betaFeedback

WorksPhysics and Astronomy

Exact thermal correlators at vanishing momenta and the black hole singularity

Abstract

We study thermal two- and three-point functions of scalar primaries in holographic CFTs dual to AdS black branes. The three-point function arises from a cubic scalar interaction in the bulk. At vanishing external momenta, the tree-level results can be written in closed form and are exact in the operator dimensions. We reproduce them through direct CFT calculations in two dimensions. Their large-dimension expansions contain subleading exponential terms encoding the radial proper time from the horizon to the black hole singularity. These results provide an exact test of earlier WKB and saddle-point predictions for higher-point thermal correlators, confirming the proper-time signature while correcting the predicted asymptotic form.

Introduction

The AdS/CFT correspondence [1, 2, 3] relates thermal CFT correlators to bulk observables in black hole geometries. The Euclidean setup contains only the exterior region, raising the question of how CFT observables encode the interior and its singularity. This paper tests a specific prediction for higher-point thermal correlators: whether their large-dimension behaviour contains the proper time from the horizon to the black hole singularity.

In [4], I studied this question for scalar self-interactions and exchange interactions using WKB and saddle-point approximations. The predicted leading exponential combined the geodesic distance between the boundary and the horizon with the proper time to the singularity. Here, we test the contact three-point prediction at vanishing external momenta in the black brane geometry, where the bulk propagator and vertex integral can be treated exactly in the operator dimension. The resulting large-dimension expansion encodes the time to singularity in subleading exponential terms, while the leading exponential depends on the boundary-to-horizon distance. This provides a direct benchmark for the earlier approximation in the zero-momentum case.

Our main results are the exact identical and mixed scalar contact three-point functions in general boundary dimension dd, together with their analytically continued large-dimension limits. We also rederive the thermal two-point function obtained by Berenstein and Mancilla [5] and analyze its asymptotic behaviour. We independently derive the d=2d = 2 results by direct CFT calculation of the zero-momentum correlators.

The proper-time interpretation is motivated by exact one-point calculations. Grinberg and Maldacena [6] computed the thermal one-point function induced by coupling a bulk scalar to the square of the Weyl tensor. Its analytically continued large-mass limit contains the proper time from the horizon to the singularity and agrees with a WKB and saddle-point calculation. David and Kumar [7] obtained further exact results for charged black branes in a large bulk spacetime dimension limit and for a hyperbolic black hole, with appropriate curvature couplings.1 Related signatures occur in curvature-induced thermal two-point contributions [8, 9]. These examples motivate testing the higher-point approximation against the exact contact contributions considered here.

A complementary approach probes singularities by analytically continuing boundary correlators [10, 11, 12]. For AdS–Schwarzschild black holes in four and higher dimensions, the geodesic approximation reveals a singularity on a secondary sheet of the two-sided correlator, associated with “bouncing geodesics”: nearly null spacelike geodesics that connect the two boundaries and approach the black hole singularity. Related signatures have been studied through the thermal OPE [13], spectral functions [14], large-frequency two-point functions [15], line defects [16], and quasinormal modes [17, 18]. Extensions to shock-wave geometries [19] and black holes with inner horizons [20, 21] have also been studied. For a charged black brane, exponentially small terms in the spectral density at large real frequency have been related to null geodesics reflecting off its timelike singularity [22]. Analytically continued, smeared thermal four-point functions provide a related probe of local scattering behind the horizon [23]. The fate of bouncing singularities has also been examined at finite coupling in SYK models [24, 25], with finite string length effects in the NS5-brane SL(2,R)k/U(1)SL(2,\mathbb{R})_k/U(1) worldsheet coset model [26], and at finite GNG_N [27, 28, 29].

The remainder of the paper is organized as follows. § 2 fixes the conventions and collects the results. The bulk calculation and large-dimension analysis are performed in § 3. § 5 gives the CFT check in two dimensions. We conclude with a short discussion of the comparison with the previous approximation and open questions in § 6.

Preliminaries and results

This section describes the setup, fixes notation, and collects the results obtained in this paper. The physical observables of interest in this work are thermal correlation functions of primary operators in holographic CFTs. Specifically, we consider a Euclidean CFT on Sβ1×Rd−1S^1_\beta\times\mathbb{R}^{d-1}, where β\beta is the inverse temperature. The bulk dual is a black brane geometry with Hawking temperature T=1βT = \frac{1}{\beta}. We use O\mathcal{O} for a scalar primary operator of conformal dimension Δ\Delta. Its dual is a scalar field ϕ\phi propagating in the bulk spacetime, with mass mm related to the conformal dimension by [2, 3]

Δ=d2+d24+m2R2,(1)\Delta= \frac{d}{2} + \sqrt{\frac{d^2}{4} + m^2 R^2}, \tag*{(1)}

where RR is the AdS radius.

The translation symmetries of the background make it convenient to work with correlators in Fourier space. The nn-point thermal correlator of O\mathcal{O} is denoted by2

⟨O(k1)⋯O(kn)⟩β.(2)\langle\mathcal{O}(k_1) \cdots\mathcal{O}(k_n) \rangle_\beta. \tag*{(2)}

Here, ki≡(ωi,k⃗i)k_i \equiv(\omega_i,\vec{k}_i) are the momenta, including the Matsubara frequencies. Translation symmetry enforces momentum conservation in the correlator (2). Therefore, following the convention of [30], we define a reduced correlator ⟨ ⁣⟨⋅⟩ ⁣⟩\langle\!\langle\cdot\rangle\!\rangle via the relation

⟨O(k1)⋯O(kn)⟩β=(2π)dδ(d)(k1+⋯+kn)⟨ ⁣⟨O(k1)⋯O(kn)⟩ ⁣⟩β,(3)\langle\mathcal{O}(k_1) \cdots\mathcal{O}(k_n) \rangle_\beta= (2\pi)^d \delta^{(d)}(k_1+\cdots+k_n) \langle\!\langle\mathcal{O}(k_1) \cdots\mathcal{O}(k_n) \rangle\!\rangle_\beta, \tag*{(3)}

where it is understood that time translation symmetry on Sβ1S^1_\beta requires the sum over Matsubara frequencies to vanish:

2πδ(ω1+⋯+ωn)⟶βδω1+⋯+ωn,0.(4)2\pi\delta(\omega_1+\cdots+\omega_n) \longrightarrow\beta\delta_{\omega_1+\cdots+\omega_n,0}. \tag*{(4)}

We set all external momenta to zero and use the exact bulk-boundary propagator in this limit. The thermal two-point function is given in (19); the identical and mixed contact three-point functions (see Figure 1 and Figure 2) are given in (30) and (40). § 5 checks these expressions using a direct CFT computation in two dimensions.

Figure 1. The contact Witten diagram sourcing the three-point function of a scalar primary O\mathcal{O}. The blue edges correspond to bulk-boundary propagators of the dual field ϕ\phi. The interaction vertex is integrated over the bulk Euclidean geometry.

Figure 2. The contact Witten diagram sourcing the mixed three-point function of two primaries O1\mathcal{O}_1 and O2\mathcal{O}_2. The edges correspond to bulk-boundary propagators of the dual fields: blue for ϕ1\phi_1 and red for ϕ2\phi_2. The interaction vertex is integrated over the bulk Euclidean geometry.

The correlators have poles for real positive values of Δ\Delta. So, to analyze the large conformal dimension behaviour, we give Δ\Delta a negative imaginary part and take the limit Δ≈mR→∞(1−iϵ)\Delta\approx mR \to\infty(1-i\epsilon). The resulting expressions, given in (22) and (32), are:

⟨ ⁣⟨O(0)O(0)⟩ ⁣⟩β∼e−2mℓh(1−2q2+2q4−2q6+2q8+⋯ ),(5)\langle\!\langle\mathcal{O}(0)\mathcal{O}(0)\rangle\!\rangle_\beta\sim e^{-2m\ell_h}\left(1-2q^2+2q^4-2q^6+2q^8+\cdots\right), \tag*{(5)}
⟨ ⁣⟨O(0)O(0)O(0)⟩ ⁣⟩β∼e−3mℓh(1−3q+3q2−3q4+3q5+⋯ ),(6)\langle\!\langle\mathcal{O}(0)\mathcal{O}(0)\mathcal{O}(0)\rangle\!\rangle_\beta\sim e^{-3m\ell_h}\left(1-3q+3q^2-3q^4+3q^5+\cdots\right), \tag*{(6)}

where q=e−iΔπd≈e−imτsq=e^{-i\Delta\frac{\pi}{d}}\approx e^{-im\tau_s}, with τs=πdR\tau_s=\frac{\pi}{d}R being the time to singularity and ℓh\ell_h the regularized distance between the asymptotic boundary and the black hole horizon; see equations (23) and (24). In this sense, the thermal correlators at vanishing momenta probe the bulk geometry, including the black hole interior and singularity. The mixed thermal three-point function of two different primaries shows a similar signature when one of the operator dimensions is taken large; see (43).

