WorksPhysics and Astronomy
Towards polarization-enhanced PET: Study of random background in polarization-correlated Compton events
Abstract
Positron Emission Tomography (PET) is a medical imaging modality that utilizes positron-emitting isotopes, such as Ga-68 and F-18, for many diagnostic purposes. The positron annihilates with an electron from the surrounding area, creating two photons of 511 keV energy and opposite momenta, entangled in their orthogonal polarizations. When each photon undergoes a Compton scattering process, the difference of their azimuthal scattering angles reflects the initial orthogonality of their polarizations, peaking at 90. This type of correlation is not yet utilized in conventional PET scanners, but could potentially offer an energy-independent method for background reduction. Measurements of these kinds of correlations can be achieved using Compton polarimeters, built from a single layer of segmented scintillating crystals such as Gadolinium Aluminium Gallium Garnet doped with Cerium (GAGG:Ce), read out by silicon photomultipliers (SiPMs). In this paper, we study the signal-to-random background ratios in measurements of these correlated annihilation photons from coincidence time spectra across clinically relevant source activities, from 200 MBq to 378 MBq. These are then compared to the standard single-pixel (photoelectric) measurements. We find that the signal-to-random background ratios (SBRs) obtained from the polarization-correlated events for Compton scattering angles and azimuthal angle difference are consistently higher than those from single-pixel events, with the ratio of their SBR values of 1.23. The SBR of the selected events also increases with the polarimetric modulation factor , gaining 50% in value during the experiment.
Introduction
Recently, a new path for enhancing Positron Emission Tomography (PET) has been proposed, to utilize the correlation of polarization of annihilation photons [1, 2, 3, 4]. Quantum mechanics, through parity and spin conservation, necessitates the entanglement of the two annihilation photons, reflected in orthogonality of their polarizations [5] - a property not yet utilized in PET, which conventionally measures only their 511 keV energies and opposite momenta. To create a line of response (LOR) through the annihilation site, the two photons originating from it must be detected in coincidence. Since the timing window is finite, it opens an opportunity for the detection of two uncorrelated photons, creating a random coincidence event. Such a LOR does not correspond to the annihilation site and, consequently, degrades the quality of the image. The information about the entanglement of the annihilation photons, exploited by measurement of their polarization correlations, is therefore an independent tool to reduce the random coincidence background, since it lacks this type of correlation [1, 2, 3, 6, 7].
The polarization correlations of annihilation photons can be measured through the Compton scattering process [5, 8] (Figure 1). If both annihilation photons detected in coincidence undergo Compton scattering in their respective detectors, through measurements of the Compton scattering angle and azimuthal scattering angle , it is possible to deduce the azimuthal scattering angle difference . The values reflect the initial orthogonality of the polarizations (Figure 2), with the largest cross-section for the difference for fixed values of [5]:
Figure 1. Simplified schematics of the experimental setup. The figure represents two segmented scintillating GAGG detector modules (in yellow) with SiPMs (in blue) in a coincidence measurement setup, read-out by the ToFPET2 ASIC system. The source (in green) emits two polarization-correlated annihilation photons (in purple) that undergo Compton scattering in their respective detector modules with Compton scattering angles and azimuthal scattering angles .
Figure 2. Acceptance corrected distribution at the sixth measurement position. The Compton scattering angle range was selected as . The highlighted regions denote the azimuthal difference range of events selected for further analysis. The regions shaded in blue correspond to the , and denote the highest probability of polarization correlations, while the regions shaded in pink, with , denote the lowest probability of two photons having correlated polarizations.
with and , where is the classical electron radius, are the solid angles, are the Compton scattering angles, and is the difference of the azimuthal scattering angles of photon 1 and 2, respectively. The polarimetric modulation factor :
reflects the sensitivity of the detector setup to the initial orthogonality of the polarizations. This factor will have the highest value of for for an ideal detector [2] in the absence of background. The experimentally determined values will always be lower than the maximum due to the finite detector acceptance. In addition, the measured value of could depend on the environment in which the positron is emitted [9], and as shown in this work, on the random background rate. There is also an ongoing experimental [10, 11, 12, 13], as well as theoretical discussions about the precise description of the conducted measurements and the nature of the annihilation process [14, 15, 16, 17, 18].
