betaFeedback

WorksPhysics and Astronomy

Equality of the Jellium and the Uniform Electron Gas Energies

Abstract

Jellium, a system of electrons in a uniform neutralizing background, and the uniform electron gas (UEG), a system of electrons with constant density and no background, are two standard models of the electron gas. We prove that the ground-state energy per unit volume of Jellium, as defined by Lieb and Narnhofer, coincides with the UEG energy defined by Lewin, Lieb and Seiringer, i.e. eJelℏ(ρ0)=eUEGℏ(ρ0)e^\hbar_{\rm Jel}(\rho_0)=e^\hbar_{\rm UEG}(\rho_0). This equality was previously established in the classical case by Lewin, Lieb and Seiringer and independently by Cotar and Petrache.

Introduction

The electron gas, an infinite system of interacting electrons spread uniformly over space, is one of the most studied models of many-body quantum mechanics [4]. In the physics literature the terms “electron gas”, (interacting) “Fermi gas” and “Jellium” are mostly used interchangeably. Jellium is a system of electrons moving in a uniform background of positive charge which exactly neutralizes them. The uniformity of Jellium is, however, only that of the background. Wigner predicted that the electrons crystallize at low density [19], and so the ground state of Jellium is not expected to have constant density [10]. Mathematically, the thermodynamic limit of Jellium was established by Lieb and Narnhofer [14], building on the work of Lieb and Lebowitz [13]. For the ground-state energy their result reads as follows. Let {ΩN}\{\Omega_N\} be a sequence of bounded domains that grow regularly to R3\mathbb{R}^3, for instance balls, with ρ0∣ΩN∣=N\rho_0|\Omega_N|=N. Then the limit

eJelℏ(ρ0)=lim⁡N→∞1∣ΩN∣inf⁡spec⁡(−ℏ2∑j=1NΔxj+∑1≤j<k≤N1∣xj−xk∣−ρ0∑j=1N∫ΩNdy∣xj−y∣+ρ022∬ΩN×ΩNdx dy∣x−y∣).e_{\mathrm{Jel}}^{\hbar}(\rho_0)=\lim_{N\to\infty}\frac{1}{|\Omega_N|}\inf\operatorname{spec}\left(-\hbar^2\sum_{j=1}^{N}\Delta_{x_j}+\sum_{1\leq j<k\leq N}\frac{1}{|x_j-x_k|}-\rho_0\sum_{j=1}^{N}\int_{\Omega_N}\frac{\mathrm{d}y}{|x_j-y|}+\frac{\rho_0^2}{2}\iint_{\Omega_N\times\Omega_N}\frac{\mathrm{d}x\,\mathrm{d}y}{|x-y|}\right).

exists and does not depend on the shape of the domains. Here the Hamiltonian acts on antisymmetric functions of NN variables in ΩN\Omega_N, each carrying qq spin states, with homogeneous Dirichlet boundary conditions on ∂ΩN\partial\Omega_N. The third term is the attraction between the electrons and the background, and the last one is the electrostatic self-energy of the background. The system is thus exactly neutral as the number of electrons equals the total charge of the background.

The approach of Lewin, Lieb and Seiringer [9] does not involve the ground-state problem. They define the uniform electron gas (UEG) as a system of electrons whose density is constant everywhere, without any background. In the quantum case its energy is expressed through the grand-canonical Levy–Lieb functional [12], the minimal kinetic and interaction energy of electrons with a prescribed density. Since quantum densities cannot be cut off sharply, the indicator function of the domain has to be smoothed. In the convenient form of [11], the UEG energy per unit volume is

