betaFeedback

WorksPhysics and Astronomy

Fixed-grid sharp-interface numerical solutions to the three-phase spherical Stefan problem

Abstract

Many metal manufacturing processes involve phase change phenomena, which include melting, boiling, and vaporization. These phenomena often occur concurrently. A prototypical 1D model for understanding the phase change phenomena is the Stefan problem. There is a large body of literature discussing the analytical solution to the two-phase Stefan problem that describes only the melting or boiling of phase change materials (PCMs) with one moving interface. Density-change effects that induce additional fluid flow during phase change are generally neglected in the literature to simplify the math of the Stefan problem. In our recent work [1], we provide analytical and numerical solutions to the three-phase Stefan problem with simultaneous occurrences of melting, solidification, boiling, and condensation in Cartesian coordinates. Our current work builds on our previous work to solve a more challenging problem: the three-phase Stefan problem in spherical coordinates for finite-sized particles. There are three moving interfaces in this system: the melt front, the boiling front, and the outer boundary which is in contact with the atmosphere. Although an analytical solution could not be found for this problem, we solved the governing equations using a fixed-grid sharp-interface method with second-order spatio-temporal accuracy. Using a small-time analytical solution, we predict a reasonably accurate estimate of temperature (in the three phases) and interface positions and velocities at the start of the simulation. Our numerical method is validated by reproducing the two-phase nanoparticle melting results of Font et al. [2]. Lastly, we solve the three-phase Stefan problems numerically to demonstrate the importance of kinetic energy terms during phase change of smaller (nano) particles. In contrast, these effects diminish for large particles (microns and larger).

Introduction

The Stefan problem is concerned with the evolution of an interface between two phases while simultaneously going through a phase change, such as melting a solid metal. In 1890, Josef Stefan introduced these problems in the context of sea ice formation in a set of four papers. The foundation of Stefan’s work traces back to 1831 when a similar problem was faced by Lamé and Clapeyron while studying the solidification of Earth’s crust [3, 4].

Although a large body of research has been conducted to solve the Stefan problem analytically and numerically, the vast majority of studies incorporate a number of restrictive assumptions that are often justified for mathematical convenience. These include constant latent heat, constant phase change temperature, constant thermal properties (thermal conductivity, specific heat) in each phase and an equal density in both phases [5, 6]. During boiling, there is a density change of 1000 or more between the liquid and vapor phases,

Email address: [email protected] (Amneet Pal Singh Bhalla) making the assumption of equal density across phases the most unreasonable. Furthermore, most Stefan problems considered in the literature have only two phases, either solid and liquid or liquid and vapor.

In metal manufacturing processes, such as welding and metal additive manufacturing (AM), a metal substrate or powder undergoes rapid melting, boiling, and vaporization under the action of a high-intensity laser or heat source. The standard two-phase Stefan problem cannot describe such a process. In our recent work [1] we introduced a three-phase Stefan problem set in half-space and Cartesian coordinates to model the simultaneous melting, solidification, boiling and condensation of a phase change material. The semi-infinite planar geometry allowed us to obtain an analytical solution to the three-phase problem that accounts for density and kinetic energy jumps during phase change. A fixed-grid sharp interface method was also presented to solve the three-phase Stefan problem with two moving interfaces in a Cartesian coordinate system. Analytical solutions were used to initialize the simulation in our prior work. The numerical method was demonstrated to be second-order accurate in both space and time.

This paper extends our previous work on the three-phase planar Stefan problem to the three-phase spherical Stefan problem while retaining appropriate density variation and kinetic energy contributions. This brings us closer to our long-term goal of developing and validating fully-resolved computational fluid dynamics (CFD) algorithms to simulate metal AM processes. In the manufacturing industry, the spherical Stefan problem has practical relevance to the production of metallic powders and spherical nanoparticles. As such, there has been extensive research in the literature regarding the spherical Stefan problem in two-phase form; see references [7, 8, 9, 10, 11]. This work contributes to the literature by introducing the three-phase version of the spherical Stefan problem and a numerical method to solve it.

The modeled system considered here is a finite-sized spherical particle exposed to the atmosphere. Unfortunately, the finite-sized spherical geometry does not permit a similarity solution. Thus, to initialize the numerical solution for the sharp-interface method, we rely on small-time analysis of the governing equations and boundary conditions to predict the temperature in the three phases and the interface positions and velocities at the start of the simulation. Our small-time analysis of the three-phase Stefan problem can be viewed as an extension of the small-time technique introduced by Myers et al. [11] for modeling the two-phase nanoparticle melting. Myers et al. considered low density contrasts between the solid and liquid phases in their small-time analysis. The small-time analyses presented in this work also consider the large density contrasts between the phases.

