WorksPhysics and Astronomy
Conditions for mass-loading: Investigating jet-disk material exchange in strongly magnetised accretion flows
Abstract
Relativistic jets are produced by accreting black holes across a wide range of masses, from stellar-mass X-ray binaries to supermassive active galactic nuclei (AGN). In low-luminosity AGN, these jets are believed to be powered by strongly magnetised accretion flows, a picture supported by Event Horizon Telescope and VLBI observations of M87. The jets often exhibit high-energy flaring emission which, if partly hadronic, implies that baryons must be loaded into the jet and accelerated despite strong magnetic barriers. However, the mechanism behind this remains unclear. We present high-resolution, three-dimensional General Relativistic Magnetohydrodynamic (GRMHD) simulations of a high-spin Magnetically Arrested Disk (MAD), a strongly magnetised accretion regime. Using passive Eulerian tracers, we track the exchange of material between the jet and disk to quantify mixing. We find that magnetic flux eruptions, a hallmark of MAD accretion, expel magnetic flux tubes initially filled with jet material (expected to be pair-dominated in real systems). Through magnetic reconnection during these eruptions, this material is mixed into the disk. Crucially, the same flux tubes reconnect the disk back to the jet, allowing disk material, expected to be primarily hadronic, to infiltrate the jet sheath and boundary. This disk-to-jet injection offers a natural mass-loading mechanism that does not require the jet to be globally baryon-dominated. The resulting ejection-injection cycle may instead drive episodic hadronic acceleration, providing a viable pathway for high-energy emission in relativistic jets.
Introduction
Relativistic jets represent one of the most ubiquitous phenomena across astrophysical objects and scales, first unwittingly discovered in the nearby galaxy M87 over a century ago (Curtis 1918) and later found to be polarised (observed at optical wavelengths; Baade 1956), a key step towards establishing them as structures originating due to ordered magnetic fields. The recognition of quasars as distant, luminous galaxies (e.g., Schmidt 1963) and the theoretical framework for accretion-powered systems (e.g., Lynden-Bell 1971) established jets as fundamental components of black hole physics. Much later, Very Large Baseline Interferometry (VLBI) observations confirmed relativistic bulk motion through proper superluminal motions (e.g., Reid et al. 1989; Biretta et al. 1989, 1999). Over subsequent decades, jets have been identified across a remarkable range of systems harboring or forming black holes: including stellar-mass X-ray binaries (XRBs) where the jets exhibit superluminal motion (e.g., Mirabel & Rodríguez 1994; Fender 2003) to the most luminous active galactic nuclei (AGN; e.g., Bridle & Perley 1984; Begelman et al. 1984), and more recently in neutron star mergers (e.g. Mooley et al. 2018) and tidal disruption events (e.g. Blum et al. 2011; Cendes et al. 2024).
Within this larger topic, there is a long-standing question regarding the origin of high-energy accelerated, hadronic particles called cosmic rays, that requires a better understanding of jet composition and potential sites for acceleration. Current instruments cannot directly measure the jet composition, and broadband Spectral Energy Distribution (SED) modeling alone remains highly degenerate between leptonic and hadronic scenarios (e.g. Böttcher et al. 2013; Cerruti et al. 2015; Madeski & Sikora 2016; Romero et al. 2017; Blanford et al. 2019). To make progress on this question, it is important to
© 2026 The Authors better constrain how and where hadronic material manages to enter the jets, and is the loading continuous, or does it occur in episodic events? Some progress has been made on measuring composition via source-specific observations where a few black hole jets show direct signatures of baryonic material. For example, the black hole XRB 4U 1630-47 displays Fe XXVI lines at ((Trigo et al. 2013; Trueba et al. 2019)); another black hole XRB SS 433 also displays Doppler-shifted Balmer, HeI, Fe XXV/XXVI consistent with baryonic jets moving at ((Margon et al. 1979; Abell & Margon 1979; Marshall et al. 2002)), where is the speed of light. However linking these results to acceleration sites and mechanisms remains challenging.
Historically, the prime candidate site proposed for extreme particle acceleration in AGN jets is a putative recollimation shock that occurs around the Bondi radius (; where is the speed of sound, and, is the mass of the black hole). The Bondi radius (hereafter ) is the gravitational capture radius of the black hole’s ambient medium, where the inflow transitions from quasi-spherical to disk-dominated, depending on its residual angular momentum (e.g. (Homan et al. 2015; Zech & Lemoine 2021; Nalewajko et al. 2014b)). In the nearby low-luminosity AGN M87, the prominent HST-1 knot at pc () has long been considered to be associated with a reconfinement shock ((Stawarz et al. 2006)). HST-1 is observed to be a site of particle re-acceleration, with a major multiwavelength outburst peaking in 2005 and exhibiting correlated variability from radio through X-rays ((Harris et al. 2009; Stawarz et al. 2006)). If protons are entrained into these acceleration zones and sufficiently accelerated, they can potentially be a source of neutrinos. The association of AGN jets with high-energy neutrinos is supported by candidate neutrino events from sources such as TXS 0506+056 ([60]), while recent work has identified other radio galaxies, including 3C 403, as candidate neutrino-emitting sources ((Bruni et al. 2026)). More broadly, AGN contributions to the extragalactic -ray background ((Ackermann et al. 2016)) and the diffuse neutrino flux ((Aartsen et al. 2017)) depend sensitively on the fraction of jets that carry sufficient baryons for hadronic acceleration ((Stecker & Venters 2013; Sahakyan 2018)), and where that acceleration occurs.
Recent observations in the very-high-energy (VHE) -rays ( TeV) with the Large High Altitude Air Shower Observatory (LHAASO; Cao et al. 2025) and the IceCube neutrino detector (Abbasi et al. 2022) have begun to challenge the canonical picture of predominantly leptonic (pair-dominated) jets. LHAASO, and now also H.E.S.S., have somewhat unexpectedly detected VHE -rays from several XRBs (SS433, GRS 1915+105, V4641 Sgr, MAXI J1820+070; Cao et al. 2025), sources that are fed by Roche-lobe overflow from a companion star rather than by a quasi-spherical ambient medium, so that a source near such an is not an obvious acceleration site. Several low-luminosity AGN including M87, whose jet is not pointed towards us, are also VHE -ray bright ((Acciari et al. 2009)), showing that VHE emission does not require a blazar-like jet closely aligned with our line of sight. Interestingly, the VHE -ray flare detected during the 2018 EHT campaign on M87 ((Algaba et al. 2024)) was not accompanied by emission from the extended jet.
IceCube’s detection of events from a few blazars such as TXS 0506+056 ([60]), and association of high-energy neutrinos with weakly jetted/choked AGN (NGC 1068, NGC 4151; Abbasi et al. 2024) further indicate that hadronic acceleration mechanisms that likely require significant baryon loading in the jet launching region, or in X-ray emitting coronal regions close to the black hole due to the lack of corresponding -ray detections. Consequently there is a growing consensus that hadronic acceleration can favourably occur in close-in regions of AGN that are opaque to GeV–TeV -rays but allow neutrinos and X-rays to escape—such as AGN coronae or their inner jets (e.g. [44 b] (Murase et al. 2016; Murase et al. 2020; Inoue et al. 2020; Eichmann et al. 2022).
