WorksPhysics and Astronomy
Discrete time liquids
Abstract
Discrete time crystals exhibit robust subharmonic oscillations, spontaneously breaking the discrete time-translation symmetry of a periodic drive. Since their emergence, the question of whether other types of temporal many-body order can exist has attracted considerable attention. Here we identify discrete time liquids – a new form of spatiotemporal order characterized by short-range temporal coherence as a result of time-solitons. We study a two-dimensional spin system coupled to a finite-temperature cavity, whose fluctuations provide a noisy, approximately periodic drive with only finite temporal coherence. Remarkably, the spins nevertheless form a metastable state with robust period-doubled dynamics over an extended parameter regime. Unlike a time crystal, this state has only finite temporal coherence: individual trajectories stochastically switch between the two symmetry-related temporal configurations of the period-doubled response. We identify these switches as time-solitons: topological defects in temporal order that preserve local period doubling while destroying long-range temporal coherence, thereby producing the time liquid state. We propose a minimal model which reproduces the distribution of temporal correlations of the many-body system, suggesting a general description of the time liquid as a time crystal with a finite density of time-solitons. Because these solitons can occur at arbitrary times, ensemble averaging restores continuous time-translation symmetry, raising the intriguing possibility that discrete time liquids can exist in thermal equilibrium.
Introduction
Fluctuations are usually regarded as an enemy of order. In spatially ordered phases, they blur static patterns and can forbid long-range order in low dimensions [1, 2]; in dynamical systems, they dephase coherent motion and broaden sharp spectral features [3, 4]. Nevertheless, fluctuations can also play a constructive role. In order by disorder, fluctuations select ordered states that are not preferred at the mean-field level [5, 6]. In stochastic and coherence resonances, fluctuations optimize the response of nonlinear dynamical systems [7, 8, 9]. Both of these cases show that fluctuations can also create regularity rather than merely destroy it. This idea has recently expanded into the field of cavity-matter hybrids [10, 11, 12, 13]. There, the goal is to generate new phases of matter by amplifying electromagnetic fluctuations around a two-dimensional heterostructure through nanopatterning of the electromagnetic environment. In this article, we find that fluctuations not only generate new spatially coherent phases of matter, but can also give rise to many-body temporal order, producing what we term discrete time liquids.
Over the past decade, quantum many-body systems have been shown to support robust phases of matter with temporal order known as time crystals. In a conventional discrete time crystal (DTC), an externally imposed periodic drive defines a discrete time-translation symmetry, which the many-body system spontaneously breaks by locking local observables to a robust subharmonic response [14]. Such order has been established in many-body-localized, prethermal, classical Floquet and driven-dissipative systems [15, 16, 17, 18, 19, 20, 21, 22, 23, 24, 25, 26, 27]. In most realizations, however, the temporal structure is supplied by an external drive that is, to a good approximation, perfectly periodic. A schematic
time-crystal evolution for ferromagnetically interacting spins is generated over one period of unit length by
which combines ferromagnetic interactions with a global spin flip. The periodic drive therefore provides a coherent clock against which the subharmonic response is defined. This raises an intriguing question: can temporal order emerge out of noise? To study this question we consider the consequences of coupling a set of spins to a finite-temperature cavity mode (see Figure 1). Thermal fluctuations of the cavity generate an approximately periodic signal centered at the cavity frequency. Fluctuations in its amplitude and phase, however, cause this signal to lose temporal coherence beyond a characteristic autocorrelation time. One might therefore expect any induced temporal order to disappear on the same timescale. Instead, we find that the spins enter a long-lived metastable state with a sharp period-doubled response at half the cavity frequency (Figure 1(b)). This response persists far beyond the coherence time of the cavity itself (Figure 3).

Figure 1. Time liquid in a cavity. (a) Schematic of the setup and three regimes reached by increasing bath temperature. A spin lattice is coupled to a cavity mode of frequency and damping rate , which is in contact with a thermal bath at temperature (color bar). The thermal fluctuations of the oscillator coordinate act on the spins as an effective drive. Each row illustrates the dynamics at the temperature of the corresponding dashed line in (b). At low temperature (blue), the effective drive is too weak to disturb the spins, which precess freely. At intermediate temperature (orange), the spins lock to a sharp subharmonic response at half the cavity frequency. At high temperature (red), the drive is too strong and the dynamics becomes disordered. Period-doubled order therefore emerges only at intermediate bath temperature. (b) Spin response amplitude as a function of frequency and bath temperature , at , , and . The subharmonic response at appears within a finite window of bath temperature and vanishes at both small and large . The period doubling is thus induced by thermal noise. (c) Phase diagram as a function of the cavity coherence time and the bath temperature , at and . We identify four regimes. At low temperature, the spins precess freely because the effective drive is too weak to disturb them. At high temperature, the dynamics is disordered and the period doubling is lost within a few cavity periods. In between, the system forms a DTC or a DTL, according to whether the correlation time is comparable to or much shorter than the thermalization time (see “Phase classification” in Methods). The DTC appears in an intermediate temperature window that’s getting narrower as the coherence time decreases and disappears below . The DTL, in contrast, persists at every coherence time shown. A short coherence time of the cavity mode therefore turns the DTC into a DTL. Panels (b) and (c) share , , , , stroboscopic periods, and noise realizations. See text for details.

