betaFeedback

WorksPhysics and Astronomy

Time-resolved measurement of Seebeck effect for superionic metals during structural phase transition

Abstract

We propose a new time (t)-resolved method of both vertical- and horizontal-temperature gradients in an orthogonal configuration (t-resolved T(t)-HVOT) to have real interpretations of the enhancement in thermoelectric Seebeck effect (SE) observed during the structural phase transition. We apply our new method to superionic-state semiconductors of p-type Cu2Se and n-type Ag2S. The experimental data differentiate the two types of enhancements during the phase transition: a colossal SE (Scolossal), exhibiting an enormous value of up to 5 mV/K, and a slight enhancement in SE (Sstructure), approximately 1.5-2.0 times larger than those in the absence of the phase transition. We provide critical insights that both enhancements in SE arising during the structural phase transition are not intrinsic phenomena.

Introduction

The Seebeck effect (SE) is the conversion of temperature difference ΔT\Delta T into electric voltage ΔV\Delta V at two different locations in a material, discovered by Seebeck in 1821. The thermoelectric phenomena, including the inverse conversion from electric to thermal energy known as the Peltier effect, discovered in 1834, and the Joule-Thomson effect discovered in 1951 in electrical conductors, are currently known as longitudinal thermoelectric phenomena [1–3]. The SE values for typical good thermoelectric materials are generally in the range of 50-500 μ\muV/K, while those for conventional good metals are usually less than 1 μ\muV/K [4–7].

When we reconsider the original physical interpretation of SE, the essential concept is recalled. The coefficient (SS) of SE, in its theoretical physical sense, is an entropy flow carried out by an elementary charged electron particle upon a given ΔT\Delta T, as described by S=−(1/e)(∂Ω/∂N)ES = -(1/e)(\partial\Omega/\partial N)_E in the Kelvin formula [2,8], wherein Ω\Omega is the entropy, ee is the elementary charge of an electron, NN is the number of elementary particles and EE is the internal energy. More careful discussions of such interpretations in the context of strongly correlated electron systems, such as doped Mott-insulators, are reviewed in recent publications [8–10]. A vital consequence of this concept is that its further enhancement in SE can be anticipated via co-interplays with other types of entropy. Triggered by this theoretical guideline, numerous intensive studies have been conducted by many scientists to exploit such intriguing possibilities. Such possible entropy terms have included the orbital freedoms of degenerate d- and f-elements, the spin freedom of order/disorder configuration of electron-spin angular momentum in magnetic materials, and the additional thermal entropy of the released/absorbed heat in motion of the constituent elements during a structural phase transition [7,11–15]. The associated phenomena, with the freedoms of orbitals and spins, have been intensively discussed in the past for Nax_xCoO2_2, which exhibits a significantly high SS=500μ\muV/K [16,17] even in a good metallic regime. Such experimental data were initially proposed to provide an essential mechanism for the cross-correlated interactions between spin and charge in an entropy flow, leading to a considerable enhancement in SE [17]. The controversial debates, however, have continued to date [18,19]. The spin entropy flow has become another recent active research frontier, as the spin Seebeck effects in the transverse direction [22] [20, 21]. The enhancement in SE found during the structural phase transition in the superionic liquid state has also been an intriguing research target [11,12]. An enormous amount of thermal entropy is continuously released as latent heat, and significant movement of the constituent elements takes place in superionic metals during the structural phase transition. Consequently, a substantial enhancement in SE was expected, given its cross-correlated coupling to a charge-flow entropy. Since the degrees of freedom of the constituent elements during a structural phase transition from a low- to high-temperature superionic phase are significantly larger than any other freedoms, such as spin angular momentum [23] and orbitals [24], a vast enhancement in SE was potentially anticipated [13]. Along with this guiding principle, various experimental surveys have been conducted on a superionic conductor Cu2_2Se, and two types of enhancements have been reported. One is an enhancement in SE (SstructureS_{\mathrm{structure}}), showing a few hundred μV/K, approximately twice the value in the absence of the structural phase transition [12]. Afterwards, an anomalously immense value of SE (named the colossal Seebeck, ScolossalS_{\mathrm{colossal}}), reaching several thousands of μV/K, was intriguingly reported under a vertical- and horizontal-gradient (∇VT\nabla_{\mathrm{V}}T and ∇HT\nabla_{\mathrm{H}}T) experimental setup [25, 26]. Similar anomalous enhancements in SE have also been reported for other superionic semiconductors [27].

The experiments described above garnered considerable attention from other scientists. A superionic flexible conductor of Cu2_2Se showed an anomalously considerable enhancement (ScolossalS_{\mathrm{colossal}}) during the structural phase transition, solely when both ∇VT\nabla_{\mathrm{V}}T and ∇HT\nabla_{\mathrm{H}}T control are simultaneously provided in the orthogonal configuration (HVOT) [25, 26]. The ScolossalS_{\mathrm{colossal}} under the HVOT configuration is significantly greater than the SstructureS_{\mathrm{structure}} observed solely by ∇TH\nabla_{\mathrm{T}}H [12]. Sun et al. proposed an energy-band evolution model to explain the enormous SE enhancement in superionic metals based on ARPES measurements [28]. The proposed mechanism’s complexity encompasses various origins, including electron-phonon scattering. The real interpretation of the reason for the enhancement in S during the phase transition into superionic metals has remained a subject of controversial scientific debates. Here, we propose a new time-resolved T(t)T(t) modulation method in the orthogonal temperature configuration (time-resolved T(t)T(t)-HVOT). In the time-resolved T(t)T(t)-HVOT, both steady-state and time-resolved analyses can be performed simultaneously within a single measurement process. Additionally, the structural phase transition can be monitored during the measurements. We study a p-type Cu2_2Se and n-type Ag2_2S by employing the T(t)T(t)-HVOT method. We demonstrate that enhancement in ScolossalS_{\mathrm{colossal}} is not the correct thermoelectric phenomenon. In addition, SstructureS_{\mathrm{structure}} during the structural phase transition has a physical origin of an increase in resistivity, but delicate arguments should be required based on the fundamental requirements of the Seebeck phenomenon.

