WorksPhysics and Astronomy
Non-ergodic Area Scaling of Andreev Transport in Al/AlO/Al Tunnel Junctions
Abstract
State-of-the-art superconducting qubits rely on Al/AlO/Al Josephson junctions (JJs) as a nonlinear element with an ideal sinusoidal current-phase dependence, with its inductance set by the junction area and oxidation conditions. This idealization holds only if the many conduction channels through the amorphous AlO barrier transmit weakly and almost identically. Here, we measure the second-order subgap Andreev current, which sets the second Josephson harmonic, in Al/AlO/Al JJs. For junction sizes relevant to qubits, we find that this current is dominated by effective channels whose transparencies exceed the ideal tunneling limit () by orders of magnitude. For small and high-aspect-ratio junctions, increasing the junction size does not average out the effect of these high transparency channels but instead adds additional channels of even greater transparency. The trend inverts once both the width and length of the junction exceed a critical length scale, above which the effective transparency decreases with area. This non-ergodic scaling of the Andreev current is reproduced by simulations and attributed to non-self-averaging statistics of the transparency distribution, which arise from variations in oxide thickness. The effect is largely invisible to the normal-state conductance used to target the inductance and reveals unexpected geometric and size-related trade-offs for scaling superconducting qubit systems to large numbers of junctions.
The Josephson junction is the cornerstone of superconducting quantum information processing, providing the nonlinearity essential for quantum operations [1, 2]. In particular, aluminum-oxide (AlO)-based tunnel Josephson junctions (JJs) have enabled superconducting hardware to become a leading platform for fault-tolerant quantum computing [3, 4, 5, 6], and form crucial elements for quantum-limited amplifiers [7], microwave photon detectors [8] and SQUID magnetometers [9]. As quantum-processor architectures scale toward junctions [10, 11, 12] and ground-plane materials improve [13, 14, 15], the junction itself becomes a limiting source of device variability and decoherence [15, 16].
The supercurrent in JJs is carried by conducting channels, each of which forms an Andreev bound state (ABS). Summing over the contributions in the zero-temperature limit appropriate to our measurements, we obtain the junction current-phase relation (CPR):
where are the energies of the ABS pair [17, 18], is the superconducting order parameter phase difference, and is the channel transparency. The final equality is obtained through a Fourier series expansion and emphasizes the presence of higher harmonics within a general JJ. A measure of junction non-ideality is the CPR skew, given by the ratio of the second to first harmonics , which results from the presence of leaky channels with large transparencies. Non-zero skew causes unpredictable deviations in transmon excited states [16], reduces readout fidelity through measurement-induced transitions [19], and increases dephasing from trapped quasiparticles and critical-current fluctuations [20].
For a junction obeying Eq. (1), expanding to second order in and summing over channels gives . Since the Josephson energy of a higher harmonic is proportional to , a ratio of is expected purely from the CPR skew. Previous work extracted higher harmonic content from the transition spectra of transmon qubits [16, 21]. To disentangle the contributions intrinsic to the junction from those of the circuit inductance, the former was assumed to be independent of junction area [21] and thus distinguishable from the inductive contribution, which is proportional to . Fundamentally, this assumption relies on the spatial averages of and converging to their ensemble values independently of junction area. That is, the ratio is constant and area-independent, and the junction scales ergodically: its size does not influence the nature of first- and second-order Andreev transport. Figure 1 illustrates this concept by comparing the tunneling transparency map of one small junction of area with that of a junction of twice the area, . With ergodic scaling, the larger junction has effectively the same transparency distribution and reproduces the hot-spot (high-transparency) statistics of the smaller junction; both and are essentially unchanged, because the smaller region is statistically representative of the larger area. In the non-ergodic case, rare and extreme high-transparency channels become more common as the area grows. The tunneling transparency statistics are then non-self-averaging [22]: the most transparent channels disproportionately affect , resulting in a strong area dependence. Conversely, , where is the normal-state conductance of the JJ, is essentially unchanged. This implies that the room-temperature conductance measurements used in frequency targeting are insensitive to this area scaling, making it challenging to discriminate from inductance-related effects in transmon experiments.
Figure 1. Ergodic (self-averaging) versus non-ergodic (non-self-averaging) area scaling of the tunneling transparency (model schematic). a, Exploded view of one Al/AlO/Al junction of area and the transparency map of its amorphous barrier (colour: local transparency , white low to red high). b,c, shows how a slice of the sample twice in size would look, under the two hypotheses. Below each map, the histogram of channel transparencies of the region alone (grey, identical in b and c) and of the full junction (colour). Self-averaging, (b) implies that any sub-area is statistically representative of the whole so both and are unchanged. In contrast, non self averaging sample, (c) the larger area samples even deeper into the right tail of the fat-tailed distribution, and adds channels of increasing transparency. These are the rare events responsible for the non-self-averaging behavior; barely changes while increases with area.
Here, we characterize the underlying transparencies and junction scaling by directly probing the second-order Andreev current using DC subgap transport measurements of 134 JJs with varied area (), oxide thickness (), and aspect ratio (, where , are the junction width and length). The large and diverse sample set allows observation of unexpected scaling of the second-order Andreev current, which depends on both the junction area and aspect ratio. For small junctions and junctions with large aspect ratio, the dependence is consistent with the non-ergodic scaling in Figure 1. We find that an emergent threshold length scale exists whereby junctions with both , display improved oxide thickness uniformity, reduced effective transparency, and behavior closer to the ideal junction with a sinusoidal CPR. For junction sizes typically relevant to transmon qubits, a small number of rare high transparency channels dominate the contribution to and therefore . Our results provide an alternative interpretation of recent area-dependent observations, and demonstrate how junction microscopics and the underlying distribution of transparencies constrain the design of scalable qubit architectures.
The 134 Al/AlO/Al JJs studied here are fabricated following standard shadow-evaporation processes, with bottom electrode width and top electrode width ranging from 0.1 m up to 2.0 m, aspect ratios , and oxidation exposures , the product of the static O pressure and the oxidation time, from 4 to 480 Torr·min. Junction areas include the overlap of the top electrode with the two sidewalls of the bottom electrode of thickness , while and are SEM-measured for Square Set A and design values otherwise (Supplementary Section S1). The junctions with comprise three different fabrication batches and are referred to as high-aspect-ratio (HAR) Sets A, B, and C. Sets A and B each contain devices with a fixed short dimension ( or 300 nm), while Set C varies both and . For square devices, set A was fabricated in a single deposition step while set B underwent multi-step fabrication. DC measurements are taken at 10 mK in a Bluefors LD dilution refrigerator, with RC- and powder-filtered lines (Figure S1).
Figure S1. Schematic of the cryogenic DC measurement circuit. Temperature stages are indicated by horizontal dashed lines (50 K, 4 K, cold plate (CP), and mixing chamber (MXC) at mK, enclosed by the red box). The junction (cross) is measured in a four-probe configuration: the DC bias line (right) and the current-measurement line (left) drive the two ends of the junction wire, and the two inner lines sense the voltage across it. Each line passes through a two-stage RC low-pass filter at MXC with component values , , , nF, nF, nF, followed by a Basel MFT silver-powder filter. Room-temperature electronics are a Basel LNHR DAC (DC voltage source), an SRS SR560 voltage preamplifier and an SRS SR570 current preamplifier, each read out by a Keithley 7510 digital multimeter (V). All DC wiring uses shielded twisted-pair cable. The sample package (gray) has a copper base and an aluminum light-tight lid.
