In this paper
AbstractIntroductionFramework and nonlinear transportUniform separation and persistence under perturbationNon-neutral stabilityObservable first-order coefficientFrom return-map perturbations to holonomy perturbationsGlobal propagation in the non-neutral regimeThe holonomy variational jetFirst variationSecond variation: exact formulaHigher-order holonomy jetFinite-dimensional holonomy unfoldings and Malgrange preparationAnalytic dependence and the flat regimeFinite-order anchor isolation and parity-sensitive existenceStability and observable finite-order coefficientsMulti-loop finite-order aggregationGlobal reconstruction stability at finite holonomy orderGeometric interpretation and remaining geometric questionsConnection-curvature perspectiveSpherical and non-umbilic perturbationsNeutral tuningNumerical experimentsAlgebraic finite-order calibrationCircular-core return geometryA genuine non-neutral exampleA numerically tuned neutral exampleConclusion and open problemsReferencesWorksMathematics
Stability in the Non-Neutral and Neutral Regimes of the Holonomy-Based Inverse Problem in the Class
Abstract
We study anchor reconstruction stability in return-map inverse problems for class . Local identifiability is governed by the first nonvanishing derivative of the holonomy map . In the non-neutral case, we prove local Lipschitz stability and multiplier estimates. In the neutral regime, using Faà di Bruno equations and Malgrange preparation, we derive quantitative -Hölder estimates for order- anchor perturbations. We also establish finite jet stability, real-analytic dependence, and global -stability of order . Numerical benchmarks on circular-core return geometries validate these theoretical convergence rates and square-root laws.
2020 Mathematics Subject Classification: Primary 37C25; Secondary 34A12, 35R30, 53A05.
Introduction
The return-map construction in the class associates to a known convex core and a surrounding admissible normal-graph boundary a discrete map . The forward geometry and regularity of this map were developed in [1, 3]. The inverse problem studied in [2] asks how much of the unknown thickness function , and hence of the outer boundary, can be reconstructed when and are known.
A central result of that inverse theory is that exact non-uniqueness reduces to a scalar anchor value. The inverse system transports a trial value along paths of , and closed paths generate nonlinear holonomy maps . The true anchor is a common fixed point. When
satisfies , the anchor is locally isolated by the ordinary transverse-root mechanism. The singular regime begins when : linearized holonomy becomes neutral, but higher vertical variations of the nonlinear transport may still retain identifying information.
The word “holonomy” also appears in several nearby geometric inverse problems, but the data and unknowns are different. Cekić and Lefeuvre recover unitary connections, modulo gauge, from traces of connection holonomies along primitive closed geodesics and prove local injectivity near generic connections [7]; their companion stability paper establishes Hölder-type estimates for that problem [6]. More broadly, transport equations, scattering data, non-Abelian X-ray transforms, boundary rigidity and range questions form a central part of contemporary geometric inverse problems [12, 4, 5, 9]. In the present paper, by contrast, the holonomy is a scalar nonlinear transport in the fibre variable representing the unknown thickness anchor. This distinction is important: the Hölder exponents below arise from finite-order singularity of a scalar anchor fixed point, while their coefficients are generated by the return-map transport geometry.
Contribution and positioning. The exponent itself should not be confused with the novelty of the paper. Multiple roots are classically ill-conditioned and their numerical treatment requires multiplicity-aware analysis; see, for example, [13]. The purpose here is to close, within the return-map inverse problem, the problem-specific chain
return-data perturbation finite holonomy-jet perturbation isolation order, anchor stability boundary reconstruction stability.
The genuinely new ingredients are the geometric realization of the multiplicity through the exact holonomy jet, its finite-jet stability under noisy return data, the Malgrange-prepared local polynomial unfolding for finite-dimensional smooth families, deterministic multi-loop aggregation, and the propagation of the anchor estimate to the full reconstructed thickness. The scalar multiple-root exponent is classical; its geometric coefficient, observability, and inverse-problem consequences are the contributions developed below.
Define
with if all derivatives vanish. The main results are as follows.
In the non-neutral case we prove a local one-loop stability theorem, an observable multiplier bound, and quantitative transfer of return-map errors to holonomy errors.
We derive the exact second holonomy variation and the explicit third variation, and prove the full finite variational hierarchy
where are partial Bell polynomials.
If the first nonzero holonomy derivative has order , every sufficiently localized perturbed zero satisfies a quantitative -Hölder estimate. Odd and even orders have different existence mechanisms.