eUEGℏ(ρ0)=lim⁡N→∞1∣ΩN∣(inf⁡ρΓ=ρ01ΩN∗χδNΓ=(Γ(n))n≥0∑n≥1Tr⁡[(−ℏ2∑j=1nΔxj+∑1≤j<k≤n1∣xj−xk∣)Γ(n)]−ρ022∬R3×R3(1ΩN∗χδN)(x)(1ΩN∗χδN)(y)∣x−y∣ dx dy).e_{\mathrm{UEG}}^{\hbar}(\rho_0)=\lim_{N\to\infty}\frac{1}{|\Omega_N|}\left(\inf_{\substack{\rho_\Gamma=\rho_0\mathbb{1}_{\Omega_N}*\chi_{\delta_N}\\ \Gamma=(\Gamma^{(n)})_{n\geq0}}}\sum_{n\geq1}\operatorname{Tr}\left[\left(-\hbar^2\sum_{j=1}^{n}\Delta_{x_j}+\sum_{1\leq j<k\leq n}\frac{1}{|x_j-x_k|}\right)\Gamma^{(n)}\right]-\frac{\rho_0^2}{2}\iint_{\mathbb{R}^3\times\mathbb{R}^3}\frac{(\mathbb{1}_{\Omega_N}*\chi_{\delta_N})(x)(\mathbb{1}_{\Omega_N}*\chi_{\delta_N})(y)}{|x-y|}\,\mathrm{d}x\,\mathrm{d}y\right).

where χδ(x)=δ−3χ(δ−1x)\chi_\delta(x)=\delta^{-3}\chi(\delta^{-1}x) for a fixed radial function 0≤χ∈Cc∞(R3)0\leq\chi\in C^\infty_c(\mathbb{R}^3) with supp⁡χ⊂B1\operatorname{supp}\chi\subset B_1 and ∫R3χ=1\int_{\mathbb{R}^3}\chi=1. The domains satisfy the hypotheses of Theorem 2.4(ii), and the smoothing scales δN>0\delta_N>0 satisfy δN/∣ΩN∣1/3→0\delta_N/|\Omega_N|^{1/3}\to0 and δN∣ΩN∣1/3→∞\delta_N|\Omega_N|^{1/3}\to\infty. The infimum is taken over all grand-canonical fermion states Γ=(Γ(n))n≥0\Gamma=(\Gamma^{(n)})_{n\geq0}, satisfying the constraint ρΓ=ρ01ΩN∗χδN\rho_\Gamma=\rho_0\mathbb{1}_{\Omega_N}*\chi_{\delta_N}. The limit exists [9, 11], and it has the expected behavior at high density [9].

For the classical UEG (which is obtained by taking ℏ=0\hbar=0, dropping χδ\chi_\delta and optimizing over classical NN-particle probability measures), it was shown that the Jellium and the UEG energies coincide [10, 1]. Averaging a crystal over translations (the “floating crystal”) gives a constant density, but the charge fluctuations at the boundary of the sample raise the energy by an amount proportional to the volume [8 Appendix B]. This issue was overcome by Lewin, Lieb and Seiringer, who constructed a floating Wigner crystal with no boundary charge fluctuations by introducing a liquid layer at the boundary [10], and independently by Cotar and Petrache [1] by a different method.

In the quantum case, it is believed that the two energies coincide as well [11 Sec. 2.2]. The easy inequality eUEGℏ(ρ0)≥eJelℏ(ρ0)e_{\mathrm{UEG}}^{\hbar}(\rho_0)\geq e_{\mathrm{Jel}}^{\hbar}(\rho_0) was proved in [9] for a grand-canonical version of Jellium. The reverse inequality is harder, because Jellium states, which are expected to be crystalline, have to be turned into states with an exactly constant density at a cost which is negligible compared with the volume.

In this paper we prove that the Jellium and the UEG energies coincide also in the quantum case. Our main result, Theorem 3.1 below, states that

eJelℏ(ρ0)=eUEGℏ(ρ0).e_{\mathrm{Jel}}^{\hbar}(\rho_0)=e_{\mathrm{UEG}}^{\hbar}(\rho_0).

In particular, the known properties of the UEG carry over to Jellium (Remark 2). For instance, at fixed ℏ>0\hbar>0,

eJelℏ(ρ0)=35(6π2q)2/3ℏ2ρ05/3−34(6qπ)1/3ρ04/3+o(ρ04/3)as ρ0→∞.e_{\mathrm{Jel}}^{\hbar}(\rho_0)=\frac{3}{5}\left(\frac{6\pi^2}{q}\right)^{2/3}\hbar^2\rho_0^{5/3}-\frac{3}{4}\left(\frac{6}{q\pi}\right)^{1/3}\rho_0^{4/3}+o(\rho_0^{4/3})\qquad\text{as }\rho_0\to\infty.

