betaFeedback

WorksPhysics and Astronomy

Penetration depth of Cooper pairs in the IrMn antiferromagnet

Abstract

Suppression of superconductivity due to the proximity effect between a superconductor and a ferromagnet can be partially alleviated when a Cooper pair simultaneously samples different directions of the short-range exchange field. The superconductor's critical temperature, TC, is therefore expected to partially recover when the ferromagnet is in a multi-domain state, as opposed to a single-domain state. Here, we discuss series of experiments performed with ferromagnet(Pt/Co)/spacer(IrMn and Pt)/superconductor(NbN) heterostructures. By tuning the various parameters in play, e.g., superconducting coherence length-to-thicknesses ratio, and domain sizes, we obtained up to 10 percent recovery of the superconducting critical temperature ΔTC/TC. This large-scale recovery made novel investigations possible. In particular, from the spacer thickness-dependence of ΔTC/TC, it was possible to deduce the characteristic length for Cooper pair penetration in an IrMn antiferromagnet. This information is crucial for electronic transport, and up to now has been difficult to access experimentally for antiferromagnets.

Introduction

The interplay between superconductivity and magnetism has attracted considerable attention in recent decades [1, 2] due to its importance for studies in basic physics and related applications. As a consequence, a variety of phenomena have been described in ferromagnet/superconductor hybrids, such as the spin switch effect [3, 4, 5], the superconducting magnetoresistance effect [6, 7], and domain wall superconductivity [8, 9, 10, 11, 12, 13]. At the heart of domain wall superconductivity, Cooper pairs consisting of electrons of opposing spins experience the short-range exchange field averaged over the superconducting coherence length. This phenomenon reduces the critical temperature (TCT_{\mathrm{C}}) of the superconducting layer. A magnetic domain wall flanked by opposite spins reduces the averaged exchange field and thus allows partial recovery of the superconducting temperature, ΔTC\Delta T_{\mathrm{C}}. Recovery is achieved through the creation of an additional – and more efficient – superconducting pathway in the magnetic layer [1]. In practice, ferromagnetic domains also generate long-range dipolar magnetic fields. While nucleation of the superconductivity can occur near domain walls [8, 14], dipolar fields may also cause the overall superconducting temperature to drop. This type of competition between exchange and dipolar interactions is especially significant for ferromagnets with out-of-plane anisotropy, such as [Pt/Co] multilayers [11]. Consequently, observation of the actual temperature enhancement due to the proximity effect near ferromagnetic domain walls is difficult. To overcome the inherent difficulty, the effects of two interfaces can be cumulated, for example by sandwiching a 38-nm-thick Nb superconductor between [Co(0.6)/Pt(1.5)]4[\mathrm{Co}(0.6)/\mathrm{Pt}(1.5)]_{4} and [Co(0.4)/Pt(1.1)]4[\mathrm{Co}(0.4)/\mathrm{Pt}(1.1)]_{4} (nm) ferromagnetic multilayers. This approach allowed Zhu et al. [12] to demonstrate a small ferromagnetic domain wall proximity effect of ΔTC/TC=0.6%\Delta T_{\mathrm{C}} / T_{\mathrm{C}} = 0.6\%.

In antiferromagnet/superconductor heterostructures, suppression of TCT_{\mathrm{C}} [15, 16, 17, 18] was reported with Cr and IrMn antiferromagnets, whereas Josephson current in superconductor/antiferromagnet/superconductor trilayers [19, 20, 21, 22] was observed with an FeMn antiferromagnet. Although few studies have been published on antiferromagnet/superconductor heterostructures compared to the number available for ferromagnet/superconductor systems, they could provide crucial information on the transport properties of antiferromagnets. Indeed, these properties recently attracted interest for their use in the context of spin-dependent transport [23, 24]. Understanding whether antiferromagnetic spin textures influence the transport of Cooper pairs and determining the characteristic lengths promoting transport are some of the basic points that deserve to be investigated.

In this study, we measured the proximity effect in ferromagnet(Pt/Co)/spacer(IrMn and Pt)/superconductor(NbN) heterostructures. We created domains in the ferromagnet and varied the configurations from multi- to single-domain. While controlling the domain state, we observed its influence on the superconductor’s critical temperature (§ 2). By tuning the various parameters in play, e.g., superconducting coherence length-to-thicknesses ratio and domain sizes, we achieved recovery of the superconducting critical temperature ΔTC/TC\Delta T_C/T_C by up to 10% (§ 3.A). This amplitude was compatible with two types of studies that were previously impossible: i) we probed the gradual evolution of ΔTC/TC\Delta T_C/T_C for all the intermediate magnetic configurations of the ferromagnet (§ 3.B); and, ii) we demonstrated how ΔTC/TC\Delta T_C/T_C decreases gradually with the thickness of the spacer layer, thus we were able to determine the penetration depth of Cooper pairs in the IrMn antiferromagnetic spacer (§ 3.C).

Experiments

The full stacks used in this study were (from substrate to surface): Si/SiO2_2(500)//[Pt(1)/Co(0.65)]n_n/spacer(tspacert_{\mathrm{spacer}})/NbN(tNbNt_{\mathrm{NbN}}) (nm) multilayers, where nn is the number of repetitions of the Pt/Co heterostructure composing the ferromagnet. The value of nn was varied between 4 and 25, corresponding to a variation of the nominal thickness between 6.6 and 41.25 nm. The thickness of the spacer layer (IrMn or Pt), tspacert_{\mathrm{spacer}}, was varied between 1 and 60 nm; tNbNt_{\mathrm{NbN}} is the thickness of the NbN superconducting layer and was set to 15, 30, or 60 nm. Stacks were deposited at room temperature by dc-magnetron sputtering on Si/SiO2_2(500) (nm) substrates under argon at a pressure of 2.3×10−32.3 \times10^{-3} mbar. The IrMn layer was deposited from an Ir20_{20}Mn80_{80} (at. %) target. The superconducting NbN layers were prepared by reactive sputtering of Nb under N2_2 gas at a partial pressure of 5×10−35 \times10^{-3} mbar. The thin films were patterned into H-bars (measuring 200 μ\mum wide and 5 mm long) by laser lithography and plasma etching. An optical image of the resulting H-bar is shown in Figure 1(a). Electrode contacts were created using aluminum-wire bonding on 200 ×\times 200 μ\mum2^2 contact pads. Electrical parameters were then measured using standard four-point current-voltage geometries, applying an ac current (lock-in detection) of amplitude 0.5 mA and frequency 13.65 Hz.

Multi-panel figure showing device layout, magnetization, resistance transitions, and microscopy

Figure 1.

By measuring the transverse voltage between contacts V1_1 and V3_3 (Figure 1(a)), the anomalous Hall contribution from the stack was determined. This contribution is known to be proportional to the perpendicular component of magnetization, MM [25]. Representative data showing how normalized MM (m=M/MSm=M/M_{\mathrm{S}}) depends on an external magnetic field, HH, applied out-of-plane for a Si/SiO2_2//[Pt(1)/Co(0.65)]15_{15}/IrMn(3)/NbN(15) (nm) stack are plotted in Figure 1(b). Data-points were measured at 12 K after demagnetizing the sample by applying an alternating field of decreasing amplitude, from 10 kOe to 0 kOe at a rate of 50 Oe.s−1^{-1}. Subsequently, distinct field sequences were applied to produce different magnetic states for the Pt/Co ferromagnet. For example, the symbols in Figure 1(b) indicate that the demagnetized (red square, for m=M/MS∼0m=M/M_{\mathrm{S}} \sim0) and saturated (blue circle, for m=M/MS∼1m=M/M_{\mathrm{S}} \sim1) states can both be accessed at a remanent field of H=0.5H=0.5 kOe. These states were used throughout the study. Magnetic force microscopy (MFM) performed at room temperature (Figure 1(d)) [26] revealed that the demagnetized state consists of maze domains, with a typical width wPt/Co=47w_{\mathrm{Pt/Co}}=47 nm. This width was determined from the power spectral density profile of the two-dimensional Fourier transform of the MFM image (Inset in Figure 1(d)). The domains are separated by domain walls (δPt/Co\delta_{\mathrm{Pt/Co}}) measuring (11.5 ±\pm 1.5) nm thick. δPt/Co\delta_{\mathrm{Pt/Co}} was calculated from δPt/Co=πA/K\delta_{Pt/Co} = \pi\sqrt{A/K}, where A=(3.4±0.4)×10−7A = (3.4 \pm0.4) \times10^{-7} erg cm−2^{-2} and K=(1.5±0.2)×106K = (1.5 \pm0.2) \times10^{6} erg cm−3^{-3} were determined by applying the Kaplan model [27]. This model will be further discussed below. The full hysteresis loop given in Figure 1(b) is also consistent with the preferential formation of maze domains, caused by competition between exchange and magnetostatic energies [28]. It should be noted that the saturated state was only accessible here at a remanent field of 0.5 kOe. Thinner Pt/Co ferromagnets produce hysteresis loops with shape closer to a square, and can thus be used to access all states in zero applied field. Nevertheless, § 3 presents a discussion of some of the considerations to be taken into account when choosing thicker vs thinner Pt/Co ferromagnets for this type of study.

