Introduction
The solution of QCD in D = 1 + 1 D = 1 + 1 D = 1 + 1 dimensions (QCD2 _2 2 ) found by ’t Hooft in 1974 [1 ] has inspired many studies and allowed insights into hadron and confinement dynamics (see [2 ] for some early contributions). ’t Hooft used light front quantization (states defined at equal x + = t + x x^+ = t + x x + = t + x ) in A + = A 0 + A 1 = 0 A^+ = A^0 + A^1 = 0 A + = A 0 + A 1 = 0 gauge, taking the limit of a large number of colors, N c → ∞ N_c \to\infty N c → ∞ at fixed g 2 N c g^2N_c g 2 N c . Planar Feynman diagrams were found to dominate, and bound states to be stable at leading order of 1 / N c 1/N_c 1/ N c [3 ] .
In 1978 Bars and Green [4 ] managed to derive ’t Hooft’s solution by quantizing QCD2 _2 2 at equal ordinary time t t t in Coulomb (Axial) gauge, A 1 = 0 A^1 = 0 A 1 = 0 . Special care was required since the confined quark propagator is singular and not Poincaré covariant. ’t Hooft’s result for the bound state wave functions was reproduced in the infinite momentum frame (IMF). Poincaré generators were found which satisfy the Lie algebra when operating on color singlet bound states. The boost covariance of the solution [4 ] was confirmed numerically, first in the rest frame [5 ] and more recently in a general frame [6 ] . There are also lattice studies of QCD2 _2 2 [7 ] .
The QCD2 _2 2 action is
S Q C D = ∫ d t d x [ 1 2 F a 01 F a 01 + ψ ˉ ( i ∂̸ − m − g A a 0 γ 0 T a + g A a 1 γ 1 T a ) ψ ] , F a 01 = ∂ t A a 1 + ∂ x A a 0 − g f a b c A b 0 A c 1 = ∫ d t d x [ 1 2 ( ∂ t A a 1 ) 2 + ψ ˉ ( i ∂̸ − m + g A a 1 γ 1 T a ) ψ ] (temporal gauge, A 0 → 0 ) (1) \begin{aligned}
S_{QCD} = \int dt\,dx \left[\frac{1}{2}F_a^{01}F_a^{01}+\bar{\psi}(i\not{\partial}-m-gA_a^0\gamma^0T^a+gA_a^1\gamma^1T^a)\psi\right], \qquad F_a^{01}=\partial_tA_a^1+\partial_xA_a^0-gf_{abc}A_b^0A_c^1 \\
&= \int dt\,dx \left[\frac{1}{2}(\partial_tA_a^1)^2+\bar{\psi}(i\not{\partial}-m+gA_a^1\gamma^1T^a)\psi\right] \qquad\text{(temporal gauge, }A^0\to0\text{)} \tag*{(1)}
\end{aligned} S QC D = ∫ d t d x [ 2 1 F a 01 F a 01 + ψ ˉ ( i ∂ − m − g A a 0 γ 0 T a + g A a 1 γ 1 T a ) ψ ] , F a 01 = ∂ t A a 1 + ∂ x A a 0 − g f ab c A b 0 A c 1 = ∫ d t d x [ 2 1 ( ∂ t A a 1 ) 2 + ψ ˉ ( i ∂ − m + g A a 1 γ 1 T a ) ψ ] (temporal gauge, A 0 → 0 ) (1)
The present study of the ’t Hooft model uses quantization at equal time t t t as in [4 , 5 , 6 ] , but differs from previous work in other respects.
(i) Temporal gauge, A 0 = 0 A^0 = 0 A 0 = 0 [8 ] , which is advantageous for canonical quantization. Since both A 0 A^0 A 0 and its conjugate field vanish (S Q C D S_{QCD} S QC D is independent of ∂ t A 0 \partial_tA^0 ∂ t A 0 ) QCD can be canonically quantized without the Dirac constraints required in Coulomb gauge (see [9 ] and Sec. 8.2 of [10 ] ). The color electric field is conjugate to A a ≡ A a 1 A_a \equiv A_a^1 A a ≡ A a 1 and i ψ † i\psi^\dagger i ψ † is conjugate to ψ \psi ψ ,
E a ( t , x ) = − δ S Q C D δ [ ∂ t A a ( t , x ) ] = − ∂ t A a ( t , x ) i ψ † ( t , x ) = δ S Q C D δ [ ∂ t ψ ( t , x ) ] (2) E_a(t,x)=-\frac{\delta S_{QCD}}{\delta[\partial_tA_a(t,x)]}=-\partial_tA_a(t,x)
\qquad
i\psi^\dagger(t,x)=\frac{\delta S_{QCD}}{\delta[\partial_t\psi(t,x)]} \tag*{(2)} E a ( t , x ) = − δ [ ∂ t A a ( t , x )] δ S QC D = − ∂ t A a ( t , x ) i ψ † ( t , x ) = δ [ ∂ t ψ ( t , x )] δ S QC D (2)
giving the equal-time commutation relations,
[ E a ( t , x ) , A b ( t , y ) ] = i δ a , b δ ( x − y ) { ψ A , α † ( t , x ) , ψ B , β ( t , y ) } = δ A B δ α β δ ( x − y ) (3) [E_a(t,x),A_b(t,y)]=i\delta_{a,b}\delta(x-y)
\qquad
\{\psi^\dagger_{A,\alpha}(t,x),\psi_{B,\beta}(t,y)\}=\delta_{AB}\delta_{\alpha\beta}\delta(x-y) \tag*{(3)} [ E a ( t , x ) , A b ( t , y )] = i δ a , b δ ( x − y ) { ψ A , α † ( t , x ) , ψ B , β ( t , y )} = δ A B δ α β δ ( x − y ) (3)
The generators of space and time translations as well as boosts are (unlike in Coulomb gauge) local functions of the quark and gluon fields. The A 0 = 0 A^0=0 A 0 = 0 condition fixes temporal gauge only up to time independent gauge transformations. Such transformations are generated by Gauss’ operator
G a ( t , x ) ≡ δ S Q C D δ A a 0 ( t , x ) = ∂ x E a ( t , x ) + g f a b c A b E c ( t , x ) − g ψ † T a ψ ( t , x ) (4) \mathcal{G}_a(t,x)\equiv\frac{\delta S_{QCD}}{\delta A_a^0(t,x)}=\partial_xE_a(t,x)+gf_{abc}A_bE_c(t,x)-g\psi^\dagger T^a\psi(t,x) \tag*{(4)} G a ( t , x ) ≡ δ A a 0 ( t , x ) δ S QC D = ∂ x E a ( t , x ) + g f ab c A b E c ( t , x ) − g ψ † T a ψ ( t , x ) (4)
which commutes with the Hamiltonian [8 ] . Gauss’ law G a ( t , x ) = 0 \mathcal{G}_a(t,x)=0 G a ( t , x ) = 0 is not an operator equation of motion in temporal gauge. Invariance under time independent gauge transformations is ensured by a constraint on physical states ,
G a ( t , x ) ∣ p h y s , t ⟩ = 0 including G a ( t , x ) ∣ 0 ⟩ = 0 (5) \mathcal{G}_a(t,x)|phys,t\rangle=0 \qquad\text{including} \qquad\mathcal{G}_a(t,x)|0\rangle=0 \tag*{(5)} G a ( t , x ) ∣ p h y s , t ⟩ = 0 including G a ( t , x ) ∣0 ⟩ = 0 (5)
This determines the divergence of the electric field ∂ x E a ( t , x ) \partial_x E_a(t,x) ∂ x E a ( t , x ) in (4) in terms of the gluons and quarks in ∣ p h y s , t ⟩ |phys,t\rangle ∣ p h y s , t ⟩ , as probed by their commutators with g f a b c A b E c ( t , x ) − g ψ † T a ψ ( t , x ) gf_{abc}A_bE_c(t,x)-g\psi^\dagger T_a\psi(t,x) g f ab c A b E c ( t , x ) − g ψ † T a ψ ( t , x ) . Gauss’ constraint (5) on ∣ p h y s , t ⟩ |phys,t\rangle ∣ p h y s , t ⟩ involves no particle creation from the vacuum.
(ii) Color singlets. Previous studies of the ’t Hooft model used (colored) quark and gluon propagators to build (color singlet) bound states via the Bethe-Salpeter equation [11 ] . Due to the confining interaction in D = 1 + 1 D=1+1 D = 1 + 1 dimensions the propagators need to be regularized, with the singularities canceling for the bound states.
I avoid the propagators by starting from color singlet q q ˉ q\bar q q q ˉ states, defined at t = 0 t=0 t = 0 in coordinate space,
∣ M , P ⟩ = ∫ d x q d x q ˉ ψ ˉ ( x q ) P ( x q ˉ → x q ) exp [ 1 2 i P ( x q + x q ˉ ) ] Φ ( P ) ( x q − x q ˉ ) ψ ( x q ˉ ) ∣ 0 ⟩ ( t = 0 ) (6) |M,P\rangle=\int dx_qdx_{\bar q}\,\bar\psi(x_q)\mathcal{P}(x_{\bar q}\to x_q)\exp\left[\frac{1}{2}iP(x_q+x_{\bar q})\right]\Phi^{(P)}(x_q-x_{\bar q})\psi(x_{\bar q})|0\rangle\qquad(t=0) \tag*{(6)} ∣ M , P ⟩ = ∫ d x q d x q ˉ ψ ˉ ( x q ) P ( x q ˉ → x q ) exp [ 2 1 i P ( x q + x q ˉ ) ] Φ ( P ) ( x q − x q ˉ ) ψ ( x q ˉ ) ∣0 ⟩ ( t = 0 ) (6)
P ( x q ˉ → x q ) ≡ P exp [ i g ∫ x q ˉ x q d x A a ( x ) T a ] ( P : path ordering ) (7) \mathcal{P}(x_{\bar q}\to x_q)\equiv\mathcal{P}\exp\left[ig\int_{x_{\bar q}}^{x_q}dx\,A_a(x)T^a\right] \qquad(\mathcal{P}:\text{ path ordering}) \tag*{(7)} P ( x q ˉ → x q ) ≡ P exp [ i g ∫ x q ˉ x q d x A a ( x ) T a ] ( P : path ordering ) (7)
where M M M denotes the mass and P ≡ P 1 P\equiv P^1 P ≡ P 1 the momentum of the bound state. The gauge link P ( x q ˉ → x q ) \mathcal{P}(x_{\bar q}\to x_q) P ( x q ˉ → x q ) is required to satisfy (5) (see below). The c-numbered wave function Φ ( P ) ( x q − x q ˉ ) \Phi^{(P)}(x_q-x_{\bar q}) Φ ( P ) ( x q − x q ˉ ) is a unit matrix in color space and a 2 × 2 2\times2 2 × 2 matrix in the Dirac indices. Nominally, ψ ˉ ( x q ) \bar\psi(x_q) ψ ˉ ( x q ) creates a quark at x q x_q x q and ψ ( x q ˉ ) \psi(x_{\bar q}) ψ ( x q ˉ ) an antiquark at x q ˉ x_{\bar q} x q ˉ , both at t = 0 t=0 t = 0 . In the absence of quark and gluon propagators there is no concept of “planar diagrams”.
Fixing the gauge over all space at the same time (A a 0 ( t , x ) = 0 A_a^0(t,x)=0 A a 0 ( t , x ) = 0 ) gives rise to the instantaneous potential derived below. The state (6) is an eigenstate of the Hamiltonian if the wave function Φ ( P ) \Phi^{(P)} Φ ( P ) satisfies the bound state equation (BSE) (22) . This is an ordinary differential equation with an analytic solution. After a Fourier transform the BSE becomes an integral equation in momentum space, which (for P → ∞ P\to\infty P → ∞ ) I compare with the equation found by ’t Hooft.
The rest of this paper is organized as follows. In Sec. II and Appendixes A and B I verify that the states (6) satisfy the constraint (5) and determine the Poincaré generators of QCD2 _2 2 in temporal gauge. The states (6) are demonstrated to be eigenstates of the generator of space translations P ^ 1 \hat P^1 P ^ 1 with eigenvalue P P P , and of the Hamiltonian H = P ^ 0 H=\hat P^0 H = P ^ 0 when the BSE (22) for the wave function is satisfied. The gauge link (7) generates the linear potential,
V ( x ) = V ′ ∣ x ∣ V ′ = 1 2 g 2 C F = g 2 N c 2 − 1 4 N c (8) V(x)=V'|x| \qquad V'=\frac{1}{2}g^2C_F=g^2\frac{N_c^2-1}{4N_c} \tag*{(8)} V ( x ) = V ′ ∣ x ∣ V ′ = 2 1 g 2 C F = g 2 4 N c N c 2 − 1 (8)
Section III determines the properties of the wave function, including its symmetries under parity and charge conjugation. Φ ( P ) ( x ) \Phi^{(P)}(x) Φ ( P ) ( x ) is expressed in terms of the confluent hypergeometric function 1 F 1 {}_1F_1 1 F 1 with argument τ P \tau_P τ P , the square of the “kinetic momentum” ( E P − V , P ) (E_P-V,P) ( E P − V , P ) ,
V ′ τ P ( x ) ≡ ( E P − V ) 2 − P 2 = M 2 − 2 E P V ′ ∣ x ∣ + V ′ 2 x 2 E P = P 2 + M 2 (9) V'\tau_P(x)\equiv(E_P-V)^2-P^2=M^2-2E_PV'|x|+V'^{2}x^2 \qquad E_P=\sqrt{P^2+M^2} \tag*{(9)} V ′ τ P ( x ) ≡ ( E P − V ) 2 − P 2 = M 2 − 2 E P V ′ ∣ x ∣ + V ′ 2 x 2 E P = P 2 + M 2 (9)
Viewed as a function of τ P \tau_P τ P , Φ ( P ) ( τ P ) \Phi^{(P)}(\tau_P) Φ ( P ) ( τ P ) is independent of P P P up to a Dirac matrix. In Appendix C I verify that the frame dependence of Φ ( P ) ( τ P ( x ) ) \Phi^{(P)}(\tau_P(x)) Φ ( P ) ( τ P ( x )) , viewed as a function of x x x , is consistent with that given by the boost generator M ^ 01 \hat M^{01} M ^ 01 .
In Sec. IV I consider the Fourier transform (38) from coordinate to momentum space, Φ ( P ) ( x ) → Φ ( P ) ( k ) \Phi^{(P)}(x)\to\Phi^{(P)}(k) Φ ( P ) ( x ) → Φ ( P ) ( k ) . The wave function is then projected (43) on components Φ s s ( P ) \Phi_{ss}^{(P)} Φ ss ( P ) according to the sign of the quark (s s s ) and antiquark (s ˉ \bar s s ˉ ) kinetic energy. The BSE in momentum space (53) shows how the potential mixes the wave function components with positive and negative kinetic energies.
§ 1.4 shows that the Fourier transform of Φ ( P ) ( x ) \Phi^{(P)}(x) Φ ( P ) ( x ) can be done analytically in the IMF, P → ∞ P\to\infty P → ∞ . The IMF BSE (69) has the form of the ’t Hooft bound state equation (70) [1 ] , but with contributions also from negative kinetic energies (at quark momentum fractions x B < 0 x_B<0 x B < 0 and x B > 1 x_B>1 x B > 1 ). An example IMF wave function is shown in Figure 1 (right) and is numerically verified to solve the BSE (69) in Table I.
Figure 1. Features of the η C = − 1 \eta_C=-1 η C = − 1 ground state, with quark mass m = 0.14 m=0.14 m = 0.14 and bound state mass M = 2.51954 M=2.51954 M = 2.51954 (V ′ = 1 V'=1 V ′ = 1 ). Left: Plot of rest frame wave function ϕ 1 ( P = 0 ) ( x ) \phi_1^{(P=0)}(x) ϕ 1 ( P = 0 ) ( x ) (36) for 0 ≤ x ≤ M 0\leq x\leq M 0 ≤ x ≤ M . ϕ 1 ( 0 ) ( x → ∞ ) \phi_1^{(0)}(x\to\infty) ϕ 1 ( 0 ) ( x → ∞ ) oscillates according to (37) . Right: The IMF wave function ϕ ( ∞ ) ( x B ) = ϕ ( ∞ ) ( 1 − x B ) \phi^{(\infty)}(x_B)=\phi^{(\infty)}(1-x_B) ϕ ( ∞ ) ( x B ) = ϕ ( ∞ ) ( 1 − x B ) (62) for 0.5 ≤ x B ≤ 1.5 0.5\leq x_B\leq1.5 0.5 ≤ x B ≤ 1.5 . ϕ ( ∞ ) ( x B → ∞ ) ≃ − 0.40 / x B 2 \phi^{(\infty)}(x_B\to\infty)\simeq-0.40/x_B^2 ϕ ( ∞ ) ( x B → ∞ ) ≃ − 0.40/ x B 2 .
Returning to x x x -space in Sec. VI I note that the electric field E a E_a E a of the q q ˉ q\bar q q q ˉ Fock state may be determined from Gauss’ constraint (5) , viewed as a differential equation for ∂ x E a \partial_xE_a ∂ x E a (4) . This (76) gives the same linear potential (8) as previously. Solving the differential equation for E a E_a E a allows (for color singlet states in QCD) to include a homogeneous solution which induces an isotropic gluon energy density E Λ E_\Lambda E Λ (87) , akin to the “bag constant” [12 ] . This gives an additional contribution to the linear potential (88) . An analogous homogeneous solution gives rise to a linear potential also in D = 3 + 1 D=3+1 D = 3 + 1 dimensions [13 ] .
In the concluding Sec. VII I discuss the relation to previous solutions of the ’t Hooft model, where the quarks have only positive kinetic energy. The negative energy components have important consequences. They induce an overlap between bound states, ⟨ B C ∣ A ⟩ \langle BC|A\rangle ⟨ B C ∣ A ⟩ , suggestive of dual dynamics and color string breaking. Because the color electric field is of O ( g 2 N c ) O\left(g^{2}N_{c}\right) O ( g 2 N c ) bound states thus acquire finite widths even in the N c → ∞ N_{c} \to\infty N c → ∞ limit.
Bound state equation in coordinate space
Physical states should satisfy (5) in temporal gauge [8 ] . This ensures that the states are invariant under time independent gauge transformations, which are generated by G a ( t , x ) \mathcal{G}_{a}(t,x) G a ( t , x ) (4) and preserve the A 0 = 0 A^{0}=0 A 0 = 0 gauge condition. Denoting the infinitesimal gauge parameter by Λ a ( x ) \Lambda_{a}(x) Λ a ( x ) , the unitary transformation generated by G a \mathcal{G}_{a} G a
U G ( t ) = 1 + i ∫ d x G a ( t , x ) Λ a ( x ) + O ( Λ a 2 ) (10) U_{G}(t)=1+i\int dx\,\mathcal{G}_{a}(t,x)\Lambda_{a}(x)+O\left(\Lambda_{a}^{2}\right) \tag*{(10)} U G ( t ) = 1 + i ∫ d x G a ( t , x ) Λ a ( x ) + O ( Λ a 2 ) (10)
transforms the quark and gluon fields as
U G ( t ) ψ ( t , x ) U G † ( t ) = [ 1 + i g Λ a ( x ) T a ] ψ ( t , x ) = exp [ i g Λ a ( x ) T a ] ψ ( t , x ) ≡ V Λ ( x ) ψ ( t , x ) U_{G}(t)\psi(t,x)U_{G}^{\dagger}(t)=\left[1+ig\Lambda_{a}(x)T^{a}\right]\psi(t,x)=\exp\left[ig\Lambda_{a}(x)T^{a}\right]\psi(t,x)\equiv V_{\Lambda}(x)\psi(t,x) U G ( t ) ψ ( t , x ) U G † ( t ) = [ 1 + i g Λ a ( x ) T a ] ψ ( t , x ) = exp [ i g Λ a ( x ) T a ] ψ ( t , x ) ≡ V Λ ( x ) ψ ( t , x )
U G ( t ) ψ ˉ ( t , x ) U G † ( t ) = ψ ˉ ( t , x ) V Λ † ( x ) U_{G}(t)\bar{\psi}(t,x)U_{G}^{\dagger}(t)=\bar{\psi}(t,x)V_{\Lambda}^{\dagger}(x) U G ( t ) ψ ˉ ( t , x ) U G † ( t ) = ψ ˉ ( t , x ) V Λ † ( x )
U G ( t ) A a ( t , x ) U G † ( t ) = A a ( t , x ) + ∂ x Λ a ( x ) + g f a b c A b ( t , x ) Λ c ( x ) (11) U_{G}(t)A_{a}(t,x)U_{G}^{\dagger}(t)=A_{a}(t,x)+\partial_{x}\Lambda_{a}(x)+gf_{abc}A_{b}(t,x)\Lambda_{c}(x) \tag*{(11)} U G ( t ) A a ( t , x ) U G † ( t ) = A a ( t , x ) + ∂ x Λ a ( x ) + g f ab c A b ( t , x ) Λ c ( x ) (11)
At t = 0 t=0 t = 0 and with U G ∣ 0 ⟩ = ∣ 0 ⟩ U_{G}|0\rangle=|0\rangle U G ∣0 ⟩ = ∣0 ⟩ (5) , U G U_{G} U G acts on the bound state (6) as,
U G ∣ M , P ⟩ = ∫ d x q d x q ˉ ψ ˉ ( x q ) V Λ † ( x q ) U G P ( x q ˉ → x q ) U G † exp [ 1 2 i P ( x q + x q ˉ ) ] Φ ( P ) ( x q − x q ˉ ) V Λ ( x q ˉ ) ψ ( x q ˉ ) ∣ 0 ⟩ = ∣ M , P ⟩ provided U G P ( x q ˉ → x q ) U G † = V Λ ( x q ) P ( x q ˉ → x q ) V Λ † ( x q ˉ ) (12) \begin{aligned}
U_{G}|M,P\rangle=\int dx_{q}dx_{\bar q}\,\bar{\psi}(x_{q})V_{\Lambda}^{\dagger}(x_{q})U_{G}P(x_{\bar q}\to x_{q})U_{G}^{\dagger}\exp\left[\frac{1}{2}iP(x_{q}+x_{\bar q})\right]\Phi^{(P)}(x_{q}-x_{\bar q})V_{\Lambda}(x_{\bar q})\psi(x_{\bar q})|0\rangle\\
&=|M,P\rangle\qquad\text{provided}\qquad U_{G}P(x_{\bar q}\to x_{q})U_{G}^{\dagger}=V_{\Lambda}(x_{q})P(x_{\bar q}\to x_{q})V_{\Lambda}^{\dagger}(x_{\bar q}) \tag*{(12)}
\end{aligned} U G ∣ M , P ⟩ = ∫ d x q d x q ˉ ψ ˉ ( x q ) V Λ † ( x q ) U G P ( x q ˉ → x q ) U G † exp [ 2 1 i P ( x q + x q ˉ ) ] Φ ( P ) ( x q − x q ˉ ) V Λ ( x q ˉ ) ψ ( x q ˉ ) ∣0 ⟩ = ∣ M , P ⟩ provided U G P ( x q ˉ → x q ) U G † = V Λ ( x q ) P ( x q ˉ → x q ) V Λ † ( x q ˉ ) (12)
The last equality is a general feature of path-ordered exponentials as shown, e.g. , in Sec. 15.3 of [14 ] . I verify (12) in Appendix A. Since G ( t , x ) \mathcal{G}(t,x) G ( t , x ) commutes with the Hamiltonian [8 ] the state will then satisfy G a ( t , x ) ∣ M , P ; t ⟩ = 0 \mathcal{G}_{a}(t,x)|M,P;t\rangle=0 G a ( t , x ) ∣ M , P ; t ⟩ = 0 at all times t t t .
Bound state momentum
The QCD2 _{2} 2 generators of space (P ^ 1 \widehat{P}^{1} P 1 ) and time (P ^ 0 = H \widehat{P}^{0}=H P 0 = H ) translations as well as of boosts (M ^ 01 \widehat{M}^{01} M 01 ) in temporal gauge are recalled in Appendix B. The momentum and energy operators (B.9) are
P ^ 1 ( t ) = ∫ d x [ E a ∂ ⃗ x A a + ψ † ( − i ∂ ⃗ x ) ψ ] (13) \widehat{P}^{1}(t)=\int dx\left[E_{a}\vec{\partial}_{x}A_{a}+\psi^{\dagger}(-i\vec{\partial}_{x})\psi\right] \tag*{(13)} P 1 ( t ) = ∫ d x [ E a ∂ x A a + ψ † ( − i ∂ x ) ψ ] (13)
P ^ 0 ( t ) = H ( t ) = ∫ d x [ 1 2 ( E a ) 2 + ψ † ( − i α 1 ∂ ⃗ x + γ 0 m − g α 1 A a T a ) ψ ] ( α 1 ≡ γ 0 γ 1 ) (14) \widehat{P}^{0}(t)=H(t)=\int dx\left[\frac{1}{2}(E_{a})^{2}+\psi^{\dagger}\left(-i\alpha^{1}\vec{\partial}_{x}+\gamma^{0}m-g\alpha_{1}A_{a}T^{a}\right)\psi\right]\qquad\left(\alpha_{1}\equiv\gamma^{0}\gamma^{1}\right) \tag*{(14)} P 0 ( t ) = H ( t ) = ∫ d x [ 2 1 ( E a ) 2 + ψ † ( − i α 1 ∂ x + γ 0 m − g α 1 A a T a ) ψ ] ( α 1 ≡ γ 0 γ 1 ) (14)
The unitary operators U x ( ℓ ) = exp ( − i ℓ P ^ 1 ) U_{x}(\ell)=\exp(-i\ell\widehat{P}^{1}) U x ( ℓ ) = exp ( − i ℓ P 1 ) and U t ( τ ) = exp ( i τ P ^ 0 ) U_{t}(\tau)=\exp(i\tau\widehat{P}^{0}) U t ( τ ) = exp ( i τ P 0 ) translate the quark and gluon fields by ℓ \ell ℓ in space and by τ \tau τ in time, respectively (B.6). Hence
U x ( ℓ ) ∣ M , P ⟩ = ∫ d x q d x q ˉ ψ ˉ ( x q + ℓ ) P exp [ i g ∫ x q ˉ x q d x A a ( x + ℓ ) T a ] exp [ 1 2 i P ( x q + x q ˉ ) ] Φ ( P ) ( x q − x q ˉ ) ψ ( x q ˉ + ℓ ) ∣ 0 ⟩ = exp ( − i ℓ P ) ∣ M , P ⟩ (15) \begin{aligned}
U_{x}(\ell)|M,P\rangle=\int dx_{q}dx_{\bar q}\,\bar{\psi}(x_{q}+\ell)\mathrm{P}\exp\left[ig\int_{x_{\bar q}}^{x_{q}}dx\,A_{a}(x+\ell)T_{a}\right]\exp\left[\frac{1}{2}iP(x_{q}+x_{\bar q})\right]\Phi^{(P)}(x_{q}-x_{\bar q})\psi(x_{\bar q}+\ell)|0\rangle\\
&=\exp(-i\ell P)|M,P\rangle \tag*{(15)}
\end{aligned} U x ( ℓ ) ∣ M , P ⟩ = ∫ d x q d x q ˉ ψ ˉ ( x q + ℓ ) P exp [ i g ∫ x q ˉ x q d x A a ( x + ℓ ) T a ] exp [ 2 1 i P ( x q + x q ˉ ) ] Φ ( P ) ( x q − x q ˉ ) ψ ( x q ˉ + ℓ ) ∣0 ⟩ = exp ( − i ℓ P ) ∣ M , P ⟩ (15)
where the state was brought to its standard form (6) by a change of integration variables, x → x ′ = x + ℓ x\to x'=x+\ell x → x ′ = x + ℓ . This verifies that P ^ 1 ∣ M , P ⟩ = P ∣ M , P ⟩ \widehat{P}^{1}|M,P\rangle=P|M,P\rangle P 1 ∣ M , P ⟩ = P ∣ M , P ⟩ , i.e. , that the state has momentum P P P .