The first term is the kinetic energy of the free Fermi gas and the second one is the Dirac exchange energy. Moreover, ρ0−4/3eJelℏ(ρ0)\rho_0^{-4/3}e_{\mathrm{Jel}}^{\hbar}(\rho_0) converges to the classical Jellium energy at unit density as ℏ2ρ01/3→0\hbar^2\rho_0^{1/3}\to0 (see Figure 1).

Figure 1. Sketch of eUEGℏ(ρ0)=eJelℏ(ρ0)e_{\mathrm{UEG}}^{\hbar}(\rho_0)=e_{\mathrm{Jel}}^{\hbar}(\rho_0) as a function of ρ0\rho_0.

Organization of the paper. In Section 2, we fix our notation (Section 2.1) and recall the definitions and the known results for Jellium (Section 2.2) and for the UEG (Section 2.3). Section 3 contains our main result, Theorem 3.1, its consequences for Jellium (Remark 2) and an outline of its proof (Section 3.1). The proofs are given in Section 4: after collecting some general facts in Section 4.1, we prove the inequality eJelℏ(ρ0)≤eUEGℏ(ρ0)e_{\mathrm{Jel}}^{\hbar}(\rho_0)\le e_{\mathrm{UEG}}^{\hbar}(\rho_0) in Section 4.2 and the inequality eUEGℏ(ρ0)≤eJelℏ(ρ0)e_{\mathrm{UEG}}^{\hbar}(\rho_0)\le e_{\mathrm{Jel}}^{\hbar}(\rho_0) in Section 4.3. Appendix A sketches the proof of the thermodynamic limit of Jellium on balls at zero temperature, and Appendix B contains the neutralization construction used in Section 4.2.

Acknowledgments

The author has received funding from the ERC-2021-STG under grant agreement No. 101041487 REGAL.

Use of AI tools

The author made substantial use of the LLMs ChatGPT (OpenAI) and Claude (Anthropic) in the preparation of this work, including the development of the proofs, writing and making figures. The author has checked all the proofs by hand, and takes full responsibility for the content of the article.

Lean verification

The formalization in Lean gpt2, produced with the help of the same AI tools, checks the lower and upper comparisons of Sections 4.2 and 4.3 and the neutralization construction of Appendix B in Lean 4 with Mathlib. The verification is relative to explicit hypotheses on abstract states and charges. The cited literature results, including the physical Lieb–Narnhofer thermodynamic limit, and the general facts of Section 4.1 remain inputs. The representation of quantum states by density operators on Hilbert space and the general identities for their kinetic and Coulomb energies are assumed rather than formalized.

Setting

Notation

For ℓ>0\ell> 0 we write Cℓ=(−ℓ/2,ℓ/2)3C_{\ell} = (-\ell/2,\ell/2)^3 for the open cube of side length ℓ\ell centered at the origin. For functions f,g:R3→Rf,g : \mathbb{R}^3 \to\mathbb{R} we write

D(f,g):=12∫R3∫R3f(x)g(y)∣x−y∣ dx dy,D(f):=D(f,f)D(f,g) := \frac{1}{2} \int_{\mathbb{R}^3} \int_{\mathbb{R}^3} \frac{f(x)g(y)}{\lvert x-y\rvert}\,\mathrm{d}x\,\mathrm{d}y,\qquad D(f) := D(f,f)

for the Coulomb inner product and the direct Coulomb energy. For an integer spin multiplicity q≥1q \ge1, the Thomas–Fermi and Dirac constants are

