In this paper
AbstractIntroductionAcknowledgmentsCohomology, symplectic modules, and the common sourceGeometric and algebraic rigidityCohomology of semidirect productsZero-weight cochainsSymplectic modulesAn equivariant Jacobi mapThe common deformation sourceToral extensionsA single toral generatorIndependent toral generatorsHeisenberg extensionsThe general kernel formulaMultiplicity-free rigiditySeparate Heisenberg centersApplications and nonrigid examplesIrreducible familiesMultiplicity-free modules and adjoint cochainsRepeated blocks with separate centersTwo repeated modules with a shared centerReferencesWorksMathematics
Rigid Lie Algebras from Semisimple Lie Algebras and Their Symplectic Modules
Abstract
We consider two extensions associated with a nonzero finite-dimensional symplectic module over a complex semisimple Lie algebra , and study their rigidity. The toral extension adjoins a derivation acting as the identity on and trivially on ; the Heisenberg extension uses the invariant symplectic form on to define a central bracket. For the toral extension, we compute the first and second adjoint cohomology groups in terms of , and obtain rigidity precisely when is irreducible. These results hold for arbitrary nonzero finite-dimensional modules. For the Heisenberg extension, we express the second adjoint cohomology as the kernel of a map combining the symplectic centralizer with an equivariant Jacobi map. A Killing-form argument shows that every multiplicity-free sum of irreducible symplectic modules gives an algebraically rigid Heisenberg extension. We also treat constructions with independent toral generators or Heisenberg centers. Repeated summands lead to explicit nonrigid examples, including a deformation to . The proofs use invariant cochains and recover several previously studied families.
Introduction
All Lie algebras and modules in our results are finite-dimensional over . A Lie algebra is geometrically rigid if its change-of-basis orbit is Zariski open in the variety of Lie algebra laws, and algebraically rigid if its second adjoint cohomology vanishes. Algebraic rigidity implies geometric rigidity [17]; the converse fails in general [18].
Let be semisimple and let be a nonzero symplectic -module. Regard as abelian. The direct product
admits two linear deformations, defined by
with all unspecified values zero. Their nonzero members have respective isomorphism types
In the first algebra, acts as the identity on . In the second, has bracket . We compute the low-degree adjoint cohomology of these targets and show how their rigidity depends on the irreducible decomposition of .
2020 Mathematics Subject Classification. Primary 17B05; Secondary 17B56.
The toral calculation applies to any nonzero -module, without a symplectic assumption. With , it gives
(Proposition 3.1). Thus is complete and algebraically rigid when is irreducible. When is reducible, equivariant projections give nontrivial linear deformations, proving geometric nonrigidity. Adjoining an independent toral generator for each irreducible component instead produces an extension whose adjoint cohomology vanishes in every degree (Proposition 3.4).
Our main Heisenberg result applies to every nonzero multiplicity-free sum of irreducible symplectic -modules:
No exclusion of adjoint components from is required (Theorem 4.2). The proof combines an invariant cochain calculation with a Killing-form argument: an equivariant map satisfying the corresponding Jacobi identity must vanish. The same argument proves rigidity when each irreducible symplectic component has its own Heisenberg center (Theorem 4.5). These algebras have a single diagonally acting Levi factor.
The general calculation underlying (2) expresses as the kernel of an explicit map involving the symplectic centralizer of the -action and the adjoint-valued two-cochains (Proposition 4.1). This formula retains the cancellations that occur when irreducible components are repeated. We exhibit two resulting failures of rigidity: three or more isomorphic Heisenberg blocks admit explicit central-valued deformations, while two copies of the defining -module with one shared center admit a deformation to .
These results belong to the cohomological approach to rigidity developed from the Hochschild–Serre factorization theorem and equivariant cochains. Richardson’s examples distinguish geometric from algebraic rigidity for semidirect products with abelian radical [18]. Related semidirect products involving were studied in [5]. Burde and Wagemann give explicit adjoint-cohomology calculations for semidirect products and low-dimensional perfect Lie algebras, including examples with Heisenberg radical [2, 3].