Bound state energy
The energy (Hamiltonian) eigenstate condition
P ^ 0 ∣ M , P ⟩ = E P ∣ M , P ⟩ E P = P 2 + M 2 (16) \hat{P}^{0}|M,P\rangle=E_{P}|M,P\rangle\qquad E_{P}=\sqrt{P^{2}+M^{2}} \tag*{(16)} P ^ 0 ∣ M , P ⟩ = E P ∣ M , P ⟩ E P = P 2 + M 2 (16)
imposes a BSE on the wave function Φ ( P ) ( x ) \Phi^{(P)}(x) Φ ( P ) ( x ) . Since the color electric field satisfies E a ∣ 0 ⟩ = 0 E_{a}|0\rangle=0 E a ∣0 ⟩ = 0 [Gauss’ constraint (5) does not involve particle creation],2
E a 2 ( x ) P ( x q ˉ → x q ) ∣ 0 ⟩ = [ E a ( x ) , [ E a ( x ) , P ( x q ˉ → x q ) ] ] ∣ 0 ⟩ (17) E_{a}^{2}(x)\mathcal{P}(x_{\bar q}\to x_{q})|0\rangle=[E_{a}(x),[E_{a}(x),\mathcal{P}(x_{\bar q}\to x_{q})]]|0\rangle \tag*{(17)} E a 2 ( x ) P ( x q ˉ → x q ) ∣0 ⟩ = [ E a ( x ) , [ E a ( x ) , P ( x q ˉ → x q )]] ∣0 ⟩ (17)
Using the discretization (A.1) and the canonical commutators (3) for x q ˉ ≤ x ≤ x q x_{\bar q}\leq x\leq x_{q} x q ˉ ≤ x ≤ x q ,
P ( x q ˉ → x q ) = P ( y l + 1 → x q ) [ 1 + i g Δ x A b ( y l ) T b + 1 2 ( i g Δ x A b ( y l ) T b ) 2 + O ( ( Δ x ) 3 ) ] P ( x q ˉ → y l − 1 ) ( x q ˉ < y l < x q ) \mathcal{P}(x_{\bar q}\to x_{q})=\mathcal{P}(y_{l+1}\to x_{q})\left[1+ig\Delta xA_{b}(y_{l})T^{b}+\frac{1}{2}(ig\Delta xA_{b}(y_{l})T^{b})^{2}+O((\Delta x)^{3})\right]\mathcal{P}(x_{\bar q}\to y_{l-1})\qquad(x_{\bar q}<y_{l}<x_{q}) P ( x q ˉ → x q ) = P ( y l + 1 → x q ) [ 1 + i g Δ x A b ( y l ) T b + 2 1 ( i g Δ x A b ( y l ) T b ) 2 + O (( Δ x ) 3 ) ] P ( x q ˉ → y l − 1 ) ( x q ˉ < y l < x q )
[ E a ( y l ) , P ( x q ˉ → x q ) ] ∣ 0 ⟩ = P ( y l + 1 → x q ) [ i 2 g T a + 1 2 i 3 g 2 Δ x ( T a A b ( y l ) T b + A b ( y l ) T b T a ) ] P ( x q ˉ → y l − 1 ) ∣ 0 ⟩ [E_{a}(y_{l}),\mathcal{P}(x_{\bar q}\to x_{q})]|0\rangle=\mathcal{P}(y_{l+1}\to x_{q})\left[i^{2}gT^{a}+\frac{1}{2}i^{3}g^{2}\Delta x(T^{a}A_{b}(y_{l})T^{b}+A_{b}(y_{l})T^{b}T^{a})\right]\mathcal{P}(x_{\bar q}\to y_{l-1})|0\rangle [ E a ( y l ) , P ( x q ˉ → x q )] ∣0 ⟩ = P ( y l + 1 → x q ) [ i 2 g T a + 2 1 i 3 g 2 Δ x ( T a A b ( y l ) T b + A b ( y l ) T b T a ) ] P ( x q ˉ → y l − 1 ) ∣0 ⟩
1 2 [ E a ( y l ) , [ E a ( y l ) , P ( x q ˉ → x q ) ] ] ∣ 0 ⟩ = 1 2 P ( y l + 1 → x q ) i 4 g 2 T a T a P ( x q ˉ → y l − 1 ) ∣ 0 ⟩ = 1 2 g 2 C F P ( x q ˉ → x q ) ∣ 0 ⟩ (18) \frac{1}{2}[E_{a}(y_{l}),[E_{a}(y_{l}),\mathcal{P}(x_{\bar q}\to x_{q})]]|0\rangle=\frac{1}{2}\mathcal{P}(y_{l+1}\to x_{q})i^{4}g^{2}T^{a}T^{a}\mathcal{P}(x_{\bar q}\to y_{l-1})|0\rangle=\frac{1}{2}g^{2}C_{F}\mathcal{P}(x_{\bar q}\to x_{q})|0\rangle \tag*{(18)} 2 1 [ E a ( y l ) , [ E a ( y l ) , P ( x q ˉ → x q )]] ∣0 ⟩ = 2 1 P ( y l + 1 → x q ) i 4 g 2 T a T a P ( x q ˉ → y l − 1 ) ∣0 ⟩ = 2 1 g 2 C F P ( x q ˉ → x q ) ∣0 ⟩ (18)
which is independent of y l y_{l} y l . The integral of E a 2 ( x ) E_{a}^{2}(x) E a 2 ( x ) over x x x in (14) gives the linear potential (8) of QCD2 _{2} 2 [1 ] ,
∫ x q ˉ x q d x 1 2 E a 2 ( x ) P ( x q ˉ → x q ) ∣ 0 ⟩ = 1 2 g 2 C F ∣ x q − x q ˉ ∣ P ( x q ˉ → x q ) ∣ 0 ⟩ ≡ V ( x q − x q ˉ ) P ( x q ˉ → x q ) ∣ 0 ⟩ (19) \int_{x_{\bar q}}^{x_{q}}dx\,\frac{1}{2}E_{a}^{2}(x)\mathcal{P}(x_{\bar q}\to x_{q})|0\rangle=\frac{1}{2}g^{2}C_{F}|x_{q}-x_{\bar q}|\mathcal{P}(x_{\bar q}\to x_{q})|0\rangle\equiv V(x_{q}-x_{\bar q})\mathcal{P}(x_{\bar q}\to x_{q})|0\rangle \tag*{(19)} ∫ x q ˉ x q d x 2 1 E a 2 ( x ) P ( x q ˉ → x q ) ∣0 ⟩ = 2 1 g 2 C F ∣ x q − x q ˉ ∣ P ( x q ˉ → x q ) ∣0 ⟩ ≡ V ( x q − x q ˉ ) P ( x q ˉ → x q ) ∣0 ⟩ (19)
The commutator of the quark part of the Hamiltonian (14) contributes,
∫ d x [ ψ ˉ ( x ) ( − i α 1 ∂ → x + m γ 0 − g α 1 A a ( x ) T a ) ψ ( x ) , ψ ˉ α ( x q ) ψ β ( x q ˉ ) ] ∣ 0 ⟩ = ψ ˉ ( x q ) ( − i α 1 ∂ → x q + m γ 0 + g α 1 A a ( x q ) T a ) α ψ β ( x q ˉ ) ∣ 0 ⟩ − ψ ˉ α ( x q ) β ( − i α 1 ∂ → x q ˉ + m γ 0 − g α 1 A a ( x q ˉ ) T a ) ψ ( x q ˉ ) ∣ 0 ⟩ (20) \begin{aligned}
\int dx[\bar{\psi}(x)(-i\alpha_{1}\overrightarrow{\partial}_{x}+m\gamma^{0}-g\alpha_{1}A_{a}(x)T^{a})\psi(x),\bar{\psi}_{\alpha}(x_{q})\psi_{\beta}(x_{\bar q})]|0\rangle\\
&=\bar{\psi}(x_{q})(-i\alpha_{1}\overrightarrow{\partial}_{x_{q}}+m\gamma^{0}+g\alpha_{1}A_{a}(x_{q})T^{a})_{\alpha}\psi_{\beta}(x_{\bar q})|0\rangle-\bar{\psi}_{\alpha}(x_{q})_{\beta}(-i\alpha_{1}\overrightarrow{\partial}_{x_{\bar q}}+m\gamma^{0}-g\alpha_{1}A_{a}(x_{\bar q})T^{a})\psi(x_{\bar q})|0\rangle \tag*{(20)}
\end{aligned} ∫ d x [ ψ ˉ ( x ) ( − i α 1 ∂ x + m γ 0 − g α 1 A a ( x ) T a ) ψ ( x ) , ψ ˉ α ( x q ) ψ β ( x q ˉ )] ∣0 ⟩ = ψ ˉ ( x q ) ( − i α 1 ∂ x q + m γ 0 + g α 1 A a ( x q ) T a ) α ψ β ( x q ˉ ) ∣0 ⟩ − ψ ˉ α ( x q ) β ( − i α 1 ∂ x q ˉ + m γ 0 − g α 1 A a ( x q ˉ ) T a ) ψ ( x q ˉ ) ∣0 ⟩ (20)
When partially integrating − i ∂ ← x q → i ∂ → x q -i\overleftarrow{\partial}_{x_{q}}\to i\overrightarrow{\partial}_{x_{q}} − i ∂ x q → i ∂ x q in ∣ M , P ⟩ |M,P\rangle ∣ M , P ⟩ (6) the derivative acts on P ( x q ˉ → x q ) \mathcal{P}(x_{\bar q}\to x_{q}) P ( x q ˉ → x q ) , on exp [ i P ( x q + x q ˉ ) / 2 ] \exp[iP(x_{q}+x_{\bar q})/2] exp [ i P ( x q + x q ˉ ) /2 ] and on Φ ( P ) ( x q − x q ˉ ) \Phi^{(P)}(x_{q}-x_{\bar q}) Φ ( P ) ( x q − x q ˉ ) , similarly for − i ∂ → x q ˉ → i ∂ → x q ˉ -i\overrightarrow{\partial}_{x_{\bar q}}\to i\overrightarrow{\partial}_{x_{\bar q}} − i ∂ x q ˉ → i ∂ x q ˉ . The derivatives of P ( x q ˉ → x q ) \mathcal{P}(x_{\bar q}\to x_{q}) P ( x q ˉ → x q ) cancel the A a A_{a} A a terms as in (A.1),
α 1 [ i ∂ → x q + g A a ( x q ) T a ] P ( x q ˉ → x q ) = 0 \alpha_{1}[i\overrightarrow{\partial}_{x_{q}}+gA_{a}(x_{q})T^{a}]\mathcal{P}(x_{\bar q}\to x_{q})=0 α 1 [ i ∂ x q + g A a ( x q ) T a ] P ( x q ˉ → x q ) = 0
P ( x q ˉ → x q ) [ i ∂ ← x q ˉ − g A a ( x q ˉ ) T a ] α 1 = 0 (21) \mathcal{P}(x_{\bar q}\to x_{q})[i\overleftarrow{\partial}_{x_{\bar q}}-gA_{a}(x_{\bar q})T^{a}]\alpha_{1}=0 \tag*{(21)} P ( x q ˉ → x q ) [ i ∂ x q ˉ − g A a ( x q ˉ ) T a ] α 1 = 0 (21)
The contribution from − ψ ˉ ( x ) g α 1 A a ( x ) T a ψ ( x ) ∣ 0 ⟩ -\bar{\psi}(x)g\alpha_{1}A_{a}(x)T^{a}\psi(x)|0\rangle − ψ ˉ ( x ) g α 1 A a ( x ) T a ψ ( x ) ∣0 ⟩ gives quark loops which are suppressed as g → 0 g\to0 g → 0 in the N c → ∞ N_{c}\to\infty N c → ∞ limit [3 ] . We are left with the bound state equation for the wave function,
i ∂ x { α 1 , Φ ( P ) ( x ) } − 1 2 P [ α 1 , Φ ( P ) ( x ) ] + m [ γ 0 , Φ ( P ) ( x ) ] + V ( x ) Φ ( P ) ( x ) = E P Φ ( P ) ( x ) ; V ( x ) = 1 2 g 2 C F ∣ x ∣ (22) i\partial_{x}\{\alpha_{1},\Phi^{(P)}(x)\}-\frac{1}{2P}[\alpha_{1},\Phi^{(P)}(x)]+m[\gamma^{0},\Phi^{(P)}(x)]+V(x)\Phi^{(P)}(x)=E_{P}\Phi^{(P)}(x);\qquad V(x)=\frac{1}{2}g^{2}C_{F}|x| \tag*{(22)} i ∂ x { α 1 , Φ ( P ) ( x )} − 2 P 1 [ α 1 , Φ ( P ) ( x )] + m [ γ 0 , Φ ( P ) ( x )] + V ( x ) Φ ( P ) ( x ) = E P Φ ( P ) ( x ) ; V ( x ) = 2 1 g 2 C F ∣ x ∣ (22)
In the next section I summarize the main properties of Φ ( P ) ( x ) \Phi^{(P)}(x) Φ ( P ) ( x ) as given by this BSE [13 , 15 ] .
Properties of Φ ( P ) ( x ) \Phi^{(P)}(x) Φ ( P ) ( x )
Parity and charge conjugation: P ∣ M , P ⟩ = η P ∣ M , − P ⟩ \mathcal{P}|M,P\rangle=\eta_{P}|M,-P\rangle P ∣ M , P ⟩ = η P ∣ M , − P ⟩ , C ∣ M , P ⟩ = η C ∣ M , P ⟩ \mathcal{C}|M,P\rangle=\eta_{C}|M,P\rangle C ∣ M , P ⟩ = η C ∣ M , P ⟩
From the expression (6) of ∣ M , P ⟩ |M,P\rangle ∣ M , P ⟩ and the action of the parity operator P \mathcal{P} P on the fields (B.15),
P ∣ M , P ⟩ = ∫ d x q d x q ˉ ψ ˉ ( − x q ) γ 0 P exp [ − i g ∫ x q ˉ x q d x A a ( − x ) T a ] exp [ i P ( x q + x q ˉ ) / 2 ] Φ ( P ) ( x q − x q ˉ ) γ 0 ψ ( − x q ˉ ) ∣ 0 ⟩ = ∫ d x q d x q ˉ ψ ˉ ( x q ) P exp [ i g ∫ x q ˉ x q d x A a ( x ) T a ] exp [ − i P ( x q + x q ˉ ) / 2 ] γ 0 Φ ( P ) ( − x q + x q ˉ ) γ 0 ψ ( x q ˉ ) ∣ 0 ⟩ = η P ∣ M , − P ⟩ if γ 0 Φ ( P ) ( − x ) γ 0 = η P Φ ( − P ) ( x ) (23) \begin{aligned}
\mathcal{P}|M,P\rangle=\int dx_{q}dx_{\bar q}\,\bar{\psi}(-x_{q})\gamma^{0}\mathcal{P}\exp\left[-ig\int_{x_{\bar q}}^{x_{q}}dx\,A_{a}(-x)T_{a}\right]\exp[iP(x_{q}+x_{\bar q})/2]\Phi^{(P)}(x_{q}-x_{\bar q})\gamma^{0}\psi(-x_{\bar q})|0\rangle\\
&=\int dx_{q}dx_{\bar q}\,\bar{\psi}(x_{q})\mathcal{P}\exp\left[ig\int_{x_{\bar q}}^{x_{q}}dx\,A_{a}(x)T_{a}\right]\exp[-iP(x_{q}+x_{\bar q})/2]\gamma^{0}\Phi^{(P)}(-x_{q}+x_{\bar q})\gamma^{0}\psi(x_{\bar q})|0\rangle\\
&=\eta_{P}|M,-P\rangle\qquad\text{if}\qquad\gamma^{0}\Phi^{(P)}(-x)\gamma^{0}=\eta_{P}\Phi^{(-P)}(x) \tag*{(23)}
\end{aligned} P ∣ M , P ⟩ = ∫ d x q d x q ˉ ψ ˉ ( − x q ) γ 0 P exp [ − i g ∫ x q ˉ x q d x A a ( − x ) T a ] exp [ i P ( x q + x q ˉ ) /2 ] Φ ( P ) ( x q − x q ˉ ) γ 0 ψ ( − x q ˉ ) ∣0 ⟩ = ∫ d x q d x q ˉ ψ ˉ ( x q ) P exp [ i g ∫ x q ˉ x q d x A a ( x ) T a ] exp [ − i P ( x q + x q ˉ ) /2 ] γ 0 Φ ( P ) ( − x q + x q ˉ ) γ 0 ψ ( x q ˉ ) ∣0 ⟩ = η P ∣ M , − P ⟩ if γ 0 Φ ( P ) ( − x ) γ 0 = η P Φ ( − P ) ( x ) (23)
The parity transformation reverses the center of mass momentum P P P of the state. From (22) we see that γ 0 Φ ( P ) ( − x ) γ 0 \gamma^0\Phi^{(P)}(-x)\gamma^0 γ 0 Φ ( P ) ( − x ) γ 0 satisfies the BSE with P → − P P \to-P P → − P .
From the action of the charge conjugation operator C C C on the fields (B.16),
C ∣ M , P ⟩ = ∫ d x q d x q ˉ ψ T ( x q ) γ 1 P exp { − i g ∫ x q ˉ x q d x [ A a ( x ) T a ] T } exp [ i P ( x q + x q ˉ ) / 2 ] Φ ( P ) ( x q − x q ˉ ) γ 1 ψ ˉ T ( x q ˉ ) ∣ 0 ⟩ = − ∫ d x q d x q ˉ ψ ˉ ( x q ˉ ) P exp [ − i g ∫ x q ˉ x q d x A a ( x ) T a ] exp [ i P ( x q + x q ˉ ) / 2 ] γ 1 [ Φ ( P ) ( x q − x q ˉ ) ] T γ 1 ψ ( x q ) ∣ 0 ⟩ = ∫ d x q d x q ˉ ψ ˉ ( x q ) P exp [ − i g ∫ x q x q ˉ d x A a ( x ) T a ] exp [ i P ( x q + x q ˉ ) / 2 ] i γ 1 [ Φ ( P ) ( x q ˉ − x q ) ] T i γ 1 ψ ( x q ˉ ) ∣ 0 ⟩ = η C ∣ M , P ⟩ (24) \begin{aligned}
C|M,P\rangle
&=\int dx_qdx_{\bar q}\,\psi^T(x_q)\gamma^1\mathrm{P}\exp\left\{-ig\int_{x_{\bar q}}^{x_q}dx\,[A_a(x)T_a]^T\right\}\exp[iP(x_q+x_{\bar q})/2]\Phi^{(P)}(x_q-x_{\bar q})\gamma^1\bar{\psi}^T(x_{\bar q})|0\rangle\\
&=-\int dx_qdx_{\bar q}\,\bar{\psi}(x_{\bar q})\mathrm{P}\exp\left[-ig\int_{x_{\bar q}}^{x_q}dx\,A_a(x)T_a\right]\exp[iP(x_q+x_{\bar q})/2]\gamma^1[\Phi^{(P)}(x_q-x_{\bar q})]^T\gamma^1\psi(x_q)|0\rangle\\
&=\int dx_qdx_{\bar q}\,\bar{\psi}(x_q)\mathrm{P}\exp\left[-ig\int_{x_q}^{x_{\bar q}}dx\,A_a(x)T_a\right]\exp[iP(x_q+x_{\bar q})/2]i\gamma^1[\Phi^{(P)}(x_{\bar q}-x_q)]^T i\gamma^1\psi(x_{\bar q})|0\rangle\\
&=\eta_C|M,P\rangle \tag*{(24)}
\end{aligned} C ∣ M , P ⟩ = ∫ d x q d x q ˉ ψ T ( x q ) γ 1 P exp { − i g ∫ x q ˉ x q d x [ A a ( x ) T a ] T } exp [ i P ( x q + x q ˉ ) /2 ] Φ ( P ) ( x q − x q ˉ ) γ 1 ψ ˉ T ( x q ˉ ) ∣0 ⟩ = − ∫ d x q d x q ˉ ψ ˉ ( x q ˉ ) P exp [ − i g ∫ x q ˉ x q d x A a ( x ) T a ] exp [ i P ( x q + x q ˉ ) /2 ] γ 1 [ Φ ( P ) ( x q − x q ˉ ) ] T γ 1 ψ ( x q ) ∣0 ⟩ = ∫ d x q d x q ˉ ψ ˉ ( x q ) P exp [ − i g ∫ x q x q ˉ d x A a ( x ) T a ] exp [ i P ( x q + x q ˉ ) /2 ] i γ 1 [ Φ ( P ) ( x q ˉ − x q ) ] T i γ 1 ψ ( x q ˉ ) ∣0 ⟩ = η C ∣ M , P ⟩ (24)
if i γ 1 [ Φ ( P ) ( − x ) ] T i γ 1 = η C Φ ( P ) ( x ) i\gamma^1[\Phi^{(P)}(-x)]^T i\gamma^1=\eta_C\Phi^{(P)}(x) i γ 1 [ Φ ( P ) ( − x ) ] T i γ 1 = η C Φ ( P ) ( x ) .
Let us check that γ 1 [ Φ ( P ) ( − x ) ] T γ 1 \gamma^1[\Phi^{(P)}(-x)]^T\gamma^1 γ 1 [ Φ ( P ) ( − x ) ] T γ 1 satisfies the BSE (22) . Taking its transpose and recalling that α 1 T = α 1 = γ 0 γ 1 \alpha_1^T=\alpha_1=\gamma^0\gamma^1 α 1 T = α 1 = γ 0 γ 1 ,
i ∂ x { α 1 , [ Φ ( P ) ( x ) ] T } + 1 2 P [ α 1 , [ Φ ( P ) ( x ) ] T ] − m [ γ 0 , [ Φ ( P ) ( x ) ] T ] = ( E P − V ) [ Φ ( P ) ( x ) ] T (25) i\partial_x\left\{\alpha_1,[\Phi^{(P)}(x)]^T\right\}+\frac{1}{2}P\left[\alpha_1,[\Phi^{(P)}(x)]^T\right]-m\left[\gamma^0,[\Phi^{(P)}(x)]^T\right]=(E_P-V)[\Phi^{(P)}(x)]^T \tag*{(25)} i ∂ x { α 1 , [ Φ ( P ) ( x ) ] T } + 2 1 P [ α 1 , [ Φ ( P ) ( x ) ] T ] − m [ γ 0 , [ Φ ( P ) ( x ) ] T ] = ( E P − V ) [ Φ ( P ) ( x ) ] T (25)
Changing x → − x x\to-x x → − x and multiplying from both sides with γ 1 \gamma^1 γ 1 gives (22) since { γ 1 , α 1 } = { γ 1 , γ 0 } = 0 \{\gamma^1,\alpha_1\}=\{\gamma^1,\gamma^0\}=0 { γ 1 , α 1 } = { γ 1 , γ 0 } = 0 ,
i ∂ x { α 1 , γ 1 [ Φ ( P ) ( − x ) ] T γ 1 } − 1 2 P [ α 1 , γ 1 [ Φ ( P ) ( − x ) ] T γ 1 ] + m [ γ 0 , γ 1 [ Φ ( P ) ( − x ) ] T γ 1 ] = ( E P − V ) γ 1 [ Φ ( P ) ( − x ) ] T γ 1 (26) i\partial_x\left\{\alpha_1,\gamma^1[\Phi^{(P)}(-x)]^T\gamma^1\right\}-\frac{1}{2}P\left[\alpha_1,\gamma^1[\Phi^{(P)}(-x)]^T\gamma^1\right]+m\left[\gamma^0,\gamma^1[\Phi^{(P)}(-x)]^T\gamma^1\right]=(E_P-V)\gamma^1[\Phi^{(P)}(-x)]^T\gamma^1 \tag*{(26)} i ∂ x { α 1 , γ 1 [ Φ ( P ) ( − x ) ] T γ 1 } − 2 1 P [ α 1 , γ 1 [ Φ ( P ) ( − x ) ] T γ 1 ] + m [ γ 0 , γ 1 [ Φ ( P ) ( − x ) ] T γ 1 ] = ( E P − V ) γ 1 [ Φ ( P ) ( − x ) ] T γ 1 (26)
This demonstrates that γ 1 [ Φ ( P ) ( − x ) ] T γ 1 \gamma^1[\Phi^{(P)}(-x)]^T\gamma^1 γ 1 [ Φ ( P ) ( − x ) ] T γ 1 satisfies the BSE if Φ ( P ) ( x ) \Phi^{(P)}(x) Φ ( P ) ( x ) is a solution.
Analytic solution of the bound state equation for Φ ( P ) ( x ) \Phi^{(P)}(x) Φ ( P ) ( x )
Expanding the 2 × 2 2\times2 2 × 2 Dirac wave function Φ α β ( P ) ( x ) \Phi_{\alpha\beta}^{(P)}(x) Φ α β ( P ) ( x ) in scalar functions ϕ j ( P ) ( x ) \phi_j^{(P)}(x) ϕ j ( P ) ( x ) (j = 0 , 1 , 2 , 3 j=0,1,2,3 j = 0 , 1 , 2 , 3 ),
Φ ( P ) ( x ) = ϕ 0 ( P ) ( x ) + α 1 ϕ 1 ( P ) ( x ) + γ 1 ϕ 2 ( P ) ( x ) + γ 0 ϕ 3 ( P ) ( x ) ( α 1 = σ 1 , γ 1 = i σ 2 , γ 0 = σ 3 ) (27) \Phi^{(P)}(x)=\phi_0^{(P)}(x)+\alpha_1\phi_1^{(P)}(x)+\gamma^1\phi_2^{(P)}(x)+\gamma^0\phi_3^{(P)}(x)
\qquad(\alpha_1=\sigma_1,\ \gamma^1=i\sigma_2,\ \gamma^0=\sigma_3) \tag*{(27)} Φ ( P ) ( x ) = ϕ 0 ( P ) ( x ) + α 1 ϕ 1 ( P ) ( x ) + γ 1 ϕ 2 ( P ) ( x ) + γ 0 ϕ 3 ( P ) ( x ) ( α 1 = σ 1 , γ 1 = i σ 2 , γ 0 = σ 3 ) (27)
the parity (23) and charge conjugation (24) conditions imply,
ϕ 0 , 3 ( P ) ( − x ) = η P ϕ 0 , 3 ( − P ) ( x ) ϕ 1 , 2 ( P ) ( − x ) = − η P ϕ 1 , 2 ( − P ) ( x ) \phi_{0,3}^{(P)}(-x)=\eta_P\phi_{0,3}^{(-P)}(x)
\qquad
\phi_{1,2}^{(P)}(-x)=-\eta_P\phi_{1,2}^{(-P)}(x) ϕ 0 , 3 ( P ) ( − x ) = η P ϕ 0 , 3 ( − P ) ( x ) ϕ 1 , 2 ( P ) ( − x ) = − η P ϕ 1 , 2 ( − P ) ( x )
ϕ 0 ( P ) ( − x ) = η C ϕ 0 ( P ) ( x ) ϕ 1 , 2 , 3 ( P ) ( − x ) = − η C ϕ 1 , 2 , 3 ( P ) ( x ) (28) \phi_0^{(P)}(-x)=\eta_C\phi_0^{(P)}(x)
\qquad
\phi_{1,2,3}^{(P)}(-x)=-\eta_C\phi_{1,2,3}^{(P)}(x) \tag*{(28)} ϕ 0 ( P ) ( − x ) = η C ϕ 0 ( P ) ( x ) ϕ 1 , 2 , 3 ( P ) ( − x ) = − η C ϕ 1 , 2 , 3 ( P ) ( x ) (28)
At P = 0 P=0 P = 0 these require η P = η C \eta_P=\eta_C η P = η C , and are compatible since ϕ 3 ( P = 0 ) ( x ) = 0 \phi_3^{(P=0)}(x)=0 ϕ 3 ( P = 0 ) ( x ) = 0 (29) . In the following I consider Φ ( P ) ( x ≥ 0 ) \Phi^{(P)}(x\geq0) Φ ( P ) ( x ≥ 0 ) , with Φ ( P ) ( x < 0 ) \Phi^{(P)}(x<0) Φ ( P ) ( x < 0 ) given by (28) .