The resulting voltage-driven – measurements (Figure 2a) show behavior typical of tunnel JJs, with a supercurrent peak at and the onset of a quasiparticle current for , where eV is the Al order parameter. Figure 3a,Figure 3d plot as a function of for the rectangular junction sets and for square junctions at four oxidation conditions. In every set the normal-state conductance increases linearly with , and it decreases with oxidation exposure according to a power-law dependence (Figure S3). When plotted on a logarithmic scale (Figure 2b), a clear step becomes visible near . The current steps and (dashed lines in Figure 2b) result from sideband scattering of quasiparticles mediated by ABSs, a process which is represented schematically in Figure 2c. For first order scattering , a quasiparticle is excited by an applied voltage , crossing the insulating barrier with transmission probability ( conduction channels). For , a right-moving quasiparticle is excited by , scattering into a sideband channel on the opposite electrode with probability while, coherently, a hole is excited and scattered with probability into the sideband above the gap edge, leaving one cooper pair on the right electrode. Thus, the coherent excitations on the ladder result in current step [17, 18, 23, 24, 25, 26, 27, 28]. In practice, only the first- () and second-order () current steps are visible in our tunneling junctions due to the relatively small step size.
Figure 2. DC transport characteristics of Al/AlO/Al Josephson junctions. a, Signed – characteristics for three junctions with , , and at a fixed oxidation exposure of 120 Torr·min. Dotted vertical lines mark ; the dashed guide indicates the normal-state conductance . b, versus on a logarithmic scale for the same three junctions as in a. Dashed lines denote the extraction of the step amplitudes and . c, Schematic of the two lowest-order Andreev tunneling processes. For a single quasiparticle excitation and barrier traversal occurs, giving . For transport requires coherent crossings of a hole-like (left-traveling) and electron-like quasiparticle (right-traveling), resulting in an additional cooper pair () on the right electrode. This process has amplitude , with each coherent channel crossing contributing a factor .
Figure 3. Normal-state conductance, effective transparency () and effective channel number () versus junction area for the high-aspect-ratio (HAR) sets (a-c) and Square Set A (d-f). a,d, versus . HAR Sets A and B have a short dimension of either nm or nm and correspond to different fabrication batches while set C varies both and . Square Set A comprises four oxidation exposures (15, 30, 120, and 240 Torr·min). Dashed lines are one-parameter fits () to each series. Insets: false-color SEM images of a representative HAR and square junction with the electrode widths , marked (scale bars 500 nm). b,e, versus . was previously assumed to be constant with junction area [21]. Here it increases with area in every HAR set, whereas the square junctions are non-monotonic with peak near µm. Large junctions show decreasing as (dashed guide). c,f, Point-wise (Eq. (3)) versus . The HAR samples show a strongly sublinear , while square devices have constant for µm and then ( in µm) for larger junctions (, dashed guide). Insets: versus for junctions with µS. Independent of oxidation condition, the points are collinear with inverse slope corresponding to a constant (fit to HAR Sets A and B) and (Square Set A, solid).
Figure S3. Effective transparency () and effective channel number () versus oxidation exposure. a, versus oxidation exposure on log–log axes for Square Set A junction areas from 0.054 to 1.71 . b, Channel density versus oxidation exposure on log–log axes. No consistent trend is observed. Variation for the smallest area ( ) is attributed to large propagated error in due to its small amplitude.
Having established the transport mechanism, the two primary observables reflecting the behavior of , are the effective number of channels and the effective transparency , which are defined as:
The normal-state conductance is extracted from a linear fit to the ohmic branch well above , and , are extracted as in Figure 2b. The values of and from experimental - data are plotted in Figure 3, with additional datasets available in the Supplementary Information (§ 2.4). Due to the starkly differing area dependencies, we segregate the data from rectangular junctions with (Figure 3a-Figure 3c) and square junctions with (Figure 3d-Figure 3f). Baseline vs curves in Figure 3a,Figure 3c, show typical linear behavior and it is only by looking at the subgap that the scaling behavior begins to differ. Focusing on HAR in Figure 3b, we first observe that the data from HAR C are co-linear, even though the set spans junctions with a range of top- and bottom-electrode widths and lengths. More strikingly, however, is that depends on –increasing by an order of magnitude across the area range studied in all HAR datasets. The square junctions in Figure 3e also show an unexpected, area-dependent , but here the trend is non-monotonic. An emergent threshold length scale appears such that for , peaks and begins to decrease as . We observe that is process
dependent, such that Square Set A inverts at (), while square junctions on a Set B inverts near – () (Figure S2). Within the sets of devices, the value of is also independent of the oxidation exposure.
Figure S2. Supplemental fit example from an independent fabrication batch (Square Set B), demonstrating that the non-monotonic – trend reproduces across processes. Fits (solid lines) use eV. a, versus for oxidation exposures of 4, 87, and 480 Torr·min. The single smallest-area 4 Torr·min die ( , drawn) is excluded from the joint fit as an outlier. Inset: versus , showing the saturation of above . b, versus . Inset: versus for the small-junction regime (87 and 480 Torr·min dies), whose inverse slope gives a constant . c, Extracted Region-I disorder (bars) and mean Region-I and Region-II oxide thicknesses , (markers) for the Square Set A exposure series, HAR Sets A, B, and C, and Square Set B. The HAR Sets are fit as pure Region I, so no is shown for them.
The source of this area dependence can be traced to the dependence of on junction area, since all junction sets have (Figure 3a,Figure 3d). The inversion of in square junctions results from saturating at , the area of a junction of side (Eq. (4)), to a constant value as increases (Figure S4) while continues to increase thus lowering . We also note that the size of the edge-overlap between the top and bottom electrodes (“rising edge”) does not affect appreciably, since HAR A, B, and C all display a similar trend.
Figure S4. Subgap current versus junction area for the rectangular and square junction families. a, Raw versus , one marker per junction; thin lines connect per-area medians. b, Subgap current density , with each series normalized to its value at the smallest measured area (within HAR Sets A and B, the nm sweep shares its own set’s nm anchor, so each set reads as one band); the dotted line marks the reference level of 1. Compared with the near-linear (see vs in Figure 3a,Figure 3d), varies by more than an order of magnitude and dominantly contributes to .
Next, Using Eq. (3), is plotted as a function of in Figure 3c,Figure 3f. is flat or increases sub-linearly for , and is independent of oxidation exposure for devices within a given fabrication batch. Fitting versus for square junctions with , we find with in . For comparison, in a homogeneous tunnel barrier should scale linearly with area, up to for an ideal junction. Zooming in on the small area region, we plot directly as a function of (insets of Figure 3c,Figure 3f). Data points from the small junctions () fabricated in the same lot collapse to a common exposure-invariant line when . The inverse slope gives constant and for the Square Set A and HAR junctions, respectively. This conductance range corresponds to (considering ), which overlaps with typical in transmon circuits. A similar analysis was used previously in small break junctions with few channels, but colinearity is unexpected in planar SIS tunnel junctions with [25].
The experimental data above indicates that small square devices with and all HAR devices have increasing and effectively constant . This behavior is consistent with increased area resulting in the addition of channels with increasing transparency that dominate the transport. Conversely, junctions with both have and . Since is constant or slowly varying for (Figure S4), we infer that only low transparency channels are added with increased area.
