betaFeedback

Reading v1View latest version

WorksMathematics

A Gap Theorem for the Möbius Cross Energy Near the Hopf Link

Abstract

We prove that the critical value 2π22π^2 is isolated for the Möbius cross energy of two-component links in the round three dimensional sphere S3\mathbb{S}^{3}. Specifically, there exists ε0>0\varepsilon_0>0 such that any non-split, regular H2H^2 pair of curves with disjoint images, having vanishing first variation and energy at most 2π2+ε02π^2+\varepsilon_0, must lie in the Möbius-reparametrization orbit of the standard Hopf link.

Introduction and main theorem

Set S1=R/(2πZ)\mathbb{S}^1 = \mathbb{R}/(2\pi\mathbb{Z}), and equip S3={z∈R4:∣z∣=1}\mathbb{S}^3 = \{z \in\mathbb{R}^4 : \lvert z\rvert= 1\} with the round metric g0g_0. For an ordered pair Γ=(γ1,γ2)\Gamma= (\gamma_1,\gamma_2) of rectifiable closed curves with disjoint component images, the Möbius cross energy is

E(Γ)=∫γ1∫γ2dℓ1(x) dℓ2(y)∣x−y∣2,(1)E(\Gamma) = \int_{\gamma_1}\int_{\gamma_2} \frac{\mathrm{d}\ell_1(x)\,\mathrm{d}\ell_2(y)}{\lvert x-y\rvert^2}, \tag*{(1)}

where ∣x−y∣\lvert x-y\rvert is the Euclidean chordal distance in R4\mathbb{R}^4. Integration along each parametrized curve counts multiplicity. The energy is invariant under separate reparametrizations and under Möbius transformations of S3\mathbb{S}^3. A pair of disjoint compact connected sets is called split if a smoothly embedded 22-sphere, disjoint from both sets, separates them; otherwise it is called non-split. For a curve pair, this terminology refers to its component images.

The standard Hopf link is

H=(x,y),x(s)=(cos⁡s,sin⁡s,0,0),y(t)=(0,0,cos⁡t,sin⁡t).(2)H = (x,y), \qquad x(s) = (\cos s,\sin s,0,0), \qquad y(t) = (0,0,\cos t,\sin t). \tag*{(2)}

Its components are unit-speed great circles in orthogonal 22-planes. Since ∣x(s)−y(t)∣2=2\lvert x(s)-y(t)\rvert^2 = 2,

E(H)=2π2.(3)E(H) = 2\pi^2. \tag*{(3)}

Freedman, He, and Wang [2] conjectured that this is the minimum cross energy among all non-split two-component links. An important step was taken by He [4], who proved that a global minimizer exists and that every such minimizer is ambiently isotopic to the Hopf link. Agol, Marques, and Neves subsequently proved the sharp lower bound and classified all equality configurations [1].

Theorem 1.1 (Agol–Marques–Neves). Every non-split two-component rectifiable link in S3\mathbb{S}^3 satisfies

E(Γ)≥2π2.E(\Gamma) \ge2\pi^2.

Equality holds if and only if a conformal transformation carries the pair to the standard Hopf link, up to separate reparametrizations and orientations.

2020 Mathematics Subject Classification. Primary 53A30, 57K10; Secondary 49Q10, 58E12.

Key words and phrases. Möbius cross energy, Hopf link, critical-value gap.

Choose a stereographic projection point outside the component images, and write Γ^=(γ^1,γ^2)\widehat{\Gamma}=(\widehat{\gamma}_1,\widehat{\gamma}_2) for the Euclidean representative. The Gauss linking number of Γ\Gamma is defined by

lk⁡(Γ)=14π∫S1∫S1det⁡(γ^1′(s),γ^2′(t),γ^1(s)−γ^2(t))∣γ^1(s)−γ^2(t)∣3 ds dt.(4)\operatorname{lk}(\Gamma)=\frac{1}{4\pi}\int_{\mathbb{S}^1}\int_{\mathbb{S}^1}\frac{\det\left(\widehat{\gamma}_1'(s),\widehat{\gamma}_2'(t),\widehat{\gamma}_1(s)-\widehat{\gamma}_2(t)\right)}{\left|\widehat{\gamma}_1(s)-\widehat{\gamma}_2(t)\right|^3}\,\mathrm{d}s\,\mathrm{d}t. \tag*{(4)}

It is the sum of the signed over-crossings of the first component over the second in a regular oriented projection. Therefore a nonzero linking number implies non-splitness, but the converse fails, as illustrated by the Whitehead link.

A direct calculus implies

E(Γ)≥4π∣lk⁡(Γ)∣.E(\Gamma)\geq4\pi\left|\operatorname{lk}(\Gamma)\right|.