Various concepts of utilizing polarization correlations to improve event classification in PET have been investigated experimentally [3, 19, 7, 20] under specific laboratory conditions. This work continues the exploration of the polarization-sensitive PET concept, building upon the initial results obtained with the demonstrator setup [21, 22]. It presents the first detailed comparative study of the random background in single-pixel hit events, and correlated Compton events.
Methods
The detector modules
Two detector modules were assembled from four matrices of GAGG:Ce crystals, with each crystal sized at , totaling two detector matrices with a matrix pitch. The SiPMs (Hamamatsu Photonics, model S13361-0808A) were glued to the crystals in a one-to-one coupling with optical cement (EJ-500, Eljen Technology, USA). The relative energy resolutions at of the two detectors were found to be and [19]. The detector modules were mounted on a rotating gantry and arranged so that their faces opposed each other at a distance of , with a container of the Ga-68 solution placed between the modules at the center of the gantry’s ring (Figure 1).
Data acquisition
Measurements were conducted at the Department of Nuclear Medicine and Radiation Protection, University Hospital Centre Zagreb, with a Ga-68 isotope source with an initial activity of . The read-out and digitization of the data acquired in this setup were performed with the TOFPET2 ASIC system (PETsys Electronics — Medical PET Detectors, S.A., Oeiras, Portugal)[23]. It was set to trigger on coincidences in which at least one pixel fired per module.
Each such hit had a timestamp that allowed grouping the hits within 100 ns into events. In case of the events in which two pixels fired in a module, only the pixel of the first interaction was considered. The pixel that is considered to have fired first is the one with lower deposited energy [24]. The difference in timestamps for events in which two pixels fired in opposite detectors can be seen in Figure 3, which represents plots of coincidence time spectra at the highest activity. The duration of the experiment was approximately one hour, and the duration of acquisition at each of the 12 positions around the source ( apart) is given in Table 1.
| Position | Acquisition time [s] | Total time [s] | Activity [MBq] |
| 1 | 240 | 260 | 377.7 |
| 2 | 251 | 272 | 361.4 |
| 3 | 262 | 283 | 345.1 |
| 4 | 275 | 297 | 328.9 |
| 5 | 289 | 311 | 312.7 |
| 6 | 304 | 326 | 296.6 |
| 7 | 322 | 345 | 280.6 |
| 8 | 341 | 364 | 264.6 |
| 9 | 362 | 387 | 248.8 |
| 10 | 387 | 412 | 232.9 |
| 11 | 415 | 441 | 217.2 |
| 12 | 447 | 475 | 201.5 |
Table 1. The experiment was conducted by rotating the detector modules around the Ga-68 source, and the data were acquired in 12 positions. The length of acquisition at each position is given in the Table, as well as the total time (acquisition length with added time required for rotation to the next position) and activity of the Ga-68 source at the start of each acquisition.
Figure 3. Coincidence time spectra for a) single-pixel (photoelectric) events and b) polarization-correlated Compton events. The selected signal (in green) is estimated as from the mean calculated by the Gaussian fit (red curve) to the highest peak in each spectrum. The random background (in blue) is estimated as area, removed from the calculated mean by .
Data selection and analysis
From the collected events, two types of events were selected: the single-pixel events, where each detector module fired with only one pixel in which the full energy (from 400 keV to 600 keV) of the annihilation photon was deposited (i.e., photoelectric events), and events with two pixels fired per module with the sum of the deposited annihilation photon energies in the full-energy range, with the minimum deposited energy of 120 keV per pixel. From the energies of the two pixels, Compton scattering angles can be determined:
and from the topology of the detector modules, the azimuthal scattering angle :
The measured distribution of the difference of the azimuthal scattering angles is influenced by the distance of the two pixels that fired , since the detector has non-uniform acceptance for different event topologies, with events in which is very large being almost negligible. This acceptance effect is corrected by normalizing the obtained distribution according to:
where is obtained from uncorrelated events [8]. The corrected distribution allows the quantification of the polarimetric modulation factor by fitting the Pryce-Ward-shaped relation:
as can be seen in Figure 2. The more in-depth description of the analysis process can be found in [8, 22, 25].