Inserting the expansion (27) of Φ ( P ) ( x ≥ 0 ) \Phi^{(P)}(x\geq0) Φ ( P ) ( x ≥ 0 ) into the BSE (22) gives the following relations between the components,
ϕ 2 ( P ) ( x ) = E P − V ( E P − V ) 2 − P 2 2 m ϕ 1 ( P ) ( x ) ϕ 3 ( P ) ( x ) = P ( E P − V ) 2 − P 2 2 m ϕ 1 ( P ) ( x ) (29) \phi_2^{(P)}(x)=\frac{E_P-V}{(E_P-V)^2-P^2}\,2m\phi_1^{(P)}(x)
\qquad
\phi_3^{(P)}(x)=\frac{P}{(E_P-V)^2-P^2}\,2m\phi_1^{(P)}(x) \tag*{(29)} ϕ 2 ( P ) ( x ) = ( E P − V ) 2 − P 2 E P − V 2 m ϕ 1 ( P ) ( x ) ϕ 3 ( P ) ( x ) = ( E P − V ) 2 − P 2 P 2 m ϕ 1 ( P ) ( x ) (29)
2 i E P − V ∂ x ϕ 1 ( P ) ( x ) = ϕ 0 ( P ) ( x ) 2 i E P − V ∂ x ϕ 0 ( P ) ( x ) = [ 1 − 4 m 2 ( E P − V ) 2 − P 2 ] ϕ 1 ( P ) ( x ) (30) \frac{2i}{E_P-V}\partial_x\phi_1^{(P)}(x)=\phi_0^{(P)}(x)
\qquad
\frac{2i}{E_P-V}\partial_x\phi_0^{(P)}(x)=\left[1-\frac{4m^2}{(E_P-V)^2-P^2}\right]\phi_1^{(P)}(x) \tag*{(30)} E P − V 2 i ∂ x ϕ 1 ( P ) ( x ) = ϕ 0 ( P ) ( x ) E P − V 2 i ∂ x ϕ 0 ( P ) ( x ) = [ 1 − ( E P − V ) 2 − P 2 4 m 2 ] ϕ 1 ( P ) ( x ) (30)
In terms of the variable τ P ( x ) \tau_P(x) τ P ( x ) (9) ,
V ′ τ P ( x ) ≡ ( E P − V ) 2 − P 2 ∂ x = − 2 ( E P − V ) ∂ τ P ( x ≥ 0 ) (31) V'\tau_P(x)\equiv(E_P-V)^2-P^2
\qquad
\partial_x=-2(E_P-V)\partial_{\tau_P}
\qquad(x\geq0) \tag*{(31)} V ′ τ P ( x ) ≡ ( E P − V ) 2 − P 2 ∂ x = − 2 ( E P − V ) ∂ τ P ( x ≥ 0 ) (31)
the relations (30) become
∂ τ P ϕ 1 ( P ) ( τ P ) = i 4 ϕ 0 ( P ) ( τ P ) ∂ τ P ϕ 0 ( P ) ( τ P ) = i 4 ( 1 − 4 m 2 V ′ τ P ) ϕ 1 ( P ) ( τ P ) \partial_{\tau_P}\phi_1^{(P)}(\tau_P)=\frac{i}{4}\phi_0^{(P)}(\tau_P)
\qquad
\partial_{\tau_P}\phi_0^{(P)}(\tau_P)=\frac{i}{4}\left(1-\frac{4m^2}{V'\tau_P}\right)\phi_1^{(P)}(\tau_P) ∂ τ P ϕ 1 ( P ) ( τ P ) = 4 i ϕ 0 ( P ) ( τ P ) ∂ τ P ϕ 0 ( P ) ( τ P ) = 4 i ( 1 − V ′ τ P 4 m 2 ) ϕ 1 ( P ) ( τ P )
∂ τ P 2 ϕ 1 ( P ) ( τ P ) + 1 16 ( 1 − 4 m 2 V ′ τ P ) ϕ 1 ( P ) ( τ P ) = 0 (32) \partial_{\tau_P}^2\phi_1^{(P)}(\tau_P)+\frac{1}{16}\left(1-\frac{4m^2}{V'\tau_P}\right)\phi_1^{(P)}(\tau_P)=0 \tag*{(32)} ∂ τ P 2 ϕ 1 ( P ) ( τ P ) + 16 1 ( 1 − V ′ τ P 4 m 2 ) ϕ 1 ( P ) ( τ P ) = 0 (32)
where ϕ ( P ) ( x ) ≡ ϕ ( P ) [ τ P ( x ) ] \phi^{(P)}(x)\equiv\phi^{(P)}[\tau_P(x)] ϕ ( P ) ( x ) ≡ ϕ ( P ) [ τ P ( x )] . Remarkably, relations (32) do not explicitly depend on E P E_P E P or P P P . This holds only for a linear potential V ( x ) = V ′ ∣ x ∣ V(x)=V'|x| V ( x ) = V ′ ∣ x ∣ , which ensures the relation between ∂ x \partial_x ∂ x and ∂ τ P \partial_{\tau_P} ∂ τ P in (31) . Hence the P P P -dependence of the wave functions ϕ 0 , 1 ( P ) [ τ P ( x ) ] \phi_{0,1}^{(P)}[\tau_P(x)] ϕ 0 , 1 ( P ) [ τ P ( x )] as functions of x x x is given by the P P P -dependence of τ P ( x ) \tau_P(x) τ P ( x ) (31) . The components ϕ 2 , 3 ( P ) ( x ) \phi_{2,3}^{(P)}(x) ϕ 2 , 3 ( P ) ( x ) have an explicit dependence on P P P ,
ϕ 2 ( P ) ( x ) = E P − V V ′ τ P ( x ) 2 m ϕ 1 ( P ) [ τ P ( x ) ] ϕ 3 ( P ) ( x ) = P V ′ τ P ( x ) 2 m ϕ 1 ( P ) [ τ P ( x ) ] (33) \phi_2^{(P)}(x)=\frac{E_P-V}{V'\tau_P(x)}2m\phi_1^{(P)}[\tau_P(x)] \qquad\phi_3^{(P)}(x)=\frac{P}{V'\tau_P(x)}2m\phi_1^{(P)}[\tau_P(x)] \tag*{(33)} ϕ 2 ( P ) ( x ) = V ′ τ P ( x ) E P − V 2 m ϕ 1 ( P ) [ τ P ( x )] ϕ 3 ( P ) ( x ) = V ′ τ P ( x ) P 2 m ϕ 1 ( P ) [ τ P ( x )] (33)
Defining the x x x -dependent “boost parameter” ζ P ( x ) \zeta_P(x) ζ P ( x ) by
cosh ζ P ( x ) = E P − V ( x ) V ′ τ P sinh ζ P ( x ) = P V ′ τ P (34) \cosh\zeta_P(x)=\frac{E_P-V(x)}{\sqrt{V'\tau_P}} \qquad\sinh\zeta_P(x)=\frac{P}{\sqrt{V'\tau_P}} \tag*{(34)} cosh ζ P ( x ) = V ′ τ P E P − V ( x ) sinh ζ P ( x ) = V ′ τ P P (34)
the full wave function (27) may be expressed as
Φ ( P ) ( x ) = ϕ 0 + ϕ 1 [ α 1 + 2 m ( E P − V ) V ′ τ P γ 1 + 2 m P V ′ τ P γ 0 ] = e − α 1 ζ P / 2 ( ϕ 0 + ϕ 1 α 1 + 2 m V ′ τ P ϕ 1 γ 1 ) e α 1 ζ P / 2 (35) \Phi^{(P)}(x)=\phi_0+\phi_1\left[\alpha_1+\frac{2m(E_P-V)}{V'\tau_P}\gamma^1+\frac{2mP}{V'\tau_P}\gamma^0\right]=e^{-\alpha_1\zeta_P/2}\left(\phi_0+\phi_1\alpha_1+\frac{2m}{\sqrt{V'\tau_P}}\phi_1\gamma^1\right)e^{\alpha_1\zeta_P/2} \tag*{(35)} Φ ( P ) ( x ) = ϕ 0 + ϕ 1 [ α 1 + V ′ τ P 2 m ( E P − V ) γ 1 + V ′ τ P 2 m P γ 0 ] = e − α 1 ζ P /2 ( ϕ 0 + ϕ 1 α 1 + V ′ τ P 2 m ϕ 1 γ 1 ) e α 1 ζ P /2 (35)
In the latter expression the term in ( ) depends on τ P \tau_P τ P only, whereas ζ P \zeta_P ζ P depends also explicitly on P P P .
The (arbitrarily normalized) solution of (32) for x ≥ 0 x\geq0 x ≥ 0 can be expressed in terms of the Kummer function [13 , 15 ] ,
ϕ 1 ( P ) ( τ P ) = V ′ τ P exp ( − i τ P / 4 ) 1 F 1 ( 1 − i m 2 / 2 V ′ , 2 , i τ P / 2 ) = ϕ 1 ∗ ( τ P ) \phi_1^{(P)}(\tau_P)=V'\tau_P\exp(-i\tau_P/4)\,{}_1F_1(1-im^2/2V',2,i\tau_P/2)=\phi_1^*(\tau_P) ϕ 1 ( P ) ( τ P ) = V ′ τ P exp ( − i τ P /4 ) 1 F 1 ( 1 − i m 2 /2 V ′ , 2 , i τ P /2 ) = ϕ 1 ∗ ( τ P )
ϕ 0 ( P ) ( τ P ) = − ϕ 1 ( τ P ) − 4 i V ′ exp ( − i τ P / 4 ) 1 F 1 ( 1 − i m 2 / 2 V ′ , 1 , i τ P / 2 ) = − ϕ 0 ∗ ( τ P ) (36) \phi_0^{(P)}(\tau_P)=-\phi_1(\tau_P)-4iV'\exp(-i\tau_P/4)\,{}_1F_1(1-im^2/2V',1,i\tau_P/2)=-\phi_0^*(\tau_P) \tag*{(36)} ϕ 0 ( P ) ( τ P ) = − ϕ 1 ( τ P ) − 4 i V ′ exp ( − i τ P /4 ) 1 F 1 ( 1 − i m 2 /2 V ′ , 1 , i τ P /2 ) = − ϕ 0 ∗ ( τ P ) (36)
This solution of the second-order differential equation (32) was determined by the requirement ϕ 1 ( τ P = 0 ) = 0 \phi_1(\tau_P=0)=0 ϕ 1 ( τ P = 0 ) = 0 , which ensures that ϕ 2 ( P ) ( x ) \phi_2^{(P)}(x) ϕ 2 ( P ) ( x ) and ϕ 3 ( P ) ( x ) \phi_3^{(P)}(x) ϕ 3 ( P ) ( x ) (33) are regular at τ P = 0 \tau_P=0 τ P = 0 . The symmetry ϕ 1 ( P ) ( − x ) = − η C ϕ 1 ( P ) ( x ) \phi_1^{(P)}(-x)=-\eta_C\phi_1^{(P)}(x) ϕ 1 ( P ) ( − x ) = − η C ϕ 1 ( P ) ( x ) imposes a continuity condition at x = 0 x=0 x = 0 , i.e., at V ′ τ P ( x = 0 ) = E P 2 − P 2 V'\tau_P(x=0)=E_P^2-P^2 V ′ τ P ( x = 0 ) = E P 2 − P 2 . This value must be independent of P P P for continuity to hold in all frames, requiring E P 2 − P 2 = M 2 E_P^2-P^2=M^2 E P 2 − P 2 = M 2 . Imposing continuity at any P P P determines the allowed values of the bound state masses M M M .
The P P P -dependence of Φ ( P ) ( x ) \Phi^{(P)}(x) Φ ( P ) ( x ) found here from the BSE (22) should agree with that given by the boost generator M ^ 01 \hat{M}^{01} M ^ 01 . This was shown in Coulomb gauge in [16 ] , here I show it for temporal gauge in Appendix C. Even though concerning only infinitesimal boosts, both demonstrations are technically involved. A simpler method might provide better physical insight.
Large separations x x x between the quarks
The variable τ P ( x ) \tau_P(x) τ P ( x ) (31) is quadratically dependent on x x x . From τ P ( x = 0 ) = M 2 / V ′ \tau_P(x=0)=M^2/V' τ P ( x = 0 ) = M 2 / V ′ it decreases to τ P ( x = E / V ′ ) = − P 2 / V ′ \tau_P(x=E/V')=-P^2/V' τ P ( x = E / V ′ ) = − P 2 / V ′ , then increases again, with τ P ( x → ∞ ) ∝ V ′ x 2 \tau_P(x\to\infty)\propto V'x^2 τ P ( x → ∞ ) ∝ V ′ x 2 . At large τ P \tau_P τ P the O ( 1 / τ P ) O(1/\tau_P) O ( 1/ τ P ) term in the BSE (32) may be neglected, so ϕ 0 , 1 ( P ) ( τ P → ∞ ) ∝ exp ( ± i τ P / 4 ) \phi_{0,1}^{(P)}(\tau_P\to\infty)\propto\exp(\pm i\tau_P/4) ϕ 0 , 1 ( P ) ( τ P → ∞ ) ∝ exp ( ± i τ P /4 ) . The analytic solution (36) gives
lim ∣ τ P ∣ → ∞ [ ϕ 1 ( τ P ) + ϕ 0 ( τ P ) ] = lim ∣ τ P ∣ → ∞ [ ϕ 1 ( τ P ) − ϕ 0 ( τ P ) ] ∗ = N exp [ i τ P / 4 − i ( m 2 / 2 V ′ ) log ( ∣ τ P ∣ / 2 ) + i arg Γ ( 1 + i m 2 / 2 V ′ ) − i π / 2 ] \begin{aligned}
\lim_{|\tau_P|\to\infty}\left[\phi_1(\tau_P)+\phi_0(\tau_P)\right]=\lim_{|\tau_P|\to\infty}\left[\phi_1(\tau_P)-\phi_0(\tau_P)\right]^* \\
&=N\exp\left[i\tau_P/4-i(m^2/2V')\log(|\tau_P|/2)+i\arg\Gamma(1+im^2/2V')-i\pi/2\right]
\end{aligned} ∣ τ P ∣ → ∞ lim [ ϕ 1 ( τ P ) + ϕ 0 ( τ P ) ] = ∣ τ P ∣ → ∞ lim [ ϕ 1 ( τ P ) − ϕ 0 ( τ P ) ] ∗ = N exp [ i τ P /4 − i ( m 2 /2 V ′ ) log ( ∣ τ P ∣/2 ) + i arg Γ ( 1 + i m 2 /2 V ′ ) − iπ /2 ]
N = 4 ( V ′ ) 3 / 2 π m exp ( π m 2 / V ′ ) − 1 e − θ ( − τ ) π m 2 / 2 V ′ (37) N=\frac{4(V')^{3/2}}{\sqrt{\pi}m}\sqrt{\exp(\pi m^2/V')-1}\,e^{-\theta(-\tau)\pi m^2/2V'} \tag*{(37)} N = π m 4 ( V ′ ) 3/2 exp ( π m 2 / V ′ ) − 1 e − θ ( − τ ) π m 2 /2 V ′ (37)
where θ ( x ) = 1 ( 0 ) \theta(x)=1\ (0) θ ( x ) = 1 ( 0 ) for x > 0 ( x < 0 ) x>0\ (x<0) x > 0 ( x < 0 ) . The oscillating behavior means that the wave function is not (globally) normalizable, and that the kinetic energy term ∂ τ P 2 ϕ 1 ( P ) \partial_{\tau_P}^2\phi_1^{(P)} ∂ τ P 2 ϕ 1 ( P ) of the BSE (32) is negative at large τ P \tau_P τ P . If the quark fields in the definition (6) of the state are expanded in the free basis in (B.13) the b k , d k ∣ 0 ⟩ b_{k,d_k}|0\rangle b k , d k ∣0 ⟩ component will dominate at large x x x . The other operator components of the state are normalizable.
It is helpful to recall an analogous feature of the Dirac equation for an electron in a linear potential. This was noted already in 1932 [17 ] , see also Sec. IV of [13 ] . For a large potential (V ≳ m V\gtrsim m V ≳ m ) the eigenstates of the Dirac equation include e + e − e^+e^- e + e − pairs (in the free fermion basis). Perturbatively the pairs are due to time-ordered “Z Z Z ”-diagrams, and they give rise to the negative (kinetic) energy components of the wave function. If the Dirac state is expressed as (a superposition of) ψ † ( x ) ∣ 0 ⟩ \psi^\dagger(x)|0\rangle ψ † ( x ) ∣0 ⟩ , the pairs reside in ∣ 0 ⟩ |0\rangle ∣0 ⟩ . A basis without pairs is obtained by Bogoliubov transforming the free creation and annihilation operators in ψ † ( x ) \psi^\dagger(x) ψ † ( x ) . Then at small values of the potential (small ∣ x ∣ |x| ∣ x ∣ for a linear potential) the single fermion is mostly an electron, while at large ∣ x ∣ |x| ∣ x ∣ it is mostly a positron. This reveals the physics: A linear potential that confines electrons repels positrons. The Dirac wave function oscillates with phase ∝ x 2 \propto x^2 ∝ x 2 at large ∣ x ∣ |x| ∣ x ∣ , describing positrons with momenta ∝ x \propto x ∝ x . In analogy to plane waves, the wave function is not normalizable and the energy levels are continuous.
The q q ˉ q\bar{q} q q ˉ bound states (6) considered here have a discrete mass spectrum, for which the wave function components ϕ 2 ( P ) ( x ) \phi_2^{(P)}(x) ϕ 2 ( P ) ( x ) and ϕ 3 ( P ) ( x ) \phi_3^{(P)}(x) ϕ 3 ( P ) ( x ) (29) are regular at τ P = 0 \tau_P=0 τ P = 0 . The negative energy components of the wave function (corresponding to contributions from the annihilation operators in ψ ˉ ( x q ) \bar{\psi}(x_q) ψ ˉ ( x q ) and ψ ( x q ˉ ) \psi(x_{\bar{q}}) ψ ( x q ˉ ) ) allow a nonvanishing overlap ⟨ B C ∣ A ⟩ \langle BC|A\rangle ⟨ B C ∣ A ⟩ , i.e., a “fragmentation” of bound state A A A into B + C B+C B + C . Physically, it is akin to string breaking, i.e., the production/annihilation of a q q ˉ q\bar{q} q q ˉ pair by the bound state potential. Since the potential V ( x ) = 1 2 g 2 C F ∣ x ∣ V(x)=\frac{1}{2}g^2C_F|x| V ( x ) = 2 1 g 2 C F ∣ x ∣ (8) is of leading order in the N c → ∞ N_c\to\infty N c → ∞ limit, the fragmentation is not suppressed. The bound state overlap qualitatively resembles the dual features of hadron dynamics; initially produced (“parent”) states describe final (“daughter”) states in an average sense [18 ] . These aspects merit further study.
I refer to [13 , 15 ] for further features of Φ ( P ) ( x ) \Phi^{(P)}(x) Φ ( P ) ( x ) .
Momentum space
The wave function Φ ( P ) ( k ) \Phi^{(P)}(k) Φ ( P ) ( k ) of momentum space is related to Φ ( P ) ( x ) \Phi^{(P)}(x) Φ ( P ) ( x ) of coordinate space through a Fourier transform,
Φ ( P ) ( x ) = ∫ − ∞ ∞ d k 2 π e i k x Φ ( P ) ( k ) Φ ( P ) ( k ) = ∫ − ∞ ∞ d x e − i k x Φ ( P ) ( x ) (38) \Phi^{(P)}(x)=\int_{-\infty}^{\infty}\frac{dk}{2\pi}e^{ikx}\Phi^{(P)}(k) \qquad\Phi^{(P)}(k)=\int_{-\infty}^{\infty}dx\,e^{-ikx}\Phi^{(P)}(x) \tag*{(38)} Φ ( P ) ( x ) = ∫ − ∞ ∞ 2 π d k e ik x Φ ( P ) ( k ) Φ ( P ) ( k ) = ∫ − ∞ ∞ d x e − ik x Φ ( P ) ( x ) (38)
The parity and charge conjugation symmetries (23) and (24) are in momentum space (η P = η C \eta_P=\eta_C η P = η C in D = 1 + 1 D=1+1 D = 1 + 1 ),
γ 0 Φ ( P ) ( − k ) γ 0 = η P Φ ( − P ) ( k ) i γ 1 [ Φ ( P ) ( − k ) ] T i γ 1 = η C Φ ( P ) ( k ) (39) \gamma^0\Phi^{(P)}(-k)\gamma^0=\eta_P\Phi^{(-P)}(k) \qquad i\gamma^1[\Phi^{(P)}(-k)]^T i\gamma^1=\eta_C\Phi^{(P)}(k) \tag*{(39)} γ 0 Φ ( P ) ( − k ) γ 0 = η P Φ ( − P ) ( k ) i γ 1 [ Φ ( P ) ( − k ) ] T i γ 1 = η C Φ ( P ) ( k ) (39)
The quark q q q and antiquark q ˉ \bar{q} q ˉ momenta are defined in terms of their relative momentum k k k as,
q ≡ 1 2 P + k q ˉ ≡ 1 2 P − k ( − ∞ < q , q ˉ < ∞ ) (40) q\equiv\frac{1}{2}P+k \qquad\bar{q}\equiv\frac{1}{2}P-k \qquad(-\infty<q,\bar{q}<\infty) \tag*{(40)} q ≡ 2 1 P + k q ˉ ≡ 2 1 P − k ( − ∞ < q , q ˉ < ∞ ) (40)
Energy projection
Kinetic energy projection is defined in terms of the free u ( k ) u(k) u ( k ) and v ( k ) v(k) v ( k ) spinors (B.14). With E k ≡ k 2 + m 2 E_k\equiv\sqrt{k^2+m^2} E k ≡ k 2 + m 2 ,
U + ( q ) = u ( q ) 2 E q = E q + m + α 1 q 2 E q ( E q + m ) ( 1 0 ) U − ( q ) = v ( − q ) 2 E q = E q + m − α 1 q 2 E q ( E q + m ) ( 0 1 ) V + ( q ˉ ) = v ( q ˉ ) 2 E q ˉ = E q ˉ + m + α 1 q ˉ 2 E q ˉ ( E q ˉ + m ) ( 0 1 ) V − ( q ˉ ) = u ( − q ˉ ) 2 E q ˉ = E q ˉ + m − α 1 q ˉ 2 E q ˉ ( E q ˉ + m ) ( 1 0 ) (41) \begin{aligned}
U_+(q)&=\frac{u(q)}{\sqrt{2E_q}}=\frac{E_q+m+\alpha_1q}{\sqrt{2E_q(E_q+m)}}\begin{pmatrix}1\\0\end{pmatrix}
&
U_-(q)&=\frac{v(-q)}{\sqrt{2E_q}}=\frac{E_q+m-\alpha_1q}{\sqrt{2E_q(E_q+m)}}\begin{pmatrix}0\\1\end{pmatrix}\\
V_+(\bar{q})&=\frac{v(\bar{q})}{\sqrt{2E_{\bar{q}}}}=\frac{E_{\bar{q}}+m+\alpha_1\bar{q}}{\sqrt{2E_{\bar{q}}(E_{\bar{q}}+m)}}\begin{pmatrix}0\\1\end{pmatrix}
&
V_-(\bar{q})&=\frac{u(-\bar{q})}{\sqrt{2E_{\bar{q}}}}=\frac{E_{\bar{q}}+m-\alpha_1\bar{q}}{\sqrt{2E_{\bar{q}}(E_{\bar{q}}+m)}}\begin{pmatrix}1\\0\end{pmatrix} \tag*{(41)}
\end{aligned} U + ( q ) V + ( q ˉ ) = 2 E q u ( q ) = 2 E q ( E q + m ) E q + m + α 1 q ( 1 0 ) = 2 E q ˉ v ( q ˉ ) = 2 E q ˉ ( E q ˉ + m ) E q ˉ + m + α 1 q ˉ ( 0 1 ) U − ( q ) V − ( q ˉ ) = 2 E q v ( − q ) = 2 E q ( E q + m ) E q + m − α 1 q ( 0 1 ) = 2 E q ˉ u ( − q ˉ ) = 2 E q ˉ ( E q ˉ + m ) E q ˉ + m − α 1 q ˉ ( 1 0 ) (41)
The projectors on positive and negative kinetic energy for the quark and antiquark are then, respectively:
U + ( q ) U + † ( q ) = 1 2 E q ( E q + γ 0 m + α 1 q ) U − ( q ) U − † ( q ) = 1 2 E q ( E q − γ 0 m − α 1 q ) V + ( q ˉ ) V + † ( q ˉ ) = 1 2 E q ˉ ( E q ˉ − γ 0 m + α 1 q ˉ ) V − ( q ˉ ) V − † ( q ˉ ) = 1 2 E q ˉ ( E q ˉ + γ 0 m − α 1 q ˉ ) ∑ s = ± U s ( q ) U s † ( q ) = ∑ s = ± V s ( q ˉ ) V s † ( q ˉ ) = 1 U s † ( q ) U s ′ ( q ) = V s † ( q ˉ ) V s ′ ( q ˉ ) = δ s , s ′ (42) \begin{aligned}
U_+(q)U_+^\dagger(q)&=\frac{1}{2E_q}(E_q+\gamma^0m+\alpha_1q)
&
U_-(q)U_-^\dagger(q)&=\frac{1}{2E_q}(E_q-\gamma^0m-\alpha_1q)\\
V_+(\bar{q})V_+^\dagger(\bar{q})&=\frac{1}{2E_{\bar{q}}}(E_{\bar{q}}-\gamma^0m+\alpha_1\bar{q})
&
V_-(\bar{q})V_-^\dagger(\bar{q})&=\frac{1}{2E_{\bar{q}}}(E_{\bar{q}}+\gamma^0m-\alpha_1\bar{q})\\
\sum_{s=\pm}U_s(q)U_s^\dagger(q)&=\sum_{s=\pm}V_s(\bar{q})V_s^\dagger(\bar{q})=1
&
U_s^\dagger(q)U_{s'}(q)&=V_s^\dagger(\bar{q})V_{s'}(\bar{q})=\delta_{s,s'} \tag*{(42)}
\end{aligned} U + ( q ) U + † ( q ) V + ( q ˉ ) V + † ( q ˉ ) s = ± ∑ U s ( q ) U s † ( q ) = 2 E q 1 ( E q + γ 0 m + α 1 q ) = 2 E q ˉ 1 ( E q ˉ − γ 0 m + α 1 q ˉ ) = s = ± ∑ V s ( q ˉ ) V s † ( q ˉ ) = 1 U − ( q ) U − † ( q ) V − ( q ˉ ) V − † ( q ˉ ) U s † ( q ) U s ′ ( q ) = 2 E q 1 ( E q − γ 0 m − α 1 q ) = 2 E q ˉ 1 ( E q ˉ + γ 0 m − α 1 q ˉ ) = V s † ( q ˉ ) V s ′ ( q ˉ ) = δ s , s ′ (42)
The energy projected ( s , s ˉ = ± ) (s,\bar{s}=\pm) ( s , s ˉ = ± ) wave functions ϕ s s ˉ ( P ) ( k ) \phi_{s\bar{s}}^{(P)}(k) ϕ s s ˉ ( P ) ( k ) are defined by (40) and
ϕ s s ˉ ( P ) ( k ) ≡ U ˉ s ( q ) Φ ( P ) ( k ) V s ˉ ( q ˉ ) Φ ( P ) ( k ) = ∑ s , s ˉ = ± γ 0 U s ( q ) ϕ s s ˉ ( P ) ( k ) V s ˉ † ( q ˉ ) (43) \phi_{s\bar{s}}^{(P)}(k)\equiv\bar{U}_s(q)\Phi^{(P)}(k)V_{\bar{s}}(\bar{q}) \qquad\Phi^{(P)}(k)=\sum_{s,\bar{s}=\pm}\gamma^0U_s(q)\phi_{s\bar{s}}^{(P)}(k)V_{\bar{s}}^\dagger(\bar{q}) \tag*{(43)} ϕ s s ˉ ( P ) ( k ) ≡ U ˉ s ( q ) Φ ( P ) ( k ) V s ˉ ( q ˉ ) Φ ( P ) ( k ) = s , s ˉ = ± ∑ γ 0 U s ( q ) ϕ s s ˉ ( P ) ( k ) V s ˉ † ( q ˉ ) (43)
BSE in momentum space
The BSE (22) is Fourier transformed and energy projected using the spinors (41) ,
∫ − ∞ ∞ d x e − i k x U ˉ s ( q ) [ Eq. ( 2.13 ) ] V s ˉ ( q ˉ ) q = 1 2 P + k , q ˉ = 1 2 P − k , s , s ˉ = ± (44) \int_{-\infty}^{\infty} dx\,e^{-ikx}\,\bar{U}_{s}(q)\,[\text{Eq. }(2.13)]\,V_{\bar{s}}(\bar{q}) \qquad q=\frac{1}{2}P+k,\qquad\bar{q}=\frac{1}{2}P-k,\qquad s,\bar{s}=\pm \tag*{(44)} ∫ − ∞ ∞ d x e − ik x U ˉ s ( q ) [ Eq. ( 2.13 )] V s ˉ ( q ˉ ) q = 2 1 P + k , q ˉ = 2 1 P − k , s , s ˉ = ± (44)
Kinetic energies
The quark kinetic energy term contributes,
∫ d x e − i k x U ˉ s ( q ) [ α 1 ( i ∂ ⃗ x − 1 2 P ) + γ 0 m ] Φ ( P ) ( x ) V s ˉ ( q ˉ ) = U s † ( q ) ( α 1 q + γ 0 m ) γ 0 Φ ( P ) ( k ) V s ˉ ( q ˉ ) = E q U s † ( q ) [ 2 U + ( q ) U + † ( q ) − 1 ] γ 0 Φ ( P ) ( k ) V s ˉ ( q ˉ ) = s E q U ˉ s ( q ) Φ ( P ) ( k ) V s ˉ ( q ˉ ) = s E q ϕ s s ˉ ( P ) ( k ) (45) \begin{aligned}
\int dx\,e^{-ikx}\,\bar{U}_{s}(q)\left[\alpha_{1}\left(i\vec{\partial}_{x}-\frac{1}{2}P\right)+\gamma^{0}m\right]\Phi^{(P)}(x)V_{\bar{s}}(\bar{q})=U_{s}^{\dagger}(q)(\alpha_{1}q+\gamma^{0}m)\gamma^{0}\Phi^{(P)}(k)V_{\bar{s}}(\bar{q}) \\
&=E_{q}U_{s}^{\dagger}(q)[2U_{+}(q)U_{+}^{\dagger}(q)-1]\gamma^{0}\Phi^{(P)}(k)V_{\bar{s}}(\bar{q})=sE_{q}\bar{U}_{s}(q)\Phi^{(P)}(k)V_{\bar{s}}(\bar{q})=sE_{q}\phi_{s\bar{s}}^{(P)}(k) \tag*{(45)}
\end{aligned} ∫ d x e − ik x U ˉ s ( q ) [ α 1 ( i ∂ x − 2 1 P ) + γ 0 m ] Φ ( P ) ( x ) V s ˉ ( q ˉ ) = U s † ( q ) ( α 1 q + γ 0 m ) γ 0 Φ ( P ) ( k ) V s ˉ ( q ˉ ) = E q U s † ( q ) [ 2 U + ( q ) U + † ( q ) − 1 ] γ 0 Φ ( P ) ( k ) V s ˉ ( q ˉ ) = s E q U ˉ s ( q ) Φ ( P ) ( k ) V s ˉ ( q ˉ ) = s E q ϕ s s ˉ ( P ) ( k ) (45)
The antiquark kinetic term similarly contributes
U ˉ s ( q ) ∫ d x Φ ( P ) ( x ) [ α 1 ( i ∂ ⃗ x + 1 2 P ) − γ 0 m ] e − i k x V s ˉ ( q ˉ ) = U ˉ s ( q ) Φ ( P ) ( k ) ( α 1 q ˉ − γ 0 m ) V s ˉ ( q ˉ ) = E q ˉ U ˉ s ( q ) Φ ( P ) ( k ) [ 2 V + ( q ˉ ) V + † ( q ˉ ) − 1 ] V s ˉ ( q ˉ ) = s ˉ E q ˉ U ˉ s ( q ) Φ ( P ) ( k ) V s ˉ ( q ˉ ) = s ˉ E q ˉ ϕ s s ˉ ( P ) ( k ) (46) \begin{aligned}
\bar{U}_{s}(q)\int dx\,\Phi^{(P)}(x)\left[\alpha_{1}\left(i\vec{\partial}_{x}+\frac{1}{2}P\right)-\gamma^{0}m\right]e^{-ikx}V_{\bar{s}}(\bar{q})=\bar{U}_{s}(q)\Phi^{(P)}(k)(\alpha_{1}\bar{q}-\gamma^{0}m)V_{\bar{s}}(\bar{q}) \\
&=E_{\bar{q}}\bar{U}_{s}(q)\Phi^{(P)}(k)[2V_{+}(\bar{q})V_{+}^{\dagger}(\bar{q})-1]V_{\bar{s}}(\bar{q})=\bar{s}E_{\bar{q}}\bar{U}_{s}(q)\Phi^{(P)}(k)V_{\bar{s}}(\bar{q})=\bar{s}E_{\bar{q}}\phi_{s\bar{s}}^{(P)}(k) \tag*{(46)}
\end{aligned} U ˉ s ( q ) ∫ d x Φ ( P ) ( x ) [ α 1 ( i ∂ x + 2 1 P ) − γ 0 m ] e − ik x V s ˉ ( q ˉ ) = U ˉ s ( q ) Φ ( P ) ( k ) ( α 1 q ˉ − γ 0 m ) V s ˉ ( q ˉ ) = E q ˉ U ˉ s ( q ) Φ ( P ) ( k ) [ 2 V + ( q ˉ ) V + † ( q ˉ ) − 1 ] V s ˉ ( q ˉ ) = s ˉ E q ˉ U ˉ s ( q ) Φ ( P ) ( k ) V s ˉ ( q ˉ ) = s ˉ E q ˉ ϕ s s ˉ ( P ) ( k ) (46)
Including the remaining terms in (22) the BSE becomes
( E P − s E q − s ˉ E q ˉ ) ϕ s s ˉ ( P ) ( k ) = U ˉ s ( q ) ∫ d x e − i k x V ( x ) Φ ( P ) ( x ) V s ˉ ( q ˉ ) (47) (E_{P}-sE_{q}-\bar{s}E_{\bar{q}})\phi_{s\bar{s}}^{(P)}(k)=\bar{U}_{s}(q)\int dx\,e^{-ikx}V(x)\Phi^{(P)}(x)V_{\bar{s}}(\bar{q}) \tag*{(47)} ( E P − s E q − s ˉ E q ˉ ) ϕ s s ˉ ( P ) ( k ) = U ˉ s ( q ) ∫ d x e − ik x V ( x ) Φ ( P ) ( x ) V s ˉ ( q ˉ ) (47)
where E P = P 2 + M 2 E_{P}=\sqrt{P^{2}+M^{2}} E P = P 2 + M 2 and the linear potential V ( x ) = V ′ ∣ x ∣ V(x)=V^{\prime}|x| V ( x ) = V ′ ∣ x ∣ with V ′ = 1 2 g 2 C F = 1 4 g 2 ( N c 2 − 1 ) / N c V^{\prime}=\frac{1}{2}g^{2}C_{F}=\frac{1}{4}g^{2}(N_{c}^{2}-1)/N_{c} V ′ = 2 1 g 2 C F = 4 1 g 2 ( N c 2 − 1 ) / N c .