Figure 3. Time-solitons and time liquid lifetime. (a) Single-trajectory stroboscopic magnetization (blue) and its period-doubled component (red), at (top) and 200 (bottom). The dashed line marks . The period-doubled component is repeatedly suppressed and revives with the opposite sign. Each such event is a time-soliton, the event of Eq. (2). (b) Thermalization time (circles), noise averaged single-trajectory correlation time (diamonds), and ensemble correlation time (squares), as a function of the coherence time . The heatmap gives the fraction of noise realizations per correlation time at fixed . The three time scales converge at long , where solitons are rare. They separate as at short , where solitons proliferate. Solitons thus destroy long-range temporal coherence. (c) Windowed subharmonic weight of Eq. (11), measured in a window opened at period , for the two coherence times of (a). The dashed and dash-dotted lines indicate and . Shaded areas mark the standard error over realizations. The weight stays finite in windows opened far beyond and falls to zero only near . Period doubling is therefore re-established after every time-soliton and lost only when the lattice thermalizes. All panels share , , , , , , , and . See text for details.
Despite the presence of a sharp subharmonic response, the state lacks the long-range temporal coherence of a time crystal. Instead, it can be viewed as a DTC containing a finite density of time-solitons. Individual trajectories exhibit long intervals of period-doubled dynamics, interrupted by stochastic switches between the two equivalent temporal configurations. We identify these switches as time-solitons: topological defects in temporal order that locally shift the phase of the period-doubled response. Their finite density destroys long-range temporal coherence while preserving local time-crystalline order. We term this defect-rich state a discrete time liquid (DTL), in analogy with the melting of a spatial crystal whose long-range order is destroyed by the proliferation of topological defects [28]. This picture motivates a minimal stochastic deformation of the DTC evolution in Eq. (1),
where sets the density of time-solitons: with probability , the usual spin flip is replaced by a rotation, producing a switch between the two temporal configurations. We show that this minimal stochastic-switching model reproduces not only the qualitative phenomenology of the cavity-spin system, but also quantitatively matches the distribution of its temporal correlations.
The DTL regime emerges only once thermal fluctuations become strong enough to switch the interaction and the transverse field on and off out-of-phase within a single cavity cycle. This leads to a threshold temperature for the onset of period-doubled order. Counterintuitively, temporal order therefore appears upon heating, providing yet another example in which noise promotes order rather than destroying it. Many-body interactions, in turn, stabilize the resulting state, allowing the DTL phase to persist over a broad temperature window, as shown in the phase diagram (Figure 1(c)).
Spins coupled to a thermal cavity mode
We consider a two-dimensional spin lattice coupled to a single damped cavity mode, which we model as a harmonic oscillator in contact with a thermal bath at temperature (sketched in Figure 1(a)). Crucially, no external periodic drive is applied, so that the thermal fluctuations of the bath are the only time-dependent input to the total system. To access long-time dynamics at large system sizes, we treat the spins classically and consider the spin Hamiltonian:
where denote nearest-neighbor pairs on an square lattice with periodic boundary conditions, is the -component of the classical unit spin at site , is the bare Ising coupling, is the bare transverse-field strength, is the cavity oscillator coordinate, and is the spin–cavity coupling. The cavity coordinate obeys the Langevin equation [29]:
where is the damping rate, is the natural frequency of the cavity, and is Gaussian white noise with zero mean and correlator . The noise strength is fixed by the bath temperature, with the oscillator mass and the linear system size (see the microscopic derivation in the Supplemental Material (SM) [29]). In the underdamped regime , the cavity mode acts as a spectral filter for the white noise. As a result, the thermal fluctuations of the bath generate an approximately periodic signal around the damped frequency , with period . This signal therefore acts on the spins as an effective, noisy periodic drive. Unlike the externally imposed periodic drive of a Floquet DTC [14, 16, 18], its amplitude is set by the bath temperature, and its phase stays coherent only over a finite coherence time of the cavity mode. Throughout, “drive” refers to this effective drive. In the following, we show that it can induce temporal order in the spin lattice.
Period doubling induced by thermal noise
We first establish the connection to the standard DTC of Eq. (1). For times short compared with the coherence time of the mode, [29], the oscillator coordinate takes the form , with a slowly varying amplitude and phase . The typical amplitude grows with the bath temperature, , where is a reference temperature [29]. When , the interaction and the transverse field in Eq. (4) are switched on out-of-phase. The dynamics over one period then approximately reproduce the kicked evolution of Eq. (1), the model underlying Floquet DTCs [14, 16, 18]. We thus set , so that the spins rotate by per period, with a fixed deviation from the ideal kick. The bath temperature then controls how closely the thermal fluctuations realize this kicked evolution: a weak drive cannot separate the interaction from the transverse field in time, whereas a strong drive is too erratic. Period-doubled order is therefore expected to emerge only at intermediate bath temperatures.
To test this expectation, we start from the extremely underdamped regime, , which is longer than the observation window of stroboscopic periods. The phase is then effectively fixed in each realization, and the amplitude is the dominant stochastic variable. To quantify the response, we consider the stroboscopic spin magnetization , , and the Fourier transform of its noise average, . Here, denotes the average over noise realizations. The transform , is the discrete counterpart of , with the dimensionless frequency, so that carries units of time. We initialize the lattice close to full polarization along , tilting each spin by a small random angle within a cone of half-angle . This tilt mimics the thermal fluctuations of a physical spin system and shows the robustness of the temporal order to different initial conditions. We then solve the coupled dynamics numerically (see “Initial conditions and simulation parameters” in Methods). Indeed, the subharmonic response at emerges within a finite window of bath temperature (see the bright vertical stripe in Figure 1(b)). It is absent at low , where side peaks reflect the precessional dynamics, and it is washed out at high , where the noise is too strong. More intuitively, at high the local field inherits a large amplitude from . A tiny spatial difference in the spin configuration then produces a large difference in the local field, which in turn amplifies the spatial difference after a short time. As a result, at high the spin lattice develops chaotic dynamics and loses temporal order (top row of Figure 1(a)).
We note that the period-doubled response at intermediate bath temperature is absent from the drive, which carries weight only near [29]. The response is also robust against randomness in the initial spin configuration and against perturbations of the kick deviation [29]. The period-doubled signal is therefore generated by the spin lattice, not inherited from the drive. To understand its origin, we compare the stochastic dynamics with a deterministic reference drive in Figure 2.

Figure 2. Thermal fluctuations as an effective Floquet drive. Columns compare a deterministic reference drive (a,d,g), in which the oscillator is replaced by a sinusoid, with single realizations of the bath-driven dynamics at a small temperature (b,e,h, shaded in blue) and at a temperature inside the ordering window (c,f,i, shaded in orange). (a–c) Oscillator coordinate , which sets the instantaneous interaction and transverse field, with gray dots marking its stroboscopic values. The deterministic drive is a sinusoid of fixed amplitude (a), whereas the stochastic drive is a small (b) or a large (c) fluctuating signal. The bath temperature thus sets the amplitude of the drive. (d–f) Corresponding spin response . The deterministic drive gives long-lived period doubling (d). The weak stochastic drive produces a response close to the free precession of the undriven spin lattice, with no period doubling left after periods (e). The large stochastic drive sustains period doubling beyond periods (f). A stochastic drive of sufficient amplitude therefore reproduces the long-lived period doubling of the deterministic drive. (g) Correlation time of Eq. (6) for the deterministic drive, over the plane of kick deviation and drive amplitude . The cross marks the drive involved in (a,d), with and . Long-lived period doubling appears in a broad region in , so the DTC does not require fine tuning of the drive amplitude. (h,i) Per-cycle effective drive parameters of the realizations in (b) and (c) (see “Per-cycle effective drive parameters” in Methods), overlaid on the contour of (g). This contour separates the DTC band from the surrounding region of short-lived period doubling. The per-cycle effective drive parameters lie below the band at (h) and fall within it at (i). Period doubling therefore appears when the per-cycle cloud overlaps the DTC band, which explains the …
To this end, we replace the oscillator by the deterministic drive with fixed amplitude and phase , i.e., the monochromatic limit of the stochastic signal (see Figure 2(a)). This reference drive plays the role of the externally imposed drive of a Floquet DTC and is not part of the cavity-spin system. The lifetime of the period doubling depends on , but this dependence weakens as the drive frequency increases [29]. We set , where the lifetime is longest. To measure how long the period doubling persists, we use the normalized staggered magnetization , which stays at for an ideal period-doubled response. We then define the correlation time
over which a trajectory keeps the memory of its initial subharmonic phase. For an exponential decay, with , Eq. (6) returns the decay time. Equivalently, is the height of the subharmonic peak of the Fourier transform used in Figure 1(b), normalized by the initial magnetization. Evaluating over a grid of gives the DTC phase diagram of Figure 2(g), in which the bright band marks a long-lived subharmonic response, with typical dynamics shown in Figure 2(d). As in prethermal DTCs [20, 30, 31], grows exponentially with the drive frequency [29].
With the reference phase diagram of Figure 2(g) at hand, we now turn to the stochastic drive. At a low temperature, , the drive amplitude is small (Figure 2(b)), so that the drive cannot separate the interaction from the transverse field in time. The response then stays close to the free precession of the undriven lattice (Figure 2(e)), which gives the side peaks in Figure 1(b). To compare such a stochastic drive with the deterministic one, we assign to every cavity cycle an effective kick deviation and an effective drive amplitude (see “Per-cycle effective drive parameters” in Methods). Each realization thereby becomes a cloud of points in the plane of Figure 2(g). At low temperature, this cloud lies far below the DTC band (Figure 2(h)). Increasing the temperature pushes the cloud upward, since the drive amplitude follows a Rayleigh distribution with [29]. This distribution is broad, so that the amplitude differs strongly between realizations. The DTC band of Figure 2(g), however, is broad in as well, a consequence of the many-body interactions. In an intermediate temperature window the two therefore overlap substantially, and the period doubling survives without any fine tuning of its amplitude. Indeed, at the drive is a strong fluctuating signal (Figure 2(c)) whose cloud sits inside the DTC band (Figure 2(i)). The period doubling then persists beyond a thousand cycles (Figure 2(f)).
doubling grows exponentially with the cavity frequency [29], we take a high cavity frequency, , and a small kick deviation, . We fix the bath temperature at , well inside the ordered region of Figure 2(g). We then analyze the period-doubled response as a function of the cavity coherence time . Figure 3(a) shows the single-trajectory dynamics at two coherence times. The period-doubled component is repeatedly suppressed and revives with the opposite sign. Once the phase of has drifted by half a period, the lattice rebuilds its subharmonic response against the new phase. The two period-doubled configurations are thereby exchanged. We identify each such
Time-solitons and the discrete time liquid
We now consider the consequence of a short coherence time of the cavity mode on the temporal order. This finite coherence time has no counterpart in an externally imposed periodic drive. To see this effect, we first make the spin order as robust as possible. Since the lifetime of the period
@endsection event as a time-soliton, the event of Eq. (2), occurring at a time set by the noise. What limits the temporal order is therefore the proliferation of time-solitons, not the loss of period doubling.
To distinguish different ways of losing the temporal order, we use the normalized staggered magnetization of Eq. (6), which satisfy in every realization. We introduce the thermalization time and two correlation times before and after ensemble averaging. We define the correlation time of the ensemble-averaged response as:
where we average the staggered magnetization first and then compute its correlation time. Then we define the averaged single-trajectory correlation time, , where we compute the correlation time of Eq. (6) for each individual trajectory, and then average over trajectories. Finally, we define the thermalization time as the overall decay of magnetization irrespective of the sign, which captures the loss of spatial order due to the slow heating,
Here, is insensitive to the subharmonic phase and measures how long the period doubling survives. In contrast, measures how long one realization spends in its dominant crystalline configuration, and measures how long the ensemble shares a phase. The three obey the inequality , with equality when no soliton occurs within the
prethermal window. In the presence of time-solitons, the three time scales separate.
Figure 3(b) shows the three time scales defined above as a function of the cavity coherence time . We see that the thermalization time depends only weakly on . As in DTCs, the thermalization time is mainly controlled by the cavity frequency. We show its scaling with the cavity frequency in the SM [29]. As mentioned earlier, the single-trajectory correlation time in Figure 3(b) lies in between the other two scales. Its distribution over trajectories is shown by the green density plot in Figure 3(b).
To check quantitatively whether this distribution of correlation times can be captured by a simpler model that contains only uncorrelated time-solitons, we propose a classical version of the quantum toy model of Eq. (2), described as:
where is a random variable that flips sign with probability in each period:
Using this model, we show in the Methods that the density of time-solitons, , is determined by the flip probability, , and that the ensemble correlation time is . Remarkably, despite its simplicity this model reproduces the full probability distribution of the single-trajectory correlation time of the many-body cavity-spin system, as shown in Figure 4. To obtain this agreement, we only match and between the toy model and the full simulation (see SM [29] for more evidence at other values of ). This agreement provides confidence that the time-soliton description captures the dynamics of the DTL. Finally, we show in Figure 3(b) that the correlation time of the averaged subharmonic response matches the coherence time of the cavity mode, in the limit of . This implies that the cavity lifetime directly specifies the density of time-solitons as . In the other limit of , saturates to the thermalization time ; here, the spatial order is lost before a single time-soliton has time to occur. The system then keeps a single subharmonic phase throughout its lifetime, which is the defining property of a prethermal DTC. The DTC and the DTL are therefore distinguished by the number of time-solitons within the lifetime, .

