betaFeedback

WorksPhysics and Astronomy

Correlations between Dynamical Dark Energy and Neutrino Parameters

Abstract

Recent Baryon Acoustic Oscillation (BAO) data from the Dark Energy Spectroscopic Instrument (DESI), fitted jointly with Cosmic Microwave Background (CMB) and Type Ia Supernovae (SNe) data, favor dynamical dark energy (DDE) over the standard ΛΛCDM model. In this work, we investigate whether the mass and degeneracy of relic neutrinos are degenerate with DDE parameters and can also account for this statistical deviation from ΛΛCDM. Using a Markov Chain Monte Carlo (MCMC) analysis of a joint Planck CMB temperature, DESI BAO, and Pantheon+ dataset, we show a robust parameter degeneracy between the DDE equation of state and neutrino physics. We supplement this with a semi-analytical framework that recovers the numerical correlation, showing that the tight constraint on the CMB acoustic scale drives this degeneracy. Our results highlight the clear correlation between DDE and neutrino parameters, underscoring the critical need to jointly constrain the neutrino sector and the dark sector in next-generation cosmological surveys.

INTRODUCTION

The Lambda cold dark matter (Λ\LambdaCDM) model is one of the most successful cosmological models in describing the cosmic microwave background (CMB) anisotropy and large-scale structure [3, 4, 1, 5, 22, 23]. However, recently, dynamical dark energy (DDE) models, such as the Chevallier-Polarski-Linder (CPL) parametrization of the dark energy (DE) equation of state (EoS), PΛ=[w0+(1−a)wa]ρΛP_{\Lambda} = [w_0 + (1-a)w_a]\rho_{\Lambda} [10, 21], received renewed attention [15, 16, 11] (G. Gu et al. 2025) since deviations from the Λ\LambdaCDM values of (w0,wa)=(−1,0)(w_0,w_a)=(-1,0) at 2.8−4.2σ2.8 - 4.2\sigma is found when fitted with Dark Energy Spectroscopic Instrument (DESI)’s latest baryon acoustic oscillation (BAO) data with CMB and different Type-IA supernovae (SNe) datasets [2], hinting at physics beyond Λ\LambdaCDM. However, before interpreting such a deviation as evidence for DDE, it is important to examine whether DDE parameters could be degenerate with extensions in other cosmological sectors, which may explain the deviation.

A simple extension of Λ\LambdaCDM model without introducing new physics is to allow finite neutrino masses and chemical potentials, namely the Λ\LambdaCDMξ\xi model [27, 28]. Neutrino oscillation experiments provided a lower bound of the total neutrino mass Mν≡∑imνi>0.058M_{\nu} \equiv\sum_i m_{\nu_i} > 0.058 eV (0.098 eV) for Normal (Inverted) Hierarchy, where mνim_{\nu_i} is the iith mass eigenvalue [14]. We define neutrino degeneracy ξν≡μν/Tν\xi_{\nu} \equiv\mu_{\nu}/T_{\nu}, where μν\mu_{\nu} and TνT_{\nu} are relic neutrino chemical potential and temperature, respectively. Although ξν\xi_{\nu} is tightly constrained to be ≲1\lesssim1 by Big Bang Nucleosynthesis (BBN) data due to its direct impact on the weak interaction rates governing the neutron-to-proton ratio [9, 13, 12], ξντ∼O(1)\xi_{\nu_{\tau}} \sim\mathcal{O}(1) is still allowed [27, 30, 6]. Galaxy pairwise velocity measurement also suggests the degeneracy of the third neutrino mass eigenstate, ξν3∼1\xi_{\nu_3} \sim1 [29]. Incorporating MνM_{\nu} and ξν3\xi_{\nu_3} in the Λ\LambdaCDM model has been shown to successfully resolve the H0H_0 and S8S_8 tensions when confronted with CMB temperature and lensing, BAO and weak lensing datasets (namely TTBW), showing a ∼3σ\sim3\sigma preference for both

Email: [email protected], [email protected], [email protected] Mν=0.57−0.13+0.17 eVM_\nu= 0.57^{+0.17}_{-0.13}\ \mathrm{eV} and ξν3=1.13−0.19+0.41\xi_{\nu3} = 1.13^{+0.41}_{-0.19} [28] over Planck Λ\LambdaCDM’s values of Mν=0.06 eVM_\nu= 0.06\ \mathrm{eV} and ξν3=0\xi_{\nu3} = 0, though the preference for non-zero MνM_\nu and ξν3\xi_{\nu3} is weakened when CMB polarization data is included.

