WorksMathematics
Holomorphic flexibility properties of strongly commuting varieties
Abstract
We study holomorphic flexibility properties of the strongly commuting variety of a complex semisimple algebraic group . We prove that the smooth locus of the strongly commuting variety of is Oka-. We also prove that the smooth locus of the commuting variety of a semisimple complex Lie algebra is Oka-, and that it contains a Zariski dense open subset which is algebraically elliptic.
Introduction
Main results. This paper studies holomorphic flexibility properties of two commuting varieties: the commuting variety of a complex algebraic group , defined as
and the commuting variety of a complex Lie algebra , defined as
The Oka-1 property is a holomorphic flexibility property introduced by Alarcón and Forstnerič [1]. Roughly speaking, a complex manifold is Oka-1 if every continuous map from an open Riemann surface into it is homotopic to a holomorphic map, with approximation and interpolation. The precise definition is recalled in § 2.1.
For a semisimple algebraic group , let be its universal covering. Define
and call it the strongly commuting variety of . Thus, a pair belongs to precisely when its entries lift to commuting elements in . Observe that if is simply connected then . Our main results are the following:
Theorem 1. Let be a semisimple complex algebraic group. The smooth locus of the strongly commuting variety of is Oka-1.
In particular, Theorem 1 implies that any continuous family of commuting pairs in the smooth locus of , parameterised by an open Riemann surface, is homotopic to a holomorphic family, with approximation and interpolation. We prove an analogous result in the Lie algebra case:
Theorem 2. Let be a semisimple complex Lie algebra. The smooth locus of the commuting variety of is Oka-1. Moreover, there is a dense open subset of which is algebraically elliptic.
Historical background. Commuting varieties were first studied in [MT55] for the Lie algebra . The authors showed that the commuting variety is irreducible of dimension . This result was later generalised by Richardson [46] who proved that the commuting varieties of reductive Lie algebras (resp. semisimple simply connected groups) over algebraically closed fields of characteristic zero are irreducible. The Lie algebra result was extended in [36] in the case of a field of positive characteristic and under certain mild assumptions on . Other versions of the commuting variety have also been studied. For instance, in [7] and [44], motivated by the study of moduli of vector bundles on algebraic surfaces, the authors investigated commuting varieties of nilpotent endomorphisms of a vector space, and related them to certain punctual Hilbert schemes. For other variants, in [11] and [31] the authors studied and classified varieties of almost commuting pairs of elements in compact Lie groups which appear naturally when one studies flat connections on principal -bundles over a torus. One may also consider the variety of commuting -tuples of a reductive group and of its maximal compact subgroup . The topology and cohomology of these varieties have been studied in [Bai07, GPS12, PS13]. In particular, it was shown that the variety of commuting -tuples in is a strong deformation retract of the variety of commuting -tuples in . Commuting varieties of algebraic groups are also special cases of representation varieties.
Representation varieties are varieties of representations of the fundamental group of a surface into a group . Thus, the commuting variety of is the representation variety associated with a torus and the group . The character variety associated with and is the quotient of the representation variety by the conjugation action of , parameterising representations up to equivalence. Character varieties, together with their related moduli spaces of flat connections and Higgs bundles, have been studied using a wide range of methods, appearing in many areas of mathematics and physics including non-abelian Hodge theory [49, 50], mirror symmetry [25], geometric Langlands [BD96, BZN18], and gauge theory [5, 26]. In this paper we study commuting varieties from the point of view of Oka theory.
Hyperbolic manifolds and Oka manifolds sit at opposite ends in the landscape of complex manifolds. The former are holomorphically rigid and the latter are holomorphically flexible. For instance, a theorem of Liouville implies that holomorphic maps are constant, illustrating the rigidity of such maps. Oka theory makes precise the property of a complex manifold of admitting ‘many’ holomorphic maps into it. Oka theory originates in the classical work of Oka and Grauert concerning analytic problems on Stein manifolds. This work gave rise to the Oka principle which says that analytic problems on Stein spaces have analytic solutions whenever there are no topological obstructions. In his seminal 1989 paper [22], Gromov introduced the notion of a dominating spray, a geometric condition which implies strong holomorphic flexibility properties. More precisely, he proved that if admits a dominating spray, then satisfies an Oka principle for holomorphic maps from Stein spaces : every continuous map is homotopic to a holomorphic one with approximation and interpolation. Building on Gromov’s work, Forstnerič and others developed the modern theory of Oka manifolds and established the equivalence of several approximation, interpolation, and parametric forms of the Oka property [16, 17].
Oka theory has now seen a diverse range of applications. These include the classification of holomorphic vector bundles on Stein spaces, the existence of holomorphic sections with prescribed local properties, problems concerning holomorphic embeddings, submersions, and matrix factorisations [18, 29]. An application closer to the setting of this paper appears in the work of Guralnick [23] and Leiterer [35] where the authors prove that holomorphic maps from 1-dimensional Stein spaces which are locally holomorphically similar are globally holomorphically similar. Guralnick proved this when is an open Riemann surface and Leiterer extended it to arbitrary 1-dimensional Stein spaces. In [35], Leiterer exploited an Oka principle for Oka pairs (in the sense of Forster and Ramsptt [FR66]) to reduce the assertion that locally holomorphically similar matrices are globally holomorphically similar to a certain topological statement and then proved the topological statement. In [17 Theorem 6.14.9], the results of Guralnick and Leiterer are obtained via an application of an Oka principle for sections of branched holomorphic maps (cf. [17 Theorem 6.14.6]).