Potential energy
Since the potential V ( x ) = V ′ ∣ x ∣ V(x)=V^{\prime}|x| V ( x ) = V ′ ∣ x ∣ is local in x x x its contribution becomes a convolution in k k k . We have
V ′ ∣ x ∣ Φ ( P ) ( x ) = 2 V ′ ∫ − ∞ ∞ d l ′ 2 π 1 l ′ 2 ( 1 − e i l ′ x ) ∫ d k ′ 2 π e i k ′ x Φ ( P ) ( k ′ ) (48) V^{\prime}|x|\Phi^{(P)}(x)=2V^{\prime}\int_{-\infty}^{\infty}\frac{dl^{\prime}}{2\pi}\frac{1}{l^{\prime2}}(1-e^{il^{\prime}x})\int\frac{dk^{\prime}}{2\pi}e^{ik^{\prime}x}\Phi^{(P)}(k^{\prime}) \tag*{(48)} V ′ ∣ x ∣ Φ ( P ) ( x ) = 2 V ′ ∫ − ∞ ∞ 2 π d l ′ l ′2 1 ( 1 − e i l ′ x ) ∫ 2 π d k ′ e i k ′ x Φ ( P ) ( k ′ ) (48)
The 1 / l ′ 2 1/l^{\prime2} 1/ l ′2 term regularizes the l ′ l^{\prime} l ′ -integral, adding an (infinite) constant to V ( x ) V(x) V ( x ) which in the BSE (47) may be absorbed in the energy E P E_{P} E P of the state. Changing variables k ′ → k k^{\prime}\to k k ′ → k , l ′ → l − k l^{\prime}\to l-k l ′ → l − k in the 1 / l ′ 2 1/l^{\prime2} 1/ l ′2 term, and k ′ → l k^{\prime}\to l k ′ → l , l ′ → k − l l^{\prime}\to k-l l ′ → k − l in the e i l ′ x / l ′ 2 e^{il^{\prime}x}/l^{\prime2} e i l ′ x / l ′2 term,
V ′ ∣ x ∣ Φ ( P ) ( x ) = − 2 V ′ ∫ − ∞ ∞ d k 2 π e i k x ∫ − ∞ ∞ d l 2 π 1 ( l − k ) 2 [ Φ ( P ) ( l ) − Φ ( P ) ( k ) ] (49) V^{\prime}|x|\Phi^{(P)}(x)=-2V^{\prime}\int_{-\infty}^{\infty}\frac{dk}{2\pi}e^{ikx}\int_{-\infty}^{\infty}\frac{dl}{2\pi}\frac{1}{(l-k)^{2}}[\Phi^{(P)}(l)-\Phi^{(P)}(k)] \tag*{(49)} V ′ ∣ x ∣ Φ ( P ) ( x ) = − 2 V ′ ∫ − ∞ ∞ 2 π d k e ik x ∫ − ∞ ∞ 2 π d l ( l − k ) 2 1 [ Φ ( P ) ( l ) − Φ ( P ) ( k )] (49)
where the l l l -integral is regularized by the principal value. The BSE (47) becomes
( E P − s E q − s ˉ E q ˉ ) ϕ s s ˉ ( P ) ( k ) = − 2 V ′ ∫ − ∞ ∞ d l 2 π 1 ( l − k ) 2 [ U ˉ s ( q ) Φ ( P ) ( l ) V s ˉ ( q ˉ ) − ϕ s s ˉ ( P ) ( k ) ] (50) (E_{P}-sE_{q}-\bar{s}E_{\bar{q}})\phi_{s\bar{s}}^{(P)}(k)=-2V^{\prime}\int_{-\infty}^{\infty}\frac{dl}{2\pi}\frac{1}{(l-k)^{2}}[\bar{U}_{s}(q)\Phi^{(P)}(l)V_{\bar{s}}(\bar{q})-\phi_{s\bar{s}}^{(P)}(k)] \tag*{(50)} ( E P − s E q − s ˉ E q ˉ ) ϕ s s ˉ ( P ) ( k ) = − 2 V ′ ∫ − ∞ ∞ 2 π d l ( l − k ) 2 1 [ U ˉ s ( q ) Φ ( P ) ( l ) V s ˉ ( q ˉ ) − ϕ s s ˉ ( P ) ( k )] (50)
Using (43) and defining p = 1 2 P + l p=\frac{1}{2}P+l p = 2 1 P + l , p ˉ = 1 2 P − l \bar{p}=\frac{1}{2}P-l p ˉ = 2 1 P − l we have
U ˉ s ( q ) Φ ( P ) ( l ) V s ˉ ( q ˉ ) = ∑ s ′ , s ˉ ′ = ± U s † ( q ) U s ′ ( p ) ϕ s ′ s ˉ ′ ( P ) ( l ) V s ′ † ( p ˉ ) V s ˉ ( q ˉ ) ≡ ∑ s ′ , s ˉ ′ = ± Θ s s ′ ( q , p ) ϕ s ′ s ˉ ′ ( P ) ( l ) Θ s ˉ ′ s ˉ ( p ˉ , q ˉ ) \bar{U}_{s}(q)\Phi^{(P)}(l)V_{\bar{s}}(\bar{q})=\sum_{s^{\prime},\bar{s}^{\prime}=\pm}U_{s}^{\dagger}(q)U_{s^{\prime}}(p)\phi_{s^{\prime}\bar{s}^{\prime}}^{(P)}(l)V_{s^{\prime}}^{\dagger}(\bar{p})V_{\bar{s}}(\bar{q})\equiv\sum_{s^{\prime},\bar{s}^{\prime}=\pm}\Theta_{ss^{\prime}}(q,p)\phi_{s^{\prime}\bar{s}^{\prime}}^{(P)}(l)\Theta_{\bar{s}^{\prime}\bar{s}}(\bar{p},\bar{q}) U ˉ s ( q ) Φ ( P ) ( l ) V s ˉ ( q ˉ ) = s ′ , s ˉ ′ = ± ∑ U s † ( q ) U s ′ ( p ) ϕ s ′ s ˉ ′ ( P ) ( l ) V s ′ † ( p ˉ ) V s ˉ ( q ˉ ) ≡ s ′ , s ˉ ′ = ± ∑ Θ s s ′ ( q , p ) ϕ s ′ s ˉ ′ ( P ) ( l ) Θ s ˉ ′ s ˉ ( p ˉ , q ˉ )
Θ s s ′ ( q , p ) ≡ U s † ( q ) U s ′ ( p ) V s ′ † ( p ˉ ) V s ˉ ( q ˉ ) = Θ s ˉ ′ s ˉ ( p ˉ , q ˉ ) (51) \Theta_{ss^{\prime}}(q,p)\equiv U_{s}^{\dagger}(q)U_{s^{\prime}}(p)\qquad V_{s^{\prime}}^{\dagger}(\bar{p})V_{\bar{s}}(\bar{q})=\Theta_{\bar{s}^{\prime}\bar{s}}(\bar{p},\bar{q}) \tag*{(51)} Θ s s ′ ( q , p ) ≡ U s † ( q ) U s ′ ( p ) V s ′ † ( p ˉ ) V s ˉ ( q ˉ ) = Θ s ˉ ′ s ˉ ( p ˉ , q ˉ ) (51)
From (41) the expressions for Θ s s ′ ( q , p ) \Theta_{ss'}(q,p) Θ s s ′ ( q , p ) are
Θ + + ( q , p ) = ( E q + m ) ( E p + m ) + q p 4 E q E p ( E q + m ) ( E p + m ) , Θ + − ( q , p ) = ( E p + m ) q − ( E q + m ) p 4 E q E p ( E q + m ) ( E p + m ) , Θ − + ( q , p ) = − Θ + − ( q , p ) , Θ − − ( q , p ) = Θ + + ( q , p ) (52) \begin{aligned}
\Theta_{++}(q,p) &= \frac{(E_q+m)(E_p+m)+qp}{\sqrt{4E_qE_p(E_q+m)(E_p+m)}}, &
\Theta_{+-}(q,p) &= \frac{(E_p+m)q-(E_q+m)p}{\sqrt{4E_qE_p(E_q+m)(E_p+m)}},\\
\Theta_{-+}(q,p) &= -\Theta_{+-}(q,p), &
\Theta_{--}(q,p) &= \Theta_{++}(q,p) \tag*{(52)}
\end{aligned} Θ ++ ( q , p ) Θ −+ ( q , p ) = 4 E q E p ( E q + m ) ( E p + m ) ( E q + m ) ( E p + m ) + q p , = − Θ +− ( q , p ) , Θ +− ( q , p ) Θ −− ( q , p ) = 4 E q E p ( E q + m ) ( E p + m ) ( E p + m ) q − ( E q + m ) p , = Θ ++ ( q , p ) (52)
The BSE in momentum space is then
( E P − s E q − s ˉ E q ˉ ) ϕ s s ′ ( P ) ( k ) = − 2 V ′ ∫ − ∞ ∞ d l 2 π 1 ( l − k ) 2 [ ∑ s ˉ ′ , s ˉ ′ = ± Θ s s ′ ( q , p ) ϕ s ˉ s ˉ ′ ( P ) ( l ) Θ s ˉ ′ s ˉ ( p ˉ , q ˉ ) − ϕ s s ′ ( P ) ( k ) ] (53) \left(E_P-sE_q-\bar{s}E_{\bar{q}}\right)\phi_{ss'}^{(P)}(k)=-2V'\int_{-\infty}^{\infty}\frac{dl}{2\pi}\frac{1}{(l-k)^2}\left[\sum_{\bar{s}',\bar{s}'=\pm}\Theta_{ss'}(q,p)\phi_{\bar{s}\bar{s}'}^{(P)}(l)\Theta_{\bar{s}'\bar{s}}(\bar{p},\bar{q})-\phi_{ss'}^{(P)}(k)\right] \tag*{(53)} ( E P − s E q − s ˉ E q ˉ ) ϕ s s ′ ( P ) ( k ) = − 2 V ′ ∫ − ∞ ∞ 2 π d l ( l − k ) 2 1 s ˉ ′ , s ˉ ′ = ± ∑ Θ s s ′ ( q , p ) ϕ s ˉ s ˉ ′ ( P ) ( l ) Θ s ˉ ′ s ˉ ( p ˉ , q ˉ ) − ϕ s s ′ ( P ) ( k ) (53)
The Θ \Theta Θ -functions determine the mixing of the positive and negative energy components of the wave function caused by the potential. Because
Θ s s ′ ( q , p ) ∣ l = k = δ s s ′ (54) \left.\Theta_{ss'}(q,p)\right|_{l=k}=\delta_{ss'} \tag*{(54)} Θ s s ′ ( q , p ) ∣ l = k = δ s s ′ (54)
the numerator of the integrand is of O ( l − k ) \mathcal{O}(l-k) O ( l − k ) near l = k l=k l = k , and the integral is defined by its principal value.
Infinite momentum frame
The wave function for P → ∞ P \to\infty P → ∞
In the limit of P → ∞ P \to\infty P → ∞ at fixed τ P ( x ) \tau_P(x) τ P ( x ) (9) the quark separation x = x q − x q ˉ x=x_q-x_{\bar q} x = x q − x q ˉ Lorentz contracts. The IMF variable τ ∞ ( u ) \tau_\infty(u) τ ∞ ( u ) becomes a linear function of the scaled separation u ≡ E P x ≃ P x u\equiv E_Px\simeq Px u ≡ E P x ≃ P x .
τ P ( x ) = M 2 / V ′ − 2 E P ∣ x ∣ + V ′ x 2 ⟶ τ ∞ ( x ) = M 2 / V ′ − 2 E P ∣ x ∣ = M 2 / V ′ − 2 ∣ u ∣ (55) \tau_P(x)=M^2/V'-2E_P|x|+V'x^2\ \longrightarrow\ \tau_\infty(x)=M^2/V'-2E_P|x|=M^2/V'-2|u| \tag*{(55)} τ P ( x ) = M 2 / V ′ − 2 E P ∣ x ∣ + V ′ x 2 ⟶ τ ∞ ( x ) = M 2 / V ′ − 2 E P ∣ x ∣ = M 2 / V ′ − 2∣ u ∣ (55)
When the wave function Φ ( P ) ( x ) → Φ ( ∞ ) ( u ) \Phi^{(P)}(x)\to\Phi^{(\infty)}(u) Φ ( P ) ( x ) → Φ ( ∞ ) ( u ) is expanded into Dirac components as in (27) , the ϕ 2 ( ∞ ) ( u ) ≃ ϕ 3 ( ∞ ) ( u ) \phi_2^{(\infty)}(u)\simeq\phi_3^{(\infty)}(u) ϕ 2 ( ∞ ) ( u ) ≃ ϕ 3 ( ∞ ) ( u ) components (29) dominate ϕ 0 ( ∞ ) ( u ) \phi_0^{(\infty)}(u) ϕ 0 ( ∞ ) ( u ) and ϕ 1 ( ∞ ) ( u ) \phi_1^{(\infty)}(u) ϕ 1 ( ∞ ) ( u ) (30) by one power of P P P . Recalling also the charge conjugation symmetry (39) and the analytic expression (36) ,
Φ ( ∞ ) ( u ) ≡ 2 m P ( γ 0 + γ 1 ) ϕ ( ∞ ) ( u ) \Phi^{(\infty)}(u)\equiv2mP(\gamma^0+\gamma^1)\phi^{(\infty)}(u) Φ ( ∞ ) ( u ) ≡ 2 m P ( γ 0 + γ 1 ) ϕ ( ∞ ) ( u )
ϕ ( ∞ ) ( u ) = exp [ − i 1 4 τ ∞ ( u ) ] 1 F 1 [ 1 − i m 2 2 V ′ , 2 ; i 2 τ ∞ ( u ) ] = − η C ϕ ( ∞ ) ( − u ) ( u ≥ 0 ) (56) \phi^{(\infty)}(u)=\exp\left[-\mathrm{i}\frac{1}{4}\tau_\infty(u)\right]\,{}_1F_1\left[1-\frac{\mathrm{i}m^2}{2V'},2;\frac{\mathrm{i}}{2}\tau_\infty(u)\right]=-\eta_C\phi^{(\infty)}(-u)\qquad(u\geq0) \tag*{(56)} ϕ ( ∞ ) ( u ) = exp [ − i 4 1 τ ∞ ( u ) ] 1 F 1 [ 1 − 2 V ′ i m 2 , 2 ; 2 i τ ∞ ( u ) ] = − η C ϕ ( ∞ ) ( − u ) ( u ≥ 0 ) (56)
In the IMF the quark and antiquark momenta (40) are defined in terms of the momentum fraction x B x_B x B ,
q = x B P , q ˉ = ( 1 − x B ) P , k = ( x B − 1 2 ) P ( − ∞ < x B < ∞ ) (57) q=x_BP,\qquad\bar{q}=(1-x_B)P,\qquad k=\left(x_B-\frac{1}{2}\right)P\qquad(-\infty<x_B<\infty) \tag*{(57)} q = x B P , q ˉ = ( 1 − x B ) P , k = ( x B − 2 1 ) P ( − ∞ < x B < ∞ ) (57)
Note that since k k k ranges over all positive and negative values at any P P P (38) , the same is true for x B x_B x B . In physical processes such as deep inelastic scattering the range 0 < x B < 1 0<x_B<1 0 < x B < 1 is mandated by positive final state energy, but this does not constrain wave functions. The Fourier transform (38) becomes in the IMF,
Φ ( ∞ ) ( x B ) = ∫ − ∞ ∞ d u P e − i u k / P Φ ( ∞ ) ( u ) = 2 m ( γ 0 + γ 1 ) ∫ − ∞ ∞ d u e − i u ( x B − 1 / 2 ) ϕ ( ∞ ) ( u ) ≡ 2 m ( γ 0 + γ 1 ) ϕ ( ∞ ) ( x B ) \Phi^{(\infty)}(x_B)=\int_{-\infty}^{\infty}\frac{du}{P}e^{-\mathrm{i}uk/P}\Phi^{(\infty)}(u)=2m(\gamma^0+\gamma^1)\int_{-\infty}^{\infty}du\,e^{-\mathrm{i}u(x_B-1/2)}\phi^{(\infty)}(u)\equiv2m(\gamma^0+\gamma^1)\phi^{(\infty)}(x_B) Φ ( ∞ ) ( x B ) = ∫ − ∞ ∞ P d u e − i u k / P Φ ( ∞ ) ( u ) = 2 m ( γ 0 + γ 1 ) ∫ − ∞ ∞ d u e − i u ( x B − 1/2 ) ϕ ( ∞ ) ( u ) ≡ 2 m ( γ 0 + γ 1 ) ϕ ( ∞ ) ( x B )
ϕ ( ∞ ) ( x B ) = ∫ 0 ∞ d u ϕ ( ∞ ) ( u ) { exp [ − i ( x B − 1 2 ) u ] − η C exp [ i ( x B − 1 2 ) u ] } = − η C ϕ ( ∞ ) ( 1 − x B ) (58) \phi^{(\infty)}(x_B)=\int_0^\infty du\,\phi^{(\infty)}(u)\left\{\exp\left[-\mathrm{i}\left(x_B-\frac{1}{2}\right)u\right]-\eta_C\exp\left[\mathrm{i}\left(x_B-\frac{1}{2}\right)u\right]\right\}=-\eta_C\phi^{(\infty)}(1-x_B) \tag*{(58)} ϕ ( ∞ ) ( x B ) = ∫ 0 ∞ d u ϕ ( ∞ ) ( u ) { exp [ − i ( x B − 2 1 ) u ] − η C exp [ i ( x B − 2 1 ) u ] } = − η C ϕ ( ∞ ) ( 1 − x B ) (58)
The charge conjugation symmetry (28) allowed to restrict the integral to u ≥ 0 u\geq0 u ≥ 0 , for which the analytic expression (56) of ϕ ( ∞ ) ( u ) \phi^{(\infty)}(u) ϕ ( ∞ ) ( u ) applies. Using the integral representation,
1 F 1 ( a , b , z ) = 1 Γ ( a ) Γ ( b − a ) ∫ 0 1 d t e z t t a − 1 ( 1 − t ) b − a − 1 (59) {}_1F_1(a,b,z)=\frac{1}{\Gamma(a)\Gamma(b-a)}\int_0^1dt\,e^{zt}t^{a-1}(1-t)^{b-a-1} \tag*{(59)} 1 F 1 ( a , b , z ) = Γ ( a ) Γ ( b − a ) 1 ∫ 0 1 d t e z t t a − 1 ( 1 − t ) b − a − 1 (59)
where
z = i τ ∞ ( u ) / 2 = i M 2 / 2 V ′ − i u z=\mathrm{i}\tau_\infty(u)/2=\mathrm{i}M^2/2V'-\mathrm{i}u z = i τ ∞ ( u ) /2 = i M 2 /2 V ′ − i u
1 Γ ( a ) Γ ( b − a ) = 1 Γ ( 1 − i m 2 / 2 V ′ ) Γ ( 1 + i m 2 / 2 V ′ ) = 2 V ′ π m 2 sinh ( π m 2 2 V ′ ) ≡ N m (60) \frac{1}{\Gamma(a)\Gamma(b-a)}=\frac{1}{\Gamma(1-\mathrm{i}m^2/2V')\Gamma(1+\mathrm{i}m^2/2V')}=\frac{2V'}{\pi m^2}\sinh\left(\frac{\pi m^2}{2V'}\right)\equiv N_m \tag*{(60)} Γ ( a ) Γ ( b − a ) 1 = Γ ( 1 − i m 2 /2 V ′ ) Γ ( 1 + i m 2 /2 V ′ ) 1 = π m 2 2 V ′ sinh ( 2 V ′ π m 2 ) ≡ N m (60)
ϕ ( ∞ ) ( x B ) = N m ∫ 0 ∞ d u e − i M 2 / 4 V ′ + i u / 2 ∫ 0 1 d t e i t M 2 / 2 V ′ − i t u ( 1 − t t ) i m 2 / 2 V ′ [ e − i ( x B − 1 / 2 ) u − η C e i ( x B − 1 / 2 ) u ] = N m ∫ 0 1 d t e i ( t − 1 / 2 ) M 2 / 2 V ′ ( 1 − t t ) i m 2 / 2 V ′ ∫ 0 ∞ d u [ e i ( 1 − x B − t ) u − η C e i ( x B − t ) u ] (61) \begin{aligned}
\phi^{(\infty)}(x_B)={}&N_m\int_0^\infty du\,e^{-iM^2/4V'+iu/2}\int_0^1dt\,e^{itM^2/2V'-itu}\left(\frac{1-t}{t}\right)^{im^2/2V'}\left[e^{-i(x_B-1/2)u}-\eta_C e^{i(x_B-1/2)u}\right]\\
={}&N_m\int_0^1dt\,e^{i(t-1/2)M^2/2V'}\left(\frac{1-t}{t}\right)^{im^2/2V'}\int_0^\infty du\left[e^{i(1-x_B-t)u}-\eta_C e^{i(x_B-t)u}\right] \tag*{(61)}
\end{aligned} ϕ ( ∞ ) ( x B ) = = N m ∫ 0 ∞ d u e − i M 2 /4 V ′ + i u /2 ∫ 0 1 d t e i t M 2 /2 V ′ − i t u ( t 1 − t ) i m 2 /2 V ′ [ e − i ( x B − 1/2 ) u − η C e i ( x B − 1/2 ) u ] N m ∫ 0 1 d t e i ( t − 1/2 ) M 2 /2 V ′ ( t 1 − t ) i m 2 /2 V ′ ∫ 0 ∞ d u [ e i ( 1 − x B − t ) u − η C e i ( x B − t ) u ] (61)
The integral over u u u is defined by shifting x B → x B − i ϵ x_B\to x_B-i\epsilon x B → x B − i ϵ (x B → x B + i ϵ x_B\to x_B+i\epsilon x B → x B + i ϵ ) in the first (second) term,
ϕ ( ∞ ) ( x B ) = N m ∫ 0 1 d t e i ( t − 1 / 2 ) M 2 / 2 V ′ ( 1 − t t ) i m 2 / 2 V ′ ( i 1 − x B − t + i ϵ − η C i x B − t + i ϵ ) = − η C ϕ ( ∞ ) ( x B ) ∗ (62) \phi^{(\infty)}(x_B)=N_m\int_0^1dt\,e^{i(t-1/2)M^2/2V'}\left(\frac{1-t}{t}\right)^{im^2/2V'}\left(\frac{i}{1-x_B-t+i\epsilon}-\eta_C\frac{i}{x_B-t+i\epsilon}\right)=-\eta_C\phi^{(\infty)}(x_B)^* \tag*{(62)} ϕ ( ∞ ) ( x B ) = N m ∫ 0 1 d t e i ( t − 1/2 ) M 2 /2 V ′ ( t 1 − t ) i m 2 /2 V ′ ( 1 − x B − t + i ϵ i − η C x B − t + i ϵ i ) = − η C ϕ ( ∞ ) ( x B ) ∗ (62)
where − ∞ < x B < ∞ -\infty<x_B<\infty − ∞ < x B < ∞ . The t t t -integral is regular for all x B ≠ 0 x_B\ne0 x B = 0 or 1 1 1 . In the limit of x B → 1 x_B\to1 x B → 1 the behavior of the integral is governed by the phase − log ( t ) m 2 / 2 V ′ -\log(t)m^2/2V' − log ( t ) m 2 /2 V ′ . This gives rise to terms ∝ ( 1 − x B ) ± i m 2 / 2 V ′ \propto(1-x_B)^{\pm im^2/2V'} ∝ ( 1 − x B ) ± i m 2 /2 V ′ , with a finite norm but a logarithmically divergent phase. The same holds for x B → 0 x_B\to0 x B → 0 .
As a numerical illustration I consider the η C = − 1 \eta_C=-1 η C = − 1 ground state with quark mass m = 0.14 V ′ m=0.14\sqrt{V'} m = 0.14 V ′ and bound state mass M = 2.51954 V ′ M=2.51954\sqrt{V'} M = 2.51954 V ′ . The component ϕ 1 ( P = 0 ) ( x ) = ϕ 1 ( 0 ) ( − x ) \phi_1^{(P=0)}(x)=\phi_1^{(0)}(-x) ϕ 1 ( P = 0 ) ( x ) = ϕ 1 ( 0 ) ( − x ) of the rest frame wave function Φ ( 0 ) ( x ) \Phi^{(0)}(x) Φ ( 0 ) ( x ) (27) is shown in Figure 1 (left) as a function of the quark separation x = x q − x q ˉ x=x_q-x_{\bar q} x = x q − x q ˉ . The condition ∂ x ϕ 1 ( 0 ) ( 0 ) = 0 \partial_x\phi_1^{(0)}(0)=0 ∂ x ϕ 1 ( 0 ) ( 0 ) = 0 ensures continuity at x = 0 x=0 x = 0 , while ϕ 1 ( 0 ) ( M / V ′ ) = 0 \phi_1^{(0)}(M/V')=0 ϕ 1 ( 0 ) ( M / V ′ ) = 0 is required for ϕ 2 ( 0 ) ( M / V ′ ) \phi_2^{(0)}(M/V') ϕ 2 ( 0 ) ( M / V ′ ) and ϕ 3 ( 0 ) ( M / V ′ ) \phi_3^{(0)}(M/V') ϕ 3 ( 0 ) ( M / V ′ ) to be finite (33) . These conditions and m m m determine the bound state mass M M M . At large quark separations ϕ 1 ( 0 ) ( ∣ x ∣ → ∞ ) \phi_1^{(0)}(|x|\to\infty) ϕ 1 ( 0 ) ( ∣ x ∣ → ∞ ) oscillates with constant norm according to (9) and (36) [13 , 15 ] .
