In this paper
AbstractIntroductionRayleigh scattering in CDM and modified recombination scenariosRayleigh Scattering effects on CMB temperature and polarisation anisotropiesDependencies of Rayleigh scattering signal on varying fundamental constantsEffect of varying fundamental constants on visibility function and CMB power spectraMethodologyFisher FormalismForeground modellingResultsForecast constraints with and without Rayleigh scatteringParameter biasesConclusionsAcknowledgmentsDerivation of Fisher matrix and parameter bias due to incorrect fiducial modelResults with LiteBIRD + PlanckReferencesWorksPhysics and Astronomy
Shedding light on modified recombination scenarios with Rayleigh scattering of the CMB
Abstract
Rayleigh scattering (RS) of cosmic microwave background (CMB) photons by neutral hydrogen and helium, during and shortly after the last scattering surface, adds a frequency-dependent contribution to the CMB anisotropies that scales approximately as at leading order. The RS signal is most relevant at and could be detected using future CMB experiments. Because RS acts in a frequency-dependent manner which is sensitive to the ionisation history of the cosmological recombination process, it provides an additional probe of the recombination history. This makes it a natural test of modified recombination scenarios, such as variable electron mass or fine-structure constant , which have been proposed to ease the Hubble tension. The correlation between the RS and primary CMB signal, both in temperature and polarisation, further enhances its usefulness for constraining cosmological parameters. Using a multi-frequency Fisher analysis with realistic noise and foregrounds, we forecast parameter constraints and biases for PICO and LiteBIRD + Planck. For PICO, adding RS improves the CDM constraints on cosmological parameters by , but improves the constraints on some parameters (, , , , ) by for some modified scenarios in the recombination history. However, the improvement for LiteBIRD + Planck is limited to less than for most of the parameters. Neglecting RS biases the cosmological parameters by up to for PICO and below for LiteBIRD + Planck. Therefore RS must be modelled in the analyses of future CMB data.
Prepared for submission to JCAP
Introduction
In modern cosmology, our understanding of the physics of the cosmic microwave background (CMB) and the precise measurement of its temperature and polarisation anisotropies with many ground- and space-based experiments [1, 2, 3, 4] has led to the demonstration that the standard ΛCDM model of the Universe provides an extremely successful description of the current data. However, several cosmological tensions still persist, e.g., (i) mismatch between the Hubble constant from CMB data [5] and the same obtained from Cepheid-calibrated Type Ia Supernovae [6]; (ii) discrepancy between the amplitude of the growth of structure () inferred from CMB data and the one from late-time large-scale structure observations [7, 8, 9, 10, 11]. Despite several efforts to attribute the Hubble tension to systematic uncertainties in the data [12, 13], it has persisted. Several new-physics models have attempted to alleviate the Hubble tension [14, 15, 16, 17, 18, 19, 20]. However, no conclusive resolution has yet been reached. Since the CMB precisely measures the angular size of the sound horizon, , the value of inferred from it depends both on the comoving sound horizon at recombination, , which is set by pre-recombination physics, and on the comoving distance to the last-scattering surface, , which depends on the post-recombination expansion history [21]. Therefore, exploring modifications to the physics of the early or late Universe is particularly interesting to alleviate the Hubble tension.
Most attempts to alleviate the Hubble tension by modifying post-recombination physics rely on changes in the late-time expansion history, within the range allowed by BAO and Type Ia supernovae data [22, 23]. These typically invoke an evolving effective dark energy component while leaving the comoving sound horizon at recombination unchanged, and include dynamical dark energy (DDE) [24], interacting dark sector [25], and modified gravity models [26]. However, the freedom of these models to alleviate the tension is largely removed once BAO and supernovae data are included, since these models leave the sound horizon unchanged [21, 23]. Late-time modifications have nevertheless received renewed attention after the DESI BAO results [27] which prefer DDE at – significance to reduce the tension, although this has been challenged by [28], claiming such tension is due to unexplored systematics.
Another compelling possibility is to change the sound horizon in the pre-recombination era. A well-studied class of models that achieves this relies on introducing an early dark energy (EDE) component that decays before the recombination epoch (see [29] for a review). Another promising avenue is to invoke early recombination, for instance via time-varying fundamental constants; in particular, varying electron mass, or fine-structure constant [15, 30, 31, 32, 33, 34]. A larger electron mass during the early Universe makes the recombination process faster, which leads to a shorter sound horizon and therefore a larger value of . The varying electron mass model is well motivated in the literature and is consistent with other cosmological data sets that favour larger electron mass with greater significance than [35, 36, 37, 38].
In the literature, the impact of varying fundamental constants is studied mainly through their influence on Thomson scattering of CMB photons off of free electrons during the recombination era, at redshift . In this work, we discuss the impact of varying fundamental constants on the scattering of CMB photons with newly formed hydrogen and helium atoms during the recombination era, namely Rayleigh scattering (RS, [39, 40]). The effect of RS is often neglected in the literature, assuming that CMB photons can travel freely after recombination. RS dampens CMB anisotropies on sub-horizon scales because photons are further scattered out of the line of sight, which leads to mixing between photons at hot and cold spots. In addition, the large-scale -mode polarisation produced at recombination arises from the coherent scattering of the local temperature quadrupole into the line of sight. Since RS is increasingly important at higher frequencies and relevant only in the later stages of recombination, when the photons have free-streamed further, and the quadrupole has grown, the additional RS increases the polarisation amplitude on large scales at high frequencies. Thus RS introduces an asymptotic part in the CMB intensity and polarisation anisotropies which scales as at leading order, making observations at frequencies particularly important for future CMB experiments. In this work, we model the effect of RS on CMB anisotropies and study its cosmological importance for future CMB experiments, e.g., LiteBIRD [41] and PICO [42].
The paper is organised as follows. In § 2, we describe the effect of RS on the CMB temperature and polarisation anisotropies, and show how a variation of or modifies the RS opacity, the Thomson and Rayleigh visibility functions, and the resulting frequency-dependent power spectra. In § 3 we describe the multi-frequency Fisher formalism (§ 3.1) used to forecast parameter constraints and to estimate the biases arising from an incorrect model, and the foreground model (§ 3.2) included in the analysis. § 4 presents our results: the forecasts cover constraints with and without RS for CDM and the modified recombination scenarios (§ 4.1), and the parameter biases that arise when RS or the variation of the fundamental constants is not modelled consistently (§ 4.2). We summarise our conclusions in § 5. The derivation of the Fisher matrix and of the parameter bias is given in Appendix § 7, and the corresponding results for LiteBIRD + Planck are presented in Appendix § 8.
Rayleigh scattering in CDM and modified recombination scenarios
In this section, we illustrate the mechanism of RS and its impact on CMB power spectra at different frequencies, both in the standard CDM and modified recombination scenarios. The fiducial values of the six CDM cosmological parameters are set to the best-fit values of the Planck 2018 results [5] throughout this paper.
Rayleigh Scattering effects on CMB temperature and polarisation anisotropies
The elastic scattering of long-wavelength photons by neutral particles is known as Rayleigh scattering [43]. By the time recombination occurs, the vast majority of CMB photons have energies well below the hydrogen ionisation energy and therefore wavelengths well above the atomic sizes of the hydrogen and helium atoms that are produced during recombination.
The dipole induced in neutral hydrogen and helium scatters these long-wavelength photons with a cross-section that is proportional to the fourth power () of their frequency at leading order. The approximate Rayleigh scattering cross-section for photons at frequency scattered by a hydrogen atom in the ground state is given by the Kramers–Heisenberg formula [44],
where is the Thomson scattering cross-section and (where is the Rydberg constant). Therefore, the total comoving opacity of the photons at frequency can be approximated as
where and are the comoving opacities for Thomson and Rayleigh scattering respectively, is the scale factor, , and are the electron, neutral hydrogen and neutral helium number densities, respectively, and is the relative strength of Rayleigh scattering of helium with respect to hydrogen [45]. Rayleigh scattering becomes increasingly important relative to Thomson scattering as drops and and increase during recombination. Furthermore, once recombination is complete, the number density of neutral hydrogen evolves with redshift as and the CMB photon frequency as , so that the Rayleigh scattering rate changes as at leading order. This makes the process efficient near the last scattering surface only. This additional scattering reduces the photon mean free paths, thus increasing the diffusion damping acting on small scales [39].