In [1], Alarcón and Forstnerič introduced the Oka-1 property which restricts the source manifolds to open Riemann surfaces. Thus, every Oka manifold is Oka-1. Roughly speaking, Oka-1 manifolds are characterised by the property that they admit many holomorphic maps from open Riemann surfaces. They proved that a complex manifold dominable by at most points is Oka-1. Furthermore, they introduced a local spray approximation property which implies the Oka-1 property, and is one of the main tools used in this paper.
Idea of proof. We outline the key ideas of the proof of Theorem 1; the proof of Theorem 2 is analogous. Suppose first that is simply connected, and put . The commuting variety is singular, so flexibility cannot be applied directly to the whole variety. Instead, we consider the open subset of pairs whose first entry is regular, and show that it lies in the smooth locus. The fibre of the first projection map to over a regular element of is its centraliser . Although the centraliser is abelian, it is not generally connected, so the exponential map from its Lie algebra only hits the identity component. We prove a structural result for (Lemma 7) which says the remaining components can be reached by multiplication by powers of and central elements. This leads us to a family of local biholomorphisms
whose images cover . These maps are constructed using differentials of the fundamental characters of [52 §8]. The source is flexible and hence has the local spray approximation property (LSAP), recalled in § 2.1. The local biholomorphisms transfer this property to . The complement of in the smooth locus of is an analytic subset of positive codimension, so a criterion [1 Proposition 7.13(b)] implies the whole smooth locus is Oka-1.
For a general semisimple group , we pass to the universal covering . Since is the inverse image of under , restricting this covering to allows us to transfer LSAP from to the regular strongly commuting variety of . Again, using the criterion in [1 Proposition 7.13(b)] gives us the Oka-1 property for .
The full Oka property. Results in the very recent preprint [2], which originated in [41], show that our proofs of Theorem 1 and Theorem 2 give a much stronger conclusion, namely the full Oka property. Indeed, the proof of Theorem 1 shows that we can find a family of local biholomorphisms whose images cover and where is flexible and hence strongly dominable. It follows that is strongly dominable and hence Oka by [2 Theorem 1.4]. Moreover, by [2 Theorem 1.8], the Oka property extends across analytic subsets of positive codimension. Similarly, for the strongly commuting variety of a semisimple group , there is a surjective local biholomorphism which makes strongly dominable and hence Oka by [2 Theorem 1.4]. Thus, the whole smooth locus is Oka by [2 Theorem 1.8]. Similarly, the conclusions that the smooth loci of the commuting variety of a complex semisimple Lie algebra and the commuting variety of for prime are Oka-1 can be upgraded to the full Oka property by the same reasoning.
Outline of the paper. In § 2 we briefly discuss some preliminaries regarding the Oka-1 property and the local spray approximation property which is a key tool in the proofs of the main results. We briefly recall the definition of regular elements in a simply connected semisimple group and prove a structural result for the centralisers of such elements. Section 3 is devoted to the study of the regular commuting variety, a Zariski open subset of the commuting variety of that plays a central role in the proof. In § 3.1, we prove that the regular commuting variety is contained in the smooth locus of the commuting variety. We then define the local biholomorphisms in § 3.2 and use these to prove Theorem 1 in § 3.3 for the case of simply connected semisimple groups. In § 4, we define the strongly commuting variety and give four equivalent descriptions of which two are topological and two are algebraic. In § 4.1, we prove Theorem 1. In § 4.2, we drop the simple connectedness assumption by proving the Oka-1 property for the smooth locus of the commuting variety of when is prime. Finally, in § 5, we move to the Lie algebra case and prove Theorem 2.
Acknowledgements. The author would like to thank Finnur Lárusson for the many helpful discussions, for carefully reading the manuscript and providing feedback, and for pointing out the upgrade from the Oka-1 property to the full Oka property. The author is also grateful to David Baraglia for reading and providing helpful comments on this paper. This research was supported by the Australian Government Research Training Program.
Use of artificial intelligence. This paper was written entirely by the author. ChatGPT was used for finding literature, and GPT-5.6 was used during the preparation of the manuscript for proof-reading and checking mathematical arguments. In particular, it helped identify minor errors in Lemma 7 and Theorem 17.
Conventions. Throughout this paper, all algebraic groups, varieties and Lie algebras are defined over the field of complex numbers . We use the convention that semisimple algebraic groups are connected.
Preliminaries
In this section, we recall the notions of holomorphic flexibility used in the paper and establish some of the key ingredients used in the proof of Theorem 1. We give a structural result for the centralisers of regular elements in a simply connected almost simple algebraic group, and recall how differentials of the fundamental characters of can provide a basis for their Lie algebras.
Holomorphic flexibility and Oka-1 manifolds
There are several precise notions of holomorphic flexibility. Here, we define the notions relevant to the paper. These notions pertain to smooth varieties and they include flexibility, (algebraic) ellipticity, the local spray approximation property, and the Oka-1 property. The notion of a flexible variety was introduced by Arzhantsev et al. [4] and further developed in [3].
Definition 3. An irreducible variety is flexible if for all smooth points , the tangent space is spanned by the tangent vectors to the orbits of one-parameter unipotent subgroups .
For an irreducible affine variety of dimension at least two, flexibility is equivalent to the subgroup , generated by one-parameter unipotent subgroups, acting infinitely transitively on the smooth locus of [3]. Furthermore, it is shown in [3 Proposition A.3] that if a smooth irreducible variety is flexible then it admits a dominating spray, a geometric condition defined by Gromov [22] which implies the Oka principle for holomorphic sections of holomorphic fibre bundles over Stein manifolds.
Definition 4. Let be a complex manifold. A dominating spray on is a holomorphic vector bundle together with a holomorphic map such that restricts to the identity on the zero section , and for each the tangent map sends the fibre surjectively onto . Furthermore, is called elliptic if it admits a dominating spray. We say that is algebraically elliptic if is a smooth algebraic variety and the holomorphic vector bundle, together with the dominating spray, are algebraic.
