betaFeedback

WorksPhysics and Astronomy

Cobalt-Controlled Interphase Partitioning Regulates Matrix Solute Transport and γ′γ' Coarsening in Ti-Rich NiCoCr-Based Superalloys

Abstract

The microstructural stability and mechanical response of γ/γ′γ/γ' superalloys at elevated temperatures are governed by solute chemistry and elemental partitioning across the γ/γ′γ/γ' heterophase interface. Conventionally, a lower γ′γ^{\prime} solvus temperature and a larger γ/γ′γ/γ^{\prime} lattice misfit are expected to increase the coarsening rate. Here, Co-for-Ni substitution is used in Ni–Co–Cr–Al–Ti superalloys to systematically modify the γγ-matrix chemistry and generate medium-entropy-alloy-type matrix environments with Ni:Co:Cr ratios of approximately 2:1:2, 2:2:1, and 1:2:1. Despite a ∼\sim65~∘^{\circ}C reduction in γ′γ^{\prime} solvus temperature, the activation energy for Ti-rich Ni33(Al,Ti)-type L12L1{2} γ′γ^{\prime} coarsening increases from ∼\sim156 to ∼\sim302~kJ~mol−1^{-1} with increasing Co content. This enhanced coarsening resistance is attributed to an increase in the multicomponent solute-transport resistance, S=∑i(ΔCi)2/(DiγCiγ)S=\sum_i (ΔC_i)^2/(D_i^γC_i^γ), from ∼8.811×1015\sim 8.811\times10^{15} to ∼1.267×1016\sim 1.267\times10^{16}~s~m−2^{-2}, together with a reduction in the apparent interfacial-energy term from 25.0 to 7.55~mJ~m−2^{-2}. The dominant transport resistance correspondingly shifts from Ni/Cr in B–10Co to Ni/Co/Cr in B–30Co.

Introduction

Superalloys derive their exceptional mechanical properties from the presence of γ′\gamma^{\prime} (Ni3_3Al) precipitates, which are coherently embedded within the γ\gamma (face-centered cubic) matrix [1, 2]. These γ′\gamma^{\prime} precipitates contribute significantly to high-temperature strength; however, their tendency to coarsen during prolonged thermal exposure at elevated temperatures leads to a gradual degradation of mechanical properties [3, 4]. The coarsening process, driven by Ostwald ripening, involves the growth of larger precipitates at the expense of smaller ones, ultimately reducing the overall high-temperature performance of the alloy [5]. To mitigate this challenge, the chemical composition of the alloy must be carefully optimized to enhance microstructural stability. Key alloying elements such as aluminum (Al) and titanium (Ti) are well-established for their role in stabilizing γ′\gamma^{\prime} precipitates, whereas refractory elements such as molybdenum (Mo) and tungsten (W) contribute to solid solution strengthening [6]. In recent years, cobalt (Co) and chromium (Cr) have garnered significant attention for their multifaceted roles in improving γ′\gamma^{\prime} precipitate stability and overall alloy performance [7].

Cobalt serves as a γ\gamma matrix stabilizer and promotes solid solution strengthening in the γ\gamma channels. It reduces the solubility of aluminium and titanium in the matrix, thereby increasing the γ′\gamma^{\prime} volume fraction, which enhances the alloy’s strength. Additionally, cobalt lowers the stacking fault energy of the alloy [8, 9]. By reducing the diffusivity of solute elements, Co effectively delays the onset of deleterious phases and extends the thermal stability of γ′\gamma^{\prime} precipitates even at elevated temperatures [10]. Chromium plays a dual role in superalloys: it enhances oxidation resistance, critical for high-temperature applications, while simultaneously modifying the chemical potential gradients between the γ\gamma and γ′\gamma^{\prime} phases, thereby influencing phase stability and reducing coarsening rates [11]. Recent research efforts have been directed toward the development of Ni–Al–Co–Cr–Ti-based superalloys, which offer high strength, excellent thermal stability, and superior resistance to environmental degradation at elevated temperatures [12]. These alloys are designed with objectives such as low cost, reduced density, enhanced mechanical performance, and improved sustainability [13]. Unlike conventional Ni-based superalloys that depend on refractory elements like Mo, W, or Ta for solid solution strengthening, Ni–Al–Co–Cr–Ti alloys exhibit superior thermal stability and mechanical properties even in the absence of these expensive and high-density elements [14, 15]. This improved performance is attributed to the concentrated nature of the γ\gamma matrix and the optimized partitioning behavior of Co, Cr, Ti, and Al, which collectively enhance the alloy’s long-term high-temperature stability [16, 17, 18].

In this work, the effect of Co variation in the Ni–xxCo–11Cr–9Al–8Ti (x=10,20,30x = 10, 20, 30 at.%) alloy system on the γ′\gamma^{\prime} coarsening behaviour was systematically investigated. Co-for-Ni substitution was employed as a compositional design strategy to generate distinct medium-entropy-alloy (MEA)-type γ\gamma-matrix environments while maintaining a Ti-rich L12L1_{2} γ′\gamma^{\prime} strengthening phase. Atom probe tomography (APT) was used to quantify the influence of Co on elemental partitioning across the γ/γ′\gamma/\gamma^{\prime} interface, whereas CALPHAD-based thermokinetic modelling was employed to analyse the diffusion-controlled contribution to γ′\gamma^{\prime} coarsening. This approach is motivated by the unresolved role of Co in controlling γ′\gamma^{\prime} coarsening in multicomponent superalloys, with previous studies reporting contradictory effects on γ/γ′\gamma/\gamma^{\prime} microstructural stability [19, 20, 21].

Materials and Methods

CALPHAD-Guided Alloy Design and Heat Treatment

CALPHAD-based thermodynamic calculations were performed using Thermo-Calc 2023a with the TCNI11 database [22] to guide the design of Ni–Co–Cr–Al–Ti γ/γ′\gamma/\gamma^{\prime} superalloys with systematically varied γ\gamma-matrix chemistry. The design objective was to generate distinct Ni–Co–Cr medium-entropy-alloy-type γ\gamma-matrix environments while retaining a Ti-rich Ni3_3(Al,Ti)-type L12_2 γ′\gamma^{\prime} precipitate phase. Co was therefore substituted at the expense of Ni, while Cr, Al, and Ti were kept nominally fixed. The selected nominal compositions (at.%) were Ni–11Cr–10Co–9Al–8Ti, Ni–11Cr–20Co–9Al–8Ti, and Ni–11Cr–30Co–9Al–8Ti, hereafter referred to as B–10Co, B–20Co, and B–30Co, respectively.

As shown in Figure 1(a), the calculated phase compositions at 900 °C indicate that increasing Co content progressively enriches the γ\gamma matrix in Co while reducing its Ni content. Cr remains preferentially partitioned to γ\gamma, whereas Al and Ti remain concentrated in γ′\gamma^{\prime}. Thus, the selected Co additions transform the γ\gamma matrix from a relatively Ni–Cr-rich environment in B–10Co to a Co-enriched Ni–Co–Cr medium-entropy matrix in B–30Co without changing the nominal γ′\gamma^{\prime}-forming Al and Ti contents. The alloys were prepared using high-purity elemental constituents in the form of pieces (≥ 99.9%, Alfa Aesar): Ni, Co, Cr, Al, and Ti. Melting was conducted in a vacuum arc furnace on a water-cooled copper hearth under a high-purity (HP, ∼99.99%) Ar atmosphere. For each alloy, a charge of approximately 25 g was arc-melted, flipped, and re-melted at least five times to promote chemical homogeneity. The buttons were subsequently cast into 3 mm rods.

CALPHAD-predicted phase compositions and phase evolution in the designed Ni–Co–Cr–Al–Ti alloys

Figure 1. CALPHAD-predicted phase compositions and phase evolution in the designed Ni–Co–Cr–Al–Ti alloys. (a) Calculated compositions of the γ\gamma and γ′\gamma^{\prime} phases at 900 °C as a function of Co content, showing the evolution of the respective phase chemistries. Calculated phase fractions as a function of temperature for (b1) B–10Co, (b2) B–20Co, and (b3) B–30Co. The calculations confirm the stability of the γ/γ′\gamma/\gamma^{\prime} two-phase field above 800 °C. The predicted transformation temperatures were used to determine the solution-treatment temperatures for the respective alloys. All calculations were performed using Thermo-Calc 2023a with the TCNI11 thermodynamic database. In the Thermo-Calc notation, FCC_L12#2 corresponds to the ordered L12 γ′\gamma^{\prime} phase, whereas FCC_L12 corresponds to the disordered FCC γ\gamma phase.

The phase stability of the designed alloys was evaluated from the calculated phase fractions as a function of temperature, as shown in Figure 1(c-Figure 1e). The predicted γ′\gamma^{\prime} solvus decreases with increasing Co content, from approximately 1245 °C for B–10Co to 1222 °C for B–20Co and 1184 °C for B–30Co. Accordingly, the supersolvus homogenisation/solutionising temperatures were selected above the respective γ′\gamma^{\prime} solvus and below the solidus temperatures (as shown in Figure 1(f): 1260 °C for B–10Co, 1230 °C for B–20Co, and 1210 °C for B–30Co. The heat-treatment protocol involved heating to 1175 °C at 300 °C h−1^{-1}, followed by a slow ramp of 20 °C h−1^{-1} to the alloy-specific homogenisation temperatures, holding for 20 h, and quenching in iced brine. The controlled slow heating through the γ′\gamma^{\prime} solvus region ensured complete dissolution of precipitates while avoiding incipient melting [23, 24]. Post-treatment EPMA-WDS analysis, averaged over 10 measurements, verified chemical homogeneity, with measured compositions within 0.5 at.% of the nominal targets [S1].