The left panel of Figure 1 shows the comoving Thomson scattering opacity (solid line), together with the frequency-dependent RS contribution to in Eq. (2) at two representative frequencies: 321 GHz (dash-dotted line) and 799 GHz (dashed line), for the fiducial CDM cosmology. We have chosen these two frequencies since they correspond to PICO channels [42] and lie in the range where the RS signal is strongest. At low frequencies the RS comoving opacity is highly subdominant compared with Thomson scattering, but its steep dependence makes it increasingly important at higher frequencies. The right panel shows the corresponding visibility functions, , for Thomson scattering alone (solid line) and for RS at 321 GHz (dash-dotted line) and 799 GHz (dashed line). Since RS acts mainly in the later stages of recombination, it shifts the peak of the visibility function towards lower redshift, an effect present at all frequencies but most pronounced at high frequencies. Different observing frequencies therefore probe slightly different stages of the evolution of the anisotropies during recombination. At these later times, the local quadrupole is larger, which boosts the -mode polarisation on scales [39, 46], while the sound horizon is slightly larger, resulting in a shift of the acoustic peaks to lower multipoles in the higher-frequency channels. This shift is potentially dependent on the ionisation history and the expansion rate of the Universe. By adding frequency-dependent information on the positions of the acoustic peaks, the RS signal can therefore help break parameter degeneracies, improving CMB constraints on the Hubble constant while also tightening constraints on the ionisation history. With the inclusion of the RS effect, CMB harmonic coefficients at frequency can be perturbatively approximated as
Figure 1. Left panel: Comoving opacity of Thomson scattering, (solid line), and of Rayleigh scattering, , at 321 GHz (dash-dotted line) and 799 GHz (dashed line). At low frequencies, the RS contribution to the total opacity is negligible compared with Thomson scattering, whereas at high frequencies it becomes relevant towards the end of recombination, before decreasing rapidly as once recombination is complete. Right panel: The corresponding normalised visibility functions. For clarity, the visibility function at 799 GHz has been multiplied by a factor of 1.5.
where is some reference frequency of RS and XT, E, are the harmonic coefficients of the primary CMB due to Thomson scattering and are the harmonic coefficients of the RS contribution at the reference frequency . Therefore, the cross-power spectra of the CMB computed between two channels can be written as
The first, second, and third terms represent the primary CMB power spectrum, the cross-spectrum between the primary CMB1 and the RS signal, and the cross-spectrum of the RS signal between two observing frequencies, respectively.
Dependencies of Rayleigh scattering signal on varying fundamental constants
In this section, we illustrate the effect of varying fundamental constants focusing on the electron mass, , and the fine-structure constant, , on the recombination history and CMB power spectra, with particular emphasis on the contribution from RS. We used the modified version of RECFAST++ [47, 48] to model the recombination history and propagate the resulting changes in the free-electron, , neutral hydrogen, and neutral helium number densities (cf. Eq. (2)) to a modified version of CAMB [49] to compute the CMB power spectra contributed by Thomson and Rayleigh scattering across frequencies.
Variations in or modify the recombination process through several distinct physical mechanisms. These include changes in atomic binding energies, atomic transition rates, photoionisation/recombination rates, and the radiative transfer of photons through modified Thomson, Compton, and resonance scattering [50, 51, 52]. The resulting modifications in the recombination history in an effective three-level atom approach [53, 54] and their impact on the primary CMB power spectra are discussed in detail by [30]. We consider deviations of and from their current values ( keV and ) during the recombination epoch, with both reaching their present values after recombination has completed. We parameterise these variations during the recombination era as, and . The most important effect of these variations is the increase in the atomic binding energies of hydrogen and helium, , for or , which makes photoionisation less efficient at a given temperature. Since CMB photon temperature drops with the expansion of the Universe as , CMB temperature falls below the ionisation threshold at a higher redshift for or . Consequently, recombination occurs earlier, leading to a larger abundance of neutral hydrogen and helium at higher redshifts compared to the standard recombination history.
The earlier production of neutral atoms initially enhances the Rayleigh scattering opacity at high redshifts. In addition, variations in and also modify the RS opacity through changes in the Rayleigh scattering cross-section, . The Rayleigh scattering cross-section, to leading order in its frequency dependence, is given by
where is the Thomson scattering cross-section and the effective Rayleigh resonance frequency scales as . Consequently, increasing or decreases the Rayleigh scattering cross-section, which leads to a reduction in the Rayleigh scattering opacity with respect to the CDM case once recombination is essentially completed. Figure 2 shows the evolution of the Rayleigh comoving opacity, (cf. Eq. (2)) for different values of (left panel) and (right panel) at two representative frequencies, 799 GHz (dashed curves) and 321 GHz (dashed-dotted curves). The corresponding curve for the CDM model is shown in grey. Increasing or shifts the onset of Rayleigh scattering opacity to higher redshifts compared to the CDM scenario, due to earlier recombination. The effect is exactly the opposite for decreasing values of and . The suppression of , which becomes apparent only after recombination is complete, produces a steeper decline in comoving opacity than in CDM. As expected, the effect is slightly greater for changes in than for , due to their different impact on the enhancement of energy transition levels and other intermediate processes of recombination as described in [30, 50]. At lower frequencies, responds in the same way to variations of and , but its amplitude is substantially smaller since it decreases according to the scaling of the Rayleigh scattering cross-section .
Figure 2. Effect of variations in and on the Rayleigh comoving opacity, , at two representative observing frequencies, 321 GHz (dash-dotted lines) and 799 GHz (dashed lines). Left panel: For different values of . Right panel: For different values of . The corresponding curves for the CDM scenario are highlighted in grey.
Effect of varying fundamental constants on visibility function and CMB power spectra
We investigate the changes in the RS visibility function, , and the Thomson visibility function, , for different recombination histories, as these are governed by the dynamics of the recombination process and ultimately determine the Thomson and Rayleigh contributions to the CMB temperature and polarisation power spectra. We computed visibilities using a modified version of CAMB and in Figure 3 we present Thomson (solid lines) and Rayleigh (dashed lines) visibilities (normalised) at the observing frequency of 799 GHz for different values of (left panel) and (right panel). The visibilities corresponding to the CDM model are coloured grey. For and , the visibility peak shifts towards higher redshifts compared to the CDM case, for Thomson and Rayleigh scattering. The peak shifts in the opposite direction for and . Moreover, lowering or broadens the Rayleigh visibility function more than the Thomson one, since the Rayleigh opacity is more sensitive to these variations.
Figure 3. Effect of variations in (left panel) and (right panel), on the Thomson (solid lines) and Rayleigh (dashed lines) visibilities (normalised). For clarity, Rayleigh visibilities at 799 GHz are multiplied by a factor of 1.5. The corresponding curves for the CDM scenario are highlighted in grey.
We then propagate the effects of varying fundamental constants through a modified version of CAMB and calculate the auto- and cross-frequency CMB power spectra across the observing frequencies. We first investigate the power spectra for the CDM scenario. In Figure 4, we illustrate the total , , and power spectra contributed by both Thomson and Rayleigh scattering at two representative frequencies, 321 GHz (dashed-dotted lines) and 799 GHz (dashed lines) and compare them with the primary CMB power spectra arising from Thomson scattering alone (solid grey lines). The lower panels show the relative difference between the total power spectra at each frequency and the primary CMB power spectra. At the lower frequency of 321 GHz, the total power spectra remain close to the primary CMB power spectra, since Rayleigh scattering is relatively inefficient at low frequencies. However, at higher frequencies, such as 799 GHz, the effects of Rayleigh scattering become more significant. In particular, the acoustic peaks of the total power spectra are shifted towards lower values of (larger scales), reflecting the shift of the visibility peak towards lower redshifts, which causes an increase in the sound horizon and a decrease in the angular diameter distance to recombination at this frequency [55]. In addition, the amplitude of the anisotropies is suppressed since increased Rayleigh scattering leads to further mixing and redistribution of photons. We further investigate the frequency dependence of this effect by examining the angular power spectra at other observing frequencies and find that the most pronounced effect of Rayleigh scattering occurs in the power spectrum. Nevertheless, for observing frequencies below 500 GHz, the relative modification remains small, with .
Figure 4. Total power spectra including both Thomson and RS effects at two observing frequencies: 799 GHz (dashed line) and 321 GHz (dash-dotted line). The grey solid lines correspond to primary CMB power spectra due to Thomson scattering alone. The , and spectra are shown in the upper left, upper right and lower left panels, respectively. All cases shown here are for the CDM model. The lower panel of each plot shows the relative difference between the total power spectrum at each frequency and the primary CMB-only power spectrum.