Based on these trends, we introduce an analysis framework which utilizes the area-dependence to extract and characterize the underlying channel transparency distribution . The data suggests two distinct disorder regions in the junctions, denoted Region I and Region II and shown schematically in Figure 4a. Region I corresponds to the small square devices and HAR junctions. Its oxide is assumed to have greater spatial variability, with mean thickness and thickness standard deviation . Region II emerges in larger square junctions and has more uniform thickness, resembling an ideal oxide. The oxide thickness distribution in this region has mean and standard deviation , with . The observed constant (Figure S4), and therefore reflect the crossover from Region I to Region II. The disordered Region I remains fixed in size, while only low-disorder Region II is added for at a rate proportional to . Algebraically, the areas of Region I (Region II), (), are then defined as
Figure 4. Two-region disorder model and fits to the experimental data. a, Schematic. Region I is a disordered oxide with thickness distribution (large ) occupying : the whole junction when and a fixed area otherwise (Eq. (4)). Region II is a more uniform oxide, (small ), covering the remaining area . Arrows indicate the transparency of the channels within each region, larger arrows corresponding to higher transparencies. b,c, Simulated and versus channel number for a junction composed only of Region I (), for , 0.14, 0.18, 0.22, 0.26, and 0.30 nm (color bar) at fixed nm. For small , is size-independent and (gray dashed line, ); increasing makes both observables strongly size-dependent. Curves are terminated where the thinnest channel of the distribution reaches . The shaded band marks for –1 m, the range swept in d,e. d,e, Region I Region II transition, sweeping from 0.1 to 1 m (color bar, shaded band) at fixed with nm and with nm. Open circles mark , where the Region-I channel count saturates (the simulation carries no sidewall term); dashed lines are the pure Region-I (, blue) and pure Region-II (, orange) limits. f,g, Experimental and versus (markers) with model fits (lines) for the four Square Set A exposure series and HAR Sets A and B (100 Torr·min). The extracted parameters are listed in Table 1. All simulations use eV, , and deterministic order statistics.
where is the area, sidewalls included, of a square junction of side . We model the tunneling behavior in Regions I and II assuming spatially inhomogeneous direct tunneling across a trapezoidal energy barrier shape, hence applying the Simmons model at [29, 30]. The low-voltage transparency at zero temperature is given by
where is the barrier thickness, , is the electron mass, is the potential energy barrier height, , and is the areal channel density assumed for this simulation. The number of simulated conducting channels is then given as . In this model, the tunneling transmission acts as a sieve whereby the channels located in regions with the thinnest barrier have an over-sized influence on , compounded at second order in . Choosing an appropriate thickness distribution , is therefore critical to the model accuracy, and we show in § 2.5 that a normal more accurately reproduces the observed experimental results. Refer to § 2.5 for comparisons of functional forms of and any details of the simulations and fitting methodology.
To connect the model to the observed trends, we begin with simulations of and for representative parameters (Figure 4b-Figure 4e). For the single-region case (HAR devices and small-area square junctions, which contain only Region I), we fix and and vary . Within a proper parameter range, an area dependence in is reproduced for (and strongly so for ), which corresponds to () at in Figure 4b,Figure 4c. Likewise, is linear with , but flattens out as is increased. Next, we simulate the behavior of large square junctions by adding a Region II with much lower disorder. Extending the results from Figure 4b,Figure 4c, we fix parameters , , and . The threshold length is used as the floating parameter with results shown in Figure 4d,Figure 4e. Both transition from the pure Region-I curve () toward the pure Region-II curve (). In Region II, where , decreases and eventually becomes linear in similar to the experimental data. Interestingly, this area dependence arises intrinsically from the sampling of the transparency distribution . Because is fat-tailed, i.e., its right tail does not quickly decay to zero as increases, sampling more channels (or, equivalently, increasing the junction area) preferably picks up high- outliers, producing a scaling similar to that shown in Figure 1c. is therefore governed by non-self-averaging behavior: its expectation value does not reflect the bulk of the channels, but is instead determined by rare, high-transparency outliers.
Assuming HAR junctions are pure Region I, experimental data is fit using a cost-minimization algorithm as described in the Supplementary Information, § 2.6. For square junctions, the two smallest areas are assumed to be Region-I dominant (for the 240 Torr-min series the second- and third-smallest, the smallest being an outlier), thus parameters are first fit per oxidation exposure using data from just these two areas. The first-stage result then seeds a joint fit over the entire area range, which determines and . Since the measured keeps decreasing and does not saturate at large (Figure 4f), can only be bounded from above, nm. The bound is set by the Region-II versus curves, which must satisfy at every area. All fits below this bound are equivalent (Figure S9), therefore is fixed at 0.10 nm during the optimization. The fit results are shown in Figure 4f,Figure 4g and the extracted parameters are listed in Table 1. The model accurately reproduces the trends in both , as function of , , including the sharp change of trends at .
| Device | (Torr·min) | ( µm) | (nm) | (nm) | (nm) | |
| Square A | 15 | 676 | 1.411 | 0.280 | 0.199 | 0.974 |
| Square A | 30 | 918 | 1.444 | 0.284 | 0.197 | 0.993 |
| Square A | 120 | 1906 | 1.493 | 0.283 | 0.189 | 1.070 |
| Square A | 240 | 3090 | 1.545 | 0.290 | 0.188 | 1.091 |
| HAR A | 100 | 1495 | 1.306 | 0.225 | 0.173 | — |
| HAR B | 100 | 1333 | 1.292 | 0.222 | 0.172 | — |
| HAR C (, var.) | 96 | 1243 | 1.388 | 0.261 | 0.188 | — |
Table 1. Region-I and Region-II fit parameters at eV on the total junction area . is the oxidation exposure (static O pressure × oxidation time); is the median normal-state resistance·area product of the junctions in each series (Supplementary Table S1). The joint Square Set A fit gives nm ( µm); nm.
Figure S9. Bounding the Region-II roughness : the two-region joint fit for the 240 Torr·min Square Set A condition (16 junctions over six areas; open circles are the per-area medians the cost is scored on, small dots individual junctions), re-solved with pinned at twelve values from 0.005 to 0.30 nm (colorbar), refitting and at each. a, versus . Solid curves lie inside the cost interval ( nm) and form a single indistinguishable bundle: a 28× range of , compensated by pm of , moves by only 6%. Dashed curves are excluded by the data. The vertical line marks ; below it the junction is pure Region I and has no channels to describe. b, versus , same encoding. Inset: the fit cost versus , flat to 1% over 0.005–0.14 nm and then rising steeply (3× at 0.20 nm, 60× at 0.30 nm, marked ×); the dotted line is the threshold. The transport data therefore set only an upper bound on ; the convention nm (thick curve; boxed value on the colorbar) lies inside the allowed plateau.
The fitted parameters in Table 1 can then be used to generate the corresponding transparency distribution for a typical junction of a desired area. As an example, we choose the Square Set A 30 Torr·min parameters (Table 1) to calculate representative histograms of (Figure 5a). These histograms are used to estimate and for square junctions across the range µm. In large junctions, although the total number of channels in Region II far exceeds that in Region I, all 50 of the most transparent channels still lie in Region I. Figure 5b quantifies the fractional contribution of the top 10, 50, and 1000 channels to and . Surprisingly, the top 10 contribute of at every area. Even in the largest devices, where Region II supplies of the channels and nearly all of , remains carried by a small number of Region-I channels. This dominance of by so few channels is consistent with the small, slowly varying . For a more direct comparison with transmon results, we plot the experimental data at GHz and overlay contours of the same ratio in Figure 5c. Each fitted curve reduces to a single point in this plane, with all values falling between and . These values are of similar magnitude to those in earlier work, but point to an alternative interpretation [16, 21]. Kim et al. carefully attributed the harmonics primarily to parasitic series inductance, under the assumption of a fixed, area-independent junction contribution (). Our methodology shows that the HAR geometries used in that study represent a special case in which the linear trend in can equally arise from non-ergodic scaling within the junction itself.