For every finite-dimensional family of admissible return data passing through an order- holonomy singularity, the Malgrange preparation theorem gives a local factorization into a
smooth unit and a monic degree- polynomial in the anchor displacement. Thus the perturbed anchor set is locally governed by a finite polynomial unfolding, while our stability estimates quantify the conditioning of its roots.
(v) For every fixed finite , perturbation of the observable return components controls the holonomy jet on uniformly separated anchor intervals. This makes the higher-order stability coefficients observable from noisy return data.
(vi) We prove a deterministic multi-loop estimate at the minimal isolation order, including approximate common fixed points.
(vii) We prove real-analytic dependence of on the initial anchor on uniformly separated intervals. Thus implies that is locally the identity near .
(viii) Under uniform separation from the singular fibre set, the local anchor estimate propagates to a global estimate
for every fixed finite order .
(ix) We validate both the non-neutral and neutral regimes on genuine return geometries of the unit circular core. The observed convergence rates are approximately 1.0002 in the non-neutral case and 0.4960 in the tuned neutral case; the corresponding global thickness rates are 1.0002 and 0.4953.
The geometric origin of the higher-order coefficients beyond the explicit vertical variational formulas remains subtler. In particular, invariant small-loop formulas on a general non-umbilic core must retain the Levi-Civita connection terms of the principal frame. We therefore separate the proved holonomy-jet theory from those remaining geometric genericity questions.
The paper is organized as follows. § 2 recalls the nonlinear transport formulation. § 3 treats the non-neutral regime. § 4 develops the variational holonomy jet, its Malgrange-prepared finite-dimensional unfoldings, and the analytic flat regime. § 5 proves finite-order isolation and parity-sensitive existence. § 6 transfers return-data perturbations to finite holonomy jets and develops observable coefficients. § 7 gives deterministic multi-loop aggregation. § 8 propagates anchor errors globally. § 9 records the remaining invariant geometric questions. § 10 contains executed algebraic and geometric numerical experiments, including a TikZ visualization of the tuned neutral geometry.
Framework and nonlinear transport
We use the notation and standing hypotheses of the inverse problem developed in [2], within the class introduced in [1]. Let be compact convex with boundary . Let be of class , let be the associated return map, and let be the shape operator of . We denote by the tangential and normal components of , and by the holonomy transport along a closed loop based at .
For a fixed closed loop based at , we write the scalar transport equation as
where
with
Set
On the domain ,
and more generally, for ,
The holonomy displacement is
with at the true anchor . We set
The isolation order is
with if all derivatives vanish. When , we write
We use two error norms on the holonomy displacement:
Evidently . The non-neutral regime requires control and is stated with . The neutral regime requires only control plus a Taylor remainder, and is stated with ; control is invoked only when existence of the perturbed fixed point is established by a contraction.
For , we set
Uniform separation and persistence under perturbation
All stability statements below require the horizontal lifts to remain at positive distance from the singular fibre set . We first record that this quantitative admissibility condition is stable under sufficiently small perturbations of the observed return components.
Definition 2.1 (Uniform separation). Let be a compact anchor interval and a curve. We say that the exact transport is uniformly separated on with margin if, for every , the lift exists on and
Lemma 2.2 (Persistence of uniform separation). Assume Definition 2.1 holds with margin . Set
Then there exists , depending only on , , and uniform bounds for the exact transport on the compact family of exact solution graphs, such that, whenever , every perturbed lift with exists on and
Moreover,
for a constant independent of the perturbation once .
Proof. Because is compact and the exact lifts depend continuously on , their union is contained in a compact fibre interval. Fix the tube
If , then throughout one has
Hence the exact and perturbed rational vector fields are uniformly bounded and Lipschitz in on this tube, and there is a constant such that
For fixed , let be the supremum of times for which the perturbed solution exists and remains in the tube, equivalently , on . On this interval the standard Gronwall comparison gives
with a uniform Lipschitz constant on . Choose so that the right-hand side is strictly smaller than and also . A first exit at is then impossible. Thus , the displayed difference estimate holds on the full interval, and
All constants are uniform in , which completes the proof.
Remark 2.3 (Conditioning near the singular fibre). The vertical Lipschitz constants below scale like . Consequently the Gronwall amplification factors deteriorate rapidly as the exact separation margin tends to zero. This blow-up records genuine ill-conditioning near the non-admissible set , rather than a proof artefact.
