betaFeedback

WorksPhysics and Astronomy

On the determination of the 3D velocity field in terms of conserved variables in a compressible ocean

Abstract

Explicit expressions of the 3D velocity field in terms of the conserved quantities of ideal fluid thermocline theory, namely Bernoulli function, density, and potential vorticity, are generalised here to a compressible ocean with a realistic nonlinear equation of state. The most general such expression is the `inactive wind' solution, an exact nonlinear solution of the inviscid compressible Navier-Stokes that satisfies the continuity equation as a consequence of Ertel's potential vorticity theorem. Such expressions are shown to be non-unique due to the non-uniqueness of the choice of Bernoulli function and in general approximately differ by the magnitude of their vertical velocity component. Due to the thermobaric nonlinearity of the equation of state, the expression of the 3D velocity field for a compressible ocean is found to resemble its ideal fluid counterpart only if constructed in terms of the available form of Bernoulli function as per Lorenz theory of available potential energy (APE). APE theory also naturally defines a quasi-material approximately neutral density variable called Lorenz reference density, which in turn defines a potential vorticity variable minimally affected by thermobaric production, thus providing all necessary tools for extending most results of ideal fluid thermocline theory to a compressible ocean.

Introduction

Although oceanic observations have increased dramatically over the past decades, especially since the development of the Argo floats program (https://argo.ucsd.edu), these still primarily constrain the density stratification rather than the velocity field. As a result, even in the most sophisticated ocean state estimate products [1, 2, 3, 4], the realism of the simulated 3D oceanic velocity field v=(u,v,w)\mathbf{v}=(u,v,w) can rarely if ever be ascertained directly. Indeed, even when current meters are available, these usually contain high-frequency motions linked to tides and gravity waves not usually captured by numerical ocean models thus complicating the comparison. In any case, comparisons when possible are only limited to the horizontal velocity field as the vertical velocity is generally too small to be directly measurable.

Since for all practical purposes the 3D oceanic velocity field is never a measurable parameter of the system, the development of accurate dynamical theories predicting how to infer it from available oceanic observations plays an especially important role in physical oceanography. It is therefore no surprise that the subject has a long history going back to the early days of the discipline, which to date has primarily relied on the use of the dynamic method [5]. As is well known, the dynamic method assumes geostrophic and hydrostatic balances and provides an explicit expression of the horizontal velocity field in terms of vertical integrals of the horizontal density gradients relative to the velocity field at some reference level. Understanding how to specify the latter is one of the main challenges of the dynamic method and has given rise to many different approaches to tackle it. The simplest approach and most often encountered one in the literature assumes the existence of a level of no motion at which the geostrophic velocity vanishes, see [6] for a discussion of its limitations. Since then, such an approach has been superseded by the beta-spiral method of [7] or the inverse method(s) of [8, 9], whose connection is discussed in [10]. [11, 12, 13, 14] are examples of studies further discussing these ideas. At some point, there was hope that the sea surface height (SSH) signal measured by satellite altimetry would be accurate enough to constrain the surface geostrophic velocity field. However, this requires a more accurate determination of the geoid than is presently available. Moreover, the fact that the SSH signal is contaminated by small-scale and high-frequency processes, while also reflecting transient variations of the interior density field, complicates filtering out only the relevant part needed by the dynamic method [15]. More recently, measurements of Argo floats displacements have shown promise for constraining the geostrophic velocity at the floats’ parking depth, as recently demonstrated by [16, 17]. Nevertheless, some limitations remain as Argo floats displacements are also a priori impacted by energetic small scale and transient ageostrophic motions in addition to the geostrophic flow, which the authors sought to mitigate by averaging over the Argo period. Outside the Argo period, or when focusing on time snapshots, alternative/complementary approaches for constraining the unknown reference level are still needed.

While the geostrophic approximation is generally accepted to represent an accurate theory for the horizontal velocity field u=(u,v)\mathbf{u} = (u,v), how best to predict the vertical velocity field ww is in contrast much less understood and still actively debated. Physically, there are two main fundamental approaches for thinking about the vertical velocity field. The first approach, which as far as we are aware underlies the computation of the vertical velocity field in all existing numerical ocean models [18], is based on vertically integrating the continuity equation ∇h⋅u+wz=0\nabla_h \cdot\mathbf{u} + w_z = 0. Doing so yields an expression for ww controlled by the horizontal velocity divergence relative to the vertical velocity at some reference level zrz_r

w(x,y,z,t)=w(x,y,zr,t)⏟wr−∫zrz∇h⋅u dz′,(1)w(x,y,z,t) = \underbrace{w(x,y,z_r,t)}_{w_r} - \int_{z_r}^{z} \nabla_h \cdot\mathbf{u}\, dz', \tag*{(1)}

where ∇h\nabla_h is the horizontal nabla operator. As is well known, using the continuity equation in conjunction with geostrophy yields the celebrated linear Sverdrup balance βv=f∂w/∂z\beta v = f \partial w/\partial z, which may be integrated to yield

w=wr+βf∫zrzv dz′,(2)w = w_r + \frac{\beta}{f}\int_{z_r}^{z} v\, dz', \tag*{(2)}

see [19], where ff is the Coriolis parameter, and β=df/dy\beta= d f/dy, with yy denoting latitude. The second approach is based on extracting ww from the conservation equation ∂C/∂t+v⋅∇C=C˙\partial C/\partial t + \mathbf{v} \cdot\nabla C = \dot{C} of any conserved tracer CC, viz.,

w=(∂C∂z)−1(C˙−∂C∂t−u⋅∇hC),(3)w = \left(\frac{\partial C}{\partial z}\right)^{-1}\left(\dot{C} - \frac{\partial C}{\partial t} - \mathbf{u} \cdot\nabla_h C\right), \tag*{(3)}

where C˙\dot{C} represents the non-material sinks/sources of CC. Both approaches come with important theoretical challenges. In the first approach, the difficulty stems from the fact that the horizontal divergence ∇⋅u\nabla\cdot\mathbf{u} is often dominated by the ageostrophic component uag\mathbf{u}_{ag} of the velocity, in which case (2) may become very inaccurate. In the second approach, the difficult stems from that the time derivative ∂C/∂t\partial C/\partial t and (perhaps to a lesser extent) the diabatic term C˙\dot{C} may both be important for predicting the large-scale vertical velocity field, yet often hard (if at all possible) to constrain observationally. Existing approaches, therefore, can be regarded as attempts to mitigate such difficulties in some way. For instance, the well-known omega equation is obtained by artfully combining two prognostic equations (for vorticity and buoyancy respectively) in񎟂 a way that eliminate the time-derivative in each equation to formulate a diagnostic elliptic problem for the vertical velocity, see [20] for a recent implementation. Another approach of interest showing how to infer the vertical velocity from individual moorings is that proposed by [21].

Physically, one key reason that makes the second approach potentially the most attractive one is because if one ignores the difficulties associated with the time-dependent and diabatic terms ∂C/∂t\partial C/\partial t and C˙\dot{C} in (3), knowledge of the geostrophic velocity field is generally sufficient enough for accurately estimating the horizontal advection term −u⋅∇C-\mathbf{u}\cdot\nabla C. In contrast, knowledge of the ageostrophic velocity component uag\mathbf{u}_{ag} is often needed for an accurate determination of the horizontal velocity divergence in the first approach, as mentioned above. As a result, there has been much interest in seeking to exploit the existence of quasi-material conserved quantities to construct explicit expressions of the steady-state 3D velocity field. Thus, if C1C_1 and C2C_2 represent two independent conserved quantities, then it is well known that in a steady state the 3D velocity should lie at the intersection of two iso-surfaces of C1C_1 and C2C_2. Mathematically, this implies that the velocity field may be written in the form

v=λ∇C1×∇C2,(4)\mathbf{v}=\lambda\nabla C_1\times\nabla C_2, \tag*{(4)}

for some scalar field λ\lambda. Physically, the constraint determining λ\lambda is that the horizontal component of (4) be geostrophic either exactly or approximately. The conserved quantities C1C_1 and C2C_2 then determine the vertical velocity according to w=u⋅S1w=\mathbf{u}\cdot\mathbf{S}_1 or w=u⋅S2w=\mathbf{u}\cdot\mathbf{S}_2 or both, where S1\mathbf{S}_1 and S2\mathbf{S}_2 are the horizontal ‘slope’ vectors

Si=−(∂Ci∂t)−1u⋅∇hCi,i={1,2}.(5)\mathbf{S}_i=-\left(\frac{\partial C_i}{\partial t}\right)^{-1}\mathbf{u}\cdot\nabla_h C_i,\qquad i=\{1,2\}. \tag*{(5)}

Thus, depending on the conserved quantities considered, the relations w=u⋅S1w=\mathbf{u}\cdot\mathbf{S}_1 and w=u⋅S2w=\mathbf{u}\cdot\mathbf{S}_2 may or may not define the same vertical velocity. In practice, this means that the problem to be solved might be over-determined and that its resolution may need the use of least-squares.

While (4) can in principle be implemented in practice using a variety of conserved tracers, three particular quantities deserve special attention owing to their theoretical and dynamical importance in oceanography, namely: the Bernoulli function BB, potential vorticity QQ, and density ρ\rho. Physically, this is because these quantities are the ones underlying the ideal fluid thermocline equations [22] that have formed the basis for most ocean circulation theories, as well as those originally considered by Needler [23], who pioneered the use of (4). Unfortunately, such quantities have been so far unambiguously defined only for an ideal fluid, which significantly hinder our ability to evaluate the usefulness of (4) for the real compressible ocean. Although several studies have extended Needler’s approach since, e.g., [24, 25, 26, 27], most discussions with a few exceptions, e.g., [28, 29], have remained limited to the case of an ideal fluid in geostrophic balance. To make progress, this paper aims to show how to generalise Needler’s approach to the case of a fully compressible ocean, in order to be able to test its usefulness systematically in the future (which is beyond the scope of this paper). § 2 reviews the basic properties of the ideal fluid thermocline equations and introduce the concept of ‘available’ Bernoulli function. § 3 shows how to generalise ideal fluid thermocline theory to compressible seawater, and shows that the results is related to [30] ‘inactive wind’ solution. § 4 discusses the results and some perspectives.