Furthermore, understanding mass-loading may help reconcile the unrealistically high power requirements found in several hadronic models for simultaneous -ray and neutrino emission, such as those invoked for the blazar TXS 0506+056 flares ([60] (Anzoldi et al. 2018), see also, e.g., Petropoulou et al. 2015; Kantzas et al. 2023). Finally, minute-scale -ray variability in blazars like 3C 279 (e.g. Shukla et al. 2020) and rapid morphological changes in VLBI imaging (Hada et al. 2016; Kim et al. 2018) suggest dynamic material exchange at jet–disk boundaries on short timescales (although they can also be framed through internal shock-turbulence, magnetic reconnection, or geometric effects). Together, all of these results provide the motivation to explore the conditions for mass mixing and loading within the highly magnetised inner regions of accreting black holes.
Ideal general relativistic magnetohydrodynamics (GRMHD) offers a framework to study the global accretion and outflow dynamics, where typical time and length scales can be expressed in units of gravitational radius and dynamical time , where is black hole mass, is the gravitational constant, and speed of light. In regimes when radiative losses do not affect the dynamics, GRMHD simulations allow us to compare the essential accretion and jet-launching physics across all black hole masses (e.g., Gammie et al. 2003; Jiang et al. 2014; Porth et al. 2019). The current generation of GRMHD simulations has robustly produced low-density, Poynting-flux dominated outflows via the Blandford-Znajek mechanism (Blandford & Znajek 1977; McKinney 2006; Tchekhovskoy et al. 2011), and also reveal that jets exist in dynamic equilibrium with their surrounding accretion flows, with steep density () gradients () and velocity shear at jet-disk boundaries. These conditions can drive mixing in the inner jets through magnetohydrodynamic instabilities (e.g., Mizuno et al. 2012; Mbarek & Sironi 2019; Figuredo et al. 2024). Kelvin-Helmholtz instabilities can develop in shear layers (e.g., Chatterjee et al. 2019; Sironi et al. 2021; Chow et al. 2023), while Rayleigh-Taylor instabilities can grow at density interfaces during pressure-driven acceleration (Stehle & Spruit 2001; Mbarek et al. 2022; Ripperda et al. 2022). Furthermore, magnetic reconnection in equatorial current sheets enables cross-field transport of material through plasmoid formation and ejection (Ripperda et al. 2020, 2022; Hakobyan et al. 2023, 2025; Chow et al. 2026), potentially injecting disk material directly into the jet, or jet material into the disk.
Despite these advances, quantifying material exchange between jets and disks remains challenging for GRMHD simulations due to insufficient resolution to resolve non-local mixing at jet-disk boundaries in 3D (Salas et al. 2024), and the inability to distinguish between physically initialised disk material and numerically injected "floor" material required for computational stability in low-density regions ([71] (Ryan et al. 2017; Chatterjee et al. 2019)). This last limitation is particularly critical because floors become dynamically important in at least the base of the Poynting-flux dominated jets.
Here we explore mass-loading and mixing in a high-resolution 3D GRMHD simulation where we have added density tracers to distinguish disk material from floored jet material, following the approach of Chow et al. (2026). We choose a prograde, rapidly spin-ning black hole surrounded by a magnetically arrested disk (MAD; Narayan et al. 2003; McKinney & Narayan 2007; Tchekhovskoy et al. 2011). MADs launch powerful jets, which makes them well suited to study jet composition and possible mechanisms of mixing. MADs are thought to be relevant for systems with powerful jets: in M87, the EHT resolves a dynamically strong magnetic field with ordered azimuthal and helical structure in 1.3 mm polarised images, favouring MAD models [40 b]. Importantly, such magnetically dominated flows often experience flux eruptions—quasi-periodic events where accumulated magnetic field violently reorganises near the event horizon (McKinney & Narayan 2007; Tchekhovskoy et al. 2011; Ripperda et al. 2022). These eruptions push magnetic flux tubes out into the disk, making them a natural candidate for episodic exchange of material between the disk and the jet. The ability to trace disk and jet material separately enables us to begin addressing critical questions such as: What fraction of disk baryons manage to enter the jet, and how does this fraction vary with different accretion states? Can we find evidence in our simulations for mechanisms that could potentially energise baryons in the base of the jets, as invoked in semi-analytical models of hadronic jets (e.g., Kantzas et al. 2021; Kantzas et al. 2023)?
This paper is organised as follows. § 2 describes our numerical approach, and the eulerian tracer algorithm (with validation tests demonstrating tracer conservation and mixing accuracy in the appendix). § 3 presents our systematic analysis of disk-jet mixing driven by flux eruption cycles in a MAD simulation. We discuss possible links between our simulation and observed phenomena from some astrophysical sources in § 4, before summarizing our conclusions and future directions in § 5.
Numerical setup
We perform our simulation using H-AMR [71], which evolves the ideal GRMHD equations on a fixed Kerr spacetime. The code employs the Harten-Lax-van Leer-Riemann (HLLR) solver (Harten et al. 1983) for flux calculations, a staggered grid configuration for magnetic fields (Gardiner & Stone 2005), and the piecewise parabolic method (PPM; Colella & Woodward 1984) for second-order spatial reconstruction. To avoid polar singularities inherent in standard spherical coordinates, we implement a 90° coordinate rotation that aligns the black hole spin axis with the grid equatorial plane. The simulation utilises adaptive mesh refinement (AMR; see appendix D) coupled with local adaptive timestepping (LAT) to achieve high resolution in dynamically important regions while maintaining computational efficiency.
We adopt geometrised Lorentz–Heaviside units where and a factor is absorbed into ( being the magnetic field strength), setting characteristic length and time scales to the gravitational radius and light-crossing time , respectively. Our computational domain is set on a spherical grid that spans , , and , where is the event horizon radius for dimensionless spin parameter . In our studies, we consider only the high spin case of . The initial base grid employs logarithmic radial spacing with cells. This ensures that the magnetorotational instability (MRI) driving the initial accretion is adequately resolved (Porth et al. 2019). Beyond the base grid, we employ AMR: blocks are refined and de-refined dynamically during the run according to physics-driven criteria that target the jet and the jet sheath (based on the magnetisation (range 0.1-1) and the Bernoulli parameter ()) and regions of strong magnetic field gradients ( change) (see Appendix D for exact numerical constraints). We allow up to 4 levels of refinement above the base grid, with all criteria triggering the maximum level, and do not refine cells below a minimum size of . With derefinement techniques within the constraints defined we record maximum grid resolution of cells in the jet and its boundary.
The initial conditions consist of a Fishbone-Moncrief torus (Fishbone & Moncrief 1976) with inner edge at and pressure maximum at . The torus is threaded by an initial magnetic field configuration designed to produce a MAD state (, where is the disk mid-plane density at (set for a corresponding plasma ; where is the gas pressure; of 100) and in code units (Narayan et al. 2003; Igumenshchev et al. 2003; Porth et al. 2019)). We set the adiabatic index to a constant value of 5/3. We implement outflow boundary conditions at the inner and outer radial boundaries, transmissive conditions at the polar boundaries of the rotated grid (which, owing to the 90° rotation, lie in the black hole equatorial plane rather than along the spin axis; see Appendix § 6), and periodic boundary conditions in the azimuthal direction of the rotated grid. We describe in the following our tracer implementation, for a more detailed description please see Appendix § 7.