The superconducting critical temperature, TCT_{\mathrm{C}}, of the NbN layer was determined from temperature(TT)-dependent measurements of the stacks’ resistance, RR, based on the longitudinal voltage between contacts V1_1 and V2_2 (Figure 1(c) and Figure 1(e)). To allow data comparison, TCT_{\mathrm{C}} was defined throughout as the temperature for which RR dropped to 0.5 mΩ\Omega, i.e., above the noise level. Typical RR vs TT measurements for HH = 0.5 kOe are shown in Figure 1(c) for [Pt/Co]n_n/IrMn/NbN multilayers with the Pt/Co ferromagnet in a demagnetized or saturated state, and in Figure 1(e) for a single layer of NbN subjected to the same field-cycling protocol. These data for the NbN monolayer were used to verify that the NbN superconductor is not intrinsically sensitive to field-cycling procedures. Subsequent findings could thus be confidently interpreted. Comparing Figure 1(c) and Figure 1(e), TCT_{\mathrm{C}} was observed to be approximately 20% smaller in the [Pt/Co]n_n/IrMn/NbN multilayer (TC∼6.5T_{\mathrm{C}} \sim6.5 K when the Pt/Co ferromagnet is saturated) than in the monolayer of NbN (TC0∼8.4T_{\mathrm{C0}} \sim8.4 K). This weakening of superconductivity is caused by the exchange field sampled by the Cooper pairs travelling across the spacer layer, inducing effective pair-breaking [10]. The fact that the 3-nm-thick IrMn spacer layer is transparent for the transport of Cooper pairs will be addressed specifically below. The results shown in Figure 1(c) confirmed that the presence of domains and the resulting domain walls in the demagnetized Pt/Co ferromagnet led to weaker Cooper pair-breaking effects, as expected from the theory [10]. This effect resulted in a larger TCT_C (∼\sim7.2 K) than that recorded for the saturated state (∼\sim 6.5 K). Thus, relative recovery of TCT_C, defined as ΔTC/TC=(TC,demagnetized state−TC,saturated state)/TC,saturated state\Delta T_C/T_C = (T_{C,\mathrm{demagnetized\ state}} - T_{C,\mathrm{saturated\ state}}) / T_{C,\mathrm{saturated\ state}}, was up to ∼\sim10% - an order of magnitude larger than the ∼\sim0.6% reported previously [12]. In fact, to observe this effect, several parameters (superconducting coherence length, ξNbN\xi_{\mathrm{NbN}}, vs layer thicknesses, tNbNt_{\mathrm{NbN}}, tIrMnt_{\mathrm{IrMn}}, tPt/Cot_{\mathrm{Pt/Co}}, vs magnetic domain width, wPt/Cow_{\mathrm{Pt/Co}}, and domain walls width, δPt/Co\delta_{\mathrm{Pt/Co}}) must be appropriately adjusted with respect to each other. For example: i) optimizing proximity effects requires the ξNbN/tNbN\xi_{\mathrm{NbN}}/t_{\mathrm{NbN}} ratio to be maximized, but minimizing finite-size effects on superconductivity imposes a lower limit on tNbNt_{\mathrm{NbN}}, or ii) optimizing the influence of a domain wall on superconductivity imposes that δPt/Co\delta_{\mathrm{Pt/Co}} be of the same order of magnitude as ξNbN\xi_{\mathrm{NbN}}. The ad hoc adjustment of several parameters produced the reported ΔTC/TC\Delta T_C/T_C, up to ∼\sim10%. Specifically, the results shown in Figure 1 were obtained with a sample in which: tNbNt_{\mathrm{NbN}} = 15 nm, ξNbN\xi_{\mathrm{NbN}} = 15 nm, δPt/Co\delta_{\mathrm{Pt/Co}} = 11.5 nm, wPt/Cow_{\mathrm{Pt/Co}} = 47 nm, tPt/Cot_{\mathrm{Pt/Co}} = 41.25 nm, and tIrMnt_{\mathrm{IrMn}} = 3 nm. Parameter tuning will be discussed in the next section.

It is interesting to note that a similar recovery of TCT_C was measured when using contacts V4V_4 and V5V_5 instead of V1V_1 and V2V_2 for the measurements (Figure 1(a)), i.e., when the total number of domains probed was reduced but the overall maze arrangement remained the same. This result confirms that it is the maze arrangement that produces the observed effect.

Results and Discussions

We will now comment on the influence of the thickness of the NbN superconductor on the recovery of TCT_C in [Pt/Co]n_n/IrMn/NbN multilayers. The data presented in Figure 2(a) show that ΔTC\Delta T_{\mathrm{C}} decreases when tNbNt_{\mathrm{NbN}} increases, confirming the interfacial nature of the effect observed [10].

Four-panel plot showing (a) $\Delta T_{\mathrm{C}}$ versus $t_{\mathrm{NbN}}$, (b) $H$ versus $T_{\mathrm{C}}$ for $t_{\mathrm{NbN}}=15$, 30, and 60 nm, (c) $T_{\mathrm{C},H=0}$ and $\xi_{\mathrm{NbN}}$ versus $t_{\mathrm{NbN}}$, and (d) $\Delta T_{\mathrm{C}}/T_{\mathrm{C}}$ versus $\xi_{\mathrm{NbN}}/t_{\mathrm{NbN}}$

Figure 2.

We gained further insights into the thickness-dependence of the NbN properties from series of measurements of RR vs TT for several applied fields. The resulting HH-dependences of TCT_{\mathrm{C}} (Figure 2(b)) were fitted using Ginzburg-Landau (GL) theory, which is expected to apply in the perpendicular field configuration for type II superconductors. Specifically, we deduced the superconducting coherence length, ξNbN\xi_{\mathrm{NbN}}, using the following equation [29]: H=Φ0(1−T/TC,H=0)2πξGL,T=02H = \frac{\Phi_{0}\left(1-T/T_{\mathrm{C},H=0}\right)}{2\pi\xi_{\mathrm{GL},T=0}^{2}}, where Φ0\Phi_{0} is the magnetic flux quantum (Φ0=h/(2e)\Phi_{0}=h/(2e)), and ξGL\xi_{\mathrm{GL}} is the GL coherence length, with ξGL,T=0=ξNbNπ/2\xi_{\mathrm{GL},T=0}=\xi_{\mathrm{NbN}}\pi/2. It should be remembered that, in the dirty limit, ξNbN=ℏDNbN/(2πkBTC)\xi_{\mathrm{NbN}}=\sqrt{\hbar D_{\mathrm{NbN}}/(2\pi k_{\mathrm{B}}T_{\mathrm{C}})}, where DNbND_{\mathrm{NbN}} is the diffusion constant (see also Appendix). Data derived from the fits of HH vs TT for several tNbNt_{\mathrm{NbN}} were plotted for [Pt/Co]n_n/IrMn/NbN and NbN stacks Figure 2(c). The corresponding tNbNt_{\mathrm{NbN}}-dependences of TC,H=0T_{\mathrm{C},H=0} and ξNbN\xi_{\mathrm{NbN}} are known to be related to finite-size effects taking weakened interfacial superconductivity into account [29]. Most importantly, measurements of the finite-size effect on ξNbN\xi_{\mathrm{NbN}} were used to produce the data presented in Figure 2(d), where ΔTC/TC\Delta T_{\mathrm{C}}/T_{\mathrm{C}} can be observed to scale linearly with ξNbN/tNbN\xi_{\mathrm{NbN}}/t_{\mathrm{NbN}}. This relationship further supports the interfacial nature of the proximity effect involved here.