The toral extensions fit the external-torus framework of Carles [6, 7]; his cohomological study of generalizations of Borel subalgebras is also relevant to the full-torus calculation [8]. We give direct proofs for the extensions considered here and separate them from these broader structural results. The deformation defined by is the split codimension-one construction of Grunewald and O’Halloran [9]; see also [10]. The deformation defined by instead changes the bracket on .
Several irreducible Heisenberg families are already known. Campoamor-Stursberg proved cohomological rigidity for the Schrödinger algebra and its mass central extension in the nonexceptional spatial dimensions [4]. Khudoyberdiyev and Jumaniyozov obtained the corresponding vanishing results for mass central extensions of conformal Galilei algebras [13 Theorems 5.1 and 5.2]. Their case includes all Heisenberg extensions by odd irreducible -modules. We recover these results as applications of the general theorem. The symplectic oscillator algebras provide another family [15]. Complete extensions with Heisenberg nilradical, which include additional derivations, were studied in [16, 12].
The emphasis of this paper is the general multiplicity-free rigidity criterion, the kernel formula that extends beyond it, and the comparison between a shared center and separate Heisenberg centers. The explicit deformations describe some of the limitations of these criteria. Section 2 collects the cohomological and representation-theoretic tools and constructs the common source. Section 3 treats toral extensions. Section 4 proves the Heisenberg results, and Section 5 gives applications and nonrigid examples.
Acknowledgments
Some of the results of this paper were obtained as part of the Ph.D. thesis of the first author. The authors thank Edison Fernández-Culma and Nadina Rojas for valuable discussions concerning that thesis.
Cohomology, symplectic modules, and the common source
We use for a general Lie algebra, for a complex semisimple Lie algebra, and for an -module. The symbol denotes the undeformed direct product in (1); its targets are and . A superscript indicates a construction with added generators. The corresponding radicals are denoted by , , and , with the same superscript convention. We write for the line spanned by , and for the scalar field or the trivial module.
Geometric and algebraic rigidity
Let be a finite-dimensional complex Lie algebra with bracket , and let denote the variety of Lie algebra laws on its underlying vector space. The group acts on by change of basis.
Definition 2.1. The Lie algebra is geometrically rigid if the orbit of under is Zariski open in . It is algebraically rigid (also called cohomologically rigid) if
where the coefficients are taken in the adjoint module.
Algebraic rigidity implies geometric rigidity [17]. The converse does not hold in general [18].
Definition 2.2. A Lie algebra is complete if its center is zero and every derivation is inner; equivalently,
Cohomology of semidirect products
For a Lie algebra and a -module , write . Our differential is
In particular, for adjoint coefficients, and . All displayed cohomology isomorphisms are vector-space isomorphisms unless explicitly stated otherwise.
Let be an ideal of . The actions of on and induce an action on , given by
This action commutes with the differential and therefore induces a -module structure on .
We use the following form of the Hochschild–Serre factorization theorem [11 Theorem 13, p. 603].
Theorem 2.3 (Hochschild–Serre factorization theorem). Let be a finite-dimensional complex Lie algebra, let be a finite-dimensional -module, and let be an ideal such that is semisimple. Then, for every ,
Here the summation denotes a direct sum of vector spaces.
Since is semisimple, we have and, by Whitehead’s lemmas,
Consequently, restriction induces isomorphisms
Now write , where is a semisimple subalgebra complementary to . By [14 (1.2), p. 1011],
Indeed, the action of on its cohomology is trivial. Combining (4) and (5) gives the reduction used below.
Corollary 2.4. Let , with semisimple, and let be a finite-dimensional -module. Then, for ,
Moreover, every -invariant cohomology class has an -invariant cocycle representative, and every -invariant coboundary has an -invariant primitive [14 (1.3)–(1.4), p. 1011]. Equivalently, taking -invariants is exact on finite-dimensional -modules, and
Thus
where . The invariant complex in the last expression has degree- term , with the restriction of the Chevalley–Eilenberg differential. Invariance is imposed on cochains, including both their arguments and their values.