Both neutrino mass and chemical potential modify the neutrino energy density and hence the cosmic expansion history. Their effects on cosmological observables can therefore be degenerate with those induced by DDE. This raises the question of whether the apparent DE variation could partially be attributed to the effects of relic neutrinos instead. If so, characteristic correlations between (Mν,ξν3)(M_\nu, \xi_{\nu3}) and DE parameters, (w0,wa)(w_0, w_a), are expected when both sectors are allowed to vary simultaneously. We demonstrate below such a degeneracy and show the origin of the correlations between these parameters.

This paper is organized as follows. In § 2, we first describe the Λ\LambdaCDMξ\xi and DDE models, and the setup for running Markov Chain Monte Carlo (MCMC) analyses. We then present the MCMC result in § 3, which is studied with a semi-analytical approach detailed in Appendix § 6. We summarize our findings in § 4.

METHODOLOGY

After decoupling, relic neutrinos remain in the mass eigenstates as time evolves. Following S. Yeung et al. [27], we assume degenerate neutrino masses, i.e. mi=Mν/3m_i = M_\nu/3, where i=1,2,3i = 1, 2, 3, while ξνi\xi_{\nu_i} in the mass eigenstate is related to ξνα\xi_{\nu_\alpha} in the flavour eigenstate, where α=e,μ,τ\alpha= e, \mu, \tau, by the Pontecorvo-Maki-Nakagawa-Sakata (PMNS) matrix (G. Barenboim et al. [6]). Given the strong mixing between νμ\nu_\mu and ντ\nu_\tau, we assume ξνμ=ξντ\xi_{\nu_\mu} = \xi_{\nu_\tau}, and we fix ξνe=0.044\xi_{\nu_e} = 0.044 as extracted from Big Bang Nucleosynthesis (BBN) data (A.-K. Burns et al. [9]), leaving only one independent parameter describing neutrino degeneracies, which we choose to be ξν3\xi_{\nu_3}. The neutrino energy density becomes

ρν(a)=12π2∑i=13∫0∞(p2+(Mν3)2epaTν−ξνi+1+p2+(Mν3)2epaTν+ξνi+1)p2 dp,(1)\rho_\nu(a) = \frac{1}{2\pi^2} \sum_{i=1}^{3} \int_{0}^{\infty} \left( \frac{\sqrt{p^2+\left(\frac{M_\nu}{3}\right)^2}}{e^{\frac{pa}{T_\nu}-\xi_{\nu_i}}+1} + \frac{\sqrt{p^2+\left(\frac{M_\nu}{3}\right)^2}}{e^{\frac{pa}{T_\nu}+\xi_{\nu_i}}+1} \right) p^2 \, \mathrm{d}p, \tag*{(1)}

which is characterized by TνT_\nu, MνM_\nu, and ξν3\xi_{\nu_3} only, where Tν∼2 KT_\nu\sim2\ \mathrm{K} is the relic neutrino temperature today. The DE density with the CPL EoS is

ρΛ(a)=ρΛ0a−3(1+w0+wa)e3wa(a−1),(2)\rho_\Lambda(a) = \rho_{\Lambda0} a^{-3(1+w_0+w_a)}e^{3w_a(a-1)}, \tag*{(2)}

where ρΛ0\rho_{\Lambda0} is the dark energy density today.

In the following, we first demonstrate that w0waw_0w_aCDM is still preferred over Λ\LambdaCDM based on the specific combination of datasets (namely TTBS) we will use – consisting of Planck CMB temperature, DESI BAO, and Pantheon+ SNe (N. Aghanim et al. [3]; M. Abdul Karim et al. [2]; D. Brout et al. [8]). Similar to TT BW, we do not include CMB polarization data, since S. Yeung et al. [28] found a possible inconsistency between the constraints inferred from CMB temperature and polarization data in the Λ\LambdaCDMξ\xi model. We therefore consistently adopt the CMB temperature-based dataset combination throughout this paper.