Figure 4. Distribution of the single-trajectory correlation time. Probability of the single-trajectory correlation time of Eq. (6), for the cavity-spin system (green histogram) and for the toy model of Eqs. (9) and (10) (dashed line), at . The toy parameters are not fitted: is the value measured on the lattice, and the soliton density follows from the measured , which gives (top). The vertical lines mark , , and from the line cut at in Figure 3(b). The toy model reproduces the probability distribution and thus captures the dynamics of the DTL in cavity-spin system. Parameters are as in Figure 3. See text for details.
We further test the time-soliton picture in the cavity-spin system. Equations (9) and (10) predict that a time-soliton affects only the phase of the subharmonic response and leaves its amplitude intact, up to an overall extremely slow thermalization decay. To test this, we measure the local period-doubled order in a window of periods opened at the stroboscopic period ,
Because it averages the product of two magnetizations, never refers to the subharmonic phase of any single realization. It therefore still registers period doubling after the solitons have scrambled that phase across the ensemble. As shown in Figure 3(c), the weight stays large in windows opened far beyond and falls only near the thermalization time . At this time, the lattice has absorbed enough energy to melt the spatial order and completely lose the period doubling. Time-solitons only reset the phase of the subharmonic response and leave its amplitude approximately intact for times between and .
Experimental observability
In ultracold atoms, our proposal is closely related to optically driven Bose gases coupled to an optical cavity [32]. In this geometry, an off-resonant laser typically pumps the Bose–Einstein condensate directly, but the cavity mode can instead be pumped. Driving the cavity directly with white noise at ultralow temperature would then realize our model, with the noise amplitude playing the role of the bath temperature in our calculation.
In condensed matter, a promising platform involves surface phonon polaritons (SPPs), which host ultrastrong electric-field fluctuations [10, 11, 12, 33, 34]. Although noise from SPPs involves multiple modes, the fluctuations are laterally coherent over a distance for a two-dimensional layer located a distance from the interface. Our model could therefore be realized using a two-dimensional array of dipoles with ferroelectric interactions at this separation. The electric-field fluctuations experienced by the dipoles scale as [10, 11, 12, 33, 34], where is the electric field, the SPP frequency, the vacuum permittivity, Boltzmann’s constant, temperature, the Bose–Einstein distribution and the reduced Planck constant. These fluctuations can be comparable to the dipoles’ internal dynamics, as required by our model [12].
For both platforms, the main challenge is engineering the prescribed coupling of the cavity to both the interaction and kick terms. As in DTC experiments, we expect our model to be one example of a broader class exhibiting DTL order. In particular, we expect that any DTC model featuring a probabilistic switch as described in Eq. (2) would lead to DTL phenomenology.
In both platforms, the main observable is the locking of spin–spin correlation functions to half the cavity frequency as a function of fluctuation amplitude. Cavity-coupled cold gases are particularly attractive because individual trajectories can be imaged, allowing time-solitons to be resolved and their distribution functions measured.
Outlook
In this article, we demonstrate a new form of temporal order, in which robust subharmonic frequency locking coexists with only short-range temporal coherence. This combination arises from the presence of temporal topological defects, which disrupt long-range coherence but preserve the characteristic subharmonic response.
Our results establish a connection between many-body temporal order and cavity–matter hybrids. Considerable efforts have been devoted to reaching the ultrastrong light–matter coupling regime [35], yet the novel collective phenomena that may emerge in this regime remain largely unexplored. Here, we show that even a relatively simple system of interacting two-dimensional spins coupled to a cavity can exhibit unconventional dynamics governed by temporal order. This suggests that temporal ordering phenomena may play an important role in more complex cavity–matter systems, including electrons in a material lattice coupled ultrastrongly to light.
From the perspective of temporal order, our results point towards a broader landscape of discrete time liquids (DTLs). The fact that the complex spin–cavity dynamics can be captured by a simple toy model governed by a single parameter, the time-soliton density, suggests that the phase studied here may belong to a broader universality class. More generally, DTLs may emerge through different mechanisms and exhibit distinct universality classes, potentially determined by the symmetries and correlations of their temporal defects. Two particularly promising directions for realizing such distinct classes are fluctuating quasiperiodic driving and spin–cavity backaction [36]. In the former, multiple incommensurate cavity frequencies could introduce additional synthetic dimensions [37, 38], potentially allowing for higher-dimensional temporal topological defects beyond the isolated time-solitons considered here. In the latter, backaction could mediate interactions between time-solitons, introducing correlations that enhance or suppress temporal coherence. Both mechanisms could thus give rise to DTLs with qualitatively different defect structures and collective dynamics. The possible existence of distinct DTL universality classes further raises the question of whether sharp transitions between temporal phases exhibit universal critical behaviour, analogous to phase transitions in spatially ordered systems.
Finally, the most striking aspect of DTLs, both quantum and classical, is the idea that a DTC with a finite density of topological time defects can restore time-translation symmetry on average. This restoration opens a pathway for temporal order to emerge in thermal equilibrium, thereby circumventing the standard no-go theorems [39, 40] that prohibit conventional time crystals in equilibrium in closed isolated systems. At the same time, the resulting phase retains many of the defining features of time-crystalline behavior, effectively bringing temporal order into the realm of equilibrium thermodynamics.
Methods
Model and equations of motion
We numerically simulate the dynamics of the two-dimensional classical spin model with Hamiltonian of Eq. (3), with the oscillator coordinate generated from the Langevin equation of Eq. (5). The resulting classical spin dynamics obeys
where is the local field and denotes the four nearest neighbors of site on the periodic square lattice. We use units with and keep , and fixed throughout. The backaction of the spins on the oscillator is neglected, so that can be generated independently of the spin configuration. Consequences of the back-action are discussed in the SM [29].
For the stochastic simulations, we adjust the bare oscillator frequency for each damping rate such that the damped oscillation frequency satisfies
This choice fixes the oscillation period at throughout the damping-rate sweeps. We generate an independent realization of from Eq. (5) for each realization of the Gaussian noise. For the deterministic reference calculations behind Figure 2, we instead use the sinusoidal signal with fixed amplitude .
Numerical integration
We integrate Eq. (12) by a splitting between the transverse-field and interaction terms of Eq. (3). Within each time step , every spin is rotated about the axis by , then about its local axis by , and then about the axis by again. The Langevin equation, Eq. (5), is propagated on the same grid, with the noise sampled as , , and held constant within the step. The noise is generated independently at each step and for every noise realization. With small enough , this trotterization method gives converged dynamics as we show in the SM [29].
Initial conditions and simulation parameters
We initialize each spin independently and uniformly within a spherical cap of half-angle about the axis:
where and . The cap half-angle sets how far the initial state departs from the perfectly polarized configuration, which is recovered at . We use in each figure of the main text, so that the lattice starts close to the ordered configuration of the Ising interaction. Before initiating the spin dynamics, we evolve the oscillator from for a time to approach its stationary state.
