betaFeedback

WorksMathematics

Initial Data Gluing for Asymptotically Hyperbolic Spacetimes

Abstract

We give a new proof of Corvino-Schoen-type gluing, also known as gluing up to linear obstructions, for asymptotically hyperbolic spacetimes satisfying appropriate smallness conditions in arbitrary dimension. The results retrieve and improve on previous known smallness requirements on initial data to conduct such gluing, including the work of Chrusciél and Delay. Our technique is highly versatile and well-suited for gluing results in highly anisotropic geometric settings.

Introduction

In classical general relativity, one of the most important problems is to understand the flexibility and limitations of solution to the Einstein Constraint equations

{R(g)+(tr⁡gK)2−∣K∣g2=2Λ∇giKij−∇jtr⁡gK=0.(1)\begin{cases} R(g) + (\operatorname{tr}_{g} K)^2 - \lvert K\rvert_{g}^{2} = 2\Lambda\\ \nabla_{g}^{i} K_{ij} - \nabla_{j} \operatorname{tr}_{g} K = 0. \tag*{(1)} \end{cases}

More precisely, a natural question to ask is in what way such a solution can be deformed on a compact or localized region while preserving the geometry elsewhere. One approach to this question is on initial data gluing, which prescribes two initial data sets solving (1) in disjoint regions and asks whether one can prescribe a global solution which interpolates between the two. One such approach is the celebrated Corvino-Schoen-type gluing, pioneered in [12] and later refined in [14]. Schematically, the approach reduces solving (1) to a linear problem of the form Pu=fP u = f, where PP is the linearized Einstein constraint operator containing the linearized scalar curvature and momentum constraint equations. If PP is surjective, or equivalently if P∗P^* has empty cokernel, one can construct a right-inverse directly. However, in general this is not the case, and the approach instead constructs a right-inverse up to a finite dimensional cokernel.

Since this seminal work, several gluing results have appeared in the literature. For the asymptotically flat case, i.e. Λ=0\Lambda= 0, we direct the interested reader to the excellent review articles [2; 11]. Some select work includes gluing an asymptotically flat initial data set to the exterior of initial data for Kerr as in [6; 7], gluing an interior region to an exterior region without changing each prescribed piece as in [1; 4], and more recently the microlocal techniques of [16; 17; 18]. In the hyperbolic setting Λ=−d(d−1)/2\Lambda= -d(d - 1)/2, the first main application of Corvino-Schoen-type gluing can be found in [8]. In this paper, they consider an annulus of fixed radial size

Aδ,4δ={1−8δ≤R≤1−2δ}A_{\delta,4\delta} = \left\{\sqrt{1-8\delta} \le R \le\sqrt{1-2\delta}\right\}

with coordinate RR on the Poincaré Ball. Instead of inverting the operator directly, they study a fourth-order operator of the form P∗(ρPu)=fP^*(\rho P u) = f, where ρ\rho is a suitable weight-function decaying at infinity, and obtain estimates in weighted Sobolev spaces. Quantitatively, for dimension dd they obtain a solution operator bound for the Hamiltonian constraint equations of O(δ−4)O(\delta^{-4}), which when running a fixed point argument corresponds to requiring a smallness bound on the order of min⁡{δ8,δ(8+d)/2}\min\{\delta^8,\delta^{(8+d)/2}\} to close their estimates. Since then, [10] demonstrated the importance of understanding the finite dimensional obstruction space using charges, and [9] describe a Carlotto-Schoen type gluing approach as in [3] that is localized to a particular angular sector.

More recently, the authors of [20; 21] developed an approach in the asymptotically flat case that allows for the construction of a Bogovskii-type operator as a direct right inverse up to cokernel with desired regularity and support properties. Their general theory and framework were presented with examples for a much broader class of equations in [19] with more forthcoming. This powerful method was observed by [5], and they present a short note explaining that the Bogovskii-type operator construction is not unique to the asymptotically flat setting, but also holds in the asymptotically hyperbolic one, providing qualitative statements on initial data gluing for asymptotically hyperbolic spacetimes using the Bogovskii-type solution operator construction.

Inspired by the previous results, we apply the support preserving Bogovskii-type operator approach outlined in [20] and [19] to the problem of initial data gluing for asymptotically hyperbolic initial data (gin,kin)(g_{\mathrm{in}}, k_{\mathrm{in}}) and (gout,kout)(g_{\mathrm{out}}, k_{\mathrm{out}}) separated by a thin annular region

A2/δ={log⁡(2/δ)≤r≤log⁡(8/δ)},A_{2/\delta} = \left\{\log(2/\delta) \le r \le\log(8/\delta)\right\},

which is the hyperboloidal analogue of [8]. Our work demonstrates that this approach provides more than an alternative proof of initial data gluing; it yields a stronger analytic framework than the existing literature. Quantitatively, we provide sharper smallness assumptions on initial data by two orders of magnitude, obtaining a solution operator bound of O(δ−2)O(\delta^{-2}) for the Hamiltonian constraint and O(δ−4)O(\delta^{-4}) for the Momentum constraint. Consequently, we require a bound of δ6ε\delta^6\varepsilon for the Hamiltonian constraint equation and δ7ε\delta^7\varepsilon for the Momentum constraint equation, where ε=εc\varepsilon= \varepsilon_c. This appears to be essentially optimal without additional regularity assumptions on the nonlinear corrections. Moreover, the approach works in highly anisotropic settings, constructing solution operators at two different scales. For a more detailed statement of the main result, see § 3. The ability for this approach to handle anisotropic directions suggests that other types of gluing, such as Czimek-Rodnianski-type gluing of [15] and localized bump constructions, are permissible with related suitable smallness assumptions.

