betaFeedback

WorksPhysics and Astronomy

A Catalog of Young Stellar Objects in the Lagoon Nebula

Abstract

M8, the Lagoon Nebula, has been known for more than 100 years as a region forming stars. It is (in projection) very close to if not in the Galactic Bulge. As a result, the source surface density is very high and source confusion is a substantial challenge. Because of the location, there have been many surveys that serendipitously observed M8, in addition to studies specifically targeting it. But to this point, there has been no effort to resolve source confusion across all the existing catalogs, spanning many different wavelengths, sensitivities, and spatial resolutions. We have done all of this source reconciliation, and present the merged catalog here. The net result is 3019 YSOs with largely photometric data and/or YSO selection from ~50 different origins, primarily ranging from gg-band through 25 um, but with a significant number of X-ray sources, and some data of limited sensitivity out through 70-450 um. The catalog includes several flags that enable users to select, e.g., the YSOs that have been identified as young by the most studies, or the YSOs with the most multi-wavelength counterparts, or the ones with the clearest IR excesses. We use this catalog in a companion paper; it will also be of use in, e.g., future SPHEREx and Roman work.

Introduction

The Lagoon Nebula, also known as M8, has been studied for more than 100 years as we have sought to understand the star formation going on within it. In one of the first studies, G. H. Herbig [43] commented on the many “T Tauri-like” stars in M8, citing stars that are bright in Hα\alpha emission and/or variable. Despite the well-more than 600 articles on M8, and more than 400 on NGC 6530, the open cluster slightly in front of the nebulosity that is also part of M8 (Figure 1), this region is difficult to study because it is more or less (in projection) in the Galactic Bulge. With Galactic coordinates of l=005.957∘l = 005.957^\circ, b=−01.166∘b = -01.166^\circ, the source surface density is very high, especially when moving to fainter magnitude limits or into the near-infrared (NIR) where the dust is more transparent than in the optical. The stars in this region are known to be young (∼\sim1-2 Myr; L. Prisinzano et al. [84]), although some distance away at ∼\sim1250 pc (L. Prisinzano et al. [84]).

The Lagoon Nebula star-forming region

Figure 1. The Lagoon Nebula star-forming region. The background image in the Palomar Observatory Sky Survey (POSS) Digitized Sky Survey (DSS) IR image in reverse greyscale; north is up and east is left. The large red square is the region studied here, ∼0.66∘×∼0.38∘\sim0.66^\circ\times\sim0.38^\circ. NGC 6530 is an open cluster just in front of the cloud forming stars; 7 Sgr is the bright star in the upper right. N. F. H. Tothill et al. [100] describe more of the features of this region.

We are carrying on the tradition begun by G. H. Herbig [43] of exploring the young stars in M8, particularly their variability properties. In L. Venuti et al. [106, 107], we have discussed results from multicolor ground- and space-based monitoring of the Lagoon Nebula, and explored the influence of environment and mass on circumstellar disk accretion. In the process of those analyses, we assembled a catalog of known young stellar objects (YSOs) and candidate YSOs from the literature. This paper consolidates all of that catalog assembly process into one place so as to make it easier for future investigators, particularly as upcoming surveys like SPHEREx and Roman will need well-vetted catalogs in order to disentangle and interpret the observations.

Since the late 1990s, there have been ∼\sim30 papers published in refereed major astronomy journals studying significant numbers of young stars in M8 and its immediate surroundings. There are an additional ∼\sim20 large catalogs over roughly that same timescale that overlapped this region as part of an all-sky survey, a Galactic Plane survey, and/or a Galactic Bulge Survey. The net result is largely photometric data and/or YSO selection from ∼\sim50 different origins, primarily ranging from gg-band through 25 μ\mum, but with a significant number of X-ray sources, and some data of limited sensitivity out to 70-450 μ\mum. There are many very bright sources here at all of the wavelengths considered, as well as unresolved multiple sources at all bands (some obvious multiples, some not). Different catalogs had varying degrees of success when it came to removing artifacts from bright and/or unresolved and/or high surface density sources. Different articles had different approaches for selecting members or young stars, including position and proper motion, HαH\alpha emission, infrared (IR) excess, X-ray emission, and variability.

We wished to aggregate all of the photometry and YSO identifications from the literature into a master catalog so that we could move forward with additional analyses. We optimized our work here for the region over which we had space-based K2 (S. B. Howell et al. [44]) light curves (L. Venuti et al. [106]), that is, the box from (18:02:19.33, −24-24:08:05.9) to (18:05:13.48, −24-24:31:40.1); see Figure 1. This is a region ∼0.66∘×∼0.38∘\sim0.66^\circ\times\sim0.38^\circ. There are legitimate members of M8 and/or NGC 6530 beyond these boundaries, but consideration of these objects is beyond the scope of the present paper.

In this paper, we primarily discuss how we went about merging the many different catalogs and checking those merges (§ 2). Identifying the stars with IR excesses (disks) is covered in § 3. The general properties of the final catalog are explored in § 5. § 6 explores issues related to reddening in this region, because it is patchy and occasionally substantial. We close with some ideas on reliability and completeness (§ 7), and wind up with some final thoughts (§ 8).

ReferencePaper or catalog focus & notesX-raysopticalNIRMIRFIR, submm
IRAS/PSC (G. Neugebauer et al. [72, 73])all-sky catalog. . .. . .. . .IRAS 12IRAS 25,60,100
M. E. van den Ancker et al. (1997)PPM to find members, SpTy. . .UBV RcIcR_{\mathrm{c}}I_{\mathrm{c}}. . .. . .. . .
H. Sung et al. [98]members via R−HαR-H\alpha but did not tabulate HαH\alpha separately. . .UBV IcI_{\mathrm{c}}. . .. . .. . .
G. Rauw et al. [86]X-raysXMM. . .. . .. . .. . .
MSX (M. P. Egan et al. [27]; MSX Team [70])Galactic Plane catalog. . .. . .. . .MSXAB1B2CDE. . .
F. Damiani et al. [20]X-rays plus archival data from prior studiesCXO. . .. . .. . .. . .
L. Prisinzano et al. [82]finding members; new optical data plus archival data from prior studies. . .BV IcI_{\mathrm{c}}. . .. . .. . .
DENIS (N. Epchtein et al. [29]; Denis Team [22])big catalog. . .. . .iJKsiJK_{\mathrm{s}}. . .. . .
2MASS/PSC (M. F. Skrutskie et al. [96]; 2MASS Team (2020))all-sky catalog. . .. . .JHKsJHK_{\mathrm{s}}. . .. . .
J.-L. Zhao et al. [118]PPM to find members. . .. . .photog. . .. . .
J. I. Arias et al. [4]tiny field of view. . .. . .JHKsJHK_{\mathrm{s}}. . .. . .
J. I. Arias et al. [5]follow-up on a few members. . .. . .. . .. . .. . .
AKARI IRC (H. Murakami et al. [71]; Akari Team [2])all-sky catalog. . .. . .. . .Akari 9,18. . .
AKARI FIS (H. Murakami et al. [71]; Akari Team [3])all-sky catalog. . .. . .. . .. . .Akari 65,90,140,160
L. Chen et al. [17]PPM to find members. . .BB. . .. . .. . .
L. Prisinzano et al. [81]spectroscopic follow up (vsin⁡iv\sin i, Li). . .BV IcI_{\mathrm{c}}. . .. . .. . .
UKIDSS (P. W. Lucas et al. [58]; UKIDSS Consortium [102])big catalog. . .. . .JHKJHK. . .. . .
Spitzer/GLIMPSE (R. A. Benjamin et al. [9]; E. Churchwell et al. [19]; Glimpse Team [36])Galactic Plane catalog. . .. . .. . .IRAC1234. . .
D. L. Kumar & B. G. Anandarao [56]members selected from IR excess. . .. . .. . .IRAC1234. . .
WISE/AllWISE (E. L. Wright et al. [114, 115])all-sky catalog. . .. . .. . .WISE1234. . .
C. B. Henderson & K. G. Stassun [42]rotation periods. . .VIcV I_{\mathrm{c}}. . .. . .. . .
VVV (R. K. Saito et al. [94]; D. Minniti et al. [67])big catalog. . .. . .ZYJHKsZYJHK_{\mathrm{s}}. . .. . .
MYStIX: M. S. Povich et al. [78]Chandra+IRACCXO. . .JHKsJHK_{\mathrm{s}}IRAC1234. . .
MYStIX: P. S. Broos et al. [11]Chandra+IRAC; larger than prior paper; smaller area in generalCXO. . .JHKsJHK_{\mathrm{s}}IRAC1234. . .
Spitzer/SEIP (P. Capak [12])catalog over large portion of sky. . .. . .. . .WISE12. . .
P. M. Bell et al. [8]catalog over large portion of sky. . .. . .ZZ. . .. . .
VPHAS+/unWISE (D. I. Lang et al. [57] (2016); A. M. Meisner et al. [64]; E. F. Schlaffly et al. (2019))big catalog. . .UgrizU griz. . .WISE12. . .
ReferencePaper or catalog focus & notesX-raysOpticalNIRMIRFIR, submm
P. J. Castro [14]Chandra, archival data from prior workCXO…………
V. M. Kalari et al. [52]members from Hα, UV excess, derived mass accretion……………
MYStIX: G. Romine et al. [92]Chandra+IRAC+Herschel; youngest YSOsCXO…JHKsJHK_sIRAC1234SPIRE 500
PanSTARRS (K. C. Chambers et al. [16]; K. C. Chambers & et al. [15]big catalog…gri zy………
Herschel/HPDP PSC 70 (G. Marton et al. [62]; PPSC Team [79]catalog over large portion of sky…………PACS 70
Herschel/HPDP PSC 160 (G. Marton et al. [62]; PPSC Team [80]catalog over large portion of sky…………PACS 160
SCUBA (J. Di Francesco et al. [23, 24]catalog…………SCUBA 450, 850
L. Prisinzano et al. [84]spectroscopic follow up (vsin⁡iv \sin i, Li), Gaia-ESO survey…VIcV I_c………
F. Damiani et al. [21]PPM members (Gaia DR2)CXO…………
N. J. Wright et al. [116]PPM members (Gaia DR2), Gaia-ESO survey…Gaia, spec………
MYStIX: M. C. Ramírez-Tannus et al. [85]spectroscopic follow up…spec………
SPICY: M. A. Kuhn et al. [54]YSOs in Gal. Plane; IRAC+Gaia+ZTF variab.………IRAC1234…
WISE/CatWISE (F. Marocco et al. [61]; P. R. M. Eisenhardt et al. [28]; F. Marocco et al. [60]all-sky catalog………WISE12…
R. J. Jackson et al. [50]PPM (Gaia EDR3), Gaia-ESO survey…Gaia, spec………
Gaia DR3 (Gaia Collaboration et al. [33]; IRSA [48]all-sky catalog…Gaia BGR………
Gaia DR3/distances (C. A. L. Bailer-Jones et al. [6]all-sky catalog; distances from Bayesian statistics…Gaia………
C. Ordenes-Huanca et al. [74]KsK_s monitoring, periods……KsK_s……
L. Venuti et al. [106]K2 and ground-based monitoring…ugriHαugri\mathrm{H}\alpha………
L. Venuti et al. [107]disk accretion…ugriHαugri\mathrm{H}\alpha………

Table 1a. Literature Included In The Catalogs, Part 1a

Specific Data Sets and the Merging Thereof

Introduction

Because the surface density of point sources in and around M8 is very high, exactly how we merge catalogs (and in what order) matters; it can substantially affect which sources remain at the end of the merging process, and what cross-IDs are assigned to which objects. We have developed considerable skill in this kind of merging across heterogeneous catalogs (see, e.g., [87, 90], and the discussions therein); this is particularly difficult when merging between the output of large, well-tested pipelines with high-quality astrometry (e.g., those from large sky surveys with many point sources) and those from specific surveys of small regions (which may not have the same level of coordinate accuracy and precision), and across wavelengths with a variety of spatial resolutions and depths (where, among other things, there may not be many point sources to anchor the astrometry). Tools available at NASA’s Infrared Science Archive (IRSA) are critical for this, because they allow for interactive exploration of images and catalogs, including overlaying multiple catalogs on the same images. We took special care in this very dense region, repeatedly merging, testing the fidelity of the merge (see discussion below), and re-merging (and re-testing). Sources were only consolidated (or removed) if we were certain that they should be consolidated (or removed).

In this section, we describe the datasets merged and the order in which they were combined (unless noted otherwise). Where possible, we ingested entire catalogs; otherwise, we incorporated YSO-only catalogs as provided. Across all datasets, we tracked cross-identifications and known or candidate YSOs. Because our primary goal is to compile a reliable list of YSOs, we focused our manual cross-match quality and detailed source assessment – including assembling spectral energy distributions (SEDs) and image inspection – exclusively on the YSO candidates.

Specifically because there are so many sources of data, Tables 1 and 2 consolidate all of the most important information to compare all the constituent catalogs, in chronological order (as opposed to the order in which they were combined). Note that the constituent catalogs sometimes cover only portions of our field (see Table 2 and text below), and these portions are not necessarily the center of the field; sometimes additional constraints are imposed by the nebulosity. Plots of each catalog’s spatial coverage are included in the subsections below. In each case, we have plotted the individual catalogs (black) on top of the entire catalog (light grey) as an indication of sky coverage. If the catalog has contributed both a source catalog and a catalog of members or YSO candidates, those are highlighted in red. Artifacts of both astrophysical (nebulosity) and instrumental (bright source masking; tile boundaries) origins are apparent.