We resolve the cavity period with at least 20 time steps, so that at , at , and at . We record periods in every run. Noise averages are taken over independent noise realizations.
Per-cycle effective drive parameters
To compare a stochastic drive with the deterministic drive , we assign to cycle the effective kick deviation and amplitude
Here, is the deviation of the spin rotation accumulated in cycle from . The amplitude is the root-mean-square of over the cycle, normalized such that for a pure tone . A deterministic drive therefore maps to the single point in every cycle. For the stochastic drive, gives . In the underdamped limit, follows the Rayleigh distribution of the drive amplitude. We analytically derive this result in the SM [29].
Toy model of time-solitons
In the toy model of Eqs. (9) and (10), a time-soliton occurs independently in each period with probability . Neighboring solitons are therefore separated by periods on average, and the density of time-solitons is . In the limit of and , Eq. (7) gives
We fix by this relation with the values of and measured in the cavity-spin system, so that the toy model has no free parameter.
The single-trajectory correlation time is , with , , and . Here, are the periods at which solitons occur. Since , with sharing the same probability distribution with , the cumulative probability distribution obeys
We solve Eq. (18) iteratively and construct the probability distribution of and (more details are found in the SM [29]).
Phase classification
Each point in the map of Figure 1(c) is classified by the correlation time of Eq. (6), the thermalization time of Eq. (8), and the precession weight
where runs over a reference window of 100 periods starting at . The weight approaches unity when oscillates down to and vanishes otherwise. We first identify the boundary of free precession as the lowest temperature at which has fallen to its high-temperature floor. We then label the remaining points as disordered when . All of the remaining points show local temporal order. We label them a DTC if exceeds 0.418, and a DTL otherwise. More details on the phase classification approach can be found in the SM [29].
Data availability.—The data and code associated with this manuscript are deposited in DOI: 10.5281/zenodo.23168407. Automatic access is restricted; access credentials will be provided to human researchers upon reasonable request via Zenodo for academic and verification purposes.
Acknowledgments.—We thank Duillio De Santis, Hope Bretcher and Sambuddha Chattopadhyay for valuable discussions. The authors used Claude Opus 5.5 during the preparation of this manuscript to assist with code optimization and to improve the readability of the manuscript. The authors assume full responsibility for the scientific content, accuracy, and integrity of this paper.
Funded by the Deutsche Forschungsgemeinschaft (DFG, German Research Foundation) – Project number 579633640 (Emmy Noether Programme, “Light–Matter Hybrids”). Funded by the European Union (ERC, QuSimCtrl, 101113633). Views and opinions expressed are, however, those of the authors only and do not necessarily reflect those of the European Union or the European Research Council Executive Agency. Neither the European Union nor the granting authority can be held responsible for them. Z.W. acknowledges financial support from the China Scholarship Council (CSC, No. 202506750006) and the NKRPDCC (Grant No. 2022YFA1405304).
Author contributions.—M.H.M. conceived the research with M.B.; Z.W. set up the theoretical framework and performed the numerical simulations with support from P.M.S., M.B., and M.H.M. M.H.M. supervised the project with support from M.B. All authors contributed to interpreting the data. Z.W. and M.H.M. wrote the manuscript with input from P.M.S. and M.B.
Competing Interests Statement.—The authors declare no competing interests.
This Supplemental Material collects the derivations and diagnostics behind the main-text results. Sections S1 and S2 derive oscillator Langevin equation, Eq. (5), by eliminating the bath and give the stationary statistics of the filtered drive. Sections S3 and S4 show the robustness of the response and compare the drive and response spectra behind Figure 1. Sections S5 and S6 give the prethermal lifetime scaling at long and at short coherence times of the cavity mode. Section S7 shows how the drive phase affects the lifetime of the deterministic DTC of Figure 2. Section S8 derives the time scales of the toy model of Eqs. (9) and (10) and the distribution of single-trajectory correlations times behind Figure 4. Section S9 gives the numerical details and checks behind the phase diagram of Figure 1(c). Sections S10 and S11 discuss the spin backaction on the oscillator and the numerical methods.
Langevin equation from thermal bath
We derive the oscillator Langevin equation by eliminating the bath, following the standard treatment of a coordinate coupled to a harmonic reservoir [41].
Bath model and Langevin equation
The reservoir is a set of harmonic modes (coordinates , momenta , masses , frequencies ) coupled linearly to with strengths , plus a counterterm cancelling the bath-induced frequency shift,
The bare oscillator is ( conjugate to , mass , natural frequency ), coupled to the spins through . Here is the intensive coordinate normalized in Sec. C, the coupling strength, and (Eq. (S.11)) the extensive spin combination modulating and . Hamilton’s equations give
Each bath mode (Eq. (S.4)) is driven by ; integrating from an initial time ,
with the free evolution of mode ,
set by the initial data , . Inserting Eq. Eq. (S.5) into Eq. Eq. (S.3) and integrating the memory term by parts, the instantaneous piece cancels the counterterm, leaving the generalized Langevin equation
with kernel and bath force . A boundary term has been dropped ().
Markovian limit and fluctuation–dissipation
When the bath correlation time is short, is nearly constant over the memory range of and the integral becomes local,
defining the damping rate ; equivalently , the factor of two from the one-sided integral (). Equation Eq. (S.7) becomes
In thermal equilibrium at temperature the modes are independent, with , , and zero means and cross-correlation ( Boltzmann’s constant). Then is zero-mean Gaussian and, from Eq. Eq. (S.6), obeys the classical fluctuation–dissipation relation . In the Markovian limit it is white,
Equations Eqs. (S.9)–(S.10) govern the extensive coordinate ; its intensive form follows in § 8 C.
Thermodynamic limit
The oscillator is a single cavity mode, , whereas the spin combination it couples to,
the part of (Eq. Eq. (3)) multiplying , is extensive: ( spins). At fixed photon density the mode amplitude scales as , so we use the intensive coordinate and per-spin force
both , with the instantaneous configuration. The coupling is then extensive while the modulation stays . Dividing Eq. Eq. (S.9) by (with ) gives
with backaction. The intensive noise is white by Eq. Eq. (S.10), the rescaling its strength by :
the noise strength below Eq. Eq. (5). Equivalently, the drive amplitude is tuned in the main text, with the reference temperature used on the figure axes. Dropping the backaction recovers Eq. Eq. (5), .
Stationary statistics of the filtered drive
We derive the Rayleigh-amplitude, uniform-phase form of . Without backaction Eq. Eq. (5) is linear; with ,
with . For , coarse-grained over , we write in quadratures,
where are slowly varying (scale ) Gaussian processes. In the stationary limit they are independent, zero-mean, and of equal variance,
with
using Eq. Eq. (S.14). This variance is exact, fixed by equipartition: and ; sets the oscillator, not the amplitude scale. With , ,
with uniform on and the amplitude Rayleigh-distributed,
The drive strength thus vanishes as and grows without bound at large . These two limits bounding the ordering window of Figure 1(b). Over times , and are frozen, so the spins see a quasi-monochromatic drive of random amplitude and phase.
Since the Green function of Eq. (5) carries the envelope , the stationary correlation of the mode decays as . The time that the mode keeps the memory of its phase is therefore
which we call coherence time in the main text.
Robustness of the noise-induced temporal order
The main text states that the period-doubled response of Figure 1(b) is robust against randomness in the initial spin configuration and against perturbations of the kick deviation . We verify both claims by repeating the Figure 1(b) measurement at the optimal bath temperature while separately scanning and the initial-state cap half-angle . Figure S1 shows the resulting subharmonic response. The bright ridge at survives over a finite window of the kick deviation (Figure S1). It also persists across a large swept range of initial-state randomness, decaying only gradually as approaches the fully random cap (Figure S1). The

