betaFeedback

WorksPhysics and Astronomy

Standard Model prediction for paramagnetic EDMs

Abstract

Standard Model CPCP violation associated with the phase of the Cabibbo-Kobayashi-Maskawa quark mixing matrix is known to give small answers for the EDM observables. Moreover, predictions for the EDMs of neutrons and diamagnetic atoms suffer from considerable uncertainties. We point out that the CPCP-violating observables associated with the electron spin (paramagnetic EDMs) are dominated by the combination of the electroweak penguin diagrams and ΔI=1/2ΔI =1/2 weak transitions in the baryon sector, and are calculable within chiral perturbation theory. The predicted size of the semileptonic operator CSC_S is 7×10−167\times 10^{-16} which corresponds to the equivalent electron EDM deeq=1.0×10−35e cmd_e^{\rm eq} = 1.0 \times 10^{-35}e\,{\rm cm}. While still far from the current observational limits, this result is three orders of magnitude larger than previously believed.

Introduction

The searches for EDMs of elementary particles [1–4] represent an important way of probing the TeV scale new physics [5–7]. Recent break-through sensitivity to CPCP violation connected to electron spin (that we will refer to as “paramagnetic EDMs”) [3] established a new limit on the linear combination of the electron EDM ded_e and semileptonic nucleon-electron NˉNeˉiγ5e\bar{N}N\bar{e}i\gamma_5 e operators, commonly parametrized by a CSC_S coefficient. Given rapid progress of the last decade, as well as some additional hopes for increased accuracy (see e.g. [8–10]) makes one to revisit the Standard Model (SM) sources of CPCP violation, and the expected size of the paramagnetic EDMs in the SM.

SM has two sources of CPCP-violation. First source, undetected thus far, corresponds to the non-perturbative effects parametrized by the QCD vacuum angle θ\theta. Recently it has been shown [11] that paramagnetic EDMs are dominated by the two-photon exchange mechanism, and the leading chiral behavior of the hadronic part of the diagram is given by the tt-channel exchange by π0\pi^0, η\eta. CPCP violation due to θ\theta comes through the π0(η)NˉN\pi^0(\eta)\bar{N}N coupling. The result, in combination with the experimental bound [3], sets the independent limit on ∣θ∣<3×10−8|\theta| < 3 \times10^{-8}, which is still subdominant to the limit provided by dn(θ)d_n(\theta).

The second source of the SM CPCP-violation is the celebrated Kobayashi-Maskawa (KM) phase δKM\delta_{\mathrm{KM}} [12], which is now observed to rather good accuracy in a plethora of flavor transitions in BB and KK mesons. Observations are often matched by rather precise theoretical predictions, starting from [13]. The predictions of EDM-like observables induced by δKM\delta_{\mathrm{KM}} thus far can be summarized by two adjectives: small and uncertain. The suppression comes from the necessity to involve at least two WW-bosons and multiple loops [14–16] involving all three generations of quarks. As a result, short distance contributions to quark EDMs do not exceed 10−33 e cm10^{-33}\,e\,\mathrm{cm} level [17]. At the same time, it is clear that long-distance nonperturbative contributions, typically described as a combination of two transitions changing strangeness by one unit, ΔS=±1\Delta S = \pm1, dominate dnd_n and nucleon-nucleon forces [18–22]. More recent estimate [23] places dnd_n in the ballpark of few ×10−32 cm\times10^{-32}\,\mathrm{cm} with a wide order-of-magnitude expected range. It is fair to say that magnitudes of dnd_n and nucleon-nucleon forces (that feeds into the nuclear-spin-dependent atomic EDMs) cannot be accurately predicted at this point.

