WorksPhysics and Astronomy
Torsional Hall Viscosity of Massive Chern Insulators: Finite Temperature and Chemical Potential
Abstract
We study the torsional Hall viscosity of Chern insulators at finite temperature and chemical potential. Our analysis considers the massive Dirac fermion and two deformations: a constant out-of-plane magnetic field and a momentum-dependent mass described by the single-block Bernevig-Hughes-Zhang (BHZ) Hamiltonian. For the massive Dirac theory, we show that temperature and chemical potential lead to UV-finite corrections and that a chemical potential outside the bulk gap modifies even at zero temperature. In a constant magnetic field, the response of massive Dirac fermions is dictated by the relativistic Landau-level spectrum, leading to a plateau structure at zero temperature that is smoothed at finite temperature. The jumps are proportional to the Dirac mass and inversely proportional to the squared magnetic length and the newly occupied Landau-level energy. Finally, we present a detailed study of the correction to in the single-block BHZ continuum model due to temperature and chemical potential. For parameters relevant to (Hg,Mn)Te quantum wells, the magnitude of the jump across a mass domain wall retains its vacuum enhancement due to the BHZ deformation as long as the chemical potential lies sufficiently deep inside the gap compared with the thermal energy. Our results extend the theory of torsional Hall viscosity to experimentally relevant conditions and may facilitate its future detection.
Introduction
Hall viscosity is a nondissipative transport coefficient characterizing the transverse response of momentum to geometric deformations in systems with broken parity or time-reversal symmetry [1, 2]. In two-dimensional gapped systems, particularly quantum Hall states, it provides a geometric probe with connections to orbital spin and electromagnetic response [3, 4, 5, 6, 7]. For relativistic fermions, geometric deformations can be described by coupling the theory to a background geometry with torsion, and the corresponding parity-odd response defines the torsional Hall viscosity [8, 9, 10]. This description is particularly natural in crystalline systems, where torsion is associated with lattice dislocations [11, 12]. Torsional geometry has been further developed as a framework for studying topological phases, quantum anomalies, and the thermal Hall response [13, 14, 15, 16, 17, 18].
The massive Dirac fermion provides the simplest continuum model in which the torsional Hall viscosity can be studied analytically. Its absolute bulk value contains an ultraviolet-sensitive contribution, whereas differences between distinct gapped phases, in particular the jump across a mass domain wall, are well defined once a common renormalization prescription is chosen [8, 9, 10]. However, the relativistic Dirac model provides only a simplified description of the electronic structure of realistic topological materials. A natural extension is provided by the Bernevig–Hughes–Zhang (BHZ) Hamiltonian, originally introduced to describe HgTe quantum wells [19]. The full BHZ Hamiltonian consists of two blocks related by time reversal and describes the quantum spin Hall phase, which was subsequently observed experimentally in HgTe/(Hg,Cd)Te quantum wells [20]. Closely related BHZ-type effective Hamiltonians also describe inverted InAs/GaSb quantum wells [21, 22] and arise in ultrathin films of three-dimensional topological insulators such as BiSe, where the low-energy theory contains massive Dirac fermions with quadratic momentum-dependent mass terms [23, 24]. These systems provide experimentally accessible settings in which the simple Dirac description is replaced by a momentum-dependent band structure.
For the Hall-type response considered here, time-reversal symmetry must be broken. It is therefore natural to focus on a single block of the BHZ Hamiltonian, which by itself describes a massive Chern insulator. A physical motivation for this reduction is provided by magnetically doped HgTe quantum wells. In (Hg,Mn)Te systems, exchange coupling to polarized Mn moments breaks time-reversal symmetry and modifies the two BHZ sectors differently, leading to quantum anomalous Hall (QAH) physics, with a weak magnetic field applied to induce the Mn polarization [25, 26, 27]. Such quantum wells and related topological insulators have been realized experimentally, and their topological transport properties have been studied in detail [27, 28, 29]. The single-block BHZ Hamiltonian therefore provides a simple effective description of the parity-odd sector relevant for the torsional response of a topological quantum well with broken time-reversal symmetry.
Motivated by this connection, in Ref. [30] we extended the torsional Hall viscosity of the massive Dirac fermion in two directions. We first considered a constant electromagnetic field and obtained the response nonperturbatively in the field strength. We then studied the quadratic momentum-dependent mass that appears in a single block of the BHZ Hamiltonian. Although this deformation does not alter the low-energy Dirac structure, it substantially modifies the torsional response. In particular, for parameters relevant to (Hg,Mn)Te quantum wells, the torsional Hall viscosity jump across a mass domain wall was found to be enhanced relative to the free massive Dirac result. This enhancement makes the momentum-dependent model particularly interesting from an experimental point of view.
The analysis of Ref. [30], however, was restricted to zero temperature and zero chemical potential. These assumptions are natural for isolating the ground-state response but are idealizations from the perspective of experiment. Measurements are necessarily performed at finite temperature, while the chemical potential in semiconductor quantum wells and thin films can be varied through doping or electrostatic gating. The occupation of the states contributing to the response therefore changes with both and , especially when the chemical potential approaches a bulk band edge or crosses a Landau level. Extending the calculation to finite temperature and chemical potential is thus an important step toward determining whether the vacuum torsional Hall viscosity, and in particular the enhanced response found for the single-block BHZ model, can persist under experimentally accessible conditions.
In this work, we carry out this extension for the free massive Dirac fermion, for the Dirac fermion in a constant magnetic field, and for the single-block BHZ deformation. For the free Dirac theory, the finite- and finite- contribution is ultraviolet finite and can be separated from the renormalized vacuum response. At zero temperature, the response remains unchanged as long as the chemical potential lies inside the bulk gap, while finite temperature smoothens the sharp onset associated with crossing a band edge. In a constant magnetic field, the thermal correction can be expressed in terms of the Fermi–Dirac occupation of the relativistic Landau levels. The zeroth Landau level gives an additional orientation-sensitive contribution at finite chemical potential, while tuning through the higher Landau levels produces a sequence of nonquantized steps in that are rounded at finite temperature.
We finally consider the single-block BHZ model at finite temperature and chemical potential. We derive an ultraviolet-finite expression for the thermal correction and obtain analytic descriptions both away from and near the band edge. A central quantity in our analysis is the torsional Hall viscosity jump across a mass domain wall. When the chemical potential lies sufficiently deep inside the bulk gap, the enhanced vacuum response of Ref. [30] is stable up to exponentially suppressed thermal corrections. As the chemical potential approaches the band edge, thermal and finite-density effects increasingly modify the response. Using parameters relevant to (Hg,Mn)Te quantum wells, we determine the regime in which the zero-temperature prediction remains a good approximation. Therefore, the finite- and finite- analysis brings the theoretical torsional response closer to the conditions under which it may be tested experimentally in the future.
The paper is organized as follows. In § 2, we review the zero-temperature torsional Hall viscosity and summarize the magnetic-field and single-block BHZ results of Ref. [30]. In § 3, we derive the response of the massive Dirac fermion at finite temperature and chemical potential. In § 3.1, we consider a constant magnetic field and express the response in terms of the Landau-level spectrum. In § 6, we study the BHZ deformation and the finite-temperature domain-wall response. We conclude in Sec. VI with a discussion of the implications for torsional transport in Chern insulators and its possible experimental observation.