Gravity calculation

The bulk geometry dual to a holographic CFT on Sβ1×Rd−1S^1_\beta\times\mathbb{R}^{d-1} is a Euclidean black brane whose metric is given by

ds2=R2z2(f(z)dτ2+dz2f(z)+dx⃗ 2),f(z)=1−zdz0d.(7)ds^2=\frac{R^2}{z^2}\left(f(z)d\tau^2+\frac{dz^2}{f(z)}+d\vec{x}^{\,2}\right),\qquad f(z)=1-\frac{z^d}{z_0^d}. \tag*{(7)}

Here, RR is the AdS radius and z0=βd4πz_0=\frac{\beta d}{4\pi} is the location of the horizon. The asymptotic boundary is at z→0z\to0. We consider the following action for a bulk scalar field ϕ\phi, dual to a boundary primary operator O\mathcal{O}:

S[ϕ]=∫dd+1xg[12∂μϕ∂μϕ+12m2ϕ2+λ3!ϕ3].(8)S[\phi]=\int d^{d+1}x\sqrt{g}\left[\frac{1}{2}\partial_\mu\phi\partial^\mu\phi+\frac{1}{2}m^2\phi^2+\frac{\lambda}{3!}\phi^3\right]. \tag*{(8)}

The relation between the mass of the bulk scalar and the conformal dimension of the boundary operator was given in (1). The self-interaction in (8) provides a cubic vertex for Witten diagrams [2, 3].

Let us first focus on the free (quadratic) part of the action, which gives the Klein–Gordon equation for the massive scalar field. In momentum space, with k≡(ω,k⃗)k\equiv(\omega,\vec{k}), it reduces to a radial equation:

zd+1∂z(z−d+1f(z)∂zϕk(z))−(ω2f(z)2z2+k⃗2z2+m2R2)ϕk(z)=0.(9)z^{d+1}\partial_z\left(z^{-d+1}f(z)\partial_z\phi_k(z)\right)-\left(\frac{\omega^2}{f(z)^2}z^2+\vec{k}^2z^2+m^2R^2\right)\phi_k(z)=0. \tag*{(9)}

The bulk-boundary propagator, Gk(z)G_k(z), is defined as a regular solution to this equation with the boundary condition

Gk(z)∼z→0zd−Δ.(10)G_k(z)\mathop{\sim}_{z\to0}z^{d-\Delta}. \tag*{(10)}

At vanishing momenta, the propagator is known in closed form as a hypergeometric function [6]:

G0(z)≡G0(w)=z0d−ΔΓ(h)2Γ(2h−1)wh2F1(h,h;1;1−w),(11)G_0(z)\equiv G_0(w)=z_0^{d-\Delta}\frac{\Gamma(h)^2}{\Gamma(2h-1)}w^h{}_2F_1(h,h;1;1-w), \tag*{(11)}

where h=Δdh=\frac{\Delta}{d} and we have defined a new radial variable

w=zdz0d.(12)w=\frac{z^d}{z_0^d}. \tag*{(12)}

An alternative form of the propagator uses the Legendre function [31]:

G0(y)=z0d−ΔΓ(h)2Γ(2h−1)Ph−1(y),y=2w−1.(13)G_0(y)=z_0^{d-\Delta}\frac{\Gamma(h)^2}{\Gamma(2h-1)}P_{h-1}(y),\qquad y=\frac{2}{w}-1. \tag*{(13)}

Two-point function

Following the standard rules of AdS/CFT [32, 33] and holographic renormalization [34], the thermal two-point function of the operator O\mathcal{O} can directly be extracted from the bulk-boundary propagator. This computation appeared in [5]. The idea is to expand the propagator around z=0z=0 as

Gk(z)=zd−Δ(1+⋯ )+BkzΔ(1+⋯ ),(14)G_k(z)=z^{d-\Delta}(1+\cdots)+B_kz^\Delta(1+\cdots), \tag*{(14)}

where the ⋯\cdots denote higher powers of zz. BkB_k is termed the normalizable coefficient. The renormalized two-point function is then given by

⟨⟨O(k)O(−k)⟩⟩β=(2Δ−d)Rd−1Bk.(15)\langle\langle\mathcal{O}(k)\mathcal{O}(-k)\rangle\rangle_\beta=(2\Delta-d)R^{d-1}B_k. \tag*{(15)}

Using the connection formula for the hypergeometric function [35 equation (15.8.4)], we can extract the near-boundary behaviour of the bulk-boundary propagator at zero momentum:

wh2F1(h,h;1;1−w)=Γ(2h−1)Γ(h)2w1−h(1+⋯ )+Γ(1−2h)Γ(1−h)2wh(1+⋯ ).(16)w^h{}_2F_1(h,h;1;1-w)=\frac{\Gamma(2h-1)}{\Gamma(h)^2}w^{1-h}(1+\cdots)+\frac{\Gamma(1-2h)}{\Gamma(1-h)^2}w^h(1+\cdots). \tag*{(16)}

Substituting this in (11) and reading off the coefficient of zΔz^\Delta gives the normalizable coefficient B0B_0:

B0=z0d−2ΔΓ(h)2Γ(1−2h)Γ(1−h)2Γ(2h−1).(17)B_0=z_0^{d-2\Delta}\frac{\Gamma(h)^2\Gamma(1-2h)}{\Gamma(1-h)^2\Gamma(2h-1)}. \tag*{(17)}

We then have the two-point function at vanishing momenta

⟨ ⁣⟨O(0)O(0)⟩ ⁣⟩β=(2Δ−d)z0d−2ΔRd−1Γ(h)2Γ(1−2h)Γ(1−h)2Γ(2h−1).(18)\langle\!\langle O(0)O(0)\rangle\!\rangle_\beta=(2\Delta-d)z_0^{d-2\Delta}R^{d-1}\frac{\Gamma(h)^2\Gamma(1-2h)}{\Gamma(1-h)^2\Gamma(2h-1)}. \tag*{(18)}

This reproduces the static response function obtained in equations (25)–(26) of [5]. Using the reflection formula, Γ(z)Γ(1−z)=πsin⁡πz\Gamma(z)\Gamma(1-z)=\frac{\pi}{\sin\pi z}, we write (18) as

⟨ ⁣⟨O(0)O(0)⟩ ⁣⟩β=dz0d−2ΔRd−1π(Γ(h)2Γ(2h−1))2sin⁡2πhsin⁡(2πh).(19)\langle\!\langle O(0)O(0)\rangle\!\rangle_\beta=\frac{d z_0^{d-2\Delta}R^{d-1}}{\pi}\left(\frac{\Gamma(h)^2}{\Gamma(2h-1)}\right)^2\frac{\sin^2\pi h}{\sin(2\pi h)}. \tag*{(19)}

Large conformal dimension limit

The thermal correlator (19), as a function of the conformal dimension, has poles at

Δ=nd+d2,n=1,2,3,…(20)\Delta=nd+\frac{d}{2},\qquad n=1,2,3,\ldots \tag*{(20)}

To avoid these poles in the asymptotic limit, we give a small negative imaginary part to Δ\Delta (equivalently mm). Since the spacetime dimension is fixed, this is implemented by h→∞(1−iϵ)h\to\infty(1-i\epsilon). It is convenient to define the following variable to organize the expansion:

q=e−iπh=e−iΔπd≈e−imRπd.(21)q=e^{-i\pi h}=e^{-i\Delta\frac{\pi}{d}}\approx e^{-imR\frac{\pi}{d}}. \tag*{(21)}

Keeping terms exponential in hh and suppressing the temperature dependence, the asymptotic form of the two-point function is

