In this paper
AbstractNLS and the -solitonThe full-line -solitonThe half-line -solitonThe non-homogeneous Robin problemValues on forced solitonsFirst-order frequency shiftsNumerical testsConcluding remarkAcknowledgementsReferencesWorksMathematics
An elementary observation on the Robin problem for NLS
Abstract
We present an infinite set of explicit solutions of the integrable focusing NLS equation on the half-line that are rapidly decaying and satisfy a homogeneous Robin condition but have very different behaviors on the wall . We then argue that a similar phenomenon exists for a small non-homogeneous perturbation of the Robin problem. This renders a potential application of the unified transform method to non-linearizable Robin problems impossible.
NLS and the -soliton
We consider the focusing NLS equation, with given initial data and a simple inhomogeneous Robin condition:
with . The homogeneous case is famously known to be integrable and have soliton solutions. We present a specific formula below.
The full-line -soliton
Let with , and let . Put
and define the reflectionless -breather [7], [8]
For this is .
The numbers are of course the eigenvalues of the associated Zakharov-Shabat operator. By choosing them purely imaginary we ensure that the solitons have zero speed and lie ”on top of each other”. They do oscillate in time, hence the name ”breather”.
Since , is a Gram matrix with kernel , which is positive definite. Hence for every , .
The half-line -soliton
Restricted to , solves (1) with in the following cases [3]
and ; the Robin condition degenerates into a Neumann condition.
, for all , with
The trace is exactly quasi-periodic, with frequencies in the -module generated by , where . Indeed, at , , so and . Every entry of and every factor in (2) is a trigonometric polynomial in the angles . The matrix is positive definite for arbitrary unimodular phases, so . Hence is a rational function of the with non-vanishing denominator.
There is no decaying radiation term because the data are reflectionless. So the quasi-periodicity is exact for all . If the are rationally independent, the trace has independent frequencies. Since the are arbitrary, there are different smooth, exponentially decaying data that give different frequency sets of any size.
Remark 1.1. The above elementary example shows that (in any reasonable sense) the map taking the data for the IBVP (initial data and the constant ) to the Dirichlet trace is very unstable in terms of long time asymptotics. Small changes in (the parameters of) the initial data can give non-decaying changes in the Dirichlet trace.
The non-homogeneous Robin problem
If is not zero the problem is non-linearizable in the sense of [5]. The question still arises whether it is still in a sense integrable. That might be so if the unified transform method introduced by Fokas [4] could transform the IBVP to a Riemann-Hilbert problem with data that depend continuously on the data of the IBVP and that is amenable to a steepest descent asymptotic analysis. This would be impossible however if the instability mentioned above persists, small changes in the initial data giving rise to many different non-decaying changes in the Dirichlet trace; simply because any possible scattering theory for the boundary data requires a fixed asymptotic -behavior. Here on the contrary we have a continuum of different asymptotically quasi-periodic behaviors.
This is indeed what the following perturbation analysis shows.
An elementary calculation gives the time derivatives of mass , and the energy in terms of the non-homogeneous term .
Proof. Mass. From we get . Substituting , the -term is real and drops out. Energy. Integrating by parts,
The last integral is . At the boundary,
which gives (2.2).
For both quantities are of course conserved.
Values on forced solitons
When a non-homogenous term appears, we can still consider the evolution of the eigenvalues of the Zakharov-Shabat operator. They of course can move in time.
Theorem 2.2. For the Robin-compatible 1-soliton of the first section with ,
Proof. Write with . Then
Combining these gives and .
The above formulae easily generalize to the case of several solitons.
First-order frequency shifts
Let with integrable and rapidly decaying, and let the unforced solution be a ”wall” 1-soliton . Assume for the moment that the forced solution will be close to a 1-soliton with amplitude , plus radiation. 5
Integrate (2.1) and (2.2) with the unforced trace inserted, and use (2.3). To first order,
and .
Since and , the two relations in (2.4) coincide. They give
This calculation can be generalized to the case of solitons, where we will end up for a system for the different and . In the general case the energy calculation becomes relevant. All and are real.