These reductions apply to both abelian and nonabelian radicals. In each case the differential uses the bracket and coefficient action of the algebra being considered.
Zero-weight cochains
We also use the following consequence of the Cartan homotopy formula. Let be a Lie algebra, let be a -module, and let . Denote by the endomorphism induced by on the cochain complex and put . Then
Here
Since , the differential preserves every eigenspace of . When is diagonalizable, these eigenspaces therefore give a direct-sum decomposition of the cochain complex into subcomplexes. If is a cocycle of eigenvalue , Cartan’s identity gives
Thus every nonzero-eigenvalue subcomplex has zero cohomology, and the inclusion of the zero-eigenvalue (zero-weight) subcomplex induces an isomorphism in cohomology. The same argument applies to when and , since insertion of then preserves -invariance.
Symplectic modules
Let be a semisimple Lie algebra and let be an -module.
Definition 2.5. The module is called symplectic if it admits a nondegenerate -invariant alternating bilinear form
Thus
for every and .
If is irreducible, such a form, when it exists, is unique up to a nonzero scalar. Indeed, an invariant bilinear form is the same as an -homomorphism . Hence an irreducible module admits a nonzero invariant bilinear form if and only if it is self-dual, and any such form is automatically nondegenerate. By Schur’s lemma, it is then either symmetric or alternating.
This distinction is measured by the Frobenius–Schur indicator. If denotes the transposition
we denote the indicator of an irreducible -module by
The Frobenius–Schur theorem gives
See [1] for the Frobenius–Schur indicators of finite-dimensional modules over complex semisimple Lie algebras. In particular, for an irreducible module,
In this case the last space is one-dimensional and is even.
The indicator is also computable directly from the highest weight. Let be the irreducible module with highest weight , let be the longest element of the Weyl group, and let be the half-sum of the positive coroots. Tits’s formula [1 Theorem 3.6] states that
Thus the symplectic condition is an explicit parity condition on a self-dual highest weight.
For a general module, write
where the are pairwise nonisomorphic irreducible modules and are their multiplicity spaces. Schur’s lemma gives the following criterion.
Proposition 2.6. Let be an -module. For each irreducible -module , let denote its multiplicity in , with when it does not occur. Then is symplectic if and only if the following conditions hold.
(a) Every irreducible module with occurs in with even multiplicity.
(b) For every non-self-dual irreducible , one has .
There is no parity restriction on the multiplicity of an irreducible module with indicator .
Proof. Write an isotypic component corresponding to a self-dual irreducible module as , where is the multiplicity space. By Schur’s lemma, every invariant bilinear form on this component is the tensor product of the invariant form on with a bilinear form on . The tensor product is alternating precisely when one factor is alternating and the other is symmetric. Thus a symplectic requires a nondegenerate symmetric form on , which exists in every dimension, whereas an orthogonal requires a nondegenerate alternating form on , which exists precisely when is even.
If is not self-dual, an invariant form pairs its isotypic component only with the component corresponding to . It is nondegenerate precisely when the two multiplicity spaces have the same dimension. In that case a perfect pairing between them gives an invariant alternating form on the sum of the two components. Different duality orbits are mutually orthogonal, and the result follows. □
Thus a symplectic module need not be a sum of irreducible symplectic modules: orthogonal components can occur with even multiplicity, and a non-self-dual component can be paired with its dual. For example, has the canonical symplectic form
By contrast, a multiplicity-free sum of irreducible symplectic modules means a sum of pairwise nonisomorphic irreducible modules, each of which is itself symplectic. This is the hypothesis of our Heisenberg rigidity theorems.
Lemma 2.7. If is an irreducible symplectic -module, then
Proof. Suppose that there exists a nonzero -homomorphism from to . Since is irreducible, it identifies with an irreducible submodule of the adjoint module . Such a submodule is a simple ideal of and therefore carries a nondegenerate invariant symmetric bilinear form, given by the restriction of its Killing form. On the other hand, carries a nondegenerate invariant alternating form. This is impossible: by Schur’s lemma, the space is one-dimensional, so two nonzero invariant bilinear forms on must be proportional. □
Lemma 2.8. If is a direct sum of irreducible symplectic -modules, then
Proof. Put . By Tits’s formula, the highest weight of each summand takes an odd integer value on . Every root takes an even integer value on , since for each simple root. All weights of therefore take odd values on , whereas all weights of take even values. An equivariant map preserves these eigenspaces, so it must be zero. □
We record a few families of irreducible symplectic modules.