Absolute velocity field based on ideal fluid thermocline theory

Thermodynamic form of ideal fluid thermocline equations

We begin by briefly reviewing the properties and structure of the ideal fluid thermocline equations [22] that underlie Needler’s determination of the absolute velocity field in terms of conserved properties [23]. Although most of the material is standard, an important new element is the introduction of the concept of ‘available’ Bernoulli function, where the term ‘available’ is meant to parallel that of Lorenz ‘available potential energy’ [31]. The ideal fluid thermocline equations are here written in the following form

fk×ρv+∇p=−ρgk,(6)f\mathbf{k} \times\rho\mathbf{v} + \nabla p = -\rho g\mathbf{k}, \tag*{(6)}
∇⋅v=0,(7)\nabla\cdot\mathbf{v} = 0, \tag*{(7)}
v⋅∇ρ=0,(8)\mathbf{v} \cdot\nabla\rho= 0, \tag*{(8)}

and respectively describe the geostrophic and hydrostatic momentum balance, continuity, and conservation of density respectively, where v=(u,v,w)\mathbf{v} = (u,v,w) is the three-dimensional velocity field, pp is pressure, ρ\rho is density, gg is the acceleration of gravity, ff is the Coriolis parameter, and k\mathbf{k} is the unit vector pointing upward. While the geostrophic and hydrostatic balances are expected to meaningfully describe the balanced part of the flow even under transient evolution for sufficiently small Rossby number, the steady form of the density equation (8) is in contrast much more difficult to justify rigorously, especially without clarity as to what density variable ρ\rho is supposed to represent. Presumably, any justification of (8) must require consideration of some form of temporal averaging that does not introduce eddy-correlation terms, such as thickness-weighted averaging [32]. As the issue is quite complex and cannot fully be addressed without having first clarified the exact nature of ρ\rho, its full treatment is deferred to a subsequent study.

The main key step for linking the velocity field to the conserved quantities of the system is to rewrite the momentum (6) in its thermodynamic form (also known as the Crocco-Vazsonyi form [33, 34]),

fk×ρv+ρ∗∇Bhideal=ρ∗Πhideal,Πhideal=gz∇ρρ∗,(9)f\mathbf{k} \times\rho\mathbf{v} + \rho_{\ast}\nabla B_{h}^{ideal} = \rho_{\ast}\Pi_{h}^{ideal}, \qquad\Pi_{h}^{ideal} = \frac{g z\nabla\rho}{\rho_{\ast}}, \tag*{(9)}

where Bhideal=(p+ρgz)/ρ∗B_{h}^{ideal} = (p+\rho g z)/\rho_{\ast} is the standard Bernoulli function and ρ∗\rho_{\ast} is a constant Boussinesq reference density.

Available and background Bernoulli functions

A key idea of this paper is that Lorenz APE theory holds the key to understanding how to generalise the key ingredients of ideal fluid thermocline theory, that is the Bernoulli function, potential vorticity, and density, to a compressible ocean. The key ingredients needed here are the reference pressure and density profiles p0(z)p_{0}(z) and ρ0(z)\rho_{0}(z) characterising Lorenz reference state of minimun potential energy obtainable by means of an adiabatic an isohaline re-arrangement of mass, and the reference position of a fluid parcel zrz_{r} defined as a solution of the level of neutral buoyancy (LNB) equation ρ=ρ0(zr)\rho=\rho_{0}(z_{r}), which defines zr=zr(ρ)z_{r}=z_{r}(\rho) as a function of density only [35, 36, 37]. Physically, APE theory is useful for providing a physical mean to tease apart the part of the potential energy that is available for reversible conversions with kinetic energy (the APE) from the dynamically inert part (the BPE) that is not. Because the Bernoulli function Bhideal=(p+ρgz)/ρ∗B_{h}^{ideal}=(p+\rho g z)/\rho_{\ast} is thermodynamic in nature, the same idea that only a fraction of it is available for reversible conversions with kinetic energy must apply. This motivates us to define its dynamically inert part in a Lagrangian sense as its value in Lorenz reference state, viz.,

Brideal=p0(zr)+ρ0(zr)gzrρ∗,(10)B_{r}^{ideal} = \frac{p_{0}(z_{r})+\rho_{0}(z_{r})g z_{r}}{\rho_{\ast}}, \tag*{(10)}

and the ‘available’ part of the Bernoulli function as

ρ⋆Baideal=ρ⋆(Bhideal−Brideal)=p−p0(z)+p0(z)−p0(zr)+ρg(z−zr)=p−p0(z)+∫zrzg(ρ−ρ0(z′)) dz′⏟ρ⋆Ea(11)\rho_\star B_a^{ideal}=\rho_\star(B_h^{ideal}-B_r^{ideal})=p-p_0(z)+p_0(z)-p_0(z_r)+\rho g(z-z_r) = p-p_0(z)+\underbrace{\int_{z_r}^{z}g(\rho-\rho_0(z'))\,\mathrm{d}z'}_{\rho_\star E_a} \tag*{(11)}

using the fact that p0′(z)=−gρ0(z)p_0'(z)=-g\rho_0(z) and ρ0(zr)=ρ\rho_0(z_r)=\rho by definition, where the underbraced quantity EaE_a can be recognised as the positive definite APE density originally introduced by [38] and [39] and later extended to multi-component Boussinesq and stratified fluids by [35, 37]. Physically, the APE density may be written as the work against buoyancy forces needed to bring a fluid parcel from its level of neutral buoyancy zrz_r (hence satisfying b(S,θ,zr)=0b(S,\theta,z_r)=0)) to its actual position, viz.,

Ea=−∫zrzb(S,θ,z′) dz′(12)E_a=-\int_{z_r}^{z}b(S,\theta,z')\,\mathrm{d}z' \tag*{(12)}

the only difference between the expressions for a Boussinesq and general compressible fluid being in the expressions for the buoyancy bb. For a Boussinesq fluid, b=−g(ρ−ρ0(z))/ρ⋆b=-g(\rho-\rho_0(z))/\rho_\star, while for compressible seawater discussed in next section b=−g[1−ρ0(z)v(S,θ,p0(z))]b=-g[1-\rho_0(z)v(S,\theta,p_0(z))]. Note that since ρ=ρ0(zr)\rho=\rho_0(z_r), ρ⋆Ea\rho_\star E_a may also be rewritten as

ρ⋆Ea=−g∫zrz∫zrz′dρ0dz(z′′) dz′′ dz′(13)\rho_\star E_a=-g\int_{z_r}^{z}\int_{z_r}^{z'}\frac{\mathrm{d}\rho_0}{\mathrm{d}z}(z'')\,\mathrm{d}z''\,\mathrm{d}z' \tag*{(13)}

so that for small departure from the reference position,

Ea≈−gρ⋆dρ0dz(zr)(z−zr)22=Nr2(z−zr)22(14)E_a\approx-\frac{g}{\rho_\star}\frac{\mathrm{d}\rho_0}{\mathrm{d}z}(z_r)\frac{(z-z_r)^2}{2}=\frac{N_r^2(z-z_r)^2}{2} \tag*{(14)}

which the reader unfamiliar with APE may still recognise, and which makes the positive definite character of EaE_a clearer if needed. If we remove ∇Br\nabla B_r from both sides of (9), using the easily verified result that ∇Br=gzr∇ρ\nabla B_r=gz_r\nabla\rho, yields the following available thermodynamic form of momentum balance

fk×ρv+ρ⋆∇Baideal=ρ⋆Paideal,ρ⋆Paideal=g(z−zr)∇ρ.(15)f\mathbf{k}\times\rho\mathbf{v}+\rho_\star\nabla B_a^{ideal}=\rho_\star\mathbf{P}_a^{ideal},\qquad\rho_\star\mathbf{P}_a^{ideal}=g(z-z_r)\nabla\rho. \tag*{(15)}

A key point to note here is that in both (9) and (15), the two P-vectors Phideal\mathbf{P}_h^{ideal} and Paideal\mathbf{P}_a^{ideal} are proportional to the gradient of density ∇ρ\nabla\rho, and therefore perpendicular to the isopycnal surfaces ρ=constant\rho=\mathrm{constant}. We shall see in § 3 that this property is lost in a compressible ocean. It is of interest to note that Phideal\mathbf{P}_h^{ideal} is the ideal fluid counterpart of the P-vector previously identified by [40].

Bernoulli and Potential vorticity (PV) theorems

The Bernoulli theorem [41] and Ertel’s PV conservation theorem [42, 43] play a key role in this paper. As regards to the former, it is trivially obtained by taking the inner product of (9) and (15) by v\mathbf{v}, accounting for (8), which immediately yields v⋅∇Bh=0\mathbf{v}\cdot\nabla B_h=0 and v⋅∇Ba=0\mathbf{v}\cdot\nabla B_a=0. The proof of the potential vorticity (PV) conservation theorem is somewhat more involved. To obtain it, first divide (6) by ρ\rho and take the curl thus leading to

k(v⋅∇f)−f∂v∂z=∇ρ×∇pρ2.(16)\mathbf{k}(\mathbf{v}\cdot\nabla f)-f\frac{\partial\mathbf{v}}{\partial z}=\frac{\nabla\rho\times\nabla p}{\rho^2}. \tag*{(16)}

Next, take the inner product of (16) by ∇ρ\nabla\rho, which then yields

∂ρ∂zv⋅∇f−f∇ρ⋅∂v∂z=v⋅∇(f∂ρ∂z)=0,(17)\frac{\partial\rho}{\partial z}\mathbf{v}\cdot\nabla f-f\nabla\rho\cdot\frac{\partial\mathbf{v}}{\partial z}=\mathbf{v}\cdot\nabla\left(f\frac{\partial\rho}{\partial z}\right)=0, \tag*{(17)}

which establishes the material conservation of the potential vorticity (PV) Q=(f/ρ⋆)∂ρ/∂zQ=(f/\rho_{\star})\partial\rho/\partial z as expected.