Acknowledgements

Acknowledgements. I thank my advisor, Sung-Jin Oh, for introducing me to this problem and taking on a consultant role throughout this project. His guidance, ideas, contributions, and words of encouragement for this project have been essential. I would also like to thank the authors of [13] and [8] for providing an excellent framework and a launching point of this project, and to Ning Tang and Zhongkai Tao for helpful discussions. This research was supported NSF through DMS-1945615, DMS2452760, the Miller Research Professorship, and through NSF GRFP grant DGE-2146752.

Conflict of Interest The authors declares that they have no conflict of interest.

Data Availability and AI Statement No datasets were created or analyzed during the present work, so data sharing is not relevant to this article. All ideas presented are either my own or from helpful discussions with my advisor. All of the writing, the figure, and the arguments in this paper are my own. Claude Opus 5.5 was used at the very end of this project exclusively for proofreading in three places: the frequency based estimate Lemma 3.9, the δ\delta-power numerology in Steps 4 and 5, and remark on comparison with [8].

Preliminaries

In this section, we make several definitions, some of which are analogous to those in [8], and recall some important propositions of [19].

Throughout our many different choices of coordinates, our hyperbolic base space will be the dd-dimensional manifold M=(r0,∞)×NM=(r_0,\infty)\times N, for some compact manifold NN. For our purposes NN can be taken to be the sphere Sd−1\mathbb{S}^{d-1}, and in practice our sets will be generalized annuli with this setting in mind. This manifold represents the spatial directions, and time will be considered separately.

Hyperbolic Metrics

Definition 2.1 ([8]). The Kottler Metric bb is defined as

b:=dr2r2+κ+r2b^(2)b := \frac{d r^2}{r^2+\kappa}+r^2\widehat{b} \tag*{(2)}

where κ∈{0,±1}\kappa\in\{0,\pm1\} and b^\widehat{b} is a metric on NN that satisfies Ric⁡(b^)=κ(d−2)b^\operatorname{Ric}(\widehat{b})=\kappa(d-2)\widehat{b}.

Note that in the hyperbolic setting, the sectional curvature κ\kappa is −1-1, and b^\widehat{b} is the round metric on the unit sphere Sd−1=N\mathbb{S}^{d-1}=N.

For our purposes, it will be convenient to rewrite this metric in coordinates reflecting the compactification M‾\overline{M} for a suitable boundary-defining function ρ\rho which vanishes on ∂M\partial M with dρd\rho nonvanishing there.

In this coordinate system, our metric reads

b:=ρ−2(dρ2+(4−κρ2)216b^)(3)b := \rho^{-2}\left(d\rho^2+\frac{(4-\kappa\rho^2)^2}{16}\widehat{b}\right) \tag*{(3)}

We can then define the conformal compactification

b‾:=ρ2b.\overline{b}:=\rho^2b.

Definition 2.2 ([8]). The metric bb is part of a larger class of metrics called generalized Kottler metrics defined as

bm=ρ−2([1−2mρn(1−κ(ρ2)2)2−n(1+κ(ρ2)2)−2]−1dρ2+(1−κ(ρ2)2)2b^)(4)b_m=\rho^{-2}\left(\left[1-2m\rho^n\left(1-\kappa\left(\frac{\rho}{2}\right)^2\right)^{2-n}\left(1+\kappa\left(\frac{\rho}{2}\right)^2\right)^{-2}\right]^{-1}d\rho^2+\left(1-\kappa\left(\frac{\rho}{2}\right)^2\right)^2\widehat{b}\right) \tag*{(4)}

We will assume that we are in the asymptotically “time-symmetric case,” namely that the second fundamental form kk tends to 00 at infinity.

Note that we will work with the standard hyperbolic metric, which on the Poincaré ball reads

b=ω−2δ(5)b=\omega^{-2}\delta \tag*{(5)}

where δ\delta is the Euclidean metric on Rd\mathbb{R}^d and the conformal factor ω(x)=12(1−∣x∣2)\omega(x)=\frac{1}{2}(1-|x|^2).

Remark 2.3. As remarked in [8], for generalized Kottler metrics bmb_m we can only hope for a one-dimensional cokernel of the linearized scalar curvature with parameter given by the mass mm. In the standard hyperbolic metric setting, the complete SO⁡(d,1)\operatorname{SO}(d,1) symmetry gives us a full cokernel of dimension (d+1)(d+2)/2(d+1)(d+2)/2. This is related to the notion of complete integrability, discussed in [19]; in particular, the lack of a full dimensional cokernel means one could run precisely the same gluing argument as we will outline in § 3, but the cost is that the solution operator bounds one obtains will be ineffective. This means that by repeating the proof of Theorem 3.1 for bmb_m but using Theorem 5.21 in [19] instead, one obtains a linear operator RR such that

P(S−R)f=f−wA⟨ZA,f⟩P(S-R)f=f-w_A\langle Z^A,f\rangle

for ZAZ^A the cokernel element corresponding to the mass and wA∈C∞(A2/δ)w_A\in C^\infty(A_{2/\delta}) and an identical gluing result holds, with no quantitative information on the necessary smallness assumptions.

