The Schrödinger operator in one dimension is considered. When the electric potential has a linear/V-shaped well, an approximation of the ground-state is established at fixed distance from the well. In this situation, the classical WKB analysis and the localization techniques à la Agmon near a non-degenerate minimum do not work. We propose an alternative to the WKB analysis better suited to the shape of the well and we prove that our Ansatz is an exponentially good approximation by means of revisited (and simplified) Agmon estimates.
Introduction and motivation
About semiclassical tunneling in one dimension
This article is devoted to the spectral analysis of Schrödinger operators in one dimension, i.e., operators of the form
L=−h2∂x2+V(x),
acting on L2(I), for some interval I and some real-valued, confining, continuous, electric potential V. By confining, we mean that, if I is unbounded, we have infV<liminf∣x∣→+∞V(x). We are especially interested in the approximation of the groundstate eigenfunction in the semiclassical limit h→0, which is equivalent to the large electric field limit.
Such a study is motivated by the tunneling effect, and probably began with the celebrated article by Harrell [8]. This work was devoted to symmetric double-well potentials, and he established formulas describing the first spectral gap in terms of the eigenfunctions, see [8 Theorem 2.1]. The exponentially small size of this gap is directly related to the exponential smallness of one-well eigenfunctions in the so-called classically forbidden zone, where the electric potential is larger than the eigenvalue, see [8 Theorems 2.8 & 2.22]. These considerations are then applied to the case of an explicit smooth non-degenerate double-well, where the one-well eigenfunctions are estimated at a fixed distance from the well, see [8 Section III]. However, for more singular wells, such estimates are not as easy to obtain.
This relation between exponential decay of the one-well eigenfunctions and the spectral gaps was then used by Simon [20, 21] and Helffer-Sjöstrand [10, 11] in order to consider quantum systems of higher dimensions. The reader might also want to consider the monograph [5 Chapters 3 & 6], where WKB constructions are performed (in any dimension) in smooth non-degenerate wells and proved to be exponentially good approximations in Appendix A, see also [9] and [19].
In this article we analyze these questions for one-dimensional singular wells. In fact this analysis is also the occasion to present an alternative to the standard WKB constructions, together with a revisited (and simplified) approach to Agmon estimates. In particular, the techniques we present below could be adapted to non-degenerate wells as well, providing slightly better decay estimates.
The problem under consideration
The purpose of the present article is to approximate the groundstate eigenfunction of the Dirichlet realization of L when I=R+, with a smooth confining V attaining a unique minimum at x=0 and such that V′(0)>0. This simple model appears in the study of the so-called Stark effect, see, for instance, [3]. It is also motivated by the analysis of broken waveguides (or asymptotically flat triangles), see [4, 17] where effective operators involve the Dirichlet realization of L on a half-line. Hopefully, our results will help establish accurate tunneling estimates by means of dimensional reductions in these contexts, see, for instance, [17 Section 1.6].
Let us gather our main assumptions.
Assumption 1.1. We consider a non-negative smooth function V on [0,+∞) such that V(0)=0 and V′(0)>0. We assume that it has a unique minimum at 0 and that it is not attained at infinity. For λ>0 small enough, we denote by xλ>0 the unique solution to V(x)=λ.
Under Assumption 1.1, we know that L has discrete eigenvalues below the essential spectrum, which we denote by
0<λ1<λ2<⋯<λj<⋯
As h→0, there are increasingly many such eigenvalues, even if for fixed h there may be only a finite number of them. We are especially interested in the asymptotic behaviour of the normalized groundstate f, in the semiclassical limit h→0. Our main result is the following.
Theorem 1.2. Under Assumption 1.1, for all j≥1, we have
λj=∣zj∣V′(0)32h32+O(h34),(1)
where zj is the j-th zero of the Airy function. For all x>0, the L2-normalized positive groundstate satisfies, in the limit h→0,
Remark 1.3. Our proof actually shows that the λj have asymptotic expansions in powers of h32. The main novelty in Theorem 1.2 is the asymptotic estimate of the groundstate eigenfunction at a fixed distance from its linear minimum. It relies on two independent steps, which are based on classical ideas when considering tunneling effect, namely:
construction of exponentially good quasimodes,
sharp exponential decay estimates of the true eigenfunctions and their approximations.
