WorksPhysics and Astronomy
The role of strangeness and baryon enhancement in heavy-quark hadronisation from pp to PbPb collisions with ALICE
Abstract
In this contribution, a combined study of charm-meson and charm-baryon production with ALICE is presented. The ratio in pp collisions at TeV and the first measurement of the nuclear modification factor of baryons in PbPb collisions at TeV are reported. Furthermore, measurements of the production ratio from low-multiplicity pp collisions at TeV to PbPb collisions at TeV are presented. Lastly, the first measurement of the -differential yield ratio is shown.
Introduction
Hadronisation is a fundamental process of nature, in which quarks combine to form hadrons. It involves non-perturbative QCD effects, thus making first-principles calculations challenging. Instead, this process is usually parametrised using data collected in and ep collisions, where hadronisation is assumed to occur via in-vacuum fragmentation, and used to describe hadron production in proton–proton (pp) collisions, under the assumption of a universal hadronisation mechanism. Measurements of charm baryon-to-meson ratios in pp collisions at the LHC [1], however, show a significant enhancement compared with those in collisions, challenging the assumption of universal hadronisation and motivating models incorporating modified hadronisation mechanisms, such as coalescence, or the formation of small droplets of quark-gluon plasma. Measurements of the production of strange hadrons as a function of charged-particle multiplicity in pp collisions [2] show an increasing trend with multiplicity, which hints at the possible formation of quark-gluon plasma also in small systems. In this context, measurements of strange and non-strange charm hadrons across collision systems are crucial to probe the hadronisation mechanism of charm quarks. In particular, hadronisation via coalescence in a strangeness-rich environment, such as the one created in Pb–Pb collisions, is expected to enhance the production of strange charm hadrons.
Measurements of charm baryons in pp and Pb–Pb collisions
Measurements of charm baryon-to-meson production-yield ratios, such as , provide important constraints on charm hadronisation mechanisms. The left panel of Figure 1 shows the ratio measured in pp collisions at TeV. At low , the ratio is significantly larger than the LEP average of [3] and than the predictions of models in which fragmentation is tuned to measurements at colliders, such as PYTHIA 8 with the Monash tune [4]. A better description of the data is provided by models incorporating additional hadronisation mechanisms, such as colour reconnections beyond the leading-colour approximation [5] in PYTHIA, or hadronisation via coalescence in Catania [6], QCM [7], and POWLANG [8], or an additional set of yet-unobserved excited charm states predicted by the Relativistic Quark Model [9] in a statistical hadronisation model (SHM+RQM) [10]. At high , the ratio approaches the value measured in collisions, suggesting that fragmentation becomes the dominant hadronisation mechanism in this regime.
Figure 1. Left panel: ratio measured in pp collisions at TeV, compared with Pythia 8 with the Monash tune [4], Pythia 8 with colour reconnections beyond the leading-colour approximation [5], Catania [6], QCM [7], POWLANG [8], and a statistical model with additional excited charm states predicted by the Relativistic Quark Model (SHM+RQM) [9, 10]. Right panel: of baryons measured in Pb–Pb collisions at TeV in the 0–10% and 30–50% centrality intervals, compared with QCM [7] and TAMU [11] models.
Possible modifications of the hadronisation mechanism in Pb–Pb collisions are investigated by measuring the nuclear modification factor of charm hadrons. The right panel of Figure 1 shows the first measurement of of baryons, performed by the ALICE Collaboration at midrapidity () in Pb–Pb collisions at TeV. The reaches a value of at its maximum, the largest among the measured charm hadrons, suggesting a strong enhancement in the production of strange charm baryons in Pb–Pb collisions. The measurement is compared with predictions from the QCM [7] and TAMU [11] models, which implement hadronisation via coalescence. Both models qualitatively describe the trend observed in the data, despite predicting a smaller enhancement than measured.
Strangeness enhancement of charm mesons from pp to Pb–Pb collisions
The ratio of strange-to-non-strange charm mesons, , is a sensitive probe of charm-quark hadronisation. Figure 2 shows the ratio measured by the ALICE Collaboration at midrapidity () in pp collisions at TeV and in Pb–Pb collisions at TeV as a function of charged-particle multiplicity, for different intervals. In pp collisions, the ratio shows a flat trend as a function of multiplicity, as expected from a scenario of hadronisation via fragmentation only. In contrast, in Pb–Pb collisions, the ratio increases with multiplicity for GeV/, suggesting that coalescence plays a role in charm hadronisation in Pb–Pb collisions. At high ( GeV/), the ratio in Pb–Pb collisions is compatible with the one measured in pp collisions, indicating that fragmentation becomes the dominant hadronisation mechanism at large .