Since we are in the hyperbolic setting, the Hamiltonian and Momentum constraint equations read

{R(g)+(tr⁡gk)2−∣k∣g2=2Λ,div⁡(k−(tr⁡g(k)g))=0(6)\begin{cases} R(g)+(\operatorname{tr}_g k)^2-\lvert k\rvert_g^2=2\Lambda,\\ \operatorname{div}(k-(\operatorname{tr}_g(k)g))=0 \tag*{(6)} \end{cases}

Here we take the cosmological constant Λ=−d(d−1)2\Lambda=-\frac{d(d-1)}{2}, so that if k=0k=0 we have that Ric⁡(g)=−(d−1)\operatorname{Ric}(g)=-(d-1) and R(g)=−d(d−1)R(g)=-d(d-1).

From [8], we read off the linearized scalar curvature and its adjoint as

PRh:=DR∣b[h]=−Δb(tr⁡bh)+div⁡b(div⁡bh)+(d−1)tr⁡bh(7)P_Rh:=DR|_b[h]=-\Delta_b(\operatorname{tr}_b h)+\operatorname{div}_b(\operatorname{div}_b h)+(d-1)\operatorname{tr}_b h \tag*{(7)}

and

PR∗f:=DR∗∣b[f]=−Δbfb+∇b∇bf+(d−1)fb(8)P_R^*f:=DR^*|_b[f]=-\Delta_b f b+\nabla_b\nabla_b f+(d-1)f b \tag*{(8)}

It will be important to introduce Schematic notation to reduce clutter and not have to consider terms explicitly:

Definition 2.4 (Definition 2.1 in [20]). We let Mσ(∗)(u1,…,uk)M_\sigma^{(*)}(u_1,\ldots,u_k) and Nσ(∗)(u1,…,uk)N_\sigma^{(*)}(u_1,\ldots,u_k) denote error terms given by linear combinations of contractions of {ui}\{u_i\} with a smooth tensor field A(σ)A(\sigma) depending only on σ\sigma to produce a scalar. Here, the superscript refers to an index used to identify the terms. Moreover for some fixed M>0M>0, we assume that if ∣σ∣≤M\lvert\sigma\rvert\le M, then for all n∈Nn\in\mathbb{N} we have ∣∂σ(n)A(σ)∣≲M,n1\lvert\partial_\sigma^{(n)}A(\sigma)\rvert\lesssim_{M,n}1.

Using Definition 2.4 and the substitutions

σij=gij−bij−bijtr⁡b(g−b);πij=kij−bijtr⁡bk,\sigma_{ij}=g_{ij}-b_{ij}-b_{ij}\operatorname{tr}_b(g-b);\qquad\pi_{ij}=k_{ij}-b_{ij}\operatorname{tr}_b k,

one can show that the equations reduce to

{∇i(b)∇j(b)σij−tr⁡bσ=Mσ(0)(π,π)+Mσ(1)(∇(b)σ,∇(b)σ)+Mσ(2)(σ,(∇(b))2σ),∇i(b)πij=Nσ(1)j(σ,∇(b)π)+Nσ(0)j(∇(b)σ,π)(9)\begin{cases} \nabla_i^{(b)}\nabla_j^{(b)}\sigma^{ij}-\operatorname{tr}_b\sigma=M_\sigma^{(0)}(\pi,\pi)+M_\sigma^{(1)}(\nabla^{(b)}\sigma,\nabla^{(b)}\sigma)+M_\sigma^{(2)}(\sigma,(\nabla^{(b)})^2\sigma),\\ \nabla_i^{(b)}\pi^{ij}=N_\sigma^{(1)j}(\sigma,\nabla^{(b)}\pi)+N_\sigma^{(0)j}(\nabla^{(b)}\sigma,\pi) \tag*{(9)} \end{cases}

where the superscript refers to the ambient metric; we will drop this for convenience. This computation is carried out explicitly in Appendix A.

Hyperbolic Annuli

Throughout the next section, it will be more convenient to consider the metric on the hyperboloid

References

  1. [22]The rotation group and its representations, in Pure and Applied Mathematics, W. Miller, Ed., vol. 50, Elsevier, 1972, pp. 222–284. DOI: https://doi.org/10.1016/S0079-8169(08)60964-2

Paper details

vlnc:W_nqngs4he
Version
v1 · latest
Published
Fresh — added to the Hub within the last 30 days
Added
License
CC BY 4.0
Usage

views · 0

downloads · 0

A view counts once per browser per day, a download each time the PDF is requested.

  • Mathematics

Not recorded for this paper

View statement
Looking for related papers…
Contents