betaFeedback

WorksPhysics and Astronomy

Delta isobar resonance effects studied by summed isospin spin strengths and nuclear matrix elements for double and single beta decays

Abstract

Nuclear matrix elements (NMEs) for double and single beta decays are crucial for studying neutrino properties beyond and within the standard model. The NMEs consist mainly of the spin isospin components. The delta isobar resonance, which is strongly excited by the qualk spin isospin excitation, is shown to quench the spin isospin NMEs by a coefficient around 0.7. Impact of the delta resonance on neutrino studies in nuclei is discused.

Introduction

Neutrino (ν\nu) properties such as the Majorana nature, the ν\nu-mass, and the right-handed weak currents beyond the standard model are studied by neutrinoless double beta decays (ββ\beta\beta) as discussed in [1, 2, 3, 4]. Astro-ν\nu productions, syntheses and oscillations are studied by ν\nu-nuclear reactions (inverse-β\beta decays). Nuclear matrix elements (NMEs) for nuclear ββ\beta\beta and inverse-β\beta decays are crucial for studying these ν\nu properties of the current astro-particle physics interests.

The NMEs, reflecting complex nuclear structures, are very sensitive to all kinds of nucleonic and non-nucleonic correlations. Major components of the NME are the isospin (τ\tau) axial-vector (spin σ\sigma) ones. Accordingly, the ββ\beta\beta and inverse-β\beta NMEs depend much on nucleonic and non-nucleonic τσ\tau\sigma correlations, which are induced by various τσ\tau\sigma-type nuclear interactions. The β\beta NMEs have been discussed extensively in [5, 6, 7, 8, 9, 10, 11, 12, 13, 14, 15] and references therein, and the ββ\beta\beta NMEs in [10, 13, 16, 17, 18, 19, 20, 21, 22, 23, 24, 25] and references therein.

A nucleus is composed mainly by nucleons (N) with τ,σ=1/2,1/2\tau,\sigma=1/2,1/2, and thus the NN τσ\tau\sigma correlations are the correlations to be considered in ββ\beta\beta and inverse-β\beta NMEs. The delta isobar (Δ=Δ33\Delta=\Delta_{33}) with τ,σ=3/2,3/2\tau,\sigma=3/2,3/2 is strongly excited by the quark τσ\tau\sigma flip from a nucleon, and the NΔ\Delta τσ\tau\sigma correlations are the key non-nucleonic correlations to be considered as well for the ββ\beta\beta and inverse-β\beta NMEs. The NMEs discussed in the present work are such τσ\tau\sigma ones that couple directly with the Δ\Delta. They are involved in axial-vector weak, isovector magnetic and τσ\tau\sigma nuclear interactions.

The strong repulsive (V>0V>0) NN τσ\tau\sigma interaction pushes up the nuclear τσ\tau\sigma strength (square of the τσ\tau\sigma NME) to form the τσ\tau\sigma NN giant resonance (GRN_N) in the 10–15 MeV region, leaving a little τσ\tau\sigma strength in low-lying quasi-

particle (QP) states. Then τσ\tau\sigma NMEs for low-lying states are much reduced due to this τσ\tau\sigma NN correlation.

Likewise, the strong repulsive NΔ\Delta τσ\tau\sigma interaction pushes up the τσ\tau\sigma strength to form the NΔ\Delta giant resonance (GRΔ_\Delta) at the high excitation region around the Δ\Delta mass (≈300\approx300 MeV), and thereby shifts some τσ\tau\sigma strength from the N region around 0–30 MeV to the Δ\Delta region around 300 MeV, resulting in considerable reduction of the summed τσ\tau\sigma strengths in the N region and thus in severe quenching of the axial-vector components of the ββ\beta\beta and inverse-β\beta NMEs in the N region.

The present report is concerned mainly with the gross non-nucleonic effect associated with the GRΔ_\Delta. This effect is studied experimentally by investigating the reduction of the summed τσ\tau\sigma strength in the N region. Actually, there are many other nucleonic correlations that affect more or less individual nuclear states and their NMEs as discussed extensively by using various kinds of nuclear models in the review [13], but they are not discussed in the present work.

The τσ\tau\sigma strengths in DBD nuclei have been well studied experimentally in the wide nucleonic excitation region (N region) of E≈0E \approx0–30 MeV by using charge exchange reactions (CERs). Then, the non-nucleonic reduction effect is well studied experimentally by investigation the summed τσ\tau\sigma strengths there.

The present work aims to study for the first time the non-nucleonic GRΔ_{\Delta} effects on τσ\tau\sigma (axial-vector) NMEs for medium-heavy DBD nuclei on the basis of the experimental summed τσ\tau\sigma strengths and GR energies measured by the medium-energy CERs. The gross feature of the non-nucleonic quenching effect is discussed by using the quasi-particle random phase approximation (QRPA(NΔ\Delta)) with both the NN τσ\tau\sigma and NΔ\Delta τσ\tau\sigma nuclear interactions. The DBD nuclei discussed are 76^{76}Ge, 82^{82}Se, 96^{96}Zr, 100^{100}Mo, 130^{130}Te, 136^{136}Xe, and 150^{150}Nd, which are of current interest. They are the nuclei with NN (neutron number) ≫Z\gg Z (proton number) since β\beta/EC (electron capture) decays are forbidden.

The QP β\beta and ββ\beta\beta transition diagrams are schematically shown in Figure 1. Here GRN_N is given by a coherent sum of jj-neutron (njn_j) to jj-proton (pjp_j) excitations, while GRΔ_{\Delta} by a coherent sum of NkN_k to Δk\Delta_k excitations. The τσ\tau\sigma NME for a low-lying QP state is reduced from the QP NME for n1n_1 to p1p_1 by the negative-phase admixtures of the NMEs for the GRN_N and GRΔ_{\Delta}. Here the admixture is due to the repulsive NN and NΔ\Delta interactions.

Schematic diagram of a QP beta decay and beta beta decay

Figure 1. Schematic diagram of a QP β\beta decay (top) and that of a ββ\beta\beta decay (bottom). ν\nu : Majorana neutrino. The NME is given schematically by a coherent sum of a QP NME for n1→p1n_{1}\to p_{1} and a GRN_N NME for Σi[ni→pi]\Sigma_i [n_i\to p_i]. The GRN_N and the GRΔ_\Delta are mixed with the QP by the NN and NΔ\Delta interactions via meson-exchange interactions.

Actually, the Δ\Delta effect on τσ\tau\sigma NMEs involved in weak, electromagnetic and nuclear (strong) interactions has been discussed before [7, 8, 9, 26, 27, 28, 29, 30, 31, 32, 33]. These works suggest severe reduction (quenching) due to the Δ\Delta effect. Exchange (meson) and 2-body (2B) currents are associated with the Δ\Delta via the meson-exchange between 2 nucleons (2B), and their effects on β\beta and ββ\beta\beta NMEs are discussed very well theoretically [14, 15, 18].

Axial-vector (τσ\tau\sigma) β\beta and ββ\beta\beta NMEs are discussed as given in reviews and references therein [10, 13] and also in recent works [11, 12, 25, 34]. There the experimental GT (Gamov-Teller) and SD (spin dipole) NMEs are shown to be reduced much more than expected from nucleonic τσ\tau\sigma correlations, and some reduction effects due to non-nucleonic correlations such as the NΔ\Delta are discussed.

Summed GT strengths

Summed GT strengths in the N region

We first discuss summed GT τ±\tau^\pm strengths defined as S±=∑B(GT±)S^\pm= \sum B(\mathrm{GT}^\pm) with B(GT±)≡∣M(GT±)∣2B(\mathrm{GT}^\pm) \equiv|M(\mathrm{GT}^\pm)|^2 for 0+→1+0^+ \to1^+ transition in the N region. The Ikeda-Fujii-Fujita sum-rule [35] is given as SN(GT)=S−−S+=6Tz=3(N−Z)S_N(\mathrm{GT}) = S^- - S^+ = 6T_z = 3(N-Z). This rule is based on nuclear models with NN (nuclei, i.e. A−ZA-Z neutrons with tz=1/2t_z=1/2 and ZZ protons with tz=−1/2t_z=-1/2 and NN correlations, but no non-nucleonic baryons like Δ\Delta and their correlations.