Figure 5. Simulated channel statistics and implications for qubit junctions. a, Histograms of channel transparencies simulated with the fitted Square Set A 30 Torr·min parameters (Table 1) for devices of size (top) and (bottom). For both areas, all 50 of the most transparent channels (dark navy) are found in Region I, despite the large device being Region II channels. b, Fraction of and carried by the top , 50, and 1000 most-transparent channels versus for the 30 Torr·min simulation. The top 10 channels already carry of at every area, while their share of decreases rapidly with area. c, Josephson-harmonics optimization map: contours of in the plane at , evaluated at fixed . Markers show the fitted Region-I parameters of each device family in this work (Square Set A and B, and HAR Sets A, B, and C). The right bar places each family on the resulting scale.
The area dependence observed provides a design handle for superconducting circuits, showing that higher Josephson harmonic content is inherently set by junction geometry for fixed oxide properties. The ensemble is a property of the oxide, and as more junctions are placed in a circuit the law of large numbers dictates that the extreme values will be sampled. In systems with thousands of qubits, designers will need to account for those atypical junctions with very transparent channels sampled from the extreme right tail of and with anomalously large higher harmonic content. The only way to eliminate these channels is to reduce oxide thickness variability so that never develops a fat tail and remains self-averaging.
The data indicate that this disorder is inherited from the metal rather than generated by the oxidation, since is independent of oxidation exposure while grows with it (Table 1). Likewise, is exposure-independent yet differs between processes. The fitted roughness – is comparable to a single atomic step of Al (–), whereas is sub-monolayer, suggesting that Region I is oxide grown over a stepped or faceted bottom-electrode surface and Region II is oxide grown over flatter terraces. Grain boundaries are the natural candidate for such a surface, and cross-sectional TEM and atomistic simulations indicate that oxide grown over boundaries between crystallographic domains and along film edges differs in thickness and structure from that over the domain interiors [31, 32, 33, 34, 35, 36]. Sidewall roughness of the climbing edge is a second candidate, but the rising-edge overlap has no appreciable effect on (HAR C). Moreover, a purely perimeter or edge contribution would grow as and make increase at least as , whereas we observe saturation. Rather than an edge effect, the fixed size of may therefore reflect a systematic roughness of the Al surface that arises when electrodes are fabricated with critical dimensions below .
Finally, because the measurement and analysis techniques presented are insensitive to series inductance, our area-dependent subgap characterization provides a geometry- and process-agnostic screen for the harmonic content intrinsic to Josephson junctions, and a powerful methodology for comparing junction fabrication processes. Applied consistently, the optimization map of Figure 5c enables such comparisons across processes, provided the geometric trends identified in this work are taken into account.
Supplementary information. Supplementary Information is available for this paper.
Acknowledgements. We thank John Teufel, Matt Matheny and Bastien Dassonneville for helpful discussions; Simon Luong, Lawrence Wong and Matthew Fling for hardware and cryogenics support; and the staff across the AWS Center for Quantum Computing (CQC) who enabled this work.
Declarations
Funding: Not applicable.
Competing interests: The authors declare no competing interests.
Data availability: Data supporting the findings of this study are available from the corresponding author upon reasonable request.
Author contribution: D.J.P. contributed to the experimental design, developed the instrumentation and model, performed the primary measurements, analyzed the data, and wrote the manuscript. A.B., M.C., and G.R. contributed to the analysis, played a critical role in contextualizing the results and framing the discussion, with A.B. and M.C. also helping to draft the manuscript. M.P., H.L., and C.C. contributed to the experimental design and measurements, and provided editorial support. Y.S. provided supervision and contributed to the experimental design and manuscript editing.
References
Supplementary Information
Non-ergodic Area Scaling of Andreev Transport in Al/AlO/Al Josephson Junctions
This document provides supplementary information for “Non-ergodic Area Scaling of Andreev Transport in Al/AlO/Al Josephson Junctions,” including fabrication details, measurement setup, supplemental DC transport data, details of the direct tunneling model with oxide thickness disorder, and model fitting procedures.
Symbol Definitions
: oxide barrier thickness (nm).
: mean oxide thickness (nm) of a generic thickness distribution , used where no region is specified; the fitted Region-I and Region-II values are and .
: standard deviation of the oxide thickness distribution (nm).
: average barrier height (eV) of the AlO insulator.
: tunneling wavefunction decay constant (nm); the transmission probability decays as .
: dimensionless tunneling disorder parameter. is the fat-tail onset (Eq. (16)); for the sampled becomes size-dependent over the experimental range, and for the thinnest channels exponentially dominate the higher moments (extreme-value regime).
: oxide thickness probability distribution.
: areal density of independent tunneling channels ().
: total number of channels in a junction.
: -th moment of the transparency distribution.
: effective transparency.
: effective number of channels.
, : log-normal shape parameters, , .
: total junction area ().
: threshold length (); junctions with behave as pure Region I.
: bottom-electrode thickness.
: area, sidewalls included, of a square junction of side ; the Region-I area saturates at .
, : areas of Regions I and II (main text, Eq. (4)); for and otherwise, .
, : mean thickness and disorder of Region I (the disordered, bounded region).
, : mean thickness and disorder of Region II (the more uniform region).
, : barrier heights of Regions I and II (eV).
: superconducting phase difference across the junction.
, : amplitudes of the first and second Fourier harmonics of the current-phase relation (CPR).
: CPR skew ratio; to leading order.
Fabrication
See Table S1. All junctions are Manhattan-style Al/AlOx/Al junctions, shadow-evaporated in a UHV electron-beam evaporator (Angstrom Engineering, HAR A in a Plassys) on high-resistivity Si. The tunnel barrier was formed by static oxidation in O; the oxidation condition is quoted as the exposure , the product of the static O pressure and the oxidation time (Torrmin), which sets the barrier thickness and specifies the process. For the median value is given and the number of junctions analysed. Individual values span –, which covers standard fabrication conditions reported in the literature [13, 37, 38, 39, 40]. Areas are , with the bottom- and the top-electrode width and the bottom-electrode thickness; the second term is the overlap of the top electrode with the two sidewalls of the bottom electrode, over which the top electrode climbs. , are design values except for Square Set A, whose face dimensions were measured by SEM on a duplicate wafer, since the as-fabricated dimensions differed from design. The tabulated and include the sidewall term.
| Set | Junction geometry () | (Torr·min) | () | () | |
| Square A | – | 15 | 0.054–1.71 | 676 | 8 |
| Square A | – | 30 | 0.054–1.71 | 918 | 16 |
| Square A | – | 120 | 0.054–1.71 | 1906 | 17 |
| Square A | – | 240 | 0.054–1.71 | 3090 | 16 |
| Square B | – | 4 | 0.018–1.08 | 340 | 7 |
| Square B | – | 87 | 0.055–1.53 | 1497 | 10 |
| Square B | – | 480 | 0.034–1.53 | 3474 | 12 |
| HAR A | or 0.3, – | 100 | 0.045–0.62 | 1495 | 22 |
| HAR B | or 0.3, – | 100 | 0.045–0.62 | 1333 | 16 |
| HAR C | –, – | 96 | 0.038–0.45 | 1243 | 10 |
Table S1. Fabrication and geometry of the measured junction sets.