Methods

Cu2_2Se and Ag2_2S were prepared according to the previous literature [25, 29]. We controlled the temperatures at two positions on a specimen, 10 mm long and 1 mm2^2 in cross-sectional area, as a function of time (tt) with an accurate increase rate of T(t)T(t) as small as 6.8×10−46.8 \times10^{-4} K/sec in the vertical direction using a large-capacity bottom heater. The T(t)T(t) at one side was further modulated in the horizontal direction from low to high TT at a higher rate of 6.7×10−16.7 \times10^{-1} K/sec repeatedly over many cycles by varying the input current intensity of a small-capacity heater. In this measurement process, a time-resolved T(t)T(t) difference of ΔT(t)\Delta T(t) was generated with high accuracy, so that ΔT(t)\Delta T(t) repeatedly can change its sign from minus to plus as shown in Figure 1(a), (Figure 1b). The generated thermoelectric voltage ΔV(t)\Delta V(t) was simultaneously monitored as a function of tt. Using the collected data sets, time-resolved SE coefficients of S(t)time−T(t)−HVOTS(t)_{\mathrm{time-T(t)-HVOT}} were evaluated in the limit of the infinitesimal time resolution of the measurements. Finally, the S(t)S(t) values were converted to S[T(t)−T(t)]S[T(t)-T(t)] relations, as described in supplementary SFig.1 and SFig.2.

Time-resolved T(t)-HVOT measurements and thermoelectric coefficients for Cu2Se

Figure 1. (a) Time(tt)-resolved T(tt)-HVOT with both horizontal and vertical TT control. The TT gradient in the horizontal direction of ΔHT(t)=T1(t)−T2(t)\Delta_{\mathrm{H}}T(t)=T_1(t)-T_2(t) is modulated as a function of time at a faster rate than ΔVT(t)\Delta_{\mathrm{V}}T(t) controlled by the bottom heater. (b) ΔT(t)\Delta T(t) as a function of tt. Before starting a new modulation sequence of T2(t)T_2(t), a reasonably long waiting period of 500 sec was provided for each modulation process, to enable a conventional steady-state analysis (Sc-steady-HVOTS_{\mathrm{c\text{-}steady\text{-}HVOT}}). The time-resolved T(tt)-HVOT data sets provide other two types of SE analyses of Stime-T(t)-HVOTS_{\mathrm{time\text{-}T(t)\text{-}HVOT}} and Ssteady-T(t)-HVOTS_{\mathrm{steady\text{-}T(t)\text{-}HVOT}}, in addition to the Sc-steady-HVOTS_{\mathrm{c\text{-}steady\text{-}HVOT}}. The analytical details are described in SFig.1. (c) Two types of thermoelectric SE coefficients, ScolossalS_{\mathrm{colossal}} and SstructureS_{\mathrm{structure}}, were observed for Cu2_2Se in Sc-steady-HVOTS_{\mathrm{c\text{-}steady\text{-}HVOT}}. In contrast, ScolossalS_{\mathrm{colossal}} smeared out in the Stime-T(t)-HVOTS_{\mathrm{time\text{-}T(t)\text{-}HVOT}} analysis. The error bars are indicated. ScolossalS_{\mathrm{colossal}} appears with a sign change at ΔT(t)≈0\Delta T(t)\approx0. (d) ΔT(t)\Delta T(t) and ΔV(t)\Delta V(t) were measured as a function of tt. The heat capacity CpC_p is shown together by correcting its position to that at the surface of a sample in the time-resolved T(tt)-HVOT. We measured S(T(t))S(T(t)) as a function of T(t)T(t) for both p-type Cu2_2Se (phase transition enthalpy of ΔHr=32\Delta H_r=32 J/g [13]) and n-type Ag2_2S (ΔHr=15\Delta H_r=15 J/g [29, 30, 31]). The resulting thermoelectric data are explained in the next section, together with resistivities measured under the same temperature modulation sequences.

Results

Time(t)-resolved T(t)-HVOT configuration

The time-resolved T(t)-HVOT configuration is shown in Figure 1(a). First, we describe the critical information available from this new measurement technique for evaluating SE coefficients during a structural phase transition. A small capacity of the second heater provides a well-controlled time-modulated T2(t)T_2(t) in the horizontal (H)-direction of TT-gradient ∇HT2(t)\nabla_{\mathrm{H}}T_2(t) with a relatively fast rate of 0.1 K/sec (25 measurement points, dT=0.0687 K, and dt=0.687 sec in the time resolution) in each modulation process. On the other hand, T1(t)T_1(t) is dominantly controlled by a large-capacity base heater with a tiny gradient ∇VT1(t)\nabla_{\mathrm{V}}T_1(t) of 0.0216 K/sec in the vertical direction. During this T(t)T(t)-HVOT periodic control process, we additionally set a t=500t=500 sec as a waiting time to generate a constant temperature at the end of every T2(t)T_2(t) modulation process, so that conventional steady state measurements with a time independent ΔT\Delta T can be additionally given in the same measurement process, as shown in Figure 1(a,Figure 1b).