Determination of the absolute velocity field in terms of conserved quantities

Taking the cross product of ∇ρ\nabla\rho with (9) or (15), and using the result that ∇ρ×(fk×v)=(v⋅∇ρ)fk−(f∇ρ⋅k)v=−fρzv\nabla\rho\times(f\mathbf{k}\times\mathbf{v})=(\mathbf{v}\cdot\nabla\rho)f\mathbf{k}-(f\nabla\rho\cdot\mathbf{k})\mathbf{v}=-f\rho_z\mathbf{v} (which follows from the vector algebra relation A×(B×C)=(A⋅C)B−(A⋅B)C\mathbf{A}\times(\mathbf{B}\times\mathbf{C})=(\mathbf{A}\cdot\mathbf{C})\mathbf{B}-(\mathbf{A}\cdot\mathbf{B})\mathbf{C} and conservation of density v⋅∇ρ=0\mathbf{v}\cdot\nabla\rho=0, with ρz\rho_z being shorthand for ∂ρ/∂z\partial\rho/\partial z) leads after some manipulation to the following explicit expression of v\mathbf{v} previously obtained by [23],

ρv=∇ρ×∇BQ,(18)\rho\mathbf{v}=\frac{\nabla\rho\times\nabla B}{Q}, \tag*{(18)}

which explicitly relies on density and the Bernoulli function being conserved following fluid parcels, regardless of which form of Bernoulli function is used (BB refers indifferently to BhB_h or BaB_a).

To show that (18) naturally satisfies the continuity equation as a consequence of Ertel’s PV conservation theorem, simply take its divergence, which yields

∇⋅(ρv)=−(∇ρ×∇B)⋅∇QQ2=−ρv⋅∇QQ=0,(19)\nabla\cdot(\rho\mathbf{v})=-\frac{(\nabla\rho\times\nabla B)\cdot\nabla Q}{Q^2}=-\frac{\rho\mathbf{v}\cdot\nabla Q}{Q}=0, \tag*{(19)}

QED. As a result, (18) represents an exact steady solution of the ideal fluid equations (6-8) that also predicts the vertical velocity

ρw=k⋅(∇hρ×∇hB)Q,(20)\rho w=\frac{\mathbf{k}\cdot(\nabla_h\rho\times\nabla_h B)}{Q}, \tag*{(20)}

not just the horizontal velocity, where ∇h\nabla_h denotes the horizontal gradient. Importantly, Needler’s formula (22) is insensitive to the particular choice of Bernoulli function — BB or BaB_a — used to estimate it due to Br=Br(ρ)B_r=B_r(\rho) being a function of ρ\rho only.

Bernoulli method

Physically, one key reason why Needler’s formula (18) is appealing is because the idea that the steady or time-averaged 3D velocity field should lie at the intersection of the iso-surfaces of two conserved quantities is a priori valid beyond the geostrophic approximation. Its other key advantage is that it naturally satisfies the continuity equation as a consequence of Ertel potential vorticity conservation theorem, which also generalises beyond the geostrophic approximation, as discussed in next section. In the context of the dynamic method, however, Needler’s formula does not in itself solve the problem of the unknown reference level. Indeed, because ∇hB=∇hp+gz∇hρ\nabla_hB=\nabla_hp+gz\nabla_h\rho, it is easily verified that the horizontal velocity that it predicts is the standard geostrophic balance, while the vertical velocity predicted by (20) is actually the one predicted more easily from the density equation v⋅∇ρ=0\mathbf{v}\cdot\nabla\rho=0, i.e.,

w=−(∂ρ∂z)−1u⋅∇hρ=u⋅Sρ,(21)w=-\left(\frac{\partial\rho}{\partial z}\right)^{-1}\mathbf{u}\cdot\nabla_h\rho=\mathbf{u}\cdot\mathbf{S}_{\rho}, \tag*{(21)}

where Sρ\mathbf{S}_{\rho} is the slope vector associated with the isopycnal surfaces. In other words, Needler’s formula does not solve the problem of the unknown reference level because the Bernoulli function depends on the same unknown constant of integration as the pressure field.

To circumvent the difficulty and turn (18) into something concretely useful, it is necessary to invoke the result that if ρ\rho, BB, and QQ are all conserved along fluid parcel trajectories, they must be functionally related. Thus, to the extent that such a result holds and that this functional relationship may be written in the form B=G(ρ,Q)B = G(\rho,Q), it become possible to rewrite (18) as

ρv=∂G∂Q∇ρ×∇QQ,(22)\rho\mathbf{v} = \frac{\partial G}{\partial Q}\frac{\nabla\rho\times\nabla Q}{Q}, \tag*{(22)}

[23]. Now, the key advantage of (22) over (18) is that the term (∇ρ×∇Q)/Q(\nabla\rho\times\nabla Q)/Q can in principle be empirically estimated from climatological fields without having to solve the problem of the unknown reference level, since the latter neither affects ρ\rho nor QQ. In other words, (22) provides a determination of the absolute velocity field up to the multiplicative constant ∂G/∂Q\partial G/\partial Q. In this approach, the problem of the unknown reference level therefore transforms into the problem of how best to evaluate the functional relationship G(ρ,Q)G(\rho,Q) and the partial derivative ∂G/∂Q\partial G/\partial Q. For related discussions of these ideas, the reader is referred to, e.g., [13, 24, 25, 26, 27, 28, 44, 45]. However, it seems fair to say that the current empirical evidence for a well defined relationship B=B(ρ,Q)B = B(\rho,Q) is inconclusive at best. Current approaches, however, have relied on using the conventional form of Bernoulli function B=BhB = B_h rather than its available form B=BaB = B_a. It will be of interest in future studies to test whether using BaB_a, as well as the density variable discussed in next section, can lead to a better defined relationship Ba=Ba(ρ,Q)B_a = B_a(\rho,Q).

Generalisation to compressible seawater

Governing equations for compressible seawater

We now turn to a realistic nonlinear ocean described by the compressible Navier-Stokes equations, treating seawater as a two-constituent stratified fluid:

DvDt+2Ω×v+1ρ∇p=−∇Φ+F,(23)\frac{D\mathbf{v}}{Dt} + 2\boldsymbol{\Omega} \times\mathbf{v} + \frac{1}{\rho}\nabla p = -\nabla\Phi+ \mathbf{F}, \tag*{(23)}
∂ρ∂t+∇⋅(ρv)=0,(24)\frac{\partial\rho}{\partial t} + \nabla\cdot(\rho\mathbf{v}) = 0, \tag*{(24)}
DηDt=η˙,DSDt=S˙,(25)\frac{D\eta}{Dt} = \dot{\eta}, \qquad\frac{DS}{Dt} = \dot{S}, \tag*{(25)}
ν=1ρ=ν(η,S,p),(26)\nu= \frac{1}{\rho} = \nu(\eta,S,p), \tag*{(26)}

where η\eta is the specific entropy, SS is salinity, ν=1/ρ\nu= 1/\rho is the specific volume, F\mathbf{F} is a friction force, and Φ=gz\Phi= gz is the geopotential. Moreover, η˙\dot{\eta} and S˙\dot{S} denote the diabatic sources/sinks of heat and salt due to molecular diffusive fluxes (radiation can be included if needed). As in the previous section, the first step is to rewrite the momentum balance (23) in its thermodynamic or Crocco-Vazsonyi form

∂v∂t+ωa×v+∇Bh=Ph+F,(27)\frac{\partial\mathbf{v}}{\partial t} + \boldsymbol{\omega}_a \times\mathbf{v} + \nabla B_h = \mathbf{P}_h + \mathbf{F}, \tag*{(27)}

where ωa=ξ+2Ω\boldsymbol{\omega}_a = \boldsymbol{\xi} + 2\boldsymbol{\Omega} is the absolute vorticity, ξ=∇×v\boldsymbol{\xi} = \nabla\times\mathbf{v} is the relative vorticity. The result was obtained by using the well known relation (v⋅∇)v=∇(v2/2)+ξ×v(\mathbf{v} \cdot\nabla)\mathbf{v} = \nabla(\mathbf{v}^2/2) + \boldsymbol{\xi} \times\mathbf{v} as well as the total differential for specific enthalpy dh=Tdη+μdS+νdpdh = T d\eta+ \mu dS + \nu dp, where TT is the in-situ temperature, μ\mu the relative chemical potential. For a compressible ocean, the conventional form of Bernoulli function is

Bh=v22+h(η,S,p)+Φ(z),(28)B_h = \frac{\mathbf{v}^2}{2} + h(\eta,S,p) + \Phi(z), \tag*{(28)}

while the P-vector Ph\mathbf{P}_h is the vector that retains the thermohaline gradient of hh, viz.,

Ph=∂h∂η∇η+∂h∂S∇S=T∇η+μ∇S.(29)\mathbf{P}_h = \frac{\partial h}{\partial\eta}\nabla\eta+ \frac{\partial h}{\partial S}\nabla S = T\nabla\eta+ \mu\nabla S. \tag*{(29)}

As in the previous section, we introduce the available Bernoulli function as Ba=Bh−BrB_a = B_h - B_r, that is, as the difference between the conventional form of Bernoulli function BhB_h and the background Bernoulli function

