ ∣ e i B ∣ / 4 + O ( ( m α ) 2 / ∣ B ∣ 3 ) A^i_\perp\sim\lvert e_iB\rvert/4+O((m\alpha)^2/\lvert B\rvert^3) A ⊥ i ∼ ∣ e i B ∣ /4 + O (( m α ) 2 / ∣ B ∣ 3 ) where O ( 1 / ∣ B ∣ ) O(1/\lvert B\rvert) O ( 1/ ∣ B ∣) terms cancel. The summation over n n n reads
∑ n ~ ∑ n [ ρ ⊥ i ] n ~ n ~ n n = ∣ e i B ∣ 2 π S ⊥ ∑ n [ ρ ⊥ i ] n n = 1 ⟶ ∑ n F n i ⊥ = 2 π ∣ e i B ∣ . (125) \sum_{\tilde n}\sum_n[\rho^i_\perp]^{nn}_{\tilde n\tilde n}=\frac{\lvert e_iB\rvert}{2\pi}S_\perp\sum_n[\rho^i_\perp]^{nn}=1\ \longrightarrow\ \sum_nF^{i\perp}_n=\frac{2\pi}{\lvert e_iB\rvert}. \tag*{(125)} n ~ ∑ n ∑ [ ρ ⊥ i ] n ~ n ~ nn = 2 π ∣ e i B ∣ S ⊥ n ∑ [ ρ ⊥ i ] nn = 1 ⟶ n ∑ F n i ⊥ = ∣ e i B ∣ 2 π . (125)
Here the guiding center index n ~ \tilde n n ~ is limited by S ⊥ / ( 2 π / ∣ e i B ∣ ) S_\perp/(2\pi/\lvert e_iB\rvert) S ⊥ / ( 2 π / ∣ e i B ∣) ; a single state occupies the area 2 π / ∣ e i B ∣ 2\pi/\lvert e_iB\rvert 2 π / ∣ e i B ∣ while the area of the system is S ⊥ S_\perp S ⊥ .
Quark distribution in a Landau basis
Having diagonalized the density matrix, we can obtain the single-quark distribution in any chosen basis by projection. We choose the momentum basis ∣ p z ⟩ \lvert p_z\rangle ∣ p z ⟩ in the z z z direction and the Landau basis ∣ n , n ~ ⟩ \lvert n,\tilde n\rangle ∣ n , n ~ ⟩ in the transverse plane.
For the longitudinal direction, the momentum distribution in a finite box is
F p z i ( K z ) ≡ ⟨ p z ∣ ρ ^ K z i ∣ p z ⟩ = 1 L z F p z ; K z i , (126) \mathcal{F}^i_{p_z}(K_z)\equiv\langle p_z\lvert\hat\rho^i_{K_z}\rvert p_z\rangle=\frac{1}{L_z}F^i_{p_z;K_z}, \tag*{(126)} F p z i ( K z ) ≡ ⟨ p z ∣ ρ ^ K z i ∣ p z ⟩ = L z 1 F p z ; K z i , (126)
which is proportional to the eigenvalue F p z ; K z i F^i_{p_z;K_z} F p z ; K z i .
For the transverse direction, the quark distribution in the Landau basis is
F n n ~ i ( K ⊥ ) ≡ i ⟨ n , n ~ ∣ ρ ^ K ⊥ i ∣ n , n ~ ⟩ i . (127) \mathcal{F}^i_{n\tilde n}(K_\perp)\equiv{}_i\langle n,\tilde n\lvert\hat\rho^i_{K_\perp}\rvert n,\tilde n\rangle_i. \tag*{(127)} F n n ~ i ( K ⊥ ) ≡ i ⟨ n , n ~ ∣ ρ ^ K ⊥ i ∣ n , n ~ ⟩ i . (127)
Explicitly,
F n n ~ i ( K ⊥ ) = 1 S ⊥ ∑ m , m ~ F m i ⊥ ∣ i ⟨ n , n ~ ∣ U i ( K ⊥ ) ∣ m , m ~ ⟩ i ∣ 2 . (128) \mathcal{F}^i_{n\tilde n}(K_\perp)=\frac{1}{S_\perp}\sum_{m,\tilde m}F^{i\perp}_m\left\lvert{}_i\langle n,\tilde n\lvert U_i(K_\perp)\rvert m,\tilde m\rangle_i\right\rvert^2. \tag*{(128)} F n n ~ i ( K ⊥ ) = S ⊥ 1 m , m ~ ∑ F m i ⊥ ∣ i ⟨ n , n ~ ∣ U i ( K ⊥ )∣ m , m ~ ⟩ i ∣ 2 . (128)
The eigenvalues F m i ⊥ F^{i\perp}_m F m i ⊥ themselves are independent of K ⊥ K_\perp K ⊥ , and the K ⊥ K_\perp K ⊥ -dependence appears through the unitary operator U i ( K ⊥ ) U_i(K_\perp) U i ( K ⊥ ) . To evaluate the matrix element i ⟨ n , n ~ ∣ U i ( K ⊥ ) ∣ m , m ~ ⟩ i {}_i\langle n,\tilde n\lvert U_i(K_\perp)\rvert m,\tilde m\rangle_i i ⟨ n , n ~ ∣ U i ( K ⊥ )∣ m , m ~ ⟩ i , it is useful to decompose r ^ i \hat r_i r ^ i into the cyclotron η i \eta_i η i and guiding-center coordinates X i X_i X i
η ^ i = z ^ × Π ^ i e i B , X ^ i = r ^ i ⊥ − η ^ i . (129) \hat\eta_i=\frac{\hat z\times\hat\Pi_i}{e_iB},\qquad\hat X_i=\hat r_{i\perp}-\hat\eta_i. \tag*{(129)} η ^ i = e i B z ^ × Π ^ i , X ^ i = r ^ i ⊥ − η ^ i . (129)
which act on H i c y c \mathcal{H}^{\mathrm{cyc}}_i H i cyc and H i g c \mathcal{H}^{\mathrm{gc}}_i H i gc , respectively. They satisfy
[ η ^ i x , η ^ i y ] = i e i B , [ X ^ i x , X ^ i y ] = − i e i B , [ X ^ i x , η ^ i y ] = 0. (130) [\hat\eta^x_i,\hat\eta^y_i]=\frac{i}{e_iB},\qquad[\hat X^x_i,\hat X^y_i]=-\frac{i}{e_iB},\qquad[\hat X^x_i,\hat\eta^y_i]=0. \tag*{(130)} [ η ^ i x , η ^ i y ] = e i B i , [ X ^ i x , X ^ i y ] = − e i B i , [ X ^ i x , η ^ i y ] = 0. (130)
Thus, the cyclotron and guiding-center coordinates form two mutually commuting oscillator algebras. Since
U i ( K ⊥ ) = exp [ i κ ⊥ i ⋅ r ^ i ⊥ ] , (131) U_i(K_\perp)=\exp\left[i\kappa_\perp^i\cdot\hat{r}_{i\perp}\right], \tag*{(131)} U i ( K ⊥ ) = exp [ i κ ⊥ i ⋅ r ^ i ⊥ ] , (131)