Influence of ferromagnetic domain configuration

As the temperature recovery observed here in [Pt/Co]n_n/IrMn/NbN multilayers was considerable, it was possible to explore how ΔTC/TC\Delta T_{\mathrm{C}}/T_{\mathrm{C}} evolved for several ferromagnetic configurations of the Pt/Co multilayer. Intermediate configurations, between the demagnetized and saturated states discussed in § 2, were obtained as illustrated in Fig. 3(a). Specifically, an incremental sequence of minor hysteresis loops was applied at 12 K. Starting from a demagnetized state, the magnetic field was raised to HiH_i and then reduced to 0.5 kOe. The symbols in Fig. 3(a) indicate the magnetic states that we considered. The gradual increase in m=M/MSm=M/M_{\mathrm{S}} for the intermediate states accounts for the partial remagnetization and gradual evolution of the domain configuration in the Pt/Co multilayer. After each step of the sequence in field, the TCT_{\mathrm{C}} of the superconductor was deduced from an RR vs TT scan at H=0.5H = 0.5 kOe (Fig. 3(b)). The plot of ΔTC,i/TC=(TC,intermediate state−TC,saturated state)/TC,saturated state\Delta T_{\mathrm{C},i}/T_{\mathrm{C}} = (T_{\mathrm{C,intermediate\ state}} - T_{\mathrm{C,saturated\ state}}) / T_{\mathrm{C,saturated\ state}} vs 1−M/MS1-M/M_{\mathrm{S}} (Fig. 3(c)) shows how the magnetic domain arrangement in the Pt/Co ferromagnet influenced superconductivity recovery in the NbN film. In particular, we observed that gradually reducing the domain size, from infinite in the saturated state (1−M/MS∼01-M/M_{\mathrm{S}} \sim0) to 45 nm in the demagnetized state (1−M/MS∼11-M/M_{\mathrm{S}} \sim1) led to progressive recovery of superconductivity, from ΔTC,i/TC∼0\Delta T_{\mathrm{C},i}/T_{\mathrm{C}} \sim0 to 10%. Overall, this behavior can be explained by a theoretical model, which is detailed below.

Before coming to the model, we considered how superconductivity recovery was affected by the thickness of the Pt/Co ferromagnet. Figure 4(a) shows that the gradual increase in ΔTC,i/TC\Delta T_{\mathrm{C},i}/T_{\mathrm{C}} as the magnetic domain configuration of the Pt/Co multilayer shifted from saturated to demagnetized appeared to follow a universal trend that is independent of tPt/Cot_{\mathrm{Pt/Co}}. However, the maximum value, corresponding to ΔTC/TC=(TC,demagnetized state−TC,saturated state)/TC,saturated state\Delta T_{\mathrm{C}}/T_{\mathrm{C}} = (T_{\mathrm{C,demagnetized\ state}} - T_{\mathrm{C,saturated\ state}}) / T_{\mathrm{C,saturated\ state}}, did significantly depend on tPt/Cot_{\mathrm{Pt/Co}} (Fig. 4(b)), leveling out from n=15n = 15. This number of Pt/Co layers corresponds to a nominal tPt/Cot_{\mathrm{Pt/Co}} thickness of 24.75 nm. We note that data in Fig. 4(b) were measured for both H=0.5H = 0.5 kOe and 1.3 kOe, to allow exploration of larger tPt/Cot_{\mathrm{Pt/Co}} values. Indeed, for larger values, saturation can only be reached with a 1.3-kOe field (see § 2 and discussion therein). Data for H=0.5H = 0.5 kOe naturally show larger values than data for H=1.3H = 1.3 kOe as superconducting properties are weakened when a stronger field is applied. The tPt/Cot_{\mathrm{Pt/Co}}-dependence of ΔTC/TC\Delta T_{\mathrm{C}}/T_{\mathrm{C}} is undoubtedly driven by several parameters. First, superconducting properties are more affected by a thicker ferromagnet, as long as tPt/Cot_{\mathrm{Pt/Co}} remains shorter than the Cooper pair coherence length, ξPt/Co\xi_{\mathrm{Pt/Co}}. However, this effect should not be involved here, as the coherence length is known to be a few nanometers in ferromagnets. Second, since the size of the domains decreases down to a threshold thickness corresponding to about 47 nm (Fig. 4(c)), the density of domain walls increases and then levels out, resulting in a similar shape for ΔTC/TC\Delta T_C/T_C vs tPt/Cot_{\mathrm{Pt/Co}}. Specifically, the size of the domains in the demagnetized state, wPt/Cow_{\mathrm{Pt/Co}}, changes with the number of layers, nn, making up the [Pt/Co]n[\mathrm{Pt/Co}]_n multilayer (i.e., with tPt/Cot_{\mathrm{Pt/Co}}). The thickness-dependence of wPt/Cow_{\mathrm{Pt/Co}} is known to obey Kaplan’s model, which accounts for the fact that the cost in domain wall energy was compensated by the gain in demagnetizing energy as the film thickness increased [27]. For wPt/Co/tPt/Co>1.5w_{\mathrm{Pt/Co}}/t_{\mathrm{Pt/Co}}>1.5, the thickness-dependence of wPt/Cow_{\mathrm{Pt/Co}} is given by: Ln⁡(wPt/Co/tPt/Co)=πw0/(2tPt/Co)+a\operatorname{Ln}(w_{\mathrm{Pt/Co}}/t_{\mathrm{Pt/Co}})=\pi w_0/(2t_{\mathrm{Pt/Co}})+a, with a=Ln⁡(π)−1+μ(0.5−Ln⁡(2))a=\operatorname{Ln}(\pi)-1+\mu(0.5-\operatorname{Ln}(2)); μ=1+2πMS2/K\mu=1+2\pi M_S^2/K. Considering MSM_S equal to 550 emu cm−3^{-3} (MS=MCotCo/(tCo+tPt)M_S=M_{\mathrm{Co}}t_{\mathrm{Co}}/(t_{\mathrm{Co}}+t_{\mathrm{Pt}})), data-fitting returned w0=(19.8±2)w_0=(19.8\pm2) nm and an anisotropy of K=(1.5±0.2)×106K=(1.5\pm0.2)\times10^6 erg.cm−3^{-3}. These values are in agreement with previous findings [26]. The domain wall energy σw=(5.5±0.5)\sigma_w=(5.5\pm0.5) erg.cm−2^{-2}, the exchange stiffness A=(3.4±0.4)×10−7A=(3.4\pm0.4)\times10^{-7} erg cm−2^{-2}, and the domain wall width δPt/Co=(11.5±1.5)\delta_{\mathrm{Pt/Co}}=(11.5\pm1.5) nm were subsequently calculated by applying the following relations: σw=4AK=2πMS2w0\sigma_w=4\sqrt{AK}=2\pi M_S^2w_0 and δPt/Co=πA/K\delta_{\mathrm{Pt/Co}}=\pi\sqrt{A/K} [27].

Because the NbN layer was grown on top of the multilayers, for which the thicknesses varied significantly, we verified that its superconducting properties were not significantly altered as a result of growth issues. ξNbN\xi_{\mathrm{NbN}} and TC,H=0T_{C,H=0} were therefore extracted using the same procedure and equations as described in Figure 2(b) and corresponding text. These data confirmed negligible variability in NbN properties across samples (Fig. 4(c)).

We next sought to develop a theoretical model supporting the experimental findings. The model considers that Cooper pairs feel a reduced effective exchange field that is spatially uniform over the surface of the demagnetized ferromagnet. Within the quasiclassical diffusive theory for superconducting heterostructures, we derived an expression for the critical temperature of a superconductor/ferromagnet bilayer in the presence of a periodic magnetic domain structure (see Appendix). Thus, assuming a thin superconducting layer (ts≪ξst_s\ll\xi_s with S=NbN) in good electrical contact with a thick ferromagnetic layer (tF≫ξSt_F \gg\xi_S with F=Pt/Co), and narrow domain walls (δF≪ξS\delta_F \ll\xi_S), we found:

ΔTC,iδTC=TC(m)−TC(m=1)δTC=\frac{\Delta T_{C,i}}{\delta T_C}=\frac{T_C(m)-T_C(m=1)}{\delta T_C}=
1−m2−2(LF/ξS)47π6ζ(3)∑p=1∞sin⁡2[π2(m+1)p]p6[π4p2(LF/ξS)2+ψ(12)−ψ(12+2π2p2(LF/ξS)2)](1)1-m^2-\frac{2(L_F/\xi_S)^4}{7\pi^6\zeta(3)}\sum_{p=1}^{\infty}\frac{\sin^2\left[\frac{\pi}{2}(m+1)p\right]}{p^6}\left[\frac{\pi^4p^2}{(L_F/\xi_S)^2}+\psi\left(\frac{1}{2}\right)-\psi\left(\frac{1}{2}+\frac{2\pi^2p^2}{(L_F/\xi_S)^2}\right)\right] \tag*{(1)}

for an arbitrary ratio LF/ξSL_F/\xi_S. Here ζ\zeta and ψ\psi are the Riemann zeta and digamma functions, respectively, and LFL_F is the period of the domain structure (LF=2wFL_F=2w_F). The domain structure consists of alternating majority and minority stripe domains, the relative lengths of which determine the reduced magnetization, m=M/MSm=M/M_S. The maximal shift was obtained for LF≪ξSL_F \ll\xi_S, given by ΔTC=δTC\Delta T_C=\delta T_C with:

δTC=7ζ(3)4π2h~2kB2TC0(2)\delta T_C=\frac{7\zeta(3)}{4\pi^2}\frac{\tilde{h}^2}{k_B^2T_{C0}} \tag*{(2)}

Here, TC0T_{C0} is the critical temperature of the bare superconducting layer, and h~\tilde{h} is an effective exchange field. This field can be related to the exchange field hh acting on the electron spins in the ferromagnetic layer as follows:

h~=ℏσFDS2σStShℏDF(3)\tilde{h}=\frac{\hbar\sigma_FD_S}{2\sigma_St_S}\sqrt{\frac{h}{\hbar D_F}} \tag*{(3)}

with the conductivities σS\sigma_S and σF\sigma_F, and the diffusion constants DSD_S and DFD_F in the superconducting and ferromagnetic layers, respectively. From Fig. 4(a) it emerges that Eq. (1) for LF≲ξSL_F \lesssim\xi_S, where it approximates to ΔTC,i=(1−m2)δTC\Delta T_{C,i}=(1-m^2)\delta T_C, qualitatively describes the experiment for 0≤m≪10 \leq m \ll1. Deviations for 1−m≪11-m \ll1 are attributed to the limitations of the model close to saturation, when the domain structure is very different from periodic stripes.

As the ratio LF/ξSL_F/\xi_S increases, the ΔTc\Delta T_c shift is progressively reduced. Ultimately, for LF≫ξSL_F \gg\xi_S, Cooper pairs mostly feel single domains, making both the demagnetized and saturated states detrimental, producing similar depairing efficiency. For LF≫ξSL_F \gg\xi_S, Eq. (1) yields:

ΔTC=(27/2−1)ζ(7/2)2π2h~2kB2TC0ξSLF(4)\Delta T_C = \frac{(2^{7/2}-1)\zeta(7/2)}{\sqrt{2}\pi^2}\frac{\tilde{h}^{2}}{k_B^{2}T_{C0}}\frac{\xi_S}{L_F} \tag*{(4)}

The above equation qualitatively describes the suppression of ΔTC\Delta T_C as the ferromagnetic layer gets thinner and LF=2wFL_F = 2w_F concomitantly increases (see Figs. 4(b) and (c)).

As LFL_F increases further, the assumption of a superconducting order parameter that is almost spatially uniform - used to derive Eq. (1) - breaks down. This happens when the transition takes place in the domain wall superconducting (DWS) phase, according to [10]. In this case, the increase in critical temperature between demagnetized and saturated configurations can be determined as follows:

ΔTC=(82−1)ζ2(7/2)8π6h~4kB4TC03(5)\Delta T_C = \frac{(8\sqrt{2}-1)\zeta^2(7/2)}{8\pi^6}\frac{\tilde{h}^{4}}{k_B^{4}T_{C0}^{3}} \tag*{(5)}

This relationship requires the walls to be sufficiently distant from each other on the characteristic DWS length scale [10], i.e., (1−m)LF≥ξDWS(T)(1-m)L_F \ge\xi_{DWS}(T), with ξDWS(T)=ξSTC0/(TC0−T)\xi_{DWS}(T) = \xi_S T_{C0}/(T_{C0}-T). As TC0−T≈h~2/(kB2TC0)T_{C0}-T \approx\tilde{h}^{2}/(k_B^{2}T_{C0}) in this regime, Eqs. (4) and (5) can be seen to match parametrically at m=0m=0 (i.e., LF≈ξDWS(TC)L_F \approx\xi_{DWS}(T_C)). Note that the DWS phases overlap extensively at LF≈ξGL(TC)L_F \approx\xi_{GL}(T_C), where ξGL(T)=π2ξSTC0/(TC0−T)\xi_{GL}(T) = \frac{\pi}{2}\xi_S\sqrt{T_{C0}/(T_{C0}-T)}, is the GL coherence length.

Influence of the nature, thickness, and domain state of the spacer layer

We next investigated the influence of the spacer thickness on the recovery of superconductivity. More particularly, we took advantage of the proximity effect in our ferromagnet/antiferromagnetic-spacer/superconductor heterostructures to study the transport properties of Cooper pairs in the IrMn antiferromagnet and to further deduce characteristic properties that could be of interest for any electronic transport-related study, e.g., for antiferromagnetic spintronics [23, 24]. How ΔTC/TC\Delta T_C / T_C depends on the IrMn spacer thickness is shown in Fig. 5(a) for two values of applied field. It should be noted that the superconducting properties of NbN, ξNbN\xi_{\mathrm{NbN}} and TC,H=0T_{C,H=0} were tested in this set of samples. These data indicated that the variability in ξNbN\xi_{\mathrm{NbN}} and TC,H=0T_{C,H=0} across samples was negligible (not shown), in line with the data presented in Fig. 4(c) and the related discussion. The overall reduction of ΔTC/TC\Delta T_C/T_C with tIrMnt_{\mathrm{IrMn}} (Fig. 5(a)) relates to the coherence length of Cooper pairs in the metallic spacer of the IrMn antiferromagnet, ξIrMn\xi_{\mathrm{IrMn}}. The fact that the overall signal only entirely vanished when the tIrMnt_{\mathrm{IrMn}} thickness reached ∼40\sim40 nm indicates that a thin IrMn layer (e.g., 3 nm as considered in the previous sections) will be completely transparent for the electronic transport of Cooper pairs. This finding can be explained by the fact that an antiferromagnetic exchange length of a few nanometers is much shorter than the superconducting coherence length of a few tens of nanometers. As a result, the different directions of the moments are sampled simultaneously by a Cooper pair, and the antiferromagnet is viewed as a non-magnetic layer in the Cooper pair reference frame. We note that the spin structure in polycrystalline IrMn thin films like the ones used in our samples resembles a disordered phase (γ\gamma-phase) of the non-collinear structure of the bulk L12_2-IrMn3_3 antiferromagnet [30]. When considering the diffusion of Cooper pairs, we took ΔTC/TC∝exp⁡[−kspacertspacer]\Delta T_C/T_C \propto\exp[-k_{\mathrm{spacer}}t_{\mathrm{spacer}}] - expected from quasiclassical theories in the diffusive limit - with a wavevector of the form kspacer=1/ξspacerk_{\mathrm{spacer}} = 1/\xi_{\mathrm{spacer}}. Fitting these relations to the data shown in Fig. 5, we obtained a coherence length of ξIrMn=(6.7±1)\xi_{\mathrm{IrMn}} = (6.7 \pm1) nm for the IrMn antiferromagnet. In comparison, a value of (12.4±2)(12.4 \pm2) nm was obtained for the non-magnetic Pt layer. The expected result was ξspacer∝Dspacerτspacer\xi_{\mathrm{spacer}} \propto\sqrt{D_{\mathrm{spacer}}\tau_{\mathrm{spacer}}}, where DspacerD_{\mathrm{spacer}} is the electron diffusion constant, and τspacer\tau_{\mathrm{spacer}} is the depairing time for Cooper pairs in the metallic spacer layer, which includes contributions from spin relaxation processes [31].

