WorksPhysics and Astronomy
Electric and magnetic dipole strength in Ni from forward-angle inelastic proton scattering
Abstract
The aim of the present work is a state-by-state analysis of possible E1 and M1 transitions in Ni with a high-resolution (p,p') experiment at 295 MeV and very forward angles including 0° and a comparison to results from studies of the dipole strength with the and (e,e') reactions. The E1 and M1 cross sections of individual peaks in the spectra are deduced with a multipole decomposition analysis and converted to reduced E1 and spin-M1 transition strengths using the virtual photon and the unit cross-section method, respectively. Despite the high level density good agreement is obtained for the deduced excitation energies of J = 1 states in the three types of experiments indicating that the same states are excited. The B(E1) and B(M1) strengths from the experiments are systematically smaller than in the present work because of the lack of information on branching ratios to lower-lying excited states and the competition of particle emission. Fair agreement with the B(M1) strengths extracted from the (e,e') data is obtained after removal of E1 transitions uniquely assigned in the present work, which belong to a low-energy toroidal mode with unusual properties mimicking M1 excitations in electron scattering. The experimental M1 strength distribution is compared to large-scale shell-model calculations with the effective GXPF1A and KB3G interactions. They provide a good description of the isospin splitting and the running sum of the M1 strength. A quenching factor 0.74 for the spin-isospin part of the M1 operator is needed to attain quantitative agreement with the data.
Introduction
Magnetic dipole excitations represent an elementary mode of low-energy nuclear structure. The transition strengths contain coherent contributions from spin and orbital currents. In heavy nuclei transitions with dominant spin or orbital contributions are energetically well separated and form the orbital scissors mode and a spin-flip resonance with energy centroids of about and , respectively [1]. In lighter nuclei the two contributions are mixed with sizable interference effects in individual transitions (see, e.g., Refs. [2, 3]). Because of the anomalous proton and neutron magnetic moments, isovector (IV) strength strongly dominates over isoscalar (IS) strength and spinflip strengths are enhanced with respect to orbital strengths [4]. Since the structure of the operator does not allow for changes of the radial quantum number, in a shell-model picture transitions are restricted to spin-orbit partners. Thus, systematic investigations of the spinflip strength can provide insight into shell evolution driven by the tensor force [5]. Knowledge of the spin strength distributions is also important for the description of neutral current neutrino reactions in astrophysical environments [4, 6] and possible signals in future underground neutrino detectors [7, 8].
Assuming isospin symmetry, IV spinflip transitions are analogs of Gamow-Teller (GT) transitions with isospin , where denotes the isospin of the target ground state (g.s.). For , selection rules also allow the excitation of states with , i.e., the analog of transitions [9]. Thus, spinflip strength distributions are an independent way to investigate the long-standing problem of quenching of the axial strength in nuclei. In -shell nuclei a comparable reduction factor for decay [10] and total [11] strengths has been established in comparison with shell-model calculations providing insight into the dominant quenching mechanisms.
It has been shown that a significant contribution to quenching arises from two-body currents and can be quantitatively described by coupled-cluster [12] and shell-model [13] calculations based on chiral effective field theory (EFT) interactions. The recent development of a corresponding EFT framework [14] for shell-model calculations of the magnetic dipole strength makes new experimental investigations particularly interesting.
The present work reports on spinflip strength in extracted from high-resolution proton inelastic scattering at extreme forward angles including . The nucleus has been subject of extensive studies of the strength distribution with photon [15, 16, 17] and electron [18] scattering as well as strength with high-resolution charge-exchange reactions [19, 20]. The new data shed light on discrepancies in the parity of assignments for some transitions between the and experiments, where character was assigned in the former and in the latter. As discussed elsewhere [21], these are toroidal excitations [22] with unusual properties mimicking the signatures of transitions in low-momentum transfer electron scattering.
A pioneering inelastic proton scattering experiment on was performed at the Indiana University Cyclotron Facility (IUCF) and used in Ref. [19] to determine final-state isospins by comparison of relative cross section to charge-exchange reactions [20, 23]. However, the experiment was limited to measurements only and no independent determination of the multipolarity based on the angular distributions was possible. Furthermore, the data contained a large instrumental background limiting the sensitivity. The results reported here obtained at the facility at the Research Center for Nuclear Physics (RCNP), Osaka, Japan [24], are based on background-subtracted spectra (obtained with the methods described in Ref. [25]) and includes measurements at finite angles which permit a MDA. The excellent energy resolution of the newly reported data enables a state-by-state analysis analog to the study of spin- strength in [26] up to excitation energies of about 13.5 MeV.
The paper is organized as follows. Section II describes the experiment and the resulting spectra. Section III provides information on the data analysis, details of the MDA, and the methods of conversion from cross sections to transition strengths. Results and a detailed comparison with previous work are presented in Sec. IV. Shell-model calculations of the and spin- strength distributions are discussed in Sec. V. Finally, Sec. VI provides a summary.
Experiment
Details of the experiment at RCNP
The experiment was performed at the RCNP cyclotron facility. An unpolarized proton beam with an energy of 295 MeV impinged on a highly enriched ( ) nickel target with an areal density of 4 mg/cm. Typical proton beam currents during the experiment were 3–7 nA. Scattered protons were detected with the Grand Raiden (GR) magnetic spectrometer [27]. The GR provides a special setup for scattering experiments [25]. Measurements were performed with the GR placed at angles of , , and . A detailed description of the raw data analysis can be found in Ref. [25].
The large angular acceptance of the GR spectrometer enables the extraction of several spectra with different scattering angles from one spectrometer setting. In doing so spectra for laboratory scattering angles , , (spectrometer angle ), , (spectrometer angle ), and , (spectrometer angle ) were obtained. An excellent energy resolution of 22 keV full width at half maximum (FWHM) was achieved by applying dispersion matching between the incoming proton beam and the spectrometer. Additionally, energy calibration measurements with a target were performed. A detailed description of the raw data analysis can be found in [25].
The experimental uncertainties of the double differential cross sections are summarized in Table I and include solid angle determination, charge collection, uncertainty in target thickness and enrichment, drift chamber efficiency, and data acquisition life time ratio. Assuming independence of the individual contributions, the total systematic uncertainty amounts to 6.5%. Statistical errors are generally much smaller due to the high statistics.
| Error contribution | Value |
| Solid angle | 5% |
| Charge collection | 3% |
| Target thickness | 1.5% |
| Live time ratio | 1.5% |
| Detector efficiency | 1.7% |
| Total | 6.5% |
Table I. Error contributions to the differential cross sections.
