betaFeedback

WorksPhysics and Astronomy

FORGE'd in Fragments: Pop III star formation in a Milky Way-like progenitor halo

Abstract

We present a radiation-magnetohydrodynamic (RMHD) cosmological zoom-in simulation of Pop III star formation, drawing initial conditions from a Milky Way-like progenitor halo at redshift z∼21z \sim 21. We follow the collapse of primordial gas over 10 orders of magnitude, through to the formation of an accretion disk that becomes gravitationally unstable Δt∼−3Δt \sim -3 kyr before the first protostar's formation. Prominent spiral arms then develop and fragment vigorously, producing ∼60\sim 60 sink formation events over the first 88 kyr post-collapse evolution, with a total stellar mass reaching >150 M⊙> 150\,{\rm M_\odot} by 1515 kyr, the end of our simulation. The disk remains magnetically supercritical throughout: the mass-to-flux ratio falls from μΦ∼102μ_Φ\sim 10^2-10310^3 to ∼15\sim 15 by 1515 kyr, as the inflow brings in magnetic flux. The magnetic energy in the disk remains sub-dominant throughout, but grows by ∼3.5\sim 3.5 orders of magnitude after the first star forms. The disk starts sub-virial and reaches virial equilibrium within ∼2\sim 2 kyr. The total stellar mass of the population grows as M∗∝t2M_* \propto t^2, confirming the prediction of accelerating accretion in self-gravitating turbulent collapse, at rates of M˙∼10−3\dot{M} \sim 10^{-3}-10−2 M⊙yr−110^{-2}\,{\rm M}_\odot {\rm yr}^{-1}. The star formation efficiency reaches ≈90%\approx 90\% within the disk (after ≈11\approx 11 kyr; ≈80%\approx 80\% at 9.59.5 kyr) and ∼50%\sim 50\% within a 0.10.1 pc sphere. We find a top heavy IMF (dN/dm∝m−αdN/dm \propto m^{-α}) with a high-mass slope α≈1α\approx 1. The cosmological environment sets the boundary conditions of the disk: an envelope delivers ∼3×10−3 M⊙yr−1\sim 3\times 10^{-3}\,{\rm M}_\odot {\rm yr}^{-1} to the outer edge of a disk with a radius of ∼103\sim 10^{3} AU; the disk spreads and, in our simulation, its fragmentation sites move outward, from ∼500\sim 500 to ∼1350\sim 1350,AU, until it has been depleted.

Introduction

The first generation of stars, Population III (Pop III), is thought to have formed from metal-free primordial gas in dark-matter minihalos at redshifts z∼20z \sim20–3030 [2, 11]. Because molecular hydrogen (H2_2) was the only efficient gas coolant at these epochs, the primordial gas could cool to a temperature floor of T∼200T \sim200 K at densities n∼104n \sim10^4 cm−3^{-3}, before reaching local thermodynamic equilibrium in its ro-vibrational levels [11, 49]. The Jeans mass at this point, MJ∼103M_J \sim10^3 M⊙_\odot, is orders of magnitude larger than that of present-day star-forming cores, leading to the early expectation that Pop III stars were predominantly massive and formed in isolation within each minihalo [2, 11, 117]. These early simulations bridged cosmological collapse down to protostellar densities (n∼1021n \sim10^{21} cm−3^{-3}), resolving the characteristic stages of primordial collapse: H2_2 three-body formation heating at n≳108n \gtrsim10^8 cm−3^{-3}, collision-induced emission cooling at n≳1014n \gtrsim10^{14} cm−3^{-3}, and a second collapse driven by H2_2 dissociation at n∼1016n \sim10^{16} cm−3^{-3} [71, 117, 115].

This picture of isolated, monolithic Pop III star formation was altered as a result of simulations that continued to follow the system after the initial protostar formed. The infalling gas inevitably carries angular momentum, seeding a self-gravitating accretion disk prone to gravitational instability and fragmentation, so that a protostellar cluster arises instead of a single object [99, 15, 26, 100, 115].

Corresponding author: Vasilii Pustovoit The protostellar cluster is shaped by competitive accretion ([7]), fragmentation-induced starvation ([78, 80]), protostellar mergers, and dynamical ejections, with 31–43% of the surviving sinks on escaping trajectories ([97, 98]).

Turbulence plays a fundamental role in shaping fragmentation and the resulting mass distribution. Cosmological infall into dark-matter potential wells drives supersonic turbulence in Pop III minihalos, with Mach numbers M≈1.8\mathcal{M} \approx1.8–5 that increase with halo mass ([14] (M.-Y. Ho et al. 2026)). K. M. J. Wollenberg et al. [115] showed that the degree of initial turbulence strongly affects the number of fragments and the resulting mass distribution, with higher initial turbulent velocities producing more fragments and more stochastic outcomes. J. Prieto et al. [79] showed that turbulent fragmentation in a larger, 3×107 M⊙3 \times10^{7}\,M_{\odot} halo at z∼11z \sim11 produces ∼25\sim25 gravitationally unstable clumps, proposing that infall-driven turbulence may be the dominant fragmentation mechanism when halo masses exceed the canonical 106 M⊙10^{6}\,M_{\odot} minihalo scale.

Magnetic fields can further modify Pop III star formation, though their net effect remains debated: even trace seed fields are amplified during collapse to 3–100% of equipartition ([29]) and can become dynamically important within ∼103\sim10^{3} yr of protostar formation ([88, 30, 60]). Strong fields can suppress disk fragmentation ([30, 101]), but fragmentation persists, if reduced, in other runs ([81, 86]), and early on magnetic fields limit protostellar masses more effectively than radiation ([89, 90]). The outcome depends on initial field strength, geometry, resolution, run duration ([49]) and even the numerical MHD scheme ([112]).

The Pop III initial mass function (IMF) inferred from these simulations is generally thought to be top-heavy, spanning ∼1\sim1 to several hundred M⊙M_{\odot}, with single stars in some halos and multiple systems in others ([107]). When radiative feedback is included, accretion onto a single protostar can be halted at ∼43 M⊙\sim43\,M_{\odot} ([43]), though episodic accretion from a fragmenting disk can produce intermittent feedback and final masses from ∼10\sim10 to several hundred M⊙M_{\odot} ([42]). The large statistical survey of S. Hirano et al. [31] across >100> 100 cosmological halos confirms that the Pop III IMF is not universal: the outcome depends on halo mass, angular momentum, and baryon streaming velocity.

While many Pop III simulations now use cosmological initial conditions ([26, 98, 56, 31, 64]), simulations that simultaneously combine cosmological ICs, full radiation-MHD, and resolved individual protostellar formation remain few. Y. J. Meziani et al. [64] use the FORGE’d in FIRE framework ([41]) to study Pop III star formation in an UFD (Ultra Faint Dwarf) galaxy progenitor, the m09 halo ([113]) (∼2×109 M⊙\sim2 \times10^{9}\,M_{\odot} at z=0z = 0), where the first Pop III star forms at z∼14z \sim14 in a halo of ∼106 M⊙\sim10^{6}\,M_{\odot}. A minimal-embedded in a strong overdensity destined to grow to Milky Way (MW) mass may experience qualitatively different infall rates, tidal torques, and angular momentum injection compared to one in a quieter environment destined to remain a dwarf galaxy. Therefore, in this paper, we zoom-in to the formation of the first stars in a massive halo of 2×107 M⊙2 \times10^{7}\,M_{\odot} (above the atomic-cooling threshold at z≈21z \approx21) that eventually grows to MW mass at z=0z=0.

We perform a cosmological radiation-magnetohydrodynamic (RMHD) zoom-in simulation of Pop III star formation in the MW-progenitor halo ([39, 113]), adopting the cosmology and the 60 h−160\,h^{-1} comoving Mpc parent box size of the AGORA project ([47]). We use the FORGE’d in FIRE framework ([41]), combining FIRE-3 ([40]) large-scale physics with STARFORGE ([27]) protostellar physics, and evolve the system for ∼15\sim15 kyr after the first protostar forms, reaching a gas mass resolution of Δm∼10\Delta m \sim10–3 M⊙3\,M_{\odot}. We study the thermodynamic collapse, disk formation and fragmentation, magnetic field amplification, and protostellar mass assembly in this environment, providing the first cosmological RMHD simulation that resolves individual Pop III protostellar formation in a MW-progenitor halo. Figure 1 shows a multi-scale view of the simulation at the end of the run (at Δt≈15\Delta t \approx15 kyr).

Multi-scale density projection of the simulation

Figure 1. Multi-scale density projection of the simulation at Δt≈15\Delta t \approx15 kyr, illustrating the dynamic range from the cosmic web (box size of ≈100\approx100 kpc) to the center of the protostellar disk (resolving AU scales). White boxes mark the region shown in the next panel. Yellow star symbols mark sink particles, with size of the marker scaling with the final mass of the star. The progenitor halo has a dark matter mass of ∼2×107 M⊙\sim2 \times10^{7}\,M_{\odot} at the first collapse, z∼21z \sim21.

The rest of the paper is organized as follows. § 2 describes the simulation setup, physics modules, refinement strategy, and analysis methods. § 3 presents the disk morphology, thermodynamic and energetic evolution, disk stability, star formation history, accretion rates, protostellar mass function, and magnetic field structure. § 5 compares our results to previous Pop III simulations. § 6 presents caveats of our simulation. We state our conclusions in § 7.

Simulation and Methods

Simulation details

For this paper we utilize the FORGE’d in FIRE framework of P. F. Hopkins et al. [41], extended to the primordial star-formation regime similar to Y. J. Meziani et al. [64]. We employ FIRE-3 ([40]) physics modules at low resolution (mDM≈3.5×104 M⊙m_{\rm DM} \approx3.5 \times10^{4}\,M_{\odot}, mb≈7×103 M⊙m_{\rm b} \approx7 \times10^{3}\,M_{\odot}) and STARFORGE ([27]) physics to resolve individual protostellar formation. We briefly review these below and refer the reader to M. Y. Grudić et al. [27]; P. F. Hopkins et al. [40, 41]. Numerical parameters not specified below are identical to those described in the above references.

Code and gravity solver

The governing equations solved by the code are the ideal MHD equations in conservative form (P. F. Hopkins & M. J. Raives [38]):

∂U∂t+∇⋅F=S,(1)\frac{\partial\mathbf{U}}{\partial t}+\nabla\cdot\mathbf{F}=\mathbf{S}, \tag*{(1)}

where the state vector of conserved quantities and the flux tensor are

U=(ρρvρeB),F=(ρv⊗v+PTI−B⊗B(ρe+PT)v−(v⋅B)Bv⊗B−B⊗v).(2)\mathbf{U} = \begin{pmatrix} \rho\\ \rho\mathbf{v}\\ \rho e\\ \mathbf{B} \end{pmatrix}, \qquad \mathbf{F} = \begin{pmatrix} \rho\mathbf{v}\otimes\mathbf{v}+P_T\mathcal{I}-\mathbf{B}\otimes\mathbf{B}\\ (\rho e+P_T)\mathbf{v}-(\mathbf{v}\cdot\mathbf{B})\mathbf{B}\\ \mathbf{v}\otimes\mathbf{B}-\mathbf{B}\otimes\mathbf{v} \end{pmatrix}. \tag*{(2)}

Here ρ\rho is the mass density, v\mathbf{v} the velocity, B\mathbf{B} the magnetic field (in Gaussian units with 4π4\pi absorbed), e=u+∣B∣2/(2ρ)+∣v∣2/2e=u+|\mathbf{B}|^2/(2\rho)+|\mathbf{v}|^2/2 the total specific energy, PT=P+∣B∣2/2P_T=P+|\mathbf{B}|^2/2 the total (thermal plus magnetic) pressure, and I\mathcal{I} the identity tensor. S\mathbf{S} includes source terms for self-gravity and the Powell 8-wave and Dedner divergence-cleaning terms (P. F. Hopkins & M. J. Raives [38]) that maintain ∇⋅B≈0\nabla\cdot\mathbf{B}\approx0.

The FORGE’d in FIRE framework is based on GIZMO Meshless Finite Mass (MFM) code (P. F. Hopkins 2015). Gravity is solved with the TreePM algorithm [3, 94], which combines a particle-mesh grid for large-scale forces with an oct-tree for short-range forces [4], as in V. Springel [95]. Gas particles use adaptive Lagrangian gravitational softening matching the hydrodynamic kernel radius. Sink particles use a fixed Plummer-equivalent softening ϵ≈0.4\epsilon\approx0.4 AU (gravitational kernel radius ≈1.2\approx1.2 AU). Direct NN-body summation is used for all sink–sink and sink–gas gravitational interactions, with direct summation applied for sink–sink separations below 1000 AU to accurately resolve close binaries and dynamical ejections [27].

Initial Conditions

We use initial conditions (ICs) developed as part of the FIRE collaboration [39], specifically the m12f halo from the Latte suite of MW-mass zoom-in simulations [113]. The m12f halo has a virial mass Mvir∼1.5×1012 M⊙M_{\mathrm{vir}} \sim1.5 \times10^{12}\,\mathrm{M}_{\odot} at z=0z = 0 and was selected as an isolated halo of this mass, without regard to its formation history [113]. It is one of the four Latte halos (with m12i, m12m and m12b) that are most similar to the MW across a range of properties [113]. At the redshift of first collapse in our simulation (z∼21z \sim21), CDM part of the progenitor halo has a mass of $2 \times 10^{7},\mathrm{M}_{\odot}$. This is above the atomic-cooling threshold at this redshift: the virial temperature is Tvir≈2×104T_{\mathrm{vir}} \approx2 \times10^{4} K, whereas Tvir=104T_{\mathrm{vir}} = 10^{4} K corresponds to ≈107 M⊙\approx10^{7}\,\mathrm{M}_{\odot} at z=21z = 21, and the halo is ∼50\sim50 times more massive than the minimum mass for H2_2 cooling, a few ×105 M⊙\times10^{5}\,\mathrm{M}_{\odot} [116, 54]. As in other atomic-cooling halos, the dense gas still cools through H2_2, whose formation there is largely insensitive to external UV (S. P. Oh & Z. Haiman 2002): later work finds that H2_2 cooling in such halos is suppressed only when the Lyman–Werner (11.2–13.6 eV) background exceeds a critical intensity. Expressed through J21J_{21}, the specific intensity in units of 10−21 erg s−1 cm−2 Hz−1 sr−110^{-21}\,\mathrm{erg}\,\mathrm{s}^{-1}\,\mathrm{cm}^{-2}\,\mathrm{Hz}^{-1}\,\mathrm{sr}^{-1}, this critical value is J21∼30J_{21} \sim30–300 for soft spectra and ∼103\sim10^{3} for realistic spectra of metal-poor galaxies, and up to 10410^{4}–10510^{5} for metal-free stellar spectra [87, 106]. This is far above the external UV background in our run, which is negligible at $z \approx 21 {xref}(subsubsection 2.2.3), and gas becomes fully molecular through three-body H$_2$ formation here by $n \sim 10^{11}$–$10^{12}\,\mathrm{cm}^{-3}$ {xref}(Figure 4); {citet}T. Abel et al. [2]. The late, massive first collapse is most plausibly a consequence of the parent-simulation resolution. With $m_{\mathrm{DM}} \approx 3.5 \times 10^{4}\,\mathrm{M}_{\odot}$, a $10^{6}\,\mathrm{M}_{\odot}$ minihalo contains only $\sim 30$ DM particles, while $\gtrsim 500$ dark-matter particles are needed to resolve the gas content of a halo {citep}[54], i.e. $\gtrsim 2 \times 10^{7}\,\mathrm{M}_{\odot}$ here. Earlier H$_2$-cooling minihalos in this region are therefore unresolved, and star formation can only begin once the halo is this massive. The hyper-Lagrangian refinement ({xref}subsection 2.1.3`) does not change this: it is switched on only at the restart, at z≈21z \approx21, after the parent run has already set the epoch and the host of the first collapse; it splits only gas particles, so a 106 M⊙10^{6}\,\mathrm{M}_{\odot} minihalo would still be resolved by ∼30\sim30 DM particles; and its Jeans criterion is triggered only once the gas is already dense and cold (n≳10n \gtrsim10–100 cm−3\mathrm{cm}^{-3} at a few hundred K for the parent gas particle mass), so it can follow a collapse but not start one in an unresolved halo.

We adopt pre-generated ICs at z=99z = 99 in a 60 Mpc/hh comoving cosmological box. This large box contains a zoom-in region of comoving size ∼3\sim3 Mpc/hh, within which the FIRE galaxy grows by z=0z = 0. Only the zoom-in region contains baryonic particles and high-resolution dark matter (DM) particles; the remainder of the volume is populated with low-resolution DM particles. As in the FIRE-2 Latte simulations, we adopt cosmological parameters from WMAP-7 [51]: h=0.702h = 0.702, Ωm=0.272\Omega_{\mathrm{m}} = 0.272, ΩΛ=0.728\Omega_{\Lambda} = 0.728, Ωb=0.0455\Omega_{\mathrm{b}} = 0.0455, σ8=0.807\sigma_{8} = 0.807, and ns=0.961n_{\mathrm{s}} = 0.961.

The full simulation snapshot contains ∼88\sim88 million CDM particles and FIRE-resolution gas particles whose smoothing lengths (∼\sim kpc) far exceed the protostellar disk scale. We extract spatial cutouts centered on the most-massive sink particle with a physical radius of 1 kpc (22 ckpc). The cutout sphere retains only the gas, high-resolution DM, and sink particles; we then split gas particles as described below, but leave the DM particles unsplit. All analysis presented in this manuscript is of this cutout simulation.

Over the ∼15\sim15 kyr of post-collapse evolution studied here, the sound-crossing time across the cutout radius (rcut≈1r_{\mathrm{cut}} \approx1 kpc) is ∼rcut/cs≳90\sim r_{\mathrm{cut}}/c_{\mathrm{s}} \gtrsim90 Myr for T≲104T \lesssim10^{4} K (cs≲11 km s−1c_{\mathrm{s}} \lesssim11\,\mathrm{km}\,\mathrm{s}^{-1}), more than three orders of magnitude longer than our integration time. The large-scale structure outside the cutout therefore has no causal influence on the disk dynamics on these timescales, and the cutout fully captures the relevant physics.

Refinement strategy

We first evolve the full cosmological simulation with FIRE-3 physics until first 105 M⊙10^{5}\,\mathrm{M}_{\odot} stellar population (SSP) particle forms. We then restart from the preceding snapshot with an additional “hyper-Lagrangian” Jeans refinement layer, applied globally; [41] use a similar “hyper-refinement” layer centred on the central black hole.

We refine gas cells (splitting into pairs of equal-mass daughter cells) whenever their mass exceeds a fraction fJf_J of the local Jeans mass:

Δm>fJMJ=fJM0(T104 K)3/2(nHcm−3)−1/2,(3)\Delta m > f_J M_J = f_J M_0 \left(\frac{T}{10^{4}\,\mathrm{K}}\right)^{3/2} \left(\frac{n_{\mathrm{H}}}{\mathrm{cm}^{-3}}\right)^{-1/2}, \tag*{(3)}

where M0=9×106 M⊙M_0 = 9 \times10^{6}\,\mathrm{M}_{\odot} is the Jeans mass of gas at T=104T = 10^{4} K and nH=1 cm−3n_{\mathrm{H}} = 1\,\mathrm{cm}^{-3} adopted in GIZMO, and TT is the gas temperature for a mean molecular weight of 1.23. Only gas well above the cosmic mean density is refined, and cells are not split below Δm=10−3 M⊙\Delta m = 10^{-3}\,M_\odot. We use fJ=10−2f_J = 10^{-2}, corresponding to 100 resolution elements per Jeans mass and satisfying the J. K. Truelove et al. [109] criterion, since we resolve λJ/Δx=(6/πfJ)1/3≈5.8>4\lambda_J/\Delta x = (6/\pi f_J)^{1/3} \approx5.8 > 4 cells per Jeans length. This is sufficient: Lagrangian methods need only ∼2\sim2 particle widths per Jeans length to avoid artificial fragmentation, and particle splitting in GIZMO’s MFM does not seed artificial fragmentation (spurious bound clumps that would go on to form sink particles), its effect on the outcome lying within the run-to-run scatter [46 and references therein]. It is, however, below the ≳30\gtrsim30 cells per Jeans length that grid codes need to capture small-scale dynamo amplification [21].

Figure 2. Top panel: Radial profile of gas particle mass (resolution), centered around the most massive sink. Scatter plot shows particle distribution at the time of first sink formation; solid line and shaded region correspond to the mean and ±1σ for radial profiles across all snapshots after first sink formation. Horizontal lines correspond to 0.5 Δm\Delta m of previous resolution region, since our particle splitting algorithm is subdividing parent particles in 2 for each new level of split. Bottom panel: Same as top panel, but for radial profile of equivalent cell size Δx=(Δm/ρ)1/3\Delta x = (\Delta m/\rho)^{1/3}.

No equivalent criterion has been calibrated for MFM: only magnetorotational instability (MRI) quality factors [18] and particle-number convergence tests of gravitoturbulent dynamos [17] exist. We therefore do not claim that a small-scale dynamo is resolved here (§ 6).

Only gas particles get split, DM particles stay at the same resolution. This is a fine approximation because dark matter’s potential is smooth at these scales, and splitting of these particles should not change the results of our simulation after the restart. It does matter for the epoch of the first collapse, which is set before the restart by DM halos resolved with mDM≈3.5×104 M⊙m_{\rm DM} \approx3.5 \times10^4\,M_\odot (subsubsection 2.1.2).

At our highest refinement level, the gas mass resolution is Δm≈10−3 M⊙\Delta m \approx10^{-3}\,M_\odot and the maximum spatial resolution is Δx≈1 AU\Delta x \approx1\,\mathrm{AU} in most snapshots, reaching 0.6 AU0.6\,\mathrm{AU} briefly, sufficient to resolve densities up to n∼1014n \sim10^{14}–1015 cm−310^{15}\,\mathrm{cm}^{-3}. This spatial resolution applies only at the highest densities: at 15 kyr the median disk particle has Δx≈110 AU\Delta x \approx110\,\mathrm{AU} (the depleted late-time disk gas has low density, which is also why it is resolved by ∼55\sim55 cells per Jeans length: the median λJ/Δx\lambda_J/\Delta x of the disk particles at 15 kyr, with 10th–90th percentiles of 26 and 160), so the disk scale height is covered by only a few resolution elements at late times.