Figure S1. Robustness of the noise-induced period doubling. Fourier amplitude of the noise-averaged response (the Figure 1(b) observable) against , at the optimal bath temperature , as (a) the static kick deviation and (b) the initial-state randomness are varied. The subharmonic ridge at persists over a finite band of and across a large range of initial-state disorder. The period doubling is therefore robust to both drive-parameter and initial-configuration perturbations. Parameters: , , , , , and . Panel (a) fixes , and panel (b) fixes .
noise-induced DTC therefore requires neither fine tuning of the effective kick nor a specially prepared initial state, consistent with the prethermal-DTC mechanism of Figure 2.
Comparison between cavity response and period-doubled spin response
The period-doubled signal is generated by the spin lattice, not inherited from the drive. Using the same Fourier amplitude of the noise-averaged signal, (the Figure 1(b) observable), Figure S2 compares drive and response. The drive has weight only near its frequency (), whereas the response develops a sharp subharmonic at that is absent from the drive. The full frequency-temperature dependence of this subharmonic, over , is the emergence map of Figure 1(b), whose bright ridge at is the period-doubled response.

Figure S2. Drive versus response spectra. Fourier amplitude of the noise-averaged drive (blue) and response (orange) against (), with the parameters of Figure 1(b) at . The drive carries weight at its frequency () but none at . The response develops a sharp subharmonic peak at , half the cavity frequency, which is absent from the drive.
Prethermal lifetime scaling
As in prethermal discrete time crystals [20, 30, 31], the lifetime of the noise-induced period doubling grows exponentially with the cavity frequency. We test this scaling by fixing the operating point and sweeping the period , hence . For a deterministic drive at a representative point of the DTC band of Figure 2(g) (, ), the correlation time (Eq. (6)), averaged over initial spin configurations, grows exponentially by two orders of magnitude, with (Figure S3). This is the exponential prethermal scaling invoked in the main text for both Figure 2 and Figure 3.

Figure S3. Prethermal lifetime scaling. Correlation time in units of the period , (Eq. (6)), against the frequency , with dashed exponential guides . (a) Deterministic drive at a representative point of the Figure 2(g) DTC region (, ), averaged over initial-state realizations (error bars: standard deviation). The lifetime grows exponentially by two orders of magnitude, with . (b) Stochastic drive at fixed coherence time . The green density shows the per-realization distribution at each frequency, with the noise-averaged mean \left\llbracket\tau_{\mathrm{corr}}\right\rrbracket (black squares) and the median (orange circles). Both grow exponentially, with and . Parameters: , , , and . Panel (b) uses and .
The same scaling survives the stochastic drive. We hold the coherence time of the cavity mode fixed in units of cavity cycles, , so that every frequency is compared at equal quality factor. We then record the single-trajectory correlation time of each noise realization. Figure S3 shows the resulting distribution against . A few long-lived realizations pull the noise-averaged mean well above the typical (median) value, Nevertheless, both the mean and the median grow exponentially, with rates and comparable to the deterministic value. The prethermal protection generated by the narrowband stochastic drive therefore obeys the same exponential frequency scaling as its deterministic counterpart.
Thermalization time at short coherence time
Section S5 shows the exponential growth of the correlation time at a long coherence time, where no time-soliton occurs. Here, we test it in the DTL regime of Figure 3, where time-solitons separate the correlation times from . We fix the coherence time at and sweep the cavity period from to , i.e., from to , with all other parameters as in Figure 3. For each noise realization, we evaluate , whose noise average is the thermalization time of Eq. (8). Figure S4 shows that grows

Figure S4. Thermalization time at short coherence time. Thermalization time, (Eq. (8)), as a function of the cavity frequency , at the fixed coherence time of the DTL in Figure 4. The green density shows the distribution of the single-realization value at each frequency, with its mean (black squares) and its median (orange circles). The cavity frequency controls the lifetime of the period doubling also in the DTL. Parameters: , , , , , , , and .
monotonically, where the distribution at each frequency is narrow. The growth is slower than a single exponential in but still shows a strong frequency dependence.
Drive-phase dependence of the DTC lifetime
To understand the mechanism, the main text replaces the oscillator with a single deterministic tone and fixes the phase to (Figure 2(a,Figure 2d,Figure 2g)). The full stochastic dynamics (Figure 2(b,Figure 2c,Figure 2e,Figure 2f,Figure 2h,Figure 2i)), however, sees a filtered drive . Its phase is uniform on and takes a different value in each noise realization (Sec. S2). Here, we show how strongly the period doubling of the deterministic model depends on this phase.
Figure S5 shows the correlation time of the deterministic response versus , normalized to its value at . The correlation time is largest near and vanishes near , where the stroboscopic sampling times fall half a drive period out of step with the kick sequence. The drive phase therefore strongly affects the lifetime of the period doubling at both frequencies. This phase dependence, however, weakens as the drive frequency increases. We take as the reference phase in the deterministic model of Figure 2(a), since it gives the longest correlation time. The fraction of phases that reach this lifetime grows with the drive frequency.

