We study degenerate nonlocal Dirichlet problems driven by the p-Laplacian, with diffusion depending on weighted sums of integral powers of the solution. Under explicit sign, spectral and size conditions, we obtain two positive solutions for each bounded positivity interval of the diffusion coefficient with zero endpoint values. Neither monotonicity of the normalized reaction f(x,t)/tp−1 nor uniqueness of the frozen problem is required. The proof combines Schauder's theorem on a product space of a scalar parameter and a function with subsolution bounds and an energy estimate. The multiplicity result also persists under uniformly small continuous perturbations of the nonlocal functional, including perturbations that do not preserve order.
Introduction
We consider the nonlocal Dirichlet problem
⎩⎨⎧−m(H(u))Δpu=f(x,u)u>0u=0in Ω,in Ω,on ∂Ω.
where Ω⊂RN is a bounded domain with smooth boundary, 1<p<+∞, and Δpu=div(∣∇u∣p−2∇u). The nonlocal functional is
H(u)=i=1∑M∫Ωμi(x)∣u∣qidx,u∈L∞(Ω),(1)
with M≥1, qi≥1 and nonnegative bounded measurable weights μi. We seek two positive solutions for each bounded interval on which m is positive and vanishes at both endpoints.
Equations of this type describe stationary states of models in which a spatially uniform diffusion rate depends on an integral of the state. For example, (P) is the stationary equation associated with
∂tu−div(m(H(u))∣∇u∣p−2∇u)=f(x,u).
This interpretation justifies the terms diffusion coefficient for m and reaction for f used below. The nonlocal dependence is in the scalar coefficient, while the differential operator is local. Classical motivations include Carrier’s string models [6, 7] and population dispersal models [8, 9]. More recent work studies how spatial heterogeneity and degeneracy of the coefficient affect positive stationary states [11, 14], as well as nonlocal evolution equations [5]. In the present setting, weights such as μi=χΩi allow the coefficient to depend on measurements over prescribed regions. These regions may overlap and need not cover Ω. Our result concerns the multiplicity of stationary states and does not address their dynamical stability.
Degeneracy of the nonlocal coefficient may change the structure of the positive solution set. For a logistic reaction, Delgado et al. [11] show that the continuum of positive solutions of the local problem is replaced by two disjoint branches in the nonlocal problem. For degenerate coefficients, multiplicity results with two positive solutions per positivity interval were obtained for the Laplacian in [15, 16] and for the p-Laplacian in [4]. Related extensions include variable exponent, Neumann and double phase problems [3, 10, 13]. In [4], the nonlocal term is ∫Ω∣u∣qdx and the autonomous reaction satisfies a strict decrease condition on f(t)/tp−1. This condition yields uniqueness for the nonlinear problem obtained by fixing the nonlocal argument. Its solution uα then defines a continuous scalar map α↦∫Ωuαqdx, whose fixed points give the required solutions.
Gasiński, Santos Júnior and Siciliano [17] treat the semilinear equation −Δu=F(u,∫Ω∣u∣qdx), allowing singular dependence of F on its second argument. Assumption (f2) of that paper requires s↦F(s,α)/s to be decreasing. Its Proposition 2.1 gives a unique positive solution for each admissible α, and its Propositions 3.1 and 3.2 use the resulting continuous scalar map to obtain 2K solutions. Here the reaction may depend measurably on x, the operator is the p-Laplacian, and no decrease condition is imposed on the normalized reaction. We retain the same multiplicity pattern through a different fixed point construction. The two results have different scopes, since we do not treat the general singular dependence of F on its second argument allowed in [17].
Our main contribution is to obtain this multiplicity conclusion without assuming monotonicity of
(0,t∗)∋t⟼tp−1f(x,t).(2)
We refer to this quotient as the normalized reaction. Fixing the nonlocal argument at a value α produces the auxiliary Dirichlet problem
−m(α)Δpu=f(x,u)in Ω,u=0on ∂Ω,(3)
which we call the frozen problem. If the normalized reaction is not decreasing, uniqueness of positive solutions of (1.3) does not follow from the principles of Brézis and Oswald [2] or Díaz and Saá [12], and no continuous selection α↦uα of solutions is available from those arguments. We instead use an operator T(α,v) defined by solving the Dirichlet problem obtained from (1.3) when the right-hand side is evaluated at a given function v and suitably truncated. Schauder’s theorem is applied to a map defined on the product of a parameter interval and a ball in C01(Ω). A fixed point (α,u) of this map satisfies u=T(α,u), so that u solves the frozen problem at α. Bounds at the two ends of the parameter interval then enforce the additional identity α=H(u), which turns u into a solution of (P). Lemma 2.2 records this elementary consequence of Schauder’s theorem.
Subsolution and supersolution methods are already used for nonlocal elliptic equations, for example in [1], where they are combined with pseudomonotone operator theory. In our proof, the lower barrier is a subsolution of the frozen problem which varies continuously with α. Near the endpoints of each positivity interval it is chosen sufficiently large to make H(u)>α for every fixed point u of the truncated operator at such a value of α, whereas an energy estimate gives H(u)<α at a suitable interior point α=τk. Both estimates apply to all fixed points at the specified endpoints, and not only to a selected one. This is what makes the argument insensitive to the possible nonuniqueness for the frozen problem. Applying the construction on each side of the interior point gives two distinct solutions. The same argument acaccommodates the weighted sum in (1.1), with different exponents and weights that need not be bounded away from zero.