Figure 2 shows the radial profile of the length scale of gas particles λ=(m/ρ)1/3\lambda= (m/\rho)^{1/3}. It exhibits the refinement profile, described in subsubsection 2.1.3 at all times, except the earliest one. Initial profile at Δt=t−t1=−0.5\Delta t = t - t_1 = -0.5 (0.5 kyrs before the first sink formation) is limited by the refinement scale inside of 100 AU radius (the center was not yet refined to the highest resolution). But by the time of first sink formation, the refinement reaches highest resolution that we expect from our scheme, (around 10−3 M⊙10^{-3}\,M_\odot or a few AU) so the inner star forming disk region is fully refined.

Physics we model

Magnetic fields

We integrate the ideal MHD equations as described in P. F. Hopkins & M. J. Raives [38], using the constrained-gradient method and divergence cleaning P. F. Hopkins [34] for divergence control, which has been validated for magnetorotational instability dynamics P. F. Hopkins et al. [41].

We include Spitzer–Braginskii thermal conduction and viscosity via P. F. Hopkins [35]. For metal-free gas at the temperatures (T∼200T \sim200–10410^4 K) and free-electron fractions relevant here, the non-ideal MHD timescales (Ohmic, Hall and ambipolar diffusion) exceed the local dynamical timescales by many orders of magnitude [64], so ideal MHD dominates throughout the simulation. Spitzer conduction and Braginskii viscosity are also negligible: even for fully ionized gas at 10310^3 K and n=1010 cm−3n = 10^{10}\,\mathrm{cm}^{-3}, the conduction and viscous timescales across 100 AU, t∼L2/Dt \sim L^2/D with DD the Spitzer thermal or momentum diffusivity, are ≳1015\gtrsim10^{15} yr, and the gas here is almost neutral.

The initial magnetic field is a trace cosmological seed field of Bx=By=Bz=10−10B_x = B_y = B_z = 10^{-10} G (physical), imposed at the start of the parent simulation (z≃99z \simeq99), i.e. ∣B0∣≈1.7×10−10|B_0| \approx1.7 \times10^{-10} G, or ≈1.7×10−14\approx1.7 \times10^{-14} G comoving, uniform in magnitude and direction, amplified self-consistently by gravitational compression, differential rotation, and (possibly) turbulent dynamo. The seed lies about two orders of magnitude below the present-day field strengths of 2×10−122 \times10^{-12}–2×10−102 \times10^{-10} G (comoving) that D. Koh et al. [50] consider, and below the CMB upper limits on primordial fields they quote, ≲10−10\lesssim10^{-10} G for inflationary and ≲2×10−11\lesssim2 \times10^{-11} G for causal fields; it therefore does not test the possibility that a strong primordial field delays or prevents the collapse. The original orientation is (1,1,1)(1, 1, 1), i.e. B0∝x^+y^+z^\mathbf{B}_0 \propto\hat{x} + \hat{y} + \hat{z}, in the cosmological box, but the protostellar disk is oriented randomly in the simulation.

Radiation

We solve radiation transport with the M1 moments method (C. D. Levermore 1984), as implemented in GIZMO and described in P. F. Hopkins & M. Y. Grudić [36]; P. F. Hopkins et al. [37]; M. Y. Grudić et al. [27]; P. F. Hopkins et al. [41] across five frequency bands: H-ionizing (>13.6> 13.6 eV), Lyman–Werner (LW)/photo-electric (8.0–13.6 eV), near-UV (NUV; 3.4–8.0 eV), optical–NIR (0.41–3.4 eV), and an adaptive-wavelength FIR band (<0.41< 0.41 eV) that tracks the evolving dust emission temperature (P. F. Hopkins et al. [40]). Gas, dust, and radiation temperatures are evolved separately with appropriate coupling terms, allowing self-consistent treatment of both optically thin and optically thick regimes. We use a reduced speed of light c~=10−3c\tilde{c} = 10^{-3}c, i.e. ≈300\approx300 km s−1^{-1}, much lower than the c~=0.1c\tilde{c} = 0.1c adopted for most runs in P. F. Hopkins et al. [41]. Tests in galaxy simulations find small effects for c~≳500\tilde{c} \gtrsim500 km s−1^{-1}, with slightly weaker radiative feedback at lower values down to 300 km s−1^{-1} (P. F. Hopkins et al. [37]), and c~≳30\tilde{c} \gtrsim30 km s−1^{-1} suffices to follow expanding ionization fronts (M. Y. Grudić et al. [27]). A radiation-hydrodynamic simulation of Pop III star formation that adopts the same c~=10−3c\tilde{c} = 10^{-3}c found no significant change in its results for c~\tilde{c} between 10−1c10^{-1}c and 10−4c10^{-4}c, with the fastest outflows at only ∼100\sim100 km s−1^{-1} (J. Park et al. [76]). Our value is therefore at the lower edge of the galaxy-scale range and well above the ionization-front limit, but we have not tested the sensitivity of our results to c~\tilde{c}. Fast jets would be the feature most likely to be affected, but the jets of this run do not propagate as intended because of an implementation error (subsection 2.2.4). No ionization fronts are followed either: the Strömgren radii of the sinks are below the resolution, so their ionizing photons are absorbed within a cell (§ 6).

The Lyman-Werner (LW) band is combined with the photo-electric (PE) heating band into a single radiation frequency bin. This follows the five-band scheme of P. F. Hopkins et al. [37] and P. F. Hopkins et al. [41], in which a single far-UV band serves both purposes. Our gas is metal-free and dust-free, so there is no photo-electric heating, and the band acts only as the Lyman–Werner band. H2_2 photo-dissociation by LW photons is accounted for through the H2_2 destruction term in Equation (4).

Thermochemistry

We solve gas thermodynamics and chemistry as in P. F. Hopkins et al. [40]. The following cooling functions are employed and are relevant to our setup: ΛH\Lambda_{\mathrm{H}} (atomic H cooling); ΛHD\Lambda_{\mathrm{HD}} (HD cooling, D. Galli & F. Palla [22]); ΛH2\Lambda_{\mathrm{H}_2} (H2_2 cooling); ΛH2thick\Lambda_{\mathrm{H}_2}^{\mathrm{thick}}, ΛH2thin\Lambda_{\mathrm{H}_2}^{\mathrm{thin}} (H2_2 interactions with e−^-, H+^+, H, He below and above the critical density at which the H2_2 levels reach LTE, combined per molecule as ΛH2thin/(1+ΛH2thin/ΛH2thick)\Lambda_{\mathrm{H}_2}^{\mathrm{thin}}/(1 + \Lambda_{\mathrm{H}_2}^{\mathrm{thin}}/\Lambda_{\mathrm{H}_2}^{\mathrm{thick}}) (P. F. Hopkins et al. [40])). The network does not include H2_2 line opacity; in GIZMO, optically thick cooling is only limited by a gray slab photosphere cap). The adiabatic index accounts for H, He, free electrons and H2_2 (A. C. Boley et al. [6]). We follow non-equilibrium H and He chemical networks. Default FIRE-3 thermochemistry includes cooling due to metal lines, but we do not evolve our simulation past the point of supernova-driven metal enrichment, thus making all metal cooling contributions effectively zero (as expected in the Pop III formation regime).

Since we simulate metal-free primordial gas, the dust-to-gas ratio is zero and the dust term in the H2_2 formation equation is absent. H2_2 formation proceeds exclusively via gas-phase channels: the two-body H−^- and H2+_2^+ pathways at low densities (n≲108n \lesssim10^8 cm−3^{-3}) and the three-body reaction (3H→H2+H3\mathrm{H} \rightarrow\mathrm{H}_2 + \mathrm{H}) at high densities. Molecular fraction of H2_2 evolves in every cell according to (eq. 6 from P. F. Hopkins et al. [40]), with the dust formation term set to zero:

dnˉH2dt=αGPnˉHnˉH+α3BnˉH2(nˉH+nˉH28)−ΓH2nˉH2−ξH2nˉH2−∑iβH2,iCinˉH2nˉi(4)\frac{d\bar{n}_{\mathrm{H}_2}}{dt} = \alpha_{\mathrm{GP}} \bar{n}_{\mathrm{H}}\bar{n}_{\mathrm{H}} + \alpha_{3\mathrm{B}} \bar{n}_{\mathrm{H}}^2 \left(\bar{n}_{\mathrm{H}} + \frac{\bar{n}_{\mathrm{H}_2}}{8}\right) - \Gamma_{\mathrm{H}_2}\bar{n}_{\mathrm{H}_2} - \xi_{\mathrm{H}_2}\bar{n}_{\mathrm{H}_2} - \sum_i \beta_{\mathrm{H}_2,i} C_i \bar{n}_{\mathrm{H}_2}\bar{n}_i \tag*{(4)}

where the gas-phase, three-body, photodissociation, cosmic-ray and collisional terms and their coefficients are defined in Appendix § 10.

The chemical energy of H2_2 (4.48 eV per molecule) is not tracked in the gas energy equation: neither the heating released when H2_2 forms nor the cooling when it is collisionally dissociated is included. This matters below the densities we resolve. Three-body H2_2 formation heating is the dominant heat source in primordial gas at n∼108n \sim10^8–101210^{12} cm−3^{-3} (M. J. Turk et al. [110]), and in real gas dissociation cooling thermostats gas heated above ∼2000\sim2000 K, which our network cannot do. The FIRE-3 network is therefore a reduced, not a complete, primordial network (see subsection 3.1 and § 6). In addition, the protostellar evolution tracks of S. S. R. Offner et al. [69] self-consistently evolve the stellar radius without requiring the gas to track dissociation energy explicitly.

The meta-galactic UV background is that of C.-A. Faucher-Giguère [20]; we expect it to be negligible at z∼21z \sim21 compared to local protostellar radiation resolved in the simulation. H2\mathrm{H}_2 self-shielding against Lyman-Werner photons is included using the shielding function of N. Y. Gnedin & B. T. Draine [25] (their Eq. 3), applied with a local Sobolev column density NH∼ρ/∣∇ρ∣N_{\mathrm{H}} \sim\rho/|\nabla\rho|, with turbulent line broadening accounted for following a Burgers velocity spectrum.

The simulation does not include a cosmic-ray (CR) module: CRs are neither transported nor injected by stellar feedback (which would in any case be negligible over ∼15\sim15 kyr without supernovae). The thermochemistry instead uses GIZMO’s default for runs without such a module, a uniform and constant CR energy density uCR=1 eV cm−3u_{\mathrm{CR}} = 1\,\mathrm{eV\,cm}^{-3}, the local interstellar value inferred from Voyager 1 data (A. C. Cummings et al. [16]), which corresponds to an ionization rate ζCR=1.6×10−17 s−1\zeta_{\mathrm{CR}} = 1.6 \times10^{-17}\,\mathrm{s}^{-1}. 200 times the cosmic mean baryon density and is fully on above 2×1052 \times10^{5} times the mean (n≳400 cm−3n \gtrsim400\,\mathrm{cm}^{-3} at z≈21z \approx21), which includes all the gas analyzed here. Without attenuation, it enters the H2\mathrm{H}_2 network (Equation (4)), the free-electron fraction and the gas heating. We discuss its effect in § 6.

Stellar formation and evolution

We resolve the formation of individual protostars in the densest region of our simulation using the STARFORGE (M. Y. Grudić et al. [27]) formation and evolution modules. A gas particle becomes a sink (protostar) particle when it meets the full STARFORGE formation criteria: the cell must be (i) locally self-gravitating (virial parameter αvir<1\alpha_{\mathrm{vir}} < 1), (ii) Jeans unstable, (iii) in a converging flow (∇⋅v<0\nabla\cdot\mathbf{v} < 0), (iv) experiencing compressive tides in all directions, (v) a local maximum of the density field, and (vi) not within the accretion radius of a pre-existing sink (M. Y. Grudić et al. [27]). For brevity we refer to these protostellar particles as “sinks” throughout this paper. When a gas particle is converted into a sink, the magnetic field of that gas is deleted.

Once formed, the sink particles accrete the bound gas whose circularized orbit falls within the sink radius. Accreted gas is first added to the sink’s internal reservoir, which represents the unresolved envelope and disk inside the sink radius. Mass flows from the reservoir onto the protostar on a smoothed accretion timescale, and when jets are enabled a fraction fw=0.3f_{\mathrm{w}} = 0.3 of it is diverted into a jet reservoir and returned to the gas as outflow (M. Y. Grudić et al. [27]). In our run the reservoirs hold ≲0.3%\lesssim0.3\% of the mass of most sinks at 15 kyr (at most 2.4%), so the sink masses we quote are effectively stellar masses. Each sink evolves along protostellar tracks following S. S. R. Offner et al. [69], explicitly tracking the stellar radius, luminosity, and effective temperature as a function of the instantaneous mass and accretion rate.

Jets are the least tested part of this feedback. Most Pop III simulations omit them, and the few that include them treat them as mass-removal prescriptions rather than resolved outflows (Y. J. Meziani et al. [64]). Whether Pop III protostars can launch jets at all depends on whether a trace magnetic field is amplified enough for the mass-to-flux ratio to permit it; Y. J. Meziani et al. [64] find that the ratios around a Pop III protostar fall well within the range required for strong jet launching. Protostellar jets are launched with a mass-loading proportional to the accretion rate onto the protostar and a launch velocity of 0.3 times the Keplerian speed at the protostellar surface (M. Y. Grudić et al. [27]). The jets module is active in the present run, but the jet material is coupled to the gas closer to the protostars than intended. STARFORGE launches jets by spawning new gas cells near the sink (M. Y. Grudić et al. [27]), and in the code version we use these jet cells are merged with the neighboring ambient gas cells too readily. Their mass and momentum are therefore spread into the surrounding gas near the protostar, and the jets propagate less far than intended. Because the internal structure of the jets is not resolved in any case, this amounts to a choice of where the jet feedback is deposited rather than an error in the injected mass or momentum. The same merging is more serious for stellar-wind bubbles, where the contact discontinuity between the shocked wind and the ambient gas must be followed, but STARFORGE winds come only from main-sequence stars (M. Y. Grudić et al. [27]), and none of our protostars reaches the main sequence (subsection 3.5). We defer the analysis of jet feedback to future work.

Postprocessing methods

Disk identification

To compute velocity dispersion, local Toomre QQ, and other disk properties, we identify the gas particles belonging to the disk at each snapshot. We center on the densest gas particle before the first sink forms and on the most massive sink afterwards, and rotate into the frame of the total angular momentum within rsearch=2000 AUr_{\mathrm{search}} = 2000\,\mathrm{AU}. Particles are selected by cuts on cylindrical radius, aspect ratio (∣z∣/rcyl<0.3|z|/r_{\mathrm{cyl}} < 0.3), density (ρ>10−15 g cm−3\rho> 10^{-15}\,\mathrm{g\,cm}^{-3}) and rotation (vϕ/vK>0.3v_{\phi}/v_{\mathrm{K}} > 0.3), and the selection is extended to its bounding cylinder. The disk radius rdiskr_{\mathrm{disk}} is the 90th-percentile cylindrical radius of the disk members. The full algorithm and tests of its robustness are given in Appendix § 11.

Figure 3 shows the gas surface density Σ\Sigma of the disk and its surroundings at the six epochs used throughout the paper (Δt=−0.5\Delta t = -0.5, 0, 1.3, 3.6, 9.5 and 15 kyr relative to the formation of the first sink). Each epoch has a face-on panel, seen along the angular momentum axis L^\hat{L} of the procedure above, and a narrower edge-on panel below it that shows the vertical structure. All panels are centerd on the most massive sink, span 4100 AU on a side, and share one logarithmic color scale (10410^4–10710^7 M⊙_\odot pc−2^{-2}); the bar in each face-on panel marks 1000 AU, and stars mark the sinks inside the image box. Before the first sink forms (Δt=−0.5\Delta t = -0.5 kyr) the gas is a smooth, centrally concentrated core with no sinks. From Δt≈3.6\Delta t \approx3.6 kyr onward the disk develops spiral arms along which the sinks that formed by fragmentation are scattered, rather than gathering in one central cluster (subsection 3.4). By 15 kyr the disk is depleted, and only a few sinks and a faint spiral remain in the field.

Face-on and edge-on surface density projections at six epochs

Figure 3. Face-on and edge-on surface density projections at six epochs spanning the ∼15\sim15 kyr after the formation of the first sink. Each panel shows a 4100×41004100 \times4100 AU region centerd on the most massive sink. Star symbols mark sink particles within the image box. The sinks are scattered throughout the disk rather than concentrated in a single cluster, tracing the spiral arms.

Results

In this section we present results from our cosmological RMHD simulation of Pop III star formation. We organize the discussion as follows: subsection 3.1 discusses the thermodynamics and chemistry of the collapse; subsection 3.2 describes the structure and kinematics of the pre-stellar envelope and shows that its collapse proceeds outside-in; subsection 3.3 characterizes the disk structure and energetics; subsection 3.4 covers its gravitational stability; subsection 3.5 covers the star formation history, accretion rates, and protostellar mass function; and subsection 3.6 describes the magnetic field evolution.

Thermodynamics

The thermal and chemical state of the gas reflects the competition between compressional heating and radiative cooling. The temperature–density phase trajectory is therefore diagnostic of which physical process dominates at each stage of collapse, while the H2_2 fraction fH2f_{\mathrm{H}_2} shows how much of the main coolant is available. We present phase space plots in Figure 4 for three representative epochs, pre-stellar, first sink formation, and post-first sink formation. Disk particles are identified by the algorithm described in 2.3.1; disk particles are green, particles in the cutout but not in the disk are red, while particles outside the cutout region are shown in blue.

Figure 4. Phase diagram (temperature and H2_2 fraction vs. number density) at three representative epochs: pre-stellar (Δt≈−0.5\Delta t \approx-0.5 kyr, left), first sink formation (Δt=0\Delta t = 0, middle), and post-first-sink (Δt=1.2\Delta t = 1.2 kyr, right). Green points correspond to disk-identified particles, red points correspond to points in our cutout simulation that have not been identified as disk, and blue points correspond to points in the full-box simulation right before the cutout was applied (only included in the leftmost plots). fH2=0f_{\mathrm{H}_2} = 0 for most of particles in the low-density region (blue particles), which therefore do not appear in the bottom-left panel. The curves in the temperature panels show the theoretical TT–nn tracks for primordial (Z=0Z = 0) and metal-enriched (Z=10−4Z⊙Z = 10^{-4} Z_{\odot}) gas from R. S. Klessen & S. C. O. Glover [49] (KG23); the shaded bands indicate the median ±\pm standard deviation of the fits over the time intervals −0.5 kyr≤Δt≤0-0.5\ \mathrm{kyr} \le\Delta t \le0 (middle) and 0≤Δt≤1.2 kyr0 \le\Delta t \le1.2\ \mathrm{kyr} (right), respectively. The spread of the fit is narrow at early times and broadens at later times. KG23 Z=0Z = 0 curve follows similar curve from K. Omukai [71] closely.

Before the first star forms (Δt=−0.5\Delta t = -0.5 kyr; Figure 4, left panels), the gas occupies a narrow track spanning n∼107n \sim10^{7}–1010 cm−310^{10}\ \mathrm{cm}^{-3} and T∼500T \sim500 K. The low temperature reflects the fact that at densities n≲104 cm−3n \lesssim10^{4}\ \mathrm{cm}^{-3}, the molecular radiative cooling Λ∼n2\Lambda\sim n^2, while the adiabatic heating Γ∼n3/2\Gamma\sim n^{3/2}, and cooling dominates. Above n∼104 cm−3n \sim10^{4}\ \mathrm{cm}^{-3} the H2_2 levels are in LTE, so that Γ∼n\Gamma\sim n, with the result that heating dominates. Our network follows the same scaling, because at high density it uses the LTE cooling rate per molecule (section 2.2.3).

The H2_2 fraction (lower panel) rises modestly from fH2∼10−2.5f_{\mathrm{H}_2} \sim10^{-2.5} at n∼107 cm−3n \sim10^{7}\ \mathrm{cm}^{-3} to fH2∼10−1.3f_{\mathrm{H}_2} \sim10^{-1.3} at n∼1010 cm−3n \sim10^{10}\ \mathrm{cm}^{-3}, driven primarily by two-body formation channels (H−^- and H2+_2^+ pathways). The increase in H2_2 fraction enhances the cooling of the gas, since H2_2 is a much more efficient coolant than atomic H.

The low-density (blue) particles in the left column (n≲10−5 cm−3n \lesssim10^{-5}\ \mathrm{cm}^{-3}; see the caption) lie outside our region of interest; the dynamical time scale is long in that region, so the thermodynamic state of the gas does not change significantly over the time interval shown in the figure.

By Δt=0\Delta t = 0 (Figure 4, middle panels), the gas has collapsed to much higher densities (n∼1013 cm−3n \sim10^{13}\ \mathrm{cm}^{-3}) and the thermal track has extended significantly. At intermediate densities (n∼108n \sim10^{8}–1010 cm−310^{10}\ \mathrm{cm}^{-3}), compressional heating outpaces H2_2 line cooling, which is saturated at the LTE value, and the temperature rises steadily through T∼650T \sim650 K. The H2_2 fraction increases steeply in this regime as three-body formation reactions (3H →\rightarrow H2_2 + H) become efficient at n≳108 cm−3n \gtrsim10^{8}\ \mathrm{cm}^{-3}, converting the gas to fully molecular (fH2→1f_{\mathrm{H}_2} \rightarrow1) by n∼1011n \sim10^{11}–1012 cm−310^{12}\ \mathrm{cm}^{-3}. Note that unlike in the pre-stellar regime, we see an increase in temperature associated with an increase in H2_2 fraction. With the levels in LTE, increasing H2_2 adds little cooling, so it cannot offset the compressional heating of the continuing infall. In real primordial gas the H2_2 lines also become optically thick at these densities (E. Ripamonti & T. Abel [82]), but our network does not model line opacity (subsubsection 2.2.3).

At Δt=1.2\Delta t = 1.2 kyr (Figure 4, right panels), the temperature range in the lower density n≲1010 cm−3n \lesssim10^{10}\,\mathrm{cm}^{-3} part of the phase diagram has broadened substantially. At higher densities, the gas has separated into 2 parts: a branch with T<2000T < 2000 K and a hot branch at T∼5000T \sim5000 K, which we interpret as the result of shock-heated and adiabatically compressed gas. This hot branch is capped at T≈8000T \approx8000 K, where Lyman-α\alpha cooling of atomic hydrogen becomes efficient (S. P. Oh & Z. Haiman 2002; J. H. Wise & T. Abel [114]). We note that while our thermochemical model does not couple H2_2 dissociation to thermodynamics, the βH2,i\beta_{\mathrm{H}_2,i} terms in Equation (4) can still drive partial dissociation of H2_2.