We then investigated the effects of varying fundamental constants on the Rayleigh-scattering contribution to the total CMB power spectra. In Figure 5, we illustrate the frequency-dependent contributions to the , , and power spectra, as defined in Eq. (4), for (left column) and (right column) at a representative frequency channel of 799 GHz. These spectra are compared with the corresponding CDM case, shown by the solid grey curves. The lower panel of each subplot shows the relative Rayleigh-scattering contributions with respect to the primary CMB power spectra in the fiducial CDM scenario for the different cases. We find that increasing or shifts the acoustic peaks towards higher values (smaller scales). This behavior reflects the shift of the effective last-scattering surface towards higher redshifts [56, 57]. We also find that the shift of the acoustic peaks due to changes in or remains largely independent of the observing frequency. The amplitudes of the acoustic peaks are also boosted when the fundamental constants are increased. For example, for , we find that the relative change in the amplitude of acoustic peaks with respect to the CDM scenario is .
Figure 5. Effect of varying the electron mass (left column) and (right column) on the frequency-dependent part of the CMB power spectra (cf. Eq. (4)) i.e., the combined Rayleigh-primary cross-correlation and Rayleigh-Rayleigh auto-correlation contributions at observing frequency, 799 GHz. The upper, middle, and lower rows represent the , , and power spectra, respectively. In each panel, the grey curves denote the power spectra for the CDM scenario. The lower panels in each plot present the Rayleigh scattering contribution with respect to the corresponding primary CMB power spectra for the CDM case as a reference, denoted by for different values of and . For the power spectrum, the relative change is normalised as .
Methodology
Fisher Formalism
We are interested in quantifying the improvement in the constraints on the parameters of the fiducial CDM cosmological model and several of its extensions due to the inclusion of the RS signal in addition to the primary CMB for future CMB experiments. To do so, we use a standard Fisher matrix approach [58, 59]. For a set of zero-mean Gaussian fields (in our case CMB spherical harmonic coefficients, for ) having parameter-dependent covariance matrix, , the Fisher matrix is defined as the expectation value of the second derivative of the log-likelihood, with respect to the model parameters of interest (denoted here as ), evaluated at their fiducial values ,
The matrix for CMB data can be written as,
where are matrices for frequency channels and each element of incorporates cross-frequency angular power spectra of CMB, foregrounds and noise. The noise power spectrum at frequency is modelled as
where (in ) is the noise sensitivity for and (in radians) is the beam FWHM at the respective frequency. In this analysis, we adopt the instrument configuration for PICO (see Table 3.2 of [42]), LiteBIRD and Planck (see Table 13 of [41] and Table 4 of [4]). We use only the frequency channels at GHz, since the RS signal is negligible at lower frequencies and since this choice avoids the need to model some of the low-frequency foregrounds, such as free-free and anomalous microwave emission, which dominate frequencies below 90 GHz. The modelling of foreground power spectra is discussed in § 3.2. Once the Fisher matrix is computed, we obtain the lower limit of the parameter covariance matrix,
| Data | Model | RS | |||||||
| Primary CMB | CDM | no | – | ||||||
| + RS | – | ||||||||
| Primary CMB | CDM | no | – | ||||||
| + RS+ | – | ||||||||
| yes | – | ||||||||
| – | |||||||||
| CDM + | no | ||||||||
| Primary CMB | CDM | no | – | ||||||
| + RS+ | – | ||||||||
| + | yes | – | |||||||
| – | |||||||||
| CDM + | no | ||||||||
| yes | |||||||||
| CDM + | no | ||||||||
| + |
Table 4. Biases in units of , with the corresponding percentage shifts in parentheses, in the six CDM parameters and for PICO. The data (all including the RS signal) are generated under three scenarios: CDM, a modified recombination history with entering only through , and the same variation also applied to and . Each data set is analysed with the models listed, without (“no”) or with (“yes”) modelling RS. When the model matches the data and RS is modelled, the biases vanish by construction and these rows are omitted.
and the marginalised uncertainties of the parameters are .
Moreover, we aim to quantify the bias in the parameter estimation if we incorrectly model the CMB power spectra, for instance ignore modelling the RS contribution in the covariance matrix . In that case, the spherical harmonic coefficients of the data are drawn from where is the true data covariance matrix. However, the log-likelihood, assumes the model covariance , which differs from . Therefore, is minimised with respect to the drifted parameter values, with associated bias for respective parameters. Minimising the first derivative of the log-likelihood, we can obtain the bias in each parameter as
where is the difference in the covariance matrix due to the mismatch between the model and the data. A detailed derivation of Eq. (6) and Eq. (10) is shown in Appendix § 7.
Foreground modelling
We modelled the foreground contamination following the baseline model of the ACT DR6 analysis [60, 61]. In temperature, we include the kinematic and thermal Sunyaev–Zel’dovich (kSZ, tSZ) effects, the Poisson and clustered components of the cosmic infrared background (CIB), the tSZCIB correlation, unresolved radio sources, Galactic dust and Galactic synchrotron emission. However, since we use only channels GHz in our analysis, we do not include a very detailed modelling of synchrotron (only for ), free-free and spinning dust emissions. The foreground power spectra are computed with the fgspectra{^2} code, assuming delta-function passbands at the channel frequencies. All components are normalised at and GHz except synchrotron. The synchrotron is normalised at and GHz. The functional forms and the values of the fiducial parameters are summarised in Table 1. The foreground spectra are added to the CMB and RS spectra in the covariance matrix of Eq. (7).
Table 1. Table 1: Foreground components included in the model, written as in CMB thermodynamic units for channels , . The pivot scale and pivot frequency are and GHz for all components except Synchrotron, which is normalised at and GHz. Where denotes the template power spectrum of component X, normalised at the pivot multipole . Here is the conversion factor from Rayleigh–Jeans units to CMB thermodynamic temperature unit, is a modified blackbody in CMB thermodynamic units, and with is the tSZ spectral function. Fiducial values of the extragalactic and Galactic-dust parameters are taken from the given references.
Results
In this section we present the forecasted constraints on the cosmological parameters obtained with and without the inclusion of the RS signal, and quantify the parameter biases that arise when RS is neglected or when the recombination history is mis-modelled. We present the results for PICO [42] noise levels in the main text. The corresponding results for LiteBIRD + Planck [4, 41] are presented in Appendix § 8. The results for both LiteBIRD+Planck and PICO noise levels are obtained with , and with the foreground model of § 3.2, using the , and spectra of all frequency channels and their cross-spectra. For PICO we set . We use for LiteBIRD and for Planck we use and for temperature and polarisation, respectively.
We consider three cosmological models. Our baseline model is CDM with six parameters, and fiducial values are set to the best-fit values of the Planck 2018 results [5]. Besides the CDM model, we study two extensions of the CDM model where we vary either or in two ways. In the model labelled CDM + , the variation of the fundamental constant enters only through the modified recombination history computed with RECFAST++ [48, 70], while the Thomson and Rayleigh cross-sections are held at their standard values. In the model labelled CDM + , the variation is propagated consistently to the scattering cross-sections as well, i.e. and (cf. Eq. (5)). The fiducial values are for the forecasts of parameter constraints in § 4.1, while the bias analysis of § 4.2 assumes (or ) in the simulated data.
Forecast constraints with and without Rayleigh scattering
For PICO: Table 2 quotes the marginalised 68% uncertainties of the related parameters for all models, and Figure 6 shows the corresponding fractional improvement, , obtained by adding the RS signal to the primary CMB for PICO. The improvement factors are quoted in Table 3.
| Model | ||||||||
| CDM | 1.4 | 6.5 | 4.9 | 6.7 | 1.8 | 7.3 | – | – |
| CDM + (for ) | 6.5 | 5.5 | 6.5 | 31.6 | 16.4 | 9.0 | 31.6 | – |
| CDM + (for ) | 1.4 | 6.5 | 7.8 | 30.7 | 16.4 | 9.2 | – | 30.9 |
| CDM + (for ) | 30.7 | 28.3 | 6.6 | 31.2 | 1.3 | 3.2 | 30.9 | – |
| CDM + (for ) | 0.9 | 5.0 | 4.3 | 7.4 | 2.8 | 5.9 | – | 4.2 |
Table 3. Fractional improvement (in %), , in the marginalised uncertainties quoted in Table 2 when the RS signal is included.
| Model | ||||||||
| CDM | ||||||||
| Without RS | 2.7 | 3.9 | 3.2 | 0.15 | 1.4 | 1.8 | – | – |
| With RS | 2.6 | 3.6 | 3.0 | 0.14 | 1.4 | 1.6 | – | – |
| CDM + | ||||||||
| Without RS | 2.8 | 4.0 | 3.2 | 0.33 | 2.1 | 1.8 | 1.6 | – |
| With RS | 2.6 | 3.7 | 3.0 | 0.23 | 1.8 | 1.6 | 1.1 | – |
| Without RS | 2.7 | 3.8 | 3.2 | 0.31 | 2.1 | 1.7 | – | 5.6 |
| With RS | 2.7 | 3.6 | 3.0 | 0.21 | 1.7 | 1.6 | – | 3.8 |
| CDM + | ||||||||
| Without RS | 31 | 18 | 3.3 | 2.8 | 1.4 | 1.7 | 14 | – |
| With RS | 21 | 13 | 3.1 | 1.9 | 1.4 | 1.7 | 9.5 | – |
| Without RS | 2.7 | 3.9 | 3.3 | 0.24 | 2.1 | 1.8 | – | 4.1 |
| With RS | 2.7 | 3.6 | 3.2 | 0.23 | 2.1 | 1.7 | – | 3.9 |
Table 2. 68% confidence intervals for the six CDM parameters and the additional parameter (and ) obtained for the CDM model and its possible extensions, comparing analyses with and without including the RS signal alongside the primary CMB for PICO.