Suitably constructed subsolutions allow us to formulate the size condition in terms of the total weighted mass M∗=∑i=1Mt∗qi∫Ωμi. A continuous family connects these barriers to a small multiple of the first eigenfunction, for every p>1. Theorem 1.4 further shows that the multiplicity conclusion persists under continuous perturbations of H that are uniformly small on 0≤u≤t∗. The perturbed functional need not preserve order. Order preservation of the reference functional supplies the strict endpoint estimates used in the proof. Example 5.3 gives a perturbation depending on an additional spatial integral and proves that the resulting coefficient cannot be expressed as a function of the reference value H(u) alone.
Definition 1.1. A function u∈W01,p(Ω)∩L∞(Ω) is a (weak) positive solution of (P) if u>0 a.e. in Ω and
m(H(u))∫Ω∣∇u∣p−2∇u⋅∇φdx=∫Ωf(x,u)φdxfor all φ∈W01,p(Ω).
We impose the following assumptions on the weights.
(Hμ) For every i∈{1,…,M}, μi∈L∞(Ω), μi≥0 a.e. in Ω, and there exists at least one i∈{1,…,M} such that μi≡0.
The coefficient satisfies the following condition.
(Hm)m:[0,+∞)→R is continuous and there exist numbers
0≤α1<α2≤α3<α4≤⋯≤α2K−1<α2K,K≥1,
such that
m>0in (α2k−1,α2k),m(α2k−1)=m(α2k)=0
for all k∈{1,…,K}.
The positivity intervals in (Hm) are pairwise disjoint. No sign condition is imposed on m outside them. Every solution furnished by Theorem 1.2 satisfies m(H(u))>0.
We assume the following properties of the reaction.
(Hf) The function f:Ω×R→R is Carathéodory and satisfies the following conditions for some t∗>0.
f(x,t∗)=0 for a.e. x∈Ω.
For every compact interval J⊂(0,t∗),
t∈Jinfx∈Ωessinff(x,t)>0.
(iii) There exists T>0 such that
(x,t)∈Ω×[0,t∗]esssupf(x,t)≤T.
Let λ1 be the first Dirichlet eigenvalue of −Δp, and let e1 be its positive eigenfunction normalized by ∥e1∥∞=1. We require three compatibility conditions.
(Hτ) For each k∈{1,…,K} there exists τk∈(α2k−1,α2k) such that
τkpm(τk)>λ1∣Ω∣(i=1∑Mt∗qi−1∥μi∥p′)pE,
where
E:=(x,t)∈Ω×[0,t∗]esssup[tf(x,t)].
Here p′=p/(p−1), ∥⋅∥p′ denotes the norm in Lp′(Ω), and ∣Ω∣ is the Lebesgue measure of Ω. Assumptions (Hf) and (Hμ) imply 0<E<+∞ and ∥μi∥p′<+∞.
We now state the first main result.
Theorem 1.2. Assume (Hμ), (Hm), (Hf), (Hλ), (HM) and (Hτ). Then problem (P) has at least 2K pairwise distinct positive solutions in C01(Ω). More precisely, for each k∈{1,…,K} there are solutions uk,1 and uk,2 such that 0<uk,j≤t∗ in Ω for j=1,2, and
α2k−1<H(uk,1)<τk<H(uk,2)<α2k.(4)
The ordering in (1.4) concerns the values of H, and does not assert a pointwise ordering of the solutions. The role of the assumptions is as follows. Assumption (Hλ) provides a small positive subsolution θ0e1 of the frozen problem (1.3) for every α in the positivity intervals of m. Assumptions (Hλ), (Hf)(ii) and (HM) provide larger subsolutions for α near the zeros of m. These give the inequality H(u)>α for the fixed points at the outer endpoints of the parameter intervals used in the proof. Assumption (Hτ) yields the reverse inequality H(u)<τk for every solution u of the frozen problem at α=τk with 0≤u≤t∗. No condition on f outside [0,t∗] is used, and the exponents qi are not restricted by a Sobolev critical exponent. Example 5.1 verifies these assumptions for a normalized reaction that is neither nondecreasing nor nonincreasing.
Remark 1.3. For measurable sets Ωi⊂Ω of positive measure, the choice μi=χΩi gives
H(u)=i=1∑M∫Ωi∣u∣qidx=i=1∑M∥u∥qi,Ωiqi.
No regularity, disjointness or covering condition is required of these sets.
The multiplicity conclusion persists for a class of perturbations that need not preserve order. Let X=C01(Ω) and set
D={u∈X:0≤u≤t∗ in Ω}.
Theorem 1.4.Assume the hypotheses of Theorem 1.2. There exists ε0>0 such that, if H:X→[0,∞) is continuous and satisfies
u∈Dsup∣H(u)−H(u)∣≤ε0,(5)
then the problem
⎩⎨⎧−m(H(u))Δpu=f(x,u)u>0u=0in Ω,in Ω,on ∂Ω(6)
has at least 2K pairwise distinct positive solutions uk,j∈X, k∈{1,…,K}, j∈{1,2}, with 0<uk,j≤t∗ in Ω, and
α2k−1<H(uk,1)<τk<H(uk,2)<α2k(k=1,…,K).(7)
Remark 1.5. No order-preserving property is required of H. The smallness assumption controls only the values of the functional on D, not its derivatives or any Lipschitz constant. Although D is not bounded in the C1 norm, the reference values satisfy 0≤H(u)≤M∗ there. No perturbation bound outside D is needed. Order preservation of the reference functional is used to establish the strict endpoint margins, which then persist for the actual functional. In particular, this theorem does not replace the monotonicity of the differential operator −Δp, and it does not claim the same conclusion for arbitrary continuous nonlocal functionals. The conclusion concerns persistence of multiplicity and does not assert continuous dependence of individual solutions on the perturbation. The proof shows that ε0 may be any number in (0,d), where d>0 is the explicit margin defined in (4.3).