The non-nucleonic Δ\Delta effect on the τσ\tau\sigma NMEs is studied by investigating if the sum in the N region gets smaller than the sum rule by shifting the strength up from the nucleonic N region around 0-30 MeV to the non-nucleonic Δ\Delta region around 300 MeV. Recently we have measured the B(GT−)B(\mathrm{GT}^-) for low-lying QP states relevant to 2νββ2\nu\beta\beta NMEs within the standard model at RCNP Osaka by using the (3^3He,tt) CERs [36, 37, 38, 39, 40, 41, 42, 43, 44, 45, 46] on medium-heavy DBD nuclei and others. We reanalyze the data to extract the GT and SD summed strengths and their GR energies relevant to the 0νββ0\nu\beta\beta NMEs beyond SM and astro-ν\nu NMEs. Note that the GT and SD NMEs studied by CERs with the strong interaction are the same GT and SD NMEs for weak and electromagnetic interactions, although their interaction couplings are very different.

The unique features of the present CER are as follows [10, 13]. i. The medium-energy (E≈0.42E \approx0.42–0.45 GeV) projectile excites preferentially GT(1+1^+) and SD(2−2^-) states because of the dominant τσ\tau\sigma (axial-vector) nuclear (strong) interaction, namely Vτσ≫VττV_{\tau\sigma} \gg V_{\tau\tau}, VTV_T where VτσV_{\tau\sigma}, VττV_{\tau\tau} and VTV_T are the axial-vector, the vector and the tensor interactions [10, 13, 47]. The distortion potential of V0V_0 gets minimum at the medium energy EE. ii. The high energy-resolution (10−510^{-5}) spectrometers for the incident and emitted particles make it possible to measure well the GT and SD strengths, being free from backgrounds. The distortion effect is well evaluated experimentally. Thus one can get experimentally reliable GT and SD τσ\tau\sigma NMEs. In fact, GT NMEs derived from the CER experiments, after adequate corrections for the VTV_T effects, agree within a few % with GT NMEs derived from β\beta-decay and EC experiments [10, 13, 43, 48]. iii. The present CERs with the nuclear probe is quite feasible, while the CERs with weak probes like neutrinos and muons are not realistic experimentally because of the extremely small cross section, the very low beam intensity and the poor energy resolutions by many orders of magnitude than those of the present CER experiment.

GT−^- and SD−^- strengths at low lying QP states are shifted to the GRN_N(GT) and GRN_N(SD) and to the possible GRΔ_{\Delta}(GT) and GRΔ_{\Delta}(SD), as shown in Figure 2. The isobaric analogue state (F in Figure 2) is the Fermi (τ−\tau^-)-type GRN_N(F).

Figure 2. The (3^{3}He,tt) energy spectrum (insert: enlarged), together with the possible GRΔ_{\Delta}. F, GT, and SD are GRN_N(F), GRN_N(GT), GRN_N(SD). Red, yellow, pink, light blue, blue and green spectra are for angle intervals of 0-0.5, 0.5-1, 1-1.5, 1.5-2, 2-2.5, and 2-2.5, each in deg. The l=0l=0 GT and the l=1l=1 SD components dominate at 0-0.5 deg. and 1.5-2 deg. [25, 41].

The GT strength from the 0+0^+ state (∣0⟩|0\rangle) to the GT (Jf=1+J_f=1^+) state is expressed by

B(GT)=∣⟨f∣∣σ∣∣0⟩∣2,δn=δl=0, δj=0,1,(1)B(\mathrm{GT}) = |\langle f\vert\vert\sigma\vert\vert0\rangle|^2,\quad\delta n=\delta l=0,\ \delta j=0,1, \tag*{(1)}

with n,l,jn,l,j being the radial-node number, the angular-node number, and the angular momentum. The GT τ−\tau^- (β−\beta^-) transitions with the transition operators of τ\tau and σ\sigma are limited, in themis nuclear shell models, to the neutron→\toproton transitions between the same n,ln,l shell-orbit in the excitation region mainly below 25 MeV (i.e. no jump in energy to higher nn shells in the region beyond E≈20E\approx20 MeV) with no changes of the radial and angular nodes of nn and ll. Thus, the GT transition is allowed only within the same NℏωN\hbar\omega shell, and not to higher N′ℏωN'\hbar\omega shells in the higher excitation continuum region. The emitted tt is limited to the forward direction of θ≈0\theta\approx0 deg. because of δl=0\delta l=0. Thus the GT excitation is limited mainly in the low excitation region around 0-20 MeV because of δn=0\delta n=0 and at the low (forward) angle region around θ=0\theta=0 deg. because of Δl=0\Delta l=0. The selection of the δn=0\delta n=0 component is crucial for identification of GT in the high excitation region as remarked in the section 3.7 of [13].

We first discuss the GT(δl=0\delta l=0, δn=0\delta n=0) strength in the CER energy spectrum at 0 deg. in the 0-28 MeV region. It consists mainly of the δl=0\delta l=0 component with the small admixtures of δl=1,2\delta l=1, 2 ones, which are corrected for in the analysis. The l=0l=0 component is due to the low-lying QP GT states, the GRN_N(GT) around 10-15 MeV and the quasi-free scattering (QFS) in the 10-28 MeV continuum region [36, 40, 46, 49]. The GRN_N(GT) width of Γ\Gamma(GT) ≈8\approx8 MeV reflects the large spreading of the GRN_N(GT) strength to 2-particle 2-hole states [50, 51]. The QFS consists of the QF-GT component, including the GT strength spreading into the 2p-2h and the upper-isospin GT strength and the QF non-GT (δn≠0\delta n \ne0) strength.

Then the summed GT strength S−S^{-}(GT) is the sum of the BB(GT) values for the low-lying QP GT states, the GRN_N(GT) and the QF-GT continuum. The non-GT (δn≠0\delta n \ne0) strength is around 7% of the S−S^{-}(GT), being consistent with the low-energy part of the calculated non-GT Jπ=1+J^{\pi}=1^{+} strength (iso-vector monopole and other Δn=1\Delta n=1) around 25-36 MeV. The summed strengths of S−S^{-}(GT) for DBD and Sn nuclei are around 47±\pm5% of SNS_N(GT) [35] as shown in Figure 3. The l=0l=0 strength extending beyond 25 MeV is mainly non-GT (δn=1,2\delta n=1,2) excitations. The individual CER cross-sections at 0 deg. are affected a little by the tensor interaction contribution, but the effects cancel out more or less in the summed strength.

Summed GT and SD strengths as a function of neutron excess

Figure 3. Top: Summed GT strength of S−(GT)S^{-}(\mathrm{GT}). Blue squares: (3He,t{}^{3}\mathrm{He},t) on DBD nuclei. Blue diamonds: (3He,t{}^{3}\mathrm{He},t) on Sn isotopes. Light blue squares: (p,np,n). Solid thin line: SN(GT)=3(N−Z)S_{\mathrm{N}}(\mathrm{GT})=3(N-Z). Thick line: 0.47SN(GT)0.47S_{\mathrm{N}}(\mathrm{GT}). Bottom: Summed SD strength of S−(SD)S^{-}(\mathrm{SD}). Blue triangles: (3He,t{}^{3}\mathrm{He},t) on DBD nuclei. Light blue squares and thick line: sum rule of SN(SD)S_{\mathrm{N}}(\mathrm{SD}). Thin line: 0.50SN(SD)0.50S_{\mathrm{N}}(\mathrm{SD}).