One reason to assume that a small perturbation does not destroy solitons is the following. All solitons corresponding to the eigenvalues correspond to zeros of some scattering data that depend continuously on the perturbation. These could move somewhat under a small enough perturbation, but cannot disappear. For this to happen they would have to hit the real line; but all zeros are at least at distance away from the real line.
Now, because of symmetries , the eigenvalues have to also remain on the imaginary line, unless there is a collision of two imaginary eigenvalues. This does not happen for a small enough perturbation. Breathers remain breathers even if frequencies can change.
Note also that even if when there is collision of two imaginary eigenvalues that gives rise to eigenvalues with non-zero real parts, the leading order asymptotics at still come from the remaining eigenvalues with zero real parts!
If has compact support and the perturbation size is small, clearly one can ensure that eigenvalues remain imaginary. For decaying not of compact support, some eigenvalues can eventually leave the imaginary line. But in general not all of them will.
To summarize, we end up with a situation similar to the unforced case: continua of solutions with different non-decaying asymptotically quasi-periodic asymptotics at the wall . This renders a unified transform impossible!
Numerical tests
We have asked Claude (Anthropic) to provide numerical runs where indeed small non-homogeneities just shift amplitudes and frequencies of breather solutions. We mention three examples below.
They used a Crank–Nicolson plus Strang splitting scheme with ghost-node Robin closure and an absorbing layer. Frequencies were measured from the trace by a zero-padded FFT with peak interpolation. They compared forced and unforced runs on the same grid, thus removing the shift of the computed frequencies.
One wall soliton, , , or resonant . The amplitude was measured from the frequency, the trace amplitude and the mass; the three agree to . A scan over with gave measured-to-predicted ratios between 0.97 and 1.01.
Two wall solitons, , , so . They used , , , and measured frequencies on . Halving roughly halves the deviation of the ratios from 1, as expected for an remainder. A single forcing moves the two frequencies independently, and here in opposite directions. The late trace is again quasi-periodic, with both frequencies shifted.
Two wall solitons, , , , , . Different values of . Same phenomena: no new zeros, no non-imaginary zeros. For larger and more solitons can appear, but there are always at least two (sometimes more) imaginary eigenvalues.
Concluding remark
The above elementary discussion is contrasted with the analysis of the Dirichlet problem. In that case (see [1] and [2]) one can show that some kind of integrability does persist when perturbing the linearisable Dirichlet data (zero data).
Acknowledgements
We are grateful for several discussions with Claude (Anthropic).
References
- [1]D.C. ANTONOPOULOU, S. KAMVISSIS, On the Dirichlet to Neumann problem for the 1-dimensional Cubic NLS Equation on the Half-Line, Nonlinearity, 28 (2015), pp. 3073–3099.
- [2]D.C. ANTONOPOULOU, S. KAMVISSIS, Addendum to: On the Dirichlet to Neumann problem for the 1-dimensional Cubic NLS Equation on the Half-Line, Nonlinearity, 29 (2016), pp. 3206–3214.DOI
- [3]G. BIONDINI AND A. BUI, On the Nonlinear Schrödinger Equation on the Half Line with Homogeneous Robin Boundary Conditions, Stud. Appl. Math. 129 (2012)DOI
- [4]A.S. Fokas, A Unified Transform Method for Solving Linear and Certain Nonlinear PDEs, Proc. R. Soc. Lond. A 453 (1997), pp. 1411–1443.DOI
- [5]A. S. Fokas, A. R. Its and L.-Y. Sung, The nonlinear Schrödinger equation on the half-line, Nonlinearity, 18 (2005), pp. 1771–1822.
- [6]Jae Min Lee, Jonatan Lenells, The nonlinear Schrödinger equation on the half-line with homogeneous Robin boundary conditions, Proc. LMS, v.126, 2022DOI
- [7]Jianke Yang, General N-solitons and their dynamics in several nonlocal nonlinear Schrodinger equations, https://arxiv.org/pdf/1712.01181
- [8]Jianke Yang, Nonlinear Waves in Integrable and Non integrable Systems, SIAM, Philadelphia, 2010.DOI