(a) For , the irreducible module of highest weight satisfies
Consequently, is symplectic precisely when is odd, or equivalently, when is even.
(b) The defining module of is irreducible and symplectic for every $n\ge 1.
(c) For , with , the irreducible module
is symplectic. Its invariant form is induced by the exterior product
which is alternating because is odd.
An equivariant Jacobi map
For an -module , define
The equation is the Jacobi identity on for the bracket on obtained by setting .
Lemma 2.9 (Killing-form criterion). If is a multiplicity-free sum of irreducible symplectic -modules, then the map in (14) is injective.
Proof. Let satisfy . On , retain the bracket of and its action on , and put . Equivariance of gives Jacobi on one input in and two in , while gives Jacobi on three inputs in . Hence is a Lie algebra.
Let be its Killing form and write with the pairwise nonisomorphic irreducible symplectic modules. There is no nonzero invariant symmetric bilinear form on : its restriction to each must vanish by Schur’s lemma, and its cross terms vanish because for . Thus . Also , by Lemma 2.7 and the self-duality of the adjoint module. Therefore is contained in the ideal .
The ideal is solvable. Indeed, acts trivially on for , so the Killing form of is the restriction of and is zero. Cartan’s solvability criterion applies. Consequently is a solvable ideal of and must be zero. It follows that
The common deformation source
Let be a nonzero symplectic -module. Put
where is abelian. Define alternating maps on by
and set them equal to zero on all unspecified pairs.
Lemma 2.10. Let be the Lie bracket of . For every , the bilinear maps
are Lie brackets.
Proof. For the first family, the only new bracket is
The endomorphism commutes with the action of on , and hence acts as a derivation of the abelian Lie algebra in a way compatible with the action of . Thus the Jacobi identity holds.
For the second family, the only new bracket is
For this bracket, . Hence the Jacobi identity for three elements of is automatic. The Jacobi identity involving an element and two elements is precisely the identity
This follows from the -invariance of . □
For , an isomorphism from the toral member at parameter to that at parameter one fixes and sends to . For the Heisenberg family it sends to instead. Thus the nonzero targets are respectively and .
Remark 2.11 (The Grunewald–O’Halloran construction). If is a codimension-one ideal of , write and take . The alternating map
defines a linear deformation : it replaces the derivation by [9, 10]. For the source above, take , , and , . This gives and the original action of on is zero. The map instead changes the bracket on and takes values in the complementary line.
Remark 2.12. The two directions do not give a two-parameter linear family. The Jacobi expression for on is , so this is a Lie bracket precisely when .
Toral extensions
A single toral generator
Let be any nonzero -module and put . No symplectic assumption is needed in this section.
Proposition 3.1. Let be a nonzero -module and let
Then
If
where the are pairwise nonisomorphic irreducible modules, then
Proof. Put . Corollary 2.4 gives
Cartan’s homotopy formula (8) reduces the calculation to
In degrees zero through three its terms are
Here all unspecified values are zero, and
Indeed, a zero-weight one-cochain can only send to and to , while a zero-weight two-cochain can only send to . Equivariance identifies the latter two types of maps with . A threefold exterior product is either in (weight three) or in (weight two); a product with two copies of is zero. Since the target has only weights zero and one, .
For a one-cochain , we use
A direct evaluation on and on gives
Consequently the map is injective, the kernel in degree one is , and the space of boundaries is . In degree two every is a cocycle, while the boundaries are exactly the scalar multiples of . This proves (15). Finally, for the decomposition (16), which gives (17). The subtraction of one comes from the scalar identity: it is a one-coboundary, and its corresponding two-cochain is . This remains true when contains trivial one-dimensional summands. □
Corollary 3.2. The algebra is algebraically rigid if and only if is irreducible. In that case is also complete.