Figure 1 (right) shows the IMF (P → ∞ P\to\infty P → ∞ ) wave function ϕ ( ∞ ) ( x B ) = ϕ ( ∞ ) ( 1 − x B ) \phi^{(\infty)}(x_B)=\phi^{(\infty)}(1-x_B) ϕ ( ∞ ) ( x B ) = ϕ ( ∞ ) ( 1 − x B ) (62) as a function of the quark momentum fraction x B = q / P x_B=q/P x B = q / P . The quark momentum ranges over − ∞ < q < ∞ -\infty<q<\infty − ∞ < q < ∞ at any P P P (40) , and thus also − ∞ < x B < ∞ -\infty<x_B<\infty − ∞ < x B < ∞ . The deep inelastic scattering (DIS) cross section is described by ∣ ϕ ( ∞ ) ( 0 < x B < 1 ) ∣ 2 |\phi^{(\infty)}(0<x_B<1)|^2 ∣ ϕ ( ∞ ) ( 0 < x B < 1 ) ∣ 2 , with x B x_B x B identified as the Bjorken variable [13 , 15 ] . In analogy to Dirac wave functions the strong potential generates also negative kinetic energy components of ϕ ( ∞ ) ( x B ) \phi^{(\infty)}(x_B) ϕ ( ∞ ) ( x B ) at x B < 0 x_B<0 x B < 0 and x B > 1 x_B>1 x B > 1 (see below).
Energy projection in the IMF
The spinors (41) simplify in the P → ∞ P\to\infty P → ∞ limit. With ϵ q = 1 \epsilon_q=1 ϵ q = 1 (− 1 -1 − 1 ) for q > 0 q>0 q > 0 (q < 0 q<0 q < 0 ),
U + ( ∞ ) ( q ) = 1 2 ( 1 ϵ q ) U − ( ∞ ) ( q ) = 1 2 ( − ϵ q 1 ) V + ( ∞ ) ( q ˉ ) = 1 2 ( ϵ ˉ q ˉ 1 ) V − ( ∞ ) ( q ˉ ) = 1 2 ( 1 − ϵ ˉ q ˉ ) U_+^{(\infty)}(q)=\frac{1}{\sqrt{2}}\begin{pmatrix}1\\ \epsilon_q\end{pmatrix}\qquad U_-^{(\infty)}(q)=\frac{1}{\sqrt{2}}\begin{pmatrix}-\epsilon_q\\ 1\end{pmatrix}\qquad V_+^{(\infty)}(\bar q)=\frac{1}{\sqrt{2}}\begin{pmatrix}\bar\epsilon_{\bar q}\\ 1\end{pmatrix}\qquad V_-^{(\infty)}(\bar q)=\frac{1}{\sqrt{2}}\begin{pmatrix}1\\ -\bar\epsilon_{\bar q}\end{pmatrix} U + ( ∞ ) ( q ) = 2 1 ( 1 ϵ q ) U − ( ∞ ) ( q ) = 2 1 ( − ϵ q 1 ) V + ( ∞ ) ( q ˉ ) = 2 1 ( ϵ ˉ q ˉ 1 ) V − ( ∞ ) ( q ˉ ) = 2 1 ( 1 − ϵ ˉ q ˉ )
U s ( ∞ ) † ( q ) ( 1 + α 1 ) = ( 1 + s ϵ q ) ( 1 1 ) 1 2 ( 1 + α 1 ) V s ˉ ( ∞ ) ( q ˉ ) = 1 2 ( 1 1 ) ( 1 + s ˉ ϵ q ˉ ) (63) U_s^{(\infty)\dagger}(q)(1+\alpha_1)=(1+s\epsilon_q)(1\ \ 1)\frac{1}{\sqrt{2}}\qquad(1+\alpha_1)V_{\bar s}^{(\infty)}(\bar q)=\frac{1}{\sqrt{2}}\begin{pmatrix}1\\ 1\end{pmatrix}(1+\bar s\epsilon_{\bar q}) \tag*{(63)} U s ( ∞ ) † ( q ) ( 1 + α 1 ) = ( 1 + s ϵ q ) ( 1 1 ) 2 1 ( 1 + α 1 ) V s ˉ ( ∞ ) ( q ˉ ) = 2 1 ( 1 1 ) ( 1 + s ˉ ϵ q ˉ ) (63)
The energy projected ( s , s ˉ = ± ) (s,\bar{s}=\pm) ( s , s ˉ = ± ) wave function defined in (43) and (56) becomes, with ϕ s s ′ ( P → ∞ ) ( k ) ≡ ϕ s s ′ ( ∞ ) ( x B ) \phi_{ss'}^{(P\to\infty)}(k)\equiv\phi_{ss'}^{(\infty)}(x_B) ϕ s s ′ ( P → ∞ ) ( k ) ≡ ϕ s s ′ ( ∞ ) ( x B ) ,
ϕ s s ′ ( ∞ ) ( x B ) ≡ 1 2 m U ‾ s ( ∞ ) ( q ) Φ ( ∞ ) ( x B ) V s ′ ( ∞ ) ( q ˉ ) = U s ( ∞ ) † ( p ) ( 1 + α 1 ) V s ′ ( ∞ ) ( p ˉ ) ϕ ( ∞ ) ( x B ) = 1 2 ( 1 + s ε q ) ( 1 + s ˉ ε q ˉ ) ϕ ( ∞ ) ( x B ) (64) \phi_{ss'}^{(\infty)}(x_B)\equiv\frac{1}{2m}\overline{U}_s^{(\infty)}(q)\Phi^{(\infty)}(x_B)V_{s'}^{(\infty)}(\bar{q})=U_s^{(\infty)\dagger}(p)(1+\alpha_1)V_{s'}^{(\infty)}(\bar{p})\phi^{(\infty)}(x_B)=\frac{1}{2}(1+s\varepsilon_q)(1+\bar{s}\varepsilon_{\bar{q}})\phi^{(\infty)}(x_B) \tag*{(64)} ϕ s s ′ ( ∞ ) ( x B ) ≡ 2 m 1 U s ( ∞ ) ( q ) Φ ( ∞ ) ( x B ) V s ′ ( ∞ ) ( q ˉ ) = U s ( ∞ ) † ( p ) ( 1 + α 1 ) V s ′ ( ∞ ) ( p ˉ ) ϕ ( ∞ ) ( x B ) = 2 1 ( 1 + s ε q ) ( 1 + s ˉ ε q ˉ ) ϕ ( ∞ ) ( x B ) (64)
where ε q = ε x B \varepsilon_q=\varepsilon_{x_B} ε q = ε x B since q = x B P q=x_BP q = x B P , and similarly ε q ˉ = ε 1 − x B \varepsilon_{\bar{q}}=\varepsilon_{1-x_B} ε q ˉ = ε 1 − x B . Hence for 0 < x B < 1 0<x_B<1 0 < x B < 1 only ϕ + + ( ∞ ) ( x B ) \phi_{++}^{(\infty)}(x_B) ϕ ++ ( ∞ ) ( x B ) is nonvanishing, while for x B < 0 x_B<0 x B < 0 only ϕ − + ( ∞ ) ( x B ) \phi_{-+}^{(\infty)}(x_B) ϕ −+ ( ∞ ) ( x B ) and for x B > 1 x_B>1 x B > 1 only ϕ + − ( ∞ ) ( x B ) \phi_{+-}^{(\infty)}(x_B) ϕ +− ( ∞ ) ( x B ) are nonzero. The ϕ − − ( ∞ ) ( x B ) \phi_{--}^{(\infty)}(x_B) ϕ −− ( ∞ ) ( x B ) component vanishes for all x B x_B x B in the P → ∞ P\to\infty P → ∞ limit at fixed τ P \tau_P τ P .
On the lhs. of the BSE (53) we may approximate E P = P 2 + M 2 ≃ P + M 2 / 2 P E_P=\sqrt{P^2+M^2}\simeq P+M^2/2P E P = P 2 + M 2 ≃ P + M 2 /2 P , and similarly for E q E_q E q and E q ˉ E_{\bar{q}} E q ˉ ,
( E − s E q − s ˉ E q ˉ ) ϕ s s ′ ( ∞ ) ( x B ) ≃ [ ( 1 − s ∣ x B ∣ − s ˉ ∣ ( 1 − x B ) ∣ ) P + 1 2 P ( M 2 − s m 2 ∣ x B ∣ − s ˉ m 2 ∣ 1 − x B ∣ ) ] ϕ s s ′ ( ∞ ) ( x B ) (65) (E-sE_q-\bar{s}E_{\bar{q}})\phi_{ss'}^{(\infty)}(x_B)\simeq\left[(1-s|x_B|-\bar{s}|(1-x_B)|)P+\frac{1}{2P}\left(M^2-s\frac{m^2}{|x_B|}-\bar{s}\frac{m^2}{|1-x_B|}\right)\right]\phi_{ss'}^{(\infty)}(x_B) \tag*{(65)} ( E − s E q − s ˉ E q ˉ ) ϕ s s ′ ( ∞ ) ( x B ) ≃ [ ( 1 − s ∣ x B ∣ − s ˉ ∣ ( 1 − x B ) ∣ ) P + 2 P 1 ( M 2 − s ∣ x B ∣ m 2 − s ˉ ∣1 − x B ∣ m 2 ) ] ϕ s s ′ ( ∞ ) ( x B ) (65)
The form of ϕ s s ′ ( ∞ ) ( x B ) \phi_{ss'}^{(\infty)}(x_B) ϕ s s ′ ( ∞ ) ( x B ) (64) ensures that the O ( P ) O(P) O ( P ) term vanishes in the P → ∞ P\to\infty P → ∞ limit for all s , s ˉ = ± s,\bar{s}=\pm s , s ˉ = ± . The rhs. of the BSE (53) is, with p = y B P p=y_BP p = y B P , l = ( y B − 1 2 ) P l=(y_B-\frac{1}{2})P l = ( y B − 2 1 ) P and ϕ s s ′ ( P → ∞ ) ( l ) ≡ ϕ s s ′ ( ∞ ) ( y B ) \phi_{ss'}^{(P\to\infty)}(l)\equiv\phi_{ss'}^{(\infty)}(y_B) ϕ s s ′ ( P → ∞ ) ( l ) ≡ ϕ s s ′ ( ∞ ) ( y B ) ,
− V ′ π P ∫ − ∞ ∞ d y B ( y B − x B ) 2 [ ∑ s ′ , s ˉ ′ = ± Θ s s ′ ( ∞ ) ( q , p ) ϕ s ′ s ˉ ′ ( ∞ ) ( y B ) Θ s ˉ ′ s ˉ ( ∞ ) ( p ˉ , q ˉ ) − ϕ s s ′ ( ∞ ) ( x B ) ] (66) -\frac{V'}{\pi P}\int_{-\infty}^{\infty}\frac{dy_B}{(y_B-x_B)^2}\left[\sum_{s',\bar{s}'=\pm}\Theta_{ss'}^{(\infty)}(q,p)\phi_{s'\bar{s}'}^{(\infty)}(y_B)\Theta_{\bar{s}'\bar{s}}^{(\infty)}(\bar{p},\bar{q})-\phi_{ss'}^{(\infty)}(x_B)\right] \tag*{(66)} − π P V ′ ∫ − ∞ ∞ ( y B − x B ) 2 d y B s ′ , s ˉ ′ = ± ∑ Θ s s ′ ( ∞ ) ( q , p ) ϕ s ′ s ˉ ′ ( ∞ ) ( y B ) Θ s ˉ ′ s ˉ ( ∞ ) ( p ˉ , q ˉ ) − ϕ s s ′ ( ∞ ) ( x B ) (66)
The factors Θ s s ′ ( ∞ ) ( q , p ) = U s ( ∞ ) ( q ) U s ′ ( ∞ ) ( p ) \Theta_{ss'}^{(\infty)}(q,p)=U_s^{(\infty)}(q)U_{s'}^{(\infty)}(p) Θ s s ′ ( ∞ ) ( q , p ) = U s ( ∞ ) ( q ) U s ′ ( ∞ ) ( p ) of (52) and (63) in the IMF are,
Θ + + ( ∞ ) ( q , p ) = 1 2 ( 1 + ε q ε p ) Θ + − ( ∞ ) ( q , p ) = 1 2 ( ε q − ε p ) \Theta_{++}^{(\infty)}(q,p)=\frac{1}{2}(1+\varepsilon_q\varepsilon_p)\qquad\Theta_{+-}^{(\infty)}(q,p)=\frac{1}{2}(\varepsilon_q-\varepsilon_p) Θ ++ ( ∞ ) ( q , p ) = 2 1 ( 1 + ε q ε p ) Θ +− ( ∞ ) ( q , p ) = 2 1 ( ε q − ε p )
Θ − + ( ∞ ) ( q , p ) = − Θ + − ( ∞ ) ( q , p ) Θ − − ( ∞ ) ( q , p ) = Θ + + ( ∞ ) ( q , p ) (67) \Theta_{-+}^{(\infty)}(q,p)=-\Theta_{+-}^{(\infty)}(q,p)\qquad\Theta_{--}^{(\infty)}(q,p)=\Theta_{++}^{(\infty)}(q,p) \tag*{(67)} Θ −+ ( ∞ ) ( q , p ) = − Θ +− ( ∞ ) ( q , p ) Θ −− ( ∞ ) ( q , p ) = Θ ++ ( ∞ ) ( q , p ) (67)
For 0 < x B < 1 0<x_B<1 0 < x B < 1 and s = s ˉ = + s=\bar{s}=+ s = s ˉ = + we have in (65) ϕ + + ( ∞ ) ( x B ) = 2 ϕ ( ∞ ) ( x B ) \phi_{++}^{(\infty)}(x_B)=2\phi^{(\infty)}(x_B) ϕ ++ ( ∞ ) ( x B ) = 2 ϕ ( ∞ ) ( x B ) (64) . Since q > 0 q>0 q > 0 and q ˉ > 0 \bar{q}>0 q ˉ > 0 the first term in (66) reduces to 2 ϕ ( ∞ ) ( y B ) 2\phi^{(\infty)}(y_B) 2 ϕ ( ∞ ) ( y B ) for all y B y_B y B ,
∑ s ′ , s ˉ ′ = ± Θ + s ′ ( ∞ ) ( q , p ) ϕ s ′ s ˉ ′ ( ∞ ) ( y B ) Θ s ˉ ′ + ( ∞ ) ( p ˉ , q ˉ ) = { Θ + − ( ∞ ) ( q > 0 , p < 0 ) ϕ − + ( ∞ ) ( y B < 0 ) Θ + + ( ∞ ) ( p ˉ > 0 , q ˉ > 0 ) = 2 ϕ ( ∞ ) ( y B < 0 ) Θ + + ( ∞ ) ( q > 0 , p > 0 ) ϕ + + ( ∞ ) ( 0 < y B < 1 ) Θ + + ( ∞ ) ( p ˉ > 0 , q ˉ > 0 ) = 2 ϕ ( ∞ ) ( 0 < y B < 1 ) Θ + + ( ∞ ) ( q > 0 , p > 0 ) ϕ + − ( ∞ ) ( y B > 1 ) Θ − + ( ∞ ) ( p ˉ < 0 , q ˉ > 0 ) = 2 ϕ ( ∞ ) ( y B > 1 ) (68) \sum_{s',\bar{s}'=\pm}\Theta_{+s'}^{(\infty)}(q,p)\phi_{s'\bar{s}'}^{(\infty)}(y_B)\Theta_{\bar{s}'+}^{(\infty)}(\bar{p},\bar{q})=
\begin{cases}
\Theta_{+-}^{(\infty)}(q>0,p<0)\phi_{-+}^{(\infty)}(y_B<0)\Theta_{++}^{(\infty)}(\bar{p}>0,\bar{q}>0)=2\phi^{(\infty)}(y_B<0)\\
\Theta_{++}^{(\infty)}(q>0,p>0)\phi_{++}^{(\infty)}(0<y_B<1)\Theta_{++}^{(\infty)}(\bar{p}>0,\bar{q}>0)=2\phi^{(\infty)}(0<y_B<1)\\
\Theta_{++}^{(\infty)}(q>0,p>0)\phi_{+-}^{(\infty)}(y_B>1)\Theta_{-+}^{(\infty)}(\bar{p}<0,\bar{q}>0)=2\phi^{(\infty)}(y_B>1)
\end{cases} \tag*{(68)} s ′ , s ˉ ′ = ± ∑ Θ + s ′ ( ∞ ) ( q , p ) ϕ s ′ s ˉ ′ ( ∞ ) ( y B ) Θ s ˉ ′ + ( ∞ ) ( p ˉ , q ˉ ) = ⎩ ⎨ ⎧ Θ +− ( ∞ ) ( q > 0 , p < 0 ) ϕ −+ ( ∞ ) ( y B < 0 ) Θ ++ ( ∞ ) ( p ˉ > 0 , q ˉ > 0 ) = 2 ϕ ( ∞ ) ( y B < 0 ) Θ ++ ( ∞ ) ( q > 0 , p > 0 ) ϕ ++ ( ∞ ) ( 0 < y B < 1 ) Θ ++ ( ∞ ) ( p ˉ > 0 , q ˉ > 0 ) = 2 ϕ ( ∞ ) ( 0 < y B < 1 ) Θ ++ ( ∞ ) ( q > 0 , p > 0 ) ϕ +− ( ∞ ) ( y B > 1 ) Θ −+ ( ∞ ) ( p ˉ < 0 , q ˉ > 0 ) = 2 ϕ ( ∞ ) ( y B > 1 ) (68)
Consequently the BSE for the IMF wave function ϕ ( ∞ ) ( x B ) \phi^{(\infty)}(x_B) ϕ ( ∞ ) ( x B ) of (62) is, for 0 < x B < 1 0<x_B<1 0 < x B < 1 and s = s ˉ = + s=\bar{s}=+ s = s ˉ = + ,
( M 2 − m 2 x B − m 2 1 − x B ) ϕ ( ∞ ) ( x B ) = − 2 V ′ π ∫ − ∞ ∞ d y B ( y B − x B ) 2 [ ϕ ( ∞ ) ( y B ) − ϕ ( ∞ ) ( x B ) ] (69) \left(M^2-\frac{m^2}{x_B}-\frac{m^2}{1-x_B}\right)\phi^{(\infty)}(x_B)=-\frac{2V'}{\pi}\int_{-\infty}^{\infty}\frac{dy_B}{(y_B-x_B)^2}\left[\phi^{(\infty)}(y_B)-\phi^{(\infty)}(x_B)\right] \tag*{(69)} ( M 2 − x B m 2 − 1 − x B m 2 ) ϕ ( ∞ ) ( x B ) = − π 2 V ′ ∫ − ∞ ∞ ( y B − x B ) 2 d y B [ ϕ ( ∞ ) ( y B ) − ϕ ( ∞ ) ( x B ) ] (69)
where V ′ = 1 2 g 2 C F V'=\frac{1}{2}g^2C_F V ′ = 2 1 g 2 C F . This may be compared with Eq. (25) of ’t Hooft [1 ] , which multiplied with g 2 / π g^2/\pi g 2 / π reads
( M 2 − m 2 x − m 2 1 − x ) ϕ ( x ) = − g 2 π ( 1 x + 1 1 − x ) ϕ ( x ) − g 2 π ∫ 0 1 ϕ ( y ) ( y − x ) 2 d y = − g 2 π ∫ 0 1 ϕ ( y ) − ϕ ( x ) ( y − x ) 2 d y (70) \left(M^2-\frac{m^2}{x}-\frac{m^2}{1-x}\right)\phi(x)=-\frac{g^2}{\pi}\left(\frac{1}{x}+\frac{1}{1-x}\right)\phi(x)-\frac{g^2}{\pi}\int_0^1\frac{\phi(y)}{(y-x)^2}\,dy=-\frac{g^2}{\pi}\int_0^1\frac{\phi(y)-\phi(x)}{(y-x)^2}\,dy \tag*{(70)} ( M 2 − x m 2 − 1 − x m 2 ) ϕ ( x ) = − π g 2 ( x 1 + 1 − x 1 ) ϕ ( x ) − π g 2 ∫ 0 1 ( y − x ) 2 ϕ ( y ) d y = − π g 2 ∫ 0 1 ( y − x ) 2 ϕ ( y ) − ϕ ( x ) d y (70)
The quark propagator corrections, which give rise to the terms − ( g 2 / π ) [ 1 / x + 1 / ( 1 − x ) ] ϕ ( x ) -(g^2/\pi)[1/x+1/(1-x)]\phi(x) − ( g 2 / π ) [ 1/ x + 1/ ( 1 − x )] ϕ ( x ) in (70) , decrease the singularity of the integral at y = x y=x y = x . There are no quark propagators in present approach, where the less singular form of the integral is a consequence of the Fourier transform (49) . Identifying ’t Hooft’s coupling g 2 → g 2 C F = 2 V ′ g^2\to g^2C_F=2V' g 2 → g 2 C F = 2 V ′ , x → x B x\to x_B x → x B and y → y B y\to y_B y → y B (70) agrees with (69) , except that the negative energy components ϕ − + ( ∞ ) ( y B < 0 ) \phi_{-+}^{(\infty)}(y_B<0) ϕ −+ ( ∞ ) ( y B < 0 ) and ϕ + − ( ∞ ) ( y B > 1 ) \phi_{+-}^{(\infty)}(y_B>1) ϕ +− ( ∞ ) ( y B > 1 ) extend the integration over y B y_B y B from [ 0 , 1 ] [0,1] [ 0 , 1 ] to [ − ∞ , ∞ ] [-\infty,\infty] [ − ∞ , ∞ ] .
The BSE (69) actually holds for all x B ≠ 0 , 1 x_B\ne0,1 x B = 0 , 1 , i.e., − ∞ < x B < ∞ -\infty<x_B<\infty − ∞ < x B < ∞ . For x B < 0 x_B<0 x B < 0 , s = − s=- s = − , s ˉ = + \bar{s}=+ s ˉ = + ,
∑ s ′ , s ˉ ′ = ± Θ − s ′ ( ∞ ) ( q , p ) ϕ s ′ s ˉ ′ ( ∞ ) ( y B ) Θ s ˉ ′ + ( ∞ ) ( p ˉ , q ˉ ) = { Θ − − ( ∞ ) ( q < 0 , p < 0 ) ϕ − + ( ∞ ) ( y B < 0 ) Θ + + ( ∞ ) ( p ˉ > 0 , q ˉ > 0 ) = 2 ϕ ( ∞ ) ( y B < 0 ) Θ − + ( ∞ ) ( q < 0 , p > 0 ) ϕ + + ( ∞ ) ( 0 < y B < 1 ) Θ + + ( ∞ ) ( p ˉ > 0 , q ˉ > 0 ) = 2 ϕ ( ∞ ) ( 0 < y B < 1 ) Θ − + ( ∞ ) ( q < 0 , p > 0 ) ϕ + − ( ∞ ) ( y B > 1 ) Θ − + ( ∞ ) ( p ˉ < 0 , q ˉ > 0 ) = 2 ϕ ( ∞ ) ( y B > 1 ) (71) \sum_{s',\bar{s}'=\pm}\Theta_{-s'}^{(\infty)}(q,p)\phi_{s'\bar{s}'}^{(\infty)}(y_B)\Theta_{\bar{s}'+}^{(\infty)}(\bar{p},\bar{q})=
\begin{cases}
\Theta_{--}^{(\infty)}(q<0,p<0)\phi_{-+}^{(\infty)}(y_B<0)\Theta_{++}^{(\infty)}(\bar{p}>0,\bar{q}>0)=2\phi^{(\infty)}(y_B<0)\\
\Theta_{-+}^{(\infty)}(q<0,p>0)\phi_{++}^{(\infty)}(0<y_B<1)\Theta_{++}^{(\infty)}(\bar{p}>0,\bar{q}>0)=2\phi^{(\infty)}(0<y_B<1)\\
\Theta_{-+}^{(\infty)}(q<0,p>0)\phi_{+-}^{(\infty)}(y_B>1)\Theta_{-+}^{(\infty)}(\bar{p}<0,\bar{q}>0)=2\phi^{(\infty)}(y_B>1)
\end{cases} \tag*{(71)} s ′ , s ˉ ′ = ± ∑ Θ − s ′ ( ∞ ) ( q , p ) ϕ s ′ s ˉ ′ ( ∞ ) ( y B ) Θ s ˉ ′ + ( ∞ ) ( p ˉ , q ˉ ) = ⎩ ⎨ ⎧ Θ −− ( ∞ ) ( q < 0 , p < 0 ) ϕ −+ ( ∞ ) ( y B < 0 ) Θ ++ ( ∞ ) ( p ˉ > 0 , q ˉ > 0 ) = 2 ϕ ( ∞ ) ( y B < 0 ) Θ −+ ( ∞ ) ( q < 0 , p > 0 ) ϕ ++ ( ∞ ) ( 0 < y B < 1 ) Θ ++ ( ∞ ) ( p ˉ > 0 , q ˉ > 0 ) = 2 ϕ ( ∞ ) ( 0 < y B < 1 ) Θ −+ ( ∞ ) ( q < 0 , p > 0 ) ϕ +− ( ∞ ) ( y B > 1 ) Θ −+ ( ∞ ) ( p ˉ < 0 , q ˉ > 0 ) = 2 ϕ ( ∞ ) ( y B > 1 ) (71)
Due to the symmetry ϕ ( ∞ ) ( x B ) = − η C ϕ ( ∞ ) ( 1 − x B ) \phi^{(\infty)}(x_B)=-\eta_C\phi^{(\infty)}(1-x_B) ϕ ( ∞ ) ( x B ) = − η C ϕ ( ∞ ) ( 1 − x B ) (58) the BSE (69) is unchanged when x B → 1 − x B x_B\to1-x_B x B → 1 − x B . The singularity of the rhs. as x B → 1 x_B\to1 x B → 1 is matched by a singularity on the lhs., since lim ϵ → 0 ϕ ( ∞ ) ( y B = 1 + ϵ ) ≠ lim ϵ → 0 ϕ ( ∞ ) ( y B = 1 + ϵ ) \lim_{\epsilon\to0}\phi^{(\infty)}(y_B=1+\epsilon)\ne\lim_{\epsilon\to0}\phi^{(\infty)}(y_B=1+\epsilon) lim ϵ → 0 ϕ ( ∞ ) ( y B = 1 + ϵ ) = lim ϵ → 0 ϕ ( ∞ ) ( y B = 1 + ϵ ) . Table 1 demonstrates the validity of the BSE for the η C = − 1 \eta_C=-1 η C = − 1 ground state of Figure 1 .
Table 1. Numerical results for the BSE (69) at various values of x B x_B x B , for the bound state of Figure 1 . The second to fourth columns show the contributions to the right hand side from the indicated integration ranges over y B y_B y B . The full result for the rhs (fifth column) agrees with the lhs of (69) (last column).