Section 2 contains the fixed point lemma and the subsolution construction. Section 3 develops the auxiliary problems and endpoint estimates. Section 4 contains the proofs of Theorems 1.2 and 1.4. Section 5 gives three examples illustrating the main results.
Preliminaries and auxiliary tools
For a measurable set D⊆Ω of positive measure, we use the standard Lebesgue spaces Lr(D) and norms ∥⋅∥r,D. When D=Ω, the subscript D is omitted. The space W01,p(Ω) is endowed with the norm ∥u∥=∥∇u∥p, and its dual is denoted by W−1,p′(Ω). We write s+=max{s,0} and s−=max{−s,0}, and denote the characteristic function of a measurable set D by χD. We also use
C01(Ω)={u∈C1(Ω):u=0 on ∂Ω},∥u∥C1(Ω)=∥u∥∞+∥∇u∥∞.
For ν∈(0,1), the embedding C1,ν(Ω)↪C1(Ω) is compact.
The operator −Δp:W01,p(Ω)→W−1,p′(Ω) is defined by
⟨−Δpu,v⟩=∫Ω∣∇u∣p−2∇u⋅∇vdx.
It is continuous, bounded on bounded sets, coercive and strictly monotone [19]. This operator monotonicity is distinct from the decrease condition on the normalized reaction discussed in the Introduction. The first eigenvalue satisfies
λ1=u∈W01,p(Ω)∖{0}inf∫Ω∣u∣pdx∫Ω∣∇u∣pdx>0.(8)
The corresponding normalized positive eigenfunction satisfies
−Δpe1=λ1e1p−1,e1∈C01(Ω),0<e1≤1 in Ω.
These properties follow from the spectral theory of the Dirichlet p-Laplacian, together with the regularity theory and the strong maximum principle, see [19 Chapters 8 and 9].
We shall repeatedly use the following consequence of the Carathéodory property of f. Suppose that a nonstrict inequality between two functions of (x,t) which are continuous in t holds, for each fixed t in an interval J, for a.e. x∈Ω. Then it holds for every t∈J outside a single null set of x. It suffices to take the union of the exceptional null sets corresponding to a countable dense subset of J and to use continuity in t. If J has nonempty interior, a nonstrict inequality valid almost everywhere on Ω×J has the same property, by Fubini’s theorem and continuity in t. In this way, (Hf)(iii) and the definition of E in (Hτ) give
0≤f(x,t)≤Tfor a.e. x∈Ω and every t∈[0,t∗],(9)
and
tf(x,t)≤Efor a.e. x∈Ω and every t∈[0,t∗],(10)
where the lower bound in (9) follows from (Hf)(ii), applied on a countable exhaustion of (0,t∗) by compact intervals, together with (Hf)(i) and the continuity of f(x,⋅) at t=0. The same argument gives a uniform positive lower bound for f on Ω×J for each compact interval J⊂(0,t∗). All these estimates remain valid when t is replaced by a measurable function with values in the relevant interval.
We use the following form of Schauder’s theorem [19 Theorem 4.7].
Theorem 2.1 (Schauder fixed point theorem). Let X be a Banach space, let C⊂X be nonempty, closed, bounded, and convex, and let K:C→C be continuous and compact, in the sense that K(C) is relatively compact in X. Then K has a fixed point.
Lemma 2.2 (Fixed point principle for a scalar constraint). Let X be a Banach space, let B⊂X be nonempty, closed, bounded and convex, and let Φ:X→R be continuous. Let a<b and let T:[a,b]×B→B be continuous with relatively compact image. Suppose that one of the following two alternatives holds, the implications being required for every u∈B.
(a)
u=T(a,u)⟹Φ(u)>a,u=T(b,u)⟹Φ(u)<b.
(b)
u=T(a,u)⟹Φ(u)<a,u=T(b,u)⟹Φ(u)>b.
Then there exists (α,u)∈(a,b)×B such that
u=T(α,u),α=Φ(u).
Proof. Let Π(s)=min{b,max{a,s}}, and set σ=1 in case (a) and σ=−1 in case (b). Define
K(α,v)=(Π(α+σ[Φ(T(α,v))−α]),T(α,v)).
This is a continuous map from [a,b]×B, a nonempty, closed, bounded and convex subset of the Banach space R×X, into itself. Its image is contained in the compact set [a,b]×T([a,b]×B), so K is a compact map. Theorem 2.1 gives a fixed point (α,u), so that u=T(α,u) and α=Π(α+σ[Φ(u)−α]). At α=a the endpoint assumption gives σ[Φ(u)−a]>0, so the first component of K(a,u) is greater than a. At α=b it gives σ[Φ(u)−b]<0, so the first component is less than b. Both possibilities contradict the fixed point identity. Hence α∈(a,b). Since Π(s)=α with α∈(a,b) forces s=α, the projection identity reduces to
α=α+σ[Φ(u)−α].
Since σ=0, we obtain α=Φ(u).
The next two lemmas provide subsolutions for the frozen problem.
Lemma 2.3. Assume that (Hm), (Hf) and (Hλ) hold, and set
m0:=k∈{1,…,K}maxα∈[α2k−1,α2k]maxm(α).
Then m0>0 and there exist ε1>0 and η0∈(0,t∗) such that
f(x,s)≥(λ1m0+ε1)sp−1>λ1m0sp−1for a.e. x∈Ω and every s∈(0,η0].(11)
Consequently, for every θ0∈(0,η0) and every α∈⋃k=1K[α2k−1,α2k], the function θ0e1 is a subsolution of
−m(α)Δpu=f(x,u),u∈W01,p(Ω),(12)
that is,
m(α)λ1(θ0e1)p−1≤f(x,θ0e1)for a.e. x∈Ω.
