betaFeedback

WorksPhysics and Astronomy

Semiclassical description of quadrupole-hexadecapole correlation in nuclear shape evolution

Abstract

Background: Theoretical investigations of nuclear shapes with realistic effective interactions or mean field potentials have suggested a remarkable systematics in the hexadecapole shape evolution with varying particle number: Within each single-particle shell, from one spherical magic number to the next, a diamond type (beta_4>0) appears in the first half, and then turn into oblong type (beta_4<0) in the second half. Purpose: Nuclear deformation is essentially governed by the single-particle shell structure. In semiclassical periodic orbit theory (POT), level density is expressed as the sum over contributions from classical periodic orbits, and the origins of the gross shell structures can be understood by the contribution of one or a few shortest orbits. Using the POT, I examine how the hexadecapole degree of freedom affect the contribution of the orbits to the deformed shell structure through their bifurcations to explain the mechanism of above shape evolution. Methods: Ground state deformations are systematically investigated by the shell correction method, taking account of axially symmetric quadrupole and hexadecapole shape degrees of freedom. For simplicity, I employ two simplest mean field potentials to obtain the shell corrections: the oscillator and the cavity (infinite well) potentials. After confirming the the systematics in shape evolution under these simplest mean-field models, semiclassical analyses are made, focusing on the role of PO bifurcation. Results and conclusions: Systematics in the hexadecapole shape evolution in each single-particle shell is clearly explained by the bifurcations of two different types of periodic orbits in the cavity model, which suggest strong correlation between quadrupole and hexadecapole parameters. This also ensures the mechanism of nuclear prolate-shape predominance within this simple potential model.

Introduction

Nuclei take variety of shapes depending on the numbers of protons and neutrons, and distinct regularities are observed in the way for deformations to manifest. The most significant aspect is the periodic appearances of strongly bound spherical “magic” states corresponding to the closed-shell configurations of the single-particle energy levels in the spherical mean field potential. Nuclei with nucleon numbers outside those magic numbers are generally deformed, where the quadrupole shape degrees of freedom play leading roles. For medium-mass to heavy nuclei, the mean-field potential have sharp surface (in comparison to the harmonic oscillator model) and it causes asymmetry in the single-particle shell structure for prolate and oblate sides. It has long been known that most of the ground-state deformations of nuclei are of the prolate type[1], and the above prolate-oblate asymmetry of the shell structure is considered one of the primary reasons of the prolate shape dominance. Various theoretical approaches have been attempted to elucidate the origin of this asymmetry[2, 3, 4, 5], including those employing semiclassical periodic-orbit theory[6, 7, 8]. In those analyses, hexadecapole shape degree of freedom has not received explicit attention.

In the multipole expansion of the surface shape, octupole degrees of freedom follow the quadrupole ones and these break the reflection symmetry. It has been suggested that a few isotopes locating “northeast” neighbors of doubly-magic configurations on the nuclear chart (N,Z)(N,Z) break reflection symmetry in their ground states[9, 10, 11, 12, 13, 14]. Even if they do not exhibit static octupole deformation, strong octupole correlation is suggested for isotopes in these regions. The octupole deformation (correlation) for those nuclei have been attributed to the existence of nearly degenerate Δl=3\Delta l = 3 single-particle orbitals lying just above the energy gap[9]. In addition, I have

pointed out the role of the gross shell effect associated with the local restoration of dynamical symmetry[15, 16]. Non-axial octupole degrees of freedom, such as tetrahedral shape, have also been examined in various theoretical approaches[10, 17, 18, 19].

Hexadecapole shape degrees of freedom also play significant roles in lowering shell energy. Recently, the interplay between quadrupole and hexadecapole shape degrees of freedom were discussed in multi-reference GCM calculations[20], which elucidated the significance of hexadecapole degree of freedom. Theoretical calculations of nuclear mass throughout the nuclear chart with modern realistic mean fields or effective interactions[12, 20] have prevailed a remarkable systematics in ground-state hexadecapole deformation. In each single-particle shell from one spherical magic to the next, diamond type shapes (β4>0\beta_4 > 0) appear in the first half and then turn into oblong type (β4<0\beta_4 < 0) in the second half. This systematics has also been suggested by a simple consideration of single-particle orbitals filling the spherical shells[21, 22]. In experiments, identification of hexadecapole deformation is generally a difficult task, as it is buried in quadrupole deformation. Recently, new experimental techniques to access hexadecapole moment have been proposed such as backward quasi-elastic scattering[23] and heavy ion collision[24], and more information on hexadecapole deformation for nuclei might be accessible in near future.

In my recent work on the systematics of ground-state octupole deformations using the semiclassical POT, bifurcations of the POs, associated with local dynamical symmetry restoration, play a significant role in stabilizing shapes with specific combinations of quadrupole and octupole parameters. In the present work, I will verify whether the above semiclassical mechanism for the enhancement of deformed shell effect also provides an explanation of the systematics in hexadecapole shape evolution. To this aim, I employ two simplest meanfield models, oscillator and cavity, as in my previous work on octupole deformation[16]. In Sec. II, the mean-field models used in this calculation are defined. Using these models, which take quadrupole and hexadecapole shape degrees of freedom into account, ground state shapes are calculated for each system with NN neutrons and ZZ protons across the entire nuclear chart. In Sec. III, semiclassical theory of gross shell structure is briefly summarized, mainly focusing the role of classical PO bifurcations. Then, semiclassical analysis is presented in Sec. IV for cavity model which qualitatively reproduces the systematics of shape evolution in a realistic mean field model. Section V is devoted to summary and discussion.

Systematics of quadrupole-hexadecapole shapes in simple potential models.