⟨ ⁣⟨O(0)O(0)⟩ ⁣⟩β∼2−4h(1−q2)21−q4=2−4h(1−2q2+2q4−2q6+2q8+⋯ ).(22)\langle\!\langle O(0)O(0)\rangle\!\rangle_\beta\sim2^{-4h}\frac{(1-q^2)^2}{1-q^4}=2^{-4h}(1-2q^2+2q^4-2q^6+2q^8+\cdots). \tag*{(22)}

We can identify the factors appearing in the expansion with geometric quantities in the black brane background. The regularized distance between the asymptotic boundary and the horizon is

ℓh=Rdlim⁡wc→0(∫wc1dww1−w+log⁡wc)=Rdlog⁡4.(23)\ell_h=\frac{R}{d}\lim_{w_c\to0}\left(\int_{w_c}^{1}\frac{dw}{w\sqrt{1-w}}+\log w_c\right)=\frac{R}{d}\log4. \tag*{(23)}

The proper time between the horizon and black hole singularity along a radially infalling geodesic is

τs=Rd∫1∞dwww−1=πRd.(24)\tau_s = \frac{R}{d}\int_1^\infty\frac{\mathrm{d}w}{w\sqrt{w-1}} = \frac{\pi R}{d}. \tag*{(24)}

Thus, at large mass, the expansion (22) can be expressed as

⟨ ⁣⟨O(0)O(0)⟩ ⁣⟩β∼e−2mℓh(1−2e−2imτs+2e−4imτs+⋯ ),(25)\langle\!\langle\mathcal{O}(0)\mathcal{O}(0)\rangle\!\rangle_\beta\sim e^{-2m\ell_h}\left(1-2e^{-2im\tau_s}+2e^{-4im\tau_s}+\cdots\right), \tag*{(25)}

where it is understood that the coefficient of each exponential factor inside the brackets is a power series in mm.

Three-point function

The cubic self-interaction vertex in (8) sources the three-point function of the operator O\mathcal{O}. The contact Witten diagram, shown in Figure 1, evaluates to

⟨ ⁣⟨O(k1)O(k2)O(k3)⟩ ⁣⟩β=−λRd+1∫0z0dzzd+1Gk1(z)Gk2(z)Gk3(z).(26)\langle\!\langle\mathcal{O}(k_1)\mathcal{O}(k_2)\mathcal{O}(k_3)\rangle\!\rangle_\beta= -\lambda R^{d+1}\int_0^{z_0}\frac{\mathrm{d}z}{z^{d+1}}G_{k_1}(z)G_{k_2}(z)G_{k_3}(z). \tag*{(26)}

Substituting (13) for the zero-momentum propagator and changing the integration variable, we obtain the correlator at vanishing momenta:

⟨ ⁣⟨O(0)O(0)O(0)⟩ ⁣⟩β=−λz02d−3ΔRd+12d(Γ(h)2Γ(2h−1))3∫1∞dy(Ph−1(y))3.(27)\langle\!\langle\mathcal{O}(0)\mathcal{O}(0)\mathcal{O}(0)\rangle\!\rangle_\beta= -\frac{\lambda z_0^{2d-3\Delta}R^{d+1}}{2d}\left(\frac{\Gamma(h)^2}{\Gamma(2h-1)}\right)^3\int_1^\infty\mathrm{d}y\left(P_{h-1}(y)\right)^3. \tag*{(27)}

The near-boundary behaviour of the integrand is y3h−3y^{3h-3} as y→∞y\to\infty. This means that the integral converges only if 3Re⁡(h)−3<−1⇒Re⁡(h)<233\operatorname{Re}(h)-3<-1\Rightarrow\operatorname{Re}(h)<\frac{2}{3}. For larger values of Re⁡(h)\operatorname{Re}(h), the integral is defined by analytic continuation in hh.

Reference [36] computed the integral of three associated Legendre functions of the same order.3 We adapt the general formula given in equations (1)–(2) of [36] to the integral of three Legendre functions:

∫1∞dy P2a−12(y)P2b−12(y)P2c−12(y)=14π2Γ(14±a±b±c)Γ(12±2a)Γ(12±2b)Γ(12±2c).(28)\int_{1}^{\infty} \mathrm{d}y\,P_{2a-\frac{1}{2}}(y)P_{2b-\frac{1}{2}}(y)P_{2c-\frac{1}{2}}(y)=\frac{1}{4\pi^{2}}\frac{\Gamma\left(\frac{1}{4}\pm a\pm b\pm c\right)}{\Gamma\left(\frac{1}{2}\pm2a\right)\Gamma\left(\frac{1}{2}\pm2b\right)\Gamma\left(\frac{1}{2}\pm2c\right)}. \tag*{(28)}

where each ±\pm in the arguments on the right-hand side denotes a product of Gamma functions over the different choices. So, the numerator of (28) contains eight Gamma functions while the denominator contains six. The integral in (27) is obtained by setting a=b=c=h2−14a=b=c=\frac{h}{2}-\frac{1}{4}. Using the reflection identity and the duplication formula, Γ(z)Γ(z+12)=21−2zπ Γ(2z)\Gamma(z)\Gamma\left(z+\frac{1}{2}\right)=2^{1-2z}\sqrt{\pi}\,\Gamma(2z), we can simplify the integral as follows:

∫1∞dy (Ph−1(y))3=1π2Γ(3h−1)Γ(h2)6Γ(h)3Γ(3h2)2sin⁡3(πh2)sin⁡(3πh2).(29)\int_{1}^{\infty}\mathrm{d}y\,\left(P_{h-1}(y)\right)^{3}=\frac{1}{\pi^{2}}\frac{\Gamma(3h-1)\Gamma\left(\frac{h}{2}\right)^{6}}{\Gamma(h)^{3}\Gamma\left(\frac{3h}{2}\right)^{2}}\frac{\sin^{3}\left(\frac{\pi h}{2}\right)}{\sin\left(\frac{3\pi h}{2}\right)}. \tag*{(29)}

Substituting (29) in (27) gives the thermal three-point function:

⟨ ⁣⟨O(0)O(0)O(0)⟩ ⁣⟩β=−λz02d−3ΔRd+12π2dΓ(3h−1)Γ(h)3Γ(h2)6Γ(2h−1)3Γ(3h2)2sin⁡3(πh2)sin⁡(3πh2).(30)\langle\!\langle O(0)O(0)O(0)\rangle\!\rangle_{\beta}=-\frac{\lambda z_{0}^{2d-3\Delta}R^{d+1}}{2\pi^{2}d}\frac{\Gamma(3h-1)\Gamma(h)^{3}\Gamma\left(\frac{h}{2}\right)^{6}}{\Gamma(2h-1)^{3}\Gamma\left(\frac{3h}{2}\right)^{2}}\frac{\sin^{3}\left(\frac{\pi h}{2}\right)}{\sin\left(\frac{3\pi h}{2}\right)}. \tag*{(30)}

Large conformal dimension limit

As with the two-point function, we now study the large conformal dimension behaviour of the thermal three-point function (30). From the ratio of sine functions, we identify the poles of the correlator at positive real values of the conformal dimension:4

Δ=2nd3,(31)\Delta=\frac{2nd}{3}, \tag*{(31)}

where n≥1n\geq1 is an integer not divisible by 3. Again, to avoid these poles, we analyze the limit h→∞(1−iϵ)h\to\infty(1-i\epsilon) of the correlator. The terms exponential in the conformal dimension come from the ratios of Gamma functions and sine functions. In the variable qq defined in (21), the thermal three-point function is expanded as

⟨ ⁣⟨O(0)O(0)O(0)⟩ ⁣⟩β∼2−6h(1−q)31−q3=2−6h(1−3q+3q2−3q4+3q5+⋯ ).(32)\langle\!\langle O(0)O(0)O(0)\rangle\!\rangle_{\beta}\sim2^{-6h}\frac{(1-q)^{3}}{1-q^{3}}=2^{-6h}\left(1-3q+3q^{2}-3q^{4}+3q^{5}+\cdots\right). \tag*{(32)}

The expansion can be re-expressed using the geometric quantities (23) and (24) as

⟨ ⁣⟨O(0)O(0)O(0)⟩ ⁣⟩β∼e−3mℓh(1−3e−imτs+3e−2imτs−3e−4imτs+3e−5imτs+⋯ ).(33)\langle\!\langle O(0)O(0)O(0)\rangle\!\rangle_{\beta}\sim e^{-3m\ell h}\left(1-3e^{-im\tau_s}+3e^{-2im\tau_s}-3e^{-4im\tau_s}+3e^{-5im\tau_s}+\cdots\right). \tag*{(33)}

This indicates that higher-point thermal correlators contain an imprint of the black hole singularity. However, the result (33) differs from the form e−3m(ℓh+iτs)e^{-3m(\ell_h+i\tau_s)} suggested in [4]. In fact, the expansion (33) has no terms corresponding to e−3ℓmτse^{-3\ell m\tau_s} for any positive integer ℓ\ell. See § 6 for further discussion.