Spectra
Figure 1 shows examples of the spectra for scattering angles , , , and . They cover an excitation energy range from 5 MeV to 26 MeV.
Figure 1. Excitation energy spectra of the reaction measured at the indicated scattering angles.
A large number of well resolved lines can be seen up to an excitation energy of approximately 13 MeV, each corresponding to an excited state. For the vast majority of states, the differential cross section drops with increasing scattering angle indicating a dipole character. The broad resonance-shaped structure centered at about 18.5 MeV is the isovector electric giant dipole resonance (IVGDR) most pronounced at small scattering angles.
A state-by-state analysis of the peaks in the spectra is presented in the following. A detailed view of the region of interest for the spectrum taken at a scattering angle 0.4° is presented in Fig. 2. The scattering around the zero line, which is somewhat vertically shifted, after background subtraction demonstrates that the spectrum is essentially background free below ≈ 9 MeV. A slowly increasing background appears towards higher excitation energies. This is mainly caused by unresolved strength due to the level density increasing with excitation energy and the emerging tail of the IVGDR. Since the proton separation threshold lies at MeV, one cannot exclude small contributions from quasi-free scattering although they should be suppressed by the Coulomb barrier up to energies of about 2 MeV above . Above the neutron separation threshold MeV a background contribution caused by quasi-free scattering is expected. However, earlier experiments with the same technique show a slow rise with excitation energy [28, 29, 30] indicating small contributions in the region considered here.
The excitation energies of the spectra were locally recalibrated using a quadratic function. For this purpose the eight most pronounced lines in the spectra were used, for which the excitation energies are precisely determined in experiments [15, 16, 17]. With this approach an uncertainty of ±10 keV is achieved.
Data Analysis
State-by-state analysis
In the following, we present a state-by-state analysis. Excitation energy regions of a several hundred keV typically containing 10 to 20 peaks were fitted simultaneously with Gaussians of equal width allowing for a piecewise linear background. The software HDTV was used [31]. With the exception of a few states at the highest excitation energies, no variations in line widths or shapes were observed. The high level density complicates an unambiguous determination of the height and shape of the background, since background-only regions in the spectra between the peaks are scarce.
Next, the consistent appearance of peaks in spectra at different scattering angles was investigated as illustrated in Figure 3. In total 147 peaks were found with the constraint that they appear in at least 5 of the 7 spectra available.
Figure 3. Spectra of the reaction in the excitation energy range of MeV at scattering angles , , and . Red curves are Gaussians, fitted to the peaks. Dashed green lines mark the average centroid energies.
Multipole decomposition analysis
Information about spin and parity of an excited state is obtained from the angular distribution of the scattered protons. Theoretical angular distributions for transitions with different multipolarities were calculated for the reaction in distorted wave Born approximation (DWBA) with the computer code DWBA07 [32] using the Love and Franey effective proton-nucleus interaction [33]. Transition amplitudes and single-particle wave functions from quasi-particle phonon model (QPM) calculations similar to Refs. [28, 30] served as input.
The angular distributions used in this work are shown in Figure 4. They represent the most collective excitation for each multipolarity. Several angular distributions were considered for transitions to take into account effects of Coulomb-nuclear interference. They showed a different behavior at low and IVGDR energies, but the resulting angular distributions were almost identical for transitions in either energy region. Thus, only one curve representative for each energy region was used in the following, cf. Figure 4.
Figure 4. Theoretical angular distributions for transitions of different multipolarities in reaction, calculated with the computer code DWBA07 [32] for an incident proton beam energy of 295 MeV. Two different curves for transitions are used in the analysis labeled (1) and (2).
The response in was studied with the reaction by Lui et al. [34], where it was shown that the
Vector (PDF)
caption: Excitation energy spectrum of the reaction between 5 and 13 MeV at a scattering angle .
largest part of the strength resides at excitation energies well above the region investigated here. Furthermore, monopole transitions are only weakly excited in the reaction. The transition plotted in Figure 4 contains a significant fraction of the isoscalar giant monopole resonance strength but is still about an order of magnitude smaller at than strong and excitations. Thus, monopole excitations were neglected in the MDA.
Then, experimental angular distributions with a clear maximum at are a signature for dipole transitions. With the exception of , transitions with multipolarities show a strong decrease of the angular distributions towards with a very similar slope in the forward-angle range covered by the experiment (cf. Ref. [24]). Thus, they are represented by a single curve () in the MDA. The superposition of at most two unresolved levels with different was considered.
A further discussion of the assumptions and approximations underlying the present MDA approach can be found in Ref. [24] and the corresponding formulas e.g. in Ref. [26].
Examples of angular distributions for known and transitions in are shown in Figure 5 and Figure 6, respectively.
Figure 5. Experimental angular distributions of the reaction for transitions assigned multipolarity . The red solid lines are the theoretical predictions with uncertainty bands from a Monte Carlo variation of experimental uncertainties.
Figure 6. Same as Fig. 5, but for transitions.
The uncertainty bands are determined from a Monte Carlo variation of the experimental error contributions summarized in Table I. For the cases, the theoretical angular distribution shows excellent agreement with the data. For the small momentum transfers covered by the experiment, IV spin- excitations exhibit an almost universal behavior independent of their particle-hole structure.
The situation is somewhat more complex for transitions. Generally, they show a steeper decrease than ’s at very small angles , which serves to distinguish between the two multipolarities. At angles , where effects of Coulomb-nuclear interference are significant, larger deviations between experimental and theoretical angular distributions are observed in many cases as illustrated in Figure 6. In particular, these transitions do not show the theoretically predicted minimum around but rather a monotonous decrease with scattering angle. A possible explanation of these discrepancies could be a different sign of the Coulomb-nuclear interference term (generally predicted to be constructive). In any case, this leads to some ambiguity in the normalization of the theoretical curves to the data and thus the extracted strength.
Figure 7 presents examples of the MDA where assuming an unresolved doublet of states with different provides the best description of the data.
Figure 7. Same as Fig. 5, but assuming two unresolved transitions with different multipolarity.
Conversion to transition strengths
The and cross sections obtained from the MDA can be converted to transition strengths with the unit cross section method for the former and assuming relativistic Coulomb excitation for the latter.
The unit cross section method was developed to extract the reduced Gamow-Teller transition strength from the cross section of a charge-exchange (CE) reaction at [35]. At beam energies MeV/nucleon one-step processes dominate CE cross sections. Then, measured cross section and the reduced transition matrix element can be related by a constant factor called unit-cross section . At , cross sections and transition strengths are related by
where depends on the nuclear mass and the projectile energy of the reaction. Kinematical corrections for non-zero momentum transfer are contained in a correction factor , which can be obtained by DWBA calculations. In Ref. [36] charge-exchange reactions at the same incident energy as in the present experiment have been evaluated, and a mass-dependent expression for was derived
resulting in mb/sr for at an incident proton energy of 295 MeV.