The model

There are several ways of parametrizing shape of nuclear surface. The most popular one is a simple multipole expansion which has been usually adopted to the calculations with the Woods-Saxon type potential models. In this work, I employ the stretched-multipole shape parametrization as in my previous work on the octupole deformation[16]. Let rs(θ)r_s(\theta) be the distance from the origin O to the potential surface in the direction of the polar angle θ\theta as shown in Figure 1. For axially symmetric deformation, rs(θ)r_s(\theta) is given by

Figure 1. Nuclear surface profile function rs(θ)r_s(\theta) for axially symmetric deformation. An example for a spheroidal shape.

rs(θ;β)=R0f(cos⁡θ;β),(1)r_s(\theta;\beta) = R_0 f(\cos\theta;\beta), \tag*{(1)}

where β\beta is the deformation parameter (or set of the parameters) and R0R_0 is the radius of the surface in the spherical limit. Due to the volume conservation condition, the shape function ff satisfies

12∫−11f3(u;β) du=1,f(u;0)=1.(2)\frac{1}{2}\int_{-1}^{1} f^3(u;\beta)\,du = 1,\qquad f(u;0)=1. \tag*{(2)}

To describe the quadrupole type deformation, I employ the spheroidal shape parametrization. The shape function for pure spheroidal shape with axis ratio η=Rz/Rρ\eta=R_z/R_\rho (see Figure 1) is give by

f2(u;η)=η2/3u2+η2(1−u2).(3)f_2(u;\eta)=\frac{\eta^{2/3}}{\sqrt{u^2+\eta^2(1-u^2)}}. \tag*{(3)}

When the hexadecapole deformation is considered, it is first applied on the spherical surface (η=1\eta=1) with the parameter β4\beta_4, and then stretched (or shrunk) in direction along the symmetry axis to combine with quadrupole deformation. In this way, the surface shape is parametrized by β4\beta_4 and η\eta as

rs(θ)=R0f2(u;η)eβ4P4(u′),u=cos⁡θ,u′=uη2−(η2−1)u2.(4)r_s(\theta)=R_0f_2(u;\eta)e^{\beta_4P_4(u')}, \qquad u=\cos\theta,\quad u'=\frac{u}{\sqrt{\eta^2-(\eta^2-1)u^2}}. \tag*{(4)}

By putting P4P_4 function in the exponent, a natural shape profile is provided up to large β4\beta_4 in comparison to a conventional linear dependence rs=R0(1+β4P4)r_s=R_0(1+\beta_4P_4). Dimensionless quadrupole and stretched-hexadecapole moments are defined as

q2=1R02⟨r2P2(cos⁡θ)⟩,(5)q_2=\frac{1}{R_0^2}\langle r^2P_2(\cos\theta)\rangle, \tag*{(5)}
q4=1R04⟨r4P4(cos⁡θ)⟩′=1R04⟨r4P4(cos⁡θ)⟩η→1,(6)q_4=\frac{1}{R_0^4}\langle r^4P_4(\cos\theta)\rangle'=\frac{1}{R_0^4}\langle r^4P_4(\cos\theta)\rangle_{\eta\to1}, \tag*{(6)}

where the average ⟨∗⟩\langle*\rangle is calculated with an assumed single-nucleon density proportional to the potential depth from the Fermi level. The useful feature of this parametrization is that the quadrupole and hexadecapole parameters are mutually independent. Change of hexadecapole parameter β4\beta_4 (“quadrupole” parameter η\eta) does not affect the q2q_2 (q4q_4), which is not the case with the simple multipole expansion. The surface shape for q2=0.1q_2=0.1 (η≈1.2\eta\approx1.2) with several values of q4q_4 are displayed in Figure 2.

Figure 2. Surface shape for combinations of quadrupole and hexadecapole deformations.

Using the above shape parametrization, single-particle potential having the power-law type radial dependence is given by

U(r)=U0(rrs(θ;β))α,β={q2,q4}.(7)U(\mathbf{r})=U_0\left(\frac{r}{r_s(\theta;\beta)}\right)^\alpha,\qquad\beta=\{q_2,q_4\}. \tag*{(7)}

With this choice of the potential, the single-particle Hamiltonian follows the scaling law:

H(c1/2p,c1/αr)=cH(p,r),(8)H(c^{1/2}\mathbf{p},c^{1/\alpha}\mathbf{r})=cH(\mathbf{p},\mathbf{r}), \tag*{(8)}

which extremely simplifies the semiclassical analysis[7]. By a suitable choice of the power parameter α\alpha, this potential provides a good approximation to the Woods-Saxon potential over a wide range of mass numbers. With inclusion of spin-orbit term (which is not considered in the current work), it can be even employed as semi-realistic mean field model for medium-mass to heavy nuclei[8]. For numerical calculations in the following part, I will consider only two limiting cases, oscillator (α=2\alpha= 2) and cavity (α=∞\alpha= \infty), because no good spherical magic numbers are obtained for intermediate values of α\alpha without spin-orbit coupling.

Ground state hexadecapole deformations

Using the shell correction method with the above mean-field models, I first calculate ground-state energies of the systems with NN neutrons and ZZ protons as functions of shape parameters. Using the single-particle energies {εi}\{\varepsilon_i\} obtained for the Hamiltonian h=t+uh = t + u which consists of kinetic energy tt and mean-field potential uu with given deformation, single-particle energy sum Es.p.E_{\mathrm{s.p.}} is calculated, and then it is decomposed into the smooth part E~\widetilde{E} and the oscillating part δE\delta E as

Es.p.(N)=∑i=1Nεi=E~s.p.(N)+δE(N).(9)E_{\mathrm{s.p.}}(N) = \sum_{i=1}^{N} \varepsilon_i = \widetilde{E}_{\mathrm{s.p.}}(N) + \delta E(N). \tag*{(9)}