The combination of these two ideas allows one to replace f by the quasimode, for which we have the pointwise asymptotic formula. This strategy is now standard, and was used in particular in the setting of non-degenerate wells, as described in [5], but also in the case of degenerate wells (V(x)∼xα with α≥2, see [14]). In these situations, the exponential decay is given by the Agmon estimates[1], and quasimodes are in the WKB form.
We stress that in our situation, with linear wells, both the standard WKB analysis and the standard Agmon strategy fail due to the linear behavior. The strategy of [14 Théorème 3.1] consisting in gluing an Ansatz living at the bottom of the well, i.e., in {V(x)<λ}, and a WKB Ansatz away from the well, does not work in our context due to a more complicated transition of scales. Indeed, the localisation near the bottom of the well is much stronger in the case of linear wells: the characteristic scale near the minimum is h32≪h21 making the connection between the classically allowed and forbidden regions, {V(x)<λ} and {V(x)>λ} respectively, more abrupt than for non-degenerate wells. Therefore, we have to provide substitutes to the WKB quasimodes to deal with this transition, and to revisit the usual Agmon estimates.
This yields a robust approach, that could be used in a more general setting. In fact, our contribution gives an alternative to the WKB constructions in the case of non-degenerate wells, and it simplifies the usual Agmon estimates in this case also. For our linear wells, one will use an Airy profile to connect the classically allowed and forbidden regions. Our quasimode construction is reminiscent of Liouville’s technique [13 Section III], see also [7 Section 2] and [15 Section 4]. More precisely, our first Ansatz (see (3.8) with N=0) is Langer’s uniform approximation near a turning point [12], see also [16 Chapter 11]. Our contribution lies in its iterative improvement and in the Agmon estimates which allow us to compare it with the true groundstate.
Organization of the article
This article is organized as follows. § 2 is devoted to the exposition of the main insights behind the proof of Theorem 1.2. We state the optimal Agmon estimate and introduce the quasimode. In § 3, we provide the reader with the detailed proofs of our statements. This section contains the proof of the Agmon estimates, a linear approximation inside the well, the detailed iterative quasimode construction, and the conclusion of the proof of Theorem 1.2. In § 4, an application to a tunneling result is discussed.
Main insights
Agmon estimates
A first key ingredient to prove Theorem 1.2 is given by the celebrated Agmon estimates (see [1]), which provide exponential decay estimates on the eigenfunctions of Schrödinger operators, of the form
∥eΦ/hf∥≤Ch−κ∥f∥,h∈(0,1].(2)
Two natural questions arise: for which weights Φ can we obtain such estimates, and with which power κ? This second question, which may seem of lower interest, will actually have implications if one wants to consider potentials of lower regularity.
In our specific situation, we obtain the following Agmon-type elliptic estimate, with optimal weight Φ=S, and a relatively small power κ. The proof is given in § 3.1 (where a slightly stronger version – which controls 2 derivatives – is established).
Proposition 2.1. Let K, E>0. There exist h0 and C>0 such that for all h∈(0,h0), all 0≤λ≤Eh32 and all u∈H01(R+)∩H2(R+),
∥eS/hu∥L2(0,K)≤Ch−34∥eS/h(L−λ)u∥+Ch−31∥u∥,
where S(x)=∫0x(V(t)−λ)+dt.
Remark 2.2. When u is an eigenfunction, we obtain an estimate of the form (2) on compact sets, with κ=31. The weight Φ=S is in fact optimal in the sense that it corresponds to the decay announced in Theorem 1.2.
The idea behind the Agmon estimates is to use the ellipticity of the conjugate operator LΦ−λ=eΦ/h(L−λ)e−Φ/h away from a small neighborhood of x=0, for a suitable weight Φ. A straightforward computation gives that, in the sense of quadratic forms,
ReLΦ−λ=h2Dx2+V(x)−Φ′(x)2−λ,(3)
which naturally leads us to consider the weight
Φ(x)=1−ε∫0xV(s)ds,ε∈(0,1),(4)
and gives
ReLΦ−λ≥εV(x)−λ.
This allows one to establish an estimate in the form
∥eΦ/hu∥≤Ch−κ1∥eΦ/h(L−λ)u∥+Ch−κ2∥u∥,(5)
for some powers κ1,κ2>0. The rather naive choice (4) allows one to show in our specific situation that the groundstate eigenfunction is exponentially localized near 0 at a scale of order h32 since, for x small, we have Φ(x)∼321−εV′(0)x23.