Mixed correlator

In [4], it was argued that factors of time to singularity may also appear in mixed thermal correlators of heavy and light operators. We can test this by directly calculating the following three-point function at vanishing momenta:

⟨ ⁣⟨O1(0)O1(0)O2(0)⟩ ⁣⟩β,(34)\langle\!\langle\mathcal{O}_1(0)\mathcal{O}_1(0)\mathcal{O}_2(0)\rangle\!\rangle_\beta, \tag*{(34)}

where O1\mathcal{O}_1 and O2\mathcal{O}_2 are two scalar primaries holographically dual to scalar fields ϕ1\phi_1 and ϕ2\phi_2, respectively. The conformal dimensions, Δi≡dhi\Delta_i \equiv d h_i, are related to the masses, mim_i, of the dual scalars by the usual relation (1). We consider the bulk action

S[ϕ1,ϕ2]=12∫dd+1xg[∂μϕ1∂μϕ1+∂μϕ2∂μϕ2+m12ϕ12+m22ϕ22+κϕ12ϕ2].(35)S[\phi_1,\phi_2] = \frac{1}{2}\int d^{d+1}x\sqrt{g}\left[\partial_\mu\phi_1\partial^\mu\phi_1+\partial_\mu\phi_2\partial^\mu\phi_2+m_1^2\phi_1^2+m_2^2\phi_2^2+\kappa\phi_1^2\phi_2\right]. \tag*{(35)}

The interaction ϕ12ϕ2\phi_1^2\phi_2 provides a cubic vertex for Witten diagrams. The contact diagram using this vertex sources the three-point function ⟨O1O1O2⟩\langle\mathcal{O}_1\mathcal{O}_1\mathcal{O}_2\rangle, as shown in Figure 2. It evaluates to the bulk integral

⟨ ⁣⟨O1(k1)O1(k2)O2(k3)⟩ ⁣⟩β=−κRd+1∫0z0dzzd+1G1,k1(z)G1,k2(z)G2,k3(z),(36)\langle\!\langle\mathcal{O}_1(k_1)\mathcal{O}_1(k_2)\mathcal{O}_2(k_3)\rangle\!\rangle_\beta=-\kappa R^{d+1}\int_0^{z_0}\frac{dz}{z^{d+1}}G_{1,k_1}(z)G_{1,k_2}(z)G_{2,k_3}(z), \tag*{(36)}

where we have denoted the bulk-boundary propagator of ϕi\phi_i by Gi,k(z)G_{i,k}(z). Using the zero-momentum propagators (13) and changing the integration variable, we express the correlator (34) as

⟨ ⁣⟨O1(0)O1(0)O2(0)⟩ ⁣⟩β=−κz02d−2Δ1−Δ2Rd+12dΓ(h1)4Γ(h2)2Γ(2h1−1)2Γ(2h2−1)×∫1∞dy Ph1−1(y)Ph1−1(y)Ph2−1(y).(37)\langle\!\langle\mathcal{O}_1(0)\mathcal{O}_1(0)\mathcal{O}_2(0)\rangle\!\rangle_\beta= -\frac{\kappa z_0^{2d-2\Delta_1-\Delta_2}R^{d+1}}{2d}\frac{\Gamma(h_1)^4\Gamma(h_2)^2}{\Gamma(2h_1-1)^2\Gamma(2h_2-1)}\times\int_1^\infty\mathrm{d}y\,P_{h_1-1}(y)P_{h_1-1}(y)P_{h_2-1}(y). \tag*{(37)}

Near-boundary behaviour implies that the integral converges for Re⁡(2h1+h2)<2\operatorname{Re}(2h_1+h_2)<2. For other values, we define it by analytic continuation in h1h_1 and h2h_2.

The general formula (28) can be used for (37) by setting a=b=h12−14a=b=\frac{h_1}{2}-\frac{1}{4} and c=h22−14c=\frac{h_2}{2}-\frac{1}{4}. The resulting ratio of Gamma functions can be simplified as follows:

∫1∞dy Ph1−1(y)Ph1−1(y)Ph2−1(y)=18π2Γ(2h1+h2−1)Γ(h1−h22)2Γ(h22)4Γ(h1+h22)2Γ(2h1−h2)Γ(h2)2 S,(38)\int_1^\infty\mathrm{d}y\,P_{h_1-1}(y)P_{h_1-1}(y)P_{h_2-1}(y)=\frac{1}{8\pi^2}\frac{\Gamma(2h_1+h_2-1)\Gamma\left(h_1-\frac{h_2}{2}\right)^2\Gamma\left(\frac{h_2}{2}\right)^4}{\Gamma\left(h_1+\frac{h_2}{2}\right)^2\Gamma(2h_1-h_2)\Gamma(h_2)^2}\,\mathcal{S}, \tag*{(38)}

where we have defined

S=sin⁡2πh1sin⁡πh2sin⁡(π(2h1+h2)2)cos⁡(π(2h1−h2)2)cos⁡2(πh22).(39)\mathcal{S}=\frac{\sin^2\pi h_1\sin\pi h_2}{\sin\left(\frac{\pi(2h_1+h_2)}{2}\right)\cos\left(\frac{\pi(2h_1-h_2)}{2}\right)\cos^2\left(\frac{\pi h_2}{2}\right)}. \tag*{(39)}

Substituting (38) in (37) gives the thermal mixed correlator:

⟨ ⁣⟨O1(0)O1(0)O2(0)⟩ ⁣⟩β=−κz02d−2Δ1−Δ2Rd+116π2dA,(40)\langle\!\langle\mathcal{O}_1(0)\mathcal{O}_1(0)\mathcal{O}_2(0)\rangle\!\rangle_\beta=-\frac{\kappa z_0^{2d-2\Delta_1-\Delta_2}R^{d+1}}{16\pi^2d}\mathcal{A}, \tag*{(40)}

where we have introduced

A=Γ(2h1+h2−1)Γ(h1−h22)2Γ(h22)4Γ(h1)4Γ(h1+h22)2Γ(2h1−h2)Γ(2h1−1)2Γ(2h2−1)S.(41)\mathcal{A}=\frac{\Gamma(2h_1+h_2-1)\Gamma\left(h_1-\frac{h_2}{2}\right)^2\Gamma\left(\frac{h_2}{2}\right)^4\Gamma(h_1)^4}{\Gamma\left(h_1+\frac{h_2}{2}\right)^2\Gamma(2h_1-h_2)\Gamma(2h_1-1)^2\Gamma(2h_2-1)}\mathcal{S}. \tag*{(41)}

Large conformal dimension limit

We wish to analyze the behaviour of the mixed correlator at large Δ1\Delta_1 while holding Δ2\Delta_2 fixed. For generic values of Δ2\Delta_2, the correlator has poles at

Δ1=nd−Δ22andΔ1=(n+12)d+Δ22,(42)\Delta_1=nd-\frac{\Delta_2}{2}\quad\text{and}\quad\Delta_1=\left(n+\frac{1}{2}\right)d+\frac{\Delta_2}{2}, \tag*{(42)}

where nn is an integer such that the BF bound, Δ1≥d2\Delta_1\ge\frac{d}{2}, is satisfied. As before, we avoid the poles by taking the limit along a ray in the lower half of the complex plane, Δ1→∞(1−iϵ)\Delta_1\to\infty(1-i\epsilon). The expansion of the mixed correlator begins as

⟨ ⁣⟨O1(0)O1(0)O2(0)⟩ ⁣⟩β∼2−4h1(1−q12(2+q2−1−q2)+O(q14)),(43)\langle\!\langle\mathcal{O}_1(0)\mathcal{O}_1(0)\mathcal{O}_2(0)\rangle\!\rangle_\beta\sim2^{-4h_1}\left(1-q_1^2(2+q_2^{-1}-q_2)+O(q_1^4)\right), \tag*{(43)}

where we have defined

qi=e−iπhi=e−iΔiπd.(44)q_i = e^{-i\pi h_i} = e^{-i\Delta_i\frac{\pi}{d}}. \tag*{(44)}