Br=h(η,S,p0(zr))+Φ(zr)(30)B_r = h(\eta,S,p_0(z_r)) + \Phi(z_r) \tag*{(30)}

where as before, zr=zr(η,S)z_r = z_r(\eta,S) is the reference height of a fluid parcel in Lorenz reference state of minimum potential energy, which in practice may be computed using the computationally efficient algorithm of Saenz et al. [36]. Physically, zrz_r is as before defined as a solution of the level of neutral buoyancy equation, which for two-component compressible seawater takes the form

υ(η,S,p0(zr))=υ0(zr),(31)\upsilon(\eta,S,p_0(z_r)) = \upsilon_0(z_r), \tag*{(31)}

where υ0(z)=1/ρ0(z)\upsilon_0(z) = 1/\rho_0(z). The available Bernoulli function may thus be written in the form

Ba=v22+h(η,S,p)−h(η,S,pr)+g(z−zr)=v22+Π+p−p0(z)ρ(32)\begin{aligned} B_a = \frac{\mathbf{v}^2}{2} + h(\eta,S,p) - h(\eta,S,p_r) + g(z-z_r) \\ &= \frac{\mathbf{v}^2}{2} + \Pi+ \frac{p-p_0(z)}{\rho} \tag*{(32)} \end{aligned}

where Π=Π1+Π2\Pi= \Pi_1 + \Pi_2 is the potential energy density defined in [37], with Π1\Pi_1 and Π2\Pi_2 the subcomponents

Π1=h(η,S,p)−h(η,S,p0(z))+p0(z)−pρ,(33)\Pi_1 = h(\eta,S,p) - h(\eta,S,p_0(z)) + \frac{p_0(z)-p}{\rho}, \tag*{(33)}
Π2=h(η,S,p0(z))−h(η,S,p0(zr))+g(z−zr)(34)\Pi_2 = h(\eta,S,p_0(z)) - h(\eta,S,p_0(z_r)) + g(z-z_r) \tag*{(34)}

As explained and demonstrated in [37], both Π1\Pi_1 and Π2\Pi_2 are positive definite. Π1\Pi_1 may be interpreted as the available compressible energy (ACE), which represents the expansion/contraction work required to compress/expand from the reference pressure p0(z)p_0(z) to the actual pressure. As to Π2\Pi_2, it is the APE density and represents the work against buoyancy forces required to move the fluid parcel from its reference position zrz_r at pressure p0(zr)=prp_0(z_r) = p_r to its actual position zz at pressure p0(z)p_0(z). As before, the available thermodynamic form of momentum balance is obtained by removing ∇Br=Tr∇η+μr∇S\nabla B_r = T_r\nabla\eta+ \mu_r\nabla S on both sides of (27), which leads to

∂v∂t+ωa×v+∇Ba=Pa+F(35)\frac{\partial\mathbf{v}}{\partial t} + \boldsymbol{\omega}_a \times\mathbf{v} + \nabla B_a = \mathbf{P}_a + \mathbf{F} \tag*{(35)}

where the P-vector Pa\mathbf{P}_a takes the form

Pa=(T−Tr)∇η+(μ−μr)∇S.(36)\mathbf{P}_a = (T-T_r)\nabla\eta+ (\mu-\mu_r)\nabla S. \tag*{(36)}

Note that the suffix ’r’ denote thermodynamic quantities estimated at the reference pressure pr=p0(zr)p_r = p_0(z_r).

Comparison of ideal and compressible forms of Bernoulli functions and P-vectors

In an ideal fluid, Needler’s formula (18) defines the 3D velocity field as being perpendicular to the density surfaces ρ=constant\rho= \text{constant} regardless of which particular form of (B,P)(B, P) is used, due to PhidealP_h^{ideal} and PaidealP_a^{ideal} being both parallel to ∇ρ\nabla\rho in that case. The 3D velocity field is also perpendicular to the iso-surfaces of the Bernoulli function in both cases, but the iso-surfaces of BhidealB_h^{ideal} and BaidealB_a^{ideal} should in general appear distinct from each other. Whether the available form (Baideal,Paideal)(B_a^{ideal}, P_a^{ideal}) is superior over the conventional form (Bhideal,Phideal)(B_h^{ideal}, P_h^{ideal}) cannot be determined from theoretical considerations alone; however, it is possible that the assumed empirical functional relationship B=B(ρ,Q)B = B(\rho, Q) underlying the Bernoulli method might be more accurately achieved in climatological observations of the density field for one of (B,P)(B, P) forms.

The situation is different for compressible seawater, however, as PaP_a and PhP_h now define different directions in general, as is clear from their expressions (29) and (36). Moreover, it is easily verified that both P-vectors have a non zero helicity Hp=P⋅(∇×P)H_p = \mathbf{P} \cdot(\nabla\times\mathbf{P}) because of thermobaricity and are therefore both non-integrable. Mathematically, this means that it is not possible to identify a well defined seawater variable whose iso-surfaces are everywhere perpendicular to P\mathbf{P}. From a theoretical viewpoint, this is both interesting and important, as it suggests that the superior form of (B,P)(B, P) may be the one for which the compressible and ideal expressions resemble the most to each other.

To explore this idea, Table 1 summarises the forms of Bernoulli function and P-vectors for an ideal and compressible forms established in the previous sections, while Figure 1 illustrates the 4 different types of Bernoulli functions along the 30°W meridional section in the Atlantic Ocean. We used the WOCE climatological dataset [46] and computed the hydrostatic pressure assuming a level of no motion at 1500 m. The Lorenz reference density and pressure profiles, as well as the computation of the reference depths, were computed as in [47]. The contribution from the kinetic energy was ignored. This figure clearly shows that the Bernoulli function depends sensitively on the approach considered as well as on the choice of the arbitrary constants entering the definition of the specific enthalpy as defined by TEOS-10 (www.teos10.org). Panel (a) shows the ideal standard Bernoulli function to be dominated by its depth variations, with values increasing with height from −700 J kg−1-700\,\mathrm{J\,kg^{-1}} at depth to close to 0 at the surface. In contrast, the compressible standard Bernoulli function (Panel (b)), which depends on the TEOS-10 definition of specific enthalpy, is dominated by thermal variations ∝cpθ\propto c_p\theta near the surface that results in much bigger values overall, which also increase with height from about close to zero at depth to about 60,000 J kg−1\mathrm{J\,kg^{-1}} near the surface. The ideal and compressible forms of Bernoulli function are depicted in Panels (c) and (d) respectively. Although our theory predicts that the ideal and compressible available Bernoulli functions should be close to each other, this is not the case in practice because our prediction (11) assumes an incompressible ρ\rho, which is not true of in-situ density. Panel (d) shows that the compressible available Bernoulli function BaB_a is dominated by horizontal variations, which seems an optimal behaviour for plotting it on isopycnal surfaces as will be discussed in details in a subsequent study. Note that the range of values exhibited by BaB_a, comprised between 0 and 20 J kg−1\mathrm{J\,kg^{-1}} approximately, is considerably smaller than that of all other Bernoulli functions, confirming the idea that BaB_a is the only one not affected by irrelevant dynamical information, which we hope can be exploited in the future.

Illustrative examples of Bernoulli functions

Figure 1. Illustrative examples of the different kinds of Bernoulli functions considered in this paper (in J kg−1^{-1}) along the 30∘W30^\circ\mathrm{W} meridional section in the Atlantic Ocean, with the hydrostatic pressure assuming a level of no motion at 1500 m. (a) BhidealB_h^{\mathrm{ideal}}; (b) BhB_h; (c) BaidealB_a^{\mathrm{ideal}}; (d) BaB_a.

QuantityIdealCompressible
BhB_hp+ρgzρ∗\dfrac{p+\rho gz}{\rho_*}h(η,S,p)+gzh(\eta,S,p)+gz
BaB_aEa+p−p0(z)ρ∗E_a+\dfrac{p-p_0(z)}{\rho_*}Π1+Π2+p−p0(z)ρ\Pi_1+\Pi_2+\dfrac{p-p_0(z)}{\rho}
Ph\mathbf{P}_hgz∇ρρ∗\dfrac{gz\nabla\rho}{\rho_*}T∇η+μ∇ST\nabla\eta+\mu\nabla S
Pa\mathbf{P}_ag(z−zr)∇ρρ∗\dfrac{g(z-z_r)\nabla\rho}{\rho_*}(T−Tr)∇η+(μ−μr)∇S(T-T_r)\nabla\eta+(\mu-\mu_r)\nabla S

Table 1. Comparison of the ideal and compressible forms of Bernoulli function and P-vectors. Note that the Bernoulli functions for a compressible fluid don’t include the kinetic energy term.

