betaFeedback

WorksMathematics

Endpoint behaviour of vertical and horizontal Riesz transforms for the flow Laplacian on homogeneous trees

Abstract

We study endpoint estimates of Riesz transforms on a homogeneous tree equipped with its canonical flow measure μμ. We prove that the known boundedness from Hat1(μ)H^1_{\mathrm{at}}(μ) to L1(μ)L^1(μ) of the vertical Riesz transform can not be strengthened to boundedness on Hat1(μ)H^1_{\mathrm{at}}(μ) itself. We also prove that the adjoint vertical Riesz transform is not of weak type (1,1)(1,1). For the scalar horizontal transforms defined by nonzero bounded coefficients with zero sum on each child set, we establish Hat1(μ)→L1(μ)H^1_{\mathrm{at}}(μ)\to L^1(μ) boundedness and show that failure to preserve cancellation on atoms prevents boundedness on Hat1(μ)H^1_{\mathrm{at}}(μ). We then introduce a horizontal derivative based on deviations from sibling averages. Its associated Riesz transform retains the Lp(μ)L^p(μ) bounds for 1<p<∞1<p<\infty and the weak type (1,1)(1,1) estimate, and is bounded on Hat1(μ)H^1_{\mathrm{at}}(μ) itself. These mapping properties parallel those of horizontal Riesz transforms in the continuous setting, supporting our construction as a natural discrete analogue. These results distinguish vertical and horizontal behaviour at the endpoint and identify cancellation on sibling sets as a mechanism for Hardy-space boundedness.

Introduction

Riesz transforms play a central role in the real-variable theory of Hardy spaces. In the Euclidean setting, the first-order Riesz transforms Rj=∂j(−Δ)−1/2R_j=\partial_j(-\Delta)^{-1/2} are of weak type (1,1)(1,1), bounded on H1(Rn)H^1(\mathbb{R}^n), and characterize H1(Rn)H^1(\mathbb{R}^n) through the norm equivalence

∥f∥H1(Rn)≃∥f∥L1(Rn)+∑j=1n∥Rjf∥L1(Rn).\|f\|_{H^1(\mathbb{R}^n)}\simeq\|f\|_{L^1(\mathbb{R}^n)}+\sum_{j=1}^{n}\|R_jf\|_{L^1(\mathbb{R}^n)}.

and are themselves bounded on H1(Rn)H^1(\mathbb{R}^n); see [6] and [18 Chapter III]. Moreover, Rj∗=−RjR_j^*=-R_j, so the transforms and their adjoints have the same mapping properties. On spaces of exponential growth, these conclusions can separate: boundedness from an atomic Hardy space to L1L^1 need not imply boundedness on the Hardy space itself, and a weak type estimate for a Riesz transform need not hold for its adjoint. This paper studies these distinctions on homogeneous trees with their canonical flow measure, and examines how the choice of horizontal differentiation affects the Hardy-space endpoint.

Let T=Tq+1T=T_{q+1}, q≥2q\ge2, be a homogeneous tree oriented towards a fixed end. For each vertex xx, we denote by p(x)p(x) its parent and by s(x)s(x) its set of qq children. Fix a reference vertex oo and normalize the level function ℓ\ell so that ℓ(o)=0\ell(o)=0 and

2020 Mathematics Subject Classification. 42B30, 42B20, 43A99, 05C05, 05C21.

Key words and phrases. homogeneous trees, Riesz transforms, atomic Hardy space, nondoubling measure, weak type estimate.

The author gratefully acknowledges the financial support of the China Scholarship Council (Grant No. 202406290140). ℓ(p(x))=ℓ(x)+1\ell(p(x))=\ell(x)+1. The canonical flow measure

μ(x)=qℓ(x)\mu(x)=q^{\ell(x)}

then satisfies μ(o)=1\mu(o)=1 and μ(x)=∑y∈s(x)μ(y)\mu(x)=\sum_{y\in s(x)}\mu(y). With the graph distance, this measured tree has exponential volume growth and is nondoubling.