Identifying the geometric quantities (23) and (24), we write

⟨⟨O1(0)O1(0)O2(0)⟩⟩β∼e−2m1ℓh(1−e−2im1τs(2+q2−1−q2)+O(e−4im1τs)).(45)\langle\langle\mathcal{O}_1(0)\mathcal{O}_1(0)\mathcal{O}_2(0)\rangle\rangle_\beta\sim e^{-2m_1\ell_h}\left(1-e^{-2im_1\tau_s}\left(2+q_2^{-1}-q_2\right)+O\left(e^{-4im_1\tau_s}\right)\right). \tag*{(45)}

We see that the thermal mixed correlator also contains a signature of the black hole singularity. The precise form (45) differs from the one suggested in [4], where the expected form was e−2m1(ℓh+iτs)e^{-2m_1(\ell_h+i\tau_s)}.

d=2d = 2 CFT

In d=2d = 2, thermal correlators on Sβ1×RS^1_\beta\times\mathbb{R} follow from the vacuum ones on the plane by a conformal map; see equation (46). The functional form of the two- and three-point correlators on the plane can be fixed completely using conformal symmetry. Moreover, the remaining data — normalization and three-point OPE coefficients — can be computed for a holographic theory using bulk Witten diagrams in the vacuum AdS geometry. Momentum-space thermal three-point functions in two dimensions were previously computed in [38] with Lorentzian ordering prescriptions. Here, we evaluate the zero-momentum Euclidean correlators, providing a separate check of the bulk formulas.

Let ξ=σ+iτ\xi= \sigma+ i\tau, ξˉ=σ−iτ\bar{\xi} = \sigma- i\tau be coordinates on the cylinder Sβ1×RS^1_\beta\times\mathbb{R}, with σ∈R\sigma\in\mathbb{R} and τ∼τ+β\tau\sim\tau+ \beta. The conformal map

z=exp⁡(2πβξ),zˉ=exp⁡(2πβξˉ)(46)z = \exp\left(\frac{2\pi}{\beta}\xi\right), \qquad\bar{z} = \exp\left(\frac{2\pi}{\beta}\bar{\xi}\right) \tag*{(46)}

takes the cylinder to the complex plane C\{0}\mathbb{C}\backslash\{0\}.5 A primary O\mathcal{O} with conformal weights (h,hˉ)(h,\bar{h}) transforms under the map (46) as:

O(ξ(z),ξˉ(zˉ))=(∂z∂ξ)h(∂zˉ∂ξˉ)hˉO(z,zˉ)=(2πβ)h+hˉzhzˉhˉO(z,zˉ).(47)\mathcal{O}(\xi(z),\bar{\xi}(\bar{z})) = \left(\frac{\partial z}{\partial\xi}\right)^h\left(\frac{\partial\bar{z}}{\partial\bar{\xi}}\right)^{\bar{h}}\mathcal{O}(z,\bar{z}) = \left(\frac{2\pi}{\beta}\right)^{h+\bar{h}}z^h\bar{z}^{\bar{h}}\mathcal{O}(z,\bar{z}). \tag*{(47)}

We now restrict to primaries with equal holomorphic and antiholomorphic weights: h=hˉ=Δ2h = \bar{h} = \frac{\Delta}{2}, where, for a holographic theory, Δ\Delta is given by (1). Further, we will use the compact notation O(z)≡O(z,zˉ)\mathcal{O}(z) \equiv\mathcal{O}(z,\bar{z}) and O(ξ)≡O(ξ,ξˉ)\mathcal{O}(\xi) \equiv\mathcal{O}(\xi,\bar{\xi}) for operators on the plane and cylinder, respectively.

Two-point function

We start with the vacuum two-point function of O\mathcal{O} on the plane, which, by conformal invariance, is given by

⟨O(z1)O(z2)⟩=CO∣z12∣4h.(48)\langle\mathcal{O}(z_1)\mathcal{O}(z_2)\rangle= \frac{C_{\mathcal{O}}}{\lvert z_{12}\rvert^{4h}} . \tag*{(48)}

where z12≡z1−z2z_{12} \equiv z_1-z_2. For a holographic theory, the normalization COC_{\mathcal{O}} of the two-point function can be computed using the bulk-boundary propagator in vacuum AdS [32 equation (96)]:

CO=2Rπ(2h−1)2.(49)C_{\mathcal{O}} = \frac{2R}{\pi}(2h-1)^2 . \tag*{(49)}

Applying the conformal transformation (47) to (48) gives the thermal two-point function in position space:

⟨O(ξ1)O(ξ2)⟩β=CO(2πβ)2Δ∣z1∣2h∣z2∣2h∣z12∣4h.(50)\langle\mathcal{O}(\xi_1)\mathcal{O}(\xi_2)\rangle_\beta= C_{\mathcal{O}}\left(\frac{2\pi}{\beta}\right)^{2\Delta}\frac{\lvert z_1\rvert^{2h}\lvert z_2\rvert^{2h}}{\lvert z_{12}\rvert^{4h}} . \tag*{(50)}

While this expression can be further simplified to [33]

⟨O(ξ1)O(ξ2)⟩β=CO(2πβ)2Δ∣2sinh⁡(πβξ12)∣4h,(51)\langle\mathcal{O}(\xi_1)\mathcal{O}(\xi_2)\rangle_\beta= \frac{C_{\mathcal{O}}\left(\frac{2\pi}{\beta}\right)^{2\Delta}}{\left\lvert2\sinh\left(\frac{\pi}{\beta}\xi_{12}\right)\right\rvert^{4h}} , \tag*{(51)}

with ξ12≡ξ1−ξ2\xi_{12} \equiv\xi_1-\xi_2, we will find it more convenient to work with (50).

The translation symmetry on the cylinder allows us to define the reduced Fourier space thermal two-point function

⟨⟨O(ω,k)O(−ω,−k)⟩⟩β=∫d2ξ e−i(ωτ+kσ)⟨O(ξ)O(0)⟩β,(52)\langle\langle\mathcal{O}(\omega,k)\mathcal{O}(-\omega,-k)\rangle\rangle_\beta= \int d^2\xi\,e^{-i(\omega\tau+k\sigma)}\langle\mathcal{O}(\xi)\mathcal{O}(0)\rangle_\beta, \tag*{(52)}

where d2ξ≡dσdτd^2\xi\equiv d\sigma d\tau. Recall that we are interested in thermal correlators at vanishing momenta. Substituting (50) into (52) and using the change of variables (46) from ξ\xi to zz gives

⟨⟨O(0)O(0)⟩⟩β=CO(2πβ)2Δ−2∫d2z ∣z∣2h−2∣1−z∣−4h,(53)\langle\langle\mathcal{O}(0)\mathcal{O}(0)\rangle\rangle_\beta= C_{\mathcal{O}}\left(\frac{2\pi}{\beta}\right)^{2\Delta-2}\int d^2z\,\lvert z\rvert^{2h-2}\lvert1-z\rvert^{-4h} , \tag*{(53)}

where d2z≡dRe⁡(z)dIm⁡(z)d^{2}z \equiv d\operatorname{Re}(z)d\operatorname{Im}(z). The integral in (53) is an instance of the complex Selberg integral [39], also sometimes referred to as the Dotsenko–Fateev integral [40]:

SnC(α,β;γ)=∫∏k=1nd2zk ∣zk∣2α−2∣1−zk∣2β−2∏1≤k<l≤n∣zk−zl∣4γ.(54)S_n^{\mathrm{C}}(\alpha,\beta;\gamma)=\int\prod_{k=1}^{n}d^{2}z_k\,|z_k|^{2\alpha-2}|1-z_k|^{2\beta-2}\prod_{1\leq k<l\leq n}|z_k-z_l|^{4\gamma}. \tag*{(54)}

The general formula for SnC(α,β;γ)S_n^{\mathrm{C}}(\alpha,\beta;\gamma) can be written as [41, 42]

SnC(α,β;γ)=n!∏j=0n−1[sin⁡(π(α+jγ))sin⁡(π(β+jγ))sin⁡(π(j+1)γ)sin⁡(π(α+β+(n+j−1)γ))sin⁡(πγ)(Γ(α+jγ)Γ(β+jγ)Γ((j+1)γ)Γ(α+β+(n+j−1)γ)Γ(γ))2].(55)S_n^{\mathrm{C}}(\alpha,\beta;\gamma)=n!\prod_{j=0}^{n-1}\left[\frac{\sin(\pi(\alpha+j\gamma))\sin(\pi(\beta+j\gamma))\sin(\pi(j+1)\gamma)}{\sin(\pi(\alpha+\beta+(n+j-1)\gamma))\sin(\pi\gamma)}\left(\frac{\Gamma(\alpha+j\gamma)\Gamma(\beta+j\gamma)\Gamma((j+1)\gamma)}{\Gamma(\alpha+\beta+(n+j-1)\gamma)\Gamma(\gamma)}\right)^{2}\right]. \tag*{(55)}

The defining integral (54) is convergent in a “narrow domain” [41, 42], but the result (55) in terms of the Gamma and trigonometric functions can be analytically continued to all complex parameter values.