the decomposition r ^ i ⊥ = X ^ i + η ^ i \hat{r}_{i\perp}=\hat{X}_i+\hat{\eta}_i r ^ i ⊥ = X ^ i + η ^ i gives
U i = exp [ i κ ⊥ i ⋅ η ^ i ] exp [ i κ ⊥ i ⋅ X ^ i ] , (132) U_i=\exp\left[i\kappa_\perp^i\cdot\hat{\eta}_i\right]\exp\left[i\kappa_\perp^i\cdot\hat{X}_i\right], \tag*{(132)} U i = exp [ i κ ⊥ i ⋅ η ^ i ] exp [ i κ ⊥ i ⋅ X ^ i ] , (132)
we find
i ⟨ n , n ~ ∣ U i ∣ m , m ~ ⟩ i = ⟨ n ∣ exp [ i κ ⊥ i ⋅ η ^ i ] ∣ m ⟩ i g c ⟨ n ~ ∣ exp [ i κ ⊥ i ⋅ X ^ i ] ∣ m ~ ⟩ i g c . (133) {}_i\langle n,\widetilde{n}|U_i|m,\widetilde{m}\rangle_i
=\langle n|\exp\left[i\kappa_\perp^i\cdot\hat{\eta}_i\right]|m\rangle_i
\,{}^{\mathrm{gc}}\langle\widetilde{n}|\exp\left[i\kappa_\perp^i\cdot\hat{X}_i\right]|\widetilde{m}\rangle_i^{\mathrm{gc}}. \tag*{(133)} i ⟨ n , n ∣ U i ∣ m , m ⟩ i = ⟨ n ∣ exp [ i κ ⊥ i ⋅ η ^ i ] ∣ m ⟩ i gc ⟨ n ∣ exp [ i κ ⊥ i ⋅ X ^ i ] ∣ m ⟩ i gc . (133)
Actually, for computations of the probability Eq. (128) , it is not necessary to evaluate g c ⟨ n ~ ∣ exp [ i κ ⊥ i ⋅ X ^ i ] ∣ m ~ ⟩ i g c {}^{\mathrm{gc}}\langle\widetilde{n}|\exp\left[i\kappa_\perp^i\cdot\hat{X}_i\right]|\widetilde{m}\rangle_i^{\mathrm{gc}} gc ⟨ n ∣ exp [ i κ ⊥ i ⋅ X ^ i ] ∣ m ⟩ i gc . Noting that the weight F m i ⊥ F_m^{i\perp} F m i ⊥ is independent of the guiding-center quantum number m ~ \widetilde{m} m , we use the completeness in the guiding-center sector, ∑ m ~ ∣ m ~ ⟩ i g c g c ⟨ m ~ ∣ = 1 g c \sum_{\widetilde{m}}|\widetilde{m}\rangle_i^{\mathrm{gc}}{}^{\mathrm{gc}}\langle\widetilde{m}|=1_{\mathrm{gc}} ∑ m ∣ m ⟩ i gc gc ⟨ m ∣ = 1 gc , together with the unitarity of exp [ i κ ⊥ i ⋅ X ^ i ] \exp\left[i\kappa_\perp^i\cdot\hat{X}_i\right] exp [ i κ ⊥ i ⋅ X ^ i ] . We find
F n ~ n i ( K ⊥ ) = 1 S ⊥ ∑ m F m i ⊥ ∣ ⟨ n ∣ exp [ i κ ⊥ i ⋅ η ^ i ] ∣ m ⟩ i ∣ 2 . (134) F_{\widetilde{n}n}^{i}(K_\perp)=\frac{1}{S_\perp}\sum_m F_m^{i\perp}\left|\langle n|\exp\left[i\kappa_\perp^i\cdot\hat{\eta}_i\right]|m\rangle_i\right|^2. \tag*{(134)} F n n i ( K ⊥ ) = S ⊥ 1 m ∑ F m i ⊥ ⟨ n ∣ exp [ i κ ⊥ i ⋅ η ^ i ] ∣ m ⟩ i 2 . (134)
To compute the matrix element, we note that the η ∼ z ^ × Π \boldsymbol{\eta}\sim\hat{\mathbf{z}}\times\boldsymbol{\Pi} η ∼ z ^ × Π can be expressed in terms of the creation and annihilation operators which raise and lower the quantum number n n n as a ^ i ∣ n ⟩ i = n ∣ n − 1 ⟩ i \hat{a}_i|n\rangle_i=\sqrt{n}|n-1\rangle_i a ^ i ∣ n ⟩ i = n ∣ n − 1 ⟩ i and a ^ i † ∣ n ⟩ i = n + 1 ∣ n + 1 ⟩ i \hat{a}_i^\dagger|n\rangle_i=\sqrt{n+1}|n+1\rangle_i a ^ i † ∣ n ⟩ i = n + 1 ∣ n + 1 ⟩ i . The exponent of exp [ i κ ⊥ i ⋅ η ^ i ] \exp\left[i\kappa_\perp^i\cdot\hat{\eta}_i\right] exp [ i κ ⊥ i ⋅ η ^ i ] can be written as [ s i ≡ sgn ( e i B ) ] [s_i\equiv\operatorname{sgn}(e_iB)] [ s i ≡ sgn ( e i B )]
i κ ⊥ i ⋅ η ^ i = α i a ^ i † − α i ∗ a ^ i , α i = i κ x i − s i κ y i 2 ∣ e i B ∣ . (135) i\kappa_\perp^i\cdot\hat{\eta}_i=\alpha_i\hat{a}_i^\dagger-\alpha_i^*\hat{a}_i,\qquad
\alpha_i=\frac{i\kappa_x^i-s_i\kappa_y^i}{\sqrt{2|e_iB|}}. \tag*{(135)} i κ ⊥ i ⋅ η ^ i = α i a ^ i † − α i ∗ a ^ i , α i = 2∣ e i B ∣ i κ x i − s i κ y i . (135)
We define
W n m ( K ⊥ ) ≡ ∣ ⟨ n ∣ exp [ i κ ⊥ i ⋅ η ^ i ] ∣ m ⟩ i ∣ 2 = e − x i min [ n , m ] ! max [ n , m ] ! x i ∣ n − m ∣ [ L min ( n , m ) ∣ n − m ∣ ( x i ) ] 2 , (136) \mathcal{W}_{nm}(K_\perp)\equiv\left|\langle n|\exp\left[i\kappa_\perp^i\cdot\hat{\eta}_i\right]|m\rangle_i\right|^2
=e^{-x_i}\frac{\min[n,m]!}{\max[n,m]!}x_i^{|n-m|}
\left[L_{\min(n,m)}^{|n-m|}(x_i)\right]^2, \tag*{(136)} W nm ( K ⊥ ) ≡ ⟨ n ∣ exp [ i κ ⊥ i ⋅ η ^ i ] ∣ m ⟩ i 2 = e − x i max [ n , m ]! min [ n , m ]! x i ∣ n − m ∣ [ L m i n ( n , m ) ∣ n − m ∣ ( x i ) ] 2 , (136)
where L n α L_n^\alpha L n α is the associated Laguerre polynomial and x i ≡ ( κ ⊥ i ) 2 / 2 ∣ e i B ∣ x_i\equiv(\kappa_\perp^i)^2/2|e_iB| x i ≡ ( κ ⊥ i ) 2 /2∣ e i B ∣ as a function of K ⊥ K_\perp K ⊥ .