Every elliptic manifold is Oka (cf. [17 Corollary 5.6.14]) and hence Oka-1. The Oka-1 property defines a class of complex manifolds characterised by the property that they admit many holomorphic curves parameterised by open Riemann surfaces. This class of complex manifolds was introduced in [1] and further studied in [FL25]. Let us recall the definition.
Definition 5. A connected complex manifold is an Oka-1 manifold if for any open Riemann surface , compact Runge set in , a discrete sequence in without repetitions, continuous map which is holomorphic on a neighbourhood of , distance function inducing the topology of , number , and integers there is a holomorphic map which is homotopic to and satisfies
, and
agrees with to order at the point for every .
We now introduce the local spray approximation property (LSAP). This property, introduced in [1], implies the Oka-1 condition [1]. The LSAP property plays an important role when we study the holomorphic flexibility properties of commuting varieties.
A pair of compact topological discs is called a special pair if both have piecewise smooth boundaries and is a disc attached to along a boundary arc. A holomorphic map to a complex manifold is called a holomorphic spray of maps with core , where denotes the unit ball in . Such a spray is said to be dominating if the partial derivative is surjective for all .
Definition 6. A complex manifold has the local spray approximation property (LSAP) at if there is an open neighbourhood of satisfying the following condition. Given a special pair of compact discs and dominating holomorphic spray , there is a number such that can be approximated uniformly on by holomorphic maps . A manifold has LSAP if the above condition holds at every .
By [1 Proposition 7.13 (b)], every manifold with LSAP is Oka-1. It is not known whether every Oka-1 manifold has LSAP.
Regular elements and centralisers
Let be a semisimple simply connected linear algebraic group. Following [52], we say an element is regular if its centraliser in has minimal dimension equal to . In [52], it is shown that the subset of regular elements is Zariski open and dense in . Moreover, since is assumed to be simply connected, is abelian [34 Theorem D].
Centralisers of regular elements
Here we give a decomposition of the centraliser in of a regular element in a simply connected almost simple algebraic group , which is vital for the proof of Theorem 1. The corresponding result for simply connected semisimple groups follows by applying the lemma to each almost simple factor. The proof is a consequence of [51 Remark 3]; see also [38 Lemma 34]. For an algebraic group , we denote by the connected component of the identity of .
Lemma 7. Let be a simply connected, almost simple algebraic group and let be a regular element. Then
Equivalently, the quotient
is finite cyclic generated by the class of .
Proof. Write for the Jordan decomposition of , and let be the centraliser of in . Using the uniqueness of the Jordan decomposition, it is readily checked that
Further, since , the unipotent part is a regular unipotent element of [13 Section 1.14], and since is simply connected, [28 Theorem 2.11] shows that is a connected reductive subgroup of maximal rank. Since is regular, it lies in a unique Borel subgroup of , where is the maximal torus and the unipotent radical of . It follows from [28 Proposition 4.1] that and . Thus,
Consider the quotient map and put . Since is connected and is a central isogeny, we have . Moreover,
is surjective. Indeed, if and then the homomorphism
is constant, because is connected and is finite, and its value at the identity is . Hence for every , so . By [51 Remark 3], the quotient
is a finite cyclic group generated by the class . We claim that
Indeed, consider the map
It is surjective with kernel given by . Thus,
Substituting this decomposition into , we obtain
Since and are connected subgroups of , their product is contained in . Therefore
It follows that
The reverse inclusion is clear. We conclude that
Finally, we may replace by in this decomposition. Indeed, since and
the images of and in the quotient
coincide. Hence
Equivalently, the quotient
is generated by the class of . □
Remark 8. When and is regular, the quotient
is trivial. Indeed, in the notation of the proof of the lemma, we saw above that
As is of type , the pseudo-Levi subgroup is actually a Levi subgroup. By [12 Proposition 3.5] this is equivalent to . We saw above that
and that , hence and the quotient
is trivial.
We provide an example in which this quotient is non-trivial.
Example 9. Let , where
Consider the semisimple element
The centraliser of is given by . Thus, the centre of is
where denotes the group of -roots of unity. Thus, the identity component is trivial. However, the centre of is
where denotes the -by-2 identity matrix. Thus,
and the class of generates this quotient. Choose the regular unipotent element
of and let . If is the unipotent radical of the unique Borel subgroup of containing , then
and
In particular, is regular in since . Moreover, has four connected components corresponding to the elements in the centre of ,
To see that in general, let and be the central elements of . Then the union
does not cover all of , as it does not contain the connected components represented by and . Since and , the classes of and in
coincide. Thus, multiplication by gives the remaining coset
Differentials of invariant functions
Recall that the action of on itself by conjugation induces an action of on its ring of functions. We denote by the corresponding ring of invariants. For , the differential , after a translation, defines an element in the dual space given by
Since we assume is semisimple, the Killing form gives an isomorphism . Let be the element in corresponding to under this isomorphism. The element is also defined by the formula
The following is stated in [21 page 264]; we prove it for completeness:
Proposition 10. Let be a semisimple algebraic group. Given and an invariant function , the corresponding element lies in the Lie algebra of the centraliser .
Proof. Recall that
It suffices to show that
where denotes the orthogonal complement with respect to the form . To this end, we compute
We are done if we show the right hand side is zero. We have
and the statement follows.