Figure S5. Drive-phase dependence of the DTC lifetime. Correlation time of Eq. (6), normalized to its value at , of the deterministic drive as a function of the initial phase , for a slow () and a fast () drive. At both frequencies, is largest near and vanishes near . The drive phase therefore strongly affects the DTC lifetime. As increases, the plateau of maximal around widens. The phase dependence thus weakens at higher frequency. Parameters: , , , , , .
Time scales of the toy model of time-solitons
Here, we show several analytic results for the toy model of Eq. (2).
Deep inside the ordered regime, the stroboscopic response of Eq. (2) is a period-doubled signal. We denote by the stroboscopic magnetization at period , which should be understood as the expectation value of the operator for all-polarized initial states in the quantum case. At , the normalized staggered magnetization of the main text therefore stays at its initial value , while for it flips sign with probability at each period. Without loss of generality, we write the normalized staggered magnetization of a single realization as
where is the period of the drive, so that period occurs at the time . The factor is the prethermal envelope we introduced to capture the decay of the period doubling due to thermalization with a lifetime
Here, is the subharmonic phase, which takes the two values of the two period-doubled configurations. A time-soliton is the event in the drive of Eq. (2), which exchanges the sign of , so that follows the process
The solitons are independent between periods. The gap between two neighboring solitons therefore has distribution , with mean periods, where denotes the average over the random realizations of the solitons. The typical time between two solitons is therefore , and the density of time-solitons is its inverse,
Because the solitons are independent, the correlator of follows immediately. Over a time separation , the sign is reversed once per soliton, so that , with the number of solitons in this interval. The averaged correlator thus is
Three time scales
We can also define the three time scales of the main text in the context of the toy model. We consider
where the prefactor converts the sum over periods into a time. Two of the three can be derived directly, as we show below.
Using , Eq. (S.27) is nothing but
In the limit of Eq. (S.23), it reduces to
which confirms that the integrated definition in Eq. (S.27) returns the prethermal scale .
Using the correlator of Eq. (S.26), we can obtain
In the limit of Eq. (S.23) and for , it reduces to
Moreover, when the solitons dominate, , this reduces to
This is the limit where the soliton density alone sets the correlation time.
The three time scales obey , because the modulus taken inside a summation or ensemble average would give a result equal or larger than the modulus taken outside them. In the DTC regime, , no soliton typically appears before thermalization. The modulus then act trivially, and three time scales collapse to one,
In the DTL regime, , they separate, and becomes directly relevant to the soliton density via Eq. (S.34).
Distribution of the single-trajectory correlation
The correlation time of single trajectory, before the modulus of Eq. (S.28) is taken, is the random variable
a sum of the signs weighted by the decaying envelope. Here, we derive the distribution for this random variable.
Let be the period where the solitons appear in one trajectory. Between two neighboring solitons the sign does not change, so for , then for , and so on, the sign alternating at each soliton. The sum in Eq. (S.36) can be written as
Each block is a partial geometric series,
so that the block running from to contributes . Summing them together, we obtain
It is convenient to separate that leading term by writing
so that all the randomness sits in , and for a trajectory without solitons.
A self-consistent equation for the distribution of W
By Eq. (S.25), each gap is an independent random variable with
Write the soliton positions as sums of the gaps, with each distributed as in Eq. (S.41), and condition on the first gap, . We can express
Consider now the bracket. Dropping its leading , what remains is
and Eq. (S.42) reads
This means that if the first soliton appears after periods (an event of probability Eq. (S.41)), then . This allows us to write
This random variable has exactly the form of Eq. (S.40), since we have , i.e. sums of the gaps , in the same way that the positions entering are sums of . To use this property, we focus on Eq. (S.45), and rewrite the as , and obtain
This is a relation between and .
Numerical solution
We solve Eq. (S.46) numerically by iteration, using the following procedure.
Grid. Since and , Eq. (S.44) gives and , so the support is bounded,
and a uniform grid of points on covers it with no truncation.
Gap sum. Truncate the sum over at with below machine precision.
Iterate. Starting from the uniform distribution on , evaluate the right-hand side of Eq. (S.46) and replace the old distribution by the result. The rescaled argument generally falls between two grid points, so that is obtained by linear interpolation. It may also fall outside the support of Eq. (S.47), where the distribution takes value 0 when below the support or 1 when above it.
Stop. Monitor and stop once it falls below the tolerance. The distribution of then follows from the change of variable of Eq. (S.40).

Figure S6. Distribution of in the toy model. (a) Distribution obtained from Eq. (S.46), for two cases with : with (), and with (). Dashed vertical lines mark the mean value from Eq. (S.32). A finite fraction of the weight lies at , coming from the trajectories with an odd number of solitons within the lifetime. (b) Convergence of the iteration, as the largest change per sweep against the sweep index . Both panels use a grid of points and a tolerance of .

Figure S7. Distribution of the single-trajectory correlation time at a longer coherence time. Same as Figure 4, at . Probability distribution , with , for the cavity-spin system (green histogram) and for the toy model with the parameters of that same lattice point (dashed line). The toy parameters are not fitted: is the value measured on the lattice, and follows from inverting Eq. (S.32) for the measured , which gives (top). The vertical lines mark , , and . The toy model again reproduces the distribution. All other parameters are as in Figure 3.
Figure S6(a) shows the distribution obtained in this way. Figure S6(b) shows that the iteration converges quickly. The distribution is broad, spanning the whole support, and carries appreciable weight on both sides of , the negative weight coming from the trajectories with an odd number of solitons within the lifetime. This is what separates the two correlation times of Eqs. (S.28) and (S.29).
The same construction can be tested against the spin lattice in cavity. For a given coherence time of the cavity mode, the lattice supplies both and directly, and inverting Eq. (S.32) for the latter fixes the soliton density . The toy model is then fully determined, and its distribution can be compared with the distribution of single-trajectory correlation times measured on the lattice. Figure 4 of the main text shows the comparison deep in the DTL, at (). Figure S7 shows it at (). Both figures show the single-trajectory correlation time on a logarithmic axis. In both cases the distribution is broad, spanning more than an order of magnitude in , and is peaked well below the prethermal scale. The toy model captures the position of the peak and the overall width, and reproduces the slow rise on the small- side.
Phase diagram
The phase diagram of Figure 1(c) is classified by three quantities, defined in the main text and in Methods. We recall them here in terms of the normalized staggered magnetization of realization , which satisfies . The three quantities are the noise-averaged single-trajectory correlation time, the thermalization time, and the precession weight,
where , and runs over a reference window of 100 periods starting at . Each parameter point is then labeled in three steps. Points in the freely precessing band at low temperature, where has not yet fallen to its high-temperature floor , show free precession. Among the remaining points, those with are disordered. All other points are a DTC if and a DTL otherwise. Figure S8 shows the three quantities over the plane of Figure 1(c). The levels and are fixed by the data, as described below, whereas the level is a choice.

Figure S8. The quantities behind the classification, over the plane of Figure 1(c). (a) Correlation time and (b) thermalization time . (c) Their ratio and (d) the precession weight , on linear scales. Each panel carries, as a white dashed line, the boundary that its own quantity defines: the disorder level in (a), the DTC level in (c), and the edge of the freely precessing band in (d). Panel (b) defines no boundary. Comparing (a) and (b) shows the origin of the DTC island. The thermalization time falls smoothly with temperature everywhere, whereas rises to meet it only within a window that widens with the coherence time of the cavity mode. Parameters as in Figure 1(c). See text for more details.
We classify with the single-trajectory scale rather than with the ensemble scale , since the DTC and the DTL are distinguished by how long a single realization keeps its subharmonic phase.
The precession weight stays at unity as long as the drive is too weak to disturb the free precession of the spins. It then falls as the temperature increases and settles on a floor of 0.02 to 0.03, set by the residual noise of the correlator. We determine from this floor in each column of fixed . Specifically, we collect the values of at the highest temperatures, from one tenth of the maximum temperature upward. We set to their median plus five times their median absolute deviation. The free precession then extends from the lowest temperature up to the temperature at which first reaches .
To fix the cut between the DTC and the DTL, we consider all points that show local temporal order, i.e., all points that are neither freely precessing nor disordered. The histogram of over these points has two groups. Most points have @page 15/18 starts_mid=0 ends_mid=1

Figure S6 (PDF p. 15). Distribution of in the toy model. (a) Distribution obtained from Eq. (S.46), for two cases with : with (), and with (). Dashed vertical lines mark the mean value from Eq. (S.32). A finite fraction of the weight lies at , coming from the trajectories with an odd number of solitons within the lifetime. (b) Convergence of the iteration, as the largest change per sweep against the sweep index . Both panels use a grid of points and a tolerance of .

