betaFeedback

WorksPhysics and Astronomy

The Akhmediev breather for the Dysthe equation and the unstable manifold of the Stokes wave

Abstract

In this article we define and compute the breather of the Dysthe equation for deep water waves, the analogue of the Akhmediev breather of the nonlinear Schrödinger equation (NLS). When a single pair of modes is unstable, the unstable manifold of the Stokes wave consists of the Stokes wave and the translates and time shifts of a single solution, the breather. The construction uses only gauge and translation invariance, not integrability or a Hamiltonian structure. We use the parameterisation method to find the breather as a power series whose coefficients follow recursively from linear equations. This is not an asymptotic expansion: the series is the Taylor series of the breather itself. For deep water waves we map the envelope amplification over steepness and group length and give a simple formula, based on the linear stability analysis, that summarises it to within a few per cent. Our results agree well with Euler simulations: the edge of the instability band of the Dysthe equation lies much closer to the onset of growth than that of the NLS, and, away from the onset and below breaking, the crest and height amplifications lie less than 5% below the Euler ones.

Introduction

A uniform train of waves on deep water, a Stokes wave, is unstable. Small modulations of its amplitude grow at the expense of the carrier wave, and the train breaks up into groups. This is the Benjamin–Feir, or modulational, instability [6, 29]. In the nonlinear Schrödinger equation (NLS) the whole process, from a small modulation to the largest wave and back to the uniform train, is described exactly by the Akhmediev breather [3, 2]. Out of an orderly wave train, a breather produces a wave much larger than the waves around it, and for this reason breathers are regarded as prototypes of freak waves. They have also been observed in wave tanks [11, 10].

The NLS is, however, only the leading-order model, and at the steepness of real wave groups breathers depart from it. In the experiments of Shemer & Alperovich [24] the spectrum of the Peregrine breather widened asymmetrically, which the NLS cannot reproduce, and the measurements agreed instead with the Dysthe equation. Slunyaev & Shrir[a] [25] followed breathers in simulations of the Euler equations and found that the NLS describes them only qualitatively: some modulations that it predicts to grow do not grow at all, and the crests grow higher than its envelope. The next model in the hierarchy is the equation of Dysthe [14], which keeps the terms of the next order in the steepness, among them the mean flow induced by the wave group, and Trulsen et al. [28] improved it further with the exact linear dispersion. These models are not integrable, and they do not share the reflection symmetry X↦−XX \mapsto-X of the NLS.

Here is where the difficulty begins. Without integrability there is no formula for the breather, and it is not even clear what the breather of the Dysthe equation is. In practice it is computed by perturbing the Stokes wave along its unstable mode, with a small amplitude, and integrating the equations forward in time, as Slunyaev & Shrira [25] did for the Euler equations. Such initial data lie close to the breather, but not on it. Already for the NLS they lead to periodic orbits that approach the breather only as the perturbation tends to zero, and data on the two sides of the breather evolve differently [1, 8]. The outcome therefore depends on how the computation is started, and the error grows with the size of the initial perturbation (Figure 2).

The series and the continuation for the Dysthe equation

Figure 2. The series and the continuation, for the Dysthe equation with the exact dispersion at ε=0.1\varepsilon= 0.1 and k1=1.3k_1 = 1.3 (Nw=5.4N_{\mathrm{w}} = 5.4), N=32N = 32. (a) ∣u∣|u| from the series alone, with J=240J = 240 terms, up to the instant where it has converged to 10−810^{-8} (white line), and the integrated breather beyond it (grey mesh), over one modulation period centred on the peak. (b) max⁡X∣u∣\max_X |u| of the partial sums with J=1J = 1 (dashed), 4 (dotted), 16 (dash-dotted) and 240 (solid), against the breather (thick grey line); the shaded region, beyond the vertical line, lies outside the disc of convergence, ∣ξ∣>ϱ|\xi| > \varrho. (c) Integrations started at δ0=0.2\delta_0 = 0.2 (vertical line) from the series (circles), from the unstable eigenvector (squares) and from equal sidebands (diamonds), against the breather (thick grey line). (d) The error of the computed peak against the amplitude δ0\delta_0 of the start, for the same starts; the thin line has slope 2.