Conventional Bernoulli function

Contrasting the ideal and compressible forms of the conventional Bernoulli function,

p+ρgzρ∗↔h(η,S,p)+gz(37)\frac{p+\rho gz}{\rho_*} \leftrightarrow h(\eta,S,p)+gz \tag*{(37)}

makes it clear that the two expressions are not easily related. The difference in behaviour between BhB_h and BhidealB_h^{\mathrm{ideal}} can be further evidenced by contrasting their vertical derivative for instance, leading to

∂Bhideal∂z=∂∂z(p+ρgzρ⋆)=gzρ⋆∂ρ∂z,(38)\frac{\partial B_h^{ideal}}{\partial z}=\frac{\partial}{\partial z}\left(\frac{p+\rho gz}{\rho_\star}\right)=\frac{gz}{\rho_\star}\frac{\partial\rho}{\partial z}, \tag*{(38)}
∂Bh∂z=∂∂z(h+gz)=T∂η∂z+μ∂S∂z.(39)\frac{\partial B_h}{\partial z}=\frac{\partial}{\partial z}(h+gz)=T\frac{\partial\eta}{\partial z}+\mu\frac{\partial S}{\partial z}. \tag*{(39)}

In order to link ∂Bh/∂z\partial B_h/\partial z to the vertical derivative of some density variable one needs to make use of the Maxwell relations attached to the total differential of enthalpy dh=Tdη+μdS+vdp\mathrm{d}h=T\mathrm{d}\eta+\mu\mathrm{d}S+v\mathrm{d}p, obtained by stating the equality of the cross derivatives, viz.,

∂2h∂η∂p=∂T∂p=∂v∂η∂2h∂S∂p=∂μ∂p=∂v∂S.(40)\frac{\partial^2h}{\partial\eta\partial p}=\frac{\partial T}{\partial p}=\frac{\partial v}{\partial\eta} \qquad \frac{\partial^2h}{\partial S\partial p}=\frac{\partial\mu}{\partial p}=\frac{\partial v}{\partial S}. \tag*{(40)}

To proceed, let us now introduce some reference pressure p⋆=p0(z⋆)p_\star=p_0(z_\star) envisioned as being not too different from pp, defining the reference values T⋆=T(η,S,p⋆)T_\star=T(\eta,S,p_\star) and μ⋆=μ(η,S,p⋆)\mu_\star=\mu(\eta,S,p_\star). If we also use use the approximation p≈p0(z)p\approx p_0(z), (39) may be rewritten as

∂Bh∂z=∫p⋆p∂v∂η dp′∂η∂z+∫p⋆p∂v∂S dp′∂S∂z+T⋆∂η∂z+μ⋆∂S∂z≈(p−p⋆)(1vη∂η∂z+1vS∂S∂z)+T⋆∂η∂z+μ⋆∂S∂z≈g(z−z⋆)ρ⋆∂ρlr∂z+T⋆∂η∂z+μ⋆∂S∂z.(41)\begin{aligned} \frac{\partial B_h}{\partial z}&=\int_{p_\star}^{p}\frac{\partial v}{\partial\eta}\,\mathrm{d}p'\frac{\partial\eta}{\partial z}+\int_{p_\star}^{p}\frac{\partial v}{\partial S}\,\mathrm{d}p'\frac{\partial S}{\partial z}+T_\star\frac{\partial\eta}{\partial z}+\mu_\star\frac{\partial S}{\partial z}\\ &\approx(p-p_\star)\left(\frac{1}{v_\eta}\frac{\partial\eta}{\partial z}+\frac{1}{v_S}\frac{\partial S}{\partial z}\right)+T_\star\frac{\partial\eta}{\partial z}+\mu_\star\frac{\partial S}{\partial z}\\ &\approx\frac{g(z-z_\star)}{\rho_\star}\frac{\partial\rho_{\mathrm{lr}}}{\partial z}+T_\star\frac{\partial\eta}{\partial z}+\mu_\star\frac{\partial S}{\partial z}. \tag*{(41)} \end{aligned}

where ρlr\rho_{\mathrm{lr}} is the potential density referenced to p⋆p_\star (or more accurately to (p⋆+p)/2(p_\star+p)/2), where the result assumed that p⋆p_\star is close enough to pp that the overbar value can be approximated by their values at p⋆p_\star. While the first term of (41) succeeds in showing dependence on the vertical derivative of some density variable that makes it directly comparable to dBhideal/dzdB_h^{ideal}/dz, the second term is extraneous. Using the same ideas, it is also easily established that the same difficulties exist for relating PhP_h to PhidealP_h^{ideal}.

Available Bernoulli function

In contrast, it is immediately apparent that the ideal and compressible available Bernoulli functions

Ea+p−p0(z)ρ⋆↔Π1+Π2+p−p0(z)ρ(42)E_a+\frac{p-p_0(z)}{\rho_\star} \quad\leftrightarrow\quad \Pi_1+\Pi_2+\frac{p-p_0(z)}{\rho} \tag*{(42)}

are directly comparable, as BaidealB_a^{ideal} can be obtained from BaB_a by neglecting Π1\Pi_1 and replacing ρ\rho by ρ⋆\rho_\star in (p−p0(z))/ρ(p-p_0(z))/\rho, as Tailleux [37] showed Π2\Pi_2 to closely resemble EaE_a. Likewise, it is possible to show that the APE-based P-vectors resemble each other

g(z−zr)∇ρρ⋆↔(T−Tr)∇η+(μ−μr)∇S(43)\frac{g(z-z_r)\nabla\rho}{\rho_\star} \quad\leftrightarrow\quad (T-T_r)\nabla\eta+(\mu-\mu_r)\nabla S \tag*{(43)}

To see the connection, one may use the Maxwell relations (40) to establish that

Pa=(T−Tr)∇η+(μ−μr)∇S=∫prp∂v∂η(η,S,p′) dp′∇η+∫prp∂v∂S(η,S,p′) dp′∇S=(p−pr)(v‾η∇η+v‾S∇S)≈g(z−zr)ρ‾(ρ‾η∇η+ρ‾S∇S)(44)\begin{aligned} \mathbf{P}_a &= (T-T_r)\nabla\eta+(\mu-\mu_r)\nabla S \\ &= \int_{p_r}^{p}\frac{\partial v}{\partial\eta}(\eta,S,p')\,\mathrm{d}p'\nabla\eta+\int_{p_r}^{p}\frac{\partial v}{\partial S}(\eta,S,p')\,\mathrm{d}p'\nabla S \\ &=(p-p_r)(\overline{v}_{\eta}\nabla\eta+\overline{v}_{S}\nabla S) \\ &\approx\frac{g(z-z_r)}{\overline{\rho}}(\overline{\rho}_{\eta}\nabla\eta+\overline{\rho}_{S}\nabla S) \tag*{(44)} \end{aligned}

using the fact that vη=−ρη/ρ2v_{\eta}=-\rho_{\eta}/\rho^2, vS=−ρS/ρ2v_{S}=-\rho_{S}/\rho^2, and p−pr≈−ρ‾g(z−zr)p-p_r\approx-\overline{\rho}g(z-z_r), where vη=∂v/∂ηv_{\eta}=\partial v/\partial\eta, vS=∂v/∂Sv_{S}=\partial v/\partial S, etc... This result shows that Pa\mathbf{P}_a is intermediate between the locally-referenced gradients referenced to the local and reference pressure respectively, which means that it is close to the standard neutral vector considered by [48]. In other words, Pa\mathbf{P}_a is approximately proportional to the gradient of the potential density referenced to the mid-pressure (p+pr)/2(p+p_r)/2. For more extensive discussion of this link, see [49].

The above considerations clearly establish that the results of ideal fluid thermocline theory can only be generalised to compressible seawater if the available form (Ba,Pa)(B_a,\mathbf{P}_a) rather than the conventional form (Bh,Ph)(B_h,\mathbf{P}_h) is used.

Inactive wind solutions

To discuss how to extend Needler’s formula to compressible seawater, we consider the steady and inviscid momentum equations written in their thermodynamic or Crocco-Vazsonyi form

ωa×v+∇Bℓ=Pℓ(45)\boldsymbol{\omega}_a\times\mathbf{v}+\nabla B_{\ell}=\mathbf{P}_{\ell} \tag*{(45)}

(from Eqs. (27) and (35)), where the subscript ℓ=a,h\ell=a,h indicates whether the conventional or available form of BB and P\mathbf{P} is used. To simplify notations, this subscript is dropped in the following and re-introduced only when needed. For small Rossby number, as pertains to the large-scale motions of interest here, the relative vorticity and kinetic energy only affect ωa\boldsymbol{\omega}_a and BB at second order. Eq. (45) is then an under-determined linear system for v\mathbf{v} that can only be solved if the following solvability condition is satisfied

ωa⋅P=ωa⋅∇B(46)\boldsymbol{\omega}_a\cdot\mathbf{P}=\boldsymbol{\omega}_a\cdot\nabla B \tag*{(46)}

(obtained by taking the inner product of (45) with ωa\boldsymbol{\omega}_a), so that v\mathbf{v} in (45) is determined only up to an arbitrary vector χωa\chi\boldsymbol{\omega}_a parallel to ωa\boldsymbol{\omega}_a, with χ\chi a scalar field. The χ=0\chi=0 solution of (45) perpendicular to both ∇B\nabla B and P\mathbf{P} and counterpart of Needler’s formula (18), is easily verified to be

v=defvia=P×∇BρQb(47)\mathbf{v}\stackrel{\mathrm{def}}{=}\mathbf{v}_{ia}=\frac{\mathbf{P}\times\nabla B}{\rho Q_b} \tag*{(47)}

while the counterpart of Q=fρzQ=f\rho z is

Qb=ωa⋅∇Bρ=ωa⋅Pρ,(48)Q_b=\frac{\boldsymbol{\omega}_a\cdot\nabla B}{\rho}=\frac{\boldsymbol{\omega}_a\cdot\mathbf{P}}{\rho}, \tag*{(48)}

the equality following from (46). In the context of a dry atmosphere, [30] derived an expression similar to (47) and referred to via\mathbf{v}_{ia} as the inactive wind.