The complex Selberg integral relevant for the thermal two-point function (53) is S1C(h,1−2h;γ)S_1^{\mathrm{C}}(h,1-2h;\gamma).6 Using the general formula (55), its value is given by

S1C(h,1−2h;γ)=(Γ(h)Γ(2h))2sin⁡2πhsin⁡(2πh),(56)S_1^{\mathrm{C}}(h,1-2h;\gamma)=\left(\frac{\Gamma(h)}{\Gamma(2h)}\right)^{2}\frac{\sin^{2}\pi h}{\sin(2\pi h)}, \tag*{(56)}

where we have used the reflection formula to simplify the expression. Substituting the formula back into (53) and using the holographic value (49) for the normalization gives

⟨ ⁣⟨O(0)O(0)⟩ ⁣⟩β=2Rπ(2πβ)2Δ−2(Γ(h)Γ(2h−1))2sin⁡2πhsin⁡(2πh).(57)\langle\!\langle O(0)O(0)\rangle\!\rangle_{\beta}=\frac{2R}{\pi}\left(\frac{2\pi}{\beta}\right)^{2\Delta-2}\left(\frac{\Gamma(h)}{\Gamma(2h-1)}\right)^{2}\frac{\sin^{2}\pi h}{\sin(2\pi h)}. \tag*{(57)}

This precisely matches the gravity result (19) for d=2d=2, in which case the black brane radius is related to the inverse temperature by z0=β2πz_0=\frac{\beta}{2\pi}.

Three-point function

We now turn to the three-point function of the primary OO. Again, by conformal invariance, the vacuum three-point correlator on the plane takes the form

⟨O(z1)O(z2)O(z3)⟩=COOO∣z12∣2h∣z23∣2h∣z13∣2h.(58)\langle O(z_1)O(z_2)O(z_3)\rangle=\frac{C_{OOO}}{|z_{12}|^{2h}|z_{23}|^{2h}|z_{13}|^{2h}}. \tag*{(58)}

where zij=zi−zjz_{ij}=z_i-z_j. The factor COOO\mathcal{C}_{\mathcal{O}\mathcal{O}\mathcal{O}} is related to the OPE coefficient of the operator O\mathcal{O}. For a holographic theory, it can be computed in the semiclassical limit by bulk perturbation theory in the vacuum AdS geometry. The vacuum contact Witten diagram (with the same schematic form as Figure 1) corresponding to a cubic interaction of bulk scalars was computed in [32]. Specializing their formula [32 equation (25)] to the self-interacting scalar in d=2d=2 gives

COOO=−λR32π2Γ(3h−1)Γ(h)3Γ(2h−1)3.(59)\mathcal{C}_{\mathcal{O}\mathcal{O}\mathcal{O}}=-\frac{\lambda R^3}{2\pi^2}\frac{\Gamma(3h-1)\Gamma(h)^3}{\Gamma(2h-1)^3}. \tag*{(59)}

We apply the conformal transformation (47) to (58) to obtain the thermal three-point function in position space:

⟨O(ξ1)O(ξ2)O(ξ3)⟩β=COOO(2πβ)3Δ∣z1∣2h∣z2∣2h∣z3∣2h∣z12∣2h∣z23∣2h∣z13∣2h.(60)\left\langle\mathcal{O}(\xi_1)\mathcal{O}(\xi_2)\mathcal{O}(\xi_3)\right\rangle_\beta=\mathcal{C}_{\mathcal{O}\mathcal{O}\mathcal{O}}\left(\frac{2\pi}{\beta}\right)^{3\Delta}\frac{|z_1|^{2h}|z_2|^{2h}|z_3|^{2h}}{|z_{12}|^{2h}|z_{23}|^{2h}|z_{13}|^{2h}}. \tag*{(60)}

This formula can be expressed as

⟨O(ξ1)O(ξ2)O(ξ3)⟩β=COOO(2πβ)3Δ∣2sinh⁡(πβξ12)∣2h∣2sinh⁡(πβξ23)∣2h∣2sinh⁡(πβξ13)∣2h,(61)\left\langle\mathcal{O}(\xi_1)\mathcal{O}(\xi_2)\mathcal{O}(\xi_3)\right\rangle_\beta=\frac{\mathcal{C}_{\mathcal{O}\mathcal{O}\mathcal{O}}\left(\frac{2\pi}{\beta}\right)^{3\Delta}}{\left|2\sinh\left(\frac{\pi}{\beta}\xi_{12}\right)\right|^{2h}\left|2\sinh\left(\frac{\pi}{\beta}\xi_{23}\right)\right|^{2h}\left|2\sinh\left(\frac{\pi}{\beta}\xi_{13}\right)\right|^{2h}}, \tag*{(61)}

with ξij=ξi−ξj\xi_{ij}=\xi_i-\xi_j, but it is easier to work with (60) when taking the Fourier transform.

The reduced Fourier space thermal three-point function is defined as

⟨ ⁣⟨O(ω1,k1)O(ω2,k2)O(ω3,k3)⟩ ⁣⟩β=∫d2ξ1d2ξ2 e−i(ω1τ1+k1σ1+ω2τ2+k2σ2)×⟨O(ξ1)O(ξ2)O(0)⟩β.(62)\begin{aligned} \left\langle\!\left\langle\mathcal{O}(\omega_1,k_1)\mathcal{O}(\omega_2,k_2)\mathcal{O}(\omega_3,k_3)\right\rangle\!\right\rangle_\beta &=\int d^2\xi_1d^2\xi_2\,e^{-i(\omega_1\tau_1+k_1\sigma_1+\omega_2\tau_2+k_2\sigma_2)}\\ &\qquad\times\left\langle\mathcal{O}(\xi_1)\mathcal{O}(\xi_2)\mathcal{O}(0)\right\rangle_\beta. \tag*{(62)} \end{aligned}

For vanishing momenta, we get

⟨ ⁣⟨O(0)O(0)O(0)⟩ ⁣⟩β=COOO(2πβ)3Δ−4×∫d2z1d2z2 ∣z1∣2h−2∣z2∣2h−2∣1−z1∣−2h∣1−z2∣−2h∣z1−z2∣−2h.(63)\begin{aligned} \left\langle\!\left\langle\mathcal{O}(0)\mathcal{O}(0)\mathcal{O}(0)\right\rangle\!\right\rangle_\beta &=\mathcal{C}_{\mathcal{O}\mathcal{O}\mathcal{O}}\left(\frac{2\pi}{\beta}\right)^{3\Delta-4}\\ &\quad\times\int d^2z_1d^2z_2\,|z_1|^{2h-2}|z_2|^{2h-2}|1-z_1|^{-2h}|1-z_2|^{-2h}|z_1-z_2|^{-2h}. \tag*{(63)} \end{aligned}

The above integral is the complex Selberg integral S2C(h,1−h;−h/2)S_2^{\mathbb{C}}(h,1-h;-h/2). Specializing the general formula (55) to this case and using the reflection identity for the Gamma function, we obtain

S2C(h,1−h;−h/2)=12Γ(h2)6Γ(3h2)2sin⁡3(πh2)sin⁡(3πh2).(64)S_2^{\mathbb{C}}(h,1-h;-h/2)=\frac{1}{2}\frac{\Gamma\left(\frac{h}{2}\right)^6}{\Gamma\left(\frac{3h}{2}\right)^2}\frac{\sin^3\left(\frac{\pi h}{2}\right)}{\sin\left(\frac{3\pi h}{2}\right)}. \tag*{(64)}