We finally considered whether the magnetic state of the IrMn antiferromagnet influenced superconductivity. We took advantage of the strong exchange bias interaction between the IrMn bottom interface and the adjacent Pt/Co ferromagnet to imprint ferromagnetic configurations in the IrMn antiferromagnet [32]. Initially, exchange bias interaction was quenched by raising the sample’s temperature to 400 K, i.e., above the blocking temperature (TBT_{\mathrm{B}}) for the ferromagnet/antiferromagnet bilayer (Fig. 6(a)). In these conditions, the IrMn antiferromagnetic layer lost its ability to pin the magnetization of the adjacent Pt/Co ferromagnet. Consequently, this layer can be considered to be a single-layer ferromagnet in which different magnetic state types – demagnetized, saturated, or any intermediate state – can be nucleated by conventional means (see Fig. 3(a) and corresponding text). Subsequently, the bilayer was cooled below TBT_{\mathrm{B}}, (here, down to T=12T = 12 K), causing the moments in the antiferromagnet to align with those of the ferromagnet due to exchange bias coupling. Indeed, below the blocking temperature, the moments in the antiferromagnet remained pinned regardless of the direction of the moments in the ferromagnet; at 12 K this effect produced a hysteresis loop shift, HEH_{\mathrm{E}}. This procedure was demonstrated to be robust and has been used elsewhere to imprint multi-domain states and magnetic textures in antiferromagnets. Thus, for example, exchange bias was shown to allow several spin arrangements to be imprinted across the core of antiferromagnets, at least across 8 nm for exchange springs in IrMn layers [33], or 3 nm for textures such as vortices in CoO and NiO layers [34]. Figure 6(a) shows the blocking temperature distribution for a Si/SiO2_2//[Pt(1)/Co(0.65)]4_4/IrMn(3)/NbN(15) (nm) stack. This distribution was obtained following a proven specific process according to which HEH_{\mathrm{E}} is recorded after each step in an incremental field-cooling procedure starting from an annealing temperature TaT_{\mathrm{a}} (inset). The procedure is extensively described elsewhere [35, 36]. Most importantly, the data presented in Fig. 6(a) indicate that the magnetic configuration of the Pt/Co ferromagnet can be stabilized in the IrMn antiferromagnet by cooling from 400 K down to 12 K, as the whole distribution of blocking temperatures was measured below 400 K. Using the domain replication approach mentioned above, we stabilized several states at T=12T = 12 K in the IrMn antiferromagnet of a Si/SiO2//[Pt(1)/Co(0.65)]15/IrMn(3)/NbN(15)\mathrm{Si/SiO_2//[Pt(1)/Co(0.65)]_{15}/IrMn(3)/NbN(15)} (nm) stack (Fig. 6(b)). This stabilization made it possible to obtain a hysteresis loop for which the shift along the HH-axis depended on the magnetic state of the antiferromagnet [32]. For every antiferromagnetic state (pinned at 12 K), we reproduced the procedure detailed in Fig. 3(a) and related text, using sequences of minor hysteresis loops, driven by HiH_{\mathrm{i}}, to scan ΔTC/TC\Delta T_{\mathrm{C}}/T_{\mathrm{C}} for several ferromagnetic configurations, from demagnetized to saturated. Figure 6(c) shows the corresponding normalized magnetization (m=M/MSm=M/M_{\mathrm{S}}) vs HiH_{\mathrm{i}}. The shift observed on these curves is a direct consequence of the fact that the IrMn antiferromagnet was prepared in three distinct states. Figure 6(d) shows the gradual enhancement of ΔTC/TC\Delta T_{\mathrm{C}}/T_{\mathrm{C}} as a function of the magnetic domain configuration of the Pt/Co for several IrMn arrangements. These results demonstrate that the recovery of superconductivity, driven by the ferromagnetic configuration of the Pt/Co multilayer (Fig. 3 and corresponding text), is independent of the domain arrangement in the IrMn antiferromagnet. This finding is consistent with the fact that a 3-nm-thick IrMn layer is transparent for the electronic transport of Cooper pairs, due to simultaneous sampling of the different directions of the moments.

Conclusion

In conclusion, the main contribution of this paper is that it presents a systematic investigation of the superconducting proximity effect in ferromagnet(Pt/Co)/spacer(IrMn and Pt)/superconductor(NbN) heterostructures. The findings presented indicate that by tuning the various parameters in play, the recovery of the superconducting critical temperature in the presence of ferromagnetic domains and domain walls can be maximized to a degree that makes it possible to carry out two types of studies that were previously impossible. We were therefore able to: i) probe how the recovery of the superconducting critical temperature gradually evolves with all the intermediate magnetic configurations of the ferromagnet; and, ii) determine that the recovery of the superconducting critical temperature gradually reduces with the thickness of the metallic spacer layer. Most importantly, these experiments allowed us to evaluate the penetration of Cooper pairs in the IrMn metallic antiferromagnet, information which is crucial for electronic transport, and up to now has been difficult to access experimentally for antiferromagnets. The results presented therefore open a new pathway for the investigation of electronic transport in antiferromagnetic materials for spintronics.

Acknowledgments

The authors acknowledge financial support from the French national research agency (ANR) [Grant Number ANR-15-CE24-0015-01], KAUST [Grant Number OSR-2015-CRG4-2626], and the CEA’s bottom-up exploratory program (Grant Number PE-18P31-ELSA). A.I.B. acknowledges support by the Ministry of Science and Higher Education of the Russian Federation within the framework of state funding for the creation and development of World-Class Research Center “Digital biodesign and personalized healthcare” N075-15-2020-92. We also thank M. Gallagher-Gambarelli for critical reading of the manuscript.

Appendix

In this Appendix we provide the derivation of Eq. (1).

Formalism

Within the quasiclassical diffusive approximation, the critical temperature TCT_C of the superconducting(S)/normal(N)/ferromagnetic(F) trilayer is obtained as the solution of the following self-consistency equation:

Δ(r)=πTλ(r)∑ωfω(r)\Delta(\mathbf{r}) = \pi T \lambda(\mathbf{r}) \sum_{\omega} f_{\omega}(\mathbf{r})

Here Δ(r)\Delta(\mathbf{r}) is the superconducting order parameter at position r=(x,y,z)\mathbf{r}=(x,y,z), ω=(2p+1)πT\omega=(2p+1)\pi T (pp integer) are Matsubara frequencies at temperature TT, and λ(r)\lambda(\mathbf{r}) is the pairing constant that takes value λ\lambda in the S layer, and vanishes otherwise. (We use units with ℏ=kB=1\hbar=k_{B}=1 throughout the Appendix). In the S layer (−tS<y<0-t_{S}<y<0), the anomalous component of the quasiclassical Green function, fω(r)f_{\omega}(\mathbf{r}), solves the Usadel equation:

−DS2∇2fω(r)+∣ω∣fω(r)=Δ(r)(6)-\frac{D_{S}}{2}\nabla^{2}f_{\omega}(\mathbf{r})+|\omega|f_{\omega}(\mathbf{r})=\Delta(\mathbf{r}) \tag*{(6)}

where tSt_{S} is the thickness of the S layer and DSD_{S} is its diffusion constant.

In the N layer (0<y<tN0<y<t_{N}), fω(r)f_{\omega}(\mathbf{r}) solves:

−DN2∇2fω(r)+(∣ω∣+1τN)fω(r)=0(7)-\frac{D_{N}}{2}\nabla^{2}f_{\omega}(\mathbf{r})+\left(|\omega|+\frac{1}{\tau_{N}}\right)f_{\omega}(\mathbf{r})=0 \tag*{(7)}

where tNt_{N} is the thickness of the N layer, DND_{N} is its diffusion constant and 1τN\frac{1}{\tau_{N}} is a depairing rate.

In the F layer (tN<y<tN+tFt_{N}<y<t_{N}+t_{F}), fω(r)f_{\omega}(\mathbf{r}) solves:

−DF2∇2fω(r)+(∣ω∣+1τF+ih(r)sign⁡(ω))fω(r)=0(8)-\frac{D_{F}}{2}\nabla^{2}f_{\omega}(\mathbf{r})+\left(|\omega|+\frac{1}{\tau_{F}}+ih(\mathbf{r})\operatorname{sign}(\omega)\right)f_{\omega}(\mathbf{r})=0 \tag*{(8)}

where tFt_{F} is the thickness of the F layer, DFD_{F} is its diffusion constant, 1τF\frac{1}{\tau_{F}} is another depairing rate, and h(r)h(\mathbf{r}) is an exchange field. Equations (6)-(8) are supplemented with boundary conditions, which express the absence of current at the interfaces with vacuum:

∂yfω(x,−tS,z)=0and∂yfω(x,tN+tF,z)=0(9)\begin{aligned} \partial_{y}f_{\omega}(x,-t_{S},z)&=0 \\ \text{and}\qquad\partial_{y}f_{\omega}(x,t_{N}+t_{F},z)&=0 \tag*{(9)} \end{aligned}

as well as current conservation at each interface between two layers:

fω(x,0−,z)=fω(x,0+,z)f_{\omega}(x,0^{-},z)=f_{\omega}(x,0^{+},z)
σS∂yfω(x,0−,z)=σN∂yfω(x,0+,z)\sigma_{S}\partial_{y}f_{\omega}(x,0^{-},z)=\sigma_{N}\partial_{y}f_{\omega}(x,0^{+},z)

and

fω(x,tN−,z)=fω(x,tN+,z)f_{\omega}(x,t_{N}^{-},z)=f_{\omega}(x,t_{N}^{+},z)
σN∂yfω(x,tN−,z)=σF∂yfω(x,tN+,z)(10)\sigma_{N}\partial_{y}f_{\omega}(x,t_{N}^{-},z)=\sigma_{F}\partial_{y}f_{\omega}(x,t_{N}^{+},z) \tag*{(10)}

Here σS\sigma_{S}, σN\sigma_{N}, and σF\sigma_{F} are the conductivities in S, N, and F layers, respectively, and we assumed a negligible tunnel resistance between two layers.