The calculated phase-fraction evolution further confirms that all three alloys retain a stable γ+γ′\gamma+ \gamma^{\prime} two-phase field at the subsolvus ageing temperatures used for coarsening-kinetics evaluation, namely 900 °C, 950 °C, and 1000 °C. To develop the initial γ/γ′\gamma/\gamma^{\prime} microstructure, the solutionised rods were vacuum sealed in quartz ampoules under a vacuum of 10 × 10−510^{-5} mbar and aged at 900 °C for 50 h. For coarsening studies, 4 mm-thick slices of the homogenised alloys were vacuum sealed under the same conditions and isothermally annealed at 900 °C, 950 °C, and 1000 °C for 50 h, 100 h, 250 h, 500 h, and

1000 h. After ageing, the samples were quenched again in iced brine to retain the evolved high-temperature microstructure.

Thermophysical Property Measurements

Thermal analysis. for all the samples was performed using a NETZSCH STA 449 F3 Jupiter instrument to evaluate critical phase transformation temperatures, including the γ′\gamma^{\prime} solvus. Prior to measurement, the sample, weighing approximately 30 mg, was soaked overnight in acetone and subsequently dried. A standardised heating and cooling protocol was followed for all experiments. Approximately 30 mg of each sample was placed in a recrystallised Al2O3\mathrm{Al}_{2}\mathrm{O}_{3} crucible, with an identical crucible used as the reference. The samples were subjected to a complete thermal cycle—heating from 50 °C to 1300 °C, followed by cooling to 30 °C—at a constant rate of 10 °C min−1^{-1} in both directions. All DSC runs were conducted under a continuous flow of high-purity argon (60 mL min−1^{-1}) to prevent oxidation. The DSC data were analysed using NETZSCH Proteus software.

The onset of the first endothermic peak during the heating cycle was identified as the γ′\gamma^{\prime} solvus temperature. For accurate determination, the method described by Boettinger et al. [25] was adopted, wherein tangents were drawn on the flanks of the asymptotic peak, and their point of intersection was used to define the onset temperature with precision.

Microstructural Characterisation and Analysis

X-ray diffraction (XRD) was used to determine the γ/γ′\gamma/\gamma^{\prime} lattice misfit in the peak-aged condition. Measurements were carried out using a Rigaku SmartLab high-resolution diffractometer with Cu Kα\alpha radiation, having a wavelength λ=0.154 06\lambda= 0.154\,06 nm, operated at 40 kV and 40 mA. The diffractometer was equipped with Johansson optics to suppress Kα2\alpha_{2} and Kβ\beta radiation, thereby improving angular resolution and peak-position accuracy. For γ/γ′\gamma/\gamma^{\prime} lattice-misfit determination, high-resolution scans were collected over a 2θ2\theta range of 49°–53° using a step size of 0.008°, covering the closely spaced γ\gamma and γ′\gamma^{\prime} reflections. The overlapping diffraction peaks were deconvoluted using pseudo-Voigt functions to accurately resolve the individual γ\gamma and γ′\gamma^{\prime} peak positions. The corresponding lattice parameters of the γ\gamma matrix and γ′\gamma^{\prime} precipitate phases were then calculated from the fitted peak positions. The γ/γ′\gamma/\gamma^{\prime} lattice misfit, δ\delta, was determined using Equation 1:

δ=2(aγ′−aγ)aγ′+aγ(1)\delta= \frac{2(a_{\gamma^{\prime}} - a_{\gamma})}{a_{\gamma^{\prime}} + a_{\gamma}} \tag*{(1)}

where aγa_{\gamma} and aγ′a_{\gamma^{\prime}} are the lattice parameters of the γ\gamma and γ′\gamma^{\prime} phases, respectively.

Backscattered electron (BSE) imaging was performed using a ZEISS GeminiSEM 450 at 30 kV/13 nA, providing contrast between the γ\gamma and γ′\gamma^{\prime} phases. Quantitative elemental analysis was carried out using JEOL JXA-8530F EPMA with WDS mode, at 15 kV and 50 nA. The measurements were averaged across multiple regions for accuracy (See Supplementary Table S1).

Volume fractions of γ′\gamma^{\prime} precipitates of the heat-treated alloy were measured using the grid method (ASTM standard E562-11) [26] using a Python-based script. The measurements were carried out utilizing 2-D projected SEM images of near [100] oriented grains for at least 200 precipitates. The precipitate size calculation was based on considering circular area-equivalent radius. The area of individual precipitates (AA) was traced from the SEM images and from which the circular area equivalent radius, rr, (precipitate size) was calculated by Equation (2):

r=Aπ(2)r = \sqrt{\frac{A}{\pi}} \tag*{(2)}

The error (ss) in the measurement of average precipitate size was calculated by Equation (3):

s=σN(3)s = \frac{\sigma}{\sqrt{N}} \tag*{(3)}

where σ\sigma is the standard deviation of the average precipitate size and NN is the number of precipitates used for the measurement.

Atom Probe Tomography

Specimens for atomic-scale compositional measurements were prepared from polished, peak-aged B-10Co, B-20Co, and B-30Co samples heat-treated at 900 °C for 50 h. Site-specific needle-shaped specimens were extracted using a dual-beam SEM/focused-ion-beam instrument (FIB, Helios Nanolab 600) following a standard in-situ lift-out protocol [27, 28]. Protective platinum (Pt) layers were deposited prior to milling to prevent surface damage to the regions of interest. The tips were sharpened by multi-step gallium (Ga) ion milling at 30 kV, with progressively reduced ion-beam currents, followed by final low-energy cleaning at 2 kV and 8 pA to minimise FIB-induced damage and remove the severely damaged surface regions produced by the Ga ion source. The final tip radii were approximately ∼ 50 nm. Atomic-scale compositional analysis across the γ/γ′\gamma/\gamma^{\prime} interfaces was performed using a local electrode atom probe, LEAP™ 5000XR (Cameca Instruments Inc.), operated in laser-pulsing mode. Ultraviolet picosecond laser pulses were applied at a repetition rate of 125 kHz, with a laser pulse energy of 55 pJ. The target detection rate was maintained at 0.5%, and the specimen base temperature was kept at 70 K during analysis. Data reconstruction and preliminary compositional analysis were carried out using IVAS™ 3.8.10 software.

Results

Microstructure after ageing at 900 °C for 50 h

Figure 2(aFigure 1–aFigure 3 shows back-scattered-electron (BSE) SEM images of the B–10Co, B–20Co, and B–30Co alloys after ageing at 900 °C for 50 h. All three alloys exhibit a two-phase γ/γ′\gamma/\gamma^{\prime} microstructure, with systematic changes in the size, volume fraction, and morphology of the γ′\gamma^{\prime} precipitates as a function of Co content. With increasing Co content, the γ′\gamma^{\prime} precipitates become progressively finer. Quantitative stereological measurements reveal a decrease in the average γ′\gamma^{\prime} precipitate radius from ∼106\sim106 nm for B–10Co to ∼82\sim82 nm for B–20Co and ∼75\sim75 nm for B–30Co, accompanied by a decrease in the γ′\gamma^{\prime} volume fraction. Supplementary Figure S1(i) shows the corresponding low-magnification images used for the precipitate-size-distribution analysis presented in Supplementary Figure S3(i).

Back-scattered-electron SEM images, APT reconstructions, and elemental proxigrams for B–10Co, B–20Co, and B–30Co alloys

Figure 2. Back-scattered-electron (BSE) SEM images of (a1) B–10Co, (a2) B–20Co, and (a3) B–30Co alloys showing the γ/γ′\gamma/\gamma' microstructure. APT reconstructions showing the distribution of Al, Ti, Cr, Ni, and Co across the γ/γ′\gamma/\gamma' microstructure are shown for (b1) B–10Co, (b2) B–20Co, and (b3) B–30Co. The corresponding elemental proxigrams in (c1–c3) illustrate the compositional profiles across the γ/γ′\gamma/\gamma' interfaces, highlighting the elemental partitioning behaviour in the respective alloys.

Solute partitioning coefficients and differential scanning calorimetry heating curves for B–10Co, B–20Co, and B–30Co alloys

Figure 3. (a) Comparison of solute partitioning coefficients across the γ/γ′\gamma/\gamma' interfaces in B–10Co, B–20Co, and B–30Co alloys. (b) Differential scanning calorimetry (DSC) heating curves for the aged alloys, showing the decrease in the γ′\gamma' solvus temperature with increasing Co content.

Precipitate morphology was further evaluated using the shape factor, χ=4πA/P2\chi= 4\pi A/P^{2}, where AA is the precipitate area and PP is the precipitate perimeter [29]. Values of χ\chi close to 1 indicate a nearly spherical morphology, whereas values in the range of 0.8–0.9 indicate rounded-cuboidal precipitates. The estimated shape factor values are 0.85 for B–10Co, 0.84 for B–20Co, and 0.83 for B–30Co, indicating that the precipitates retain a rounded-cuboidal morphology with increasing Co content. This suggests that Co addition reduces the precipitate size while maintaining shape uniformity. The measured density of all three alloys is approximately 7.44 g cm−3^{-3}, which is lower than that of conventional Ni-based and Co-based superalloys [30].

Atomic-scale compositional analysis: To accurately quantify elemental partitioning between the γ\gamma and γ′\gamma^{\prime} phases, atom probe tomography (APT) experiments were conducted on B–10Co, B–20Co, and B–30Co alloys aged at 900 °C for 50 h. Figure 2(bFigure 1–bFigure 3 shows the APT reconstructions for the three alloys, displaying the spatial distribution of Ni, Co, Cr, Ti, and Al atoms.