ReferenceArea covered# srcs/# YSOs^aYSO flag^bSp. Res.^cDepth^d
IRAS/PSC (G. Neugebauer et al. [72, 73])whole area19/5∼1−3′′\sim1-3^{\prime\prime}to >1.2>1.2 Jy at 12 μ\mum
M. E. van den Ancker et al. [105]most of area96/96x∼16′′\sim16^{\prime\prime}Ks∼11K_{\mathrm{s}}\sim11 mag
H. Sung et al. [98]smaller area900/446x∼2′′\sim2^{\prime\prime}Ks∼12K_{\mathrm{s}}\sim12 mag
G. Rauw et al. [86]smaller area105/105(x)∼6′′\sim6^{\prime\prime}Ks∼12K_{\mathrm{s}}\sim12 mag
MSX (M. P. Egan et al. [27]; MSX Team 2019)whole area292/35∼20′′\sim20^{\prime\prime}to ≳0.07\gtrsim0.07 Jy at 4.29 μ\mum
F. Damiani et al. [20]smaller area884/884(x)∼1′′\sim1^{\prime\prime}Ks∼13.2K_{\mathrm{s}}\sim13.2 mag
L. Prisinzano et al. [82]smaller area1,329/926x∼0.8′′\sim0.8^{\prime\prime}Ks∼13.2K_{\mathrm{s}}\sim13.2 mag
DENIS (N. Epchtein et al. 1999; Denis Team 2020)most of area24,550/1,550∼2′′\sim2^{\prime\prime}KD∼13K_{\mathrm{D}}\sim13 mag
2MASS/PSC (M. F. Skrutskie et al. 2006; 2MASS Team 2020)whole area29,501/2,069∼1.5′′\sim1.5^{\prime\prime}Ks∼13.2K_{\mathrm{s}}\sim13.2 mag
J.-L. Zhao et al. [118]most of area112/112x∼1′′\sim1^{\prime\prime}?Ks∼10.5K_{\mathrm{s}}\sim10.5 mag
J. I. Arias et al. [4]small area744/127x<1′′<1^{\prime\prime}Ks∼15.7K_{\mathrm{s}}\sim15.7 mag
J. I. Arias et al. [5]small area44/44x∼1′′\sim1^{\prime\prime}Ks∼13K_{\mathrm{s}}\sim13 mag
AKARI IRC (H. Murakami et al. 2007; Akari Team 2020a)whole area79/27∼5′′\sim5^{\prime\prime}to ≳0.1\gtrsim0.1 Jy at 9 μ\mum
AKARI FIS (H. Murakami et al. 2007; Akari Team 2020b)whole area61/1≳2′′\gtrsim2^{\prime\prime}to ≳0.75\gtrsim0.75 Jy at 65 μ\mum
L. Chen et al. [17]most of area147/147x∼1.5′′\sim1.5^{\prime\prime}?Ks∼10.7K_{\mathrm{s}}\sim10.7 mag
L. Prisinzano et al. [81]smaller area332/332x. . .Ks∼12.4K_{\mathrm{s}}\sim12.4 mag
UKIDSS [58, 102]most of area157,995/2,580∼0.8′′\sim0.8^{\prime\prime}Ks∼16K_{\mathrm{s}}\sim16 mag
Spitzer/GLIMPSE (R. A. Benjamin et al. 2003; E. Churchwell et al. 2009; Glimpse Team 2020a,b)whole area69,080/2,210∼1.6′′\sim1.6^{\prime\prime}[3.6] ∼14.0\sim14.0 mag
D. L. Kumar & B. G. Anandarao (2010)most of area221/221x∼6′′\sim6^{\prime\prime}Ks∼11.6K_{\mathrm{s}}\sim11.6 mag
WISE/AllWISE (E. L. Wright et al. 2010, 2019)whole area6,006/284∼6′′\sim6^{\prime\prime}[3.4] ∼11\sim11 mag
C. B. Henderson & K. G. Stassun (2012)smaller area290/290(x)∼1.5′′\sim1.5^{\prime\prime}Ks∼13.2K_{\mathrm{s}}\sim13.2 mag
VVV [94, 67]whole area168,338/2,665∼1′′\sim1^{\prime\prime}Ks∼16.5K_{\mathrm{s}}\sim16.5 mag
MYStIX: M. S. Povich et al. [78]smaller area1,327/1,235x∼1′′\sim1^{\prime\prime}Ks∼13K_{\mathrm{s}}\sim13 mag
MYStIX: P. S. Broos et al. [11]smaller area1,914/1,914x∼1′′\sim1^{\prime\prime}Ks∼13K_{\mathrm{s}}\sim13 mag
Spitzer/SEIP [12]whole area15,778/993∼1.6′′\sim1.6^{\prime\prime}[3.6] ∼13.0\sim13.0 mag
C. P. M. Bell et al. [8]smaller area8,567/936x∼1.5′′\sim1.5^{\prime\prime}Ks∼15.0K_{\mathrm{s}}\sim15.0 mag
VPHAS+ (J. E. Drew et al. 2014, 2016)whole area59,473/2,280∼1′′\sim1^{\prime\prime}i∼21i\sim21 mag
WISE/unWISE (D. Lang et al. 2014, 2016; A. M. Meisner et al. 2017a,b; E. F. Schlafly et al. 2019)whole area24,759/628∼6′′\sim6^{\prime\prime}[3.4] ∼12.5\sim12.5 mag
P. J. Castro [14]smaller area1,350/1,303(x)∼1′′\sim1^{\prime\prime}Ks∼13.5K_{\mathrm{s}}\sim13.5 mag
V. M. Kalari et al.most of area195/195x∼1′′\sim1^{\prime\prime}Ks∼12.7K_{\mathrm{s}}\sim12.7 mag
ReferenceArea covered# srcs/# ysosa^{a}YSO flagb^{b}Sp. Res.c^{c}Depthd^{d}
MYStIX: G. Romine et al. [92]smaller area48/48x∼1′′\sim1^{\prime\prime}Ks∼13K_{\mathrm{s}}\sim13 mag
PanSTARRS [16, 15]whole area84,118/2,494y∼1′′\sim1^{\prime\prime}y∼19y\sim19 mag
Herschel/HPDP PSC 70 [62, 79]basically off-edge1/0∼6′′\sim6^{\prime\prime}…
Herschel/HPDP PSC 160 [62, 80]basically off-edge2/0∼11′′\sim11^{\prime\prime}…
SCUBA [23, 24]smaller area33/0∼9−14′′\sim9-14^{\prime\prime}…
L. Prisinzano et al. [84]smaller area616/616x∼0.5′′\sim0.5^{\prime\prime} (Gaia)Ks∼13.2K_{\mathrm{s}}\sim13.2 mag
F. Damiani et al. [21]most of area2,901/2,031x∼1′′\sim1^{\prime\prime}Ks∼13.6K_{\mathrm{s}}\sim13.6 mag
N. J. Wright et al. [116]most of area776/776x∼0.5′′\sim0.5^{\prime\prime} (Gaia)Ks∼13.6K_{\mathrm{s}}\sim13.6 mag
MYStIX: M. C. Ramírez-Tannus et al. [85]smaller area86/86x∼1′′\sim1^{\prime\prime}Ks∼13K_{\mathrm{s}}\sim13 mag
SPICY: M. A. Kuhn et al. (2021a,b)whole area466/466x∼1′′\sim1^{\prime\prime}Ks∼13.0K_{\mathrm{s}}\sim13.0 mag
WISE/CatWISE [61, 28, 60]whole area16,926/447∼6′′\sim6^{\prime\prime}[3.4]∼12.5\sim12.5 mag
R. J. Jackson et al. [50]whole area1,458/735x∼0.5′′\sim0.5^{\prime\prime} (Gaia)Ks∼13.2K_{\mathrm{s}}\sim13.2 mag
Gaia DR3 [33, 48]whole area36,939/2,374∼0.5′′\sim0.5^{\prime\prime}G∼20.7G\sim20.7 mag
Gaia DR3/distances [6 b]whole area27,693/2,202∼0.5′′\sim0.5^{\prime\prime}G∼20.5G\sim20.5 mag
C. Ordenes-Huanca et al. [74]whole area361/361(x)Ks∼13.2K_{\mathrm{s}}\sim13.2 mag
L. Venuti et al. [106]whole area275/271x∼1′′\sim1^{\prime\prime}Ks∼13.2K_{\mathrm{s}}\sim13.2 mag
L. Venuti et al. [107]whole area943/928x∼1′′\sim1^{\prime\prime}Ks∼13.2K_{\mathrm{s}}\sim13.2 mag

Table 2. Literature Included In The Catalog, Part 2

The final catalog is described in § 5 and appears online, delivered to IRSA and described in Appendix § 11 and Table 5.