Measurement Setup and Wiring
All measurements were performed in a dilution refrigerator (Bluefors LD) at a base temperature of approximately 10 mK. Junctions were mounted in an Al/Cu light-tight sample package. A schematic of the DC measurement circuit is shown in Figure S1.
DC bias lines were heavily filtered using a combination of Basel MFT silver-powder filters and modified QDevil filters, configured in two stages. The low-pass component values were chosen such that the total line resistance satisfies while maintaining a 3 dB cutoff frequency below 50 kHz.
A Basel LNHR DAC served as the low-noise DC voltage source. Voltage was measured using an SRS SR560 low-noise voltage preamplifier followed by a Keithley 7510 digital multimeter. Current was measured using an SRS SR570 low-noise current preamplifier and a second Keithley 7510.
Supplemental DC Transport Data
Every type of junction analyzed showed the geometry- and -dependent behavior. Here we show further examples, with fits, which demonstrate that the phenomenology remains the same, but the absolute magnitudes of , can depend on the individual fabrication process. Figure S2 shows data from Square Set B with oxidation exposures of 4, 87, and 480 Torr·min.
and versus oxidation exposure
Figure S3 plots (see Figure 2b of the main text for definitions of ) versus oxidation exposure for fixed junction area. For all areas, the observed power-law dependence is consistent with a Mott–Cabrera oxidation process [41, 42], wherein the oxide thickness () grows logarithmically with exposure. Substituting into an exponential tunneling model, , yields the power law , which linearizes on the log–log axes of Figure S3. Here is the logarithmic growth coefficient of the oxide, with units of length, so that the exponent is dimensionless. Fitting the Region-I thicknesses of main-text Table 1 against gives nm, i.e., 0.11 nm of additional oxide per decade of exposure (Region
II gives 0.045 nm, or 0.10 nm per decade, essentially the same), hence a predicted exponent . This agrees with the measured slopes , which have a median of across the six areas. This result serves as confirmation of fabrication consistency between sample lots, which is critical for reliably extracting the conclusions presented in the main text.
Figure S3b plots for fixed junction areas as a function of oxidation exposure. Many of the 120 and 240 Torrmin data points for the smallest devices have extremely small values, which propagate into correspondingly large error bars in . No
correlation is observed between and oxidation exposure over the range of areas and exposures covered in this study.
Determining the form of based on the area dependence of ,
The oxide thickness distribution in a Josephson junction has been evaluated with TEM metrology and described by both normal [32, 43] and log-normal distributions [35], with the latter argued to be more physical due to the presence of thick regions serving as an upper tail. The right-skew of the oxide thickness distribution is less critical than the shape of the left tail due to the exponential tunneling dominance of thin channels. TEM on cross-sectional cuts is useful for correlation, but cannot easily distinguish the subtle difference in the extreme limits of the left tail structure. Therefore, we develop an analysis procedure that includes (i) introduction of moment generating functions, (ii) order statistics, (iii) tail enhancement, and (iv) moment convergence using order statistics.
The experimental results in the main text indicate both geometric and area dependencies which are unexpected in ergodic systems. For the square devices, is both area-dependent and non-monotonic, while has two distinct regions with different dependence. For both small-area junctions and high-aspect-ratio junctions, increases with area, while is constant or increases sub-linearly. Here, the experimental results are compared with possible solution spaces of log-normal and normal oxide thickness distributions to test whether each can recreate the dependence observed for . The overarching goal of this section is to define the correct distribution, understand how this distribution results in the area dependence of the observed , and discuss junction quality metrics based on the properties of .
Moment-Generating Functions
Here we derive expressions for the moment-generating function for both normal and log-normal distributions. These functions are useful for evaluating the role of rare tunneling events, which is critical for analyzing subgap – data.
The main text defines the analysis parameters in terms of the experimentally measured . These can also be expanded in terms of the moments of , , as follows:
can then be written in terms of :
Normal distribution
The normal distribution has the form:
from which we can calculate the moment (using , where is the prefactor of the Simmons transparency, Eq. (5) of the main text):
Defining a shifted mean , simplifies to:
The experimental data are limited to the first two moments of :
Defining an criterion, and the validity of Eqs. S9–S10.
In the equations above, weights the thickness distribution by , and the channels that carry are not those near but those near which are displaced into the thin tail by
where the displacement is expressed in units of the disorder itself. Equivalently, the standard deviation of . Both expressions are functions of only: they contain no reference to , , or . The condition , i.e. , is therefore the point at which each successive moment is sourced by a subpopulation displaced a full standard deviation from the mean relative to the previous one. Below it, all accessible moments are set by channels within of and the transparency statistics self-average; above it, is controlled by a rare thin-channel tail whose sampling depends on . This is the defining property of the fat-tail regime and the reason can be used as a figure of merit for the disorder. The result is self-consistent with the size-dependent estimate in the main text also. For eV ( nm), corresponds to nm. is therefore the lower limit for any size dependence, although the effect is gradual. Below it, is size-independent at every . The threshold quoted in the main text, , lies above this limit because the experimental window is finite. Between the two, the tail exists but is not sampled strongly enough to show over our range of junction sizes.
The same logic sets the limits of Eqs. (14) and (15). They are second-order Laplace approximations about . Checked against direct numerical integration of Eq. (12) at nm, the closed form for is accurate to 2% at and 6% at , but the expression fails entirely by , where passes through zero and the prefactor diverges. At the fitted Region-I disorder (Table S2) is negative, so Eqs. (14)–(15) cannot be evaluated at the parameters of these devices and are retained only to expose the structure. Every moment, , , and value quoted in this work is instead computed from either the order-statistics sum (Eq. (23)), from Monte Carlo sampling, or from direct numerical integration of Eq. (12). All of these calculations apply the same two cutoffs, a numerical floor nm on the thickness and on the transparency. At every fitted and every measured , the smallest order statistic lies well above one monolayer, so no fitted parameter depends on either cutoff. The far-field illustrations (Figure S5 and Figure S6) extrapolate to channel counts and disorders at which the thin tail reaches . There the capped and perfectly transmitting sub-population carries the higher moments, with the region where it dominates marked in Figure S6.
| Geometry | (nm) | (nm) | ||
| Square Set A (120 Torr·min) | 1.498 | 0.285 | 0.190 | 1.56 |
| HAR A+B ( nm, pooled) | 1.302 | 0.226 | 0.173 | 1.24 |
Table S2. Small-junction (pure Region-I) best-fit parameters for Figure S8, with barrier height fixed at eV ( nm).
Figure S5. Tail enhancement factor comparing order-statistics (OS) summation to the exact integral, for normal (solid) and log-normal (dashed) thickness distributions with nm and eV, using the numerical floor nm and the unitarity cap of all calculations in this work. Shaded bands denote the 99% confidence interval (0.5–99.5 percentile) of the Monte Carlo simulations. Without spatial correlations, the variation around results in overestimated tail amplification for small . a, Convergence with channel count at fixed , 1.05, and 1.55; thin horizontal lines mark the limit. At the onset value the curves are flat, i.e. is already converged at . At the normal-distribution curve saturates early because its thinnest channels reach the cap ; the capped sub-population then carries . b, Dependence on disorder strength at fixed , with 1000 Monte Carlo realizations drawn from the corresponding distribution. The dotted vertical line marks the fat-tail onset . The dimensionless parameter is the natural scale for the normal distribution; log-normal curves are plotted at matched variance (i.e. the same physical ), with shape parameter . At large the two distributions diverge because the log-normal tail vanishes as , suppressing the thin-barrier enhancement that dominates .