It has been shown, that this method can be extended to the extraction of the isovector spin-flip transition strength [37] utilizing isospin symmetry [9] and neglecting small isoscalar contributions to the cross sections. For small momentum transfers . The resulting IV spin-flip strength is denoted in the following because the excited states are isospin analogs of the transitions with , where denotes the ground-state isospin. However, one should note that the selection rules also permit the excitation of states with .
For a direct comparison to experiments using electromagnetic probes, like and , it is convenient to convert the values to the equivalent electromagnetic reduced transition strength . The latter is defined for a transition from initial state to final state as
where denotes the magnetic dipole operator. The magnetic dipole operator can be decomposed into isoscalar (IS) and isovector (IV) terms
with -factors , and . Spin-Pauli matrices and orbital angular momentum are denoted as and respectively, and the isospin operator as . In the extraction of strengths from the reaction terms containing the angular momentum operator as well as isoscalar contributions are neglected leading to
A detailed discussion of the underlying assumptions and related systematic uncertainties can be found in Refs. [9, 37].
Conversion of E1 cross sections to reduced transition strengths is achieved with the aid of the virtual photon method relating relativistic Coulomb excitation and equivalent photoabsorption cross sections [38]
Here, is the number of virtual photons with multipolarity calculated in the present work in an eikonal approach [39]. For examples of the energy and angular dependence of in the present kinematics, see Ref. [24]. The method has been verified for discrete transitions in a study of [40].
E1 and M1 strength distributions
Results and comparison with other experiments
The results of the state-by-state analysis are summarized in Table II and compared to high-resolution studies of dipole strength with polarized photon [15, 16, 17] and electron [18] scattering. Excited states observed in the latter experiments are considered being the same as in the present data when they satisfy the condition [41]
Here, denote the excitation energies from the transitions found in experiment 1(2) and are the respective uncertainties in excitation energy.
In total 116 dipole transitions were identified based on their forward-peaked angular distribution in a experiment. 26 of them allow an unambiguous , 11 an assignment, and 22 a preference for either multipolarity with the procedure described above. The parity levels could not be unambiguously determined from the present data.
Parity assignments of the excited dipole states are also possible from the other experiments. Polarization of the incident photon beam permits a distinction between and transitions by the comparison of in-plane and out-of-plane measurements of the scattered photon [42]. Especially laser Compton backscattering-generated photon beams [43, 44] with 100% linear polarization show unprecedented sensitivity for an unique multipolarity determination. The experiment was performed at low incident energies and backward angles [18]. These kinematics favor (and to a lesser extent ) transitions which show increasing cross sections with scattering angle, while transitions typically show small cross sections at backward angles.
The identification of related transitions according to Eq. (7) in the three reactions is illustrated in Figure 8 combining a spectrum at the most forward angle with
Figure 8. Comparison of spectra from the Ni, and reactions in the excitation energy range 8 − 10 MeV for kinematics where dipole excitations are enhanced. The vertical lines indicate dipole transitions seen in all three experiments. Their (red) or (blue) character is based on the combined analysis of the and data.
| [MeV] | [] | [] | [MeV] | [] | [MeV] | [] | [] | ||||||
| 9.635 | 1 | 9.643 | 9.631 | 1 | 3.82(74) | ||||||||
| 9.667 | 9.667 | 9.668 | 1 | 2.57(82) | |||||||||
| 9.728 | 9.723 | 5.49(81) | |||||||||||
| 9.746 | 1 | 9.755 | 0.32(5) | ||||||||||
| 9.842 | 9.846 | 0.54(7) | |||||||||||
| 9.870 | (1) | 9.870 | |||||||||||
| 9.921 | (1) | ||||||||||||
| 9.952 | 1 | 9.941 | |||||||||||
| 10.036 | |||||||||||||
| 10.073 | 0.35(3) | ||||||||||||
| 10.095 | 1 | ||||||||||||
| 10.119 | 10.105 | 0.21(2) | |||||||||||
| 10.159 | 10.157 | 0.37(4) | |||||||||||
| 10.214 | 10.218 | 0.56(4) | |||||||||||
| 10.240 | |||||||||||||
| 10.310 | |||||||||||||
| 10.377 | (1) | 10.385 | 0.15(3) | ||||||||||
| 10.423 | 1 | ||||||||||||
| 10.453 | 10.438 | ||||||||||||
| 10.494 | |||||||||||||
| 10.514 | 0.40(3) | ||||||||||||
| 10.616 | (1) | ||||||||||||
| 10.643 | 10.633 | 0.32(12) | |||||||||||
| 10.668 | 10.670 | 1.25(6) | |||||||||||
| 10.688 | 1 | ||||||||||||
| 10.713 | |||||||||||||
| 10.735 | 1 | 10.735 | |||||||||||
| 10.993 | (1) | ||||||||||||
| 11.011 | 11.013 | 0.57(3) | |||||||||||
| 11.037 | 11.041 | ||||||||||||
| 11.062 | 1 | ||||||||||||
| 11.080 | 1 | 11.080 | 0.22(7) | ||||||||||
| 11.169 | 11.160 | ||||||||||||
| 11.299 | 11.297 | ||||||||||||
| 11.389 | 1 | ||||||||||||
| 11.418 | 11.410 | ||||||||||||
| 11.438 | (1) | ||||||||||||
| 11.545 | (1) | 11.536 | |||||||||||
| 11.566 | 1 | ||||||||||||
| 11.632 | 1 | 11.639 | |||||||||||
| 11.676 | 11.680 | 0.17(3) | |||||||||||
| 11.706 | 1 | ||||||||||||
| 11.806 | 11.800 | ||||||||||||
| 11.856 | (1) | 11.860 | 0.43(29) |
Table II (PDF p. 8). Dipole transitions observed in the present experiment and comparison with results from [18] and [15, 16, 17] experiments.