ColumnContents
Primary Identifications
cat_numPosition-based catalog number – assembled here to be compliant with IAU nomenclature rules, based on the best J2000 RA and Dec we have for the object. All names should start with ‘J’ when used in the text (as per T. X. Chen et al. [18]), but are not listed as such here just for space considerations.
nameAlternate name (from Simbad)
raRight ascension (J2000; decimal degrees)
decDeclination (J2000; decimal degrees)
ysolitAll the YSO tags from the literature, separated by semicolons (;). Strings should largely be self-explanatory; an additional # means that the corresponding reference assigned it a number, implying it was a YSO, e.g., “spicy#” means that the SPICY catalog gave it a number, so by extension that means SPICY tagged it as a YSO.
Basic High-Level Descriptors
ysotagsNumber of references tagging this star as a YSO.
npts_sedNumber of points in the SED assembled here.
longestwaveWavelength in microns of the longest wavelength detection here.
sedclassSED class of this star, where the class comes from a fit to all detections (not limits) between 2 and 25 μm25\,\mu\mathrm{m}.
sedslopeSED slope for this star, which is a fit to all detections (not limits) between 2 and 25 μm25\,\mu\mathrm{m}.
finaldisk1Final primary disk category (see the text for more information).
finaldisk2Final secondary disk category, if any (subgroups defined in § 3; ‘?’ = possibly; multiple subgroups separated by ‘/’)
finaldiskcodeFinal disk code: 0 = no data past KsK_s (noinfo); 1 = no IR excess (no); 1.1 = no significant excess, but all IRAC bands offset slightly above the photosphere relative to KsK_s (offset); 1.2 = as 1.1, but only IRAC-3 and IRAC-4 offset (offseti3i4); 2 = probably no excess (no?); 3 = significant excess in the longest-wavelength band only (1band); 3.1 = excess significant in one band, with the adjacent shorter-wavelength band also offset (1+band); 4 = likely excess (yes?); 5 = unambiguous excess (yes).
sptyAdopted spectral type
sptysrcOrigin of adopted spectral type (see § 6)
Optical Photometry & Associated Information
UmagUU magnitude (Vega mag; all errors taken to be 0.1 mag)
UsrcOrigin of UU magnitude (string that should be self-explanatory)
BmagBB magnitude (Vega mag; all errors taken to be 0.1 mag)
BsrcOrigin of BB magnitude (string that should be self-explanatory)
VmagVV magnitude (Vega mag; all errors taken to be 0.1 mag)
VsrcOrigin of VV magnitude (string that should be self-explanatory)
RcmagRcR_c magnitude (Vega mag; all errors taken to be 0.1 mag)
RcsrcOrigin of RcR_c magnitude (string that should be self-explanatory)
IcmagIcI_c magnitude (Vega mag; all errors taken to be 0.1 mag)
IcsrcOrigin of IcI_c magnitude (string that should be self-explanatory)
ColumnContents
Gaia3IDIdentifier from Gaia DR3 catalog
gaia3gmagGaia DR3 GG magnitude (Vega mag)
gaia3gmerrGaia DR3 GG magnitude error (Vega mag)
gaia3bpmagGaia DR3 GBPG_{BP} magnitude (Vega mag)
gaia3bpmerrGaia DR3 GBPG_{BP} magnitude error (Vega mag)
gaia3rpmagGaia DR3 GRPG_{RP} magnitude (Vega mag)
gaia3rpmerrGaia DR3 GRPG_{RP} magnitude error (Vega mag)
gaia3plxGaia DR3 parallax (mas)
gaia3eplxGaia DR3 error on parallax (mas)
gaia3distGaia DR3 distance (pc)
gaia3bjdistGeometric distance (rgeor_{\mathrm{geo}}) from C. A. L. Bailer-Jones et al. [6], based on Gaia EDR3, in pc
gaia3bjdistup84th percentile of the geometric distance from C. A. L. Bailer-Jones et al. [6], in pc
gaia3bjdistdwn16th percentile of the geometric distance from C. A. L. Bailer-Jones et al. [6], in pc
PanIDIdentifier from PanSTARRS catalog
pangmagPanSTARRS gg magnitude (AB mag)
pangmerrPanSTARRS gg magnitude error (AB mag); 0.3 mag where assigned (see text)
panrmagPanSTARRS rr magnitude (AB mag)
panrmerrPanSTARRS rr magnitude error (AB mag); 0.3 mag where assigned (see text)
panimagPanSTARRS ii magnitude (AB mag)
panimerrPanSTARRS ii magnitude error (AB mag); 0.3 mag where assigned (see text)
panzmagPanSTARRS zz magnitude (AB mag)
panzmerrPanSTARRS zz magnitude error (AB mag); 0.3 mag where assigned (see text)
panymagPanSTARRS yy magnitude (AB mag)
panymerrPanSTARRS yy magnitude error (AB mag); 0.3 mag where assigned (see text)
VPHASnumidentifier from VPHAS catalog
vphasumagVPHAS uu magnitude (Vega mag)
vphasumerrVPHAS uu magnitude error (Vega mag); 0.3 mag where assigned (see text)
vphasgmagVPHAS gg magnitude (Vega mag)
vphasgmerrVPHAS gg magnitude error (Vega mag); 0.3 mag where assigned (see text)
vphasrmagVPHAS rr magnitude (Vega mag)
vphasrmerrVPHAS rr magnitude error (Vega mag); 0.3 mag where assigned (see text)
vphasimagVPHAS ii magnitude (Vega mag)
vphasimerrVPHAS ii magnitude error (Vega mag); 0.3 mag where assigned (see text)
vphashamagVPHAS Hα\alpha magnitude (Vega mag)
vphashamerrVPHAS Hα\alpha magnitude error (Vega mag); 0.3 mag where assigned (see text)
bellnumIdentifier from C. P. M. Bell et al. [8]
bellumagC. P. M. Bell et al. [8] UU magnitude (AB mag)
bellumerrC. P. M. Bell et al. [8] UU magnitude error (AB mag)
bellgmagC. P. M. Bell et al. [8] gg magnitude (AB mag)
bellgmerrC. P. M. Bell et al. [8] gg magnitude error (AB mag)
bellrmagC. P. M. Bell et al. [8] rr magnitude (AB mag)
bellrmerrC. P. M. Bell et al. [8] rr magnitude error (AB mag)
bellimagC. P. M. Bell et al. [8] ii magnitude (AB mag)
bellimerrC. P. M. Bell et al. [8] ii magnitude error (AB mag)
bellzmagC. P. M. Bell et al. [8] zz magnitude (AB mag)
bellzmerrC. P. M. Bell et al. [8] zz magnitude error (AB mag)
bellmembSet to 1 if C. P. M. Bell et al. [8] indicates it is a member.
venuti21numIdentifier from L. Venuti et al. [106].
venuti21sptSpectral type from L. Venuti et al. [106].
venutiumaguu magnitude from L. Venuti et al. [107] or L. Venuti et al. [106] (AB mag)
venutiumerruu magnitude error (assigned, 0.15 mag) (AB mag)
venutigmaggg magnitude from L. Venuti et al. [107] or L. Venuti et al. [106] (AB mag)
ColumnContents
venutigmerrgg magnitude error (assigned, 0.15 mag) (AB mag)
venutirmagrr magnitude from L. Venuti et al. [107] or L. Venuti et al. [106] (AB mag)
venutirmerrrr magnitude error (assigned, 0.15 mag) (AB mag)
venutiimagii magnitude from L. Venuti et al. [107] or L. Venuti et al. [106] (AB mag)
venutiimerrii magnitude error (assigned, 0.15 mag) (AB mag)
venutihamagHα magnitude from L. Venuti et al. [107] or L. Venuti et al. [106] (AB mag)
venutihamerrHα magnitude error (assigned, 0.15 mag) (AB mag)
sungnumIdentifier from H. Sung et al. [98] (optical data from this paper are included in the UBVRIUBVRI columns above).
sungysoflagSet to 1 if H. Sung et al. [98] indicates it is a YSO
NIR Photometry & Associated Information
bestjmagBest available JJ magnitude (Vega mags)
bestjmerrBest available JJ magnitude error (Vega mags)
bestjsrcOrigin of best available JJ magnitude (tm = 2MASS, ukidss = UKIDSS, vvv = VVV, denis = DENIS, mystix = MYStIX, arias06 = J. I. Arias et al. [4]; see § 2.10)
besthmagBest available HH magnitude (Vega mags)
besthmerrBest available HH magnitude error (Vega mags)
besthsrcOrigin of best available HH magnitude (codes as for bestjsrc)
bestkmagBest available KsK_s magnitude (Vega mags)
bestkmerrBest available KsK_s magnitude error (Vega mags)
bestksrcOrigin of best available KsK_s magnitude (codes as for bestjsrc)
twomassnumIdentifier from 2MASS (if available)
jflimSet to < if true brightness is fainter than the given magnitude at JJ
jmag2MASS JJ magnitude measurement (Vega mags); where jsrc = mystix, this is the value adopted by MYStIX, which may be from 2MASS or UKIRT
jmerr2MASS JJ magnitude error (Vega mags); blank for upper limits
jsrcOrigin of this measurement – 2m means 2MASS photometry matched by position by the authors; mystix means the counterpart and photometry were adopted from the MYStIX catalogs (from 2MASS or UKIRT).
hflimSet to < if true brightness is fainter than the given magnitude at HH
hmag2MASS HH magnitude measurement (Vega mags); where hsrc = mystix, this is the value adopted by MYStIX, which may be from 2MASS or UKIRT
hmerr2MASS HH magnitude error (Vega mags); blank for upper limits
hsrcOrigin of this measurement – 2m means 2MASS photometry matched by position by the authors; mystix means the counterpart and photometry were adopted from the MYStIX catalogs (from 2MASS or UKIRT).
kflimSet to < if true brightness is fainter than the given magnitude at KsK_s
kmag2MASS KsK_s magnitude measurement (Vega mags); where ksrc = mystix, this is the value adopted by MYStIX, which may be from 2MASS or UKIRT
kmerr2MASS KsK_s magnitude error (Vega mags); blank for upper limits
ksrcOrigin of this measurement – 2m means 2MASS photometry matched by position by the authors; mystix means the counterpart and photometry were adopted from the MYStIX catalogs (from 2MASS or UKIRT).
vvvnumIdentifier from VVV
vvvzmagVVV ZZ magnitude (Vega mag)
vvvzmerrVVV ZZ magnitude error (Vega mag); 0.3 mag where assigned (see text)
vvvymagVVV YY magnitude (Vega mag)
vvvymerrVVV YY magnitude error (Vega mag); 0.3 mag where assigned (see text)
vvvjmagVVV JJ magnitude (Vega mag)
vvvjmerrVVV JJ magnitude error (Vega mag)
vvvhmagVVV HH magnitude (Vega mag)
vvvhmerrVVV HH magnitude error (Vega mag)
vvvkmagVVV KsK_s magnitude (Vega mag)
ColumnContents
vvvkmerrVVV KsK_s magnitude error (Vega mag)
denisnumIdentifier from DENIS
idmagDENIS ii magnitude (Vega mag)
idmerrDENIS ii magnitude error (Vega mag)
jdmagDENIS JJ magnitude (Vega mag)
jdmerrDENIS JJ magnitude error (Vega mag)
kdmagDENIS KsK_s magnitude (Vega mag)
kdmerrDENIS KsK_s magnitude error (Vega mag)
ukidssnumIdentifier from UKIDSS
ukidssjmagUKIDSS JJ magnitude (Vega mag)
ukidssjmerrUKIDSS JJ magnitude error (Vega mag); 0.3 mag where assigned (see text)
ukidss hmagUKIDSS HH magnitude (Vega mag)
ukidsshmerrUKIDSS HH magnitude error (Vega mag); 0.3 mag where assigned (see text)
ukidsskmagUKIDSS KK magnitude (Vega mag)
ukidsskmerrUKIDSS KK magnitude error (Vega mag); 0.3 mag where assigned (see text)
MIR Photometry & Associated Information
bestirac1magBest available IRAC-1 magnitude (Vega mag)
bestirac1merrBest available IRAC-1 magnitude error (Vega mag)
bestirac2magBest available IRAC-2 magnitude (Vega mag)
bestirac2merrBest available IRAC-2 magnitude error (Vega mag)
bestirac3magBest available IRAC-3 magnitude (Vega mag)
bestirac3merrBest available IRAC-3 magnitude error (Vega mag)
bestirac4magBest available IRAC-4 magnitude (Vega mag)
bestirac4merrBest available IRAC-4 magnitude error (Vega mag)
iracsrcOrigin of any of the best available IRAC fluxes (mystix=MYStIX papers, gl=GLIMPSE, seip=SEIP, kumar= Kumar et al., own=this paper)
bestmips1flimSet to < if true brightness is fainter than the given magnitude at MIPS-1
bestmips1magBest available MIPS-1 magnitude (Vega mag)
bestmips1merrBest available MIPS-1 magnitude error (Vega mag)
mips1srcOrigin of any the best available MIPS-1 flux (seip=SEIP, own=this paper)
seipnameIdentifier from SEIP
seipirac1magSEIP IRAC-1 magnitude (Vega mag)
seipirac1merrSEIP IRAC-1 magnitude error (Vega mag)
seipirac2magSEIP IRAC-2 magnitude (Vega mag)
seipirac2merrSEIP IRAC-2 magnitude error (Vega mag)
seipirac3magSEIP IRAC-3 magnitude (Vega mag)
seipirac3merrSEIP IRAC-3 magnitude error (Vega mag)
seipirac4magSEIP IRAC-4 magnitude (Vega mag)
seipirac4merrSEIP IRAC-4 magnitude error (Vega mag)
seipmips1flimSet to < if true brightness is fainter than the given magnitude at MIPS-1 in SEIP
seipmips1magSEIP MIPS-1 magnitude (Vega mag)
seipmips1merrSEIP MIPS-1 magnitude error (Vega mag)
glnameIdentifier from GLIMPSE
glirac1magGLIMPSE IRAC-1 magnitude (Vega mag)
glirac1merrGLIMPSE IRAC-1 magnitude error (Vega mag)
glirac2magGLIMPSE IRAC-2 magnitude (Vega mag)
glirac2merrGLIMPSE IRAC-2 magnitude error (Vega mag)
glirac3magGLIMPSE IRAC-3 magnitude (Vega mag)
glirac3merrGLIMPSE IRAC-3 magnitude error (Vega mag)
glirac4magGLIMPSE IRAC-4 magnitude (Vega mag)
glirac4merrGLIMPSE IRAC-4 magnitude error (Vega mag)
kumarnumIdentifier from D. L. Kumar & B. G. Anandrao [56]
ColumnContents
kumarirac1magIRAC-1 magnitude (Vega mag)
kumarirac2magIRAC-2 magnitude (Vega mag)
kumarirac3magIRAC-3 magnitude (Vega mag)
kumarirac4magIRAC-4 magnitude (Vega mag)
kumarclassYSO class from D. L. Kumar & B. G. Anandarao [56]
kumarysoflagSet to 1 if D. L. Kumar & B. G. Anandarao [56] identified it as a YSO
wisenumIdentifier from AllWISE
wise1flimSet to < if true brightness is fainter than the given magnitude at WISE-1
wise1magAllWISE WISE-1 magnitude (Vega mag)
wise1merrAllWISE WISE-1 magnitude error (Vega mag)
wise2flimSet to < if true brightness is fainter than the given magnitude at WISE-2
wise2magAllWISE WISE-2 magnitude (Vega mag)
wise2merrAllWISE WISE-2 magnitude error (Vega mag)
wise3flimSet to < if true brightness is fainter than the given magnitude at WISE-3
wise3magAllWISE WISE-3 magnitude (Vega mag)
wise3merrAllWISE WISE-3 magnitude error (Vega mag)
wise4flimSet to < if true brightness is fainter than the given magnitude at WISE-4
wise4magAllWISE WISE-4 magnitude (Vega mag)
wise4merrAllWISE WISE-4 magnitude error (Vega mag)
catwisenumIdentifier from CatWISE
catwise1flimSet to < if true brightness is fainter than the given magnitude at WISE-1
catwise1magCatWISE WISE-1 magnitude (Vega mag)
catwise1merrCatWISE WISE-1 magnitude error (Vega mag)
catwise2flimSet to < if true brightness is fainter than the given magnitude at WISE-2
catwise2magCatWISE WISE-2 magnitude (Vega mag)
catwise2merrCatWISE WISE-2 magnitude error (Vega mag)
unwise­nameIdentifier from unWISE
unwise1flimSet to < if true brightness is fainter than the given magnitude at WISE-1
unwise1magunWISE WISE-1 magnitude (Vega mag)
unwise1merrunWISE WISE-1 magnitude error (Vega mag)
unwise2flimSet to < if true brightness is fainter than the given magnitude at WISE-2
unwise2magunWISE WISE-2 magnitude (Vega mag)
unwise2merrunWISE WISE-2 magnitude error (Vega mag)
MYSTiX and Related Catalogs
mystixjmagMYSTiX JJ magnitude (Vega mag)
mystixjmerrMYSTiX JJ magnitude error (Vega mag)
mystixhmagMYSTiX HH magnitude (Vega mag)
mystixhmerrMYSTiX HH magnitude error (Vega mag)
mystixkmagMYSTiX KsK_{s} magnitude (Vega mag)
mystixkmerrMYSTiX KsK_{s} magnitude error (Vega mag)
mystixirac1magMYSTiX IRAC-1 magnitude (Vega mag)
mystixirac1merrMYSTiX IRAC-1 magnitude error (Vega mag)
mystixirac2magMYSTiX IRAC-2 magnitude (Vega mag)
mystixirac2merrMYSTiX IRAC-2 magnitude error (Vega mag)
mystixirac3magMYSTiX IRAC-3 magnitude (Vega mag)
mystixirac3merrMYSTiX IRAC-3 magnitude error (Vega mag)
mystixirac4magMYSTiX IRAC-4 magnitude (Vega mag)
mystixirac4merrMYSTiX IRAC-4 magnitude error (Vega mag)
povich_mirnameIdentifier from M. S. Povich et al. [78] based on MIR catalog
povich_nirnameIdentifier from M. S. Povich et al. [78] based on NIR catalog
povich_xraynameIdentifier from M. S. Povich et al. [78] based on X-ray catalog
broos_iaunameIdentifier from P. S. Broos et al. [11] that is IAU-compliant
ColumnContents
broos_xraynameIdentifier from P. S. Broos et al. [11] based on X-ray catalog
broos_mirnameIdentifier from P. S. Broos et al. [11] based on MIR catalog
broos_nirnameIdentifier from P. S. Broos et al. [11] based on NIR catalog
broos_ob3nameIdentifier from P. S. Broos et al. [11] based on OB catalog
romine_nameIdentifier from G. Romine et al. [92]
mystixmembSet to 1 if any of the preceding MYStIX papers indicates it is a member.
ramirez20numIdentifier from M. C. Ramírez-Tannus et al. [85]
spicynumIdentifier from M. A. Kuhn et al. [54]
spicyclassClass from M. A. Kuhn et al. [54]
Sparser MIR and FIR Catalogs
akariircnameIdentifier from AKARI IRC
akari9fluxAKARI 9 μm9\,\mu\mathrm{m} flux in μJy\mu\mathrm{Jy}
akari9ferrError in AKARI 9 μm9\,\mu\mathrm{m} flux in μJy\mu\mathrm{Jy}
akari18fluxAKARI 18 μm18\,\mu\mathrm{m} flux in μJy\mu\mathrm{Jy}
akari18ferrError in AKARI 18 μm18\,\mu\mathrm{m} flux in μJy\mu\mathrm{Jy}
akarifisnameIdentifier from AKARI FIS
akari65fluxAKARI 65 μm65\,\mu\mathrm{m} flux in μJy\mu\mathrm{Jy}
akari65ferrError in AKARI 65 μm65\,\mu\mathrm{m} flux in μJy\mu\mathrm{Jy}
akari90fluxAKARI 90 μm90\,\mu\mathrm{m} flux in μJy\mu\mathrm{Jy}
akari90ferrError in AKARI 90 μm90\,\mu\mathrm{m} flux in μJy\mu\mathrm{Jy}
akari140fluxAKARI 140 μm140\,\mu\mathrm{m} flux in μJy\mu\mathrm{Jy}
akari140ferrError in AKARI 140 μm140\,\mu\mathrm{m} flux in μJy\mu\mathrm{Jy}
akari160fluxAKARI 160 μm160\,\mu\mathrm{m} flux in μJy\mu\mathrm{Jy}
akari160ferrError in AKARI 160 μm160\,\mu\mathrm{m} flux in μJy\mu\mathrm{Jy}
msxnameIdentifier from MSX
msxafluxMSX A band flux in μJy\mu\mathrm{Jy}
msxaferrError in MSX A band flux in μJy\mu\mathrm{Jy}, computed from the percentage uncertainty in the MSX catalog
msxb1fluxMSX B1 band flux in μJy\mu\mathrm{Jy}
msxb1ferrError in MSX B1 band flux in μJy\mu\mathrm{Jy}, computed from the percentage uncertainty in the MSX catalog
msxb2fluxMSX B2 band flux in μJy\mu\mathrm{Jy}
msxb2ferrError in MSX B2 band flux in μJy\mu\mathrm{Jy}, computed from the percentage uncertainty in the MSX catalog
msxcfluxMSX C band flux in μJy\mu\mathrm{Jy}
msxcferrError in MSX C band flux in μJy\mu\mathrm{Jy}, computed from the percentage uncertainty in the MSX catalog
msxdfluxMSX D band flux in μJy\mu\mathrm{Jy}
msxdferrError in MSX D band flux in μJy\mu\mathrm{Jy}, computed from the percentage uncertainty in the MSX catalog
msxefluxMSX E band flux in μJy\mu\mathrm{Jy}
msxeferrError in MSX E band flux in μJy\mu\mathrm{Jy}, computed from the percentage uncertainty in the MSX catalog
irasnameIdentifier from IRAS
iras1fluxIRAS-1 flux in μJy\mu\mathrm{Jy}
iras1ferrError in IRAS-1 band flux in μJy\mu\mathrm{Jy}, taken to be 20% of the flux
iras2fluxIRAS-2 flux in μJy\mu\mathrm{Jy}
iras2ferrError in IRAS-2 band flux in μJy\mu\mathrm{Jy}, taken to be 20% of the flux
iras3fluxIRAS-3 flux in μJy\mu\mathrm{Jy}
iras3ferrError in IRAS-3 band flux in μJy\mu\mathrm{Jy}, taken to be 20% of the flux
iras4fluxIRAS-4 flux in μJy\mu\mathrm{Jy}
iras4ferrError in IRAS-4 band flux in μJy\mu\mathrm{Jy}, taken to be 20% of the flux
Remaining Catalogs
ColumnContents
vandenancker_ysoflagSet to 1 if M. E. van den Ancker et al. (1997) indicates it is a YSO.
vanaltenajonesIdentifier from W. F. van Altena & B. F. Jones (1972) as tabulated by M. E. van den Ancker et al. (1997)
sagIdentifier from R. Sagar & U. C. Joshi [93] as tabulated by M. E. van den Ancker et al. (1997)
walkerIdentifier from M. F. Walker [108] as tabulated by M. E. van den Ancker et al. (1997)
othervanOther identifier from M. E. van den Ancker et al. (1997)
zhao06numIdentifier from J.-L. Zhao et al. [118]
zhao06memSet to 1 if J.-L. Zhao et al. [118] indicates it is a YSO.
chen07numIdentifier from L. Chen et al. [17]
chenmembprobMembership probability from L. Chen et al. [17]
chenmembflagSet to 1 for those stars from L. Chen et al. [17] we took as members
kalarinumIdentifier from V. M. Kalari et al. [52]
rauwnumIdentifier from G. Rauw et al. [86]
castronumIdentifier from P. J. Castro [14]
pris19nameIdentifier from L. Prisinzano et al. [84]
prisclassClass from L. Prisinzano et al. [84]
damiani19nameIdentifier from F. Damiani et al. [21]
damiani19bestmembSet to 1 for best members from F. Damiani et al. [21]
damiani19membSet to 1 for members from F. Damiani et al. [21]
damiani04numIdentifier from F. Damiani et al. [20]
prisin zano05numIdentifier from L. Prisinzano et al. [82]
prisin zano07numIdentifier from L. Prisinzano et al. [81]
pris07diskSet to 1 for disks from L. Prisinzano et al. [81]
pris07membSet to 1 for members from L. Prisinzano et al. [81]
arias06numIdentifier from J. I. Arias et al. [4]
arias06jmagJJ magnitude (Vega mag) from J. I. Arias et al. [4]
arias06jmerrJJ magnitude error (Vega mag) from J. I. Arias et al. [4]
arias06hmagHH magnitude (Vega mag) from J. I. Arias et al. [4]
arias06hmerrHH magnitude error (Vega mag) from J. I. Arias et al. [4]
arias06kmagKsK_s magnitude (Vega mag) from J. I. Arias et al. [4]
arias06kmerrKsK_s magnitude error (Vega mag) from J. I. Arias et al. [4]
arias07numIdentifier from J. I. Arias et al. [5]
arias07sptySpectral type from J. I. Arias et al. [5]
arias07ysoSet to 1 if J. I. Arias et al. [5] indicated it was a YSO
wrightmemSet to 1 for those stars identified as members by N. J. Wright et al. [116]
jacksonmemMembership probability P3DP_{3D} from R. J. Jackson et al. [50]; −1-1 means the star is in their sample but was excluded from their membership analysis (see Section 2.5.19)
hendersonnumIdentifier from C. B. Henderson & K. G. Stassun [42]
hendersonperiodRotation period from C. B. Henderson & K. G. Stassun [42]
ordenesnumIdentifier from C. Ordenes-Huanca et al. [74]
ordeneskmagKsK_s magnitude from C. Ordenes-Huanca et al. [74]
ordeneskmerrKsK_s magnitude error from C. Ordenes-Huanca et al. [74]
ordenesclassClass from C. Ordenes-Huanca et al. [74]
ordenesperiodRotation period from C. Ordenes-Huanca et al. [74]