Proof. Assumption (Hm) gives m0>0. By (Hλ), there are ε1>0 and η0∈(0,t∗) such that
x∈Ωessinfsp−1f(x,s)>λ1m0+ε1for every s∈(0,η0].
The null set argument recalled at the beginning of this section gives (11). For 0<θ0<η0, the inequalities 0<e1≤1 and m(α)≤m0 then yield
−m(α)Δp(θ0e1)=m(α)λ1(θ0e1)p−1≤f(x,θ0e1)a.e. in Ω.
Lemma 2.4. Assume that (Hm), (Hf) and (Hλ) hold. Let θ∗∈(0,t∗). There exists c0>0 such that
f(x,s)≥λ1c0sp−1for a.e. x∈Ω and every s∈(0,θ∗].(13)
Consequently, if m(α)<c0 and θ∈(0,θ∗], then θe1 is a subsolution of (12).
Proof. Use m0 and η0 from Lemma 2.3. If θ∗≤η0, take c0=m0. Otherwise, (Hf)(ii) applied to J=[η0,θ∗] and the null set argument give ρ∗>0 such that
f(x,s)≥ρ∗≥θ∗p−1ρ∗sp−1for a.e. x∈Ω and every s∈[η0,θ∗].
If m(α)<c0 and 0<θ≤θ∗, substituting s=θe1(x) in (13) gives the subsolution inequality.
Lemma 2.5 (A continuous path of subsolutions). Assume (Hμ), (Hm), (Hf), (Hλ) and (HM). There exist 0<θ0<θ∗<t∗, w∈C01(Ω), and a continuous map [0,1]∋r↦Lr∈C01(Ω) such that
L0=θ0e1,L1=w,0<Lr≤θ∗ in Ω,H(w)>α2K.(14)
The function L0 is a subsolution of (2.5) throughout the positivity intervals of m. There exists c∗>0 such that, for every r∈[0,1], Lr is a subsolution of (2.5) whenever 0<m(α)<c∗.
Proof. By (HM) and the continuity of [0,t∗]∋θ↦H(θ), choose θ∗∈(0,t∗) with H(θ∗)>α2K. Fix an integer n>max{1,1/(p−1)} and put
This is a concave, nondecreasing C1 function, linear with slope (Aδ)−1 on [0,δ], and equal to 1 on [2δ,∞). In particular hδ(0)=0, hδ(1)=1, and s≤hδ(s)≤1 for s∈[0,1]. As e1>0 in Ω, hδ(e1(x))→1 for every x∈Ω as δ→0+. Dominated convergence, applied to the weighted integrals, yields
H(θ∗hδ(e1))⟶H(θ∗)>α2K.
Fix δ so small that w=θ∗hδ(e1) satisfies H(w)>α2K. Only convergence of these integrals is used. Uniform convergence up to the boundary is neither asserted nor needed.
Then e1≤vr≤1 and r↦vr is continuous in C01(Ω). We verify a bound on ar′ uniform in r. This also addresses the singular case 1<p<2. Set B=max{1,(Aδ)−1}. Clearly 0≤ar≤Bp−1. On δ<s<2δ,
hδ′(s)=Aδ(2−s/δ)n,hδ′′(s)=−Aδ2n(2−s/δ)n−1.
For p≥2 it follows that ∣ar′∣≤(p−1)Bp−2n/(Aδ2). If 1<p<2 and r>0, the negative exponent p−2 and 1−r+rhδ′≥rhδ′ give
For r=0 the derivative vanishes, as it does outside the transition interval. Since n(p−1)>1, ar is Lipschitz across both joining points, also for r=1. Thus ar′≤0 and ∣ar′∣≤D, uniformly, where
D={(p−1)Bp−2n/(Aδ2),(p−1)n/(Ap−1δp),p≥2,1<p<2.
Testing the weak eigenfunction equation with ar(e1)φ gives
−Δpvr=λ1ar(e1)e1p−1−ar′(e1)∣∇e1∣p
in the weak sense. {#eq:2.8}
Indeed, ∇vr=ψr′(e1)∇e1, and the product test is admissible since ar is Lipschitz and e1∈C1(Ω). The chain rule is understood a.e. The values of ar′ at joining points are immaterial since ∇e1=0 a.e. on each corresponding level set. No second derivatives of e1 are required. On {e1≤δ}, vr is a constant multiple of e1, so the right-hand side is λ1vrp−1. On {e1>δ}, vr≥e1>δ. Consequently,
Choose 0<θ0<min{θ∗,η0}, with η0 from Lemma 2.3, and set
Lr=((1−r)θ0+rθ∗)vr.
By homogeneity, (15) holds also with Lr in place of vr. Lemma 2.4 gives f(x,s)≥λ1c0sp−1 for 0<s≤θ∗. Hence the choice
c∗=Cδλ1c0>0(16)
ensures −m(α)ΔpLr≤f(x,Lr) whenever 0<m(α)<c∗. The remaining assertions follow from the construction and Lemma 2.3.
Auxiliary problems and endpoint estimates
Throughout this section the assumptions of Theorem 1.2 are in force. We first record the properties of the functional H defined in (1.1).
Lemma 3.1. Under (Hμ), the following properties hold.
(a) H is continuous on C(Ω), in particular on C01(Ω).
(b) H preserves order on nonnegative functions, in the sense that 0≤v≤u a.e. in Ω implies H(v)≤H(u).