In this paper we take a different route, and the paper has two main parts. The first part is mathematical. We define the breather through the unstable manifold of the Stokes wave, that is, the set of solutions that converge to the Stokes wave exponentially fast as time tends to −∞-\infty. It turns out that two symmetries are enough to describe this manifold completely: the gauge invariance, which turns the Stokes wave into a fixed point in a rotating frame, and the invariance under translations along the wave train. Whenever a single pair of eigenvalues is unstable, the unstable manifold is a surface made of the Stokes wave and of the translates and time shifts of a single solution, which we call the breather. The breather is therefore unique, and its peak is a property of the model and of its parameters, not of an initial condition.

We show this for the Galerkin truncations of the models, and find numerically that their breathers converge as the truncation is increased. Nothing else is needed: integrability, a Hamiltonian structure, the reflection symmetry and time reversibility play no part. For the NLS the breather is the Akhmediev breather, in agreement with the integrable theory [1] (Li & McLaughlin 1994).

To compute the breather we adapt the parameterisation method [7, 17, 23] to our setting. The Stokes wave is not a hyperbolic fixed point, but it has a single positive, unstable eigenvalue λ1\lambda_1, which is what the method needs, and the translations reduce the computation to a single real variable, ξ=eλ1τ\xi= e^{\lambda_1 \tau}. The breather becomes a power series in ξ\xi whose coefficients are vectors of Fourier amplitudes. They are found recursively, to any order, from linear systems that can always be solved.

We stress that this is not an asymptotic expansion, which would merely approximate the breather. For the NLS the series converges, it is the Taylor series of the breather itself, and inside its disc of convergence it is the breather. We find this disc exactly: its boundary passes through the peak of the Akhmediev breather, so the series describes the whole growth of the wave up to its peak. For the Dysthe equations the series converges for every truncation of the model; whether it converges for the full equations is an open question, but we expect it to. To go beyond the disc we integrate the equations from a point inside it, which lies on the unstable manifold and not merely close to it. Against the Akhmediev breather, the computed peak is correct to 2×10−82 \times10^{-8}. The leading coefficients of the series also give, in every model, the instability cascade that Chin et al. [12] described for the NLS.

The second part of the paper is about deep water waves. We take the Dysthe equation with the exact dispersion as our model and compute the peak PP of its breather, the largest value of the envelope, over the whole instability band and for steepness up to 0.120.12. Since this breather need not return to the Stokes wave, we define its first peak through the exchange of wave action between the carrier and the sidebands. The resulting map is our main physical result. It shows that PP lies below the value of the NLS over most of the band, and rises above it only for the longest groups of the steepest wave trains. The map is summarised, to within 3%3\% for steepness up to 0.10.1, by the formula of the Akhmediev breather, 1+2sin⁡θ11 + 2 \sin\theta_1, evaluated with the angle θ1\theta_1 of the unstable eigenvector of the Dysthe equation. The formula needs only the linear stability of the Stokes wave, so it is easy to use, but the fact that it holds is a result of the nonlinear computations. From the envelope we also reconstruct the free surface. The highest crest is that of a local Stokes wave of amplitude PP, with no fitted constants, while the wave height amplification stays below PP.

Finally, we compare our breathers with the Euler simulations of Slunyaev & Shrira [25]. The edge of the instability band of the Dysthe equation lies much closer to the onset of growth in the Euler equations than that of the NLS. For groups of six or more waves, once the crests have grown well above the background and until they approach breaking, our crest and height amplifications lie less than 5% below theirs. Slunyaev & Shrira [25] described these features by fitting the NLS; here they follow from the Dysthe equation with no fitted constants.