To probe the degeneracy between neutrino and DE parameters, we apply the Boltzmann code CLASS (D. Blas et al. [7]) with both massive neutrino and CPL DE activated. We call this combined model w0waw_0w_aCDMξ\xi model in the following. Then, we perform MCMC fitting using Cobaya (J. Torrado & A. Lewis [24, 25]) of the TTBS dataset with R−1=0.01R - 1 = 0.01 being the convergent criterion. We adopt Gaussian priors on six parameters Ωbh2\Omega_b h^2, Ωch2\Omega_c h^2, τreio\tau_{\mathrm{reio}}, log⁡(1010As)\log(10^{10} A_s), nsn_s, H0H_0 as tabulated in Table 1 based on S. Yeung et al. [28]’s result of the TT BW dataset, and flat priors on w0w_0, waw_a, MνM_\nu, ξν3\xi_{\nu_3} to probe the degeneracy around the parameter space favored by the CMB temperature constraint. Alongside MCMC fitting, we perform a semi-analytical analysis of the correlations among w0w_0, waw_a, MνM_\nu and ξν3\xi_{\nu_3}. In this approach, we assume that w0w_0, waw_a, MνM_\nu and ξν3\xi_{\nu_3} are varied subject to fixed CMB acoustic scale and angle-averaged BAO angles. Any changes induced by one parameter should therefore be compensated by those induced by the rest of the parameters. Full details of the analysis are presented in Appendix § 6.

MeanStandard Deviation
Ωbh2\Omega_b h^20.023250.00042
Ωch2\Omega_c h^20.12230.0051
τreio\tau_{\mathrm{reio}}0.2010.045
log⁡(1010As)\log(10^{10}A_s)3.3370.096
nsn_s1.0190.022
H0H_0 [km s−1^{-1} Mpc−1^{-1}]71.22.1

caption: Mean and standard deviation values of Gaussian priors on six cosmological parameters Ωbh2\Omega_b h^2, Ωch2\Omega_c h^2, τreio\tau_{\mathrm{reio}}, log⁡(1010As)\log(10^{10}A_s), nsn_s, H0H_0 in the MCMC fitting, adopted from S. Yeung et al. [28].

:::

RESULTS

The MCMC results are summarized in Table 2. Under this TTBS dataset, there are 2.9σ2.9\sigma and 2.2σ2.2\sigma deviations from Λ\LambdaCDM’s values for w0w_0 and waw_a, respectively.

w0w_0waw_aMνM_\nu [eV]ξν3\xi_{\nu3}H0H_0 [km s−1^{-1} Mpc−1^{-1}]
w0waw_0w_aCDM−0.769±0.079-0.769 \pm0.079−0.68−0.27+0.31-0.68^{+0.31}_{-0.27}0.060.0066.58±0.7966.58 \pm0.79
w0waw_0w_aCDMξ\xi + prior−0.796±0.079-0.796 \pm0.079−0.56−0.30+0.34-0.56^{+0.34}_{-0.30}0.41±0.130.41 \pm0.131.14−0.13+0.181.14^{+0.18}_{-0.13}69.7±1.169.7 \pm1.1

Table 2. Mean values of w0w_0, waw_a, MνM_\nu, ξν3\xi_{\nu3}, H0H_0 (68% CL) for w0waw_0w_aCDM and w0waw_0w_aCDMξ\xi with Gaussian priors obtained from MCMC fitting to the TTBS dataset.

We perform a semi-analytical analysis of the DDE and neutrino parameters (S. Yeung et al. [27, 28]) (see Appendix § 6 for details). We assume that the well-determined CMB acoustic scale and angle-averaged BAO angles are fixed, and we vary the DDE and neutrino parameters from their reference values, (w0ref,waref,Mνref,ξν3ref)(w_0^{\mathrm{ref}}, w_a^{\mathrm{ref}}, M_\nu^{\mathrm{ref}}, \xi_{\nu3}^{\mathrm{ref}}), to obtain Eq. (3).

0=Cwa(wa−waref)+Cξν3(1)(ξν3−ξν3ref)+Cξν3(2)(ξν3−ξν3ref)2,(3)0 = C_{w_a}(w_a-w_a^{\mathrm{ref}}) + C_{\xi_{\nu3}}^{(1)}(\xi_{\nu3}-\xi_{\nu3}^{\mathrm{ref}}) + C_{\xi_{\nu3}}^{(2)}(\xi_{\nu3}-\xi_{\nu3}^{\mathrm{ref}})^2, \tag*{(3)}