Tracer implementation
To investigate mass loading and mixing processes in our black hole jet-disk system, we implement a tracer scheme that tracks the distinct origins of plasma throughout the simulation domain (as in Chow et al. 2026). We employ two complementary density tracer species that follow the mass fraction of disk-origin plasma (assumed to be fully ionised, charge-neutral electron-ion plasma) and jet-origin plasma (assumed pair-dominated), typically injected as density floors.
Tracking of jet and disk material
During evolution, maintaining numerical stability in highly magnetised regions requires injection of density floors when falls below a critical threshold, or the magnetization, , becomes too high (Gammie et al. 2003). These floor injections occur predominantly in the magnetically-dominated jet base along the Black Hole spin axis interior to the stagnation surfaces, where charge separation and strong electric fields are expected to drive pair production (Beskin et al. 1992; Levinson 2000; Hirotani & Pu 2016). Theoretical works have demonstrated that diverging mass flow near stagnation surfaces leads to charge separation and subsequent pair cascade formation (Parfrey et al. 2019; Crinquand et al. 2020, 2021; Medvedev & Zdziarski 2026). The injected floor density thus seems to serve as a reasonable proxy for pair plasma created through these micro-physical processes (McKinney et al. 2012), which are not captured in fluid GRMHD simulations. Numerical tracers have been used to follow the origin of injected floor plasma in GRMHD simulations (e.g. Wong et al. 2021; Chow et al. 2026).
The density floor criterion employed is the standard (Porth et al. 2019):
where is the squared magnitude of the magnetic field in the fluid’s comoving-frame, while is the rest-mass density. The first term prevents the magnetization from exceeding 25, the second term provides a power law floor, and the third term sets an absolute minimum [71] (Liska et al. 2018).
Tracer evolution equations
Following the approach of Keppens et al. (2014), we model the tracers as advected scalar quantities. We define the conserved tracer density for each species as:
which evolves according to the continuity equation:
where and is the metric determinant in non-rotated frame, ensuring that is advected with the flow velocity in the same manner as the bulk density . The primitive tracer fraction is recovered as , which satisfies:
Moreover, in our tilted spherical Kerr-Schild coordinate system, the tracer advection equation retains its covariant form:
where primed quantities refer to the rotated coordinate system, is the metric determinant, and the four-velocity components transform according to:
Tracer update during floor injection
The highest magnetization regions primarily occur near the black hole. When density floors are triggered, the tracer fractions must be updated to account for the injected mass. If the pre-floor density is and the post-floor density is (same subscripts for ), the tracer fractions are updated as
For the disk tracer (species 0):
For the floor tracer (species 1):
In words, a floor injection leaves the mass density of disk-origin material, , unchanged, so the disk fraction is merely diluted by the factor , while the mass density of jet-origin (floor) material, , grows by exactly the injected amount, . If before the injection, this therefore still holds afterwards. This prescription thus ensures mass conservation (see Figure C1) while attributing all injected mass to the floor tracer species. Throughout this paper, the subscript ‘jet’ on tracer quantities (e.g. , ) refers to this jet-origin (floor) material, and ‘disk’ to disk-origin material. The tracers thus evolve dynamically with the flow.
Figure C1. Contour plot of the tracer numerical error in the meridional plane () of the GRMHD simulation.
The described implementation allows us to quantify mass exchange between the disk and jet components, track the penetration of disk material into the jet-disk boundary (the jet sheath) and the main jet itself, as well as jet material into the disk. For a prograde MAD around a high-spin black hole (), we quantify mixing into the jet as a function of time relative to flux eruption phases, as a function of height in the jet and across the co-existing jet, sheath (jet disk boundary layer) and disk components.
Results
Temporal Phase Classification
Our fiducial GRMHD simulation of a high-spin (), prograde MAD evolves over , revealing three distinct dynamical phases: build-up to a MAD, the phase where the magnetic pressure in the inner region is saturated, i.e. MAD, and the eruption phase where magnetic flux is ejected through reconnection (Ripperda et al. 2022; Najafi-Ziyazi et al. 2024). These phases are identified through the evolution of the magnetic flux across the event horizon , jet power (where is the rest-mass energy flux into the black hole and is the total energy flux through the event horizon, both taken positive for inflow into the black hole (e.g., Tchekhovskoy et al. 2011), so that is the net power extracted from the black hole, which in a MAD is dominated by the electromagnetic Blandford–Znajek contribution), and mass accretion rate at the black hole event horizon (Figure 1). The characteristic saw-tooth pattern of , gradual accumulation followed by sudden drops, marks the MAD eruption cycle, with periods of .
Figure 1. Time evolution of magnetic flux, jet power, and mass accretion rate, showing flux eruption cycles in aMAD. Build-up phases (peach) where magnetic flux accumulates near the horizon as field lines are advected inward by accretion (); MAD phases (light blue) where flux reaches saturation and exhibits high variability as further flux accumulation is inhibited ( with elevated variance); and Eruption phases (lavender) where accumulated flux is expelled through magnetic reconnection (). Top panel: Dimensionless magnetic flux threading the black hole horizon , showing a characteristic saw-tooth pattern with gradual buildup followed by sudden drops during eruptions. The dashed gray line marks the MAD saturation level measured in GRMHD simulations (Tchekhovskoy et al. 2011). Middle panel: Jet power revealing strong modulation with eruption cycles. Bottom panel: Mass accretion rate (horizon-averaged), which also correlates with : accretion rates gradually increases during buildup states, saturates around a fixed value during the MAD state, then drops during eruptions.
Buildup Phase
The buildup phase is the longest and most variable, lasting (a coefficient of variation, CV, i.e. standard deviation divided by mean, of 58%). Magnetic flux gradually accumulates from post-eruption lows to near-MAD levels, while jet power rises by a factor from eruption minima to saturation. The disk–jet material accretion ratio (, with the numerator and denominator being the accretion rates of disk and jet tracer masses respectively) recovers from 1.4 in the eruption phase we see later, to 2.9 – a greater than 100% increase – signalling the re-establishment of a disk-dominated accretion flow. This phase also exhibits the largest fluctuations in jet power (72% CV).
MAD Phase
The MAD phase is the most dynamically settled state, lasting ( variation). Here the magnetic flux saturates at a value above the eruption threshold, driving the strongest Blandford–Znajek jet power (a factor higher than during the subsequent eruptions) and the highest mass accretion rate ( the eruption value).
Flux Eruption Phase
During eruptions, the magnetic flux drops by on a timescale of (high cycle-to-cycle variation, 44%). This is consistent with Ripperda et al. (2022), who show that the duration of this phase is set predominantly by the universal fast magnetic reconnection rate, which is independent of the Lundquist number in the plasmoid-dominated regime. The jet power decreases by relative to the MAD phase, and the accretion rate falls by . Most strikingly, the disk–jet material accretion ratio drops to 1.4 (58% disk, 42% floor) – a 30% reduction from MAD levels. This demonstrates that eruptions preferentially disrupt the disk component while enhancing wind/outflow contributions, consistent with flux expulsion via magnetic reconnection (Ripperda et al. 2020, 2022; Chatterjee & Narayan 2022).
The fourth eruption cycle (the strongest in our simulation) is chosen for further analysis because it exhibits the highest pre-eruption flux and the most dramatic post-eruption reorganisation, offering the clearest signature of baryon loading into the jet funnel. We restrict the mass-flux and analysis below to this eruption and have not analysed the other cycles in the same detail.