The transverse distribution in the fixed Landau basis then takes the form
F n ~ n ~ i ( K ⊥ ) = 1 S ⊥ ∑ m F m i W n m ( K ⊥ ) ≡ ϕ K ⊥ i ⊥ ( n ) S ⊥ . (137) \mathcal{F}_{\tilde n\tilde n}^{i}(K_\perp)=\frac{1}{S_\perp}\sum_m\mathcal{F}_{m}^{i}W_{nm}(K_\perp)\equiv\frac{\phi_{K_\perp}^{i\perp}(n)}{S_\perp}. \tag*{(137)} F n ~ n ~ i ( K ⊥ ) = S ⊥ 1 m ∑ F m i W nm ( K ⊥ ) ≡ S ⊥ ϕ K ⊥ i ⊥ ( n ) . (137)
where F n ~ n ~ i ( K ⊥ ) \mathcal{F}_{\tilde n\tilde n}^{i}(K_\perp) F n ~ n ~ i ( K ⊥ ) is independent of n ~ \tilde n n ~ . Figure 4 illustrates the transverse single-quark distribution for parameter set B at K ⊥ = 0 K_\perp=0 K ⊥ = 0 . As the magnetic field increases, the distribution becomes increasingly concentrated in the lowest Landau level. The approach to the lowest-Landau-level regime differs between the u u u and d d d quarks because their transverse density matrices involve different charges and widths.
Figure 4. Landau-level distribution of a single quark in the lowest neutral-baryon state for parameter set B at K ⊥ = 0 K_\perp=0 K ⊥ = 0 . The left and right panels show the u u u - and d d d -quark distributions, respectively. We plot P n i = ∣ e i B ∣ ∣ ϕ K ⊥ i ( n ) ∣ 2 / 2 π P_n^i=|e_iB|\lvert\phi_{K_\perp}^i(n)\rvert^2/2\pi P n i = ∣ e i B ∣ ∣ ϕ K ⊥ i ( n ) ∣ 2 /2 π for ∣ e B ∣ = 0.05 |eB|=0.05 ∣ e B ∣ = 0.05 , 0.10 0.10 0.10 , and 0.20 G e V 2 0.20\,\mathrm{GeV}^2 0.20 GeV 2 . As the magnetic field increases, the distribution becomes increasingly concentrated in the lowest Landau level.
The dependence on the baryon transverse pseudomomentum is illustrated in Figure 5 for ∣ e B ∣ = 0.05 G e V 2 \lvert eB\rvert=0.05\,\mathrm{GeV}^2 ∣ e B ∣ = 0.05 GeV 2 . As K ⊥ K_\perp K ⊥ increases, the unitary shift U i ( K ⊥ ) U_i(K_\perp) U i ( K ⊥ ) mixes different Landau levels, and the probability is gradually redistributed from the lowest Landau level to higher levels. The detailed redistribution differs between the u u u and d d d quarks because the overlap factor W n m ( K ⊥ ) W_{nm}(K_\perp) W nm ( K ⊥ ) depends on the quark charge through both κ ⊥ i \kappa_\perp^i κ ⊥ i and ∣ e i B ∣ \lvert e_iB\rvert ∣ e i B ∣ .
Figure 5. Dependence of the single-quark Landau-level occupation probabilities on the transverse baryon pseudomomentum K ⊥ K_\perp K ⊥ for parameter set B at ∣ e B ∣ = 0.05 G e V 2 \lvert eB\rvert= 0.05\,\mathrm{GeV}^2 ∣ e B ∣ = 0.05 GeV 2 . The left and right panels show the u u u - and d d d -quark distributions, respectively. We plot P n i ( K ⊥ ) = ∣ e i B ∣ ϕ K ⊥ i ⊥ ( n ) / 2 π P_n^i(K_\perp)=\lvert e_iB\rvert\phi_{K_\perp}^{i\perp}(n)/2\pi P n i ( K ⊥ ) = ∣ e i B ∣ ϕ K ⊥ i ⊥ ( n ) /2 π for the Landau levels n = 0 , 1 , 2 , n=0,1,2, n = 0 , 1 , 2 , and 3 3 3 . As K ⊥ K_\perp K ⊥ increases, the occupation probability is redistributed from the lowest Landau level to higher Landau levels.