In Sec. 2 of our work, we mathematically formulate two-phase and three-phase spherical Stefan problems while retaining density and kinetic energy jump terms in the Stefan conditions. Governing equations and boundary conditions are non-dimensionalized and small-time analytical solutions for temperature and interface positions and velocities are derived for both two- and three-phase Stefan problems. Sec. 3 presents a sharp-interface numerical method using a second-order, finite difference/volume discretization, with explicit tracking of moving interfaces using an immersed-boundary (IB) method [12]. We then validate the proposed methodology in Sec. 5 by reproducing the two-phase nanoparticle melting results of Font et al. [2]. Font et al. transform the spherical heat equations to Cartesian equations and immobilize the moving boundaries by mapping them on a fixed rectilinear domain. In contrast, we solve the governing equations directly in spherical coordinates on a fixed axisymmetric grid which allows the interfaces to freely move through the underlying mesh. Lastly, we apply the method to numerically solve the three-phase Stefan problem to quantify the influence of density and kinetic-energy terms on interface evolution. It is found that the kinetic energy terms significantly affect the melt times of smaller particles, whereas for large particles their effect diminishes significantly.

Governing equations for the spherical Stefan problem

We consider a phase change material (PCM) with a melting temperature TmT_m and a vaporization temperature TvT_v. At any time tt, the three phases of the PCM occupy a spherically symmetric domain Ω:0≤r≤Rb(t)\Omega: 0 \le r \le R_b(t). At the initial time t=0t = 0, the full domain is occupied by the solid phase. The initial radius of the solid particle is Rb(t=0)=R0R_b(t = 0) = R_0. The outer boundary (s3=Rb(t))(s_3 = R_b(t)) is open to the atmosphere, and it is allowed to freely expand or contract during the phase change process. Imposing a temperature of T∞>TvT_\infty> T_v at the outer boundary melts and boils the PCM. The thermophysical properties of the solid phase are ρS\rho^S, CSC^S, and κS\kappa^S, those of the liquid phase are ρL\rho^L, CLC^L, and κL\kappa^L, and those of the vapor phase are ρV\rho^V, CVC^V, and κV\kappa^V. In each phase, these properties are assumed to be constant. When the PCM melts, the melt front s1=R1(t)s_1 = R_1(t) moves inwards. The boiling front s2=R2(t)s_2 = R_2(t) can move inwards or outwards during the phase change process. Due to the imposed temperature T∞>TvT_\infty> T_v, the molten PCM begins to boil and forms a boiling front s2=R2(t)s_2 = R_2(t); see Figure 1. At t=0+t = 0^+, both fronts appear simultaneously at r=R0r = R_0. The solid-to-liquid density ratio is denoted ρSL=ρS/ρL\rho^{\mathrm{SL}} = \rho^{\mathrm{S}}/\rho^{\mathrm{L}}, whereas its inverse is denoted ρLS=ρL/ρS\rho^{\mathrm{LS}} = \rho^{\mathrm{L}}/\rho^{\mathrm{S}}. Similarly, the liquid-to-vapor and vapor-to-liquid density ratios are denoted ρLV=ρL/ρV\rho^{\mathrm{LV}} = \rho^{\mathrm{L}}/\rho^{\mathrm{V}} and ρVL=ρV/ρL\rho^{\mathrm{VL}} = \rho^{\mathrm{V}}/\rho^{\mathrm{L}}, respectively. The same notation is also used to define the ratio of other thermophysical quantities, such as thermal diffusivity/conductivity.

Schematic of the two-phase and three-phase spherical Stefan problems

Figure 1. Schematic of the (a) two-phase and (b) three-phase spherical Stefan problem in which an initially solid PCM melts and boils, respectively due to an imposed temperature condition at the outer surface (r=Rb(t)r = R_b(t)).

The conservation of mass, momentum and energy equations in the solid, liquid, and vapor phases read as

∂ρ∂t+∇⋅(ρu)=0,(1)\frac{\partial\rho}{\partial t} + \nabla\cdot(\rho\mathbf{u}) = 0, \tag*{(1)}
∂ρu∂t+∇⋅(ρu⊗u+pI)−σCδ(r−s)n=0,(2)\frac{\partial\rho\mathbf{u}}{\partial t} + \nabla\cdot(\rho\mathbf{u} \otimes\mathbf{u} + p\mathbf{I}) - \sigma C \delta(r-\mathbf{s})\mathbf{n} = 0, \tag*{(2)}
∂∂t(ρ[e+12∣u∣2])+∇⋅(ρ[e+12∣u∣2]u+q+pu)−σCδ(r−s)u⋅n=0.(3)\frac{\partial}{\partial t}\left(\rho\left[e+\frac{1}{2}|\mathbf{u}|^2\right]\right) + \nabla\cdot\left(\rho\left[e+\frac{1}{2}|\mathbf{u}|^2\right]\mathbf{u}+\mathbf{q}+p\mathbf{u}\right)-\sigma C\delta(r-\mathbf{s})\mathbf{u}\cdot\mathbf{n}=0. \tag*{(3)}