| [MeV] | [] | [] | [MeV] | [] | [MeV] | [] | [] | |||||
| 11.889 | 11.890 | |||||||||||
| 12.047 | 12.040 | |||||||||||
| 12.074 | 12.090 | |||||||||||
| 12.206 | 1 | 12.197 | ||||||||||
| 12.268 | 1 | 12.249 | ||||||||||
| 12.280 | ||||||||||||
| 12.300 | ||||||||||||
| 12.358 | (1) | |||||||||||
| 12.392 | 1 | 12.368 | ||||||||||
| 12.414 | ||||||||||||
| 12.448 | 1 | 12.447 | ||||||||||
| 12.472 | (1) | 12.482 | ||||||||||
| 12.574 | 12.573 | |||||||||||
| 12.605 | 12.613 | |||||||||||
| 12.637 | 1 | 12.647 | ||||||||||
| 12.660 | ||||||||||||
| 12.750 | 12.746 | |||||||||||
| 12.773 | 1 | |||||||||||
| 12.801 | 1 | 12.796 | ||||||||||
| 12.819 | 1 | 12.837 | ||||||||||
| 12.846 | 1 | 12.858 | ||||||||||
| 12.874 | 1 | |||||||||||
| 12.892 | 1 | |||||||||||
| 12.966 | 12.971 | |||||||||||
| 12.983 | (1) | |||||||||||
| 13.029 | 1 | 13.022 | ||||||||||
| 13.034 | 1 | |||||||||||
| 13.090 | ||||||||||||
| 13.175 | 13.176 | |||||||||||
| 13.251 | 1 | 13.233 | ||||||||||
| 13.260 | ||||||||||||
| 13.329 | 1 | 13.345 |
Table 2 (PDF p. 9). Dipole transitions observed in the present experiment and comparison with results from [18] and [15, 16, 17] experiments.
an spectrum at the most backward angle and unpublished data measured at HIS [44]. For better visibility, the excitation energy region covered is limited to 8–10 MeV. The vertical dashed lines indicate E1 (red) or M1 (blue) transitions observed in all three reactions.
Finally, IV spinflip-M1 transitions in the present data can be identified from comparison to the results of Fujita et al. [19], who studied analog transitions from a experiment at and GT transitions populated in the reaction. Furthermore, the conversion of cross sections to GT strength contains isospin Clebsch-Gordan coefficients [9], which allow to determine the final-state isospin from the cross section ratio in the two experiments. Cross sections for the reaction at MeV and extrapolated to are given in Table I of Ref. [19]. The cross section ratio for the population of the same states at a fixed angle in the present experiment should be constant.
The comparison in Table II reveals several cases of unambiguous assignments from the present work and the data identified as in the the data. Since modes like the IS compressional and IV giant resonances are irrotational, their transverse form factors are weak. Accordingly, dipole transitions with large transverse cross sections were considered to be of nature only in Ref. [18]. However, recent work [21] shows that these states likely belong to a toroidal electric dipole mode [22] with unusual properties like large transverse electron scattering form factors mimicking the behavior of transitions.
In general, there is fair agreement between the multipolarity assignments from the different experiments. However, there is an unclear assignment already noted in Ref. [19] with respect to the state seen at 9.529 MeV in the present experiment with corresponding states at 9.513 MeV in and at 9.523 MeV in . The data [15, 17] unambiguously assign a prominent transition with character. On the other hand, the CE data described in Ref. [19] see a possible analog state which would point towards a character. The transition seen in the experiments (present work and Ref. [19]) might thus represent an unresolved doublet. However, the absence of any signal in the experiments led us to assume dominance of the transition making it part of the toroidal mode discussed above. Furthermore, according to Ref. [17], the transition at 8.513 MeV identified as toroidal candidate represents an unresolved doublet.
E1 strength
A comparison of strengths deduced from the present experiment up to 10 MeV with results from the experiments [15, 17] is presented in Figure 9. Transitions with unique character in both experiments or with a assignment in the former and an unique assignment in the latter data are included.
Figure 9. Comparison of strengths in Ni deduced from the present work and experiments [15, 17].
In general, larger strengths are found in the present experiment. The conversion of cross sections to transition strengths depends on the unknown branching ratio of the g.s. decay. Except for a few cases of direct decay to low-lying states observed and included, the transitions strengths in Table II and Figure 9 assume 100% g.s. decay. Further, competition of proton emission is expected above the threshold ( MeV). Thus, the values from represent lower limits only. The average difference to the present results is about a factor of 2. The most prominent transition at 8.236 MeV is an exception where the difference is smaller than 25%.
M1 strength
The comparison of the strength distributions extracted from the , and experiments is shown in Figure 10. The values from the present work were obtained with the aid of Eq. (5), i.e., neglecting orbital contributions. While this may be a reasonable assumption for the total strength because of the random sign of the interference term [45], differences are expected for individual transitions when comparing with electromagnetic probes. As discussed for the case of transitions above, the strengths deduced from the data are lower limits only.

Figure 10. Comparison of strengths in deduced from the present work, [15, 17] and [18] experiments.
In the experiments only the strength up to 9.3 MeV was measured [15, 17]. While the experiment is mainly sensitive to the spin part and isovector excitations, the strength distributions from and consist of spin and orbital contributions as well as their interference. The strength distribution shows a good agreement with the present results indicating small orbital strength and dominant g.s. back decay. A similar behavior was observed in and successfully interpreted in the framework of the quasiparticle-phonon model [16]. The strong transition at 8.678 MeV is observed with similar strength as in the experiment, while electron scattering gives a value about a factor of 2 smaller. On the other hand, the state at 7.715 MeV is enhanced in compared to the other experiments. The agreement between the and strength distributions increases with excitation energy, even though many of the transitions observed in the latter are slightly larger.
Spinflip- strength
The bottom part of Figure 11 presents the distribution of IV spinflip- strength extracted with the method described in Sec. III C. Blue triangles denote unique assignments using the same criteria as discussed for the case. Orange squares are tentative assignments ( in Table II). The latter are weak and typically below the
Figure 11. Bottom: Distribution of the isovector spin-flip transition strength in . Blue triangles refer to transitions with uniquely defined character, orange squares to tentative assignments. Top: Running sum excluding (blue) or including (orange) tentative assignments.
sensitivity limit of the experiment due to the strong radiative tail background in the spectra of Ref. [18]. The upper part of Figure 11 shows the running sum excluding (blue) or including (orange) tentative assignments. Their contribution is negligible up to 9 MeV and reaches about 20%(40%) at 12(13) MeV.
As discussed in Sec. IV A, IV spinflip- transitions can be assigned independently by comparison with GT strength distributions from high-resolution CE reactions [19]. Here we compare directly with cross section data given in Table II of Ref. [19] obtained in the solid-angle range . For transitions, a constant cross section ratio is expected for any of the present spectra. The data at are chosen as representative example. The corresponding integrated cross sections of resolved transition are displayed in the top and middle row of Figure 12, respectively.
Figure 12. Cross sections of dipole transitions observed in the reaction at in the present work and in Ref. [19]. The horizontal dashed line shows the average ratio expected to be constant for transitions, cf. Eq. (8).
is shown in the bottom row of Figure 12. The average value is indicated as dashed line.