Table 5. Contents of Table: Literature YSOs and YSO Candidates in the Lagoon Nebula a

Infrared - the Anchors

2MASS

The Two Micron All-Sky Survey (2MASS; [96]) surveyed the entire sky in JHKsJHK_s. It provides a highly reliable large-scale coordinate system across the sky, and can provide a reliable position reference for both optical and IR surveys. 2MASS is used to establish coordinate systems by many recent surveys. We started with the 2MASS catalog (2MASS Team 2020), retaining all of the sources from that catalog. The spatial resolution of the 2MASS survey is usually cited as ∼1.5′′\sim1.5^{\prime\prime} ([96]).

Coverage and numbers. 2MASS covers our entire survey region, with 29,501 sources. They are plotted in Figure 2. The depth at KsK_s is usually cited as ∼\sim15.3 mag ([96]), but here in this incredibly complicated region, a histogram of KsK_s peaks at ∼\sim13.2 mag. While no YSOs are identified as part of the 2MASS catalog itself, 2,069 2MASS sources in this region are identified in the literature as YSOs or candidates, vetted through the analysis below. All of the sources from this catalog are retained in the master catalog.

2MASS sources

Figure 2. 2MASS/PSC (M. F. Skrutskie et al. 2006; 2MASS Team 2020) sources (black) on the entire catalog (light grey). Because there are 2MASS data densely distributed over the field, it is very hard to see the light grey. Places where there are bright nebulosity and extinction (compare to optical image in Figure 1) are evident as lower source densities.

Spitzer/GLIMPSE

The Spitzer Space Telescope ([113]) pipelines produced positions that are anchored to those from 2MASS, so we next worked with Spitzer data. The Spitzer Legacy program called Galactic Legacy Infrared Mid-Plane Survey Extraordinaire (GLIMPSE; [19]) included the Galactic plane. The Lagoon Nebula occupies a corner of the GLIMPSE coverage. Most of our field was observed as part of the second extension of this program (GLIMPSE II; [36]), but not quite all of it. Part of our field was also observed as part of GLIMPSE3D ([37]), which was targeting (among other things) the Galactic Center. The net result is complete coverage of our region by aggregate GLIMPSE catalogs. All of the GLIMPSE-affiliated observations here used the Infrared Array Camera (IRAC; [30]), with four channels (3.6, 4.5, 5.8, and 8 μ\mum). We used the ‘more complete, less reliable’ catalogs from both the GLIMPSE II and GLIMPSE 3D deliveries (the ‘Archive’; [36 b]). We used TOPCAT ([99]) to merge these two large catalogs together with a 1′′{}^{\prime\prime} matching radius. (We made a note of the 2MASS sources that the GLIMPSE pipeline had identified as counterparts for comparison/debugging downstream.) We merged the GLIMPSE data to the 2MASS data by position, with a 1′′{}^{\prime\prime} radius, retaining all of the sources from that catalog. (Note that there are more Spitzer data included and discussed below.) Spitzer/IRAC’s spatial resolution at 3.6 μ\mum is ∼\sim1.6′′{}^{\prime\prime} ([30]).

Coverage and numbers. GLIMPSE covers our entire survey region, with 69,080 sources. They are plotted in Figure 3. GLIMPSE’s sensitivity is typically quoted as 15.5 mag at [3.6] ([19]); a histogram of the GLIMPSE [3.6] magnitudes in this incredibly complicated region rolls over at ∼\sim14 mags. While no YSO candidates are identified as part of the GLIMPSE catalog itself, 2,210 GLIMPSE sources in this region are identified in the literature as YSOs or candidates, vetted through the analysis below. All of the sources from this catalog are retained in the master catalog.

GLIMPSE sources

Figure 3. Spitzer/GLIMPSE [9, 19, 36 b] sources (black) on the entire catalog (light grey). Because there are GLIMPSE data densely distributed over the field, it is very hard to see the light grey. Places where there are bright nebulosity and extinction (compare to optical image in Figure 1) are evident as lower source densities.

Spitzer/SEIP

The Spitzer Enhanced Imaging Products (SEIP5; [12]) extracted sources (including bandfilled fluxes and limits) for all four IRAC bands plus Multiband Imaging Photometer for Spitzer (MIPS; [91]) 24 μ\mum, nominally to a SNR=10, meaning limited to the brighter sources. Note that SEIP is a reanalysis of the data that compose GLIMPSE, but with generally shallower photometry, as can be seen in the different numbers of sources in the catalog and in Figure 4 as compared to Figure 3. We merged the SEIP data to the aggregate catalog by position with 1″ radius, keeping track of limits as distinct from detections and retaining all of the sources from that catalog. (Note that there are more Spitzer data included and discussed below.)

Spitzer/SEIP sources

Figure 4. Spitzer/SEIP ([12]) sources (black) on the entire catalog (light grey). By comparison to Figure 3, it’s obvious that this catalog does not go as deep as GLIMPSE, and there is a mask of some sort in the upper left.

Coverage and numbers. SEIP covers our entire survey region, with 15,778 sources. They are plotted in Figure 4. SEIP’s sensitivity is shallower than GLIMPSE (compare Figure 3 and Figure 4); a histogram of the SEIP [3.6] magnitudes peaks at ∼12.5\sim12.5 and rolls over at ∼13\sim13 magnitudes. YSO candidates are not identified as part of the SEIP catalog itself. After all of the analysis described below, 993 are identified in the literature as YSOs or candidates. All of the sources from this catalog are retained in the master catalog.

MYStIX

The Massive Young Star-Forming Complex Study in Infrared and X-ray (MYStIX; [31]) was a very large study that combined Chandra X-ray Observatory (CXO; [111]) and Spitzer Space Telescope ([113]) data (plus additional NIR data from 2MASS and UKIRT, the United Kingdom Infrared Telescope) to identify young stars in 20 star-forming regions, including the Lagoon Nebula. They did extensive work to match sources across wavelengths, a non-trivial task given the point-spread functions, coordinate uncertainties, and large wavelength ranges involved. The MYStIX overview ([31]) cites an average of ∼1′′\sim1'' spatial resolution and a limit of Ks∼14K_s\sim14–18. Chandra’s on-axis spatial resolution is ∼0.5′′\sim0.5^{\prime\prime} and varies substantially over the field of view. MYStIX uses a modified GLIMPSE pipeline; Spitzer’s resolution at [3.6] is ∼1.6′′\sim1.6''.

We took MYStIX’s NIR and Spitzer measurements, and their source matching where it was available. M. S. Povich et al. [78] identified IR-excess sources, P. S. Broos et al. [11] presented a list of young stars (based on IR and X-rays), and G. Romine et al. [92] extended the analysis to include FIR and identified the youngest stars. M. C. Ramírez-Tannus et al. [85] followed up spectroscopically to confirm (or refute) the status of the objects they identified earlier. (We note for completeness that these papers also used data from [53].)

Because the source matching was done so carefully in MYStIX, it was important for us to inherit this matching, linking it explicitly to the Spitzer/NIR sources, early in our process. We added in to the master catalog sources from MYStIX that did not have Spitzer/NIR counterparts at the positions given in the MYStIX catalog, since there is not much more we can do for those sources. We also kept track of the sources identified as young stars in these papers.

Coverage and numbers. MYStIX covers our entire survey region, but in a complicated fashion. The Spitzer data they used cover our entire region, but the Chandra data they used do not, nor do some of the other ancillary data they incorporated in their later work. The MYStIX catalogs (particularly those from the latter papers) are often just the YSOs, and as such the histograms are not necessarily as easy to characterize as those for entire surveys. Therefore, we characterize them all together: a histogram of all the MYStIX KsK_s mags used here peaks at ∼13\sim13 mag, and that for [3.6] peaks at ∼12\sim12 mag. M. S. Povich et al. [78] reports 1,327 sources (plotted in Figure 5), 1,235 of which end up on our YSO list after all of the analysis below; P. S. Broos et al. [11] lists 1,914 YSO candidates (plotted in Figure 5); G. Romine et al. [92] describes 48 YSOs (plotted in Figure 5); and M. C. Ramírez-Tannus et al. [85] works with 86 YSOs (plotted in Figure 5). The difference between the Spitzer and Chandra coverage can be seen in comparing the M. S. Povich et al. [78] and P. S. Broos et al. [11] plots, where the latter requires Chandra. Comparing the 1,327 sources from M. S. Povich et al. [78] and the 1,914 sources from P. S. Broos et al. [11], there are 962 that appear in both papers. The 48 sources from G. Romine et al. [92] include 14 that also appear in M. S. Povich et al. [78] and 36 that also appear in P. S. Broos et al. [11]. Finally, the 86 from M. C. Ramírez-Tannus et al. [85] are entirely encompassed by P. S. Broos et al. [11]; 59 also appear in M. S. Povich et al. [78]. All of the sources reported by these papers are retained in our master catalog.

Six panels showing MYStIX, WISE/AllWISE, and Herschel/PACS catalog sources

Figure 5. In all cases, the indicated catalog is plotted in black and the entire catalog is shown in light grey. Top left: MYStIX: M. S. Povich et al. [78] members. This is the first figure in this series where the background catalog is clearly evident. Top right: MYStIX: P. S. Broos et al. [11] members. Middle left: MYStIX: G. Romine et al. [92] members. Middle right: MYStIX: M. C. Ramírez-Tannus et al. [85] members. Bottom left: WISE/AllWISE (E. L. Wright et al. [114, 115]) sources. Bottom right: Herschel/HPDP PSC 70 and 160 (G. Marton et al. [62]; PPSC Team [79]) sources. None of the Herschel/PACS sources are identified here as YSOs or candidates.

Lower-Resolution Catalogs

WISE/AllWISE

The Widefield Infrared Survey Explorer (WISE; E. L. Wright et al. [114, 115]), like 2MASS, is an all-sky survey; like Spitzer, it is tied to the 2MASS coordinate system, so it provides a good anchor to which we can tie other catalogs. WISE data were obtained in 3.43.4, 4.64.6, 1212, and 22 μm22\,\mu\mathrm{m}. We primarily used the AllWISE release (E. L. Wright et al. [115]), which sums up all available data prior to 2011 February. In general, this catalog reaches much fainter objects in 3.43.4 and 4.6 μm4.6\,\mu\mathrm{m} than in 1212 and 22 μm22\,\mu\mathrm{m}; the nominal completeness limits are 17.1, 15.7, 11.5, and 7.7 magnitudes for the four WISE bands, respectively. The spatial resolution is low compared to optical or even Spitzer – ∼6.1\sim6.1, 6.4, 6.5, and 12′′12^{\prime\prime} for the four channels, respectively. (Spitzer is ∼1.6′′−2′′\sim1.6^{\prime\prime} - 2^{\prime\prime} between 3.63.6 and 8 μm8\,\mu\mathrm{m}, and ∼6′′\sim6^{\prime\prime} at 24 μm24\,\mu\mathrm{m}; see Table 2 for spatial resolutions of other studies incorporated here.)