The choice (4) was made in the case of non-degenerate wells, see [10 Lemma 2.3] but it prevents one from taking the limiting weight Φ=∫0xV(s)ds, which is needed to get an exponentially good approximation of the eigenfunctions far from the well. To fix this issue in [10 Prop. 5.5], the authors introduce a slightly better weight, which is a logarithmic correction of the previous one satisfying
Φ≃∫0xV(s)ds−Nh∣logh∣,
with a large constant N. With their more involved choice, one can actually replace Φ by ∫0xV(s)ds at the price of increasing the powers κ1 and κ2 by N. Note that smooth versions of such weights have recently been considered in a pseudodifferential framework in [6 Section 4.2].
In our situation with linear wells, none of these weights works since the eigenvalues are much larger (they are of order λ≃h32) than in the non-degenerate case (when they are of order h). For this reason, we rather consider the weight:
Φh(x)=1−h∫0x(V(s)−λ)+ds,(6)
with which we can directly prove (5) with κ1=34, κ2=31, and no fancy logarithmic correction is needed. Then, we can easily replace Φh by S since ∣Φh−S∣=O(h) on any compact set.
Remark 2.3. Our strategy also provides a simpler proof for non-degenerate wells, for which one can still use the weight (6), without any logarithmic correction. This choice allows one to prove simultaneously the optimal exponential decay of the eigenfunctions and their exponential approximation far from the well.
Quasimodes and approximation
Thanks to the Agmon estimate (5) with the naive weight (4), we can see that most of the mass of the groundstate f lives on an interval of size h32 around the origin. Thus, a Taylor expansion near x=0 suggests considering the Airy operator
A=−h2∂x2+V′(0)x.
A first approximation of f is then given by the groundstate of A, i.e., uniformly on [0,1],
f(x)=c0h−31Ai(V′(0)31h−32x+z1)+O(h31),(7)
where Ai denotes the Airy function, z1 its first negative zero, and
is a normalizing constant. In L2 norm, the error in (7) is even O(h32). It also suggests that the first eigenvalues behave like in (1). These approximations are made rigorous in Proposition 3.2.
However (7) is only good for x of order h32. Indeed, Ai decays exponentially fast at infinity, thus making the error term O(h32) too large to describe the announced behavior of f, when x≫h32, see Theorem 1.2.
For larger values of x, one may want to consider a WKB Ansatz, i.e., a trial function of the form
fWKB=e−hS(a0+ha1+h2a2+⋯).
It is well-known that such an Ansatz can be built, and that it is a good approximation of the solution for large values of x (i.e. far inside the classically forbidden region {V(x)>λ}={x>xλ}). However, this construction degenerates when we reach the classically allowed region, when x is of order h32. To overcome this problem, we give an alternative to the classical WKB method by changing the exponential profile of the WKB Ansatz, especially in the region x≳h32, see § 3.3. This Ansatz already appeared (for N=0) a long time ago in [15 Section 5 (iii)].
Proposition 2.4. Let N≥0, K≥1; let λ=λ1. There exist h0,c>0 and, for h∈(0,h0), a smooth function φ on [0,K] such that φ′≥c and φ′(xλ)=V′(0)31+O(h32) and such that the function
Compared to the WKB Ansatz, our construction is better suited for the shape of the well, through the use of the Airy function instead of the exponential. This idea could be generalized to other kinds of wells by using other special functions.
Remark 2.5. In fact, in order to prove Theorem 1.2, we only need the construction with N=0. This is due to the low powers of h−1 appearing in our Agmon estimates. For larger N, we get higher order approximations of f. See § 3.6.
Remark 2.6. – The function φ that we construct satisfies φ(0)=z1h32+O(h34) and thus fNapp almost satisfies the Dirichlet boundary condition. However, we will mainly use our Ansatz in the classically forbidden region.
In Lemma 3.6, it is shown that (f~Napp)′(xλ) almost coincides with f′(xλ).
We recall that
Ai(x)x→+∞=2πx1/41e−32x3/2(1+o(1)).
Thus, for all fixed x>0, we have, when h→0,
fNapp(x)=h61V(x)41ce−h1S(x)(1+o(1)),(9)
with c=2πc0V′(0)61 and where (7) is used to estimate αh. This matches the asymptotic behavior in Theorem 1.2.