Brief Review of the Vacuum Results
In this section, we summarize the zero-temperature and zero-chemical-potential results that will serve as the starting point for the thermal analysis below. We first recall the coupling between Dirac fermions and torsion and the corresponding definition of the torsional Hall viscosity. We then review the vacuum results for the free massive Dirac fermion, the constant magnetic field deformation, and the BHZ deformation. Throughout this section we work in units unless stated otherwise.
Torsional Hall viscosity and the effective action
We consider a massive Dirac fermion in dimensions coupled to a background dreibein and an independent, metric-compatible spin connection . The Lorentzian action is
where . In terms of the coframe , the torsion 2-form is
The spin connection can be decomposed as
where is the Levi-Civita spin connection and is the contorsion 1-form. Since , one equivalently has
Decomposing the fermion action in terms of the contorsion shows that a Dirac fermion couples only to its completely antisymmetric part. In dimensions this coupling can be expressed through the torsion pseudoscalar
and hence the part of the fermion action linear in torsion is
Integrating out the fermion generates the parity-odd torsional term
where we used (4) in the second equality. The coefficient defines the torsional Hall viscosity.4
More generally, if the torsion-dependent fermion action takes the form
then the contribution linear in gives
Here the trace is over spinor indices and is the torsion-free fermion propagator, which may include external fields or higher-derivative deformations such as the magnetic-field and single-block BHZ deformations considered below. For the minimally coupled Dirac theory in Eq. (1), the torsion vertex is .
Eq. (9) reduces the calculation of to a one-loop tadpole. Its coincidence limit is generally UV divergent and must be regularized and renormalized. Consequently, the absolute bulk value of can contain scheme-dependent contributions from local counterterms. The difference in between phases, and in particular the jump across a domain wall, is a universal observable in the sense that it is insensitive to common phase-independent finite counterterms after the torsion coupling and vacuum subtraction prescription have been fixed [8, 9, 10, 30].
Massive Dirac vacuum
In flat Euclidean space, the propagator of the massive Dirac fermion reads
Only the mass term survives the spinor trace in Eq. (9). The vacuum torsional Hall viscosity can therefore be written as5
After regularization, the tadpole contains a linear UV divergence together with a finite parity-odd contribution. In the convention used in Ref. [30], its regulated form is
The linearly divergent term is removed by a local counterterm. The counterterm also fixes which side of the mass transition is identified as the trivial phase. Choosing the phase to be trivial gives
A symmetric prescription instead assigns equal and opposite bulk values to the two signs of . These prescriptions differ only by a local, phase-independent finite counterterm and therefore predict the same jump across a mass domain wall.
For a domain wall separating the phases with and , we define the universal jump by
Once the subtraction convention is fixed, the sign of encodes the direction of the interfacial torsional response. Note that unlike dissipative bulk and shear viscosities, Hall viscosity is nondissipative and is not constrained to be positive; its sign determines the direction of the transverse momentum response relative to the applied strain.
Constant magnetic field
We next recall the vacuum result in the presence of a constant magnetic field perpendicular to the two-dimensional system. Introducing the covariant Dirac operator
the torsional Hall viscosity is determined by the heat kernel of
At , the contribution proportional to the Dirac operator vanishes after the symmetric frequency integral, and hence the vacuum torsional Hall viscosity is determined entirely by the mass term. The trace of the coincident heat kernel is
where
After -function regularization, one obtains the exact result
Here denotes the Hurwitz zeta function. Eq. (19) is nonperturbative in the ratio and resums the weak-field expansion to all orders. Restoring and , it is useful to introduce the magnetic field scale
Here denotes the gap parameter in energy units. The exact result can then be written as
The -function-regularized result in Eq. (21) has several notable properties. First, it is odd under and even under . The even dependence on follows from gauge and Lorentz invariance, which allow the magnetic field to enter through . Second, within this prescription, the magnitude of the response decreases with increasing up to , where the response vanishes and then changes sign.
Eq. (19) uses the symmetric -function prescription, for which the limit is . To recover the convention of Eq. (13), one adds the finite counterterm . Since this counterterm is independent of , , and , it does not affect the change induced by the magnetic field or the thermal and chemical potential corrections.
One can also derive the torsional Hall response in a constant electric field, which contains nonperturbative contributions associated with Schwinger pair production and acquires a nonzero imaginary part, reflecting the instability of the driven vacuum [30]. Since a constant electric field does not define thermal equilibrium in the absence of energy relaxation, we restrict our attention here to equilibrium backgrounds and omit the electric field analysis.
BHZ deformation
The second deformation considered in this work is the momentum-dependent mass appearing in a single spin block of the BHZ model. Its Hamiltonian is
where . The corresponding spectrum is
The parameter controls the momentum-dependent hybridization between the electron-like and hole-like sectors and sets the characteristic Dirac velocity. The parameter controls the quadratic band curvature and is related to an effective Newtonian mass through in units with . Except when restoring physical units, we set below. The corresponding continuum Lagrangian is
The higher-derivative term proportional to breaks Lorentz symmetry down to spatial rotations. Although it is an irrelevant operator in the infrared, it is a dangerously irrelevant operator since it controls the large-momentum behavior of the tadpole. We treat as a spurion and adopt the minimal geometric coupling in which torsion continues to enter only through the Dirac operator. The torsion vertex therefore remains .
With , the bare vacuum torsional Hall viscosity is
In contrast to the free massive Dirac theory, the BHZ tadpole contains quadratic and logarithmic UV divergences. This occurs since the momentum-dependent effective mass , rather than the Dirac mass , controls the large-momentum behavior. Consequently, the limits and do not commute. A consistent renormalization must remove the quadratic and logarithmic divergences associated with the -dominated UV behavior. Recovering the Dirac result as requires an additional renormalization prescription, as described in Ref. [30], rather than simply taking the limit of the fixed- result.
Using the Pauli–Villars prescription, the renormalized bulk result can be written compactly as follows [30]:
For fixed , changing the sign of takes the system between two distinct band phases. Unlike in a commonly used renormalization of the pure Dirac theory, however, the renormalized torsional Hall viscosity does not vanish in either phase. Moreover, its absolute bulk value depends on the finite part of the renormalization prescription. The condition therefore cannot by itself determine whether a phase is topologically nontrivial. The topological assignment is instead fixed by the topology of the occupied band, as reflected in the single-block BHZ Hall conductivity [24, 31, 32],
It follows that the phases with are topologically nontrivial, whereas those with are topologically trivial. This classification is consistent with a common renormalization of the parity-odd gauge and torsional responses. Although finite local counterterms affect the absolute bulk value of , they do not change the band topology. Common phase-independent counterterms also leave the domain-wall jump unchanged.