The γ/γ′\gamma/\gamma^{\prime} interface was identified using iso-composition surfaces of 50 at % Ni for B–10Co, 45 at % Ni for B–20Co, and 35 at % Ni for B–30Co. The γ′\gamma^{\prime} precipitates are surrounded by γ\gamma channels, with the phase distinction made based on preferential solute partitioning: Ni, Al, and Ti partition preferentially to γ′\gamma^{\prime}, whereas Co and Cr partition preferentially to the γ\gamma matrix [31, 32]. The comparison of solute partitioning coefficients across the γ/γ′\gamma/\gamma^{\prime} interfaces is shown in Figure 3(a), while the corresponding measured phase compositions and partitioning coefficients are listed in Table 1.

Alloy / PhaseNi (at.%)Cr (at.%)Co (at.%)Al (at.%)Ti (at.%)
B–10Co (γ\gamma)40.2 ± 1.231.2 ± 1.120.8 ± 1.03.8 ± 0.52.9 ± 0.4
B–10Co (γ′\gamma')65.5 ± 0.32.7 ± 0.16.6 ± 0.214.3 ± 0.210.7 ± 0.2
B–10Co (K±σK \pm\sigma)1.6 ± 0.10.1 ± 0.10.3 ± 0.13.8 ± 0.53.7 ± 0.5
B–20Co (γ\gamma)37.0 ± 0.621.6 ± 0.533.4 ± 0.54.2 ± 0.23.8 ± 0.2
B–20Co (γ′\gamma')58.3 ± 0.52.5 ± 0.214.6 ± 0.411.0 ± 0.313.6 ± 0.4
B–20Co (K±σK \pm\sigma)1.6 ± 0.10.1 ± 0.10.4 ± 0.12.6 ± 0.23.6 ± 0.2
B–30Co (γ\gamma)22.9 ± 0.425.7 ± 0.544.2 ± 0.55.1 ± 0.22.2 ± 0.2
B–30Co (γ′\gamma')46.0 ± 0.74.0 ± 0.326.3 ± 0.612.1 ± 0.511.6 ± 0.5
B–30Co (K±σK \pm\sigma)2.0 ± 0.10.2 ± 0.10.6 ± 0.12.4 ± 0.15.3 ± 0.2

Table 1. Measured compositions of γ\gamma and γ′\gamma' phases in the B–10Co, B–20Co, and B–30Co alloys after ageing at 900 °C for 50 h, together with the corresponding partitioning coefficients, K=Ciγ′/CiγK = C_i^{\gamma'}/C_i^\gamma.

The composition of γ′\gamma^{\prime} indicates a stoichiometry close to (Co,Ni,Cr)3(Al,Ti)(\mathrm{Co},\mathrm{Ni},\mathrm{Cr})_{3}(\mathrm{Al},\mathrm{Ti}), consistent with an A3_{3}B-type L12_{2} crystal structure. In this structure, Co, Ni, and Cr occupy the A sublattice positions, while Al and Ti occupy the B sublattice positions [33]. Specifically, the (Ni+Co+Cr)/(Al+Ti)(\mathrm{Ni}+\mathrm{Co}+\mathrm{Cr})/(\mathrm{Al}+\mathrm{Ti}) ratio in the γ′\gamma^{\prime} phase is close to ∼3\sim3 for all alloys. This ratio is further used to estimate the approximate sublattice occupancy of elements and to infer the effect of phase chemistry on the thermophysical properties, as discussed in § 4.1.

Volume fraction of phases as a function of nominal Co content: Stereological analysis of the microstructure images reveals a decrease in the γ′\gamma' volume fraction from 0.753 for B–10Co to 0.635 for B–30Co. This decreasing trend is consistent with the γ\gamma volume fraction estimated from APT composition measurements using the lever rule.

AlloyApprox. Ni:Co:Cr ratio in γ\gammaApprox. Ni:Co ratio in γ′\gamma'Approx. Al:Ti ratio in γ′\gamma'
B–10Co2:1:22:0.21.3:1
B–20Co2:2:12:0.50.8:1
B–30Co1:2:12:1.11.0:1

Table 2. Approximate elemental ratios describing the chemistry of the γ\gamma matrix and γ′\gamma' precipitates determined from APT measurements.

Since the microstructure contains only γ\gamma and γ′\gamma' phases with similar densities, the γ′\gamma' volume fraction, fγ′f_{\gamma'}, was estimated using:

fγ′=Cialloy−CiγCiγ′−Ciγ(4)f_{\gamma'} = \frac{C_i^{\mathrm{alloy}} - C_i^\gamma}{C_i^{\gamma'} - C_i^\gamma} \tag*{(4)}

The regression slopes yield direct estimates of the γ′\gamma' volume fractions, as shown in Figure 4. The decrease in γ′\gamma' volume fraction with increasing Co content can be attributed primarily to the reduction in Al partitioning to the γ′\gamma' phase.

Plots of the lever-rule calculations for B–10Co, B–20Co, and B–30Co alloys

Figure 4. Plot of (Cialloy−Ciγ′)(C_i^{\mathrm{alloy}} - C_i^{\gamma'}) against (Ciγ′−Ciγ)(C_i^{\gamma'} - C_i^\gamma) used to determine the γ′\gamma' volume fraction in (a) B–10Co, (b) B–20Co, and (c) B–30Co alloys via the lever rule.

Comparison of γ/γ′\gamma/\gamma^{\prime} lattice misfit as a function of Co content

Figure 5 shows the X-ray diffraction peak of the (200) reflection from all three alloys. The peaks were deconvoluted using a pseudo-Voigt function. The γ\gamma and γ′\gamma^{\prime} peaks were distinguished based on their relative peak intensities and full width at half maximum. The broader and more intense peak was attributed to γ′\gamma^{\prime}, consistent with its higher volume fraction and finer size distribution in the microstructure. The calculated constrained γ/γ′\gamma/\gamma^{\prime} lattice misfit values for the B–10Co, B–20Co, and B–30Co alloys, based on the extracted lattice parameters, are summarized in Table 3 and plotted in Figure 2(d–Figure 2f).

Alloyγ′\gamma^{\prime} lattice parameter (Å)γ\gamma lattice parameter (Å)Lattice misfit (%)
B–10Co3.5823.5720.25
B–20Co3.5833.5740.26
B–30Co3.5853.5650.28

Table 3. Lattice parameters and constrained lattice misfits derived from XRD measurements for B–10Co, B–20Co, and B–30Co alloys.

X-ray diffraction analysis of B–10Co, B–20Co, and B–30Co alloys, with lattice parameter and lattice misfit plots

Figure 5. X-ray diffraction (XRD) analysis of (a) B–10Co, (b) B–20Co, and (c) B–30Co alloys after ageing at 900 °C for 50 h. Deconvolution of the (200) peak intensity using pseudo-Voigt functions reveals two contributions from the γ\gamma and γ′\gamma^{\prime} phases.

The misfit values for all three alloys are positive, unlike most commercial Ni-based superalloys [34], which typically exhibit negative misfit. These alloys therefore resemble Co-based superalloys in terms of the sign of misfit, indicating a larger γ′\gamma^{\prime} unit cell relative to the γ\gamma matrix [35]. Lattice misfit depends on elemental partitioning across the γ/γ′\gamma/\gamma^{\prime} interface and on the site occupancy of solutes in the ordered L12_2 γ′\gamma^{\prime} unit cell.

Coarsening kinetics of precipitates as a function of Co content

The temporal evolution of γ′\gamma' precipitates in B–10Co, B–20Co, and B–30Co alloys was investigated during isothermal annealing at 900 °C, 950 °C, and 1000 °C. Figure 6 presents representative BSE SEM images for the alloys annealed at these temperatures for selected durations.

Representative SEM micrographs of the B–10Co, B–20Co, and B–30Co alloys isothermally heat-treated at 900 °C, 950 °C, and 1000 °C

Figure 6. Representative SEM micrographs of the B–10Co, B–20Co, and B–30Co alloys isothermally heat-treated at 900 °C, 950 °C, and 1000 °C, showing microstructural evolution during isothermal holding for 50, 500, and 1000 h.

Microstructures after isothermal annealing at 900 °C

The microstructures show that the γ′\gamma' precipitates are uniformly distributed with a rounded-cuboidal morphology up to 1000 h in all three alloys. There is no indication of directional coarsening, rafting, or coalescence within the grains or at grain boundaries, indicating good microstructural stability. Even after 1000 h, similar morphology persists, with no evidence of secondary phases such as topologically close-packed phases. Quantitative stereological analysis shows that the mean γ′\gamma' precipitate radius, ⟨r⟩\langle r \rangle, increases with time, consistent with Ostwald ripening.

Microstructure after isothermal annealing at 950 °C and 1000 °C

At both temperatures, the γ′\gamma' precipitates retained a rounded-cuboidal morphology. Precipitate coarsening was evident from the progressive increase in ⟨r⟩\langle r \rangle with time. After 1000 h of ageing, the mean precipitate sizes were 366 ± 61 nm for B–10Co, 313 ± 59 nm for B–20Co, and 239 ± 29 nm for B–30Co at 950 °C; and 494 ± 16 nm for B–10Co, 446 ± 6 nm for B–20Co, and 416 ± 43 nm for B–30Co at 1000 °C. These values indicate slower coarsening with increasing Co content.

Comparison of evolution of rr as a function of time and Co content

To isolate coarsening from concurrent nucleation and growth processes, all samples were peak-aged prior to extended exposures. Log–log plots of average precipitate radius, ⟨r⟩\langle r \rangle, versus time were constructed at each temperature to assess coarsening kinetics under thermodynamically stable conditions.

To isolate coarsening from concurrent nucleation and growth processes, all samples were peak-aged prior to extended exposures. Log–log plots of average precipitate radius, ⟨r⟩\langle r \rangle, versus ageing time were constructed at each temperature to assess coarsening kinetics under thermodynamically stable conditions.

Table 4: Coarsening rate constants, KrK_r, at 900 °C, 950 °C, and 1000 °C, and activation energies for γ′\gamma' coarsening in B–10Co, B–20Co, and B–30Co alloys derived from ⟨r(t)⟩3\langle r(t) \rangle^3 versus ageing-time plots and Arrhenius-type analysis.