The coincidence time spectra for measurements at the highest activity (first position) are presented in Figure 3. The central peak was fitted by a Gaussian to determine its mean and standard deviation, and the data selected within from the peak centroid (i.e. ns from the peak) was considered as a signal. The random background data was chosen as a wide area at ( ns) distance from the calculated peak. The small off center peaks are a know artifact of the TOFPET2 ASIC [26]. The regions of interest are chosen to avoid them. After normalization of the random background data, the signal-to-random background (SBR) ratio is calculated by dividing the number of selected events in the signal and random background areas.
The data analysis was conducted in ROOT [27], with the optimization help from the GNU parallel command [28]. The obtained data was plotted in Python.
Results
We first investigated how the polarimetric modulation factor behaves during the measurements with this experimental setup at high (approx. 200 MBq - 378 MBq) activity levels. The results are presented in Figure 4. For angular selection of , we considered two samples based on Compton event topology, one with any pair of fired pixels, the other containing pairs with the nearest neighbors excluded ( mm). A third sample with , and all pixel pairs is added for comparison. The first sample exhibits increase in as the source activity declines from MBq to MBq. The second, shows higher values than the former, which is expected [29, 25] owing to better angular precision. The selection also has a gain of at the end of the measurement. The third sample demonstrates the lower polarimetric sensitivity, as expected from eq. (2), with a maximum . In addition,
Figure 4. The measured values of the polarimetric modulation factor exhibit higher values at lower source activity levels for all selected event topologies.
we explored how the SBR values of these samples vary with the source activity. The results can be seen in Figure 5. We observe a clear gain in SBR at the lower activities, however the difference between the samples is not pronounced.
Figure 5. The variation of SBR of different polarization-correlated events’ topologies compared to the single-pixel events with the source activity .
We also examined how the signal-to-random background ratios, calculated from the coincidence time spectra (Figure 3), varied with the source activity for single-pixel events and different selections of polarization-correlated events. In Figure 6, the events with polarization-correlated quanta at and (i.e. the blue-shaded area in Figure 2) exhibit higher random background suppression compared to the single-pixel events and the polarization-correlated events with the same selection; however, the selection of the that encompasses the valleys of the distribution (areas shaded in pink in Figure 2) shows the lowest SBR of all examined event types.
Figure 6. The SBR variation with the source activity, , for different event samples.
The SBR dependence of the polarization-correlated events on the polarimetric modulation factor has been extracted and shown in Figure 7. It demonstrates an increase of the SBR by a factor of with variation in range. This signals that the polarimetric modulation is a clear indication of the random background contents of the sample.
Figure 7. The variation of the SBR with the modulation factor , for events with .
Finally, we extracted the ratio of the SBR values for selected polarization-correlated events and single-pixel events [8]. We observe a falling trend with the ratio being reduced at higher activities, but remains larger than 1, favoring polarization-correlated events in this respect.
Discussion and conclusion
We performed an experimental study using a polarization-sensitive PET demonstration setup. Data from a Ga-68 source were acquired, with activity in 200-380
Figure 8. The ratios of the SBR values obtained with the polarization-correlated events and single-pixel events and their linear dependance on the source activity .
MBq range. Polarization-correlated events, with specific two pixel topologies were selected, along with a sample of single-pixel events.
For the polarization correlated Compton events, we demonstrate a higher SBR for any selected event topology, compared to single-pixel events. For the largest selected sample of those events ( and azimuthal angle difference ), this ratio remains above 1.1, suggesting that the polarization-correlated events may be a valuable resource for PET imaging. We also observe a raising trend of this ratio with lower activities, pointing at further enhancement.