In the time-resolved T(t)-HVOT measurements, the evolution of the structural phase transition can be sensitively monitored by a T=T1(t)−T2(t)T=T_1(t)-T_2(t) response as a function of tt. In contrast, T1(t)T_1(t) increased linearly at a very slow rate, showing minor sensitivity to the structural phase transition. In these well-controlled TT regulations, not only multiple cycles of time-resolved ΔT(t)\Delta T(t) but also a conventional steady-state constant ΔT\Delta T, before starting each modulation cycle, were repeated. The T2(t)T_2(t) evolution exhibited a dip, as shown in Figure 1(d), indicating heat absorption during the structural phase transition. We simultaneously observed the generated thermoelectric voltage ΔV(t)=V2(t)−V1(t)\Delta V(t)=V_2(t)-V_1(t), corresponding to ΔT(t)=T2(t)−T1(t)\Delta T(t)=T_2(t)-T_1(t), at an identical time tt between two positions x1(T(t))x_1(T(t)) and x2(T(t))x_2(T(t)) of a sample. A voltage with a sign of ±ΔV(t)\pm\Delta V(t) is observed as the thermoelectric response to ±(∓)ΔT(t)\pm(\mp)\Delta T(t), corresponding to p(n)-type carriers of materials. Three types of analyses were provided. We first measured thermoelectric ΔV(t)\Delta V(t) as a function of time, and the SE coefficients were evaluated, based on the general definition of S(t)=−ΔV(t)/ΔT(t)S(t)=-\Delta V(t)/\Delta T(t). Such an evaluated S(t)S(t) value is denoted as Ssteady-T(t)-HVOTS_{\mathrm{steady\text{-}T(t)\text{-}HVOT}}. As the second evaluation, by taking the time evolution taking into consideration, the S(t)S(t) values were evaluated by Stime-T(t)-HVOT=−d[ΔV(t)/dt]/d[ΔT(t)/dt]S_{\mathrm{time\text{-}T(t)\text{-}HVOT}}=-\mathrm{d}[\Delta V(t)/\mathrm{d}t]/\mathrm{d}[\Delta T(t)/\mathrm{d}t] in the infinitesimal time of dt\mathrm{d}t within the time resolution of our experiments, as shown by the red data in Figure 1(b,Figure 1c). As the third type of analysis, a conventional steady-state SE coefficient Sc-steadyS_{\mathrm{c\text{-}steady}} was evaluated by collecting experimental points under steady-state equilibrium with ΔT\Delta T constant. The details of these three types of analyses are described in the supplementary SFig.1 and SFig.2.

Thermoelectric data of Cu2_2Se by time-resolved T(tt)-HVOT

Figure 1c,Figure 1d shows Sc-steadyS_{\mathrm{c\text{-}steady}} and Stime-T(t)-HVOTS_{\mathrm{time\text{-}T(t)\text{-}HVOT}} for Cu2_2Se with p-carriers obtained from the analyses of the tt-resolved T(tt)-HVOT measurements. In the Sc-steadyS_{\mathrm{c\text{-}steady}}, a large ScolossalS_{\mathrm{colossal}} [25, 26] (displayed by the blue line) was analyzed at a TT away from the phase transition temperature, together with a small enhancement in SstructureS_{\mathrm{structure}} [32] [13] (displayed as the same blue line) as shown in Figure 1c. The latter was observed at a similar temperature to that of the structural phase transition. As justified by more careful examinations described later, ScolossalS_{\mathrm{colossal}} is observed when ΔV(t)\Delta V(t) is finite but not zero under the condition that the zero-denominator term ΔT(t)=0\Delta T(t)=0, hitherto leading to a vast ScolossalS_{\mathrm{colossal}} that is divergently enormous. It is essential to note that the ScolossalS_{\mathrm{colossal}} signal smeared out when we employed the tt-resolved analysis of Stime-T(t)-HVOTS_{\mathrm{time\text{-}T(t)\text{-}HVOT}}, leaving only SstructureS_{\mathrm{structure}} (red line) with its weakened intensity, as shown clearly in Figure 1c.

In the ScolossalS_{\mathrm{colossal}}, both positive and negative signs were observed as previously reported [25, 26]. As clearly understood by the polarity of ΔT(t)\Delta T(t) in Figure 1c, the reason for the sign change in ScolossalS_{\mathrm{colossal}} is due to the crossing into the opposite polarity of ΔT(t)\Delta T(t) and a generated finite thermoelectric ΔV(t)\Delta V(t) with the same sign. Although a local equilibrium, in a small area of the material, is achieved, a global system equilibrium, in the whole size of the material, is hardly attained during the structural phase transition, as described later in the discussion. The situation is strongly dependent on the experimental condition (see supplementary SFig.3, measured using a different time sequence). The experimental evidence so far explained unambiguously indicates the fact that the origin of the colossal SE is Scolossal=−ΔV(t,x≠x1,x2)/(T(t,x1)−T(t,x2))S_{\mathrm{colossal}}=-\Delta V(t, x\ne x_1,x_2)/(T(t,x_1)-T(t,x_2)), which does not arise from the identical locations of x1(t)x_1(t) and x2(t)x_2(t) where the temperatures were monitored, at the same measurement time tt. The requirements for the intrinsic SE definition of both identical tt and position x(t)x(t) are violated as described in the discussion. This is also why the immense value of ScolossalS_{\mathrm{colossal}} is observed at a position away from the phase transition temperature with a sign change.

Thermoelectric Seebeck values of Ag2_2S by time-resolved T(tt)-HVOT

Similar experiments were performed for Ag2_2S with electron carriers using the time-resolved T(t)(t)-HVOT (dtt = 0.036 sec, dTT = 0.036 K, and Δt\Delta t/cycle = 0.9 sec/cycle). A similar dip in T2(t)T_2(t) to that of Cu2_2Se, reflecting the latent heat absorption [29] at TT = 435 ~ 445 K during the structural phase transition, was observed (Figure 2a). By reflecting the n-type carriers of Ag2_2S, which differ from p-type Cu2_2Se, the majority of the experimental data were a response of ±ΔT(t)/∓ΔV(t)\pm\Delta T(t)/\mp\Delta V(t).