Substituting the formula back into (63) and using the holographic value (59) for COOOC_{\mathcal{O}\mathcal{O}\mathcal{O}} gives the thermal three-point function

⟨⟨O(0)O(0)O(0)⟩⟩β=−κR34π2(2πβ)3Δ−4Γ(3h−1)Γ(h)3Γ(h2)6sin⁡3(πh2)Γ(2h−1)3Γ(3h2)2sin⁡(3πh2)(65)\langle\langle\mathcal{O}(0)\mathcal{O}(0)\mathcal{O}(0)\rangle\rangle_{\beta}=-\frac{\kappa R^{3}}{4\pi^{2}}\left(\frac{2\pi}{\beta}\right)^{3\Delta-4}\frac{\Gamma(3h-1)\Gamma(h)^{3}\Gamma\left(\frac{h}{2}\right)^{6}\sin^{3}\left(\frac{\pi h}{2}\right)}{\Gamma(2h-1)^{3}\Gamma\left(\frac{3h}{2}\right)^{2}\sin\left(\frac{3\pi h}{2}\right)} \tag*{(65)}

This is in precise agreement with the gravity result (30) for d=2d=2 and z0=β2πz_{0}=\frac{\beta}{2\pi}.

Mixed correlator

We now repeat the CFT calculation for the mixed three-point function (34). Conformal invariance fixes the vacuum form to

⟨O1(z1)O1(z2)O2(z3)⟩=C112∣z12∣4h1−2h2∣z13∣2h2∣z23∣2h2(66)\langle\mathcal{O}_{1}(z_{1})\mathcal{O}_{1}(z_{2})\mathcal{O}_{2}(z_{3})\rangle=\frac{C_{112}}{|z_{12}|^{4h_{1}-2h_{2}}|z_{13}|^{2h_{2}}|z_{23}|^{2h_{2}}} \tag*{(66)}

where the vacuum contact diagram for the interaction in (35) gives [32]

C112=−κR32π2Γ(2h1+h2−1)Γ(2h1−h2)Γ(h2)2Γ(2h1−1)2Γ(2h2−1)(67)C_{112}=-\frac{\kappa R^{3}}{2\pi^{2}}\frac{\Gamma(2h_{1}+h_{2}-1)\Gamma(2h_{1}-h_{2})\Gamma(h_{2})^{2}}{\Gamma(2h_{1}-1)^{2}\Gamma(2h_{2}-1)} \tag*{(67)}

Applying (47) gives the thermal correlator. Its zero-momentum Fourier transform, as before, is given by a complex Selberg integral:

⟨⟨O1(0)O1(0)O2(0)⟩⟩β=C112(2πβ)2Δ1+Δ2−4S2C(h1,1−h2;h2/2−h1).(68)\langle\langle\mathcal{O}_{1}(0)\mathcal{O}_{1}(0)\mathcal{O}_{2}(0)\rangle\rangle_{\beta}=C_{112}\left(\frac{2\pi}{\beta}\right)^{2\Delta_{1}+\Delta_{2}-4}\mathcal{S}_{2}^{\mathbb{C}}\left(h_{1},1-h_{2};h_{2}/2-h_{1}\right). \tag*{(68)}

Using (55) and the reflection formula gives

S2C(h1,1−h2;h2/2−h1)=116Γ(h1)4Γ(h1−h22)2Γ(h22)4Γ(h1+h22)2Γ(2h1−h2)2Γ(h2)2S,(69)\mathcal{S}_{2}^{\mathbb{C}}\left(h_{1},1-h_{2};h_{2}/2-h_{1}\right)=\frac{1}{16}\frac{\Gamma(h_{1})^{4}\Gamma\left(h_{1}-\frac{h_{2}}{2}\right)^{2}\Gamma\left(\frac{h_{2}}{2}\right)^{4}}{\Gamma\left(h_{1}+\frac{h_{2}}{2}\right)^{2}\Gamma(2h_{1}-h_{2})^{2}\Gamma(h_{2})^{2}}\mathcal{S}, \tag*{(69)}

with S\mathcal{S} defined in (39). Combining the result with (67), we find

⟨⟨O1(0)O1(0)O2(0)⟩⟩β=−κR332π2(2πβ)2Δ1+Δ2−4A,(70)\langle\langle\mathcal{O}_{1}(0)\mathcal{O}_{1}(0)\mathcal{O}_{2}(0)\rangle\rangle_{\beta}=-\frac{\kappa R^{3}}{32\pi^{2}}\left(\frac{2\pi}{\beta}\right)^{2\Delta_{1}+\Delta_{2}-4}\mathcal{A}, \tag*{(70)}

where A\mathcal{A} is given in (41). This precisely reproduces (40) at d=2d=2 and z0=β2πz_{0}=\frac{\beta}{2\pi}.

Discussion

We have computed thermal two- and three-point correlators at vanishing external momenta in the black brane background. The two-point function follows from the normalizable coefficient of the exact bulk-boundary propagator, while the contact three-point diagrams reduce to integrals of three Legendre functions. These integrals give closed-form expressions both for identical scalar primaries and for the mixed correlator with two identical operators and a third of arbitrary dimension. The results are exact in the operator dimensions and temperature at the bulk orders considered: the free two-point function and the tree-level three-point contributions. In d=2d=2, we independently reproduced all three expressions by mapping vacuum CFT correlators to the thermal cylinder and evaluating their zero-momentum Fourier transforms as complex Selberg integrals.

We identified the poles arising from the trigonometric dependence of the zero-momentum thermal correlators on the operator dimension. These poles are isolated on the positive real axis. Analogous poles were seen in the thermal one-point function in the black brane background [5, 6].7 Those poles were interpreted, in the semiclassical large-NN limit, as a consequence of enhanced operator mixing at resonant values of the operator dimension. It would be interesting to develop a similar interpretation of the poles in higher-point thermal correlators.

By analytically continuing the conformal dimension to the lower half of the complex plane, we analyzed the large conformal dimension behaviour of the thermal correlators. We showed that their asymptotic forms encode geometric information about the black hole, including a signature of its singularity. More precisely, the leading exponential mass dependence is e−2mℓhe^{-2m\ell_h} for the two-point function and e−3mℓhe^{-3m\ell_h} for the three-point function, where ℓh\ell_h is the regularized geodesic distance between the horizon and the asymptotic boundary. The proper time to singularity, τs\tau_s, appears through powers of e−imτse^{-im\tau_s} in the subleading exponential terms.

The exact three-point result for identical primaries disagrees with the leading form e−3m(ℓh+iτs)e^{-3m(\ell_h+i\tau_s)} predicted in [4 equation (4.7)] for the continued zero-momentum contact contribution. The earlier calculation retained the WKB prefactors and included a family of complex saddles near the singularity, but left the horizon endpoint contribution uncontrolled because the WKB approximation breaks down there. The discrepancy may arise from this endpoint contribution as well as from an incomplete account of the relevant saddles and their contributions. The present calculation does not show how to repair the failure of the WKB calculation in the higher-point function, nor does it explain why the one-point saddle calculation succeeds. However, the asymptotic expansion constrains how the proper time to the singularity enters: the leading exponential depends only on the boundary-to-horizon length, and terms of the form e−3lIm⁡τse^{-3l\operatorname{Im}\tau_s} are absent for every positive integer ll. An exact WKB analysis [43, 44] is a natural next step to address these questions.8

Acknowledgments

I am grateful to Justin R. David for important comments and prompt feedback on the original calculations. I thank R. Loganayagam for several discussions on this work. I also thank Saikat Ghosh, Ashoke Sen, Spenta Wadia, and the rest of the ICTS string group for various interactions during the course of this work. I acknowledge support from the Department of Atomic Energy, Government of India, under project no. RTI4019.

Statement on AI use. I used ChatGPT for some editing, figures, typesetting, and verification of certain claims in this work. The manuscript was written by me and I take full responsibility for any errors.