Consider an interface at which remains fixed while the Dirac mass changes sign. Using the same subtraction convention as in the Dirac theory, we define the corresponding vacuum jump by
It is convenient to normalize it by the pure Dirac jump in Eq. (14),
Thus, the BHZ band curvature enhances the universal interface response relative to the relativistic Dirac limit in magnitude, but reverses the sign. For a set of parameters appropriate for a (Hg,Mn)Te quantum well, meV, meV nm and meV nm, one finds
Thus, the magnitude of the torsional Hall viscosity jump is enhanced by a factor 4.30, while its sign is reversed relative to the Dirac limit. The finite-temperature BHZ analysis in § 6 will determine how this vacuum enhancement is modified by thermal occupation and by tuning the chemical potential through the bulk band edge. The results reviewed above provide the three vacuum limits against which the thermal calculations will be checked: the free massive Dirac response, the nonperturbative magnetic-field response, and the universal BHZ domain-wall response. Since finite temperature and chemical potential do not alter the short-distance structure of the theory, the same vacuum counterterms will apply below. Consequently, the corrections due to temperature and chemical potential can be isolated by subtracting the vacuum results, and the resulting differences are UV finite.
Torsional Hall Viscosity at Finite Temperature and Chemical Potential
In this section, we extend our results for the torsional Hall viscosity to finite temperature and chemical potential, in view of applying them to more realistic experimental setups. We begin by explaining how the formalism of § 2 must be modified to include finite-temperature and finite-chemical-potential effects.
Recall that we work in Euclidean signature. We can therefore place the system at a finite temperature by compactifying the Euclidean time direction into a circle with period . In every case considered here, the coordinate is a cyclic coordinate and can be identified with the Wick-rotated time coordinate. The fermion fields obey antiperiodic boundary conditions around the thermal circle. We can thus translate the vacuum results to finite temperature by replacing the integral over the momentum in the direction with a sum over the fermionic Matsubara frequencies
More precisely, we make the substitution
We can further introduce a nonzero chemical potential by treating as a Lagrange multiplier that fixes the average charge of the system. Practically, this amounts to shifting the Matsubara frequencies according to
The final expressions in this section are even in , as required by particle-hole symmetry. At , thermally excited particles and holes can produce a nonzero thermal correction even though their net charge density vanishes.
Let us first apply this prescription to the simplest case, namely a free massive Dirac fermion with Lagrangian given by Eq. (1). For the vacuum torsional Hall viscosity , Eq. (9) gives
where denotes the squared momentum in the spatial plane, while is the momentum along the Wick-rotated time direction. The overall normalization in Eq. (34) includes the trace over the two-component spinor indices and is fixed by matching the vacuum result reviewed in § 2.
An expression for at finite temperature and chemical potential can now be read off directly from Eq. (34):
where in the second equality we introduced polar coordinates in the spatial plane and defined .
The resulting integral is logarithmically divergent in spatial momentum and must be regularized. Introducing a spatial momentum cutoff , we find
The sum over Matsubara frequencies can be evaluated in closed form, as shown in Appendix A. Taking gives
The linear divergence in Eq. (37) is independent of temperature and chemical potential, and hence the same vacuum counterterms apply.6 Denoting the finite counterterm fixed by the vacuum prescription of § 2 by , the renormalized response can be written as
At zero chemical potential, this reduces to
The corresponding renormalized vacuum response is
Later on, the superscript “ren” will be suppressed when there is no ambiguity. The correction due to temperature and chemical potential is the difference between these responses, in which the common counterterm cancels:
The full response therefore separates into its vacuum value and a UV-finite correction,
Therefore, the correction is [14]
This form makes explicit that the thermal and chemical-potential correction is UV finite.
Using the vacuum renormalization prescription introduced in § 2,
the fully renormalized result becomes
The first term is the finite counterterm fixed by the vacuum renormalization condition and is independent of temperature and chemical potential.
We can use Eq. (45) to recover the zero-temperature result and extend it to nonzero chemical potential. In the limit , we have
and hence
When the chemical potential lies inside the bulk gap, , we recover the vacuum result:
Thus, at zero temperature the torsional Hall viscosity is exactly independent of the chemical potential as long as the Fermi level remains inside the gap. In terms of the finite correction,
Once , a Fermi surface appears and the occupation of bulk states modifies the torsional Hall response. This should not be interpreted as a change in the topology of the underlying Dirac bands. In this regime, the system is no longer insulating, and the response acquires a finite-density contribution from the occupied bulk states.
Magnetic field deformation
At finite temperature, the sharp zero-temperature threshold is thermally rounded. When the chemical potential lies well inside the gap, , the leading correction is exponentially suppressed:
The vacuum response is therefore exponentially stable at low temperature, with the activation scale determined by the distance between the chemical potential and the nearest band edge.
In the present section, we extend the analysis of § 3 by including an external constant magnetic field , alongside temperature and chemical potential, to establish how the torsional Hall viscosity is affected.
At zero magnetic field, as seen from Eq. (10), the part of the propagator proportional to the Dirac operator vanishes after the spinor trace, and hence the torsional Hall viscosity is determined entirely by the mass term. In a magnetic field, however, the Dirac operator and the corresponding heat kernel have a nontrivial Landau-level structure, and the Dirac-operator contribution need not vanish at finite chemical potential. Therefore, we separate the response into two parts:
where
In § 3.1 A we evaluate the mass-trace contribution , and in § 3.1 B we evaluate the Dirac-operator contribution \zeta_{\mathrm{H},\slashed{D}}^{B}.
Mass-trace contribution and weak-field representation
For the mass-trace contribution , we start from the vacuum heat-kernel representation reviewed in § 2 C.
Leaving the integral over the Euclidean frequency explicit, we write
where and are the dimensionless momentum and mass, with magnetic length . In the second equality, we used the analytic continuation of an integral representation of the Hurwitz zeta function . Since is a singular point of , we leave the limit implicit for the moment and return to it below. At finite , , and , the mass-trace contribution can be written as
where we defined the shifted Matsubara frequency , with .
We now discuss how to take the limit in Eq. (55). We begin by noting that satisfies
where is the digamma function. We use the formal relation (56) to obtain a well-defined expression for . Suppose that is indexed by an integer and sum Eq. (56) over . Formally interchanging the sum and the limit gives
The second term in the brackets contains the divergent sum . We regularize it by writing
where in the third equality we used the analytic continuation of the geometric series. This prescription assigns zero to the regulated constant and will be used in the following. Thus, for our purposes, we may write
and hence
The remaining Matsubara sum is not straightforward to perform due to the appearance of the digamma function. Nevertheless, we can obtain a perturbative expansion of Eq. (60). As , the digamma function behaves as
where are the Bernoulli numbers. In our case, , and hence this gives the following perturbative expansion in for :
where we have renormalized away the infinite constant using the prescription in Eq. (58). Eq. (62) naturally separates into a contribution and terms containing all dependence on the magnetic field through the sum over . The Matsubara sum can be performed term by term, after which the series in can also be formally resummed. To this end, we use the relation
Subtracting the expression with the same regulator and using the linearity of the differential operator gives
Here we reintroduced the dimensionless mass and formally summed the series over . Eq. (64) gives the finite-temperature and chemical-potential correction to the mass-trace contribution . The differential expression in Eq. (64) can be evaluated directly. Eq. (43) gives
where we have the Fermi-Dirac distribution
Using the spectral Laplace representation derived in Appendix B, the differential operator in Eq. (64) therefore acts as
where , and
It follows that the finite-temperature and chemical-potential correction to the mass-trace contribution is
Thus, Eq. (69) is the Landau-level resummation of the mass-trace calculation in this subsection. The shifts reproduce the squared Dirac Landau-level energies .