In § 3.4, the function fNapp is used to construct an exponentially good quasimode defined as follows. We consider the function defined by
ψ(x)={f(x)χ(x)f~Napp(x)if x∈[0,xλ],if xλ≤x,
where χ is a smooth cutoff function and f~Napp is a very small correction of fNapp locally near xλ to make it C1 at xλ and belong to the domain of L, see (19). In Proposition 3.7, we prove that ψ is a good L2-approximation of f.
In § 3.5, we prove that ψ is an exponentially good quasimode, see Lemma 3.8. The crucial ingredient is (8), combined with the asymptotic behavior of the Airy function.
Finally in § 3.6, we use the Agmon estimates (apply Proposition 3.1 to u=f−ψ) and we get, for all fixed x>0,
eΦ(x)/h(f(x)−ψ(x))=O(h2N),
with a weight Φ such that Φ(x)=S(x)+O(h). Then, we have
f(x)=ψ(x)+O(h2N)e−S(x)/h.
For fixed x, and h small enough, ψ(x)=fNapp(x), which is estimated with (9), and thus Theorem 1.2 follows by taking N=0.
Analysis of the single singular well
Proof of the optimal Agmon estimates
As explained in the introduction, the main idea to prove the Agmon estimates with optimal weight S (as stated in Proposition 2.1), is to first consider the quasi-optimal weight Φ.
Proposition 3.1. Let E>0. There exist h0 and C>0 such that for all h∈(0,h0), all 0≤λ≤Eh32, the following holds. Let M≥1. Let us consider the bounded and Lipschitz function
Φ(x)=1−hmin(S(x),S(2M)),
with S(x)=∫0x(V−λ)21. For u∈H2(R+)∩H01(R+),
eΦ/hu≤Ch−34eΦ/h(L−λ)u+Ch−31∥u∥,
h∂xeΦ/hu≤Ch−32eΦ/h(L−λ)u+Ch31∥u∥.
Additionally, there exists a constant CM>0 so that
The Agmon estimates show that the groundstate f of L is localized on an h2/3 neighborhood of 0. For this reason we can approximate f by the groundstate gh0 of the Airy operator
A=−h2∂x2+V′(0)x.
gh0 can be expressed in terms of the Airy function, solution to
−∂x2Ai+xAi=0,x→+∞limAi(x)=0.
The eigenvalue associated to gh0 is ∣z1∣V′(0)2/3h2/3, where z1 is the first negative zero of Ai. Higher order Taylor expansions of V yield good approximations of f in L2 and even C1 norm.
Proposition 3.2. For all k≥1, we have
λk(h)=∣zk∣V′(0)2/3h2/3+O(h4/3),
where zk is the k-th negative zero of the Airy function. Moreover, there exists a family of functions in the Schwartz class (gj)j≥0, all vanishing at 0, the first one being given by
g0(x)=c0Ai(V′(0)1/3x+z1),
with c0=V′(0)1/6∣Ai′(z1)∣−1, such that, for N≥0, the function
for any cutoff function χ supported and equal to 1 near 0. For some such cutoff, set gh=χghN.
Proof. The proof follows classical arguments. Let us recall the main steps. We start by constructing a rather naive quasimode. By rescaling, the operator L is unitarily equivalent to Lresc=−h2/3∂y2+V(h2/3y) which we can formally Taylor expand as
This suggests looking for a quasi-eigenvalue μ=h32∑j=0Nh32jμj and for a quasimode in the form
g(y)=j=0∑Nh32jgj(y).
Solving formally
(Lresc−μ)g=0
gives a sequence of equations. The first one is
(L0−μ0)g0=0,
which leads to the choice μ0=∣z1∣V′(0)32 (the groundstate eigenvalue of the Airy operator L0) and to
g0(y)=c0Ai(V′(0)31y+z1),
the corresponding normalized eigenfunction.
Then, the next (μj,gj) are determined by an induction procedure requiring us to solve an equation in the form
(L0−μ0)gj=μjg0+Rj(11)
where Rj is known and belongs to the Schwartz class. Since the left-hand side must be orthogonal to g0, we need to choose μj such that the right-hand side also is, i.e. μj=−⟨Rj,g0⟩. Then, for such right-hand side, there is a unique solution gj to (11) that
ℓ=0∑jh32ℓgℓ2=1+O(h32(j+1)).
This determines the sequence μj and gj. The gj are Schwartz class, this is shown by variation of parameters. For any C>0, using the Taylor formula with remainder to order N+2 for V, and the fact that the gj's are Schwartz class, we get
(We have to restrict to C<∞ because we have not made any assumption on the size of the derivatives of V at infinity).