Since the transverse and longitudinal density matrices factorize, the single-quark distribution in a baryon with pseudomomentum K K K is
ϕ K i ( n , p z ) = ϕ K ⊥ i ⊥ ( n ) ϕ i ( p z − K z / 3 ) . (138) \phi_K^i(n,p_z)=\phi_{K_\perp}^{i\perp}(n)\,\phi^i(p_z-K_z/3). \tag*{(138)} ϕ K i ( n , p z ) = ϕ K ⊥ i ⊥ ( n ) ϕ i ( p z − K z /3 ) . (138)
The volume-independent distribution is normalized with the Landau-level phase-space measure as
∣ e i B ∣ 2 π ∑ n ∫ d p z 2 π ϕ K i ( n , p z ) = 1 , (139) \frac{\lvert e_iB\rvert}{2\pi}\sum_n\int\frac{dp_z}{2\pi}\,\phi_K^i(n,p_z)=1, \tag*{(139)} 2 π ∣ e i B ∣ n ∑ ∫ 2 π d p z ϕ K i ( n , p z ) = 1 , (139)
where we used
∑ n W n m ( K ⊥ ) = 1 , ∑ m F m i = 2 π ∣ e i B ∣ , ∫ p z ϕ i ( p z − K z / 3 ) = 1. (140) \sum_n W_{nm}(K_\perp)=1,\qquad\sum_m\mathcal{F}_m^i=\frac{2\pi}{\lvert e_iB\rvert},\qquad\int_{p_z}\phi^i(p_z-K_z/3)=1. \tag*{(140)} n ∑ W nm ( K ⊥ ) = 1 , m ∑ F m i = ∣ e i B ∣ 2 π , ∫ p z ϕ i ( p z − K z /3 ) = 1. (140)
Baryon and quark occupation probabilities
Sum rules
We now construct the quark occupation probabilities in baryonic matter. We denote the baryon eigenstates by b b b in which the spin-flavor and orbital quantum numbers are all distinguished, the quark spin-flavor species by i = ( u ↑ , u ↓ , d ↑ , d ↓ , ⋯ ) i=(u_\uparrow,u_\downarrow,d_\uparrow,d_\downarrow,\cdots) i = ( u ↑ , u ↓ , d ↑ , d ↓ , ⋯ ) , and the quark Landau-level index by n n n . We emphasize that, at finite B B B , the usual baryon classification, ( n ↑ , p ↑ , ⋯ ) (n_\uparrow,p_\uparrow,\cdots) ( n ↑ , p ↑ , ⋯ ) and so on, no longer holds. The single-quark distribution inside a baryon, derived in § 3 , is denoted by
ϕ K i / b ( n , p z ) , (141) \phi_K^{i/b}(n,p_z), \tag*{(141)} ϕ K i / b ( n , p z ) , (141)
where K = ( K ⊥ , K z ) K=(K_\perp,K_z) K = ( K ⊥ , K z ) is the baryon (pseudo)momentum. The occupation probability of a baryon state ( b , K ) (b,K) ( b , K ) is denoted by f b ( K ) f_b(K) f b ( K ) .
The spin-flavor factors N i b ( K ) N_i^b(K) N i b ( K ) entering the convolution are determined by the spin composition of the baryon state discussed in § 2.3 . Figure 6 illustrates these factors for the lowest n ~ ↓ \tilde n_\downarrow n ~ ↓ branch at K = 0 K=0 K = 0 for parameter set B. At B = 0 B=0 B = 0 , the neutron spin-flavor wave function gives
Figure 6. Spin-flavor baryon-number fractions N i b N_i^b N i b in the lowest n ~ ↓ \tilde n_{\downarrow} n ~ ↓ branch as functions of the magnetic field for parameter set B at K = 0 K=0 K = 0 . At B = 0 B=0 B = 0 , the fractions are N u ↑ = 2 / 9 N_{u_\uparrow}=2/9 N u ↑ = 2/9 , N u ↓ = N d ↑ = 1 / 9 N_{u_\downarrow}=N_{d_\uparrow}=1/9 N u ↓ = N d ↑ = 1/9 , and N d ↓ = 5 / 9 N_{d_\downarrow}=5/9 N d ↓ = 5/9 . With increasing ∣ e B ∣ |eB| ∣ e B ∣ , the state approaches the strongly polarized configuration d ↓ d ↓ u ↑ d_\downarrow d_\downarrow u_\uparrow d ↓ d ↓ u ↑ , for which N u ↑ → 1 / 3 N_{u_\uparrow}\to1/3 N u ↑ → 1/3 , N u ↓ = N d ↑ → 0 N_{u_\downarrow}=N_{d_\uparrow}\to0 N u ↓ = N d ↑ → 0 , and N d ↓ → 2 / 3 N_{d_\downarrow}\to2/3 N d ↓ → 2/3 .
N u ↑ = 2 9 , N u ↓ = N d ↑ = 1 9 , N d ↓ = 5 9 . (142) N_{u_\uparrow}=\frac{2}{9},\qquad N_{u_\downarrow}=N_{d_\uparrow}=\frac{1}{9},\qquad N_{d_\downarrow}=\frac{5}{9}. \tag*{(142)} N u ↑ = 9 2 , N u ↓ = N d ↑ = 9 1 , N d ↓ = 9 5 . (142)
As the magnetic field increases, the baryon becomes increasingly polarized toward the d ↓ d ↓ u ↑ d_\downarrow d_\downarrow u_\uparrow d ↓ d ↓ u ↑ configuration. Consequently,
N u ↑ → 1 3 , N u ↓ , N d ↑ → 0 , N d ↓ → 2 3 , B → ∞ . (143) N_{u_\uparrow}\to\frac{1}{3},\qquad N_{u_\downarrow},N_{d_\uparrow}\to0,\qquad N_{d_\downarrow}\to\frac{2}{3},\qquad B\to\infty. \tag*{(143)} N u ↑ → 3 1 , N u ↓ , N d ↑ → 0 , N d ↓ → 3 2 , B → ∞. (143)
This spin-flavor redistribution is important for quark saturation, because it enhances the weight carried by the d ↓ d_\downarrow d ↓ states in the lowest baryon branch.
The quark occupation probability is then obtained by convoluting the baryon distribution with the single-quark distribution
f n i ( p z ) = ∑ b ∫ K N i b ( K ) f b ( K ) ϕ K i / b ( n , p z ) . (144) f_n^i(p_z)=\sum_b\int_K N_i^b(K)f_b(K)\phi_K^{i/b}(n,p_z). \tag*{(144)} f n i ( p z ) = b ∑ ∫ K N i b ( K ) f b ( K ) ϕ K i / b ( n , p z ) . (144)
Figure 7. Fermi-surface cross sections of the ground state baryon, lowest n ~ ↓ \tilde{n}_{\downarrow} n ~ ↓ branch, in the ( K ⊥ , K z ) (K_{\perp},K_z) ( K ⊥ , K z ) plane at μ B = 0.95 G e V \mu_B=0.95\ \mathrm{GeV} μ B = 0.95 GeV for several magnetic fields. With increasing ∣ e B ∣ |eB| ∣ e B ∣ , the occupied region expands as the baryon energy is lowered. The transverse flattening of the single-baryon dispersion produces an increasingly anisotropic Fermi surface elongated in the K ⊥ K_{\perp} K ⊥ direction. Results are for parameter set B.