:::`
Proof. (a) Let un→u in C(Ω) and set c:=supn∥un∥∞+∥u∥∞<+∞. Since qi≥1, the function t↦∣t∣qi is Lipschitz on [−c,c], say with constant Li, whence
∣H(un)−H(u)∣≤i=1∑MLi∥μi∥∞∣Ω∣∥un−u∥∞⟶0.
(b) Immediate from μi≥0 a.e. in Ω and the monotonicity of t↦tqi on [0,+∞).
Fix θ0, θ∗, w, c∗ and the family Lr given by Lemma 2.5. In particular,
H(w)>α2K.(17)
We next arrange these barriers continuously along each parameter interval.
Lemma 3.2. For each k∈{1,…,K} there exist
βk∈(α2k−1,τk),γk∈(τk,α2k)(18)
and continuous maps ℓk−:[βk,τk]→C01(Ω), ℓk+:[τk,γk]→C01(Ω) such that 0<ℓk±(α)≤θ∗<t∗ in Ω and
−m(α)Δpℓk±(α)≤f(x,ℓk±(α))in the weak sense.(19)
and put ℓk±(α)=Lrk±(α). On the outer strips, (3.5) and Lemma 2.5 give the subsolution inequality for all values of r. On the remaining parts, rk±=0, so ℓk±=θ0e1, which is a subsolution throughout the positivity intervals by Lemma 2.3. Continuity and the endpoint values follow directly. For the illustration below, write the amplitude factors as
θk±(α)=(1−rk±(α))θ0+rk±(α)θ∗.(22)
Thus ℓk±(α)=θk±(α)ψrk±(α)(e1). Both the amplitude and the spatial profile vary on the outer strips.
Figure 1. Construction of the parameter-dependent barriers in Lemma 3.2. The upper panel shows a schematic positivity interval of m. The lower panel shows the amplitude factors θk− and θk+. The spatial profile also varies through ψρk±(e1). No unimodality assumption on m is used.
From now on we fix, for every k∈{1,…,K}, a choice of βk, γk and of the barrier functions ℓk± provided by Lemma 3.2. Let I be one of the two intervals
Ik−:=[βk,τk],Ik+:=[τk,γk],
and let ℓI(α) denote the corresponding lower barrier, namely
Remark 3.3. For every (α,s)∈I×R the function fI(α,⋅,s) is measurable, and for almost every x∈Ω the function fI(⋅,x,⋅) is continuous on I×R. Indeed, α↦ℓI(α) is continuous with values in C1(Ω), and the pieces in (3.7) agree at both joining points, at s=t∗ because of (Hf)(i). Moreover, (2.2) gives
0≤fI(α,x,s)≤Tfor a.e. x∈Ω and every (α,s)∈I×R.(24)
Lemma 3.4. Fix k∈{1,…,K} and let I∈{Ik−,Ik+}. For every (α,v)∈I×C01(Ω), the problem
{−m(α)Δpz=fI(α,x,v(x))z=0in Ω,on ∂Ω(25)
has a unique weak solution z, and z≥0 a.e. in Ω. We denote it by
TI(α,v):=z.
Moreover, TI:I×C01(Ω)→C01(Ω) is continuous, and TI(I×C01(Ω)) is a relatively compact subset of C01(Ω).
Proof. The interval I is a compact subset of a positivity interval of m, so
mI:=α∈Iminm(α)>0.(26)
For fixed (α,v) the right-hand side of (25) is a prescribed function in L∞(Ω), bounded between 0 and T by (24). The theorem of Minty and Browder therefore gives a unique weak solution z. Testing with −z− gives
m(α)∫Ω∣∇z−∣pdx=−∫ΩfI(α,x,v)z−dx≤0,
and hence z≥0.
Next, let w0∈W01,p(Ω)∩L∞(Ω) be the solution of −Δpw0=1 in Ω. Since
the weak comparison principle gives 0≤z≤(T/mI)1/(p−1)w0, a bound in L∞(Ω) independent of (α,v). The global C1,ν regularity estimate for bounded data [18] therefore gives ν∈(0,1) and CI>0, independent of (α,v), such that
∥TI(α,v)∥C1,ν(Ω)≤CI.(27)
The compact embedding into C1(Ω) proves relative compactness of the image.
To prove continuity, let (αn,vn)→(α,v) in I×C01(Ω) and set zn=TI(αn,vn). Every subsequence has a further subsequence converging in C01(Ω) to some z. By Remark 3.3 and dominated convergence,
fI(αn,x,vn(x))⟶fI(α,x,v(x))in Lp′(Ω).
Passing to the limit in the weak formulation shows that z=TI(α,v) by uniqueness for the prescribed right-hand side. Every convergent subsequence has this same limit, so the full sequence converges in C01(Ω).
Uniqueness in the above lemma concerns the problem with the given input v. It does not assert uniqueness of fixed points of TI(α,⋅).
Lemma 3.5. Fix k∈{1,…,K}, let I∈{Ik−,Ik+} and let (α,u)∈I×C01(Ω) be such that
u=TI(α,u).
Then
ℓI(α)≤u≤t∗a.e. in Ω.(28)
Consequently, u solves the untruncated frozen problem
−m(α)Δpu=f(x,u),u∈W01,p(Ω).(29)
Proof. Write ℓ=ℓI(α). Since u=TI(α,u),
m(α)∫Ω∣∇u∣p−2∇u⋅∇φdx=∫ΩfI(α,x,u)φdxfor every φ∈W01,p(Ω).(30)
Take φ=(ℓ−u)+. On the set {u<ℓ}, where φ may be nonzero, the truncated reaction equals f(x,ℓ). Subtracting (3.14) from the weak form of the subsolution inequality (3.3) for ℓ, both tested with φ, yields
m(α)∫Ω(∣∇ℓ∣p−2∇ℓ−∣∇u∣p−2∇u)⋅∇(ℓ−u)+dx≤0.