Using the temporal gauge constraint to determine E a E_a E a
Reproducing the linear potential
The eigenvalue condition H ∣ M , P ⟩ = E ∣ M , P ⟩ H \lvert M,P\rangle= E \lvert M,P\rangle H ∣ M , P ⟩ = E ∣ M , P ⟩ for the states ∣ M , P ⟩ \lvert M,P\rangle ∣ M , P ⟩ (6) of momentum P P P ,
∣ M , P ⟩ = ∫ d x q d x q ˉ ψ ˉ ( x q ) P exp [ i g ∫ x q ˉ x q d x A a ( x ) T a ] exp [ i P ( x q + x q ˉ ) / 2 ] Φ ( P ) ( x q − x q ˉ ) ψ ( x q ˉ ) ∣ 0 ⟩ (72) \lvert M,P\rangle= \int dx_q dx_{\bar q}\,\bar{\psi}(x_q)P \exp\left[ig\int_{x_{\bar q}}^{x_q} dx\,A_a(x)T_a\right]\exp\left[iP(x_q+x_{\bar q})/2\right]\Phi^{(P)}(x_q-x_{\bar q})\psi(x_{\bar q})\lvert0\rangle \tag*{(72)} ∣ M , P ⟩ = ∫ d x q d x q ˉ ψ ˉ ( x q ) P exp [ i g ∫ x q ˉ x q d x A a ( x ) T a ] exp [ i P ( x q + x q ˉ ) /2 ] Φ ( P ) ( x q − x q ˉ ) ψ ( x q ˉ ) ∣ 0 ⟩ (72)
determines the BSE (22) for the wave function Φ ( P ) ( x q − x q ˉ ) \Phi^{(P)}(x_q-x_{\bar q}) Φ ( P ) ( x q − x q ˉ ) . In Section II C the Hamiltonian P ^ 0 = H \hat{P}^{0}=H P ^ 0 = H (14) was determined canonically from the QCD2 _2 2 action in temporal (A 0 = 0 A^{0}=0 A 0 = 0 ) gauge,
H = ∫ d x [ 1 2 ( E a ) 2 + ψ † ( − i α 1 ∂ → x + γ 0 m − g A a T a α 1 ) ψ ] (73) H=\int dx\left[\frac{1}{2}(E_a)^2+\psi^\dagger\left(-i\alpha^1\overrightarrow{\partial}_x+\gamma^0m-gA_aT^a\alpha^1\right)\psi\right] \tag*{(73)} H = ∫ d x [ 2 1 ( E a ) 2 + ψ † ( − i α 1 ∂ x + γ 0 m − g A a T a α 1 ) ψ ] (73)
Physical states are required to be invariant under time-independent gauge transformations, which preserve A 0 = 0 A^{0}=0 A 0 = 0 . Those transformations are generated by Gauss’ operator (4) ,
G a ( t , x ) ≡ δ S Q C D δ A a 0 ( t , x ) = ∂ x E a ( t , x ) + g f a b c A b E c ( t , x ) − g ψ † T a ψ ( t , x ) (74) G_a(t,x)\equiv\frac{\delta S_{\mathrm{QCD}}}{\delta A^0_a(t,x)}=\partial_x E_a(t,x)+gf_{abc}A_bE_c(t,x)-g\psi^\dagger T^a\psi(t,x) \tag*{(74)} G a ( t , x ) ≡ δ A a 0 ( t , x ) δ S QCD = ∂ x E a ( t , x ) + g f ab c A b E c ( t , x ) − g ψ † T a ψ ( t , x ) (74)
In Sec. II A and Appendix A I verified that G a ( x ) ∣ M , P ⟩ = 0 G_a(x)\lvert M,P\rangle=0 G a ( x ) ∣ M , P ⟩ = 0 . Hence
∂ x E a ( x ) ∣ M , P ⟩ = g [ − f a b c A b E c ( x ) + ψ † T a ψ ( x ) ] ∣ M , P ⟩ ≡ g E a ( x ) ∣ M , P ⟩ (75) \partial_xE_a(x)\lvert M,P\rangle=g\left[-f_{abc}A_bE_c(x)+\psi^\dagger T^a\psi(x)\right]\lvert M,P\rangle\equiv g\mathcal{E}_a(x)\lvert M,P\rangle \tag*{(75)} ∂ x E a ( x ) ∣ M , P ⟩ = g [ − f ab c A b E c ( x ) + ψ † T a ψ ( x ) ] ∣ M , P ⟩ ≡ g E a ( x ) ∣ M , P ⟩ (75)
Viewed as a differential equation for E a ( x ) E_a(x) E a ( x ) this provides an alternative expression for the E a 2 E_a^2 E a 2 contribution to H H H . Recalling that ∂ x 2 ∣ x − y ∣ = 2 δ ( x − y ) \partial_x^2\lvert x-y\rvert=2\delta(x-y) ∂ x 2 ∣ x − y ∣ = 2 δ ( x − y ) we may solve for E a ( x ) E_a(x) E a ( x ) ,
E a ( x ) = 1 2 g ∂ x ∫ d y ∣ x − y ∣ E a ( y ) (76) E_a(x)=\frac{1}{2}g\partial_x\int dy\,\lvert x-y\rvert\,\mathcal{E}_a(y) \tag*{(76)} E a ( x ) = 2 1 g ∂ x ∫ d y ∣ x − y ∣ E a ( y ) (76)
The contribution of the color electric field to the Hamiltonian H H H (73) is thus
H V ≡ 1 2 ∫ d x E a 2 ( x ) = g 2 8 ∫ d x [ ∂ x ∫ d y ∣ x − y ∣ E a ( y ) ] [ ∂ x ∫ d z ∣ x − z ∣ E a ( z ) ] = − g 2 4 ∫ d y d z ∣ y − z ∣ E a ( y ) E a ( z ) (77) \begin{aligned}
H_V&\equiv\frac{1}{2}\int dx\,E_a^2(x)=\frac{g^2}{8}\int dx\left[\partial_x\int dy\,\lvert x-y\rvert\,\mathcal{E}_a(y)\right]\left[\partial_x\int dz\,\lvert x-z\rvert\,\mathcal{E}_a(z)\right]\\
&=-\frac{g^2}{4}\int dy\,dz\,\lvert y-z\rvert\,\mathcal{E}_a(y)\mathcal{E}_a(z) \tag*{(77)}
\end{aligned} H V ≡ 2 1 ∫ d x E a 2 ( x ) = 8 g 2 ∫ d x [ ∂ x ∫ d y ∣ x − y ∣ E a ( y ) ] [ ∂ x ∫ d z ∣ x − z ∣ E a ( z ) ] = − 4 g 2 ∫ d y d z ∣ y − z ∣ E a ( y ) E a ( z ) (77)
The fermion part ψ † T a ψ ( x ) \psi^\dagger T^a\psi(x) ψ † T a ψ ( x ) of E a ( x ) \mathcal{E}_a(x) E a ( x ) acting on the quark fields in ∣ M , P ⟩ \lvert M,P\rangle ∣ M , P ⟩ (72) gives,
[ E a ( x ) , ψ ˉ A ( x q ) ] = ψ ˉ A ′ ( x q ) T A ′ A a δ ( x − x q ) [ E a ( x ) , ψ A ( x q ˉ ) ] = − T A A ′ a ψ A ′ ( x q ˉ ) δ ( x − x q ˉ ) (78) \left[\mathcal{E}_a(x),\bar{\psi}_A(x_q)\right]=\bar{\psi}_{A'}(x_q)T^a_{A'A}\delta(x-x_q)\qquad\left[\mathcal{E}_a(x),\psi_A(x_{\bar q})\right]=-T^a_{AA'}\psi_{A'}(x_{\bar q})\delta(x-x_{\bar q}) \tag*{(78)} [ E a ( x ) , ψ ˉ A ( x q ) ] = ψ ˉ A ′ ( x q ) T A ′ A a δ ( x − x q ) [ E a ( x ) , ψ A ( x q ˉ ) ] = − T A A ′ a ψ A ′ ( x q ˉ ) δ ( x − x q ˉ ) (78)
The − f a b c A b E c ( x ) -f_{abc}A_bE_c(x) − f ab c A b E c ( x ) term in E a ( x ) \mathcal{E}_a(x) E a ( x ) (75) operating on the gauge link in ∣ M , P ⟩ |M,P\rangle ∣ M , P ⟩ is suppressed by O ( g ) O(g) O ( g ) compared to the fermion contribution. Ignoring the gauge link contribution we have for a (globally) color singlet q q ˉ q\bar{q} q q ˉ state,
∣ q ( x q ) q ˉ ( x q ˉ ) ⟩ ≡ ∑ A ψ ˉ A α ( x q ) ψ A β ( x q ˉ ) ∣ 0 ⟩ (79) |q(x_q)\bar{q}(x_{\bar q})\rangle\equiv\sum_A \bar{\psi}^{\alpha}_A(x_q)\psi^\beta_A(x_{\bar q})|0\rangle \tag*{(79)} ∣ q ( x q ) q ˉ ( x q ˉ )⟩ ≡ A ∑ ψ ˉ A α ( x q ) ψ A β ( x q ˉ ) ∣0 ⟩ (79)
H V ∣ q ( x q ) q ˉ ( x q ˉ ) ⟩ = 1 2 g 2 ∣ x q − x q ˉ ∣ ψ ˉ ( x q ) T a T a ψ ( x q ˉ ) ∣ 0 ⟩ = 1 2 g 2 C F ∣ x q − x q ˉ ∣ ∣ q ( x q ) q ˉ ( x q ˉ ) ⟩ = V ( x q − x q ˉ ) ∣ q ( x q ) q ˉ ( x q ˉ ) ⟩ H_V|q(x_q)\bar{q}(x_{\bar q})\rangle= \frac{1}{2}g^2|x_q-x_{\bar q}|\bar{\psi}(x_q)T^aT^a\psi(x_{\bar q})|0\rangle= \frac{1}{2}g^2C_F|x_q-x_{\bar q}||q(x_q)\bar{q}(x_{\bar q})\rangle= V(x_q-x_{\bar q})|q(x_q)\bar{q}(x_{\bar q})\rangle H V ∣ q ( x q ) q ˉ ( x q ˉ )⟩ = 2 1 g 2 ∣ x q − x q ˉ ∣ ψ ˉ ( x q ) T a T a ψ ( x q ˉ ) ∣0 ⟩ = 2 1 g 2 C F ∣ x q − x q ˉ ∣∣ q ( x q ) q ˉ ( x q ˉ )⟩ = V ( x q − x q ˉ ) ∣ q ( x q ) q ˉ ( x q ˉ )⟩
The potential V ( x ) = 1 2 g 2 C F ∣ x ∣ V(x)=\frac{1}{2}g^2C_F|x| V ( x ) = 2 1 g 2 C F ∣ x ∣ agrees with that previously obtained in (19) , where it arose from the commutator of E a 2 E_a^2 E a 2 with the gauge link in ∣ M , P ⟩ |M,P\rangle ∣ M , P ⟩ .
Adding a homogeneous solution to E a E_a E a
The electric fields generated by QED and QCD bound states differ in an important respect. The electric field E ( x ) E(x) E ( x ) of QED2 _2 2 is given by (76) without a gauge boson or color matrix T a T^a T a contribution,
E ( x ) = 1 2 e ∂ x ∫ d y ∣ x − y ∣ ψ e † ( y ) ψ e ( y ) = 1 2 e ∫ d y ϵ ( x − y ) ψ e † ( y ) ψ e ( y ) (80) E(x)=\frac{1}{2}e\partial_x\int dy|x-y|\psi_e^\dagger(y)\psi_e(y)=\frac{1}{2}e\int dy\,\epsilon(x-y)\psi_e^\dagger(y)\psi_e(y) \tag*{(80)} E ( x ) = 2 1 e ∂ x ∫ d y ∣ x − y ∣ ψ e † ( y ) ψ e ( y ) = 2 1 e ∫ d y ϵ ( x − y ) ψ e † ( y ) ψ e ( y ) (80)
where ϵ ( x ) = 1 \epsilon(x)=1 ϵ ( x ) = 1 (− 1 -1 − 1 ) for x > 1 x>1 x > 1 (x < 1 x<1 x < 1 ). The electric field of an e − e + e^-e^+ e − e + state ∣ e − ( x e ) e + ( x e ˉ ) ⟩ ≡ ψ ˉ e α ( x e ) ψ e β ( x e ˉ ) ∣ 0 ⟩ |e^-(x_e)e^+(x_{\bar e})\rangle\equiv\bar{\psi}^{\alpha}_e(x_e)\psi^\beta_e(x_{\bar e})|0\rangle ∣ e − ( x e ) e + ( x e ˉ )⟩ ≡ ψ ˉ e α ( x e ) ψ e β ( x e ˉ ) ∣0 ⟩ is
E ( x ) ∣ e − ( x e ) e + ( x e ˉ ) ⟩ = 1 2 e [ ϵ ( x − x e ) − ϵ ( x − x e ˉ ) ] ∣ e − ( x e ) e + ( x e ˉ ) ⟩ (81) E(x)|e^-(x_e)e^+(x_{\bar e})\rangle=\frac{1}{2}e[\epsilon(x-x_e)-\epsilon(x-x_{\bar e})]|e^-(x_e)e^+(x_{\bar e})\rangle \tag*{(81)} E ( x ) ∣ e − ( x e ) e + ( x e ˉ )⟩ = 2 1 e [ ϵ ( x − x e ) − ϵ ( x − x e ˉ )] ∣ e − ( x e ) e + ( x e ˉ )⟩ (81)
The field is nonvanishing only between the charges. For x e > x e ˉ x_e>x_{\bar e} x e > x e ˉ ,
⟨ e − ( x e ) e + ( x e ˉ ) ∣ E ( x ) ∣ e − ( x e ) e + ( x e ˉ ) ⟩ ⟨ e − ( x e ) e + ( x e ˉ ) ∣ e − ( x e ) e + ( x e ˉ ) ⟩ = { − e ( x e ˉ < x < x e ) 0 otherwise (82) \frac{\langle e^-(x_e)e^+(x_{\bar e})|E(x)|e^-(x_e)e^+(x_{\bar e})\rangle}{\langle e^-(x_e)e^+(x_{\bar e})|e^-(x_e)e^+(x_{\bar e})\rangle}=
\begin{cases}
-e & (x_{\bar e}<x<x_e)\\
0 & \text{otherwise}
\end{cases} \tag*{(82)} ⟨ e − ( x e ) e + ( x e ˉ ) ∣ e − ( x e ) e + ( x e ˉ )⟩ ⟨ e − ( x e ) e + ( x e ˉ ) ∣ E ( x ) ∣ e − ( x e ) e + ( x e ˉ )⟩ = { − e 0 ( x e ˉ < x < x e ) otherwise (82)
In QCD we have instead, from (76) and (78) ,
⟨ q ( x q ) q ˉ ( x q ˉ ) ∣ E a ( x ) ∣ q ( x q ) q ˉ ( x q ˉ ) ⟩ ∝ Tr T a = 0 for all x (83) \langle q(x_q)\bar{q}(x_{\bar q})|E_a(x)|q(x_q)\bar{q}(x_{\bar q})\rangle\propto\operatorname{Tr}T^a=0 \qquad\text{for all }x \tag*{(83)} ⟨ q ( x q ) q ˉ ( x q ˉ ) ∣ E a ( x ) ∣ q ( x q ) q ˉ ( x q ˉ )⟩ ∝ Tr T a = 0 for all x (83)
External observers see a vanishing color field due to the sum over quark colors. Equivalently, a color singlet state does not give rise to a color octet field. However, there is no sum over colors in the binding of a meson’s q q ˉ q\bar q q q ˉ constituents. A red quark feels the color octet field generated by its anti-red anti-quark companion in the Fock state, and vice versa.
In D = 3 + 1 D=3+1 D = 3 + 1 dimensions Gauss’ law determines the (dipole) electric field of an e + e − e^+e^- e + e − state. The solution is unique for fields that vanish at large distances, which is required to avoid long range interactions in QED. For color singlet q q ˉ q\bar q q q ˉ states there is no such requirement, since the state does not generate a color octet field at any x x x .
This motivates adding a homogeneous solution to (76) , for which ∂ x E a ( x ) = 0 \partial_xE_a(x)=0 ∂ x E a ( x ) = 0 ,
E a ( x ) = ∂ x ∫ d y [ − κ x y + 1 2 g ∣ x − y ∣ ] E a ( y ) (84) E_a(x)=\partial_x\int dy\left[-\kappa xy+\frac{1}{2}g|x-y|\right]E_a(y) \tag*{(84)} E a ( x ) = ∂ x ∫ d y [ − κ x y + 2 1 g ∣ x − y ∣ ] E a ( y ) (84)
The normalization κ \kappa κ may depend on the state ∣ M , P ⟩ |M,P\rangle ∣ M , P ⟩ that E a ( x ) E_a(x) E a ( x ) acts on. Linearity in x x x ensures that the homogeneous (sourceless) part of E a ( x ) E_a(x) E a ( x ) is independent of x x x . Linearity in y y y ensures translation invariance for color singlet states. After partial integrations H V = 1 2 ∫ d x E a 2 ( x ) H_V=\frac{1}{2}\int dx\,E_a^2(x) H V = 2 1 ∫ d x E a 2 ( x ) becomes
H V = ∫ d y d z [ y z ( 1 2 κ 2 ∫ d x + g κ ) − 1 4 g 2 ∣ y − z ∣ ] E a ( y ) E a ( z ) (85) H_V=\int dy\,dz\left[yz\left(\frac{1}{2}\kappa^2\int dx+g\kappa\right)-\frac{1}{4}g^2|y-z|\right]E_a(y)E_a(z) \tag*{(85)} H V = ∫ d y d z [ y z ( 2 1 κ 2 ∫ d x + g κ ) − 4 1 g 2 ∣ y − z ∣ ] E a ( y ) E a ( z ) (85)
Acting on the state in (79) gives
H V ∣ q ( x q ) q ˉ ( x q ˉ ) ⟩ = [ ( 1 2 κ 2 ∫ d x + g κ ) C F ( x q − x q ˉ ) 2 + 1 2 g 2 C F ∣ x q − x q ˉ ∣ ] ∣ q ( x q ) q ˉ ( x q ˉ ) ⟩ (86) H_V|q(x_q)\bar{q}(x_{\bar q})\rangle=\left[\left(\frac{1}{2}\kappa^2\int dx+g\kappa\right)C_F(x_q-x_{\bar q})^2+\frac{1}{2}g^2C_F|x_q-x_{\bar q}|\right]|q(x_q)\bar{q}(x_{\bar q})\rangle \tag*{(86)} H V ∣ q ( x q ) q ˉ ( x q ˉ )⟩ = [ ( 2 1 κ 2 ∫ d x + g κ ) C F ( x q − x q ˉ ) 2 + 2 1 g 2 C F ∣ x q − x q ˉ ∣ ] ∣ q ( x q ) q ˉ ( x q ˉ )⟩ (86)
The coefficient of κ 2 \kappa^2 κ 2 is proportional to the volume of space: the homogeneous contribution has introduced an isotropic vacuum field energy density E Λ E_\Lambda E Λ . This energy is irrelevant provided it is universal, i . e . i.e. i . e . , the same for all states. Consequently we must take κ 2 \kappa^2 κ 2 to be inversely proportional to ( x q − x q ˉ ) 2 (x_q-x_{\bar q})^2 ( x q − x q ˉ ) 2 . Defining the universal constant Λ \Lambda Λ by
κ ≡ Λ 2 g C F 1 ∣ x q − x q ˉ ∣ E Λ = Λ 4 2 g 2 C F (87) \kappa\equiv\frac{\Lambda^2}{gC_F}\frac{1}{|x_q-x_{\bar q}|}
\qquad
E_\Lambda=\frac{\Lambda^4}{2g^2C_F} \tag*{(87)} κ ≡ g C F Λ 2 ∣ x q − x q ˉ ∣ 1 E Λ = 2 g 2 C F Λ 4 (87)
gives, after subtracting the (infinite but universal) vacuum energy E Λ ∫ d x E_{\Lambda}\int dx E Λ ∫ d x ,
H V ∣ q ( x q ) q ˉ ( x q ˉ ) ⟩ = ( Λ 2 + 1 2 g 2 C F ) ∣ x q − x q ˉ ∣ ∣ q ( x q ) q ˉ ( x q ˉ ) ⟩ (88) H_{V}\lvert q(x_{q})\bar{q}(x_{\bar{q}})\rangle= \left(\Lambda^{2}+\frac{1}{2}g^{2}C_{F}\right)\lvert x_{q}-x_{\bar{q}}\rvert\lvert q(x_{q})\bar{q}(x_{\bar{q}})\rangle \tag*{(88)} H V ∣ q ( x q ) q ˉ ( x q ˉ )⟩ = ( Λ 2 + 2 1 g 2 C F ) ∣ x q − x q ˉ ∣ ∣ q ( x q ) q ˉ ( x q ˉ )⟩ (88)
Inclusion of the homogeneous solution to E a ( x ) E_{a}(x) E a ( x ) (84) added Λ 2 \Lambda^{2} Λ 2 to the slope V ′ V' V ′ of the linear potential.
The possibility to include a homogeneous solution is potentially interesting in D = 3 + 1 D=3+1 D = 3 + 1 dimensions. It adds a linear term V ′ ∣ x ∣ V'|x| V ′ ∣ x ∣ to the − α s C F / ∣ x ∣ -\alpha_{s}C_{F}/|x| − α s C F /∣ x ∣ Coulomb q q ˉ q\bar{q} q q ˉ potential, with V ′ V' V ′ related (as above) to the energy density of the vacuum. The corresponding potentials for color singlet q q q qqq q q q , g g gg g g and q q ˉ g q\bar{q}g q q ˉ g Fock states are also confining, and are correctly related to each other when the coordinates of two constituents coincide [13 ] .
Discussion
Color confinement is a central feature of hadron dynamics. Numerical (lattice) calculations have determined that the hadron spectrum of QCD agrees with data [19 ] , whereas analytic methods remain elusive. Confinement has not been demonstrated using the formally exact Bethe-Salpeter [11 ] approach to bound states. QCD2 _{2} 2 may provide insights since the Coulomb potential is confining in D = 1 + 1 D=1+1 D = 1 + 1 dimensions. ’t Hooft found [1 ] that the Bethe-Salpeter equation of QCD2 _{2} 2 can be solved exactly in the N c → ∞ N_{c}\to\infty N c → ∞ limit, which inspired many further studies.
The present study of the ’t Hooft model does not use the Bethe-Salpeter approach. This avoids quark propagators, which were found to be singular and to lack Lorentz covariance [4 ] . Instead, I directly determine the color singlet ∣ q q ˉ ⟩ \lvert q\bar{q}\rangle ∣ q q ˉ ⟩ eigenstates (6) of the QCD2 _{2} 2 Hamiltonian (14) . Poincaré covariance emerges in an explicit, yet nontrivial way for these equal-time states. The ’t Hooft equation (70) is reproduced (69) with a surprising twist: The wave function ϕ ( ∞ ) ( x B ) \phi^{(\infty)}(x_{B}) ϕ ( ∞ ) ( x B ) (62) has negative energy components even in the IMF. Hence ϕ ( ∞ ) ( x B ) \phi^{(\infty)}(x_{B}) ϕ ( ∞ ) ( x B ) does not vanish for x B → 0 , 1 x_{B}\to0,1 x B → 0 , 1 as postulated by ’t Hooft (Figure 1 , right).
Negative energy solutions are familiar from the Dirac equation, but it may seem surprising that they survive in the IMF. Due to Lorentz contraction the potential is of O ( 1 / P ) O(1/P) O ( 1/ P ) while the kinetic energies are of O ( P ) O(P) O ( P ) . However, the kinetic energy contributions to the BSE cancel at O ( P ) O(P) O ( P ) (65) , leaving only O ( 1 / P ) O(1/P) O ( 1/ P ) terms in the ’t Hooft equation. A bound state constituent with negative kinetic energy in the rest frame is boosted to a large negative energy in the IMF. This allows the energy and momentum x B P x_{B}P x B P of a quark to be balanced by that of an antiquark with ( 1 − x B ) P (1-x_{B})P ( 1 − x B ) P even if x B > 1 x_{B}>1 x B > 1 .
The q q ˉ q\bar{q} q q ˉ wave function (37) oscillates ∝ exp ( i V ′ x 2 / 4 ) \propto\exp(iV'x^{2}/4) ∝ exp ( i V ′ x 2 /4 ) at large values of the variable x P ( x ) = M 2 / V ′ − 2 E P ∣ x ∣ + V ′ x 2 x_{P}(x)=M^{2}/V'-2E_{P}|x|+V'x^{2} x P ( x ) = M 2 / V ′ − 2 E P ∣ x ∣ + V ′ x 2 (9) , and is thus not globally normalizable. There is a nonvanishing overlap ⟨ B C ∣ A ⟩ \langle B C|A\rangle ⟨ B C ∣ A ⟩ between bound states A A A , B B B and C C C , due to q q ˉ q\bar{q} q q ˉ production in the binding potential, with features expected of “string breaking”. When E A = E B + E C E_{A}=E_{B}+E_{C} E A = E B + E C this allows the decay A → B + C A\to B+C A → B + C , giving the bound states finite widths of O ( g 2 N c ) O(g^{2}N_{c}) O ( g 2 N c ) . It has previously been assumed that decays are due to the interaction term of O ( g ) O(g) O ( g ) , implying zero widths at leading order in N c → ∞ N_{c}\to\infty N c → ∞ [3 ] . For E A ≪ E B + E C E_{A}\ll E_{B}+E_{C} E A ≪ E B + E C on the other hand the rapid oscillations of the wave function should suppress contributions to physical processes. Further study is required to establish whether these features can give an explanation of the duality observed in data on hadron dynamics [18 ] .
The present bound state method suggests a mechanism for confinement in D = 3 + 1 D=3+1 D = 3 + 1 dimensions. In Sec. VII B I noted that adding a homogeneous term (84) to the solution of Gauss’ constraint (5) implied an isotropic gluon field energy density E Λ E_{\Lambda} E Λ given by a new parameter Λ \Lambda Λ (87) . This does not change the equations of motion and maintains full Poincaré covariance. Instead of taking the N c → ∞ N_{c}\to\infty N c → ∞ limit we may now set N c = 3 N_{c}=3 N c = 3 and consider 1 2 g 2 N c ≪ Λ 2 \frac{1}{2}g^{2}N_{c}\ll\Lambda^{2} 2 1 g 2 N c ≪ Λ 2 in (88) . This allows a perturbative expansion in g 2 g^{2} g 2 , which at lowest order gives all the previous results with V ′ = Λ 2 V'=\Lambda^{2} V ′ = Λ 2 .
Adding a homogeneous solution similarly introduces a scale Λ Q C D \Lambda_{\mathrm{QCD}} Λ QCD and a confining instantaneous potential in D = 3 + 1 D=3+1 D = 3 + 1 [13 ] . Such a change of boundary condition for the gauge-dependent, longitudinal color electric field seems not to violate the basic principles of QCD. At O ( α s 0 ) O(\alpha_{s}^{0}) O ( α s 0 ) the hadronic states and processes given by Λ Q C D \Lambda_{\mathrm{QCD}} Λ QCD qualitatively agree with data. The essential and nontrivial requirement of Poincaré covariance was verified for the electromagnetic form factor in [20 ] . The spontaneous breaking of chiral symmetry required for a quantitative phenomenology of light hadrons remains to be studied.
Acknowledgments
I thank Matti Järvinen for helpful discussions and comments on the manuscript. I am privileged to be associated as Professor Emeritus to the Physics Department of the University of Helsinki.