Clearly, most transitions agree with the average value within error bars. The states observed in Ref. [19] at 9.739 MeV and 11.003 MeV were left out. They each correspond to the sum of two close-lying states resolved in the present work due to the slightly better energy resolution. For a few transitions between 8 and 9 MeV, values are obtained. Comparison with Table II reveals that these are transitions. Their cross section ratios are consistent with the increase of the virtual photon flux in relativistic Coulomb excitation for the two beam energies.
| [MeV] | [] | [] | [MeV] | [] | [MeV] | [] | [] | |||||
| 6.027 | 6.031 | 6.027 | 1 | 5.69(29) | ||||||||
| 6.474 | 6.475 | 0.17(5) | ||||||||||
| 7.050 | 7.051 | 7.048 | 4.52(14) | |||||||||
| 7.155 | ||||||||||||
| 7.254 | 7.255 | 7.250 | 0.37(13) | |||||||||
| 7.273 | 7.290 | 7.272 | 1 | 0.31(3) | 3.40(40) | |||||||
| 7.390 | 7.388 | 0.33(7) | 7.389 | 0.294(15) | ||||||||
| 7.471 | 1 | 7.470 | 0.25(5) | |||||||||
| 7.554 | 7.560 | 0.15(4) | ||||||||||
| 7.590 | 7.585 | 0.58(27) | ||||||||||
| 7.603 | 7.596 | |||||||||||
| 7.650 | 1 | |||||||||||
| 7.711 | 7.715 | 0.74(5) | 7.710 | 0.358(13) | ||||||||
| 8.076 | 1 | 8.069 | 1.81(24) | |||||||||
| 8.197 | 8.096 | 1 | 0.139(26) | 1.54(29) | ||||||||
| 8.236 | 8.240 | 1.27(20) | 8.237 | 18.41(28) | ||||||||
| 8.275 | 8.276 | 0.26(3) | ||||||||||
| 8.323 | 8.317 | 1 | 1.19(18) | |||||||||
| 8.366 | ||||||||||||
| 8.391 | 8.395 | 8.395 | 4.05(38) | |||||||||
| 8.417 | ||||||||||||
| 8.461 | 8.475 | 8.461 | 0.382(21) | |||||||||
| 8.513 | 8.516 | 1.04(15) | 8.513 | 0.138(33) | ||||||||
| 8.514 | 1.67(37) | |||||||||||
| 8.602 | 8.601 | 0.44(5) | 8.601 | 0.328(33) | ||||||||
| 8.678 | 8.680 | 0.47(3) | 8.679 | 0.815(41) | ||||||||
| 8.811 | 1 | 8.817 | 0.19(2) | |||||||||
| 8.856 | 8.854 | 8.857 | 1 | 0.281(55) | ||||||||
| 8.881 | 8.875 | 0.51(4) | 8.880 | 4.79(18) | ||||||||
| 8.959 | 8.967 | 0.23(6) | 8.961 | 1 | 0.136(14) | |||||||
| 8.988 | ||||||||||||
| 9.044 | 1 | 9.037 | 0.30(4) | |||||||||
| 9.073 | 9.073 | 0.26(5) | 9.073 | 0.309(21) | ||||||||
| 9.159 | 9.163 | 0.23(3) | 9.157 | 0.201(27) | ||||||||
| 9.191 | 9.191 | 2.92(28) | ||||||||||
| 9.245 | ||||||||||||
| 9.268 | 1 | |||||||||||
| 9.292 | 1 | |||||||||||
| 9.326 | 9.326 | 0.312(20) | ||||||||||
| 9.361 | 9.368 | 0.34(4) | 9.369 | 4.32(40) | ||||||||
| 9.421 | 9.407 | |||||||||||
| 9.463 | 9.468 | 9.455 | 1 | 0.068(13) | 0.75(15) | |||||||
| 9.529 | 9.513 | 0.22(15) | 9.523 | 7.47(48) | ||||||||
| 9.554 | 9.552 | 9.554 | 1 | 4.48(28) |
Table II. Dipole transitions observed in the present experiment and comparison with results from [18] and [15, 16, 17] experiments.
Following the approach of Refs. [9, 19], one can also assign isospin quantum numbers to the excited states by comparison with the analog transitions observed in the high-resolution study of the reaction presented in Ref. [19]. The results are displayed in Figure 13 and exhibit a two-bump structure of centered around 8.5 MeV and 11 MeV for and 2 transitions, respectively. Below an excitation energy in corresponding to the analog of the g.s. in only is possible. Since all excited states reported in Ref. [19] between 8 MeV und 13 MeV are also found in the present work, but no additional states (except the doublets mentioned above), the conclusions regarding the isospin of the excited states remain unchanged with respect to Table II of Ref. [19]. Some spinflip- excitations without an experimental counterpart in Refs. [18, 19] were observed in the present data at higher excitation energies, probably due to sensitivity limits of these experiments resulting from the significant background in the spectra.
Figure 13. Isospin of final states excited by spin-flip transitions in the present work based on the comparison to analog transitions studied in Ref. [19]. The colors indicate (cyan), (blue), not determined (grey).
Shell model calculations
Details of the calculations
Calculations within the shell model framework have been performed to assist in the assignment of isospin and interpretation of the transitions. The model space adopted is composed by the , , and proton and neutron orbitals resting on a core. Due to the large dimension of the problem, a truncation was required on the admitted configurations, allowing only configurations with at most 8 particle-hole excitations. The -shell effective interactions GXPF1A [46, 47] and KB3G [48] have been used. The usual quenching factor for Gamow–Teller processes in the -shell of 0.74 [10] has been employed. The calculations have been performed in the -coupled scheme using a fast implementation of the Lanczos algorithm through the code NATHAN [49]. The results shown correspond to 100 Lanczos iterations.
Comparison to experiment
Figure 14 presents a comparison of the experimental strength to shell model calculations with both effective interactions. Within the limitations of the model approach, which is not sufficient to fully reproduce details of the fragmentation, the KB3G results provide a fair description of the data although the strength in the excitation energy region 8 – 10 MeV is somewhat overestimated. The bimodal shape of the strength distribution due to isospin splitting is reproduced even though the center of mass for and transitions is pushed to slightly higher excitation energies. The calculation also reproduces the exceptionally strong transition at about 10.5 MeV. The bimodal shape is not clearly present in the GXPF1A result, which produces wider and distributions. The centroid of the strength is shifted to even higher excitation energies.