This study also reveals for the first time the dependence of the signal-to-random background ratio on the polarimetric modulation factor. This clear correlation indicates that can be an additional estimator of the random background, complementary to single rate-based or delayed window-based random estimates in PET imaging. The dependence of the on the random background has also implications on proposed polarization-sensitive positronium imaging [20], where it needs to be disentangled from the positronium formation effects.
Acknowledgements
This work was supported by the “Research Cooperability” Program of the Croatian Science Foundation, funded by the European Union from the European Social Fund under the Operational Programme Efficient Human Resources 2014–2020, grant number PZS-2019-02-5829. This work was also supported by the Croatian Science Foundation under the project number IP-2022-10-3878.
References
- [1]Kuncic Z, McNamara A, Wu K, and Boardman D. Polarization enhanced x-ray imaging for biomedicine. Nuclear Instruments and Methods in Physics Research Section A: Accelerators, Spectrometers, Detectors and Associated Equipment, 648:S208–S210, 2011.DOI
- [2]Toghyani M, Gillam JE, McNamara A, and Kuncic Z. Polarisation-based coincidence event discrimination: An in silico study towards a feasible scheme for Compton-PET. Physics in Medicine and Biology, 61:5803–5817, 2016.DOI
- [3]Watts DP, Bordes J, Brown JR, Cherlin A, Newton R, Allison J, Bashkanov M, Effthimiou N, and Zachariou NA. Photon quantum entanglement in the MeV regime and its application in PET imaging. Nature Communications, 12:2646, 2021.DOI
- [4]Moskal P. Positron Emission Tomography Could Be Aided by Entanglement. Physics, 17:138, September 2024.DOI
- [5]M. H. L. Pryce and J. C. Ward. Angular correlation effects with annihilation radiation. Nature, 160:4065, 1947.DOI
- [6]McNamara A, Toghyani M, Gillam JE, Wu K, and Kuncic Z. Towards optimal imaging with PET: An in silico feasibility study. Physics in Medicine and Biology, 59:7587–7600, 2014.DOI
- [7]Kim D, Rachman AN, Taisei U, Uenomachi M, Shimazoe K, and Takahashi H. Background reduction in PET by double compton scattering of quantum entangled annihilation photon. Journal of Instrumentation, 18:P07007, 2023.DOI
- [8]Makek M, Bosnar D, Pavelić L, Šenjug P, and Žugec P. Single-layer Compton detectors for measurement of polarization correlations of annihilation quanta. Nuclear Instruments and Methods in Physics Research Section A: Accelerators, Spectrometers, Detectors and Associated Equipment, 958:162835, 2020.DOI
- [9]Kumar D, Sharma S, and Moskal P On behalf of J-PET collaboration. Investigating quantum entanglement of high-energy photons from positron annihilation in a porous medium. Journal of Physics: Conference Series, 3029(1):012006, June 2025.DOI
- [10]Ivashkin A, Abdurashitov D, Baranov A, Guber F, Morozov S, Musin S, Strizhak A, and Tkachev I. Testing entanglement of annihilation photons. Scientific Reports, 13:7559, 2023.DOI
- [11]Parashari S, Bosnar D, Friščić I, Kožuljević AM, Kuncic Z, Žugec P, and Makek M. Closing the door on the “puzzle of decoherence” of annihilation quanta. Physics Letters B, 852:138628, 2024.arxiv.org/abs/2304.11362
- [12]Tkachev I, Musin S, Abdurashitov D, Baranov A, Guber F, Ivashkin A, and Strizhak A. Measuring the evolution of entanglement in compton scattering. Scientific Reports, 15:6064, 2025.DOI
- [13]Bordes J, Brown JR, Watts DP, Bashkanov M, Gibson K, Newton R, and Zachariou N. First detailed study of the quantum decoherence of entangled gamma photons. Phys. Rev. Lett., 133:132502, Sep 2024.DOI