The classical atomic Hardy-space theory of Coifman and Weiss [4] is formulated on spaces of homogeneous type and therefore does not apply directly to the measured tree considered here. To deal with this geometry, Hebisch and Steger [7] developed a Calderón–Zygmund theory based on suitable trapezoids rather than metric balls. Building on this framework, Arditti, Tabacco and Vallarino [1, 2] introduced the corresponding atomic Hardy and BMO spaces and established their duality and interpolation properties.

More recently, Conde Alonso, Martini and Vallarino [5] developed a general nondoubling Calderón–Zygmund theory based on families of admissible sets equipped with recursive partitions. Their framework provides atomic Hardy and BMO spaces, duality and interpolation results, as well as endpoint estimates for singular integral operators satisfying suitable kernel conditions. In particular, it applies to arbitrary flow trees without requiring their flow measures to be locally or globally doubling; see [5 Section 4]. Throughout this paper, Hat1(μ)H^1_{\mathrm{at}}(\mu) denotes the atomic Hardy space associated with admissible trapezoids on the tree under consideration.

Let ∇\nabla denote the flow gradient, defined by

∇f(x)=f(x)−f(p(x)),(1)\nabla f(x)=f(x)-f(p(x)), \tag*{(1)}

and let L=∇∗∇/2L=\nabla^*\nabla/2 be the flow Laplacian. The associated vertical Riesz transform is defined by

R=∇L−1/2(2)\mathcal{R}=\nabla L^{-1/2} \tag*{(2)}

This Riesz transform has been extensively studied. Its weak type (1,1)(1,1) estimate and Lp(μ)L^p(\mu) boundedness for 1<p≤21<p\le2 follow from [7 Theorem 2.3]. The full range of Lp(μ)L^p(\mu) boundedness, 1<p<∞1<p<\infty, was subsequently established in [9 Theorem 1.1]. At the Hardy-space endpoint, the boundedness R:Hat1(μ)→L1(μ)\mathcal{R}:H^1_{\mathrm{at}}(\mu)\to L^1(\mu) is also known; see [7 Theorem 2.3], [1 Theorem 3], or [15 Theorem 1.2 (1)].

These results have since been extended to more general flow trees. Levi, Santagati, Tabacco and Vallarino [10] developed a Calderón–Zygmund theory and a Hardy–BMO framework for locally doubling flow measures. More recently, Martini, Santagati, Tabacco and Vallarino [13 Theorem 1.2] established LpL^p boundedness for the full range 1<p<∞1<p<\infty on locally finite flow trees, together with a sharp Mihlin–Hörmander spectral multiplier theorem. When the flow measure is additionally assumed to be locally doubling, they also obtained weak type (1,1)(1,1) and Hat1(μ)→L1(μ)H^1_{\mathrm{at}}(\mu)\to L^1(\mu) estimates. Analogous endpoint estimates are established in [5] even without the local doubling assumption, with an appropriate definition of the atomic Hardy space.

Continuous models for related questions arise on solvable Lie groups of exponential growth. On the ax+bax+b group Gn=Rn⋊R+G_n=\mathbb{R}^n\rtimes\mathbb{R}^+, the distinguished Laplacian and its first-order Riesz transforms are

LG=−∑j=0nXj2,RG,j=XjLG−1/2,\mathcal{L}_{G}=-\sum_{j=0}^{n}X_j^2,\qquad\mathcal{R}_{G,j}=X_j\mathcal{L}_{G}^{-1/2},

where X0=a∂aX_0=a\partial_a is the vertical field and Xj=a∂xjX_j=a\partial_{x_j}, 1≤j≤n1\le j\le n, are the horizontal fields. The dilation direction and horizontal level structure have discrete counterparts in the orientation and horocycles of a homogeneous flow tree; see [9]. Martini [12 Theorem 1.1] proved LpL^p boundedness of RG,j\mathcal{R}_{G,j} for every 1<p<∞1<p<\infty and weak type (1,1)(1,1) estimate from [7]. More generally, Liu and Martini [11] obtained the same range of LpL^p boundedness, as well as weak type (1,1)(1,1) estimates, for the first-order Riesz transforms associated with the distinguished Laplacian on Damek–Ricci spaces, with respect to right Haar measure.