Since the baryons are color singlets, the three colors contribute equally; for a given color, f n i ≡ [ f n i ] R = [ f n i ] G = [ f n i ] B f_n^i \equiv[f_n^i]^{R} = [f_n^i]^{G} = [f_n^i]^{B} f n i ≡ [ f n i ] R = [ f n i ] G = [ f n i ] B . Here, N i b N_i^b N i b denotes the baryon number (1/3 of quark number) of quarks of species i i i contained in the baryon state b b b . For instance, in a neutron state at B = 0 B=0 B = 0 , the baryon-number fraction carried by each quark species is N n ↑ u + N n ↓ u = 1 / 3 N_{n\uparrow}^{u}+N_{n\downarrow}^{u}=1/3 N n ↑ u + N n ↓ u = 1/3 and N n ↑ d + N n ↓ d = 2 / 3 N_{n\uparrow}^{d}+N_{n\downarrow}^{d}=2/3 N n ↑ d + N n ↓ d = 2/3 , since a neutron with a given spin contains one u u u quark and two d d d quarks. Indeed, integrating the quark distribution for a given color leads to the total baryon number, n B = ∑ i n i R = ∑ i n i G = ∑ i n i B n_B=\sum_i n_i^R=\sum_i n_i^G=\sum_i n_i^B n B = ∑ i n i R = ∑ i n i G = ∑ i n i B ,
n B = ∑ i ∣ e i B ∣ 2 π ∑ n ∫ p z f n i ( p z ) = ∑ i ∑ b ∫ K N i b ( K ) f b ( K ) = ∑ b n b (145) n_B=\sum_i\frac{|e_iB|}{2\pi}\sum_n\int_{p_z} f_n^i(p_z)=\sum_i\sum_b\int_K N_i^b(K)f_b(K)=\sum_b n_b \tag*{(145)} n B = i ∑ 2 π ∣ e i B ∣ n ∑ ∫ p z f n i ( p z ) = i ∑ b ∑ ∫ K N i b ( K ) f b ( K ) = b ∑ n b (145)
where we have used the normalization condition Eq. (139) for φ K i / b \varphi_K^{i/b} φ K i / b and ∑ i N i b ( K ) = 1 \sum_iN_i^b(K)=1 ∑ i N i b ( K ) = 1 for any baryon state b b b and pseudomomentum K K K .
At zero temperature, the baryon states are filled from the lowest energies up to a maximum energy E max E_{\max} E m a x ,
f b ( K ) = Θ ( E max − E b ( K ) ) . (146) f_b(K)=\Theta\left(E_{\max}-E_b(K)\right). \tag*{(146)} f b ( K ) = Θ ( E m a x − E b ( K ) ) . (146)
For an ideal baryon gas before quark saturation occurs, E max = μ B E_{\max}=\mu_B E m a x = μ B .
Ideal baryon gas
Below we consider an ideal baryon gas for which E max = μ B E_{\max}=\mu_B E m a x = μ B . For each baryon branch b b b , the occupied region in pseudomomentum space is determined by
E b ( K ⊥ , K z ) ≤ μ B . (147) E_b(K_{\perp},K_z)\leq\mu_B. \tag*{(147)} E b ( K ⊥ , K z ) ≤ μ B . (147)
We use this occupied phase space to evaluate the baryon density and the corresponding quark occupation probabilities. We define K ⊥ max b K_{\perp\max}^b K ⊥ m a x b by
E b ( K ⊥ max b , 0 ) = μ B , (148) E_b(K_{\perp\max}^b,0)=\mu_B, \tag*{(148)} E b ( K ⊥ m a x b , 0 ) = μ B , (148)
and, for a fixed K ⊥ K_\perp K ⊥ , the maximum of the longitudinal momentum K z , max b ( K ⊥ ) K_{z,\max}^{b}(K_\perp) K z , m a x b ( K ⊥ ) by
E b ( K ⊥ , K z , max b ( K ⊥ ) ) = μ B . (149) E_b\left(K_\perp,K_{z,\max}^{b}(K_\perp)\right)=\mu_B. \tag*{(149)} E b ( K ⊥ , K z , m a x b ( K ⊥ ) ) = μ B . (149)
Accordingly, Eq. (144) can be written as
f n i ( p z ) = ∑ b ∫ 0 K ⊥ , max b K ⊥ d K ⊥ 2 π ∫ − K z , max b ( K ⊥ ) K z , max b ( K ⊥ ) d K z 2 π N j b ( K ) ϕ K i / b ( n , p z ) . (150) f_n^i(p_z)=\sum_b\int_0^{K_{\perp,\max}^{b}}\frac{K_\perp\,\mathrm{d}K_\perp}{2\pi}\int_{-K_{z,\max}^{b}(K_\perp)}^{K_{z,\max}^{b}(K_\perp)}\frac{\mathrm{d}K_z}{2\pi}N_j^b(\mathbf{K})\phi_{\mathbf{K}}^{i/b}(n,p_z). \tag*{(150)} f n i ( p z ) = b ∑ ∫ 0 K ⊥ , m a x b 2 π K ⊥ d K ⊥ ∫ − K z , m a x b ( K ⊥ ) K z , m a x b ( K ⊥ ) 2 π d K z N j b ( K ) ϕ K i / b ( n , p z ) . (150)
The baryon number density is
n B ( μ B ) = 2 ∑ b ∫ 0 K ⊥ , max b K ⊥ d K ⊥ 2 π ∫ 0 K z , max b ( K ⊥ ) d K z 2 π . (151) n_B(\mu_B)=2\sum_b\int_0^{K_{\perp,\max}^{b}}\frac{K_\perp\,\mathrm{d}K_\perp}{2\pi}\int_0^{K_{z,\max}^{b}(K_\perp)}\frac{\mathrm{d}K_z}{2\pi}. \tag*{(151)} n B ( μ B ) = 2 b ∑ ∫ 0 K ⊥ , m a x b 2 π K ⊥ d K ⊥ ∫ 0 K z , m a x b ( K ⊥ ) 2 π d K z . (151)
Quark saturation in magnetic fields
We now examine when the quark occupation probability constructed above reaches unity, its maximum possible value. For a given baryon density and magnetic field, we define the maximum single-quark occupation probability by
f max ( n B , B ) ≡ max i , n , p z f n i ( p z ) . (152) f_{\max}(n_B,B)\equiv\max_{i,n,p_z}f_n^i(p_z). \tag*{(152)} f m a x ( n B , B ) ≡ i , n , p z max f n i ( p z ) . (152)
The quark-saturation density n B q s a t n_B^{\mathrm{qsat}} n B qsat is then defined by
f max ( n B q s a t , B ) = 1. (153) f_{\max}\left(n_B^{\mathrm{qsat}},B\right)=1. \tag*{(153)} f m a x ( n B qsat , B ) = 1. (153)
Below this density, all quark one-particle states have occupation probabilities smaller than unity. Beyond this point, continuing the same baryonic filling would make the occupation of some quark states exceed unity. We therefore use n B q s a t n_B^{\mathrm{qsat}} n B qsat as an estimate of the upper limit of applicability of the purely baryonic description, without making any assumption about the state of matter beyond this point.