Supplementary Figure S3 shows the temporal evolution of ⟨r⟩\langle r \rangle at 900 °C, 950 °C, and 1000 °C, respectively, by plotting log⁡⟨r⟩\log\langle r \rangle against log⁡t\log t. The corresponding ⟨r⟩3\langle r \rangle^{3} versus tt plots are shown in Figure 7. The calculated temporal exponents and coarsening rate constants indicate matrix-diffusion-controlled coarsening kinetics [37]. At 900 °C, KrK_r decreases from 8.98 nm3^{3} s−1^{-1} for B–10Co to 4.28 nm3^{3} s−1^{-1} for B–20Co and 1.73 nm3^{3} s−1^{-1} for B–30Co. A similar trend is observed at 950 °C and 1000 °C, as summarized in Table 4. These results indicate that coarsening accelerates with increasing temperature for all three alloys, while increasing Co content systematically reduces the coarsening rate at each ageing temperature.

AlloyActivation energy, QQ (kJ mol−1^{-1})KrK_r at 900 °C (nm3^3 s−1^{-1})KrK_r at 950 °C (nm3^3 s−1^{-1})KrK_r at 1000 °C (nm3^3 s−1^{-1})
B–10Co155.748.9812.5731.75
B–20Co215.394.288.3524.41
B–30Co302.011.733.7619.96

Table 4.

Temporal evolution of $\gamma'$ precipitates and coarsening behaviour in B–xCo alloys

Figure 7. Temporal evolution of γ′\gamma' precipitates in B–10Co, B–20Co, and B–30Co alloys during isothermal ageing at (a) 900 °C, (b) 950 °C, and (c) 1000 °C. The plots of ⟨r(t)⟩3\langle r(t)\rangle^3 versus ageing time demonstrate a linear trend indicative of diffusion-controlled coarsening. The slope of each linear fit provides the coarsening rate constant, KrK_r. (d) Summary of coarsening rate constants for B–xCo alloys compared with selected commercial superalloys and back-calculated KrK_r values at 900 °C, 950 °C, and 1000 °C [36]. (e) Arrhenius plot of ln⁡(Kr)\ln(K_r) versus 1000/T1000/T used to extract the activation energy for γ′\gamma' coarsening.

The coarsening process is thermally activated and follows an Arrhenius-type relationship between the coarsening rate constant, KrK_r, and absolute temperature, TT, expressed as [38]:

Kr=K0exp⁡(−QRT)(5)K_r = K_0 \exp\left(-\frac{Q}{RT}\right) \tag*{(5)}

where K0K_0 is the pre-exponential factor, QQ is the activation energy for coarsening, RR is the universal gas constant, and TT is the absolute temperature in Kelvin. By plotting ln⁡(Kr)\ln(K_r) against 1/T1/T, the activation energy can be extracted from the slope of the fitted linear curve, as shown in Figure 7(e).

The calculated activation energies for coarsening are 155.74 kJ mol−1^{-1} for B–10Co, 215.39 kJ mol−1^{-1} for B–20Co, and 302.01 kJ mol−1^{-1} for B–30Co. The activation energy for B–30Co is therefore nearly twice that of B–10Co, indicating a substantially higher energy barrier for solute redistribution during γ′\gamma' coarsening. Since the coarsening behaviour is primarily governed by matrix diffusion, the higher activation energy in B–30Co suggests that Co enrichment of the γ\gamma matrix slows solute transport and enhances the thermal stability of the γ′\gamma' precipitates.

Discussion

Effect of Co partitioning on γ/γ′\gamma/\gamma' phase chemistry and γ′\gamma' solvus temperature

A reduction in the γ′\gamma' solvus temperature is observed with increasing Co content, decreasing from ∼1250\sim1250 °C for B–10Co to ∼1185\sim1185 °C for B–30Co. This reduction cannot be explained solely by the nominal Co-for-Ni substitution, but is closely linked to the accompanying changes in γ/γ′\gamma/\gamma' elemental partitioning and the resulting modification of the L12_2 γ′\gamma' chemistry. With increasing Co content, the partitioning coefficient of Al decreases from KAl∼3.8K_{\mathrm{Al}} \sim3.8 to ∼2.4\sim2.4, whereas the partitioning coefficients of Ti, Ni, and Co increase from KTi∼3.6K_{\mathrm{Ti}} \sim3.6 to ∼5.3\sim5.3, KNi∼1.6K_{\mathrm{Ni}} \sim1.6 to ∼2.0\sim2.0, and KCo∼0.3K_{\mathrm{Co}} \sim0.3 to ∼0.6\sim0.6, respectively. This indicates that the γ′\gamma^\prime phase becomes progressively enriched in Ti, Ni, and Co, while the relative Al enrichment in γ′\gamma^\prime decreases.

The decrease in γ′\gamma^\prime solvus temperature with increasing Co content can therefore be rationalized by the combined effect of three factors. First, the reduction in Al partitioning weakens the conventional Ni3Al\mathrm{Ni_3Al}-type L12\mathrm{L1_2} chemistry, which is primarily responsible for the high γ′\gamma^\prime ordering stability in Ni-based superalloys. Second, the increased enrichment of Co and Ti in γ′\gamma^\prime enhances the probability of Co–Ti and Ni–Ti bonding within the L12\mathrm{L1_2} unit cell. Although Ni3Ti\mathrm{Ni_3Ti} does not crystallize in the L12\mathrm{L1_2} structure in the binary Ni–Ti system, the Co–Ti binary system contains a stable L12\mathrm{L1_2} Co3Ti\mathrm{Co_3Ti} phase with a considerably lower solvus temperature of ∼1005\sim1005 °C [39, 40]. Third, increased Co and Cr contents are known to reduce the ordering energy of the L12\mathrm{L1_2} Ni3Al\mathrm{Ni_3Al} structure [41]. Hence, the observed reduction in γ′\gamma^\prime solvus temperature is attributed to the combined effects of reduced Al partitioning, increased Co–Ti/Ni–Ti bonding tendency, and reduced L12\mathrm{L1_2} ordering stability.

The Co-induced changes in phase chemistry also influence the γ/γ′\gamma/\gamma^\prime lattice parameters and lattice misfit. Both γ\gamma and γ′\gamma^\prime lattice parameters show a marginal decrease with increasing Co content. However, the positive γ/γ′\gamma/\gamma^\prime lattice misfit increases from ∼0.25%\sim0.25\% in B–10Co to ∼0.28%\sim0.28\% in B–30Co, indicating that the contraction of the γ\gamma matrix is relatively greater than that of the γ′\gamma^\prime phase. This trend can be understood from the APT-derived elemental partitioning. With increasing Co content, the γ\gamma matrix is progressively enriched in Co and depleted in Ni, while Ti shows a substantial reduction in the γ\gamma phase, particularly from B–20Co to B–30Co. Since Ti has a relatively large atomic radius of ∼147\sim147 pm, its depletion from the γ\gamma matrix contributes significantly to the contraction of the γ\gamma lattice parameter.

In contrast, the lattice parameter of the γ′\gamma^\prime phase is controlled by competing effects. Based on the measured phase compositions, Co is inferred to substitute primarily on the Ni sublattice, whereas Ti substitutes on the Al sublattice of the L12\mathrm{L1_2} structure. This substitution increases the fraction of Co–Ti bonds in γ′\gamma^\prime. The L12\mathrm{L1_2} Co3Ti\mathrm{Co_3Ti} phase has a larger lattice parameter of ∼3.606\sim3.606 Å compared with ∼3.570\sim3.570 Å for Ni3Al\mathrm{Ni_3Al} [39, 40]. In addition, first-principles calculations have shown that Co–Ni and Ti–Ni bonding environments in L12\mathrm{L1_2} Co–Ti-containing alloys can introduce stronger and more directional bonding than the native Ni–Al bonds, generating additional steric strain and promoting lattice expansion [42]. However, this expansion tendency is partly offset by the substantial reduction in Ni content in γ′\gamma^\prime, from ∼65\sim65 at.% in B–10Co to ∼46\sim46 at.% in B–30Co. As a result, the γ′\gamma^\prime lattice parameter decreases only marginally, whereas the γ\gamma matrix contracts more strongly. The relatively greater contraction of γ\gamma compared with γ′\gamma^\prime therefore leads to the observed increase in positive γ/γ′\gamma/\gamma^\prime lattice misfit with increasing Co content.

Coarsening resistance and multicomponent solute transport

The coarsening of γ′\gamma^{\prime} precipitates was analysed within the framework of Ostwald ripening, where larger precipitates grow at the expense of smaller ones to reduce the total interfacial area. The earliest Lifshitz–Slyozov–Wagner (LSW) model was developed for dilute binary systems containing a vanishingly small precipitate volume fraction [43, 44]. This dilute-limit assumption is not applicable to the present alloys, where the γ′\gamma^{\prime} volume fraction is greater than 0.6, ranging from ϕ=0.635\phi= 0.635 for B–30Co to ϕ=0.753\phi= 0.753 for B–10Co. In addition, the present Ni–Co–Cr–Al–Ti system is not a dilute binary alloy consisting of a single solute in a matrix, but a concentrated multicomponent γ/γ′\gamma/\gamma^{\prime} alloy. Therefore, γ′\gamma^{\prime} coarsening involves the coupled redistribution of Ni, Cr, Co, Al, and Ti across the γ/γ′\gamma/\gamma^{\prime} interface.