Figure 2. ratio measured by the ALICE Collaboration at midrapidity () in pp collisions at TeV and in Pb–Pb collisions at TeV as a function of charged-particle multiplicity, for different intervals of .
To assess whether an increase in the total production of strange-charm mesons as compared to non-strange ones is observed, or whether the observed trend with charged-particle multiplicity is due to a different transverse momentum distribution in Pb–Pb collisions, the ratio was integrated over and is shown in the left panel of Figure 3. An increase in the measured ratio is observed in Pb–Pb collisions as compared to pp collisions, suggesting that hadronisation via coalescence may occur in this system. The measurement is compared with expectations from Pythia 8 with colour reconnections beyond the leading-colour approximation [5, 12], which predicts a flat trend as a function of multiplicity, also in Pb–Pb collisions. EPOS4HQ [13] is a core-corona model, where in the corona region hadronisation occurs via fragmentation, while in the core region coalescence can take place. The model predicts an increase of the ratio with multiplicity, qualitatively describing the trend observed in the data, but it also predicts a dependence on multiplicity in pp collisions, which is not observed. Lastly, the measurement is compared with the GSI-Heidelberg [14] and ThermalFIST [15] statistical hadronisation models for Pb–Pb collisions. In pp collisions, a statistical model including the canonical suppression required to describe local quantum-number conservation in small systems (CE-SHMc) [10] is also shown. The statistical models predict an increasing trend with charged-particle multiplicity; however, they overestimate the measured ratio.
Figure 3. Left panel: -integrated D/D ratio as a function of charged-particle multiplicity in pp collisions at TeV and in Pb–Pb collisions at TeV, compared with Pythia 8 with colour reconnections beyond the leading-colour approximation [5, 12], EPOS4HQ [13], and statistical hadronisation models [14, 15, 10]. Right panel: -differential D/D production yield ratio multiplied by the D DK branching ratio measured in pp collisions at TeV, compared with Pythia 8 with colour reconnections beyond the leading-colour approximation [5] and statistical hadronisation models [14, 10].
Feed-down from excited strange-charm hadrons decaying to non-strange ones could change the trend with multiplicity of the ratio predicted by different models. Therefore, precise measurements of the production of excited charm states are crucial to interpret the measured ratio. The first measurement of the -differential production yield ratio in pp collisions at TeV is shown in the right panel of Figure 3. The ratio is compatible with the -integrated ratio measured by the ALICE Collaboration in Run 2 [16], and shows a mild increasing trend with . Predictions from Pythia 8 and from the TAMU statistical hadronisation model [10] are also shown. The first model, in which the production of the excited strange-charm states was tuned to reproduce Run 2 results, shows good agreement with the data, while the latter underestimates the measured ratio. The GSI-Heidelberg statistical model [14] is in agreement with the -integrated ratio measured in Run 2.
Conclusions
Charm-hadron production measurements provide key information on charm-quark hadronisation in different collision systems. The ratio measured by ALICE in pp collisions is significantly enhanced with respect to collisions, indicating that hadronisation is not universal across collision systems. The first measurement of the nuclear modification factor of baryons in Pb–Pb collisions shows a strong enhancement in the production of strange charm baryons, highlighting the importance of coalescence in charm hadronisation in this system. Measurements of the strange-to-non-strange charm-meson ratio show that the ratio increases with charged-particle multiplicity in Pb–Pb collisions as compared to pp collisions, and that fragmentation alone, as implemented in Pythia 8, does not fully describe the observed trend. Lastly, the reported measurement of the production of excited charm states provides the first important insights into the role of the feed-down contribution to the ratio.
References
References
- [1]S. Acharya, et al., First measurement of Λ+c production down to pT = 0 in pp and p–Pb collisions at √sNN = 5.02 TeV, Phys. Rev. C 107 (6) (2023) 064901. arXiv:2211.14032, doi:10.1103/PhysRevC.107.064901.DOI
- [2]J. Adam, et al., Enhanced production of multi-strange hadrons in high-multiplicity proton-proton collisions, Nature Phys. 13 (2017) 535–539. arXiv:1606.07424, doi:10.1038/nphys4111.DOI
- [3]L. Gladilin, Fragmentation fractions of c and b quarks into charmed hadrons at LEP, Eur. Phys. J. C 75 (1) (2015) 19. arXiv:1404.3888, doi:10.1140/epjc/s10052-014-3250-3.DOI
- [16]S. Acharya, et al., First measurement of Ds1(1+)(2536)+ and Ds2(2+)(2573)+ production in proton-proton collisions at √s = 13 TeV at the LHC, Phys. Rev. D 111 (11) (2025) 112005. arXiv:2409.11938, doi:10.1103/PhysRevD.111.112005.DOI