We have several long-wavelength catalogs that are lower spatial resolution and less sensitive. As a whole, these catalogs should have counterparts, if they exist at all, within the AllWISE catalog. That is, we can use the AllWISE catalog to correct the astrometry of the smaller, lower-resolution, longer-wavelength catalogs.

Coverage and numbers. WISE/AllWISE covers our entire survey region, with 6,006 sources. They are plotted in Figure 5. As mentioned above, [W1] spatial resolution is ∼6′′\sim6^{\prime\prime}; a histogram of [3.4] in this complicated region peaks at ∼11\sim11 mag. YSO candidates are not identified in the AllWISE catalog itself. After all of the analysis described below, 284 are identified in the literature as YSOs or candidates. All of the sources from this catalog are retained in the master catalog.

Herschel

The Herschel Space Observatory (G. L. Pilbratt et al. [76]) observed portions of this region with both the Photodetector Array Camera and Spectrometer (PACS, 70-160 μ\mum; A. Poglitsch et al. [77]; G. Marton et al. [62]) and the Spectral and Photometric Imaging Receiver (SPIRE, 250-500 μ\mum; M. J. Griffin et al. [39]). The Herschel High Level Images (HHLI5; HSA [45]) provide reduced images, and the PACS and SPIRE Point Source Catalogs (G. Marton et al. [62]) provide catalogs. However, the region in which we are working here is largely off the edge of the Herschel data. Only a few extracted PACS sources overlap the extreme northwestern edge of our region, none of which correspond to literature YSOs. We did not retain in our catalog Herschel sources that had no AllWISE counterpart, on the assumption that those sources were unlikely to have counterparts of interest in any of the other catalogs under consideration.

Coverage and numbers. Herschel/PACS covers only a tiny portion of our survey region. The only sources that were retained from this catalog are the three sources that had counterparts in AllWISE. They are plotted in Figure 5. YSO candidates are not identified in the Herschel/PACS catalog itself. None are identified in the literature considered here as YSOs or candidates.

AKARI

AKARI (H. Murakami et al. [71]; Akari Team [2]) was an all-sky Japanese mission, but was not as sensitive as Spitzer or WISE. We included data from the Infrared Camera (IRC) at 9 and 18 μ\mum and the Far-Infrared Surveyor (FIS) at 65, 90, 140, and 160 μ\mum. The published spatial resolution of IRC is ∼5′′\sim5^{\prime\prime} (H. Murakami et al. [71]); that for FIS is 1.5′′1.5^{\prime\prime} to 1′1^{\prime} (Y. Doi et al. [25]). AKARI IRC data required a 3′′3^{\prime\prime} matching radius to find counterparts, and the FIS data required a much larger 15′′15^{\prime\prime} matching radius. The reason for this probably has its origin in the fact that there are fewer point sources detected in IRC and fewer still in FIS, so there are fewer sources per unit area that can be tied to, e.g., astrometry from WISE or 2MASS. As a result, there are larger position uncertainties in any given AKARI source position. However, any legitimate AKARI source is extremely likely to also have been detected in WISE; we have found empirically (not just here but in other clusters as well) that extending the search radius to find the nearest WISE source is often the correct choice, and that is the origin of the matching radii we used. AKARI data are limited to the brighter sources – nominally at 9 μ\mum, all sources brighter than ∼0.2\sim0.2 Jy are detected and at 65 μ\mum, all sources brighter than ∼5\sim5 Jy are detected.

Fewer than 30 IRC sources correspond to literature YSOs discussed here, and just one FIS source has a literature YSO counterpart. We did not retain in our catalog AKARI sources that had no AllWISE counterpart, on the assumption that, given the other data we have merged to this point, those sources were somewhat less likely to be legitimate sources.

Coverage and numbers. AKARI covers our entire survey region with both instruments. The only sources that were retained from this catalog are the sources that had counterparts in AllWISE, which are 79 IRC sources, and 61 FIS sources. They are plotted in Figure 6. YSO candidates are not identified in either catalog. After all of the analysis described below, 27 IRC sources and 1 FIS source are identified in the literature as YSOs or candidates. AKARI sources in our region are bright – the faintest AKARI 9 μ\mum source is ∼0.1\sim0.1 Jy and the faintest AKARI 65 μ\mum source is ∼0.75\sim0.75 Jy.

Six panels showing AKARI IRC, AKARI FIS, MSX, IRAS, SCUBA, and unWISE source catalogs

Figure 6. In all cases, the indicated catalog is plotted in black and the entire catalog is shown in light grey. If there are additional cyan squares, these denote stars that are identified as YSOs or candidate YSOs later in the process. Top left: AKARI IRC ([71, 2]) sources. Top right: AKARI FIS ([71, 3]) sources. Middle left: MSX ([27, 70]) sources. Middle right: IRAS PSC ([72, 73]) sources. Bottom left: SCUBA ([23, 24]) sources. None of the SCUBA sources are apparently counterparts of literature YSOs considered here. Bottom right: WISE/unWISE ((D. Lang 2014; A. M. Meisner et al. 2017a,b; E. F. Schlafly et al. 2019)) sources. Pile-ups of sources at edges of nebulosity are apparent.

MSX

The Midcourse Space Experiment (MSX; M. P. Egan et al. [27]) was an Air Force mission that surveyed the Galactic Plane, including our region in the Lagoon nebula, though it’s not very sensitive (completeness is reached at about $\sim 0.1 Jy) and relatively low spatial resolution (∼20′′\sim20^{\prime\prime}). They published catalogs at 4.29, 4.35, 8.28, 12.13, 14.65, and 21.3 μ\mum ([70]) but only published images between 8 and 21 μ\mum. There are nominally ∼300\sim300 sources in our region. Using a 10′′10^{\prime\prime} search radius to match sources by position, just 35 match to literature YSO candidates considered here. In general, we did not retain MSX-only sources, but in the brightest heart of the region (the Hourglass Nebula), it may be that MSX is the highest spatial resolution instrument at these wavelengths that is not saturated, so sources within 3′3^{\prime} of 18:03:37 -24:23:12 were retained even if they were MSX-only.

Coverage and numbers. MSX covers our entire survey region. Sources with counterparts were retained, except in the Hourglass, where sources without counterparts were retained. MSX sources (a total of 292) are plotted in Figure 6. YSO candidates are not identified in this catalog. After all of the analysis described below, 35 MSX sources are identified in the literature as YSOs or candidates. MSX sources in our region are bright – the faintest MSX band A (4.29 μ\mum) source is ∼\sim0.07 Jy.

IRAS

The Infrared Astronomical Satellite (IRAS; [72, 73]) was the first space-based all-sky infrared survey, conducted at 12, 25, 60, and 100 μ\mum, with spatial resolution of ∼1\sim1-3′3^{\prime}, far worse than most other data sets.

included here. We used 15′′15^{\prime\prime} for positional matching. The completeness limits for the Point Source Catalog (PSC) are 0.4–1 Jy. We adopted uncertainties of 20% of the flux in all four IRAS bands.

Coverage and numbers. IRAS covers our entire survey region. Nineteen sources with counterparts were retained, and are plotted in Figure 6. The faintest IRAS-1 flux in our region is ∼\sim1.2 Jy. YSO candidates are not identified in this catalog. After all of the analysis described below, just 5 IRAS sources are identified in the literature as YSOs or candidates.

SCUBA

The Submillimetre Common User Bolometer Array (SCUBA) Legacy Catalogues [23, 24] provide catalogs of point sources at 450 and 850 μ\mum. There are SCUBA data covering the heart of the region, from the center of NGC 6523 to M8E, plus three smaller pointings in the area. Given the 33 sources overlapping our region, we looked for counterparts within 15′′15^{\prime\prime}. Again, given the bright heart of the Hourglass Nebula, sources within 3 arcminutes of 18:03:37 -24:23:12 were retained even if they were SCUBA-only.

Coverage and numbers. SCUBA data do not cover our entire survey region. All 33 sources were retained, and are plotted in Figure 6. YSO candidates are not identified in this catalog. After all of the analysis described below, none of the SCUBA sources are apparently counterparts of literature YSOs considered here.

WISE/unWISE and CatWISE

Finally, after the other lower-resolution data, we explored the remaining WISE data. The WISE satellite continued to take data between 2013 Dec and 2024 Aug, with the mission renamed NEOWISE. However, the project itself was not funded to create ensemble data products. CatWISE [61, 28, 60] and unWISE (D. Lang 2014; A. M. Meisner et al. 2017a,b; E. F. Schlafly et al. 2019; unWISE Team 2021) were both efforts to include these more recent data; both used images created by unWISE but obtain independent photometry. We included catalogs from both CatWISE and unWISE, matching by position with a 1′′1^{\prime\prime} radius; we retained all sources detected only by CatWISE and/or unWISE. The reason we didn’t merge these right after the AllWISE merge above is that we found empirically that all of the intervening catalogs were more likely to find a correct counterpart within AllWISE, and any fainter sources found in CatWISE and/or unWISE are more likely to be decoys to the true match. The spatial resolution is still ∼6′′\sim6^{\prime\prime}; both claim sensitivities at [3.4] down to slightly fainter than 17th magnitude.

Coverage and numbers. NEOWISE data cover our entire region. The ∼\sim25,000 sources from unWISE are plotted in Figure 6, and the ∼\sim17,000 sources from CatWISE are plotted in Figure 7. Pile-ups of sources at edges of nebulosity are apparent in unWISE, and remnants of source masking are readily apparent in CatWISE. Histograms of [3.4] from both these catalogs in this region are broad but peak at about 12.5 mag, and are clearly rolling over by 13. CatWISE has a longer fainter tail. Neither of these catalogs identified YSOs. Downstream from this point, 628 stars from unWISE and 447 stars from CatWISE were identified as YSOs or candidates.

Six-panel catalog location plots

Figure 7. In all cases, the indicated catalog is plotted in black and the entire catalog is shown in light grey. In two cases here, the cited article provided a list of members distinct from a list of sources; those members are indicated in red. Top left: CatWISE (F. Marocco et al. [61]; P. R. M. Eisenhardt et al. [28]; F. Marocco et al. [60]) sources. Remnants of source masking are readily apparent. Top right: L. Prisinzano et al. [84] members. Middle left: F. Damiani et al. [21] sources and members. Middle right: M. E. van den Ancker et al. (1997) members. Bottom left: H. Sung et al. [98] sources and members. Bottom right: G. Rauw et al. [86] members.

Smaller Literature Catalogs

The next catalogs we ingested were published in various articles focused on the Lagoon region, often on NGC 6530. Most of these catalogs identify YSOs and publish tables of just the YSOs (or candidates), as opposed to large catalogs of everything detected in the region. For the most part, we retain the identification of YSOs (or candidates), but when new photometry (or other relevant information) is available, we retain that as well. In some cases, this means that the only thing that is retained from a given paper is the fact that the star was listed as a YSO. In all cases (except where specified below), we retained the cross-ids as well as sources that appeared solely in that catalog (e.g., without matches to other catalogs).

We first work with two large, relatively recent catalogs: L. Prisninzano et al. (2019) and [21]. Having established a reasonably reliable catalog with these fairly large catalogs, we then backtracked to older catalogs to attempt to merge those. In some cases, we used the same technique as described in, e.g., [87] where we take a relatively old catalog, compare the sources to 2MASS to get improved coordinates, and then use the improved 2MASS coordinates for those sources to merge into the master catalog. For other cases, we empirically determined the best radius for source matching – for each object in a new catalog, we calculate the distance to the nearest match in the master catalog, and then make a histogram of these distances. Usually this distribution is sharply peaked and the majority of the sources fall < 1′′1^{\prime\prime}. (See individual discussions below.)

Because these catalogs are small and they vary a lot in wavelength coverage, in each one’s “coverage and numbers” paragraph (and in Table 2), the peak KsK_{\mathrm{s}} mag of the sample is used to characterize each sample for easy comparison to each other.

2019AA...623A.159P

L. Prisinzano et al. [84] explored the age spread in NGC 6530 using Gaia (specifically Gaia DR2 data; Gaia Collaboration et al. [32]) and Gaia-ESO survey (G. Gilmore et al. [35]) data. This paper used several sources of photometric data in the literature (all incorporated from their origins above or below), but the data we retained from their data table included VV, ICI_{\mathrm{C}}, and vsin⁡iv \sin i. They only listed members in their data table, so we also retained the mere fact that the stars were listed in their paper as a member.

Coverage and numbers. L. Prisinzano et al. [84] data cover our entire region but build upon data that are more concentrated on the East side; see Figure 7 for the locations of the 616 members. A histogram of KsK_{\mathrm{s}} for stars from this paper peaks at ∼13.2\sim13.2 mag.

2019AA...623A..25D

F. Damiani et al. [21] also worked with NGC 6530, where their scientific goals were to study its global properties. They used data published by this same group (see below) and other data we incorporated above or below, including those from MYStIX, VPHAS+ (see Sec. 2.6.6 below; J. E. Drew et al. [26] (2016)), and other data. While essentially all of the photometry they used should be absorbed by us from their respective origins (see Table 1), the identification of cluster members is unique to this paper. We retained cross-ids and photometry for later comparison, as well as all of the flags they used for identifying possible members.

Incorporating the information from this article was somewhat challenging because we had to correct considerable astrometric confusion. The baseline for their catalogs was the output of the VPHAS+ (J. E. Drew et al. [26] (2016)) pipeline, which, at least as of the time that it was run here, left residual sources in the catalog. (For example, the spatial resolution of VPHAS+ should be ∼1′′\sim1^{\prime\prime}, so all sources found within ∼0.4′′\sim0.4^{\prime\prime} of each other are likely duplicates.) In the end, we accepted only the stars identified by these authors as Gaia members as the best possible members. We merged this catalog to L. Prisinzano et al. [84] by position with a 1′′1^{\prime\prime} radius.

Coverage and numbers. F. Damiani et al. [21] cover most but not all of our region; see Figure 7. There are 2,901 sources incorporated into our master catalog, and 2,031 are retained as possible members. A histogram of KsK_s for stars from this paper peaks at ∼\sim13.6 mag.

1997AAS..123...63V

This is the first of the older, small catalogs that we merged in. M. E. van den Ancker et al. (1997) presents UBVUBV photometry for stars they thought were YSOs, as well as spectral types and cross-identifications for those stars from W. F. van Altena & B. F. Jones (1972), R. Sagar & U. C. Joshi [93], and M. F. Walker [108]. (The observations reported in M. E. van den Ancker et al. (1997) were probably all obtained at ∼15−16′′\sim15-16^{\prime\prime} spatial resolution, though in one instance in the text, ∼16′\sim16^{\prime} is mentioned.)