Example 11. Let , , and . We will show that . Instead of using the Killing form, in this example we use the non-degenerate invariant bilinear form . We have and, on the other hand, we have
Thus,
Hence we conclude that is orthogonal to . Using the standard decomposition , the orthogonal complement of with respect to the trace form is . Thus,
for some . Taking traces on both sides, one finds that . Thus,
Since is semisimple, its algebra of invariant functions is a polynomial algebra
where and the are the characters of the fundamental representations (cf. [52]). For instance, when , the generators are the coefficients of the characteristic polynomial. We end this section with a proposition due to Steinberg which will be useful for defining a basis for the Lie algebras of the centralisers of regular elements:
Theorem 12. [[52 Theorem 8.1]] Let be a semisimple simply connected algebraic group. An element is regular if and only if the differentials of the fundamental characters are linearly independent at .
Regular commuting variety
In this section, we prove that the regular commuting variety lies inside the smooth locus of the commuting variety and that it has LSAP, and deduce the Oka-1 property of the smooth locus.
Smoothness of the regular commuting variety
Let be a simply connected semisimple algebraic group and let denote the commuting variety defined as
There is a projection map from to :
Consider the inverse image under of the dense open subset of regular elements
We call the open subset the regular commuting variety. Furthermore, is irreducible since it is an open subset of the irreducible variety [46]. Now we have a surjective map between irreducible varieties whose fibre over each point has dimension equal to . By [48 §6.3, Theorem 1.25] it follows that
We identify and with by right translation, and hence with . Consider the set
Then differentiating the commuting equation gives . We have the following proposition:
Proposition 13. For every the projection
onto the first coordinate is surjective. Moreover, the point is smooth.
Proof. To show that is surjective, we need, for a given , to show that there is with
Consider the linear map
It suffices to show that lies in . Let denote the Killing form on , which is non-degenerate because is semisimple. By basic linear algebra,
where denotes the orthogonal complement of and the adjoint with respect to .
We claim that . Indeed, using the Ad-invariance of , for we compute
so . Hence,
where the last equality holds because if and only if $\operatorname{Ad}_{x^{-1}}(\beta) = \beta. Therefore, it suffices to show that
But for , using -invariance of ,
Finally, since , its centraliser in is abelian [34 Theorem D]. As commutes with , we have , so acts trivially on . Hence, for all , giving
This proves that , so is surjective. Consequently,
Moreover, for we have
so is a smooth point in and thus is contained in the smooth locus of . □
Local parameterisation of the regular commuting variety
In this section, we give local parameterisations for the open subset of the commuting variety of a simply connected almost simple algebraic group . The more general simply connected semisimple case will follow by taking products over the almost simple factors. For , we write for the Lie algebra of its centraliser.
Let be holomorphic maps associated to a set of generators for the invariant functions on , so that , for , form a basis for (cf. § 2.2.2).
Lemma 14. Let be a simply connected almost simple algebraic group of rank . For a fixed integer and , the map
is a local biholomorphism onto its image.
Proof. Since
by the holomorphic inverse function theorem, it suffices to show that the differential of is injective at every point of .
Fix and . For ease of notation, write
Let and suppose that the differential at satisfies
The restriction of to the first coordinate is the identity map on , and hence so is its differential. Then, by assumption, we must have . In the second coordinate, all terms involving and vanish. Thus the second component of reduces to
We now compute the differential . Write
and observe that and both lie in (cf. Proposition 10). Since and is simply connected, the Lie algebra is abelian ([52 Remark 3.13] or [34 Theorem D]). In particular, and commute, so we have
So
In particular, we get
Since is invertible, it follows that , that is,
By Theorem 12, are linearly independent in , so for all . Thus
and hence is injective. □
Lemma 15. Let be a simply connected almost simple algebraic group. Then
Proof. Let . Then and . By Lemma 7, there exist , , and such that . We will show that lies in the image of . Since is a connected commutative linear algebraic group, it is isomorphic to a product , where is a connected commutative unipotent group [13 Section 1.6]. The exponential maps from the Lie algebras and to the respective groups and are surjective. Hence, the exponential map
is surjective. Therefore there exists an with . Since form a basis of , we can write
for some and, in particular,
Hence
Thus, the images of the maps cover .
We will require a special case of the following lemma which says that a complex manifold covered by images of local biholomorphisms from LSAP manifolds has LSAP.
Lemma 16. Let be a family of complex manifolds, each having LSAP, and let be another complex manifold. Suppose further for each we have a collection of local biholomorphisms indexed by a set such that
Then has the LSAP property.
Proof. Let . By the assumption in the lemma, there are , , and neighbourhoods of and of such that
is a biholomorphism. Since has LSAP, after possibly shrinking , we may assume that is an LSAP neighbourhood of . We claim that is an LSAP neighbourhood of . Let be a special pair of compact discs, and let
be a dominating holomorphic spray. Composing with , we obtain a dominating holomorphic spray
By the LSAP property for , there exists such that can be approximated uniformly on by holomorphic maps
Composing with , we obtain holomorphic maps
Since is holomorphic, these maps approximate uniformly on . Therefore is an LSAP neighbourhood of , so has the LSAP property at . Since was arbitrary, has the LSAP property.
Oka-1 theorem
Theorem 17. Let be a connected simply connected semisimple algebraic group. Then has the LSAP property.
Proof. Write as the product of its almost simple factors. Since is simply connected, the multiplication map
is an isomorphism [39 §24a]. Under this isomorphism,
Applying Lemmas 14 and 15 to each almost simple factor and taking products, we obtain a family of local biholomorphisms from whose images cover .
By Lemma 16, it remains to show that has LSAP. Since finite products of LSAP manifolds have LSAP and has LSAP, it is enough to show that does. Indeed, in [4 Proposition 1.1] it is shown that semisimple algebraic groups are flexible and in [14 Theorem 1.1] that complements of flexible affine varieties of a closed subvariety of codimension remain flexible. Finally, Steinberg [52 Theorem 1.3 (a) and (b)] showed that is the complement of a closed subvariety of of codimension . Thus, is flexible, hence has the LSAP property.