What is the size of paramagnetic EDMs induced by δKM\delta_{\mathrm{KM}}? Recent estimates of ded_e [24] (dominated again by long-distance effects) converge at the tiniest value of ∼6×10−40 e cm\sim6 \times10^{-40}\,e\,\mathrm{cm}, presumably with considerable uncertainties corresponding to hadronic modelling of quark loops. This result is subdominant to the CSC_S estimate due to the two-photon exchange mechanism in combination with ΔS=±1\Delta S = \pm1 transitions [25], that corresponds to equivalent ded_e of ∼10−38 e cm\sim10^{-38}\,e\,\mathrm{cm}. To introduce useful notations, this is EW2^2 or EM2^2 order effect, where EW/EM stands for electroweak/electromagnetic.

In this Letter we demonstrate that the dominant contribution to paramagnetic EDMs associated with the KM CPCP-violation is given by the semileptonic CSC_S induced in EW3^3 order. It has an unambiguous answer in the flavor-SU(3)SU(3) chiral limit, and is calculable to ∼30%\sim30\% accuracy that can be further improved. Remarkably, the result reaches the level of ∼10−35 e cm\sim10^{-35}\,e\,\mathrm{cm} in terms of the ded_e equivalent, which is three orders of magnitude larger than previously believed [25].

Our starting point is the expression for the equivalent ded_e that follows from atomic/molecular theory, and defines the linear combination of two Wilson coefficients constrained by the most precise paramagnetic EDM measurements performed with ThO molecule:

deequiv=de+CS×1.5×10−20 e cm,(1)d_e^{\mathrm{equiv}} = d_e + C_S \times1.5 \times10^{-20}\,e\,\mathrm{cm}, \tag*{(1)}

where ee is the positron charge. Current experimental limit [3] stands as ∣deequiv∣<1.1×10−29 e cm|d_e^{\mathrm{equiv}}| < 1.1 \times10^{-29}\,e\,\mathrm{cm}. As per convention, CSC_S is defined with the Fermi constant factored out, and γ5\gamma_5 corresponds to the 12γμ(1−γ5)\frac{1}{2}\gamma_\mu(1-\gamma_5) definition of the left-handed current:

LeN=CSGF2(eˉiγ5e)(pˉp+nˉn).(2)\mathcal{L}_{eN}=C_{S}\frac{G_{F}}{\sqrt{2}}(\bar{e}i\gamma_{5}e)(\bar{p}p+\bar{n}n). \tag*{(2)}

Our goal is to calculate CS(δKM)C_{S}(\delta_{\mathrm{KM}}).

Leading chiral order CSC_{S} calculation

Because of the conservation of the electron chirality in the SM, it is clear that CS∝meC_{S} \propto m_{e}. This in turn rules out single photon exchange (EM penguin) as origin of meeˉiγ5em_{e}\bar{e}i\gamma_{5}e, and one would need either a two-photon mechanism [11, 25] or the EW penguin ZZ-boson exchange/WW-box diagram. The most crucial property of EW penguins is that although they are formally of the second order in weak interactions, their size is enhanced by the heavy top, so that the result scales as GF2mt2G_{F}^{2}m_{t}^{2}. EW penguins1 induce Bs,d→μ+μ−B_{s,d}\to\mu^{+}\mu^{-} decays, and dominate the dispersive part of KL→μ+μ−K_{L}\to\mu^{+}\mu^{-} amplitude. Dropping the vector part of the lepton current (as not leading to meeˉiγ5em_{e}\bar{e}i\gamma_{5}e), and integrating out heavy WW, ZZ, tt particles, one can concisely write down the semileptonic operator as

LEWP=PEW×eˉγμγ5e×sˉγμ(1−γ5)d+(h.c.),(3)\mathcal{L}_{\mathrm{EWP}}=\mathcal{P}_{\mathrm{EW}}\times\bar{e}\gamma_{\mu}\gamma_{5}e\times\bar{s}\gamma^{\mu}(1-\gamma_{5})d+\text{(h.c.)}, \tag*{(3)}

where

PEW=GF2×Vts∗Vtd×αEM(mZ)4πsin⁡2θWI(xt),(4)\mathcal{P}_{\mathrm{EW}}=\frac{G_{F}}{\sqrt{2}}\times V_{ts}^{*}V_{td}\times\frac{\alpha_{\mathrm{EM}}(m_{Z})}{4\pi\sin^{2}\theta_{W}}I(x_{t}), \tag*{(4)}

and the loop function is given by [26]