The Hardy-space framework on these groups was developed by Vallarino [19], who established Hardy–BMO duality and interpolation results adapted to their nondoubling geometry. On G2G_2, Sjögren and Vallarino [16] proved that all three first-order Riesz transforms are bounded from the atomic Hardy space to L1L^1, whereas none of their adjoints enjoys this property. They subsequently showed that these Riesz transforms do not characterize the associated atomic Hardy space; see [17 Theorem 1.3]. They also proved that both horizontal transforms are bounded on this Hardy space [17 Theorem 1.4], leaving the corresponding question for the vertical transform open.

On homogeneous flow trees, Santagati [15 Theorem 1.2] likewise proved that the Riesz-transform characterization fails:

Hat1(μ)⊊HR1(μ):={f∈L1(μ):Rf∈L1(μ)}.H^1_{\mathrm{at}}(\mu) \subsetneq H^1_{\mathcal{R}}(\mu) := \{f \in L^1(\mu) : \mathcal{R}f \in L^1(\mu)\}.

This shows that integrability of ff and Rf\mathcal{R}f does not characterize membership in the atomic Hardy space. It leaves a different question: whether R\mathcal{R} preserves that space when the input already belongs to Hat1(μ)H^1_{\mathrm{at}}(\mu). Our first main result answers this question negatively.

Theorem 1.1. There are (1,∞)(1,\infty)-atoms aha_h, indexed by integers h≥2h \ge2, and constants cq,Cq>0c_q,C_q > 0 such that

∥Rah∥Hat1(μ)≥cqlog⁡h−Cq.\|\mathcal{R}a_h\|_{H^1_{\mathrm{at}}(\mu)} \ge c_q \log h - C_q.

Here the norm is interpreted as +∞+\infty when Rah∉Hat1(μ)\mathcal{R}a_h \notin H^1_{\mathrm{at}}(\mu). Consequently, R\mathcal{R} does not extend to a bounded operator from Hat1(μ)H^1_{\mathrm{at}}(\mu) to itself.

Thus the failure of boundedness persists despite both the known Hat1(μ)→L1(μ)H^1_{\mathrm{at}}(\mu) \to L^1(\mu) estimate and preservation of the zero integral condition: these properties do not control the atomic Hardy norm.

The proof relates the growth of these norms to the geometry of the transform away from the support of the atoms. We choose aha_h on two consecutive blocks of descendant layers below oo and test Rah\mathcal{R}a_h against bounded truncations of

b(x)=log⁡(1+d(x,γ)),γ={pk(o):k≥0}.b(x) = \log(1+d(x,\gamma)), \qquad\gamma= \{p^k(o): k \ge0\}.

These truncations have uniformly bounded BMO seminorms. Outside the descendant subtree of oo, the transform is positive on the ancestor ray γ\gamma and negative on its side branches. The test function vanishes on the ray, while its logarithmic growth detects the branch contribution at distances comparable to hh. A summation-by-parts argument bounds the contribution from the descendant subtree uniformly in hh. The resulting pairings yield a logarithmic lower bound for the Hardy norm through Hardy–BMO duality.

We next turn to the endpoint behaviour of the adjoint R∗\mathcal{R}^*. It was already known that R∗\mathcal{R}^* is not bounded from Hat1(μ)H^1_{\mathrm{at}}(\mu) to L1(μ)L^1(\mu), as follows from [9 Proposition 4.4] and Hardy–BMO duality in [2 Theorem 13] or [10 Theorem 4.10]. Analogous failures of H1→L1H^1 \to L^1 boundedness are known on ax+bax+b groups [12 Proposition 7.1] and Damek–Ricci spaces [3].

At the weak type (1,1)(1,1) endpoint, a distinction arises between horizontal and vertical Riesz transforms. Levi, Martini, Santagati, Tabacco and Vallarino [9 Theorem 5.5] proved that the adjoints of the horizontal Riesz transforms on homogeneous trees are of weak type (1,1)(1,1), while leaving the corresponding question for R∗\mathcal{R}^* open [9 Remark 4.2].