The above smooth part will be given by the sum of the averaged values of kinetic energy and mean field potential as E~s.p.=⟨t⟩+⟨u⟩\widetilde{E}_{\mathrm{s.p.}} = \langle t\rangle+ \langle u\rangle. Assuming uu as what is deduced from a two-body interaction, the smooth part of the many-body energy should be given by E~=⟨t⟩+12⟨u⟩\widetilde{E} = \langle t\rangle+ \frac{1}{2}\langle u\rangle to avoid the double counting of the interaction. Using the Virial-theorem relation for our power-law potential model 12⟨t⟩=1α⟨u⟩\frac{1}{2}\langle t\rangle= \frac{1}{\alpha}\langle u\rangle, one obtains[7]

E~(N,Z)=α+1α+2(E~s.p.(N)+E~s.p.(Z)).(10)\widetilde{E}(N,Z) = \frac{\alpha+ 1}{\alpha+ 2}\left(\widetilde{E}_{\mathrm{s.p.}}(N) + \widetilde{E}_{\mathrm{s.p.}}(Z)\right). \tag*{(10)}

For the cavity potential (α=∞\alpha= \infty), the above prescription gives E~=E~s.p.\widetilde{E} = \widetilde{E}_{\mathrm{s.p.}}. However, it is known that this relation significantly underestimates the relative magnitude of the shell effect. Here, in somewhat an ad hoc way, I set E~=12E~s.p.\widetilde{E} = \frac{1}{2}\widetilde{E}_{\mathrm{s.p.}}, which might be acceptable since qualitative results are not very sensitive to this choice. Figure 3 shows the systematics of the ground-state hexadecapole deformation on the nuclear chart. The upper panel (a) is for the cavity (infinite-well, α=∞\alpha= \infty) potential model, and the lower panel (b) is for the oscillator-type (α=2\alpha= 2) potential model. Vertical and horizontal dotted lines indicate spherical magic numbers for each potential model: N(Z)=8,20,34,58,92,138,…N(Z) = 8,20,34,58,92,138,\ldots for the cavity and 8,20,40,70,112,168,…8,20,40,70,112,168,\ldots for the oscillator. In the both panels, positive hexadecapole deformation systematically appear at the ‘northeast’ neighbors of the doubly-magic nuclei (corresponding to the crossing points of the vertical and horizontal dotted lines) and then it turns negative as approaching the ‘southwest’ neighbors of doubly magic one. This suggests that these simple models already include the essential mechanism for the systematics in the ground-state hexadecapole shape evolution found in the realistic models.

Deformation is essentially governed by the gross shell structure. In the following, I will examine the shell effect responsible for the above systematic hexadecapole shape evolution from a spherical magic to the next, and clarify its semiclassical origin using the periodic orbit theory.

Ground-state hexadecapole deformation calculated for nuclei with $Z \le N \le 2Z$

Figure 3. Ground-state hexadecapole deformation calculated for nuclei with Z≤N≤2ZZ \le N \le2Z by the shell correction method with (a) cavity and (b) oscillator type potential models. Horizontal and vertical dotted lines indicate the spherical magic numbers in each model.

Semiclassical theory of shell structure

Trace formula for level density and shell energy

In general, density of energy eigenvalues for a particle confined in a three-dimensional potential shows a gross oscillating pattern which is called a shell effect. Except for several integrable systems such as Coulomb and harmonic oscillator potential models, the origin of such fluctuation cannot be explained by a purely quantum mechanical concept. In early 1970s, semiclassical formulas were found which express quantum level density in the form of the summation over contributions of classical periodic orbits (POs) [25, 26, 27, 28]. Those formulas, which can be only applied to a limited class of systems in their original forms, have been extended to those applicable to more generic systems[29, 30, 31, 32, 33, 34, 35]. The general form of the semiclassical level density is expressed as

g(e)=∑nδ(e−en)=g‾(e)+∑poApo(e)cos⁡(1ℏSpo(e)−π2μpo).(11)g(e) = \sum_n \delta(e-e_n) = \overline{g}(e) + \sum_{\mathrm{po}} A_{\mathrm{po}}(e)\cos\left(\frac{1}{\hbar}S_{\mathrm{po}}(e)-\frac{\pi}{2}\mu_{\mathrm{po}}\right). \tag*{(11)}

Spo=∮pop⋅drS_{\mathrm{po}} = \oint_{\mathrm{po}} \mathbf{p}\cdot d\mathbf{r} is the action integral along the PO and it is generally a monotonically increasing function of energy. μpo\mu_{\mathrm{po}} is the Maslov index which is related to the geometric character of the orbit. It should be emphasized that the contribution of each PO is not related to individual quantum levels but to a certain periodic structure embedded in the distribution of the levels.

Derivation of this formula is based on the stationary-phase method for evaluating integrals including the path integral. Let us consider the path integral representation of the level density

g(e)=Tr⁡δ(e−h^)=12πiℏ∫−∞∞dt∫dr⟨r∣ei(e−h^)t/ℏ∣r⟩=12πiℏ∫−∞∞dt eiet/ℏ∫dr∫D[rq]eiR[rq(τ)]/ℏ,(12)g(e)=\operatorname{Tr}\delta(e-\hat{h}) = \frac{1}{2\pi i\hbar}\int_{-\infty}^{\infty}dt\int d\boldsymbol{r}\langle\boldsymbol{r}|e^{i(e-\hat{h})t/\hbar}|\boldsymbol{r}\rangle = \frac{1}{2\pi i\hbar}\int_{-\infty}^{\infty}dt\,e^{iet/\hbar}\int d\boldsymbol{r}\int\mathcal{D}[r_q]e^{iR[r_q(\tau)]/\hbar}, \tag*{(12)}

where R[rq(τ)]R[r_q(\tau)] represents the action integral along the closed path rq(τ)r_q(\tau) (0≤τ≤t0\leq\tau\leq t) which starts from rq(0)=rr_q(0)=r at time τ=0\tau=0 and returns to rq(t)=rr_q(t)=r at τ=t\tau=t,

R[rq(τ)]=∫0tdτ L(rq(τ),r˙q(τ)).R[r_q(\tau)]=\int_0^t d\tau\,L(r_q(\tau),\dot{r}_q(\tau)).