In the momentum (2), σ\sigma is the surface energy coefficient between the two phases (vapor-liquid and liquid-solid in this context), CC represents the mean local curvature of the interface, s\mathbf{s} represents the position of the interface, δ\delta is the Dirac delta distribution, and n\mathbf{n} is the outward unit normal vector of the interface (pointing in the positive rr direction in Figure 1). In the energy (3), ee denotes the internal energy and q=−κ∇T\mathbf{q}=-\kappa\nabla T is the conductive heat flux. The melt front moves with a velocity u1=dR1/dtu_1 = dR_1/dt and the boiling front moves with a velocity u2=dR2/dtu_2 = dR_2/dt. We ignore the viscous stress tensor in the momentum (2) as shear forces are zero in a one-dimensional setting. Internal energy eΓe^\Gamma of phase Γ={S,L,V}\Gamma= \{S,L,V\} can be expressed in terms of phasic enthalpy hΓh^\Gamma or temperature TΓT^\Gamma as

hS=CS(TS−Tr)=eS+pSρS,(4)h^{S}=C^{S}(T^{S}-T_r)=e^{S}+\frac{p^{S}}{\rho^{S}}, \tag*{(4)}
hL=CL(TL−Tr)+Lm=eL+pLρL,(5)h^{L}=C^{L}(T^{L}-T_r)+L_m=e^{L}+\frac{p^{L}}{\rho^{L}}, \tag*{(5)}
hV=CV(TV−Tr)+Lm+Lv=eV+pVρV.(6)h^{V}=C^{V}(T^{V}-T_r)+L_m+L_v=e^{V}+\frac{p^{V}}{\rho^{V}}. \tag*{(6)}

Here, pΓp^\Gamma is the phasic pressure, TrT_r is the reference temperature at which enthalpies are measured, and LmL_m and LvL_v are the latent heats of melting and vaporization, respectively.

Two phase spherical Stefan problem

We consider a simplified scenario where the PCM melts only during phase change. This is achieved by setting T∞T_{\infty} greater than TmT_{m} but less than TvT_{v}. A similar two-phase spherical Stefan problem has been considered in the literature [2]. The two-phase problem serves to (i) introduce the non-dimensional parameters of the problem; (ii) introduce a small-time analytical solution method; and (iii) validate our fixed-grid sharp-interface numerical method with a coordinate transformed numerical solution reported in the literature.

To find the evolution of temperature in the solid (TS(r,t)T^{S}(r,t)) and liquid (TL(r,t)T^{L}(r,t)) phases as a result of melting, we need to solve the temperature equation in the two domains. This is obtained by expressing the internal energy ee in terms of temperature (see Eqs. (2a) and (2b)), and neglecting terms related to pressure work and viscous dissipation in Eq. (1c). The resulting temperature equation in the solid and liquid phases reads as

ρSCS(∂TS∂t+uS∂TS∂r)=κSr2∂∂r(r2∂TS∂r),0≤r<R1(t)(7)\rho^{S}C^{S}\left(\frac{\partial T^{S}}{\partial t}+u^{S}\frac{\partial T^{S}}{\partial r}\right)=\frac{\kappa^{S}}{r^{2}}\frac{\partial}{\partial r}\left(r^{2}\frac{\partial T^{S}}{\partial r}\right), \qquad0\le r<R_{1}(t) \tag*{(7)}
ρLCL(∂TL∂t+uL∂TL∂r)=κLr2∂∂r(r2∂TL∂r),R1(t)<r≤Rb(t)(8)\rho^{L}C^{L}\left(\frac{\partial T^{L}}{\partial t}+u^{L}\frac{\partial T^{L}}{\partial r}\right)=\frac{\kappa^{L}}{r^{2}}\frac{\partial}{\partial r}\left(r^{2}\frac{\partial T^{L}}{\partial r}\right), \qquad R_{1}(t)<r\le R_{b}(t) \tag*{(8)}

Five boundary conditions are needed to solve Eqs. (3) to determine TS(r,t)T^{S}(r,t), TL(r,t)T^{L}(r,t), and R1(t)R_{1}(t).