The right panel of Figure 8 shows f max f_{\max} f m a x as a function of n B n_B n B for parameter set B. At finite B B B , the d ↓ , n = 0 d_{\downarrow,n=0} d ↓ , n = 0 state reaches saturation first. Figure 9 summarizes the resulting saturation density for parameter sets A–C. For all three sets, n B q s a t n_B^{\mathrm{qsat}} n B qsat first decreases at weak magnetic fields and then increases again at stronger fields.
Figure 8. (Left panel) Baryon density n B n_B n B as a function of the baryon chemical potential μ B \mu_B μ B for an ideal gas of charge-neutral baryons at several magnetic fields. The magnetic field lowers the onset chemical potential of the lowest n ~ ↓ \tilde n_{\downarrow} n ~ ↓ branch and enhances the baryon density at fixed μ B \mu_B μ B . Crosses mark the onset of the n ~ ↑ \tilde n_{\uparrow} n ~ ↑ branch. (Right panel) Maximum quark occupation probability, max i , n , p z f n i ( p z ) \max_{i,n,p_z} f_n^i(p_z) max i , n , p z f n i ( p z ) , as a function of the baryon density. At finite B B B , the maximum occurs in the d ↓ m , n = 0 d_{\downarrow}^{m}, n=0 d ↓ m , n = 0 state. Open circles indicate the quark-saturation density. Results are shown for parameter set B, with n 0 = 0.16 f m − 3 n_0=0.16\ \mathrm{fm}^{-3} n 0 = 0.16 fm − 3 .
Figure 9. Quark-saturation density n B q s a t n_B^{\mathrm{qsat}} n B qsat as a function of the magnetic field for parameter sets A–C. The saturation density is defined by f max ( n B q s a t , B ) = 1 f_{\max}(n_B^{\mathrm{qsat}},B)=1 f m a x ( n B qsat , B ) = 1 , where f max = max i , n , p z f 1 i ( p z ) f_{\max}=\max_{i,n,p_z}f^i_1(p_z) f m a x = max i , n , p z f 1 i ( p z ) . For all three parameter sets, a weak magnetic field initially lowers the saturation density, while stronger fields increase it again, leading to a characteristic nonmonotonic dependence on ∣ e B ∣ |eB| ∣ e B ∣ . The variation among the three curves reflects the sensitivity to the zero-field baryon size.
The turnover reflects a competition between two magnetic-field effects. At relatively weak fields, the spin-flavor polarization of the baryon and the concentration of quarks in the lowest Landau levels enhance the d ↓ d_{\downarrow} d ↓ occupation, leading to quark saturation at lower density. At stronger magnetic fields, however, the internal quark wave function is compressed in the transverse directions, as shown in Figure 2 , suggesting reduced overlap between quark wave functions in neighboring baryons and hence a tendency to delay quark saturation. More precisely, the number of available guiding-center states per unit transverse area increases with ∣ e B ∣ |eB| ∣ e B ∣ , since each guiding-center state occupies a spatial area of order 1 / ∣ e B ∣ 1/|eB| 1/∣ e B ∣ . Consequently, at a given baryon density, the occupation probability of the lowest cyclotron state at each guiding center increases more slowly, delaying quark saturation. These competing effects, spin-flavor polarization and spatial squeezing, produce a minimum in n B q s a t n_B^{\mathrm{qsat}} n B qsat .
Summary
We have studied the onset of quark saturation in magnetized matter composed of electrically neutral d d u ddu dd u baryons. Using a simple constituent-quark model, we first examined the spectra and internal structure of the low-lying neutral baryons in a magnetic field. The magnetic field strongly modifies both the spin-flavor composition and the orbital wave function. In particular, the lowest n ~ ↓ \tilde{n}_{\downarrow} n ~ ↓ branch becomes increasingly polarized toward the d ↓ d ↓ u ↑ d_{\downarrow}d_{\downarrow}u_{\uparrow} d ↓ d ↓ u ↑ configuration. At the same time, the baryon is squeezed in the transverse direction, and its transverse dispersion becomes strongly flattened. The resulting large transverse effective mass indicates an effective dimensional reduction of the baryon dynamics.
Starting from these baryon wave functions, we constructed the one-body reduced density matrix and derived the single-quark distributions. The longitudinal distribution is naturally described in momentum space, while the transverse distribution is expressed in the Landau-level basis. The magnetic field concentrates the quark distribution toward the lowest Landau levels, while the increasing guiding-center degeneracy reduces the occupation probability of each transverse one-particle state. Finite transverse baryon pseudomomentum further redistributes the occupation among different Landau levels.
We then considered an ideal gas of the neutral baryons and evaluated the quark occupation probabilities as the baryon density is increased. Quark saturation is defined by the point at which the maximum single-quark occupation probability reaches unity. At finite magnetic field, the d ↓ d_{\downarrow} d ↓ quark in the lowest Landau level is the first state to reach saturation. The resulting saturation density shows a characteristic nonmonotonic dependence on the magnetic field: it first decreases at weak fields and then increases again at stronger fields. This behavior is found for all parameter sets considered here.
The nonmonotonic behavior reflects a competition between spin-flavor polarization and spatial squeezing. At relatively weak fields, the enhanced d ↓ d_{\downarrow} d ↓ component promotes quark saturation. At stronger fields, transverse compression increases the number of available guiding-center states per unit area and thereby reduces the occupation probability of each transverse one-particle state and delays saturation. Thus, magnetic fields can either reduce or extend the density range over which a purely baryonic description remains applicable. The present analysis does not specify the state of matter beyond quark saturation; determining how quark-level constraints modify dense matter beyond this point is left for future work.