where the upper indices in the parenthesis of Cξν3C_{\xi_{\nu3}} refer to their orders. We focus on three sub-samples grouped by MνM_\nu: 0.050.05 eV ≤Mν≤0.2\le M_\nu\le0.2 eV, 0.350.35 eV ≤Mν≤0.5\le M_\nu\le0.5 eV, and 0.650.65 eV ≤Mν≤0.8\le M_\nu\le0.8 eV, and then we extract the mean of waw_a, ξν3\xi_{\nu3}, and MνM_\nu from the MCMC data points of w0waΛw_0w_a\LambdaCDMξ\xi+prior fitting of each group. These are the reference points warefw_a^{\mathrm{ref}}, MνrefM_\nu^{\mathrm{ref}}, and ξν3ref\xi_{\nu3}^{\mathrm{ref}}, respectively. We also take the mean ±1\pm1 SD to be the reference points of w0w_0 for each group. These reference points are listed in Table 3. We then obtain the coefficients CwaC_{w_a}, Cξν3(1)C_{\xi_{\nu3}}^{(1)} and Cξν3(2)C_{\xi_{\nu3}}^{(2)} corresponding to the six sets of reference points. These are all summarized in Table 3 with each row corresponding to a perturbation curve via Eq. (3) plotted in Figure 1. All other cosmological parameters except w0w_0, waw_a, MνM_\nu and ξν3\xi_{\nu3} are fixed at the mean values of the entire MCMC sample.

w0refw_0^{\mathrm{ref}} (wˉ0±σw0\bar{w}_0 \pm\sigma_{w_0})MνrefM_\nu^{\mathrm{ref}} [eV]warefw_a^{\mathrm{ref}}ξν3ref\xi_{\nu3}^{\mathrm{ref}}CwaC_{w_a}Cξν3(1)C_{\xi_{\nu3}}^{(1)}Cξν3(2)C_{\xi_{\nu3}}^{(2)}
−0.74+0.08-0.74 + 0.080.69−0.88-0.881.28−2.12-2.123.861.99
−0.74−0.08-0.74 - 0.080.69−0.88-0.881.28−1.61-1.613.902.00
−0.79+0.08-0.79 + 0.080.42−0.58-0.581.15−2.47-2.473.632.01
−0.79−0.08-0.79 - 0.080.42−0.58-0.581.15−1.82-1.823.672.03
−0.85+0.07-0.85 + 0.070.15−0.23-0.231.01−3.00-3.003.372.03
−0.85−0.07-0.85 - 0.070.15−0.23-0.231.01−2.22-2.223.412.06

Table 3. Reference values of w0w_0, waw_a, MνM_\nu and ξν3\xi_{\nu3}, and their corresponding coefficients CwaC_{w_a}, Cξν3(1)C_{\xi_{\nu3}}^{(1)} and Cξν3(2)C_{\xi_{\nu3}}^{(2)} in the perturbation equation (Eq. (3)).

Figure 1. Left Panel: 2D contours (68% and 95% CL) for waw_a and ξν3\xi_{\nu3} obtained from the whole MCMC sample of fitting w0waΛw_0w_a\LambdaCDMξ+\xi+prior to the TTBS dataset. Scatter points are colored based on values of MνM_\nu, as indicated by the color bar. Right Panel: 2D contours (68% and 95% CL) for waw_a and ξν3\xi_{\nu3} obtained from the three MCMC sub-samples grouped by MνM_\nu, colored based on the mean value of MνM_\nu in each group. In both panels, the six curves represent Eq. (3) expanded at different reference points denoted by the stars, corresponding to different rows in Table 3.

As shown in Figure 1, curves based on Eq. (3) align well with the MCMC result for fixed MνM_\nu, suggesting the correlations between the neutrino and DE parameters arises from CMB acoustic scale and BAO angles, with the former dominating due to a significantly smaller error bar. Applying the perturbation curve described by Row 6 in Table 3, we calculated the corresponding ξν3\xi_{\nu3} (and waw_a) by assuming wa=0w_a=0 (and ξν3=0\xi_{\nu3}=0) while keeping w0w_0 and MνM_\nu at their reference values. Using these parameters, we show in Figure 2 that the corresponding CMB temperature power spectra overlap very well, particularly their peak and trough positions. This confirms that the two cosmological models, which fall on the same perturbation curve, have the same CMB acoustic scale to a good approximation. In Figure 1, we see a clear correlation between waw_a and ξν3\xi_{\nu3} for fixed w0w_0 and MνM_\nu. Furthermore, for the same MνM_\nu, the curve with +σw0+\sigma_{w_0} and hence a larger w0w_0 is steeper. Increasing w0w_0 and MνM_\nu together shift these curves upward, demanding a larger ξν3\xi_{\nu3}. Overall, the correlations among neutrino and DE parameters are clearly shown.

Figure 2. CMB temperature power spectra DℓTT=ℓ(ℓ+1)CℓTT/2πD_{\ell}^{TT} = \ell(\ell+ 1)C_{\ell}^{TT}/2\pi with ωa=0\omega_a = 0 (ξν3=0\xi_{\nu3} = 0) and ξν3=1.15\xi_{\nu3} = 1.15 (ωa=−0.83\omega_a = -0.83), shown as black solid (red dashed) line.

