betaFeedback

WorksPhysics and Astronomy

Classical Dirac particle I

Abstract

In this work we produce a classical Lagrangian description of an elementary spinning particle which satisfies Dirac equation when quantized. We call this particle a classical Dirac particle. We analyze in detail the way we arrive to this model and how the different observables and constants of the motion can be expressed in terms of the degrees of freedom and their derivatives, by making use of Noether's theorem. The main feature is that the particle has a center of charge r, moving at the speed of light, that satisfies fourth-order diferential equations and all observables can be expressed only in terms of this point and their time derivatives. The particle has also a center of mass q, that is a different point than the center of charge. This implies that two different spin observables can be defined, one S with respect to the point r and another SCM with respect to the point q, that satisfy different dynamical equations. The spin S satisfies the same dynamical equation than Dirac's spin operator. The fourth-order differential equations for the point r can be transformed into a system of second-order ordinary differential equations for the center of charge and center of mass. The dynamics can be described in terms of dimensionless variables. The possible interaction Lagrangians are described and we devote the main part of the work to the electromagnetic interaction of the Dirac particle with uniform and oscillating electric and magnetic fields. The numerical integrations of the dynamical equations are performed with different Mathematica notebooks that are available for the interested reader.

Introduction

We call a classical Dirac particle a classical mechanical system obtained through a general formalism to describe classical elementary particles with spin, that satisfies the Dirac equation when it is quantized.

It depends on two intrinsic parameters: the mass mm and the absolute value SS of the spin in the center of mass frame. When quantized, the value of the nonvanishing mass mm is arbitrary but the value of S=ℏ/2S = \hbar/2, and it represents a classical model of a fermion.

The main feature of this classical spinning model is that we only need to describe the evolution of a single point r\boldsymbol{r}, the center of charge, where the external forces are defined, and which satisfies a system of fourth-order differential equations. All observables, energy, linear momentum, angular momentum, center of mass position, angular velocity and spins are expressed in terms of this point r\boldsymbol{r} and their time derivatives.

This model has also another characteristic point, the center of mass q\boldsymbol{q}, which is a different point than the center of charge. The fourth-order differential equations for the point r\boldsymbol{r} can be decoupled into a system of second-order differential equations for the points q\boldsymbol{q} and r\boldsymbol{r}, where q\boldsymbol{q} satisfies Newton-type dynamical equations in terms of the external force evaluated at the position of the center of charge r\boldsymbol{r}.

The center of charge r\boldsymbol{r} is moving at the speed of light and the complete dynamical equations for the evolution of the center of mass q\boldsymbol{q} and center of charge r\boldsymbol{r} can be expressed in terms of dimensionless classical variables.

In the Section 2 we make a summary of the theoretical ideas that have lead us to this formalism and which are developped in the mentioned Sections and references.

Scope and steps of the theoretical analysis

The formalism we have proposed is based on the following considerations [1]:

  • (i) The constituent elements of matter are elementary particles.

  • (ii) From the point of view of classical mechanics it is possible to describe an elementary particle as a mechanical Lagrangian system with a finite but unknown number of degrees of freedom. Section 3.

  • (iii) In nature, there is a limiting speed cc for the motion of the centers of mass of massive bodies. This implies that equivalent inertial observers are related by the Poincaré group transformations. Section 3.

  • (iv) We accept that elementary particles interact. We assume that when an elementary particle interacts and if it is not annihilated, its internal structure is not modified by the interaction. Therefore, the boundary variables of the Lagrangian description of an elementary particle are restricted to belong to a homogeneous space of the Poincaré group [2]. Section 3. The maximum number of boundary variables is the same as the parameters of the Poincaré group.

  • (v) The formalism must be quantized and our interest is to find at least one model that satisfies the Dirac equation when quantized. [3].

  • (vi) The Lagrangian that describes the more complex elementary particle has as boundary variables (t,r,u,α)(t,\boldsymbol{r},\boldsymbol{u},\boldsymbol{\alpha}), what are interpreted as the time tt, the position of a point r\boldsymbol{r}, the velocity of this point u\boldsymbol{u} and the orientation α\boldsymbol{\alpha} of a comoving cartesian frame attached to the point r\boldsymbol{r}. It is therefore a function L(t,r,u,a,ω)L(t,\boldsymbol{r},\boldsymbol{u},\boldsymbol{a},\boldsymbol{\omega}) of these variables and of the acceleration of the point a\boldsymbol{a} and of the angular velocity ω\boldsymbol{\omega} of the

comoving frame. The free Lagrangian L0(u,a,ω)L_0(\mathbf{u},\mathbf{a},\boldsymbol{\omega}), is invariant under translations and, therefore, independent of tt and r\mathbf{r}. Section 4.

