WorksPhysics and Astronomy
On the equivalence of three extended Calogero–Bogoyavlenskii–Schiff models to the classical CBS equation
Abstract
We examine the three extended Calogero–Bogoyavlenskii–Schiff (CBS) models introduced by Wazwaz, Alhejaili, and El-Tantawy [Eur.\ Phys.\ J.\ Plus 141, 1218 (2026)]. Explicit invertible point transformations map the first model, and generically the second, to the classical CBS equation. The third model is generically equivalent to CBS with an additional spectator coordinate absent from the differential operator. We identify the exceptional parameter regimes and explain the reported exponential dispersion relations through these transformations. These equivalences show that the proposed models do not, in the generic parameter regimes, introduce new point-inequivalent CBS equations or genuine four-variable differential coupling.
Introduction
In a recent article, Wazwaz, Alhejaili, and El-Tantawy [1] introduced three extended Calogero–Bogoyavlenskii–Schiff (CBS) models: two in dimensions and one in dimensions. The proposed equations combine the classical CBS nonlinear structure with additional linear derivative terms and, in the third model, a second CBS-type block involving the original time variable. The authors investigated these equations using the Weiss–Tabor–Carnevale Painlevé test, exponential multi-wave constructions, and traveling-wave reductions. They presented the models as new integrable extensions, including a higher-dimensional equation with nontrivial transverse and temporal coupling.
Before interpreting additional terms or independent variables as evidence of a new integrable structure, one must determine whether they can be eliminated by invertible point transformations. Equations with different appearances may represent the same differential equation in different coordinates. Such equivalences transport local solutions and auxiliary integrability structures and therefore provide a necessary basis for assessing the novelty of a proposed extension.
The reference equation in this comment is the classical potential CBS equation, written in the normalization
This normalization follows from the potential CBS equation in [2 Eq. (17), p. 594] by multiplying its dependent variable by four. It also occurs directly in the general equation of [3 Eq. (19), p. 174] when the nonlinear coefficients are and . Earlier exact-solution treatments include [4], while the logarithmic multi-wave constructions relevant here appear in [2 Sec. 3, pp. 594–595] and [3 Sec. 3.1, p. 175].
We establish explicit invertible point transformations relating the three models of [1] to (1). The first model is point-equivalent to this equation for all values of its two parameters, and the second has the same property when . For the third model, whenever , the transformed equation is (1) with an additional independent variable absent from the differential operator. Thus, it describes a family of CBS solutions parameterized by , without differential coupling in that direction. This conclusion follows from an invertible transformation of the full equation and does not impose . The exceptional parameter regimes are treated separately.
The solution comparison goes beyond equation equivalence. Using the same transformations, together with an affine-background adjustment where required, we recover the reported one-, two-, and three-wave families from the earlier constructions in [2 Eqs. (24)–(31), pp. 594–595] and [3 Eqs. (27)–(35), p. 175]. The transformations account for the parameter-dependent exponential dispersion relations while preserving the pairwise interaction coefficients. Moreover, the four-variable equation in [3 Eq. (63), p. 177], for and , also admits a CBS representation with a spectator coordinate, as shown below.
These results require a reassessment of the claimed novelty of the models and their higher-dimensional coupling. They explain both the underlying CBS structure and the recovery of the specified multi-wave families from earlier formulas. They do not establish that every traveling-wave or cnoidal expression reported in [1] has previously appeared, nor do they invalidate solutions merely because those solutions are expressed in noncanonical coordinates.
Our conclusions concern local differential equations. Transformations that interchange independent variables or introduce affine backgrounds need not preserve a prescribed physical initial-boundary value problem. Any distinct physical interpretation therefore requires a separate formulation of that problem. We first present the equivalence transformations and their parameter restrictions, then establish the solution correspondence and discuss its implications for integrability and dimensional novelty.
Equivalence of the two (2+1)-dimensional models
We use explicit point transformations in the standard sense [5]. Throughout, the transformed equation is (1), unless an exceptional parameter regime is specified.
First model: removal of constant drift terms
The first model, equation (4) of [1], is
The translating coordinate transformation
has unit Jacobian and maps (2) exactly to (1). Its inverse is , , . Thus, for every , the added terms are removable constant drifts and do not define a point-inequivalent extension of CBS.
Second model: affine change of variables
The second model, equation (5) of [1], is
For , the point transformation
maps (4) exactly to (1). The independent-variable Jacobian is , and the inverse is
The affine terms remove the separate and contributions; interchanging and rescaling the independent variables supplies the canonical CBS evolution term. For , use instead , , and . The resulting equation is
with no -derivatives. This exceptional regime is the stationary CBS equation with one spectator coordinate. Thus, the first model and the second model with are representations of the same classical CBS equation.
The (3+1)-dimensional model and its spectator coordinate
The third model, equation (6) of [1], is
Its two CBS-type blocks involve the same directional derivative . To expose this structure, set
This invertible transformation reduces (8) to
The only remaining evolution direction is the constant vector field
If , a linear change of coordinates rectifies it to , leaving a complementary coordinate absent from the differential operator.