Proof. By complete reducibility, equals one precisely when is irreducible. Apply Proposition 3.1. □
Every class represented by integrates by replacing the action of with .
Corollary 3.3. If is reducible, then is not geometrically rigid.
Proof. Choose a proper nonzero submodule and an -equivariant projection onto it. For , replace the action of by
Because commutes with , this defines a linear deformation whose infinitesimal part is . For , this action is invertible. The solvable radical is , and any nilpotent ideal is contained in it. If such an ideal contained with , its brackets with would contain , on which is invertible. This contradicts nilpotence. Hence the nilradical is and is characteristic. The center of the quotient by is the line spanned by the class of . Hence an isomorphism with , the member at of this new family, would have to conjugate a nonzero scalar multiple of to . For , this is impossible: the action has two distinct eigenvalues, and , on nonzero subspaces. Thus arbitrarily close members of the family are not isomorphic to , and is not geometrically rigid. □
Independent toral generators
Choose a decomposition into irreducible components, allowing repetitions, and let be a trivial -module. The projections onto the define commuting semisimple derivations of . Hence
is a Lie algebra. It is the nonzero target of the linear deformation of defined by .
An external torus is an abelian subalgebra of semisimple derivations with zero intersection with the inner derivations. The derivations just described span a maximal torus in and form an external torus of . Indeed, an inner derivation vanishing on is defined by a vector in and acts trivially on . The scalar derivation defining is the sum of these independent generators; its span is maximal precisely when is irreducible. This identifies the constructions within the external-torus framework of [6, 7]. The following direct calculation gives the cohomology of the full-torus extension; compare also the broader cohomological setting of [8].
Proposition 3.4 (The full-torus extension). Let be any decomposition into nonzero irreducible -modules, allowing isomorphic or trivial summands. Let act by , and put . Then
In particular, this extension is complete and algebraically rigid.
Proof. Apply Theorem 2.3 with semisimple factor and radical . Cartan’s homotopy formula for the commuting operators reduces to its common zero-weight part. Let be the dual basis, so . The output weights are zero and the ; hence a cochain of weight zero has either only toral inputs and toral output, or exactly one input in and output in that same . Even if two modules are isomorphic, their torus weights are different. Schur’s lemma gives
where . If is in the first summand, then
The differential is zero on the second summand: the action on its output cancels the action on its one input, and is abelian. Thus the differential identifies the first summand in degree isomorphically with the second summand in degree . The whole zero-weight complex is acyclic. The factorization theorem then gives the assertion in every degree. □
Heisenberg extensions
The general kernel formula
Let be a nonzero symplectic -module and put , with . We use the spaces
The symplectic centralizer of the -action is
Define by
This map is surjective. Indeed, for write . Invariance gives , and alternation gives , so . The dilation derivation is given by
Proposition 4.1. Suppose that and . For one has
Here is given by (24), and represents the derivation
If, in addition, , define
Let be the map in (14). Then
Proof. Put , with , so that . Corollary 2.4 reduces the calculation to the invariant complex . In degrees zero and one it has terms
where is extended by , and , . With and all other values zero,
Thus a one-cochain is a cocycle precisely when . Since , it decomposes uniquely as
with the second term in . The invariant zero-cochain has zero differential because . This proves the assertions in degrees zero and one.
Under the additional hypothesis, every invariant two-cochain is uniquely
where and is zero on . Every is a cocycle and, by surjectivity of , a coboundary. The remaining differential is
These are all possible types of input triples. Therefore the cocycle conditions are and . The invariant two-coboundaries have only the component, which proves (28).
For , is injective on . For , the quotient is symplectic of dimension , so there are with . Then . Nevertheless, a nonzero may cancel in (28); injectivity of alone is not a vanishing argument when .
Multiplicity-free rigidity
Theorem 4.2. Let be a nonzero multiplicity-free sum of irreducible symplectic -modules. For every invariant symplectic form on , the algebra satisfies
In particular, is algebraically and geometrically rigid.