Dirac-operator contribution
We now evaluate the Dirac-operator contribution \zeta_{\mathrm{H},\slashed{D}}^{B} in Eq. (53). It vanishes at zero temperature and chemical potential after the symmetric frequency integral, but need not vanish when the Matsubara frequencies are shifted by . To evaluate it in the same Landau-level basis as the mass-trace contribution, consider the single-particle Dirac Hamiltonian in the convention of Eq. (22) at ,
For , the paired Landau levels have energies for , while the zeroth Landau level is unpaired and has energy .7 Each Landau level has degeneracy per unit area. In this basis, the corresponding operators take the form
For each paired level , we have in the corresponding two-dimensional Landau-level sector. In the oscillator basis with , the spatial Dirac operator is off diagonal. Choosing the relative phase of the two spinor components so that the off-diagonal matrix element is real and positive, we obtain
where the subscript on the left-hand side denotes restriction to this sector. Taking the spinor trace gives
Thus, the paired levels provide no contribution to the Dirac-operator trace at any shifted Matsubara frequency. The zeroth Landau level has only the spinor component with eigenvalue , and the spatial operator annihilates its state. Eq. (71) therefore gives
Including the degeneracy , Eq. (53) gives
where we used . At , the corresponding frequency integral vanishes since its integrand is odd. As in § 3, we isolate the finite-temperature and chemical-potential correction by subtracting the result at with the same regulator. To perform the remaining Matsubara sum, we write
and pair opposite Matsubara frequencies in the symmetric prescription. Using the standard Matsubara sum, for any we have
Together with , this gives the finite-temperature and chemical-potential correction for \zeta_{\mathrm{H},\slashed{D}}^{B}:
Complete response and physical interpretation
Combining the mass-trace contribution in Eq. (69) with the Dirac-operator contribution in Eq. (78), we obtain the complete correction
The complete response is consequently
where is the symmetric vacuum result in Eq. (19) and the same finite counterterm as at has been added.
Eq. (79) contains both the contribution that depends only on and a contribution from the zeroth Landau level proportional to . The latter vanishes at and changes sign under either or . Thus, for a single Dirac block at , the response depends on the sign of the magnetic field through the zeroth Landau level. Consequently, the complete correction is invariant under the simultaneous transformation , as required by charge conjugation. In particular, the vacuum response and the thermal response at are even in .
A thermal state or a finite-density state provides a preferred timelike vector . The scalar , with , reduces to the signed magnetic field in the rest frame. An orientation-sensitive equilibrium term is therefore allowed once its coefficient is odd in .
The zero-field limit provides a direct check. For a smooth function , we have
The contribution from the zeroth Landau level vanishes linearly with , and Eq. (79) reduces to
in agreement with Eq. (43).
At zero temperature, Eq. (79) becomes
where is the Heaviside step function. At a threshold we use the convention . The response remains unchanged while the chemical potential lies in the spectral gap. At zero temperature, the paired-level
steps occur at for , while the threshold of the zeroth Landau level has magnitude . Since the zeroth Landau level has signed energy , this threshold occurs only on the corresponding side of the spectrum. In particular, for and , the zeroth Landau level lies at negative energy, whereas the first step at positive chemical potential occurs at . Whenever crosses a paired Landau level with , the response develops a new step. At the threshold of the zeroth Landau level , the mass-trace and orientation-sensitive contributions may cancel or reinforce, depending on the signs of , , and . These steps are a spectral Landau-level effect rather than quantized torsional Hall plateaus, since the paired-level step heights contain the nonuniversal factor . At finite temperature, each step is rounded over an energy scale of order , smoothing the sharp edges of the zero-temperature plateaus. The resulting Landau-level steps and their thermal rounding are illustrated in Figure 1.
Figure 1. The finite-temperature and chemical-potential correction as a function of for and , for which the magnetic length and the inverse gap scale are comparable. The orange curve illustrates how finite temperature rounds the steps as the chemical potential crosses successive Landau levels.
For and , all occupation factors are exponentially suppressed. Hence, vanishes exponentially, and the full response approaches the renormalized vacuum magnetic field result. By contrast, for , many Landau levels are occupied and the sum approaches its continuum limit, giving . This unbounded linear behavior is a formal property of the continuum Dirac model and should only be interpreted within the energy range where the low-energy Dirac description remains valid.
BHZ DEFORMATION
We now consider the BHZ deformation for a massive Dirac fermion in thermal equilibrium. The purpose of this section is to determine how the zero-temperature BHZ result is modified by finite temperature and chemical potential.
As in the vacuum calculation, we set below. Physical units can be restored by replacing and multiplying by , where . The two energy bands are
We will focus on the regime
In this regime has a unique minimum at , with band edges at . This is the regime relevant for the (Hg,Mn)Te quantum well in the quantum anomalous Hall experiments. Following the finite-temperature prescription introduced in § 3, the Euclidean frequency integral is replaced by a fermionic Matsubara sum, and the chemical potential is introduced by the shift . Applying this prescription to the BHZ tadpole gives the formal expression
Like the vacuum BHZ tadpole, Eq. (86) is UV divergent and is understood to be evaluated using the same regularization and counterterms as the vacuum response. Since this expression is even in , below we will consider to be positive.
The vacuum BHZ calculation showed that the bare value of contains UV divergences. At finite temperature and chemical potential, the natural object is therefore the finite difference
The two terms may be understood as either bare quantities evaluated with the same regulator or renormalized quantities evaluated using the same counterterms. This subtraction is convergent since finite temperature and chemical potential do not modify the UV structure of the BHZ tadpole. At large momentum the BHZ term dominates, with , and hence the divergent part is the same quadratic and logarithmic contribution already present in the vacuum calculation [30]. After the Matsubara sum, subtracting the vacuum integrand leaves terms weighted by Fermi–Dirac factors, which are exponentially suppressed at large for fixed and finite . Hence, is UV finite and requires no additional regularization, while the same Pauli–Villars counterterms used at apply to the full response. We will not consider the formal high temperature expansion, since expanding the thermal factors before taking the UV limit is nonuniform and can obscure the vacuum power counting; moreover, the low temperature regime is the one relevant for experiments.
Using , the finite correction Eq. (87) can be written in terms of the Fermi–Dirac distribution as
Eq. (88) is the main working formula of this section. Since it is UV finite, it can be evaluated numerically without additional regularization. In the following we will analyze this integral analytically in the low temperature regime. For the numerical results in this section, we use a specific set of parameters meV, meV nm, and meV nm valid for (Hg,Mn)Te quantum wells.
Chemical potential correction at zero temperature
At zero temperature, the Fermi–Dirac functions become step functions. If the chemical potential lies inside the gap, i.e., , there is no Fermi surface and the correction vanishes exactly:
Thus, at , tuning the chemical potential does not change the torsional Hall viscosity as long as the Fermi level remains in the bulk gap.