The τ+\tau^{+} strength in the DBD nuclei has been investigated by (d,2d,{}^{2}He) and (t,3t,{}^{3}He) reactions [40, 52, 53]. It is around 5% of SNS_N(GT) because of the blocking of the pp to nn transition by the large excess neutrons in the β−β−\beta^{-}\beta^{-}-DBD nuclei. The non-GT (δn≠0\delta n \ne0) β+\beta^{+} strength extends beyond 10 MeV in the QFS region, being not blocked by the excess neutrons [54, 55]. Then one gets S−−S+≈0.42±0.05S^{-}-S^{+} \approx0.42 \pm0.05 of SNS_N(GT) for the summed GT (δl=δn=0\delta l=\delta n=0) strengths up to 28 MeV. The error includes systematic errors in corrections for the small non-GT (δl≠0\delta l \ne0, δn≠0\delta n \ne0) components. The δl=0\delta l=0 strength extends due to the 2p-2h spreading certainly beyond 28 MeV, but is mainly of non-GT with δn≥1\delta n \ge1. The GT component beyond 28 MeV is evaluated to be an order of 5 % of SNS_N(GT). Then, including this, we get S−−S+≈0.47±0.07S^{-}-S^{+} \approx0.47 \pm0.07 of SNS_N(GT). This reduction is nearly same with the reduction around 0.5 in other nuclei [10, 13, 56, 57].

Comments on (p,n) CERs reactions

GT and SD strengths for non-DBD nuclei have been extensively studied in the 1980’ and 1990’ by using medium energy (p,n) and (n,p) reactions as given in the review [10, 13] and refs therein. They excite preferentially GT and other τσ\tau\sigma states/resonances as the present (3^{3}He,tt) reactions because of the dominant VτσV_{\tau\sigma} interaction. The summed strengths of SNS_N(GT) in the N region of around E=0E=0-30 MeV are found to be around 50 % of the sum rule limit of 3(N−Z)3(N-Z) in a wide mass region of the mass number A=30A=30-208, including 90^{90}Zr [56, 57]. These are similar to the present (3^{3}He,tt) CER results for DBD nuclei.

The (p,n) reaction on 90^{90}Zr shows the large summed GT strength of S−−S+≈3(N−Z)S^{-}-S^{+} \approx3(N-Z) below 50 MeV [58]. It is claimed that the 90% of the sum rule limit [35] is the minimum value, and suggests a large strength of the order of 10-20 % of the limit in the higher region of 50-60 MeV. A similar work on 90^{90}Zr reports 88±\pm6% of the sum rule [59]. These works are in support of the sum rule, but are contrasted to the other CER data for the same 90^{90}Zr and others [56, 57].

The (p,n) spectra for 90^{90}Zr in both [56, 57] and [58] show the same strong GT (δn=0\delta n=0) GRN_N around E≈10E \approx10 MeV of the δn=0\delta n=0 region, extending up to around 16 MeV and the similar continuum spectrum increasing slowly from 16 MeV to 50 MeV and beyond. This high-excitation region corresponds just to the non-GT δn=1,2,3\delta n=1, 2, 3 region. The strength in this continuum is not included into the summed GT strength, resulting in the severe quenching with respect to the sum rule limit in [57] and other (p,n) works. On the other hand, the strength in this continuum, except the IVSM (Isovector spin monopole) contribution, is considered to be included in the summed GT strength, resulting in the full sum-rule limit [58]. The observed strength in the δn≥1\delta n \ge1 continuum region beyond 25 MeV should be corrected for the main non-GT components with δn=1\delta n=1-3.

Actually the observed strength around 30 MeV is consistent with the calculated δn=1\delta n=1 strength. Then the large observed GT strength of SN(GT)>90S_N(\mathrm{GT})>90 % of the sum rule value could be reduced to about 50-60 % of it if the large non-GT strength with δn≥1\delta n \ge1 in the high excitation region would be corrected for. The systematic studies of the (p,n) CERs in the mass region of A=13A=13-90 show some 50-60 % of the sum rule limit [60]. The (p,n) reaction on the much lighter nucleus of 48Ca{}^{48}\mathrm{Ca} gives the S−−S+=52S^{-}-S^{+}=52 % of 3(N−Z)3(N-Z) below 30 MeV [61]. The measured S−S^{-} up to 30 MeV is certainly smaller than the 2p-2h calculation without the Δ\Delta [51].

The RPA calculation for the 90Zr{}^{90}\mathrm{Zr} shows that the strength in the GRN\mathrm{GR}_{N} δn=0\delta n=0 region below 25 MeV is GT with δn=0\delta n=0, but the large strength in the δn≥1\delta n\geq1 region beyond 30 MeV is not GT [29]. On the other hand, the calculation including coupling with 2p-2h shows a large spread of the GT strength of around 40 % into the higher excitation region of 25 - 40 MeV in case of no coupling with Δ\Delta [50].

In the (p,n) experiment, a wide excitation energy region is covered by measuring emitted neutrons by TOF (time of flight) method, while in the present (3He,t{}^{3}\mathrm{He},t) experiment the emitted tritons are measured by the spectrometer at RCNP with the limited region around 0-30 MeV in the excitation energy. Then we have corrected for the non-GT (δ≠0\delta\ne0) contribution in the continuum region of 18-28 MeV, and then evaluates the possible small GT contribution beyond 28 MeV to be included in the summed GT strength.

The CER strength in the continuum region beyond 20 MeV is also treated as QFS (quasi-free scattering), where a nucleon in the target nucleus is excited to the unbound continuum region. It includes a little GT strength in the lower excitation region below 20 MeV, but is mainly non-GT strengths with δn≥1\delta n\geq1, and thus all the QFS at the higher excitation is not included into the GT with δn=0\delta n=0, being in contrast to the (p,n) work in [58].

It is noted here that the present GRΔ\mathrm{GR}_{\Delta} is based on the experimental data showing the severe quenching of the summed strengths with respect to the sum rule limit [35]. The recent theoretical work on 2B [14] shows also the severe quenching of the summed GT strength. In fact, the present GRΔ\mathrm{GR}_{\Delta} and other Δ\Delta effects and the exchange (2B) effects are based mainly on the non-nucleonic quenching effect of Δ\Delta located far above the N region. Thus they would be not be right if all the GT strengths would be found experimentally or theoretically in the N region of 0-50 MeV as claimed in [58]. So further theoretical and experimental studies of the summed GT strengths are interesting.

Summed SD strength in the N region

The SD strength for the δn=0,1\delta n=0,1 and δl=1\delta l=1 στ\sigma\tau transitions is given by B(SD)=∣⟨f∣∣[τY1]J∣∣0⟩∣2B(\mathrm{SD})=|\langle f||[\tau Y_{1}]_{J}||0\rangle|^{2} with J=0,1,2J=0,1,2. The GRN(SD)\mathrm{GR}_{N}(\mathrm{SD}) is located about 1 ℏω≈10\hbar\omega\approx10-8 MeV above the GRN(GT)\mathrm{GR}_{N}(\mathrm{GT}) as shown in Figure 2. The large width around 15 MeV is due to the spreading of the SD strengths to 2p-2h states and the JJ dependence of E(SD)E(\mathrm{SD}). The summed SD strength S−(SD)S^{-}(\mathrm{SD}) is derived from the measured (3He,t{}^{3}\mathrm{He},t) CER spectra at θ≈2\theta\approx2 deg. where the l=1l=1 cross section gets maximum. The strengths, including the QFS with δl=δn=1\delta l=\delta n=1 for the DBD nuclei are around 50±\pm7 % of the N-based summed strength of SN−(SD)≈∑(2l+1)(Nn/2π)Rn2S^{-}_{N}(\mathrm{SD})\approx\sum(2l+1)(N_n/2\pi)R_n^{2} with NnN_n and RnR_n being the effective number and the radius of the neutrons involved in the lhw(δl=1)l_{\mathrm{hw}}(\delta l=1) neutron to proton transitions, as shown in Figure 3. The summed strengths measured by the (p,n) reactions for medium-heavy nuclei are about a half of the Tamm Donkoff limit and the N-based QRPA (QRPA(N)) calculations [56]. These data indicate the quenching effect due to the non-nucleonic Δ\Delta effect.