Thermoelectric SE data of Ag2S together with its heat capacity

Figure 2. Thermoelectric SE data of Ag2_2S together with its heat capacity (Cp_p). (a) Temperature difference ΔT(t)=T1(t)−T2(t)\Delta T(t)=T_1(t)-T_2(t). A dip in ΔT(t)\Delta T(t) was observed, corresponding to the latent heat during the structural phase transition. (b) Evaluated SE values as a function of Tsample(t)(=(T1(t)+T2(t))/2)T_{\mathrm{sample}}(t) (= (T_1(t)+T_2(t))/2). Both anomalously huge ScolossalS_{\mathrm{colossal}} and small SstructureS_{\mathrm{structure}} (orange line) were observed in the Sc−steadyS_{\mathrm{c-steady}} (orange line) analysis. However, ScolossalS_{\mathrm{colossal}} smeared out in the Stime−T(t)-HVOTS_{\mathrm{time-T}(t)\text{-HVOT}} (red line) analysis with solely remaining a SstructureS_{\mathrm{structure}} with a large decrease in its intensity. The error bars are displayed. After the corrections of the ScolossalS_{\mathrm{colossal}} influence, the intensity of SstructureS_{\mathrm{structure}} (pink line) was further reduced. The analytical details are described in SFig. 2.

Although the measurement sequence of time-resolved T(t)(t)-HVOT was the same as that for Cu2_2Se, the collected data of ΔT(t)\Delta T(t) and ΔV(t)\Delta V(t) of Ag2_2S as a function of tt were very dissimilar from those of Cu2_2Se. The significant difference is that an indelibly large non-zero thermoelectric voltage ΔV(t)\Delta V(t) is generated in a wide ΔT(t)\Delta T(t) in the vicinity of the ΔT(t)=0\Delta T(t)=0 zone (see, SFig. 2). This clearly indicates that we are not guaranteed to monitor the intrinsic thermoelectric voltage generated by the temperature difference at the identical time tt and place x(t)x(t) as described earlier. The enhancements observed for anomalous ScolossalS_{\mathrm{colossal}} by the two-types steady state analyses of Ssteady−T(t)-HVOTS_{\mathrm{steady-T}(t)\text{-HVOT}} and Sc−steadyS_{\mathrm{c-steady}} are very huge of 6-10 mV/K, as shown in SFig. 2. The two anomalous ScolossalS_{\mathrm{colossal}} signals were analyzed corresponding to the position of ΔT(t)≃0\Delta T(t) \simeq0, as explained for Cu2_2Se. The ScolossalS_{\mathrm{colossal}} signal located away from the structural phase transition disappeared when the analysis was undertaken using Stime−T(t)-HVOTS_{\mathrm{time-T}(t)\text{-HVOT}}, leaving a SstructureS_{\mathrm{structure}}. These are consistent with the situation of Cu2_2Se. It is noted that the other ScolossalS_{\mathrm{colossal}} observed ΔT(t)≃0\Delta T(t) \simeq0 during the structural phase transition was still left in the Stime−T(t)-HVOTS_{\mathrm{time-T}(t)\text{-HVOT}} due to the large latent heat, not to be ignored in the case of the inhomogeneous Ag2_2S sample. After the corrections of the ScolossalS_{\mathrm{colossal}} influence, significantly reduced intensity of SstructureS_{\mathrm{structure}} was evaluated (the pink line, see more details in supplementary SFig. 2).

Discussion

Two possible reasons are considered for the SE coefficients increasing to an enormous mV/K level. One is the constituent-element motion under a super-ionic state by greatly modulating a carrier number as suggested previously [25], and the other is the phonon drag [33, 34, 35, 36, 37]. However, our experimental data rule out the former because we did not observe such a change in electrical resistivity ρ\rho that indicates an extensive carrier modulation of the opposite sign. In addition, the phonon drag effect really low temperatures and is generally accompanied by an increase in thermal conductivity [38], which is also not evident in the present case.