For , a Fermi surface appears. In the single-minimum regime , the Fermi momentum is determined by , giving
The -dependent part of the tadpole can then be evaluated analytically. Since Eq. (89) shows that the zero-temperature response inside the gap is equal to the vacuum response, the correction at zero temperature can be written as
with any . For one finds8
In the limit, Eq. (92) reduces to the free-Dirac zero-temperature correction in Eq. (49).
This correction vanishes continuously as from above. Thus, the zero temperature response has a sharp kink at the band edge: below the gap there is no correction, while above the gap the Fermi surface contributes, see Figure 2.
Figure 2. The zero-temperature chemical-potential correction as a function of . The correction vanishes inside the bulk gap and develops a kink when crosses the band edge.
Low temperature expansion above the band edge
We next consider the regime in which the chemical potential lies above the band edge, i.e., . At zero temperature this produces a Fermi surface, and the correction due to chemical potential is given by Eq. (92). At small but finite temperature, the natural analytic approximation is the Sommerfeld expansion. As we will see below, this expansion accurately describes the numerical result when is sufficiently far above the band edge, but it breaks down when approaches .
In the single-minimum regime , the dispersion is monotonic for . We may therefore change variables from to and define by
Solving for we find
The correction due to finite temperature contains the integral
where the contribution involving is exponentially suppressed at low temperature for positive above the edge of the conduction band. Applying the Sommerfeld expansion to Eq. (95) yields
The regime of validity of this expansion follows from the structure of the Fermi-Dirac distribution. At , is a step function at . At finite temperature, this step is smoothed over an energy interval of order , and hence the finite-temperature correction is controlled by energies satisfying . The Sommerfeld expansion assumes that the integrand is smooth throughout this interval and that the lower endpoint of the integral, , is not inside it. Hence, the approximation is controlled when
This explains the comparison with the numerical evaluation of Eq. (88) shown in Figure 3: the Sommerfeld approximation agrees well when is sufficiently above the band edge, but fails as , where the lower endpoint begins to affect the finite crossover.
Figure 3. Comparison between the full numerical evaluation of and the Sommerfeld approximation at K. The results agree when lies sufficiently above the band edge.
For a fixed chemical potential above the band edge, the same criterion also gives a useful estimate of the temperature range where the Sommerfeld result should remain accurate. The endpoint correction omitted by the Sommerfeld expansion is controlled by . Thus, the validity scale for the Sommerfeld expansion is given by , with a chosen error tolerance. For example, taking and , a criterion gives , while a criterion gives (see Appendix C for details). Equivalently, at the endpoint factor is already only . This explains why the Sommerfeld approximation is expected to be very accurate through the low temperature regime relevant for QAH experiments, provided is sufficiently above the band edge.
In the Dirac limit , the energy space integrand becomes constant, and hence all algebraic Sommerfeld corrections vanish. Thus, for , the finite temperature Dirac result agrees with the result up to exponentially small endpoint corrections of order . The nonzero term in Eq. (96) is therefore a genuine effect of the BHZ deformation.
Thermal rounding of the band edge
The Sommerfeld expansion fails when approaches . In this regime the integral is dominated by states near the bottom of the band, and the sharp zero-temperature kink is thermally rounded. This is the physically important regime for understanding why can deviate from its zero temperature insulating value even before reaches the band edge.
Using Eq. (94), the finite correction may be written as
Expanding around gives the band-edge expansion
where the polylogarithm function appears at -th order in the expansion. As a check, in the Dirac limit , the first line of Eq. (99) reduces precisely to the free-Dirac thermal and chemical potential correction in Eq. (43).
The leading term in Eq. (99) makes the physical crossover at the band edge transparent. For positive near the edge of the conduction band, the second logarithm is exponentially smaller than the first one, as it is controlled by . The dominant crossover is therefore governed by , which gives the smoothing of the kink at zero temperature. Indeed, in the zero temperature limit we have
Thus, the statement that is unchanged for is replaced at finite temperature by a smooth crossover of width .
To estimate the chemical potential at which begins to deviate from its vacuum value, a useful quantitative diagnostic is the slope of the leading correction. Near the band edge we have
The sharp step at in slope is therefore rounded into a Fermi-Dirac function. If an onset value is defined as the point where this slope reaches a fraction of its asymptotic value, then
from which we obtain
If we set the visibility criterion , then approximately we have
For K and 40 K, we have meV and 14.7 meV, respectively. As can be seen in Figure 4, the curves indeed begin to rise near these values of .

Figure 4. Numerical and analytical results for as a function of at fixed temperatures. The agreement is excellent when is not much greater than the band edge.
The validity of the band edge expansion can be estimated analytically by comparing the first omitted term with the retained terms. For the (Hg,Mn)Te parameters and meV (5 meV above the band edge), this estimate shows that the approximation through begins to deviate at temperatures of a few tens of Kelvin, while including the term extends the useful range to temperatures of order 100 K. The details of this estimate are given in Appendix C. Thus, the band edge expansion is well controlled in the low temperature regime relevant for QAH experiments, provided is not far above the band edge.
Finite temperature at zero chemical potential
The band-edge expansion also gives a useful approximation at zero chemical potential. Setting in Eq. (99), the particle and hole contributions become equal, and we obtain
The physical content of Eq. (105) is simple. At and , there are no thermally excited carriers and the correction vanishes. At finite temperature, particle-hole excitations across the gap produce an exponentially small correction. For , the leading term behaves as
Thus, at charge neutrality the BHZ torsional Hall viscosity is exponentially stable at low temperature, with the activation scale set by the energy from the chemical potential to the band edge.
Domain wall jump and physical interpretations
The most robust observable of the torsional Hall viscosity is the jump of across a domain wall where the Dirac mass changes sign, as reviewed in § 2 D. We use the same vacuum prescription and require both sides to lie in the single-minimum regime, i.e., , or when is restored. At finite temperature and chemical potential, we decompose the jump across the domain wall as
where has been given in (28), and
The thermal correction is finite without additional regularization and independent of the vacuum counterterms. The vacuum jump is evaluated using the prescription of § 2 D. Using Eq. (88), the finite temperature correction to the domain wall jump can be written in the manifestly UV finite form
This integral is one of the main results of this section: for given and , one can directly obtain numerically a prediction for how the domain wall response is modified in thermal equilibrium. Analytically, below we evaluate this integral in the same limits considered above for the bulk , which makes the physical content of the domain wall correction transparent.
First, at zero temperature, the correction vanishes if the chemical potential lies inside the gap:
Thus, the vacuum domain wall response is exactly unchanged at as long as the Fermi level remains in the bulk gap. Once , a Fermi surface appears and the jump receives a correction. In the single minimum regime , this correction is9
This expression vanishes continuously as . At finite temperature the sharp zero temperature threshold is rounded. Near the band edge, the finite temperature correction to the domain wall jump can be obtained by applying the band edge expansion to the two sides of the wall. For convenience, we define
and for ,
Keeping terms up to , the band edge expansion of the finite temperature correction to the domain wall jump is
Eq. (114) is the band edge approximation to the finite temperature correction of the domain wall response. The first term gives the leading contribution near , while the and terms are corrections generated by the subleading terms in the expansion of around . The physical content is clearest in the leading term. For positive close to the conduction band edge, the second logarithm in is exponentially smaller, and
Therefore, finite temperature rounds the sharp zero temperature kink at over an energy window of order . Even when the chemical potential is still inside the gap, thermally occupied states near the band edge modify the domain wall jump by an amount controlled by .