CONCLUSIONS

In this paper, we demonstrate the correlations between DDE parameters, w0w_0 and waw_a, and neutrino parameters, MνM_\nu and ξν3\xi_{\nu3}, using MCMC fitting to a combination of datasets, including Planck CMB temperature, DESI BAO, and Pantheon+ SNe. We also present a semi-analytical analysis, showing that the dominant cause of the correlations is the well-determined CMB acoustic scale. The result implies a degeneracy between the DDE and Λ\LambdaCDMξ\xi models, at least with respect to CMB and BAO acoustic scales. As such, introducing neutrino parameters together with DDE faces severe penalties due to redundancy, which makes it statistically less favorable. To distinguish the two models, we need tight measurements that constrain cosmological models beyond the expansion history. Precise measurements on the growth of large-scale structure could be the key.

ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS

All computational resources used in this paper were provided by the Chinese University of Hong Kong Central Research Computing Cluster. This research is supported by grants from the Research Grants Council of the Hong Kong Special Administrative Region, China, under Projects AoE/P-404/18 and 14300223. Besides, Getdist ({link?}) A. Lewis

  1. and Matplotlib [19] were used to visualize data while Scipy [26] and Numpy [18] were used to perform calculations for the semi-analytical analyses.

Semi-Analytical Study of Correlation

We perform a semi-analytical analysis following S. Yeung et al. [27, 28] on the inverse of CMB acoustic scale 1/θ∗1/\theta_* and the angle-averaged BAO angle βavg(z)\beta_{\mathrm{avg}}(z) to study the correlations between different parameters. In general, we obtain a the relation between all four parameters w0w_0, waw_a, MνM_\nu, ξν3\xi_{\nu3} together:

0=Cw0(w0−w0ref)+Cwa(wa−waref)+CMνMν−MνrefMνref+Cξν3(1)(ξν3−ξν3ref)+Cξν3(2)(ξν3−ξν3ref)2,(4)0 = C_{w_0}(w_0 - w_0^{\mathrm{ref}}) + C_{w_a}(w_a - w_a^{\mathrm{ref}}) + C_{M_\nu}\frac{M_\nu- M_\nu^{\mathrm{ref}}}{M_\nu^{\mathrm{ref}}} + C_{\xi_{\nu3}}^{(1)}(\xi_{\nu3} - \xi_{\nu3}^{\mathrm{ref}}) + C_{\xi_{\nu3}}^{(2)}(\xi_{\nu3} - \xi_{\nu3}^{\mathrm{ref}})^2, \tag*{(4)}

where Cw0,wa,MνC_{w_0,w_a,M_\nu}, Cξν3(1)C_{\xi_{\nu3}}^{(1)} and Cξν3(2)C_{\xi_{\nu3}}^{(2)} are coefficients derived below. However, in practice, we only visualize each pair of them in a contour plot such as Figure 1, fixing the other two to their reference values. Since we have more than one measurements, including multiple BAO angles and one CMB acoustic scale, the weighted average is taken at the end.

Perturbation on 1/θ∗1/\theta_*

The inverse of the CMB acoustic scale 1/θ∗1/\theta_* is defined by

1θ∗=DM(z∗)r∗,(5)\frac{1}{\theta_*} = \frac{D_M(z_*)}{r_*}, \tag*{(5)}

where r∗r_* is the comoving sound horizon of the photon-baryon fluid at the photon decoupling epoch z∗z_* with sound speed csc_s, and DMD_M is the transverse comoving distance:

r∗=∫z∗∞cs(z′) dz′H(z′),(6)r_* = \int_{z_*}^{\infty}\frac{c_s(z')\,\mathrm{d}z'}{H(z')}, \tag*{(6)}
DM(z)=∫0zdz′H(z′).(7)D_M(z) = \int_0^z\frac{\mathrm{d}z'}{H(z')}. \tag*{(7)}

We assume 1/θ∗1/\theta_* is fixed, i.e.