The integrand is nonnegative by the monotonicity of ξ↦∣ξ∣p−2ξ, and since m(α)>0 it vanishes a.e. in Ω. By strict monotonicity, ∇ℓ=∇u a.e. on {u<ℓ}, that is, ∇(ℓ−u)+=0 a.e. in Ω. Poincaré’s inequality gives (ℓ−u)+=0, and hence u≥ℓ.
Next take φ=(u−t∗)+, which belongs to W01,p(Ω). The truncated reaction vanishes on {u>t∗}, so
m(α)∫Ω∣∇(u−t∗)+∣pdx=0.
Poincaré’s inequality now gives u≤t∗. The truncation therefore agrees with f(x,u) a.e., proving (3.13).
Lemma 3.6. Fix k∈{1,…,K}. Every weak solution u∈W01,p(Ω) of
The last inequality is (Hτ) in equivalent form. □
Proofs of the main results
Proof of Theorem 1.2. Set X=C01(Ω). The uniform bounds in (27) and the finiteness of the family of intervals Ik± give R>0 such that each TIk± maps Ik±×BR into BR={v∈X:∥v∥C1(Ω)≤R}. By Lemmas 3.1 and 3.4, Φ=H is continuous and these solution operators are continuous and compact. Thus the functional and operator assumptions of Lemma 2.2 hold.
Fix k. If u=TIk−(βk,u) or u=TIk+(γk,u), then Lemma 3.5 and (20) give u≥w. Since H preserves order on nonnegative functions,
H(u)≥H(w)>α2K≥α2k>γk>βk.(34)
At the common endpoint τk, every fixed point of either operator solves (31) and lies between 0 and t∗ by Lemma 3.5. Lemma 3.6 therefore gives
H(u)<τk.
These estimates hold for every fixed point at the respective endpoints, as required in Lemma 2.2.
Apply Lemma 2.2(a) on [βk,τk] and part (b) on [τk,γk]. We obtain pairs (ak,1,uk,1) and (ak,2,uk,2) with
Substituting ak,j=H(uk,j) proves that these are positive solutions of (P). They belong to C01(Ω) by construction. Since α2k−1<βk and γk<α2k by (3.2), this gives (1.4). Distinct nonlocal values separate the two solutions in each pair, and the disjoint positivity intervals of m separate the pairs. Hence all 2K solutions are distinct.
Proof of Theorem 1.4. Fix the function w given by Lemma 2.5 and the intervals Ik−=[βk,τk] and Ik+=[τk,γk], where βk and γk are chosen as in Lemma 3.2. Define
Positivity follows from (3.1) and (Hτ). Any choice of ε0∈(0,d) gives a sufficient perturbation tolerance.
Fix a continuous functional H:X→[0,∞) satisfying (1.5). Use the barriers ℓk± and operators TIk± constructed in Section 3. Their construction uses f, m and the fixed barriers, and does not require the functional appearing in the scalar constraint to preserve order. Choose the same ball BR⊂X as in the proof of Theorem 1.2. Lemma 3.4 gives continuous compact maps Ik±×BR→BR. We apply Lemma 2.2 with Φ=H.
Every fixed point lies in D by Lemma 3.5. At either outer endpoint, (3.4) gives u≥w. The reference functional H preserves order, so
H(u)≥H(u)−ε0≥H(w)−ε0≥α2K+d−ε0>α2K>γk>βk.
At the common endpoint τk, the fixed point solves the untruncated frozen equation. The estimate (3.17) gives H(u)≤Rk, and hence
H(u)≤Rk+ε0≤τk−d+ε0<τk.
Both estimates hold for all fixed points at the corresponding endpoints. Lemma 2.2(a) on Ik− and part (b) on Ik+ therefore provide points (ak,j,uk,j) satisfying
uk,j=TIk±(ak,j,uk,j),ak,j=H(uk,j),
βk<ak,1<τk<ak,2<γk.
By Lemma 3.5, substitution of this scalar identity into the frozen equation gives (1.6). Positivity follows from the lower barrier, and regularity follows from the definition of TI. The disjoint intervals containing the values of H give (1.7) and separate all 2K solutions.
Examples
Example 5.1. Let N=2, p=3, t∗>1 and Ω=B(x0,3). Choose x2∈B(x0,2), set Ω1=B(x0,1) and Ω2=B(x2,1) (so that Ω2⊂Ω), and define
μ1=χΩ1,μ2=2χΩ2.
These weights satisfy (Hμ). The two regions may overlap, and their union does not cover Ω.
Fix any q1,q2≥1. Since ∣Ω1∣=∣Ω2∣=π and t∗>1,
M∗=πt∗q1+2πt∗q2>3π>23.
Thus (HM) holds for the coefficient m defined in (5.1) below, for which K=1 and α2K=α2=3/2.
We consider the autonomous Carathéodory reaction f(x,t)=f(t), where
f(t)=λ1(t∗−t)2(1+43sint∗4πt),t∈R.
Since
1+43sint∗4πt≥41for all t∈R,
we have f(t)≥0 for all t∈R. Moreover, f(t∗)=0. If J⋐(0,t∗), then inft∈Jf(t)>0, and
Therefore (Hλ) holds for every continuous coefficient m satisfying (Hm), in particular for the one defined in (5.1) below.
Let us also observe that the quotient t↦f(t)/tp−1 is not monotone on (0,t∗). Indeed, for t∈(0,t∗) set
Q(t):=t2f(t)=λ1t2(t∗−t)2(1+43sint∗4πt).