Figure 6. Improvement in the error bars of the cosmological parameters and electron mass (left) or fine-structure constant (right) when we include the RS signal alongside the primary CMB signal for PICO. The blue, red and orange bars correspond to the CDM and two modified recombination cases, respectively.
We first investigate the improvement in the constraints on the six parameters for the standard CDM model. Including RS tightens the constraints on all parameters, but by different amounts (see Table 3). The largest gains are for (7.3%), (6.7%) and (6.5%), followed by (4.9%). The gains for (1.8%) and (1.4%) are marginal. The overall improvement is modest because in CDM, the recombination history is fixed by standard atomic physics, so RS does not open a new degree of freedom. It only provides a frequency-dependent view of the same acoustic structure. Moreover, the RS contribution becomes significant only at high frequencies, where instrumental noise and dust contamination are dominant. The improvement differs between parameters because RS adds information mainly through two effects. With RS, the peak of visibility shifts across frequency channels. Each channel therefore probes the sound horizon at a slightly different redshift around last scattering, producing a frequency-dependent shift of the acoustic peaks whose size depends on , and hence on the matter density. This constrains directly, and through their degeneracy, which is why the precision of both parameters improves by a similar amount (). Second, RS boosts the power at (see Figure 4). This additional polarisation information tightens the constraints on (7.3%) and, through its correlations with , the constraint on the primordial amplitude also improves by 4.9%. In contrast, RS produces no tilt-like change in the total power spectra in the CDM framework. Furthermore, although RS depends on the baryon density since , in the CDM framework this information is already encoded in the primary CMB acoustic peak structure. Since the primary CMB already measures and precisely, from the overall tilt and the relative peak heights, their precision improves only by with the addition of RS. Overall, RS shrinks the CDM posteriors without changing the degeneracy directions, as shown in the contour plots represented on the top panel of Figure 7.
Figure 7. and confidence contours obtained for the CDM model and its extensions when we analyse the data with primary CMB only (red) and primary CMB + RS signal (blue) for PICO.
Next we investigate the two cases of modified recombination history. First we discuss the results for the case in which only the ionisation history is modified by varying or , but scattering rates are unchanged. The impact of RS is considerably larger for some of the parameters once the recombination history is allowed to vary (see Table 3). For instance, for varying electron mass, the uncertainty on improves from 0.0016 to 0.0011 and that on from 0.33 to 0.23 km sMpc, i.e. by in both parameters. Varying leads to a very similar pattern: decreases from 0.0006 to 0.0004 and from 0.31 to 0.21 km sMpc which is a improvement. These are the parameters RS probes most directly. In the primary CMB, a change in or shows up only through the shift of the Thomson visibility. The changes in the Rayleigh visibilities are, however, more pronounced and frequency dependent. The multi-frequency RS signal provides additional, partly independent information on the timing and duration of recombination,
beyond what is available from the primary CMB alone. An earlier recombination caused by increased or values reduces the sound horizon, and with the angular size of the sound horizon, fixed by the data, this is compensated almost exactly by a larger , giving the near-perfect – (and –) degeneracy as illustrated in the middle-left (and middle-right) panel of Figure 7. Since RS can sample the recombination timing, this gives improved constraints on and and hence as well through – (or –) correlation. Therefore improves by almost the same amount as or . The other parameters improve according to how strongly they are degenerate with the fundamental constants.
The constraint on the spectral index improves by 16.4%, which is substantially more than in CDM (1.8%). This improvement is closely related to the changes in the damping tail of CMB power spectra in modified recombination scenarios. A change in the fundamental constant shifts the epoch of recombination and hence modifies the photon diffusion scale, thereby changing the suppression of power at high . A change in also alters the relative amount of power between large and small scales. From the primary CMB alone, these effects can therefore be partially degenerate, producing a correlation between and the fundamental constants. RS helps to break this degeneracy because its contribution to the damping is frequency-dependent. In particular, RS adds extra diffusion damping that grows as , and therefore its damping effect on the anisotropies varies with frequency, while the primordial tilt is common to all frequency channels. Comparing the damping tail across frequencies therefore helps distinguish changes in the damping caused by the modified recombination history from those associated with . This additional information reduces the – (or –) degeneracy, leading to an improvement in the constraint on . The slightly larger gain for is consistent with its stronger impact on the recombination history and, consequently, on the damping and visibility structure. In contrast, , and improve by 5–9%, similar to CDM. Because the scattering rates are unchanged in this model, the relative peak heights still determine the matter density and the amplitude independently of or . These parameters are therefore only weakly correlated with the fundamental constants (quantitatively the correlation coefficients, ), and their gain comes mainly from the same effects as in CDM. improves somewhat more than in CDM (6.5% for ). This is because a shift of the recombination redshift changes the baryon loading, at decoupling. Since the RS opacity is linked with this introduces a mild correlation between and , which gives RS more leverage on than in the standard CDM case. For , is essentially uncorrelated with the fundamental constant already in the primary CMB, and its improvement is minimal.
When the variation of is consistently propagated to the scattering cross-sections, the constraints from the primary CMB degrade substantially. In particular, the marginalised uncertainties increase to , , and , , roughly an order of magnitude weaker than in the -only model. This happens because two effects of a larger partly cancel. First, recombination happens earlier, , when the Universe is denser, so there are more electrons available to scatter photons. Second, each electron scatters less, because . The net Thomson scattering rate at recombination therefore changes only mildly, roughly as . This remaining change can be absorbed by a faster expansion, , obtained by increasing and , with adjusted to keep the angular scale of the acoustic peaks fixed. These adjustments leave the ratio unchanged, which decides the shape of the Thomson visibility function [32, 71]. As a result, the primary CMB can hardly distinguish a change in from a combined shift of , and , and these four parameters become strongly degenerate, as demonstrated in the bottom-left panel of Figure 7.
Rayleigh scattering does not completely break this scaling. Although at fixed observed frequency , the photon frequency at the last scattering epoch is . Consequently, at a fixed observed frequency, . Since , the Rayleigh scattering rate scales approximately as , which has the same leading dependence on as the Thomson scattering rate, . Thus, readjustment of other parameters to keep the primary CMB unchanged also preserves RS. However, the multi-frequency RS spectra provide additional, partly independent measurements of the same acoustic and damping structure, which are not completely redundant with the primary CMB. These modes provide additional information along the otherwise poorly constrained degeneracy direction, reducing its allowed extent without substantially changing its orientation, as shown in the bottom-left panel of Figure 7. As a result, the parameters that are most strongly aligned with this degeneracy improve by nearly the same percentage. In contrast, , , and are less strongly aligned with this degeneracy and improve by only 1–7%.
The behaviour for is qualitatively different. Although changes both the atomic binding energies and the scattering cross-sections, the different processes governing recombination do not scale with a common power of . In particular, the rates associated with Lyman- escape, two-photon decay, and photoionisation have different dependences from . Therefore, no analogous rescaling of , , and can preserve the Thomson scattering history throughout recombination. The primary CMB consequently already constrains tightly, with , leaving little degeneracy for RS to break. The inclusion of RS therefore produces only modest additional improvements, at the level of .