:::
Remark 18. Recall that we defined as the preimage of by the projection map on the first component. However, the choice of projection map to the first component was arbitrary. If we denote the two projection maps for , then . Define
By symmetry the conclusion of Theorem 17 also holds for
Since the LSAP property is a Hausdorff local property [FL25, Proposition 5.5], we have that the union has LSAP.
Corollary 19. Let be a simply connected semisimple algebraic group. The smooth locus of the commuting variety of is an Oka-1 manifold.
Proof. Set . The complement is a proper analytic subset of and thus has complex dimension . Thus, the Hausdorff measure of is zero. By Theorem 17, has LSAP and hence is Oka-1 by [1 Proposition 7.13 (b)]. □
Remark 20. (1) There are many instances where the assumption of simple connectedness of was used. One of the main reasons we require simple connectedness is Steinberg’s result that, for simply connected, are linearly independent if and only if . Other applications of simple connectedness are that the centralisers of semisimple elements are connected and that the centralisers of regular elements are abelian.
(2) Within the classification of reductive algebraic groups, the simply connected almost simple algebraic groups are , , , together with the simply connected forms of the exceptional types , , , , [37 Table 9.2, p. 72]. Every simply connected semisimple algebraic group is a finite direct product of groups from this list [39 §24a].
Strongly commuting varieties
The motivation for defining strongly commuting varieties is the following. Suppose that we are interested in commuting elements in . Two elements commute if and only if their representatives commute up to an element of the centre , i.e., . Hence, we may impose a stronger condition on the elements to commute by requiring that the representatives commute in . In this case, we will say that and strongly commute. We give four equivalent descriptions of which two are topological and two are algebraic in nature. The algebraic formulations are inspired by [46 Section 3].
We begin with some notation. Let be a connected semisimple algebraic group and let be its universal covering, and let . Since is connected and is a finite normal subgroup, it follows that . Let and be any lift. Define the set-theoretic map
Proposition 21. The map is well-defined and is a morphism of varieties.
Before proving this proposition, for each , we introduce
Then, we have
Indeed, for any the images and commute. Conversely, for any with , we have that . Applying to both sides shows that . Now define the following subset of
We think of as the subset of whose lifts to commute up to the element . It follows immediately that and if .
Proof of Proposition 21. Since is finite and hence closed, the are closed in , as the are closed. Since there are finitely many , the are pairwise disjoint and their union covers . It follows that the are also open. The result of the proposition follows from the following claim: A set-theoretic map between an affine variety and a finite variety is induced by a morphism of varieties if and only if the fibres are open and closed. The forward direction is obvious. The converse is an application of [24 II, Ex 2.19]. □
Definition 22. Two commuting elements strongly commute if
We define the strongly commuting variety of as
By Richardson’s theorem, is irreducible because is semisimple and simply connected. Therefore, the strongly commuting variety is the image of the irreducible variety, hence is irreducible and connected and contains . Thus, it is the identity component of . The topology of the identity component of has been studied in [Bai07,GPS12,PS13].
We now state another topological description.
Definition 23. Two commuting elements topologically strongly commute if for some paths , with
the product paths and in are homotopic relative to the endpoints. Denote by the collection of pairs of elements which topologically strongly commute.
The next definition is algebraic and comes from [46 §3].
Definition 24. Let denote the pairs of elements such that there exists a maximal torus containing both and . Let denote the Zariski closure of .
We now introduce a fourth definition which is also inspired by [46 §3]:
Definition 25. Consider the subset
of . Denote the Zariski closure of by .
Theorem 26. Let be a semisimple algebraic group. We have
We prove this in the following order: then , and lastly .
Proposition 27. The equality holds.
Proof. Let , i.e., strongly commute. We will show that , i.e., and topologically strongly commute. Let be paths with
We must show that the product paths and are homotopic. By assumption, there are lifts such that
Let be the unique lifts of and such that
Then and differ by an element in the kernel . Specifically, if then . Similarly, for , we have . Define and . Since finite normal subgroups of connected algebraic groups are central, it follows that are central elements in . Moreover, from the assumption that it follows that
Thus, the endpoints of the lifts and commute so the products of the lifts and have the same endpoints and therefore are homotopic by some homotopy as is simply connected. Then gives a homotopy between and . Thus, and topologically strongly commute.
Conversely, suppose and topologically strongly commute. We are required to show that there exist such that and and . The paths have unique lifts with start point . The product paths and satisfy
because is a homomorphism of groups so and are the unique lifts for the paths and . Since by the covering homotopy lemma,
have the same endpoints and are homotopic. In particular,
Thus, and
□
Proposition 28. The equality holds.
Proof. If two elements are contained in a maximal torus then their images and are contained in the maximal torus of [10 Proposition 11.4]. Conversely, if is a maximal torus, then is a maximal torus of with . Hence any pair in has lifts in . Since the map is a finite map, it is closed and, in particular, the map commutes with taking Zariski closures. With these facts at hand we have
Note that the fourth equality is [46 Theorem C]. □
Proposition 29. The equality holds.
Proof. The inclusion follows from [46 §3, Theorem B]. For the other inclusion, suppose and are contained in the maximal torus so that . Then and , thus, . In particular, . Thus, . □
Oka-1 for strongly commuting varieties
In this section we prove that the smooth locus of the strongly commuting variety of a semisimple algebraic group is Oka-1. Let be a semisimple algebraic group and be its strongly commuting variety. The open subset of defined by
is called the regular strongly commuting variety.
Theorem 30. Let be a connected semisimple algebraic group. Then the regular strongly commuting variety has LSAP. Consequently, the smooth locus is an Oka-1 manifold.