Since Q(t)→+∞ as t→0+, Q is not nondecreasing. On the other hand, writing Q=λ1hg with h(t)=t2(t∗−t)2 and g(t)=1+43sint∗4πt, we have h(t∗/2)=g(t∗/2)=1, h′(t∗/2)=−8/t∗ and g′(t∗/2)=3π/t∗, whence
Q′(2t∗)=λ1(h′g+hg′)(2t∗)=t∗λ1(3π−8)>0.
Thus Q is not nonincreasing either. This reaction violates the decrease condition used for the multiplicity results in [4, 15, 16, 17].
Let α1=1<α2=23 and define
m(s)=As(s−1)(23−s),s≥0,(37)
where
A>187528672π3t∗3(t∗q1−1+2t∗q2−1)3.(38)
Then m>0 in (1,3/2) and m(1)=m(3/2)=0, hence (Hm) holds with K=1.
It remains to verify (Hτ). Since K=1, we choose τ1=5/4 and write τ:=τ1 for brevity. By (5.1) and (5.2),
Combining this estimate with (5.3), we obtain (Hτ).
All assumptions of Theorem 1.2 are now verified. Problem (P), with the weights, reaction and coefficient specified above, therefore has two positive solutions u1,u2∈C01(Ω) satisfying
The normalized reaction is nonmonotone, so the cited multiplicity theorems requiring a decreasing quotient do not apply to these data.
Example 5.2 (Explicit data for a quadratic coefficient). Let p=3, M=1, q1=1, μ1=1, and t∗>0, on any bounded smooth domain as above. Then H(u)=∫Ω∣u∣dx, M∗=t∗∣Ω∣. Set b=M∗/2, a=b/2, τ=3b/4, and define
f(x,t)=(t∗−t)2(t∈R),m(s)=A0(s−a)(b−s)(s≥0).
The reaction satisfies (Hf), with T=t∗2, and f(x,t)/t2→+∞ as t→0+, so (Hλ) holds for every finite A0>0. The coefficient satisfies (Hm) with K=1, α1=a and α2=b. Since b<M∗, (HM) also holds. Moreover,
E=0≤t≤t∗maxt(t∗−t)2=274t∗3,∥μ1∥3/2=∣Ω∣2/3.
Consequently (Hτ) holds whenever
A0>27λ1τ3(τ−a)(b−τ)4∣Ω∣t∗3.(40)
For every such A0, Theorem 1.2 gives two positive solutions u1,u2 with
a<H(u1)<τ<H(u2)<b.
These data will also be used in Example 5.3.
Example 5.3 (A perturbation depending on an additional spatial integral). This example illustrates Theorem 1.4 through a perturbation involving an additional spatial integral. We verify that order preservation may fail and show that in general the effect of the perturbation cannot be reproduced by changing m while keeping H unchanged.
Use the data from Example 5.2, with A0 satisfying (40), and let d>0 be the margin defined in (36) in the proof of Theorem 1.4. Let U⊆Ω be any measurable set with ∣U∣>0, and put
J(u)=∫U∣u∣dx,0<η<min{1/5,d/M∗}.
For ω>0 define
Hη,ω(u)=H(u)[1+ηsin(ωJ(u))],u∈X.(41)
This functional is continuous and nonnegative on X. For u∈D,
∣Hη,ω(u)−H(u)∣≤ηH(u)≤ηM∗<d.
The proof of Theorem 1.4 allows any ε0∈(0,d). Choosing ε0∈(ηM∗,d) therefore gives two positive solutions for every ω>0.
We now choose ω so that the functional fails to preserve order. Set s0=5b/8=5M∗/16 and choose v0∈X such that
0<v0<t∗in Ω,H(v0)=s0.
Such a choice is possible since s0<M∗, by approximating the constant t∗ from below with positive functions in X and rescaling. Since ∣U∣>0 and v0>0 in Ω,
ρ=s0J(v0)∈(0,1].
Choose an integer j≥1 such that η(2j−1)π>1, and set
ω=2ρs0(4j+1)π,s1=ωρ(2j−1)π∈(0,s0).
Along the ordered family us=(s/s0)v0, 0<s<s0, we have H(us)=s, J(us)=ρs and us∈D. Consequently, for G(s)=s[1+ηsin(ωρs)],
Hη,ω(us)=G(s),G′(s1)=1−η(2j−1)π<0.
There are therefore s−<s+ near s1 with us−≤us+ but
Hη,ω(us−)>Hη,ω(us+).
In particular, this functional cannot be a sum of integral powers with non-negative weights, since every functional of that form preserves order on non-negative functions.
To rule out absorption of the perturbation into m, assume in addition that ∣U∣<∣Ω∣. Choose h∈C∞(Ω) such that
∫Ωhdx=0,∫Uhdx=1.
Such an h exists because the two integration functionals are linearly independent on C∞(Ω). Otherwise the characteristic function of U would be constant a.e. in Ω, contrary to 0<∣U∣<∣Ω∣. For sufficiently small ε>0, the function vε=v0+εh belongs to X and satisfies 0<vε<t∗ in Ω. Moreover,
H(vε)=H(v0)=s0,J(vε)=J(v0)+ε.
Since ωJ(v0)=(4j+1)π/2, choosing also 0<ωε<π/2 gives
Hη,ω(vε)=s0[1+ηcos(ωε)]<s0(1+η)=Hη,ω(v0).
As η<1/5, both values belong to (a,τ), since
a<s0<Hη,ω(vε)<Hη,ω(v0)=s0(1+η)<τ=(a+b)/2.