Quantifying eruption-induced mass redistribution
To quantify how mass is distributed over magnetisation, we compute : the tracer-weighted mass within a radius per logarithmic interval of the magnetisation (Appendix E). This allows us to track how disk and jet plasma are redistributed in magnetisation and radius as the MAD undergoes a flux eruption: it shows how much disk material reaches the magnetisations of the sheath and the jet, and conversely how much jet material ends up at disk-like magnetisations. In Figure 2 we show at times , , and for multiple radial cuts –, with three shaded bands in : a “disk” band at , a “sheath” band , and a “jet” band at . The detailed calculations, definitions and considerations for this analysis are laid out in Appendix E.
Figure 2. Magnetisation-resolved mass distributions at , , and for multiple radial cuts –. Dashed curves show disk-origin material (tracer 1) and dotted curves show jet/floor material (tracer 2). The eruption window corresponds to the transition from the onset () to the mid-eruption () and post-eruption () snapshots.
At the onset of eruption () the disk tracer is concentrated in the disk physical region (green band on the panels), with only a modest high- tail in the sheath and jet regions. The jet/floor tracer, by contrast, contributes relatively little in the disk band but shows a clear peak in the jet band. There is some separation between – for jet material in the sheath, marking the remnant of an earlier eruption trapped in the sheath, structures relating to which possibly cause the separation between – for material originating in the disk.
In the middle of the eruption () the curves change qualitatively in the sheath band. For both tracers, the curves at – become nearly coincident in the disk and sheath bands, indicating that material in this radial range is all contained in the inner . As the eruption develops, the curve for the disk tracer remains at roughly the same level, while the curves for move upward in the sheath band. This behaviour – near overlap of the – curves, followed by a co-rise of the cuts towards the end of the eruption () – shows that disk material between and is shifted to sheath-like magnetisations during the eruption. On its own, does not show whether this material enters the jet; we address this with the mass fluxes across the jet boundary below.
The jet/floor tracer also responds to the eruption. Over the eruption window its curves increase in the disk band (green region) and the sheath, indicating that floored material is pushed into the flux tubes through reconnection in the equatorial current sheet, and is carried into the disk as the tubes are ejected. In the middle of the eruption (), we see no separation between – for the jet tracer in the sheath, whereas towards the end of the eruption () widening gaps develop between the cuts. This is consistent with former jet material, carried within the ejected flux tubes, moving to larger radii as the tubes move outwards.
Because most of the radial motion seen in the curves occurs in the – range for both tracers, we focus our analysis of the mass fluxes across the jet boundary on this band. The three-panel flux figure (Figure 3) summarises the time evolution of the tracer-weighted mass flux across the jet boundary, defined as the surface: panel (a) shows disk tracer inflow and outflow, and ; panel (b) shows the corresponding jet/floor tracer fluxes, and ; and panel (c) shows the net fluxes (in–out) for both tracers. At each radius in the – band, we identify the cells adjacent to the surface, compute the tracer-weighted mass flux normal to it, where is the component of the fluid fourvelocity along (positive into the jet), and sum the inward (‘in’) and outward (‘out’) contributions over the surface in both hemispheres (see Appendix E0.3 for details).
Figure 3. Tracer-weighted mass fluxes across the magnetisation-defined jet boundary () as a function of time over the fourth eruption period. Panel (a): disk tracer inflow and outflow, (solid) and (dashed). Panel (b): jet/floor tracer inflow and outflow, (solid) and (dashed), on a logarithmic -axis. Panel (c): net fluxes (in–out) for disk (blue) and jet/floor (red). The shaded band marks the period in the eruption window where the flux tubes bring entrained disk material across the jet boundary.
In the leadup to the eruption (–) the disk inflow is comparable to or smaller than the outflow, and the net disk flux in panel (c) is close to zero or slightly negative. Across the eruption (–) the balance reverses: rises to – while drops to –, producing a strongly positive net disk flux in panel (c). This shows that, during the eruption, more disk material crosses the jet boundary into the high- region than leaves it in the – band.
The jet/floor tracer in panel (b) exhibits a parallel enhancement: increases by an order of magnitude over the eruption window while stays nearly constant. The net jet/floor flux in panel (c) therefore remains small but positive, indicating a weak net mass loading of the jet with former jet material. Combined with the behaviour, this suggests that the flux tubes ejected during the eruption move through the – band, entrain disk plasma, and bring both former jet material (loaded into the tubes through reconnection) and disk material to the jet boundary. The increase in disk tracer mass in the sheath and jet bands, together with the positive net disk flux across the jet boundary, indicates that flux eruptions enhance the loading of the jet boundary and sheath with disk material. Flux eruptions are therefore mass-transfer events: former jet material that has passed through the flux tubes, mixed with disk material, flows into the jet sheath and enters the high- region at –, but does not reach the jet spine.
Flux tubes as mass transfer highways
We now investigate whether the flux tubes ejected during the eruption mediate the loading of the jet, i.e. whether they can explain the injection of disk material into the jet that we find at –, as well as the increased content of former jet material in the disk and sheath at larger radii. We note that this radial range likely reflects how far the tubes have travelled during the analysed period rather than a preferred location: at later times, and with higher resolution at large radii, the same process may operate further out.
The equatorial () – slices in Figure 4 show where material is exchanged between the flux tubes and the disk. At early times, the tubes appear as narrow, low-density channels that are almost completely devoid of disk-origin plasma and are instead filled with material injected in the jet (our jet/floor tracer): the panels tracking the material originating in the jet show that the flux tubes are filled with former jet material, which subsequently mixes with disk material. As the eruption progresses, the tubes are pushed into the disk, where they orbit the black hole. At the boundaries between the tubes and the disk, Rayleigh–Taylor-like fingers of high develop within the inner , mixing disk gas into the tubes and former jet material into the disk; in the jet-tracer panels, these regions coincide with a reduction in . The zoomed views in Figure 5–Figure 7 show these boundaries in detail: a tongue of disk material extends between two flux tubes and is pinched into them (Figure 5); along the edge of a flux tube the magnetic potential contours are strongly bunched and distorted, with the signature of disk material loading onto a forming Rayleigh–Taylor-like plume (Figure 6); and at elongated fingers of lower-density gas alternate with denser disk material pinched through the black-hole-facing edge of a flux tube (Figure 7). The disk panels show the low-density cavities that the tubes carve out of the midplane, while the jet panels show the pockets of jet-origin material they leave behind in the disk. In these cuts, magnetically dominated () gas is present only close to the black hole, where the jet base is narrowest, indicating that in the midplane the mixing occurs at the boundary between the flux tubes and the disk, and not at the jet boundary. This motivates a complementary view in the meridional – plane, where the vertical structure of the tubes and their connection to the jet can be followed.
Figure 4. Equatorial () – slices of disk- and jet-tracer density across the eruption, at , and (top to bottom). Panels (a), (c) and (e) show and panels (b), (d) and (f) show ; black lines are magnetic potential contours.
Figure 5. Zoomed view of the equatorial () slice at (top row of Figure 4). Panel (a) shows and panel (b) ; black lines are magnetic potential contours. The white box marks the region magnified in the inset, at the boundary between the low-density flux tubes and the surrounding disk. A tongue of disk material extends between two flux tubes, and the potential contours bend along it, pinching disk material into the flux tubes.
Figure 6. As Figure 5, at (middle row of Figure 4). The inset magnifies the inner edge of the large flux tube below the black hole, where disk material borders the flux tube and the magnetic potential contours are strongly bunched and distorted, with the signature of disk material loading onto a forming Rayleigh–Taylor-like plume.