Proof. Since is a central isogeny, it is a finite holomorphic covering map hence a local biholomorphism. Moreover, regular elements in descend to regular elements in via [34 Proposition 2.3 (2)]. It follows that the map
is a surjective local biholomorphism. Since is smooth and has LSAP by Theorem 17, it follows that is smooth and also has LSAP. Set . The complement is a proper analytic subset of complex dimension . Thus the Hausdorff measure of is zero. Thus, is Oka-1 by [1 Proposition 7.13 (b)]. □
Oka-1 for PSL(C)
In Theorem 30 we showed that the smooth locus of the strongly commuting variety of a semisimple algebraic group is Oka-1. In this section, we prove an Oka-1 result for the full commuting variety of the semisimple (but not simply connected) group when is prime. This will involve the study of almost commuting elements which have previously been studied in [11] and [31] in the case of compact Lie groups. Here, we adapt some of their results to the setting of semisimple algebraic groups.
We return to the case where is a semisimple algebraic group and let be its universal covering and let . Then
where
and we have identified the strongly commuting variety with the image . It is an interesting problem to describe the components , i.e., collections of elements commuting up to a central element . Following Serre [47], we define the notion of irreducible pairs:
Definition 31. A subgroup of is said to be irreducible if it is not contained in any proper parabolic subgroup of . We say that a pair is irreducible if is an irreducible subgroup of . Here denotes the Zariski closure of the group generated by elements .
Note that irreducibility of implies that is reductive. Indeed, the unipotent radical of is normalised by , and hence . By [27 Cor 30.3], is contained in a parabolic subgroup of , so, by irreducibility of , it follows that . Consequently, is reductive and irreducibility of a pair implies that is finite (cf. [45 Lemma 7.6]). Note that, in [11], irreducible pairs are called rank zero pairs.
Lemma 32. Let be a semisimple algebraic group and let be an irreducible pair satisfying
Then and are semisimple of finite order. Moreover, if is simply connected then and are regular elements.
Proof. Since is finite, we may assume that has finite order . Using the relation in the statement, we have
Thus, and similarly, . Thus, and are contained in the finite group , where , and thus have finite order by [45 Lemma 7.6]. Furthermore, since and have finite order they must be semisimple. Moreover, if is simply connected then and are connected [28 Theorem 2.11] and reductive. Furthermore, normalises and thus conjugation by restricted to defines an automorphism of whose fixed-point set is the finite group . By [53 Corollary 10.10], is necessarily solvable. Thus, is a connected reductive solvable group and therefore a torus [27 Theorem 19.3 (b)]. By symmetry the same argument holds for . Thus, and are regular elements. □
The following lemma is the algebraic group version of [11 Proposition 4.1.1]:
Lemma 33. Let be a semisimple simply connected algebraic group and let . Suppose that
are irreducible pairs satisfying
Assume that and are regular semisimple. Then the two pairs are simultaneously in if and only if and are conjugate in .
Proof. The forward direction is trivial. For the converse, we may assume that . The goal is to find a so that . Since normalises , the commutator map
is well-defined. Its kernel is
Since the pair is irreducible, is finite, hence and, since the image is closed, we may conclude that is surjective. Furthermore, one
can check that , hence there is a such that which is equivalent to . Since , we have
Lemma 34. Let and let be a central element where each generates . Then all pairs satisfying
are irreducible.
Proof. Let be a nonzero invariant subspace for the action of and an eigenvector. Since has order , using the relation , it is easy to see that has eigenvectors which are all linearly independent, hence form a basis for . Thus, and it follows that each is irreducible and hence so is the pair .
Corollary 35. Let be a prime number. Every pair satisfying
is irreducible and all such pairs are conjugate. In particular, is a homogeneous space isomorphic to .
Proof. Let be a prime number and fix a nontrivial central element . Let for be to pairs in . Using the defining relation, one sees that the eigenvalues of and are equal, thus and are conjugate and by Lemma 33 so are the pairs. If , then is an intertwiner for the restriction to of the standard representation of on . Since is irreducible, Schur’s lemma implies that is a scalar multiple of the identity, hence . Clearly, , hence .
Theorem 36. Let , where is a prime. Then the smooth locus of the commuting variety of is Oka-1.
Proof. Let be the quotient map. Then
Let and and let . We have already seen that
By Corollary 35, the , and hence also , are homogeneous for . Consequently, the with are Oka-1. The smooth locus is Oka-1 by Theorem 30. Therefore all connected components of the full smooth locus are Oka-1. The statement of the theorem follows since the Riemann surface in the definition of Oka-1 is connected. □
Remark 37. The assumption that is prime in Theorem 36 is used to ensure that every non-identity component is a homogeneous space. If were not prime, a non-identity element need not generate the whole centre. The varieties corresponding to such elements need not be homogeneous spaces. We refer the reader to [11 §4] for the classification of general -pairs in the case of compact Lie groups.
The Lie algebra case
In this section we study the holomorphic flexibility properties of the smooth locus of the commuting variety of a semisimple Lie algebra.
Let be a rank complex semisimple Lie algebra with adjoint group . Recall that an element is regular if the dimension of its centraliser in is minimal equal to the rank of . The commuting variety of the Lie algebra is defined as
We define two dense open subsets
Furthermore, we denote by their union
Remark 38. In [43 §2], the author defines the subset
also called the regular subset of , which is an open subset of the smooth locus [[43 Theorem 1.3 (ii)]]. We remark that the open subset we defined above is contained in . The distinction already appears in for and where denotes the standard basis vector whose th row and th column is 1 and zero elsewhere. One verifies that but neither nor is regular elements. Hence, in general there is a proper containment .
By Chevalley’s theorem, we may choose homogeneous generators . For , the differentials may be identified with elements of the dual space . Using the non-degeneracy of the Killing form , we have an isomorphism . Define as the element . Equivalently, is defined by the formula
Proposition 40. The map
is an algebraic isomorphism.