The temperature TmIT^{I}_{m} at the S-L interface differs from the bulk melting temperature TmT_{m} due to the curvature and surface energy/tension effects. The two temperatures are related by the Gibbs-Thomson relation

TmI(R1(t))=Tm−σSLTmρSLm2R1(t).(9)T^{I}_{m}(R_{1}(t))=T_{m}-\frac{\sigma_{SL}T_{m}}{\rho^{S}L_{m}}\frac{2}{R_{1}(t)}. \tag*{(9)}

Here, σSL\sigma_{SL} denotes the surface energy coefficient between the solid and liquid phases. At any time tt during the melting process, the temperature in the liquid and solid phase near the melt front is the same: TS(R1(t),t)=TL(R1(t),t)=TmI(R1(t))T^{S}(R_{1}(t),t)=T^{L}(R_{1}(t),t)=T^{I}_{m}(R_{1}(t)). The outer boundary is maintained at an ambient temperature of TL(Rb(t),t)=T∞T^{L}(R_{b}(t),t)=T_{\infty}. Solid phase temperature at the center of the sphere satisfies the homogeneous Neumann boundary condition ∂TS∂r∣r=0=0\left.\frac{\partial T^{S}}{\partial r}\right|_{r=0}=0. The Stefan condition (and the fifth boundary condition) for the melt front is obtained by applying the Rankine-Hugoniot jump condition to the energy equation across the solid-liquid interface

References

  1. [1]M. Soleimani, K. Koponen, N. Tilton, A. P. S. Bhalla, Analytical and numerical solutions to the three-phase stefan problem with simultaneous occurrences of melting, solidification, boiling, and condensation phenomena, ASME Journal of Heat and Mass Transfer 148 (1) (2026) 012401.arxiv.org/abs/2503.06360
  2. [2]F. Font, T. G. Myers, S. L. Mitchell, A mathematical model for nanoparticle melting with density change, Microfluidics and Nanofluidics 18 (2015) 233–243.DOI
  3. [3]C. Vuik, Some historical notes about the Stefan problem, Tech. rep., Delft University of Technology, Faculty of Technical Mathematics and Informatics (1993).
  4. [4]L. I. Rubin v stein, The Stefan problem, Vol. 8, American Mathematical Soc., 2000.
  5. [5]D. W. Hahn, M. N. Özisik, Heat conduction, John Wiley & Sons, 2012.
  6. [6]V. Alexiades, A. D. Solomon, Mathematical modeling of melting and freezing processes, Routledge, 2018.
  7. [7]S. W. McCue, B. Wu, J. M. Hill, Micro/nanoparticle melting with spherical symmetry and surface tension, IMA journal of applied mathematics 74 (3) (2009) 439–457.DOI
  8. [8]S. W. McCue, B. Wu, J. M. Hill, Classical two-phase stefan problem for spheres, Proceedings of the Royal Society A: Mathematical, Physical and Engineering Sciences 464 (2096) (2008) 2055–2076.DOI
  9. [9]F. Font, T. Myers, Spherically symmetric nanoparticle melting with a variable phase change temperature, Journal of nanoparticle research 15 (12) (2013) 2086.DOI
  10. [10]B. Wu, P. Tillman, S. W. McCue, J. M. Hill, Nanoparticle melting as a stefan moving boundary problem, Journal of Nanoscience and Nanotechnology 9 (2) (2009) 885–888.pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/19441414
  11. [11]T. G. Myers, M. G. Hennessy, M. Calvo-Schwarzwälder, The stefan problem with variable thermophysical properties and phase change temperature, International Journal of Heat and Mass Transfer 149 (2020) 118975. doi:10.1016/j.ijheatmasstransfer.2019.118975.DOI
  12. [12]K. Koponen, A. P. S. Bhalla, B. Sprinkle, N. Wu, N. Tilton, A direct forcing, immersed boundary method for conjugate heat transport, Journal of Computational Physics (2025) 114135.DOI
  13. [13]N. Nangia, B. E. Griffith, N. A. Patankar, A. P. S. Bhalla, A robust incompressible navier-stokes solver for high density ratio multiphase flows, Journal of Computational Physics 390 (2019) 548–594.DOI
  14. [14]P. Buffat, J.-P. Borel, Size effect on the melting temperature of gold particles, Physical Review A 13 (6) (1976) 2287–2297.DOI
  15. [15]R. Thirumalaisamy, A. P. S. Bhalla, A low mach enthalpy method to model non-isothermal gas–liquid–solid flows with melting and solidification, International Journal of Multiphase Flow 169 (2023) 104605.DOI
  16. [16]M. Doble, Perry’s chemical engineers’ handbook, McGraw-Hil, New York, US (2007).
  17. [17]J. E. Hatch, Aluminium: Properties and physical metallurgy, by asm, Metals Park, OH 135 (1984).
  18. [18]P. Desai, Thermodynamic properties of aluminum, International journal of thermophysics 8 (1987) 621–638.DOI

Paper details

vlnc:W_kecs7sjs
Version
v1 · latest
Published
Fresh — added to the Hub within the last 30 days
Added
License
CC BY 4.0
Usage

views · 10

downloads · 0

A view counts once per browser per day, a download each time the PDF is requested.

  • Physics and Astronomy

Not recorded for this paper

View statement
Looking for related papers…
Contents