The band edge expansion should not be used when the chemical potential is deep in the conduction or valence band. In the regime with , the appropriate approximation is instead the Sommerfeld expansion. Applying the Sommerfeld result on the two sides of the domain wall gives
Here, is the zero temperature finite chemical potential correction to the domain wall jump. Hence, Eq. (114) describes the rounded band edge regime , while Eq. (116) describes the regime where the Fermi level is well inside the band. For numerical predictions across the full range of , we use the exact integral in Eq. (109).
It is useful to express the result as a prediction for the ratio relative to the pure Dirac domain wall jump,
Restoring , the vacuum ratio is given by Eq. (29). We have seen that for the same (Hg,Mn)Te parameters, one finds . At finite temperature and chemical potential, the prediction is obtained from Eq. (117), where is evaluated from the exact integral, from the band edge expansion near , or from the Sommerfeld expansion for . The resulting behavior is shown in Figure 5. The ratio is essentially unchanged from its vacuum value whenever , namely when the chemical potential lies well inside the bulk gap. In this regime the correction is thermally activated as . As shown in Figure 5(a), increasing the temperature broadens the crossover in , and hence the reduction begins already below the zero temperature band edge . Equivalently, Figure 5(b) shows that, at fixed , the magnitude of decreases from that of once thermal occupation of band edge states becomes appreciable; the onset occurs at lower temperature when is closer to . For , the zero temperature value is already reduced from , and finite temperature produces the Sommerfeld correction once the chemical potential is well inside the band. The finite temperature and chemical potential correction therefore acts against the vacuum enhancement generated by the BHZ deformation.

Figure 5. The magnitude of the domain wall ratio for (Hg,Mn)Te parameters. The vacuum value is stable when and is reduced near the thermally rounded band edge.
The fixed- curves in Figure 5(a) exhibit an approximate clustering at chemical potentials above the band edge. Near the band edge, thermal rounding reduces , whereas deeper in the band the leading Sommerfeld correction has the opposite sign for , causing the ordering of the curves to reverse. At larger or , the differences among the curves decrease, and all curves approach the common continuum limit , which is approximately for the (Hg,Mn)Te parameters considered here. However, these extreme chemical potential and temperature limits lie outside the quantitative range of validity of the low-energy BHZ model and should be understood as formal properties of the continuum result.
Conclusions
In this work, we have extended the torsional Hall viscosity of Chern insulators to finite temperature and chemical potential. This continues the analysis of [30], where the effects of a constant magnetic field and of the momentum-dependent mass appearing in a single block of the BHZ Hamiltonian were studied at zero temperature and zero chemical potential. Our main goal here was to determine how thermal occupation and finite chemical potential modify these vacuum results and, in particular, under which conditions the torsional Hall viscosity remains close to its ground-state value. A general feature of the analysis is that finite and do not modify the ultraviolet structure of the theory. The same renormalization as in the vacuum can therefore be used, while the corrections due to finite temperature and chemical potential are finite.
For the free massive Dirac fermion, we found that at zero temperature the torsional Hall viscosity remains unchanged as long as the chemical potential lies inside the bulk gap. At finite temperature, the sharp onset associated with crossing a band edge is smoothed by the Fermi–Dirac distribution, while the correction is exponentially suppressed when the chemical potential lies sufficiently deep inside the gap. We then considered a constant magnetic field, for which the response can be organized in terms of the relativistic Landau levels. The zeroth Landau level gives an additional orientation-sensitive contribution at finite chemical potential. At zero temperature, tuning through the higher Landau levels produces a staircase structure in . In contrast to the Hall conductivity, the step heights are not quantized in a fixed universal unit, but depend on the mass and the Landau-level energy. Moreover, finite temperature rounds the steps over an energy scale of order .
We finally studied the momentum-dependent mass of the single-block BHZ model. The correction at finite temperature and chemical potential is ultraviolet finite and can be obtained for arbitrary and within the continuum model. Away from the band edge, its low-temperature behavior is captured by a Sommerfeld expansion, whereas close to the band edge a separate expansion in terms of polylogarithms describes the thermal rounding of the zero-temperature threshold. We also studied the torsional Hall viscosity jump across a mass domain wall. The enhancement found in Ref. [30] for parameters relevant to (Hg,Mn)Te quantum wells remains essentially unchanged when the chemical potential lies sufficiently deep inside the gap, i.e.,
up to exponentially suppressed corrections. As the chemical potential approaches and enters a bulk band, thermal occupation and finite-density effects reduce the magnitude of the enhanced domain-wall response, while finite temperature smooths the zero-temperature crossover near the band edge.
An important next step is to combine the magnetic-field and momentum-dependent mass deformations. In magnetically doped (Hg,Mn)Te quantum wells, a weak external magnetic field can be used to polarize the Mn moments. Although the role of this field is primarily to align the magnetic moments, its orbital coupling to the electronic states cannot in general be neglected. A direct comparison with this experimental setting therefore calls for the torsional Hall viscosity of the single-block BHZ Hamiltonian in a finite magnetic field, including the resulting Landau-level structure, and eventually at finite temperature and chemical potential. Together with the results obtained here, such an analysis would provide a more complete description of the torsional response under conditions relevant to experiments on topological quantum wells with broken time-reversal symmetry.
Acknowledgments
We thank Christian Tutschku and Raffael Klees for collaboration in the early stages of this project. W.J. thanks Jingyuan Chen, Zheng-Cheng Gu and Ze-Min Huang for helpful discussions. E.M.H. thanks Joel Moore and James Analytis for the insightful discussions and the support as well as the hospitality at the University of California, Berkeley. E.M.H., J.E., and R.M. acknowledge the support of the German Research Foundation (DFG) through the Collaborative Research Center ToCoTronics, Project-ID 258499086 — SFB 1170, as well as Germany’s Excellence Strategy through the Würzburg-Dresden Cluster of Excellence on Complexity, Topology and Dynamics in Quantum Matter - ctd.qmat (EXC 2147, Project-ID 390858490). R.M. furthermore acknowledges hospitality from the Shanghai Institute for Mathematics and Interdisciplinary Sciences (SIMIS) and associated travel support under STCSM Grant 25HB2701900. W.J. is supported by the Research Grants Council of Hong Kong Special Administrative Region of China (Project No. 14302725) under the scheme of General Research Fund. The work of I.M. is supported by the STFC consolidated grant (ST/X000583/1) ‘New Frontiers In Particle Physics, Cosmology And Gravity’. Z.Y.X. acknowledges support from the basic startup funding from Sun Yat-sen University and from the Berlin Quantum Initiative.