At higher densities attained at later times, H2_2 is formed primarily by three-body interactions. This results in constantly increasing fraction of molecular hydrogen in the disk with time.

Pre-stellar envelope and collapse

Here we describe the mass distribution and infall rate of the pre-stellar envelope (subsubsection 3.2.1) and its kinematics (subsubsection 3.2.2), and then compare both with self-similar collapse solutions to show that the simulated collapse is driven from the outside in (subsubsection 3.2.3). This contrasts with the inside-out expansion wave picture of F. H. Shu [91], which applies only when a core is marginally critical.

Mass distribution and infall rate

The density profiles of all epochs coincide outside ∼103\sim10^3 AU, so only the inner region changes with time (Figure 5, top panel). Between 10310^3 and 10510^5 AU the envelope follows ρ∝r−2.08\rho\propto r^{-2.08} (one fit to all epochs). Inside ∼103\sim10^3 AU the profile changes with time: it is shallower before the first sink forms, when the center is not yet fully refined, and it becomes irregular once the spiral arms and the sinks dominate the azimuthal average.

Figure 5. Top panel: Radial density profiles through simulation time. The x-axis begins at ∼1\sim1 AU, corresponding to the resolution limit of the simulation. The dashed line is a single power law fitted to all epochs together between 10310^3 and 10510^5 AU, where the profiles coincide: ρ∝r−2.08\rho\propto r^{-2.08}. Top-middle panel: Enclosed gas mass M(<r)M(<r) in a sphere vs radius rr of the sphere. The fit is roughly M∝r1.3M \propto r^{1.3}. Bottom-middle panel: the infall rate into a sphere of radius rr, M˙infall(<r)=−∑shellmivr,i/ri\dot{M}_{\mathrm{infall}}(<r) = -\sum_{\mathrm{shell}} m_i v_{r,i}/r_i, counting only infalling gas (vr<0v_r < 0) on the surface of the sphere of radius rr. At later times the inner region gains mass slower than at the earlier times (mostly close to the time of the first sink forming). There is a characteristic “flattening” at smaller radii inside of the disk before the first star has formed. Outer shells gain mass faster at all times—a characteristic of “outside-in” collapse. Bottom panel: evolution of radial profile of kinematic virial parameter with time, calculated with the energies defined in subsubsection 3.3.1 for the gas and sinks inside a sphere of radius rr (dark matter and stars included in the potential). Each curve starts at the resolution limit of its epoch. Inside 10510^5 AU, αvir≈1\alpha_{\mathrm{vir}} \approx1.

The enclosed gas mass (Figure 5, top-middle panel) follows M(<r)∝r1.3M(<r) \propto r^{1.3} overall, a mean density slope of ρˉ∝r−1.7\bar{\rho} \propto r^{-1.7} over the whole range, and the curves of all epochs again differ only at small radii. The infall rate through each sphere (Figure 5, bottom-middle panel) is nearly independent of radius, at ≈3×10−3 M⊙ yr−1\approx3 \times10^{-3}\,\mathrm{M}_{\odot}\,\mathrm{yr}^{-1} between ∼102\sim10^2 and ∼105\sim10^5 AU, at all epochs, and rises as M˙∝r1.4\dot{M} \propto r^{1.4} further out, to ∼10−1 M⊙ yr−1\sim10^{-1}\,\mathrm{M}_{\odot}\,\mathrm{yr}^{-1} at ∼5×105\sim5 \times10^5 AU. A flux that does not change with radius means that the gas does not pile up on its way in: the inner envelope is a quasi-steady flow fed from larger scales.

The virial parameter αvir(r)\alpha_{\mathrm{vir}}(r) (Figure 5, bottom panel) is the ratio 2(Ekin+Etherm)/∣Epot∣2(E_{\mathrm{kin}} + E_{\mathrm{therm}})/|E_{\mathrm{pot}}| of the energies defined for the disk in subsubsection 3.3.1 (Equation 5), but calculated for all the gas and sinks inside a sphere

of radius rr instead of the disk particles only (Figure 8). The ratio is αvir≈0.85\alpha_{\rm vir} \approx0.85 before the first sink forms and ≈1.1\approx1.1 afterwards between 10310^3 and 10510^5 AU, so the gas is close to virial balance in the collapsing region outside of the disk.

Figure 8. Top panel: Time evolution of the main energy components computed for disk-identified particles (the disk radius rdiskr_{\mathrm{disk}} is taken as the 90th-percentile cylindrical radius of disk-identified particles, see subsection 3.3): rotational kinetic energy ErotE_{\mathrm{rot}} (yellow), turbulent kinetic energy EturbE_{\mathrm{turb}} (cyan), total kinetic energy Ekin=Erot+EturbE_{\mathrm{kin}}=E_{\mathrm{rot}}+E_{\mathrm{turb}} (green), gravitational potential energy ∣Epot∣\lvert E_{\mathrm{pot}}\rvert (red), thermal energy EthermE_{\mathrm{therm}} (orange), and magnetic energy EmagE_{\mathrm{mag}} (magenta). Bottom panel: pure kinematic virial ratio αkin=2Ekin/∣Epot∣\alpha_{\mathrm{kin}}=2E_{\mathrm{kin}}/\lvert E_{\mathrm{pot}}\rvert (black); virial ratio with added thermal component (orange) αkin+th=2(Ekin+Etherm)/∣Epot∣\alpha_{\mathrm{kin+th}}=2(E_{\mathrm{kin}}+E_{\mathrm{therm}})/\lvert E_{\mathrm{pot}}\rvert, and with added thermal and magnetic components (purple), αvir=2(Ekin+Etherm+Emag)/∣Epot∣\alpha_{\mathrm{vir}}=2(E_{\mathrm{kin}}+E_{\mathrm{therm}}+E_{\mathrm{mag}})/\lvert E_{\mathrm{pot}}\rvert. The dashed red line marks virial equilibrium (=1=1). The disk starts sub-virial and reaches equilibrium by ∼2\sim2 kyr. Including the thermal energy matters mainly at early times, when EthermE_{\mathrm{therm}} is comparable to the kinetic terms; at late times the disk is supported mainly by rotation and turbulence. Magnetic energy provides negligible additional support to the virial ratio.

Gas kinematics

Figure 6 shows radial profiles of the gas velocity components, the turbulent velocity magnitude and dispersion, and the Keplerian speed vK=GM(<r)/rv_K = \sqrt{GM(<r)/r} of the enclosed mass. We plot the radial velocity, −vr-v_r (negated so that positive values indicate radially inward flow), to simplify comparison. All quantities are mass-weighted averages in logarithmically spaced cylindrical bins about the disk axis. Here vrv_r and vϕv_\phi are the mean radial and azimuthal velocities of a bin and σr=⟨vr2⟩−⟨vr⟩2\sigma_r = \sqrt{\langle v_r^2\rangle- \langle v_r\rangle^2} is the radial velocity dispersion. The turbulent velocity ∣δv∣=⟨[(vr−⟨vr⟩)2+(vϕ−⟨vϕ⟩)2+vz2]1/2⟩|\delta v| = \left\langle\left[(v_r-\langle v_r\rangle)^2 + (v_\phi-\langle v_\phi\rangle)^2 + v_z^2\right]^{1/2}\right\rangle is the mean speed after subtracting the bin’s mean radial and azimuthal flow, and csc_s is the sound speed.

Figure 6. Radial profiles of inward radial velocity −vr-v_r, azimuthal velocity vϕv_\phi, sound speed csc_s, magnitude of turbulent velocity ∣δv∣|\delta v|, radial/azimuthal/vertical turbulent velocity dispersion σr/σϕ/σz\sigma_r/\sigma_\phi/\sigma_z, Keplerian speed vKv_K at each radius, computed from the enclosed mass. Bright lines show functions with spline smoothing, dim lines show actual data. σr\sigma_r grows with time, as well as ∣δv∣|\delta v|. Radial infall (vrv_r) speeds up until the bulk star formation events (1.3–3.6 kyr), and slows down afterwards. Disk rotation (vϕv_\phi) is constantly speeding up, leveling off outside of the disk (r≳2500r \gtrsim2500 AU). σr\sigma_r, σϕ\sigma_\phi, σz\sigma_z track each other very closely, but σz\sigma_z decouples from the other two by the Δt≳9\Delta t \gtrsim9 kyr time outside of the disk. Turbulence is supersonic at all times, tracking Keplerian speed vKv_K closely for most times outside of the disk, but falling below it inside of the disk. Dot-dashed lines correspond to virial radius rvirr_{\rm vir} and virial velocity vvirv_{\rm vir} of the halo in the xx and yy axes respectively. The turnover seen in the innermost bins of these wide profiles is a numerical artifact of plotting data in the cutout region – it does not exist in Figure 7, which uses the full simulation data. This is not a physical feature and thus is excluded from the interpretation.

The general trend is that vϕv_\phi, ∣δv∣|\delta v|, σr\sigma_r increase with time everywhere. vrv_r is negative and thus gas is mostly infalling for the whole simulation, with ∣vr∣|v_r| increasing until stabilizing at around 1.3–3.6 kyr (bulk star formation events), and dropping after stars are fully formed. csc_s rises until 1.3 kyr, after which it stabilizes. It is clear that the turbulence starts off as sonic or sub-sonic, but becomes greatly supersonic once the sink forms. The turbulent velocity dispersion increases inward, tracking the increase in gravitational potential. Because the collapse compresses the gas faster than the turbulence can decay, the turbulence is continuously re-driven by the contraction itself rather than by stellar feedback (B. Robertson & P. Goldreich [84]); feedback only begins to contribute once the first protostar forms.

Figure 7 shows the same inflow over the full simulation volume: beyond the disk, −vr-v_r rises with radius overall. Here rvirr_{\rm vir} is the radius inside which the mean total density (gas, dark matter, stars and sinks) equals Δcρcrit(z)\Delta_c\rho_{\rm crit}(z), with the spherical-collapse overdensity Δc=18π2+82x−39x2\Delta_c = 18\pi^2 + 82x - 39x^2 and x=Ωm(z)−1x = \Omega_m(z) - 1 (the fit for a flat universe of G. L. Bryan & M. L. Norman [12], MvirM_{\rm vir} is the mass inside it, and vvir=GMvir/rvirv_{\rm vir} = \sqrt{GM_{\rm vir}/r_{\rm vir}}. Between 10410^{4} and 10610^{6} AU, where the gas dominates the enclosed mass, it stays close to the local Keplerian speed (−vr≈vK-v_r \approx v_K, i.e. ≈0.7\approx0.7 of the local free-fall speed 2vK\sqrt{2}v_K), so this envelope collapses at close to free fall. Further out −vr-v_r drops below vKv_K, to ≈0.45vK\approx0.45v_K near 10710^{7} AU, and reaches ≈0.8vvir\approx0.8v_{\rm vir} at the virial radius, about half the free-fall speed of the whole halo. Beyond the virial radius vKv_K rises steeply as the enclosed mass takes in the surrounding structure, while −vr-v_r stays at ≈18 km s−1\approx18\ {\rm km\ s^{-1}}. This extends the outside-in signature seen in the cutout to the full range of scales feeding the core. Inside ∼104\sim10^{4} AU, −vr-v_r falls below vKv_K as rotation takes over, and within the disk (r<2500r < 2500 AU) the flow becomes predominantly subsonic. The deceleration is gradual rather than abrupt (subsubsection 3.3.2).

Figure 7. Radial inflow profile over the full simulation volume, out to ∼109\sim10^{9} AU (far beyond the virial radius), at four epochs (Δt=−0.5\Delta t = -0.5, 0, 1.3, and 3.6 kyr): the mean inflow velocity −vr-v_r (solid) and the Keplerian speed vK=GM(<r)/rv_K = \sqrt{GM(<r)/r} from the total enclosed mass, including dark matter (dashed), both in the color of each epoch, and in black beyond 10510^{5} AU, where the epochs are combined. Beyond ∼104\sim10^{4} AU the curves of the four epochs coincide, because the enclosed mass and the inflow there barely change over these 4 kyr, with the virial velocity vvirv_{\rm vir} and the virial radius rvirr_{\rm vir} marked. Bottom: enclosed gas mass Mgas(<r)M_{\rm gas}(<r). Unlike the wide kinematics profiles of Figure 6, this plot reaches the scale of the halo. The few bins inside 200 AU with −vr≤0-v_r \leq0 are not shown on the logarithmic axis.

Outside-in collapse

The infall-rate profile (Figure 5, bottom-middle panel), flat inside and rising outward, is the opposite of an inside-out collapse, where M˙\dot{M} approaches a constant at small radii but falls as 1/r1/r at large radii (F. H. Shu [91]; D. W. Murray et al. [66]), and so is a signature of outside-in collapse. It is what the model of self-gravitating turbulent collapse of N. W. Murray & P. Chang [67] predicts, with M˙\dot{M} independent of radius inside the sphere of influence of the central mass (their Eq. 45), and what D. W. Murray et al. [66] find in their simulations, where the accretion rate is either nearly flat or increasing with radius. Our plateau extends over a much wider range of radii and our density slope (−2.08-2.08) differs from their −3/2-3/2 inside the sphere of influence, so we regard the comparison to their solution as qualitative.

We find that the outer layers gain mass faster (Figure 5, bottom-middle panel). This contrasts with the inside-out model of F. H. Shu [91] and is qualitatively similar to the runaway, Larson–Penston-type collapse (R. B. Larson [55]; M. V. Penston [77]). Our envelope slope, ρ∝r−2.08\rho\propto r^{-2.08} between 10310^{3} and 10510^{5} AU, is close to the ρ∝r−2\rho\propto r^{-2} of the isothermal Larson–Penston solution, although the correspondence remains approximate because our gas is not isothermal. Supersonic infall alone does not distinguish the two pictures, since the interior of the Shu expansion wave also falls in supersonically. The envelope allows to differentiate between the two cases. The envelope mass flux, M˙≈10−2 M⊙ yr−1≈48 cs3/G\dot{M} \approx10^{-2}\,M_{\odot}\,{\rm yr}^{-1} \approx48\,c_{s}^{3}/G, is well above the Shu rate and comparable to the Larson–Penston values.

The comparison above concerns the collapse dynamics only: the core is not a Bonnor–Ebert sphere (R. Ebert [19]; W. B. Bonnor [8]) since (i) the core is never in hydrostatic equilibrium: it is assembled continuously by supersonic inflow from the halo (Figure 6, Figure 7) and its virial parameter is αvir≈0.9\alpha_{\rm vir} \approx0.9 between 10310^{3} and 10510^{5} AU at Δt=−0.5\Delta t = -0.5 kyr (Figure 5, bottom panel). The gas is therefore near virial balance, but because it is still infalling there is no static equilibrium state that later becomes unstable. (ii) The gas is not isothermal: across the pre-stellar core the temperature changes between ∼200\sim200 and ∼800\sim800 K as H2_2 cooling saturates and compressional heating takes over (subsection 3.1). (iii) There is no confining external pressure: the core merges smoothly into the infalling halo envelope instead of ending at a pressure boundary. Rotation, turbulence and magnetic fields also provide support that the Bonnor–Ebert model does not include. The Larson–Penston solution remains a useful comparison because it does not require an equilibrium starting state: R. B. Larson [55] found that the inner density and velocity profiles approach the same self-similar form for various initial conditions, provided the collapse time exceeds the sound-crossing time.

Disk evolution

Once the accretion flow acquires sufficient angular momentum to form a centrifugal barrier, a rotationally supported disk grows around the central protostar. The disk radius rdiskr_{\rm disk} (subsubsection 2.3.1) stays at ≈1.8×103\approx1.8 \times10^{3} AU throughout the run, close to rsearchr_{\rm search}. The disk gas mass grows from ≈28 M⊙\approx28\,M_{\odot} just before the first sink forms to ≈65 M⊙\approx65\,M_\odot at Δt≈3.5\Delta t \approx3.5 kyr, and then falls to ≈35 M⊙\approx35\,M_\odot at 9.5 kyr and ≈16 M⊙\approx16\,M_\odot at 15 kyr as it is converted into stars. Its mass-weighted thickness, ⟨z2⟩1/2/⟨R⟩\langle z^2\rangle^{1/2}/\langle R\rangle, is 0.23. The disk is thus comparable in size to the ∼0.01\sim0.01 pc (≈2000\approx2000 AU) disk of Y. J. Meziani et al. [64], but unlike that Toomre-stable disk, here the disk fragments (subsection 3.4). The subsequent evolution of the system is governed by the competition between gravitational instability (which fragments the outer disk into secondary protostars) and the supply of mass and angular momentum by infall from the envelope; the magnetic energy stays well below the thermal and kinetic energies (subsection 3.6).

Energetics

In this section, we consider the interplay of the gravitational, kinetic, thermal and magnetic energies for the particles identified in the disk. We compute the following energy components: potential EpotE_{\mathrm{pot}}, rotational ErotE_{\mathrm{rot}}, turbulent EturbE_{\mathrm{turb}}, thermal EthermE_{\mathrm{therm}}, and magnetic EmagE_{\mathrm{mag}}, each summed over the gas particles identified as disk members (subsubsection 2.3.1); the explicit expressions are given in Equation 5 below.

Epot=−G∑i,j∈diskmimj∣ri−rj∣2+ϵ2−G∑s∈sinks∑i∈diskmsmi∣rs−ri∣2+ϵ2,(5)\begin{aligned} E_{\mathrm{pot}}={}&-G\sum_{i,j\in\mathrm{disk}}\frac{m_i m_j}{\sqrt{\lvert\mathbf{r}_i-\mathbf{r}_j\rvert^2+\epsilon^2}}\\ &-G\sum_{s\in\mathrm{sinks}}\sum_{i\in\mathrm{disk}}\frac{m_s m_i}{\sqrt{\lvert\mathbf{r}_s-\mathbf{r}_i\rvert^2+\epsilon^2}}, \tag*{(5)} \end{aligned}
Erot=12∑i∈diskmivϕ,i2,(6)E_{\mathrm{rot}}=\frac{1}{2}\sum_{i\in\mathrm{disk}}m_i v_{\phi,i}^2, \tag*{(6)}
Eturb=12∑i∈diskmi∣vi−vϕ,iϕ^−vr,ir^∣2,(7)E_{\mathrm{turb}}=\frac{1}{2}\sum_{i\in\mathrm{disk}}m_i\left\lvert\mathbf{v}_i-v_{\phi,i}\hat{\boldsymbol{\phi}}-v_{r,i}\hat{\mathbf{r}}\right\rvert^2, \tag*{(7)}
Etherm=∑i∈diskmiui,(8)E_{\mathrm{therm}}=\sum_{i\in\mathrm{disk}}m_i u_i, \tag*{(8)}
Emag=∑i∈disk∣Bi∣2mi8πρi,(9)E_{\mathrm{mag}}=\sum_{i\in\mathrm{disk}}\frac{\lvert\mathbf{B}_i\rvert^2m_i}{8\pi\rho_i}, \tag*{(9)}

where mim_i is the mass of particle ii, vi\mathbf{v}_i its total velocity vector, vϕ,iv_{\phi,i}, vr,iv_{r,i} are bulk velocity profile fits for the azimuthal and radial components in each annulus (both functions of rr only), Bi\mathbf{B}_i is the magnetic field vector, ρi\rho_i is the density, and uiu_i is the internal energy.

Figure 8 shows the time evolution of the main energy components computed for disk-identified particles. Throughout the simulation, ∣Epot∣\lvert E_{\mathrm{pot}}\rvert dominates over all other components, confirming that the disk is gravitationally bound. ErotE_{\mathrm{rot}} and EturbE_{\mathrm{turb}} are the main support terms and track each other to within a factor of ∼2\sim2, with ErotE_{\mathrm{rot}} slightly exceeding EturbE_{\mathrm{turb}}. EthermE_{\mathrm{therm}} starts comparable to the kinetic energies at early times but becomes subdominant at late times as the gravitational potential well deepens faster than the gas heats.

The magnetic energy, EmagE_{\mathrm{mag}}, grows over the ∼15\sim15 kyr simulation, from ∼1042\sim10^{42} erg at Δt≈−0.5\Delta t\approx-0.5 kyr to ∼1045.3\sim10^{45.3} erg at 15 kyr. This growth is consistent with a combination of flux-freezing compression during the collapse, field-line winding by differential rotation, and potentially both the small-scale turbulent dynamo and the large-scale mean-field dynamo ([88]), but we cannot separate these channels (subsection 3.6).

Despite this rapid amplification, EmagE_{\mathrm{mag}} remains below EthermE_{\mathrm{therm}} throughout the simulation, though the gap narrows at late times – consistent with the declining mass-to-flux ratios discussed in subsection 3.6.

The bottom panel shows the virial ratio 2Ekin/∣Epot∣2E_{\mathrm{kin}}/\lvert E_{\mathrm{pot}}\rvert. At early times (Δt<0\Delta t < 0), the virial ratio is ∼0.65\sim0.65, indicating a sub-virial, contracting state, i.e. the system has insufficient kinetic energy to balance gravity. The virial ratio rises as the disk forms and spins up, reaching ∼1.0\sim1.0 by Δt≈2\Delta t \approx2 kyr. From 2 kyr onward, the virial ratio oscillates around unity, indicating that the disk has achieved and maintains approximate virial equilibrium through a balance of rotational support, turbulent pressure, and gravitational collapse. The virial ratio never approaches the unbound threshold of 2, except towards the end of our run, confirming that the system remains gravitationally bound throughout.

Disk morphology and evolution

As the disk accretes mass and angular momentum, its morphology undergoes a characteristic sequence: an initially smooth, centrally concentrated structure gives way to spiral arms as the Toomre parameter drops below 1 (the disk becomes unstable), and those arms subsequently fragment into secondary sinks. Face-on and edge-on surface density projections at six representative epochs spanning the ∼15\sim15 kyr after the formation of the first sink (t1t_1) are shown in Figure 3 (subsubsection 2.3.1).