For LiteBIRD + Planck: The corresponding results for LiteBIRD + Planck are given in Appendix § 8: Table 6 and Table 7 present the 68% confidence limits and relative improvement in the error bars of the parameters, respectively. Figure 10 displays the error-bar improvements as quoted in Table 7. The trends are the same as for PICO, but the gains are much smaller for most cases. In CDM no parameter improves by more than 0.7%, and in the CDM + model the largest gains are 1.9% for and 1.4% for (similarly 1.2% and 0.7% for and , respectively). This is expected as the RS signal is concentrated at high frequencies, where the noise of the Planck channels limits its detectability, and partially because we conservatively restrict the LiteBIRD multipole range to in this analysis. The exception is the CDM + model for varying , where , , and improve by 55–58%. With the higher noise of LiteBIRD + Planck as compared to PICO, the primary CMB alone constrains the degeneracies among these four parameters discussed above even more weakly, with and . Even the small amount of information that RS adds along this direction of therefore reduces these uncertainties substantially, to 0.019 and . For , where no such degeneracy exists as also discussed above, the improvement stays below 1%.
| Model | ||||||||
| CDM | ||||||||
| Without RS | 9.3 | 8.2 | 3.9 | 0.36 | 2.4 | 1.9 | – | – |
| With RS | 9.2 | 8.1 | 3.9 | 0.36 | 2.4 | 1.9 | – | – |
| CDM + | ||||||||
| Without RS | 9.8 | 9.9 | 4.1 | 0.89 | 3.8 | 1.9 | 5.0 | – |
| With RS | 9.7 | 9.8 | 4.1 | 0.88 | 3.8 | 1.9 | 4.9 | – |
| Without RS | 9.3 | 9.4 | 4.4 | 0.79 | 4.4 | 1.9 | – | 17 |
| With RS | 9.2 | 9.4 | 4.4 | 0.78 | 4.3 | 1.9 | – | 17 |
| CDM + | ||||||||
| Without RS | 103 | 57 | 4.3 | 9.8 | 2.6 | 1.9 | 46 | – |
| With RS | 44 | 26 | 4.0 | 4.1 | 2.4 | 1.9 | 19 | – |
| Without RS | 9.5 | 8.9 | 4.4 | 0.59 | 4.2 | 1.9 | – | 13 |
| With RS | 9.4 | 8.8 | 4.4 | 0.58 | 4.2 | 1.9 | – | 13 |
Table 6. 68% confidence intervals for the six CDM parameters and the additional parameter (and ) obtained for the CDM model and its possible extensions, comparing analyses with and without including the RS signal along with the Primary CMB for LiteBIRD + Planck.
| Model | ||||||||
| CDM | 0.4 | 0.6 | 0.0 | 0.7 | 0.2 | 0.2 | – | – |
| CDM + (for ) | 0.9 | 0.2 | 0.1 | 1.9 | 0.6 | 0.1 | 1.4 | – |
| CDM + (for ) | 0.5 | 0.2 | 0.2 | 1.2 | 0.4 | 0.2 | – | 0.7 |
| CDM + (for ) | 57.4 | 54.5 | 6.7 | 57.8 | 6.6 | 1.5 | 57.6 | – |
| CDM + (for ) | 0.3 | 0.4 | 0.0 | 0.7 | 0.1 | 0.2 | – | 0.2 |
Table 7. Fractional improvement (in %), , in the marginalised uncertainties quoted in Table 6 when the RS signal is included for LiteBIRD + Planck.
Figure 10. Improvement in the error bars of the cosmological parameters and the electron mass (left) or the fine-structure constant (right) when we include the RS signal with the primary CMB signal for LiteBIRD + Planck. The blue, red and orange bars correspond to the CDM and the two modified recombination cases, respectively. For clarity, in the left-hand panel, the improvements for the CDM + model are separately plotted since the values are much larger than in the other two cases.
Parameter biases
We now quantify the biases in the inferred parameters using Eq. (10). We generate three sets of mock data, all including the RS signal: (i) standard CDM; (ii) a modified recombination history in which the variation of the fundamental constant enters only through ; and (iii) the same variation applied also to and . For the electron mass we adopt and for the fine-structure constant , with all other parameters at their fiducial values. Each data set is analysed with CDM and with the extended models, with and without modelling the RS contribution. In each case, the bias is projected with the Fisher matrix of the model used in the analysis, and is quoted in units of that model’s marginalised uncertainty (and in % in the parentheses). The results are shown in Table 4 (for ) and 5 (for ) and illustrated in Figure 8 and Figure 9, where each point marks the recovered value with the corresponding error bar, and the vertical line marks the input value. When the model matches the data and RS is modelled, the bias vanishes by construction. Note that Eq. (10) is a linear approximation, valid for a few ; biases of tens of found below should therefore be read as indicating a severe mis-modelling rather than as precise values.
Figure 8. Data: Primary CMB + RS; Data: Primary CMB + RS + ; Data: Primary CMB + RS + ; Model: CDM; Model: CDM + ; Model: CDM + ; Without RS; With RS. Panel labels: , , , , , , and . Figure 8: Biased estimated values, , with their marginalised error bars, of the six CDM parameters and for PICO, when the simulated data are analysed with CDM and its extensions. The shaded horizontal bands correspond to the three simulated data sets, all including the RS signal: CDM (blue band), a modified recombination history with entering only through (orange band), and the same variation also applied to and (cyan band). Within each band, the colour of the points indicates the model used in the analysis: CDM (blue), CDM + (red), and CDM + (orange). Filled and open markers denote analyses without and with modelling RS, respectively. Each vertical line marks the input value used to generate the data.
Figure 9. Biased estimated values, , with their marginalised error bars, of the six CDM parameters and for PICO. The data, generated with , include the RS signal, with the variation of entering only through (orange band) or also through and (cyan band). Colours, markers and vertical lines are as in Figure 8. The CDM-data case, identical to Figure 8, is not repeated in this figure.
For PICO: We begin by discussing the parameter biases expected for the PICO instrument configuration.
Neglecting the RS in CDM model: If the data follow CDM but RS is omitted from the model, all biases remain below . The largest shifts are in (), () and (), corresponding to fractional shifts of . Although small, a bias of nearly in would become relevant when combined with external data such as BBN, showing that RS must be modelled at the sensitivity of next-generation experiments.
Fitting a modified recombination history with CDM model: If the recombination history in the data is modified only through (data set ii) and the analysis assumes CDM, the inferred parameters are severely biased, whether or not RS is modelled. An increase in or shifts recombination to earlier times and reduces the sound horizon; CDM can mimic this only by lowering to keep the angular acoustic scale fixed, together with a larger and a correlated increase of and . For , is shifted by (, i.e. ), by to (), by to and by to , while is shifted by 18–25%. For , which shifts the atomic energy levels () by the same 2%, the shifts are even larger, reflecting the additional, non-uniform -dependence of the recombination rates: by (–57 km s Mpc), by (12–14%) and by 29–42%. In this case the model mis-specification dominates, and modelling RS within a CDM fit does not reduce the bias; it only increases its significance, since RS tightens the error bars. Once the fundamental constant is included in the model (CDM ), the biases from neglecting RS fall to for all parameters (at most in and in , and in and in ), and they vanish when RS is also modelled.
Mis-modelling the scattering cross-section dependence: For data set (iii), in which the variation also rescales and , a CDM fit again gives very large biases. For these reach in (), in , in both and , and 18–27% in ; for , is shifted by () and by , whereas and are much less affected ().
More importantly, analysing these data with the CDM model, i.e. allowing for a varying constant but neglecting its effect on the cross-sections, leads to qualitatively different outcomes for and . For , large biases remain: in , () in and () in without (with) RS. The recovered electron mass is shifted by , to , so that a true 2% variation would be inferred as consistent with no variation at all. This is a direct consequence of the scaling degeneracy discussed in § 4.1: the reduction of largely compensates the earlier recombination, so that the data resemble a standard recombination history with shifted and . The fractional shifts are almost identical with and without RS, but their significance increases with RS because the error bars are tighter. For , where no such compensation exists, the recovered value remains close to the input: () without RS and () with RS, accompanied by biases of – in and in (without RS) or (with RS). In both cases, only the fully consistent CDM model recovers the input parameters; neglecting RS in this model produces biases of for and for .