Figure 14. Experimental and theoretical strength in . Top panel: cumulative sum of the experiment excluding (blue) and including (orange) tentative assignments and shell-model calculations with the GXPF1A (solid red line) and KB3G (green dashed line) interactions. Second and third panel: strength distributions obtained with the GXPF1A [46, 47] and KB3G [48] interactions, respectively. Bottom panel: experimental strength distributions from the reaction. Final-state isospins are indicated by cyan () and blue ().
In the top panel of Figure 14, the cumulative sums are shown. Here, the GXPF1A interaction provides a very good description of the data up to 10.5 MeV. The KB3G result agrees fairly well up to 9 MeV and overshoots about 20% up to 10.5 MeV. At even higher excitation energies up to 13 MeV the model predictions lie above the experimental cumulative sum, even including tentative assignments, cf. Figure 11. Again, the GXPF1A results are closer to the data. In this high-energy region it is likely that some strength is missed in the experiment due to the increasing level density.
Finally, the running sums of the strengths from the three experiments are displayed in Figure 15 together with the shell-model results using the GXPF1A and KB3G interactions, respectively. The differences between the two theoretical results are smaller than for the case and they coincide well with all three experimental data sets. One distinct difference though is the absence of strength in the KB3G result below 8 MeV. The data do show a small but finite experimental strength amounting to about 0.6 in the and about 1 in the results well described by the GXPF1A calculation.
Figure 15. Running sums of the strength in deduced from the present inelastic proton (top), photon [15, 17] (middle), and electron [18] (bottom) scattering experiments compared to shell-model results with the GXPF1A [46, 47] (red line) and KB3G [48] (green line) interactions.
Conclusions
We present here a state-by-state analysis of dipole transitions in measured with the reaction at extreme forward angles including . This is possible up to excitation energies of 13 MeV due to the excellent energy resolution of 22 keV (FWHM). The resulting and strength distributions are compared to results obtained with the and reactions.
The multipolarity assignments are in fair agreement except for a certain class of transitions unambiguously assigned by the proton and photon scattering data but interpreted as because of their large transverse cross sections in electron scattering. They provide the first clear experimental evidence for a toroidal mode in nuclei as demonstrated elsewhere [21]. The strengths deduced from the present data are generally larger than those from the experiments indicating sizable inelastic branching ratios. This is particularly true above the proton emission threshold. Effects are less pronounced for transitions.
The and strength distributions are compared to large scale shell-model calculations with the effective GXPF1A and KB3G interactions. Although details of the strength fragmentation cannot be reproduced because of necessary constraints on the huge model space, cumulative properties like the running sums are well described once a quenching factor 0.74 is included for the spin-isospin part of the operator.
Acknowledgments
We thank the Accelerator Group at RCNP for providing a high-quality dispersion-matched beam for the experiment. This work was supported by the Deutsche Forschungsgemeinschaft (DFG, German Research Foundation) under Contract No. SFB 1245 (Project ID No. 79384907). MS acknowledges financial support by the UK-STFC (Grant N0 ST/P005101/1).
References
- [1]K. Heyde, P. von Neumann-Cosel, and A. Richter, Magnetic dipole excitations in nuclei: Elementary modes of nucleonic motion, Rev. Mod. Phys. 82, 2365 (2010).DOI
- [2]Y. Fujita, H. Akimune, I. Daito, M. Fujiwara, M. N. Harakeh, T. Inomata, J. Jänecke, K. Katori, C. Lü ttge, S. Nakayama, P. von Neumann-Cosel, A. Richter, A. Tamii, M. Tanaka, H. Toyokawa, H. Ueno, and M. Yosoi, Isospin and spin-orbital structures of Jπ = 1+ states excited in 28Si, Phys. Rev. C 55, 1137 (1997).DOI
- [3]F. Hofmann, P. von Neumann-Cosel, F. Neumeyer, C. Rangacharyulu, B. Reitz, A. Richter, G. Schrieder, D. I. Sober, L. W. Fagg, and B. A. Brown, Magnetic dipole transitions in 32S from electron scattering at 180°, Phys. Rev. C 65, 024311 (2002).
- [4]K. Langanke, G. Martínez-Pinedo, P. von Neumann-Cosel, and A. Richter, Supernova inelastic neutrino-nucleus cross sections from high-resolution electron scattering experiments and shell-model calculations, Phys. Rev. Lett. 93, 202501 (2004).
- [5]T. Otsuka, A. Gade, O. Sorlin, T. Suzuki, and Y. Utsuno, Evolution of shell structure in exotic nuclei, Rev. Mod. Phys. 92, 015002 (2020).DOI
- [6]K. Langanke, G. Martínez-Pinedo, B. Müller, H.-T. Janka, A. Marek, W. R. Hix, A. Juodagalvis, and J. M. Sampaio, Effects of inelastic neutrino-nucleus scattering on supernova dynamics and radiated neutrino spectra, Phys. Rev. Lett. 100, 011101 (2008).
- [7]U. Gayer, T. Beck, M. Bhike, J. Isaak, N. Pietralla, P. C. Ries, D. Savran, M. Schilling, W. Tornow, and V. Werner, Experimental M1 response of 40Ar as a benchmark for neutrino-nucleus scattering calculations, Phys. Rev. C 100, 034305 (2019).
- [8]W. Tornow, A. Tonchev, S. Finch, Krishichayan, X. Wang, A. Hayes, H. Yeomans, and D. Newmark, Neutral-current neutrino cross section and expected supernova signals for 40Ar from a three-fold increase in the magnetic dipole strength, Phys. Lett. B 835, 137576 (2022).
- [9]Y. Fujita, B. Rubio, and W. Gelletly, Spin–isospin excitations probed by strong, weak and electro-magnetic interactions, Prog. Part. Nucl. Phys. 66, 549 (2011).DOI
- [10]G. Martínez-Pinedo, A. Poves, E. Caurier, and A. P. Zuker, Effective gA in the pf shell, Phys. Rev. C 53, R2602 (1996).pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/9971316
- [11]P. von Neumann-Cosel, A. Poves, J. Retamosa, and A. Richter, Magnetic dipole response in nuclei at the N = 28 shell closure: A new look, Phys. Lett. B 443, 1 (1998).