The disk does not begin as a rotationally supported structure. At the pre-stellar epoch vϕv_\phi lies well below the local Keplerian speed at every radius in Figure 6, so the centrifugal support of the collapsing core is weak and the infall is close to radial. Rotational support is acquired only gradually: vϕv_\phi rises monotonically with time while −vr-v_r falls after the bulk star formation events, and only then does vϕ/vKv_\phi/v_K approach the fkep=0.3f_{\mathrm{kep}} = 0.3 threshold used for disk membership (subsubsection 2.3.1) over an extended range of radii. The disk we identify is therefore assembled from an initially slowly rotating, predominantly infalling core. The disk starts thick, with aspect ratio h/rh/r at ≈0.9\approx0.9 during the pre-stellar epoch (Δt=−0.5\Delta t = -0.5 kyr), drops to a minimum of ∼0.3\sim0.3 around the first bulk star formation event (Δt≈3.5\Delta t \approx3.5 kyr) as the disk settles and gains rotational support, and then rises again at later times, to ≈0.8\approx0.8 at 15 kyr. This late-time increase is most plausibly a consequence of the disk being disrupted: as gas is converted into stars it is removed from the disk, leaving material that is less rotationally supported and vertically more extended.

Disk stability and fragmentation

In this section, we analyze the stability properties of the disk. Whether a self-gravitating disk fragments into bound clumps, or instead disperses the accumulated mass through spiral-arm shocks and turbulent transport depends on the ratio of stabilizing pressures (thermal, turbulent) to the destabilizing self-gravity of the gas. The Toomre parameter, defined in Equation (10) ([108]), quantifies this balance locally: Q<1Q < 1 marks regions where perturbations on the disk scale grow faster than orbital shear can wind them up. We track the spatial and temporal evolution of QQ to identify when and where fragmentation occurs, and how the velocity dispersion stirred up by the forming sinks subsequently self-regulates the disk back toward marginal stability.

Toomre-Q maps and radial profiles

To characterize non-thermal motions in the disk, we decompose particle velocities into radial and azimuthal components (vr,vϕ)(v_r, v_\phi) in the disk-plane coordinate system. We subdivide the disk into concentric cylindrical annuli and compute the mass-weighted mean velocity in each annulus, yielding radial profiles vˉr(r)\bar{v}_r(r) and vˉϕ(r)\bar{v}_\phi(r). The residual (streaming-subtracted) velocity for each particle is δv⃗=(vr−vˉr, vϕ−vˉϕ, vz)\delta\vec{v} = (v_r-\bar{v}_r,\ v_\phi-\bar{v}_\phi,\ v_z). The velocity dispersion σv\sigma_v is computed as the root-mean-square of ∣δv⃗∣\lvert\delta\vec{v}\rvert within each annulus.

We calculate the Toomre QQ parameter as:

Q=ζκπGΣ,ζ=σr2+cs2(10)Q = \frac{\zeta\kappa}{\pi G\Sigma},\qquad\zeta= \sqrt{\sigma_r^2+c_s^2} \tag*{(10)}

where csc_s is the sound speed, σr\sigma_r is the radial velocity dispersion, κ\kappa the epicyclic frequency, computed numerically from the angular velocity profile as κ2=(2Ω/r) d(r2Ω)/dr\kappa^2 = (2\Omega/r)\,\mathrm{d}(r^2\Omega)/\mathrm{d}r (so κ=Ω\kappa= \Omega for Keplerian rotation), and Σ\Sigma the surface density. In hot disks ζ≈cs\zeta\approx c_s, while in N-body systems (like a galactic disk) ζ≈σr\zeta\approx\sigma_r. ζ=σr2+cs2\zeta= \sqrt{\sigma_r^2+c_s^2} thus includes both thermal and turbulent contributions, since supersonic turbulence provides additional effective pressure support. We measure Σ\Sigma, σr\sigma_r, Ω\Omega and κ\kappa in radial annuli and construct a pixel-by-pixel map in the same way; the estimators are given in Appendix § 12.

Figure 9 (top) shows face-on maps of the local QQ. At the pre-stellar epoch (Δt=−0.5\Delta t = -0.5 kyr), the gas is broadly unstable with Q≲1Q \lesssim1 throughout most of the region. By Δt=0\Delta t = 0, the central region near the first sink begins to stabilize, while the surroundings remain marginally unstable. At Δt≈1.3\Delta t \approx1.3 kyr, a clear boundary emerges between a stabilized inner region and an unstable outer envelope. By the time spiral arms have developed (Δt≈3.6\Delta t \approx3.6 kyr), a ring of Q<1Q < 1 material traces the spiral arms, while the inner disk is stabilized (Q>1Q > 1) by the strong velocity dispersion generated near the central sinks.

Figure 9. Top: Face-on maps of the local Toomre QQ parameter at six epochs. The black contour marks Q=1Q = 1. Bottom: Evolution of radial profile of Toomre QQ (heatmap), and sink formations, mergers, and radial positions’ evolution (lines). At early times the gas is globally unstable (Q<1Q < 1); at late times the inner disk is strongly stabilized while the outer spiral arms remain near or below Q=1Q = 1. Radial profile of Toomre QQ at six epochs. The horizontal dashed line marks Q=1Q = 1. At early times the entire region has Q<1Q < 1; at late times a radial gradient develops, with Q∼60Q \sim60 at r<100r < 100 AU, falling to Q∼1Q \sim1 at r∼2700r \sim2700 AU. Heavy sinks are the 10 most massive sinks at Δt=15\Delta t = 15 kyr (sinks that have merged away by then do not count); all other sinks are light and drawn in gray. In the maps, the size of the sink markers scales with sink mass. In the bottom panel, each heavy sink’s trajectory r(t)r(t) and formation marker have the same color as that sink in Figure 12 and Figure 13. Most massive sink always stays at r=0r = 0 by definition of the center of our disk.

The radial Toomre QQ profile (Figure 10) quantifies its evolution. At the pre-stellar epoch (Δt=−0.5\Delta t = -0.5 kyr), QQ is below unity inside ∼1500\sim1500 AU (Q≈0.55Q \approx0.55) and close to unity farther out, reflecting a globally unstable collapsing core. As the first sink forms and accretes, the inner QQ rises: by Δt=1.3\Delta t = 1.3 kyr (green), Q≈1Q \approx1 throughout, consistent with a marginally stable state.

Figure 10. Toomre QQ radial profiles time evolution. The disk starts with Q<1Q < 1 inside and Q≈1Q \approx1 near the edge, but QQ rises with disk evolution, since gas is removed from the disk because of star formation events. Center of the disk is extremely stable (Q∼60Q \sim60) by the 15 kyr mark, preventing any further star formation in the middle.

By Δt=9.5 kyr\Delta t = 9.5\ \mathrm{kyr} (brown), QQ is mostly stable in the whole disk, with the central region (r≲150 AUr \lesssim150\ \mathrm{AU}, where Q≳60Q \gtrsim60) being the most stable. At later times a radial gradient develops, with the inner disk more stable (Q≫1Q \gg1); the outer spiral arms seen at earlier epochs remain near or below Q∼1Q \sim1. By the latest epochs the disk (r≲2000 AUr \lesssim2000\ \mathrm{AU}) is Toomre-stable throughout, and the QQ profile remains near or above unity out to r∼2700 AUr \sim2700\ \mathrm{AU}.

What sets Q: thermal versus turbulent support

The shape of these profiles follows directly from the disk kinematics of Figure 6. Using κ≈Ω=vˉϕ/r\kappa\approx\Omega= \bar{v}_{\phi}/r and Σ≈Mdisk/(πr2)\Sigma\approx M_{\mathrm{disk}}/(\pi r^{2}) for the disk mass enclosed at rr, and eliminating GG through vK2=GMenc/rv_{\mathrm{K}}^{2} = GM_{\mathrm{enc}}/r, Equation (10) can be rearranged into Equation (11):

Q≈ζvKvˉϕvKMencMdisk(11)Q \approx\frac{\zeta}{v_{\mathrm{K}}}\frac{\bar{v}_{\phi}}{v_{\mathrm{K}}}\frac{M_{\mathrm{enc}}}{M_{\mathrm{disk}}} \tag*{(11)}

where ζ=σr2+cs2\zeta= \sqrt{\sigma_{r}^{2} + c_{s}^{2}} as above and Menc=M∗+MdiskM_{\mathrm{enc}} = M_{*} + M_{\mathrm{disk}}. The balance between these two terms in ζ\zeta changes with time. Near marginal stability (0.3<Q<30.3 < Q < 3), thermal pressure dominates (Δt≲4 kyr\Delta t \lesssim4\ \mathrm{kyr}). The radial velocity dispersion only becomes comparable to csc_{s} at Δt≈5 kyr\Delta t \approx5\ \mathrm{kyr} and dominates afterwards.

The Q<1Q < 1 at early times is easy to explain from Equation (11): at that point the first two terms are <1< 1 (turbulence is sonic/subsonic, and rotational support is weak), and M∗≈0M_{*} \approx0, making the last term 1. The product is well below unity at every radius, which is why the core starts out globally unstable.

After the first sinks form, all three factors from Equation (11) move upward. σr\sigma_{r} and ∣δv∣\lvert\delta v\rvert (mostly tracing ζ\zeta) grow monotonically. The inner vKv_{\mathrm{K}} rises slightly as Menc\sqrt{M_{\mathrm{enc}}} is growing from the infalling gas; vˉϕ\bar{v}_{\phi} rises steadily as the disk spins up; and the stellar mass grows quadratically while the disk gas is depleted by star formation, so Menc/MdiskM_{\mathrm{enc}}/M_{\mathrm{disk}} climbs by more than an order of magnitude. The extreme central values (Q≳102Q \gtrsim10^{2} inside ∼150 AU\sim150\ \mathrm{AU}) are dominated by the last of these, since there the enclosed mass is almost entirely stellar and very little gas is left. The outer disk stays near Q∼1Q \sim1 because it remains gas-dominated and its turbulent velocities stay a roughly fixed fraction of the local orbital speed. The stabilization of the disk is therefore kinematic and structural rather than thermal: turbulence rises relative to the orbital speed, the disk spins up, and gas is converted into stars.

Fragmentation, heating fronts, and self-regulation

Figure 9 (bottom) shows the space–time evolution of the azimuthally-averaged Toomre QQ radial profile. The disk begins in a predominantly unstable state (Q<1Q < 1, red) at all radii. The first sink forms at the center, and within ∼0.2 kyr\sim0.2\ \mathrm{kyr} the Q=1Q = 1 contour (black line) begins to propagate outward from the center, tracing a wave of stabilization driven by heating of the gas, which we speculate is caused by the first sink. A second stabilization wave starts at Δt≈1.1 kyr\Delta t \approx1.1\ \mathrm{kyr}, together with the formation of a second sink near the center. The leading edge of the first wave, 2.52.5 times the sound speed of the gas ahead of it. Both fronts are driven by a rise in the sound speed. We speculate that this gas is heated by the first sink.

The second wave coincides with the formation of the second sink, but the second sink doesn’t start producing radiation until the ”stability wave” has already began traveling through the disk. We speculate that the second wave is also driven mainly by the first sink. Because QQ is then already ≲1\lesssim1 throughout the inner 1000 AU, the Q=1Q = 1 contour of this wave sweeps the whole disk within ≲0.1 kyr\lesssim0.1\ \mathrm{kyr}, while the maximum of QQ moves outward at ≈4.5 km s−1\approx4.5\ \mathrm{km\ s^{-1}}. Only sinks forming at the center produce such fronts, because later sinks form in gas that has already been heated. In the second wave the gas stays at ≳2000 K\gtrsim2000\ \mathrm{K} for a further ∼0.2 kyr\sim0.2\ \mathrm{kyr}, while at 150 AU the molecular fraction falls from ≈0.5\approx0.5 to 0 at Δt∼1.2 kyr\Delta t \sim1.2\ \mathrm{kyr}. This is consistent with collisional dissociation by atomic hydrogen in the network, which at these temperatures destroys H2\mathrm{H}_{2} in much less than 50 yr but, unlike in real gas, does not absorb energy (subsection 2.2.3).

The early stabilization waves are therefore thermally driven. After ∼3 kyr\sim3\ \mathrm{kyr} the inner disk stays stable because accretion onto sinks depletes its gas, while QQ falls back to ≲1\lesssim1 farther out as gas accumulates. At ≈3 kyr\approx3\ \mathrm{kyr} a spiral arm fragments into ∼40\sim40 stellar seeds within ≈1 kyr\approx1\ \mathrm{kyr}; many merge soon after (see [27], for the merging criteria), leaving ∼19\sim19 stars. Locking gas into stars lowers the disk mass and stabilizes it.

The outer disk reaches Q>1Q > 1 by ∼8 kyr\sim8\,\mathrm{kyr}, coinciding with the second and last bulk star formation event, which converts most of the available disk gas into stars. In the bottom panel of Figure 9, each successive event occurs farther from the center because the inner gas has already been depleted, so stability propagates inside-out.

Star Formation and the protostellar mass function

In this section, we analyze the star formation outcome of the system by quantifying the total stellar mass growth, the instantaneous star formation efficiency within the disk, and the shape of the proto-stellar mass function (PMF). Because the jet feedback in this run is deposited close to the protostars and does not propagate as far as intended (subsubsection 2.2.4), the stellar masses, accretion rates and star formation efficiencies below represent upper limits (§ 6).

Total stellar mass growth and accretion rates

The top panel of Figure 11 shows the evolution of gas, stellar (sink), and total mass within a 0.1 pc sphere centered on the most massive star in the disk. The total stellar mass (orange, solid line) reaches ∼200 M⊙\sim200\,M_\odot by 15 kyr, growing as M⋆∝Δt2.08M_\star\propto\Delta t^{2.08} (dashed red line). This is consistent with the M⋆∝t2M_\star\propto t^2 scaling predicted by the theory of collapse in self-gravitating turbulent fluids (N. W. Murray & P. Chang [67]) and confirmed in high-resolution AMR simulations by E. J. Lee et al. [57]; D. W. Murray et al. [66]. The density inside the stellar sphere of influence evolves to a time-independent attractor ρ(r,t)→ρ(r)∝r−3/2\rho(r,t) \to\rho(r) \propto r^{-3/2}, which, combined with infall at a fixed fraction of the Keplerian speed, yields a mass accretion rate M˙∝t\dot{M} \propto t and thus M⋆∝t2M_\star\propto t^2.

Figure 11. Top panel: time evolution of the stellar mass (all sinks; orange), disk gas mass (cyan), gas within a 0.1 pc sphere, MsphereM_{\mathrm{sphere}} (navy), and total mass (Mdisk+M⋆M_{\mathrm{disk}} + M_\star, dark gray; Msphere+M⋆M_{\mathrm{sphere}} + M_\star, light gray). The best-fit power law M⋆∝t2.08M_\star\propto t^{2.08} is shown as a dashed red line. Top-middle panel: three net rates of change between consecutive snapshots: the growth rate of the total sink mass, M˙⋆=dM⋆/dt\dot{M}_\star= dM_\star/dt (magenta); the rate at which the sphere loses gas, −M˙sphere=−dMsphere/dt-\dot{M}_{\mathrm{sphere}} = -dM_{\mathrm{sphere}}/dt (navy); and the rate of change of the disk gas mass, M˙disk=dMdisk/dt\dot{M}_{\mathrm{disk}} = dM_{\mathrm{disk}}/dt (cyan). Dim lines show the rates at each snapshot, bright lines the same rates smoothed. Where the smoothed rate is negative, its absolute value is shown dotted. These are changes of the mass inside a region, not fluxes through a surface, so M˙disk\dot{M}_{\mathrm{disk}} is not measured at the disk edge; it is the infall minus the accretion onto sinks. The infall rate through a sphere of radius rr is shown in Figure 5. Bottom-middle panel: sphere of influence radius rSOIr_{\mathrm{SOI}} (Mgas,enc=M⋆M_{\mathrm{gas,enc}} = M_\star; orange). Bottom panel: star formation efficiency within the disk, SFEdisk=M⋆/(Mdisk+M⋆)\mathrm{SFE}_{\mathrm{disk}} = M_\star/(M_{\mathrm{disk}} + M_\star) (green solid), and within the 0.1 pc sphere, SFEsphere=M⋆/(Msphere+M⋆)\mathrm{SFE}_{\mathrm{sphere}} = M_\star/(M_{\mathrm{sphere}} + M_\star) (green dashed), and within the whole halo, SFEhalo=M⋆/(Mgas,halo+M⋆)\mathrm{SFE}_{\mathrm{halo}} = M_\star/(M_{\mathrm{gas,halo}} + M_\star) (black dash-dotted), where Mgas,halo=5.7×106 M⊙M_{\mathrm{gas,halo}} = 5.7 \times10^6\,M_\odot is the gas inside the virial radius (0.46 kpc, physical), held constant because it changes by less than 0.01% over the run, together with the star formation efficiency per free-fall time ϵff\epsilon_{\mathrm{ff}} (blue), ϵff=tff/tdep\epsilon_{\mathrm{ff}} = t_{\mathrm{ff}}/t_{\mathrm{dep}}, where tdep=Msphere/M˙⋆t_{\mathrm{dep}} = M_{\mathrm{sphere}}/\dot{M}_\star and tfft_{\mathrm{ff}} is the free-fall time at the mean density of gas and sinks inside the sphere.

The disk gas mass (cyan) grows as infall from the envelope outweighs gas consumed by sink accretion (values in subsection 3.3). Both the infall rate and the total stellar accretion rate are of order 10−210^{-2}–10−3 M⊙ yr−110^{-3}\,M_\odot\,\mathrm{yr}^{-1} over this period, with infall initially the larger of the two (Figure 5; top-middle panel of Figure 11). It then declines as the star formation efficiency rises and the envelope supply is depleted. The gas mass within the 0.1 pc sphere (navy) rises from ≈160\approx160 to ≈180 M⊙\approx180\,M_\odot over the first ∼3\sim3 kyr, declines to ≈130 M⊙\approx130\,M_\odot by ∼10\sim10 kyr as accretion drains it, and then rises again to ≈160 M⊙\approx160\,M_\odot by 15 kyr as infalling gas enters the sphere. The reason for this is a large amount of infalling gas suddenly entering the sphere, resulting in a positive M˙gas,sphere\dot{M}_{\mathrm{gas,sphere}} (i.e. more gas is entering the system than is being converted to stellar mass). This sudden rise in the gas mass also “ignites” the stellar accretion again after its slow-down, driven by the depletion of initial accessible reservoirs in the original disk, and one can see this “bounce-back” in the top and bottom panels of Figure 11: M⋆M_\star grows slowly, with MapertM_{\mathrm{apert}} increasing faster after Δt≈10 kyr\Delta t \approx10\,\mathrm{kyr}, while MdiskM_{\mathrm{disk}} stays roughly constant.

Figure 11 (top-middle panel) shows the corresponding mass rates. The stellar accretion rate (magenta) fluctuates around ∼5×10−3 M⊙ yr−1\sim5 \times10^{-3}\,M_\odot\,\mathrm{yr}^{-1} at early times, rising to ∼10−2 M⊙ yr−1\sim10^{-2}\,M_\odot\,\mathrm{yr}^{-1} at late times. The median accretion rate is M˙∗≈0.011 M⊙ yr−1\dot{M}_* \approx0.011\,M_\odot\,\mathrm{yr}^{-1}, and the disk-wide gas infall rate is ≈0.016 M⊙ yr−1\approx0.016\,M_\odot\,\mathrm{yr}^{-1}. These rates are ∼16cs3/G\sim16c_s^3/G for 600 K gas, an order of magnitude above the Shu rate 0.975cs3/G∼10−3 M⊙ yr−10.975c_s^3/G \sim10^{-3}\,M_\odot\,\mathrm{yr}^{-1} (F. H. Shu [91]). They are comparable to the Larson–Penston rates (29cs3/G29c_s^3/G in the envelope at core formation, 47cs3/G47c_s^3/G after it; C. F. McKee & E. C. Ostriker [62]) and to the ∼10−2 M⊙ yr−1\sim10^{-2}\,M_\odot\,\mathrm{yr}^{-1} found by A. Stacy et al. [99], as expected from the envelope kinematics (§ 3).

Figure 11 (third panel) shows the sphere of influence radius rSOIr_{\mathrm{SOI}}, defined as the radius where the enclosed gas mass equals the total stellar mass (Mgas,enc=M∗M_{\mathrm{gas,enc}} = M_*). This grows from ∼80\sim80 AU at 1 kyr to ∼104\sim10^4 AU by 10 kyr. It drops slightly with the new gas entering the sphere. The growth of rSOIr_{\mathrm{SOI}} quantifies the outward expansion of the region from which the central cluster can draw its gas: as M∗M_* grows superlinearly, the scale on which the cluster potential dominates the gravitational field expands at ∼103\sim10^3 AU kyr−1^{-1}, roughly as rSOI∝t2r_{\mathrm{SOI}} \propto t^2. This is faster than the r∗∝t4/3r_* \propto t^{4/3} predicted for a self-similar envelope (N. W. Murray & P. Chang [67], Eq. 42), which would give only ≈1700\approx1700 AU at 10 kyr. The difference is consistent with the finite disk reservoir being consumed rather than continuously replenished, since the gas reigniting star formation after 10 kyrs only had time to enter the 0.1 pc sphere and did not yet fall into the disk.

Star formation efficiency

We now examine the star formation efficiency, SFE, and the efficiency per free-fall time, ϵff\epsilon_{\mathrm{ff}}. Both are instantaneous quantities, evaluated at each snapshot for a region XX (the disk, the 0.1 pc sphere or the whole halo), and shown in the bottom panel of Figure 11:

SFE∗,X(t)=M∗,X(t)Mgas,X(t)+M∗,X(t)(12)\mathrm{SFE}_{*,X}(t) = \frac{M_{*,X}(t)}{M_{\mathrm{gas},X}(t) + M_{*,X}(t)} \tag*{(12)}
ϵff,X(t)=M˙∗,X(t)tff,X(t)Mgas,X(t)(13)\epsilon_{\mathrm{ff},X}(t) = \frac{\dot{M}_{*,X}(t)t_{\mathrm{ff},X}(t)}{M_{\mathrm{gas},X}(t)} \tag*{(13)}

where X∈{disk,sphere,halo}X \in\{\mathrm{disk},\mathrm{sphere},\mathrm{halo}\}, Mgas,XM_{\mathrm{gas},X} and M∗,XM_{*,X} are the gas and stellar (sink) masses in XX, M˙∗,X\dot{M}_{*,X} is the rate at which the stellar mass in XX grows, and tff,X=3π/(32GρˉX)t_{\mathrm{ff},X} = \sqrt{3\pi/(32G\bar{\rho}_X)} is the free-fall time at the mean density ρˉX\bar{\rho}_X of gas and sinks in XX.