Figure S6. Required number of channels for the partial moments and to converge to within a fractional tolerance of their asymptotic values, shown as a function of for normal a,c and log-normal b,d thickness distributions. The red contour marks , i.e. a junction at . converges according to its variance, ; convergence is set by . For the log-normal distribution, typical moments are converged for all relevant ; is converged for devices with –. For the normal distribution, depends on and , with convergence occurring across a large range –. For disordered oxides ( nm), small areas may therefore be expected to have depend on . effectively never converges for these devices, consistent with experimental results where vary across the entire range of junction areas. The dashed line in the normal-distribution panels bounds the corner of parameter space in which more than 0.1% of all channels sit at the unitarity cap ; there the capped sub-population dominates the moments, and the rapid convergence reflects the cap rather than the sampling of the normal tail. All fitted devices lie far outside this corner.
Log-normal distribution
For the log-normal distribution, we have:
For the log-normal to have the same mean and variance as the normal distribution, and , giving and when is small. The moment is
with
Order Statistics and Partial Moments
The expectation value (first moment) of the order statistic (OS, or ordered thickness) taken from a set of oxide thicknesses with given thickness distribution is given by:
where is the oxide thickness, , and is the PDF of the th order statistic. For a normal distribution this is estimated using the quantile (probit) approximation [44]:
where denotes the standard-normal quantile (probit) function. For a log-normal distribution, is then given by:
Mean values of the partial moments can then be calculated for () using order statistics:
Tail Enhancement
At the heart of the non-self-averaging behavior and experimental trends for , is the fat tail of the distribution. To quantify the rare-event statistics resulting from the tail, we use the above formalism and define an order tail-enhancement factor as the ratio of the -th moment to the value expected if all channels had the mean thickness :
Since is defined per channel (Eq. (23) normalized by ), carries no explicit factor; its dependence enters only through the sampling of the tail. Figure S5 shows numerical results from Eqs. (12),(18) compared with results from 1000 Monte Carlo (MC) trials and OS calculations. The amount of oxide thickness disorder is represented by the dimensionless , which increases with . On one extreme, represents a perfectly uniformly thick oxide layer. In such a case, nearly all channels have the same and . In the other extreme, grows monotonically as becomes of order . This is further shown in the - simulation in Figure 4, where is fixed but is swept through representative values for a junction oxide.
For a normal distribution of , the tunneling transmission maps a symmetric oxide thickness distribution into a heavily right-skewed transparency distribution. Both the exponential decay and the prefactor amplify the contribution of thin-barrier channels. Even modest oxide roughness produces a fat-tailed whose higher moments are dominated by rare thin channels. The resulting grows as disorder increases. Conversely, for the log-normal thickness distribution, the saddle point (Eq. (19)) never shifts far into the thin-barrier tail (, i.e. ), and saturates at a fixed value in junctions with . It is this tail enhancement or fat-tail of the distribution that is largely responsible for the area dependence observed in , .
The expectation value of probability distributions with fat tails depends on the number of samples. For small devices, the expectation value is channel-number dependent and the value reflects the typical result, because few extreme outliers are sampled. Increasingly, more extreme values (thin channels) occur which dominate , , and push the typical solution toward the average. These rare thin-channel transparencies are large enough to rival the summed transparency of all remaining channels. With a large enough device, or large enough number of samples, the typical value of , converges to the fully sampled average. The number of channels required to transition from the typical to the average depends on the relative level of oxide disorder, given by , as in Figure S5. The fully sampled average regime is well described by the -independent values given numerically by Eqs. (12),(18).
Figure S5 exemplifies the second-moment tail enhancement and its -dependence for normal distributions with . The log-normal distribution, however, has orders-of-magnitude smaller and requires only – channels for to reach the fully-sampled average. Normal-distributed oxide thicknesses have -dependent convergence of the OS simulations to the fully-sampled numerical result. Figure S5 indicates that at , is required for convergence, at least 5 times as large as the biggest samples here. At the earlier saturation is set by the cap rather than by sampling.
Numerical Comparison of log-normal and normal convergence using order statistics
The convergence of partial moments to their average determines the area dependence of . When partial moments are converged, will not depend on . While the saturation of matches convergence of (see Figure S5), here we quantitatively map the -dependent convergence using the coefficient of variation . If we require to lie within of with probability 0.68, we have:
where defines convergence, and defines convergence and hence linearity in , both of which are signatures of convergence to the thermodynamic regime. Figure S6 shows the required for different . If are small, normal and log-normal convergence of occur in the same order of magnitude. However, as increase together, the log-normal distribution results in convergence orders of magnitude faster for (). The areas probed experimentally all fall into the simulation range that has converged for . The order of magnitude of is not consistent with experimental results, which show no convergence of .
Large Junction ,
For large junctions, converge to their average values given by numerical integration of Eq. (18) and Eq. (12). From Eq. (13):
where is a constant. Similarly, converges to a constant value:
both of which follow from Eq. (13) and inherit its validity range ; as noted above, they are not evaluable at the fitted and the quoted values come from the exact OS/MC/numerical calculations.
The model reproduces the experimental area dependence. The constant- limit of Eq. (26) is the asymptote reached only once has converged, which for these disorder parameters requires (Figure S6); over the measured range instead grows by roughly an order of magnitude. The experimental larger-area trend is dominated by the transition to less-disordered oxide in larger devices.
Small-area , : Why is there an area dependence?
We now derive the expected area dependence of using order statistics. From Eq. (23), the partial moments are deterministic functions of . When the channel count increases , a new thinnest channel always appears with expected thickness:
for the normal distribution, and
for log-normal. Simultaneously, all existing quantiles shift from . In the small-junction regime the dominant contribution to comes from the new extreme channel; the quantile compression of existing channels contributes at . Defining the transparency of this new extreme channel to be , the updated effective transparency is:
and the expected change in per added channel is:
We can make the approximation since even the most transparent single channel carries negligible compared to the sum. increases with area whenever the new thinnest channel is more transparent than the current weighted average, i.e., .
For the normal distribution, the expected minimum thickness from Eq. (28) gives:
For large , , so and:
This function grows sub-polynomially but without bound in (as ). In contrast, for the log-normal distribution:
with and , giving:
The rate , which is an experimentally measurable quantity, trends to zero. Noting that converges to zero much more slowly than , saturates at modest while continues to grow. This causes the log-normal to converge to its true average in all but the smallest of junctions, while the normal-distribution continues to increase. Based on the areal trends predicted by the model, only a normal distribution of oxide thickness matches the experimental dependence observed in .