SD and δl=1\delta l=1 NMEs for low-lying states in medium heavy nuclei are smaller than nuclear model NMEs with NN correlations, suggesting the possible Δ\Delta effects due to non-nucleonic NΔ\Delta correlations [7, 8]. The SD NMEs are also discussed in terms of the shell model, and are shown to be quenched by a coefficient around 0.77 [62].

In short, the summed GT and SD strengths are reduced from the sum rule limits by a factor around (KΔ)2(K_{\Delta})^{2} with KΔ=0.7±0.07K_{\Delta}=0.7\pm0.07 being the quenching coefficient. Here the error includes the systematic ones in subtracting the small non-GT components with δl≠0\delta l\ne0, δn≠0\delta n\ne0, and also the uncertainty in getting CER cross section. The tensor component with <[Y2σ]1><[\mathrm{Y}_{2}\sigma]_{1}> is not more than a few %. Noting that the sum rule is independent of nuclear models with nucleonic (NN) correlations, the deviation from the rule indicates some non-nucleonic correlation, which is mainly the NΔ\Delta resonance effect as shown later. The GT sum rule in the nucleon region is about 50 % smaller than the limit of 3(N−Z)3(N-Z) [35] because of the 50 % shifted to the non-nucleonic GRΔ\mathrm{GR}_{\Delta} region.

Non-nucleonic effects and QRPA(NΔ\Delta)

NΔ\Delta coupling and στ\sigma\tau quenching

Experimental στ\sigma\tau NMEs involved in axial-vector β\beta and EM transitions are known to be smaller than NMEs based on theoretical models with various nucleonic (NN) correlations, suggesting appreciable non-nucleonic effects. Non-nucleonic effects have been extensively discussed theoretically as stated in section I. Some of them are made in terms of the NΔ\Delta coupling (core-polarization) effect in [7, 9, 27, 31, 32, 33] and others recently in terms of the 2B (exchange) current using the very advanced effective field theory in [14, 15, 18]. The non-nucleonic Δ\Delta effect on axial-vector weak transitions is discussed in terms of the effective weak coupling of gAeffg_{A}^{\mathrm{eff}} in [13] and refs therein, and also in [11, 12].

The ΔN\Delta N coupling theory relies on effective NΔ\Delta interaction, and explains more or less the quenched στ\sigma\tau NMEs as observed. The 2B (meson-exchange) quenching effects are non-nucleonic effects associated with excited nucleons (i.e. non-nucleons as Δ\Delta and other baryons) that couple with nucleons via the meson-exchange interactions. In the present case of the τσ\tau\sigma NMEs, Δ\Delta is the only one non-nucleon that couples strongly with the nucleon via the π\pi-exchange interaction. Thus, the origin and the effect of the 2B quenching are nealy the same as those of the ΔN\Delta N quenching, although the theoretical ways of evaluating them are different. These thoretical approaches lead to the severe quenching for the τσ\tau\sigma NMEs and also for the summed τσ\tau\sigma strengths in the N region.

On the other hand, the present quenching effect is based on the experimental reduction (quenching) of the summed τσ\tau\sigma strengths in the N region. Since the Δ\Delta involved in the ΔN\Delta N interaction and in the 2B current is located far (300 MeV) above the N region, the quenchin effects for the NMEs in low-lying (a few MeV) state and for the summed strength in the N region are almost same. Accordingly the present experimental quenching coefficient and the theoretical NΔN\Delta/2B quenching coefficient are considered to agree with each other within the experimental and theoretical uncertainties.

In fact, the 2B effects for 100Sn{}^{100}\mathrm{Sn} and for the summed GT strength in the A=90A=90 nucleus are similar to the present effect of 0.7±0.070.7\pm0.07 for the similar mass medium heavy nuclei. It is interesting to see how the 2B calculations for DBD nuclei reproduce the present experimental τσ\tau\sigma strengths.

The 2p-2h correlations [50, 51] are the nucleonic NN correlations, which are not included in simple QP and QRPA models with 1p-1h correlations, and modify the τσ\tau\sigma NMEs for low-lying states. They spread and shift

some τσ\tau\sigma strengths from the GRN_{\mathrm{N}} region around 10-15 MeV to the higher excitation region above 15 MeV within the N region. Thus it is different from the present non-nucleonic Δ\Delta and 2B correlations that shift the τσ\tau\sigma strengths to the non-nucleonic Δ\Delta region at 300 MeV far beyond the N region. Thus the 2p-2h correlation does not quench the summed τσ\tau\sigma strength.

Then, we discuss how the non-nucleonic effect shown in the summed τσ\tau\sigma strengths may be well explained by using the GRΔ_{\Delta} as explained in section I. The strong repulsive NΔN\Delta interaction gives rise to the giant resonance of GRΔ_{\Delta}, which is a coherent sum of the 2A NΔN\Delta amplitudes with AA being the mass number of the nucleus, and the Δ\Delta-origin quenching effect is exclusively incorporated in the GRΔ_{\Delta} effect. The merits of using the GRΔ_{\Delta} concept is to help understand the effect as given in Figure 1 and in the following subsection and to be linked to the experimental GRN_{\mathrm{N}} and GRΔ_{\Delta}.

So far, most QRPA(N), ISM, IBM, and other model calculations for DBD NMEs take explicitly realistic nucleonic NN τσ\tau\sigma correlations, but not explicitly non-nucleonic NΔN\Delta correlations [13]. QRPA(N) takes into accounts so many relevant NN correlations as extensively used for β\beta, DBD and others [6, 10, 13]. In these QRPA(N), the non-nucleonic Δ\Delta interaction is not explicitly included in the model, and then the τσ\tau\sigma NN interactions are adjusted so as to reproduce the observed GRN_{\mathrm{N}} energies, and the calculated summed GT strength is not quenched because the NΔN\Delta interaction is not explicitly included.

NN-NΔ\Delta QRPA for GRΔ_{\Delta}

Let us use a schematic QRPA(NΔN\Delta) model with both the NN and NΔN\Delta τσ\tau\sigma interactions to evaluate gross effects of their correlations on the summed GT strengths and the β\beta and ββ\beta\beta NMEs in the N region of E≤30E\leq30 MeV. In fact, the NΔN\Delta effects have been discussed also in the QRPA calculations [31, 32, 56]. The interaction is expressed as

V=gNN′CV12σ1σ2τ1τ2+gNΔ′C′V12S1S2T1T2,(2)V=g'_{NN}CV_{12}\sigma_{1}\sigma_{2}\tau_{1}\tau_{2}+g'_{N\Delta}C'V_{12}S_{1}S_{2}T_{1}T_{2}, \tag*{(2)}

where gNN′g'_{NN} and gNΔ′g'_{N\Delta} are the NN and NΔN\Delta interaction coefficients, V12=δ3(r1,r2)V_{12}=\delta^{3}(r_{1},r_{2}), C=392 MeV fm3C=392\ {\rm MeV\ fm}^{3} and C′=(fTΔ/fπNN)2CC'=(f_{T\Delta}/f_{\pi NN})^{2}C, and TT and SS are for the Δ\Delta isospin and spin [31, 32, 63]. In the present case of the τ−\tau^{-} transition, the particle hole excitations involved are n to p, n to Δ+\Delta^{+} and p to Δ++\Delta^{++} for the forward correlations and p to n, p to Δ0\Delta^{0} and n to Δ−\Delta^{-} for the backward ones.