- [14]Caradonna P. Kinematic analysis of multiple compton scattering in quantum-entangled two-photon systems. Annals of Physics, 470:169779, 2024.DOI
- [15]Caradonna P. Compton scattering mediated by quantum entanglement. Phys. Rev. A, 111:053708, May 2025.DOI
- [16]Caradonna P and Shimazoe K. Entanglement, steering, and separability in compton-scattered annihilation photons. Phys. Rev. A, 112:032413, 2025.DOI
- [17]Hiesmayr BC, Krzemień W, and Bała M. Quantum error channels in high energetic photonic systems. Scientific Reports, 14:9672, 2024.DOI
- [18]Bała M, Krzemień W, Hiesmayr B, Baran J, Dulski K, Klimaszewski K, Raczyński L, Shopa RY, and Wiślicki W. Probing arbitrary polarized photon pairs undergoing double compton scatterings by a dedicated mc simulator validated with experimental data. The European Physical Journal C, 85:1115, 2025.DOI
- [19]S. Parashari et al. Optimisation of detector modules for measuring gamma-ray polarization in Positron Emission Tomography. Nuclear Instruments and Methods in Physics Research Section A: Accelerators, Spectrometers, Detectors and Associated Equipment, 1040:167186, 2022.DOI
- [20]Moskal P, Kumar D, Sharma S, Yitayew E, Chug N, Couss at A, Curceanu C, Czerwiński E, Das M, Dulski K, Gorgol M, Jasińska B, Kacprzak K, Kaplanoglu T, Kapłon Ł, Kozik T, Lisowski E, Lisowski F, Mryka W, Niedźwiecki S, Parzych S, del Rio EP, Rädler M, Skurzok M, Stepień EL, Tanty P, Tayefi Ardebili K, and Valsan Eliyan K. Nonmaximal entanglement of photons from positron-electron annihilation demonstrated using a plastic pet scanner. Science Advances, 11(18):eads3046, 2025.DOI
- [21]Mihael Makek, Tomislav Bokulić, Damir Bosnar, Ana Marija Kožuljević, Zdenka Kuncic, Siddharth Parashari, Luka Pavelić, and Petar Žugec. Development of the Quantum-PET Demonstrator. In 2022 IEEE Nuclear Science Symposium and Medical Imaging Conference (NSS/MIC), pages 1–3, 2022.DOI
- [22]Kožuljević AM, Bokulić T, Grošev D, Kuncic Z, Parashari S, Pavelić L, and Makek M. Investigation of the spatial resolution of PET imaging system measuring polarization-correlated Compton events. Nuclear Instruments and Methods in Physics Research Section A: Accelerators, Spectrometers, Detectors and Associated Equipment, 1068:169795, 2024.DOI
- [23]Di Francesco A, Bugalho R, Oliveira L, Pacher L, Rivetti A, Rolo M, Silva J C, Silva R, and Varela J. TOFPET2: A high-performance ASIC for time and amplitude measurements of SiPM signals in time-of-flight applications. Journal of Instrumentation, 11:C03042, 2016.DOI
- [24]Kožuljević AM, Bosnar D, Kuncic Z, Makek M, Parashari S, and Žugec P. Study of multi-pixel scintillator detector configurations for measuring polarized gamma radiation. Condensed Matter, 6:43, 2021.DOI
- [25]S. Parashari et al. Measurement of angular correlations of Compton-scattered gamma quanta from positron annihilation using GAGG:Ce scintillator matrices with single-side readout. Journal of Instrumentation, 17:C09007, 2022.DOI
- [26]Nadig V, Schug D, Weissler B, and Schulz V. Evaluation of the petsys tofpet2 asic in multi-channel coincidence experiments. European Journal of Nuclear Medicine and Molecular Imaging Physics, 8:30, 2021.DOI
- [27]Brun R and Rademakers F. ROOT - An Object Oriented Data Analysis Framework. Nucl. Instrum. Methods Phys. Res. A, 389:81–86, 1997.
- [28]O. Tang. GNU Parallel 20210822 (’Kabul’). Zenodo, 2022.
- [29]Makek M, Bosnar D, Gačić V, Pavelić L, Šenjug P, and Žugec P. Performance of scintillation pixel detectors with MPPC read-out and digital signal processing. Acta Physica Polonica B, 48(10):1721–1726, 2017.DOI