δ(1θ∗)=0.(8)\delta\left(\frac{1}{\theta_*}\right)=0. \tag*{(8)}

Since we focus on the local relation around the reference point, Taylor expansion is taken up to the first order for w0w_0, waw_a, MνM_\nu and second order for ξν3\xi_{\nu3} (the first order of ξν3\xi_{\nu3} is negligible at some reference points where ξν3∼0\xi_{\nu3}\sim0), which yields the following:

Cw0∗=I1∗[Kw0(z∗)],(9)C_{w_0}^{*}=I_1^*[K_{w_0}(z_*)], \tag*{(9)}
Cwa∗=I1∗[Kwa(z∗)],(10)C_{w_a}^{*}=I_1^*[K_{w_a}(z_*)], \tag*{(10)}
CMν∗=MνrefI1∗[KMν(z∗)],(11)C_{M_\nu}^{*}=M_\nu^{\mathrm{ref}}I_1^*[K_{M_\nu}(z_*)], \tag*{(11)}
Cξν3∗(1)=I1∗[Kξν3(z∗)],(12)C_{\xi_{\nu3}}^{*(1)}=I_1^*[K_{\xi_{\nu3}}(z_*)], \tag*{(12)}
Cξν3∗(2)=12∂Cξν3(1)∂ξν3,(13)C_{\xi_{\nu3}}^{*(2)}=\frac{1}{2}\frac{\partial C_{\xi_{\nu3}}^{(1)}}{\partial\xi_{\nu3}}, \tag*{(13)}

where the upper indices in the parenthesis of Cξν3∗C_{\xi_{\nu3}}^* denote their orders, and

I1∗[f(z)]≡DM(z)r∗2∫z∞dz′cs(z′)f(z′)−1r∗∫0zdz′f(z′),(14)I_1^*[f(z)]\equiv\frac{D_M(z)}{r_*^2}\int_z^\infty dz'c_s(z')f(z')-\frac{1}{r_*}\int_0^z dz'f(z'), \tag*{(14)}
Kw0(z)≡H022H3(z)3ln⁡(1+z)ΩΛe3(1+w0+wa)ln⁡(1+z)+3wa(11+z−1),(15)K_{w_0}(z)\equiv\frac{H_0^2}{2H^3(z)}3\ln(1+z)\Omega_\Lambda e^{3(1+w_0+w_a)\ln(1+z)+3w_a\left(\frac{1}{1+z}-1\right)}, \tag*{(15)}
Kwa(z)≡H022H3(z)3(ln⁡(1+z)+11+z−1)ΩΛe3(1+w0+wa)ln⁡(1+z)+3wa(11+z−1),(16)K_{w_a}(z)\equiv\frac{H_0^2}{2H^3(z)}3\left(\ln(1+z)+\frac{1}{1+z}-1\right)\Omega_\Lambda e^{3(1+w_0+w_a)\ln(1+z)+3w_a\left(\frac{1}{1+z}-1\right)}, \tag*{(16)}
KMν(z)≡H022H3(z)∑i=1312π2∫0∞Mν9p2+(Mν3)2p2(1ep/((1+z)Tν)+ξνi+1+1ep/((1+z)Tν)−ξνi+1)dp,(17)K_{M_\nu}(z)\equiv\frac{H_0^2}{2H^3(z)}\sum_{i=1}^{3}\frac{1}{2\pi^2}\int_0^\infty\frac{M_\nu}{9\sqrt{p^2+\left(\frac{M_\nu}{3}\right)^2}}p^2\left(\frac{1}{e^{p/((1+z)T_\nu)+\xi_{\nu i}}+1}+\frac{1}{e^{p/((1+z)T_\nu)-\xi_{\nu i}}+1}\right)dp, \tag*{(17)}
K_{\xi_{\nu3}}(z)\equiv\frac{H_0^2}{2H^3(z)}\sum_{i=1}^{3}\frac{1}{2\pi^2}\int_0^\infty\sqrt{p^2+\left(\frac{M_\nu}{3}\right)^2}p^2\frac{d\xi_{\nu i}}{d\xi_{\nu3}}\left(\frac{-e^{p/((1+z)T_\nu)+\xi_{\nu i}}}{\left(e^{p/((1+z)T_\nu)+\xi_{\nu i}}+1\right)^2}+\frac{e^{p/((1+z)T_\nu)-\xi_{\nu i}}{\left(e^{p/((1+z)T_\nu)-\xi_{\nu i}}+1\right)^2}\right)dp.} \tag*{(18)}

Perturbation on avg(z)

The angle-averaged BAO angle detected at redshift zz is given by

βavg(z)=(zβ⊥2(z)β∥(z))1/3,(19)\beta_{\mathrm{avg}}(z)=\left(z\beta_\perp^2(z)\beta_\parallel(z)\right)^{1/3}, \tag*{(19)}

where β⊥(z)\beta_\perp(z) and β∥(z)\beta_\parallel(z) are BAO angles perpendicular and parallel to the line of sight