Allowing a choice of component orientations, He [4] shows that a pair of non-split curves is link-homotopic to the Hopf link provided E(Γ)<8πE(\Gamma)<8\pi.

The present paper concerns critical points rather than minimizers. The equality classification in (1) does not by itself exclude non-minimizing critical pairs with energies arbitrarily close to 2π22\pi^2. We prove that no such sequence exists. To state the result precisely, consider the extrinsic Sobolev space

H2(S1,S3)={γ∈H2(S1,R4):∣γ∣=1 a.e.}.H^2(\mathbb{S}^1,\mathbb{S}^3)=\left\{\gamma\in H^2(\mathbb{S}^1,\mathbb{R}^4):|\gamma|=1\ \text{a.e.}\right\}.

The embedding H2(S1)↪C1,1/2(S1)H^2(\mathbb{S}^1)\hookrightarrow C^{1,1/2}(\mathbb{S}^1) provides a unique C1,1/2C^{1,1/2} representative, which we use throughout. A closed curve γ\gamma is regular if min⁡S1∣γ′∣>0\min_{\mathbb{S}^1}|\gamma'|>0. Define

A={(γ1,γ2): γ1,γ2 are regular curves in H2(S1,S3) s.t. γ1(S1)∩γ2(S1)=∅}.(5)\mathcal{A}=\left\{(\gamma_1,\gamma_2):\ \gamma_1,\gamma_2\ \text{are regular curves in }H^2(\mathbb{S}^1,\mathbb{S}^3)\ \text{s.t. }\gamma_1(\mathbb{S}^1)\cap\gamma_2(\mathbb{S}^1)=\varnothing\right\}. \tag*{(5)}

No injectivity of the individual parametrizations is assumed. The set A\mathcal{A} is open in the H2H^2 mapping manifold, and EE is smooth on A\mathcal{A}. A pair is weakly critical if δEΓ=0\delta E_\Gamma=0 on every H2H^2 tangent variation; explicitly, the admissible fields ξi∈H2(S1,R4)\xi_i\in H^2(\mathbb{S}^1,\mathbb{R}^4) satisfy ⟨ξi,γi⟩=0\langle\xi_i,\gamma_i\rangle=0 everywhere.

Let Diff⁡2(S1)\operatorname{Diff}^2(\mathbb{S}^1) denote the H2H^2 circle maps that are C1C^1 diffeomorphisms, allowing both orientations, and set

G=Mo¨b⁡+(S3)×Diff⁡2(S1)×Diff⁡2(S1).(6)\mathcal{G}=\operatorname{M\ddot{o}b}^{+}(\mathbb{S}^3)\times\operatorname{Diff}^2(\mathbb{S}^1)\times\operatorname{Diff}^2(\mathbb{S}^1). \tag*{(6)}

We write G⋅H\mathcal{G}\cdot H for the pairs obtained from HH by a common orientation-preserving Möbius transformation and separate reparametrizations.2

Theorem 1.2 (Critical-value gap). There exists ε0>0\varepsilon_0>0 such that every non-split, weakly critical pair Γ∈A\Gamma\in\mathcal{A} satisfying

E(Γ)≤2π2+ε0E(\Gamma)\leq2\pi^2+\varepsilon_0

belongs to G⋅H\mathcal{G}\cdot H. In particular, E(Γ)=2π2E(\Gamma)=2\pi^2.

Remark 1.3. He [4] gave a geometric interpretation of critical points of the Möbius cross energy. With γ2\gamma_2 fixed, define

ρ2(x)=∫γ2dℓ2(y)∣x−y∣2.\rho_2(x)=\int_{\gamma_2}\frac{\mathrm{d}\ell_2(y)}{|x-y|^2}.

Then the critical equation for γ1\gamma_1 is precisely the geodesic equation for the conformal metric ρ22g0\rho_2^2g_0 on S3∖γ2\mathbb{S}^3\setminus\gamma_2, and similarly with the two components interchanged. Thus a critical pair can be viewed as a pair of mutually interacting closed geodesics in each other’s complement space equipped with a complete conformal metric.

Theorem 1.2 shows that 2π22\pi^2 is an isolated critical value of the Möbius cross energy among non-split pairs. Exact criticality is essential, since non-Möbius perturbations of the Hopf link can have energies arbitrarily close to 2π22\pi^2. Although we work with regular H2H^2 pairs, the critical equation implies smoothness after constant-speed reparametrization.

Outline of the proof. The proof combines global compactness modulo Möbius transformations with local nondegeneracy of the Hopf orbit. Energy bounds and the critical equation yield smooth compactness, so any critical sequence with energy tending to 2π22\pi^2 converges, modulo symmetries, to a Hopf link. We then compute the Hopf Hessian, identify its kernel with the infinitesimal Möbius motions, and prove coercivity on the transverse space. A local Möbius slice and a nonlinear Taylor estimate give local uniqueness, which together with compactness proves the gap theorem.