Gauge invariance of the bound states
Here I verify (12) , U G P ( x q ˉ → x q ) U G † = V ( x q ) P ( x q ˉ → x q ) V † ( x q ˉ ) U_{\mathcal{G}}\mathbb{P}(x_{\bar q}\to x_q)U_{\mathcal{G}}^\dagger=V(x_q)\mathbb{P}(x_{\bar q}\to x_q)V^\dagger(x_{\bar q}) U G P ( x q ˉ → x q ) U G † = V ( x q ) P ( x q ˉ → x q ) V † ( x q ˉ ) , by discretizing in x x x (t = 0 t=0 t = 0 is understood). For x q ˉ ≤ x ≤ x q x_{\bar q}\leq x\leq x_q x q ˉ ≤ x ≤ x q and 0 ≤ n ≤ N P 0\leq n\leq N_{\mathrm{P}} 0 ≤ n ≤ N P ,
x → y n = x q ˉ + n Δ x Δ x = x q − x q ˉ N P ∫ x q ˉ x q d x f ( x ) → Δ x ∑ n = 0 N P f ( y n ) x\to y_n=x_{\bar q}+n\Delta x \qquad\Delta x=\frac{x_q-x_{\bar q}}{N_{\mathrm{P}}} \qquad\int_{x_{\bar q}}^{x_q}dx\,f(x)\to\Delta x\sum_{n=0}^{N_{\mathrm{P}}}f(y_n) x → y n = x q ˉ + n Δ x Δ x = N P x q − x q ˉ ∫ x q ˉ x q d x f ( x ) → Δ x n = 0 ∑ N P f ( y n )
P ( x q ˉ → x q ) ≡ P exp [ i g ∫ x q ˉ x q d x A a ( x ) T a ] = ∏ n = 0 N P exp [ i g Δ x A a ( y n ) T a ] ( N P → ∞ ) = ∏ n = l + 1 N P exp [ i g Δ x A a ( y n ) T a ] [ 1 + Δ x i g A a ( y l ) T a + O ( ( Δ x ) 2 ) ] ∏ n = 0 l − 1 exp [ i g Δ x A a ( x n ) T a ] = P ( y l → x q ) [ 1 + Δ x i g A a ( y l ) T a + O ( ( Δ x ) 2 ) ] P ( x q ˉ → y l ) ( x q ˉ < y l < x q ) \begin{aligned}
\mathbb{P}(x_{\bar q}\to x_q)\equiv\mathcal{P}\exp\left[ig\int_{x_{\bar q}}^{x_q}dx\,A_a(x)T^a\right]=\prod_{n=0}^{N_{\mathrm{P}}}\exp\left[ig\Delta x\,A_a(y_n)T^a\right]\qquad(N_{\mathrm{P}}\to\infty) \\
&=\prod_{n=l+1}^{N_{\mathrm{P}}}\exp\left[ig\Delta x\,A_a(y_n)T^a\right]\left[1+\Delta x\,igA_a(y_l)T^a+O\left((\Delta x)^2\right)\right]\prod_{n=0}^{l-1}\exp\left[ig\Delta x\,A_a(x_n)T^a\right] \\
&=\mathbb{P}(y_l\to x_q)\left[1+\Delta x\,igA_a(y_l)T^a+O\left((\Delta x)^2\right)\right]\mathbb{P}(x_{\bar q}\to y_l)\qquad(x_{\bar q}<y_l<x_q)
\end{aligned} P ( x q ˉ → x q ) ≡ P exp [ i g ∫ x q ˉ x q d x A a ( x ) T a ] = n = 0 ∏ N P exp [ i g Δ x A a ( y n ) T a ] ( N P → ∞ ) = n = l + 1 ∏ N P exp [ i g Δ x A a ( y n ) T a ] [ 1 + Δ x i g A a ( y l ) T a + O ( ( Δ x ) 2 ) ] n = 0 ∏ l − 1 exp [ i g Δ x A a ( x n ) T a ] = P ( y l → x q ) [ 1 + Δ x i g A a ( y l ) T a + O ( ( Δ x ) 2 ) ] P ( x q ˉ → y l ) ( x q ˉ < y l < x q )
∂ ∂ x q P ( x q ˉ → x q ) = i g A a ( x q ) T a P ( x q ˉ → x q ) \frac{\partial}{\partial x_q}\mathbb{P}(x_{\bar q}\to x_q)=igA_a(x_q)T^a\mathbb{P}(x_{\bar q}\to x_q) ∂ x q ∂ P ( x q ˉ → x q ) = i g A a ( x q ) T a P ( x q ˉ → x q )
{#eq:A.1}
\frac{\partial}{\partial x_{\bar q}}\mathbb{P}(x_{\bar q}\to x_q)=-\mathbb{P}(x_{\bar q}\to x_q)igA_a(x_{\bar q})T^a
The discretized derivative and the commutation relations (3) are,
∂ ∂ y k f ( y k ) = f ( y k ) − f ( y k − 1 ) Δ x (89) \frac{\partial}{\partial y_k}f(y_k)=\frac{f(y_k)-f(y_{k-1})}{\Delta x} \tag*{(89)} ∂ y k ∂ f ( y k ) = Δ x f ( y k ) − f ( y k − 1 ) (89)
[ E a ( y k ) , A b ( y l ) ] = i Δ x δ k , l δ a , b { ψ α , A † ( y k ) , ψ β , B ( y l ) } = δ α , β δ A , B δ k , l Δ x (90) [E_a(y_k),A_b(y_l)]=\frac{i}{\Delta x}\delta_{k,l}\delta_{a,b}\qquad\{\psi^\dagger_{\alpha,A}(y_k),\psi_{\beta,B}(y_l)\}=\delta_{\alpha,\beta}\delta_{A,B}\frac{\delta_{k,l}}{\Delta x} \tag*{(90)} [ E a ( y k ) , A b ( y l )] = Δ x i δ k , l δ a , b { ψ α , A † ( y k ) , ψ β , B ( y l )} = δ α , β δ A , B Δ x δ k , l (90)
The generator of time-independent gauge transformations G a ( t , x ) \mathcal{G}_a(t,x) G a ( t , x ) is given in (4) , the unitary transformation U G ( t ) U_{\mathcal{G}}(t) U G ( t ) in (10) and the unitary matrix V Λ ( x ) V_\Lambda(x) V Λ ( x ) in (11) . For x q ˉ < y l , y l + 1 < x q x_{\bar q}<y_l,y_{l+1}<x_q x q ˉ < y l , y l + 1 < x q , using (A.1) and up to O ( Δ x ) O(\Delta x) O ( Δ x ) corrections,
[ ∂ ∂ y l E a ( y l ) , P ( x q ˉ → x q ) ] = 1 Δ x P ( y l + 2 → x q ) [ E a ( y l + 1 ) − E a ( y l ) , ( 1 + i g Δ x A b ( y l + 1 ) T b ) ( 1 + i g Δ x A c ( y l ) T c ) ] P ( x q ˉ → y l − 1 ) = 1 Δ x P ( y l + 2 → x q ) { i 2 g T a ( 1 + i g Δ x A b ( y l ) T b ) − ( 1 + i g Δ x A b ( y l + 1 ) T b ) i 2 g T a } P ( x q ˉ → y l − 1 ) = P ( y l → x q ) i 3 g 2 A b ( y l ) ( T a T b − T b T a ) P ( x q ˉ → y l ) = P ( y l → x q ) g 2 f a b c A b ( y l ) T c P ( x q ˉ → y l ) \begin{aligned}
\left[\frac{\partial}{\partial y_l}E_a(y_l),\mathbb{P}(x_{\bar q}\to x_q)\right]
=\frac{1}{\Delta x}\mathbb{P}(y_{l+2}\to x_q)\left[E_a(y_{l+1})-E_a(y_l),(1+ig\Delta xA_b(y_{l+1})T^b)(1+ig\Delta xA_c(y_l)T^c)\right]\mathbb{P}(x_{\bar q}\to y_{l-1}) \\
&=\frac{1}{\Delta x}\mathbb{P}(y_{l+2}\to x_q)\left\{i^2gT^a(1+ig\Delta xA_b(y_l)T^b)-(1+ig\Delta xA_b(y_{l+1})T^b)i^2gT^a\right\}\mathbb{P}(x_{\bar q}\to y_{l-1}) \\
&=\mathbb{P}(y_l\to x_q)i^3g^2A_b(y_l)(T^aT^b-T^bT^a)\mathbb{P}(x_{\bar q}\to y_l)=\mathbb{P}(y_l\to x_q)g^2f_{abc}A_b(y_l)T^c\mathbb{P}(x_{\bar q}\to y_l)
\end{aligned} [ ∂ y l ∂ E a ( y l ) , P ( x q ˉ → x q ) ] = Δ x 1 P ( y l + 2 → x q ) [ E a ( y l + 1 ) − E a ( y l ) , ( 1 + i g Δ x A b ( y l + 1 ) T b ) ( 1 + i g Δ x A c ( y l ) T c ) ] P ( x q ˉ → y l − 1 ) = Δ x 1 P ( y l + 2 → x q ) { i 2 g T a ( 1 + i g Δ x A b ( y l ) T b ) − ( 1 + i g Δ x A b ( y l + 1 ) T b ) i 2 g T a } P ( x q ˉ → y l − 1 ) = P ( y l → x q ) i 3 g 2 A b ( y l ) ( T a T b − T b T a ) P ( x q ˉ → y l ) = P ( y l → x q ) g 2 f ab c A b ( y l ) T c P ( x q ˉ → y l )
[ g f a b c A b E c ( y l ) , P ( x q ˉ → x q ) ] = P ( y l → x q ) i 2 g 2 f a b c A b ( y l ) T c P ( x q ˉ → y l ) (91) [g f_{abc}A_bE_c(y_l),\mathbb{P}(x_{\bar q}\to x_q)]=\mathbb{P}(y_l\to x_q)i^2g^2f_{abc}A_b(y_l)T^c\mathbb{P}(x_{\bar q}\to y_l) \tag*{(91)} [ g f ab c A b E c ( y l ) , P ( x q ˉ → x q )] = P ( y l → x q ) i 2 g 2 f ab c A b ( y l ) T c P ( x q ˉ → y l ) (91)
The last two lines cancel in G a ( x ) \mathcal{G}_a(x) G a ( x ) ,
[ G a ( x ) , P ( x q ˉ → x q ) ] = 0 for x q ˉ < x < x q (92) [\mathcal{G}_a(x),\mathbb{P}(x_{\bar q}\to x_q)]=0\qquad\text{for }x_{\bar q}<x<x_q \tag*{(92)} [ G a ( x ) , P ( x q ˉ → x q )] = 0 for x q ˉ < x < x q (92)
At the endpoints y l = x q y_l=x_q y l = x q and y l = x q ˉ y_l=x_{\bar q} y l = x q ˉ the derivative of the commutator is discontinuous,
∂ x q E a ( x q ) ≡ E a ( x q + Δ x ) − E a ( x q ) Δ x ∂ x q ˉ E a ( x q ˉ ) ≡ E a ( x q ˉ ) − E a ( x q ˉ − Δ x ) Δ x (93) \partial_{x_q}E_a(x_q)\equiv\frac{E_a(x_q+\Delta x)-E_a(x_q)}{\Delta x}\qquad
\partial_{x_{\bar q}}E_a(x_{\bar q})\equiv\frac{E_a(x_{\bar q})-E_a(x_{\bar q}-\Delta x)}{\Delta x} \tag*{(93)} ∂ x q E a ( x q ) ≡ Δ x E a ( x q + Δ x ) − E a ( x q ) ∂ x q ˉ E a ( x q ˉ ) ≡ Δ x E a ( x q ˉ ) − E a ( x q ˉ − Δ x ) (93)
and [ E a ( x q + Δ x ) , P ( x q ˉ → x q ) ] = [ E a ( x q ˉ − Δ x ) , P ( x q ˉ → x q ) ] = 0 [E_a(x_q+\Delta x),\mathbb{P}(x_{\bar q}\to x_q)]=[E_a(x_{\bar q}-\Delta x),\mathbb{P}(x_{\bar q}\to x_q)]=0 [ E a ( x q + Δ x ) , P ( x q ˉ → x q )] = [ E a ( x q ˉ − Δ x ) , P ( x q ˉ → x q )] = 0 . Hence
[ ∂ x q E a ( x q ) , P ( x q ˉ → x q ) ] = − 1 Δ x [ E a ( x q ) , P ( x q ˉ → x q ) ] = − i 2 g Δ x T a P ( x q ˉ → x q ) [\partial_{x_q}E_a(x_q),\mathbb{P}(x_{\bar q}\to x_q)]
=-\frac{1}{\Delta x}[E_a(x_q),\mathbb{P}(x_{\bar q}\to x_q)]
=-\frac{i^2g}{\Delta x}T^a\mathbb{P}(x_{\bar q}\to x_q) [ ∂ x q E a ( x q ) , P ( x q ˉ → x q )] = − Δ x 1 [ E a ( x q ) , P ( x q ˉ → x q )] = − Δ x i 2 g T a P ( x q ˉ → x q )
[ ∂ x q ˉ E a ( x q ˉ ) , P ( x q ˉ → x q ) ] = 1 Δ x [ E a ( x q ˉ ) , P ( x q ˉ → x q ) ] = i 2 g Δ x P ( x q ˉ → x q ) T a (94) [\partial_{x_{\bar q}}E_a(x_{\bar q}),\mathbb{P}(x_{\bar q}\to x_q)]
=\frac{1}{\Delta x}[E_a(x_{\bar q}),\mathbb{P}(x_{\bar q}\to x_q)]
=\frac{i^2g}{\Delta x}\mathbb{P}(x_{\bar q}\to x_q)T^a \tag*{(94)} [ ∂ x q ˉ E a ( x q ˉ ) , P ( x q ˉ → x q )] = Δ x 1 [ E a ( x q ˉ ) , P ( x q ˉ → x q )] = Δ x i 2 g P ( x q ˉ → x q ) T a (94)
Analogously [ g f a b c A b E c ( x q + Δ x / 2 ) , P ( x ˉ q → x q ) ] = [ g f a b c A b E c ( x ˉ q − Δ x / 2 ) , P ( x ˉ q → x q ) ] = 0 [gf_{abc}A_bE_c(x_q+\Delta x/2),P(\bar{x}_q\to x_q)]=[gf_{abc}A_bE_c(\bar{x}_q-\Delta x/2),P(\bar{x}_q\to x_q)]=0 [ g f ab c A b E c ( x q + Δ x /2 ) , P ( x ˉ q → x q )] = [ g f ab c A b E c ( x ˉ q − Δ x /2 ) , P ( x ˉ q → x q )] = 0 . Hence (12) is verified in the continuum limit,
[ G a ( x ) , P ( x ˉ q → x q ) ] = δ ( x − x q ) g T a P ( x ˉ q → x q ) − δ ( x − x ˉ q ) P ( x ˉ q → x q ) g T a [G_a(x),P(\bar{x}_q\to x_q)]=\delta(x-x_q)gT^aP(\bar{x}_q\to x_q)-\delta(x-\bar{x}_q)P(\bar{x}_q\to x_q)gT^a [ G a ( x ) , P ( x ˉ q → x q )] = δ ( x − x q ) g T a P ( x ˉ q → x q ) − δ ( x − x ˉ q ) P ( x ˉ q → x q ) g T a
U G P ( x ˉ q → x q ) U G † = P ( x ˉ q → x q ) + i ∫ d x [ G a ( x ) , P ( x ˉ q → x q ) ] Λ a ( x ) = [ 1 + i g T a Λ a ( x q ) ] P ( x ˉ q → x q ) [ 1 − i g T a Λ a ( x ˉ q ) ] = V Λ ( x q ) P ( x ˉ q → x q ) V Λ † ( x ˉ q ) (95) \begin{aligned}
U_G P(\bar{x}_q\to x_q)U_G^\dagger=P(\bar{x}_q\to x_q)+i\int dx\,[G_a(x),P(\bar{x}_q\to x_q)]\Lambda_a(x) \\
&=[1+igT^a\Lambda_a(x_q)]P(\bar{x}_q\to x_q)[1-igT^a\Lambda_a(\bar{x}_q)]=V_\Lambda(x_q)P(\bar{x}_q\to x_q)V_\Lambda^\dagger(\bar{x}_q) \tag*{(95)}
\end{aligned} U G P ( x ˉ q → x q ) U G † = P ( x ˉ q → x q ) + i ∫ d x [ G a ( x ) , P ( x ˉ q → x q )] Λ a ( x ) = [ 1 + i g T a Λ a ( x q )] P ( x ˉ q → x q ) [ 1 − i g T a Λ a ( x ˉ q )] = V Λ ( x q ) P ( x ˉ q → x q ) V Λ † ( x ˉ q ) (95)
Poincaré covariance
General definitions
In D = 1 + 1 D=1+1 D = 1 + 1 dimensions we may use a two-dimensional Dirac algebra with Pauli matrices
γ 0 = σ 3 γ 1 = i σ 2 γ 0 γ 1 ≡ α 1 = σ 1 (96) \gamma^0=\sigma_3\qquad\gamma^1=i\sigma_2\qquad\gamma^0\gamma^1\equiv\alpha_1=\sigma_1 \tag*{(96)} γ 0 = σ 3 γ 1 = i σ 2 γ 0 γ 1 ≡ α 1 = σ 1 (96)
The unitary Poincaré operators are related to their generators as
U x ( ℓ ) = exp ( − i ℓ P ^ 1 ) Space translation by ℓ (97) U_x(\ell)=\exp(-i\ell\hat{P}^1)\qquad\text{Space translation by }\ell \tag*{(97)} U x ( ℓ ) = exp ( − i ℓ P ^ 1 ) Space translation by ℓ (97)
U t ( τ ) = exp ( i τ P ^ 0 ) Time translation by τ (98) U_t(\tau)=\exp(i\tau\hat{P}^0)\qquad\text{Time translation by }\tau \tag*{(98)} U t ( τ ) = exp ( i τ P ^ 0 ) Time translation by τ (98)
U t x ( ξ ) = exp ( − i ξ M ^ 01 ) Boost by ξ (99) U_{tx}(\xi)=\exp(-i\xi\hat{M}^{01})\qquad\text{Boost by }\xi \tag*{(99)} U t x ( ξ ) = exp ( − i ξ M ^ 01 ) Boost by ξ (99)
The generators satisfy the equal-time Lie algebra
[ P ^ 0 , P ^ 1 ] = 0 , [ P ^ 0 , M ^ 01 ] = i P ^ 1 , [ P ^ 1 , M ^ 01 ] = i P ^ 0 (100) [\hat{P}^0,\hat{P}^1]=0,\qquad[\hat{P}^0,\hat{M}^{01}]=i\hat{P}^1,\qquad[\hat{P}^1,\hat{M}^{01}]=i\hat{P}^0 \tag*{(100)} [ P ^ 0 , P ^ 1 ] = 0 , [ P ^ 0 , M ^ 01 ] = i P ^ 1 , [ P ^ 1 , M ^ 01 ] = i P ^ 0 (100)
Infinitesimal translations of a field O ^ \hat{O} O ^ are generated by
[ P ^ 1 , O ^ ] = i ∂ x O ^ : U x ( δ x ) O ^ U x † ( δ x ) = O ^ − i δ x [ P ^ 1 , O ^ ] = O ^ + δ x ∂ x O ^ = O ^ ( x + δ x ) [\hat{P}^1,\hat{O}]=i\partial_x\hat{O}:\qquad U_x(\delta x)\hat{O}U_x^\dagger(\delta x)=\hat{O}-i\delta x[\hat{P}^1,\hat{O}]=\hat{O}+\delta x\,\partial_x\hat{O}=\hat{O}(x+\delta x) [ P ^ 1 , O ^ ] = i ∂ x O ^ : U x ( δ x ) O ^ U x † ( δ x ) = O ^ − i δ x [ P ^ 1 , O ^ ] = O ^ + δ x ∂ x O ^ = O ^ ( x + δ x )
[ P ^ 0 , O ^ ] = − i ∂ t O ^ : U t ( δ t ) O ^ U t † ( δ t ) = O ^ + i δ t [ P ^ 0 , O ^ ] = O ^ + δ t ∂ t O ^ = O ^ ( t + δ t ) (101) [\hat{P}^0,\hat{O}]=-i\partial_t\hat{O}:\qquad U_t(\delta t)\hat{O}U_t^\dagger(\delta t)=\hat{O}+i\delta t[\hat{P}^0,\hat{O}]=\hat{O}+\delta t\,\partial_t\hat{O}=\hat{O}(t+\delta t) \tag*{(101)} [ P ^ 0 , O ^ ] = − i ∂ t O ^ : U t ( δ t ) O ^ U t † ( δ t ) = O ^ + i δ t [ P ^ 0 , O ^ ] = O ^ + δ t ∂ t O ^ = O ^ ( t + δ t ) (101)
The Lie algebra ensures that the momentum and energy of a state ∣ M , P ⟩ |M,P\rangle ∣ M , P ⟩ , which satisfies P ^ 1 ∣ M , P ⟩ = P ∣ M , P ⟩ \hat{P}^1|M,P\rangle=P|M,P\rangle P ^ 1 ∣ M , P ⟩ = P ∣ M , P ⟩ and P ^ 0 ∣ M , P ⟩ = E P ∣ M , P ⟩ \hat{P}^0|M,P\rangle=E_P|M,P\rangle P ^ 0 ∣ M , P ⟩ = E P ∣ M , P ⟩ , transform correctly under boosts,
P ^ 1 ( 1 − i δ ξ M ^ 01 ) ∣ M , P ⟩ = { ( 1 − i δ ξ M ^ 01 ) P ^ 1 − i δ ξ [ P ^ 1 , M ^ 01 ] } ∣ M , P ⟩ = ( P + δ ξ E P ) ( 1 − i δ ξ M ^ 01 ) ∣ M , P ⟩ \hat{P}^1(1-i\delta\xi\hat{M}^{01})|M,P\rangle=\{(1-i\delta\xi\hat{M}^{01})\hat{P}^1-i\delta\xi[\hat{P}^1,\hat{M}^{01}]\}|M,P\rangle=(P+\delta\xi E_P)(1-i\delta\xi\hat{M}^{01})|M,P\rangle P ^ 1 ( 1 − i δ ξ M ^ 01 ) ∣ M , P ⟩ = {( 1 − i δ ξ M ^ 01 ) P ^ 1 − i δ ξ [ P ^ 1 , M ^ 01 ]} ∣ M , P ⟩ = ( P + δ ξ E P ) ( 1 − i δ ξ M ^ 01 ) ∣ M , P ⟩
P ^ 0 ( 1 − i δ ξ M ^ 01 ) ∣ M , P ⟩ = { ( 1 − i δ ξ M ^ 01 ) P ^ 0 − i δ ξ [ P ^ 0 , M ^ 01 ] } ∣ M , P ⟩ = ( E P + δ ξ P ) ( 1 − i δ ξ M ^ 01 ) ∣ M , P ⟩ (102) \hat{P}^0(1-i\delta\xi\hat{M}^{01})|M,P\rangle=\{(1-i\delta\xi\hat{M}^{01})\hat{P}^0-i\delta\xi[\hat{P}^0,\hat{M}^{01}]\}|M,P\rangle=(E_P+\delta\xi P)(1-i\delta\xi\hat{M}^{01})|M,P\rangle \tag*{(102)} P ^ 0 ( 1 − i δ ξ M ^ 01 ) ∣ M , P ⟩ = {( 1 − i δ ξ M ^ 01 ) P ^ 0 − i δ ξ [ P ^ 0 , M ^ 01 ]} ∣ M , P ⟩ = ( E P + δ ξ P ) ( 1 − i δ ξ M ^ 01 ) ∣ M , P ⟩ (102)
Hence we may identify U t x ( δ ξ ) ∣ M , P ⟩ = ∣ M , P + δ ξ E P ⟩ U_{tx}(\delta\xi)|M,P\rangle=|M,P+\delta\xi E_P\rangle U t x ( δ ξ ) ∣ M , P ⟩ = ∣ M , P + δ ξ E P ⟩ .
Generators of QCD2 in temporal gauge
The translation invariance of the action defines the conserved energy-momentum tensor (see, e.g. , Secs. 7.3 and 7.4 of [10 ] ). For a Lagrangian L \mathcal{L} L [here given by (1) ] depending on fields O ^ ℓ \hat{O}^{\ell} O ^ ℓ (here A a ≡ A a 1 A_a\equiv A_a^1 A a ≡ A a 1 and ψ \psi ψ ),
T μ ν ≡ ∂ L ∂ ( ∂ ν O ^ ℓ ) ∂ μ O ^ ℓ − g μ ν L ∂ ν T μ ν = 0 (103) T^\nu_{\mu}\equiv\frac{\partial\mathcal{L}}{\partial(\partial_\nu\hat{O}^{\ell})}\partial_\mu\hat{O}^{\ell}-g^\nu_{\mu}\mathcal{L}\qquad\partial_\nu T^\nu_{\mu}=0 \tag*{(103)} T μ ν ≡ ∂ ( ∂ ν O ^ ℓ ) ∂ L ∂ μ O ^ ℓ − g μ ν L ∂ ν T μ ν = 0 (103)
The generators of space and time translations are time independent. With α 1 ≡ γ 0 γ 1 \alpha_1\equiv\gamma^0\gamma^1 α 1 ≡ γ 0 γ 1 ,
P ^ 1 ≡ ∫ d x T 01 = − ∫ d x ∂ L Q C D ∂ ( ∂ 0 O ^ ℓ ) ∂ 1 O ^ ℓ = ∫ d x [ E a ∂ x A a + ψ † ( − i ∂ x ) ψ ] \hat{P}^1\equiv\int dx\,T^{01}=-\int dx\,\frac{\partial\mathcal{L}_{QCD}}{\partial(\partial_0\hat{O}^{\ell})}\partial_1\hat{O}^{\ell}=\int dx\,[E_a\partial_xA_a+\psi^\dagger(-i\partial_x)\psi] P ^ 1 ≡ ∫ d x T 01 = − ∫ d x ∂ ( ∂ 0 O ^ ℓ ) ∂ L QC D ∂ 1 O ^ ℓ = ∫ d x [ E a ∂ x A a + ψ † ( − i ∂ x ) ψ ]
P ^ 0 = H ≡ ∫ d x T 00 = ∫ d x [ ∂ L Q C D ∂ ( ∂ 0 O ^ ℓ ) ∂ 0 O ^ ℓ − L ] = ∫ d x { 1 2 ( E a ) 2 + ψ † ( − i α 1 ∂ x + γ 0 m − g α 1 A a T a ) ψ } (104) \hat{P}^0=H\equiv\int dx\,T^{00}=\int dx\left[\frac{\partial\mathcal{L}_{QCD}}{\partial(\partial_0\hat{O}^{\ell})}\partial_0\hat{O}^{\ell}-\mathcal{L}\right]=\int dx\left\{\frac{1}{2}(E_a)^2+\psi^\dagger(-i\alpha_1\partial_x+\gamma^0m-g\alpha_1A_aT^a)\psi\right\} \tag*{(104)} P ^ 0 = H ≡ ∫ d x T 00 = ∫ d x [ ∂ ( ∂ 0 O ^ ℓ ) ∂ L QC D ∂ 0 O ^ ℓ − L ] = ∫ d x { 2 1 ( E a ) 2 + ψ † ( − i α 1 ∂ x + γ 0 m − g α 1 A a T a ) ψ } (104)
The boost generator M ^ 01 \hat{M}^{01} M ^ 01 (B.4) may be expressed in terms of P ^ 1 \hat{P}^{1} P ^ 1 and the (Hermitian) Hamiltonian density H \mathcal{H} H in (B.9),
M ^ 01 = t P ^ 1 − ∫ d x x H = ∫ d x { t [ E a ∂ ↔ x A a + ψ † ( − i ∂ ↔ x ) ψ ] − x [ 1 2 ( E a ) 2 + ψ † ( − i α 1 ∂ → x + γ 0 m − g α 1 A a T a ) ψ ] } = ∫ d x { t [ E a ∂ ↔ x A a + ψ † ( − i ∂ ↔ x ) ψ ] − x [ 1 2 ( E a ) 2 + ψ † ( − i α 1 ∂ → x + γ 0 m − g α 1 A a T a + i 2 α → 1 ) ψ ] } (105) \begin{aligned}
\hat{M}^{01}=t\hat{P}^{1}-\int dx\,x\mathcal{H}=\int dx\left\{t\left[E_{a}\overleftrightarrow{\partial}_{x}A_{a}+\psi^{\dagger}(-i\overleftrightarrow{\partial}_{x})\psi\right]-x\left[\frac{1}{2}(E_{a})^{2}+\psi^{\dagger}(-i\alpha_{1}\overrightarrow{\partial}_{x}+\gamma^{0}m-g\alpha_{1}A_{a}T^{a})\psi\right]\right\} \\
&=\int dx\left\{t\left[E_{a}\overleftrightarrow{\partial}_{x}A_{a}+\psi^{\dagger}(-i\overleftrightarrow{\partial}_{x})\psi\right]-x\left[\frac{1}{2}(E_{a})^{2}+\psi^{\dagger}(-i\alpha_{1}\overrightarrow{\partial}_{x}+\gamma^{0}m-g\alpha_{1}A_{a}T^{a}+\frac{i}{2}\overrightarrow{\alpha}_{1})\psi\right]\right\} \tag*{(105)}
\end{aligned} M ^ 01 = t P ^ 1 − ∫ d x x H = ∫ d x { t [ E a ∂ x A a + ψ † ( − i ∂ x ) ψ ] − x [ 2 1 ( E a ) 2 + ψ † ( − i α 1 ∂ x + γ 0 m − g α 1 A a T a ) ψ ] } = ∫ d x { t [ E a ∂ x A a + ψ † ( − i ∂ x ) ψ ] − x [ 2 1 ( E a ) 2 + ψ † ( − i α 1 ∂ x + γ 0 m − g α 1 A a T a + 2 i α 1 ) ψ ] } (105)
where on the first line ∂ ↔ = 1 2 ( ∂ → − ∂ ← ) \overleftrightarrow{\partial}=\frac{1}{2}(\overrightarrow{\partial}-\overleftarrow{\partial}) ∂ = 2 1 ( ∂ − ∂ ) acts only on the fermion fields.