The SFE remains below unity throughout our run. Within the disk, SFE rises steeply and saturates at ∼80%\sim80\% by 10 kyr. Within the 0.1 pc sphere, however, SFE only reaches a maximum of ∼50%\sim50\% by 10 kyr. Over the whole halo the efficiency is only ≈3×10−5\approx3 \times10^{-5} at 15 kyr, where Mgas,halo=5.7×106 M⊙M_{\mathrm{gas,halo}} = 5.7 \times10^6\,M_\odot is the gas inside the virial radius (0.46 kpc, physical), which stays constant to better than 0.01% over the run. This is not the case for ϵff\epsilon_{\mathrm{ff}},

which exceeds far above unity, and exhibits a sensitive dependence on the star formation rate and ongoing gas accretion. While ϵff\epsilon_{\mathrm{ff}} is only ∼1%\sim1\% in Galactic clouds and galaxies from the local universe to high redshift (M. R. Krumholz et al. [53]), it can exceed unity locally when a star forming region is being fed by multiple filaments or streamers (see e.g. C. D. Matzner & P. H. Jumper [61]). This is indeed the case here. Between 4 and 10 kyr the median ϵff≈1.4\epsilon_{\mathrm{ff}} \approx1.4 (and ≲1\lesssim1 before and after); Appendix § 13 shows that this is what the stellar accretion rate of ≈1.7×10−2 M⊙ yr−1\approx1.7 \times10^{-2}\,M_\odot\,\mathrm{yr}^{-1} implies for the free-fall time of a Larson–Penston-like envelope.

Protostellar mass function

The PMF uses the current masses of the 32 sinks present at Δt=15\Delta t = 15 kyr, not their maximum masses. Most low-mass sinks merged early, so only one sink lies below 0.1 M⊙0.1\,M_\odot and the PMF at 15 kyr is not skewed by them.

Figure 12 shows the protostellar mass function (PMF) of the sinks at Δt=15\Delta t = 15 kyr, compared to the present-day P. Kroupa [52] and G. Chabrier [13] initial mass functions (IMFs). The high-mass slope of the PMF is well fitted by a power law dN/dM∝M−αPMFdN/dM \propto M^{-\alpha_{\mathrm{PMF}}} with αPMF=1.01−0.14+0.14\alpha_{\mathrm{PMF}} = 1.01^{+0.14}_{-0.14} much shallower than the Salpeter slope (α=2.35\alpha= 2.35) and the Kroupa high-mass slope (α=2.3\alpha= 2.3). A slope of ≈1\approx1 means equal numbers of sinks per logarithmic mass interval, i.e. a flat dN/dlog⁡M\mathrm{d}N/\mathrm{d}\log M. We compare this slope with other Pop III simulations in subsection 4.5.

Figure 12. Protostellar mass function of the 32 sinks present at Δt=15\Delta t = 15 kyr (blue histogram), compared to the G. Chabrier [13] system IMF (dashed) and the P. Kroupa [52] IMF (dotted), both scaled to the number of sinks above 0.1 M⊙0.1\,M_\odot. The blue dashed line is the power-law fit dN/dM∗∝M∗−αPMFdN/dM_* \propto M_*^{-\alpha_{\mathrm{PMF}}} above 0.3 M⊙0.3\,M_\odot, αPMF=1.01−0.14+0.14\alpha_{\mathrm{PMF}} = 1.01^{+0.14}_{-0.14}. Star symbols mark individual sinks: the xx position is the sink mass and the height is its formation time along the arrow (Δt=0\Delta t = 0 at the bottom, 15 kyr at the top), not a value of dN/dM∗dN/dM_*. Star size grows with mass. Heavy sinks, the 10 most massive sinks at Δt=15\Delta t = 15 kyr, are colored and light sinks are gray; each heavy sink has the same color as in Figure 9 and Figure 13 (bottom). The gray shaded region lies below the completeness limit (∼100 Δm≈0.1 M⊙\sim100\,\Delta m \approx0.1\,M_\odot).

The low-mass end of the distribution must be read with care. Because the PMF is a 15 kyr snapshot, many of the lowest-mass sinks have only recently formed or have been ejected from the disk, and have not yet had time to accrete; they populate the gray region below the completeness limit rather than a genuine low-mass tail. The only sink below that limit, of 1.7×10−3 M⊙1.7 \times10^{-3}\,M_\odot, formed at Δt≈3\Delta t \approx3 kyr and was ejected before it could accrete. In Figure 12 the star symbols form two rows, the sinks of the two fragmentation bursts at Δt≈3.5\Delta t \approx3.5 and ≈7.5\approx7.5 kyr, and ten of the 13 sinks below 2 M⊙2\,M_\odot have moved beyond 2500 AU from the most massive sink, after which they barely accrete. None of the sinks have reached the main sequence by the end of our simulation.

In the protostellar model ([69, 27]) all 18 sinks above 2 M⊙2\,M_\odot are in the shell deuterium-burning phase at 15 kyr, the ten sinks of 1.5 M⊙1.5\,M_\odot burn deuterium in their cores at fixed core temperature, three of 0.45 M⊙0.45\,M_\odot have not yet ignited deuterium, and the ejected 1.7×10−3 M⊙1.7 \times10^{-3}\,M_\odot sink is still a pre-collapse first core. None has reached the main sequence.

Individual accretion histories and runaway

Figure 13 shows integrated accretion history of individual sinks. A lot of low-mass (<3M⊙< 3M_\odot) sinks stop accreting relatively early because they get ejected out of the disk, thus limiting the amount of gas, available to them. The accretion histories in Figure 13 (with the times at which sinks move beyond 2500 AU marked as ticks at the end of the lines) shows that accretion is active for most of the time for most of the sinks until they leave the disk.

Figure 13. Evolution of masses of individual sinks. Dashed line represents ideal M∗∝t2M_* \propto t^2 law, which is being followed for total mass of all the sinks (black line). At earlier times, before the first bulk star formation event at 2-3 kyr, all of stellar mass is concentrated in the 2 central sinks (top blue lines). These massive sinks reach mass of around 20M⊙20M_\odot by the 15 kyr mark, with their accretion slowing down compared to less massive sinks, which still accrete rapidly. Small vertical ticks mark the time at which each sink first moves more than 2500 AU from the most massive sink (“far” sinks). The mass history for these far sinks is drawn fainter because their mass doesn’t change by more than 3% afterwards. The lower panel shows the time evolution of the number of all formed sinks, including those that merged later (black, cumulative), of the sinks present at that time (blue), of far sinks (red, cumulative), and of gravitationally unbound sinks (green): sinks beyond 2500 AU from the center of mass of the central cluster with vrad>vesc=2GMenc/rv_{\rm rad} > v_{\rm esc} = \sqrt{2GM_{\rm enc}/r}, where MencM_{\rm enc} includes the gas and the other sinks. A sink is counted as unbound (or bound again) only after the criterion has held for 10 consecutive snapshots (≈0.25\approx0.25 kyr), with an N∝t1.5N \propto t^{1.5} reference (P. S. Li et al. 2018). Heavy sinks, the 10 most massive sinks at Δt=15\Delta t = 15 kyr, are colored with the same color as in Figure 9 (bottom) and Figure 12; all other (light) sinks are gray.

Of the 62 sinks formed during the run, 30 (48%) were lost to mergers at low mass: STARFORGE merges two sinks when they are bound with a semimajor axis below the sink radius and the lighter one has less than 10 Δm≈0.01 M⊙10\,\Delta m \approx0.01\,M_\odot, to remove spurious sinks that form next to existing ones ([27]).

In our simulation, 14 of the 32 surviving sinks are far (r>2500r > 2500 AU) by 15 kyr. Applying the escape criterion of A. Stacy & V. Bromm [97], vrad>vescv_{\rm rad} > v_{\rm esc} (lower panel of Figure 13), only 7 of the 32 survivors are unbound at 15 kyr (≈20%\approx20\%). All of them have M≲2 M⊙M \lesssim2\,M_\odot, as expected for dynamical ejection, which preferentially removes the lowest-mass members of a few-body system.

The unbound count peaks at 8 at Δt≈13.6\Delta t \approx13.6 kyr, and these sinks are on wide orbits within the envelope rather than escaping. Far sinks typically retain close to their mass at ejection.

Figure 13 also shows that the 2 heaviest sinks are the first 2 sinks that formed in the simulation, both in the

center of the disk. At the same figure it can be seen that the accretion in the center of the disk (heaviest 2 sinks) mostly halts, which is a consequence of depletion of gas reservoir. This gas depletion is shown by a drop in stellar accretion rate in Figure 11. The most massive sink reaches 25 M⊙M_\odot by 15 kyr, but its accretion has slowed to M˙≈2.5×10−4 M⊙ yr−1\dot{M} \approx2.5 \times10^{-4}\,M_\odot\,\mathrm{yr}^{-1} over the final kiloyear as the local gas reservoir is depleted. The “bounce-back”, described in detail in subsection 3.5, seems to mostly target the non-central sinks, since we still observe their growth after Δt≈11\Delta t \approx11 kyr.

The second-most massive sink (23 M⊙M_\odot) is at ∼4500\sim4500 AU and its accretion has stalled entirely by 15 kyr. It is a far sink, but it is gravitationally bound to the central group of five sinks (≈60 M⊙\approx60\,M_\odot within 200 AU of the primary). Between 12 and 15 kyr its two-body orbit has E≈−0.5 GM/rE \approx-0.5\,GM/r, a semi-major axis of ≈4000\approx4000 AU, an eccentricity of ≈0.6\approx0.6 and a period of ≈30\approx30 kyr. It is a wide, eccentric companion near apocenter, and it returns to ≈1200\approx1200 AU at ≈18\approx18 kyr in the extended run. Its accretion stalls because its orbit lies largely outside the gas disk.

Competitive accretion in a cluster environment would preferentially feed the most massive objects (I. A. Bonnell et al. [7]), flattening the mass function slope. To distinguish competitive accretion from simple disk fragmentation, we show in Figure 14 (top) the accretion rate M˙\dot{M} against the current mass mm for all sinks, with the binned median, compared with the scalings of tidal-lobe (M˙∝m2/3\dot{M} \propto m^{2/3}), Bondi–Hoyle (M˙∝m2\dot{M} \propto m^2) competitive accretion (I. A. Bonnell et al. [7]), accretion from a turbulent core (M˙∝m1/2\dot{M} \propto m^{1/2}; C. F. McKee & J. C. Tan [63]) and inertial inflow (M˙\dot{M} independent of mm; P. Padoan et al. [74]). Above ∼1 M⊙\sim1\,M_\odot the median rises roughly as M˙∝m0.8−0.9\dot{M} \propto m^{0.8-0.9}, between the tidal-lobe and Bondi–Hoyle cases. Discarding the ≈7\approx7 per cent of rates below 10−5 M⊙ yr−110^{-5}\,M_\odot\,\mathrm{yr}^{-1}, from sinks that have almost stopped accreting, flattens the slope to ≈0.65\approx0.65, between the turbulent-core (1/2) and tidal-lobe (2/3) values; the data cannot distinguish between these two. Below 1 M⊙1\,M_\odot it falls with mass, because newly formed sinks accrete fastest just after formation.

Figure 14. Top: accretion rate M˙\dot{M} against current mass mm for all sinks (gray) with the binned median (black), compared with tidal-lobe (M˙∝m2/3\dot{M} \propto m^{2/3}) and Bondi–Hoyle (M˙∝m2\dot{M} \propto m^2) competitive accretion (I. A. Bonnell et al. [7]), turbulent-core accretion (M˙∝m1/2\dot{M} \propto m^{1/2}; C. F. McKee & J. C. Tan [63]) and inertial inflow (M˙\dot{M} independent of mm; P. Padoan et al. [74]), normalized to the median (line colors as in the legend of the bottom panel). Bottom: mass of each sink against time since its formation, with the integrated form of each scaling anchored to the median track at 1 kyr. Individual sinks grow at most linearly in time, with no sign of the runaway growth of Bondi–Hoyle accretion.

This ensemble relation mixes sinks of different ages, however: the most massive sinks are the oldest, central ones with the best access to gas. The bottom panel therefore tests the scalings on individual sinks, comparing their mass growth since formation with the integrated form of each model. Individual sinks grow at most linearly in time, close to the constant-rate (inertial-inflow) track and far slower than the runaway growth expected from Bondi–Hoyle accretion. We find no evidence of runaway competitive accretion: each sink grows at a roughly constant or declining rate set by its local gas supply, and growth is limited by competition for a shared, finite reservoir.

Magnetic fields

In this section, we analyze the evolution of the magnetic field as the disk collapses and fragments. The magnetic fields are amplified during the collapse, and within the disk once it forms. We characterize the resulting field morphology and its evolution through the vertical (BzB_z) and toroidal (BϕB_\phi) components.

Field morphology and topology

Figure 15–Figure 16 show face-on and edge-on thin slices of the toroidal and vertical components of the magnetic field at six epochs. In the pre-stellar epoch, BzB_z shows large-scale coherent structure with a preferred sign, aligned with the imposed initial field orientation. As the disk forms and develops spiral structure, BzB_z is amplified in the disk midplane and develops sign reversals that trace the spiral arms, with field strengths reaching ∣Bz∣∼10−2|B_z| \sim10^{-2} G at late times.

Thin face-on and edge-on slices through the most massive sink showing the toroidal magnetic field component at six epochs, with in-plane magnetic field lines overlaid

Figure 15. Thin face-on (∣z∣<Δ|z| < \Delta) and edge-on (∣y∣<Δ|y| < \Delta) slices through the most massive sink, with Δ\Delta equal to 5% of the panel width (≈200\approx200 AU for the 4100 AU panels) and the field mass-weighted across the slice thickness, of the toroidal magnetic field component BϕB_{\phi} at six epochs, with in-plane magnetic field lines overlaid (face-on panels: BxB_x, ByB_y; edge-on panels: BxB_x, BzB_z). The m=1m = 1 sign pattern of BϕB_{\phi} is present before the first sink forms and is inherited from the nearly uniform seed field; differential rotation winds it into the two-armed spiral visible by Δt≈1.3\Delta t \approx1.3 kyr.

Thin face-on and edge-on slices of the vertical magnetic field component $B_z$ at six epochs

Figure 16. Thin face-on and edge-on slices, as in Figure 15, of the vertical magnetic field component BzB_z at six epochs. By the late epochs shown here, most of the stars in the simulation have already formed, so the field structure reflects the post-formation disk rather than the initial collapse.

The toroidal component BϕB_{\phi} (Figure 15) has a two-tone appearance before the first sink forms (Δt=−0.5\Delta t = -0.5 kyr, top left panel): roughly half of the disk plane has Bϕ>0B_{\phi} > 0, shown as red, and the other Bϕ<0B_{\phi} < 0, shown as blue, with the two colors inhabiting clearly distinct regions. Differential rotation winds the two regions into a two-armed spiral pattern of alternating color by Δt≈1.3\Delta t \approx1.3 kyr, with the field gaining in strength close to the center of the spiral.

By Δt≈3.6\Delta t \approx3.6 kyr, the toroidal field component reaches strengths of ∣Bϕ∣≳10−2|B_{\phi}| \gtrsim10^{-2} G over a region of size 1000 AU. The field winding due to the differential rotation of the disk has produced a field that is primarily toroidal. This is the expected geometry: winding an in-plane seed produces a toroidal field that is symmetric about the midplane ([10 Sec. 11.5.2]). By late times (15 kyr), the toroidal field in the inner disk is predominantly negative (in our chosen reference frame, where the disk rotates with Ω>0\Omega> 0).

The alternating sign of BϕB_{\phi} between the two arms is similar to the well known in-plane bisymmetric spiral (BSS) configuration seen in galactic magnetic fields; the field reverses direction from one arm to the next across a neutral line in the interarm region ([92, 5, 73]). In our simulation, the reversal is inherited from our choice of a uniform initial magnetic field, i.e., a field with an azimuthal m=1m = 1 pattern. As long as differential rotation and collapse remain approximately axisymmetric, they amplify the field while preserving the initial m=1m = 1 pattern [83, 9]. The approximate axisymmetry of the flow holds until Δt∼3\Delta t \sim3 kyr.

At later times the spiral arms and the lopsided potential of the off-center sink cluster make the flow non-axisymmetric; the induction term transfers field from the m=1m = 1 pattern into other azimuthal modes, including an axisymmetric (m=0m = 0) net toroidal component. We see only weak evidence of growth in the radial field, discussed below, suggesting that this early-time pattern results from linear amplification of the seed field rather than arising from a dynamo [93 Secs. 4.2, 5.1].

W.-T. Kim & E. C. Ostriker [48] showed that magnetic fields modify the growth of non-axisymmetric structure in self-gravitating disks when the fields are dynamically important (β∼1\beta\sim1). Here Emag<EthermE_{\mathrm{mag}} < E_{\mathrm{therm}} throughout (subsubsection 3.3.1), so on energetic

grounds the field is not expected to shape the spiral arms strongly, although only a run without magnetic fields can confirm this. The field does not remain wound up: the ratio of toroidal to radial field stays at ≈2\approx2 rather than growing with the shear, the net toroidal flux has a definite sign set by the more massive spiral arm, and the ∣B∣|B|–nn relation steepens from α≈2/3\alpha\approx2/3 to ≈1\approx1. We cannot say whether this is anisotropic compression, winding or a small-scale dynamo; the evidence and the amplification channels are discussed in Appendix § 14.

Mass-to-flux ratio

We define mass-to-flux ratio per annulus bb as:

μΦ,b=2πG Σb∣Bz,b∣(14)\mu_{\Phi,b} = \frac{2\pi\sqrt{G}\,\Sigma_b}{|B_{z,b}|} \tag*{(14)}

where, in Figure 18, ∣Bz,b∣|B_{z,b}| is the mass-weighted mean of ∣Bz∣|B_z| in the annulus. This measures the unsigned flux.

Figure 18. Dimensionless mass-to-flux ratio μΦ\mu_\Phi as a function of radius at six epochs. Solid lines use the net vertical flux (volume-weighted signed BzB_z in each annulus), which sets the magnetic support; dashed lines use the unsigned flux (mass-weighted ∣Bz∣|B_z|), which also counts field reversals. The dotted line marks the critical value μΦ=1\mu_\Phi=1. The net-flux ratio falls from ∼102\sim10^2–10310^3 at early times to ≳3\gtrsim3 at late times, whereas the unsigned ratio drops below unity at some inner radii by 9.5 kyr as the field becomes tangled.

We also compute μΦ,net\mu_{\Phi,\mathrm{net}} from the volume-weighted signed mean of BzB_z in each annulus, and its cumulative version μΦ,net(<R)=2πGMgas(<R)/∣Φ(<R)∣\mu_{\Phi,\mathrm{net}}(<R)=2\pi\sqrt{G}M_{\mathrm{gas}}(<R)/|\Phi(<R)|. The mass-to-flux ratio μΦ\mu_\Phi (Figure 18) evolves significantly over time.

At early times (Δt≤1.3 kyr\Delta t \leq1.3\ \mathrm{kyr}), μΦ∼200\mu_\Phi\sim200 at all radii, indicating an extremely magnetically supercritical state in which gravity overwhelms magnetic support by more than two orders of magnitude. The mass-to-flux ratio then declines steadily as the unsigned vertical field ∣Bz∣|B_z| grows relative to Σ\Sigma: by Δt=3.6 kyr\Delta t=3.6\ \mathrm{kyr} (red), μΦ\mu_\Phi has dropped to ∼10\sim10–100100. By Δt=6.3 kyr\Delta t=6.3\ \mathrm{kyr} (purple), μΦ\mu_\Phi exhibits large radial scatter, with values ranging from ∼1\sim1 to ∼100\sim100 and dipping below the critical value (μΦ<1\mu_\Phi<1) at some inner radii. At the latest epoch (Δt=9.5 kyr\Delta t=9.5\ \mathrm{kyr}, brown), significant portions of the inner disk (r∼350 AUr\sim350\ \mathrm{AU}) have μΦ<1\mu_\Phi<1 in this unsigned measure.

The net-flux ratio tells a different story. At Δt≲1.3 kyr\Delta t\lesssim1.3\ \mathrm{kyr}, μΦ,net(<R)≈400\mu_{\Phi,\mathrm{net}}(<R)\approx400 within 2500 AU, consistent with the unsigned values because the field is still coherent. By 3.6 kyr the unsigned ratio has dropped to ∼0.2\sim0.2–9090 in individual annuli, while μΦ,net≈50\mu_{\Phi,\mathrm{net}}\approx50–600600 in the same annuli. At 9.5 kyr and 15 kyr, μΦ,net(<R)≈28\mu_{\Phi,\mathrm{net}}(<R)\approx28 and ≈16\approx16, respectively. In individual annuli (solid lines in Figure 18) the net ratio never falls below ≈3\approx3, reached in the innermost annuli at 9.5 kyr, where little gas is left. The unsigned flux inside 2500 AU exceeds the net flux by a factor of ∼2\sim2 at early times and ∼15\sim15 at late times.

The net ratio μΦ\mu_\Phi (solid lines in Figure 18) falls by one to two orders of magnitude as time increases. In ideal MHD, neither compression nor winding can do this: compression conserves the mass-to-flux ratio of a flux tube, and winding converts BrB_r into BϕB_\phi without changing BzB_z. The decline instead comes from the flux budget of the disk region. Between −0.5-0.5 and 15 kyr the net flux inside 2500 AU grows by a factor of ∼6.5\sim6.5 as the inflow drags field inward, while the gas mass there falls by a factor of ∼7\sim7 as ∼200 M⊙\sim200\ M_\odot is accreted onto sinks. Sink accretion removes the accreted gas together with its field, but the accreted gas is the densest, and since B∝nαB\propto n^\alpha with α<1\alpha<1 (Figure 17) the flux per unit mass, ∝B/n\propto B/n, is smallest there. Accretion therefore removes mass much more efficiently than flux. (In the sink implementations of S. Hirano & M. N. Machida [30] and A. Stacy et al. [101] accretion removes the mass but not the flux, which lowers μΦ\mu_\Phi even more strongly.)