Figure S7 (PDF p. 15). Distribution of the single-trajectory correlation time at a longer coherence time. Same as Figure 4, at . Probability distribution , with , for the cavity-spin system (green histogram) and for the toy model with the parameters of that same lattice point (dashed line). The toy parameters are not fitted: is the value measured on the lattice, and follows from inverting Eq. (S.32) for the measured , which gives (top). The vertical lines mark , , and . The toy model again reproduces the distribution. All other parameters are as in Figure 3.
Figure S6(a) shows the distribution obtained in this way. Figure S6(b) shows that the iteration converges quickly. The distribution is broad, spanning the whole support, and carries appreciable weight on both sides of , the negative weight coming from the trajectories with an odd number of solitons within the lifetime. This is what separates the two correlation times of Eqs. (S.28) and (S.29).
The same construction can be tested against the spin lattice in cavity. For a given coherence time of the cavity mode, the lattice supplies both and directly, and inverting Eq. (S.32) for the latter fixes the soliton density . The toy model is then fully determined, and its distribution can be compared with the distribution of single-trajectory correlation times measured on the lattice. Figure 4 of the main text shows the comparison deep in the DTL, at (). Figure S7 shows it at (). Both figures show the single-trajectory correlation time on a logarithmic axis. In both cases the distribution is broad, spanning more than an order of magnitude in , and is peaked well below the prethermal scale. The toy model captures the position of the peak and the overall width, and reproduces the slow rise on the small- side.
Phase diagram
The phase diagram of Figure 1(c) is classified by three quantities, defined in the main text and in Methods. We recall them here in terms of the normalized staggered magnetization of realization , which satisfies . The three quantities are the noise-averaged single-trajectory correlation time, the thermalization time, and the precession weight,
where , and runs over a reference window of 100 periods starting at . Each parameter point is then labeled in three steps. Points in the freely precessing band at low temperature, where has not yet fallen to its high-temperature floor , show free precession. Among the remaining points, those with are disordered. All other points are a DTC if and a DTL otherwise. Figure S8 shows the three quantities over the plane of Figure 1(c). The levels and are fixed by the data, as described below, whereas the level is a choice.
We classify with the single-trajectory scale rather than with the ensemble scale , since the DTC and the DTL are distinguished by how long a single realization keeps its subharmonic phase.
The precession weight stays at unity as long as the drive is too weak to disturb the free precession of the spins. It then falls as the temperature increases and settles on a floor of 0.02 to 0.03, set by the residual noise of the correlator. We determine from this floor in each column of fixed . Specifically, we collect the values of at the highest temperatures, from one tenth of the maximum temperature upward. We set to their median plus five times their median absolute deviation. The free precession then extends from the lowest temperature up to the temperature at which first reaches .
To fix the cut between the DTC and the DTL, we consider all points that show local temporal order, i.e., all points that are neither freely precessing nor disordered. The histogram of over these points has two groups. Most points have a small ratio, around 0.12, and form the DTL. A smaller group has a ratio up to 0.83, where is comparable to , and forms the DTC. The two groups are separated by a dip near 0.4. We place the cut at the value that best separates the two groups, 0.418. Because the dip is shallow, the number of DTC points depends on the exact cut.
The boundary between the DTL and the disordered region is the least sharp of the three. The distribution of shows no feature near the cut . Moving the cut between 3 and 30 cavity periods changes the number of disordered points from 256 to 816. This is expected, since the local temporal order is lost gradually on heating.
Spin backaction on the oscillator
Here, we demonstrate the backaction effect by including the backaction term of § 8 C. The intensive oscillator equation then reads
Numerical methods
We evolve the classical spins by the Poisson-bracket equation , with the instantaneous local field . It is integrated by a second-order Strang splitting into a transverse-field sector (every spin rotates about by ) and an Ising sector (each spin rotates about by , with all , and hence every -field,
The per-spin force is defined in § 8 C, with given by Eq. (S.11).
We repeat the calculation of Figure 2(h,Figure 2i) with the backaction term included and compare the per-cycle effective-drive parameters in Figure S9. At both and , the backaction reshapes the cloud, shifting its weight toward smaller and broadening its distribution along . These results indicate that the spins can reshape the noisy drive. How this feedback modifies the phase diagram of Figure 1(c) remains an open question. frozen during the substep). Each substep is an exact rotation, so is preserved to machine precision and the scheme is stable over the periods used here. The oscillator coordinate is propagated on the same time step and held fixed within it. Each spin is initialized in a spherical cap of half-angle about (see Methods), from a fixed random seed.

Figure S9. Effect of spin backaction. Per-cycle effective-drive parameters for single trajectories at (a) and (b) . Blue circles show the backaction-free trajectories used in Figure 2(h,i), and orange triangles show the corresponding trajectories with backaction. At each temperature, the two trajectories use the same noise sequence and initial spin configuration. All other parameters are those of Figure 2.
We validate the splitting against an independent high-order adaptive ODE solver. Figure S10 shows that the subharmonic response is indistinguishable across Strang steps and the ODE reference over periods, and that the error versus the reference follows the expected second-order scaling at early times (inset). Over the full run, the error remains bounded at for the smaller steps. This value is the accuracy of the reference solver itself, whose solutions at successive tolerances already differ by this much. No residual splitting error is therefore resolvable below this level, and the production step lies well within the converged regime.