Subsequent LSW-based treatments account for finite precipitate volume fraction [45] and multicomponent diffusion effects [46]. These modified theories generally retain the characteristic t1/3t^{1/3} coarsening dependence, but the rate constant becomes more complex because it depends on precipitate volume fraction, interfacial energy, phase compositions, and the diffusivities of all solutes participating in redistribution across the γ/γ′\gamma/\gamma^{\prime} interface. Therefore, the coarsening kinetics of the γ′\gamma^{\prime} precipitates in the present alloys were first evaluated from the temporal evolution of the mean precipitate radius using:

⟨rt⟩3−⟨r0⟩3=Kexpt(6)\langle r_t \rangle^3 - \langle r_0 \rangle^3 = K_{\mathrm{exp}}t \tag*{(6)}

where ⟨rt⟩\langle r_t \rangle is the mean γ′\gamma^{\prime} precipitate radius after ageing time tt, ⟨r0⟩\langle r_0 \rangle is the initial mean precipitate radius, and KexpK_{\mathrm{exp}} is the experimentally measured coarsening-rate constant. For a concentrated multicomponent γ/γ′\gamma/\gamma^{\prime} alloy, KexpK_{\mathrm{exp}} can be related to the dilute-limit LSW coefficient by including corrections for finite precipitate volume fraction and precipitate morphology:

Kexp=AKLSWf(ϕ)χ(7)K_{\mathrm{exp}} = A K_{\mathrm{LSW}} f(\phi)\chi \tag*{(7)}

where AA is the prefactor correction, f(ϕ)f(\phi) is the finite-volume-fraction correction factor, ϕ\phi is the γ′\gamma^{\prime} volume fraction, and χ\chi is the precipitate shape factor. The finite-volume-fraction correction factor was evaluated using the analytical correction adopted for high-volume-fraction γ′\gamma^{\prime} coarsening [45, 47]. In this form, the volume-fraction-corrected coarsening coefficient is written as:

Kϕ=KLSWf(ϕ)(8)K_{\phi} = K_{\mathrm{LSW}} f(\phi) \tag*{(8)}

where f(ϕ)f(\phi) is given by:

f(ϕ)=274[2−(1−3ϕ)(1−13ϕ+13ϕ+13ϕ+1)(1−13ϕ+13ϕ+13ϕ+1)3](9)f(\phi)=\frac{27}{4}\left[\frac{2-\left(1-\sqrt{3\phi}\right)\left(1-\frac{1}{\sqrt{3\phi}}+\sqrt{\frac{1}{3\phi}+\frac{1}{3\phi}+1}\right)}{\left(1-\frac{1}{\sqrt{3\phi}}+\sqrt{\frac{1}{3\phi}+\frac{1}{3\phi}+1}\right)^3}\right] \tag*{(9)}

For the present alloys, Equation (9) gives f(0.753)=3.431f(0.753)=3.431 for B–10Co, f(0.704)=3.348f(0.704)=3.348 for B–20Co, and f(0.635)=3.227f(0.635)=3.227 for B–30Co. Thus, although the high γ′\gamma' volume fraction must be explicitly accounted for, the correction varies only weakly across the present composition range.

The multicomponent LSW coefficient was expressed in terms of the resistance to solute redistribution through the γ\gamma matrix:

KLSW=8σVm9RT[∑i(ΔCi)2DiγCiγ]−1,i=Ni,Cr,Co,Al,Ti(10)K_{\mathrm{LSW}}=\frac{8\sigma V_m}{9RT}\left[\sum_i\frac{(\Delta C_i)^2}{D_i^\gamma C_i^\gamma}\right]^{-1},\qquad i=\mathrm{Ni},\mathrm{Cr},\mathrm{Co},\mathrm{Al},\mathrm{Ti} \tag*{(10)}

where σ\sigma is the apparent γ/γ′\gamma/\gamma' interfacial-energy term, VmV_m is the molar volume, RR is the universal gas constant, TT is the absolute temperature, ΔCi=∣Ciγ′−Ciγ∣\Delta C_i=\lvert C_i^{\gamma'}-C_i^\gamma\rvert is the composition difference of element ii between the γ′\gamma' precipitate and the γ\gamma matrix, DiγD_i^\gamma is the tracer diffusivity of element ii in the γ\gamma matrix, and CiγC_i^\gamma is the corresponding matrix composition.

The summation term in Equation (10) represents the cumulative resistance offered by all solutes that must redistribute during γ′\gamma' coarsening. This multicomponent solute-transport resistance, SS, is defined as:

S=∑i(ΔCi)2DiγCiγ(11)S=\sum_i\frac{(\Delta C_i)^2}{D_i^\gamma C_i^\gamma} \tag*{(11)}

A high value of SS indicates that coarsening is kinetically restricted either because the relevant solute diffuses slowly in the γ\gamma matrix, because it exhibits a large composition difference across the γ/γ′\gamma/\gamma' interface, or because both effects operate simultaneously. Rearranging Equation (10) allows the apparent interfacial-energy term to be estimated from the experimentally measured coarsening rate:

σ=Kexp⁡9RT8VmSAf(ϕ)χ(12)\sigma=K_{\exp}\frac{9RT}{8V_m}\frac{S}{Af(\phi)\chi} \tag*{(12)}

All calculations were carried out at 900 °C using T=1173.15T=1173.15 K, R=8.314R=8.314 J mol−1^{-1} K−1^{-1}, and Vm=7.12×10−6V_m=7.12\times10^{-6} m3^3 mol−1^{-1}. The prefactor correction, AA, was evaluated from thermokinetic precipitation simulations performed using Thermo-Calc with the TCNI11 thermodynamic database and the MOBNI5 mobility database. In the simulations, the alloy compositions and ageing temperature were fixed, and simulated coarsening-rate constants were obtained for the corresponding γ/γ′\gamma/\gamma' systems. The simulated values were then compared iteratively with the experimentally measured coarsening-rate constants by adjusting the prefactor in Equation (7). A common value of A=1.67A=1.67 gave the best simultaneous agreement with the experimental coarsening rates of B–10Co and B–30Co and was therefore used for the apparent interfacial-energy evaluation.

Solute-transport resistance and apparent interfacial-energy evaluation

The calculated resistance terms show that Co addition changes the solute-transport pathway controlling γ′\gamma' coarsening, as summarized in Table 5. In B–10Co, the total transport resistance is 8.811×1015 s m−28.811 \times10^{15}\ \mathrm{s\,m^{-2}}, with the largest contributions arising from Cr and Ni. These elements contribute 35.4% and 32.2% of the total resistance, respectively, indicating that γ′\gamma' coarsening in B–10Co is primarily controlled by redistribution within the Ni–Cr-rich γ\gamma matrix. In contrast, the total resistance increases to 1.267×1016 s m−21.267 \times10^{16}\ \mathrm{s\,m^{-2}} in B–30Co, and Co becomes the largest contributor, accounting for 36.2% of SS. Ni and Cr still provide substantial contributions, but the dominant transport pathway shifts from Ni–Cr-controlled in B–10Co to Co-assisted Ni–Co–Cr-controlled in B–30Co.

AlloyElementDiγD_i^{\gamma} (m2^2s$−1{}^{-1}) | ΔCi\Delta C_i | DiγCiγD_i^{\gamma}C_i^{\gamma} (m2^2s$−1{}^{-1})Si=(ΔCi)2/(DiγCiγ)S_i = (\Delta C_i)^2/(D_i^{\gamma}C_i^{\gamma}) (s m−2^{-2})Contribution to SS (%)
B–10CoNi5.62×10−175.62 \times10^{-17}0.2532.259×10−172.259 \times10^{-17}2.834×10152.834 \times10^{15}32.2
Cr8.35×10−178.35 \times10^{-17}0.2852.605×10−172.605 \times10^{-17}3.118×10153.118 \times10^{15}35.4
Co1.01×10−161.01 \times10^{-16}0.1422.101×10−172.101 \times10^{-17}9.597×10149.597 \times10^{14}10.9
Al2.79×10−162.79 \times10^{-16}0.1051.060×10−171.060 \times10^{-17}1.040×10151.040 \times10^{15}11.8
Ti2.44×10−162.44 \times10^{-16}0.0780.7076×10−170.7076 \times10^{-17}8.598×10148.598 \times10^{14}9.8
Total–––8.811×10158.811 \times10^{15}100
B–30CoNi6.38×10−176.38 \times10^{-17}0.2311.461×10−171.461 \times10^{-17}3.652×10153.652 \times10^{15}28.8
Cr7.29×10−177.29 \times10^{-17}0.2171.874×10−171.874 \times10^{-17}2.513×10152.513 \times10^{15}19.8
Co1.58×10−171.58 \times10^{-17}0.1790.6984×10−170.6984 \times10^{-17}4.588×10154.588 \times10^{15}36.2
Al4.37×10−164.37 \times10^{-16}0.0702.229×10−172.229 \times10^{-17}2.198×10142.198 \times10^{14}1.7
Ti2.37×10−162.37 \times10^{-16}0.0940.5214×10−170.5214 \times10^{-17}1.695×10151.695 \times10^{15}13.4
Total–––1.267×10161.267 \times10^{16}100

Table 5. Element-wise diffusivity and solute-transport resistance terms calculated for B–10Co and B–30Co aged at 900 °C. Bold values indicate the largest resistance contributions to SS. Detailed derivation and full resistance analysis are provided in Supplementary Note 1.

This change is important because Co is not merely a passive matrix-forming element in the present alloys. Although Co partitions less strongly to γ′\gamma' than Ti or Al, the absolute composition difference of Co across the γ/γ′\gamma/\gamma' interface becomes large in B–30Co. Combined with its reduced diffusivity in the Co-rich γ\gamma matrix, this makes Co a major contributor to the solute flux required for precipitate coarsening. Therefore, the improved coarsening resistance of B–30Co arises from a collective multicomponent transport effect rather than from a single slow-diffusing solute.