When we come back to the original definition of SE coefficient, S(T)=−[1T1−T2∫x1(T1)x2(T2)dV(x)dT(x)dT(x)dxdx]S(T) = -\left[\frac{1}{T_1-T_2}\int_{x_1(T_1)}^{x_2(T_2)}\frac{\mathrm{d}V(x)}{\mathrm{d}T(x)}\frac{\mathrm{d}T(x)}{\mathrm{d}x}\mathrm{d}x\right], a local equilibrium of a segment ii of Si[Ti(xi(t))]=−dVi[xi(t)]/dTi[xi(t)]S_i[T_i(x_i(t))] = -\mathrm{d}V_i[x_i(t)]/\mathrm{d}T_i[x_i(t)] at an observation time of tt is continuously connected to a global system equilibrium: S(t→∞)=−(V(x1)−V(x2))/(T1(x1)−T2(x2))S(t\rightarrow\infty) = -(V(x_1)-V(x_2))/(T_1(x_1)-T_2(x_2)) between x1(t)x_1(t) and x2(t)x_2(t) as tt increases, where the equilibrium is simultaneously realized over the whole measurement segments. In the definition of SE coefficient, the system global equilibrium between x1(T1(t))x_1(T_1(t)) and x2(T2(t))x_2(T_2(t)) is required, where x1(T1(t))x_1(T_1(t)) and x2(T2(t))x_2(T_2(t)) are the two positional ends of a material having temperatures of T1(t)T_1(t) and T2(t)T_2(t), respectively. For evaluating intrinsic S(T)S(T), a global equilibrium state is assumed to be realized in conventional materials, given a sufficient waiting time to reach it. However, this is not the case for a structural phase transition. Considering the non-negligible T(x(t))T(x(t)) fluctuation during a structural phase transition, a latent heat is generated or absorbed in various positions of a sample specimen at around the phase transition temperature. In the conventional steady-state measurements, temperatures of the two endpoints of a sample, T(x1(t))T(x_1(t)) and T(x2(t))T(x_2(t)), are used for SE evaluations by assuming the system’s global equilibrium. In contrast, the thermoelectric voltage ΔV(t)=lim⁡Δx(t)→0∑iΔVi[Δx(t)]=∫x1x2V(x(t))dx(t)\Delta V(t) = \lim_{\Delta x(t)\rightarrow0}\sum_i \Delta V_i[\Delta x(t)] = \int_{x_1}^{x_2}V(x(t))\mathrm{d}x(t) is an integration of each segment at a time of tt, and the time for reaching the electronic-state equilibrium is greatly shorter than that for the thermal equilibrium. As a result, the global ΔV(t)\Delta V(t) can have a non-zero value despite ΔT(t)=0\Delta T(t)=0 by violating a global equilibrium requirement of ΔVi[Δx(t)]=0\Delta V_i[\Delta x(t)]=0 for ΔTi[Δx(t)]=0\Delta T_i[\Delta x(t)]=0, even if a local equilibrium is satisfied. Such a situation is unambiguously evident in the case of Ag2S\mathrm{Ag}_2\mathrm{S}, as explained earlier, where non-zero ΔV(t)\Delta V(t) appears for ΔT(t)=0\Delta T(t)=0 over a wide range of tt.

According to the SE coefficient in the framework of the Boltzmann transport equation, S(T)=∫BZdk(1/T)[((−e/3)D(ε(k))τ(ε(k))v(ε(k))2(ε(k)−μ)(∂f/∂ε(k))/[∫BZdkD(ε(k))τ(ε(k))v(ε(k))2(∂fFD/∂ε(k))]S(T)=\int_\mathrm{BZ} dk (1/T)[((-e/3)D(\varepsilon(k))\tau(\varepsilon(k))v(\varepsilon(k))^2(\varepsilon(k)-\mu)(\partial f/\partial\varepsilon(k))/[\int_\mathrm{BZ} dk D(\varepsilon(k))\tau(\varepsilon(k))v(\varepsilon(k))^2(\partial f_\mathrm{FD}/\partial\varepsilon(k))], where fFDf_\mathrm{FD} is the Fermi-Dirac distribution function, D(ε(k))D(\varepsilon(k)) is the density of states, τ(ε(k))\tau(\varepsilon(k)) is the relaxation time, v(ε(k))v(\varepsilon(k)) is the group velocity, and the integration is made over the entire 1st Brillouin zone (BZ). Since the denominator in the equation of S(T(t))S(T(t)) corresponds to the electrical conductivity σ(=1/ρ)\sigma(=1/\rho) dominated by the carrier density at the Fermi level, an increase in resistivity gives an enhancement in S(T(t))S(T(t)). The SS values evaluated in our time-resolved T(t)-HVOT showed a higher S=130 μV/KS=130\,\mu\mathrm{V}/\mathrm{K} with a higher ρ\rho of 4.6×10−1 Ω⋅cm4.6\times10^{-1}\,\Omega\cdot\mathrm{cm} in the low-T phase than S=124 μV/KS=124\,\mu\mathrm{V}/\mathrm{K} of the high-T phase with the lower ρ\rho of 4.3×10−2 Ω⋅cm4.3\times10^{-2}\,\Omega\cdot\mathrm{cm}, and these are consistent with the general theory. A similar correspondence, between the enhancement in SstructureS_\mathrm{structure} and an increase in ρ\rho during the structural phase transition, is also reported in the previous literature [11,12]. Our T(t)-HVOT showed that SstructureS_\mathrm{structure} is enhanced because of the increase in ρ\rho via the grain boundary scattering during the structural phase transition.

transition. However, the peak positions of the SstructureS_\mathrm{structure} and the inflection point of the ρ\rho (RIFP_\mathrm{IFP}) have a discrepancy beyond the experimental errors for both Cu2_2Se and Ag2_2S, as can be displayed in the inset figures of Figure 3a and Figure 3b. Furthermore, the strength of SstructureS_\mathrm{structure} changes sensitively upon measurements (see the inset of Fig.3b). These experimental facts indicate unambiguously that the essential requirement of the identical time and location for the SE definition is also violated even in the case of SstructureS_\mathrm{structure}. The real discussion on SstructureS_\mathrm{structure} should be made more carefully. There is no experimental evidence, so far, about the contribution of cross-conversion from other entropies during the structural phase transition.