In order to examine the consistency of the inactive wind solution (47) with mass conservation, let us take take the divergence of ρvia\rho\mathbf{v}_{ia}, which yields

∇⋅(ρvia)=−(P×∇B)Qb2⋅∇Qb+(∇×P)⋅∇BQb=−ρvia⋅∇QbQb+(∇×P)⋅∇BQb.(49)\nabla\cdot(\rho\mathbf{v}_{ia}) = -\frac{(\mathbf{P} \times\nabla B)}{Q_b^2} \cdot\nabla Q_b + \frac{(\nabla\times\mathbf{P}) \cdot\nabla B}{Q_b} = -\frac{\rho\mathbf{v}_{ia} \cdot\nabla Q_b}{Q_b} + \frac{(\nabla\times\mathbf{P}) \cdot\nabla B}{Q_b}. \tag*{(49)}

As for one of Needler’s formula, it can be shown that via\mathbf{v}_{ia} satisfies the continuity equation as a consequence of Ertel’s PV conservation theorem applied to the PV constructed from the Bernoulli function Q=ωa⋅∇B/ρQ = \boldsymbol{\omega}_a \cdot\nabla B/\rho. To show this, let us recall that in its most general form, [50]’s theorem (see [43] for an English translation) establishes that for any scalar λ\lambda, the PV variable Qλ=ωa⋅∇λ/ρQ_\lambda= \boldsymbol{\omega}_a \cdot\nabla\lambda/\rho can be shown to satisfy the conservation law

DQλDt=ωaρ⋅∇(DλDt)+1ρ3∇λ⋅(∇ρ×∇p)+∇λ⋅∇×Fρ(50)\frac{D Q_\lambda}{D t} = \frac{\boldsymbol{\omega}_a}{\rho} \cdot\nabla\left(\frac{D \lambda}{D t}\right) + \frac{1}{\rho^3} \nabla\lambda\cdot(\nabla\rho\times\nabla p) + \frac{\nabla\lambda\cdot\nabla\times\mathbf{F}}{\rho} \tag*{(50)}

e.g., see Eq. (4.95) of [51]. To make the link with (49), it is important to understand the different equivalent forms that the baroclinic production term (the term proportional to ∇ρ×∇p\nabla\rho\times\nabla p in (50)) may assume. As seen previously, from the definitions of Ph\mathbf{P}_h and Pa\mathbf{P}_a, we have the following equivalence relations

1ρ∇p+∇Φ=∇(h+ϕ)−Ph=∇(h+Φ−Br)−Pa.(51)\frac{1}{\rho}\nabla p + \nabla\Phi= \nabla(h+\phi) - \mathbf{P}_h = \nabla(h+\Phi-B_r) - \mathbf{P}_a. \tag*{(51)}

Taking the curl yields the following equivalent expressions

1ρ2∇ρ×∇p=1ρ2N×∇p=∇×Ph=∇×Pa.(52)\frac{1}{\rho^2}\nabla\rho\times\nabla p = \frac{1}{\rho^2}\mathbf{N} \times\nabla p = \nabla\times\mathbf{P}_h = \nabla\times\mathbf{P}_a. \tag*{(52)}

which are proportional to the baroclinic production term, where N=ρS∇S+ρθ∇θ=ρη∇η+ρS∇S\mathbf{N} = \rho_S \nabla S + \rho_\theta\nabla\theta= \rho_\eta\nabla\eta+ \rho_S \nabla S is the so called N-neutral vector entering [48]’s definition of (approximately) neutral surfaces (ANS). Now, if we use B=λB = \lambda, in the inviscid case F=0\mathbf{F} = 0 and invoke Bernoulli theorem, DB/Dt=0DB/Dt = 0, (50) predicts that

DQbDt=via⋅∇Qb=1ρ∇B⋅(∇×P)(53)\frac{D Q_b}{D t} = \mathbf{v}_{ia} \cdot\nabla Q_b = \frac{1}{\rho}\nabla B \cdot(\nabla\times\mathbf{P}) \tag*{(53)}

Comparing this with (49) shows that

∇⋅(ρvia)=0,(54)\nabla\cdot(\rho\mathbf{v}_{ia}) = 0, \tag*{(54)}

as expected, thus confirming that via\mathbf{v}_{ia} satisfies the continuity equation regardless of which form of (B,P)(B,\mathbf{P}) is used.

Uniqueness of the inactive wind solution

The two inactive wind solutions introduced above may be written explicitly as

viah=Ph×∇Bhωa⋅∇Bh,viaa=Pa×∇Baωa⋅∇Ba.(55)\mathbf{v}_{ia}^{h} = \frac{\mathbf{P}_h \times\nabla B_h}{\boldsymbol{\omega}_a \cdot\nabla B_h}, \qquad\mathbf{v}_{ia}^{a} = \frac{\mathbf{P}_a \times\nabla B_a}{\boldsymbol{\omega}_a \cdot\nabla B_a}. \tag*{(55)}

Since these two solutions both satisfy the continuity equation, a question that naturally arises is whether these may actually define the same velocity field despite being constructed from different fields. To examine this, let us recall that by definition Pa=Ph−∇Br\mathbf{P}_a = \mathbf{P}_h - \nabla B_r, while Ba=Bh−BrB_a = B_h - B_r. It follows that

Pa×∇Ba=(Ph−∇Br)×∇(Bh−Br)=Ph×∇Bh+(∇Bh−Ph)×∇Br=Ph×∇Bh+(∇v22+1ρ∇hp)×∇Br,(56)\mathbf{P}_a \times\nabla B_a = (\mathbf{P}_h - \nabla B_r) \times\nabla(B_h - B_r) \\ = \mathbf{P}_h \times\nabla B_h + (\nabla B_h - \mathbf{P}_h) \times\nabla B_r \\ = \mathbf{P}_h \times\nabla B_h + \left(\nabla\frac{\mathbf{v}^{2}}{2} + \frac{1}{\rho}\nabla_h p\right) \times\nabla B_r, \tag*{(56)}

which suggests that viah\mathbf{v}_{ia}^{h} and viaa\mathbf{v}_{ia}^{a} define two different vector fields. However, because they both represent an exact solution of (45), it follows that their difference must be proportional to the null-space solution ωa\boldsymbol{\omega}_a. In other words, there must exist some scalar δλ\delta\lambda such that

viah−viaa=δλ ωa.(57)\mathbf{v}_{ia}^{h} - \mathbf{v}_{ia}^{a} = \delta\lambda\,\boldsymbol{\omega}_a. \tag*{(57)}

For small Rossby number, ωa≈fk\boldsymbol{\omega}_a \approx f\mathbf{k} (where ff is the Coriolis parameter), which implies that viah\mathbf{v}_{ia}^{h} and viaa\mathbf{v}_{ia}^{a} must primarily differ by their vertical velocity component. Physically, this is plausible because in this case the horizontal components of viah\mathbf{v}_{ia}^{h} and viaa\mathbf{v}_{ia}^{a} must both be approximately geostrophic, i.e., uiah≈uiaa≈ug\mathbf{u}_{ia}^{h} \approx\mathbf{u}_{ia}^{a} \approx\mathbf{u}_g, while their vertical components must satisfy wiah=ug⋅Shw_{ia}^{h} = \mathbf{u}_g \cdot\mathbf{S}_h and wiaa=ug⋅Saw_{ia}^{a} = \mathbf{u}_g \cdot\mathbf{S}_a respectively, where Sh\mathbf{S}_h and Sa\mathbf{S}_a are the horizontal slope vectors defined by Ph\mathbf{P}_h and Pa\mathbf{P}_a respectively. As a result,

wiah−wiaa=ug⋅(Sh−Sa),(58)w_{ia}^{h} - w_{ia}^{a} = \mathbf{u}_g \cdot(\mathbf{S}_h - \mathbf{S}_a), \tag*{(58)}

which confirms that the two vertical velocities wiahw_{ia}^{h} and wiaaw_{ia}^{a} might differ if the slopes defined by the two different P-vectors differ, as is indeed generally the case. It will be of interest to ascertain whether the vertical velocity component of viaa\mathbf{v}_{ia}^{a} is a better predictor of the actual vertical velocity field than that of viah\mathbf{v}_{ia}^{h}, which we plan on investigating in a subsequent study.

Reformulation in terms of quantities independent of pressure

Let γT=γT(S,θ)\gamma^{T} = \gamma^{T}(S,\theta) denote an approximately neutral quasi-material density variable and QγT=ωa⋅∇γT/ρQ_{\gamma^{T}} = \boldsymbol{\omega}_a \cdot\nabla\gamma^{T}/\rho the PV variable constructed from it. As discussed in [36, 47, 49, 52], APE theory naturally comes with a generalised form of potential density ρLZ(S,θ)\rho^{LZ}(S,\theta) that is naturally very accurately neutral outside the Southern Ocean (even more so than Jackett and McDougall [53] empirical neutral density variable γn\gamma^{n}), while also being mathematically and physically well defined. This motivated [47, 52] to define thermodynamic neutral density γT\gamma^{T} as

γT=ρ(S,θ,pr)−fn(pr)(59)\gamma^{T} = \rho(S,\theta,p_r) - f_n(p_r) \tag*{(59)}

where fn(pr)f_n(p_r) is a polynomial pressure correction empirically fitted to make γT\gamma^{T} looks as much like γn\gamma^{n}. Because it tends to be more accurately neutral than γn\gamma^{n} outside the Southern Ocean, γT\gamma^{T} is the variable that is currently the least affected by the thermobaric production term.

If one accepts γT\gamma^{T} and QγTQ_{\gamma^{T}} as the most sensible generalisation of the concepts of density and PV to compressible seawater, then one may proceed similarly as in [23] and assume that if BB, γT\gamma^{T} and QγTQ_{\gamma^{T}} are all approximately conserved along fluid parcel trajectories, a functional relationship should exist between BB, γT\gamma^{T} and QγTQ_{\gamma^{T}}, say B=G(γT,QγT)B = G(\gamma^{T},Q_{\gamma^{T}}) as in ideal fluid thermocline theory, then the seawater counterpart of Needler’s second formula (22) becomes

via=∂G∂γTP×∇γTρQb+∂G∂QγTP×∇QγTρQb.(60)\mathbf{v}_{ia} = \frac{\partial G}{\partial\gamma^{T}}\frac{\mathbf{P} \times\nabla\gamma^{T}}{\rho Q_b} + \frac{\partial G}{\partial Q_{\gamma^{T}}}\frac{\mathbf{P} \times\nabla Q_{\gamma^{T}}}{\rho Q_b}. \tag*{(60)}

In comparison to Needler’s formula, (60) possesses the extra and undesirable thermobaricity-induced term proportional to P×∇γT\mathbf{P} \times\nabla\gamma^{T}. This term can only be neglected if Pa\mathbf{P}_a rather than Ph\mathbf{P}_h is used, however, as the angle between Ph\mathbf{P}_h and ∇γT\nabla\gamma^{T} is not generally small enough. If so,

via≈∂G∂QγTPa×∇QγTρQb(61)\mathbf{v}_{ia} \approx\frac{\partial G}{\partial Q_{\gamma T}} \frac{\mathbf{P}_a \times\nabla Q_{\gamma T}}{\rho Q_b} \tag*{(61)}

which is more directly comparable to (22), stressing again the fundamental importance of APE theory to extend the results of ideal fluid thermocline theory to compressible seawater.