Several extensions of the present framework are worth pursuing. For applications to realistic neutron-star matter, it will be necessary to include additional baryonic species together with leptons under charge-neutrality and beta-equilibrium conditions, and to go beyond the ideal baryon gas by incorporating realistic baryon-baryon interactions. The inclusion of charged baryons requires an additional extension, since their transverse center-of-mass motion is itself Landau quantized and cannot be characterized by the commuting pseudomomentum components used for the neutral baryons considered here.
Finite-temperature effects require a more substantial extension. In addition to thermal smearing of the occupation probabilities, thermally excited baryons, mesonic excitations, particle-hole excitations, and higher Landau levels may become important. A consistent treatment of such excited states will likely require a relativistic formulation [26 , 57 ] , since the magnetic-field dependence of states involving higher Landau levels of quarks can differ qualitatively from that of the low-lying states considered in the present nonrelativistic framework. Developing such a relativistic finite-temperature description is therefore an important direction for future work.
Another interesting direction is to test the present mechanism in theories accessible to first-principles calculations at finite density. Two-color QCD provides one such setting, where the absence of the sign problem can be maintained even in an external magnetic field for suitable choices of the quark electric charges [58 , 59 ] . Recent lattice studies have explored its finite-density phase structure, equation of state, and hadron spectrum [60 , 61 , 62 , 63 ] . QCD at finite isospin chemical potential provides another useful laboratory without a sign problem at vanishing magnetic field [64 , 65 , 66 , 67 , 68 ] , although the introduction of an external magnetic field with physical quark charges generally requires additional care [69 ] .
Complementarily, substantial progress has recently been made in dense QCD in ( 1 + 1 ) (1+1) ( 1 + 1 ) dimensions using tensor-network methods. In these calculations, quark momentum distributions and the formation of quark Fermi seas can be studied directly [70 , 71 ] . Such lower-dimensional theories may therefore provide a particularly useful setting for investigating the microscopic relation between quark occupation, baryonic degrees of freedom, and quark saturation.
Matrix elements
For the lowest orbital state, the expectation values of the short-range interactions can be reduced to one-dimensional integrals. For the d d dd dd pair,
r 12 = − ρ , (154) r_{12}=-\rho, \tag*{(154)} r 12 = − ρ , (154)
while for the two u d ud u d pairs,
r 13 = − λ − ρ 2 , r 23 = − λ + ρ 2 . (155) r_{13}=-\lambda-\frac{\rho}{2},\qquad r_{23}=-\lambda+\frac{\rho}{2}. \tag*{(155)} r 13 = − λ − 2 ρ , r 23 = − λ + 2 ρ . (155)
The two u d ud u d matrix elements are identical because of the ρ → − ρ \rho\to-\rho ρ → − ρ symmetry. The transverse displacement relevant for the u d ud u d pairs is
λ 0 2 ≡ ∣ λ ⊥ 0 ∣ 2 = B q 2 K ⊥ 2 4 ( B q 2 + 3 m α ) 2 . (156) \lambda_0^2\equiv\left|\lambda_\perp^0\right|^2=\frac{B_q^2K_\perp^2}{4\left(B_q^2+3m\alpha\right)^2}. \tag*{(156)} λ 0 2 ≡ λ ⊥ 0 2 = 4 ( B q 2 + 3 m α ) 2 B q 2 K ⊥ 2 . (156)
Color-electric interaction
For the color-electric interaction, we use
1 r = 1 π ∫ 0 ∞ d s s e − s r 2 , (157) \frac{1}{r}=\frac{1}{\sqrt{\pi}}\int_0^\infty\frac{ds}{\sqrt{s}}e^{-sr^2}, \tag*{(157)} r 1 = π 1 ∫ 0 ∞ s d s e − s r 2 , (157)
and define
Y E ( a , c , r 0 ) ≡ 1 π ∫ 0 ∞ d s s 1 ( 1 + a s ) 1 + c s exp [ − s r 0 2 1 + a s ] . (158) \mathcal{Y}_E(a,c,r_0)\equiv\frac{1}{\sqrt{\pi}}\int_0^\infty\frac{ds}{\sqrt{s}}\frac{1}{(1+as)\sqrt{1+cs}}\exp\left[-\frac{sr_0^2}{1+as}\right]. \tag*{(158)} Y E ( a , c , r 0 ) ≡ π 1 ∫ 0 ∞ s d s ( 1 + a s ) 1 + cs 1 exp [ − 1 + a s s r 0 2 ] . (158)
The color-electric matrix elements are
⟨ ν d d E ⟩ 0 K = − 2 3 α s ( Q d d ) Y E ( β d d ⊥ , β d d z , 0 ) , ⟨ ν u d E ⟩ 0 K = − 2 3 α s ( Q u d ) Y E ( β u d ⊥ , β u d z , λ 0 ) . (159) \begin{aligned}
\left\langle\nu_{dd}^E\right\rangle_0^K&=-\frac{2}{3}\alpha_s(Q_{dd})\mathcal{Y}_E\left(\beta_{dd}^{\perp},\beta_{dd}^{z},0\right),\\