Figure 7. As Figure 5, at (bottom row of Figure 4). Two regions are magnified. Upper inset: the black-hole-facing side of a flux tube to the upper left of the black hole, where elongated fingers of lower-density gas alternate with denser disk material pinched through the flux-tube edge. Lower inset: the elongated flux tube to the left of the black hole, whose upper edge is lined by compressed magnetic potential contours with loaded disk material.
The meridional – slices in Figure 8 show how these flux tubes evolve in height during the eruption. We plot so that regions dominated by jet-origin material appear red–orange and disk-dominated regions appear blue–purple. The green contour marks , where is the Bernoulli parameter, with the specific enthalpy and the contravariant component of the four-velocity; it encloses unbound, outflowing gas ((Tchekhovskoy et al. 2011; McKinney et al. 2012)). We adopt this threshold following Moscibrodzka et al. (2014), who used to separate the jet from the disk and its slower wind. A different threshold would change the width of the sheath and would therefore affect our results quantitatively; however, the mean magnetisation of the gas with is close to , the value at which the flux-tube field lines settle in the sheath (§ 3.2). We note that the inner is dominated by former floor material in these slices, so that the composition there is largely set by the density floors. In the left panel, taken near the beginning of the eruption, the yellow box marks a remnant flux tube from a previous event. This tube has already been distorted by the disk pushing on it, and disk material is already mixed into it along much of its length. Near , where the remnant tube connects to the jet sheath, it develops localised knots and spiral distortions, suggestive of tube material mixing into the jet; a zoom just below this region (Figure 9) shows closed loops of the in-plane field on either side of the tube. By contrast, the turquoise box in the right panel highlights a much more coherent, nearly poloidal flux tube from the end-of-eruption snapshot. This tube is just forming at smaller radii in the left panel, as a result of a reconnection event in the midplane within the inner few , and becomes fully developed by the time of the right panel. A zoom into the disk-facing edge of this tube (Figure 10) shows the in-plane field curling into closed loops on the disk side of the contour, the largest at , . Such vortices could arise from turbulence or from kink-like distortions of the tube; we defer an investigation of their origin to a follow-up paper. In the left panel, closed loops of the in-plane field also appear just outside the outer contour in the lower hemisphere (Figure 11); these are instabilities around a surface wave running down the jet–disk boundary through the sheath. Whether the disk material mixed into the tubes is carried along them into the jet is examined with field-line tracing below.
Figure 8. Meridional – slices of the jet–to–disk composition ratio across the eruption. The colour scale shows , so that red–orange regions are jet dominated and blue-purple regions are disk dominated. Black streamlines trace the in-plane component of the magnetic field; the green contour marks the surface. Left: At the beginning of the eruption. The yellow box encloses a remnant flux tube from the previous event. The turquoise box captures a portion of a forming flux tube. Right: end of the eruption. The turquoise box shows that the nascent tube from the left panel has completed roughly half an orbit around the black hole, and is now more coherent and predominantly poloidal. Notably, it has vortical features now appearing along the length of the disk-facing edge of the tube.
Figure 9. Zoom into the upper part of the remnant flux tube (yellow box in the left panel of Figure 8) at , covering and . As in Figure 8, the colour scale shows , black streamlines trace the in-plane magnetic field and the green line is the contour. A bundle of nearly vertical field lines (the remnant tube) runs through the centre of the panel; on either side of it the in-plane field forms closed loops (at , and , and at , ). The contour enters only the upper-right corner.
Figure 10. Zoom into the disk-facing edge of the flux tube highlighted by the turquoise box in the right panel of Figure 8, at , covering and (extending further from the axis than the box); quantities as in Figure 9. The jet-dominated tube (right) is bounded on its disk-facing side by the contour (green). On the disk side of this contour the in-plane field curls into closed loops, a large one at , and a smaller one at , ; these are the vortical features noted in Figure 8.
Figure 11. Zoom into the region below the midplane to the right of the jet at (left panel of Figure 8), covering and ; quantities as in Figure 9. Gas with a higher jet fraction (, left) is separated from more disk-dominated gas (right) at the outer contour (green). Outside this contour the in-plane field forms several closed loops; the largest, elongated one lies directly against the contour at to .
To connect the midplane and meridional views with the actual flow of material along magnetic structures, we integrate representative magnetic field lines in full 3D with a fourth-order Runge–Kutta integrator along the local magnetic field (Figure 12 and Figure 13). We distinguish ‘jet lines’, seeded just outside the horizon in a narrow polar cone, from ‘disk lines’, seeded in the equatorial midplane at ; Figure 14 shows disk and jet lines down to the footpoints of the disk lines in the equatorial plane. For each line we record the magnetisation and the loading with disk material as a function of height, and . Figure 12 plots these quantities for a single representative jet line (blue) and several disk lines (orange). The jet line starts near the horizon at high magnetisation and negligible disk-tracer content, remaining loaded almost purely with jet-origin plasma until it reaches –. In this range the disk lines, which begin at the midplane with low and high , have already risen through the flux tube to the jet sheath. They first coil among themselves and then around the jet line (as seen in Figure 13), in agreement with Nalewajko et al. (2026), gradually transferring mass into the jet line. This exchange appears in Figure 12 as a modest but clear rise in along the jet line while its magnetisation declines from toward intermediate values. Above the bundle of disk and jet lines bends away from the axis, consistent with the helical distortion of the jet that follows a flux eruption (Nalewajko et al. 2026), and the lines settle into the sheath, characterised by intermediate magnetisation and mixed (but still disk-dominated) composition, consistent with the diagnostic and – plots discussed earlier.
!Magnetisation and disk-tracer density along representative magnetic field lines. Panel (a) shows versus and panel (b) shows versus . The legend identifies disk field lines and jet field lines. bbox=0.13,0.08,0.47,0.54
Figure 12. Magnetisation and disk-tracer density along representative magnetic field lines. Top: as a function of height ; bottom: along the same lines. The blue curve shows a jet line, seeded near the horizon, that starts at high magnetisation and negligible disk content. Orange curves show disk lines seeded in the equatorial midplane at . Disk lines begin at low and high , rise through the flux tube to the jet sheath, and coil around the jet line, gradually losing disk mass as they mix with jet-origin plasma. Correspondingly, the jet line exhibits a clear increase in as it passes through –, where the tubes interact most strongly. Above this region the combined bundle of disk and jet lines bends away from the axis into the sheath. The horizontal line in the top panel marks , separating matter-dominated () from magnetically dominated () segments along each field line.
Figure 13. Zoomed 3D view of a flux tube resulting from an eruption. Both panels show magnetic field lines, clipped to and . Orange lines are seeded in the equatorial midplane (disk lines), blue lines are seeded near the horizon in the polar cone (jet lines). Semi-transparent yellow and cyan surfaces mark, respectively, the iso-surface (the jet boundary) and the iso-surface, which encloses all unbound, outflowing gas (the jet sheath lies between the two surfaces), restricted to the same box. The left and right panels correspond to viewing azimuths and . The disk lines start out predominantly toroidal in the disk and run predominantly vertically through the flux tube; they coil among themselves and then wrap around the jet lines where the tube connects to the jet sheath, before both sets of lines bend away from the axis into the sheath. The full height of the tube, down to the equatorial plane, is shown in Figure 14.