Remark 2.4 (Certifying separation near the true anchor). For a concrete geometry it is enough first to certify a positive separation margin along the true horizontal section . Continuity of the transport with respect to the initial anchor then gives a compact interval around on which Definition 2.1 holds, possibly with a smaller margin. In § 10, the interval enclosures of the circular-core geometry provide precisely such quantitative geometric margins; they are used as evidence for a well-separated true section, not as a substitute for Definition 2.1 on an arbitrary anchor interval.
Non-neutral stability
Throughout this section we assume
This is the non-neutral regime already underlying the first-order holonomy mechanism in [2]. The purpose here is quantitative stability under perturbed return data.
Theorem 3.1 (Local one-loop stability in the non-neutral regime). Let and on an interval . Assume
and
Set
and assume
Then has a unique zero in ; in fact , and
In particular,
If and , then only the upper asymptotic estimate
is asserted. No global uniqueness in follows from these hypotheses alone.
Proof. Set . For ,
so has constant sign on the closed interval . Replacing and by their negatives if necessary, suppose . Moreover,
and similarly . Hence , and the inverse branch is defined there with
Define on the complete metric space
Then
so . Also
Banach’s fixed-point theorem therefore gives a unique fixed point , necessarily in the open ball. The identity is equivalent to , and every zero of in the closed ball is a fixed point of , proving uniqueness.
Finally,
On the segment joining to ,
while . This yields (14); the remaining estimates follow immediately.
Observable first-order coefficient
The exact quantity depends on the unknown anchor. Define instead
Lemma 3.2 (Proximity of the observed multiplier). Under the hypotheses of Theorem 3.1,
Proof. Use the reverse triangle inequality and split
The first term is bounded by , the second by , and .
Corollary 3.3 (Observable non-neutral bound). Assume, in addition,
Then
and the anchor error admits the observable-form estimate
Proof. The interval for follows from Lemma 3.2. Since , one has . Combining this with gives (16).
From return-map perturbations to holonomy perturbations
Lemma 3.4 (Continuity of the transport map). Let be a curve, and set
Fix and assume . Assume that the exact transport issued from the compact interval is uniformly separated with margin in the sense of Definition 2.1. Shrinking if necessary, Lemma 2.2 gives perturbed separation with margin and a common bounded fibre region. Then there exist constants , depending only on that common fibre bound, , , the geometry of , and uniform bounds for the exact fields, such that along
and
Consequently, with ,
where is explicit in and . In particular, a bound is available on every fixed admissible loop.
Proof. Writing , the identities
give the first two estimates. Let denote the common lower separation margin after applying Lemma 2.2. For the exact–perturbed pair one may take the common Lipschitz constant
Because , this quantity is bounded uniformly in terms of the exact field bounds, , , and . The perturbation estimates follow by differentiating the rational function with respect to on the common separation region.
If denotes the difference of lifts with the same initial value, Gronwall’s inequality gives
For and ,
The exact variation satisfies . Subtracting the two equations and using
followed by a second Gronwall estimate proves (18). ▫
Global propagation in the non-neutral regime
Corollary 3.5 (Global non-neutral reconstruction stability). Assume the hypotheses of Theorem 3.1 and Lemma 3.4, uniformly along paths from to . Let be reconstructed by transport with . Then
with as in (19). If is connected and
is its intrinsic Riemannian diameter, then
The holonomy variational jet
First variation
Define
Then
so
Hence
The neutral condition is therefore
Second variation: exact formula
Define
Differentiating the variational equation gives
Since ,
Therefore
Theorem 4.1 (Exact second holonomy variation). Assume that the horizontal transport is defined on a common fibre interval around and is twice differentiable with respect to the initial anchor. Then
Equivalently,
In the neutral regime , one has
Proof. The formula follows from the variational equation for and the identity
The explicit expression uses
Remark 4.2. Theorem 4.1 replaces the earlier assertion that second-order holonomy is “controlled by ”. The correct object is the vertical second variation of the nonlinear transport along the true horizontal section.
Higher-order holonomy jet
For , define
The first two equations are
The general equation is most compactly written with the partial Bell polynomials . We use the convention
where the sum is over satisfying and .
Theorem 4.3 (Finite holonomy variational hierarchy). Assume the horizontal transport is defined on a common fibre interval around and that is there. Then, for ,
with
At the endpoint,
Proof. Differentiate the identity times with respect to . Faà di Bruno’s formula gives (32); the initial conditions follow from . Since and , the endpoint identities follow.