For LiteBIRD + Planck: The corresponding biases for LiteBIRD + Planck are listed in Table 8 (for ) and 9 (for ) in Appendix § 8. The corresponding biases are also shown in Figure 11 and 12 respectively. The pattern is the same as for PICO, but the significances are smaller because the uncertainties are larger. Neglecting RS in a CDM analysis of CDM data gives biases of at most , so at this sensitivity omitting RS is harmless for the standard model. In contrast, fitting CDM to data with a modified recombination history still gives strong biases as expected. When the cross-section scaling is neglected (data set for CDM analysed with CDM ), the scaling degeneracy again biases the electron mass: is shifted by (, i.e. ), together with in and in . For , the corresponding biases remain . Once the correct model is used, neglecting RS biases all parameters by less than .
| Data | Model | RS | |||||||
| Primary CMB + RS | CDM | no | <br> | <br> | <br> | <br> | <br> | <br> | – |
| Primary CMB + RS+ | CDM | no | <br> | <br> | <br> | <br> | <br> | <br> | – |
| yes | <br> | <br> | <br> | <br> | <br> | <br> | – | ||
| CDM + | no | <br> | <br> | <br> | <br> | <br> | <br> | <br> | |
| Primary CMB + RS+ + | CDM | no | <br> | <br> | <br> | <br> | <br> | <br> | – |
| yes | <br> | <br> | <br> | <br> | <br> | <br> | – | ||
| CDM + | no | <br> | <br> | <br> | <br> | <br> | <br> | <br> | |
| yes | <br> | <br> | <br> | <br> | <br> | <br> | <br> | ||
| CDM + + | no | <br> | <br> | <br> | <br> | <br> | <br> | <br> |
Table 8. Same as Table 4, but for LiteBIRD + Planck: biases in units of , with the corresponding percentage shifts in parentheses, in the six CDM parameters and , for data generated with and analysed with different models.
Figure 11. Recovered biased values, of the six CDM parameters and with their marginalised error bars for LiteBIRD + Planck. The data sets, models, colours and markers are as in Figure 8.
Conclusions
In this work, we have studied Rayleigh scattering of CMB photons as a probe of the cosmological recombination process, with particular focus on recombination scenarios modified by a variation of the electron mass, , or the fine-structure constant, . We modelled the RS signal with modified versions of Recfast++ and CAMB, and used a multi-frequency Fisher analysis including realistic noise and foregrounds to forecast parameter constraints and biases for PICO and LiteBIRD + Planck.
Increasing or increases atomic binding energies, so recombination occurs earlier. Neutral hydrogen and helium therefore appear at higher redshift, which shifts the onset of RS opacity and both the Thomson and Rayleigh visibility functions to earlier times. Because the RS contribution scales as , these changes imprint a frequency-dependent signature on the , and especially the spectra, which is most pronounced in the highest-frequency channels.
For PICO, adding RS to the primary CMB improves the CDM constraints by , since RS does not open any new degree of freedom when the recombination history is fixed. This finding is in good agreement with [55]. The gain is substantially greater once the recombination history is allowed to vary. In the CDM model, the uncertainties in , and shrink by , and the error bars of other parameters also improve, because RS samples the timing of recombination independently at each frequency. When the variation of is propagated consistently to the Thomson and Rayleigh cross-sections, the primary CMB alone suffers from an almost exact scaling degeneracy between , , and . RS reduces the extent of this degeneracy and improves all four parameters by . For , there is no such degeneracy and the gain is . For LiteBIRD + Planck the improvements are below 2%, except along the same scaling degeneracy, where they reach 55–58% because the primary-CMB constraints are much weaker.
The bias analysis shows that RS must be modelled in future analyses. For PICO, neglecting RS biases the CDM parameters by up to , while for LiteBIRD + Planck the biases remain below . A modified recombination history analysed with CDM produces very large biases for both experiments. Most importantly, if the effect of a varying on the scattering cross-sections is neglected, the scaling degeneracy drives the inferred electron mass back to . A genuine 2% variation of would then be completely missed because the data is fitted by readjusting the other parameters. A variation of , in contrast, is still recovered close to its input value. Only when the variation is modelled consistently, including and , are the input parameters recovered, with residual biases from neglecting RS of .
Our forecasts rely on the Fisher formalism, and the bias estimates use a linear expansion. Biases of tens of should therefore be read as signs of severe mis-modelling rather than as precise values, and the constraints along the near-degenerate direction would benefit from a full likelihood analysis. More accurate foreground modelling and calibration parameters, and exploiting the high-frequency channels of future experiments, will be essential to fully realise the potential of RS as an independent probe of recombination physics and of proposed modified recombination-based solutions to the Hubble tension.
Acknowledgments
DA, RTGS, CHM and JARM acknowledge financial support from the projects PID2023-150398NB-I00 and PID2023-151567NB-I00, funded by the Ministry of Science, Innovation and Universities of Spain, AEI/10.13039/501100011033 and by FEDER, EU. This work is part of grant CEX2025-001609-S, awarded to the Instituto de Astrofísica de Canarias under the Severo Ochoa Centre of Excellence program and funded by MI-CIU/AEI/10.13039/501100011033. JC acknowledges the support of the Fundación Occident and the Instituto de Astrofísica de Canarias under the Visiting Researcher Programme 2025-2028 agreed between both institutions. EV acknowledges that the project that gave rise to these results received the support of a fellowship from the a “Caixa” Foundation (ID B006373). The fellowship code is LCF/BQ/DI24/12070001. JC was also supported by the UKSA grant: LiteBIRD UK ST/Y005945/1. We thank the Simons Observatory collaboration for making the fgspectra code publicly available, and Antony Lewis for providing the modified version of CAMB to include the Rayleigh scattering. The paper uses the python packages, numpy [72], matplotlib [73], scipy [74].
Derivation of Fisher matrix and parameter bias due to incorrect fiducial model
The log-likelihood of a Gaussian random vector, , having a covariance matrix, is given by
where is a block-diagonal matrix, with the matrix of size as its elements for each multipole . Taking the derivative with respect to parameter and using the log-determinant matrix identities and , we obtain
Taking the second derivative with respect to the parameter and using the matrix identity, where , we derive the Fisher matrix as
For CMB data, since the covariance matrix is block-diagonal for each of size , the Fisher matrix for a sky-fraction of is given by
Now we show the derivation of the bias in the parameters due to the mismatch between model and true data . Due to the systematic difference between the true power spectrum and our model’s expectation, the maximum of the likelihood will be shifted to from the true parameter values by a bias . Therefore the estimator satisfies the condition,
Expanding Eq. A.5 around the true parameter values we get,
Taking the expectation value of Eq. A.6 and using the definition of the Fisher matrix, , we obtain
Therefore, the bias vector is
Using the expression in Eq. A.2 and considering and the matrix identity, , Eq. A.8 can be expressed as,
Using and considering that CMB power spectra are diagonal in and space, from Eq. A.8, we get the final expression for the parameter bias vector,
where .
Results with LiteBIRD + Planck
Figure 12. Recovered biased values, of the six CDM parameters and with their marginalised error bars, for LiteBIRD + Planck. The data sets, models, colours and markers are as in Figure 9.
| Data | Model | RS | |||||||
| Primary CMB + RS + | CDM | no | – | ||||||
| – | |||||||||
| yes | – | ||||||||
| – | |||||||||
| CDM + | no | ||||||||
| Primary CMB + RS + + | CDM | no | – | ||||||
| – | |||||||||
| yes | – | ||||||||
| – | |||||||||
| CDM + | no | ||||||||
| yes | |||||||||
| CDM + | no | ||||||||
| + |
Table 9. Same as Table 5, but for LiteBIRD + Planck: biases in units of , with the corresponding percentage shifts in parentheses, in the six CDM parameters and , for data generated with and analysed with different models.
| Data | Model | RS | |||||||
| Primary CMB + RS + | CDM | no | – | ||||||
| – | |||||||||
| yes | – | ||||||||
| – | |||||||||
| CDM + | no | ||||||||
| Primary CMB + RS + + | CDM | no | – | ||||||
| – | |||||||||
| yes | – | ||||||||
| – | |||||||||
| CDM + | no | ||||||||
| yes | |||||||||
| CDM + + | no | ||||||||
Table 5. Biases in units of , with the corresponding percentage shifts in parentheses, for data generated with , entering either only through or also through and for PICO. Each data set is analysed with the models listed, without (“no”) or with (“yes”) modelling RS. When the model matches the data and RS is modelled, the biases vanish by construction and these rows are omitted. The case of CDM data is identical to Table 4.
References
- [1]J. J. McMahon, K. A. Aird, B. A. Benson, L. E. Bleem, J. Britton, J. E. Carlstrom et al., SPTpol: an instrument for CMB polarization, in American Institute of Physics Conference Series, B. Young, B. Cabrera, & A. Miller, ed., vol. 1185 of American Institute of Physics Conference Series, pp. 511–514, Dec., 2009, DOI.DOI
- [2]M. D. Niemack, P. A. R. Ade, J. Aguirre, F. Barrientos, J. A. Beall, J. R. Bond et al., ACTPol: a polarization-sensitive receiver for the Atacama Cosmology Telescope, in Society of Photo-Optical Instrumentation Engineers (SPIE) Conference Series, vol. 7741 of Presented at the Society of Photo-Optical Instrumentation Engineers (SPIE) Conference, July, 2010, 1006.5049, DOI.DOI
- [3]C. L. Bennett, D. Larson, J. L. Weiland, N. Jarosik, G. Hinshaw, N. Odegard et al., Nine-year wilkinson microwave anisotropy probe (wmap) observations: Final maps and results, The Astrophysical Journal Supplement Series 208 (2013) 20.