Figure 17. Evolution of phase plot of magnitude of magnetic field ∣B∣|B| vs number density nn. Solid lines correspond to mass-weighted median profiles at different times, with the shaded regions spanning the 16th–84th percentiles. α\alpha corresponds to the exponent in power-law fit ∣B∣∝nα|B|\propto n^\alpha. ∣B∣|B| spans 3 orders of magnitude at the point of first sink formation, and up to 4 orders of magnitude at later times. The best-fit power-law slope α=dlog⁡∣B∣/dlog⁡n\alpha=\mathrm{d}\log|B|/\mathrm{d}\log n rises from α=0.55\alpha=0.55 at the pre-stellar epoch to α=0.65\alpha=0.65 (first sink), 0.69 (early disk), 0.76 (GI onset), 0.92 (late time) and 1.00 (extended), i.e. from ∼2/3\sim2/3 (flux-freezing compression) toward ∼1\sim1 at late times; each fitted slope is given in the legend and drawn as a dotted line.

The much larger growth of the unsigned flux requires some other growth mechanism, for example, vertical motions that tilt the strong toroidal field into BzB_z of both signs, as at spiral-arm shocks, and possibly a turbulent dynamo.

Comparison to previous studies

The collapse and subsequent disk fragmentation picture in this work is consistent with the broad expectations of Pop III star formation theory. In this section, we compare our results with other works and highlight differences.

Role of the large-scale environment

The properties of the first collapsing core are set by the large-scale accretion history of the host minihalo, which in turn depends on where that halo sits within the cosmic web. A halo embedded in a stronger overdensity accretes faster and with more angular momentum than one in a quieter region of the cosmic web, biasing the collapse toward a more massive, rotationally supported structure. Our halo has a mass of 2×107 M⊙2 \times10^{7}\,\mathrm{M}_{\odot} when the first star forms, which is above the atomic-cooling threshold. The halo is a progenitor of a MW-mass system (with Mhalo≈1012 M⊙M_{\mathrm{halo}} \approx10^{12}\,\mathrm{M}_{\odot} at z=0z = 0) and sits in a large-scale overdensity, unlike the field minihalos studied in most prior work.

Our halo is a typical Pop III host in this kind of environment: in the MEGATRON simulations [103] of a MW progenitor, the very first Pop III stars form in minihalos, but most form above the atomic-cooling threshold, in halos of 3×1063 \times10^{6}–3×107 M⊙3 \times10^{7}\,\mathrm{M}_{\odot}, once a Lyman–Werner background is established [103].

The most directly comparable simulation, Y. J. Meziani et al. [64], targets the dwarf galaxy progenitor halo, and finds a single Pop III protostar growing to ∼27 M⊙\sim27\,\mathrm{M}_{\odot} over 31 kyr – in stark contrast to our ∼60\sim60-fragment cluster. The two runs differ in more than environment, however: that star forms at z∼14z \sim14 in a minihalo of ∼106 M⊙\sim10^{6}\,\mathrm{M}_{\odot} (Tvir∼103 KT_{\mathrm{vir}} \sim10^{3}\,\mathrm{K}), with ≈55\approx55 times finer DM resolution, but similar baryonic resolution, and in a disk that stays Toomre-stable (Q≫1Q \gg1) with jets active from the start. We speculate that the difference in the outcome is partially dictated by the environment in which the gravitational collapse is happening.

The overdense filamentary infall geometry of the MW-progenitor naturally seeds higher angular momentum, more complex disk structure, and stronger turbulence than the quieter m09 environment. M.-Y. Ho et al. (2026) showed that infall into dark-matter potential wells drives supersonic turbulence (M≈1.8\mathcal{M} \approx1.8–4.24.2) in 15 minihalos, with M\mathcal{M} increasing with halo mass.

In our simulation, at r∼0.1r \sim0.1–11 pc, the velocity dispersion about the mean infall gives M≈3.5\mathcal{M} \approx3.5 at all times, similar to the value M≈4\mathcal{M} \approx4 seen in the slightly less massive (Mh=8×106 M⊙M_{\mathrm{h}} = 8 \times10^{6}\,\mathrm{M}_{\odot}) halo in M.-Y. Ho et al. (2026). Within the disk in our simulation, M≡∣δv∣/cs≈0.75\mathcal{M} \equiv|\delta v|/c_{\mathrm{s}} \approx0.75 before Δt≈1.3\Delta t \approx1.3 kyr and M≈3\mathcal{M} \approx3 after the first fragmentation burst (Figure 6).

Fragmentation and sink counts

Comparing sink counts across simulations is difficult due to differences in the sink formation and accretion algorithm used, the spread in integration times, or the stochastic nature of large simulations. Early simulations with cosmological initial conditions found 4–5 protostars within ∼100\sim100 yr in one halo [15] and of order ten per halo after 1 kyr in five halos [26]. Single-halo integrations over ∼5\sim5 kyr found 5–8 sinks [100], whereas A. Stacy et al. [98] formed 102 sinks within 2 kyr, and O. Jaura et al. [45] formed 40–150 sinks over 20 kyr. The radiation-hydrodynamic cosmological zoom-ins of M. A. Latif et al. [56] across five minihalos produced up to 23 stars per halo (55 total), with masses 0.10.1–37 M⊙37\,\mathrm{M}_{\odot} and a slope dN/dM∝M−1.18dN/dM \propto M^{-1.18}. The systematic study of K. M. J. Wollenberg et al. [115] with 45 controlled simulations (varying rotation and turbulence) found 15 to ∼120\sim120 sinks (mean 30–59 per setup) within ∼1\sim1 kyr, without sink mergers. Thus our ∼60\sim60 sink formation events over the first ∼8\sim8 kyr fall within the range of other high-resolution runs, confirming that fragmentation is highly stochastic and sensitive to initial conditions.

Several factors contribute to our fragment count. First, our 15 kyr integration is substantially longer than most published runs at similar resolution in cosmological environment, allowing many cycles of instability, collapse, and re-accretion. Second, cosmological initial conditions from the MW progenitor provide asymmetric, turbulent infall that continually replenishes the outer disk and seeds new unstable structures.

Of the 62 sinks formed, 30 (48%) were lost to mergers, and 14 of the 32 survivors (44%) have moved more than 2500 AU from the primary, of which 7 (≈20%\approx20\% of the survivors) are unbound by the vrad>vescv_{\mathrm{rad}} > v_{\mathrm{esc}} criterion. The merger fraction is in line with [97] (59%) and [98] (64%); the unbound fraction (≈20%\approx20\% of survivors) is about half of their escaping fractions (43% and 31% of survivors), while the fraction beyond 2500 AU (44%) is comparable. Other works report merger fractions of ∼10\sim10–50% depending on the merging criterion [115] and ejection fractions of up to ∼70%\sim70\% [56].

Stellar mass growth and accretion rates

The total stellar mass assembled by a given time is the time-integrated sum of the accretion rates of all active sinks, so it reflects both the efficiency of angular momentum transport (which determines how quickly gas drains inward through the disk) and the number of competing accretion regions (which determines how the common reservoir is partitioned among the protostars). A large sink count spreading the accretion over many objects can produce a similar total mass to a single rapidly accreting protostar while leaving a completely different PMF. We compare our integrated mass growth and accretion rates to prior work to disentangle these effects.

The total stellar mass of ∼200 M⊙\sim200\,\mathrm{M}_{\odot} at 15 kyr is broadly consistent with canonical Pop III accretion rates. A. Stacy et al. [99] found ∼10−2 M⊙ yr−1\sim10^{-2}\,\mathrm{M}_{\odot}\,\mathrm{yr}^{-1} onto the star-disk system over 5 kyr, similar to our time-averaged rate, and a 43 M⊙43\,M_{\odot} main sink at 5 kyr growing as M∝t0.55M \propto t^{0.55}. Single-star growth in other runs is similarly sub-linear: P. Sharda & S. H. Menon [89] find M∝t0.47−t0.57M \propto t^{0.47- t^{0.57}}. Our M∗∝tM_\ast\propto t scaling is consistent with that found by D. W. Murray et al. [66] and P. S. Li et al. (2018), and is a property of the whole cluster, not of individual sinks, which indeed grow sub-linearly (Figure 13).

The POPSICLE simulations of P. Sharda & S. H. Menon [89] produce a single most-massive protostar of 57 M⊙57\,M_{\odot} within 5 kyr in their RMHD run; our total mass of ∼200 M⊙\sim200\,M_{\odot} is distributed across ∼30\sim30 surviving sinks at 15 kyr, implying a mean sink mass of ∼6 M⊙\sim6\,M_{\odot}, consistent with fragmentation-induced starvation redistributing mass from the most massive object to the cluster population ([78, 80, 89]). K. Sugimura et al. [104] and K. Sugimura et al. [105] produced massive Pop III binaries with individual masses >30 M⊙> 30\,M_{\odot} at separations >2000> 2000 AU. In their runs the first protostar’s disk fragments, most fragments merge in few-body encounters, and only 2–4 stars survive. They accrete from a shared circumbinary disk, which drives the mass ratio towards unity and widens the orbit, because the accreted gas has high angular momentum. Radiative feedback ends accretion after ∼105\sim10^{5} yr, at final mass ratios q≈0.3q \approx0.3–0.80.8 and separations of 2×1032 \times10^{3}–2×1042 \times10^{4} AU (K. Sugimura et al. [105]).

Our two most massive sinks (24.824.8 and 23.1 M⊙23.1\,M_{\odot}, q=0.93q = 0.93) also form a bound pair. After ≈12\approx12 kyr, the secondary orbits the central group on a wide, eccentric orbit (a≈4000a \approx4000 AU, e≈0.6e \approx0.6), with a separation similar to that of the K. Sugimura et al. [104] binary at ≈2×104\approx2 \times10^{4} yr, when it has widened from ∼103\sim10^{3} AU to a few ×103\times10^{3} AU. Unlike their pair, our secondary has stopped accreting because its orbit carries it outside the gas disk, and the separation was set by few-body dynamics rather than by circumbinary accretion. Without radiative feedback, and with a different sink radius and merger criterion, our pair is therefore at most a qualitative analogue of their early binary phase.

Star formation efficiency

The star formation efficiency we find (SFE ≈90%\approx90\% within the disk and ≈50%\approx50\% within a 0.10.1 pc sphere at 15 kyr) is high compared to present-day values (∼1\sim1–10%10\%), but these are typically measured for entire giant molecular clouds rather than individual protostellar disks, so this comparison is only qualitative. Other Pop III simulations measure the efficiency across the halo. Over the whole halo our efficiency is ≈3×10−5\approx3 \times10^{-5} at 15 kyr (Figure 11), below the ϵIII∼10−2\epsilon_{\mathrm{III}} \sim10^{-2}–10−410^{-4} of S. Hirano et al. [31], who divide the core mass by the gas mass of the virial halo.

Protostellar mass function and runaway fraction

A top-heavy, roughly log-flat PMF is commonly found in numerical studies of Pop III star formation, although most of them, like ours, follow only the first ∼104\sim10^{4}–10510^{5} yr. Several authors attribute it to fragmentation together with mergers and ejections (e.g. [98, 56]). Two effects favor a top-heavy PMF: the primordial gas temperature (∼103\sim10^{3} K) sets a large Jeans mass at the fragmentation scale, seeding comparatively massive protostars ([11]), and low-mass objects are preferentially ejected or starved, which flattens the slope at the low-mass end ([115]).

Our protostellar mass function (PMF) at 15 kyr has a high-mass slope αPMF=1.01−0.14+0.14\alpha_{\mathrm{PMF}} = 1.01^{+0.14}_{-0.14}, shallower than the Salpeter slope (α=2.35\alpha= 2.35) but broadly consistent with other Pop III simulations that find top-heavy, log-flat distributions. A. Stacy & V. Bromm [97] find α=1.17\alpha= 1.17 and M. A. Latif et al. [56] find α≈1.18\alpha\approx1.18 across five halos with RHD; A. Stacy et al. [98] and T. H. Greif et al. [26] both report roughly log-flat mass functions extending from sub-solar to ≳10 M⊙\gtrsim10\,M_{\odot} (α=1.13\alpha= 1.13 in A. Stacy et al. [98]). These slopes drift with time and resolution ([98, 80]).

We emphasize that our PMF is a snapshot at 15 kyr, not a final IMF: all sinks are still actively accreting, no radiative feedback has terminated accretion, and the population will be further shaped by continued mergers, ejections, and eventual UV feedback ([43, 42, 98]).

The two most massive sinks, a bound wide pair, have each reached ∼25 M⊙\sim25\,M_{\odot} by 15 kyr, about half of the mass at which accretion was halted by feedback in the cloud of T. Hosokawa et al. [43]. At late times, their accretion rates flatten due to local gas depletion in the inner disk. The outer sinks, by contrast, continue to grow by accreting from the surrounding envelope, so the cluster mass budget shifts progressively outward.

The Pop III IMF is not necessarily universal: its slope and peak can be modified by the large-scale environment, the initial turbulence and angular momentum, and the strength and geometry of the magnetic field, so different halos may produce different mass distributions ([115, 30, 31, 89]). With the same physics setup, albeit with a smaller halo mass, Y. J. Meziani et al. [64] form just a single ∼27 M⊙\sim27\,M_{\odot} protostar. This indicates that the large-scale environment is a key driver of the Pop III PMF. Y. J. Meziani et al. [65] simulate an ultra-faint dwarf progenitor from z∼16z \sim16 to z∼7z \sim7 (about 500 Myr) and form 56 stars across five minihalos. Although the slope of the IMF for all the stars taken together is α≃1.9\alpha\simeq1.9, their most massive, first collapsing halo has a slope α≈1\alpha\approx1.

Magnetic field evolution

The amplification of primordial seed fields during the collapse and disk phase is one of the most uncertain aspects of Pop III star formation: the initial field strength is poorly constrained, and the relevant dynamo mechanisms (turbulent small-scale, large-scale differential rotation) operate on overlapping timescales. We compare the evolution of our mass-to-flux ratio and magnetic energy to MHD simulations that resolve the disk phase, to assess whether the rapid amplification we observe is generic or a consequence of our particular choice of seed field and numerical method.

Our net-flux mass-to-flux ratio falls from μΦ,net∼102\mu_{\Phi,\mathrm{net}} \sim10^{2}–10310^{3} at early times to ∼15\sim15 by 15 kyr (subsection 3.6), and the magnetic energy grows by ∼3.5\sim3.5 orders of magnitude. Despite this amplification, disk fragmentation in our simulation remains vigorous until ∼8\sim8 kyr, in contrast to the strong suppression found in some MHD simulations. M. N. Machida et al. [60] systematically varied initial field strength from B0=10−20B_{0} = 10^{-20} to 10−410^{-4} G and found that even the weakest field suppresses fragmentation and drives protostellar mergers within the first ∼1000\sim1000 yr, once it has been amplified (weak-field models fragment first and merge afterwards). A. Stacy et al. [101] found only two secondary sinks in cosmological MHD runs. A key difference is that our simulation starts from a cosmologically plausible highly supercritical configuration (μΦ∼300\mu_{\Phi} \sim300). We have not measured the magnetic torques directly. How much the field changes the fragmentation and the disk evolution can only be measured against an otherwise identical run without magnetic fields, which we leave to future work.

K. E. Sadanari et al. [85] found that ambipolar diffusion is dynamically subdominant in primordial gas (diffusion heating always smaller than compressional heating), broadly consistent with our use of ideal MHD (Y. J. Meziani et al. [64]). K. E. Sadanari et al. [86] similarly found in primordial disk simulations that turbulent magnetic fields reduce but do not eliminate fragmentation, consistent with the vigorous fragmentation of our magnetized disk.

Caveats

Several limitations of this calculation should be kept in mind when reading the results above.

Cosmic-ray background. The cosmic-ray ionization and dissociation rate entering the H2_2 network is left at its default, MW-like value rather than being scaled to a primordial environment. Cosmic rays destroy H2_2, but the free electrons they supply also increase H2_2 and HD formation through the H−^- channel. The net effect of the MW-like rate is to make the ≈200\approx200 K gas that contracts slowly before runaway collapse more molecular and colder, and the lowest-density gas hotter, than it would be at the much lower rate expected at z∼21z \sim21 (D. Nakauchi et al. [68]; J. A. Hummel et al. [44]). Across a wide range of rates, the thermal path of the collapsing gas converges to that without cosmic rays once runaway collapse begins (J. A. Hummel et al. [44]). The cosmic-ray rate is therefore unlikely to cause the offset from the primordial TT–nn track at n≳107 cm−3n \gtrsim10^{7}\ \mathrm{cm}^{-3} (subsection 3.1), which is more likely set by the reduced chemistry network (see below).

Chemistry network. The primordial chemistry is followed with the network described in subsection 2.2.3 rather than with a dedicated package such as GRACKLE, and H2_2 dissociation is not coupled self-consistently to the radiation transport. The network also omits the chemical heating and cooling associated with H2_2 formation and dissociation, and ties HD to H2_2 by a fixed ratio. The three-body rate is a single prescription, whereas published fits are uncertain by nearly an order of magnitude and can change the disk accretion and fragmentation (M. J. Turk et al. [111]). Our gas is 0.4 dex colder than the primordial track, which lowers the Jeans mass by a factor of ≈4\approx4. Raising the temperature to the primordial track (a factor of 1.8–3.2) would increase QQ by ≈43%\approx43\% during the first fragmentation burst, when thermal pressure supplies most of the support (subsection 3.4), and by ≈20%\approx20\% after ∼5\sim5 kyr, when turbulence dominates. The disk would still fragment, but this bias would make our sink count an upper estimate, and the initial fragment masses may be low by a factor of a few. The total stellar mass is less affected, because it is set by the envelope inflow at densities below those where three-body H2_2 formation heating matters. The molecular fractions and temperatures we quote should therefore be treated as indicative rather than converged.

Magnetic field limitations. We cannot establish whether a small-scale turbulent dynamo is resolved in this calculation. The BB–nn relation and the field normalization (subsection 3.6) cannot separate anisotropic compression, winding and dynamo amplification, and a resolved dynamo could add to the field strengths we report. In addition to that, the current STARFORGE implementation removes the magnetic field of a gas particle when a sink particle is spawned, which is not a realistic prescription.

Parent-simulation resolution. The epoch (z≈21z \approx21) and host (2×107 M⊙2 \times10^{7}\,M_{\odot}, an atomic-cooling halo) of the first collapse are set by the parent FIRE-resolution run, before the hyper-refinement is switched on. With mDM≈3.5×104 M⊙m_{\mathrm{DM}} \approx3.5 \times10^{4}\,M_{\odot}, H2_2-cooling minihalos of 10510^{5}–106 M⊙10^{6}\,M_{\odot} are resolved by only ∼16\sim16 DM particles, and the gas-only Jeans refinement cannot compensate for this. In MW-progenitor regions the very first Pop III stars form earlier, in minihalos, but most form in atomic-cooling halos like ours once a Lyman–Werner background is established (§ 5; A. Storck et al. [103]). Our results therefore describe the first collapse in an atomic-cooling halo, and the progenitor minihalos, their Lyman-Werner radiation and any pre-enrichment are missing.

Protostellar radii and accretion luminosity. The protostellar model (S. S. R. Offner et al. [69]) gives our central sinks radii of only 5.5 R⊙5.5\,R_{\odot} while they grow from 0.20.2 to 2.4 M⊙2.4\,M_{\odot} during the first 1.5 kyr. Pop III protostars accreting at 10−310^{-3}–10−2 M⊙ yr−110^{-2}\,\mathrm{M}_{\odot}\,\mathrm{yr}^{-1} are instead swollen to ≈50 R⊙\approx50\,\mathrm{R}_{\odot} at 0.20.2–2 M⊙2\,\mathrm{M}_{\odot}, R∗≈48 R⊙ (M∗/M⊙)0.27(M˙/4.4×10−3 M⊙ yr−1)0.41R_{\ast}\approx48\,\mathrm{R}_{\odot}\,(M_{\ast}/\mathrm{M}_{\odot})^{0.27}(\dot{M}/4.4\times10^{-3}\,\mathrm{M}_{\odot}\,\mathrm{yr}^{-1})^{0.41} (S. W. Stahler et al. [102], Eq. 21b), as in the protostellar tracks of K. Omukai & F. Palla [72]. Since the accretion luminosity scales as GMM˙/R∗GM\dot{M}/R_{\ast}, it, and with it the early heating fronts of subsection 3.4, is likely overestimated by a factor of ∼6\sim6.

Integration time. We follow only ∼15\sim15 kyr after the first protostar forms. All the sinks are still accreting when the calculation ends, no object has reached the main sequence (all sinks above 2 M⊙2\,\mathrm{M}_{\odot} are in the shell deuterium-burning phase of the protostellar model; subsection 3.5), and the ionizing feedback that would eventually terminate accretion has not had time to act. The mass function we report is protostellar, and the final stellar masses could differ substantially. Fragmentation in the disk has stopped by ≈8\approx8 kyr, while the central sinks keep accreting, so in the near term the high-mass end should grow further. Over longer times the mass function is expected to steepen, as in the population run of Y. J. Meziani et al. [65] (subsection 4.5).

Protostellar jets. The jets are launched with the intended mass loading but couple to the gas close to the protostars, so they propagate less far than intended and entrain and clear little of the infalling envelope (sub-subsection 2.2.4). Jets matter for the stellar masses: in STARFORGE simulations of present-day clouds they reduce the stellar masses by about an order of magnitude, both by removing accreted gas and by disrupting the accretion flow onto the protostars (D. Guszejnov et al. [28]). In the FORGE’d in FIRE Pop III protostar of Y. J. Meziani et al. [64], jets regulate the accretion and the final mass of the star. With jets that couple only close to the star, the part of the accreted gas they remove is still taken out, but the disruption of the larger-scale accretion flow is underestimated, so our protostellar masses, accretion rates and star formation efficiency are therefore overestimates, and the PMF may be shifted to lower masses.

Conclusions

We have presented a radiation-magnetohydrodynamic cosmological zoom-in simulation of Pop III star formation, following the collapse of primordial gas in the FIRE MW-progenitor halo from cosmological initial conditions through the formation and evolution of a protostellar accretion disk over ∼15\sim15 kyr. Our main conclusions are as follows:

  1. Vigorous disk fragmentation. The accretion disk becomes gravitationally unstable within ∼3\sim3 kyr of the first protostar’s formation, developing spiral arms that fragment into ∼60\sim60 sink formation events over the first ∼8\sim8 kyr, producing a total stellar mass >150 M⊙>150\,\mathrm{M}_{\odot}.

  1. Sub-virial start to virial equilibrium. The disk starts in a sub-virial state (2Ekin/∣Epot∣≈0.62E_{\mathrm{kin}}/|E_{\mathrm{pot}}|\approx0.6) and reaches virial equilibrium within ∼2\sim2 kyr, thereafter self-regulating around 2Ekin/∣Epot∣≈12E_{\mathrm{kin}}/|E_{\mathrm{pot}}|\approx1, robustly across disk identification criteria.