Evaluating at finite temperature and chemical potential
In the present appendix, we show how to evaluate the torsional Hall viscosity at finite temperature and chemical potential. To begin our calculation, recall that is given by Eq. (36) as
where , and we have defined the Matsubara sum as
The individual sums in Eq. (120) are formal; their difference in Eq. (119) converges at fixed . We evaluate this difference before taking . To evaluate , we shall employ complex analysis. To this end, we introduce two auxiliary functions
The two functions and are not independent, but related as . Importantly, has poles at with residue
The function has branch points at the poles of .
Consider now the integral
where is the contour of Figure 6. We choose the branch of that vanishes at infinity, with cuts from to and from to . The contour consists of an outer counterclockwise circle and two clockwise contours enclosing the excluded cuts.

Figure 6. Contour , with an outer circle of radius , for performing the integral in Eq. (123), for simplicity shown at . The crosses designate the poles of the integral along the real axis, while the small disks mark the four branch points along the imaginary axis. The two cuts connect to and to .
With this choice of contour, we encircle the poles of inside and do not cross either branch cut. We can then employ the residue theorem to evaluate , and find in the limit
This establishes that if we calculate , we can calculate the difference in Eq. (119). At fixed , . Taking through circles that stay a fixed distance from the Matsubara poles, remains bounded and the outer-circle integral vanishes as . Hence, only the clockwise contours contribute. To calculate directly, we integrate by parts to introduce under the integral as
The contours shown in Figure 7 lie within , where has an analytic branch. Both and return to their starting values along each closed contour, and hence and the integration-by-parts boundary term vanishes. The resulting integrand has poles only at , inside . Therefore, we can once again use Cauchy’s theorem with clockwise orientation to find
Figure 7. Clockwise contours for performing the integral in Eq. (125), for simplicity shown at . The crosses designate the four poles at , , while the small disks mark the branch points of along the real axis. Both contours lie inside the dashed lines, where is analytic.
which implies for
Equation (A9) is our final result for the regulated torsional Hall viscosity. At fixed and , the logarithm of the numerator is . Using and taking reproduces Eq. (37) presented in the main text. The vacuum counterterms then give the renormalized response in Eq. (38).
Laplace transform of at finite magnetic field
We evaluate the differential operator in Eq. (64) spectrally. Set , , and , and define
On either gapped branch the sign of the Dirac mass is carried by the overall factor of , whereas depends only on . For , the function is smooth and decays exponentially in as . We first take and , where the logarithms admit convergent expansions in . Using the identity, for ,
we obtain the Laplace representation
with
For , these expansions and the integrals below converge absolutely, justifying the interchanges of sums, integrals, and derivatives. The spectral weight need not be positive. This representation diagonalizes . Since and is even, one obtains
For ,
Substituting Eq. (131) into Eq. (130) and differentiating Eq. (129) gives
For the function in Eq. (128),
Writing
Eq. (132) becomes
Multiplication by the overall factor of in Eq. (64) reproduces Eq. (69). At fixed and , the Landau-level sum converges locally uniformly and is analytic in throughout . It therefore continues the mass-trace result from to all real ; the Laplace integral itself need not converge outside its initial domain. The zero-temperature result is obtained by taking afterwards. The continued Landau-level expression defines the differential operator for and requires no boundary data at . It gives the complete mass-trace correction at fixed nonzero mass; the massless point, when needed, is understood as a one-sided limit of the gapped response.
Validity of the BHZ low-temperature expansions
In this appendix we estimate the regimes of validity of the two analytic approximations used in § 6. First consider the Sommerfeld expansion for . After changing variables from to , the finite-temperature correction contains an integral of the form
At , becomes a step function at . At finite temperature this step is rounded over an interval of order . The Sommerfeld expansion assumes that the lower endpoint lies outside this interval, and hence the endpoint correction is exponentially small, with leading behavior
A useful estimate of the Sommerfeld validity scale is obtained by choosing a small and defining by
which gives
The Sommerfeld expansion is then expected to be quantitatively reliable for , provided the omitted higher-order terms are also small. For 1% and 5% criteria, we have
For example, for (Hg,Mn)Te we have and we take , corresponding to , this gives
It is useful to compare these analytic estimates with the direct numerical evaluation of the full finite-temperature integral. The Sommerfeld approximation up to differs from the numerical result by about 1% at and by about 5% at (see Figure 8). Hence, the above estimation is consistent with the comparison between the Sommerfeld approximation and the full numerical result.
Figure 8. (a) Numerical (orange) and Sommerfeld approximation (blue) results for as a function of at . (b) The error of Sommerfeld approximation compared to the numerical result, with 1% and 5% dashed lines.
We now estimate the regime of validity of the band-edge expansion used for the finite-temperature BHZ correction. The band-edge expansion is obtained by Taylor expanding about ,
and then performing the Fermi integrals exactly. This expansion also requires the chemical potential to remain sufficiently close to the band edge for the Taylor expansion of to be accurate. In the regime of positive near the conduction-band edge, the antiparticle contribution is exponentially suppressed, and the expansion of takes the form
where
The first four coefficients are
A simple estimate of the truncation error is obtained by comparing the first omitted term with the retained result. If the expansion is kept through , the first omitted contribution is the term, and we define
Similarly, if the expansion is kept through , the first omitted contribution is the term, and we define
In analogy with the Sommerfeld case, we define the band-edge validity scale as the temperature at which the first omitted term estimate for the truncation after reaches a prescribed tolerance . Thus, is determined from Eq. (147), while is determined from Eq. (148).
For (Hg,Mn)Te parameters we take
To apply the above formulas to these physical units, one replaces in the preceding expressions, where had been set to 1. Taking , for which , the estimator temperatures are
and
Now we compare these analytic estimates with the direct numerical evaluation. For , the approximation truncated at differs from the numerical result by about 1% at and by about 5% at . Including the term substantially improves the agreement: the corresponding differences are about 1% at and about 5% at (see Figure 9). Thus, the first omitted term estimate captures the correct temperature scale for the breakdown of the approximation and gives a reasonable theoretical estimate for the onset of deviations in the approximation. The actual quantitative accuracy, however, is best determined by direct comparison with the numerical integral. For QAH experiments, which are typically performed at temperatures well below these scales, the band-edge expansion is well controlled in the experimentally relevant regime.
Figure 9. (a) Numerical result (orange) and the band edge approximations truncated at (blue) and (green) for as a function of at . (b) The error of the band edge approximations truncated at (blue) and (green) compared to the numerical result, with 1% and 5% dashed lines.
References
- [1]J. E. Avron, R. Seiler, and P. G. Zograf, Viscosity of quantum Hall fluids, Phys. Rev. Lett. 75, 697 (1995).DOI
- [2]C. Hoyos, Hall viscosity, topological states and effective theories, Int. J. Mod. Phys. B 28, 1430007 (2014).DOI
- [3]N. Read, Non-abelian adiabatic statistics and Hall viscosity in quantum Hall states and pₓ + ipᵧ paired superfluids, Phys. Rev. B 79, 045308 (2009).DOI
- [4]N. Read and E. H. Rezayi, Hall viscosity, orbital spin, and geometry: Paired superfluids and quantum Hall systems, Phys. Rev. B 84, 085316 (2011).