Acknowledgments: The authors thank Professor Jian Ge for useful discussions. The first author is supported by the China Postdoctoral Science Foundation (2026M793350). The second author is supported by the Open Project Program of the Key Laboratory of Mathematics and Complex System at Beijing Normal University (Grant No. 202501). The principal arguments and the core of the paper were developed by the second author while visiting SIMIS.

AI assistance declaration: The main ideas and most proofs are solely the work of the authors. ChatGPT (version 5.6sol) was used only to assist in proving Proposition 3.1 and to aid in manuscript preparation. The authors have verified all contributions and assume complete accountability for the paper.

First variation and the critical equation

We derive the first variation directly in the spherical model, including its weak H2H^2 formulation. The corresponding Euclidean computation appears in the proof of [4], Lemma 3.1, equations (3-2)-(3-3).

Analytic preliminaries

We denote DD the Euclidean connection on R4\mathbb{R}^4 and ∇\nabla the Levi-Civita connection of g0g_0 on S3\mathbb{S}^3. Let X,YX,Y be tangent vector fields on S3\mathbb{S}^3, then for each x∈S3x \in\mathbb{S}^3, the Gauss formula gives

DXY=∇XY+II(X,Y),II(X,Y)=−⟨X,Y⟩g0x,(7)D_XY = \nabla_XY + II(X,Y), \qquad II(X,Y) = -\langle X,Y\rangle_{g_0}x, \tag*{(7)}

where IIII is the second fundamental form of S3⊂R4\mathbb{S}^3 \subset\mathbb{R}^4. Thus, for a unit-speed curve, γ′′=κ−γ\gamma'' = \kappa- \gamma, where κ=∇XX\kappa= \nabla_XX is its curvature vector in S3\mathbb{S}^3. S1=R/(2πZ)\mathbb{S}^1 = \mathbb{R}/(2\pi\mathbb{Z}), without averaging the integrals.

For a variation Γτ\Gamma_\tau with initial velocity ξ\xi, we write δEΓ[ξ]=ddτE(Γτ)∣τ=0\delta E_\Gamma[\xi] = \left.\frac{d}{d\tau}E(\Gamma_\tau)\right|_{\tau=0} and δ2\delta^2 for the second differential in a fixed chart. Ordinary coordinate derivatives are denoted by ∂\partial or dd. The parameter (configuration) torus is T2=Ss1×St1\mathbb{T}^2 = \mathbb{S}^1_s \times\mathbb{S}^1_t. Throughout the paper,

∬F(s,t) ds dt:=∫02π∫02πF(s,t) ds dt\iint F(s,t)\,ds\,dt := \int_0^{2\pi}\int_0^{2\pi} F(s,t)\,ds\,dt

always refers to this fixed torus with the product parameter measure. Integrals over the component curves or other parameter intervals are written with explicit domains.

Lemma 2.1. Every regular closed H2H^2 curve admits a constant-speed parametrization obtained by an orientation-preserving H2H^2 circle diffeomorphism. Separate such reparametrizations preserve the cross energy, non-splitness, and weak criticality. Proof. For a lift of the parameter to [0,2π][0,2\pi], set

References

  1. [1]Ian, Agol; Fernando C. Marques; André Neves. Min-max theory and the energy of links. J. Amer. Math. Soc. 29 (2016), no. 2, 561–578.DOI
  2. [2]Michael H. Freedman; Zheng-Xu, He; Zhenghan, Wang. Möbius energy of knots and unknots. Ann. of Math. (2) 139 (1994), no. 1, 1–50.DOI
  3. [3]Jian, Ge. Gehring link problem, focal radius and over-torical width. Amer. J. Math. 146 (2024), no. 5, 1295–1304.
  4. [4]Zheng-Xu, He. On the minimizers of the Möbius cross energy of links. Experiment. Math.11 (2002), no. 2, 244–248.DOI
  5. [5]U. Hertrich-Jeromin, Introduction to Möbius Differential Geometry, London Mathematical Society Lecture Note Series, vol. 300, Cambridge University Press, Cambridge, 2003.
  6. [6]Andrea, Mondino; Huy The, Nguyen. A gap theorem for Willmore tori and an application to the Willmore flow. Nonlinear Anal. 102 (2014), 220–225.DOI

Paper details

vlnc:W_mvehjs7t
Published
Added
License
CC BY 4.0
Usage

views · 0

downloads · 0

A view counts once per browser per day, a download each time the PDF is requested.

  • Mathematics

GPT-5.6 Sol (bare)

View statement
Looking for related papers…
Contents