References

  1. [1]J.M. Maldacena, The Large N limit of superconformal field theories and supergravity, Adv. Theor. Math. Phys. 2 (1998) 231 [hep-th/9711200].
  2. [2]S.S. Gubser, I.R. Klebanov and A.M. Polyakov, Gauge theory correlators from noncritical string theory, Phys. Lett. B 428 (1998) 105 [hep-th/9802109].DOI
  3. [3]E. Witten, Anti de Sitter space and holography, Adv. Theor. Math. Phys. 2 (1998) 253 [hep-th/9802150].arxiv.org/abs/hep-th/9802150
  4. [4]K. Singhi, Proper time to the singularity and thermal correlators, Phys. Rev. D 112 (2025) 106011 [2406.08553].DOI
  5. [5]D. Berenstein and R. Mancilla, Aspects of thermal one-point functions and response functions in AdS black holes, Phys. Rev. D 107 (2023) 126010 [2211.05144].DOI
  6. [6]M. Grinberg and J. Maldacena, Proper time to the black hole singularity from thermal one-point functions, JHEP 03 (2021) 131 [2011.01004].
  7. [7]J.R. David and S. Kumar, Thermal one point functions, large d and interior geometry of black holes, JHEP 03 (2023) 256 [2212.07758].DOI
  8. [8]D. Rodriguez-Gomez and J.G. Russo, Correlation functions in finite temperature CFT and black hole singularities, JHEP 06 (2021) 048 [2102.11891].
  9. [9]H. Krishna and D. Rodriguez-Gomez, Holographic thermal correlators revisited, JHEP 11 (2021) 139 [2108.00277].DOI
  10. [10]P. Kraus, H. Ooguri and S. Shenker, Inside the horizon with AdS / CFT, Phys. Rev. D 67 (2003) 124022 [hep-th/0212277].DOI
  11. [11]L. Fidkowski, V. Hubeny, M. Kleban and S. Shenker, The Black hole singularity in AdS / CFT, JHEP 02 (2004) 014 [hep-th/0306170].
  12. [12]G. Festuccia and H. Liu, Excursions beyond the horizon: Black hole singularities in Yang-Mills theories. I., JHEP 04 (2006) 044 [hep-th/0506202].
  13. [13]N. Čepļak, H. Liu, A. Parnachev and S. Valach, Black Hole Singularity from OPE, JHEP 10 (2024) 105 [2404.17286].arxiv.org/abs/2404.17286
  14. [14]H.F. Jia and M. Rangamani, Exact holographic thermal spectral functions: OPE, non-perturbative corrections, and black hole singularity, 2604.10803.
  15. [15]N. Afkhami-Jeddi, S. Caron-Huot, J. Chakravarty and A. Maloney, Imprint of the black hole singularity on thermal two-point functions, Phys. Rev. D 114 (2026) 025005 [2510.21673].
  16. [16]S. Giombi, Y.-Z. Li and J. Shan, Bouncing singularities and thermal correlators on line defects, JHEP 07 (2026) 170 [2603.11012].
  17. [17]G. Festuccia and H. Liu, A Bohr-Sommerfeld quantization formula for quasinormal frequencies of AdS black holes, Adv. Sci. Lett. 2 (2009) 221 [0811.1033].DOI
  18. [18]P. Arnaudo and B. Withers, Bouncing singularities in Schwarzschild: a geometric origin of the QNM convergence region, 2605.16489.arxiv.org/abs/2605.16489
  19. [19]G.T. Horowitz, H. Leung, L. Queimada and Y. Zhao, Boundary signature of singularity in the presence of a shock wave, SciPost Phys. 16 (2024) 060 [2310.03076].DOI
  20. [20]N. Čepļak, H. Liu, A. Parnachev and S. Valach, Fooling the censor: going beyond inner horizons with the OPE, JHEP 05 (2026) 001 [2511.09638].arxiv.org/abs/2511.09638
  21. [21]S. Ali Ahmad, A. Almheiri and S. Lin, Continuing past the inner horizon using WKB, 2601.02354.arxiv.org/abs/2601.02354
  22. [22]J. Chakravarty and Y. Zిగdon, A signature of the timelike singularity in holography, 2610.30134.arxiv.org/abs/2610.30134
  23. [23]J. Chakravarty, Imprint of black hole interior on thermal four-point correlators, JHEP 09 (2026) 034 [2512.10912].arxiv.org/abs/2512.10912
  24. [24]M. Dodelson, C. Iossa and R. Karlsson, Bouncing off a stringy singularity, JHEP 07 (2026) 161 [2511.09616].
  25. [25]I. Burić, C.-M. Chang, I. Gusev, E. Helfenberger, A. Parnachev and M. Rangamani, Thermal two-point functions in SYK and complex-time singularities, 2607.05258.arxiv.org/abs/2607.05258
  26. [26]I. Burić, I. Gusev and A. Parnachev, Stringy resolution of bouncing singularities, 2610.12311.arxiv.org/abs/2610.12311
  27. [27]Z. Komargodski, Fate of Bouncing Singularities at Finite G_N, 2609.31309.arxiv.org/abs/2609.31309
  28. [28]G. Batra, A. Levine and S.H. Shenker, A backreacted bouncing geodesic in 2D, 2609.32071.arxiv.org/abs/2609.32071
  29. [29]M. Liu and S.-M. Ruan, Smoothing the Bouncing-Geodesic Singularity in AdS/CFT, 2611.03347.arxiv.org/abs/2611.03347
  30. [30]A. Bzowski, P. McFadden and K. Skenderis, Implications of conformal invariance in momentum space, JHEP 03 (2014) 111 [1304.7760].
  31. [31]A. Yarom, Notes on the bulk viscosity of holographic gauge theory plasmas, JHEP 04 (2010) 024 [0912.2100].DOI
  32. [32]D.Z. Freedman, S.D. Mathur, A. Matusis and L. Rastelli, Correlation functions in the CFT(d) / AdS(d+1) correspondence, Nucl. Phys. B 546 (1999) 96 [hep-th/9804058].DOI
  33. [33]D.T. Son and A.O. Starinets, Minkowski space correlators in AdS / CFT correspondence: Recipe and applications, JHEP 09 (2002) 042 [hep-th/0205051].
  34. [34]K. Skenderis, Lecture notes on holographic renormalization, Class. Quant. Grav. 19 (2002) 5849 [hep-th/0209067].DOI
  35. [35]“NIST Digital Library of Mathematical Functions.” https://dlmf.nist.gov/, Release 1.2.4 of 2025-03-15.
  36. [36]J. Bros, H. Epstein, M. Gaudin, U. Moschella and V. Pasquier, Triangular invariants, three-point functions and particle stability on the de Sitter universe, Commun. Math. Phys. 295 (2010) 261 [0901.4223].DOI
  37. [37]P. Breitenlohner and D.Z. Freedman, Positive energy in anti-de Sitter backgrounds and gauged extended supergravity, Physics Letters B 115 (1982) 197.DOI
  38. [38]M. Becker, Y. Cabrera and N. Su, Finite-temperature three-point function in 2D CFT, JHEP 09 (2014) 157 [1407.3415].
  39. [39]K. Aomoto, On the complex Selberg integral, Quart. J. Math. Oxford Ser. (2) 38 (1987) 385.
  40. [40]V.S. Dotsenko and V.A. Fateev, Four-point correlation functions and the operator algebra in 2D conformal invariant theories with central charge C ≤ 1, Nucl. Phys. B 251 (1985) 691.DOI
  41. [41]P.J. Forrester and S.O. Warnaar, The importance of the Selberg integral, Bull. Amer. Math. Soc. (N.S.) 45 (2008) 489 [0710.3981].arxiv.org/abs/0710.3981
  42. [42]Y.A. Neretin, On the Dotsenko–Fateev complex twin of the Selberg integral and its extensions, Ramanujan J. (2023) [2212.09112].DOI
  43. [43]T. Kawai and Y. Takei, Algebraic Analysis of Singular Perturbation Theory, Iwanami series in modern mathematics, American Mathematical Society (2005).
  44. [44]K. Iwaki and T. Nakanishi, Exact WKB analysis and cluster algebras, J. Phys. A 47 (2014) 474009 [1401.7094].arxiv.org/abs/1401.7094

Paper details

vlnc:W_m3z2wd2v
Version
v1 · latest
Published
Fresh — added to the Hub within the last 30 days
Added
License
CC BY 4.0
Usage

views · 0

downloads · 0

A view counts once per browser per day, a download each time the PDF is requested.

  • Physics and Astronomy

ChatGPT

View statement
Looking for related papers…
Contents