Discussion

The idea that steady fluid parcel trajectories lie at the intersection of the iso-surfaces of conserved quantities is arguably one of the most promising avenues of research for progressing the theory of the 3D oceanic velocity field, as it is one that is a priori as equally valid for an ideal fluid, for which it was originally developed by [23], as well as for a fully compressible ocean with a realistic nonlinear equation of state, as recently initiated by [29]. In this paper, we made significant progress towards generalising this idea to compressible seawater encapsulated into three main new results.

Our first main result is that Needler’s formula (18) can be interpreted as a linear approximation of a much more general nonlinear and exact solution of the compressible NSE, called the ’inactive wind’ solution. Such a solution was previously derived by [30] in the context of a dry atmosphere and extended here to two-component compressible seawater. Like Needler’s formula, the inactive wind solution satisfies the continuity equation as a consequence of Ertel’s PV conservation theorem [42] (that is itself related to the generalised Bernoulli theorem of [41]). Like Needler’s formula, the inactive wind solution is perpendicular to the gradient of the Bernoulli function, but unlike Needler’s formula, it is perpendicular to a vector P\mathbf{P} rather than to the gradient of density ∇ρ\nabla\rho. Physically, the inactive wind solution is most easily obtained by rewriting the momentum equations in their Crocco-Vazsonyi or thermodynamic form, which appears to be the most illuminating form for relating the 3D velocity field to the conserved quantities of the fluid.

Our second main result is that both Needler’s formula and the inactive wind solution are sensitive to how the Bernoulli function is defined, as it is always possible to redefine the latter by subtracting an arbitrary quasi-material function of ρ\rho (for a simple fluid) or of SS and θ\theta (for compressible seawater). We find that only if the ‘available’ form of Bernoulli function is used it is possible to meaningfully relate the inactive wind solution to Needler’s formula. Physically, the available Bernoulli function is defined as the difference between the conventional Bernoulli function and its background reference value in Lorenz state of minimum potential energy entering Lorenz APE theory [31]. Indeed, only in this case is the vector P\mathbf{P} parallel to an approximately neutral density variable, namely the Lorenz reference density (LRD) discussed at length in [47, 49, 52].

Our third main result is that inactive wind solutions defined for different forms of Bernoulli function and vector P\mathbf{P} do not necessarily define the same 3D velocity field even if each represents an exact solution of the compressible NSE satisfying the continuity equation. Mathematically, this is because the nonlinear balance equation from which the inactive wind solution is determined is degenerate. For small Rossby number, this is equivalent to say that different inactive wind solution differ primarily in their vertical velocity component. More generally, this result means that while it is in principle possible to construct a 3D velocity field as λ∇C1×∇C2\lambda\nabla C_1 \times\nabla C_2 in terms of any arbitrary conserved quantities C1C_1 and C2C_2 for some λ\lambda, this does not necessarily imply that all constructions define the same velocity field, which does not appear to have received much attention so far. Physically, this is important because it provides the means, at least in principle, to test the usefulness of different constructions by comparing the 3D velocity field that each expression predicts against the 3D velocity field from any dynamically consistent ocean state estimate, as we plan on pursuing in a subsequent study.

The present results are important because we believe that they can pave the way towards a more rigorous and general theory of the oceanic 3D velocity field valid for a realist compressible ocean, as we hope to further demonstrate through concrete applications in future studies.

Funding: This research has been supported by the NERC-funded OUTCROP project (grant no. NE/R010536/1).

Data Availability Statement: The WOCE Global Ocean Climatology 1990-1998 (file ’wghc_params.nc’) used in this study is available at doi:10.25592/uhhfdm.8987. Enthalpy and other functions of state were estimated using the TEOS-10 library available at www.teos-10.org. Software to compute the analytic form of thermodynamic neutral density is available at doi:10.5281/zenodo.4957697. See also https://github.com/GammaTN for regular software updates and illustrative code examples.

Acknowledgments: The author gratefully acknowledges comments from A. Colin de Verdière and Geoff Stanley on a original version of the paper, as well as constructive and supportive comments from three anonymous referees.

Conflicts of Interest: The author declares no conflict of interest

Abbreviations

The following abbreviations are used in this manuscript:

AbbreviationMeaning
PVPotential vorticity
APEAvailable Potential Energy
ACEAvailable Compressible Energy
LRDLorenz Reference Density
ANSApproximately Neutral Surface
NSENavier-Stokes Equations

Table 2.

1.Lee, T.; Awaji, T.; Balmaseda, M.A.; Greiner, E.; Stammer, D. Ocean State Estimation for Climate Research. Oceanography 2009, 22, 160–167.
2.Forget, G.; Ferrerira, D.; Liang, X. On the observability of turbulent transport rates by ARGO: supporting evidence from an inversion experiment. Ocean Sciences 2015, 11, 839–853.
3.Masuda, S.; Osafune, S. Ocean state estimations for synthesis of ocean-mixing observations. J. Oceanography 2021, 77, 359–366. https://doi.org/10.1007/s10872-020-00587-x.
4.Wunsch, C.; Ferrari, R. 100 years of the ocean general circulation. A century of progress in atmospheric and related sicences: celebrating the american meteorological society centennial; Vol. 59, Meteor. Monogr., Amer. Meteor. Soc., 2019. https://doi.org/10.1175/AMSMONOGRAPHS-D-18-0002.1.
5.Fomin, L.M. The dynamic method in oceanography; Elsevier Oceanography Series; 2, Elsevier, 1964.
6.Olbers, D.J.; Willebrand, J. The level of no motion in an ideal fluid. J. Phys. Oceanogr. 1984, 14, 203–212.
7.Schott, F.; Stommel, H. Beta spirals and absolute velocities in different oceans. Deep-Sea Res. 1978, 16(Suppl.), 301–323.
8.Wunsch, C. Determining the general circulation of the oceans: a preliminary discussion. Science 1977, 196, 871–875. https://doi.org/10.1126/science.196.4292.871.
9.Wunsch, C. The North Atlantic general circulation west of 50W determined by inverse methods. Rev. Geophys. 1978, 16, 583–620. https://doi.org/https://doi.org/10.1029/JC091iC04p05103.
10.Davis, R.E. On estimating velocity from hydrographic data. J. Geophys. Res. 1978, 83, 5507–5509.
11.Behringer, D.W. On computing the absolute geostrophic velocity spiral. J. Mar. Res. 1979, 37, 459–470.
12.Behringer, D.W.; Stommel, H. The beta spiral in the North Atlantic subtropical gyre. Deep-Sea Res. 1980, 27A, 225–238. https://doi.org/https://doi.org/10.1016/0198-0149(80)90014-X.
13.Killworth, P.D. A Bernoulli inverse method for determining the ocean circulation. J. Phys. Oceanogr. 1986, 16, 2031–2051.
14.Bigg, G.R. The beta spiral method. Deep Sea Res. 1985, 32, 465–484.
15.Park, Y.H. Determination of the surface geostrophic velocity field from satellite altimetry. J. Geophys. Res. Oceans 2004, 109. https://doi.org/10.1029/2003JC002115.
16.Colin de Verdière, A.; Ollitrault, M. A direct determination of the world ocean barotropic circulation. J. Phys. Oceanogr. 2016, 46, 255–273. https://doi.org/10.1175/JPO-D-15-0046.1.

Table 3.

Disclaimer/Publisher’s Note: The statements, opinions and data contained in all publications are solely those of the individual author(s) and contributor(s) and not of MDPI and/or the editor(s). MDPI and/or the editor(s) disclaim responsibility for any injury to people or property resulting from any ideas, methods, instructions or products referred to in the content.