β⊥(z)=DM(z)rd,(20)\beta_\perp(z)=\frac{D_M(z)}{r_d}, \tag*{(20)}
β∥(z)=1rdH(z).(21)\beta_\parallel(z)=\frac{1}{r_dH(z)}. \tag*{(21)}

rdr_d is the comoving sound horizon of the photon-baryon fluid at the drag epoch zdz_d:

rd=∫zd∞cs(z′)H(z′)dz′.(22)r_d=\int_{z_d}^{\infty}\frac{c_s(z')}{H(z')}dz'. \tag*{(22)}

Similarly, we assume

δβavg(z)=0,(23)\delta\beta_{\mathrm{avg}}(z)=0, \tag*{(23)}

which yields the following:

Cw0d=zβ⊥(z)3βavg2(z)(2β∥(z)I1d[Kw0(z)]+β⊥(z)I2d[Kw0(z)]),(24)C_{w_0}^{d}=\frac{z\beta_\perp(z)}{3\beta_{\mathrm{avg}}^2(z)}\left(2\beta_\parallel(z)I_1^d[K_{w_0}(z)]+\beta_\perp(z)I_2^d[K_{w_0}(z)]\right), \tag*{(24)}
Cwad=zβ⊥(z)3βavg2(z)(2β∥(z)I1d[Kwa(z)]+β⊥(z)I2d[Kwa(z)]),(25)C_{w_a}^{d}=\frac{z\beta_\perp(z)}{3\beta_{\mathrm{avg}}^2(z)}\left(2\beta_\parallel(z)I_1^d[K_{w_a}(z)]+\beta_\perp(z)I_2^d[K_{w_a}(z)]\right), \tag*{(25)}
CMνd=Mνrefzβ⊥(z)3βavg2(z)(2β∥(z)I1d[KMν(z)]+β⊥(z)I2d[KMν(z)]),(26)C_{M_\nu}^{d}=M_\nu^{\mathrm{ref}}\frac{z\beta_\perp(z)}{3\beta_{\mathrm{avg}}^2(z)}\left(2\beta_\parallel(z)I_1^d[K_{M_\nu}(z)]+\beta_\perp(z)I_2^d[K_{M_\nu}(z)]\right), \tag*{(26)}
Cξν3d(1)=zβ⊥(z)3βavg2(z)(2β∥(z)I1d[Kξν3(z)]+β⊥(z)I2d[Kξν3(z)]),(27)C_{\xi_{\nu_3}}^{d(1)}=\frac{z\beta_{\perp}(z)}{3\beta_{\mathrm{avg}}^2(z)}\left(2\beta_{\parallel}(z)I_1^d[K_{\xi_{\nu_3}}(z)]+\beta_{\perp}(z)I_2^d[K_{\xi_{\nu_3}}(z)]\right), \tag*{(27)}
Cξν3d(2)=12∂Cξν3d(1)∂ξν3,(28)C_{\xi_{\nu_3}}^{d(2)}=\frac{1}{2}\frac{\partial C_{\xi_{\nu_3}}^{d(1)}}{\partial\xi_{\nu_3}}, \tag*{(28)}

where we define

I1d[f(z)]≡DM(z)rd2∫zd∞dz′cs(z′)f(z′)−1rd∫0zdz′f(z′),(29)I_1^d[f(z)]\equiv\frac{D_M(z)}{r_d^2}\int_{z_d}^{\infty} dz^\prime c_s(z^\prime)f(z^\prime)-\frac{1}{r_d}\int_0^z dz^\prime f(z^\prime), \tag*{(29)}
I2d[f(z)]≡1rd2H(z)∫zd∞dz′cs(z′)f(z′)−f(z)rd.(30)I_2^d[f(z)]\equiv\frac{1}{r_d^2H(z)}\int_{z_d}^{\infty} dz^\prime c_s(z^\prime)f(z^\prime)-\frac{f(z)}{r_d}. \tag*{(30)}

Weighted Average of Coefficients

Each of the CMB acoustic scale and BAO angles at different redshifts gives a set of different values of the coefficients. We take the weighted average of each coefficient according to

Cˉ=WCMBCCMB+∑i=1NBAOWBAO,iCBAO,iWCMB+∑i=1NBAOWBAO,i,(31)\bar{C}=\frac{W_{\mathrm{CMB}}C_{\mathrm{CMB}}+\sum_{i=1}^{N_{\mathrm{BAO}}}W_{\mathrm{BAO},i}C_{\mathrm{BAO},i}}{W_{\mathrm{CMB}}+\sum_{i=1}^{N_{\mathrm{BAO}}}W_{\mathrm{BAO},i}}, \tag*{(31)}

where NBAON_{\mathrm{BAO}} is the number of BAO measurements, WW is the weighting defined by W=1/σ2W=1/\sigma^2, and σ\sigma is the error bar of each measurement. Note that we apply the same perturbation analysis to different kind of BAO angles, βavg(z)\beta_{\mathrm{avg}}(z), β⊥(z)\beta_{\perp}(z), and β∥(z)\beta_{\parallel}(z), according to Appendix § 6.§ 2.