Case . The combined transformation is
Its independent-variable Jacobian is , and it maps (8) to
The inverse is
For each fixed , equation (13) is precisely CBS. No condition has been imposed: the absence of -derivatives follows from an invertible transformation of the full equation, not from a reduction restricting its solutions.
Case , . The alternative transformation
again gives (13). Its independent-variable Jacobian is ; the inverse is , , , , with at the corresponding arguments. Hence, whenever
the third model is point-equivalent to CBS extended by a spectator independent variable.
Case , . Here , and (9) gives
Both and are spectators. Thus, the exceptional regime is the stationary CBS equation with two spectator coordinates, whereas the generic regime is the CBS evolution equation with one. Neither representation supplies a new differential coupling in all four independent variables.
Consequences for integrability, dispersion, and novelty
The equivalences established above explain several features reported in [1]. They also distinguish properties inherited from classical CBS from claims that would require additional justification.
Inherited integrability properties
An invertible point transformation allows local solutions and auxiliary differential structures to be transferred between equivalent equations. In particular, a Lax representation for the canonical CBS equation can be rewritten in the original coordinates, and conservation laws and symmetry generators can be transported by the corresponding transformation. For the first model and the second model with , their relation to classical CBS therefore supplies a direct explanation of the integrability features observed in [1].
For the third model under , this statement applies to the CBS equation at each fixed value of the spectator coordinate . The resulting structures describe a family of CBS systems parameterized by ; they do not, by themselves, establish a new differential coupling in that direction.
The transformations used here are nonsingular affine maps in their respective parameter regimes. Consequently, the local Laurent-series structure is transported without introducing branching through the coordinate changes. The CBS-type leading behavior and resonances reported in the original article are therefore consistent with the underlying equivalences. Their occurrence does not provide independent evidence for a new integrable extension.
Interpretation of the exponential dispersion relations
The exponential dispersion relations can also be interpreted through the point transformations. For the first model, a phase
becomes, under (3),
The canonical CBS exponential relation therefore gives
which is precisely the relation reported for the first model. The additional terms are thus the frequency shift associated with the translating coordinates.
For the third model, consider and the phase
Using the inverse transformation (14), this becomes
The affine change of the dependent variable must also be included: the original background corresponds to
Linearizing the canonical CBS equation about , with , gives
For an exponential perturbation with phase (22), equation (24) yields
Substituting the definition of and rearranging gives
This is exactly the exponential dispersion relation reported for the third model. Thus, the appearance of the parameters in this relation is explained by the coordinate transformation and the affine background. It does not establish a new dispersion mechanism independent of classical CBS. Here, as in the original exponential construction, the relation concerns real exponential phases; it should be distinguished from the oscillatory Fourier dispersion relation.
Limits of the dimensional novelty
The third model retains four independent variables under the invertible transformation. Accordingly, it is not point-equivalent to a three-variable equation on a space of lower dimension. The precise result is that it is equivalent to the trivial extension
in which is an additional independent variable absent from the differential operator. This distinction allows arbitrary parameter dependence on , subject to the CBS equation being satisfied for each fixed . It does not impose independence of , but it does show that the apparent fourth-direction coupling is removable. Therefore, wave profiles drawn in different coordinate planes, or phases containing an additional wavenumber, do not alone demonstrate an intrinsically four-variable integrable structure.
Scope of the novelty assessment
The equivalence results do not invalidate exact solutions merely because those solutions were obtained in noncanonical coordinates. Nor do they establish, without a separate comparison with the literature, that every reported solution formula was previously known. They establish that the proposed equations, in the generic regimes identified above, do not define new point-inequivalent CBS structures.
Physical equivalence requires a separate assessment. The transformations may interchange the original temporal and spatial coordinates or introduce an affine background, and therefore need not preserve specified initial data, boundary conditions, or admissibility requirements. A distinct physical interpretation could consequently remain meaningful if supported by a concrete model and a prescribed initial–boundary value problem. Such a distinction, however, cannot be inferred solely from the additional terms in the displayed equations.
Recovery of the reported multi-wave solutions
The multi-wave constructions in [1] can be related explicitly to the earlier CBS solutions in [2 Sec. 3, pp. 594–595]. The potential CBS equation considered in [2 Eq. (17), p. 594] is
where the transverse coordinate, denoted by in that reference, has been renamed . The normalization maps (28) to (1).
The logarithmic representation in [2 Eq. (24), p. 594] therefore becomes
The one-, two-, and three-wave auxiliary functions, given respectively in [2 Eqs. (22), (26), and (30), p. 594], take the form
Here,
The dispersion relation and pairwise interaction coefficients are those of [2 Eqs. (19) and (28), p. 594]; the triple-interaction coefficient is specified in [2 Eq. (31), p. 594]. The constants are included through translation invariance. These formulas are considered where , with whenever occurs.