Proof. The map is algebraic so we need to show that it has an algebraic inverse. To do so, we construct local inverses on a suitable open cover of and then show they agree on overlaps.
Fix a basis for and identify . For each -subset of the -set define the coordinate projection . For each denote by the image of under the projection map under the above identification. Explicitly, if then corresponds to
Now, for each , let be the matrix whose columns are the for . That is,
Thus, we may write the map as
By Lemma 39, for there exists a subset of rows of such that the -by- sub-matrix
of is invertible. For such a choice of , the restriction is an isomorphism. For each -subset as above, define the open set of
Hence, we have shown that, for each there exists a subset for which is invertible, and thus the collection of all forms an open cover of . Corresponding to the open subsets , we define
Then, as varies over all -subsets of , the open sets cover . For each define
If for two subsets and of , the restrictions of and to the intersection agree. Indeed, since , by Lemma 39 we have . Therefore, there are unique constants such that which under the identification we write as
Then, in particular,
and, similarly, . Thus, the agree on the overlaps. The define local inverses to since the restrictions are given by
Furthermore, since matrix inversion is algebraic, the are algebraic and glue to a global algebraic inverse. □
Remark 41. In [43 Theorem 1.12] the author proves the variety is rational. We give an alternative proof of this fact: The composition identifies the dense open subset with a dense open subset of , hence is rational.
Corollary 42. The regular commuting variety is algebraically elliptic.
Proof. The Zariski open sets , in are algebraically elliptic since they are each isomorphic to the elliptic manifold . Indeed, by [Vel72, Theorem 4.12], is a closed subvariety of codimension 3 in the flexible variety . By [14 Theorem 1.1], is flexible and hence the product is algebraically elliptic. Furthermore, algebraic ellipticity is Zariski local, so the union is algebraically elliptic [30 Theorem 0.1]. □
Remark 43. Applying Corollary 42 in the case of , we see that the smooth locus
is algebraically elliptic (see also [43 Example 1.10]).
Corollary 44. The smooth locus is Oka-1.
Proof. Set and let . Since is Zariski dense, is a proper analytic subvariety with . Consequently, the Hausdorff measure of is zero. Since is algebraically elliptic, it has the LSAP property and thus is Oka-1 [1 Proposition 7.13 (b)]. □
References
School of Mathematical Sciences, College of Science, Adelaide University, SA 5005, Australia
Email address: [email protected]
References
- [1]A. Alarcón and F. Forstnerič, Oka-1 manifolds, Math. Z. 311 (2025), no. 2, Paper No. 33, 34 pp.
- [2]S. An, Y.-H. Du, B. Guo, P.-C. Wang, and S.-Y. Xie, A local approximation characterization of Oka manifolds (2026), available at arXiv:2610.10475v3[math.CV]. Version 3, 19 October 2026.
- [3]I. Arzhantsev, H. Flenner, S. Kaliman, F. Kutzschebauch, and M. Zaidenberg, Flexible varieties and automorphism groups, Duke Math. J. 162 (2013), no. 4, 767–823.
- [4]I. V. Arzhantsev, M. G. Zaidenberg, and K. G. Kuyumzhiyan, Flag varieties, toric varieties, and suspensions: three examples of infinite transitivity, Mat. Sb. 203 (2012), no. 7, 3–30 (Russian, with Russian summary); English transl., Sb. Math. 203 (2012), no. 7, 923–949.
- [5]M. F. Atiyah and R. Bott, The Yang–Mills equations over Riemann surfaces, Philos. Trans. Roy. Soc. London Ser. A 308 (1983), no. 1505, 523–615.
- [7]V. Baranovsky, The variety of pairs of commuting nilpotent matrices is irreducible, Transform. Groups 6 (2001), no. 1, 3–8, DOI 10.1007/BF01236059. MR1825165DOI
- [10]A. Borel, Linear algebraic groups, 2nd ed., Graduate Texts in Mathematics, vol. 126, Springer-Verlag, New York, 1991.
- [11]A. Borel, R. Friedman, and J. W. Morgan, Almost commuting elements in compact Lie groups, Mem. Amer. Math. Soc. 157 (2002), no. 747, x+136.DOI
- [12]G. Carnovale and F. Esposito, On sheets of conjugacy classes in good characteristic, Int. Math. Res. Not. IMRN 4 (2012), 810–828.DOI
- [13]R. W. Carter, Finite groups of Lie type, Wiley Classics Library, John Wiley & Sons, Ltd., Chichester, 1993. Conjugacy classes and complex characters; Reprint of the 1985 original; A Wiley-Interscience Publication.
- [14]H. Flenner, S. Kaliman, and M. Zaidenberg, A Gromov-Winkelmann type theorem for flexible varieties, J. Eur. Math. Soc. (JEMS) 18 (2016), no. 11, 2483–2510.DOI
- [16]F. Forstnerič, Runge approximation on convex sets implies the Oka property, Ann. of Math. (2) 163 (2006), no. 2, 689–707.DOI
- [17]F. Forstnerič, Stein manifolds and holomorphic mappings, 2nd ed., Ergebnisse der Mathematik und ihrer Grenzgebiete. 3. Folge. A Series of Modern Surveys in Mathematics [Results in Mathematics and Related Areas. 3rd Series. A Series of Modern Surveys in Mathematics], vol. 56, Springer, Cham, 2017. The homotopy principle in complex analysis.