In the present DBD and other medium-heavy nuclei with the large neutron excess, the valence neutron shell is so separated from the proton one that the cross term (D2D^{2} in [5]) is around or less than 0.03. So we assume D2=0D^{2}=0. Then, using χN=48 gNN′\chi_{N}=48\,g'_{NN} MeV and χΔ=96 gNΔ′\chi_{\Delta}=96\,g'_{N\Delta} MeV for the DBD nuclei with the density of ρ0=1.21 fm−3\rho_{0}=1.21\ {\rm fm}^{-3}, the dispersion equation for the present medium-heavy DBD nuclei with the large N−ZN-Z is given by

χNA∑i∣⟨ϕi−∣στ−∣0⟩∣2ϵi−ϵ+χΔA∑j∣⟨ψj−∣ST−∣0⟩∣2ϵΔj−ϵ+χΔA∑k∣⟨ψk+∣ST+∣0⟩∣2ϵΔk+ϵ=−1,(3)\frac{\chi_N}{A}\sum_i\frac{|\langle\phi_i^-|\sigma\tau^-|0\rangle|^2}{\epsilon_i-\epsilon} +\frac{\chi_\Delta}{A}\sum_j\frac{|\langle\psi_j^-|S T^-|0\rangle|^2}{\epsilon_{\Delta j}-\epsilon} +\frac{\chi_\Delta}{A}\sum_k\frac{|\langle\psi_k^+|S T^+|0\rangle|^2}{\epsilon_{\Delta k}+\epsilon}=-1, \tag*{(3)}

where ϕi−\phi_i^- stands for the n−1pin^{-1}p_i state, ψj−\psi_j^- for the n−1Δj+n^{-1}\Delta_j^+ and pj−1Δ++p_j^{-1}\Delta^{++} states and ψk+\psi_k^+ for the nk−1Δk−n_k^{-1}\Delta_k^- and pk−1Δk0p_k^{-1}\Delta_k^0 states. ϵi\epsilon_i, ϵj\epsilon_j and ϵk\epsilon_k are their energies and ϵ\epsilon is the eigen energy. The backward p−1np^{-1}n correlation is assumed to be blocked by the large nn excess in the DBD nuclei. Contributions from the Δ\Delta at around 300 MeV are given by the second and third terms of eq. (3). Their sum is given by

κΔ≈χΔA[2(A+0.33A)300 MeV]=0.009χΔ/MeV,(4)\kappa_\Delta\approx\frac{\chi_\Delta}{A}\left[\frac{2(A+0.33A)}{300\ \mathrm{MeV}}\right]=0.009\chi_\Delta/\mathrm{MeV}, \tag*{(4)}

where κΔ\kappa_\Delta stands for the Δ τσ\Delta\ \tau\sigma susceptibility. Then using κΔ\kappa_\Delta, the dispersion equation is rewritten as

χNA(1+κΔ)[∑i∣⟨ϕi∣στ−∣0⟩∣2ϵi−ϵ]=−1,(5)\frac{\chi_N}{A(1+\kappa_\Delta)}\left[\sum_i\frac{|\langle\phi_i|\sigma\tau^-|0\rangle|^2}{\epsilon_i-\epsilon}\right]=-1, \tag*{(5)}

where χN/(1+κΔ)\chi_N/(1+\kappa_\Delta) is the renormalized NN interaction that includes the Δ\Delta isobar effect. The summed GT strength in the N region is quenched by the same coefficient of

KΔ=1/(1+κΔ).(6)K_\Delta=1/(1+\kappa_\Delta). \tag*{(6)}

The quenching coefficient of KΔ=0.7±0.07K_\Delta=0.7\pm0.07 derived experimentally from the summed GT and SD strengths corresponds to the susceptibility of κΔ≈0.43\kappa_\Delta\approx0.43 in eq. (6). This is just expected from gNΔ≈0.5g_{N\Delta}\approx0.5 as in the Jülich-Tokyo potential, [31] and the NΔN\Delta interaction χΔ=48\chi_\Delta=48 MeV in eq. (4).

The quenching due to the GRΔ\mathrm{GR}_\Delta effect is a kind of the τσ\tau\sigma-type NΔN\Delta core polarization with κΔ\kappa_\Delta being the τσ\tau\sigma-NΔN\Delta susceptibility (polarizability) [7, 9, 30]. The present susceptibility is nearly the same as the one derived theoretically in [30].

The non-nucleonic reduction effect of GRΔ\mathrm{GR}_\Delta, which is far above the N region, is considered to be common for all nuclear τσ\tau\sigma components of the weak, electromagnetic and nuclear interaction NMEs in the N region. It is expressed by using the reduced coupling of gτσΔg_{\tau\sigma}^\Delta as

gτσΔ≈gτσ(1+κΔ)−1≈0.7gτσ(7)g_{\tau\sigma}^\Delta\approx g_{\tau\sigma}(1+\kappa_\Delta)^{-1}\approx0.7g_{\tau\sigma} \tag*{(7)}

where gτσg_{\tau\sigma} is the coupling for a free nucleon. In case of the weak τσ\tau\sigma NME, the gτσg_{\tau\sigma} is the axial-vector weak coupling of gAg_A for a free nucleon. It is given as gA=1.27gVg_A=1.27g_V with gVg_V being the vector coupling.

The Δ\Delta mixing amplitude aia_i is of the order of (χΔ/A)/300(\chi_\Delta/A)/300 MeV≈1.5 10−3\approx1.5\ 10^{-3} per nucleon, and the Δ\Delta probability is as small as ai2≈2×10−6a_i^2\approx2\times10^{-6}, but the coherent sum of aia_i over 2A≈2002A\approx200 of the Δ\Deltas excited from A≈100A\approx100 of Ns (nucleons) is of the order of κΔ≈0.3\kappa_\Delta\approx0.3, resulting in the severe quenching coefficient around 0.7 as observed.

Since the NΔN\Delta interaction depends on the interaction parameter gNΔ′g_{N\Delta}^\prime and the density ρ\rho, gτσΔ/gτσg_{\tau\sigma}^\Delta/g_{\tau\sigma} depends on gNΔ′g_{N\Delta}^\prime and ρ\rho as shown in Figure 4. The observed quenching coefficient is just as expected from the appropriate NΔN\Delta coupling around gNΔ′≈0.5g_{N\Delta}^\prime\approx0.5 and the known nuclear density around ρ≈1.25 fm−3\rho\approx1.25\ \mathrm{fm}^{-3}. The similar ρ\rho dependence is seen in the analysis in terms of the 2B effect [18].

Figure 4. Top: Axial-vector (τσ\tau\sigma) effective coupling against the NΔN\Delta interaction parameter gNΔ′g_{N\Delta}^\prime at the density ρ=1.21 fm−3\rho=1.21\ \mathrm{fm}^{-3}. Bottom: Axial-vector (τσ\tau\sigma) effective coupling against the density ρ\rho with the NΔN\Delta interaction parameter gNΔ′=0.5g_{N\Delta}^\prime=0.5. The rectangles correspond to the observed regions of gτσΔ/gτσ=0.7±0.07g_{\tau\sigma}^\Delta/g_{\tau\sigma}=0.7\pm0.07.

The present schematic QRPA(NΔN\Delta) analysis with both NN and NΔN\Delta interactions is limited on the gross effect of the GRΔ\mathrm{GR}_\Delta and GRN\mathrm{GR}_N. Since Δ\Delta is isolated from the N region and is only one resonance that couples strongly with N via the τσ\tau\sigma interaction, the non-nucleonic quenching effect on the σ\sigma NME is mostly (≥90%\geq90\%) taken into account by KΔK_\Delta and gτσΔg_{\tau\sigma}^\Delta in eqs. (6) and (7).

NN and NΔ\Delta GRs

The NΔN\Delta interaction pushes down the GRN\mathrm{GR}_N in energy, while the NN one pushes up that. The GRN\mathrm{GR}_N(GT) energy is calculated by using eq. (3) with the NΔN\Delta interaction of gNΔ′=0.5g_{N\Delta}^\prime=0.5 and the NN interaction of gNN′=0.62g_{NN}^\prime=0.62 (χN≈30\chi_N\approx30 MeV) as in the Jülich Tokyo potential and other potentials [31, 32]. The calculated values reproduce well the observed GRN\mathrm{GR}_N(GT) energies as shown in Figure 5. They are given as EGA(GT)≈0.22(N−Z)+9.3E_{\mathrm{GA}}(\mathrm{GT})\approx0.22(N-Z)+9.3 MeV. The NN interaction that would fit the observed GRN\mathrm{GR}_N(GT) energy without the NΔN\Delta interaction would be around χN′≈21\chi_N^\prime\approx21 MeV, which is just KΔ×χN≈0.7×30K_\Delta\times\chi_N\approx0.7\times30 MeV with the NΔN\Delta interaction.