I(xt)=34(xtxt−1)2log⁡xt+14xt−34xtxt−1,xt=mt2mW2.(5)I(x_{t})=\frac{3}{4}\left(\frac{x_{t}}{x_{t}-1}\right)^{2}\log x_{t}+\frac{1}{4}x_{t}-\frac{3}{4}\frac{x_{t}}{x_{t}-1},\qquad x_{t}=\frac{m_{t}^{2}}{m_{W}^{2}}. \tag*{(5)}

These results are well established, and unlike the case of four-quark operators, the subsequent QCD evolution of (3) introduces only small corrections (see e.g. [27]).

The most convenient representation of the CKM matrix is when δKM\delta_{\mathrm{KM}} enters mostly in VtdV_{td}. It enters the imaginary part of PEW\mathcal{P}_{\mathrm{EW}} and couples the axial vector current of leptons to the sˉγμ(1−γ5)d−dˉγμ(1−γ5)s\bar{s}\gamma_{\mu}(1-\gamma_{5})d-\bar{d}\gamma_{\mu}(1-\gamma_{5})s quark current. This current can create/annihilate CPCP-even combination of the neutral kaons that (in neglection of small ϵK\epsilon_{K}) can be identified with KSK_{S} field. Same operator in the muon channel induces KS→μ+μ−K_{S}\to\mu^{+}\mu^{-} meson decay [28, 29]. Within chiral perturbation theory, the axial vector current of leptons is treated as an external left-handed current, which gives rise to

LUee=−if022PEW×eˉγμγ5e×Tr⁡[h†(∂μU)U†]+(h.c.),(6)\mathcal{L}_{Uee}=-\frac{i f_{0}^{2}}{2}\mathcal{P}_{\mathrm{EW}}\times\bar{e}\gamma_{\mu}\gamma_{5}e\times\operatorname{Tr}\left[h^{\dagger}(\partial^{\mu}U)U^{\dagger}\right]+\text{(h.c.)}, \tag*{(6)}

where UU is the exponential of the meson octet MM, U=exp⁡[2iMf0−1]U=\exp[2iM f_{0}^{-1}], in our convention it transforms as U→RUR†U\to RUR^{\dagger}, and hij=δi2δj3h_{ij}=\delta_{i2}\delta_{j3}. At linear order, this leads to ∂μK×eˉγμγ5e\partial_{\mu}K\times\bar{e}\gamma^{\mu}\gamma_{5}e, and upon application of the equation of motion for electrons we arrive to

LKee=−22f0meeˉiγ5e(KS×Im⁡PEW+KL×Re⁡PEW).(7)\mathcal{L}_{Kee}=-2\sqrt{2}f_{0}m_{e}\bar{e}i\gamma_{5}e\left(K_{S}\times\operatorname{Im}\mathcal{P}_{\mathrm{EW}}+K_{L}\times\operatorname{Re}\mathcal{P}_{\mathrm{EW}}\right). \tag*{(7)}

In this expression, f0f_{0} is the meson coupling constant, that in the SU(3)SU(3) symmetric limit is equal to ≃134 MeV\simeq134\,\mathrm{MeV}, and we follow Ref. [30] conventions. Subsequent msm_{s}-dependent corrections renormalize this coupling to f0→fK≃160 MeVf_{0}\to f_{K}\simeq160\,\mathrm{MeV}. While other ss-quark containing resonances may also contribute, the neutral kaon exchange, Figure 1, will give the only ms−1m_{s}^{-1}-enhanced contribution in the chiral limit.

Image not extracted

Figure 1. EW3^{3} order diagram that dominates in the chiral limit. The top vertex is the CPCP-odd, PP-even KSeeˉiγ5eK_{S}e\bar{e}i\gamma_{5}e generated in EW2^{2} order, and the bottom vertex is CPCP-even, PP-odd KSNNˉK_{S}N\bar{N} coupling generated at EW1^{1} order.