For the third derivative the recursion is explicit:
Dividing by and using gives the following useful formula.
Corollary 4.4 (Exact third holonomy variation). Under the hypotheses of Theorem 4.3,
where
The holonomy jet is therefore the endpoint jet of the vertical variational hierarchy:
The isolation order is the first nonzero component of this jet.
Finite-dimensional holonomy unfoldings and Malgrange preparation
The finite-order condition is not only a Taylor-order statement. For smooth finite-dimensional families of admissible return data it has an exact local preparation in the sense of Malgrange. We use the standard smooth preparation theorem; see Golubitsky–Guillemin [8 Chap. IV]. The restriction to finite-dimensional parameter families is essential for this direct application: the full space of return-map perturbations is infinite-dimensional and is not covered by the classical theorem without additional functional-analytic structure.
Let be a neighbourhood of . Consider a family of return components
along a fixed closed loop , and let denote the corresponding loop transport. Assume that the horizontal lifts are defined on a common fibre neighbourhood of and remain uniformly separated from the singular set. Standard smooth dependence of ODE solutions on parameters and initial data then gives a jointly smooth displacement
Theorem 4.5 (Malgrange preparation of a finite-order holonomy singularity). Assume that, at ,
Set . Then there exist neighbourhoods and , a smooth function
and smooth coefficient functions with
such that, after shrinking the neighbourhoods if necessary,
In particular, is nonvanishing on , and the local real anchors of the perturbed holonomy equation are exactly the real roots of the prepared polynomial
Proof. The uniform separation assumption removes the pole of the rational transport field from a common neighbourhood of the relevant solution graphs. Since the family is , standard parameter dependence for ODEs implies that , and hence , is jointly near . In the coordinate , the displayed derivative conditions say precisely that the smooth germ is regular of order in the distinguished variable . The Malgrange preparation theorem therefore yields a smooth unit times a monic polynomial of degree in , with smooth parameter-dependent coefficients. Because the unperturbed germ has multiplicity exactly , the prepared coefficients satisfy . Shrinking the neighbourhoods makes the unit nonvanishing throughout. The last assertion follows immediately from (34).
Corollary 4.6 (Quadratic neutral unfolding and discriminant). If , then locally
Hence the local real-anchor structure is governed by the discriminant
For sufficiently small , gives two nearby simple real anchors, a multiple real anchor, and no nearby real anchor. This is the prepared-polynomial counterpart of the even-order root-splitting alternatives in Proposition 5.2.
Proposition 4.7 (First-order coefficients of a quadratic prepared unfolding). Assume the hypotheses of Corollary 4.6. Write all derivatives below at , and set
Then, as ,
In particular, to first order the discriminant is controlled by the parameter derivative of the holonomy residual at the singular anchor, whereas the linear coefficient also feels the cubic anchor jet through unless .
Proof. Write and
At , comparison with the Taylor expansion of gives
Setting and differentiating with respect to yields
Differentiating first in and then in , and using , gives
which is equivalent to (36). Finally , so
Remark 4.8 (Structural versus quantitative information). The preparation theorem does not replace the explicit Hölder estimates of § 5. It provides an exact local structural reduction for smooth finite-dimensional unfoldings, while Theorem 5.1 quantifies how far a perturbed root can move under norm-bounded perturbations and Theorem 6.1 connects those perturbations to noisy return data. Thus the two viewpoints are complementary:
with the stability theory supplying the corresponding conditioning estimates.
Analytic dependence and the flat regime
The rational fibre dependence of gives more structure than regularity. Analytic dependence of flows on initial conditions for time-varying analytic vector fields is standard; see, for example, [10]. We include the short argument in the present scalar setting.
Theorem 4.9 (Analyticity of the holonomy map). Let be an interval of initial anchors such that, for every , the horizontal lift exists for and
uniformly in . Then is real analytic on . Consequently, if , , and
then there exists a neighbourhood of on which
Thus infinite isolation order for one loop is equivalent locally to identity holonomy for that loop.
Proof. Fix . By the uniform separation and continuous dependence of solutions, the exact solution graph through is contained in a compact real strip that has positive distance from the pole . The rational function therefore extends holomorphically in to a complex neighbourhood of that strip, uniformly for . On a sufficiently short time interval, Picard iteration for the complexified ODE maps a common complex neighbourhood of into itself; every iterate is holomorphic in the initial value and the iterates converge uniformly. Hence the local flow is holomorphic in the initial value. A finite composition of such short-time flow maps covers , so is holomorphic near and therefore real analytic on .