Sources from M. E. van den Ancker et al. (1997) were retained with their improved 2MASS coordinates. Once the coordinates were updated to 2MASS, we could match by position with a 1′′1^{\prime\prime} radius.

Coverage and numbers. M. E. van den Ancker et al. (1997) covers most of our area. The 96 members appear in Figure 7. A histogram of KsK_s for counterparts to stars from this paper peaks at ∼\sim11 mag.

2000AJ....120..333S

H. Sung et al. [98] used Hα\alpha and UBVRIUBVRI photometry to find 37 YSOs in NGC 6530. Helpfully, they published their entire catalog, not just the catalog of YSOs. We absorbed all of their photometry as well as their indication of whether or not they thought the star was a YSO. They report seeing was ∼\sim2-3″. We matched by position using a 2″ radius, which is an empirically-determined distance. Most of the astrometry did not require correction to find the appropriate counterpart; a few sources needed some shifting by less than 2″ to ensure that the correct counterpart was matched.

Coverage and numbers. H. Sung et al. [98] did not cover our whole region; see Figure 7 which shows the 900 sources from that catalog as well as the 446 members we carried forward. A histogram of KsK_s for counterparts to stars from this paper peaks at ∼\sim12.0 mag.

2002AA...395..499R

G. Rauw et al. [86] is the only X-ray study we incorporate that does not use data from Chandra; it analyzes an X-ray Multi-Mirror Mission (XMM-Newton; F. Jansen et al. [51]) observation of this region. They report on sources they detect that match uniquely to optical sources from H. Sung et al. [98], sources that match ambiguously to H. Sung et al. [98] sources, and sources that have no match in H. Sung et al.. We took the positions they reported, compared the positions to 2MASS sources, and largely but not always adopted the 2MASS counterpart’s position. G. Rauw et al. [86] took all of their detections as likely YSOs, so we followed suit and identified all of the G. Rauw et al. sources as implicit literature YSO candidates. XMM’s nominal resolution is 6″. We matched by position using a 2″ radius, again an empirically determined distance.

Coverage and numbers. G. Rauw et al. [86] did not cover our whole region. Figure 7 shows all 105 sources. A histogram of KsK_s for counterparts to stars from this paper peaks at ∼\sim12.0 mag.

2004ApJ...608..781D

F. Damiani et al. [20] used Chandra to study NGC 6530. They presented matches to 2MASS counterparts in most cases. We absorbed their catalog of X-ray detections, taking the fact that they detected it as an indicator of likely youth. If they indicated that they found a 2MASS counterpart, we took that as the match. If they listed more than one 2MASS counterpart, we took the closest one. If they did not list a counterpart, we took the position they listed for the source. We merged these sources with a 2′′2^{\prime\prime} radius.

Coverage and numbers. F. Damiani et al. [20] did not cover our whole region; all 884 sources are shown in Figure 8. A histogram of KsK_s for counterparts to stars from this paper peaks at ∼13.2\sim13.2 mag.

Six panels showing catalog sources and members across the NGC 6530 region

Figure 8. In all cases, the indicated catalog is plotted in black and the entire catalog is shown in light grey. In two cases here, the cited article provided a list of members distinct from a list of sources; the members are indicated in red. Top left: F. Damiani et al. [20] members. Top right: Surviving L. Prisinzano et al. [82] members (black) on the entire catalog (light grey). Middle left: J. I. Arias et al. [4] and J. I. Arias et al. [5] sources and members. Middle right: J.-L. Zhao et al. [118] sources and members. Bottom left: L. Chen et al. [17] members. Bottom right: L. Prisinzano et al. [81] members.

L. Prisinzano et al. (2005)

L. Prisinzano et al. [82] presented ground-based BVICBV I_C photometry of NGC 6530, and used these data in conjunction with the X-ray data from F. Damiani et al. [20] and 2MASS data to assess the age, distance, and initial mass function. We retained BVICBV I_C, the cross-identifications with H. Sung et al. [98], M. F. Walker [108], and F. Damiani et al. [20]. The best seeing in the paper is described as ∼0.8′′\sim0.8^{\prime\prime}, but there are several sources that are separated by ≤0.5′′\le0.5^{\prime\prime}. We consolidated these sources by hand where necessary. Aside from that, we took the counterparts they list for H. Sung et al. [98] and F. Damiani et al. [20]. The objects in this paper are described as being at least 90% members. We found that ∼70%\sim70\% have counterparts that are also identified as YSOs or YSO candidates by at least one other study here, but the remaining ∼30%\sim30\%, which is ∼400\sim400 sources, are identified as YSO candidates solely by L. Prisinzano et al. [82]. Based on that, and the fact that several subsequent papers written by many people within this same collaboration have reported more refined lists of YSO candidates, we retained the cross-ids from this paper but did not carry along the YSO identification for any of the stars identified as YSO candidates solely by this paper.

Coverage and numbers. Data from this paper did not cover our whole region. There were 1329 sources in the catalog from this paper originally, but 926 are carried forward as unique, real members, and those are what is shown in Figure 8. A histogram of KsK_s for counterparts to final YSOs or candidates from this paper peaks at ∼\sim13.2 mag.

Arias et al.

J. I. Arias et al. [4] studied the Hourglass Nebula in the heart of M8 using ground- and space-based NIR data. J. I. Arias et al. [5] continued work in this region, conducting follow-up spectroscopy of several candidate YSOs. We retained the JHKsJHK_s photometry from the first paper, but much of the photometry reported in the second paper is archival data that we have absorbed (or will below) from the original catalogs. Most of the stars in the 2006 paper may not be YSOs, but we took all of the stars in the 2007 paper to be literature YSOs. We also retained the spectral types from the 2007 paper. The ground-based data from 2006 had seeing <1′′<1^{\prime\prime}.

Coverage and numbers. The data from these two papers covered only a very tiny portion of our field, with the latter extending over a much larger region than the former; see Figure 8. J. I. Arias et al. [4] reports on 744 targets, 127 of which are likely members. J. I. Arias et al. [5] has just 44 members. A histogram of KsK_s for counterparts to stars from J. I. Arias et al. [4] peaks at ∼\sim15.7 mag. For counterparts to stars from J. I. Arias et al. [5], the histogram peaks at ∼\sim13.

2006ChJAA...6..435Z

J.-L. Zhao et al. [118] identified members from proper motions with a time baseline of 87 years. They used photographic plates with a baseline of nearly 100 years. We retained the cross-ids and the member probability, taking as members those with >90%>90\% probability. Neither spatial resolution nor seeing is mentioned in the article, but given that the mean positional error is considerably less than an arcsecond, one assumes that the seeing was at least comparable to an arcsecond. We used a matching radius of 1′′1^{\prime\prime}.

Coverage and numbers. Data from J.-L. Zhao et al. [118] cover most of our region. There are 112 targets in their catalog, 59 of which they report as having a membership probability of >90%>90\%, and these are the ones highlighted in Figure 8. However, all 112 are ultimately identified as YSOs in one way or another. A histogram of KsK_s for counterparts to stars from this paper is very broad but peaks at ∼\sim10.5 mag.

2007AJ....134.1368C

L. Chen et al. [17] studied mass segregation in NGC 6530 and one other cluster using photographic plates. We retained the BB magnitude for everything reported, plus the identification of objects that were tagged as likely members. The seeing for these data was not reported in the article. We used an empirically-determined matching radius of 2′′2^{\prime\prime}.

Coverage and numbers. This catalog covers most of our region. All 147 stars are shown in Figure 8. A histogram of KsK_s for counterparts to stars from this paper peaks at ∼\sim10.7 mag.

2007AA...462..123P

L. Prisinzano et al. [81] followed up some of the work from their 2005 paper (L. Prisinzano et al. [82]) with spectroscopy to identify members. The information we absorbed included the photometry, vsin⁡iv\sin i, whether or not they identified the star as having a disk, and whether or not they identified the star as being a member. We used an empirically-determined matching radius of 2′′2^{\prime\prime}; the overwhelming majority of sources could be matched within 1′′1^{\prime\prime}, but 3% needed the larger matching radius.

Coverage and numbers. Because it builds on L. Prisinzano et al. [82], these data did not cover our whole region; see Figure 8, where 332 stars are shown. A histogram of KsK_s for counterparts to stars from this paper peaks at ∼\sim12.4 mag.

2010MNRAS.407.1170K

D. L. Kumar & B. G. Anandarao [56] studied M8 with Spitzer/IRAC, incorporating JHKsJHK_s data from 2MASS and J. I. Arias et al. [4, 5]. They published photometry for the YSO candidates they identified using the R. A. Gutermuth et al. [40, 41] approach. We matched by position with a 1′′1^{\prime\prime} radius and retained the IRAC photometry as well as the fact that they are listed as YSOs. D. L. Kumar & B. G. Anandarao [56] do not report photometric uncertainties; where our best available IRAC value (see § 2.10) comes from them, we assigned an uncertainty of 0.3 mag.

Coverage and numbers. The 221 targets reported by D. L. Kumar & B. G. Anandarоao [56] are distributed across most of our area; see Figure 9. A histogram of KsK_s for stars from this paper peaks at ∼\sim11.6 mag.

Six-panel spatial distributions of catalog members, variables, and sources

Figure 9. In all cases, the indicated catalog is plotted in black and the entire catalog is shown in light grey. Top left: D. L. Kumar & B. G. Anandarоao [56] members. Top right: C. B. Henderson & K. G. Stassun [42] variables. Middle left: P. J. Castro [14] sources. Middle right: V. M. Kalari et al. [52] members. Bottom left: N. J. Wright et al. [116] members. Bottom right: SPICY: M. A. Kuhn et al. [54] members.

C. B. Henderson & K. G. Stassun (2012)

C. B. Henderson & K. G. Stassun [42] presented rotation periods for 290 stars in the Lagoon Nebula, to which they add literature data, all of which has been incorporated above. The spatial resolution of their data is not described in their paper, but the seeing at Cerro Tololo is often ∼1−1.5′′\sim1 - 1.5''. We used an empirically determined matching radius of 2′′2''; we retained the reported period and tagged all of these reported variable stars as implicit candidate YSOs.

Coverage and numbers. C. B. Henderson & K. G. Stassun [42] focused their attention on a subset of our field. The 290 targets for which they reported periods appear in Figure 9. A histogram of KsK_s for stars from this paper peaks at ∼\sim13.2 mag.

P. J. Castro (2013)

P. J. Castro [14] worked with some Chandra observations of the Lagoon Nebula that were not included in the works by Damiani, Prisinzano, et al. above, but were included in the MYStIX analysis. A copy of the relevant table from his thesis was obtained via private communication in 2015 with the intention of being incorporated into our catalog. Sources were not (could not be) matched to counterparts in as sophisticated a fashion as was done within the MYStIX program. There are 1482 sources from the P. J. Castro [14] catalog. Treating the P. J. Castro [14] catalog just as all the other independent catalogs here and merging it (matching by position within 2″) in to the master catalog, 84% have counterparts within MYStIX. Out of those that don’t match MYStIX, 64 sources in the final catalog have positions that don’t match any other source from any other catalog used here; given the wealth of other data we have, it is unusual that these sources would both be legitimate additional sources and have no other counterparts. There are also 91 sources that are tagged as possible YSOs based solely on their presence in the Castro catalog (all the remaining Castro sources were also identified as YSOs by at least one other catalog here). Based on the entirety of this assessment, we left the Castro catalog merged in for cross-ids, but did not add in to the master catalog those sources found only in P. J. Castro [14], and did not tag sources found only in Castro as YSO candidates. (This is the same treatment as for L. Prisinzano et al. [82] above.)

Coverage and numbers. The data from P. J. Castro [14] do not cover our whole region; see Figure 9. All 1,350 sources are shown in the Figure, though only 1,303 end up as YSO candidates after the analysis here. A histogram of KsK_s for counterparts to stars from this paper peaks at ∼13.5 mag.

V. M. Kalari et al. (2015)

V. M. Kalari et al. [52] used VPHAS+ (see Sec. 2.6.6) data to estimate accretion rates for 235 YSOs in the Lagoon; they used both Hα and uu-band and selected YSO candidates. We matched by position with a search radius of 2″, and retained their cross-id (with it their implicit YSO tag) and their estimate of accretion rate.

Coverage and numbers. Data from V. M. Kalari et al. [52] cover most of our region; see Figure 9. All 195 targets are included as YSOs. A histogram of KsK_s for counterparts to stars from this paper is very broad but peaks at ∼12.7 mag.

N. J. Wright et al. (2019a)

N. J. Wright et al. [116] worked with the Gaia-ESO data set to explore the 3D3\mathrm{D} structure of NGC 6530. All of the ancillary (non-Gaia-ESO) data they worked with come from several different resources we have already incorporated above or below, so the only thing we retained is the membership flag (their table in N. J. Wright et al. [117]).

Coverage and numbers. Data from N. J. Wright et al. [116] basically cover our region, but are biased towards the east; see Figure 9. All 776 targets are included as YSOs. A histogram of KsK_s for counterparts to stars from this paper is broad and flat but is turning over by ∼13.6 mag.

SPICY: 2021ApJS..254...33K

M. A. Kuhn et al. [54] worked with machine learning to identify YSOs over the Galactic plane using data we have incorporated above or below, and used MYStIX data as the training set. We pulled data from this catalog, called SPICY (Spitzer/IRAC Candidate YSO; M. A. Kuhn et al. [55]), in our region, matched to the master catalog within 1″, and identified them as YSO candidates in our catalog.

Coverage and numbers. Sources from SPICY cover our region; see Figure 9. All 466 targets are included as YSOs. A histogram of KsK_s from these stars peaks at ∼13.0 mag.

2022MNRAS.517.6191O

C. Ordenes-Huanca et al. [74] studied the variability of YSOs in this region in KsK_s. They identified their YSOs based on a subset of the literature we have also considered above. However, the region on the sky that they considered is larger than the region we have considered, so not all of their sources are in our catalog. We matched by position within 1″ and retained their mean KsK_s, rotation period, and variability class. We also tagged their variable sources as implicit YSO candidates.

Coverage and numbers. Data from C. Ordenes-Huanca et al. [74] basically cover our region, but are biased towards the east; see Figure 10. All 361 variables are shown. A histogram of KsK_s for counterparts to stars from this paper is at ∼13.2 mag.