Experimental GRN(GT) energies against calculated ones

Figure 5. Experimental GRN(GT)GR_{\mathrm{N}}(\mathrm{GT}) energies against calculated ones. Line EEX(GT)=ECA(GT)E_{\mathrm{EX}}(\mathrm{GT}) = E_{\mathrm{CA}}(\mathrm{GT}).

The SD mode is the τσ\tau\sigma excitation over 1ℏω1\hbar\omega. The GRN(SD)GR_{\mathrm{N}}(\mathrm{SD}) energies for DBD nuclei are extracted from the CERs data [36, 37, 38, 39, 40, 41, 42]. The GRN(SD)GR_{\mathrm{N}}(\mathrm{SD}) is at about 1ℏω1\hbar\omega above the GRN(GT)GR_{\mathrm{N}}(\mathrm{GT}), and the SD QP NMEs follow the similar reduction (quenching) as the GT ones [25].

The GRΔGR_{\Delta} is pushed up in energy due to the repulsive NΔN\Delta interaction from the GRNGR_{\mathrm{N}}. The GRΔGR_{\Delta} energy is expressed by using the unperturbed energy EΔ(0)E_{\Delta}(0) for Δ\Delta in the nucleus and the NΔN\Delta interaction energy of χΔ\chi_{\Delta},

E(GRΔ)=EΔ(0)+χΔA4Z+2A3,(8)E(GR_{\Delta}) = E_{\Delta}(0) + \frac{\chi_{\Delta}}{A}\frac{4Z+2A}{3}, \tag*{(8)}

Using (4Z+2A)/3A≈1.2(4Z+2A)/3A \approx1.2 for the DBD nuclei, one gets E(GRΔ)≈EΔ(0)+58E(GR_{\Delta}) \approx E_{\Delta}(0)+58 MeV. Assuming the Δ\Delta binding energy of 20 MeV as the nucleon one, the unperturbed Δ\Delta energy is evaluated as EΔ(0)≈276E_{\Delta}(0)\approx276 MeV, and the Δ\Delta GR energy as E(GRΔ)≈334E(GR_{\Delta}) \approx334 MeV. The GRΔGR_{\Delta} energy has been studied by using photo nuclear reaction [33, 64]. The average excitation energy for heavy nuclei with the similar (4Z+2A)/3A≈1.2(4Z+2A)/3A \approx1.2 as for DBD nuclei is around 330-340 MeV, although the resonance energy is not well defined due to the large intrinsic and spreading widths of Δ\Delta. The cross sections are proportional to AA. These are consistent with the present GRΔGR_{\Delta} with the χΔ\chi_{\Delta}.

Quenching of τσ\tau\sigma NMEs for Low-Lying States

.

The GT and SD NMEs for the low-lying QP states are reduced due to the NN and NΔN\Delta τσ\tau\sigma correlations. The GT strength is partly shifted from the QP to the GRN(GT)GR_{\mathrm{N}}(\mathrm{GT}) around 11-15 MeV and partly to the GRΔ(GT)GR_{\Delta}(\mathrm{GT}) above 300 MeV. Then, the NME MM for the ground state GT transition is given as [5, 6, 10]

M=KNΔMQP,KNΔ=11+κN+κΔ,(9)M = K_{N\Delta}M_{\mathrm{QP}}, \quad K_{N\Delta} = \frac{1}{1+\kappa_N+\kappa_{\Delta}}, \tag*{(9)}

where κΔ≈0.43\kappa_{\Delta}\approx0.43 as discusses in section 3 and κN\kappa_N is the τσ\tau\sigma-NN susceptibility due to the GRNGR_{\mathrm{N}} as discussed extensively in [6, 10]. In the medium-heavy nuclei κN\kappa_N is around 2 [6], but it depends much on the nuclear structure. Then, assuming κN≈2\kappa_N\approx2, the reduction coefficient is KNΔ=1/(1+2+0.43)≈0.3K_{N\Delta}=1/(1+2+0.43)\approx0.3. The τσ\tau\sigma NME for the ground QP state is reduced by a coefficient around 0.3 with respect to the simple QP NME due to the distractive couplings of GRNGR_{\mathrm{N}} and GRΔGR_{\Delta}. We get the same quenching coefficient by using

KNΔ=KN′×KΔ,(10)K_{N\Delta}=K^{\prime}_{N}\times K_{\Delta}, \tag*{(10)}

where KN′=1/(1+κN′)K^{\prime}_{N}=1/(1+\kappa^{\prime}_{N}) and κN′=κNKΔ≈0.7κN\kappa^{\prime}_{N}=\kappa_NK_{\Delta}\approx0.7\kappa_N.

We have discussed the non-nucleonic quenching effect of the GRΔGR_{\Delta} on the basis of the experimental summed strengths. Actually, the non-nucleonic effect has been discussed theoretically since 1970 mainly in terms of the Δ\Delta effects [7, 9, 26, 27, 28, 29, 31, 32, 33], and also the 2B and the exchange-current (π\pi-exchange between 2B) effects [9, 14, 15, 18, 30]. These are mostly on weak GT NMEs. The Δ\Delta effect on the weak SD NMEs is discussed in [7].

Now we discuss briefly effects of the GRΔGR_{\Delta} and the GRNGR_{\mathrm{N}} on β\beta and ββ\beta\beta NMEs for low-lying QP states in DBD nuclei. Experimental GT and SD NMEs for the ground state β\beta/EC transitions in medium-heavy DBD and other nuclei are smaller by a reduction coefficient KEX≈0.21±0.03K_{\mathrm{EX}}\approx0.21\pm0.03 with respect to the simple QP NMEs without NN and NΔN\Delta correlations [11, 12].

The reduction coefficient KN′≈0.4K^{\prime}_{N}\approx0.4 is found to be due to the NN τσ\tau\sigma (GRNGR_{\mathrm{N}}) and other NN correlations in the QRPA(N) with the realistic G-matrix NN interactions. [11, 12]. Here the particle-hole interaction parameter of gphg_{\mathrm{ph}} is adjusted so as to reproduce the experimental GRNGR_{\mathrm{N}} energies. The coefficient of KEX≈0.21K_{\mathrm{EX}}\approx0.21 is smaller than the product of KN′≈0.4K^{\prime}_{N}\approx0.4 and KΔ≈0.7K_{\Delta}\approx0.7 (see eq. (10)), suggesting further reduction around 0.8 due to such nucleonic and non-nucleonic effects that are not well included in that QRPA(N) model. These effects depend much on the individual QP ground state, being small in case of the ground state isolated in energy from other NN states.

The axial-vector ββ\beta\beta NME is expressed as MA0ν=(gAeff)2MA0M_{\mathrm{A}}^{0\nu}=(g_{\mathrm{A}}^{\mathrm{eff}})^2M_{\mathrm{A}}^{0}, where MA0M_{\mathrm{A}}^{0} is the model NME. Here the effective coupling of gAeffg_{\mathrm{A}}^{\mathrm{eff}} in units of gAg_{\mathrm{A}} for a free nucleon is introduced to incorporate effects which are not included in the model [25]. Using MA0M_{\mathrm{A}}^{0} and MA0νM_{\mathrm{A}}^{0\nu} derived by the QRPA (N) [25] and the value of 0.8 KΔ=0.8×0.7K_{\Delta}=0.8\times0.7 for gAeffg_{\mathrm{A}}^{\mathrm{eff}}, we get M0ν≈5.2−0.025AM^{0\nu}\approx5.2-0.025A, with AA being the mass number. This is close to the NMEs in [25] with similar gAeffg_{\mathrm{A}}^{\mathrm{eff}}, and those with the 2BC [18].