Validating the existence of a small-junction solution space
Although the area-dependent trend of is directly predicted for normal, the question arises as to whether any physically reasonable combination of , , satisfies the actual experimental , trends. As a demonstration, we consider the three smallest junction sizes () because increases monotonically in this region. OS is then used to calculate the deterministic solution space of normal and log-normal distributions for , , and . For a given solution, if and , that parameter set scores +1. For every die where this holds we add another point; the 16 dies at the three smallest sizes (, 0.080 and 0.153 ) are scored. Results for both normal and log-normal are shown in Figure S7, with the solution spaces resulting from different () values. Curves sit along constant (normal) and (log-normal). The collinearity of the points indicates that acts only as a scaling parameter within the model, and can be chosen based on TEM data or literature values for the oxide and contacts. As Figure S7,Figure S7 shows, no combinations from the log-normal distribution fit more than a single experimental () data point. The rapid convergence of results in (i) a linear vs. relationship instead of the sublinear dependence observed experimentally for small areas, and (ii) , instead of the linear increase. These results are consistent with the convergence analysis presented in Figure S5 and Figure S6, but shown explicitly to hold also for the experimental data. We therefore conclude that the underlying is described best by a normal distribution (Eq. (11)). We cannot rule out the possibility that the normal distribution skews right, but this upper tail is irrelevant to the tunneling transparencies and adds unnecessary complexity. This result reflects the properties of the lower tail of the oxide thickness distribution, where the majority of tunnel current flows.
Figure S7. Comparing the area dependence of junction observables assuming normal or log-normal oxide thickness distributions. a, Colored points denote where, for eV, a solution curve passes within 10% of any experimental pair. Each curve is scored against the 16 dies at the three smallest junction sizes and . From a total simulation pool of 288,684 valid combinations, for , 329 curves matched a single die and none matched more than one. For , 749 curves matched, up to five dies at once, and these curves captured the area dependence much more accurately for , as shown in b and c. The dashed lines in c represent the expected when reach convergence. d, Example histogram comparing optimum fit curves from (b,c). The normal distribution results in a much wider fat-tailed . e, The linear dependence in (a) shows that is simply a rescaling parameter for the solution space. The true metric determining is . Likewise, every solution has , well above the fat-tail onset and the size-dependence threshold , so the entire solution space is in the non-self-averaging regime.
For a normal distribution, convergence of to the true average requires or , which is larger than standard junction sizes in quantum computing circuits. The histograms of the distributions from (b),(c) are shown in Figure S7 on a log scale. As predicted above, fewer than channels in the fat tail account for the differences between normal and log-normal. As Figure S7 shows, the solution space collapses onto lines of constant : because enters only through , and depend on through and alone, and is the -independent invariant of the fit. Every solution has , which places the entire space beyond both thresholds established above: the fat-tail onset (Eq. (16)), above which is sourced by a rare thin-channel tail rather than by channels near , and the size-dependence threshold quoted in the main text, above which the sampled varies over the experimental window $10^4 < N_{\mathrm{ch}} < 2 \times 10^6$ (strongly so for ). The Region-I fits of Table S2 to lie in the same regime. Below the onset, by contrast, all accessible moments are carried by channels within of and the transparency statistics self-average, so is size-independent and (main text, Figure 4b,Figure 4c); Region II, with $\omega_I \approx 0.55 (§ 2.6), sits below the size-dependence threshold and self-averages over the measured range. is therefore the figure of merit for junction quality: it sets both the convergence of with and the tail enhancement (Figure S5), while fixes it for a given barrier height.
The remainder of the analysis will proceed considering only a normal distribution for .
Model Fitting
Small-Junction Fitting
We fit the small-junction (pure Region-I) regime using:
where is the cost function. As shown in Figure S7, the solution space for is not unique, but rather scales with the choice of . Further, for all samples tested in this study, which limits the fitting so that optimization is constrained and a global minimum can be found.
Results are shown in Figure S8. The OS method of extracting parameters is also confirmed using the same , , in MC simulations (1000 runs). MC has the advantage of showing the entire solution space, compared to OS which gives the typical result. Unfortunately, in non-self-averaging systems the average of the entire solution space implies randomness 1–2 orders of magnitude larger than experimentally observed. For this reason, channel homogeneity is handled more deterministically with order statistics. As shown in Figure S8, the MC median value tracks with the OS value with the same input parameters for , , . Large statistics of devices (hundreds), which is not experimentally viable, would be needed to account for the rare extreme events.
Figure S8. Small-area fits: order statistics (OS) and Monte Carlo simulations. The OS fit is performed on the pooled nm HAR junctions (Sets A and B) and on the Square Set A 120 Torr·min junctions at the two smallest areas () using Eq. (36) with parameters listed in Table S2. The error band uses fixed , while varying . MC simulations show 80% CI using the same parameters extracted from the OS fitting. No correlations are included in the MC simulations, therefore due to the non-self-averaging behavior of , the resulting error bars are an order of magnitude larger than experimentally (or ‘typically’) observed. If we re-solve for , while varying , the resulting error bands are invisible behind the original line, further confirming that acts only as a scaling parameter for junctions with the same fabrication process. a, vs. . b, vs. . c, vs. trends are correctly reproduced. The dependence of results from a large value which prevents from converging for μm. This is a consequence of a fat-tailed distribution, and can be reduced by fabricating junctions with smaller . Varying eV results in changes that are far greater than experimentally observed; therefore this disorder mechanism is not present in the junctions.
Region-II and Multi-device Fitting
eV and the Region-II roughness nm are held fixed, with serving as a scaling factor during combined cost minimization to find the remaining free parameters: , , and the threshold length that caps the Region-I area at once (main text, Eq. (4)). Results of the fitting are shown in Figure 4 in the main text. These results are deterministic and identical for all junctions of a given area .
Holding fixed is a convention and not a fit result. The transport data bound from above but the fit does not resolve it. Re-solving the joint fit with pinned at values spanning 0.005–0.30 nm, refitting and at each (Figure S9), leaves the cost flat to 1% up to nm, giving a 1 upper bound nm with no lower limit. Within this plateau is degenerate with : both act only through the thin-barrier tail of , and a 28 change in is absorbed by a pm shift of . The upper bound is algebraic, since Region II must remain self-averaging over the measured range. Therefore or nm at eV. Beyond this threshold the Region-II tail becomes non-self-averaging and dominates , erasing the small/large-junction contrast that defines . As rises, the fit cost rises accordingly by 3 at nm () and 60 at 0.30 nm. The adopted
nm () sits inside the allowed plateau, well below the fitted Region-I roughness – nm; the residual conventional freedom enters the quoted only as a pm systematic.
References
- [1]Josephson, B. D. Possible new effects in superconductive tunnelling. Physics letters 1, 251–253 (1962).DOI
- [2]Josephson, B. D. The discovery of tunnelling superconductors. Reviews of Modern Physics 46, 251 (1974).
- [3]Google Quantum AI. Exponential suppression of bit or phase errors with cyclic error correction. Nature 595, 383–387 (2021).DOI
- [4]Sivak, V. V. et al. Real-time quantum error correction beyond break-even. Nature 616, 50–55 (2023).DOI
- [5]Krinner, S. et al. Realizing repeated quantum error correction in a distance-three surface code. Nature 605, 669–674 (2022).DOI
- [6]Putterman, H. et al. Hardware-efficient quantum error correction via concatenated bosonic qubits. Nature 638, 927–934 (2025).DOI
- [7]Roy, A. & Devoret, M. Introduction to parametric amplification of quantum signals with josephson circuits. Comptes Rendus Physique 17, 740–755 (2016).DOI
- [8]Albertinale, E. et al. Detecting spins by their fluorescence with a microwave photon counter. Nature 600, 434–438 (2021).DOI
- [9]Fagaly, R. L. Superconducting quantum interference device instruments and applications. Review of Scientific Instruments 77, 101101 (2006).DOI
- [10]Kim, Y. et al. Evidence for the utility of quantum computing before fault tolerance. Nature 618, 500–505 (2023).DOI
- [11]Morvan, A. et al. Phase transition in random circuit sampling. Nature 634, 328–333 (2024).DOI
- [12]Bravyi, S., Dial, O., Gambetta, J. M., Gil, D. & Nazario, Z. The future of quantum computing with superconducting qubits. Journal of Applied Physics 132, 160902 (2022).DOI
- [13]Place, A. P. et al. New material platform for superconducting transmon qubits with coherence times exceeding 0.3 milliseconds. Nature communications 12, 1779 (2021).DOI
- [14]Ganjam, S. et al. Surpassing millisecond coherence in on chip superconducting quantum memories by optimizing materials and circuit design. Nature Communications 15, 3687 (2024).DOI
- [15]Bland, M. P. et al. Millisecond lifetimes and coherence times in 2d transmon qubits. Nature 647, 343–348 (2025). URL http://dx.doi.org/10.1038/s41586-025-09687-4.