Figure 14. Three-dimensional view of disk (orange) and jet (blue) magnetic field lines over the full height of the flux tube, from the equatorial plane up to , complementing the clipped view in Figure 13. The equatorial slice shows at with magnetic potential () contours as black lines, so that the footpoints of the disk lines are visible. Semi-transparent grey and green surfaces mark the and iso-surfaces, respectively.
In terms of the mass distribution over magnetisation (), the mass of disk material at sheath-like () and jet-like () magnetisations increases during the eruption, while over the same period (between and ) the mass of former jet material at disk-like and sheath-like magnetisations () also increases, indicating that both disk and former jet material are carried by the ejected flux tubes. The jet boundary is thus not compositionally static: it is repeatedly and intermittently loaded with disk-origin plasma.
Discussion
The redistribution of disk and jet material that we find during flux eruptions can be understood within the framework of flux eruption dynamics (McKinney & Narayan 2007; Tchekhovskoy et al. 2011; Ripperda et al. 2022). In the pre-eruption state, magnetic flux accumulates on the horizon and powers the jet through the Blandford–Znajek mechanism. Once the flux saturates, the magnetic pressure balances the ram pressure of the accreting gas, and the accretion flow near the horizon is squeezed into a thin equatorial current sheet that becomes tearing unstable and reconnects. This reconnection ejects a flux tube into the disk, which then orbits the black hole while moving outwards in radius (Ripperda et al. 2022). Both the reconnection and the ejected flux tubes can accelerate particles (Hakobyan et al. 2023; Zhdankin et al. 2023). Our tracer diagnostics reveal the compositional signature of this process for the first time in 3D.
In the mass distributions over magnetisation, this process appears as disk material being shifted from disk-like to sheath-like magnetisations as the eruption proceeds. We interpret this as follows: the ejected flux tubes mix with the disk at their outer boundaries through Rayleigh–Taylor-like instabilities, and the disk material mixed into a tube can then move vertically along it to where the tube connects to the jet sheath, while the tube itself moves outwards.
As shown in § 3.2 (Figure 3), the net flux of disk material across the jet boundary changes from close to zero to strongly positive during the eruption.
From an observational perspective, this redistribution of material may have important multi-wavelength and multi-messenger consequences. In real systems, the floored material is expected to be dominated by pair plasma. We stress, however, that the floor tracer only records where this material resides: it carries no information on the actual pair content, which is set by pair-production physics not included in our GRMHD simulation. With this caveat, such material could supply a leptonic population that, if a fraction is accelerated to relativistic energies, can produce synchrotron emission and thereby increase the local synchrotron photon density. These photons can subsequently act as seed photons for synchrotron self-Compton (SSC) scattering, potentially enhancing the inverse-Compton emission from the inner jet (Böttcher et al. 2013). The disk-origin component could instead primarily increase the baryonic content and inertia of the outflow. If a fraction of the ions from the disk were subsequently accelerated, they could provide an energetic proton population potentially capable of producing secondary emission through hadronic interactions. In proton–proton () interactions, the surrounding disk-origin baryons may provide the target material for the accelerated protons, whereas in proton–photon () interactions the target is the local photon field, which may include synchrotron photons produced by the accelerated leptonic component; both channels produce pions, whose decays yield neutrinos and -rays. Additionally, if disk material is accelerated in the jet boundary it can potentially be a source of cosmic rays. Thus, if the two tracer populations are taken as proxies for pairs and baryons, the material they track at the jet boundary could influence the high-energy emission through distinct but coupled channels. During flux eruptions, the order-unity enhancement of disk-origin material at the jet boundary and in the inner sheath found in our simulations could therefore transiently modify the composition, baryon density, and available non-thermal particle reservoir there, while concurrent changes in the floor-origin component (a proxy for, but not a measure of, the pair content) could alter the synchrotron photon field relevant for SSC and interactions. Although our simulations do not directly model particle acceleration or radiative transfer, these changes in the disk- and floor-origin content of the jet boundary provide a physically motivated pathway by which variations in mass loading could modulate VHE -ray and neutrino emission without requiring the jet as a whole to be hadron dominated at all times.
Black hole X-ray binaries (BHXRBs) in luminous states are in a different regime from the radiatively inefficient flow simulated here: their accretion flows are radiatively cooled and need to be modelled with radiative GRMHD. When such flows reach the MAD regime, the disk truncates and magnetic flux is expelled over much longer timescales, rather than in the recurrent eruption cycle seen in our simulation [72]. The decay of magnetic flux in such truncated disks also produces flux tubes [72 Musoke et al., in prep.], which can potentially connect disk material to the jet in the same way as the flux tubes in our simulation. We therefore do not relate the timescales of our eruption cycle to the rapid, correlated X-ray and optical/infrared variability observed in BHXRBs (e.g., Gandhi et al. 2008, 2010; Casella et al. 2010; Gandhi et al. 2017), but we note that flux tubes may act as highways for disk material into the jet in these systems as well.
Semi-analytical multi-zone jet models (e.g., Lucchini et al. 2022), which enable broadband modelling of black hole X-ray binaries, place the onset of non-thermal particle acceleration on compact jet scales, although the inferred distance is source-dependent; for example, modelling of GX 339–4 places it at [33]. More importantly for the present work, the semi-analytical mass-loaded jet model of Kantzas et al. (2023) identifies as the fiducial location at which mass entrainment begins, explicitly linking the onset of mass loading to the inner acceleration/dissipation region. These models demonstrate that substantial dynamical processing and the injection of baryonic material can begin at , well inside the region subsequently probed by large-scale jet–environment interactions (Lucchini et al. 2022; Kantzas et al. 2023). This provides a natural connection to the recent detection of TeV -ray emission from Galactic jet sources by LHAASO, including V4641 Sgr and SS 433, which demonstrates that particle acceleration can persist or be re-established on macroscopic scales (Cao et al. 2025). In particular, the extended emission associated with these systems indicates that the highest-energy particles need not be accelerated exclusively in the compact inner jet, but can instead arise from interactions between the evolved outflow and its surrounding interstellar medium. Within this multi-scale picture, the efficient disk mass loading found in our GRMHD simulations, as traced in the jet boundary and sheath, provides the physical connection between the two regimes. Material entrained and accelerated near the launching region establishes the baryonic content, inertia, and momentum flux of the outflow, while the associated magnetic-to-kinetic energy conversion determines the kinetic power ultimately transported to larger distances.
Similarly, the IceCube neutrino event IC 170922A was associated with a -ray flare of the blazar TXS 0506+056 [60]. As discussed in § 1, this association points to hadronic acceleration that likely requires significant baryon loading close to the black hole. TXS 0506+056 is, however, a luminous source, whose accretion flow is likely radiatively efficient and therefore not directly described by our simulation. Moreover, the duration of flux eruptions depends on the reconnection rate, which is underestimated in ideal GRMHD simulations such as ours, so we do not compare timescales directly. Luminous, truncated disks can nevertheless also expel magnetic flux and produce flux tubes that connect the disk to the jet [72 Musoke et al., in prep.]. During flux eruptions in our simulation (§ 3.2), the exchange of disk material across the jet boundary at – changes from nearly balanced () to an inflow that exceeds the outflow by a
factor of –. If luminous, truncated disks produce flux tubes that behave similarly, such episodes of enhanced sheath loading could provide a trigger for flaring of this kind.