Rescaling back, and using the fact [L,χ] is supported where ghN is O(h∞), we deduce that
∥(L−μ)(χghN)∥L2(R+)=O(h32N+4).(12)
Thanks to the spectral theorem, this shows that dist(sp(L),μ)≤Ch32N+4. Playing the same game by choosing other eigenfunctions of the Airy operator associated with the next zeroes, we build a sequence of quasi-eigenvalues, all of order O(h32).
By means of Proposition 3.1, it can be established that there exists c>0 such that, for all F∈E:=ker(L−λ1(h))⊕ker(L−λ2(h)),
∫R+eh2/3cx∣F(x)∣2dx≤C∥F∥2.(13)
To prove this, one can proceed directly with the usual strategy for Agmon estimate. Considering Q the quadratic form associated with L, we have
Q(F)=∫R+(h2∣F′(x)∣2+V(x)∣F(x)∣2)dx≤λ2(h)∥F∥2.
and then, by using the Taylor expansion of V and estimating the remainders thanks to (13),
Q(F)≥∫R+(h2∣F′(x)∣2+V′(0)x∣F(x)∣2)dx−Ch34∥F∥2.
By the min-max theorem, this shows that
λ2(h)≥∣z2∣∣V′(0)∣32h32−Ch34,
and therefore ∣λ1(h)−μ∣=dist(sp(L),μ)=O(h32N+4). (The same argument gives similar estimation for the next eigenvalues that are thus all simple). With the spectral theorem and (12), we deduce that
∥f−gh∥L2(R+)=O(h32N+2).
To obtain a uniform estimate, we can use that for u∈H2∩H01 supported in [0,K],
with constants depending on K (actually ∥V′′∥L∞(0,K)). Inserting a cutoff against f−gh, and using that f is O(h∞) for x>1, we deduce that
∥h2∂x2(f−gh)∥L2(0,K)≤Ch32N+3.
For large values of x>K, we use the fact that V>λ and f>0, so that
f′′=h−2(V−λ)f>0.
This implies that f′ is non-decreasing, but it goes to 0, so f′(K)≤f′(x)≤0, and 0≤f(x)≤f(K). □
Since Ai is exponentially decaying at infinity, the approximation of f given by Proposition 3.2 is only good on an h2/3 neighborhood of 0. Still, this allows to compute the asymptotic value of f at the boundary of the well, i.e. the point xλ such that V(xλ)=λ1.
Corollary 3.3. We have
f(xλ)∼h→0c0h−31Ai(0).
Proof. First note that xλ must be of order h32. By a Taylor approximation we deduce that
λ1=V(xλ)=V′(0)xλ+O(h34),
and since λ1=∣z1∣V′(0)32h32+O(h34) we obtain
xλ=∣z1∣V′(0)−31h32+O(h34).(14)
Using the uniform estimates in Proposition 3.2, we find that
We now construct a quasimode that will be exponentially good. It will be shown later to be a correct approximation of the true groundstate f at large and intermediate distance from the well.
In the following, we denote by λ=λ1 the first eigenvalue of L. We recall that xλ denotes the boundary of the well, i.e. the solution to V(xλ)=λ. It will be convenient to extend V to a smooth function on (−ε,∞), for some small ε>0.
Lemma 3.4. Let M≥1. There exists ε>0 such that the function φ0 is smooth and increasing on (−ε,M). Moreover, there exist c>0 and h0>0 such that, for all h∈(0,h0) and all x∈(−ε,M), we have φ0′(x)≥c>0. In addition, we have
V(x)−λ=φ0(x)φ0′(x)2.(16)
Proof. The regularity problem appears near x=0. Thanks to the Taylor formula, we get
V(x)−V(xλ)=(x−xλ)∫01V′(xλ+t(x−xλ))dt.
For h small enough and x in a neighborhood of 0, we can write
∫01V′(xλ+t(x−xλ))dt=R(x−xλ)2,(17)
for some smooth function R such that R≥c0>0. Then, for x≥xλ, we have
We can check that this formula also holds for x≤xλ. We see that φ0 is a smooth function of x, since R≥c0>0 everywhere. Finally we can compute φ0′ using (15) and we immediately see that φ0 is increasing and satisfies (16). □
The next proposition gives the construction of our quasimode, which is a combination of the Airy function (well-suited for the shape of the well) and an iterative perturbation φ of φ0.