Using the same correction factors, the apparent γ/γ′\gamma/\gamma' interfacial-energy term decreases from 25.0 mJ m−225.0\,\mathrm{mJ\,m^{-2}} for B–10Co to 7.55 mJ m−27.55\,\mathrm{mJ\,m^{-2}} for B–30Co, as shown in Table 6. The finite-volume-fraction correction varies only slightly over this composition range, decreasing from f(ϕ)=3.431f(\phi) = 3.431 for B–10Co to f(ϕ)=3.227f(\phi) = 3.227 for B–30Co. The ratio f(0.753)/f(0.635)=1.063f(0.753)/f(0.635) = 1.063 indicates that the difference in γ′\gamma' volume fraction would account for only a small change in the coarsening rate. This is much smaller than the experimentally observed coarsening-rate ratio, KrB–10Co/KrB–30Co=8.98/1.73=5.19K_{\mathrm{r}}^{\mathrm{B\text{–}10Co}}/K_{\mathrm{r}}^{\mathrm{B\text{–}30Co}} = 8.98/1.73 = 5.19. Thus, the large reduction in coarsening rate with increasing Co content cannot be explained by finite-volume-fraction effects alone. Instead, it results from the simultaneous increase in multicomponent solute-transport resistance and decrease in the apparent interfacial-energy term.

AlloyKexpK_{\mathrm{exp}} (nm3^{3}s−1^{-1})SS (s m−2^{-2})ϕ\phif(ϕ)f(\phi)χ\chiσ\sigma (mJ m−2^{-2})
B–10Co8.988.811×10158.811 \times10^{15}0.7533.4310.8525.0
B–20Co4.288.529×10158.529 \times10^{15}0.7043.3480.8413.2
B–30Co1.731.267×10161.267 \times10^{16}0.6353.2270.837.55

Table 6. Prefactor-corrected apparent γ/γ′\gamma/\gamma' interfacial-energy term calculated for alloys aged at 900 °C.

The σ\sigma values obtained here should therefore be treated as apparent interfacial-energy terms rather than equilibrium γ/γ′\gamma/\gamma' interfacial energies, because the calculation uses tracer diffusivities and assumes diagonal transport without explicitly considering cross-diffusion or thermodynamic interaction terms. Nevertheless, the analysis provides a useful comparative measure of how Co addition modifies the kinetic pathway for γ′\gamma' coarsening. Overall, increasing Co content transforms the coarsening process from a primarily Ni–Cr-controlled transport pathway in B–10Co to a Co-assisted multicomponent transport-controlled pathway in B–30Co, thereby stabilizing the γ/γ′\gamma/\gamma' microstructure at 900 °C.

Conclusions

This work examined the effect of increasing Co content in Ti-rich Ni–Co–Cr–Al–Ti γ/γ′\gamma/\gamma' superalloys on the γ′\gamma' coarsening behaviour. The following conclusions can be drawn from the present work:

  • All three alloys show a two-phase γ/γ′\gamma/\gamma' microstructure after heat treatment, without detectable secondary phases within the resolution of the present SEM/XRD analysis. Increasing Co from B–10Co to B–30Co refines the mean γ′\gamma' precipitate radius from ∼106\sim106 nm to ∼75\sim75 nm, while reducing the γ′\gamma' volume fraction from ∼75.3%\sim75.3\% to ∼63.5%\sim63.5\%. APT analysis shows that the γ′\gamma' precipitates retain an A3_3B-type L12_2 stoichiometry close to (Ni,Co,Cr)3_3(Al,Ti). With increasing Co, Ti partitioning to γ′\gamma' increases, whereas Al partitioning decreases, indicating progressive Ti substitution on the B sublattice of the L12_2 unit cell. Concurrently, the γ\gamma matrix evolves from a relatively Ni–Cr-rich matrix in B–10Co, with an approximate Ni:Co:Cr ratio of 2:1:2, to a more balanced Ni–Co–Cr matrix in B–20Co, with Ni:Co:Cr ∼\sim2:2:1, and finally to a Co-enriched matrix in B–30Co, with Ni:Co:Cr ∼\sim1:2:1. Thus, systematic Co-for-Ni substitution establishes distinct MEA-type γ\gamma-matrix environments across the alloy series.

  • Increasing Co content decreases the γ′\gamma' solvus temperature from ∼1250 ∘C\sim1250\,^{\circ}\mathrm{C} in B–10Co to ∼1185 ∘C\sim1185\,^{\circ}\mathrm{C} in B–30Co. At the same time, the constrained γ/γ′\gamma/\gamma' lattice misfit increases slightly from approximately +0.25%+0.25\% to +0.28%+0.28\%. Thus, B–30Co exhibits better coarsening resistance despite having a lower γ′\gamma' solvus temperature and a slightly higher positive lattice misfit, showing that solvus temperature and lattice misfit alone do not control the coarsening response.

  • B–30Co exhibits the slowest γ′\gamma' coarsening kinetics among the investigated alloys, with coarsening rate constants of ∼1.73 nm3 s−1\sim1.73\,\mathrm{nm}^{3}\,\mathrm{s}^{-1} at 900 ∘C900\,^{\circ}\mathrm{C}, ∼3.85 nm3 s−1\sim3.85\,\mathrm{nm}^{3}\,\mathrm{s}^{-1} at 950 ∘C950\,^{\circ}\mathrm{C}, and ∼7.46 nm3 s−1\sim7.46\,\mathrm{nm}^{3}\,\mathrm{s}^{-1} at 1000 ∘C1000\,^{\circ}\mathrm{C}. The apparent activation energy for coarsening increases from ∼155.7 kJ mol−1\sim155.7\,\mathrm{kJ}\,\mathrm{mol}^{-1} for B–10Co to ∼302.0 kJ mol−1\sim302.0\,\mathrm{kJ}\,\mathrm{mol}^{-1} for B–30Co, confirming that Co enrichment in the γ\gamma matrix strongly modifies the solute-redistribution pathway during γ′\gamma' coarsening.

  • The prefactor-corrected multicomponent LSW analysis shows that coarsening resistance is governed by the combined effects of elemental diffusivity and γ/γ′\gamma/\gamma' compositional partitioning through the transport-resistance term, S=∑i(ΔCi)2DiγCiγS = \sum_i \frac{(\Delta C_i)^2}{D_i^\gamma C_i^\gamma}. The total transport resistance increases from ∼8.811×1015 s m−2\sim8.811 \times10^{15}\,\mathrm{s}\,\mathrm{m}^{-2} for B–10Co to ∼1.267×1016 s m−2\sim1.267 \times10^{16}\,\mathrm{s}\,\mathrm{m}^{-2} for B–30Co, with the dominant resistance pathway shifting from primarily Ni–Cr controlled in B–10Co to Ni–Co–Cr controlled in B–30Co. Within the same framework, the apparent γ/γ′\gamma/\gamma' interfacial energy decreases from ∼25.0 mJ m−2\sim25.0\,\mathrm{mJ}\,\mathrm{m}^{-2} to ∼7.55 mJ m−2\sim7.55\,\mathrm{mJ}\,\mathrm{m}^{-2}, indicating a reduced apparent capillarity contribution in the Co-rich alloy.

Data and code availability

Relevant Codes can be accessed at : https://l1nq.com/pqjjb86 (SM’s Github repository), it also includes the relevant simulation or plotting data as applicable.

Acknowledgments

S.M. thanks Dr. Hemant Kumar, Department of Materials Engineering, IISc, and Ms. Archana S., AFMM, IISc, for their assistance with FIB/APT training and the initial APT experiments .

Funding Statement

The authors acknowledge the Advanced Facility for Microscopy and Microanalysis (AFMM), Indian Institute of Science (IISc), Bangalore, funded by the DST-FIST program, Government of India, for access to microscopy and tomography facilities used in the work. S.K.M. and S.M. acknowledge financial support from the MPG–IISc Partner Group. S.M. acknowledges the DST Prime Minister’s Research Fellowship (PMRF).

Author Contributions

  • S.M.: Conceptualization; methodology; alloy design / preparation; microscopy, microanalysis; data analysis and interpretation; writing–original draft.

  • S.S.: resources; supervision; writing–review and editing.

  • B.S.M.: Interpretation of thermodynamic modelling; computational resources; supervision; writing–review and editing.

  • S.K.M.: Validation and interpretation of atom-probe-tomography data and superalloy physical metallurgy; resources; supervision; writing–review and editing.

All authors reviewed and approved the final manuscript.

Declaration of Competing Interest

The authors declare no competing interests. The manuscript is original, has been approved by all authors, and is not under consideration elsewhere.

Supplementary Material

Nominal composition (at.%)Alloy designationMeasured composition (at.%)
Ni–11Cr–xxCo–9Al–8Ti, x=10,20x = 10, 20, and 3030B–10CoNi–bal. Cr–10.9 ± 0.3 Co–9.1 ± 0.2 Al–8.2 ± 0.1 Ti–8.0 ± 0.2
Ni–11Cr–xxCo–9Al–8Ti, x=10,20x = 10, 20, and 3030B–20CoNi–bal. Cr–11.0 ± 0.2 Co–19.8 ± 0.3 Al–9.0 ± 0.2 Ti–8.1 ± 0.1
Ni–11Cr–xxCo–9Al–8Ti, x=10,20x = 10, 20, and 3030B–30CoNi–bal. Cr–11.3 ± 0.2 Co–29.2 ± 0.4 Al–8.9 ± 0.2 Ti–7.9 ± 0.1

Table S1. Nominal and measured compositions obtained by WDS for the B–10Co, B–20Co, and B–30Co alloys and their corresponding designations.

Figure i. SEM micrographs of B–10Co, B–20Co, and B–30Co alloys isothermally heat-treated at 900 ∘C^\circ\mathrm{C}, showing their microstructural evolution during ageing for 50, 100, 250, and 500 h. All micrographs were acquired at a magnification of 50 000×50\,000\times to permit direct comparison.