- [4]Planck Collaboration, N. Aghanim, Y. Akrami, F. Arroja, M. Ashdown, J. Aumont et al., Planck 2018 results. I. Overview and the cosmological legacy of Planck, A&A 641 (2020) A1 [1807.06205].
- [5]Planck Collaboration, N. Aghanim, Y. Akrami, M. Ashdown, J. Aumont, C. Baccigalupi et al., Planck 2018 results. VI. Cosmological parameters, A&A 641 (2020) A6 [1807.06209].
- [6]A. G. Riess, W. Yuan, L. M. Macri, D. Scolnic, D. Brout, S. Casertano et al., A comprehensive measurement of the local value of the hubble constant with 1 km s−1 Mpc−1 uncertainty from the hubble space telescope and the shoes team, The Astrophysical Journal Letters 934 (2022) L7.
- [7]E. Di Valentino, L. A. Anchordoqui, Ö. Akarsu, Y. Ali-Haimoud, L. Amendola, N. Arendse et al., Cosmology Intertwined III: fσ8 and S8, Astroparticle Physics 131 (2021) 102604 [2008.11285].
- [8]I. d. O. C. Pedreira, M. Benetti, E. G. M. Ferreira, L. L. Graef and L. Herold, Visual tool for assessing tension-resolving models in the H0–σ8 plane, Phys.Rev.D 109 (2024) 103525 [2311.04977].
- [9]ACT, DES collaboration, Cosmology from cross-correlation of ACT-DR4 CMB lensing and DES-Y3 cosmic shear, Mon. Not. Roy. Astron. Soc. 528 (2024) 2112 [2309.04412].
- [10]F. J. Qu, Q. Hang, G. Farren, B. Bolliet, J. N. Aguilar, S. Ahlen et al., Atacama cosmology telescope dr6 and desi: Structure growth measurements from the cross-correlation of desi legacy imaging galaxies and cmb lensing from act dr6 and planck pr4, Phys. Rev. D 111 (2025) 103503.
- [11]T. Karim, S. Singh, M. Rezaie, D. Eisenstein, B. Hadzhiyska, J. S. Speagle et al., Measuring σ8 using desi legacy imaging surveys emission-line galaxies and planck cmb lensing, and the impact of dust on parameter inference, Journal of Cosmology and Astroparticle Physics 2025 (2025) 045.DOI
- [12]E. Mörtsell, A. Goobar, J. Johansson and S. Dhawan, Sensitivity of the Hubble Constant Determination to Cepheid Calibration, ApJ 933 (2022) 212 [2105.11461].DOI
- [13]E. Mörtsell, A. Goobar, J. Johansson and S. Dhawan, The Hubble Tension Revisited: Additional Local Distance Ladder Uncertainties, ApJ 935 (2022) 58 [2106.09400].DOI
- [14]C.-T. Chiang and A. Slosar, Inferences of H₀ in presence of a non-standard recombination, arXiv e-prints (2018) arXiv:1811.03624 [1811.03624].arxiv.org/abs/1811.03624
- [15]L. Hart and J. Chluba, Updated fundamental constant constraints from Planck 2018 data and possible relations to the Hubble tension, MNRAS 493 (2020) 3255 [1912.03986].DOI
- [16]S. Roy Choudhury, S. Hannestad and T. Tram, Updated constraints on massive neutrino self-interactions from cosmology in light of the H₀ tension, JCAP 03 (2021) 084 [2012.07519].DOI
- [17]K. Jedamzik and L. Pogosian, Relieving the Hubble Tension with Primordial Magnetic Fields, Phys.Rev.Lett 125 (2020) 181302 [2004.09487].DOI
- [18]Ruchika, H. Rathore, S. Roy Choudhury and V. Rentala, A gravitational constant transition within cepheids as supernovae calibrators can solve the Hubble tension, JCAP 06 (2024) 056 [2306.05450].DOI
- [19]E. Calabrese, J. C. Hill, H. T. Jense, A. La Posta, I. Abril-Cabezas, G. E. Addison et al., The Atacama Cosmology Telescope: DR6 constraints on extended cosmological models, JCAP 2025 (2025) 063 [2503.14454].arxiv.org/abs/2503.14454
- [20]D. Wang and D. Mota, Did DESI DR2 truly reveal dynamical dark energy?, European Physical Journal C 85 (2025) 1356 [2504.15222].arxiv.org/abs/2504.15222
- [21]L. Knox and M. Millea, Hubble constant hunter’s guide, Phys.Rev.D 101 (2020) 043533 [1908.03663].DOI
- [22]E. Di Valentino, O. Mena, S. Pan, L. Visinelli, W. Yang, A. Melchiorri et al., In the realm of the Hubble tension-a review of solutions, Classical and Quantum Gravity 38 (2021) 153001 [2103.01183].DOI
- [23]N. Schöneberg, G. Franco Abellán, A. Pérez Sánchez, S. J. Witte, V. Poulin and J. Lesgourgues, The H0 Olympics: A fair ranking of proposed models, Phys. Rept. 984 (2022) 1 [2107.10291].
- [24]G.-B. Zhao, M. Raveri, L. Pogosian, Y. Wang, R. G. Crittenden, W. J. Handley et al., Dynamical dark energy in light of the latest observations, Nature Astronomy 1 (2017) 627 [1701.08165].DOI
- [25]E. Di Valentino, A. Melchiorri and O. Mena, Can interacting dark energy solve the H₀ tension?, Phys. Rev. D 96 (2017) 043503 [1704.08342].DOI
- [26]L. Pogosian, M. Raveri, K. Koyama, M. Martinelli, A. Silvestri, G.-B. Zhao et al., Imprints of cosmological tensions in reconstructed gravity, Nature Astron. 6 (2022) 1484 [2107.12992].arxiv.org/abs/2107.12992
- [27]A. G. Adame, J. Aguilar, S. Ahlen, S. Alam, D. M. Alexander, M. Alvarez et al., DESI 2024 VI: cosmological constraints from the measurements of baryon acoustic oscillations, JCAP 2025 (2025) 021 [2404.03002].DOI
- [28]E. Ó Colgáin and M. M. Sheikh-Jabbari, DESI and SNe: dynamical dark energy, Ωₘ tension or systematics?, MNRAS 542 (2025) L24 [2412.12905].DOI
- [29]M. Kamionkowski and A. G. Riess, The Hubble Tension and Early Dark Energy, Annual Review of Nuclear and Particle Science 73 (2023) 153 [2211.04492].arxiv.org/abs/2211.04492
- [30]L. Hart and J. Chluba, New constraints on time-dependent variations of fundamental constants using planck data, Monthly Notices of the Royal Astronomical Society 474 (2017) 1850 [https://academic.oup.com/mnras/article-pdf/474/2/1850/22636771/stx2783.pdf].DOI
- [31]L. Hart and J. Chluba, Improved model-independent constraints on the recombination era and development of a direct projection method, MNRAS 495 (2020) 4210 [1912.04682].DOI
- [32]T. Sekiguchi and T. Takahashi, Early recombination as a solution to the H₀ tension, Phys.Rev.D 103 (2021) 083507 [2007.03831].DOI
- [33]Y. Toda, W. Giarè, E. Özülker, E. Di Valentino and S. Vagnozzi, Combining pre- and post-recombination new physics to address cosmological tensions: Case study with varying electron mass and sign-switching cosmological constant, Physics of the Dark Universe 46 (2024) 101676.DOI
- [34]N. Schöneberg and L. Vacher, The mass effect — variations of the electron mass and their impact on cosmology, JCAP 2025 (2025) 004 [2407.16845].
- [35]K. Hoshiya and Y. Toda, Electron mass variation from dark sector interactions and compatibility with cosmological observations, Phys.Rev.D 107 (2023) 043505 [2202.07714].DOI
- [36]O. Seto and Y. Toda, Big bang nucleosynthesis constraints on varying electron mass solution to the Hubble tension, Phys.Rev.D 107 (2023) 083512 [2206.13209].DOI
- [37]Y. Toda and O. Seto, Constraints on the simultaneous variation of the fine structure constant and the electron mass in light of desi bao data, Physics of the Dark Universe 49 (2025) 102035.