SE value and resistivity of Cu2Se and Ag2S

Figure 3. (a) SE value (SS) and resistivity (ρ\rho) of Cu2_2Se with p-type carriers analyzed by Sc-steadyS_\mathrm{c\text{-}steady} and Stime-T(t)-HVOTS_\mathrm{time\text{-}T(t)\text{-}HVOT}. The observed SS is reported as the average SS over each ΔT(t)\Delta T(t) modulation sequence (the details are described in SFig.1). An enhancement in SstructureS_\mathrm{structure} is observed by Sc-steadyS_\mathrm{c\text{-}steady} and Stime-T(t)-HVOTS_\mathrm{time\text{-}T(t)\text{-}HVOT}, and their enhancements occur when the ρ\rho increases during the phase transition. (b) SS and ρ\rho of Ag2_2S with n-type carriers evaluated by Sc-steadyS_\mathrm{c\text{-}steady} and Stime-T(t)-HVOTS_\mathrm{time\text{-}T(t)\text{-}HVOT} analyses based on the T(t)-HVOT data. (see the details in SFig.2). Reflecting the n-type carriers, SS with a negative sign was observed in the absence of a structural phase transition. The inset figures of Fig.3(a, b) show a discrepancy between the maximum of ∣Sstructure∣\lvert S_\mathrm{structure}\rvert and the inflection point of ρ\rho (RIFP_\mathrm{IFP}), which is critical for further careful arguments on SstructureS_\mathrm{structure}, as described in the text.

The tt-resolved T(t)-HVOT method unambiguously exhibited that the peak position between SS and ρ\rho are not at the identical time and place as seen evidently in Figure 3. This suggests that although the scattering among the grain boundaries is the primary reason for the SstructureS_\mathrm{structure} [9], the requirement for the intrinsic SE phenomena is not fully fulfilled within the accuracy of experiments even in the case of SstructureS_\mathrm{structure}. According to the microscopic origin of SE in its physical meaning is the electric field of E~=E0−(1/(−e))(dμ(T(x))/dx)(dx/dT(x))\tilde{E}=E_0-(1/(-e))(\mathrm{d}\mu(T(x))/\mathrm{d}x)(\mathrm{d}x/\mathrm{d}T(x)) generated by the ∇T\nabla T [39], where μ(T(x))\mu(T(x)) is the chemical potential at x(T(t),t)x(T(t),t), the identical time and place between ∇E(x,t)\nabla E(x,t) and ∇T(x,t)\nabla T(x,t) is essential. Consequently, the enhancement in SstructureS_\mathrm{structure} is also most likely extrinsic, or it should be significantly smaller than what we observed within the experimental accuracy.

Conclusions

Ever since the discovery of a large SE coefficient SS for Nax_xCoO2_2 in its metallic states, a critical question has continued about whether SE can be enhanced via the cross-conversion of other entropies, such as the freedom of orbitals and spin angular momentum. More recently, various intensive studies have been conducted on superionic metals, exhibiting a structural phase transition. Two types of enhancements, SstructureS_\mathrm{structure} and ScolossalS_\mathrm{colossal} were reported. We proposed a new time-resolved T(t)-HVOT measurement method as a powerful tool for obtaining the intrinsic interpretations. The time-resolved T(t)-HVOT provided both steady-state and time-resolved information during a single measurement process, together with the information of the structural phase transition. We showed that ScolossalS_\mathrm{colossal} is not an intrinsic SE phenomenon. We concluded that the enhancement in SstructureS_\mathrm{structure} is not due to entropy conversion from the latent heat entropy during the structural transition. The SstructureS_\mathrm{structure} reported in the past is greatly overestimated or nearly zero, because the requirements of identical time and position based on the definition of SE phenomena are violated in the steady-state measurements.

Acknowledgments

Measurements of electrical conductivity were conducted at the Nano-platform facility, Beijing Academy of Quantum Information Sciences (BAQIS), China, and the Advanced Institute of Materials Science (AIMR), Tohoku University, Japan. We acknowledge Tsunehiro Takeuchi for supplying high quality Cu2Se\mathrm{Cu}_{2}\mathrm{Se} and Ag2S\mathrm{Ag}_{2}\mathrm{S}. KT thanks Yinshang Liu for his technical support in developing the temperature control sequence program using the Labview program code. This research project was supported by Program Innovation for Quantum Science and Technology (Grant No. 2023ZD0300500), the National Natural Science Foundation of China (NSFC Grant No. 12174027), Beijing Natural Science Foundation (Grant No. IS25007), and the CREST project by JST on Thermal Management.

Supplementary of Time-resolved measurement of Seebeck effect for superionic metals during structural phase transition

Shilin Li; Hailiang Xia; Takuma Ogasawara; Liguo Zhang; Katsumi Tanigaki

Thermoelectric data of Cu2_2Se observed by time-resolved T(t)-HVOT.

Time-resolved thermoelectric data of Cu$_2$Se

Figure SFig1. (a) Time-resolved temperature sequences (different-color lines). We use a large-capacity heater to control the overall temperature of the sample, and a small-capacity second heater to periodically heat a single position (Heater 2 in Fig.1a) of the sample. A 500-sec waiting time was provided between cycles to stabilize the temperature gradient (the temperature error was smaller than 0.01 K). The first data point of each cycle (called the time t0_0) can be used for the conventional steady state analysis of Sc−steady_{\mathrm{c-steady}} (b) Modulated temperature difference ΔT(t)=T1(t)−T2(t)\Delta T(t)=T_1(t)-T_2(t). (c) Thermoelectric voltage ΔV(t)\Delta V(t) measured at time tt. (d-f) SE values were evaluated by the three analytical methods, such as Stime−T(t)−HVOT(t)=−d[(ΔV(t))/dt]/d[(ΔT(t)/dt)]_{\mathrm{time-T(t)-HVOT}}(t)=-\mathrm{d}[(\Delta V(t))/\mathrm{d}t]/\mathrm{d}[(\Delta T(t)/\mathrm{d}t)], Ssteady−T(t)−HVOT(t)=−(ΔV(t))/(ΔT(t))_{\mathrm{steady-T(t)-HVOT}}(t)=-(\Delta V(t))/(\Delta T(t)), and Sc−steady(t)=−(ΔV(t0))/(ΔT(t0))_{\mathrm{c-steady}}(t)=-(\Delta V(t_0))/(\Delta T(t_0)), as a function of time tt. (g-i) Stime−T(t)−HVOT(T)_{\mathrm{time-T(t)-HVOT}}(T), Ssteady−T(t)−HVOT(T)_{\mathrm{steady-T(t)-HVOT}}(T), and Sc−steady(T)_{\mathrm{c-steady}}(T) as a function of Tsample(t)=(T1(t)+T2(t))/2_{\mathrm{sample}}(t)=(T_1(t)+T_2(t))/2. The Ssteady−T(t)−HVOT_{\mathrm{steady-T(t)-HVOT}} analytical method directly shows the relationship between ΔT(t)\Delta T(t) and ΔV(t)\Delta V(t) as a function of time tt, as shown SFig.1e and h. Sc−steady_{\mathrm{c-steady}} and Stime−T(t)−HVOT_{\mathrm{time-T(t)-HVOT}} analyses show both Scolossal_{\mathrm{colossal}} and Sstructure_{\mathrm{structure}} due to the lack of the global equilibrium, as described in the main text. However, Scolossal_{\mathrm{colossal}} disappeared in the Stime−T(t)−HVOT_{\mathrm{time-T(t)-HVOT}} analysis, and Sstructure_{\mathrm{structure}} also became smaller.