L(r,r˙)L(r,\dot{r}) is the Lagrangian and D[rq]\mathcal{D}[r_q] represents the integration measure of the path rqr_q in the path integral. Noting that the stationary phase condition with respect to the variation of the path is equivalent to the Hamilton’s principle which derives the classical equations of motion, the resulting formula appears as a sum over the terms associated with the classical closed trajectory. Evaluation of the trace integral by the stationary-phase method extracts the periodic orbit because the stationary-phase condition requires the matching of initial and final momenta of the closed trajectory. In these procedures, continuous symmetry of the system should be properly taken into account which generally leads to a degeneracy of the periodic orbits. For a KK parameter family of orbit, KK integrals should be carried out exactly and other integrals are evaluated by the saddle-point approximation as

∫dfx eiS(x)/ℏ≃∑i(2πiℏ)fdet⁡S′′(xˉi)eiS(xˉi)/ℏ(13)\int d^f x\,e^{iS(x)/\hbar}\simeq\sum_i\sqrt{\frac{(2\pi i\hbar)^f}{\det S^{\prime\prime}(\bar{x}_i)}}e^{iS(\bar{x}_i)/\hbar} \tag*{(13)}

where xˉi\bar{x}_i are the stationary points of the action satisfying (∂S/∂x)xˉi=0(\partial S/\partial x)_{\bar{x}_i}=0. Since the dimension ff of the integration for a degenerate orbit is smaller by KK than that for an isolated orbit, one finds the semiclassical order of the contribution of degenerate POs forming a KpoK_{\rm po}-parameter family to be Apo∝ℏ−Kpo/2A_{\rm po}\propto\hbar^{-K_{\rm po}/2}.

Here, let us focus on the integral with respect to a certain coordinate xx which is relevant to a bifurcation. Each stationary point corresponds to a periodic orbit, and the curvature S′′S^{\prime\prime} of the action at the stationary point describes the stability of the orbit against the deviation of the initial point to xx direction. Here, stability refers to how a trajectory diverges from the original one when initial conditions are perturbed. Stable orbits stay around the original one, but unstable orbits diverge exponentially as functions of time. With varying deformation parameter β\beta, the curvature S′′S^{\prime\prime} may change its sign at a certain value β=βbif\beta=\beta_{\rm bif}. This sign reversal is generally

accompanied by a bifurcation of PO because the number of stationary points changes. Figure 4 illustrates it for a bifurcation of “pitchfork” type. In this bifurcation, the mother PO which is stable at β<βbif\beta<\beta_{\rm bif} turns unstable at β>βbif\beta>\beta_{\rm bif} and two stable daughter POs emerge on both sides of the mother. Near the bifurcation point βbif\beta_{\rm bif}, a family of quasi-periodic orbits are generated around the PO and it makes coherent contribution to the integral and enhance the amplitude ApoA_{\rm po} in the PO sum (3.1). Such enhancement is especially remarkable in the case of short and simple POs[36], and an enhancement of gross shell effect can be expected around their bifurcation points. It plays a crucial role in the formation of a prominent shell structure under specific deformation. At the bifurcation point where the curvature S′′S^{\prime\prime} at the stationary point vanishes, the simple saddle point approximation (3.3) breaks down, and a higher order expansion around the stationary point should be considered to evaluate the amplitude factor, e.g., by the uniform approximations[33, 35].

Figure 4. Illustration of the periodic orbit bifurcation in case of the pitchfork type. Upper three panels describe the intersections of action SS along the relevant coordinate xx (the left-hand side), and the behavior of the Poincaré surface (the right-hand side), with varying deformation parameter β\beta around the bifurcation point βbif\beta_{\rm bif}. The bottom panel illustrates the behaviors of stationary points xˉ\bar{x} as functions of β\beta.

By using the POT trace formula (11) for the level density, one can obtain the semiclassical PO-sum formula for shell energy. According to the Strutinsky’s theorem of shell correction[28, 30], shell energy is expressed in terms of the fluctuation part of the level density as

δE(N)=∫0eF(e−eF)δg(e) de.(14)\delta E(N)=\int_{0}^{e_F}(e-e_F)\delta g(e)\,de. \tag*{(14)}

eFe_F can be taken as the Fermi energy associated with the averaged level density gˉ(e)\bar{g}(e), and is determined as a function of particle number NN by

∫0eFgˉ(e) de=N.(15)\int_{0}^{e_F}\bar{g}(e)\,de=N. \tag*{(15)}

Inserting the semiclassical level density (11) in Eq. (14), the trace formula for the shell energy is obtained1 as

δE(N)=∑poApo(eF)(Tpo/ℏ)2cos⁡(1ℏSpo(eF)−π2μpo).(16)\delta E(N)=\sum_{\mathrm{po}}\frac{A_{\mathrm{po}}(e_F)}{(T_{\mathrm{po}}/\hbar)^2}\cos\left(\frac{1}{\hbar}S_{\mathrm{po}}(e_F)-\frac{\pi}{2}\mu_{\mathrm{po}}\right). \tag*{(16)}

In this formula, the contributions of longer orbits are strongly suppressed by the additional factor 1/Tpo21/T_{\mathrm{po}}^2, where Tpo(e)=dSpo(e)/deT_{\mathrm{po}}(e)=dS_{\mathrm{po}}(e)/de represents the period of the orbit. Consequently, the shell energy is dominated by the contributions of a few shortest POs. In this way, POT is particularly useful in the analysis of shell energy.