Six catalog spatial distributions

Figure 10. In all cases, the indicated catalog is plotted in black and the entire catalog is shown in light grey. In two cases here, the cited article provided a list of members distinct from a list of sources; the members are indicated in red. Top left: C. Ordenes-Huanca et al. [74] variables. Top right: R. J. Jackson et al. [50] catalog and members. Middle left: DENIS (N. Epchtein et al. [29]; Denis Team [22]) sources. Tile boundaries and margins are immediately apparent. Middle right: C. P. M. Bell et al. [8] sources and members. Bottom left: Gaia DR3 (Gaia Collaboration et al. [33]; IRSA [48]) sources. The additional extinction from dust is immediately obvious. Bottom right: UKIDSS (P. W. Lucas et al. [58]; UKIDSS Consortium [102]) sources.

2022MNRAS.509.1664J

R. J. Jackson et al. [50] explored membership of NGC 6530 (among many other clusters) using Gaia-ESO spectra. We matched their catalog to ours based on Gaia DR3 ID – we did not match by position, so the actual merging of this catalog took place after the Gaia merge below, but we list this catalog here in the text because it is another small catalog. We took as members those where their P3D≥0.90P_{3D} \ge0.90 (retaining that number in our catalog) and identified those stars as YSO candidates in our catalog. Stars with P3D=−1P_{3D} = -1 are in their sample but were excluded from their maximum-likelihood membership analysis, because of incomplete Gaia data, because they were identified as likely background giants or distant background stars, or because their radial or tangential velocity was more than 75 km s−1^{-1} from the cluster median (R. J. Jackson et al. [50], their Sections 2.4, 3.1, and 4.3).

Coverage and numbers. Data from R. J. Jackson et al. [50] cover our region. There are 1458 targets, 735 of which are in our final catalog and 439 of which we took as members tagged by this paper; see Figure 10. A histogram of KsK_s from counterparts of these stars peaks at ∼13.2\sim13.2 mag.

Larger Catalogs

We waited until this point in the process to merge the larger catalogs that are more likely to have false sources, or sources that would be more likely to provide decoy matches to YSO candidates in the above catalogs. For example, a bright IR source is reasonably likely to break into several optical pieces (if for no other reason than the optical surveys tend towards higher spatial resolution), but the bright IR source is also more likely to be the YSO, so by merging the large optical catalogs later in the process, we are more likely to match the correct sources by simple position matching.

Some of these large catalogs report a magnitude with an uncertainty of zero, or with no uncertainty at all. Rather than discard these measurements, we assigned them an uncertainty of 0.3 mag, both so that they can be used in the SEDs and to flag them as suspect for later investigators. The affected bands are noted in each subsection below.

DENIS

The Deep Near Infrared Survey of the Southern Sky (DENIS; N. Epchtein et al. [29]; Denis Team [22]) covered our region in II, JJ, and KsK_s. Nominally, the depth of this survey is KD∼18.5K_D \sim18.5, and the spatial resolution is ∼1−3′′\sim1-3^{\prime\prime}. We matched sources from this catalog with a 2′′2^{\prime\prime} radius. We incorporated into the catalog sources that appeared for the first time in DENIS.

Coverage and numbers. DENIS nominally covers the whole region, but as can be seen in Figure 10, there is a stripe of missing coverage, a stripe of lesser coverage, and stripes of deeper coverage (presumably where tiles overlapped). There are 24,550 DENIS sources in the master catalog, 1,550 of which get tagged as YSOs by any other literature considered here. A histogram of KDK_D for sources in our region is clearly rolling over by ∼13\sim13 mag.

2013MNRAS.434..806B

C. P. M. Bell et al. [8] published their entire large catalog as part of their analysis of 13 star forming regions. We retained their catalog number, UgriZUgriZ, and their membership flag. The spatial resolution is not described in their paper but the seeing is likely ∼1.5′′\sim1.5^{\prime\prime}. We matched sources from this catalog with a 2′′2^{\prime\prime} radius.

Coverage and numbers. C. P. M. Bell et al. [8] has complicated tile boundaries and edges; see Figure 10. All 8,567 sources in the catalog are shown, along with the 936 sources identified as members. A histogram of KsK_s from counterparts of these stars peaks at ∼15.0\sim15.0 mag.

Gaia

The next set of these very large catalogs provided additional challenges due to their size. We used TOPCAT to merge all of these with a 1′′1^{\prime\prime} radius.

We first merged Gaia DR3 (Gaia Collaboration et al. [33]; IRSA [48]) data for this region with geometric distances from C. A. L. Bailer-Jones et al. [6] (via VizieR; C. A. L. Bailer-Jones et al. [7]). We retained optical photometric data in GBPG_{BP}, GG, GRPG_{RP} as well as parallax and proper motion, plus other diagnostics like renormalised unit weight error (RUWE), astrometric excess noise, and duplicated source flags. We merged those two catalogs together within TOPCAT, and then carried that merged catalog forward.

As a space-based astrometric mission, the spatial resolution is at least ∼0.5′′\sim0.5^{\prime\prime} and it reaches at least G∼21G \sim21 mag, which is better in both resolution and sensitivity than anything else we have incorporated. However, since it is working in the optical, it is limited by the dust in this region, so it doesn’t reach those depths everywhere here in practice.

Coverage and numbers. Gaia covers our whole region, and is limited by dust; see Figure 10. There are 36,939 sources in our master catalog, 2,374 of which are identified by other studies here as YSOs. For the ones that also have distances from C. A. L. Bailer-Jones et al. [6], there are 27,693 in the master catalog, 2,202 of which are identified by other studies here as YSOs. A histogram of GG in this region peaks at ∼20.7\sim20.7 mag. A histogram of KsK_s from counterparts of these stars peaks at ∼15.0\sim15.0 mag, but that is limited by the existence of KsK_s counterparts, not Gaia.

UKIDSS

The next large catalog we used was that from the UKIRT (United Kingdom Infrared Telescope) Infrared Deep Sky Survey (UKIDSS) Galactic Plane Survey (P. W. Lucas et al. [58]; UKIDSS Consortium [102]), which observed in JHKsJHK_s. Nominally, this survey reaches Ks∼18K_s \sim18 mag, with a resolution of ∼0.8′′\sim0.8^{\prime\prime} (P. W. Lucas et al. [58]). Where UKIDSS reports an uncertainty of zero, we assigned 0.3 mag (see above).

Coverage and numbers. UKIDSS covers our whole region. There are 157,995 sources from UKIDSS (see Figure 10), 2,580 of which are tagged as YSOs by the literature explored here. A histogram of the UKIDSS KsK_s for all sources in this region is broad but rolls over by Ks∼16K_s \sim16 mag.

VVV

VISTA variables in the Vía Láctea (VVV; R. K. Saito et al. [94]; D. Minniti et al. [67]) was another large catalog we used, specifically their DR2, which includes single-epoch observations. They observed in ZYJHKsZYJHK_s; the magnitudes are on the Vega system, calibrated to 2MASS (R. K. Saito et al. [94]). The spatial resolution is ∼1′′\sim1^{\prime\prime} and nominally the KsK_s limit is between 16 and 18, depending on location in the sky ([94]). Where VVV reports an uncertainty of zero (only in ZZ and YY, and only for a handful of YSOs), we assigned 0.3 mag.

Coverage and numbers. VVV covers our whole region. There are 168,338 sources from VVV in our master catalog (see Figure 11), 2,665 of which are tagged as YSOs by the literature explored here. The histogram of VVV KsK_s for sources in this region is broad and textured, but peaks at ∼15.7\sim15.7 and rolls over by ∼16.5\sim16.5 mag.

VVV, VPHAS+, PanSTARRS, and Venuti et al. members

Figure 11. In all cases, the indicated catalog is plotted in black and the entire catalog is shown in light grey. Top left: VVV ([94, 67]) sources. Top right: VPHAS+ ([26] (J. E. Drew et al. 2016)) sources. This survey, being further into the optical than UKIDSS or VVV, is more impacted by dust. Bottom left: PanSTARRS ([16, 15]) sources. Bottom right: L. Venuti et al. [106] and L. Venuti et al. [107] members.

VPHAS+

The VST Photometric Halpha Survey of the Southern Galactic Plane and Bulge (VPHAS+; [26] (J. E. Drew et al. 2016)) was carried out in ugriugri and Hα\mathrm{H}\alpha. This survey, being further into the optical than UKIDSS or VVV, is more impacted by dust; see Figure 11. The spatial resolution is ∼1′′\sim1^{\prime\prime} and the target depth is 20th mag (on the Vega system) at all bands ([26]). Where VPHAS+ reports an uncertainty of zero, we assigned 0.3 mag.

Coverage and numbers. VPHAS+ covers our whole region; see Figure 11. There are 59,473 sources from VPHAS+ in our master catalog, 2,280 of which are tagged as YSOs by the literature explored here. A histogram of VPHAS+ ii magnitudes for sources in this region peaks at ∼21\sim21, better than designed.

Pan-STARRS

The last large catalog was Panoramic Survey Telescope and Rapid Response System (Pan-STARRS; [16, 15]). These data are grizygrizy mean PSF magnitudes, averaged over the single-epoch detections. The impact of the dust can be seen in Figure 11. The quoted spatial resolution is ∼1′′\sim1^{\prime\prime} and depth is ∼20\sim20 mag at yy ([16]). Where Pan-STARRS reports no uncertainty, or an uncertainty of zero, we assigned 0.3 mag.

Coverage and numbers. Pan-STARRS covers our whole region. There are 84,118 stars from PanSTARRS in our master catalog, 2,494 of which are tagged as YSOs by the literature explored here. A histogram of yy magnitudes for targets in this region peaks at ∼19.0\sim19.0 mag.

Combining These Big Catalogs

We took these five catalogs (Gaia plus the merged distances, UKIDSS, VVV, VPHAS+, and Pan-STARRS) and carried out a 5-way position merge with a 1′′1^{\prime\prime} radius in TOPCAT, retaining all sources whether or not they had a counterpart. We took all of the sources as-is from the catalogs of origin, and merged them into the master catalog with a 1′′1^{\prime\prime} radius. Further weeding of phantom sources from these catalogs was identified downstream from this point.

The Last Literature Catalogs: Venuti et al.

Finally, we merged in the catalogs from L. Venuti et al. [106, 107]. Both of these projects started from earlier versions of our catalog, so it made sense to add these catalogs near the end of our process. Both of these catalogs, however, include sources from a region larger than our current catalog. Out of 1018 unique sources found in the combined catalogs from both Venuti papers, 72 are outside of the region we defined for this paper, leaving 946; 275 from L. Venuti et al. [106] have counterparts in our current catalog, and 943 from L. Venuti et al. [107] have counterparts in our current catalog. We retained the average ugriHαugriH\alpha, spectral types, and mass accretion rates, as well as catalog ID (and implicit identification as a YSO), from these catalogs. The photometry is taken from L. Venuti et al. [107], or from L. Venuti et al. [106] for bands missing from the later catalog; where both catalogs report a value, they agree to within 0.005 mag. We assigned an uncertainty of 0.15 mag to all of the Venuti et al. photometry. Some source confusion present in our early catalog version has been corrected here, but this only affects 15 stars, and none of these issues affect the conclusions of L. Venuti et al. [106] or L. Venuti et al. [107].

Coverage and numbers. Our region is covered by both L. Venuti et al. [106] and L. Venuti et al. [107]. The 271 surviving counterparts from L. Venuti et al. [106] and the 928 surviving counterparts from L. Venuti et al. [107] are shown in Figure 11. A histogram of KsK_s from counterparts of these stars peaks just below ∼\sim13th mag.

Patching Spitzer Photometry

By the time we reached this point in the process, most of the literature-identified YSO candidates had Spitzer IRAC and MIPS-24 measurements. For those that did not have measurements, we performed aperture photometry. Following guidelines from the IRAC Instrument Handbook (IRAC Instrument Team & IRAC Instrument Support Team [47]), for the IRAC data, we used an aperture of 3 native px, an annulus of 3-7 px, and aperture corrections 1.124, 1.127, 1.143, and 1.234 for the four bands, respectively. Similarly, from the MIPS Instrument Handbook (MIPS Instrument MIPS Instrument Support Teams [68]), for MIPS-24, we used an aperture of 2.857 px, an annulus of 2.857-5.306 px, and an aperture correction of 2.05. This bandfill is only necessary for targets where somehow all the existing Spitzer photometry attempts (primarily SEIP, GLIMPSE, and MYStIX) missed them – meaning that they are likely very faint (or very bright), and/or with a very complicated background (near a bright source, artifacts, or nebulosity). In those cases, aperture photometry is likely sub-optimal, but it is unclear if more advanced photometric techniques would be useful. As a result, when we inspected SEDs (see § 2.11 below), if this new photometry was inconsistent with the rest of the SED, particularly for MIPS, we simply dropped it.

Best Available Photometry

For some bands, it’s useful to have a ‘best available’ value.

The best available JHKsJHK_s photometry were populated first from 2MASS, then UKIDSS, VVV, DENIS (just JKsJ K_s), MYStIX, and finally J. I. Arias et al. [4]. The catalog in Appendix § 11 (Table 5) has the best available data as well as all of the individual JHKsJHK_s values from all the surveys. The individual JHKsJHK_s values from all the surveys appear in the SEDs. The best available values carry the uncertainties of the catalog they were taken from, including the 0.3 mag uncertainties assigned where the original catalog gave none (see the individual subsections above).

The best available IRAC and MIPS photometry were populated in this priority order: SEIP, MYStIX, GLIMPSE, D. L. Kumar & B. G. Anandaroo [56], and then patched photometry (as described above). The catalog in Appendix § 11 (Table 5) has the best available data as well as all of the individual IRAC and MIPS values from all the individual surveys. Because all of these studies are working with the same data, the best available data are plotted in the SEDs.

SED and Image Inspection

Because the source surface density is so high, the potential for catalog mismatches is high. As an integral part of the catalog matching process, we constructed SEDs for each literature-identified YSO and overlaid catalogs on as many images as possible and relevant (typically at least 2MASS, WISE, Spitzer, POSS, Pan-STARRS, and/or VVV), attempting to resolve source confusion issues using this additional information.

For the list of literature YSO candidates, we iterated among SEDs, images, remerging catalogs as we moved through the list multiple times, looking in detail at each source. If the SED was contiguous throughout all available wavelengths and the star seemed point-like and relatively isolated in all images in IRSA’s Finder Chart tool [49], then we assumed it was correctly merged across catalogs. These SED and image inspections also primarily revealed:

  • discontinuous SEDs, suggesting a source mismatch or incorrect photometry;

  • SEDs where the net result looks like two sources are plotted on the same SED, suggesting source confusion or a source mismatch in at least one band;

  • catalogs with artifacts that draw matches of real detections away from a real source;

  • ‘detections’ from the same catalog that are much closer together than the stated spatial resolution of the survey of origin;

  • ‘detections’ that are not real – no source is apparent in the corresponding image and the flux as plotted in the SED is inconsistent with the rest of the SED;

  • sources that are single in some low-spatial-resolution bands but that are multiple in higher-spatial-resolution bands;

  • X-ray sources that have no known counterparts at any other bands here.