The exchange field in the F layer is generated by a periodic structure of magnetic domains with period LFL_{F} along the xx-direction. Assuming narrow domain walls, we approximate the exchange field as:

h(r)=h(x)={hfor 0<x<a−hfor a<x<LF(11)h(\mathbf{r})=h(x)= \begin{cases} h & \text{for }0<x<a\\ -h & \text{for }a<x<L_{F} \end{cases} \tag*{(11)}

Here hh is the exchange field inside a domain with (saturation) magnetization MSM_{S}, and the relative length of majority and minority domains is related with the reduced magnetization, m=M/MS=2a/LF−1m=M/M_{S}=2a/L_{F}-1, where MM is the magnetization. For this magnetic texture, the zz-dependence drops out from all above equations.

To proceed further, we assume that the S layer is thin on the scale of the superconducting coherence length, ξS=DS/(2πTC0)\xi_{S}=\sqrt{D_{S}/(2\pi T_{C0})}, where TC0T_{C0} is the bare critical temperature of the S material. Then ff hardly varies along the yy-direction in that layer. We find that Eq. (6) averaged over the thickness of the S layer yields:

−DS2∂x2fω(x)−DS2tS∂yfω(x)+∣ω∣fω(x)=Δ(x)(12)-\frac{D_{S}}{2}\partial_{x}^{2}f_{\omega}(x)-\frac{D_{S}}{2t_{S}}\partial_{y}f_{\omega}(x)+\lvert\omega\rvert f_{\omega}(x)=\Delta(x) \tag*{(12)}

where we used integration by parts and boundary condition of Eq. (9). The relation between ∂yfω(x)\partial_y f_\omega(x) and fω(x)f_\omega(x) is obtained by solving the Usadel equations in N and F layers.

For this, we also assume that the F layer is thick on the scale of the ferromagnetic coherence ξF=DF/h\xi_F = \sqrt{D_F/h}, and 1τF,h≫T\frac{1}{\tau_F}, h \gg T such that the term proportional to ∣ω∣|\omega| in Eq. (8) can be dropped out. Then, the solution of Eq. (8) approximately satisfies:

∂yfω(x,tN+)fω(x,tN+)=−(1ξF1+iξF2h(x)hsign⁡(ω))(13)\frac{\partial_y f_\omega(x,t_N^+)}{f_\omega(x,t_N^+)}=-\left(\frac{1}{\xi_{F1}}+\frac{i}{\xi_{F2}}\frac{h(x)}{h}\operatorname{sign}(\omega)\right) \tag*{(13)}

with

ξF1,F2=ξF(hτF)2+1∓1hτF(14)\xi_{F1,F2}=\xi_F\sqrt{\frac{\sqrt{(h\tau_F)^2+1}\mp1}{h\tau_F}} \tag*{(14)}

In particular, ξF1,F2≈ξF\xi_{F1,F2}\approx\xi_F if hτF≫1h\tau_F\gg1.

We are left with solving Eq. (7) in the N layer. In the following, we consider the case of a thin N layer.

Thin N layer

By using the boundary conditions Eqs. (10), and (13), for a thin N layer, Eq. (12) simplifies into:

−DS2∂x2fω(x)+(∣ω∣+1τ~+ih~(x)sign⁡(ω))fω(x)=Δ(x)(15)-\frac{D_S}{2}\partial_x^2 f_\omega(x)+\left(|\omega|+\frac{1}{\tilde{\tau}}+i\tilde{h}(x)\operatorname{sign}(\omega)\right)f_\omega(x)=\Delta(x) \tag*{(15)}

with

h~(x)=h~h(x)h,h~=DSσF2tSσSξF2=1τ~ξF1ξF2(16)\tilde{h}(x)=\tilde{h}\frac{h(x)}{h},\qquad\tilde{h}=\frac{D_S\sigma_F}{2t_S\sigma_S\xi_{F2}}=\frac{1}{\tilde{\tau}}\frac{\xi_{F1}}{\xi_{F2}} \tag*{(16)}

The critical temperature is then obtained from the linearized self-consistency equation:

Δ(x)ln⁡TC0T=πT∑ω[Δ(x)∣ω∣−fω(x)](17)\Delta(x)\ln\frac{T_{C0}}{T}=\pi T\sum_{\omega}\left[\frac{\Delta(x)}{|\omega|}-f_{\omega}(x)\right] \tag*{(17)}

where we used a standard regularization procedure to trade λ\lambda with TC0T_{C0} in Eq. (6).

We consider the regime h~,1/τ~≪TC0\tilde{h},1/\tilde{\tau}\ll T_{C0} for which the critical temperature is weakly suppressed, TC0−TC≪TC0T_{C0}-T_C\ll T_{C0}. We also consider the case of a dense domain structure, such that the order parameter at the transition into the superconducting state is almost uniform. This approximation is discussed in § 3.B. By expressing Eq. (15) in Fourier space, and treating perturbatively the Fourier components of ff and Δ\Delta with q≠0q\ne0 (similar to [37]), we find:

f0≈Δ0∣ω∣+1τ~+ih~0+∑q≠0∣h~q∣2DSq2/2+∣ω∣(18)f_0\approx\frac{\Delta_0}{|\omega|+\frac{1}{\tilde{\tau}}+i\tilde{h}_0+\sum_{q\ne0}\frac{|\tilde{h}_q|^2}{D_Sq^2/2+|\omega|}} \tag*{(18)}

Here h~0=mh~\tilde{h}_0=m\tilde{h} and ∣h~q∣2=[4h~sin⁡(qa/2)/qLF]2|\tilde{h}_q|^2=\left[4\tilde{h}\sin(qa/2)/qL_F\right]^2 with q=2πp/LFq=2\pi p/L_F for the domain texture described by Eq. (11). The self-consistency Eq. (17) yields the shift of critical temperature:

TC0−TCTC0=2πTC0∑ω>0[1τ~ω2+h~02ω3+∑q≠0∣h~q∣2ω2[ω+DSq2/2]](19)\frac{T_{C0}-T_C}{T_{C0}}=2\pi T_{C0}\sum_{\omega>0}\left[\frac{1}{\tilde{\tau}\omega^2}+\frac{\tilde{h}_0^2}{\omega^3}+\sum_{q\ne0}\frac{|\tilde{h}_q|^2}{\omega^2[\omega+D_Sq^2/2]}\right] \tag*{(19)}

Equation (19) is alternatively expressed as Eq. (1) in the main text, while Eq. (16) simplifies to Eq. (3) for hτF≫1h\tau_F\gg1.

Figure Captions

Fig. 1. (color online) (a) Optical image of a typical device used to perform transport measurements. The complete image is reconstructed from three optical images (indicated by the dotted squares). (b) Normalized magnetization M/MSM/M_{\mathrm{S}} starting from a demagnetized state measured at 12 K for a Si/SiO2_2//[Pt(1)/Co(0.65)]15_{15}/IrMn(3)/NbN(15) (nm) ferromagnetic/spacer/superconductor stack. (c) Representative data showing the TT-dependence of RR, for the same sample as in (b), prepared in two distinct magnetic states: saturated and demagnetized, through two procedures involving field-cycling and cooling (see text). ΔTC\Delta T_{\mathrm{C}} (here, systematically measured at R=0.5R = 0.5 mΩ\Omega) represents the difference in superconducting critical temperature between the saturated and demagnetized states (ΔTC=TC,demagnetized state−TC,saturated state\Delta T_{\mathrm{C}} = T_{\mathrm{C,demagnetized\ state}} - T_{\mathrm{C,saturated\ state}}). (d) MFM image taken at room temperature, for the sample used in (b) and (c), showing maze domains after demagnetization. (Inset) PSD profile of the MFM image. (e) Control experiment with a bare Si/SiO2_2//NbN(15) (nm) stack subjected to the two procedures used for (c). Data in (c) and (e) were measured for an applied field H=0.5H = 0.5 kOe. The symbols in (b) represent the two magnetic states, demagnetized (square) and saturated (circle).