In any way it is indispensable for reliable β\beta/EC and DBD NME calculations for individual medium heavy nuclei to include exactly all relevant 1p-1h, 2p-2h, and other nucleonic correlations as well as the non-nucleonic GRΔ\Delta effects that affect the axial-vector, vector and tensor DBD NMEs. This is beyond the scope of the present paper, which discusses mainly the non-nucleonic GRΔ\Delta effect common to all medium heavy nuclei.

Discussions and concluding remarks

GT and SD τσ\tau\sigma NMEs for the medium-heavy DBD nuclei are investigated on the basis of the experimental τσ\tau\sigma summed strengths measured by the medium energy CERs. Summed GT and SD strengths in the N region are shown to be quenched by a factor around (KΔ=0.7±0.07)2(K_{\Delta}=0.7\pm0.07)^2 with respect to the sum rule limits for nuclei composed by nucleons without non-nucleonic NΔ\Delta correlations, i.e. the sum rule [35] in case of GT.

The quenching of the τσ\tau\sigma NME in the N region is based on the reduction of the summed strengths in the nucleonic (N) region and thus is due to the non-nucleonic Δ\Delta effect in the present case of the τσ\tau\sigma NME. The measured quenching is shown by using a schematic QRPA(NΔ\Delta) to be explained by the destructive coupling (interference) with the GRΔ\Delta. This is a kind of the Δ\Delta polarization effect and the main part of the 2B/exchange current effect discussed in other nuclei. The Δ\Delta effect is mainly represented by the GRΔ\Delta effect.

The present GRΔ\Delta explains well how the small Δ\Delta components in the GRΔ\Delta lying far in energy above the N region reduces the τσ\tau\sigma strength in the N region by acting coherently. The GRΔ\Delta is shown to be consistent with the experimental GRΔ\Delta and GRN_N energies.

The present quenching coefficient is based on the missing summed τσ\tau\sigma strengths by the CERs. It could be around 0.77 if some 10 % of the sum rule [35] would be located beyond the present measurement for the N region. On the other hand, the present GRΔ\Delta and other Δ\Delta and 2B machanisms, which are based mainly on the Δ\Delta with the strong non-nucleonic NΔ\Delta coupling, would not be appropriate if the summed GT strength in the N region would agree exactly with the sum rule [35, 58].

The quenching coefficient derived from the experimental summed τσ\tau\sigma strengths, together with the experimental GRN_N and GRΔ\Delta energies, are consistent with the QRPA(NΔ\Delta) evaluations using the NΔ\Delta and NN interactions [31]. It is noted here that the GRΔ\Delta is only the axial-vector (τσ\tau\sigma) non-nucleonic resonance that couples strongly with the axial-vector NMEs in the N region.

The quenching effects on the axial-vector β\beta and ββ\beta\beta NMEs are expressed as M(β)=(gAΔ/gA)MN(β)M(\beta)=(g_A^\Delta/g_A)M_N(\beta) and M(ββ)=(gAΔ/gA)2MN(ββ)M(\beta\beta)=(g_A^\Delta/g_A)^2M_N(\beta\beta) with gAΔ/gA=KΔ=0.7±0.07g_A^\Delta/g_A=K_\Delta=0.7\pm0.07, and MN(β)M_N(\beta) and MN(ββ)M_N(\beta\beta) are the axial-vector β\beta and ββ\beta\beta NMEs with all relevant NN correlations. The quenching effect due to the GRΔ\Delta, which is located far beyond the nucleon region of E=0E=0-30 MeV, is common to all τσ\tau\sigma NMEs in the medium-heavy nuclei, being not dependend on individual nuclear structures.

The GRΔ\Delta effect on axial-vector NMEs for the medium-heavy DBD nuclei with A=76A=76-136 is discussed in the present work. The interactions used are χN′=21\chi'_N=21 MeV (=0.7χN=0.7\chi_N) and χΔ=48\chi_\Delta=48 MeV for all nuclei, and thus the quenching coefficient is 0.7 for all the medium heavy DBD nuclei. The quenching effect gets much less at light nuclei in case of the AA dependent interaction proportional to A0.3A^{0.3} as suggested in [65]. In this case the quenching coefficients for light nuclei are gTΔ/gT≈0.9g^\Delta_T/g_T\approx0.9, 0.82, 0.79, and 0.77 for nuclei with A=5A=5, 10, 20, and 30. Actually, the quenching coefficients evaluated for light nuclei with A=15A=15-38 are 0.9 - 0.7 [26], and a similar feature is seen in [14]. The coefficients for the medium-heavy DBD nuclei with A=76A=76-136 are 0.71-0.68, being nearly the same as 0.7 for the present constant interaction. The AA dependence may reflect the density dependence in Figure 4. So interesting is to measure the summed GT strength in light nuclei to see the AA dependence of the GRΔ\Delta effect.

The present work is mainly on the axial-vector (τσ\tau\sigma) component in β\beta and ββ\beta\beta NMEs. In fact, β\beta and ββ\beta\beta NMEs include the vector (τ\tau) component, which is considered to be not much quenched because of no coupling with GRΔ\Delta. It is important to measure them experimentally to see if any quenching in there and to validate the theoretical model calculation for them. Gamma rays from isobaric analogue states excited by CERs are used to study vector NMEs [66]. OMC (ordinary muon capture), which is a kind of the lepton CER of (μ,νμ)(\mu,\nu_\mu), is useful to study both the vector and axial-vector NMEs up to around 50 MeV [13, 67].

The present GRΔ\Delta effect is considered to be the dominant non-nucleonic τσ\tau\sigma correlation. There are so many nucleonic correlations to be exactly taken into the model calculations for accurate evaluations of the β\beta and ββ\beta\beta NMEs. Then the CER cross section data are used to check the theoretical models with nucleonic and non nucleonic correlations, as the summed GT and SD strengths are used for the present non-nucleonic GRΔ\Delta effect.

The GRΔ\Delta effect is associated with the GRΔ\Delta excited by the strong τσ\tau\sigma-type nuclear interaction, and reduce (quench) τσ\tau\sigma components of the weak-, electromagnetic- and strong-interaction NMEs in astro-nuclear physics. Then, the τσ\tau\sigma-type NMEs involved in supernova ν\nu-nuclear syntheses, photo-nuclear excitations, isovector spin nuclear reactions and others are reduced similarly by the quenching coefficient KΔK_\Delta, which is around 0.7 in medium and heavy nuclei. Thus impact of the GRΔ\Delta on astro-nuclear and particle physics is indeed very large. It is important to include explicitly and precisely in ββ\beta\beta and other NME calculations the NΔ\Delta interaction in addition to the relevant NN interactions.

It is noted that the effect of the present GRΔ\Delta associated with the strong τσ\tau\sigma (isospin spin) coupling is exclusively on the isospin spin components of the weak, electromagnetic and nuclear interaction NMEs. The τσ\tau\sigma component is the dominant one in cases of the low-energy axial-vector (unique:GT) weak and also in the mediumenergy CER NMEs for 1+→0+1^{+} \rightarrow0^{+}, and thus they are quenched by the similar coefficient, and the GRΔ\mathrm{GR}_{\Delta} and the 2B2\mathrm{B} effects are nearly the same. On the other hand, in the other cases as non-unique weak, electro-magnetic, and inelastic nuclear interactions, the vector, the isoscalar, the orbital and even the tensor components are involved more or less in addition to the τσ\tau\sigma component [10, 13]. Accordingly, the 2B2\mathrm{B} quenching effects depend much on the relative weights of these components, and on ndividual nuclear structures, and thus are different from the GRΔ\mathrm{GR}_{\Delta} quenching effects. The 2B2\mathrm{B} effects on electro-magnetic NMEs are discussed in the recent works [68, 69].