The coefficient m(s)=A0(s−a)(b−s) is strictly increasing on (a,τ). Hence both coefficient values are positive and
m(Hη,ω(vε))<m(Hη,ω(v0)).
As the reference values are equal, no function m:[0,∞)→R can satisfy
m(Hη,ω(u))=m(H(u))for every u∈D.
The obstruction already occurs for strictly positive functions in D, since both v0 and vε are positive in Ω.
If ∣U∣=∣Ω∣, then J=H, and the perturbation can be absorbed into m by setting
m(s)=m(s[1+ηsin(ωs)]),s≥0.
Acknowledgements
The first author is a member of the Gruppo Nazionale per l’Analisi Matematica, la Probabilità e le loro Applicazioni (GNAMPA) of the Istituto Nazionale di Alta Matematica (INdAM). This work was partially supported by the INdAM GNAMPA Project with CUP E5324001950001.
Conflict of interest
The authors declare that they have no conflict of interest.
References
[1]C. O. Alves, D.-P. Covei, Existence of solution for a class of nonlocal elliptic problem via sub–supersolution method, Nonlinear Anal. Real World Appl. 23 (2015), 1–8. 10.1016/j.nonrwa.2014.11.003arxiv.org/abs/1306.1211
[2]H. Brézis, L. Oswald, Remarks on sublinear elliptic equations, Nonlinear Anal. 10 (1986), no. 1, 55–64. 10.1016/0362-546X(86)90011-8DOI
[3]P. Candito, G. Failla, R. Livrea, Pairs of positive solutions for a Carrier p(x)-Laplacian type equation, Mathematics 12 (2024), no. 16, Paper No. 2441. 10.3390/math12162441DOI
[4]P. Candito, L. Gasiński, R. Livrea, J. R. Santos Júnior, Multiplicity of positive solutions for a degenerate nonlocal problem with p-Laplacian, Adv. Nonlinear Anal. 11 (2022), no. 1, 357–368. 10.1515/anona-2021-0200DOI
[5]S. Carillo, M. Chipot, On some nonlocal in time and space parabolic problem, Appl. Numer. Math. 208 (2025), 314–322. 10.1016/j.apnum.2024.11.001DOI
[6]G. F. Carrier, A note on the vibrating string, Quart. Appl. Math. 7 (1949), 97–101. 10.1090/qam/28511DOI
[7]G. F. Carrier, On the non-linear vibration problem of the elastic string, Quart. Appl. Math. 3 (1945), 157–165. 10.1090/qam/12351DOI
[8]M. Chipot, B. Lovat, Some remarks on nonlocal elliptic and parabolic problems, Nonlinear Anal. 30 (1997), no. 7, 4619–4627. 10.1016/S0362-546X(97)00169-7DOI
[9]M. Chipot, J. F. Rodrigues, On a class of nonlocal nonlinear elliptic problems, RAIRO Modél. Math. Anal. Numér. 26 (1992), no. 3, 447–467. 10.1051/m2an/1992260304471DOI
[10]Á. Crespo-Blanco, G. Failla, B. Vassallo, Multiple solutions for a nonlocal Neumann p-Laplacian problem, Nonlinear Anal. Real World Appl. 87 (2026), Paper No. 104449. 10.1016/j.nonrwa.2025.104449
[11]M. Delgado, C. Morales-Rodrigo, J. R. Santos Júnior, A. Suárez, Non-local degenerate diffusion coefficients break down the components of positive solutions, Adv. Nonlinear Stud. 20 (2020), no. 1, 19–30. 10.1515/ans-2019-2046DOI
[12]J. I. Díaz, J. E. Saa, Existence et unicité de solutions positives pour certaines équations elliptiques quasilinéaires, C. R. Acad. Sci. Paris Sér. I Math. 305 (1987), no. 12, 521–524.
[13]G. Failla, L. Gasiński, Nonlocal Carrier’s double phase problem, Proc. Roy. Soc. Edinburgh Sect. A, Published online, 1–24 (2025). 10.1017/prm.2025.10099DOI
[14]G. M. Figueiredo, T. S. Figueiredo-Sousa, C. Morales-Rodrigo, A. Suárez, Existence of positive solutions of an elliptic equation with local and nonlocal variable diffusion coefficient, Discrete Contin. Dyn. Syst. Ser. B 24 (2019), no. 8, 3689–3711. 10.3934/dcdsb.2018311DOI
[15]L. Gasiński, J. R. Santos Júnior, Multiplicity of positive solutions for an equation with degenerate nonlocal diffusion, Comput. Math. Appl. 78 (2019), no. 1, 136–143. 10.1016/j.camwa.2019.02.029arxiv.org/abs/1807.01900
[16]L. Gasiński, J. R. Santos Júnior, Nonexistence and multiplicity of positive solutions for an equation with degenerate nonlocal diffusion, Bull. Lond. Math. Soc. 52 (2020), no. 3, 489–497. 10.1112/blms.12342DOI
[17]L. Gasiński, J. R. Santos Júnior, G. Siciliano, Positive solutions for a class of nonlocal problems with possibly singular nonlinearity, J. Fixed Point Theory Appl. 24 (2022), no. 3, Paper No. 65, 15 pp. 10.1007/s11784-022-00982-5arxiv.org/abs/2006.13674
[18]G. M. Lieberman, Boundary regularity for solutions of degenerate elliptic equations, Nonlinear Anal. 12 (1988), no. 11, 1203–1219. 10.1016/0362-546X(88)90053-3DOI
[19]D. Motreanu, V. V. Motreanu, N. S. Papageorgiou, Topological and variational methods with applications to nonlinear boundary value problems. Springer, New York, 2014. 10.1007/978-1-4614-9323-5DOI