Fig. 2. (color online) (a) NbN thickness (tNbNt_{\mathrm{NbN}}) dependence of ΔTC\Delta T_{\mathrm{C}}. (b) Representative data showing HH vs. TCT_{\mathrm{C}} as measured for Si/SiO2_2//[Pt(1)/Co(0.65)]15_{15}/IrMn(3)/NbN(tNbNt_{\mathrm{NbN}}) (nm) stacks. These data were used to calculate the superconducting coherence length, ξNbN\xi_{\mathrm{NbN}} and the zero-field superconducting temperature, TC,H=0T_{\mathrm{C},H=0}. Lines were fitted to the data using the model described in the text. (c) Corresponding tNbNt_{\mathrm{NbN}}-dependences of ξNbN\xi_{\mathrm{NbN}} and TC,H=0T_{\mathrm{C},H=0} compared to data obtained for bare Si/SiO2_2//NbN(tNbNt_{\mathrm{NbN}}) (nm) stacks. The lines serve as visual guides. (d) Dependence of ΔTC/TC=(TC,demagnetized state−TC,saturated state)/TC,saturated state\Delta T_{\mathrm{C}}/T_{\mathrm{C}} = (T_{\mathrm{C,demagnetized\ state}} - T_{\mathrm{C,saturated\ state}}) / T_{\mathrm{C,saturated\ state}} with the superconducting coherence length to thickness ratio (ξNbN/tNbN\xi_{\mathrm{NbN}}/t_{\mathrm{NbN}}). The line is a linear fit to the data constrained to pass through (0,0).

Image not extracted

Figure 3. (color online) (a) Normalized magnetization M/MSM/M_{\mathrm{S}} of a Si/SiO2//[Pt(1)/Co(0.65)]15/IrMn(3)/NbN(15) (nm) stack for field cycling series. Measurements were performed at 12 K starting from a demagnetized state. Selected magnetic configurations are labeled as follows: (square) Saturated; (triangle) Intermediate; and (diamond) Demagnetized. The cooling procedures used to access each magnetic configuration are described in the text. (b) Data showing the TT-dependences of RR for the three magnetic states examined. (c) Dependence of ΔTC,i/TC\Delta T_{\mathrm{C,i}}/T_{\mathrm{C}} on 1−M/MS1-M/M_{\mathrm{S}}, where ΔTC,i\Delta T_{\mathrm{C,i}} represents the difference in superconducting critical temperature between any state and the saturated state.

Image not extracted

Figure 4. (color online) (a) Dependence of ΔTC,i/ΔTC\Delta T_{\mathrm{C,i}}/\Delta T_{\mathrm{C}} on 1−M/MS1-M/M_{\mathrm{S}} for Si/SiO2//[Pt(1)/Co(0.65)]n_n/IrMn(3)/NbN(15) (nm) stacks (n=4n = 4, 8, 11, 15), measured while applying an external field of H = 0.5 kOe. Lines were calculated using the model described in the text, for LF/ξS≈0.25L_{\mathrm{F}}/\xi_{\mathrm{S}} \approx0.25; 2.5; 5; 12.5; and 25. (b) Corresponding dependence of ΔTC/TC\Delta T_{\mathrm{C}}/T_{\mathrm{C}}, corresponding to (Tc,demagnetized state−Tc,saturated stateT_{\mathrm{c,demagnetized\ state}} - T_{\mathrm{c,saturated\ state}}) / Tc,saturated stateT_{\mathrm{c,saturated\ state}}) on the total thickness (tPt/Cot_{\mathrm{Pt/Co}}) of the [Pt/Co]n_n multilayer, measured at H = 0.5 and 1.3 kOe. (c) tPt/Cot_{\mathrm{Pt/Co}}-dependence of the domain sizes (wPt/Cow_{\mathrm{Pt/Co}}), deduced from MFM images taken at room temperature after demagnetization, ie for M/MS∼0M/M_{\mathrm{S}} \sim0. (Inset) Semilogarithmic-scale dependence of wPt/Cow_{\mathrm{Pt/Co}} on 1/tPt/Co1/t_{\mathrm{Pt/Co}}. Lines were fitted to the data using a model described in the text. (d) Control measurements for ξNbN\xi_{\mathrm{NbN}} and TC,H=0T_{\mathrm{C,H=0}} vs tPt/Cot_{\mathrm{Pt/Co}}.

Image not extracted

Figure 5. (color online) (a-b) tspacert_{\mathrm{spacer}}-dependence of ΔTC/TC\Delta T_{\mathrm{C}}/T_{\mathrm{C}} measured for Si/SiO2//[Pt(1)/Co(0.65)]15_{15}/spacer(tspacert_{\mathrm{spacer}})/NbN(15) (nm) stacks, for IrMn and Pt spacers. Lines

Image not extracted

Figure 5 (PDF p. 25). Correspond to exponential fits of the data (see text). (Inset) Corresponding semilogarithmic scale dependence of ΔTC/TC\Delta T_{\mathrm{C}}/T_{\mathrm{C}} on tspacert_{\mathrm{spacer}}.

Image not extracted

Figure 6. (color online) (a) Blocking temperature distribution measured for a Si/SiO2_2//[Pt(1)/Co(0.65)]4_4/IrMn(3)/NbN(15) (nm) stack. (b) Normalized magnetization M/MSM/M_{\mathrm{S}}, measured at 12 K for a Si/SiO2_2//[Pt(1)/Co(0.65)]15_{15}/IrMn(3)/NbN(15) (nm) stack, after stabilizing several states in the IrMn antiferromagnet (see text). (c) Corresponding normalized magnetization at the remanent state for H=0.5H = 0.5 kOe. (d) Dependence of ΔTC,i/TC\Delta T_{\mathrm{C},i}/T_{\mathrm{C}} on 1−M/MS1-M/M_{\mathrm{S}}.

Three-panel figure showing magnetization, resistance, and transition-temperature data

Figure 3 (PDF p. 28).

Four-panel plot showing magnetic and structural properties as functions of Pt/Co thickness

Figure 4 (PDF p. 29).

Plots of $\Delta T_{\mathrm{C}}/T_{\mathrm{C}}$ versus thicknesses

Figure 5 (PDF p. 30).

Four-panel plot showing antiferromagnetic amount, magnetization curves, initial-field magnetization, and relative transition temperature

Figure 6 (PDF p. 31).