We now need to find out how the neutral kaons couple to the nucleon scalar densities, pˉp\bar{p}p and nˉn\bar{n}n that occur due to ΔS=±1\Delta S=\pm1 transitions in the EW1^{1} order. Instead of attempting such calculation from first principles (see e.g. [31]) we will use flavor SU(3)SU(3) relations and connect this coupling to the ss-wave amplitudes of hadronic decays of strange hyperons, following [30]. It is well known that empirical ΔI=1/2\Delta I=1/2 rule holds for hyperon decays, and the leading order SU(3)SU(3) relations fit ss-wave amplitudes with O(10%)O(10\%) accuracy. It is strongly suspected that these amplitudes are indeed induced by strong penguins (SP), although this assumption is not crucial for us. With that, one can write down the two types of couplings consistent with (8L,1R)(8_{L},1_{R}) transformation properties:

LSP=−aTr⁡(Bˉ[ξ†hξ,B])−bTr⁡(Bˉ{ξ†hξ,B})+(h.c.).(8)\mathcal{L}_{\mathrm{SP}}=-a\operatorname{Tr}(\bar{B}[\xi^{\dagger}h\xi,B])-b\operatorname{Tr}(\bar{B}\{\xi^{\dagger}h\xi,B\})+\text{(h.c.)}. \tag*{(8)}

In this expression, BB is the baryon octet matrix, and ξ=exp⁡[iMf0−1]\xi=\exp[iM f_{0}^{-1}]. Assuming aa and bb to be real, and taking f0=fπf_0=f_\pi, they are fit to be2

a=0.56GFfπ×[mπ+]2;b=−1.42GFfπ×[mπ+]2.(9)a=0.56G_Ff_\pi\times[m_{\pi^+}]^2;\quad b=-1.42G_Ff_\pi\times[m_{\pi^+}]^2. \tag*{(9)}

Brackets over mπ+m_{\pi^+} indicate that these are numerical values taken, 139.5 MeV, rather than mu+mdm_u+m_d-proportional theoretical quantity mπm_\pi. In the assumption of aa and bb being real, only the KSK_S meson couples to nucleons, 21/2f0−1((b−a)pˉp+2bnˉn)KS2^{1/2}f_0^{-1}((b-a)\bar{p}p+2b\bar{n}n)K_S, which will provide the dominant contribution. This type of coupling breaks PP but respects CPCP symmetry. Restoring the CKM factors, one can also include much subdominant coupling to KLK_L so that we have:

LKNN≃−2GF×[mπ+]2fπ∣VudVus∣f0×2.84(0.7pˉp+nˉn)×(Re⁡(Vud∗Vus)KS+Im⁡(Vud∗Vus)KL).(10)\begin{aligned} \mathcal{L}_{KNN}\simeq-\frac{\sqrt{2}G_F\times[m_{\pi^+}]^2f_\pi}{\lvert V_{ud}V_{us}\rvert f_0}\times2.84(0.7\bar{p}p+\bar{n}n) \\ &\times\left(\operatorname{Re}(V_{ud}^{*}V_{us})K_S+\operatorname{Im}(V_{ud}^{*}V_{us})K_L\right). \tag*{(10)} \end{aligned}

At the last step, we integrate out the KK mesons as shown in Figure 1. Adopting it for a nucleus containing A=Z+NA=Z+N nucleons, one arrives to a straightforward prediction for the δKM\delta_{\mathrm{KM}}-induced size of the electron-nucleon interaction:

CS≃J×N+0.7ZA×13[mπ+]2fπmeGFmK2×αEMI(xt)πsin⁡θW2,(11)C_S\simeq\mathcal{J}\times\frac{N+0.7Z}{A}\times\frac{13[m_{\pi^+}]^2f_\pi m_eG_F}{m_K^2}\times\frac{\alpha_{\mathrm{EM}}I(x_t)}{\pi\sin\theta_W^2}, \tag*{(11)}

where J\mathcal{J} is the rephasing invariant combination of the CKM angles,

J=Im⁡(Vts∗VtdVud∗Vus)≃3.1×10−5,(12)\mathcal{J}=\operatorname{Im}(V_{ts}^{*}V_{td}V_{ud}^{*}V_{us})\simeq3.1\times10^{-5}, \tag*{(12)}

that carries about ∼6%\sim6\% uncertainty. Notice that the f0f_0 factor in the numerator of (7) cancels against f0f_0 in the denominator of (10), and this cancellation would persist even one changes f0f_0 for fKf_K.