- [38]S. Ghosh, K. K. Boddy and T.-T. Yu, Early Universe Constraints on Variations in Fundamental Constants Induced by Ultralight Scalar Dark Matter, arXiv e-prints (2025) arXiv:2511.14532 [2511.14532].arxiv.org/abs/2511.14532
- [39]Q. Yu, D. N. Spergel and J. P. Ostriker, Rayleigh scattering and microwave background fluctuations, The Astrophysical Journal 558 (2001) 23.DOI
- [40]A. Lewis, Rayleigh scattering: blue sky thinking for future CMB observations, JCAP 2013 (2013) 053 [1307.8148].
- [41]LiteBIRD collaboration, Probing Cosmic Inflation with the LiteBIRD Cosmic Microwave Background Polarization Survey, PTEP 2023 (2023) 042F01 [2202.02773].DOI
- [42]S. Hanany, M. Alvarez, E. Artis, P. Ashton, J. Aumont, R. Aurlien et al., PICO: Probe of Inflation and Cosmic Origins, arXiv e-prints (2019) arXiv:1902.10541 [1902.10541].arxiv.org/abs/1902.10541
- [43]L. Rayleigh, X. On the electromagnetic theory of light, The London, Edinburgh, and Dublin Philosophical Magazine and Journal of Science 12 (1881) 81 [https://doi.org/10.1080/14786448108627074].
- [44]H.-W. Lee, Exact low-energy expansion of the rayleigh scattering cross-section by atomic hydrogen, Monthly Notices of the Royal Astronomical Society 358 (2005) 1472 [https://academic.oup.com/mnras/article-pdf/358/4/1472/18660986/358-4-1472.pdf].DOI
- [45]S. P. Tarafdar and M. S. Vardya, The rayleigh scattering cross-sections of he, c, n and o, Monthly Notices of the Royal Astronomical Society 145 (1969) 171 [https://academic.oup.com/mnras/article-pdf/145/2/171/9360740/mnras145-0171.pdf].DOI
- [46]F. Takahara and S. Sasaki, Effect of rayleigh scattering on cosmic microwave background anisotropies, Progress of Theoretical Physics 86 (1991) 1021 [https://academic.oup.com/ptp/article-pdf/86/5/1021/5430029/86-5-1021.pdf].DOI
- [47]J. Chluba and R. M. Thomas, Towards a complete treatment of the cosmological recombination problem, MNRAS 412 (2011) 748 [1010.3631].
- [48]J. Chluba, G. M. Vasil and L. J. Dursi, Recombinations to the Rydberg states of hydrogen and their effect during the cosmological recombination epoch, MNRAS 407 (2010) 599 [1003.4928].
- [49]A. Lewis, A. Challinor and A. Lasenby, Efficient Computation of Cosmic Microwave Background Anisotropies in Closed Friedmann-Robertson-Walker Models, ApJ 538 (2000) 473 [astro-ph/9911177].DOI
- [50]C. G. Scóccola, S. J. Landau and H. Vucetich, WMAP 5-year constraints on time variation of alpha and m_e, Memorie della Societ Astronomica Italiana 80 (2009) 814 [0910.1083].arxiv.org/abs/0910.1083
- [51]S. Seager, D. D. Sasselov and D. Scott, How Exactly Did the Universe Become Neutral?, ApJS 128 (2000) 407 [astro-ph/9912182].
- [52]J. Chluba and Y. Ali-Haïmoud, COSMOSPEC: fast and detailed computation of the cosmological recombination radiation from hydrogen and helium, MNRAS 456 (2016) 3494 [1510.03877].DOI
- [53]Y. B. Zeldovich, V. G. Kurt and R. A. Syunyaev, Recombination of Hydrogen in the Hot Model of the Universe, Zhurnal Eksperimental noi i Teoreticheskoi Fiziki 55 (1968) 278.
- [54]S. Seager, D. D. Sasselov and D. Scott, A New Calculation of the Recombination Epoch, ApJ 523 (1999) L1.DOI
- [55]B. Beringue, P. D. Meerburg, J. Meyers and N. Battaglia, Cosmology with Rayleigh scattering of the cosmic microwave background, JCAP 2021 (2021) 060 [2008.11688].DOI
- [56]M. Kaplinghat, R. J. Scherrer and M. S. Turner, Constraining variations in the fine-structure constant with the cosmic microwave background, Phys.Rev.D 60 (1999) 023516 [arXiv:astro-ph/9810133].DOI
- [57]R. A. Battye, R. Crittenden and J. Weller, Cosmic concordance and the fine structure constant, Phys.Rev.D 63 (2001) 043505 [astro-ph/0008265].DOI
- [58]M. Tegmark, A. N. Taylor and A. F. Heavens, Kahrünen-Löeve Eigenvalue Problems in Cosmology: How Should We Tackle Large Data Sets?, ApJ 480 (1997) 22 [astro-ph/9603021].
- [59]J. Carron, On the assumption of Gaussianity for cosmological two-point statistics and parameter dependent covariance matrices, A&A 551 (2013) A88 [1204.4724].DOI
- [60]T. Louis, A. La Posta, Z. Atkins, H. T. Jense, I. Abril-Cabezas, G. E. Addison et al., The Atacama Cosmology Telescope: DR6 power spectra, likelihoods and ΛCDM parameters, JCAP 2025 (2025) 062 [2503.14452].
- [61]B. Beringue, K. M. Surrao, J. C. Hill, Z. Atkins, N. Battaglia, B. Bolliet et al., The Atacama Cosmology Telescope: DR6 power spectrum foreground model and validation, JCAP 2025 (2025) 082 [2506.06274].DOI
- [62]N. Battaglia, A. Natarajan, H. Trac, R. Cen and A. Loeb, Reionization on large scales. iii. predictions for low-ℓ cosmic microwave background polarization and high-ℓ kinetic sunyaev–zel’dovich observables, The Astrophysical Journal 776 (2013) 83.
- [63]N. Battaglia, J. R. Bond, C. Pfrommer and J. L. Sievers, On the Cluster Physics of Sunyaev-Zel’dovich and X-Ray Surveys. II. Deconstructing the Thermal SZ Power Spectrum, ApJ 758 (2012) 75 [1109.3711].DOI
- [64]Planck Collaboration, P. A. R. Ade, N. Aghanim, C. Armitage-Caplan, M. Arnaud, M. Ashdown et al., Planck 2013 results. XXX. Cosmic infrared background measurements and implications for star formation, A&A 571 (2014) A30 [1309.0382].
- [65]S. K. Choi, M. Hasselfield, S.-P. Ho, B. Koopman, M. Lungu, M. H. Abitbol et al., The Atacama Cosmology Telescope: a measurement of the Cosmic Microwave Background power spectra at 98 and 150 GHz, JCAP 2020 (2020) 045 [2007.07289].
- [66]G. E. Addison, J. Dunkley and D. N. Spergel, Modelling the correlation between the thermal Sunyaev Zel’dovich effect and the cosmic infrared background, MNRAS 427 (2012) 1741 [1204.5927].DOI
- [67]J. Dunkley, R. Hlozek, J. Sievers, V. Acquaviva, P. A. R. Ade, P. Aguirre et al., The Atacama Cosmology Telescope: Cosmological Parameters from the 2008 Power Spectrum, ApJ 739 (2011) 52 [1009.0866].DOI
- [68]Planck Collaboration, Y. Akrami, M. Ashdown, J. Aumont, C. Baccigalupi, M. Ballardini et al., Planck 2018 results. XI. Polarized dust foregrounds, A&A 641 (2020) A11 [1801.04945].
- [69]Planck Collaboration, Y. Akrami, M. Ashdown, J. Aumont, C. Baccigalupi, M. Ballardini et al., Planck 2018 results. IV. Diffuse component separation, A&A 641 (2020) A4 [1807.06208].
- [70]J. Chluba, D. Paoletti, F. Finelli and J.-A. Rubino-Martin, Effect of primordial magnetic fields on the ionization history, ArXiv:1503.04827 (2015) [1503.04827].arxiv.org/abs/1503.04827
- [71]K. L. Greene and F.-Y. Cyr-Racine, Thomson scattering: one rate to rule them all, JCAP 2023 (2023) 065 [2306.06165].DOI
- [72]C. R. Harris, K. J. Millman, S. J. van der Walt, R. Gommers, P. Virtanen, D. Cournapeau et al., Array programming with NumPy, Nature 585 (2020) 357 [2006.10256].