This paper is organised as follows. In § 2 we present the envelope models, the reconstruction of the free surface and the models in Fourier space. In § 3 we study the linear stability of the Stokes wave, describe its unstable manifold and the breather, and define its first peak. In § 4 we construct the breather as a power series, find its radius of convergence for the NLS and continue it beyond. In § 5 we discuss the consequences for trains of deep water waves: the breathers of the four models, the map of PP and its linear summary, the crest and height amplifications, and the comparison with the Euler equations. Finally, § 6 summarises our results. Appendix § 7 gives the numerical details, appendix § 8 the first orders of the recursion, and appendix § 9 the Akhmediev breather and its Fourier modes in our variables.

Trains of deep water waves

We consider unidirectional, long-crested trains of deep-water waves represented as a carrier wave modulated by a slowly varying envelope BB which depends on a single horizontal coordinate xx. The carrier has a wavenumber k0k_0 and an amplitude a0a_0, so it has frequency ω0=gk0\omega_0 = \sqrt{g k_0} and steepness ε=k0a0\varepsilon= k_0 a_0. To leading order the free surface elevation is

η(x,t)=Re⁡[Bei(k0x−ω0t)],(1)\eta(x,t) = \operatorname{Re}\left[B e^{i(k_0x-\omega_0t)}\right], \tag*{(1)}

and we work throughout with

u=B‾a0,X=2 εk0(x−cgt),τ=12ε2ω0t,cg=ω02k0,(2)u = \frac{\overline{B}}{a_0}, \qquad X = \sqrt{2}\,\varepsilon k_0(x-c_g t), \qquad\tau= \frac{1}{2}\varepsilon^2\omega_0 t, \qquad c_g = \frac{\omega_0}{2k_0}, \tag*{(2)}

so that a uniform wave train has ∣u∣=1|u| = 1 and τ\tau runs forward in physical time.

The conjugation in (2) gives the forward time orientation, but it also makes the nnth Fourier mode of uu, denoted by nKnK, correspond to the surface wavenumber k0−nKk_0 - nK, so positive nn is the lower sideband of the carrier k0k_0.

All envelopes under consideration are periodic in XX and so each of them has a discrete Fourier spectrum defined by a modulation wavenumber, which is denoted by KK in physical units and k1k_1 in the dimensionless ones. They are related through

Kk0=2 εk1.(3)\frac{K}{k_0} = \sqrt{2}\,\varepsilon k_1. \tag*{(3)}

The corresponding period of the envelope is therefore 2π/k12\pi/k_1.

It is often clearer to use, instead of KK, the number of carrier waves per modulation, Nw=k0/KN_{\mathrm{w}} = k_0/K. The wave dynamics depend on two parameters only: the wave steepness ε\varepsilon, and either k1k_1 or NwN_{\mathrm{w}}.

Envelope models for deep water

All four models used here are of the form

i ∂τu=Ω(−i∂X)u−F(u),F(u)=u(1−s∣∂X∣)∣u∣2+γ∣u∣4u−ic(p∣u∣2uX+qu2u‾X),(4)i\,\partial_\tau u = \Omega(-i\partial_X)u - F(u), \qquad F(u) = u\left(1-s|\partial_X|\right)|u|^2 + \gamma|u|^4u - ic\left(p|u|^2u_X + q u^2\overline{u}_X\right), \tag*{(4)}

with Ω\Omega a real Fourier multiplier and ∣∂X∣|\partial_X| the multiplier ∣k∣|k|. The coefficients are collected in Table 1.

modelΩ(k)\Omega(k)ssγ\gammaccppqqorder
NLSk2/2k^2/2000000——O(ε3)O(\varepsilon^3)
Stokes-correctedk2/2k^2/200ε2\varepsilon^200——O(ε3)+O(ε5)O(\varepsilon^3)+O(\varepsilon^5)
Dysthek2/2+(2ε/4)k3k^2/2+(\sqrt{2}\varepsilon/4)k^32ε\sqrt{2}\varepsilon00−2ε-\sqrt{2}\varepsilon331/21/2O(ε4)O(\varepsilon^4)
Dysthe, exact dispersioneq. (5)2ε\sqrt{2}\varepsilon00−2ε-\sqrt{2}\varepsilon331/21/2O(ε4)O(\varepsilon^4)