References

  1. [1]Lee, T.; Awaji, T.; Balmaseda, M.A.; Greiner, E.; Stammer, D. Ocean State Estimation for Climate Research. Oceanography 2009, 22, 160–167.DOI
  2. [2]Forget, G.; Ferrreira, D.; Liang, X. On the observability of turbulent transport rates by ARGO: supporting evidence from an inversion experiment. Ocean Sciences 2015, 11, 839–853.
  3. [3]Masuda, S.; Osafune, S. Ocean state estimations for synthesis of ocean-mixing observations. J. Oceanography 2021, 77, 359–366. https://doi.org/10.1007/s10872-020-00587-x.
  4. [4]Wunsch, C.; Ferrari, R. 100 years of the ocean general circulation. A century of progress in atmospheric and related sciences: celebrating the american meteorological society centennial; Vol. 59, Meteor. Monogr., Amer. Meteor. Soc., 2019. https://doi.org/10.1175/AMS_MONOGRAPHS-D-18-00021.1.
  5. [5]Fomin, L.M. The dynamic method in oceanography; Elsevier Oceanography Series; 2, Elsevier, 1964.
  6. [6]Olbers, D.J.; Willebrand, J. The level of no motion in an ideal fluid. J. Phys. Oceanogr. 1984, 14, 203–212.
  7. [7]Schott, F.; Stommel, H. Beta spirals and absolute velocities in different oceans. Deep-Sea Res. 1978, 16(Suppl.), 301–323.DOI
  8. [8]Wunsch, C. Determining the general circulation of the oceans: a preliminary discussion. Science 1977, 196, 871–875. https://doi.org/DOI:10.1126/science.196.4292.871.
  9. [9]Wunsch, C. The North Atlantic general circulation west of 50W determined by inverse methods. Rev. Geophys. 1978, 16, 583–620. https://doi.org/10.1029/JC091iC04p05103.
  10. [10]Davis, R.E. On estimating velocity from hydrographic data. J. Geophys. Res. 1978, 83, 5507–5509.DOI
  11. [11]Behringer, D.W. On computing the absolute geostrophic velocity spiral. J. Mar. Res. 1979, 37, 459–470.
  12. [12]Behringer, D.W.; Stommel, H. The beta spiral in the North Atlantic subtropical gyre. Deep-Sea Res. 1980, 27A, 225–238. https://doi.org/10.1016/0198-0149(80)90014-X.
  13. [13]Killworth, P.D. A Bernoulli inverse method for determining the ocean circulation. J. Phys. Oceanogr. 1986, 16, 2031–2051.doi.org/10.1175/1520-0485(1986)016<2031:abimfd>2.0.co;2
  14. [14]Bigg, G.R. The beta spiral method. Deep Sea Res. 1985, 32, 465–484.DOI
  15. [15]Park, Y.H. Determination of the surface geostrophic velocity field from satellite altimetry. J. Geophys. Res. Oceans 2004, 109. https://doi.org/10.1029/2003JC002115.
  16. [16]Colin de Verdière, A.; Ollitrault, M. A direct determination of the world ocean barotropic circulation. J. Phys. Oceanogr. 2016, 46, 255–273. https://doi.org/10.1175/JPO-D-15-0046.1.
  17. [17]Colin de Verdière, A.; Meunier, T.; Ollitrault, M. Meridional overturning and heat transport from Argo floats displacements and the planetary geostrophic method (PGM): Application to the subpolar North Atlantic. J. Geophys. Res. Oceans 2019, 124, 5309–6432. https://doi.org/10.1029/2018JC014565.
  18. [18]Griffies, S.M. Fundamentals of ocean models; Princeton University Press, 2004; p. 424pp.
  19. [19]Wunsch, C. The decadal mean ocean circulation and Sverdrup balance. J. Mar. Res. 2011, 69, 417–434.DOI
  20. [20]Nardelli, B.B. A multi-year time series of observatio-based 3D horizontal and vertical quasi-geostrophic global ocean currents. Earth Syst. Sci. Data 2020, 12, 1711–1723. https://doi.org/10.5194/essd-12-1711-2020.
  21. [21]Sevellec, F.; Garabato, A.C.N.; Brearley, J.A.; Sheen, K.L. Vertical flow in the Southern Ocean estimated from individual moorings. J. Phys. Oceanogr. 2015, 45, 2209–2220. https://doi.org/10.1175/JPO-D-14-0065.1.
  22. [22]Welander, P. The thermocline problem. Philos. Trans. R. Soc. Lond. A., 270, 415–421. https://doi.org/10.1098/rsta.1971.0081.
  23. [23]Needler, G.T. The absolute velocity as a function of conserved measurable quantities. Prog. Oceanogr. 1985, 14, 421–429.DOI
  24. [24]Chu, P.C. P-vector method for determining absolute velocity from hydrographic data. Mar. Tech. Soc. J. 1995, 29, 3–14.
  25. [25]Chu, P.C. P-vector spirals and determination of absolute velocities. J. Oceanography 2000, 56, 591–599.DOI
  26. [26]Kurgansky, M.V.; Budillon, G.; Salusti, E. Tracers and potential vorticities in ocean dynamics. J. Phys. Oceanogr. 2002, 32, 3562–3577. https://doi.org/https://doi.org/10.1175/1520-0485(2002)032<3562:TAPVIO>2.0.CO;2.
  27. [27]Kurgansky, M.V. On the determination of the absolute velocity of steady flows of a baroclinic fluid with applications to ocean currents. Dyn. Atmos. Oceans 2021, 95.DOI
  28. [28]McDougall, T.J. The influence of ocean mixing on the absolute velocity vector. J. Phys. Oceanogr. 1995, 25, 705–725.doi.org/10.1175/1520-0485(1995)025<0705:tioomo>2.0.co;2
  29. [29]Ochoa, J.; Badan, A.; Sheinbaum, J.; Castro, J. ’Preferred trajectories’ defined by mass and potential vorticity conservation. Geofisica Internacional 2020, 59-3, 195–207.DOI
  30. [30]Gassmann, A. Deviations from a general nonlinear wind balance: local and zonal-mean perspectives. Met. Zeit 2014, 23, 467–481.DOI
  31. [31]Lorenz, E.N. Available potential energy and the maintenance of the general circulation. Tellus 1957, 7, 138–157.
  32. [32]Young, W.R. An exact thickness-weighted average formulation of the Boussinesq equations. J. Phys. Oceanogr. 2012, pp. 692–707.DOI
  33. [33]Crocco, L. Eine neue Stromfunktion für die Erforschung der Bewegung der Gase mit Rotation. ZAMM - Zeitschrift für Angewandte Mathematik und Mechanik 1937, 17, 1–7. https://doi.org/10.1002/zamm.19370170103.
  34. [34]Vazsonyi, A. On rotational gas flows. Quart. Applied Math. 1945, 3, 29–37.DOI
  35. [35]Tailleux, R. Available potential energy density for a multicomponent Boussinesq fluid with a nonlinear equation of state. J. Fluid Mech. 2013, 735, 499–518. https://doi.org/10.1017/jfm.2013.509.
  36. [36]Saenz, J.A.; Tailleux, R.; Butler, E.D.; Hughes, G.O.; Oliver, K.I.C. Estimating Lorenz’s reference state in an ocean with a nonlinear equation of state for seawater. J. Phys. Oceanogr. 2015, 45, 1242–1257. https://doi.org/10.1175/JPO-D-14-0105.1.
  37. [37]Tailleux, R. Local available energetics of multicomponent compressible stratified fluids. J. Fluid Mech. 2018, 842. https://doi.org/10.1017/jfm.2018.196.
  38. [38]Holliday, D.; McIntyre, M.E. On potential energy density in an incompressible, stratified fluid. J. Fluid Mech. 1981, 107, 221–225.DOI
  39. [39]Andrews, D.G. A note on potential energy density in a stratified incompressible fluid. J. Fluid Mech. 1981, 107, 227–236.DOI
  40. [40]Nycander, J. Energy conversion, mixing energy, and neutral surfaces with a nonlinear equation of state. J. Phys. Oceanogr. 2011, 41, 28–41.
  41. [41]Schär, C. A generalization of Bernoulli’s theorem. J. Atm. Sci. 1993, 50, 1437–1443. https://doi.org/10.1175/1520-0469(1993)050%3C1437:AGOBT%3E2.0.CO;2.
  42. [42]Muller, P. Ertel’s potential vorticity theorem in physical oceanography. Rev. Geophys. 1995, 33, 67–97. https://doi.org/10.1029/94RG03215.
  43. [43]Schubert, W.; Ruprecht, E.; Hertenstein, R.; Ferreira, R.N.; Taft, R.; Rozoff, C.; Ciesielski, P.; Kuo, H.C. English translations of twenty-one of Ertel’s papers on geophysical fluid dynamics. Meteo. Zeitschrift 2004, 13, 527–576.DOI
  44. [44]Killworth, P.D. A note on velocity determination from hydrographic data. J. Geophys. Res. 1979, 84, 5093–5094. https://doi.org/10.1029/JC084iC08p05093.
  45. [45]Killworth, P.D. On determination of absolute velocities and density gradients in the ocean from a single hydrostatic section. Deep-Sea Res. 1980, 27A, 901–929. https://doi.org/10.1016/0198-0149(80)90003-5.
  46. [46]Gouretski, V.V.; Koltermann, K.P. WOCE global hydrographic climatology. Berichte des Bundesamtes für Seeschifffahrt und Hydrographie Tech. Rep. 35/2004 2004, p. 49pp.DOI
  47. [47]Tailleux, R. Spiciness theory revisited, with new views on neutral density, orthogonality and passiveness. Ocean Science 2021, 17, 203–219. https://doi.org/10.5194/os-17-203-2021.
  48. [48]McDougall, T.J. Neutral surfaces. J. Phys. Oceanogr. 1987, 17, 1950–1964.doi.org/10.1175/1520-0485(1987)017<1950:ns>2.0.co;2
  49. [49]Tailleux, R.; Wolf, G. On the links between thermobaricity, available potential energy, neutral directions, buoyancy forces, potential vorticity, and lateral stirring in the Ocean. J. Phys. Oceanogr. 2023, submitted. https://doi.org/10.48550/arXiv.2202.00456.
  50. [50]Ertel, H. Ein neuer hydrodynamischer Wirbelsatz. Meteo. Zeitschrift 1942, 59, 277–281.DOI
  51. [51]Vallis, G.K. Atmospheric and Oceanic Fluid Dynamics; Cambridge University Press, 2006; p. 745.
  52. [52]Tailleux, R. Generalized patched potential density and thermodynamic neutral density: Two new physically based quasi-neutral density variables for ocean water masses analyses and circulation studies. J. Phys. Oceanogr. 2016, 46, 3571–3584. https://doi.org/10.1175/JPO-D-16-0072.1.
  53. [53]Jackett, D.R.; McDougall, T.J. A neutral density variable for the World’s oceans. J. Phys. Oceanogr. 1997, 27, 237–263. https://doi.org/10.1175/1520-0485(1997)027<0237:ANDVFT>2.0.CO;2.

Paper details

vlnc:W_nv8zgg3y
Version
v1 · latest
Published
Fresh — added to the Hub within the last 30 days
Added
License
CC BY 4.0
Usage

views · 0

downloads · 0

A view counts once per browser per day, a download each time the PDF is requested.

  • Physics and Astronomy

Not recorded for this paper

View statement
Looking for related papers…
Contents