Proof. Each is nontrivial, and Lemma 2.7 gives . Lemma 2.8 gives . By Schur’s lemma,
There are no invariant cross pairings between different , so restricts nondegenerately to every . If belongs to , then for every . Thus . Proposition 4.1 now gives the first two assertions and identifies with . Lemma 2.9 proves the remaining vanishing. □
For an irreducible symplectic module, both nonzero targets of Lemma 2.10 are therefore algebraically rigid. For a multiplicity-free sum of two or more irreducible symplectic modules, the Heisenberg target is algebraically rigid whereas the single-generator toral target is geometrically nonrigid.
Remark 4.3. Whenever , the algebra is perfect, and its radical and nilradical are both . Indeed, by complete reducibility, and by nondegeneracy. Every nilpotent ideal maps to zero in the semisimple quotient, so it lies in the Heisenberg radical. Thus these targets belong to the perfect case in Carles’s structural alternatives for geometrically rigid algebras [6].
Remark 4.4 (The stronger adjoint exclusion). The condition and implies the hypotheses of Theorem 4.2, but is not needed there. To see this implication, let be the Killing form of . For , the form is symmetric and invariant. Define by
Symmetry and invariance make alternating and equivariant. If , then for all ; since , one has . Hence injects into , and forces .
The multiplicity-space description in Proposition 2.6 identifies the factors of with for a symplectic irreducible component, for an orthogonal one, and for a non-self-dual pair. Here is the corresponding nondegenerate symmetric or alternating form on the multiplicity space. These factors all vanish precisely when every component is symplectic and has multiplicity one. In particular, the stronger exclusion implies this condition. Examples with are given in § 5.
Separate Heisenberg centers
Suppose , with each a nonzero symplectic -module carrying a form . Let be a trivial module and put
Different radical blocks commute. The same Levi factor acts on all blocks; this is not a direct product of semidirect products. Its radical is .
The algebra (33) is a nonzero target of the linear deformation of given by
Jacobi follows from the centrality of and the invariance of each . Rescaling the identifies all nonzero members. When the are irreducible, this source also gives the full-torus target of (20).
Theorem 4.5. If are pairwise nonisomorphic irreducible symplectic -modules, then
The first cohomology is generated by the classes of the derivations defined by , , and zero on the remaining components. In particular, is algebraically rigid.
Proof. Corollary 2.4 reduces the calculation to the -invariant cochain complex of . Schur’s lemma gives
Also , , and , by the preceding lemmas.
The invariant zero-cochains are and have zero differential. An invariant one-cochain has the form , , with and . Its differential is
and is zero on the other pairs. Thus it is a cocycle precisely when for all . This proves the assertions in degrees zero and one.
Every invariant two-cochain is uniquely a sum
where for arbitrary , for , , and . Each map is extended by zero on the other types of pairs. The stated vanishing results exclude all further cochain types.
The differential on is
Thus a cocycle satisfies . Taking gives . Taking and exchanging gives
For , linear independence of forces both coefficients to vanish. Hence for all and . Every is a coboundary: in (35), take and . The remaining cocycle equation on three inputs in is . Lemma 2.9 gives , proving the vanishing in degree two. □
Applications and nonrigid examples
Irreducible families
Corollary 5.1. Let be the defining module of , where . Both nonzero targets associated with are algebraically rigid. The Heisenberg target is the symplectic oscillator algebra .
Proof. The defining module is irreducible and symplectic. Apply Corollary 3.2 and Theorem 4.2. For the terminology, see [15]. □
Corollary 5.2. Let be a positive odd integer and let or . Put
where is the irreducible -module of highest weight . Then both associated nonzero targets are algebraically rigid. The Heisenberg target is the complexified mass central extension of the conformal Galilei algebra of spin ; for this is the Schrödinger family.
Proof. For , the module is irreducible, and the tensor product of the alternating form on with the symmetric form on is symplectic. For , itself is irreducible symplectic. Apply Corollary 3.2 and Theorem 4.2. □
The Heisenberg rigidity assertions in this corollary recover [13 Theorems 5.1 and 5.2], and for the corresponding results of [4]. In particular, the case of a single odd irreducible -module is already included in that literature. The factor is abelian, so the spatial dimension is outside the semisimple-Levi formulation used here.