References

  1. [1]A. I. Buzdin, Proximity Effects in Superconductor-Ferromagnet Heterostructures, Rev. Mod. Phys. 77, 935 (2005).DOI
  2. [2]J. Linder and J. W. A. Robinson, Superconducting Spintronics, Nat. Phys. 11, 307 (2015).DOI
  3. [3]L. R. Tagirov, Low-Field Superconducting Spin Switch Based on a Superconductor/Ferromagnet Multilayer, Phys. Rev. Lett. 83, 2058 (1999).DOI
  4. [4]J. Y. Gu, J. S. Jiang, J. Pearson, and S. D. Bader, Magnetization-Orientation Dependence of the Superconducting Transition Temperature in the Ferromagnet-Superconductor-Ferromagnet System : CuNi = Nb = CuNi, Phys. Rev. Lett. 89, 267001 (2002).DOI
  5. [5]A. Potenza and C. H. Marrows, Superconductor-Ferromagnet CuNi/Nb/CuNi Trilayers as Superconducting Spin-Valve Core Structures, Phys. Rev. B 71, 180503 (2005).DOI
  6. [6]R. Steiner and P. Ziemann, Magnetic Switching of the Superconducting Transition Temperature in Layered Ferromagnetic/Superconducting Hybrids: Spin Switch versus Stray Field Effects, Phys. Rev. B 74, 094504 (2006).DOI
  7. [7]D. Stamopoulos, E. Manios, and M. Pissas, Synergy of Exchange Bias with Superconductivity in Ferromagnetic- Superconducting Layered Hybrids: The Influence of in-Plane and out-of-Plane Magnetic Order on Superconductivity, Supercond. Sci. Technol. 20, 1205 (2007).DOI
  8. [8]Y. Aladyshkin, A. Fraerman, S. Mel’nikov, A. Ryzhov, V. Sokolov, and I. Buzdin, Domain-Wall Superconductivity in Hybrid Superconductor-Ferromagnet Structures, Phys. Rev. B 68, 184508 (2003).DOI
  9. [9]A. Y. Rusanov, M. Hesselberth, and J. Aarts, Enhancement of the Superconducting Transition Temperature in Nb = Permalloy Bilayers by Controlling the Domain State of the Ferromagnet, Phys. Rev. Lett. 93, 057002 (2004).DOI
  10. [10]M. Houzet and A. I. Buzdin, Theory of Domain-Wall Superconductivity in Superconductor/Ferromagnet Bilayers, Phys. Rev. B 74, 214507 (2006).DOI
  11. [11]A. Singh, C. Sürgers, and H. Löहneysen, Superconducting Spin Switch with Perpendicular Magnetic Anisotropy, Phys. Rev. B 75, 024513 (2007).DOI
  12. [12]L. Y. Zhu, T. Y. Chen, and C. L. Chien, Altering the Superconductor Transition Temperature by Domain-Wall Arrangements in Hybrid Ferromagnet-Superconductor Structures, Phys. Rev. Lett. 101, 017004 (2008).pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/18764146
  13. [13]M. Z. Cieplak, Z. Adamus, M. Kończykowski, L. Y. Zhu, X. M. Cheng, and C. L. Chien, Tuning Vortex Confinement by Magnetic Domains in a Superconductor/Ferromagnet Bilayer, Phys. Rev. B 87, 014519 (2013).DOI
  14. [14]Z. Yang, M. Lange, A. Volodin, R. Szymczak, and V. V. Moshchalkov, Domain-Wall Superconductivity in Superconductor-Ferromagnet Hybrids, Nat. Mater. 3, 793 (2004).pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/15467724
  15. [15]Y. Cheng and M. B. Stearns, Superconductivity of Nb / Cr Multilayers, J. App. Phys. 67, 118 (1990).DOI
  16. [16]M. Hübener, D. Tikhonov, I. AGarifullin, K. Westerholt, and H. Zabel, The Antiferromagnet / Superconductor Proximity Effect in Cr / V / Cr Trilayers M H Ubener, J. Phys. Condens. Matter 14, 8687 (2002).
  17. [17]B. L.Wu, Y. M. Yang, Z. B. Guo, Y. H.Wu, and J. J. Qiu, Suppression of Superconductivity in Nb by IrMn in IrMn / Nb Bilayers, Appl. Phys. Lett. 109, 152602 (2013).
  18. [18]C. Bell, J. Tarte, G. Burnell, W. Leung, D. J. Kang, and G. Blamire, Proximity and Josephson Effects in Superconductor/Antiferromagnetic Nb/γ-Fe50Mn50 Heterostructures, Phys. Rev. B 68, 144517 (2003).DOI
  19. [19]I. V. Bobkova, P. J. Hirschfeld, and Y. S. Barash, Spin-Dependent Quasiparticle Reflection and Bound States at Interfaces with Itinerant Antiferromagnets, Phys. Rev. Lett. 94, 037005 (2005).pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/15698311
  20. [20]B. M. Andersen, I. V. Bobkova, P. J. Hirschfeld, and Y. S. Barash, 0-π Transitions in Josephson Junctions with Antiferromagnetic Interlayers, Phys. Rev. Lett. 96, 117005 (2006).pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/16605855
  21. [21]P. Komissinskiy, G. A. Ovsyannikov, I. V. Borisenko, Y. V. Kislinskii, K. Y. Constantinian, A. V. Zaitsev, and D. Winkler, Josephson Effect in Hybrid Oxide Heterostructures with an Antiferromagnetic Layer, Phys. Rev. Lett. 99, 017004 (2007).pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/17678184
  22. [22]C. Bell, J. Tarte, G. Burnell, W. Leung, D. J. Kang, and G. Blamire, Proximity and Josephson Effects in Superconductor/Antiferromagnetic Nb/γ-Fe50Mn50heterostructures, Phys. Rev. B 68, 144517 (2003).DOI
  23. [23]V. Baltz, A. Manchon, M. Tsoi, T. Moriyama, T. Ono, and Y. Tserkovnyak, Antiferromagnetic Spintronics, Rev. Mod. Phys. 90, 015005 (2018).DOI
  24. [24]T. Jungwirth, X. Marti, P. Wadley, and J. Wunderlich, Antiferromagnetic Spintronics, Nat. Nanotechnol. 11, 231 (2016).
  25. [25]C. Canedy, X. Li, and G. Xiao, Large Magnetic Moment Enhancement and Extraordinary Hall Effect in Co/Pt Superlattices, Phys. Rev. B 62, 508 (2000).DOI
  26. [26]V. Baltz, A. Marty, B. Rodmacq, and B. Dieny, Magnetic Domain Replication in Interacting Bilayers with Out-of-Plane Anisotropy: Application to Co/Pt Multilayers, Phys. Rev. B 75, 014406 (2007).DOI
  27. [27]B. Kaplan and G. A. Gehring, The Domain Structure in Ultrathin Magnetic Films, J. Magn. Magn. Mater. 128, 111 (1993).DOI
  28. [28]P. D. Johnson, Reports on Progress in Physics Related Content, Rep. Prog. Phys. 60, 1217 (1997).
  29. [29]P. G. de Gennes, Superconductivity of Metals and Alloys (Cambridge, MA : Perseus, 1999).
  30. [30]A. Kohn, A. Kovács, R. Fan, G. J. McIntyre, R. C. C. Ward, and J. P. Goff, The Antiferromagnetic Structures of IrMn3 and Their Influence on Exchange-Bias., Sci. Rep. 3, 2412 (2013).DOI
  31. [31]F. S. Bergeret, M. Silaev, P. Virtanen, and T. T. Heikkilä, Colloquium: Nonequilibrium Effects in Superconductors with a Spin-Splitting Field, Rev. Mod. Phys. 90, 41001 (2018).DOI
  32. [32]S. Brück, J. Sort, V. Baltz, S. Suriñach, J. S. Muñoz, B. Dieny, M. D. Baró, and J. Nogués, Exploiting Length Scales of Exchange-Bias Systems to Fully Tailor Double-Shifted Hysteresis Loops, Adv. Mater. 17, 2978 (2005).DOI
  33. [33]G. Salazar-Alvarez, J. J. Kavich, J. Sort, A. Mugarza, S. Stepanow, A. Potenza, H. Marchetto, S. S. Dhesi, V. Baltz, B. Dieny, A. Weber, L. J. Heyderman, J. Nogues, and P. Gambardella, Direct Evidence of Imprinted Vortex States in the Antiferromagnet of Exchange Biased Microdisks, Appl. Phys. Lett. 95, 012510 (2009).
  34. [34]J. Wu, D. Carlton, J. S. Park, Y. Meng, E. Arenholz, A. Doran, A. T. Young, A. Scholl, C. Hwang, H. W. Zhao, J. Bokor, and Z. Q. Qiu, Direct Observation of Imprinted Antiferromagnetic Vortex States in CoO/Fe/Ag(001) Discs, Nat. Phys. 7, 303 (2011).DOI
  35. [35]S. Soeya, T. Imagawa, K. Mitsuoka, and S. Narishige, Distribution of Blocking Temperature in Bilayered Ni81Fe19/NiO Films, J. Appl. Phys. 76, 5356 (1994).DOI
  36. [36]V. Baltz, B. Rodmacq, A. Zarefy, L. Lechevallier, and B. Dieny, Bimodal Distribution of Blocking Temperature in Exchange-Biased Ferromagnetic/Antiferromagnetic Bilayers, Phys. Rev. B 81, 052404 (2010).DOI
  37. [37]A. I. Buzdin and Bulaevskii L. N., Ferromagnetic Film on the Surface of a Superconductor: Possible Onset of Inhomogeneous Magnetic Ordering, Sov. Phys. JETP 67, 576 (1988).

Paper details

vlnc:W_ntn5g6hu
Version
v1 · latest
Published
Fresh — added to the Hub within the last 30 days
Added
License
CC BY 4.0
Usage

views · 0

downloads · 0

A view counts once per browser per day, a download each time the PDF is requested.

  • Physics and Astronomy

Not recorded for this paper

View statement
Looking for related papers…
Contents