Since is real analytic, vanishing of and all derivatives at forces its Taylor series to vanish identically in a neighbourhood of . The identity theorem gives there.
Finite-order anchor isolation and parity-sensitive existence
The scalar exponent follows from the Taylor structure of a zero of multiplicity . In the present inverse problem, the substantive point is that the multiplicity is the first nonzero component of the holonomy jet derived in § 4.
Theorem 5.1 (Order- isolation). Let , let , and assume
Set
If , set
and assume . Let , with , and suppose . Assume either
(a) and , or
(b) and .
Then
Proof. Taylor’s formula gives
If , the localization hypothesis implies
Since , one has , and therefore
This is (38). If , the Taylor remainder vanishes identically on ; the same bound remains valid (and is slightly weaker than the exact remainder-free estimate).
:::
Proposition 5.2 (Parity-sensitive local existence). Let , let , and assume
Set and let satisfy
Choose such that
and, when ,
If
then:
(i) if is odd, has at least one zero in ;
(ii) if is even and , then has at least one zero in each of and ;
(iii) if is even and , then itself remains a zero.
Proof. Taylor’s formula and the choice of give
The perturbation bound preserves the endpoint signs. For odd , these signs are opposite, so the intermediate value theorem gives a zero. For even , the endpoint signs agree with ; the stated sign condition at gives one zero on each side. The last case is immediate.
Corollary 5.3 (Finite-order stability hierarchy). Let .
(i) If , Theorem 3.1 gives first-order stability .
(ii) If , every perturbed zero satisfying the localization hypothesis of Theorem 5.1 obeys
Existence is automatic for sufficiently small perturbations when is odd, and for even follows under the sign alternatives of Proposition 5.2.
If , no finite-order location estimate follows from that loop alone.
Remark 5.4 (Size of the quantitative constants). For the pure local model
the exact root displacement is
Theorem 5.1 gives instead the coefficient . For the exact pure-root coefficients are approximately 1.4142, 1.8171, 2.2134, while the theorem gives 1.4771, 1.8566, 2.2419. Thus the explicit Taylor-remainder constants are quantitative rather than optimal, but are already close to the pure-root asymptotic constants at low order.
Stability and observable finite-order coefficients
The previous section assumes control of the holonomy displacement. We now close the inverse-problem chain by showing that perturbations of the observable return components control every fixed finite vertical holonomy jet.
Theorem 6.1 (Finite-jet stability under return-data perturbations). Fix an integer , a closed loop , a compact anchor interval , and a perturbation ceiling . Let and be exact and perturbed return components satisfying
Assume that the exact horizontal lifts are uniformly separated on with margin in the sense of Definition 2.1. Shrinking if necessary, Lemma 2.2 supplies existence, a common bounded fibre region, and perturbed separation with margin . Then, for every , there is a constant depending only on , , , the exact geometric bounds, and such that
In particular,
while the same conclusion for follows from .
Proof. For , the exact fibre derivatives are
and the perturbed derivatives have the same form with hatted data. Uniform separation and boundedness imply, for , uniform bounds
and, by direct subtraction of the rational expressions,
The derivative at order is used when comparing and by the mean-value estimate in the fibre variable. The case is the standard Gronwall comparison of the two transport equations. For , let and . Theorem 4.3 gives triangular Bell-polynomial systems for and . Uniform bounds for the lower-order variations follow inductively from Gronwall. Subtracting the two equations at order yields a linear term in plus a forcing bounded by and lower-order differences, already controlled by the induction hypothesis. A further Gronwall estimate gives
Evaluating at proves (39). □
Remark 6.2. Theorem 6.1 is specific to the vertical anchor jet. It requires only perturbation of the observable fields along the loop because all anchor derivatives are derivatives with respect to the scalar fibre variable; no spatial differentiation of the noisy return data is introduced.
The theoretical coefficient is evaluated at the unknown true anchor. It is therefore useful to quantify how accurately it can be replaced by a coefficient computed at the reconstructed anchor.
Proposition 6.3 (Observable holonomy coefficient). Let . Assume , , and
Set
Then
If the right-hand side is at most for some , then
Consequently, whenever Theorem 5.1 applies,
Proof. The reverse triangle inequality gives
which is (40). The two-sided comparison of and is immediate, and substituting into Theorem 5.1 gives (41). □
For and , the observable estimate becomes
whereas the theorem constant expressed with the unknown exact coefficient is . The leading scalar asymptotic coefficient for a pure quadratic root is , so the displayed theorem constant is quantitative rather than optimal.