The overall scaling of this formula in the chiral limit and at large xtx_t is

GFCS∝JGF3mt2mems−1Λhadr2.(13)G_FC_S\propto\mathcal{J}G_F^3m_t^2m_em_s^{-1}\Lambda_{\mathrm{hadr}}^2. \tag*{(13)}

where Λhadr\Lambda_{\mathrm{hadr}} is a typical hadronic energy/momentum scale. Notice that this is far more singular behavior with mqm_q of a light quark than that arising in the chiral-loop-induced expressions for dnd_n. Also notice that the KSK_S exchange dominates for any conventional parametrization of the CKM matrix, and the role of KLK_L exchange is to add small pieces of the amplitude that take Re⁡(VudVus∗)Im⁡(VtsVtd∗)\operatorname{Re}(V_{ud}V_{us}^{*})\operatorname{Im}(V_{ts}V_{td}^{*}), arising from KSK_S exchange, to full J\mathcal{J}. Substituting all SM parameters, we obtain the following leading order result:

CS(LO)≃5×10−16.(14)C_S(\mathrm{LO})\simeq5\times10^{-16}. \tag*{(14)}

In order to estimate accuracy of the LO ∼O(ms−1)\sim O(m_s^{-1}) result, one could try to evaluate the NLO corrections in the expansion over small msm_s. These corrections can be divided into two groups: A. corrections to the KˉN ⁣N\bar{K}N\!N vertex at mslog⁡msm_s\log m_s order, B. diagrams that do not reduce to the tt-channel KK-meson exchange. Type A corrections involve essentially same diagrams as those appearing in the corresponding corrections to the ss-wave hyperon decays [30, 33]. The analysis of Ref. [33] showed that when the loop corrections are included with the tree-level aa and bb parameters and the total theoretical result is fit to experimental data, one notices that the tree level values for aa and bb come out smaller than in (9), while total result is rather close to the tree-level fit for a,ba,b. This comes mostly from the renormalization of the meson and baryon wave functions. The lesson from this is that the corrections of type A for KNNKNN weak coupling are expected to mirror results of Ref. [33] for ss-wave amplitudes, and therefore would not deviate substantially from (10).

We then estimate type B corrections. It turns out that they parametrically dominate over other types of corrections, as the baryon pole diagrams, Figure 2, contribute. The msm_s scaling of these corrections is set by the ratio of the loop integral, proportional to mKm_K (at mK2≫mπ2m_K^2\gg m_\pi^2 limit), divided by mass splitting ΔmB\Delta m_B in the baryon octet, e.g. mΛ−mNm_\Lambda-m_N. This quantity scales as ms−1/2m_s^{-1/2} and therefore these baryon pole diagrams dominate the NLO contributions in the chiral limit. They are fully calculable (i.e.i.e. do not depend on unknown counterterms), and the result for these corrections are:

Image not extracted

Figure 2. The baryon pole diagrams that contribute to CSC_S at the NLO level in the chiral limit. The left vertex is the nucleon-hyperon mixing induced by Eq. (8), while the top vertex is induced by Eq. (6). The vertices without black dots are the strong interaction with the coupling constants DD and FF. The diagrams with the nucleon-hyperon mixing on the right side give the same amount of contribution.