Semiclassical analysis of the hexadecapole shape evolution

Fourier analysis

Since our Hamiltonian has the scaling rule (8), one has the same set of POs independently of energy ee for a given shape β\beta, and the action integral can be factorized as

Spo(e,β)=ετpo(β),(17)S_{\mathrm{po}}(e,\beta)=\varepsilon\tau_{\mathrm{po}}(\beta), \tag*{(17)}
τpo(β)=Spo(e0,β),ε=(ee0)1/2+1/α,(18)\tau_{\mathrm{po}}(\beta)=S_{\mathrm{po}}(e_0,\beta),\qquad\varepsilon=\left(\frac{e}{e_0}\right)^{1/2+1/\alpha}, \tag*{(18)}

where e0e_0 is an appropriate energy unit. For a cavity system (α=∞\alpha=\infty), ε\varepsilon can be taken as wave number kk and then τpo\tau_{\mathrm{po}} becomes the orbit length LpoL_{\mathrm{po}}. With the wave number variable, trace formula (11) is rewritten as

g(k)=dedkg(e)=g0(k)+∑poApo(k)cos⁡(kLpo−π2μpo).(19)g(k)=\frac{de}{dk}g(e) =g_0(k)+\sum_{\mathrm{po}}A_{\mathrm{po}}(k)\cos\left(kL_{\mathrm{po}}-\frac{\pi}{2}\mu_{\mathrm{po}}\right). \tag*{(19)}

g0g_0 represents the average level density corresponding to the Thomas-Fermi (or the extended Thomas-Fermi) approximation. For this scaling system, Fourier transformation technique provides a convenient way of examining quantum-classical correspondence[7, 26]. Consider the Fourier transform of the level density

F(L)=∫eikLg(k) dk.F(L)=\int e^{ikL}g(k)\,dk.

Inserting the quantum level density g(k)=∑iδ(k−ki)g(k)=\sum_i\delta(k-k_i), it is simply written as F(L)=∑ieikiLF(L)=\sum_i e^{ik_iL}. Practically, summation over infinite number of eigenvalues in the above expression is impossible, and a gaussian cutoff factor is inserted in the integrand as

F(L)=2π1kc∫0∞e−12(k/kc)2g(k) dk.(20)F(L)=\sqrt{\frac{2}{\pi}}\frac{1}{k_c}\int_{0}^{\infty}e^{-\frac{1}{2}(k/k_c)^2}g(k)\,dk. \tag*{(20)}

Then, it allows us to evaluate F(L)F(L) with a finite number of quantum levels kik_i that do not significantly exceed kck_c,

Fqm(L)=2π1kc∑ie−12(ki/kc)2eikiL.(21)F_{\mathrm{qm}}(L)=\sqrt{\frac{2}{\pi}}\frac{1}{k_c}\sum_i e^{-\frac{1}{2}(k_i/k_c)^2}e^{ik_iL}. \tag*{(21)}

By inserting the semiclassical trace formula (19) into (20), it turns out to be a function exhibiting successive peaks at the lengths of POs:

Fcl(L)=F0(L)+∑poApoeiπμpo/2e−12kc2(L−Lpo)2.(22)F_{\mathrm{cl}}(L)=F_0(L)+\sum_{\mathrm{po}}A_{\mathrm{po}}e^{i\pi\mu_{\mathrm{po}}/2}e^{-\frac{1}{2}k_c^2(L-L_{\mathrm{po}})^2}. \tag*{(22)}

Taking larger kck_c makes the width of those peaks ΔL∼1kc\Delta L\sim\frac{1}{k_c} narrower, and improves the resolution of the lengths. To obtain a simple Gaussian expression in Eq. (22), the amplitude factor ApoA_{\mathrm{po}} is assumed to be a constant. Even when the kk dependence of the amplitude is correctly taken into account, however, the Fourier transform remains a peaked function similar to a Gaussian (see Fig. 11 of Ref. [37]). Therefore, the Fourier transform (21) evaluated by the quantum mechanically calculated levels will show a series of peaks at the lengths of classical POs with intensities corresponding to the magnitude of amplitude factor ApoA_{\mathrm{po}}. In this way, one can examine which POs make critical contribution to the quantum shell structures without directly evaluating the trace formula.

Figure 5 shows the correspondence between peaks in modulus of the Fourier transform (21), evaluated by the quantum levels, and the lengths of classical POs. In this calculation, quadrupole parameter is fixed at q2=0.1q_2=0.1 in the upper panel (a) and q2=−0.1q_2=-0.1 in the lower panel (b), and the hexadecapole parameter q4q_4 is varied from −0.1-0.1 to 0.10.1. At q4=0q_4=0, meridian-plane triangular (M3) and parallelogram (M4) family of orbits play significant role because of the extra degeneracy associated with the dynamical symmetry of spheroidal cavity system. Let us first discuss the prolate case in the upper panel (a) of Figure 5. With increasing q4>0q_4>0, curvature of the potential surface at the equatorial plane becomes larger and the curvature radius coincides with the equatorial radius at q4∼0.024q_4\sim0.024, and then the spherical symmetry is locally restored in vicinity of the equatorial plane (see the left panel of Fig. 6). This local symmetry restoration causes bifurcations of the equatorial POs and new families of orbits emerge, that are not on the equatorial plane but are rotated as indicated by the arrows. One can see enhancement of the Fourier peaks corresponding to the equatorial diametric (E2), triangular (E3) and square (E4) orbits around this bifurcation point. With decreasing q4<0q_4<0, curvature at the equatorial plane decreases and becomes zero at q4∼−0.04q_4\sim-0.04. Thereafter, asymmetric orbit planes parallel to the equatorial plane are generated as in the right panel of Figure 7, and new POs on them emerge via the bifurcations of the equatorial ones. One finds some enhancement in the Fourier amplitudes of the equatorial orbits there, but they are not as remarkable as in the q4>0q_4>0 side. This may be related to the difference in the degeneracy of the local symmetry: K=3K=3 for a sphere and K=2K=2 for a cylinder. One also notices a significant enhancement of the Fourier amplitude for meridian-plane diamond orbit M4, which encounters bifurcations around q4≃−0.02q_4\simeq-0.02 (see Figure 8). For q2=0.1q_2=0.1, this orbit encounters bifurcations of two types shown in the panels (a) and (b) at different values of q4q_4. Furthermore, if I also change the value of q2q_2, coalescence of these two bifurcation points is found at (q2,q4)≃(0.05,−0.019)(q_2,q_4)\simeq(0.05,-0.019) as shown in panels (c) and (d). Here, two different pitchfork bifurcations occur almost simultaneously, which leads to a local symmetry of higher dimension. This kind of bifurcation interference is called a codimension-two bifurcation[36, 38]. This peculiar bifurcation is expected to play significant roles in deformed shell structure.