Corollary 6.4 (Observable coefficients from return data). Under the hypotheses of Theorem 6.1, for every fixed ,
Hence whenever the right-hand side is at most with , the observable estimate (41) applies with a coefficient computable from the perturbed holonomy jet.
Multi-loop finite-order aggregation
A single loop may have a weak or high-order signal. Several loops sharing the same true anchor can be combined deterministically without assuming statistical independence.
Let be closed loops based at the same , with holonomy displacements . Set
Assume and set
For define
and
Theorem 7.1 (Deterministic multi-loop finite-order bound). Assume and for and every . Let
and suppose
Let be an approximate common anchor satisfying
If , set , assume , and suppose . If , assume only . Then
Proof. Write . Vector Taylor expansion gives
with
Under the localization hypothesis,
On the other hand,
Combining the two estimates yields (43). If , the remainder vanishes and the same bound follows directly.
Remark 7.2 (Loop-design consequence). The theorem gives a deterministic ordering principle: first minimize the isolation order ; among loops of the minimal order, increase the collective coefficient while controlling loop length and transport conditioning. The residual allows numerically computed loops that do not possess an exactly common perturbed fixed point.
Global reconstruction stability at finite holonomy order
The local anchor estimate propagates through the same scalar transport equation used for exact reconstruction.
Theorem 8.1 (Global finite-order reconstruction stability). Let be finite. Assume:
(i) the exact and perturbed transports satisfy the uniform separation and boundedness hypotheses of Lemma 3.4 along paths connecting to every point of ;
(ii) has a zero satisfying the localization hypotheses of Theorem 5.1 (for example, under the odd/even sufficient conditions of Proposition 5.2);
(iii) the holonomy perturbation obeys for the chosen identifying loop.
Let
Then
where one may take
with from (19). Hence, for fixed ,
Proof. For a path from to , the standard Gronwall comparison gives
Choose paths with . By Theorem 5.1,
Substitution yields (44).
Geometric interpretation and remaining geometric questions
The exact second- and third-variation formulas give rigorous geometric signals beyond the linearized multiplier: and are integrals of vertical derivatives of the nonlinear return transport along the true horizontal section. Theorem 4.3 extends this to every finite order, while Theorem 4.9 settles the local analytic meaning of the flat regime for a fixed loop. The material below is deliberately stated as geometric perspective and open problems; no unproved small-loop curvature expansion or genericity assertion is used in the theorem chain.
Connection-curvature perspective
The inverse transport can be written as the horizontal distribution of the one-form
on the scalar bundle , as in the nonlinear-holonomy formulation of [2]; the connection language is standard, see [11]. If
then
This suggests the scalar curvature two-form
A remaining invariant problem is to express small-loop holonomy-jet coefficients in terms of the vertical curvature jet . Such a formula would connect the finite-order scalar singularity theory proved here to intrinsic local geometry of the inverse connection.
Spherical and non-umbilic perturbations
For a perturbation , the true anchor is
and the true horizontal section is . Expansions in must therefore be performed along this moving section.
Likewise, a compact convex surface in should not be modelled globally by two distinct constant principal curvatures. For a genuine non-umbilic core, such as an ellipsoid, an invariant leading coefficient must include the Levi-Civita connection terms of the principal frame. Deriving such a coefficient and proving generic non-vanishing remain open geometric problems. These questions are distinct from the vertical anchor-jet hierarchy, which is exact once the observed transport is fixed.
Neutral tuning
If a one-parameter family satisfies
then the sign is fixed for sufficiently small positive ; a nonzero linear coefficient prevents nearby neutral tuning. A generic search for neutral configurations should therefore use either a two-parameter family or a specially designed one-parameter family. Section § 10 shows that exact neutral tuning can nevertheless be achieved explicitly in a finite Fourier family on the circular core.
Numerical experiments
The numerical section has two purposes. First, it calibrates the finite-order scalar exponent without geometric complications. Second, it tests the actual return-map transport on genuine admissible geometries. All computations reported below were performed in double precision with Python 3.13.5, NumPy 2.3.5 and SciPy 1.17.0. The transport equations and their first two variational equations were integrated by DOP853 with relative tolerance (and for the exact baseline derivatives), absolute tolerance at most , and maximum step 0.02. Roots were refined by Brent’s method to relative and absolute tolerances of order . Geometric margins were first sampled on a grid of 20,000 angles and then enclosed independently by outward-rounded interval arithmetic (mpmath.iv) on 2,000 angular subintervals. A reference implementation accompanies the manuscript.