Proposition 3.5. Let K≥1. There exist ε0,h0>0 and, for h∈(0,h0), smooth increasing functions φ1,…,φN,… defined on φ0((−2ε0,K+ε0)) such that the following holds. Uniformly and for all j≥1 we have
φj(x)=x+OC∞(h2j).
Thus, for N>0 and h>0 small enough, φ=φN∘⋯∘φ1∘φ0 is well defined and we let
fN(x)=φ′(x)1Ai(h−32φ(x)).
Then, uniformly on (−ε0,K) we have
(L−λ)fN=O(h2N+2)fN.
Proof. To construct the announced quasimode, we first look for it in the form
u(x)=α(x)v(φ(x)).
The second derivative of such a function is given by
u′′(x)=α′′v+2α′φ′v′+αφ′′v′+αφ′2v′′
and we choose
α(x)=φ′(x)1,
in order to kill first order derivatives in v. Letting y=φ(x), a computation gives
for all y∈(φ0(−ε),φ0(M)). We let the remainder term be
r0=[(φ0′)−3/2((φ0′)−1/2)′′]∘φ0−1,
so that
(L−λ)u=(φ0′)23(−h2∂y2v+yv−h2r0v).
If r0 were 0 we could choose v=Ai(h−2/3y). Instead we will recursively reduce the size of the remainder term. We look for v in the form
v(y)=φ1′(y)1w(φ1(y)).
The map y↦y−h2r0(y)=W1(y) is increasing when h is small enough. There exists a unique yλ such that yλ−h2r0(yλ)=0. We let, for all y∈(φ0(−ε),φ0(M)),
The conclusion follows by using that W(K)=O(h∞) and by recalling Corollary 3.3.
We make a small perturbation of fNapp in order to correct its derivative at x=xλ. In what follows, we consider a smooth non increasing function χ such that 0≤χ≤1, equal to 1 on [0,43M] and 0 on (M,+∞). Let us add a small perturbation of fNapp by considering
fNapp=fNapp+(x−xλ)βhχh(x),(19)
where βh=(f−fNapp)′(xλ) and χh(x)=χ(h−32x). Provided M is large enough, χh(xλ)=1, and this function has derivative (fNapp)′(xλ)=f′(xλ) at the boundary of the well.
Proposition 3.7.We let
ψ(x)={f(x)χ(x)fNapp(x)if x∈[0,xλ],if x≥xλ,
which is of class C1 and belongs to the domain of L by construction. It satisfies in L2
(L−λ)ψ=O(h2N+35)∥ψ∥.
Moreover,
∥ψ−f∥L2(R+)=O(h2N+1).
Proof. We estimate the two terms separately in (19) to find
∥(L−λ)ψ∥=O(h2N+2αh)+O(h34βh)=O(h2N+35).
Using the same arguments as in the proof of Proposition 3.2, the spectral theorem gives that
Approximation of the groundstate in exponentially weighted norm
In this section we improve the estimates on our quasimode ψ, defined in Proposition 3.7. We show that ψ is a good approximation of the true groundstate f in exponentially weighted norm.
Once we have proven sharp exponential decay estimates on the single-well eigenfunctions, together with pointwise asymptotic formulas, we have all the necessary ingredients to obtain tunneling formulas for the double-well problem.
In this section we briefly explain how to obtain a tunneling formula between linear wells using our single well results. We will only recall the main ideas, since they follow a standard strategy.
Let us consider a smooth non-negative electric potential W which is an even function on I=[−a,a]. We assume that W has exactly two minima at ±a such that W(±a)=0 and W′(a)=−W′(−a)<0. We consider the operator
L=−h2∂x2+W,
acting on the domain H2(I)∩H01(I). A tunneling effect between the two wells yields the following spectral gap.
Proposition 4.1. There exists a universal constant κ>0 such that
The tunneling estimate of Proposition 4.1 does not seem to be already known. To the authors’ knowledge, the only similar result appears in [18 Section 1.5] in the special case when W(x)=1−∣x∣ and a=1. There the author describes the eigenfunctions explicitly by means of the Airy functions Ai and Bi. Note that, in this case,
Sh=34−2∣z1∣h32+O(h).