Our second main result answers this question negatively: R∗R^* is not of weak type (1, 1). This establishes a distinction between the horizontal and vertical adjoints and provides a discrete counterpart to Hormozi’s result [8 Theorem 1.1].

Theorem 1.2. The adjoint vertical Riesz transform R∗R^* is not of weak type (1, 1).

Motivated by the continuous counterexample in the proof of [8 Theorem 1.1], we construct nonnegative, finitely supported functions of unit L1L^1 norm whose mass is distributed sparsely over many descendant layers. The explicit formula for R−R∗R-R^* separates descendant averages from ancestor values; see [9 Eq. (3.4) and (4.4)]. Removing the latter contribution on a sufficiently large set produces logarithmically growing weak L1L^1 norms. The known weak type (1, 1) bound for RR then yields the conclusion for R∗R^*.

We next turn to horizontal differentiation. On ax+bax+b groups, the semidirect-product structure distinguishes the dilation direction from the translation directions, giving rise to vertical and horizontal left-invariant derivatives. On a tree, the chosen orientation defines the parent derivative in (1), but it does not select horizontal coordinate directions: vertices on the same horocycle are not joined by edges. A horizontal derivative must therefore specify how values within a level are compared.

Motivated by the continuous theory, Levi, Martini, Santagati, Tabacco and Vallarino introduced in [9 Section 5] a family of scalar horizontal Riesz transforms RεR_\varepsilon. Specifically speaking, for a nonzero ε∈L∞(μ)\varepsilon\in L^\infty(\mu) satisfying

∑y∈s(x)ε(y)=0,x∈T,(3)\sum_{y\in s(x)} \varepsilon(y)=0,\quad x\in T, \tag*{(3)}

the scalar horizontal Riesz transform is defined by

∇εf(x)=1q∑y∈s(x)ε(y)f(y),Rε=∇εL−1/2.(4)\nabla_\varepsilon f(x)=\frac{1}{q}\sum_{y\in s(x)}\varepsilon(y)f(y),\quad R_\varepsilon=\nabla_\varepsilon\mathcal{L}^{-1/2}. \tag*{(4)}

The children of a vertex lie on the same horocycle, so this derivative compares values within a horizontal level. These transforms are bounded on Lp(μ)L^p(\mu) for 1<p<∞1<p<\infty and are of weak type (1, 1); their adjoints are also of weak type (1, 1); see [9 Section 5]. Nevertheless, their behaviour on the atomic Hardy space is different from that of the continuous horizontal transforms on G2G_2.

Theorem 1.3. For the above nonzero ε\varepsilon, RεR_\varepsilon is bounded from Hat1(μ)H^1_{\mathrm{at}}(\mu) to L1(μ)L^1(\mu), but not bounded from Hat1(μ)H^1_{\mathrm{at}}(\mu) to itself.

Indeed, for every nonzero ε\varepsilon as above, there is a (1,∞)(1,\infty)-atom aa such that

∑x∈TRεa(x)μ(x)≠0.\sum_{x\in T}R_\varepsilon a(x)\mu(x)\ne0.

Thus, although the coefficient condition makes ∇ε\nabla_\varepsilon annihilate constants, it does not ensure that RεR_\varepsilon preserves the zero integral condition of the atomic space.

This obstruction motivates a horizontal derivative whose output has cancellation on each sibling set s(p(x))s(p(x)). We define

∇hf(x)=1q(f(x)−1q−1∑z∈b(x)f(z)),Rh=∇hL−1/2.\nabla_h f(x)=\frac{1}{q}\left(f(x)-\frac{1}{q-1}\sum_{z\in b(x)}f(z)\right),\quad R_h=\nabla_h\mathcal{L}^{-1/2}.

where b(x)=s(p(x))∖{x}b(x)=s(p(x))\setminus\{x\} is the set containing all the siblings of xx. For later use, we rewrite this operator in a form which makes the cancellation explicit. Set u=L−1/2fu=\mathcal{L}^{-1/2}f, then