- [5]C. Hoyos and D. T. Son, Hall viscosity and electromagnetic response, Phys. Rev. Lett. 108, 066805 (2012).pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/22401104
- [6]B. Bradlyn, M. Goldstein, and N. Read, Kubo formulas for viscosity: Hall viscosity, Ward identities, and the relation with conductivity, Phys. Rev. B 86, 245309 (2012).DOI
- [7]B. Bradlyn and N. Read, Low-energy effective theory in the bulk for transport in a topological phase, Phys. Rev. B 91, 125303 (2015), erratum: Phys. Rev. B 93, 239902 (2016).
- [8]T. L. Hughes, R. G. Leigh, and E. Fradkin, Torsional response and dissipationless viscosity in topological insulators, Phys. Rev. Lett. 107, 075502 (2011).
- [9]T. L. Hughes, R. G. Leigh, and O. Parrikar, Torsional anomalies, Hall viscosity, and bulk-boundary correspondence in topological states, Phys. Rev. B 88, 045104 (2013).
- [10]O. Parrikar, T. L. Hughes, and R. G. Leigh, Torsion, parity-odd response and anomalies in topological states, Phys. Rev. D 90, 105004 (2014).
- [11]M. A. Katanayev and I. V. Volovich, Theory of defects in solids and three-dimensional gravity, Ann. Phys. 216, 1 (1992).
- [12]F. de Juan, A. Cortijo, and M. A. Vozmediano, Dislocations and torsion in graphene and related systems, Nucl. Phys. B 828, 625 (2010).
- [13]G. Y. Cho, O. Parrikar, Y. You, R. G. Leigh, and T. L. Hughes, Condensation of lattice defects and melting transitions in quantum Hall phases, Phys. Rev. B 91, 035122 (2015), arXiv:1407.5637 [cond-mat.str-el].
- [14]M. Valle, Torsional response of relativistic fermions in 2 + 1 dimensions, JHEP 07, 006, arXiv:1503.04020 [hep-th].
- [15]A. Gromov, Chiral topological elasticity and fracton order, Phys. Rev. Lett. 122, 076403 (2019), arXiv:1712.06600 [cond-mat.str-el].DOI
- [16]Z.-M. Huang, B. Han, and M. Stone, Nieh-Yan anomaly: Torsional Landau levels, central charge, and anomalous thermal Hall effect, Phys. Rev. B 101, 125201 (2020), arXiv:1911.00174 [cond-mat.mes-hall].
- [17]Z.-M. Huang, B. Han, and M. Stone, Hamiltonian approach to the torsional anomalies and its dimensional ladder, Phys. Rev. B 101, 165201 (2020), arXiv:1912.06051 [cond-mat.mes-hall].
- [18]Z.-M. Huang, B. Han, and X.-Q. Sun, Torsion, energy magnetization, and thermal Hall effect, Phys. Rev. B 105, 085104 (2022), arXiv:2105.01600 [cond-mat.mes-hall].
- [19]B. A. Bernevig, T. L. Hughes, and S.-C. Zhang, Quantum spin Hall effect and topological phase transition in HgTe quantum wells, Science 314, 1757–1761 (2006).pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/16605772
- [20]M. König, S. Wiedmann, C. Brüne, A. Roth, H. Buhmann, L. W. Molenkamp, X.-L. Qi, and S.-C. Zhang, Quantum spin Hall insulator state in HgTe quantum wells, Science 318, 766–770 (2007).
- [21]C. Liu, T. L. Hughes, X.-L. Qi, K. Wang, and S.-C. Zhang, Quantum spin Hall effect in inverted Type-II semiconductors, Phys. Rev. Lett. 100, 236601 (2008).
- [22]I. Knez, R. R. Du, and G. Sullivan, Finite conductivity in mesoscopic Hall bars of inverted InAs/GaSb quantum wells, Phys. Rev. B 81, 201301 (2010).
- [23]Y. Zhang, H. He, C.-Z. Chang, C.-L. Song, L.-L. Wang, X. Chen, J.-F. Jia, Z. Fang, X. Dai, W.-Y. Shan, S.-Q. Shen, Q. Niu, X.-L. Qi, S.-C. Zhang, X.-C. Ma, and Q.-K. Xue, Crossover of the three-dimensional topological insulator Bi2Se3 to the two-dimensional limit, Nat. Phys. 6, 584 (2010).
- [24]H.-Z. Lu, W.-Y. Shan, W. Yao, Q. Niu, and S.-Q. Shen, Massive Dirac fermions and spin physics in an ultrathin film of topological insulator, Phys. Rev. B 81, 115407 (2010).
- [25]E. G. Novik, A. Pfeuffer-Jeschke, T. Jungwirth, V. Latussek, C. R. Becker, G. Landwehr, H. Buhmann, and L. W. Molenkamp, Band structure of semimagnetic Hg1−yMnyTe quantum wells, Phys. Rev. B 72, 035321 (2005).
- [26]C.-X. Liu, X.-L. Qi, X. Dai, Z. Fang, and S.-C. Zhang, Quantum anomalous Hall effect in Hg1−yMnyTe quantum wells, Phys. Rev. Lett. 101, 146802 (2008).
- [27]S. Shamim, W. Beugeling, J. Böttcher, P. Shekhar, A. Budewitz, P. Leubner, L. Lunczer, E. M. Hankiewicz, H. Buhmann, and L. W. Molenkamp, Emergent quantum Hall effects below 50 mT in a two-dimensional topological insulator, Sci. Adv. 6, eaba4625 (2020).
- [28]S. Shamim, P. Shekhar, W. Beugeling, J. Böttcher, A. Budewitz, J.-B. Mayer, L. Lunczer, E. M. Hankiewicz, H. Buhmann, and L. W. Molenkamp, Counterpropagating topological and quantum Hall edge channels, Nat. Commun. 13, 2682 (2022).
- [29]L.-X. Wang, W. Beugeling, F. Schmitt, L. Lunczer, J.-B. Mayer, H. Buhmann, E. M. Hankiewicz, and L. W. Molenkamp, Spectral asymmetry induces a re-entrant quantum Hall effect in a topological insulator, Adv. Sci. 11, 2307447 (2024).
- [30]I. Matthaiakakis, W. Jia, R. L. Klees, D. R. Fernández, Z.-Y. Xian, R. Meyer, J. Erdmanenger, and E. M. Hankiewicz, Torsional Hall viscosity of massive chern insulators: Magnetic field and momentum deformations, Phys. Rev. B 113, 085410 (2026), arXiv:2504.13250 [cond-mat.mes-hall].
- [31]J. Böttcher, C. Tutschku, L. W. Molenkamp, and E. M. Hankiewicz, Survival of the quantum anomalous Hall effect in orbital magnetic fields as a consequence of the parity anomaly, Phys. Rev. Lett. 123, 226602 (2019).
- [32]C. Tutschku, J. Böttcher, R. Meyer, and E. M. Hankiewicz, Momentum-dependent mass and AC Hall conductivity of quantum anomalous Hall insulators and their relation to the parity anomaly, Phys. Rev. Res. 2, 033193 (2020).