- [12]P. Gysbers, G. Hagen, J. D. Holt, G. R. Jansen, T. D. Morris, P. Navrátil, T. Papenbrock, S. Quaglioni, A. Schwenk, S. R. Stroberg, and K. A. Wendt, Discrepancy between experimental and theoretical β-decay rates resolved from first principles, Nat. Phys. 15, 428 (2019).DOI
- [13]L. Coraggio, N. Itaco, G. De Gregorio, A. Gargano, Z. H. Cheng, Y. Z. Ma, F. R. Xu, and M. Viviani, The renormalization of the shell-model Gamow-Teller operator starting from effective field theory for nuclear systems, Phys. Rev. C 109, 014301 (2024).DOI
- [14]R. Seutin, O. J. Hernandez, T. Miyagi, S. Bacca, K. Hebeler, S. König, and A. Schwenk, Magnetic dipole operator from chiral effective field theory for many-body expansion methods, Phys. Rev. C 108, 054005 (2023).arxiv.org/abs/2308.00136
- [15]F. Bauwens, J. Bryssinck, D. De Frenne, K. Govaert, L. Govor, M. Hagemann, J. Heyse, E. Jacobs, W. Mondelaers, and V. Y. Ponomarev, Dipole transitions to bound states in 56Fe and 58Ni, Phys. Rev. C 62, 024302 (2000).
- [16]M. Scheck, V. Y. Ponomarev, M. Fritzsche, J. Joubert, T. Aumann, J. Beller, J. Isaak, J. H. Kelley, E. Kwan, N. Pietralla, R. Raut, C. Romig, G. Rusev, D. Savran, L. Schörrenberger, K. Sonnabend, A. P. Tonchev, W. Tornow, H. R. Weller, A. Zilges, and M. Zweidinger, Photoresponse of 60Ni below 10-MeV excitation energy: Evolution of dipole resonances in fp-shell nuclei near N = Z, Phys. Rev. C 88, 044304 (2013).
- [17]T. Shizuma, M. Omer, T. Hayakawa, F. Minato, S. Matsuba, S. Miyamoto, N. Shimizu, and Y. Utsuno, Parity assignment for low-lying dipole states in 58Ni, Phys. Rev. C 109, 014302 (2024).
- [18]W. Mettner, A. Richter, W. Stock, B. Metsch, and A. Van Hees, Electroexcitation of 58Ni: A study of the fragmentation of the magnetic dipole strength, Nucl. Phys. A 473, 160 (1987).DOI
- [19]H. Fujita, Y. Fujita, T. Adachi, A. Bacher, G. Berg, T. Black, E. Caurier, C. Foster, H. Fujimura, K. Hara, K. Harada, K. Hatanaka, J. Jänecke, J. Kamiya, Y. Kanzaki, K. Katori, T. Kawabata, K. Langanke, G. Martínez-Pinedo, T. Noro, D. Roberts, H. Sakaguchi, Y. Shimbara, T. Shinada, E. Stephenson, H. Ueno, T. Yamanaka, M. Yoshifuku, and M. Yosoi, Isospin structure of Jπ = 1+ states in 58Ni and 58Cu studied by 58Ni(p,p′) and 58Ni(3He,t)58Cu measurements, Phys. Rev. C 75, 034310 (2007).DOI
- [20]M. Hagemann, C. Bäumer, A. M. van den Berg, D. De Frenne, D. Frekers, V. M. Hannen, M. N. Harakeh, J. Heyse, M. A. de Huu, E. Jacobs, K. Langanke, G. Martínez-Pinedo, A. Negret, L. Popescu, S. Rakers, R. Schmidt, and H. J. Wörtche, Spin-isospin excitations in the medium-mass nucleus $^{58}$Co investigated with the $(d, ^{2}$He) reaction, Phys. Rev. C 71, 014606 (2005).
- [21]P. von Neumann-Cosel, V. O. Nesterenko, I. Brandherm, P. I. Vishnevskiy, P. G. Reinhard, J. Kvasil, H. Matsubara, A. Repko, A. Richter, M. Scheck, and A. Tamii, Evidence for a toroidal electric dipole mode in nuclei, arXiv:2310.04736 [nucl-ex].
- [22]A. Repko, V. O. Nesterenko, J. Kvasil, and P.-G. Reinhard, Systematics of toroidal dipole modes in Ca, Ni, Zr, and Sn isotopes, Eur. Phys. J. A 55, 242 (2019).DOI
- [23]Y. Fujita, H. Fujita, T. Adachi, G. P. A. Berg, E. Caurier, H. Fujimura, K. Hara, K. Hatanaka, Z. Janas, J. Kamiya, T. Kawabata, K. Langanke, G. Martínez-Pinedo, T. Noro, E. Roeckl, Y. Shimbara, T. Shinada, S. Y. van der Werf, M. Yoshifuku, M. Yosoi, and R. G. T. Zegers, Gamow-Teller transitions from $^{58}$Ni to discrete states of $^{58}$Cu - The study of isospin symmetry in atomic nuclei, Eur. Phys. J. A 13, 411 (2002).
- [24]P. von Neumann-Cosel and A. Tamii, Electric and magnetic dipole modes in high-resolution inelastic proton scattering at 0°, Eur. Phys. J. A 55, 110 (2019).
- [25]A. Tamii, Y. Fujita, H. Matsubara, T. Adachi, J. Carter, M. Dozono, H. Fujita, K. Fujita, H. Hashimoto, K. Hatanaka, T. Itahashi, M. Itoh, T. Kawabata, K. Nakanishi, S. Ninomiya, A. Perez-Cerdan, L. Popescu, B. Rubio, T. Saito, H. Sakaguchi, Y. Sakemi, Y. Sasamoto, Y. Shimbara, Y. Shimizu, F. Smit, Y. Tameshige, M. Yosoi, and J. Zenhiro, Measurement of high energy resolution inelastic proton scattering at and close to zero degrees, Nucl. Instrum. Methods Phys. Res., Sect. A 605, 326 (2009).DOI
- [26]M. Mathy, J. Birkhan, H. Matsubara, P. von Neumann-Cosel, N. Pietralla, V. Y. Ponomarev, A. Richter, and A. Tamii, Search for weak M1 transitions in $^{48}$Ca with inelastic proton scattering, Phys. Rev. C 95, 054316 (2017).DOI
- [27]M. Fujiwara, H. Akimune, I. Adachi, H. Fujimura, Y. Fujita, K. Hatanaka, H. Ikegami, I. Katayama, K. Nagayama, N. Matsuoka, S. Morinobu, T. Noro, M. Yoshimura, H. Sakaguchi, Y. Sakemi, A. Tamai, and M. Yosoi, Magnetic spectrometer Grand Raiden, Nucl. Instrum. Methods Phys. Res., Sect. A 422, 484 (1999).DOI
- [28]J. Birkhan, M. Miorelli, S. Bacca, S. Bassauer, C. A. Bertulani, G. Hagen, H. Matsubara, P. von Neumann-Cosel, T. Papenbrock, N. Pietralla, V. Y. Ponomarev, A. Richter, A. Schwenk, and A. Tamii, Electric dipole polarizability of $^{48}$Ca and implications for the neutron skin, Phys. Rev. Lett. 118, 252501 (2017).DOI
- [29]S. Bassauer, P. von Neumann-Cosel, P.-G. Reinhard, A. Tamii, S. Adachi, C. A. Bertulani, P. Y. Chan, A. D’Alessio, H. Fujioka, H. Fujita, Y. Fujita, G. Gey, M. Hilcker, T. H. Hoang, A. Inoue, J. Isaak, C. Iwamoto, T. Klaus, N. Kobayashi, Y. Maeda, M. Matsuda, N. Nakatsuka, S. Noji, H. J. Ong, I. Ou, N. Pietralla, V. Y. Ponomarev, M. S. Reen, A. Richter, M. Singer, G. Steinhilber, T. Sudo, Y. Togano, M. Tsumura, Y. Watanabe, and V. Werner, Electric and magnetic dipole strength in $^{112,114,116,118,120,124}$Sn, Phys. Rev. C 102, 034327 (2020).DOI
- [30]R. W. Fearick, P. von Neumann-Cosel, S. Bacca, J. Birkhan, F. Bonaiti, I. Brandherm, G. Hagen, H. Matsubara, W. Nazarewicz, N. Pietralla, V. Y. Ponomarev, P.-G. Reinhard, X. Roca-Maza, A. Richter, A. Schwenk, J. Simonis, and A. Tamii, Electric dipole polarizability
- [32]J. Raynal, Computer Code: DWBA07, NEA Data Service NEA1209/008 (2007).