Figure S10. Integrator convergence. Deterministic drive, . Main panel: the stroboscopic subharmonic response from the exact-rotation Strang splitting at and from the adaptive ODE solver (black dashed, reference), which coincide over periods. Inset: the Strang error relative to the ODE reference versus , over the first 100 periods (squares) and over the full -period run (circles). The early error follows the second-order scaling (gray line). The full-run error stays bounded and saturates near the reference’s own accuracy floor (), confirming the integrator over the whole run.
References
References
- [1]N. D. Mermin and H. Wagner, Absence of Ferromagnetism or Antiferromagnetism in One- or Two-Dimensional Isotropic Heisenberg Models, Physical Review Letters 17, 1133 (1966).
- [2]P. C. Hohenberg, Existence of Long-Range Order in One and Two Dimensions, Physical Review 158, 384 (1967).
- [3]M. Lax, Classical Noise. V. Noise in Self-Sustained Oscillators, Physical Review 160, 290 (1967).DOI
- [4]A. Pikovsky, M. Rosenblum, and J. Kurths, Synchronization: A Universal Concept in Nonlinear Sciences, Cambridge Nonlinear Science Series (Cambridge University Press, 2001).
- [5]J. Villain, R. Bidaux, J.-P. Carton, and R. Conte, Order as an effect of disorder, Journal of Physics 41, 1263 (1980).DOI
- [6]C. L. Henley, Ordering due to disorder in a frustrated vector antiferromagnet, Physical Review Letters 62, 2056 (1989).pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/10039845
- [7]R. Benzi, A. Sutera, and A. Vulpiani, The mechanism of stochas- tic resonance, Journal of Physics A: Mathematical and General 14, L453 (1981).DOI
- [8]L. Gammaitoni, P. Hänggi, P. Jung, and F. Marchesoni, Stochastic resonance, Reviews of Modern Physics 70, 223 (1998).
- [9]A. S. Pikovsky and J. Kurths, Coherence Resonance in a Noise- Driven Excitable System, Physical Review Letters 78, 775 (1997).
- [10]H. M. Bretscher, L. Graziotto, M. H. Michael, A. Montanaro, I.-T. Lu, A. Grankin, J. W. McIver, J. Faist, D. Fausti, M. Eckstein, M. Ruggenthaler, A. Rubio, D. Basov, M. Hafezi, M. Claassen, D. M. Kennes, and M. A. Sentef, Fluctuation engineering in cavity quantum materials (2026), arXiv:2604.08666 [cond-mat.mes-hall].arxiv.org/abs/2604.08666
- [11]C. J. Eckhardt, A. Grankin, D. M. Kennes, M. Ruggenthaler, A. Rubio, M. A. Sentef, M. Hafezi, and M. H. Michael, Surface-mediated ultrastrong cavity coupling of two-dimensional itinerant electrons, Phys. Rev. Lett. 135, 156902 (2025).DOI
- [12]E. Viñas Boström, M. H. Michael, C. Eckhardt, and A. Rubio, Equilibrium nonlinear phononics by electric field fluctuations of terahertz cavities, Phys. Rev. Res. 7, 033163 (2025).
- [13]I. Keren, T. A. Webb, S. Zhang, J. Xu, D. Sun, B. S. Y. Kim, D. Shin, S. S. Zhang, J. Zhang, G. Pereira, J. Yao, T. Okugawa, M. H. Michael, E. Viñas Boström, J. H. Edgar, S. Wolf, M. Julian, R. P. Prasankumar, K. Miyagawa, K. Kanoda, G. Gu, M. Cothrine, D. Mandrus, M. Buzzi, A. Cavalleri, C. R. Dean, D. M. Kennes, A. J. Millis, Q. Li, M. A. Sentef, A. Rubio, A. N. Pasupathy, and D. N. Basov, Cavity-altered superconductivity, Nature 650, 864 (2026).
- [14]M. P. Zaletel, M. Lukin, C. Monroe, C. Nayak, F. Wilczek, and N. Y. Yao, Colloquium : Quantum and classical discrete time crystals, Reviews of Modern Physics 95, 031001 (2023).DOI
- [15]K. Sacha and J. Zakrzewski, Time crystals: A review, Reports on Progress in Physics 81, 016401 (2017).DOI
- [16]D. V. Else, B. Bauer, and C. Nayak, Floquet Time Crystals, Physical Review Letters 117, 090402 (2016).DOI
- [17]V. Khemani, A. Lazarides, R. Moessner, and S. L. Sondhi, Phase Structure of Driven Quantum Systems, Physical Review Letters 116, 250401 (2016).DOI
- [18]N. Y. Yao, A. C. Potter, I.-D. Potirniche, and A. Vishwanath, Discrete Time Crystals: Rigidity, Criticality, and Realizations, Physical Review Letters 118, 030401 (2017).DOI
- [19]S. Choi, J. Choi, R. Landig, G. Kucsko, H. Zhou, J. Isoya, F. Jelezko, S. Onoda, H. Sumiya, V. Khemani, C. von Keyserlingk, N. Y. Yao, E. Demler, and M. D. Lukin, Observation of discrete time-crystalline order in a disordered dipolar many-body system, Nature 543, 221 (2017).
- [20]D. V. Else, B. Bauer, and C. Nayak, Prethermal Phases of Matter Protected by Time-Translation Symmetry, Physical Review X 7, 011026 (2017).DOI
- [21]A. Kyprianidis, F. Machado, W. Morong, P. Becker, K. S. Collins, D. V. Else, L. Feng, P. W. Hess, C. Nayak, G. Pagano, N. Y. Yao, and C. Monroe, Observation of a prethermal discrete time crystal, Science 372, 1192 (2021).DOI
- [22]N. Y. Yao, C. Nayak, L. Balents, and M. P. Zaletel, Classical discrete time crystals, Nature Physics 16, 438 (2020).DOI
- [23]F. Iemini, A. Russomanno, J. Keeling, M. Schirò, M. Dalmonte, and R. Fazio, Boundary Time Crystals, Physical Review Letters 121, 035301 (2018).
- [24]Z. Gong, R. Hamazaki, and M. Ueda, Discrete Time-Crystalline Order in Cavity and Circuit QED Systems, Physical Review Letters 120, 040404 (2018).DOI
- [25]F. M. Gambetta, F. Carollo, M. Marcuzzi, J. P. Garrahan, and I. Lesanovsky, Discrete Time Crystals in the Absence of Manifest Symmetries or Disorder in Open Quantum Systems, Physical Review Letters 122, 015701 (2019).DOI
- [26]H. Keßler, P. Kongkhambut, C. Georges, L. Mathey, J. G. Cosme, and A. Hemmerich, Observation of a Dissipative Time Crystal, Physical Review Letters 127, 043602 (2021).
- [27]J. C. Schumann, I. Lesanovsky, and P. Solanki, Hierarchical time crystals (2026), 2601.09779 [quant-ph].DOI
- [28]B. I. Halperin and D. R. Nelson, Theory of two-dimensional melting, Phys. Rev. Lett. 41, 121 (1978).
- [29]See Supplemental Material.
- [30]F. Machado, D. V. Else, G. D. Kahanamoku-Meyer, C. Nayak, and N. Y. Yao, Long-Range Prethermal Phases of Nonequilibrium Matter, Physical Review X 10, 011043 (2020).DOI
- [31]B. Ye, F. Machado, and N. Y. Yao, Floquet phases of matter via classical prethermalization, Physical Review Letters 127, 140603 (2021).DOI
- [32]P. Kongkhambut, J. Skulte, L. Mathey, J. G. Cosme, A. Hemmerich, and H. Keßler, Observation of a continuous time crystal, Science 377, 670 (2022), https://www.science.org/doi/pdf/10.1126/science.abo3382.DOI
- [33]C. J. Eckhardt, S. Chattopadhyay, D. M. Kennes, E. A. Demler, M. A. Sentef, and M. H. Michael, Theory of resonantly enhanced photo-induced superconductivity, Nature Communications 15, 2300 (2024).
- [34]L. Grunwald, X. Cheng, E. V. Boström, M. Ruggenthaler, M. H. Michael, D. M. Kennes, and A. Rubio, Cavity control of strongly correlated electrons beyond resonant coupling (2026), arXiv:2603.18933 [quant-ph].arxiv.org/abs/2603.18933
- [35]G. Kipp, H. M. Bretscher, B. Schulte, D. Herrmann, K. Kusyak, M. W. Day, S. Kesavan, T. Matsuyama, X. Li, S. M. Langner, J. Hagelstein, F. Sturm, A. M. Potts, C. J. Eckhardt, Y. Huang, K. Watanabe, T. Taniguchi, A. Rubio, D. M. Kennes, M. A. Sentef, E. Baudin, G. Meier, M. H. Michael, and J. W. McIver, Cavity electrodynamics of van der waals heterostructures, Nature Physics 21, 1926 (2025).
- [36]In this article we neglect the backaction of the spins on the cavity mode, whose effect on the effective drive we discuss in the SM [29]. In this case, the time-solitons are set by the cavity fluctuations alone and occur independently. Once the backaction becomes relevant, the cavity mode keeps a memory of the spin dynamics and may generate effective interactions between time-solitons. In the toy model, such interactions can be provided by a flip probability conditioned on the history of the trajectory. Such interactions could lock the solitons at regular separations, as in the case of soliton crystals [42], or enhance their proliferation. They would thereby either strengthen or weaken the temporal coherence.
- [37]I. Martin, G. Refael, and B. Halperin, Topological Frequency Conversion in Strongly Driven Quantum Systems, Physical Review X 7, 041008 (2017).DOI
- [38]D. V. Else, W. W. Ho, and P. T. Dumitrescu, Long-Lived Interacting Phases of Matter Protected by Multiple Time-Translation Symmetries in Quasiperiodically Driven Systems, Physical Review X 10, 021032 (2020).
- [39]P. Bruno, Impossibility of Spontaneously Rotating Time Crystals: A No-Go Theorem, Physical Review Letters 111, 070402 (2013).DOI
- [40]H. Watanabe and M. Oshikawa, Absence of Quantum Time Crystals, Physical Review Letters 114, 251603 (2015).pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/26197119
- [41]G. W. Ford, M. Kac, and P. Mazur, Statistical Mechanics of Coupled Oscillators, Journal of Mathematical Physics 6, 504 (1965).DOI