Algebraic finite-order calibration
For at and the perturbation , the relevant real root has exact magnitude (for even we take the positive branch). Thus the exponents , and are exact for .
| order | exact displacement | predicted exponent | observed log–log slope |
| 2 | 0.500000 | ||
| 3 | 0.333333 | ||
| 4 | 0.250000 |
Table 1. Exact scalar calibration of the finite-order exponent.
This benchmark only tests scalar singular-root geometry. The next experiments use return data generated by actual normal-incidence geometry.
Circular-core return geometry
Let be the unit disk and write
For a positive thickness set
The outer point is and its inward normal is
Writing the return decomposition as
one obtains
The inverse transport around the positively oriented circle is therefore
For the perturbation experiments we keep fixed and add smooth measurement error to the observed normal component,
The perturbed pair need not itself be an exact return map; it represents smooth observational error in the return components, which is precisely the setting of the stability theory.
A genuine non-neutral example
Take
The true anchor at is . Direct integration of (49) and its variational equations gives
The geometry is well separated from degeneracy. A 20,000-point grid gives
The independent interval enclosure on 2,000 angular cells yields the outward-rounded bounds
Thus the normal graph stays embedded and the first-hit discriminant is uniformly positive. The transversality is uniformly negative throughout the circle.
The perturbation response at the true anchor satisfies numerically
First-order root perturbation therefore predicts
At the observed coefficient is 4.69017, agreeing with the predicted leading constant to the displayed precision. For the perturbation (50), Table 2 shows the reconstructed anchor and global thickness errors. A least-squares fit over all nine noise levels gives slopes 1.00018 and 1.00023, respectively.
Table 2. Non-neutral geometric experiment.

Figure 1. Non-neutral return geometry: both local anchor error and global thickness error are first order in the return-data perturbation.
A numerically tuned neutral example
Consider the one-parameter Fourier family
We tune the first coefficient by solving the scalar neutrality equation
with Brent’s method on . This gives
We then set
At the base point ,
The tuned loop transport is neutral to machine precision,
while the exact second-variation formula gives
The geometry again has substantial admissibility margins. The 20,000-point grid gives
The independent interval enclosure on 2,000 angular cells gives
Hence the tuned normal graph is uniformly admissible for the numerical return construction. This is a numerically tuned second-order neutral holonomy generated by the return geometry, not an imposed scalar model.
For the perturbation (50), the residual at the true anchor has the linear response
Combining this with (55) gives the quadratic normal-form prediction
At the observed upper-branch coefficient is 10.1268, again matching the leading constant as well as the exponent.
Figure 2 displays the core, the Fourier outer boundary and several actual inward-normal return segments. The segment from to has length and the arrow on the core represents the closed loop used in the scalar transport.
Figure 2. TikZ rendering of the numerically tuned neutral circular-core geometry (54). The arrows are actual inward-normal return segments for five base points.
Under the same perturbation (50), the even-order neutral root splits into two branches. Table 3 reports both anchor displacements and the global thickness error for the upper branch. The fitted slopes over the complete range are
| lower root error | upper root error | ||
Table 3. Tuned neutral geometric experiment.
in agreement with the theoretical exponent .
The observed separation remains above 0.58 at the smallest noise levels and above 0.63 at , so the experiment stays well inside the uniformly separated regime of the transport estimates. The numerics therefore validate not only the scalar root exponent but the full chain from perturbed return components to anchor reconstruction and global thickness propagation.
Conclusion and open problems
The paper develops a finite-order singular stability theory for the anchor parameter in the nonlinear holonomy formulation of the return-map inverse problem. The proved chain is
At first order, the non-neutral regime is locally Lipschitz stable. At finite neutral order , the anchor obeys a -Hölder location estimate with parity-sensitive existence. Exact uniform separation is stable under sufficiently small return-data perturbations, so the singular fibre set enters the stability theory through an explicit quantitative conditioning margin. The exact second and third holonomy variations and the Bell-polynomial hierarchy identify the relevant coefficients as vertical derivatives of the geometric transport. For smooth finite-dimensional families, Malgrange preparation further shows that an order- holonomy singularity is locally equivalent, up to multiplication by a nonvanishing smooth factor, to a monic degree- polynomial in the anchor displacement; in the quadratic case Proposition 4.7 identifies the first-order prepared coefficients and discriminant correctly, including the contribution of the cubic anchor jet to . The finite-jet perturbation theorem makes the holonomy coefficients quantitatively observable from perturbed return data, while the multi-loop theorem combines several closed-loop signals without a statistical-independence assumption. Finally, the analytic-dependence theorem shows that infinite-order flatness for a fixed uniformly separated loop means local identity holonomy, rather than an arbitrary flat germ. The numerical experiments support the theorem chain on genuine return geometries. A non-neutral circular example gives first-order anchor and global reconstruction rates, while a numerically tuned neutral Fourier geometry has at machine zero, and yields observed rates close to for both the anchor and the full reconstructed thickness. In both regimes the observed leading anchor constant agrees with the corresponding local normal-form prediction.