\left\langle\nu_{ud}^E\right\rangle_0^K&=-\frac{2}{3}\alpha_s(Q_{ud})\mathcal{Y}_E\left(\beta_{ud}^{\perp},\beta_{ud}^{z},\lambda_0\right). \tag*{(159)}
\end{aligned} ⟨ ν dd E ⟩ 0 K ⟨ ν u d E ⟩ 0 K = − 3 2 α s ( Q dd ) Y E ( β dd ⊥ , β dd z , 0 ) , = − 3 2 α s ( Q u d ) Y E ( β u d ⊥ , β u d z , λ 0 ) . (159)
For vanishing transverse displacement,
Y E ( a , c , 0 ) = 2 π a sin − 1 1 − c / a 1 − c / a , a > c , (160) \mathcal{Y}_E(a,c,0)=\frac{2}{\sqrt{\pi a}}\frac{\sin^{-1}\sqrt{1-c/a}}{\sqrt{1-c/a}},\qquad a>c, \tag*{(160)} Y E ( a , c , 0 ) = π a 2 1 − c / a sin − 1 1 − c / a , a > c , (160)
while
Y E ( a , c , 0 ) = 2 π a sinh − 1 c / a − 1 c / a − 1 , c > a . (161) \mathcal{Y}_E(a,c,0)=\frac{2}{\sqrt{\pi a}}\frac{\sinh^{-1}\sqrt{c/a-1}}{\sqrt{c/a-1}},\qquad c>a. \tag*{(161)} Y E ( a , c , 0 ) = π a 2 c / a − 1 sinh − 1 c / a − 1 , c > a . (161)
At a = c a=c a = c ,
Y E ( a , a , 0 ) = 2 π a . (162) \mathcal{Y}_E(a,a,0)=\frac{2}{\sqrt{\pi a}}. \tag*{(162)} Y E ( a , a , 0 ) = π a 2 . (162)
Color-magnetic interaction
For the color-magnetic interaction, we relativize the standard factor α s / ( m i m j ) \alpha_s/(m_i m_j) α s / ( m i m j ) by replacing
α s m i m j ⟶ α s E i E j . (163) \frac{\alpha_s}{m_i m_j}\longrightarrow\frac{\alpha_s}{E_iE_j}. \tag*{(163)} m i m j α s ⟶ E i E j α s . (163)
Taking ∣ p 1 ∣ = ∣ p 2 ∣ = ∣ q ∣ / 2 \lvert p_1\rvert=\lvert p_2\rvert=\lvert q\rvert/2 ∣ p 1 ∣ = ∣ p 2 ∣ = ∣ q ∣ /2 and m i = m j = m m_i=m_j=m m i = m j = m , we use
ν i j M ( q ) = C M 4 π 9 α s ( Q i j ) m 2 + q 2 / 4 , (164) \nu_{ij}^M(q)=C_M\frac{4\pi}{9}\frac{\alpha_s(Q_{ij})}{m^2+q^2/4}, \tag*{(164)} ν ij M ( q ) = C M 9 4 π m 2 + q 2 /4 α s ( Q ij ) , (164)
where the Fourier-transform convention is
v ( r ) = ∫ d 3 q ( 2 π ) 3 e i q ⋅ r v ~ ( q ) . (165) v(r)=\int\frac{d^{3}q}{(2\pi)^{3}}e^{i\mathbf{q}\cdot\mathbf{r}}\widetilde{v}(q). \tag*{(165)} v ( r ) = ∫ ( 2 π ) 3 d 3 q e i q ⋅ r v ( q ) . (165)
The corresponding coordinate-space interaction is
v i j z , M ( r ) = C M 4 α s ( Q i j ) 9 e − 2 m r r . (166) v_{ij}^{z,M}(r)=C_{M}\frac{4\alpha_{s}(Q_{ij})}{9}\frac{e^{-2mr}}{r}. \tag*{(166)} v ij z , M ( r ) = C M 9 4 α s ( Q ij ) r e − 2 m r . (166)
Using a formula
e − μ r r = 1 π ∫ 0 ∞ d s s exp ( − s r 2 − μ 2 4 s ) , (167) \frac{e^{-\mu r}}{r}=\frac{1}{\sqrt{\pi}}\int_{0}^{\infty}\frac{ds}{\sqrt{s}}\exp\left(-sr^{2}-\frac{\mu^{2}}{4s}\right), \tag*{(167)} r e − μ r = π 1 ∫ 0 ∞ s d s exp ( − s r 2 − 4 s μ 2 ) , (167)
we define
Y M ( a , c , r 0 ; μ ) ≡ 1 π ∫ 0 ∞ d s s 1 ( 1 + a s ) 1 + c s × exp [ − μ 2 4 s − s r 0 2 1 + a s ] . (168) \mathcal{Y}_{M}(a,c,r_{0};\mu)\equiv\frac{1}{\sqrt{\pi}}\int_{0}^{\infty}\frac{ds}{\sqrt{s}}\frac{1}{(1+as)\sqrt{1+cs}}\times\exp\left[-\frac{\mu^{2}}{4s}-\frac{sr_{0}^{2}}{1+as}\right]. \tag*{(168)} Y M ( a , c , r 0 ; μ ) ≡ π 1 ∫ 0 ∞ s d s ( 1 + a s ) 1 + cs 1 × exp [ − 4 s μ 2 − 1 + a s s r 0 2 ] . (168)
The magnetic matrix elements are then
⟨ v d d M ⟩ 0 K = C M 4 α s ( Q i j ) 9 Y M ( β d d ⊥ , β d d z , 0 ; 2 m ) , \left\langle v_{dd}^{M}\right\rangle_{0}^{K}=C_{M}\frac{4\alpha_{s}(Q_{ij})}{9}\mathcal{Y}_{M}\left(\beta_{dd}^{\perp},\beta_{dd}^{z},0;2m\right), ⟨ v dd M ⟩ 0 K = C M 9 4 α s ( Q ij ) Y M ( β dd ⊥ , β dd z , 0 ; 2 m ) ,
⟨ v u d M ⟩ 0 K = C M 4 α s ( Q i j ) 9 Y M ( β u d ⊥ , β u d z , λ 0 ; 2 m ) . (169) \left\langle v_{ud}^{M}\right\rangle_{0}^{K}=C_{M}\frac{4\alpha_{s}(Q_{ij})}{9}\mathcal{Y}_{M}\left(\beta_{ud}^{\perp},\beta_{ud}^{z},\lambda_{0};2m\right). \tag*{(169)} ⟨ v u d M ⟩ 0 K = C M 9 4 α s ( Q ij ) Y M ( β u d ⊥ , β u d z , λ 0 ; 2 m ) . (169)
For a = c a=c a = c and r 0 = 0 r_{0}=0 r 0 = 0 , the integral can be evaluated explicitly,
Y M ( a , a , 0 ; μ ) = 2 π a − μ exp ( μ 2 a 4 ) erfc ( μ a 2 ) . (170) \mathcal{Y}_{M}(a,a,0;\mu)=\frac{2}{\sqrt{\pi a}}-\mu\exp\left(\frac{\mu^{2}a}{4}\right)\operatorname{erfc}\left(\frac{\mu\sqrt{a}}{2}\right). \tag*{(170)} Y M ( a , a , 0 ; μ ) = π a 2 − μ exp ( 4 μ 2 a ) erfc ( 2 μ a ) . (170)
Funding: This work is supported by JSPS KAKENHI Grant No. 26K07077.
Data Availability Statement: Data are available upon request.
Conflicts of Interest: The authors declare no conflicts of interest.
Acknowledgments: We thank Drs. Akinobu Dote, GuangJuan Wang, Asanosuke Jinno, and Mr. Haru Yoshimori for useful discussions at the KEK hadron meeting.
References