Modulus of the Fourier transform of the single-particle level density as a function of length parameter $L$ and hexadecapole parameter $q_4$

Figure 5. Modulus of the Fourier transform (4.4) of the single-particle level density as function of length parameter LL and hexadecapole parameter q4q_4, with the quadrupole parameter fixed at (a) q2=0.1q_2=0.1 and (b) q2=−0.1q_2=-0.1. Black curves represent the lengths of the classical PO families as functions of q4q_4. Solid lines show the lengths of the equatorial (E2–4) and meridian (M2–4) orbits that continuously exist for all q4q_4 value. They encounter bifurcations at the deformations indicated by the open circle symbols and new orbits bifurcate off from them whose lengths are shown by broken lines.

Figure 7. Bifurcation of equatorial orbits with fixed q2=0.1q_2=0.1 and decreasing q4q_4. The curvature radius of the surface at the equatorial plane changes sign at q4∼−0.04q_4\sim-0.04, which generates additional orbital planes parallel to the equatorial plane on both sides of it.

Figure 8. Meridian-plane diamond orbit and the daughter orbits bifurcated off from it. Thick solid and broken lines in each panel represent the daughters that are mirror images of each other and have identical properties.

On the other hand, no such significant peak enhancement with varying q4q_4 are found for the oblate case (b). Dominant orbits are still meridian triangular (M3) and parallelogram (M4) families, whose lengths are not very sensitive to q4q_4 and they cannot make a driving force for the hexadecapole deformation. One possible effect of the hexadecapole to enhance oblate shell effect is found in equatorial orbits, that encounters bifurcation as shown in the right panel of Figure 6. The large surface curvature at the equatorial plane due to an oblate deformation is reduced by adding the β4<0\beta_4<0 hexadecapole term and a spherical symmetry is locally restored at

Restoration of local spherical symmetry for certain combinations of quadrupole and hexadecapole deformations

Figure 6. Restoration of local spherical symmetry for certain combinations of quadrupole and hexadecapole deformations. Horizontal dotted line represents the symmetry axis and the vertical solid line represents the equatorial diameter orbit. Circle with broken line indicates the sphere whose radius is equal to the curvature radius of the surface at the equatorial plane.

certain combination of β2<0\beta_2 < 0 and β4<0\beta_4 < 0. Its effect is not remarkable enough in the cavity model to realize oblate ground state shape, but their contributions become more significant in the potential with realistic radial dependence in which relative magnitudes of equatorial orbits (compared with the meridian ones) are larger.

As suggested by those results, the contribution of equatorial and meridian orbits enhance the deformed shell effect on the prolate side, each with positive and negative hexadecapole parameter. Let us confirm this effect to the shape evolution by focusing on the dominant PO contribution to the shell energy.

Constant action curves

Properties of classical POs, such as action and stability, continuously vary as the functions of the deformation parameter β\beta. Let us assume that the shell energy (3.6) is dominated by the contribution of single PO,

δE(N)=Apo(eF)(Tpo/ℏ)2cos⁡(1ℏSpo(eF)−π2μpo).(23)\delta E(N) = \frac{A_{\mathrm{po}}(e_{\mathrm{F}})}{(T_{\mathrm{po}}/\hbar)^2} \cos\left(\frac{1}{\hbar}S_{\mathrm{po}}(e_{\mathrm{F}})-\frac{\pi}{2}\mu_{\mathrm{po}}\right). \tag*{(23)}

Then, the energy E(N,β)E(N,\beta) will show a valley along the constant action curves (CACs) on the NN-β\beta plane

1ℏSpo(eF(N),β)−π2μPO=(2n+1)π,(n: integer)(24)\frac{1}{\hbar}S_{\mathrm{po}}(e_{\mathrm{F}}(N),\beta)-\frac{\pi}{2}\mu_{\mathrm{PO}}=(2n+1)\pi,\qquad(n:\ \text{integer}) \tag*{(24)}

where the cosine function of the PO contribution in Eq. (23) takes the minimum value. Let us apply this formula to the cavity model.

Due to the short-range nature of nuclear force, the volume of the body surrounded by the potential surface is usually assumed to be conserved under deformation and is proportional to the mass number AA. Therefore, the radius of the cavity surface in the spherical limit can be put R0(N)=r0N1/3R_0(N)=r_0N^{1/3} with r0r_0 independent of NN. Then, the action integral along the PO is expressed as

Spo(eF,β)=∮p⋅dq=pFLpo(N,β)=pFR0(N)lpo(β),(25)\begin{aligned} S_{\mathrm{po}}(e_{\mathrm{F}},\beta)=\oint\boldsymbol{p}\cdot\mathrm{d}\boldsymbol{q}=p_{\mathrm{F}}L_{\mathrm{po}}(N,\beta) \\ &=p_{\mathrm{F}}R_0(N)l_{\mathrm{po}}(\beta), \tag*{(25)} \end{aligned}

where lpo(β)l_{\mathrm{po}}(\beta) is the length of the PO in the deformed cavity whose volume is same as that of a unit sphere. The Fermi momentum pF=ℏkFp_{\mathrm{F}}=\hbar k_{\mathrm{F}} is known to be approximately independent of NN in nuclei not very far from beta stability line. Using these properties, equation of the CAC Eq. (24) is rewritten as