  1. Magnetic field amplification and tangling. Magnetic energy grows by ∼3.5\sim3.5 orders of magnitude. The net-flux to flux ratio falls from ∼102\sim10^{2}–10310^{3} to ∼10−15\sim10^{-15}, because the inflow brings in flux while the dense gas accreted onto sinks carries little flux per unit mass, while the unsigned vertical flux grows 1515 times more than the net flux. The field becomes tangled into mixed polarity, with BzB_z reversing along the spiral arms.

  1. Accelerating accretion and high SFE. The total stellar mass grows as M∗∝t2M_{\ast}\propto t^{2} at accretion rates of ∼10−3\sim10^{-3}–10−2 M⊙ yr−110^{-2}\,\mathrm{M}_{\odot}\,\mathrm{yr}^{-1}, an order of magnitude above the Shu rate and close to the Larson-Penston rate of an outside-in envelope, which falls in at a nearly constant ≈3.5 km s−1\approx3.5\,\mathrm{km\,s}^{-1}. The star formation efficiency reaches ≈90%\approx90\% within the disk (after ≈11\approx11 kyr; ≈80%\approx80\% at 9.59.5 kyr) and ∼50%\sim50\% within a 0.10.1 pc sphere.

  1. Top-heavy protostellar mass function. The protostellar mass function has a high-mass slope αPMF=1.01−0.14+0.14\alpha_{\mathrm{PMF}}=1.01^{+0.14}_{-0.14}, i.e. roughly flat in dN/dlog⁡M\mathrm{d}N/\mathrm{d}\log M, much shallower than the Salpeter/Kroupa value (α=2.35/2.3\alpha=2.35/2.3) and similar to other Pop III simulations (α∼1.1\alpha\sim1.1–1.21.2). Individual sinks grow at most linearly in time, with no sign of runaway (Bondi–Hoyle) competitive accretion; the most massive sinks are the oldest, central ones. The second most massive sink is on a wide, bound, eccentric orbit.

  1. The cosmological envelope sets the mass supply. The cosmological environment sets the mass supply, its duration and its angular momentum: a Larson-Penston-like inflow of ≈10−2 M⊙ yr−1\approx10^{-2}\,\mathrm{M}_{\odot}\,\mathrm{yr}^{-1} through 30003000 AU for most of the run (falling to ≈7×10−3 M⊙ yr−1\approx7\times10^{-3}\,\mathrm{M}_{\odot}\,\mathrm{yr}^{-1} after ∼12\sim12 kyr), whose centrifugal radius stays at ∼0.7×103\sim0.7\times10^{3} AU throughout, with a broad spread.

  1. Fragmentation moves outward. In our simulation the fragmentation sites move outward: the first burst (∼3.5\sim3.5 kyr, ∼40\sim40 sinks) forms at ∼500\sim500 AU and the second (∼8\sim8 kyr, ∼11\sim11 sinks) at ∼103\sim10^{3} AU, outside where most of the infall lands. The gas mass of the disk moves outward with them, the sinks empty the inner disk while the outer disk keeps gaining mass.

The results presented here are for a single realization of collapse in a massive halo at z≈21z\approx21, and are therefore subject to that caveat. Pop III star formation is highly stochastic, so the fragment counts and the shape of the protostellar mass function carry an uncertainty that a single run cannot quantify. We leave a population study of Pop III collapse from a large-scale cosmological environment to future work.

Acknowledgments

We thank Shyam Menon, James Beattie, Bart Ripperda, Chris Thompson, Piyush Sharda, and several members of CITA for useful discussions, as well as SciNet maintenance and support teams for help with the usage of Trillium supercomputer. Analysis was performed on the Trillium supercomputer at the SciNet HPC Consortium. SciNet is funded by Innovation, Science and Economic Development Canada; the Digital Research Alliance of Canada; the Ontario Research Fund: Research Excellence; and the University of Toronto. VP thanks the CCA at the Flatiron Institute for hospitality while a portion of this research was carried out. The Center for Computational Astrophysics at the Flatiron Institute is supported by the Simons Foundation. The Flatiron Institute is a division of the Simons Foundation. The computations in this work were, in part, run at facilities supported by the Scientific Computing Core at the Flatiron Institute, a division of the Simons Foundation. NM and VP were supported in part by the Natural Sciences & Engineering Research Council of Canada (NSERC) [funding reference number RGPIN-2023-04901]. Cette recherche a été financée par le Conseil de recherches en sciences naturelles et en génie du Canada (CRSNG), [numéros de référence RGPIN-2023-04901]. It was performed in part at Aspen Center for Physics, which is supported by National Science Foundation grant PHY-2210452. CAFG was supported by NSF through grants AST-2108230, AST-2307327 and AST-2606015; by NASA through grants 80NSSC22K0809, 80NSSC22K1124 and 80NSSC24K1224; by STScI through grant JWST-AR-03252.001-A; and by BSF through grant #2024262. Support for P.F.H. was provided by a Simons Investigator grant.

Software: GIZMO, NumPy, SciPy, Matplotlib, Astropy, h5py, yt, Meshoid

Appendix

H2 network coefficients

The rate equation for the H2_2 abundance is given in Equation (4). Here nˉx\bar{n}_x is volume-averaged number density of xx inside of a cell. Cm=⟨nm⟩/⟨n⟩mC_m = \langle n^m\rangle/ \langle n\rangle^m is the mmth-order clumping factor. αGP\alpha_{\mathrm{GP}} is the gas-phase formation rate coefficient via the H−^- and H2+_2^+ pathways [1, 22, 24]. The three-body formation coefficient α3B=6×10−32T−0.25+2×10−31T−0.5 cm6 s−1\alpha_{\mathrm{3B}} = 6 \times10^{-32} T^{-0.25} + 2 \times10^{-31} T^{-0.5}\ \mathrm{cm^6\,s^{-1}} [40], which is a single prescription that differs from the fits of T. Abel et al. [2] and F. Palla et al. [75], becomes the dominant H2_2 formation channel for n≳108 cm−3n \gtrsim10^8\ \mathrm{cm^{-3}}. ΓH2\Gamma_{\mathrm{H_2}} is the coefficient associated with LW and ionizing photon dissociation. ζH2\zeta_{\mathrm{H_2}} accounts for cosmic-ray-induced ionization and dissociation (the code uses a fixed cosmic-ray energy density of 1 eV cm−31\ \mathrm{eV\ cm^{-3}}, giving ζCR=1.6×10−17 s−1\zeta_{\mathrm{CR}} = 1.6 \times10^{-17}\ \mathrm{s^{-1}} and ζH2=ζCR/2=8×10−18 s−1\zeta_{\mathrm{H_2}} = \zeta_{\mathrm{CR}}/2 = 8 \times10^{-18}\ \mathrm{s^{-1}} in gas denser than ∼103\sim10^3 times the cosmic mean, a MW-like value; this rate is unconstrained at n∼21n \sim21, where the physically expected value is far lower in the absence of supernovae. Besides destroying H2_2, cosmic-ray ionization supplies free electrons that catalyse H2_2 (and HD) formation through the H−^- channel, so a rate this high makes the ≈200 K\approx200\ \mathrm{K} gas that contracts slowly before runaway collapse more molecular and colder (and can move into onto the HD-cooling track), while CR heating warms the lowest-density gas [96, 68, 44]. These differences are erased as the gas collapses: once runaway collapse begins, its thermal path converges to that without CRs [44]; see § 6. The last sum runs over collisional dissociation contributions from e−e^-, H+^+, H2_2, H, HeI, HeII, with rate coefficients βH2,i\beta_{\mathrm{H_2},i} from [23 Table A1, reactions 7–11, 24–25 and 37–39].

Disk identification

To compute velocity dispersion, local Toomre QQ, and other disk properties, we identify gas particles belonging to the disk at each snapshot using the following procedure:

  1. We define a search radius rsearch=2000 AUr_{\mathrm{search}} = 2000\ \mathrm{AU}, chosen because it roughly matches the size of the disk that forms in our simulation. This radius sets the region over which the bulk velocity and angular momentum are measured, and we adopt it as the disk scale throughout this work: the disk we identify below is approximately equal to rsearchr_{\mathrm{search}}.

  1. Before any sinks form, the center is placed at the densest gas particle within a refinement region. After the first sink forms, we place the disk center at the most massive sink particle. We find that this approach results in a

center location that is more stable than using than the mass-weighted center-of-mass (COM) of all sinks once secondary sinks form at large separations.

  1. We compute a mass-weighted COM velocity vCOMv_{\mathrm{COM}} from gas particles within r<rsearchr < r_{\mathrm{search}} and subtract it from all particle velocities.

  1. We compute the disk normal L^\hat{L} from the total angular momentum L=∑imi(ri×vi)\mathbf{L} = \sum_i m_i(\mathbf{r}_i \times\mathbf{v}_i) summed over particles within rsearchr_{\mathrm{search}}, using the COM-subtracted velocities from the previous step. The sign of L^\hat{L} is fixed so that Lz>0L_z > 0 to prevent frame-to-frame flipping.

  1. We convert particle positions and velocities onto the disk-plane coordinate system (rcyl,ϕ,z,vr,vϕ,vz)(r_{\mathrm{cyl}}, \phi, z, v_r, v_\phi, v_z).

  1. We apply geometric and density cuts: rcyl<rmax⁡=2000r_{\mathrm{cyl}} < r_{\max} = 2000 AU, fkep=∣z∣/rcyl<0.3f_{\mathrm{kep}} = |z|/r_{\mathrm{cyl}} < 0.3 (aspect ratio), and ρ>ρthresh=10−15 g cm−3\rho> \rho_{\mathrm{thresh}} = 10^{-15}\ \mathrm{g\,cm^{-3}}.

  1. We apply kinematic cuts: vϕ>0v_\phi> 0 (co-rotating) and vϕ/vK>fkep=0.3v_\phi/v_K > f_{\mathrm{kep}} = 0.3, where vK=GMenc(<r)/rv_K = \sqrt{GM_{\mathrm{enc}}(<r)/r} is the Keplerian speed computed from the cumulative enclosed gas mass plus the total sink mass placed at the origin.

  1. We extend the kinematically selected set to its bounding cylinder (100th percentile in rcylr_{\mathrm{cyl}} and ∣z∣|z|) to recover any disk material just outside the strict kinematic boundary.

Particles passing all cuts are labeled as disk members. The disk radius rdiskr_{\mathrm{disk}} is taken as the 90th-percentile cylindrical radius of disk members.

We tested this selection at nine epochs with eleven variants. The disk mass changes by ≲15%\lesssim15\% for aspect ratios of 0.2–0.5, for fkep=0f_{\mathrm{kep}} = 0–0.5, for a center at the center of mass of gas and sinks, and for an iterated disk axis. It depends more strongly on the bounding-cylinder step and on the density threshold: dropping the former, or raising the latter to 10−14 g cm−310^{-14}\ \mathrm{g\,cm^{-3}}, lowers MdiskM_{\mathrm{disk}} by up to a factor of ∼2.5\sim2.5 at late times, when the disk is small. The star formation efficiency within the disk is robust to all of these choices (SFE=0.8SFE = 0.8 at 9.5 kyr and 0.94 at 15 kyr).

Toomre-Q estimator

For each snapshot the gas is binned into 20 annular bins. In each annulus bb we compute mass-weighted face-on density:

Σb=∑i∈bmiπ(rout,b2−rin,b2)(15)\Sigma_b = \frac{\sum_{i\in b} m_i}{\pi(r_{\mathrm{out},b}^{2} - r_{\mathrm{in},b}^{2})} \tag*{(15)}

with rin,br_{\mathrm{in},b} and rout,br_{\mathrm{out},b} corresponding to the inner and outer radii of the annulus bb respectively. The radial velocity dispersion for each gas particle is measured as its deviation from the annulus average vˉr,b\bar{v}_{r,b}:

σr,i=vr,i2−vˉr,b2(16)\sigma_{r,i} = \sqrt{v_{r,i}^{2} - \bar{v}_{r,b}^{2}} \tag*{(16)}

The angular velocity is measured directly from the rotation profile:

Ωb=∣vˉϕ,b∣rb(17)\Omega_b = \frac{|\bar{v}_{\phi,b}|}{r_b} \tag*{(17)}

where vˉϕ,b\bar{v}_{\phi,b} is the mass-weighted mean azimuthal velocity in annulus bb and rbr_b is the bin center. The epicyclic frequency is computed numerically from the measured rotation curve (e.g. [108]),

κb2=2Ωbrbd(r2Ω)dr∣rb(18)\kappa_b^{2} = \left.\frac{2\Omega_b}{r_b}\frac{\mathrm{d}(r^{2}\Omega)}{\mathrm{d}r}\right|_{r_b} \tag*{(18)}

The Toomre parameter per annulus is then

Qb=ζbκbπGΣb(19)Q_b = \frac{\zeta_b\kappa_b}{\pi G\Sigma_b} \tag*{(19)}

A pixel-by-pixel face-on QQ map is produced by computing local mass-weighted quantities for all of the relevant parameters:

Q(x,y)=ζb(x,y)κ(rx,y)πGΣ(x,y)(20)Q(x,y) = \frac{\zeta_b(x,y)\kappa(r_{x,y})}{\pi G\Sigma(x,y)} \tag*{(20)}

where rx,y=x2+y2r_{x,y} = \sqrt{x^2+y^2}, and ζ=σr2+σs2\zeta= \sqrt{\sigma_r^2+\sigma_s^2}, which sums over thermal and turbulent contributions.

Star formation efficiency per free-fall time

We make the following assumptions. (i) The pre-stellar envelope is spherically symmetric, with a power-law density profile ρ∝r−2\rho\propto r^{-2} out to the radius considered. The sound speed is not constant in the envelope: in Figure 6 it rises outward and stays close to a constant fraction of the Keplerian speed, cs≈0.25c_s \approx0.25–0.3 vK0.3\,v_K (≈1\approx1–2 km s−12\ \mathrm{km}\ \mathrm{s}^{-1} between 10410^4 and 10510^5 AU before the first sink forms). For ρ∝r−2\rho\propto r^{-2} the enclosed mass is M∝rM \propto r, so vKv_K and hence csc_s are then constant with radius, and A=1/(2β2)A = 1/(2\beta^2) for cs=βvKc_s = \beta v_K; β≈0.28\beta\approx0.28 gives the A≈6A \approx6 found below. We use csc_s only through the product Acs2A c_s^2, which is set by the measured density normalization, so ϵff\epsilon_{\rm ff} does not depend on the value of csc_s. (ii) The normalization AA of the profile is fixed by the gas mass inside our 0.1 pc sphere before the first sink forms, which gives A≈6A \approx6 below, i.e. between the singular isothermal sphere (A=1A = 1) and the Larson–Penston value. (iii) The gas mass in the sphere is taken to stay equal to this envelope mass, so that ϵff\epsilon_{\rm ff} follows from the stellar accretion rate alone. (iv) The free-fall time is that of the gas alone, whereas the measured ϵff\epsilon_{\rm ff} also includes the sinks in ρˉ\bar{\rho}; the difference is quantified at the end of this appendix.

Approximate the envelope as a power law ρ∝r−2\rho\propto r^{-2}, written relative to the singular isothermal sphere (SIS) of sound speed csc_s as

ρ(r)=Acs22πGr2,(21)\rho(r) = A \frac{c_s^2}{2\pi G r^2}, \tag*{(21)}

where A=1A = 1 for the SIS and A≈4.4A \approx4.4 for the Larson–Penston envelope (F. H. Shu [91]). The mass and the mean density inside rr are

M(<r)=∫0r4πr′2ρ dr′=2Acs2rG,ρˉ(<r)=3M4πr3=3Acs22πGr2,(22)M(<r) = \int_0^r 4\pi r^{\prime2}\rho\,\mathrm{d}r' = \frac{2A c_s^2 r}{G}, \qquad\bar{\rho}(<r) = \frac{3M}{4\pi r^3} = \frac{3A c_s^2}{2\pi G r^2}, \tag*{(22)}

so the free-fall time at that mean density is

tff=3π32Gρˉ=πr4Acs.(23)t_{\rm ff} = \sqrt{\frac{3\pi}{32G\bar{\rho}}} = \frac{\pi r}{4\sqrt{A}c_s}. \tag*{(23)}

The mass inside rr divided by its own free-fall time, i.e. the rate at which this gas would turn into stars if all of it collapsed within one free-fall time, is then the same at every radius,

Mtff=8πA3/2cs3G,(24)\frac{M}{t_{\rm ff}} = \frac{8}{\pi}A^{3/2}\frac{c_s^3}{G}, \tag*{(24)}

and the efficiency per free-fall time of a sphere of radius rr in the envelope is

ϵff=M˙∗tffMgas=π8A−3/2GM˙∗cs3.(25)\epsilon_{\rm ff} = \frac{\dot{M}_* t_{\rm ff}}{M_{\rm gas}} = \frac{\pi}{8}A^{-3/2}\frac{G\dot{M}_*}{c_s^3}. \tag*{(25)}

Before the first sink forms, the envelope holds ≈160 M⊙\approx160\,M_\odot inside our 0.1 pc sphere, where cs≈1 km s−1c_s \approx1\ \mathrm{km}\ \mathrm{s}^{-1} (Figure 6), i.e. A≈6A \approx6, so that M/tff≈9×10−3 M⊙ yr−1M/t_{\rm ff} \approx9 \times10^{-3}\,M_\odot\,\mathrm{yr}^{-1} (this is ≈37cs3/G\approx37c_s^3/G for cs=1 km s−1c_s = 1\ \mathrm{km}\ \mathrm{s}^{-1}; for the SIS it would be ≈2.5cs3/G\approx2.5c_s^3/G). Between 4 and 10 kyr the stars accrete at M˙∗≈1.7×10−2 M⊙ yr−1\dot{M}_* \approx1.7 \times10^{-2}\,M_\odot\,\mathrm{yr}^{-1} (≈70cs3/G\approx70c_s^3/G for cs=1 km s−1c_s = 1\ \mathrm{km}\ \mathrm{s}^{-1}), which gives ϵff≈1.9\epsilon_{\rm ff} \approx1.9 with the free-fall time of the gas alone. Including the sinks in ρˉ\bar{\rho}, as in our definition, shortens tfft_{\rm ff} and gives the measured median ϵff≈1.4\epsilon_{\rm ff} \approx1.4 over this period (≲1\lesssim1 before 4 kyr and after 10 kyr).

Magnetic field amplification channels and net toroidal flux

The field does not remain wound up for long; by Δt=9.5\Delta t = 9.5 kyr the field shows little order. Differential rotation, q=−dln⁡Ω/dln⁡Rq = -\mathrm{d}\ln\Omega/\mathrm{d}\ln R, winds a radial field into a toroidal one that grows linearly in time, Bϕ≈−qΩtBrB_\phi\approx-q\Omega t B_r (A. Brandenburg & K. Subramanian [10], Sec. 3.3), so after a time tt the toroidal field should exceed the radial one by a factor qΩtq\Omega t.

We measure the ratio of the two in midplane annuli at R=300R = 300, 500 and 800 AU as the ratio of their mass-weighted rms values, Bϕ,rms/Br,rms=⟨Bϕ2⟩1/2/⟨Br2⟩1/2B_{\phi,\mathrm{rms}}/B_{r,\mathrm{rms}} = \langle B_\phi^2\rangle^{1/2}/\langle B_r^2\rangle^{1/2}, which avoids the divergence of Bϕ/BrB_\phi/B_r where BrB_r changes sign. This ratio stays at ≈2\approx2, and the mass-weighted median pitch angle arctan⁡(∣Br∣/∣Bϕ∣)\arctan(|B_r|/|B_\phi|) at ≈38∘\approx38^\circ, at all epochs, whereas winding since Δt=0\Delta t = 0 would give qΩt≈15q\Omega t \approx15 at 550 AU by 2.8 kyr and ∼100\sim100 later. Winding also brings field lines of opposite polarity together (A. Brandenburg & K. Subramanian [10], Sec. 6.5): the radial wavenumber of the wound field grows as kR=qΩt/Rk_R = q\Omega t/R, so reversals are πR/(qΩt)\pi R/(q\Omega t) apart. This spacing stays larger than the local resolution until ≳6\gtrsim6 kyr at 300 AU, so numerical reconnection cannot explain the deficit at early times. This suggests that the radial field is instead continually regenerated by the turbulent, gravitationally driven motions of the disk, whose velocity dispersion is comparable to the rotation speed, as in a gravoturbulent dynamo, in which vertical circulation around the spiral arms regenerates the poloidal field (H. Deng et al. [17]), but we have not confirmed this.

The net sign of BϕB_{\phi} is not set by the winding, which by symmetry leaves the azimuthal average near zero. It is instead set by the uneven, one-sided mass distribution of the disk, which the star formation traces. The denser, strongly Bϕ<0B_{\phi}<0 arm is the one in which most of the stars form (see the lower left panel at Δt=3.6 kyr\Delta t=3.6\ \mathrm{kyr} of the field-morphology figure in subsection 3.6); that arm is also where compression has made the field strongest. Because the field is frozen into the gas, the inflow of this arm carries its negative toroidal flux into the inner disk, while the positive flux of the lighter arm remains at larger radii. Opposite-signed flux brought together reconnects, and the net flux that remains in the inner disk is negative; the sign of the field is simply that carried by the spiral arm that happened to become more massive.

We have verified that the dense gas does carry most of the negative toroidal field: inside 2500 AU the mass-weighted ⟨Bϕ⟩\langle B_{\phi}\rangle exceeds the volume-weighted one by a factor of ∼20\sim20–800800.

The redistribution of magnetic flux, and the reduction of toroidal flux by reconnection, is, however, not the whole story. The net toroidal flux through the meridional plane stays negative out to 1.6×1041.6\times10^{4} AU (not shown in the figure), with ∣Φϕnet∣/Φϕunsigned≈0.35|\Phi_{\phi}^{\mathrm{net}}|/\Phi_{\phi}^{\mathrm{unsigned}}\approx0.35, instead of being balanced by positive flux at larger radii; we conclude that a net (m=0m=0) toroidal field is also being generated, by winding of a net radial field, by the disk’s turbulent motions, or by some other mechanism.