Of course, we cannot directly apply our result due to the peak at x=0, but our estimate agrees with [18 Corollaire 1.18]. Note also that a similar formula is obtained in [14 Corollaire 3.2] in the case of degenerate wells (with a behavior $x^{2 \sigma near the minima, with σ≥11 and it is consistent with ours if one were allowed to take σ=21, but their Agmon distance does not include a perturbation like our h32.
Proof. Let us only sketch the proof by explaining how to use our estimate of the one-well groundstate in Theorem 1.2. The details of the computations can be found in [5 Chapter 6] and also in recent articles, see for instance [6 Section 5] or [2 Section 5].
Given a/2>η>0, we consider a smooth single-well potential Wℓ on [−a,+∞) that coincides with W on [−a,a−η]. We also assume that Wℓ is bounded (with all its derivatives) and that, on [a−η,+∞), Wℓ≥c>0. We denote by fℓ the positive, L2-normalized groundstate of the associated operator Lℓ=−h2∂x2+Wℓ and we denote by μ the corresponding eigenvalue. We consider a smooth cutoff function 0≤χℓ≤1 supported in [−a,a−η) and equal to 1 on [−a,a−2η).
Thanks to our decay estimate on fℓ and support considerations, we have
(L−μ)(χℓfℓ)=O(e−(S0−ε)/h)
where S0=∫−aaW(s)ds, and ε>0 can be made as small as we want by taking η>0 small enough. By symmetry, we also define the right-well potential Wr, and using self-evident notation, we have
(L−μ)(χrfr)=O(e−(S0−ε)/h).
We also notice that
⟨χℓfℓ,χrfr⟩=O(e−(S0−ε)/h).
Then, the spectral theorem shows that there are at least two eigenvalues near μ at a distance of order at most O(e−(S0−ε)/h). In fact there are exactly two: we can show that the eigenfunctions of L are localized near ±a and that the low-lying spectra of L and Lℓ⊕Lr coincide modulo O(h∞). Due to the spectral asymptotics of Lℓ/r (see Theorem 1.2), we deduce that
λ2(h)−λ1(h)=O(e−(S0−ε)/h)
and that λ3(h)−λ2(h)≥ch32.
There remains to get the accurate asymptotics of the spectral gap. We denote by Π the spectral projector onto Ker(L−λ1)⊕Ker(L−λ2). The above discussion and the spectral theorem imply that
(Id−Π)(χ⋆f⋆)=O(e−(S0−ε)/h).(22)
We let
g⋆=Π(χ⋆f⋆).
The vectors (gℓ,gr) form a basis of RanΠ. However, it is not orthonormal. Therefore, we consider the associated Gram matrix of the family (gℓ,gr), namely the 2×2 matrix G=(⟨gj,gk⟩). Using (22) we can check that
which shows that the family (gℓ,gr) is almost orthonormal. The family G−1/2(gℓ,gr) is orthonormalized and the matrix of L in this basis is given by
In this final subsection we discuss how to adapt the results of this article to V-shaped wells. Take a>0 and consider an even continuous non-negative electric potential W that is piecewise smooth on R∖{±a} with exactly two minima at ±a such that W(±a)=0. Assume that A=W′(a+)>0 and −B=W′(a−)<0. Also assume that W is confining, i.e. liminf∣x∣→∞W>0. We consider the corresponding operator
L=−h2∂x2+W.
The following operator plays an important role in the analysis:
M=−h2∂x2−Bx1R−(x)+Ax1R+(x).
It appears as a first order approximation of L near the well at a. This selfadjoint operator has compact resolvent and its eigenvalues and eigenfunctions can be expressed in terms of the Airy functions. By homogeneity, its groundstate eigenvalue z(h) satisfies z(h)=h32z(1).
Proposition 4.2. There exists a 2/3 homogeneous positive function κ(A,B) such that
The κ function is obtained by solving an implicit equation involving Airy functions. There does not seem to be a compact formula for it.
Proof idea. The proof follows the same lines as for Proposition 4.1. We start with a piecewise linear approximation near the bottom of a single well, which gives an L2 approximation of the normalized eigenfunctions in terms of Airy functions (at leading order), and permits the computation of the relevant constants. Then a quasimode construction and Agmon estimates propagate the Airy approximation inside the forbidden region between the two wells. □
Declaration of AI use
AI tools were used solely to check the mathematical calculations and reasoning in the final version of the manuscript. They were not used to write the manuscript, develop proofs, or generate mathematical ideas.