N1/3=(2n+1+12μpo)πkFr0lpo(β).(26)N^{1/3}=\frac{(2n+1+\frac{1}{2}\mu_{\mathrm{po}})\pi}{k_{\mathrm{F}}r_0l_{\mathrm{po}}(\beta)}. \tag*{(26)}

In Figure 9, the CACs for major POs are shown. They are drawn overlaid on the contour plot of the shell-deformation energy[8]

Contour plots of shell-deformation energy for quadrupole parameter $q_2$ and particle number $N$

Figure 9. Contour plot of shell-deformation energy for quadrupole parameter q2q_2 and particle number NN. Panel (a) is for pure spheroidal shape, and circles indicate the ground-state deformation q2q_2 for given NN. In panel (b), hexadecapole deformation is taken into account and determined so as to minimize the energy E(N)E(N) for each q2q_2. Diamonds, squares and circles indicate the ground-state deformations with the hexadecapole parameter q4>0.01q_4 > 0.01, q4<−0.01q_4 < -0.01 and ∣q4∣<0.01\lvert q_4\rvert< 0.01, respectively. White solid and dashed curves indicate the constant action curves for major POs (see text for details) with and without considering hexadecapole deformation, respectively.

Esh−def(N,β)≡E(N,β)−E~(N,0),(27)E_{\mathrm{sh-def}}(N,\beta)\equiv E(N,\beta)-\widetilde{E}(N,0), \tag*{(27)}

which evaluates the energy by taking spherical liquid drop as reference. Since the lengths of the equatorial orbits decrease with increasing q2q_2, the CACs become those sloping downward to the right. The lengths of the meridian orbits are increasing function of q2q_2 in the prolate side, while it is relatively flat in the oblate side.

In the panel (a), shell-deformation energy is calculated by considering only the quadrupole (spheroidal) shape degree of freedom. Ground-state shape for each NN is indicated by a circle symbol. White broken curves represent the CACs of the POs (with the Maslov indices evaluated in the prolate side). Most of the ground state shapes are locating along the CACs of meridian orbits in the prolate side, which explains the predominance of prolate shapes[6]. Since the CACs of the meridian orbits are flat on the oblate side, they cannot produce significant change of gross shell structure there. On the other hand, one finds good slope on the prolate side and nuclei have more chances to gain energy by the deformation. Looking at the panel (a) of Figure 9, however, the system just above the spherical magic number tend to take oblate shapes, and then turn into prolate shapes with increasing nucleon number. This does not match the actual situation of nuclei that take prolate shapes first and then turn into oblate shapes when the nucleon number increases from one spherical magic to the next one.

In the panel (b), hexadecapole deformation is additionally considered and optimized for each value of q2q_2. White broken curves are the same for the panel (a) and white solid curves are CACs for POs with setting q4q_4 at the bifurcation point(s) for each value of q2q_2. For the CACs of equatorial orbits, q4q_4 is set to the bifurcation point corresponding to the local spherical symmetry. For the CACs of meridian diamond orbit, two downward-right curves correspond to those evaluated at two successive bifurcation deformations shown in Figure 8. The most significant effect of the hexadecapole deformation is the enhancement of equatorial orbit contribution due to the local spherical symmetry. This makes nuclei belonging to the first halves of the shells to take prolate shape with positive q4q_4. For nuclei belonging to the second halves of the shells, the contribution of meridian orbit becomes more significant due to the effect of codimension-two bifurcation with negative q4q_4. This scenario clearly and consistently explains the prolate shape dominance and hexadecapole shape evolution.

For a clearer illustration of the significance of bifurcations, correlation between quadrupole and hexadecapole parameters for the ground-state shapes is shown in Figure 10. The values of the parameters (q2,q4)(q_2,q_4) are indicated, distinguished by open diamond and solid square for nuclei whose particle numbers belong to the first and second halves of the shells. Solid curve represents the shape where the equatorial orbits encounter bifurcation due to the restoration of local spherical symmetry. Most of the diamond symbols distribute along this curve. Two broken curves represent the shapes where the meridian diamond orbit encounters two successive pitchfork bifurcations shown in Figure 8. The square symbols are concentrated around the crossing point (q2,q4)∼(0.05,−0.02)(q_2,q_4) \sim(0.05,-0.02) of these two curves, where a local symmetry with higher dimension is restored (codimension-two bifurcation). In this way, effect of PO bifurcation taking places at certain combinations of quadrupole and hexadecapole parameters clearly explains the origin of the quadrupole-hexadecapole correlation and hexadecapole shape evolution in ground-state shape evolution.

Figure 10. Distribution of the ground-state shapes in (q2,q4)(q_2,q_4) plane. Open diamonds and solid squares indicate the results of the first and second halves of the spherical shell gap between each magic number and the next, respectively. Curves represent the bifurcation deformations of major classical POs (see text for details).

In a calculation with more realistic mean field potential, oblate ground states appear near the last part of the shells. This could be explained by the bifurcation of equatorial orbits of the type displayed in the right panel of Figure 6: spherical symmetry is locally restored around the equatorial plane for certain combinations of negative q2q_2 and negative q4q_4. By considering surface diffuseness of the potential, the relative magnitudes of the equatorial orbit contributions enhance and the oblate valley of equatorial orbit CAC surpasses the prolate valley of the meridian orbit CAC. This can be actually examined in the power-law potential model (7) putting α\alpha sufficiently larger than that of the oscillator. The semiclassical analysis of power-law potential model (7) with intermediate values of α\alpha, also including spin-orbit coupling, is in preparation.