Figure 17 shows the evolution of ∣B(n)∣|B(n)| as a function of nn for each of the 6 epochs. We fit a power law ∣B(n)∣∼nα|B(n)|\sim n^{\alpha} at each epoch. The power-law exponent rises from α≈2/3\alpha\approx2/3 at early times, consistent with flux-freezing compression of spherically collapsing gas, toward α≈1\alpha\approx1 at late times. The value α≈1\alpha\approx1 is expected when compression becomes anisotropic and the field is stretched in the plane of the forming disk. However, kinematic-dynamo calculations give similar slopes, B∝n0.8–0.9B\propto n^{0.8\text{–}0.9} (see the summary in S. Hirano & M. N. Machida [30]), so the BB–nn relation alone cannot separate anisotropic compression, winding and dynamo amplification. The magnitude of ∣B∣|B| up to the time the first star forms is consistent with flux freezing of the initial seed field. Assuming flux freezing, the cosmological expansion gives ≈8×10−12 G\approx8\times10^{-12}\ \mathrm{G} at the mean density at z=21z=21 (the redshift when the disk forms), which is what the low-density gas of the parent simulation has. Isotropic compression from the mean baryon density (nˉ≈2×10−3 cm−3\bar{n}\approx2\times10^{-3}\ \mathrm{cm}^{-3}) to n=1010 cm−3n=10^{10}\ \mathrm{cm}^{-3} then gives ≈2×10−3 G\approx2\times10^{-3}\ \mathrm{G} (subsection 2.2.1), close to the ≈10−3 G\approx10^{-3}\ \mathrm{G} measured at that density before the first sink forms (Figure 17). Compression alone therefore can account for the field strength at the onset of star formation.

The later steepening towards α≈1\alpha\approx1 may come from anisotropic compression, winding or a dynamo.

The alignment of in-plane flow and field lines does not allow us to determine whether a dynamo is acting. The median ∣cos⁡θ∣|\cos\theta| rises from 0.69 before the first sink forms, which is the value for randomly oriented in-plane vectors (cos⁡45∘=0.71\cos45^{\circ}=0.71), to 0.94 once the spiral arms are established. In a rotating disk, winding aligns B\mathbf{B} with v\mathbf{v} whatever the field strength. The ratio Emag/EkinE_{\mathrm{mag}}/E_{\mathrm{kin}}, the plasma β\beta or the Alfvén Mach number would be the appropriate diagnostics; at late times Emag/Etherm≈0.3E_{\mathrm{mag}}/E_{\mathrm{therm}}\approx0.3 near the center (Figure 8), so the field is not deeply kinematic there. We cannot demonstrate that a small-scale dynamo is resolved, but it is absent (see § 6), and neither the measured α\alpha nor the flow–field alignment can decide whether compression and shear alone account for the amplification.

This caution is reinforced by the scheme dependence of magnetic amplification reported by M. I. Ugalino et al. [112]. Evolving identical Milky-Way-like galaxy initial conditions with Eulerian (ART, RAMSES) and (quasi-)Lagrangian (AREPO, SWIFT) MHD codes, they found that the two families differ by orders of magnitude in their amplification histories: the lower numerical diffusivity of the Lagrangian schemes allows small-scale motions to persist and the field to grow to near equipartition, whereas the grid-based codes remain close to the shear-driven Emag∝t2E_{\mathrm{mag}}\propto t^{2} scaling. Because the meshless finite-mass scheme used here is Lagrangian, the same tendency could inflate the field strengths and lower the mass-to-flux ratios we measure relative to grid-based calculations, although that comparison was made for galactic disks and did not include GIZMO.

References

  1. [1]Abel, T., Anninos, P., Zhang, Y., & Norman, M. L. 1997, New Astronomy, 2, 181, doi: 10.1016/S1384-1076(97)00010-9
  2. [2]Abel, T., Bryan, G. L., & Norman, M. L. 2002, Science, 295, 93, doi: 10.1126/science.1063991DOI
  3. [3]Bagla, J. S. 2002, Journal of Astrophysics and Astronomy, 23, 185, doi: 10.1007/BF02702282DOI
  4. [4]Barnes, J., & Hut, P. 1986, Nature, 324, 446–449, doi: 10.1038/324446a0
  5. [5]Beck, R. 2015, A&A Rv, 24, 4, doi: 10.1007/s00159-015-0084-4DOI
  6. [6]Boley, A. C., Hartquist, T. W., Durisen, R. H., & Michael, S. 2007, ApJL, 656, L89, doi: 10.1086/512235DOI
  7. [7]Bonnell, I. A., Bate, M. R., Clarke, C. J., & Pringle, J. E. 2001, MNRAS, 323, 785, doi: 10.1046/j.1365-8711.2001.04270.xDOI
  8. [8]Bonnor, W. B. 1956, Monthly Notices of the Royal Astronomical Society, 116, 351, doi: 10.1093/mnras/116.3.351
  9. [9]Brandenburg, A., & Ntormousi, E. 2023, ARA&A, 61, 561, doi: 10.1146/annurev-astro-071221-052807DOI
  10. [10]Brandenburg, A., & Subramanian, K. 2005, Physics Reports, 417, 1
  11. [11]Bromm, V., Coppi, P. S., & Larson, R. B. 2002, ApJ, 564, 23, doi: 10.1086/323947DOI
  12. [12]Bryan, G. L., & Norman, M. L. 1998, The Astrophysical Journal, 495, 80, doi: 10.1086/305262DOI
  13. [13]Chabrier, G. 2003, PASP, 115, 763, doi: 10.1086/376392DOI
  14. [14]Chen, K.-J., Ho, M.-Y., & Tung, P.-C. 2025, ApJL, 988, L67, doi: 10.3847/2041-8213/adf18dDOI
  15. [15]Clark, P. C., Glover, S. C. O., Smith, R. J., et al. 2011, Science, 331, 1040, doi: 10.1126/science.1198027DOI
  16. [16]Cummings, A. C., Stone, E. C., Heikkila, B. C., et al. 2016, The Astrophysical Journal, 831, 18, doi: 10.3847/0004-637X/831/1/18DOI
  17. [17]Deng, H., Mayer, L., & Latter, H. T. 2020, The Astrophysical Journal, 891, 154, doi: 10.3847/1538-4357/ab77b2DOI
  18. [18]Deng, H., Mayer, L., Latter, H., Hopkins, P. F., & Bai, X.-N. 2019, The Astrophysical Journal Supplement Series, 241, 26, doi: 10.3847/1538-4365/ab0957DOI
  19. [19]Ebert, R. 1955, Zeitschrift für Astrophysik, 37, 217
  20. [20]Faucher-Giguère, C.-A. 2020, Monthly Notices of the Royal Astronomical Society, 493, 1614, doi: 10.1093/mnras/staa302DOI
  21. [21]Federrath, C., Sur, S., Schleicher, D. R. G., Banerjee, R., & Klessen, R. S. 2011, The Astrophysical Journal, 731, 62, doi: 10.1088/0004-637X/731/1/62DOI
  22. [22]Galli, D., & Palla, F. 1998, A&A, 335, 403
  23. [23]Glover, S. C. O., & Abel, T. 2008, MNRAS, 388, 1627, doi: 10.1111/j.1365-2966.2008.13224.xDOI
  24. [24]Glover, S. C. O., & Jappsen, A.-K. 2007, The Astrophysical Journal, 666, 1–19, doi: 10.1086/519445DOI
  25. [25]Gnedin, N. Y., & Draine, B. T. 2014, The Astrophysical Journal, 795, 37, doi: 10.1088/0004-637X/795/1/37DOI
  26. [26]Greif, T. H., Springel, V., White, S. D. M., et al. 2011, ApJ, 737, 75, doi: 10.1088/0004-637X/737/2/75DOI
  27. [27]Grudić, M. Y., Guszejnov, D., Hopkins, P. F., Offner, S. S. R., & Faucher-Giguère, C.-A. 2021, Monthly Notices of the Royal Astronomical Society, 506, 2199–2231, doi: 10.1093/mnras/stab1347DOI
  28. [28]Guszejnov, D., Grudić, M. Y., Offner, S. S. R., et al. 2022, MNRAS, 515, 4929, doi: 10.1093/mnras/stac2060DOI
  29. [29]Higashi, S., Susa, H., Federrath, C., & Chiaki, G. 2024, ApJ, 962, 158, doi: 10.3847/1538-4357/ad2066DOI
  30. [30]Hirano, S., & Machida, M. N. 2022, ApJL, 935, L16, doi: 10.3847/2041-8213/ac85e0DOI
  31. [31]Hirano, S., Shen, Y., Nishijima, S., Sakai, Y., & Umeda, H. 2023, MNRAS, 525, 5737, doi: 10.1093/mnras/stad2693DOI
  32. [34]Hopkins, P. F. 2016, MNRAS, 462, 576, doi: 10.1093/mnras/stw1578DOI
  33. [35]Hopkins, P. F. 2017, Monthly Notices of the Royal Astronomical Society, 466, 3387–3405, doi: 10.1093/mnras/stw3306DOI
  34. [36]Hopkins, P. F., & Grudić, M. Y. 2019, Monthly Notices of the Royal Astronomical Society, 483, 4187–4196, doi: 10.1093/mnras/stz3089
  35. [37]Hopkins, P. F., Grudić, M. Y., Wetzel, A., et al. 2020, Monthly Notices of the Royal Astronomical Society, 491, 3702–3729, doi: 10.1093/mnras/stz3129DOI
  36. [38]Hopkins, P. F., & Raives, M. J. 2016, Monthly Notices of the Royal Astronomical Society, 455, 51–88, doi: 10.1093/mnras/stv2180DOI
  37. [39]Hopkins, P. F., Wetzel, A., Kereš, D., et al. 2018, Monthly Notices of the Royal Astronomical Society, 480, 800–863, doi: 10.1093/mnras/sty1690DOI
  38. [40]Hopkins, P. F., Wetzel, A., Wheeler, C., et al. 2022, Monthly Notices of the Royal Astronomical Society, 519, 3154–3181, doi: 10.1093/mnras/stac3489DOI
  39. [41]Hopkins, P. F., Grudic, M. Y., Su, K.-Y., et al. 2024, The Open Journal of Astrophysics, 7, doi: 10.21105/astro.2309.13115DOI
  40. [42]Hosokawa, T., Hirano, S., Kuiper, R., et al. 2016, ApJ, 824, 119, doi: 10.3847/0004-637X/824/2/119DOI
  41. [43]Hosokawa, T., Omukai, K., Yoshida, N., & Yorke, H. W. 2011, Science, 334, 1250, doi: 10.1126/science.1207433DOI
  42. [44]Hummel, J. A., Stacy, A., & Bromm, V. 2016, Monthly Notices of the Royal Astronomical Society, 460, 2432, doi: 10.1093/mnras/stw1127DOI
  43. [45]Jaura, O., Glover, S. C. O., Wollenberg, K. M. J., et al. 2022, Monthly Notices of the Royal Astronomical Society, 512, 116, doi: 10.1093/mnras/stac487DOI
  44. [46]Khullar, S., Grudić, M. Y., Matzner, C. D., et al. 2026, arXiv e-prints, arXiv:2610.00513, doi: 10.48550/arXiv.2610.00513DOI
  45. [47]Kim, J.-h., Abel, T., Agertz, O., et al. 2013, The Astrophysical Journal Supplement Series, 210, 14, doi: 10.1088/0067-0049/210/1/14DOI
  46. [48]Kim, W.-T., & Ostriker, E. C. 2001, ApJ, 559, 70, doi: 10.1086/322330DOI
  47. [49]Klessen, R. S., & Glover, S. C. O. 2023, ARA&A, 61, 65, doi: 10.1146/annurev-astro-071221-053453DOI
  48. [50]Koh, D., Abel, T., & Jedamzik, K. 2021, ApJL, 909, L21, doi: 10.3847/2041-8213/abe8ddDOI
  49. [51]Komatsu, E., et al. 2011, ApJS, 192, 18, doi: 10.1088/0067-0049/192/2/18DOI
  50. [52]Kroupa, P. 2001, MNRAS, 322, 231, doi: 10.1046/j.1365-8711.2001.04022.xDOI
  51. [53]Krumholz, M. R., Dekel, A., & McKee, C. F. 2012, ApJ, 745, 69, doi: 10.1088/0004-637X/745/1/69DOI
  52. [54]Kulkarni, M., Visbal, E., & Bryan, G. L. 2021, The Astrophysical Journal, 917, 40, doi: 10.3847/1538-4357/ac08a3
  53. [55]Larson, R. B. 1969, MNRAS, 145, 271, doi: 10.1093/mnras/145.3.271DOI
  54. [56]Latif, M. A., Whalen, D., & Khochfar, S. 2022, ApJ, 925, 28, doi: 10.3847/1538-4357/ac3916DOI
  55. [57]Lee, E. J., Chang, P., & Murray, N. W. 2015, ApJ, 800, 49, doi: 10.1088/0004-637X/800/1/49DOI
  56. [60]Machida, M. N., Hirano, S., & Basu, S. 2025, ApJ, 988, 6, doi: 10.3847/1538-4357/addc56DOI
  57. [61]Matzner, C. D., & Jumper, P. H. 2015, The Astrophysical Journal, 815, 68, doi: 10.1088/0004-637X/815/1/68
  58. [62]McKee, C. F., & Ostriker, E. C. 2007, Annual Review of Astronomy and Astrophysics, 45, 565
  59. [63]McKee, C. F., & Tan, J. C. 2003, ApJ, 585, 850, doi: 10.1086/346149DOI
  60. [64]Meziani, Y. J., Hopkins, P. F., Grudić, M. Y., et al. 2026a, arXiv e-prints. https://arxiv.org/abs/2602.02953
  61. [65]Meziani, Y. J., Hopkins, P. F., Gandhi, P. J., et al. 2026b
  62. [66]Murray, D. W., Chang, P., Murray, N. W., & Pittman, J. 2017, MNRAS, 465, 1316, doi: 10.1093/mnras/stw2796DOI
  63. [67]Murray, N. W., & Chang, P. 2015, ApJ, 804, 44, doi: 10.1088/0004-637X/804/1/44DOI
  64. [68]Nakauchi, D., Inayoshi, K., & Omukai, K. 2014, Monthly Notices of the Royal Astronomical Society, 442, 2667, doi: 10.1093/mnras/stu1042DOI
  65. [69]Offner, S. S. R., Klein, R. I., McKee, C. F., & Krumholz, M. R. 2009, The Astrophysical Journal, 703, 131–149, doi: 10.1088/0004-637X/703/1/131
  66. [71]Omukai, K. 2000, The Astrophysical Journal, 534, 809, doi: 10.1086/308776
  67. [72]Omukai, K., & Palla, F. 2003, The Astrophysical Journal, 589, 677
  68. [73]Oswald, L. S., Weltvrede, P., Posselt, B., et al. 2025, MNRAS, doi: 10.1093/mnras/staf645DOI
  69. [74]Padoan, P., Pan, L., Juvela, M., Haugbølle, T., & Nordlund, Å. 2020, The Astrophysical Journal, 900, 82
  70. [75]Palla, F., Salpeter, E. E., & Stahler, S. W. 1983, ApJ, 271, 632, doi: 10.1086/161231DOI
  71. [76]Park, J., Ricotti, M., & Sugimura, K. 2022, Population III star formation in an X-ray background: III. Periodic radiative feedback and luminosity induced by elliptical orbits, https://arxiv.org/abs/2212.04564
  72. [77]Penston, M. V. 1969, MNRAS, 144, 425, doi: 10.1093/mnras/144.4.425DOI
  73. [78]Peters, T., Klessen, R. S., Mac Low, M.-M., & Banerjee, R. 2010, The Astrophysical Journal, 725, 134
  74. [79]Prieto, J., Padoan, P., Jiménez, R., & Infante, L. 2011, ApJL, 731, L38, doi: 10.1088/2041-8205/731/2/L38DOI
  75. [80]Prole, L. R., Clark, P. C., Klessen, R. S., & Glover, S. C. O. 2022a, Monthly Notices of the Royal Astronomical Society, 510, 4019, doi: 10.1093/mnras/stab3697
  76. [81]Prole, L. R., Clark, P. C., Klessen, R. S., Glover, S. C. O., & Pakmor, R. 2022b, MNRAS, 516, 2223, doi: 10.1093/mnras/stac2327DOI
  77. [82]Ripamonti, E., & Abel, T. 2004, Monthly Notices of the Royal Astronomical Society, 348, 1019, doi: 10.1111/j.1365-2966.2004.07422.x
  78. [83]Roberts, W. W., & Yuan, C. 1970, ApJ, 161, 887, doi: 10.1086/150592
  79. [84]Robertson, B., & Goldreich, P. 2012, ApJL, 750, L31, doi: 10.1088/2041-8205/750/2/L31DOI
  80. [85]Sadanari, K. E., Omukai, K., Sugimura, K., Matsumoto, T., & Tomida, K. 2023, MNRAS, 519, 3076, doi: 10.1093/mnras/stac3724DOI
  81. [86]Sadanari, K. E., Omukai, K., Sugimura, K., Matsumoto, T., & Tomida, K. 2024, PASJ, 76, 823, doi: 10.1093/pasj/psae051DOI
  82. [87]Shang, C., Bryan, G. L., & Haiman, Z. 2010, MNRAS, 402, 1249, doi: 10.1111/j.1365-2966.2009.15960.xDOI
  83. [88]Sharda, P., Federrath, C., Krumholz, M. R., & Schleicher, D. R. G. 2021, MNRAS, 503, 2014, doi: 10.1093/mnras/stab531DOI
  84. [89]Sharda, P., & Menon, S. H. 2025, MNRAS, 540, 1745, doi: 10.1093/mnras/staf803DOI
  85. [90]Sharda, P., Menon, S. H., Gerasimov, R., et al. 2025, MNRAS, 541, L1, doi: 10.1093/mnras/slaf043
  86. [91]Shu, F. H. 1977, The Astrophysical Journal, 214, 488–497, doi: 10.1086/155274
  87. [92]Sofue, Y., & Fujimoto, M. 1983, ApJ, 265, 722, doi: 10.1086/160718DOI
  88. [93]Sofue, Y., Fujimoto, M., & Wielebinski, R. 1986, Annual Review of Astronomy and Astrophysics, 24, 459
  89. [94]Springel, V. 2005, Monthly Notices of the Royal Astronomical Society, 364, 1105, doi: 10.1111/j.1365-2966.2005.09655.xDOI
  90. [95]Springel, V. 2010, Monthly Notices of the Royal Astronomical Society, 401, 791–851, doi: 10.1111/j.1365-2966.2009.15715.xDOI
  91. [96]Stacy, A., & Bromm, V. 2007, Monthly Notices of the Royal Astronomical Society, 382, 229, doi: 10.1111/j.1365-2966.2007.12247.xDOI
  92. [97]Stacy, A., & Bromm, V. 2013, Monthly Notices of the Royal Astronomical Society, 433, 1094–1107, doi: 10.1093/mnras/stt789DOI
  93. [98]Stacy, A., Bromm, V., & Lee, A. T. 2016, MNRAS, 462, 1307, doi: 10.1093/mnras/stw1728DOI
  94. [99]Stacy, A., Greif, T. H., & Bromm, V. 2010, MNRAS, 403, 45, doi: 10.1111/j.1365-2966.2009.16113.xDOI
  95. [100]Stacy, A., Greif, T. H., & Bromm, V. 2012, MNRAS, 422, 290, doi: 10.1111/j.1365-2966.2012.20605.xDOI
  96. [101]Stacy, A., McKee, C. F., Lee, A. T., Klein, R. I., & Li, P. S. 2022, MNRAS, 511, 5042, doi: 10.1093/mnras/stac372DOI
  97. [102]Stahler, S. W., Palla, F., & Salpeter, E. E. 1986, The Astrophysical Journal, 302, 590
  98. [103]Storck, A., Katz, H., Devrient, J., et al. 2026, MNRAS, 548, stag529, doi: 10.1093/mnras/stag529DOI
  99. [104]Sugimura, K., Matsumoto, T., Hosokawa, T., Hirano, S., & Omukai, K. 2020, ApJL, 892, L14, doi: 10.3847/2041-8213/ab7d37DOI
  100. [105]Sugimura, K., Matsumoto, T., Hosokawa, T., Hirano, S., & Omukai, K. 2023, ApJ, 959, 17, doi: 10.3847/1538-4357/ad02fcDOI
  101. [106]Sugimura, K., Omukai, K., & Inoue, A. K. 2014, MNRAS, 445, 544, doi: 10.1093/mnras/stu1778DOI
  102. [107]Susa, H., Hasegawa, K., & Tominaga, N. 2014, ApJ, 792, 32, doi: 10.1088/0004-637X/792/1/32DOI
  103. [108]Toomre, A. 1964, The Astrophysical Journal, 139, 1217–1238, doi: 10.1086/147861DOI
  104. [109]Truelove, J. K., Klein, R. I., McKee, C. F., et al. 1997, ApJL, 489, L179, doi: 10.1086/310975DOI
  105. [110]Turk, M. J., Clark, P., Glover, S. C. O., et al. 2011a, The Astrophysical Journal, 726, 55
  106. [111]Turk, M. J., Clark, P., Glover, S. C. O., et al. 2011b, ApJ, 726, 55, doi: 10.1088/0004-637X/726/1/55DOI
  107. [112]Ugalino, M. I., Diemer, B., Semenov, V. A., et al. 2026, arXiv e-prints. https://arxiv.org/abs/2610.02308
  108. [113]Wetzel, A., Hayward, C. C., Sanderson, R. E., et al. 2023, ApJS, 265, 44, doi: 10.3847/1538-4365/acb99aDOI
  109. [114]Wise, J. H., & Abel, T. 2007, The Astrophysical Journal, 665, 899
  110. [115]Wollenberg, K. M. J., Glover, S. C. O., Clark, P. C., & Klessen, R. S. 2020, MNRAS, 494, 1871, doi: 10.1093/mnras/staa289DOI
  111. [116]Yoshida, N., Abel, T., Hernquist, L., & Sugiyama, N. 2003, The Astrophysical Journal, 592, 645
  112. [117]Yoshida, N., Omukai, K., & Hernquist, L. 2008, Science, 321, 669, doi: 10.1126/science.1160259DOI

Paper details

vlnc:W_m2nkmyy2
Version
v1 · latest
Published
Fresh — added to the Hub within the last 30 days
Added
License
CC BY 4.0
Usage

views · 6

downloads · 0

A view counts once per browser per day, a download each time the PDF is requested.

  • Physics and Astronomy

Not recorded for this paper

View statement
Looking for related papers…
Contents