Affine-background adjustment. For the second and third models, the affine terms in our equivalence transformations must also be accounted for. Direct substitution shows that, whenever satisfies (1),
satisfies the same equation. Applying this identity to (29) gives
where the auxiliary functions retain (30), with phases
For the trivial extension by a spectator coordinate , the phase constants may be replaced by smooth functions .
First model. Applying (3) to (29) gives
where
Thus, the first model’s multi-wave expressions follow from the logarithmic representation and auxiliary functions in [2 Eqs. (24)–(31), pp. 594–595] by the translating coordinate transformation. The interaction coefficients remain unchanged.
Second model. Assume . In (33) and (34), choose
Under (5), the background cancels the affine term , yielding
The background dispersion relation gives
Consequently, the same auxiliary functions [2 Eqs. (22), (26), and (30), p. 594], after the background adjustment and point transformation, reproduce the second model’s one-, two-, and three-wave expressions, including their interaction coefficients.
Third model. First suppose , and use (12). Choose
The background-adjusted phases are then
In the original coordinates, these become
provided
It follows that
The background cancels the affine part of (12). Thus, the earlier logarithmic construction [2 Eq. (24), p. 594] again yields
with the phases and interaction coefficients reported in [1].
When and , the same conclusion follows from (15), using
The exceptional regimes identified above are governed instead by the stationary CBS equation and are not covered by this recovery argument.
These identifications recover the one-, two-, and three-wave constructions of [2 Eqs. (24)–(31), pp. 594–595] in the coordinates and normalization used in [1], throughout the stated nondegenerate regimes. The additional wavenumber in the third model is accommodated by phase dependence on the spectator coordinate, while the interaction coefficients remain those of the earlier CBS solutions. This comparison concerns the multi-wave families; it does not establish prior publication of all the other traveling-wave or cnoidal formulas in [1].
Conclusion
We have established explicit invertible point transformations relating the three extended models proposed in [1] to the classical potential CBS equation. The first model is equivalent to CBS for all parameter values, and the second has the same property when . For the third model, whenever , the transformed equation is CBS with an additional spectator coordinate. The exceptional regimes reduce to stationary CBS equations with spectator coordinates.
Beyond equation equivalence, we have explicitly recovered the reported one-, two-, and three-wave families from the earlier CBS constructions in [2 Eqs. (24)–(31), pp. 594–595] and [3 Eqs. (27)–(35), p. 175]. Normalization, the point transformations, and the appropriate affine-background adjustment reproduce their exponential phases and dispersion relations, while preserving the interaction coefficients. For the third model, the additional wavenumber is accommodated by phase dependence on the spectator coordinate. Thus, in the stated nondegenerate regimes, these multi-wave families are transformed versions of earlier CBS constructions.
The equivalences also explain the occurrence of CBS-type integrability features. The additional terms in the first model are removable constant drifts, while the apparent fourth-direction coupling in the third model disappears under an invertible transformation. Accordingly, neither the proposed equations nor the recovered multi-wave families establish new point-inequivalent CBS structures in these regimes.
These conclusions do not invalidate the recovered solutions or establish prior publication of every other traveling-wave or cnoidal formula reported in [1]. Any remaining mathematical novelty requires a separate demonstration beyond the equation representations and multi-wave constructions identified here. A distinct physical interpretation likewise requires a specified initial–boundary value problem, since the transformations need not preserve the original temporal interpretation, boundary conditions, or admissible backgrounds.
Statements and declarations
Funding No external funding was received for this work.
Data availability All transformations supporting the findings are presented in the manuscript. No external datasets were generated or analysed.
Conflict of interest The authors declare no competing interests.
Ethics approval and consent to participate Not applicable.
References
- [1]A.-M. Wazwaz, W. Alhejaili, S. A. El-Tantawy, Three extended Calogero–Bogoyavlenskii–Schiff models in (2 + 1) and (3 + 1) dimensions: Painlevé integrability, multi-shock, cnoidal, and traveling waves, The European Physical Journal Plus 141 (2026) 1218. doi:10.1140/epjp/s13360-026-08459-x.DOI
- [2]A.-M. Wazwaz, Multiple-soliton solutions for the Calogero–Bogoyavlenskii–Schiff, Jimbo–Miwa and YTSF equations, Applied Mathematics and Computation 203 (2) (2008) 592–597. doi:10.1016/j.amc.2008.05.004.DOI
- [3]A.-M. Wazwaz, The (2+1) and (3+1)-dimensional CBS equations: Multiple soliton solutions and multiple singular soliton solutions, Zeitschrift für Naturforschung A 65 (3) (2010) 173–181. doi:10.1515/zna-2010-0304.DOI
- [4]B. Li, Y. Chen, Exact analytical solutions of the generalized Calogero–Bogoyavlenskii–Schiff equation using symbolic computation, Czechoslovak Journal of Physics 54 (5) (2004) 517–528. doi:10.1023/B:CJOP.0000024955.75594.8c.DOI
- [5]P. Olver, Applications of Lie Groups to Differential Equations, Vol. 107, Springer-Verlag Inc., New York, 1986. doi:10.1007/978-1-4612-4350-2.