The author thank Prof. T. Sato, Osaka University for valuable discussions.

References

  1. [1]M. Doi, T. Kotani, and E. Takasugi, Prog. Theor. Phys. Suppl. 83, 1 (1985).
  2. [2]F. Avignone, S. Elliott, and J. Engel, Rev. Mod. Phys. 80, 481 (2008).
  3. [3]J. Vergados, H. Ejiri, and F. Šimkovic, Rep. Prog. Phys. 75, 106301 (2012).
  4. [4]M. Agostini, G. Benato, J. A. Detwiler, J. Menéndez, and F. Vissani, Rev. Mod. Phys. 95 025002 (2023).
  5. [5]H. Ejiri, K. Ikeda and J.I. Fujita, Phys. Rev. 176, 1277 (1968).
  6. [6]H. Ejiri and J.I. Fujita, Phys. Rep. 38C, 85 (1978).
  7. [7]H. Ejiri, Phys. Rev. C 26 2628 (1982).
  8. [8]H. Ejiri, Nucl. Phys. A 396 181c (1983).
  9. [9]I.S. Towner, Phys, Rep. 155, 263 (1987).
  10. [10]H. Ejiri, Phys. Rep. 338, 265 (2000).
  11. [11]H. Ejiri, N. Soukouti, and J. Suhonen, Phys. Lett. B 729, 27 (2014).
  12. [12]H. Ejiri and J. Suhonen, J. Phys. G 42, 055201 (2015).
  13. [13]H. Ejiri, J. Suhonen and K. Züber, Phys. Rep. 797, 1 (2019).
  14. [14]P. Gysbers et al., Nature Physics 15, 428 (2019).
  15. [15]L. Coraggio, et al., Phys. Rev. C 109, 014301 (2024).
  16. [16]J. Suhonen and O. Civitarese, Phys. Rep. 300, 123 (1998).
  17. [17]A. Faessler and F. Simkovic, J. Phys. G Nucl. Part. Phys. 24, 2139 (1998).
  18. [18]J. Menéndez, D. Gazit, and A. Schwenk, Phys. Rev. Lett. 107, 062501 (2011).
  19. [19]J. Suhonen and O. Civitarese, J. Phys. G Nucl. Part Phys. 39, 085105 (2012).
  20. [20]J. Barea, J. Kotila and F. Iachello, Phys. Rev. C 87, 014315 (2013).
  21. [21]J. Suhonen, Phys. Rev. C 96, 055501 (2017).
  22. [22]J. Engel and J. Menéndez, Rep. Prog. Phys. 80, 046301 (2017).
  23. [23]L. Jokiniemi, H. Ejiri, D. Frekers, and J. Suhonen, Phys. Rev. C 98, 024608 (2018).
  24. [24]F. Šimkovic, R. Dvornicky, D. Stephanik, and A. Faessler, Phys. Rev. C 97, 054315 (2018).
  25. [25]H. Ejiri, L. Jokiniemi and J. Suhonen, Phys. Rev. C 105, L022501 (2022).
  26. [26]E. Oset and M. Rho, Phys. Rev. Lett. 42 47 (1979).
  27. [27]A. Bohr and B. Mottelson, Phys. Letters B 199, 10 (1981). Nuclear Structure, I, II , W.A. Benjamin, INC., Amsterdam, (1969, 1975).
  28. [28]H. Sagawa, and N. Van Giai, Phys. Lett. B 113, 119 (1982).
  29. [29]F. Osterfeld, D. Cha and J. Speth, Phys. Rev. C 31 372 (1985).
  30. [30]D.O. Riska, Phys. Rep. 181 207 (1989).
  31. [31]F. Osterfeld, Rev. Mod. Phys. 64, 491 (1992).
  32. [32]E.D. Kirckuk, J. Blomqvist and R.J. Liotta, Phys. Scriptа 59, 416 (1999).
  33. [33]G. Cattapan and L.S. Ferreira, Phys. Rep. C 362, 303 (2002).
  34. [34]H. Ejiri, Front. Phys 7, 30 (2019).
  35. [35]K. Ikeda, S. Fujii, and J.I. Fujita, Prog. Theor. Phys. 31, 434 (1963).
  36. [36]H. Akimune, et al., Phys. Lett. B 394, 23 (1997); 665, 424 (2008).
  37. [37]J. H. Thies, et al., Phys. Rev. C 86, 014304 (2012).
  38. [38]J. H. Thies et al., Phys. Rev. C 86, 054323 (2012).
  39. [39]J. Puppe et al., Phys. Rev. C 84, 051305R (2011).
  40. [40]C. J. Guess et al., Phys. Rev. C 83, 064318 (2011).
  41. [41]J. H. Thies, et al., Phys. Rev. C 86, 044309 (2012).
  42. [42]J. Puppe, et al., Phys. Rev. C 86, 044603 (2012).
  43. [43]D. Frekers, P. Puppe, J.H. Thies and H. Ejiri, Nucl. Phys. A 916, 219 (2013).
  44. [44]H. Ejiri and D. Frekers, J. Phys. G Part. Phys. 43, 11LT01 (2016).
  45. [45]R.G.T. Zegers et al., Phys. Rev. Lett. 99, 202501 (2007).
  46. [46]C.A. Douma et al., Eur. Phys. J. A , 56, 51 (2020).
  47. [47]M.A. Franey and W.G. Love, Phys. Rev. C 31, 488 (1985).
  48. [48]S.R. Elliott et al., Phys. Rev. C 108 035502 (2023).
  49. [49]K.Pham et al., Phys. Rev. C 51, 526 (1995).
  50. [50]G.F. Berch and I. Hamamoto, Phys. Rev. C 26 1323 (1982).
  51. [51]Gambacurta, M. Grasso, and J. Engel, Phys. Rev. Letters 125 212501 (2020).
  52. [52]H. Dohmann et al., Phys. Rev. C 78, 041602(R) (2008).
  53. [53]E. -W. Grew et al., Phys. Rev. C 78, 044301 (2008).
  54. [54]K.J. Raywood et al., Phys. Rev. C 41, 2836 (1990).
  55. [55]H. Condé, et al., Nucl. Phys. A 545, 785 (1992).
  56. [56]C. Gaarde, et al, Nucl. Phys. A 369, 258 (1981).
  57. [57]C. Gaarde, Nucl. Phys. A 396 127C (1983).
  58. [58]T. Wakasa, et al., Phys. Rev. C 55, 2909 (1997).
  59. [59]K. Yako et al., Phys. Lett. B 615, 193 (2003).
  60. [60]C. D. Goodman and S.D. Bloom, Proc. Int. Conf. Spin Excitations in Nuclei, ed. F. Petrovich et al., Plenum, New York, p 143.
  61. [61]K. Yako et al. Phys. Rev. Letters 103, 012503 (2009).
  62. [62]B.A. Brown and D.H. Wildenthal, Annual Review Nucl. Science 38 29 (1988).
  63. [63]G.E. Brown and M. Rho, Nucl. Phys. A 372, 397 (1981).
  64. [64]J. Ahrens, L.S. Ferreira, and W. Weise, Nucl. Phys. A 485, 621 (1988).
  65. [65]H. Homuth et al., Phys. Rev. C 54, 2972 (1996).
  66. [66]H. Ejiri, Phys. Rev. C 108 L011302 (2025).
  67. [67]I. H. Hashim et al., Phys. Rev. C 97 014617 (2018).
  68. [68]T. Miyagi, et al., Phys. Rev. Lett. 132 232503 (2024).
  69. [69]B. Acharya, et al., Phys. Rev. Lett. 132 232504 (2024).

Paper details

vlnc:W_nge7vfba
Version
v1 · latest
Published
Fresh — added to the Hub within the last 30 days
Added
License
CC BY 4.0
Usage

views · 0

downloads · 0

A view counts once per browser per day, a download each time the PDF is requested.

  • Physics and Astronomy

Not recorded for this paper

View statement
Looking for related papers…
Contents