Figure ii (PDF p. 22). SEM micrographs of the alloys after ageing at 900 ∘C^\circ\mathrm{C} for 1000 h: (a) B–10Co, (b) B–20Co, and (c) B–30Co.

Figure iii (PDF p. 23). SEM micrographs of B–10Co, B–20Co, and B–30Co alloys isothermally heat-treated at 950 °C, showing their microstructural evolution during ageing for 50, 100, 250, 500, and 1000 h.

Figure iv (PDF p. 23, second). SEM micrographs of B–10Co, B–20Co, and B–30Co alloys isothermally heat-treated at 1000 °C, showing their microstructural evolution during ageing for 50, 100, 250, 500, and 1000 h.

Temporal evolution plots and alloy coarsening-rate table

Figure i. Temporal evolution of the γ′\gamma^{\prime} precipitates in the B–10Co, B–20Co, and B–30Co alloys during ageing at 900 °C. The plots show: (a) the area-equivalent precipitate radius, ⟨r(t)⟩\langle r(t)\rangle, as a function of ageing time; (b) log⁡⟨r(t)⟩\log\langle r(t)\rangle versus log⁡t\log t, showing the temporal exponent of the γ′\gamma^{\prime} precipitate-size evolution relative to the classical and modified LSW models; and (c) ⟨r(t)⟩3\langle r(t)\rangle^{3} as a function of ageing time, with linear regression fits used to determine the coarsening-rate constants, KrK_{\mathrm{r}}.

Temporal evolution of the $\gamma^\prime$ precipitates in the B–10Co, B–20Co, and B–30Co alloys during ageing at 950 °C

Figure ii. Temporal evolution of the γ′\gamma^\prime precipitates in the B–10Co, B–20Co, and B–30Co alloys during ageing at 950 °C. The plots show: (a) the area-equivalent precipitate radius, ⟨r(t)⟩\langle r(t)\rangle, as a function of ageing time; (b) log⁡⟨r(t)⟩\log\langle r(t)\rangle versus log⁡t\log t, showing the temporal exponent of the γ′\gamma^\prime precipitate-size evolution relative to the classical and modified LSW models; and (c) ⟨r(t)⟩3\langle r(t)\rangle^3 as a function of ageing time, with linear regression fits used to determine the coarsening-rate constants, KrK_r.

AlloyTemporal exponent (1/n)Rate constant (KrK_r), nm³/s
B-10Co0.2812.57
B-20Co0.328.35
B-30Co0.313.76

Table ii.

Figure iii. Temporal evolution of the γ′\gamma^{\prime} precipitates in the B–10Co, B–20Co, and B–30Co alloys during ageing at 1000 °C. The plots show: (a) the area-equivalent precipitate radius, ⟨r(t)⟩\langle r(t)\rangle, as a function of ageing time; (b) log⁡⟨r(t)⟩\log\langle r(t)\rangle versus log⁡t\log t, showing the temporal exponent of the γ′\gamma^{\prime} precipitate-size evolution relative to the classical and modified LSW models; and (c) ⟨r(t)⟩3\langle r(t)\rangle^{3} as a function of ageing time, with linear regression fits used to determine the coarsening-rate constants, KrK_{\mathrm{r}}.

AlloyTemporal exponent (1/n1/n)Rate constant (KrK_{\mathrm{r}}), nm3^{3}/s
B-10Co0.2631.75
B-20Co0.3324.41
B-30Co0.3319.96

Table iii.

AlloyTemporal exponent (1/n1/n)Rate constant (KrK_{\mathrm{r}}), nm3^{3}/s
B-10Co0.2631.75
B-20Co0.3324.41
B-30Co0.3319.96

Table iii.

Figure i. Precipitate-size-distribution evolution of the B–10Co, B–20Co, and B–30Co alloys aged at 900 °C for 50, 100, 250, 500, and 1000 h. Each plot shows the normalized PSD as a function of precipitate radius, together with the corresponding Gaussian fit and LSW distribution.

Figure ii (PDF p. 28). Precipitate-size-distribution evolution of the B–10Co, B–20Co, and B–30Co alloys aged at 950 °C for 50, 100, 250, 500, and 1000 h. Each plot shows the normalized PSD as a function of precipitate radius, together with the corresponding Gaussian fit and LSW distribution.

Figure iii (PDF p. 29). Precipitate-size-distribution evolution of the B–10Co, B–20Co, and B–30Co alloys aged at 1000 °C for 50, 100, 250, 500, and 1000 h. Each plot shows the normalized PSD as a function of precipitate radius, together with the corresponding Gaussian fit and LSW distribution.

Figure iv (PDF p. 30). Normalized precipitate-size-distribution evolution of the B–10Co, B–20Co, and B–30Co alloys aged at 900 ∘C900\,^\circ\mathrm{C} for 50, 100, 250, 500, and 1000 h. Each plot shows the PSD as a function of normalized precipitate radius, r/⟨r⟩r/\langle r\rangle, together with the corresponding Gaussian fit and LSW distribution.

Figure v (PDF p. 31). Normalized precipitate-size-distribution evolution of the B–10Co, B–20Co, and B–30Co alloys aged at 950 °C for 50, 100, 250, 500, and 1000 h. Each plot shows the PSD as a function of normalized precipitate radius, r/⟨r⟩r/\langle r\rangle, together with the corresponding Gaussian fit and LSW distribution.

Figure vi (PDF p. 32). Normalized precipitate-size-distribution evolution of the B–10Co, B–20Co, and B–30Co alloys aged at 1000 ∘C1000\,^\circ\mathrm{C} for 50, 100, 250, 500, and 1000 h. Each plot shows the PSD as a function of normalized precipitate radius, r/⟨r⟩r/\langle r\rangle, together with the corresponding Gaussian fit and LSW distribution.