References

  1. [1]Codina Cotar and Mircea Petrache. Equality of the Jellium and uniform electron gas next-order asymptotic terms for Coulomb and Riesz potentials. arXiv preprint arXiv:1707.07664, 2019. URL https://arxiv.org/abs/1707.07664v5.
  2. [2]Lawrence C. Evans and Ronald F. Gariepy. Measure Theory and Fine Properties of Functions. Textbooks in Mathematics. CRC Press, Boca Raton, FL, revised edition, 2015.
  3. [3]Michael E. Fisher. The free energy of a macroscopic system. Archive for Rational Mechanics and Analysis, 17(5):377–410, 1964.DOI
  4. [4]Gabriele Giuliani and Giovanni Vignale. Quantum theory of the electron liquid. Cambridge University Press, 2005.
  5. [5]Gian Michele Graf and Daniel Schenker. On the molecular limit of Coulomb gases. Communications in Mathematical Physics, 174:215–227, 1995.DOI
  6. [6]Maria Hoffmann-Ostenhof and Thomas Hoffmann-Ostenhof. “Schrödinger inequalities” and asymptotic behavior of the electron density of atoms and molecules. Physical Review A, 16(5):1782, 1977.
  7. [7]Mathieu Lewin. Coulomb and Riesz gases: The known and the unknown. Journal of Mathematical Physics, 63(6):061101, 2022. doi: 10.1063/5.0086835.DOI
  8. [8]Mathieu Lewin and Elliott H. Lieb. Improved Lieb–Oxford exchange-correlation inequality with a gradient correction. Physical Review A, 91(2):022507, 2015.DOI
  9. [9]Mathieu Lewin, Elliott H. Lieb, and Robert Seiringer. Statistical mechanics of the uniform electron gas. Journal de l’École polytechnique-Mathématiques, 5:79–116, 2018.DOI
  10. [10]Mathieu Lewin, Elliott H. Lieb, and Robert Seiringer. Floating Wigner crystal with no boundary charge fluctuations. Physical Review B, 100(3):035127, 2019.DOI
  11. [11]Mathieu Lewin, Elliott H. Lieb, and Robert Seiringer. The local density approximation in density functional theory. Pure and Applied Analysis, 2(1):35–73, 2020.DOI
  12. [12]Mathieu Lewin, Elliott H. Lieb, and Robert Seiringer. Universal functionals in density functional theory. In Eric Cancès and Gero Friesecke, editors, Density Functional Theory: Modeling, Mathematical Analysis, Computational Methods, and Applications, pages 115–182. Springer, 2023. doi: 10.1007/978-3-031-22340-2_3.DOI
  13. [13]Elliott H. Lieb and Joel L. Lebowitz. The constitution of matter: Existence of thermodynamics for systems composed of electrons and nuclei. Advances in Mathematics, 9(3):316–398, 1972.
  14. [14]Elliott H. Lieb and Heide Narnhofer. The thermodynamic limit for jellium. Journal of Statistical Physics, 12(4):291–310, 1975.
  15. [15]Elliott H. Lieb and Stephen Oxford. Improved lower bound on the indirect Coulomb energy. International Journal of Quantum Chemistry, 19(3):427–439, 1981.
  16. [16]Elliott H. Lieb and Robert Seiringer. The stability of matter in quantum mechanics. Cambridge University Press, 2010.DOI
  17. [17]Lars Onsager. Electrostatic interaction of molecules. The Journal of Physical Chemistry, 43(2):189–196, 1939.DOI
  18. [18]R. R. Sari and D. Merlini. On the ν-dimensional one-component classical plasma: the thermodynamic limit problem revisited. Journal of Statistical Physics, 14(2):91–100, 1976.DOI
  19. [19]Eugene Wigner. On the interaction of electrons in metals. Physical Review, 46(11):1002–1011, 1934.

Paper details

vlnc:W_n3vmvbfu
Version
v1 · latest
Published
Fresh — added to the Hub within the last 30 days
Added
License
CC BY 4.0
Usage

views · 0

downloads · 2

A view counts once per browser per day, a download each time the PDF is requested.

  • Physics and Astronomy

OpenAI ChatGPT 6, Anthropic Claude Opus 5.5

View statement
Looking for related papers…
Contents