Summary

The mechanism for the systematic evolution of hexadecapole deformation suggested in realistic theoretical calculations is investigated in simplified mean-field potential models. In both cavity and oscillator type potential models, the same kind of hexadecapole shape evolution is found. Semiclassical analysis of the gross shell structure is carried out for the cavity potential model. For the systems belonging to the first halves of the shells, bifurcation of equatorial orbits that occur at specific combination of prolate and positive hexadecapole deformation play the essential role in the enhancement of deformed shell effect. For the systems belonging to the second halves of the shells, codimension-two bifurcation of the meridian diamond orbits that occur at specific combination of prolate and negative hexadecapole deformation play a significant role. The effect of these bifurcations also provide stronger support for the mechanism of prolate-shape predominance in nuclear ground states.

When one considers quadrupole shape degree of freedom alone, shell effect rapidly decreases with increasing deformation. However, a suitable combination of two different shape degrees of freedom, quadrupole and hexadecapole, can partially recover the symmetry and can keep strong shell effect in deformed states. This phenomenon manifest itself differently depending on the system (cavity or oscillator), but the essential mechanism may be understood in the same footing. For instance, the codimension-two bifurcation of diamond orbit in the cavity model will take another form in a different model, say, with finite power parameter α\alpha in Eq. (7), as the mechanism of enhanced deformed shell effect. On the other hand, the restoration of local spherical symmetry takes place in general systems. Then, the same kind of bifurcation enhancement will be expected as the origin of hexadecapole shape evolution found for more realistic mean-field potential models. The analysis along this line is one of the important subjects in our future study.

References

  1. [1]A. Bohr and B. R. Mottelson, Nuclear Structure Vol. II (W. A. Benjamin INC, Reading, 1975).
  2. [2]I. Hamamoto and B. R. Mottelson, Phys. Rev. C 79, 034317 (2009).
  3. [3]N. Tajima, Y. R. Shimizu, and N. Suzuki, Prog. Theor. Phys. Suppl. 146, 628 (2002).
  4. [4]S. Takahara, N. Tajima, and Y. R. Shimizu, Phys. Rev. C 86, 064323 (2012).
  5. [5]M. Horoi and V. Zelevinsky, Phys. Rev. C 81, 034306 (2010).
  6. [6]H. Frisk, Nucl. Phys. A 511, 309 (1990).
  7. [7]K. Arita, Phys. Rev. C 86, 034317 (2012).
  8. [8]K. Arita, Phys. Scr. 91, 063002 (2016).
  9. [9]P. A. Butler and W. Nazarewicz, Rev. Mod. Phys. 68, 349 (1996).
  10. [10]I. Hamamoto, B. R. Mottelson, H. Xie, and X. Z. Zhang, Z. Phys. D 21, 163 (1991).
  11. [11]L. M. Robledo and G. F. Bertsch, Phys. Rev. C 84, 054302 (2011).
  12. [12]P. Möller, A. J. Sierk, T. Ichikawa, and H. Sagawa, Atomic Data and Nuclear Data Tables 109-110, 1 (2016).
  13. [13]S. Ebata and T. Nakatsukasa, Phys. Scr. 92, 064006 (2017).
  14. [14]Y. Cao, S. E. Agbemava, A. V. Afanasjev, W. Nazarewicz, and E. Olsen, Phys. Rev. C 102, 024311 (2020).
  15. [15]K. Arita, Phys. Rev. C 108, 014303 (2023).
  16. [16]K. Arita, Phys. Rev. C 108, 044311 (2023).
  17. [17]N. Schunck and J. Dudek, Int. J. Mod. Phys. E 13, 213 (2004).
  18. [18]S. Tagami and Y. R. Shimizu, Phys. Rev. C 87, 054306 (2013).
  19. [19]K. Arita and Y. Mukumoto, Phys. Rev. C 89, 054308 (2014).
  20. [20]C. V. N. Kumar and L. M. Robledo, Phys. Rev. C 108, 034312 (2023).
  21. [21]S. Suekane and Y. Yamaguchi, Prog. Theor. Phys. 17, 449 (1957).
  22. [22]G. F. Bertsch, Physics Letters B 26, 130 (1967).
  23. [23]H. M. J. et al., Phys. Rev. C 90, 031601(R) (2014).
  24. [24]H. Xu, J. Zhao, and F. Wang, Phys. Rev. Lett. 132, 262301 (2024).
  25. [25]M. C. Gutzwiller, J. Math. Phys. 12, 343 (1971).
  26. [26]R. Balian and C. Bloch, Ann. Phys. 69, 76 (1972).
  27. [27]M. C. Gutzwiller, Chaos in Classical and Qnautum Mechanics (Springer-Verlag, Yew York, 1990).
  28. [28]M. Brack and R. K. Bhaduri, Semiclassical Physics (Westview Press, Boulder, 2003).
  29. [29]M. V. Berry and M. Tabor, Proc. R. Soc. Lond. A 349, 101 (1976).
  30. [30]V. M. Strutinsky and A. G. Magner, Sov. J. Part. Nucl. 7, 138 (1976).
  31. [31]S. C. Creagh and R. G. Littlejohn, Phys. Rev. A 44, 836 (1991).
  32. [32]S. C. Creagh, J. Phys. A: Math. Gen. 26, 95 (1993).
  33. [33]M. Sieber, J. Phys. A: Math. Gen. 29, 4715 (1996).
  34. [34]H. Schomerus and M. Sieber, J. Phys. A: Math. Gen. 30, 4537 (1997).
  35. [35]M. Sieber, J. Phys. A: Math. Gen. 31, 165 (1998).
  36. [36]K. Arita and M. Brack, Phys. Rev. E 77, 056211 (2008).
  37. [37]K. Arita, Phys. Rev. C 98, 064310 (2018).
  38. [38]H. Schomerus, Europhys. Lett. 38, 423 (1997).

Paper details

vlnc:W_ktdqwzzr
Version
v1 · latest
Published
Fresh — added to the Hub within the last 30 days
Added
License
CC BY 4.0
Usage

views · 0

downloads · 0

A view counts once per browser per day, a download each time the PDF is requested.

  • Physics and Astronomy

Not recorded for this paper

View statement
Looking for related papers…
Contents