References

  1. [1]L. Arditti, A. Tabacco and M. Vallarino. Hardy spaces on weighted homogeneous trees. In Advances in Microlocal and Time-Frequency Analysis, Applied and Numerical Harmonic Analysis. Birkhäuser, Cham, 2020, pp. 21–39.arxiv.org/abs/1902.09273
  2. [2]L. Arditti, A. Tabacco and M. Vallarino. BMO spaces on weighted homogeneous trees. J. Geom. Anal. 31(9) (2021): 8832–8849.arxiv.org/abs/2006.02693
  3. [3]M. Bernardelli and J. Liu. Calderón–Zygmund theory and endpoint results for Riesz transforms on Damek–Ricci spaces. In preparation.
  4. [4]R. R. Coifman and G. Weiss. Extensions of Hardy spaces and their use in analysis. Bull. Amer. Math. Soc. 83(4) (1977): 569–645.
  5. [5]J. M. Conde Alonso, A. Martini and M. Vallarino. Nondoubling Calderón–Zygmund theory across geometries. arXiv preprint arXiv:2611.18991, 2026.
  6. [6]C. Fefferman and E. M. Stein. Hᵖ spaces of several variables. Acta Math. 129 (1972): 137–193.
  7. [7]W. Hebisch and T. Steger. Multipliers and singular integrals on exponential growth groups. Math. Z. 245(1) (2003): 37–61.
  8. [8]M. Hormozi. Endpoint failure for the adjoint vertical Riesz transform on ax + b groups. J. Geom. Anal. 36 (2026): Article No. 317.
  9. [9]M. Levi, A. Martini, F. Santagati, A. Tabacco and M. Vallarino. Riesz transform for a flow Laplacian on homogeneous trees. J. Fourier Anal. Appl. 29 (2023): Paper No. 15.
  10. [10]M. Levi, F. Santagati, A. Tabacco and M. Vallarino. Analysis on trees with nondoubling flow measures. Potential Anal. 58(4) (2023): 731–759.
  11. [11]J. Liu and A. Martini. Riesz transforms for the distinguished Laplacian on Damek–Ricci spaces and operator-valued multivariate spectral multipliers. J. Funct. Anal. 292(2) (2026): Article No. 111694. DOI: 10.1016/j.jfa.2026.111694.
  12. [12]A. Martini. Riesz transforms on ax + b groups. J. Geom. Anal. 33(7) (2023): Article No. 222.DOI
  13. [13]A. Martini, F. Santagati, A. Tabacco and M. Vallarino. Riesz transform and spectral multipliers for the flow Laplacian on nonhomogeneous trees. Rev. Mat. Iberoam. 41(6) (2025): 2221–2282.
  14. [15]F. Santagati. Hardy spaces on homogeneous trees with flow measures. J. Math. Anal. Appl. 510(2) (2022): Paper No. 126015.DOI
  15. [16]P. Sjögren and M. Vallarino. Boundedness from H¹ to L¹ of Riesz transforms on a Lie group of exponential growth. Ann. Inst. Fourier (Grenoble) 58(4) (2008): 1117–1151.
  16. [17]P. Sjögren and M. Vallarino. Hardy spaces and Riesz transforms on a Lie group of exponential growth. Proc. Edinb. Math. Soc. 68(3) (2025): 731–762.
  17. [18]E. M. Stein. Harmonic Analysis: Real-Variable Methods, Orthogonality, and Oscillatory Integrals. Princeton Mathematical Series, vol. 43. Princeton University Press, Princeton, NJ, 1993.
  18. [19]M. Vallarino. Spaces H¹ and BMO on ax + b-groups. Collect. Math. 60(3) (2009): 277–295.

Paper details

vlnc:W_m8s7mzbe
Version
v1 · latest
Published
Fresh — added to the Hub within the last 30 days
Added
License
CC BY 4.0
  • Mathematics

ChatGPT-6

View statement
Looking for related papers…
Contents