Table 1. The models of section 2.1 as coefficient sets of (4), in the variables (2) where the background is ∣u∣=1|u|=1 and τ\tau runs forward. The Dysthe equation with the exact dispersion keeps only the modes n<Nwn<N_{\mathrm{w}}, whose surface wavenumber k0−nKk_0-nK is positive. All are written for the surface-elevation envelope; the velocity-potential and Zakharov conventions differ in qq, taking −1/2-1/2 and 00, and each carries its own reconstruction of the free surface. The last column is the order in steepness to which the model is derived, not the order of the terms it retains: the Stokes-corrected equation keeps one term of O(ε5)O(\varepsilon^5) while omitting those of O(ε4)O(\varepsilon^4).

Within the class of models in (4) we have:

The NLS: This model corresponds to setting s=c=γ=0s=c=\gamma=0 and Ω=k2/2\Omega= k^2/2. It is the leading-order, narrow-band, envelope equation for deep water wave trains (see [29, 26]). The model is of order O(ε3)O(\varepsilon^3), has a Hamiltonian structure and is integrable.

The Stokes-corrected NLS: This model adds the quintic term γ=ε2\gamma=\varepsilon^2, which reproduces the fifth-order frequency correction ω=ω0(1+12ε2+12ε4)\omega=\omega_0(1+\frac{1}{2}\varepsilon^2+\frac{1}{2}\varepsilon^4) of a Stokes wave [15]. It is not a consistent deep-water model, since it keeps a term of O(ε5)O(\varepsilon^5) while discarding those of O(ε4)O(\varepsilon^4). However, it is the simplest non-integrable model of the class that keeps the reflection symmetry of the NLS; whenever u(X,τ)u(X,\tau) is a solution, so is u(−X,τ)u(-X,\tau). In (4) this symmetry holds when c=0c=0 and Ω\Omega is even.