Figure 3. Tuned neutral return geometry: the anchor and globally reconstructed thickness both exhibit the square-root stability law.
The principal remaining questions are geometric rather than scalar:
derive invariant formulas relating small-loop holonomy jets to the curvature and vertical curvature jet of the nonlinear inverse connection;
determine generic non-vanishing of those coefficients on genuine non-umbilic compact cores, including ellipsoids, without suppressing Levi-Civita connection terms;
characterize configurations for which all relevant loop holonomies are locally the identity and decide whether global admissibility or topology still isolates the anchor;
optimize loop families by combining isolation order, collective jet amplitude, loop length and transport conditioning;
extend the reconstruction and stability theory to lower regularity, for example ;
develop a range characterization for noisy candidate return maps that couples the transport residuals with geometric admissibility of the reconstructed normal graph.
References
- [1]M. Barkatou, Some geometric properties for a class of non-Lipschitz domains, New York J. Math. 8 (2002), 189–213.
- [2]M. Barkatou and M. El Morsalani, Inverse Problems for the Return Map in the Class O_C: Reconstruction and Identifiability, preprint (2026), arXiv:2604.24915 [math.DS].arxiv.org/abs/2604.24915
- [3]M. Barkatou and M. El Morsalani, The Return Map in the Class O_C: Geometry, Dynamics, and Thickness Regularity, Journal of Nonlinear Dynamics and Applications 2 (2026), no. 3, 192–216.
- [4]J. Bohr, Stability of the non-abelian X-ray transform in dimension ≥ 3, J. Geom. Anal. 31 (2021), 11226–11269. https://doi.org/10.1007/s12220-021-00679-0.
- [5]M. Cekić, C. Guillarmou, and T. Lefeuvre, Local lens rigidity for manifolds of Anosov type, Anal. PDE 17 (2024), no. 8, 2737–2795. https://doi.org/10.2140/apde.2024.17.2737.
- [6]M. Cekić and T. Lefeuvre, Stability estimates for the holonomy inverse problem, Comm. Partial Differential Equations 49 (2024), no. 5–6, 428–469. https://doi.org/10.1080/03605302.2024.2346942.
- [7]M. Cekić and T. Lefeuvre, The holonomy inverse problem, J. Eur. Math. Soc. 27 (2025), no. 6, 2187–2250. https://doi.org/10.4171/JEMS/1409.
- [8]M. Golubitsky and V. Guillemin, Stable Mappings and Their Singularities, Graduate Texts in Mathematics, vol. 14, Springer-Verlag, New York, 1973; Chapter IV, “The Malgrange Preparation Theorem,” pp. 91–110. https://doi.org/10.1007/978-1-4615-7904-5.
- [9]H. Grebnev, The non-abelian X-ray transform on asymptotically hyperbolic spaces, J. Geom. Anal. 36 (2026), Article 73. https://doi.org/10.1007/s12220-025-02296-7.
- [10]S. Jafarpour and A. D. Lewis, Time-Varying Vector Fields and Their Flows, SpringerBriefs in Mathematics, Springer, Cham, 2014. https://doi.org/10.1007/978-3-319-10139-2.
- [11]S. Kobayashi and K. Nomizu, Foundations of Differential Geometry, Vol. I, Interscience Publishers, 1963.
- [12]G. P. Paternain, M. Salo, and G. Uhlmann, Geometric Inverse Problems: With Emphasis on Two Dimensions, Cambridge Studies in Advanced Mathematics 204, Cambridge University Press, 2023.
- [13]Z. Zeng, Computing multiple roots of inexact polynomials, Math. Comp. 74 (2005), no. 250, 869–903. https://doi.org/10.1090/S0025-5718-04-01692-8.