CS,NLO(p)CS,LO(p)=mK3(0.7D2+2.7DF−2.3F2)24πf02(mΣ+−mp)(15)\frac{C_{S,\mathrm{NLO}}(p)}{C_{S,\mathrm{LO}}(p)}=\frac{m_K^3\left(0.7D^2+2.7DF-2.3F^2\right)}{24\pi f_0^2\left(m_{\Sigma^+}-m_p\right)} \tag*{(15)}
CS,NLO(n)CS,LO(n)=mK324πf02(a/b+322(mΛ−mn)(−0.44D2+3.2DF+1.3F2)+a/b−122(mΣ0−mn)(−0.53D2−1.9DF+1.6F2)).(16)\begin{aligned} \frac{C_{S,\mathrm{NLO}}(n)}{C_{S,\mathrm{LO}}(n)} ={}&\frac{m_K^3}{24\pi f_0^2}\left(\frac{a/b+3}{2\sqrt{2}\left(m_\Lambda-m_n\right)} \left(-0.44D^2+3.2DF+1.3F^2\right)\right.\\ &\left.+\frac{a/b-1}{2\sqrt{2}\left(m_{\Sigma^0}-m_n\right)} \left(-0.53D^2-1.9DF+1.6F^2\right)\right). \tag*{(16)} \end{aligned}

It has been obtained using heavy baryon chiral perturbation theory, and DD, FF are the coupling constants characterizing the strength of the SU(3)SU(3)-invariant baryon-meson strong interaction, with F=0.46F=0.46, D=0.8D=0.8 typically used [30]. Since the dominant contribution comes from loops with K−πK-\pi transition, it is appropriate to take f02≃fπfKf_0^2 \simeq f_\pi f_K. Using these numbers, we discover that NLO corrections interfere constructively with LO, and give 30% correction for the proton, and 40% for the neutron, correspondingly. Combining LO and NLO, we arrive at our final result,

CS(LO+NLO)≃6.9×10−16⇒deequiv≃1.0×10−35 e cm.(17)\begin{aligned} C_S(\mathrm{LO+NLO})\simeq6.9\times10^{-16} \\ &\Rightarrow d_e^{\mathrm{equiv}}\simeq1.0\times10^{-35}\ e\,\mathrm{cm}. \tag*{(17)} \end{aligned}

The size of the NLO corrections also allows us to estimate the accuracy of this computation as O(30%)O(30\%).

As stated in the introduction, this result is much larger than previously believed, and exceeds any contributions of ded_e into deequivd_e^{\mathrm{equiv}} by at least four orders of magnitude. The enhancement of CSC_S at EW3 order compared to EW2EM2 can be roughly ascribed to αW/αEM2∼O(103)\alpha_W/\alpha_{\mathrm{EM}}^2\sim O(10^3). We note that, although translating CSC_S to deequivd_e^{\mathrm{equiv}} depends on atoms/molecules that one considers (ThO above), this dependence is mild and deequivd_e^{\mathrm{equiv}} is within the same ballpark if we instead consider, e.g., Tl or YbF [25].

Stepping away from chiral expansion, one can formulate the necessary hadronic matrix element that will be required to generate CSC_S in combination with the dominant Im⁡PEW\operatorname{Im}P_{\mathrm{EW}} channel of Eq. (3). The corresponding dd-to-ss transitions need to be taken in the first order, EW1, that break PP and CC separately but conserve CPCP.

⟨N∣i(sˉγμ(1−γ5)d−dˉγμ(1−γ5)s)∣N⟩EW1=fSmNiqμNˉN+fTmNqνNˉσμνγ5N.(18)\left\langle N\left|i\left(\bar{s}\gamma_\mu(1-\gamma_5)d-\bar{d}\gamma_\mu(1-\gamma_5)s\right)\right|N\right\rangle_{\mathrm{EW}^1} =\frac{f_S}{m_N}iq_\mu\bar{N}N+\frac{f_T}{m_N}q_\nu\bar{N}\sigma^{\mu\nu}\gamma_5N. \tag*{(18)}

In this formula, qμq_\mu stands for the momentum transfer. It turns out that there are only two form factors on the r.h.s. of this expression that have the same CPCP properties as the left-hand side. Moreover, fTf_T in combination with Im⁡PEW\operatorname{Im}P_{\mathrm{EW}} leads to CPCP-odd PP-even interactions that do not induce EDMs. Therefore only fSf_S form factor (that sometimes is called induced scalar) at q2→0q^2\to0 is relevant. We have provided first two terms in the chiral expansion of fSf_S for neutrons and protons, so that effectively fS∝a(b)×mNmK−2+…f_S\propto a(b)\times m_Nm_K^{-2}+\ldots. While we use chiral perturbation theory, in principle, calculation of fSf_S can be attempted using lattice QCD methods.