- [18]F. Forstnerič, Holomorphic embeddings and immersions of Stein manifolds: a survey, Geometric complex analysis, Springer Proc. Math. Stat., vol. 246, Springer, Singapore, 2018, pp. 145–169.arxiv.org/abs/1709.05630
- [21]W. Goldman, Invariant functions on Lie groups and Hamiltonian flows of surface group representations, Invent. Math. 85 (1986), no. 2, 263–302.DOI
- [22]M. Gromov, Oka’s principle for holomorphic sections of elliptic bundles, J. Amer. Math. Soc. 2 (1989), no. 4, 851–897.DOI
- [23]R. Guralnick, Similarity of holomorphic matrices, Linear Algebra Appl. 99 (1988), 85–96.DOI
- [24]R. Hartshorne, Algebraic geometry, Graduate Texts in Mathematics, vol. 52, Springer-Verlag, New York-Heidelberg, 1977.
- [25]T. Hausel and M. Thaddeus, Mirror symmetry, Langlands duality, and the Hitchin system, Invent. Math. 153 (2003), no. 1, 197–229.DOI
- [26]N. J. Hitchin, The self-duality equations on a Riemann surface, Proc. London Math. Soc. (3) 55 (1987), no. 1, 59–126.DOI
- [27]J. E. Humphreys, Linear algebraic groups, Graduate Texts in Mathematics, vol. 21, Springer-Verlag, New York-Heidelberg, 1975.DOI
- [28]J. E. Humphreys, Conjugacy classes in semisimple algebraic groups, Mathematical Surveys and Monographs, vol. 43, American Mathematical Society, Providence, RI, 1995.
- [29]B. Ivarsson and F. Kutzschebauch, Holomorphic factorization of mappings into SL_n(C), Ann. of Math. (2) 175 (2012), no. 1, 45–69.arxiv.org/abs/0812.0312
- [30]S. Kaliman and M. Zaidenberg, Gromov ellipticity and subellipticity, Forum Math. 36 (2024), no. 2, 373–376.arxiv.org/abs/2301.03058
- [31]V. G. Kac and A. V. Smilga, Vacuum structure in supersymmetric Yang-Mills theories with any gauge group, The many faces of the superworld, World Sci. Publ., River Edge, NJ, 2000, pp. 185–234.
- [32]B. Kostant, Lie group representations on polynomial rings, Amer. J. Math. 85 (1963), 327–404.
- [33]B. Kostant, The solution to a generalized Toda lattice and representation theory, Adv. in Math. 34 (1979), no. 3, 195–338.DOI
- [34]J. F. Kurtzke Jr., Centralizers of irregular elements in reductive algebraic groups, Pacific J. Math. 104 (1983), no. 1, 133–154.DOI
- [35]J. Leiterer, Similarity of holomorphic matrices on 1-dimensional Stein spaces, Functional analysis and geometry: Selim Grigorievich Krein centennial, Contemp. Math., vol. 733, Amer. Math. Soc., [Providence], RI, 2019, pp. 209–231.arxiv.org/abs/1710.10969
- [36]P. Levy, Commuting varieties of Lie algebras over fields of prime characteristic, J. Algebra 250 (2002), no. 2, 473–484.DOI
- [37]G. Malle and D. Testerman, Linear algebraic groups and finite groups of Lie type, Cambridge Studies in Advanced Mathematics, vol. 133, Cambridge University Press, Cambridge, 2011.DOI
- [38]G. J. McNinch and E. Sommers, Component groups of unipotent centralizers in good characteristic, J. Algebra 260 (2003), no. 1, 323–337. Special issue celebrating the 80th birthday of Robert Steinberg.
- [39]J. S. Milne, Algebraic groups, Cambridge Studies in Advanced Mathematics, vol. 170, Cambridge University Press, Cambridge, 2017. The theory of group schemes of finite type over a field.
- [41]OpenAI, Every complex K3 surface is Oka, 2026. OpenAI Math Release preprint OAI:Every-complex-K3-surface-is-Oka-September-23-2026.
- [43]V. Popov, Irregular and singular loci of commuting varieties, Transform. Groups 13 (2008), no. 3–4, 819–837.arxiv.org/abs/0801.3074
- [44]A. Premet, Nilpotent commuting varieties of reductive Lie algebras, Invent. Math. 154 (2003), no. 3, 653–683.
- [45]Z. Reichstein and B. Youssin, Essential dimensions of algebraic groups and a resolution theorem for G-varieties, Canad. J. Math. 52 (2000), no. 5, 1018–1056. With an appendix by János Kollár and Endre Szabó.DOI
- [46]R. Richardson, Commuting varieties of semisimple Lie algebras and algebraic groups, Compositio Math. 38 (1979), no. 3, 311–327.
- [47]J-P. Serre, Complète réductibilité, Astérisque 299 (2005), Exp. No. 932, viii, 195–217 (French, with French summary). Séminaire Bourbaki. Vol. 2003/2004.
- [48]I. Shafarevich, Basic algebraic geometry 1: Varieties in projective space, 3rd ed., Springer, Heidelberg, 2013.DOI
- [49]C. T. Simpson, Higgs bundles and local systems, Inst. Hautes Études Sci. Publ. Math. 75 (1992), 5–95.DOI
- [50]C. T. Simpson, Moduli of representations of the fundamental group of a smooth projective variety. I, Inst. Hautes Études Sci. Publ. Math. 79 (1994), 47–129.DOI
- [51]E. Sommers, A generalization of the Bala–Carter theorem for nilpotent orbits, Internat. Math. Res. Notices 11 (1998), 539–562.
- [52]R. Steinberg, Regular elements of semisimple algebraic groups, Inst. Hautes Études Sci. Publ. Math. 25 (1965), 49–80.DOI
- [53]R. Steinberg, Endomorphisms of linear algebraic groups, Memoirs of the American Mathematical Society, vol. 80, American Mathematical Society, Providence, RI, 1968.DOI