(vii) The point r\mathbf{r} must satisfy fourth-order differential equations, so its free motion is accelerated and has torsion and therefore does not represent the center of inertia or center of mass (CM) of the free particle. The possible interaction Lagrangians will be defined at that point. The point r\mathbf{r} represents the center of interaction or center of charge (CC) of the elementary particle. Section 4.

(viii) The classical model we have found that when quantized satisfies the Dirac equation corresponds to the previous system in which u=cu=c, i.e., the CC moves at the speed of light. We call this elementary particle the classical Dirac particle. [1], [3].

(ix) Without explicit knowledge of the free Lagrangian and by using Noether’s theorem we have found that the free particle has another characteristic point q\mathbf{q}, defined in terms of r\mathbf{r} and its time derivatives and that for the free particle moves in a straight line at a constant speed v=dq/dt\mathbf{v}=d\mathbf{q}/dt. The energy HH and the linear momentum p\mathbf{p} of the particle are expressed in terms of this velocity in the form H=γ(v)mc2H=\gamma(v)mc^2 and p=γ(v)mv\mathbf{p}=\gamma(v)m\mathbf{v}. We interpret this point as the center of inertia or center of mass of the particle. We have found the differential equations that satisfy the point r\mathbf{r} for the center of mass observer who measures q=0\mathbf{q}=0 and v=0\mathbf{v}=0. Section 5.

(x) Because the Dirac particle has two distinguished points q\mathbf{q} and r\mathbf{r} we obtain two different angular momenta observables with respect to them. They are the spin S\mathbf{S} with respect to the CC and the spin SCM\mathbf{S}_{CM} with respect to the CM. Both spins satisfy different dynamical equations. All observables of the Dirac particle can finally be expressed in terms of the point r\mathbf{r} and its subsequent time derivatives. Section 6.

(xi) If the trajectory of the point r\mathbf{r} for the center of mass observer is written in another inertial reference system by means of an arbitrary Poincaré transformation, we obtain the complete family of all possible trajectories of the point described by all inertial observers. If in that family of trajectories we eliminate the parameters of the Poincaré group on which it depends, from the equation of the family and its successive time derivatives we finally obtain a fourth-order system of differential equations for the point r\mathbf{r}, independent of the parameters of the group. These are the Poincaré invariant relativistic differential equations of the free particle. [6]

(xii) By the analysis of the Poincaré invariant magnitudes of the Dirac particle we have found how the spin transforms among inertial observers and the dynamical equations of the center of mass spin. Section 8.

(xiii) From the expression of q\mathbf{q} in terms of r\mathbf{r} and its time derivatives it has been possible to transform the system of fourth-order differential equations for the point r\mathbf{r}, in a coupled second-order system of ordinary differential equations for the points q\mathbf{q} and r\mathbf{r}, and extend these equations when there exist any interaction. Section 6.

(xiv) The most general interaction Lagrangian of the Dirac particle is described by L=L0+LIL=L_0+L_I, where L0(u,a,ω)L_0(\mathbf{u},\mathbf{a},\boldsymbol{\omega}) is the still unknown free Lagrangian and the interaction Lagrangian LI(t,r,u)=A0(t,r,u)+u⋅A(t,r,u)L_I(t,\mathbf{r},\mathbf{u})=A_0(t,\mathbf{r},\mathbf{u})+\mathbf{u}\cdot\mathbf{A}(t,\mathbf{r},\mathbf{u}), is only a function of tt, r\mathbf{r} and u\mathbf{u}, independent of a\mathbf{a} and ω\boldsymbol{\omega}, as a consequence that the interaction does not modify the internal structure of the Dirac particle. § 7.

(xv) The possibility that the functions A0A_0 and A\mathbf{A} may also be functions of the CC speed u\mathbf{u} has not been considered here, and opens the door to the analysis of possible classical interactions of non-electromagnetic nature that should be explored. § 9.