Multiplicity-free modules and adjoint cochains
For , let denote the irreducible module of highest weight . The standard decompositions are
and
The second follows from the first because the flip acts on the component by . For the sum is empty. Also , so is symplectic precisely when every even has even multiplicity .
Corollary 5.3. Let , where the are pairwise distinct positive odd integers. Then
whereas satisfies (32) for every . The extension with a separate Heisenberg center for each satisfies (34).
Proof. Apply Proposition 3.1, Theorem 4.2, and Theorem 4.5. □
The adjoint module occurs in for distinct odd precisely when . Thus can be nonzero in this corollary. Such cochains are eliminated by the Jacobi equation in Lemma 2.9, rather than by a representation-theoretic exclusion. The same phenomenon occurs for other semisimple Levi factors.
Example 5.4. Take and
The two components are irreducible symplectic and nonisomorphic. Their cross tensor product contains , an adjoint component of , by (36). Hence , but both the single-center and separate-center Heisenberg targets are algebraically rigid.
Repeated blocks with separate centers
Repeated irreducible components need not preserve rigidity. We first consider the construction with one center for each copy.
Proposition 5.5. Let be a nonzero irreducible symplectic -module and let
For , this algebra is geometrically nonrigid. Moreover,
Proof. Write for the copy of in , and let . Choose three distinct indices, say , and define an alternating map by
with all other types of pairs zero. If is the original bracket, then is a Lie bracket for every : all radical brackets still take values in , and the new bracket is -equivariant.
The cocycle is not a coboundary. By Corollary 2.4 and exactness of taking invariants, it is enough to check invariant one-cochains on the radical. Every such cochain has components in and , since is nontrivial and . On , its differential takes values only in : the original bracket of these two blocks is zero, and each remaining term brackets against either or . It cannot equal the nonzero component in (38).
If the orbit of were open, the curve would lie in that orbit for in a neighborhood of zero. Its tangent would then belong to the orbit tangent space, which is the space of two-coboundaries. This proves geometric nonrigidity.
For the dimension estimate, put . The central-valued invariant two-cochains on , extended by zero on inputs in , are all cocycles and have dimension
The invariant one-cochains have dimension . Their kernel contains the independent block dilations, so the boundary space has dimension at most . Subtracting gives the stated bound. □
The proposition does not assert nonrigidity for two repeated blocks. The number of centers also matters, as the next example illustrates.
Two repeated modules with a shared center
Remark 5.6. For , the Lie algebra of equivariant symplectic endomorphisms is
with the symmetric or alternating multiplicity-space forms from Proposition 2.6. For a sum of odd components, and , so Proposition 4.1 computes and gives the kernel formula for with arbitrary multiplicities. Repeated odd components introduce adjoint-valued cochains through
since occurs in for every positive odd . The kernel formula retains both the centralizer and these adjoint-valued cochains. Even components require separate checks of all the hypotheses of Proposition 4.1.
Example 5.7 (Two copies of the defining module). Let with its standard symplectic form , and let be two copies of . Write , with form , and denote by the copy of . Then
Use a single shared generator for both copies, so that and . For ,
Moreover, admits a linear deformation whose nonzero members are isomorphic to . In particular, is not geometrically rigid, whereas every nonzero member is algebraically and geometrically rigid.
To see this explicitly, identify and set
Let and , and define an alternating map by , \quad .
Here and is spanned by the cross-pair cochain . The two-dimensional symplectic identity
gives, on a triple with two inputs in the first copy,
The same calculation with the copies exchanged gives on all triples. Since , the kernel in (28) is precisely the line represented by . This proves the cohomology dimensions.