Using the mass of M87* (), the gravitational time is days. Hence an eruption cycle period of – translates to – years, the MAD phase duration () to days, and the fast eruption drop () to days. These numbers are in rough agreement with the long-term X-ray/radio variability patterns reported for the M87* jet (e.g., Hada et al. 2016; Kim et al. 2018). In particular, the day rise time of individual eruptions matches the fastest flares from the nucleus of M87 seen by Chandra and Swift (see also Ripperda et al. 2022). The intraday X-ray variability of the M87 core, which traces emission from the base of the jet on scales of , has been observed with a timescale of days (e.g., with Chandra), consistent with the rapid fluctuations seen in our simulation during the buildup and eruption phases. Our phase classification therefore provides a physical framework for interpreting the multi-wavelength variability of M87* and other low-luminosity systems that may be in a MAD state.
An important implication of this flux-tube picture is that the mass loading of the jet boundary is intermittent and tied to the eruption cycle, in agreement with Chow et al. (2026). The Rayleigh–Taylor–like plumes at the tube–disk interface (Ripperda et al. 2022), together with the helical, kink-like distortions of the jet where the tubes connect to it (Nalewajko et al. 2026), provide natural sites where dense gas from the disk is injected into regions of intermediate magnetisation () and relativistic bulk motion at . In these !Panel (a): versus ; panel (b): versus , with disk and jet field lines bbox=0.13,0.08,0.47,0.54
zones, magnetic energy may be converted into non-thermal particle energy via reconnection and current-driven or shear-driven instabilities, which have been shown to accelerate particles (Davelaar et al. 2020; Sironi et al. 2021), while the enhanced baryon fraction may supply the hadronic targets required for and interactions. This suggests that flux eruptions may seed localised, baryon-rich patches in the jet sheath and jet boundary that may be capable of powering the VHE flares and neutrino production discussed in § 1, without requiring the jet as a whole to be hadron-dominated. Our results therefore support a scenario in which repeated flux eruptions in MAD systems act as a ‘highway’ that episodically injects disk material into the magnetised jet sheath, potentially linking accretion dynamics to the transient VHE and neutrino activity of accreting black holes.
Conclusions
In this work we have used a high–spin MAD GRMHD simulation with rotated coordinates, adaptive mesh refinement, and strictly conserved eulerian tracers to investigate how accretion disks interact with, and mass-load, their relativistic jets. Our main results can be summarised as follows.
(i) Flux eruptions load the jet sheath through flux tubes. During a flux eruption, reconnection in the equatorial current sheet ejects a coherent flux tube into the disk (Ripperda et al. 2022), and the reconnection fills the tube with former jet material. At the outer boundary of the tube, Rayleigh–Taylor-like instabilities mix this former jet material into the disk, leaving behind low-density cavities in the midplane, while the same instabilities mix disk material into the tube. As the flux tube moves outwards, its connection point to the jet moves upwards (Nalewajko et al. 2026). Disk material moves along the flux tube and is mixed into the jet at the tube–jet boundary, mass-loading the jet sheath.
(ii) Streamline view of disk–jet exchange. By integrating 3D field lines from disk and jet seeds, we follow individual flux tubes up to the jet. Jet lines start near the horizon with high and negligible disk content, while disk lines originate at the midplane with low and high . Magnetised field lines originating at the jet base and weakly magnetised field lines originating in the disk connect where the flux tube connects to the jet, and mix there, indicating mass loading: the jet line acquires a modest but distinct increase in as it passes through the point where the flux tube connects to the jet. Above this region the jet shows signs of a helical, kink-like distortion (Nalewajko et al. 2026).
(iii) Implications for hadronic loading and emission. Although the absolute amount of jet-origin (floor) material at low remains small, the eruption-driven exchange between disk and jet tracer components enhances the loading of the jet sheath and jet boundary with disk material by order-unity factors. The ejected flux tubes therefore offer a plausible mechanism for intermittently supplying the hadronic content required by high-energy -ray and neutrino observations, without demanding that the jet as a whole be hadron dominated.
Future work will build on these results constraining where and when baryons enter the jet, to quantifying how turbulence in the baryon-loaded sheath shapes particle acceleration and the multi–messenger output of accreting black holes.
Data availability
Plotting scripts and relevant data objects can be found on 10.5281/zenodo.24139886. The H-AMR code itself, along with the dumps can be provided under reasonable request by S.P., or M.T.P.L.
Acknowledgements
S.P. thanks Oliver Porth for his useful discussions and suggestions. S.P., A.L.S. and S.M. are supported by a European Research Council Synergy Grant ‘Blackholistic’ (grant agreement no. 101071643). This work was supported by a grant from the Simons Foundation (MP-SCMPS-00001470). L.S. acknowledges support from DoE Early Career Award DE-SC0023015, NASA ATP 80NSSC24K1238, NASA ATP 80NSSC24K1826, NSF AST-2307202, and the Multimessenger Plasma Physics Center (MPPC), grant NSF PHY-2206609. B.R. acknowledges the support of the Natural Sciences and Engineering Research Council of Canada (NSERC) funding reference numbers RGPIN-2023-04844 and ALLRP 592744. B.R. is supported by a grant from the Simons Foundation (MP-SCMPS-00001470). B.R. is supported by the Canadian Space Agency
(23JWGO2A01). The computational resources and services used in this work were partially provided by SciNet, Compute Ontario, Calcul Quebec and the Digital Research Alliance of Canada (alliancecan.ca), compute allocation rrg-ripperda and rrg-dhaggard. ML was supported by the NASA Hubble Fellowship Program fellowships, NSF grants AST-2407809 and AST-2606780, and NASA grant 80NSSC22K0817. S.P. also credits use of A.I., specifically claude for help with data visualisation and grammar/word checks.
Flipped metric derivation for coordinate flip
We begin with the standard spherical coordinates where corresponds to the positive -axis (jet direction) and corresponds to the equatorial plane (disk midplane). We transform to new coordinates via a 90-degree rotation about the -axis:
In spherical coordinates, this transformation becomes:
From these relations, we derive:
In spherical Kerr-Schild coordinates , the metric components are (Kerr 1963; Schild 1967):
For the coordinate transformation, the transformed metric components are given by:
The Jacobian matrix elements for our 90-degree rotation are:
where the inverse relations are:
After applying the rotation transformation, the metric in the new coordinates becomes:
Note that in the rotated coordinates, the jet axis (originally at ) now corresponds to , eliminating the coordinate singularity.
Initial tracer distribution
At , we initialise the tracer fractions based on the initial plasma distribution. All plasma within the Fishbone-Moncrief torus (Fishbone & Moncrief 1976) is assigned disk tracer fraction and floor tracer fraction . Conversely, all plasma outside the torus is initialised with and . These fractions satisfy the conservation constraint at all times and locations. Figure B1 shows the initial tracer distribution at .
Figure B1. Initial density configuration at showing the decomposition into floor and disk components in the meridional plane (). Panel (a) displays the floor density and panel (b) shows the disk density , both in logarithmic scale.
Numerical mass conservation with tracers
+We study the magnitude of the numerical error (mass divergence) using logarithmic normalization to capture deviations from mass continuity across multiple orders of magnitude in Figure C1. The yellow contour indicates the field lines projected to the x-z slice, showing correspondence of the white noise region with poloidal field dominated regions in the jet. The numerical errors are well within machine precision and arise from the limiting contribution of the grid and the numerical schemes employed to evolve the fluid equations in the strong-field regime.