References

  1. [1]Abbott, T. M., Aguena, M., Alarcon, A., et al. 2022, Physical Review D, 105, 023520
  2. [2]Abdul Karim, M., Aguilar, J., Ahlen, S., et al. 2025, Physical Review D, 112, 083515
  3. [3]Aghanim, N., et al. 2020, Astron. Astrophys, 641, A6
  4. [4]Alam, S., Aubert, M., Avila, S., et al. 2021, Physical Review D, 103, 083533
  5. [5]Balkenhol, L., Dutcher, D., Spurio Mancini, A., et al. 2023, Physical Review D, 108, 023510
  6. [6]Barenboim, G., Kinney, W. H., & Park, W.-I. 2017, The European Physical Journal C, 77, 590
  7. [7]Blas, D., Lesgourgues, J., & Tram, T. 2011, Journal of Cosmology and Astroparticle Physics, 2011, 034
  8. [8]Brout, D., Scolnic, D., Popovic, B., et al. 2022, The Astrophysical Journal, 938, 110
  9. [9]Burns, A.-K., Tait, T. M., & Valli, M. 2023, Physical Review Letters, 130, 131001
  10. [10]Chevallier, M., & Polarski, D. 2001, International Journal of Modern Physics D, 10, 213
  11. [11]Cortês, M., & Liddle, A. R. 2024, Journal of Cosmology and Astroparticle Physics, 2024, 007
  12. [12]Domcke, V., Kamada, K., Mukaida, K., Schmitz, K., & Yamada, M. 2023, Physical Review Letters, 130, 261803
  13. [13]Escudero, M., Ibarra, A., & Maura, V. 2023, Physical Review D, 107, 035024
  14. [14]Esteban, I., Gonzalez-Garcia, M. C., Maltoni, M., et al. 2024, Journal of High Energy Physics, 2024, 216
  15. [15]Gialamas, I. D., Hütsi, G., Kannike, K., et al. 2025, Physical Review D, 111, 043540
  16. [16]Giarè, W., Najafi, M., Pan, S., Di Valentino, E., & Firouzjaee, J. T. 2024, Journal of Cosmology and Astroparticle Physics, 2024, 035
  17. [18]Harris, C. R., Millman, K. J., van der Walt, S. J., et al. 2020, Nature, 585, 357, doi: 10.1038/s41586-020-2649-2DOI
  18. [19]Hunter, J. D. 2007, Computing in Science & Engineering, 9, 90, doi: 10.1109/MCSE.2007.55DOI
  19. [21]Linder, E. V. 2003, Physical review letters, 90, 091301
  20. [22]Louis, T., La Posta, A., Atkins, Z., et al. 2025, Journal of Cosmology and Astroparticle Physics, 2025, 062
  21. [23]Madhavacheril, M. S., Qu, F. J., Sherwin, B. D., et al. 2024, The Astrophysical Journal, 962, 113
  22. [24]Torrado, J., & Lewis, A. 2019, Astrophysics Source Code Library, ascl
  23. [25]Torrado, J., & Lewis, A. 2021, Journal of Cosmology and Astroparticle Physics, 2021, 057
  24. [26]Virtanen, P., Gommers, R., Oliphant, T. E., et al. 2020, Nature Methods, 17, 261, doi: 10.1038/s41592-019-0686-2DOI
  25. [27]Yeung, S., Lau, K., & Chu, M.-C. 2021, Journal of Cosmology and Astroparticle Physics, 2021, 024
  26. [28]Yeung, S., Zhang, W., & Chu, M.-c. 2025, The Astrophysical Journal Letters, 990, L45
  27. [29]Zhang, W., Chu, M.-c., & Liao, S. 2026, arXiv preprint arXiv:2604.19922arxiv.org/abs/2604.19922
  28. [30]Zhao, Z.-C., Xia, D.-M., & Wang, S. 2025, arXiv preprint arXiv:2504.09624DOI

Paper details

vlnc:W_m78fcs9k
Version
v1 · latest
Published
Fresh — added to the Hub within the last 30 days
Added
License
CC BY 4.0
Usage

views · 0

downloads · 0

A view counts once per browser per day, a download each time the PDF is requested.

  • Physics and Astronomy

Not recorded for this paper

View statement
Looking for related papers…
Contents