The map is itself a Lie bracket. Indeed, and , so the Jacobi identity on three vectors of is automatic. The only remaining condition is , which follows from the displayed formulas. Here the vector subspace lies in the center for the bracket alone, not for the original bracket . If denotes the bracket of , then shows that is a linear deformation of . For , put and view as a row covector. An isomorphism onto is given, for , by
Indeed, , the brackets within either copy vanish, and
The identity identifies this mixed bracket with the matrix commutator; the other brackets follow from the -invariance of . Whitehead’s second lemma shows that every nonzero member is algebraically, and hence geometrically, rigid. Its center is zero, whereas , so these members are nonisomorphic to . This proves the geometric nonrigidity of . The cohomology dimensions also agree with the corresponding eight-dimensional entry in [3 Proposition 5.3].
References
FaCET, Universidad Nacional de Tucumán, Argentina
Email address: [email protected]
CIEM – FaMAF, CONICET – Universidad Nacional de Córdoba, Argentina
Guangdong Technion Israel Institute of Technology, China
Email address: [email protected]
References
- [1]M. Abu-Hamed and S. Gelaki, Frobenius–Schur indicators for semisimple Lie algebras, J. Algebra 315 (2007), no. 1, 178–191.
- [2]D. Burde and F. Wagemann, Sympathetic Lie algebras and adjoint cohomology for Lie algebras, J. Algebra 629 (2023), 381–398.arxiv.org/abs/1908.05963
- [3]D. Burde and F. Wagemann, Cohomology of perfect Lie algebras, arXiv:2411.14952 [math.RT] (2024).arxiv.org/abs/2411.14952
- [4]R. Campoamor-Stursberg, Cohomological rigidity of the Schrödinger algebra S(N) and its central extension \widetilde{S}(N), J. Lie Theory 27 (2017), no. 2, 315–328.
- [5]R. Campoamor-Stursberg, Some structural properties of semidirect sums of so(3) and abelian Lie algebras, Geometry, Integrability and Quantization, Proceedings Series 22 (2021), 88–106.
- [6]R. Carles, Sur la structure des algèbres de Lie rigides, Ann. Inst. Fourier (Grenoble) 34 (1984), no. 3, 65–82.DOI
- [7]R. Carles, Sur certaines classes d’algèbres de Lie rigides, Math. Ann. 272 (1985), 477–488, doi:10.1007/BF01455861.DOI
- [8]R. Carles, Sur la cohomologie d’une nouvelle classe d’algèbres de Lie qui généralisent les sous-algèbres de Borel, J. Algebra 154 (1993), no. 2, 310–334.
- [9]F. Grunewald and J. O’Halloran, Deformations of Lie algebras, J. Algebra 162 (1993), no. 1, 210–224.DOI
- [10]J. F. Herrera-Granada and P. Tirao, The Grunewald–O’Halloran conjecture for nilpotent Lie algebras of rank ≥ 1, Comm. Algebra 44 (2016), no. 5, 2180–2192.
- [11]G. Hochschild and J.-P. Serre, Cohomology of Lie algebras, Ann. of Math. (2) 57 (1953), no. 3, 591–603.DOI
- [12]C. Jiang and D. Meng, The realization and structure of complete Lie algebras whose nilpotent radicals are Heisenberg algebras, Chinese Sci. Bull. 43 (1998), 383–385.
- [13]A. Khudy... and D. Juman...iyozov, Cohomological rigidity of conformal Galilei algebras and their central extensions, arXiv:2508.17752 [math.RA] (2025).
- [14]G. F. Leger, Jr., On cohomology of Lie algebras, Proc. Amer. Math. Soc. 8 (1957), no. 6, 1010–1020.DOI
- [15]G. Liu and K. Zhao, The category of weight modules for symplectic oscillator Lie algebras, Transform. Groups 27 (2022), 1025–1044.arxiv.org/abs/1908.04534
- [16]D. Meng, Complete Lie algebras and Heisenberg algebras, Comm. Algebra 22 (1994), 5509–5524.DOI
- [17]A. Nijenhuis and R. W. Richardson, Jr., Deformations of Lie algebra structures, J. Math. Mech. 17 (1967), no. 1, 89–105.DOI
- [18]R. W. Richardson, Jr., On the rigidity of semi-direct products of Lie algebras, Pacific J. Math. 22 (1967), no. 2, 339–344.DOI