(L. Morin) Laboratoire de Mathématiques Jean Leray (UMR CNRS 6629), Nantes Université, 2 rue de la Houssinière, 44322 Nantes Cedex 03, France Email address:[email protected]
(N. Raymond) Univ Angers, CNRS, LAREMA, Institut Universitaire de France, F-49000 Angers, France Email address:[email protected]
References
[1]S. Agmon. Lectures on exponential decay of solutions of second-order elliptic equations: bounds on eigenfunctions of N-body Schrödinger operators, volume 29 of Mathematical Notes. Princeton University Press, Princeton, NJ; University of Tokyo Press, Tokyo, 1982.
[2]M. Averseng, N. Frantz, F. Hérau, and N. Raymond. Semiclassical tunneling for some 1D Schrödinger operators with complex-valued potentials. J. Spectr. Theory, 2026. Published online first, 3 September 2026.
[3]H. Cornean, D. Krejčiřík, T. G. Pedersen, N. Raymond, and E. Stockmeyer. On the two-dimensional quantum confined Stark effect in strong electric fields. SIAM J. Math. Anal., 54(2):2114–2127, 2022.DOI
[4]M. Dauge and N. Raymond. Plane waveguides with corners in the small angle limit. J. Math. Phys., 53(12):123529, 2012.DOI
[5]M. Dimassi and J. Sjöstrand. Spectral asymptotics in the semi-classical limit, volume 268 of London Mathematical Society Lecture Note Series. Cambridge University Press, Cambridge, 1999.DOI
[6]A. Duraffour and N. Raymond. An example of accurate microlocal tunneling in one dimension. Math. Res. Lett., 32(5):1421–1463, 2025.
[7]A. Erdélyi. Asymptotic solutions of differential equations with transition points or singularities. J. Math. Phys., 1(1):16–26, 1960.DOI
[8]E. M. Harrell. Double wells. Commun. Math. Phys., 75:239–261, 1980.DOI
[9]B. Helffer. Semi-classical analysis for the Schrödinger operator and applications, volume 1336 of Lecture Notes in Mathematics. Springer-Verlag, Berlin, 1988.DOI
[10]B. Helffer and J. Sjöstrand. Multiple wells in the semiclassical limit. I. Comm. Partial Differential Equations, 9(4):337–408, 1984.DOI
[11]B. Helffer and J. Sjöstrand. Puits multiples en limite semi-classique. II: Interaction moléculaire. Symétries. Perturbation. Ann. Inst. Henri Poincaré, Phys. Théor., 42(2):127–212, 1985.
[12]R. E. Langer. On the asymptotic solutions of ordinary differential equations, with an application to the Bessel functions of large order. Trans. Amer. Math. Soc., 33:23–64, 1931.DOI
[13]J. Liouville. Second mémoire sur le développement des fonctions ou parties de fonctions en séries dont les divers termes sont assujettis à satisfaire à une même équation différentielle du second ordre, contenant un paramètre variable. Journal de Mathématiques Pures et Appliquées, 1e série, 2:16–35, 1837.
[14]A. Martinez and M. Rouleux. Effet tunnel entre puits dégénérés. Commun. Partial Differ. Equations, 13(9):1157–1187, 1988.DOI
[15]F. W. J. Olver. Error bounds for first approximations in turning-point problems. J. Soc. Ind. Appl. Math., 11(3):748–772, 1963.
[16]F. W. J. Olver. Asymptotics and Special Functions. Academic Press, 1974.
[18]N. Popoff. Sur le spectre de l’opérateur de Schrödinger magnétique dans un domaine diédral. Ph.D. thesis, Université Rennes 1, Nov. 2012.
[19]D. Robert. Analyse semi-classique de l’effet tunnel [d’après B. Helfer et J. Sjöstrand]. In Séminaire Bourbaki, Vol. 1985/86, number 145–146 in Astérisque, pages 257–281. Société Mathématique de France, 1987. Exp. no. 665.
[20]B. Simon. Semiclassical analysis of low lying eigenvalues. I. Non-degenerate minima: asymptotic expansions. Ann. Inst. Henri Poincaré, Phys. Théor., 38(3):295–308, 1983. Erratum: ibid. 40 (1984), no. 2, 224.
[21]B. Simon. Semiclassical analysis of low lying eigenvalues. II: Tunneling. Ann. Math. (2), 120(1):89–118, 1984.