Finally, we note that other semi-leptonic operators such as eˉeNˉiγ5N\bar{e}e\bar{N}i\gamma_5N that lead to nuclear-spin-dependent effects are not generated the same way at EW3 order and therefore will be suppressed compared to (11).

Conclusions

We have shown that δKM\delta_{\mathrm{KM}} induces CPCP-odd electron nucleon interaction at the level much larger than previous estimates [25]. The main mechanism is not a two-photon exchange, EW2EM2, between electron and the nucleus, but the combination of weak non-leptonic EW1 transition with the semileptonic EW2 electroweak penguin. Although the result is still small, it is not unthinkable that the progress in sensitivity to paramagnetic EDMs may reach the level of deequivd_e^{\mathrm{equiv}} in the future. Indeed, some novel proposals [8] envision that statistical sensitivity to paramagnetic EDMs can be brought down to de∼O(10−35d_e\sim O(10^{-35}–10−37) e cm10^{-37})\ e\,\mathrm{cm}.

It is not surprising that the CSC_S operator can be predicted, at least in the SU(3)SU(3) chiral expansion, rather precisely. This puts in clear distinction with dn(δKM)d_n(\delta_{\mathrm{KM}}) estimate that carries an order of magnitude uncertainty with unclear prospects for improvement. In contrast, the only significant source of uncertainty in CSC_S is in the induced scalar form factor (18) that can be improved in the future with the use of lattice QCD methods.

Even if one takes chiral SU(3)SU(3) expansion sceptically, it is clear that unique ms−1m_s^{-1} (LO) and ms−1/2m_s^{-1/2} (NLO) contributions to CSC_S identified in our work would not be cancelled - unless completely accidentally - by other contributions, mirroring a similar argument of [34] made for dn(θ)d_n(\theta). Therefore, 10−35 e cm10^{-35}\ e\,\mathrm{cm} should be adopted as the robust δKM\delta_{\mathrm{KM}}-induced SM benchmark value for all experiments attempting the search of ded_e using electron spins in heavy atoms and molecules. It also allows for establishing the maximum sensitivity to CP-violating New Physics via ded_e. Taking a one-loop perturbative scaling, de∝(α/π)meΛNP−2d_e\propto(\alpha/\pi)m_e\Lambda_{\mathrm{NP}}^{-2}, and equating it to deequiv(δKM)d_e^{\mathrm{equiv}}(\delta_{\mathrm{KM}}) one arrives at the maximum scale that is possible to probe with paramagnetic EDMs: ΛNP∼5×107 GeV\Lambda_{\mathrm{NP}}\sim5\times10^7\ \mathrm{GeV}.

Acknowledgments

Y.E. and M.P. are supported in part by U.S. Department of Energy Grant No. desc0011842. The Feynman diagrams in this paper are drawn with TikZ-Feynman [2].

References

  1. [2]J. Ellis, “TikZ-Feynman: Feynman diagrams with TikZ,” Comput. Phys. Commun. 210 (2017) 103–123, arXiv:1601.05437 [hep-ph].DOI

Paper details

vlnc:W_n22sd3rc
Version
v1 · latest
Published
Fresh — added to the Hub within the last 30 days
Added
License
CC BY 4.0
Usage

views · 4

downloads · 0

A view counts once per browser per day, a download each time the PDF is requested.

  • Physics and Astronomy

Not recorded for this paper

View statement
Looking for related papers…
Contents