- [33]W. G. Love and M. A. Franey, Effective nucleon-nucleon interaction for scattering at intermediate energies, Phys. Rev. C 24, 1073 (1981).DOI
- [34]Y.-W. Lui, D. H. Youngblood, H. L. Clark, Y. Tokimoto, and B. John, Isoscalar giant resonances for nuclei with mass between 56 and 60, Phys. Rev. C 73, 014314 (2006).DOI
- [35]T. Taddeucci, C. Goulding, T. Carey, R. Byrd, C. Goodman, C. Gaarde, J. Larsen, D. Horen, J. Rapaport, and E. Sugarbaker, The $(p,n)$ reaction as a probe of beta decay strength, Nucl. Phys. A 469, 125 (1987).DOI
- [36]M. Sasano, H. Sakai, K. Yako, T. Wakasa, S. Asaji, K. Fujita, Y. Fujita, M. B. Greenfield, Y. Hagihara, K. Hatanaka, T. Kawabata, H. Kuboki, Y. Maeda, H. Okamura, T. Saito, Y. Sakemi, K. Sekiguchi, Y. Shimizu, Y. Takahashi, Y. Tameshige, and A. Tamii, Gamow-Teller unit cross sections of the $(p,n)$ reaction at 198 and 297 MeV on medium-heavy nuclei, Phys. Rev. C 79, 024602 (2009).DOI
- [37]J. Birkhan, H. Matsubara, P. von Neumann-Cosel, N. Pietralla, V. Y. Ponomarev, A. Richter, A. Tamii, and J. Wambach, Electromagnetic $M1$ transition strengths from inelastic proton scattering: The cases of $^{48}$Ca and $^{208}$Pb, Phys. Rev. C 93, 041302(R) (2016).DOI
- [38]C. A. Bertulani and G. Baur, Electromagnetic processes in relativistic heavy ion collisions, Phys. Rep. 163, 299 (1988).
- [39]C. Bertulani and A. Nathan, Excitation and photon decay of giant resonances from high-energy collisions of heavy ions, Nucl. Phys. A 554, 158 (1993).DOI
- [40]I. Poltoratska, P. von Neumann-Cosel, A. Tamii, T. Adachi, C. A. Bertulani, J. Carter, M. Dozono, H. Fujita, K. Fujita, Y. Fujita, K. Hatanaka, M. Itoh, T. Kawabata, Y. Kalmykov, A. M. Krumbholz, E. Litvinova, H. Matsubara, K. Nakanishi, R. Neveling, H. Okamura, H. J. Ong, B. Özel-Tashenov, V. Y. Ponomarev, A. Richter, B. Rubio, H. Sakaguchi, Y. Sakemi, Y. Sasamoto, Y. Shimbara, Y. Shimizu, F. D. Smit, T. Suzuki, Y. Tameshige, J. Wambach, M. Yosoi, and J. Zenihiro, Pygmy dipole resonance in $^{208}$Pb, Phys. Rev. C 85, 041304 (2012).DOI
- [41]K. Weise and W. Wogner, Comparison of two measurement results using the Bayesian theory of measurement uncertainty, Meas. Sci. Technol. 5, 879 (1995).DOI
- [42]A. Zilges, D. Balabanski, J. Isaak, and N. Pietralla, Photonuclear reactions—from basic research to applications, Prog. Part. Nucl. Phys. 122, 103903 (2022).DOI
- [43]S. Amano, K. Horikawa, K. Ishihara, S. Miyamoto, T. Hayakawa, T. Shizuma, and T. Mochizuki, Several-MeV γ-ray generation at NewSUBARU by laser Compton backscattering, Nucl. Instrum. Methods Phys. Res., Sect. A 602, 337 (2009).DOI
- [44]H. R. Weller, M. W. Ahmed, H. Gao, W. Tornow, Y. K. Wu, M. Gal, and R. Miskimen, Research opportunities at the upgraded HIγS facility, Prog. Part. Nucl. Phys. 62, 257 (2009).
- [45]M. Fayache, P. von Neumann-Cosel, A. Richter, Y. Sharon, and L. Zamick, Effects of the spin-orbit and tensor interactions on $M1$ excitations in light nuclei, Nucl. Phys. A 627, 14 (1997).
- [46]M. Honma, T. Otsuka, B. A. Brown, and T. Mizusaki, New effective interaction for pf-shell nuclei and its implications for the stability of the N = Z = 28 closed core, Phys. Rev. C 69, 034335 (2004).DOI
- [47]M. Honma, T. Otsuka, B. A. Brown, and T. Mizusaki, Shell-model description of neutron-rich pf-shell nuclei with a new effective interaction GXPF1, Eur. Phys. J. A 25, 499 (2005).
- [48]A. Poves, J. Sánchez-Solano, E. Caurier, and F. Nowacki, Shell model study of the isobaric chains A = 50, A = 51 and A = 52, Nucl. Phys. A 694, 157 (2001).DOI
- [49]E. Caurier, G. Martínez-Pinedo, F. Nowacki, A. Poves, and A. P. Zuker, The shell model as a unified view of nuclear structure, Rev. Mod. Phys. 77, 427 (2005).DOI