Adaptive mesh refinement
To efficiently resolve the multi-scale physics governing jet-disk interactions while maintaining computational tractability, we employ a block-based AMR approach implemented within the H-AMR framework ([71]). H-AMR utilises different prolongation and restriction operators for cell-centered (Berger & Oliger 1984; Berger & Colella 1989) and face-centered variables (Balsara 2001). This offers stable dynamic spatial refinement based on the following discussion, coupled with local adaptive time-stepping based on the Courant–Friedrichs–Lewy (CFL) condition (Courant et al. 1928), offering an efficient test bed to study our physics goals.
This strategy allows us to reach an effective resolution of cells in the most refined simulation state. We apply uniform AMR, i.e. all refinement criteria trigger the same maximum refinement level. The refinement criteria are as follows:
Jet refinement: The jet is identified using the magnetization parameter and the Bernoulli parameter , where is the specific enthalpy and the contravariant time component of the four-velocity (Tchekhovskoy et al. 2011; McKinney et al. 2012):
This criterion targets the highly magnetised () and unbound () regions characteristic of relativistic jets (Mościbrodzka et al. 2016, 2014).
Jet sheath refinement: The jet sheath is identified by moderate magnetization and outflowing Bernoulli parameter values (Porth et al. 2019; Chatterjee et al. 2019):
This range captures the transition region between the magnetically-dominated jet core and the thermally-dominated disk (Nalewajko et al. 2014a; Wong et al. 2021).
Turbulence and gradient refinement: To capture magnetic reconnection and turbulent structures, we employ a gradient-based criterion using the magnetic field strength (Ripperda et al. 2021; Chernoglazov et al. 2021):
where is the local cell size (). The refinement decision is based on a composite criterion that combines several plasma parameters:
where refinement is triggered when . Figure D1 shows the plasma parameters and the refinement criterion over the grid.

Figure D1. Adaptive mesh refinement structure in GRMHD black hole jet-disk simulations. Meridional slices showing AMR block structure and key plasma diagnostics for a high-spin black hole simulation () at . Cyan contours at mark the boundary of the outflow, and black lines mark the block boundaries. (a) Magnetization parameter revealing magnetically dominated regions in the jet () versus magnetically sub-dominant disk regions (). (b) Plasma delineating the jet-disk interface where , with regions of indicating magnetically-dominated plasma in the jet and showing pressure-dominated gas in the accretion disk. (c) Magnetic field gradient magnitude highlighting sites of strong field structure variation. (d) Combined refinement metric incorporating three criteria: jet core refinement ( and , colored dark green), jet sheath refinement ( and , intermediate green), and turbulence-based refinement (sensitive to , yellow/orange). Black crosses mark the center of each block which meets the refinement criteria in this snapshot (). Blocks the same size but not having these crosses were part of the same parent block that met the criteria before but not post refinement
dM/dlnsigma diagnostics: Calculations and practical considerations
To quantify the composition of jet and disk material across the simulation domain we employ a diagnostic that measures the mass distribution per logarithmic interval of magnetisation, , defined as . This diagnostic, computed at multiple radial cuts , provides a scale-dependent view of how mass is distributed between weakly magnetised (disk-like, ), moderately magnetised (sheath-like, ), and strongly magnetised (jet-like, ) plasma states, where the disk–sheath boundary is defined as (the mean sigma measured along the magnetic field streamlines along the sheath). Following the volume-element integration scheme of McKinney (2006) and Porth et al. (2019), we compute
where is the tracer fraction for either disk-origin material (, tracer 1) or floor/jet-origin material (, tracer 2), and is the metric determinant serving as the covariant volume element. In practice, the integral over is replaced by a discrete sum over the azimuthal cells with uniform spacing , while the integrals over and are replaced by a sum over all grid cells within . The per-cell mass contribution is therefore
where is evaluated at each grid point and broadcast to all azimuthal cells.
We bin logarithmically over bins spanning the range , where is the minimum positive in the domain (floored at to avoid numerical zeros) and is the maximum. The bin edges are
and the bin centre is taken as the geometric mean . Within each bin the distribution is approximated as
This ensures adequate sampling across the orders of magnitude dynamic range from (disk dominated) to (the maximum in the simulation, set by the density floor and reached in the jet core).
Mass integrals and composition diagnostics
By integrating the curves over we obtain the total tracer-weighted masses
The integration employs Simpson’s rule when the number of nonempty bins exceeds two, with a trapezoidal fallback for undersampled curves and a single-bin approximation () otherwise. To characterise the composition in specific magnetisation bands we additionally integrate over two restricted ranges. In the high- band we compute
and in the low- band we compute and via the same procedure. These quantities are used later when we discuss the relative contributions of disk and jet/floor material in the disk, sheath, and jet bands.
Jet-shell mass budget
To isolate the composition of the jet () we additionally compute the disk and jet/floor masses directly inside the magnetisation-defined jet shell, defined as the set of cells satisfying and with and . For each such cell the tracer-weighted mass is
and the total masses in the jet shell are
Unlike the integrals, which are computed via logarithmic binning, the jet-shell masses are computed by direct cell summation without binning, making them sensitive to the instantaneous composition of the jet.
Jet-boundary mass flux
To track the time-resolved exchange of disk and jet/floor material across the jet boundary, we compute the tracer-weighted mass flux through the surface. We define the jet boundary at each radius as the set of cells satisfying and having at least one meridional () neighbour with . This identifies the outermost layer of jet cells, adjacent to the lower-magnetisation sheath and disk. The normal to the jet boundary is approximated by the gradient of in the plane,
computed via second-order centred finite differences,
The normal component of the four-velocity at each wall cell is then
where and are the contravariant radial and meridional components of the fluid four-velocity. The tracer-weighted mass flux through the area element is
where gives the magnitude of the normal flux. The direction (into or out of the jet) of mass transport across the jet boundary is determined from the velocity component normal to the boundary, rather than from alone. Since the jet is defined by , the gradient points toward increasing magnetization and therefore toward the interior of the jet. We define the normal component of the velocity as
The magnitude of the normal velocity is therefore . The sign of determines the direction of transport across the jet boundary: corresponds to flow into the jet, while corresponds to flow out of the jet. This definition accounts for both radial and polar motion and does not assume that the sign of alone determines whether gas enters or leaves the funnel.
The total inward and outward fluxes for each tracer are consequently
integrated over the radial band and summed over both hemispheres. We report these quantities separately for the disk tracer () and the jet/floor tracer (), to diagnose any inflow-outflow asymmetry during the eruption.
This paper has been typeset from a TeX/LaTeX file prepared by the author.
References
- [33]Connors R. M. T., et al., 2019, Monthly Notices of the Royal Astronomical Society, 485, 3696
- [40]Event Horizon Telescope Collaboration 2021a, The Astrophysical Journal Letters, 910, L12
- [44]Fiorillo D. F. G., Petropoulou M., Comisso L., Peretti E., Sironi L., 2024a, ApJ, 961, L14
- [60]IceCube Collaboration et al., 2018, Science, 361, eaat1378
- [71]Liska M. T. P., et al., 2022a, ApJS, 263, 26
- [72]Liska M. T. P., Musoke G., Tchekhovskoy A., Porth O., Beloborodov A. M., 2022b, ApJ, 935, L1