References

  1. [1]Ablowitz, Mark J. & Herbst, B. M. 1990 On homoclinic structure and numerically induced chaos for the nonlinear Schrödinger equation. SIAM Journal on Applied Mathematics 50 (2), 339–351.
  2. [2]Akhmediev, N. N., Eleonskii, V. M. & Kulagin, N. E. 1987 Exact first-order solutions of the nonlinear Schrödinger equation. Theoretical and Mathematical Physics 72 (2), 809–818.
  3. [3]Akhmediev, N. N. & Korneev, V. I. 1986 Modulation instability and periodic solutions of the nonlinear Schrödinger equation. Theoretical and Mathematical Physics 69 (2), 1089–1093.
  4. [4]Andrade, David & Stuhlmeier, Raphael 2023 The nonlinear Benjamin–Feir instability – Hamiltonian dynamics, discrete breathers and steady solutions. Journal of Fluid Mechanics 958, A17.DOI
  5. [5]Banner, Michael L. & Tian, Xin 1998 On the determination of the onset of breaking for modulating surface gravity water waves. Journal of Fluid Mechanics 367, 107–137.
  6. [6]Benjamin, T. Brooke & Feir, J. E. 1967 The disintegration of wave trains on deep water Part 1. Theory. Journal of Fluid Mechanics 27 (3), 417–430.
  7. [7]Cabré, Xavier, Fontich, Ernest & de la Llave, Rafael 2003 The parameterization method for invariant manifolds I: Manifolds associated to non-resonant subspaces. Indiana University Mathematics Journal 52 (2), 283–328.DOI
  8. [8]Calini, A., Ercolani, N. M., McLaughlin, D. W. & Schober, C. M. 1996 Mel’nikov analysis of numerically induced chaos in the nonlinear Schrödinger equation. Physica D 89 (3–4), 227–260.DOI
  9. [9]Calini, A. & Schober, C. M. 2002 Homoclinic chaos increases the likelihood of rogue wave formation. Physics Letters A 298, 335–349.DOI
  10. [10]Chabchoub, A., Hoffmann, N., Onorato, M. & Akhmediev, N. 2012 Super rogue waves: Observation of a higher-order breather in water waves. Physical Review X 2 (1), 011015.DOI
  11. [11]Chabchoub, A., Hoffmann, N. P. & Akhmediev, N. 2011 Rogue wave observation in a water wave tank. Physical Review Letters 106 (20), 204502.
  12. [12]Chin, Siu A., Ashour, Omar A. & Belić, Milivoj R. 2015 Anatomy of the Akhmediev breather: Cascading instability, first formation time, and Fermi-Pasta-Ulam recurrence. Physical Review E 92 (6), 063202.DOI
  13. [13]Dyachenko, A. I. & Zakharov, V. E. 2011 Compact equation for gravity waves on deep water. JETP Letters 93 (12), 701–705.
  14. [14]Dysthe, K. B. 1979 Note on a modification to the nonlinear Schrödinger equation for application to deep water waves. Proceedings of the Royal Society of London A 369, 105–114.DOI
  15. [15]Fenton, John D. 1985 A fifth-order Stokes theory for steady waves. Journal of Waterway, Port, Coastal, and Ocean Engineering 111 (2), 216–234.
  16. [16]Gramstad, Odin & Trulsen, Karsten 2011 Hamiltonian form of the modified nonlinear Schrödinger equation for gravity waves on arbitrary depth. Journal of Fluid Mechanics 670, 404–426.DOI
  17. [17]Haro, Àlex, Canadell, Marta, Figueras, Jordi-Lluís, Luque, Alejandro & Mondelo, Josep Maria 2016 The Parameterization Method for Invariant Manifolds, Applied Mathematical Sciences, vol. 195. Springer International Publishing.
  18. [18]Holthuijsen, L. H. 2007 Waves in Oceanic and Coastal Waters. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
  19. [21]Li, Y. Charles 2004 Chaos in Partial Differential Equations, Graduate Series in Analysis, vol. 2. International Press, also arXiv:0909.0910.
  20. [22]Mei, Chiang C., Stiassnie, Michael & Yue, Dick K.-P. 2005 Theory and Applications of Ocean Surface Waves. Part 2: Nonlinear Aspects, Advanced Series on Ocean Engineering, vol. 23. Singapore: World Scientific.
  21. [23]Reinhardt, Christian & Mireles James, J. D. 2019 Fourier–Taylor parameterization of unstable manifolds for parabolic partial differential equations: Formalism, implementation and rigorous validation. Indagationes Mathematicae 30 (1), 39–80.
  22. [24]Shemer, L. & Alperovich, L. 2013 Peregrine breather revisited. Physics of Fluids 25 (5), 051701.DOI
  23. [25]Slunyaev, Alexey V. & Shrira, Victor I. 2013 On the highest non-breaking wave in a group: fully nonlinear water wave breathers versus weakly nonlinear theory. Journal of Fluid Mechanics 735, 203–248.DOI
  24. [26]Stiassnie, Michael 1984 Note on the modified nonlinear Schrödinger equation for deep water waves. Wave Motion 6 (4), 431–433.DOI
  25. [27]TRILLO, S. & WARNITZ, S. 1991 Dynamics of the nonlinear modulational instability in optical fibers. Optics Letters 16 (13), 986.
  26. [28]TRULSEN, K., KLIAKHANDLER, I., DYSTHE, K. B. & VELARDE, M. G. 2000 On weakly nonlinear modulation of waves on deep water. Physics of Fluids 12, 2432–2437.
  27. [29]ZAKHAROV, V. E. 1968 Stability of periodic waves of finite amplitude on the surface of a deep fluid. Journal of Applied Mechanics and Technical Physics 9 (2), 190–194.DOI

Paper details

vlnc:W_kn7rkj7m
Version
v1 · latest
Published
Fresh — added to the Hub within the last 30 days
Added
License
CC BY 4.0
Usage

views · 0

downloads · 0

A view counts once per browser per day, a download each time the PDF is requested.

  • Physics and Astronomy

Claude

View statement
Looking for related papers…
Contents