Thermoelectric data of n-type Ag2_2S The time-resolved T(t)-HVOT.

Figure SFig2. (a) Time-resolved temperature sequences (different-color lines), including the conventional steady-state sequence. (b) Temperature difference ΔT(t)=T1(t)−T2(t)\Delta T(t)=T_1(t)-T_2(t). (c) Generated thermoelectric voltage ΔV(t)\Delta V(t) corresponding to ΔT(t)\Delta T(t). (d-f) Stime−T(t)−HVOT(t)=−[d(ΔV(t))/dt]/[d(ΔT(t))/dt]_{\mathrm{time-T(t)-HVOT}}(t)=-[\mathrm{d}(\Delta V(t))/\mathrm{d}t]/[\mathrm{d}(\Delta T(t))/\mathrm{d}t], Ssteady−T(t)−HVOT(t)=−(ΔV(t))/(ΔT(t))_{\mathrm{steady-T(t)-HVOT}}(t)=-(\Delta V(t))/(\Delta T(t)) and Sc−steady(t)=−(ΔV(t0))/(ΔT(t0))_{\mathrm{c-steady}}(t)=-(\Delta V(t_0))/(\Delta T(t_0)) as a function of time tt. (g-i) Stime−T(t)−HVOT(T)=−d(ΔV(t))/d(ΔT(t))_{\mathrm{time-T(t)-HVOT}}(T)=-\mathrm{d}(\Delta V(t))/\mathrm{d}(\Delta T(t)), Ssteady−T(t)−HVOT(T)=−(ΔV(t))/(ΔT(t))_{\mathrm{steady-T(t)-HVOT}}(T)=-(\Delta V(t))/(\Delta T(t)) and Sc−steady(T)=−(ΔV(t0))/(ΔT(t0))_{\mathrm{c-steady}}(T)=-(\Delta V(t_0))/(\Delta T(t_0)) as a function of Tsample_{\mathrm{sample}}. Since ΔT(t)≃0\Delta T(t)\simeq0 overlaps the structural phase transition and Ag2_2S is more inhomogeneous than Cu2_2Se, a signal of Scolossal_{\mathrm{colossal}} remained even in the S$_{\mathrm{time-

:::

T(t)T(t)-HVOT(TT) method as shown in SFig. 2(d, g). After making corrections of the influences of ScolossalS_{\mathrm{colossal}} signal, the real SstructureS_{\mathrm{structure}} was evaluated to be greatly smaller. Because the maximum of ∣Sstructure∣\lvert S_{\mathrm{structure}}\rvert and the reflection point of resistivity ρ\rho show a discrepancy in position, the intrinsic understanding of SstructureS_{\mathrm{structure}} needs further careful consideration, as described in the main text.

Different time sequence in time-resolved T(t)-HVOT measurements for Cu2Se

Figure SFig.3. A different time sequence in time-resolved T(t)T(t)-HVOT measurements for Cu2_2Se. (a) The modulation of temperature T2(t)T_2(t). (b) Temperature difference ΔT(t)=T1(t)−T2(t)\Delta T(t)=T_1(t)-T_2(t). (c) Generated thermoelectric voltage ΔV(t)\Delta V(t) corresponding to ΔT(t)\Delta T(t). (d-f) Stime−HVOT(t)S_{\mathrm{time-HVOT}}(t), Stime−HVOT(T)S_{\mathrm{time-HVOT}}(T) and the average of Stime−HVOT(T)S_{\mathrm{time-HVOT}}(T). The measurements during the phase transition depend on the time-resolved sequence. A different ΔT(t)\Delta T(t), with a relatively higher increase than that described in the text and SFig.1, was used for Cu2_2Se with a rate of 0.67 K/sec and T2(t)T_2(t) modulation in the time-resolved T(t)T(t)-HVOT method. As long as the modulation temperature rate is sufficiently sensitive to detect the structural phase transition, a dip corresponding to it was observed. However, the ambiguity of the collected thermoelectric voltage data at ΔT(t)≃0\Delta T(t)\simeq0 greatly increased. For obtaining the physically meaningful experimental data during the structural phase transition, a sufficiently low rate of increase and highly time-resolved modulation are critical.