- [16]Willsch, D., Rieger, D. & Winkel, P. e. a. Observation of Josephson harmonics in tunnel junctions. Nature Physics 20, 815–821 (2024). URL https://doi.org/ 10.1038/s41567-024-02400-8.
- [17]Beenakker, C. W. J. Universal limit of critical-current fluctuations in mesoscopic Josephson junctions. Physical Review Letters 67, 3836–3839 (1991).pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/10044838
- [18]Golubov, A. A., Kupriyanov, M. Y. & Il’ichev, E. The current-phase relation in josephson junctions. Rev. Mod. Phys. 76, 411–469 (2004). URL https://link.aps.org/doi/10.1103/RevModPhys.76.411.DOI
- [19]Féchant, M. et al. Offset charge dependence of measurement-induced transitions in transmons. Phys. Rev. Lett. 135, 180603 (2025). URL https://link.aps.org/doi/10.1103/yLJV-b4kj.DOI
- [20]Catelani, G., Nigg, S. E., Girvin, S. M., Schoelkopf, R. J. & Glazman, L. I. Decoherence of superconducting qubits caused by quasiparticle tunneling. Phys. Rev. B 86, 184514 (2012). URL https://link.aps.org/doi/10.1103/PhysRevB.86.184514.DOI
- [21]Kim, J. et al. Emergent harmonics in josephson tunnel junctions due to series inductance (2025). URL https://arxiv.org/abs/2507.08171. arXiv:2507.08171.
- [22]Refael, G. & Fisher, D. S. Energy correlations in random transverse field ising spin chains. Phys. Rev. B 70, 064409 (2004). URL https://link.aps.org/doi/10.1103/PhysRevB.70.064409.DOI
- [23]Shumeiko, V. S., Bratus, E. N. & Wendin, G. Scattering theory of superconductive tunneling in quantum junctions. Low Temperature Physics 23, 181–198 (1997). URL https://doi.org/10.1063/1.593475.
- [24]Lahiri, A., Choi, S.-J. & Trauzettel, B. Origin of the subharmonic gap structure of dc current-biased josephson junctions. Phys. Rev. B 111, L220504 (2025). URL https://link.aps.org/doi/10.1103/zbd5-1cc2.
- [25]van der Post, N., Peters, E. T., Yanson, I. K. & van Ruitenbeek, J. M. Subgap structure as function of the barrier in atom-size superconducting tunnel junctions. Phys. Rev. Lett. 73, 2611–2613 (1994). URL https://link.aps.org/doi/10.1103/PhysRevLett.73.2611.DOI
- [26]Octavio, M., Tinkham, M., Blonder, G. E. & Klapwijk, T. M. Subharmonic energy-gap structure in superconducting constrictions. Phys. Rev. B 27, 6739–6746 (1983). URL https://link.aps.org/doi/10.1103/PhysRevB.27.6739.DOI
- [27]Cuevas, J. C., Martín-Rodero, A. & Levy Yeyati, A. Hamiltonian approach to the transport properties of superconducting quantum point contacts. Physical Review B 54, 7366–7379 (1996).DOI
- [28]Flensberg, K., Bindslev Hansen, J. & Octavio, M. Subharmonic energy-gap structure in superconducting weak links. Physical Review B 38, 8707–8711 (1988).pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/9945647
- [29]Räisänen, I. & Maasilta, I. Improvement of the simmons model for tunnel junctions (2025). URL https://arxiv.org/abs/2511.16337. arXiv:2511.16337.
- [30]Simmons, J. G. Electric Tunnel Effect between Dissimilar Electrodes Separated by a Thin Insulating Film. Journal of Applied Physics 34, 2581–2590 (1963).DOI
- [31]Oh, J.-S. et al. Correlating aluminum layer deposition rates, josephson junction microstructure, and superconducting qubits’ performance. Acta Materialia 284, 120631 (2025). URL https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S1359645424009790.DOI
- [32]Cyster, M. J., Smith, J. S., Vogt, N. et al. Simulating the fabrication of aluminium oxide tunnel junctions. npj Quantum Information 7, 12 (2021). URL https://doi.org/10.1038/s41534-020-00360-4.
- [33]Kennedy, O. W., Cole, J. H. & Shelly, C. D. Josephson junction tuning described by depinning physics. Phys. Rev. Lett. 135, 196202 (2025). URL https://link.aps.org/doi/10.1103/xkqs-grnd.DOI
- [34]Wolff, O. F. et al. Structural control of two-level defect density revealed by high-throughput correlative measurements of josephson junctions (2026). URL https://arxiv.org/abs/2602.11469. arXiv:2602.11469.
- [35]Zhu, Y., Beaudoin, F. & Guo, H. Device variability of josephson junctions induced by interface roughness (2026). URL https://arxiv.org/abs/2602.03037. arXiv:2602.03037.
- [36]Zeng, L. J. et al. Direct observation of the thickness distribution of ultra thin alox barriers in al/alox/al josephson junctions. Journal of Physics D: Applied Physics 48, 395308 (2015). URL https://doi.org/10.1088/0022-3727/48/39/395308.
- [37]Arute, F. et al. Quantum supremacy using a programmable superconducting processor. Nature 574, 505–510 (2019).DOI
- [38]Gambetta, J. M., Chow, J. M. & Steffen, M. Building logical qubits in a superconducting quantum computing system. npj Quantum Information 3, 2 (2017).DOI
- [39]Barends, R. et al. Coherent Josephson qubit suitable for scalable quantum integrated circuits. Physical Review Letters 111, 080502 (2013).DOI
- [40]Krantz, P. et al. A quantum engineer’s guide to superconducting qubits. Applied Physics Reviews 6, 021318 (2019).DOI
- [41]Baran, J. D., Grönbeck, H. & Hellman, A. Mechanism for limiting thickness of thin oxide films on aluminum. Phys. Rev. Lett. 112, 146103 (2014). URL https://link.aps.org/doi/10.1103/PhysRevLett.112.146103.
- [42]Cabrera, N. & Mott, N. F. Theory of the oxidation of metals. Reports on Progress in Physics 12, 163–184 (1949).
- [43]Aref, T. et al. Characterization of aluminum oxide tunnel barriers by combining transport measurements and transmission electron microscopy imaging. Journal of Applied Physics 116, 073702 (2014). URL https://doi.org/10.1063/1.4893473.
- [44]David, H. A. & Nagaraja, H. N. Order Statistics 3rd edn. Wiley Series in Probability and Statistics (Wiley-Interscience, 2003).