(xvi) We have expressed the dynamical equations in natural units where the unit of velocity is cc, the unit of length is 2R02R_0, being R0R_0 the separation between the CC and CM in the center of mass frame and the unit of time is 2R0/c2R_0/c. The boundary conditions for solving the dynamical equations are expressed in terms of 10 essential parameters. These essential parameters define the relationship between the laboratory observer and the center of mass observer of the Dirac particle. § 10.

(xvii) In this work we have analyzed the case in which the interaction is of the form of the minimal coupling, LI=−eA0(t,r)+eu⋅A(t,r)L_I=-eA_0(t,\mathbf{r})+e\mathbf{u}\cdot\mathbf{A}(t,\mathbf{r}), in terms of the electric charge and in terms of the scalar A0A_0, and vector potential A\mathbf{A}, defined at the CC position r\mathbf{r}, which give rise to uniform and oscillating electric and magnetic fields of constant frequency. The surprise is that we do not need the explicit knowledge of the free Lagrangian. § 11-§ 13.

Classical elementary spinning particles

Different models of classical elementary spinning particles have been obtained through a general formalism [1], that is based on the following three fundamental principles: Restricted Relativity Principle, Variational Principle and Atomic Principle.

The Restricted Relativity Principle admits the existence of a class of equivalent observers which describe the mechanical systems with the same dynamical equations. Equivalent observers are related by means of a group of space-time transformations, called the kinematical group of the formalism. For describing the Dirac particle we shall restrict this group to the Poincaré group. We call this principle as a restricted principle because we are going to consider only the class of inertial observers. Accelerated observers are not considered here.

The Variational Principle states that the dynamical equations of any mechanical system between an initial fixed point x1x_1 to a final fixed point x2x_2 of a kinematical space x1,x2∈Xx_1,x_2\in X, are the Euler-Lagrange dynamical equations obtained from a Lagrangian function which is an explicit function of the variables xx and their first order time derivative L(x,x˙)L(x,\dot{x}).

The definition of a classical elementary particle lies on the Atomic principle [2]. The assumption of this principle is that an elementary particle does not have internal excited states in the sense that any interaction, if it does not annihilate the particle, does not modify its internal structure. If an inertial observer describes the initial state of the elementary particle in the Lagrangian description through a set of variables x≡(x1,…,xn)\mathbf{x}\equiv(x_1,\ldots,x_n) and the dynamics changes this state to another y≡(y1,…,yn)\mathbf{y}\equiv(y_1,\ldots,y_n), if the internal structure has not been modified, then it is possible to find another inertial observer who describes this new state of the particle with exactly the same values of the variables as of the previous state. This means that there must exist a Poincaré transformation gg, between both inertial observers, in such a way that the above values are transformed into each other:

y=g∗x,x=g−1∗y.y = g * x,\qquad x = g^{-1} * y.

This relation must be valid for any pair of states of any elementary particle. The Atomic Principle restricts the classical boundary variables manifold of the variational description of an elementary particle, to span a homogeneous space of the Poincaré group [1]. The largest homogeneous space of a Lie group is the group itself, and the possible different homogeneous spaces of the Poincaré group will supply different models of elementary particles. The point particle is the simplest of these possible models.

The boundary variables

If tt and r\mathbf{r} are the time and position coordinates of a space-time event for the inertial observer OO, and t′t' and r′\mathbf{r}' are the time and position of the same event for any arbitrary inertial observer O′O', they are related by the Poincaré transformation:

xμ′=Λνμxν+aμ,xμ′≡(ct′,r′),xμ≡(ct,r),aμ≡(cb,d),x^{\mu'} = \Lambda^{\mu}_{\nu}x^\nu+ a^\mu,\qquad x^{\mu'} \equiv(ct',\mathbf{r}'),\qquad x^\mu\equiv(ct,\mathbf{r}),\qquad a^\mu\equiv(cb,\mathbf{d}),

and Λ=L(v)R(α)\Lambda= L(\mathbf{v})R(\boldsymbol{\alpha}) is a general Lorentz transformation, as a composition of a rotation R(α)R(\boldsymbol{\alpha}), followed by a boost or pure Lorentz transformation L(v)L(\mathbf{v}). The three vector α\boldsymbol{\alpha} that defines the rotation matrix can be the vector α=αn\boldsymbol{\alpha} = \alpha\mathbf{n}, where n\mathbf{n} is a unit vector along the rotation axis and α\alpha the rotated angle around this direction, so that any rotation is finally described in terms of three angles, α\alpha and the zenithal θ\theta and azimuthal ϕ\phi that describe the unit vector n\mathbf{n}.