The Lie algebra (B.5) may be verified using the canonical commutation relations (3) . More generally, all generators are independent of time, and the translation operators satisfy (B.6). Then
[ P ^ 0 , P ^ 1 ] = − i ∂ t P ^ 1 = 0 [\hat{P}^{0},\hat{P}^{1}]=-i\partial_{t}\hat{P}^{1}=0 [ P ^ 0 , P ^ 1 ] = − i ∂ t P ^ 1 = 0
[ P ^ 1 , M ^ 01 ] = − ∫ d x x i ∂ x H = ∫ d x i H = i P ^ 0 (106) [\hat{P}^{1},\hat{M}^{01}]=-\int dx\,x\,i\partial_{x}\mathcal{H}=\int dx\,i\mathcal{H}=i\hat{P}^{0} \tag*{(106)} [ P ^ 1 , M ^ 01 ] = − ∫ d x x i ∂ x H = ∫ d x i H = i P ^ 0 (106)
The explicit time dependence of the boost generator M ^ 01 \hat{M}^{01} M ^ 01 in (B.10) implies,
d d t M ^ 01 = ∂ t e x p l M ^ 01 + i [ P ^ 0 , M ^ 01 ] = 0 \frac{d}{dt}\hat{M}^{01}=\partial_{t}^{\mathrm{expl}}\hat{M}^{01}+i[\hat{P}^{0},\hat{M}^{01}]=0 d t d M ^ 01 = ∂ t expl M ^ 01 + i [ P ^ 0 , M ^ 01 ] = 0
[ P ^ 0 , M ^ 01 ] = i ∂ t e x p l M ^ 01 = i P ^ 1 (107) [\hat{P}^{0},\hat{M}^{01}]=i\partial_{t}^{\mathrm{expl}}\hat{M}^{01}=i\hat{P}^{1} \tag*{(107)} [ P ^ 0 , M ^ 01 ] = i ∂ t expl M ^ 01 = i P ^ 1 (107)
Parity and charge conjugation
The fermion field may be expanded in the basis given by the free creation/annihilation operators,
ψ ( t , x ) = ∫ d k 2 π 2 E k [ u ( k ) e − i t E k + i x k b k + v ( k ) e i t E k − i x k d k † ] (108) \psi(t,x)=\int\frac{dk}{2\pi\,2E_{k}}\left[u(k)e^{-itE_{k}+ixk}b_{k}+v(k)e^{itE_{k}-ixk}d_{k}^{\dagger}\right] \tag*{(108)} ψ ( t , x ) = ∫ 2 π 2 E k d k [ u ( k ) e − i t E k + i x k b k + v ( k ) e i t E k − i x k d k † ] (108)
u ( k ) = 1 E k + m ( E k + m + α 1 k ) ( 1 0 ) E k = k 2 + m 2 u(k)=\frac{1}{\sqrt{E_{k}+m}}(E_{k}+m+\alpha_{1}k)\begin{pmatrix}1\\0\end{pmatrix}
\qquad E_{k}=\sqrt{k^{2}+m^{2}} u ( k ) = E k + m 1 ( E k + m + α 1 k ) ( 1 0 ) E k = k 2 + m 2
v ( k ) = 1 E k + m ( E k + m + α 1 k ) ( 0 1 ) = α 1 u ( k ) α 1 = γ 0 γ 1 = σ 1 (109) v(k)=\frac{1}{\sqrt{E_{k}+m}}(E_{k}+m+\alpha_{1}k)\begin{pmatrix}0\\1\end{pmatrix}=\alpha_{1}u(k)
\qquad\alpha_{1}=\gamma^{0}\gamma^{1}=\sigma_{1} \tag*{(109)} v ( k ) = E k + m 1 ( E k + m + α 1 k ) ( 0 1 ) = α 1 u ( k ) α 1 = γ 0 γ 1 = σ 1 (109)
The parity transformation ( t , x ) → ( t , − x ) (t,x)\to(t,-x) ( t , x ) → ( t , − x ) is implemented by the operator P \mathcal{P} P , which leaves the action (1) invariant,
P b k P † = b k P d k P † = − d k \mathcal{P}b_{k}\mathcal{P}^{\dagger}=b_{k}
\qquad
\mathcal{P}d_{k}\mathcal{P}^{\dagger}=-d_{k} P b k P † = b k P d k P † = − d k
P ψ ( t , x ) P † = γ 0 ψ ( t , − x ) P ψ ˉ ( t , x ) P † = ψ ˉ ( t , − x ) γ 0 P A 1 a ( t , x ) P † = − A 1 a ( t , − x ) (110) \mathcal{P}\psi(t,x)\mathcal{P}^{\dagger}=\gamma^{0}\psi(t,-x)
\qquad
\mathcal{P}\bar{\psi}(t,x)\mathcal{P}^{\dagger}=\bar{\psi}(t,-x)\gamma^{0}
\qquad
\mathcal{P}A_{1}^{a}(t,x)\mathcal{P}^{\dagger}=-A_{1}^{a}(t,-x) \tag*{(110)} P ψ ( t , x ) P † = γ 0 ψ ( t , − x ) P ψ ˉ ( t , x ) P † = ψ ˉ ( t , − x ) γ 0 P A 1 a ( t , x ) P † = − A 1 a ( t , − x ) (110)
For charge conjugation we have correspondingly, with γ 1 = σ 3 σ 1 = i σ 2 \gamma^{1}=\sigma_{3}\sigma_{1}=i\sigma_{2} γ 1 = σ 3 σ 1 = i σ 2 ,
C b k C † = d k C d k C † = b k \mathcal{C}b_{k}\mathcal{C}^{\dagger}=d_{k}
\qquad
\mathcal{C}d_{k}\mathcal{C}^{\dagger}=b_{k} C b k C † = d k C d k C † = b k
C ψ ( t , x ) C † = − γ 1 ψ ˉ T ( t , x ) C ψ ˉ ( t , x ) C † = − ψ T ( t , x ) γ 1 C A a 1 ( t , x ) T a C † = − [ A a 1 ( t , x ) T a ] T (111) \mathcal{C}\psi(t,x)\mathcal{C}^{\dagger}=-\gamma^{1}\bar{\psi}^{T}(t,x)
\qquad
\mathcal{C}\bar{\psi}(t,x)\mathcal{C}^{\dagger}=-\psi^{T}(t,x)\gamma^{1}
\qquad
\mathcal{C}A_{a}^{1}(t,x)T^{a}\mathcal{C}^{\dagger}=-[A_{a}^{1}(t,x)T^{a}]^{T} \tag*{(111)} C ψ ( t , x ) C † = − γ 1 ψ ˉ T ( t , x ) C ψ ˉ ( t , x ) C † = − ψ T ( t , x ) γ 1 C A a 1 ( t , x ) T a C † = − [ A a 1 ( t , x ) T a ] T (111)
P-dependence of Φ ( P ) \Phi^{(P)} Φ ( P ) from M ^ 01 ∣ M , P ⟩ \hat{M}^{01}|M,P\rangle M ^ 01 ∣ M , P ⟩
Here I verify that the P P P -dependence of the wave function determined by the BSE (22) agrees with that given by the boost generator M ^ 01 \hat{M}^{01} M ^ 01 (B.10). Taking (6) to define ∣ M , P ⟩ |M,P\rangle ∣ M , P ⟩ at t = 0 t=0 t = 0 I set t = 0 t=0 t = 0 in the expression (B.10) for M ^ 01 \hat{M}^{01} M ^ 01 ,
M ^ 01 ( t = 0 ) = ∫ d x { − x 1 2 ( E a ) 2 + ψ † [ − x ( − i α 1 ∂ → x + m γ 0 − g A a T a α 1 ) + i 2 α 1 ] ψ } (112) \hat{M}^{01}(t=0)=\int dx\left\{-x\frac{1}{2}(E_{a})^{2}+\psi^{\dagger}\left[-x(-i\alpha_{1}\overrightarrow{\partial}_{x}+m\gamma^{0}-gA_{a}T^{a}\alpha_{1})+\frac{i}{2}\alpha_{1}\right]\psi\right\} \tag*{(112)} M ^ 01 ( t = 0 ) = ∫ d x { − x 2 1 ( E a ) 2 + ψ † [ − x ( − i α 1 ∂ x + m γ 0 − g A a T a α 1 ) + 2 i α 1 ] ψ } (112)
The generator transforms the operators in ∣ M , P ⟩ |M,P\rangle ∣ M , P ⟩ as follows,
[ M ^ 01 , ψ ‾ α ( x q ) ] = ψ ‾ ( x q ) { − x q ( − i α 1 ∂ → x q + m γ 0 + α 1 g A a ( x q ) T a ) − 1 2 i α 1 } α [ M ^ 01 , ψ β ( x q ˉ ) ] = { x q ˉ ( − i α 1 ∂ ← x q ˉ + m γ 0 − α 1 g A a ( x q ˉ ) T a ) − 1 2 i α 1 } ψ ( x q ˉ ) β [ M ^ 01 , P ( x q ˉ → x q ) ] = ∫ d x [ − 1 2 x E a 2 , P ( x q ˉ → x q ) ] = − 1 2 ∫ x q ˉ x q d x x g 2 C F P ( x q ˉ → x q ) = − 1 2 ( x q 2 − x q ˉ 2 ) V ′ P ( x q ˉ → x q ) (113) \begin{aligned}
\left[\widehat{M}^{01},\overline{\psi}_{\alpha}(x_q)\right]&=\overline{\psi}(x_q)\left\{-x_q\left(-i\alpha_1\overrightarrow{\partial}_{x_q}+m\gamma^0+\alpha_1gA_a(x_q)T^a\right)-\frac{1}{2}i\alpha_1\right\}_{\alpha}\\
\left[\widehat{M}^{01},\psi_{\beta}(x_{\bar q})\right]&=\left\{x_{\bar q}\left(-i\alpha_1\overleftarrow{\partial}_{x_{\bar q}}+m\gamma^0-\alpha_1gA_a(x_{\bar q})T^a\right)-\frac{1}{2}i\alpha_1\right\}\psi(x_{\bar q})_{\beta}\\
\left[\widehat{M}^{01},\mathrm{P}(x_{\bar q}\to x_q)\right]&=\int dx\left[-\frac{1}{2}xE_a^2,\mathrm{P}(x_{\bar q}\to x_q)\right]=-\frac{1}{2}\int_{x_{\bar q}}^{x_q}dx\,xg^2C_F\,\mathrm{P}(x_{\bar q}\to x_q)=-\frac{1}{2}\left(x_q^2-x_{\bar q}^2\right)V'\mathrm{P}(x_{\bar q}\to x_q) \tag*{(113)}
\end{aligned} [ M 01 , ψ α ( x q ) ] [ M 01 , ψ β ( x q ˉ ) ] [ M 01 , P ( x q ˉ → x q ) ] = ψ ( x q ) { − x q ( − i α 1 ∂ x q + m γ 0 + α 1 g A a ( x q ) T a ) − 2 1 i α 1 } α = { x q ˉ ( − i α 1 ∂ x q ˉ + m γ 0 − α 1 g A a ( x q ˉ ) T a ) − 2 1 i α 1 } ψ ( x q ˉ ) β = ∫ d x [ − 2 1 x E a 2 , P ( x q ˉ → x q ) ] = − 2 1 ∫ x q ˉ x q d x x g 2 C F P ( x q ˉ → x q ) = − 2 1 ( x q 2 − x q ˉ 2 ) V ′ P ( x q ˉ → x q ) (113)
where I used (18) on the last line, and denoted V ′ = 1 2 g 2 C F V'=\frac{1}{2}g^2C_F V ′ = 2 1 g 2 C F (8) . Altogether,
M ^ 01 ∣ M , P ⟩ = ∫ d x q d x q ˉ ψ ‾ ( x q ) { [ − x q ( i α 1 ∂ → x q + m γ 0 + α 1 g A a ( x q ) T a ) − 1 2 i α 1 ] P ( x q ˉ → x q ) exp [ i P ( x q + x q ˉ ) / 2 ] Φ ( P ) ( x q − x q ˉ ) − 1 2 ( x q 2 − x q ˉ 2 ) V ′ P ( x q ˉ → x q ) exp [ i P ( x q + x q ˉ ) / 2 ] Φ ( P ) ( x q − x q ˉ ) + P ( x q ˉ → x q ) exp [ i P ( x q + x q ˉ ) / 2 ] Φ ( P ) ( x q − x q ˉ ) [ x q ˉ ( i α 1 ∂ ← x q ˉ + m γ 0 − α 1 g A a ( x q ˉ ) T a ) − 1 2 i α 1 ] } ψ ( x q ˉ ) ∣ 0 ⟩ (114) \begin{aligned}
\widehat{M}^{01}|M,P\rangle={}&\int dx_qdx_{\bar q}\,\overline{\psi}(x_q)\Big\{\left[-x_q\left(i\alpha_1\overrightarrow{\partial}_{x_q}+m\gamma^0+\alpha_1gA_a(x_q)T^a\right)-\frac{1}{2}i\alpha_1\right]\mathrm{P}(x_{\bar q}\to x_q)\exp[iP(x_q+x_{\bar q})/2]\Phi^{(P)}(x_q-x_{\bar q})\\
&-\frac{1}{2}(x_q^2-x_{\bar q}^2)V'\mathrm{P}(x_{\bar q}\to x_q)\exp[iP(x_q+x_{\bar q})/2]\Phi^{(P)}(x_q-x_{\bar q})\\
&+\mathrm{P}(x_{\bar q}\to x_q)\exp[iP(x_q+x_{\bar q})/2]\Phi^{(P)}(x_q-x_{\bar q})\left[x_{\bar q}\left(i\alpha_1\overleftarrow{\partial}_{x_{\bar q}}+m\gamma^0-\alpha_1gA_a(x_{\bar q})T^a\right)-\frac{1}{2}i\alpha_1\right]\Big\}\psi(x_{\bar q})|0\rangle \tag*{(114)}
\end{aligned} M 01 ∣ M , P ⟩ = ∫ d x q d x q ˉ ψ ( x q ) { [ − x q ( i α 1 ∂ x q + m γ 0 + α 1 g A a ( x q ) T a ) − 2 1 i α 1 ] P ( x q ˉ → x q ) exp [ i P ( x q + x q ˉ ) /2 ] Φ ( P ) ( x q − x q ˉ ) − 2 1 ( x q 2 − x q ˉ 2 ) V ′ P ( x q ˉ → x q ) exp [ i P ( x q + x q ˉ ) /2 ] Φ ( P ) ( x q − x q ˉ ) + P ( x q ˉ → x q ) exp [ i P ( x q + x q ˉ ) /2 ] Φ ( P ) ( x q − x q ˉ ) [ x q ˉ ( i α 1 ∂ x q ˉ + m γ 0 − α 1 g A a ( x q ˉ ) T a ) − 2 1 i α 1 ] } ψ ( x q ˉ ) ∣0 ⟩ (114)
As in (21) the derivatives acting on P ( x q ˉ → x q ) \mathrm{P}(x_{\bar q}\to x_q) P ( x q ˉ → x q ) are cancelled by the α 1 g A a T a \alpha_1gA_aT^a α 1 g A a T a terms. For ∂ ← x q ˉ \overleftarrow{\partial}_{x_{\bar q}} ∂ x q ˉ acting on x q ˉ x_{\bar q} x q ˉ ,
− 1 2 i α 1 Φ ( P ) + Φ ( P ) [ i α 1 ( x q ˉ ∂ ← x q ˉ ) − 1 2 i α 1 ] = − 1 2 i [ α 1 , Φ ( P ) ] (115) -\frac{1}{2}i\alpha_1\Phi^{(P)}+\Phi^{(P)}\left[i\alpha_1\left(x_{\bar q}\overleftarrow{\partial}_{x_{\bar q}}\right)-\frac{1}{2}i\alpha_1\right]=-\frac{1}{2}i[\alpha_1,\Phi^{(P)}] \tag*{(115)} − 2 1 i α 1 Φ ( P ) + Φ ( P ) [ i α 1 ( x q ˉ ∂ x q ˉ ) − 2 1 i α 1 ] = − 2 1 i [ α 1 , Φ ( P ) ] (115)
With these simplifications,
M ^ 01 ∣ M , P ⟩ = ∫ d x q d x q ˉ ψ ‾ ( x q ) P ( x q ˉ → x q ) { − x q ( i α 1 ∂ → x q + m γ 0 ) exp [ i P ( x q + x q ˉ ) / 2 ] Φ ( P ) ( x q − x q ˉ ) − 1 2 ( x q 2 − x q ˉ 2 ) V ′ exp [ i P ( x q + x q ˉ ) / 2 ] Φ ( P ) ( x q − x q ˉ ) − 1 2 i [ α 1 , Φ ( P ) ] + exp [ i P ( x q + x q ˉ ) / 2 ] Φ ( P ) ( x q − x q ˉ ) ( i α 1 ∂ ← x q ˉ + m γ 0 ) x q ˉ } ψ ( x q ˉ ) ∣ 0 ⟩ (116) \begin{aligned}
\widehat{M}^{01}|M,P\rangle={}&\int dx_qdx_{\bar q}\,\overline{\psi}(x_q)\,\mathrm{P}(x_{\bar q}\to x_q)\Big\{-x_q\left(i\alpha_1\overrightarrow{\partial}_{x_q}+m\gamma^0\right)\exp[iP(x_q+x_{\bar q})/2]\Phi^{(P)}(x_q-x_{\bar q})\\
&-\frac{1}{2}(x_q^2-x_{\bar q}^2)V'\exp[iP(x_q+x_{\bar q})/2]\Phi^{(P)}(x_q-x_{\bar q})-\frac{1}{2}i[\alpha_1,\Phi^{(P)}]\\
&+\exp[iP(x_q+x_{\bar q})/2]\Phi^{(P)}(x_q-x_{\bar q})\left(i\alpha_1\overleftarrow{\partial}_{x_{\bar q}}+m\gamma^0\right)x_{\bar q}\Big\}\psi(x_{\bar q})|0\rangle \tag*{(116)}
\end{aligned} M 01 ∣ M , P ⟩ = ∫ d x q d x q ˉ ψ ( x q ) P ( x q ˉ → x q ) { − x q ( i α 1 ∂ x q + m γ 0 ) exp [ i P ( x q + x q ˉ ) /2 ] Φ ( P ) ( x q − x q ˉ ) − 2 1 ( x q 2 − x q ˉ 2 ) V ′ exp [ i P ( x q + x q ˉ ) /2 ] Φ ( P ) ( x q − x q ˉ ) − 2 1 i [ α 1 , Φ ( P ) ] + exp [ i P ( x q + x q ˉ ) /2 ] Φ ( P ) ( x q − x q ˉ ) ( i α 1 ∂ x q ˉ + m γ 0 ) x q ˉ } ψ ( x q ˉ ) ∣0 ⟩ (116)
= ∫ d x q d x q ˉ ψ ‾ ( x q ) P ( x q ˉ → x q ) exp [ i P ( x q + x q ˉ ) / 2 ] { − i x q α 1 ∂ → x q Φ ( P ) ( x q − x q ˉ ) − i x q ˉ ∂ ← x q ˉ Φ ( P ) ( x q − x q ˉ ) α 1 + 1 2 x q P α 1 Φ ( P ) − 1 2 x q ˉ P Φ ( P ) α 1 − x q m γ 0 Φ ( P ) + x q ˉ m Φ ( P ) γ 0 − 1 2 V ′ ( x q − x q ˉ ) ( x q + x q ˉ ) Φ ( P ) − 1 2 i [ α 1 , Φ ( P ) ] } ψ ( x q ˉ ) ∣ 0 ⟩ (117) \begin{aligned}
={}&\int dx_qdx_{\bar q}\,\overline{\psi}(x_q)\,\mathrm{P}(x_{\bar q}\to x_q)\exp[iP(x_q+x_{\bar q})/2]\Big\{-ix_q\alpha_1\overrightarrow{\partial}_{x_q}\Phi^{(P)}(x_q-x_{\bar q})-ix_{\bar q}\overleftarrow{\partial}_{x_{\bar q}}\Phi^{(P)}(x_q-x_{\bar q})\alpha_1\\
&+\frac{1}{2}x_qP\alpha_1\Phi^{(P)}-\frac{1}{2}x_{\bar q}P\Phi^{(P)}\alpha_1-x_qm\gamma^0\Phi^{(P)}+x_{\bar q}m\Phi^{(P)}\gamma^0-\frac{1}{2}V'(x_q-x_{\bar q})(x_q+x_{\bar q})\Phi^{(P)}-\frac{1}{2}i[\alpha_1,\Phi^{(P)}]\Big\}\psi(x_{\bar q})|0\rangle \tag*{(117)}
\end{aligned} = ∫ d x q d x q ˉ ψ ( x q ) P ( x q ˉ → x q ) exp [ i P ( x q + x q ˉ ) /2 ] { − i x q α 1 ∂ x q Φ ( P ) ( x q − x q ˉ ) − i x q ˉ ∂ x q ˉ Φ ( P ) ( x q − x q ˉ ) α 1 + 2 1 x q P α 1 Φ ( P ) − 2 1 x q ˉ P Φ ( P ) α 1 − x q m γ 0 Φ ( P ) + x q ˉ m Φ ( P ) γ 0 − 2 1 V ′ ( x q − x q ˉ ) ( x q + x q ˉ ) Φ ( P ) − 2 1 i [ α 1 , Φ ( P ) ] } ψ ( x q ˉ ) ∣0 ⟩ (117)
With x ≡ x q − x q ˉ x\equiv x_q-x_{\bar q} x ≡ x q − x q ˉ , replace
x q = 1 2 ( x q + x q ˉ ) + 1 2 x x q ˉ = 1 2 ( x q + x q ˉ ) − 1 2 x ∂ x q Φ ( P ) ( x q − x q ˉ ) = ∂ x Φ ( P ) ( x ) (118) x_q=\frac{1}{2}(x_q+x_{\bar q})+\frac{1}{2}x\qquad
x_{\bar q}=\frac{1}{2}(x_q+x_{\bar q})-\frac{1}{2}x\qquad
\partial_{x_q}\Phi^{(P)}(x_q-x_{\bar q})=\partial_x\Phi^{(P)}(x) \tag*{(118)} x q = 2 1 ( x q + x q ˉ ) + 2 1 x x q ˉ = 2 1 ( x q + x q ˉ ) − 2 1 x ∂ x q Φ ( P ) ( x q − x q ˉ ) = ∂ x Φ ( P ) ( x ) (118)
Use the bound state equation (22) on the terms ∝ x q + x q ˉ \propto x_q+x_{\bar q} ∝ x q + x q ˉ ,
− 1 2 ( x q + x q ˉ ) ( i ∂ x { α 1 , Φ ( P ) ( x ) } − 1 2 P [ α 1 , Φ ( P ) ( x ) ] + m { γ 0 , Φ ( P ) ( x ) } + V ′ x Φ ( P ) ( x ) ) = − 1 2 ( x q + x q ˉ ) E P Φ ( P ) ( x ) (119) -\frac{1}{2}(x_q+x_{\bar q})\left(i\partial_x\{\alpha_1,\Phi^{(P)}(x)\}-\frac{1}{2}P[\alpha_1,\Phi^{(P)}(x)]+m\{\gamma^0,\Phi^{(P)}(x)\}+V'x\Phi^{(P)}(x)\right)=-\frac{1}{2}(x_q+x_{\bar q})E_P\Phi^{(P)}(x) \tag*{(119)} − 2 1 ( x q + x q ˉ ) ( i ∂ x { α 1 , Φ ( P ) ( x )} − 2 1 P [ α 1 , Φ ( P ) ( x )] + m { γ 0 , Φ ( P ) ( x )} + V ′ x Φ ( P ) ( x ) ) = − 2 1 ( x q + x q ˉ ) E P Φ ( P ) ( x ) (119)
giving
M ^ 01 ∣ M , P ⟩ = ∫ d x q d x q ˉ ψ ‾ ( x q ) P ( x q , x q ˉ ) exp [ i P ( x q + x q ˉ ) / 2 ] { − 1 2 ( x q + x q ˉ ) E P Φ ( P ) − 1 2 i ∂ x [ α 1 , Φ ( P ) ] + 1 4 x P { α 1 , Φ ( P ) } − 1 2 x m { γ 0 , Φ ( P ) } − 1 2 i [ α 1 , Φ ( P ) ] } ψ ( x q ˉ ) ∣ 0 ⟩ (120) \begin{aligned}
\widehat{M}^{01}|M,P\rangle={}&\int dx_qdx_{\bar q}\,\overline{\psi}(x_q)\,\mathrm{P}(x_q,x_{\bar q})\exp[iP(x_q+x_{\bar q})/2]\Big\{-\frac{1}{2}(x_q+x_{\bar q})E_P\Phi^{(P)}-\frac{1}{2}i\partial_x[\alpha_1,\Phi^{(P)}]\\
&+\frac{1}{4}xP\{\alpha_1,\Phi^{(P)}\}-\frac{1}{2}xm\{\gamma^0,\Phi^{(P)}\}-\frac{1}{2}i[\alpha_1,\Phi^{(P)}]\Big\}\psi(x_{\bar q})|0\rangle \tag*{(120)}
\end{aligned} M 01 ∣ M , P ⟩ = ∫ d x q d x q ˉ ψ ( x q ) P ( x q , x q ˉ ) exp [ i P ( x q + x q ˉ ) /2 ] { − 2 1 ( x q + x q ˉ ) E P Φ ( P ) − 2 1 i ∂ x [ α 1 , Φ ( P ) ] + 4 1 x P { α 1 , Φ ( P ) } − 2 1 x m { γ 0 , Φ ( P ) } − 2 1 i [ α 1 , Φ ( P ) ] } ψ ( x q ˉ ) ∣0 ⟩ (120)
According to Eq. (A.93) of [13 ] the BSE (22) implies
− i 2 x ∂ x [ α 1 , Φ ( P ) ] + 1 4 x P { α 1 , Φ ( P ) } − 1 2 x m { γ 0 , Φ ( P ) } = i x P E P − V ∂ x Φ ( P ) − i V ′ x 2 ( E P − V ) [ α 1 , Φ ( P ) ] (121) -\frac{i}{2}x\partial_x[\alpha_1,\Phi^{(P)}]+\frac{1}{4}xP\{\alpha_1,\Phi^{(P)}\}-\frac{1}{2}xm\{\gamma^0,\Phi^{(P)}\}=\frac{ixP}{E_P-V}\partial_x\Phi^{(P)}-\frac{iV'x}{2(E_P-V)}[\alpha_1,\Phi^{(P)}] \tag*{(121)} − 2 i x ∂ x [ α 1 , Φ ( P ) ] + 4 1 x P { α 1 , Φ ( P ) } − 2 1 x m { γ 0 , Φ ( P ) } = E P − V i x P ∂ x Φ ( P ) − 2 ( E P − V ) i V ′ x [ α 1 , Φ ( P ) ] (121)
Use this in (C.9) to obtain
M ^ 01 ∣ M , P ⟩ = ∫ d x q d x q ˉ ψ ˉ ( x q ) P ( x q , x q ˉ ) exp [ i P ( x q + x q ˉ ) / 2 ] { − 1 2 ( x q + x q ˉ ) E P Φ ( P ) + i x P E P − V ∂ x Φ ( P ) − i E P 2 ( E P − V ) [ α 1 , Φ ( P ) ] } ψ ( x q ˉ ) ∣ 0 ⟩ (122) \widehat{M}^{01}|M,P\rangle=\int dx_qdx_{\bar q}\bar{\psi}(x_q)\mathbb{P}(x_q,x_{\bar q})\exp[iP(x_q+x_{\bar q})/2]\left\{-\frac{1}{2}(x_q+x_{\bar q})E_P\Phi^{(P)}+\frac{ixP}{E_P-V}\partial_x\Phi^{(P)}-\frac{iE_P}{2(E_P-V)}[\alpha_1,\Phi^{(P)}]\right\}\psi(x_{\bar q})|0\rangle \tag*{(122)} M 01 ∣ M , P ⟩ = ∫ d x q d x q ˉ ψ ˉ ( x q ) P ( x q , x q ˉ ) exp [ i P ( x q + x q ˉ ) /2 ] { − 2 1 ( x q + x q ˉ ) E P Φ ( P ) + E P − V i x P ∂ x Φ ( P ) − 2 ( E P − V ) i E P [ α 1 , Φ ( P ) ] } ψ ( x q ˉ ) ∣0 ⟩ (122)
From the definition of M ^ 01 \widehat{M}^{01} M 01 in (B.4), using ∂ ξ P = E P \partial_\xi P=E_P ∂ ξ P = E P ,
U t x ( δ ξ ) ∣ M , P ⟩ = ( 1 − i δ ξ M ^ 01 ) ∣ M , P ⟩ (123) U_{tx}(\delta\xi)|M,P\rangle=(1-i\delta\xi\widehat{M}^{01})|M,P\rangle \tag*{(123)} U t x ( δ ξ ) ∣ M , P ⟩ = ( 1 − i δ ξ M 01 ) ∣ M , P ⟩ (123)
− i M ^ 01 ∣ M , P ⟩ = δ δ ξ ∣ M , P ⟩ = δ δ ξ ∫ d x q d x q ˉ ψ ˉ ( x q ) P exp [ i g ∫ x q ˉ x q d x A a ( x ) T a ] exp [ i 2 P ( x q + x q ˉ ) ] Φ ( P ) ( x q − x q ˉ ) ψ ( x q ˉ ) ∣ 0 ⟩ = ∫ d x q d x q ˉ ψ ˉ ( x q ) P exp [ i g ∫ x q ˉ x q d x A a ( x ) T a ] exp [ i P ( x q + x q ˉ ) / 2 ] { i 2 E P ( x q + x q ˉ ) Φ ( P ) + ∂ ξ Φ ( P ) } ψ ( x q ˉ ) ∣ 0 ⟩ (124) \begin{aligned}
-i\widehat{M}^{01}|M,P\rangle=\frac{\delta}{\delta\xi}|M,P\rangle=\frac{\delta}{\delta\xi}\int dx_qdx_{\bar q}\bar{\psi}(x_q)\mathbb{P}\exp\left[ig\int_{x_{\bar q}}^{x_q}dx\,A_a(x)T_a\right]\exp\left[\frac{i}{2}P(x_q+x_{\bar q})\right]\Phi^{(P)}(x_q-x_{\bar q})\psi(x_{\bar q})|0\rangle\\
&=\int dx_qdx_{\bar q}\bar{\psi}(x_q)\mathbb{P}\exp\left[ig\int_{x_{\bar q}}^{x_q}dx\,A_a(x)T_a\right]\exp[iP(x_q+x_{\bar q})/2]\left\{\frac{i}{2}E_P(x_q+x_{\bar q})\Phi^{(P)}+\partial_\xi\Phi^{(P)}\right\}\psi(x_{\bar q})|0\rangle \tag*{(124)}
\end{aligned} − i M 01 ∣ M , P ⟩ = δ ξ δ ∣ M , P ⟩ = δ ξ δ ∫ d x q d x q ˉ ψ ˉ ( x q ) P exp [ i g ∫ x q ˉ x q d x A a ( x ) T a ] exp [ 2 i P ( x q + x q ˉ ) ] Φ ( P ) ( x q − x q ˉ ) ψ ( x q ˉ ) ∣0 ⟩ = ∫ d x q d x q ˉ ψ ˉ ( x q ) P exp [ i g ∫ x q ˉ x q d x A a ( x ) T a ] exp [ i P ( x q + x q ˉ ) /2 ] { 2 i E P ( x q + x q ˉ ) Φ ( P ) + ∂ ξ Φ ( P ) } ψ ( x q ˉ ) ∣0 ⟩ (124)
Comparing with (C.11) implies that M ^ 01 \widehat{M}^{01} M 01 generates the following change of Φ ( P ) ( x ) \Phi^{(P)}(x) Φ ( P ) ( x ) ,
∂ ξ Φ ( P ) ( x ) = x P E P − V ∂ x Φ ( P ) − E P 2 ( E P − V ) [ α 1 , Φ ( P ) ] (125) \partial_\xi\Phi^{(P)}(x)=\frac{xP}{E_P-V}\partial_x\Phi^{(P)}-\frac{E_P}{2(E_P-V)}[\alpha_1,\Phi^{(P)}] \tag*{(125)} ∂ ξ Φ ( P ) ( x ) = E P − V x P ∂ x Φ ( P ) − 2 ( E P − V ) E P [ α 1 , Φ ( P ) ] (125)
This agrees with Eq. (7.32) of [13 ] , which was derived from the P P P -dependence of the solution of the BSE. Hence the P P P -dependence induced by the boost agrees with that implied by the BSE (22) , confirming the analysis in [16 ] .
References