References

  1. [1]A. Suzuki, K. Kawagishi, T. Yokokawa, M. Kobayashi, Overview of the development of ll₂ γ′-strengthened cobalt-base superalloys, in: SpringerLink. doi: 978-981-19-4743-8_7.
  2. [2]R. C. Reed, The Superalloys: Fundamentals and Applications, Cambridge University Press, Cambridge, 2006.
  3. [3]X. Li, N. Saunders, A. P. Miodownik, The coarsening kinetics of γ′ particles in nickel-based alloys, Metallurgical and Materials Transactions A 33 (2002) 3367–3373. doi:10.1007/s11661-002-0325-9.DOI
  4. [4]P. Pandey, A. K. Sawant, B. Nithin, Z. Peng, S. K. Makineni, B. Gault, K. Chattopadhyay, On the effect of re addition on microstructural evolution of a coni-based superalloy, Acta Materialia 168 (2019) 37–51. doi:10.1016/j.actamat.2019.01.046.DOI
  5. [5]M. Mrotzek, E. Nembach, Ostwald ripening of precipitates during two successive heat treatments performed at different temperatures, Acta Materialia 56 (2008) 150–154. doi:10.1016/j.actamat.2007.09.024.DOI
  6. [6]S. Meher, Comparative coarsening kinetics of gamma prime precipitates in nickel and cobalt base superalloys, Ph.D. thesis, University of North Texas (2013). URL https://digital.library.unt.edu/ark:/67531/metadc699871/DOI
  7. [7]D.-W. Chung, J. P. Toinin, E. A. Lass, D. N. Seidman, D. C. Dunand, Effects of cr on the properties of multicomponent cobalt-based superalloys with ultra high γ′ volume fraction, Journal of Alloys and Compounds 832 (2020) 154790. doi: 10.1016/j.jallcom.2020.154790.DOI
  8. [8]R. Su, D. Hao, P. He, D. Wu, Q. Wang, H. Dong, H. Ma, Effect of co on creep and stress rupture properties of nickel-based superalloys – a review, Journal of Alloys and Compounds 967 (2023) 171744. doi:10.1016/j.jallcom.2023.171744.DOI
  9. [9]S. Meher, S. Nag, J. Tiley, A. Goel, R. Banerjee, Coarsening kinetics of γ′ precipitates in cobalt-base alloys, Acta Materialia (2013). doi:10.1016/J.ACTAMAT.2013.03.052.DOI
  10. [10]H. Bian, et al., Regulating the coarsening of the γ′ phase in superalloys, NPG Asia Materials (2015). doi:10.1038/AM.2015.96.DOI
  11. [11]L. Li, L. Wang, Z. Liang, J. He, J. Qiu, F. Pyczak, M. Song, Effects of ni and cr on the high-temperature oxidation behavior and mechanisms of co- and coni-base superalloys, Materials & Design 224 (2022) 111291. doi:10.1016/j.matdes.2022.111291.DOI
  12. [12]J. Joseph, M. Senadeera, Q. Chao, K. F. Shamlaye, S. Rana, S. Gupta, S. Venkatesh, P. Hodgson, M. Barnett, D. Fabijanic, Computational design of thermally stable and precipitation-hardened al–co–cr–fe–ni–ti high entropy alloys, Journal of Alloys and Compounds 888 (2021) 161496. doi:10.1016/j.jallcom.2021.161496.DOI
  13. [13]J. L. Cann, A. D. Luca, D. C. Dunand, D. Dye, D. B. Miracle, H. S. Oh, E. A. Olivetti, T. M. Pollock, W. J. Poole, R. Yang, C. C. Tasan, Sustainability through alloy design: Challenges and opportunities, Progress in Materials Science 117 (2021) 100722. doi:10.1016/j.pmatsci.2020.100722.DOI
  14. [14]D. Miracle, Lightweighting and the future of aerospace metals, in: Light Weighting for Defense, Aerospace, and Transportation, Springer, Singapore, 2019, pp. 27–38. doi:10.1007/978–981–15–1263–6_2.DOI
  15. [15]A. Ghasemi, A. R. Eivani, S. M. Abbasi, H. R. Jafarian, M. Ghosh, S. H. M. Anijdan, Al–co–cr–fe–ni–ti high entropy alloys: A review of microstructural and mechanical properties at elevated temperatures, Journal of Alloys and Compounds 1010 (2025) 178216. doi:10.1016/j.jallcom.2024.178216.
  16. [16]Z. Wang, Y. Huang, J. Wang, C. T. Liu, Design of high entropy alloys based on the experience from commercial superalloys, Philosophical Magazine Letters 95 (2015) 71–77. doi:10.1080/09500839.2014.987841.DOI
  17. [17]A.-C. Yeh, T.-K. Tsao, J.-W. Yeh, P. K. Liaw, Developing new type of high temperature alloys–high entropy superalloys, Insights in Metallurgy and Materials Engineering 1 (2015) 107. doi:10.15344/2455–2372/2015/107.DOI
  18. [18]A.-C. Yeh, T.-K. Tsao, High-entropy superalloy (2017). doi:10.1080/09500839.2014.987841.
  19. [19]Z. Wang, C. Liang, D. Wang, X. Yue, J. Li, X. Ding, Unveiling the co effect on the temporal evolution kinetics of γ′ phase in ni–al–co model superalloys via calphad-informed phase field simulations, Acta Materialia 258 (2023) 119247. doi: 10.1016/j.actamat.2023.119247.DOI
  20. [20]Q. Shi, X. Ding, M. Wang, Y. Zheng, J. He, S. Tin, Q. Feng, Co effect on as-cast and heat-treated microstructures in ru-containing single-crystal superalloys, Metallurgical and Materials Transactions A 45 (2014) 1833–1843.DOI
  21. [21]B. Wang, J. Zhang, T. Huang, W. Yang, H. Su, Z. Li, L. Liu, H. Fu, Effect of co on microstructural stability of the third generation ni-based single crystal superalloys, Journal of Materials Research 31 (2016) 1328–1337.DOI
  22. [22]Thermo-Calc Software AB, Thermo-calc software version 2023a and TCS Ni-based superalloys database version TCNI11, Solna, Sweden, https://thermocalc.com (2022).
  23. [23]T. Etter, R. Engeli, A. Künzler, Method for post-built heat treatment of additively manufactured components made of gamma-prime strengthened superalloys, patent CN105088119A. https://patents.google.com/patent/CN105088119A/en (Accessed: January 28, 2025) (2015).
  24. [24]S. R. Hegde, R. M. Kearsey, J. C. Beddoes, Designing homogenization–solution heat treatments for single crystal superalloys, Materials Science and Engineering: A 527 (2010) 5528–5538. doi:10.1016/j.msea.2010.05.019.
  25. [25]W. J. Boettinger, U. R. Kattner, K.-W. Moon, J. Perepezko, NIST recommended practice guide: DTA and heat-flux DSC measurements of alloy melting and freezing, Tech. Rep. NIST Special Publication 960-15, National Institute of Standards and Technology (NIST) (2006).
  26. [26]ASTM E562-11, Standard test method for determining volume fraction by systematic manual point count (2011).
  27. [27]K. Thompson, D. Lawrence, D. J. Larson, J. D. Olson, T. F. Kelly, B. Gorman, In situ site-specific specimen preparation for atom probe tomography, Ultramicroscopy 107 (2007) 131–139. doi:10.1016/j.ultramic.2006.06.008.DOI
  28. [28]S. K. Makineni, M. Lenz, P. Kontis, Z. Li, A. Kumar, P. J. Felfer, S. Neumeier, M. Herbig, E. Spiecker, D. Raabe, B. Gault, Correlative microscopy—novel methods and their applications to explore 3d chemistry and structure of nanoscale lattice defects: A case study in superalloys, JOM (2018) 1–8doi:10.1007/s11837-018-2802-7.DOI
  29. [29]Ł. Rakoczy, O. Milković, B. Rutkowski, R. Cygan, M. Grudzień-Rakoczy, F. Kromka, A. Zielińska-Lipiec, Characterization of γ′ precipitates in cast Ni-based superalloy and their behaviour at high-homologous temperatures studied by TEM and in situ XRD, Materials 13 (2020) 2397. doi:10.3390/ma13102397.DOI
  30. [30]T. E. Elliott, S. Tin, J. E. King, T. M. Pollock, A castability model based on elemental solid-liquid partitioning in advanced nickel-base single-crystal superalloys, Metallurgical and Materials Transactions A (2005). doi:10.1007/s11661-005-0272-3. URL https://link.springer.com/article/10.1007/s11661-005-0272-3
  31. [31]S. Mukhopadhyay, P. Pandey, N. Baler, K. Biswas, S. K. Makineni, K. Chattopadhyay, The role of Ti addition on the evolution and stability of γ/γ′ microstructure in a Co–30Ni–10Al–5Mo–2Ta alloy, Acta Materialia 208 (2021) 116736. doi:10.1016/j.actamat.2021.116736.
  32. [32]B. Nithin, A. Samanta, S. K. Makineni, T. Alam, P. Pandey, A. K. Singh, R. Banerjee, K. Chattopadhyay, Effect of Cr addition on γ–γ′ cobalt-based Co–Mo–Al–Ta class of superalloys: a combined experimental and computational study, Journal of Materials Science 52 (2017) 11036–11047. doi:10.1007/s10853-017-1159-6.
  33. [33]P. Pandey, S. K. Makineni, A. Samanta, A. Sharma, S. M. Das, B. Nithin, C. Srivastava, A. K. Singh, D. Raabe, B. Gault, K. Chattopadhyay, Elemental site occupancy in the L1₂ A₃B ordered intermetallic phase in Co-based superalloys and its influence on the microstructure, Acta Materialia 163 (2019) 140–153. doi:10.1016/j.actamat.2018.09.049.
  34. [34]H. Mughrabi, The importance of sign and magnitude of γ/γ′ lattice misfit in superalloys—with special reference to the new γ′-hardened cobalt-base superalloys, Acta Materialia 81 (2014) 21–29. doi:10.1016/j.actamat.2014.08.005.DOI
  35. [35]S. K. Makineni, M. P. Singh, K. Chattopadhyay, Low-density, high-temperature Co base superalloys, Annual Review of Materials Research 51 (2021) 187–208. doi:10.1146/annurev-matsci-080619-014459.DOI
  36. [36]J. Lapin, M. Gebura, T. Pelachova, M. Nazmy, Coarsening kinetics of cuboidal γ precipitates in single crystal nickel base superalloy CMSX-4, Kovove Materialy (Metallic Materials) 46 (2008) 313–322.
  37. [37]P. Pandey, A. S. Prasad, N. Baler, K. Chattopadhyay, On the effect of Ti addition on microstructural evolution, precipitate coarsening kinetics and mechanical properties in a Co–30Ni–10Al–5Mo–2Nb alloy, Materialia 16 (2021) 101072. doi:10.1016/j.mtla.2021.101072.DOI
  38. [38]H. Li, L. Zuo, X. Song, Y. Wang, G. Chen, Coarsening behavior of γ′ particles in a nickel-base superalloy, Rare Metals 28 (2009) 197–201. doi:10.1007/s12598-009-0039-x.DOI
  39. [39]T. B. Massalski, H. Okamoto, P. R. Subramanian, L. Kacprzak (Eds.), Binary Alloy Phase Diagrams, 2nd Edition, ASM International, Materials Park, OH, 1990.
  40. [40]H. J. Im, S. K. Makineni, B. Gault, F. Stein, D. Raabe, P.-P. Choi, Elemental partitioning and site-occupancy in γ/γ′ forming co–ti–mo and co–ti–cr alloys, Scripta Materialia 154 (2018) 159–162. doi:10.1016/j.scriptamat.2018.05.041.DOI
  41. [41]H. Zhu, J. Wang, Y. Chen, M. Liu, Y. Sun, Comprehensive ab initio study of effects of alloying elements on generalized stacking fault energies of ni and ni3al, Physical Review Materials 7 (2023) 043602. doi:10.1103/PhysRevMaterials.7.043602.DOI
  42. [42]X. F. Gong, Z. H. Gao, L. P. Nie, S. Qiu, Q. Yu, H. Wu, G. P. Zheng, Z. B. Jiao, Alloying effects on site preference, mechanical properties, and deformation behavior of l1₂ co–ti-based alloys, Journal of Materials Research and Technology 24 (2023) 1429–1441. doi:10.1016/j.jmrt.2023.03.099.DOI
  43. [43]I. M. Lifshitz, V. V. Slyozov, The kinetics of precipitation from supersaturated solid solutions, Journal of Physics and Chemistry of Solids 19 (1–2) (1961) 35–50.DOI
  44. [44]C. Wagner, Theorie der alterung von niederschlägen durch umlösen (Ostwald-Reifung), Zeitschrift für Elektrochemie 65 (1961) 581–591.DOI
  45. [45]C. K. L. Davies, P. Nash, R. N. Stevens, The effect of volume fraction of precipitate on Ostwald ripening, Acta Metallurgica 28 (2) (1980) 179–189.DOI
  46. [46]T. Philippe, P. W. Voorhees, Ostwald ripening in multicomponent alloys, Acta Materialia 61 (11) (2013) 4237–4244.DOI
  47. [47]S. Y. Yuan, Y. Q. Yang, B. B. Zhang, K. G. Wang, Y. T. Zhu, X. Y. Li, Y. Zhang, Suppressing γ precipitates coarsening at high volume fractions in a NiCoCr alloy by synergy of Co and Cr, Scripta Materialia 259 (2025) 116561. doi:10.1016/j.scriptamat.2025.116561.

Paper details

vlnc:W_kqmbnknf
Version
v1 · latest
Published
Fresh — added to the Hub within the last 30 days
Added
License
CC BY 4.0
Usage

views · 0

downloads · 0

A view counts once per browser per day, a download each time the PDF is requested.

  • Physics and Astronomy

Not recorded for this paper

View statement
Looking for related papers…
Contents