A Lorentz transformation of velocity v\mathbf{v}, is given by the 4×44 \times4 matrix

L(v)=(γγvx/cγvy/cγvz/cγvx/c1+vx2c2γ2γ+1vxvyc2γ2γ+1vxvzc2γ2γ+1γvy/cvyvxc2γ2γ+11+vy2c2γ2γ+1vyvzc2γ2γ+1γvz/cvzvxc2γ2γ+1vzvyc2γ2γ+11+vz2c2γ2γ+1),(1)L(\mathbf{v}) = \begin{pmatrix} \gamma& \gamma v_x/c & \gamma v_y/c & \gamma v_z/c \\ \gamma v_x/c & 1+\dfrac{v_x^2}{c^2}\dfrac{\gamma^2}{\gamma+1} & \dfrac{v_xv_y}{c^2}\dfrac{\gamma^2}{\gamma+1} & \dfrac{v_xv_z}{c^2}\dfrac{\gamma^2}{\gamma+1} \\ \gamma v_y/c & \dfrac{v_yv_x}{c^2}\dfrac{\gamma^2}{\gamma+1} & 1+\dfrac{v_y^2}{c^2}\dfrac{\gamma^2}{\gamma+1} & \dfrac{v_yv_z}{c^2}\dfrac{\gamma^2}{\gamma+1} \\ \gamma v_z/c & \dfrac{v_zv_x}{c^2}\dfrac{\gamma^2}{\gamma+1} & \dfrac{v_zv_y}{c^2}\dfrac{\gamma^2}{\gamma+1} & 1+\dfrac{v_z^2}{c^2}\dfrac{\gamma^2}{\gamma+1} \end{pmatrix}, \tag*{(1)}

where γ≡(1−(vx/c)2−(vy/c)2−(vz/c)2)−1/2\gamma\equiv\left(1-(v_x/c)^2-(v_y/c)^2-(v_z/c)^2\right)^{-1/2}. The Poincaré transformation is

References

  1. [1]M. Rivas (2001), Kinematical Theory of Spinning Particles, Fundamental Theories of Physics Series, Vol 116, Dordrecht, Holland. Updated versions of this formalism can be obtained under the publications of the author, at the web site of Research Gate: https://www.researchgate.net/publication/381660537
  2. [2]M. Rivas (2008), The atomic hypothesis: Physical consequences, J. Phys. A, 41, 304022.DOI
  3. [3]M. Rivas (1994), Quantization of generalized spinning particles. New derivation of Dirac’s equation, J. Math. Phys. 35, 3380.DOI
  4. [4]https://www.zitter-institute.org/p/freediracparticlenb.html
  5. [5]J.Barandiaran and M.Rivas (2025) Poincaré invariant interaction of two Dirac particles, arXiv:2501.10445v1.arxiv.org/abs/2501.10445
  6. [6]M. Rivas (2003), The dynamical equation of the spinning electron, J. Phys. A, 36, 4703.
  7. [7]M. Rivas(2024), Considerations about the measurement of the magnetic moment and electric dipole moment of the electron, arXiv:2406.15502v3.arxiv.org/abs/2406.15502
  8. [8]https://www.zitter-institute.org/p/dirac-particle-magnetic-electric-field.html The Wolfram Community Project has included the following two notebooks: J. Barandiaran (2025) Classical Dirac Particle I https://community.wolfram.com/groups/-/m/t/3521996 Classical Dirac particle I: the electron spinning particle model for dynamic simulations (Part II) https://community.wolfram.com/groups/-/m/t/3543405

Paper details

vlnc:W_m9f8k7rh
Version
v1 · latest
Published
Fresh — added to the Hub within the last 30 days
Added
License
CC BY 4.0
Usage

views · 0

downloads · 0

A view counts once per browser per day, a download each time the PDF is requested.

  • Physics and Astronomy

Not recorded for this paper

View statement
Looking for related papers…
Contents