Comparison of Scolossal and Sstructure between the present work and previous reports for Cu2Se and Ag2S

Figure SFig.4. Comparison of ScolossalS_{\mathrm{colossal}} and SstructureS_{\mathrm{structure}} between our present work and those of the previous reports for Cu2_2Se (a) and Ag2_2S (b). The phase transition temperature, SstructureS_{\mathrm{structure}}, and ScolossalS_{\mathrm{colossal}} are experimentally reproduced. However, the intrinsic interpretations need careful consideration, based on the identical time and space of the fundamental SE phenomenon as described in the main text.

References

  1. [22]K. Uchida, J. Xiao, H. Adachi, J. Ohe, S. Takahashi, J. Ieda, T. Ota, Y. Kajiwara, H. Umezawa, H. Kawai, G. E. W. Bauer, et al., Spin Seebeck insulator, Nature Mater 9, 894 (2010).DOI
  2. [23]B. S. Shastry, Thermopower in Correlated Systems, in New Materials for Thermoelectric Applications: Theory and Experiment, edited by V. Zlatic and A. Hewson (Springer Netherlands, Dordrecht, 2013), pp. 25–29.DOI
  3. [24]J. Mravlje and A. Georges, Thermopower and Entropy: Lessons from Sr₂RuO₄, Phys. Rev. Lett. 117, 036401 (2016).DOI
  4. [25]D. Byeon, R. Sobota, K. Hirata, S. Choi, K. Hirata, M. Adachi, M. Kiyama, T. Matsuura, Y. Yamamoto, M. Matsunami, and T. Takeuchi, Discovery of colossal Seebeck effect in metallic Cu₂Se, Nat Commun 10, 72 (2019).DOI
  5. [26]D. Byeon, R. Sobota, S. Singh, S. Choi, N. Kubo, M. Adachi, Y. Yamamoto, M. Matsunami, and T. Takeuchi, Long-Term Stability of the Colossal Seebeck Effect in Metallic Cu₂Se, Journal of Elec Materi 49, 2855 (2020).DOI
  6. [27]D. Byeon, R. Sobota, K. Hirata, S. Singh, S. Choi, M. Adachi, Y. Yamamoto, M. Matsunami, and T. Takeuchi, Dynamical variation of carrier concentration and colossal Seebeck effect in Cu₂S low-temperature phase, Journal of Alloys and Compounds 826, 154155 (2020).DOI
  7. [28]S. Sun, Y. Li, Y. Chen, X. Xu, L. Kang, J.-L. Zhou, W. Xia, S. Liu, M. Wang, J. Jiang, A. Liang, et al., Electronic origin of the enhanced thermoelectric efficiency of Cu₂Se., Science Bulletin 65 22, 1888 (2020).DOI
  8. [29]G. Kim, D. Byeon, S. Singh, K. Hirata, S. Choi, M. Matsunami, and T. Takeuchi, Mixed-phase effect of a high Seebeck coefficient and low electrical resistivity in Ag₂S, J. Phys. D: Appl. Phys. 54, 115503 (2021).DOI
  9. [30]X. Shi, H. Chen, F. Hao, R. Liu, T. Wang, P. Qiu, U. Burkhardt, Y. Grin, and L. Chen, Room-temperature ductile inorganic semiconductor, Nature Mater 17, 421 (2018).DOI
  10. [31]Wang T., Chen H.-Y., Qiu P.-F., Shi X., and Chen L.-D., Thermoelectric properties of Ag₂S superionic conductor with intrinsically low lattice thermal conductivity, Acta Phys. Sin. 68, 090201 (2019).DOI
  11. [32]S. D. Kang, S. A. Danilkin, U. Aydemir, M. Avdeev, A. Studer, and G. J. Snyder, Apparent critical phenomena in the superionic phase transition of Cu₂₋ₓSe, New J. Phys. 18, 013024 (2016).DOI
  12. [33]J. P. Jay-Gerin, Thermoelectric power of semiconductors in the extreme quantum limit. II. The “phonon-drag” contribution, Phys. Rev. B 12, 1418 (1975).
  13. [34]Q. Jie, R. Hu, E. Bozin, A. Llobet, I. Zaliznyak, C. Petrovic, and Q. Li, Electronic thermoelectric power factor and metal-insulator transition in FeSb₂, Phys. Rev. B 86, (2012).
  14. [35]H. Takahashi, R. Okazaki, S. Ishiwata, H. Taniguchi, A. Okutani, M. Hagiwara, and I. Terasaki, Colossal Seebeck effect enhanced by quasi-ballistic phonons dragging massive electrons in FeSb₂, Nat Commun 7, (2016).DOI
  15. [36]A. Jaoui, G. Seyfarth, C. W. Rischau, S. Wiedmann, S. Benhabib, C. Proust, K. Behnia, and B. Fauqué, Giant Seebeck effect across the field-induced metal-insulator transition of InAs, Npj Quantum Mater. 5, (2020).arxiv.org/abs/2008.06356
  16. [37]Q. Du, L. Wu, H. Cao, C.-J. Kang, C. Nelson, G. L. Pascut, T. Besara, T. Siegrist, K. Haule, G. Kotliar, I. Zaliznyak, et al., Vacancy defect control of colossal thermopower in FeSb₂, Npj Quantum Mater. 6, (2021).DOI
  17. [38]B. Skinner and L. Fu, Large, nonsaturating thermopower in a quantizing magnetic field, Sci. Adv. 4, (2018).DOI
  18. [39]Neil W Ashcroft and N. David Mermin, Solid State Physics, Vol. 13 (Thomson Learning, 1976).

Paper details

vlnc:W_kwxtxf34
Version
v1 · latest
Published
Fresh — added to the Hub within the last 30 days
Added
License
CC BY 4.0
Usage

views · 0

downloads · 0

A view counts once per browser per day, a download each time the PDF is requested.

  • Physics and Astronomy

Not recorded for this paper

View statement
Looking for related papers…
Contents