If we could shift matches around within 11-1.5′′1.5^{\prime\prime} to create two (or occasionally three) continuous, internally-consistent SEDs where before there was a single garbled one, we retained the cross-matches that resulted in the two (or three) good SEDs. If one source from one catalog could be identified as a likely artifact, we dropped it and shifted any spurious matches to the nearest real source. If a logical solution wasn’t obvious even if the SED was a mess, we left it as is. If a flux was inconsistent with the rest of the SED, and the source wasn’t apparent in the image, that flux was removed or converted to a limit. If there was information from Gaia that could help (RUWE, astrometric excess noise, duplicated source flags), we incorporated that information in our assessment. Many sources were carefully tweaked, consolidated, unhooked, removed, or otherwise clarified during this time-consuming manual process, resulting in the final cleaned-up catalog presented here. Some X-ray sources obstinately persisted in having no known counterparts at any of the bands assembled here, and at this time, there is not much more we can do about exploring those sources, other than listing them in the catalog.7

Example SEDs

Figure 12 shows some of the final SEDs that emerged from this entire process. In that figure, there are two sample SEDs where there is likely to be no IR excess and two SEDs where there is a very large IR excess and detections out past 50 μm50\ \mu\mathrm{m}. The first thing that is immediately apparent from the SEDs is just how many different catalogs have been combined. The different catalogs are largely in very good agreement, such that it is hard to distinguish the individual symbols in the figure, especially in the optical. Some of the residual scatter in the SED is likely from intrinsic variability, particularly in the optical for the stars with a significant IR excess.

Figure 12. Example SEDs, part 1. These use cgs units for the λFλ\lambda F_{\lambda} axis, erg sec−1^{-1} cm−2^{-2}, and the wavelength axis is in microns. Error bars are vertical black lines, most obvious here in just a few of the points. The dashed line is the expected flux density from photosphere assuming KsK_{\mathrm{s}} is on the photosphere. Coordinate-based names appear above each plot. Sample SEDs show (first row) a likely earlier type, well-populated SED with no likely IR excess to 8 μ\mum and upper limits at 12, 22, and 24 μ\mum; (second row) a likely later type, well-populated SED with no IR excess; (third row, left) well-populated SED with substantial IR excess (and detections at all four IRAS bands); (third row, right) minimally populated SED with no points longer than 2 μ\mum; (fourth row, left) well-populated SED of embedded object and large IR excess, with detections at several IRAS, MSX, and Akari bands; (fourth row, right) minimally populated, likely irretrievably confused SED with no points longer than 2 μ\mum.

Figure 12 also has an example SED of an object about which we know nothing past KsK_s, so we cannot assess whether or not it has an IR excess. And, finally, Figure 12 includes an object for which we could not resolve the evident source confusion that is apparent from the SED. Additional data will be needed to untangle this source and the few others like it in our final catalog.

Disks

Identifying IR Excesses: Initial Placement

We have diverse data for the YSO candidates in our collection, so it is difficult to come up with a single prescription for identifying disks across the entire sample. To attempt to take into account all the available data and still identify the YSOs with IR excesses, we used a quantitative approach for an initial classification and then manually inspected each SED multiple times to place the object in an appropriate bin. We now describe the quantitative approach for the initial classification.

As discussed in, e.g., T. F. Mizusawa et al. [69] or D. E. Trilling et al. [101], one way of calculating the significance of an IR excess is the following for two bands, B1B_1 and B2B_2, where σ\sigma is the uncertainty:

χB1−B2=([B1]−[B2])observed−([B1]−[B2])predictedσ([B1]−[B2])(1)\chi_{B_1-B_2}=\frac{([B1]-[B2])_{\mathrm{observed}}-([B1]-[B2])_{\mathrm{predicted}}}{\sigma_{([B1]-[B2])}} \tag*{(1)}

We have many bands to compare, but comparing across different instruments can be complicated (see below re: systematic IRAC offset). We also don’t have spectral types for most of our stars. For most FGK and early M stars, if the shorter band is on the photosphere, the expected IR color is 0, but for later M stars, it is not 0. Fortunately, given that this target is at ∼1250\sim1250 pc, there are not many M stars in our YSO list, so we assumed that the predicted photospheric IR colors were 0 for all of our YSOs. For situations where the shorter band is not on the photosphere, in most cases, the SED is well-populated enough that the excess is apparent from the SED alone, and any χ\chi calculations are less important.

We calculated χ\chi within Spitzer (for colors [I1]−[I2][I1]-[I2], [I1]−[I3][I1]-[I3], [I1]−[I4][I1]-[I4], [I1]−[M24][I1]-[M24], using the best available values) and within WISE (for colors [W1]−[W2][W1]-[W2], [W1]−[W3][W1]-[W3], [W1]−[W4][W1]-[W4], using AllWISE); and then comparing KsK_s with Spitzer (for colors [Ks]−[I2][K_s]-[I2], [Ks]−[I3][K_s]-[I3], [Ks]−[I4][K_s]-[I4], [Ks]−[M24][K_s]-[M24], using the best available values) and WISE (for colors [Ks]−[W2][K_s]-[W2], [Ks]−[W3][K_s]-[W3], [Ks]−[W4][K_s]-[W4], using the best available KsK_s and AllWISE). Because the Spitzer data are the highest resolution and sensitivity IR data we have, the χ\chi values for those should be the most sensitive. The χ\chi within WISE should be the next most sensitive, followed by the ones that combine KsK_s and Spitzer, and then KsK_s and WISE. The distribution of these χ\chi values were inspected and used to set some limits. We fit Gaussians to each distribution and looked at how far out we needed to go to reach ∼3σ\sim3\sigma from the mean; this is easier where there are more χ\chi values. There are few χWISE\chi_{\mathrm{WISE}} in general, but even within those, there are very few involving [W3] or [W4], just because there are so few with detections at those bands. Based on the distributions, for each χ\chi, a corresponding threshold was set for identifying an IR excess: χ>4\chi> 4 for any of the combinations within Spitzer, χ>5\chi> 5 within WISE, χ>8\chi> 8 for the combination of KsK_s and Spitzer, and χ>9\chi> 9 for the combination of KsK_s and WISE.

For each source, if there are data past 2 μ\mum, and everything that has detections also has the corresponding χ\chi above those thresholds, then it has a significant IR excess. If it is all below those thresholds, then it does not have a significant IR excess. It is common, however, that there are mixed results. More weight was put on longer wavelengths than shorter. An excess that starts at >5>5 μ\mum can still be a legitimate excess. A significant excess at 24 or 8 μ\mum with no detections longer than that, but no excess shorter than that, is still a significant IR excess. An apparently significant excess at 3 or 4 μ\mum, but photospheric fluxes between 5 and 25 μ\mum, is probably not a real excess. More weight was placed on Spitzer than WISE data, because of the difference in sensitivity and spatial resolution. If there was no significant excess within Spitzer or WISE, but there was a significant excess when comparing those to KsK_s, it’s possible that there is a small excess.

IR Excesses: Final Placement

After automatic placement in the initial, provisional excess bins, each object was individually visually inspected and their placement adjusted if necessary. Patterns within the final disk categories were noted and similar stars were grouped together; see next section.

We emphasize that the quantitative use of the χ\chi values is for an initial disk placement, but all stars’ SEDs are inspected and verified individually to be sure that they are properly characterized before their final disk placement.

IR Excess Categories

There are three easy categories into which we can place SEDs. One is “no data” – there are no data past KsK_s, so there is no information as to whether or not there is an IR excess (18% of YSO sample); an example appears in the third row of Figure 12. “Unambiguous no excess” (“no”) means that there are data at KsK_s and longer bands, and everything up to and including the longest wavelength available is consistent with photospheric emission (30% of YSO sample); two examples appear in the first two rows of Figure 12. This includes situations where only the longest band has an excess but it is not significant because there is also a big error bar. “Unambiguous excess” (“yes”) means that there is more than one band past KsK_s involved in a many-sigma IR excess – that is, the SED could be in a textbook as an example SED (like the two in the lower left of Figure 12); there is no ambiguity as to whether or not there is an excess (26% of YSO sample). Most (72%) of the YSO sample are in these straightforward bins.

We found it necessary to create additional categories beyond these “easy” categories. There are cases we have tagged “no?” (5%) – there are data past KsK_s, the longest wavelength available seems like it might be consistent with the photosphere, but maybe there is a small excess (Figure 13c). There are stars where the SED is photospheric except for one band, the longest band, which seems to be significantly above the photosphere (“1-band”; 4%; Figure 13e). There are stars where there seems to be an excess, but it is only manifesting significantly in one band, and the adjacent shorter-wavelength point is offset from the photosphere, though not statistically significantly given the χ\chi value (“1+-band”; 2%; Figure 13f). There are stars where there is marginal evidence for a disk (“yes?”; 8%; Figure 14) – most often that means that 2 bands seem to have a slight excess.

Figure 13. Example SEDs, part 2. These use cgs units for the λFλ\lambda F_{\lambda} axis, erg sec−1^{-1} cm−2^{-2}, and the wavelength axis is in microns. Legend is as in Figure 12. Coordinate-based names appear above each plot. Sample SEDs show: a- offset IRAC; b- offset IRAC-3 and -4; c- “no?” disk; d- “no?”/v-shape; e- 1-band; f- 1+band; g- weird/scatter; h- straightup. See the text for more details.

Figure 14. Example SEDs, part 3. These use cgs units for the λFλ\lambda F_{\lambda} axis, erg sec−1^{-1} cm−2^{-2}, and the wavelength axis is in microns. Legend is as in Figure 12. Coordinate-based names appear above each plot. Sample SEDs show possible disks (“yes?”) in first two rows, and confident disks (“yes”) in the last two rows.

In some cases (∼7%\sim7\% of the YSOs), there is an apparently systematic offset of the IRAC measurements. That is, all of the measured IRAC bands (all four, or, more commonly, just the shortest two where the longest 2 are non-detections) appear on a line parallel to the Rayleigh-Jeans line but offset slightly high. There is no significant excess apparent within the IRAC bands (e.g., [I1]−[I2]∼0\sim0, [I1]−[I4]∼0\sim0), but there is a small, apparently significant excess when comparing to KsK_s. Examples of these stars are in Figure 13, panels a and b, where a has all four IRAC bands offset and b has just IRAC 3 and 4 offset. We spent considerable time investigating the origin of this offset to no avail. This does not appear to be an error in data reduction. It could be a result of source confusion at the IRAC bands (additional contributing flux at IRAC), or it could be real. We have identified these sources in the tables below, so that they can be followed up (or dropped) as later investigators prefer. We have generally lumped these in with the ‘no excess’ stars because the most sensitive excess metric is χ\chi within IRAC, and that is usually <4<4 (our threshold), often ≪4\ll4, for these stars. Combining these with the other “no disks” means that 36% of the sample have no disks.

In some cases, as with the IRAC offset stars, we have added an extra qualitative subgrouping to help identify similar sources within the SED collection. Some targets have more than one subgroup. These subcategories are:

  • fewpoints – SED that has very few points in it. So many of our targets have such well-defined SEDs that it is worth calling out those targets whose placement is less secure specifically because there are so few points in the SED. (Note that this is different from those with no points in the SED, which are the X-ray-only sources; those have npts_sed = 0 in the data table in Appendix § 11.)

  • offset/offsetx – SED that has an IRAC offset (as described above), but an additional ‘x’ means it appears to also have a legitimate IR excess. (Figure 13ab)

  • vshape – SED that seems to have an excess but where the excess points rise abruptly into a ‘V’ shape that is almost implausibly steep, though the points that create that steep rise seem to be legitimate detections. (Figure 13d) Within this class, vshape2, vshape3, and vshape4 identify three subgroups of SEDs that more closely resemble each other than they do the rest of the vshape SEDs; these subgroups are qualitative and are intended only to group like with like.

  • reddened – SED that is highly reddened and/or embedded such that the highest rollover point is longer than KsK_s. (In these cases, χ\chi values are less meaningful.)

  • scatter/scatterx – SED with a lot of scatter; additional ‘x’ means it appears to also have a legitimate IR excess. This group encompasses those sources where the scatter could be due to intrinsic variability or source confusion, but some of the scatter could also be photometric problems; we currently have no way to know. Note that a star could have no data past KsK_s and still be tagged ‘scatter’ in order to include these source confusion/variability cases. (Figure 12, lower right)

  • straightup – SED that rises more or less straight up, very steeply. These could be deeply embedded YSOs or they could be some other kind of source. (Figure 13h)

  • what/whatx – SED is strange, and just doesn’t look like a YSO(?); additional ‘x’ means it appears to also have a legitimate IR excess. (Figure 13g)

  • weird/weirdx – SED is, well, weird; additional ‘x’ means it appears to also have a legitimate IR excess.

A ‘?’ appended to any of these (e.g., vshape?) means the source possibly belongs to that subgroup. Where more than one subgroup applies, they are separated by ‘/’ (e.g., offsetx/vshape). The secondary category can also contain one of the primary categories (offset, offseti3i4, 1band, 1+band) when a second one applies.

On the whole, out of 3019 stars, 537 (18%) have no data past KsK_s, 1097 (36%) have unambiguously no disk (no IR excess), 160 (5%) probably have no disk, 193 (6%) likely have a small excess at the longest available wavelength, 252 (8%) likely have a disk, and 780 (26%) have an unambiguous IR excess (disk).

All of these disk classifications are included in the data table in Appendix § 11.

Example SEDs

Figure 12 includes SED examples of stars that were unambiguously ‘no IR excess’ (‘no’) and ‘clear IR excess’ (‘yes’), as well as ‘no data past KsK_{\mathrm{s}}’ (‘nodata’). Figure 13 has examples of more complex cases discussed above. Panels a and b demonstrate the offset IRAC – panel a has all four IRAC channels offset and panel b has primarily the longest two bands offset, although a case could be made that the first two channels are also offset. The uncertainty on the points is large enough that there may or may not be an IR excess. In contrast, panel c is a case where IRAC-1 and -2 are photospheric, and the SED is pulling away from the photosphere in IRAC-3 and -4 such that there could be a legitimate excess, and the excess is larger at 4 than 3, consistent with astrophysical expectations. The error bars are small enough that the IR excess at IRAC-3 and -4 is just over the thresholds described above. Panel d’s SED is photospheric until IRAC-4, where the SED rises abruptly, perhaps unphysically. There is nothing obviously wrong with the IRAC-4 photometry, except for the shape of this SED. It’s characterized here as ‘v-shape’ as a result. As in panel d, panel e is photospheric until the longest band, in this case MIPS-24. However, here the rise from photospheric at 24 μ\mum isn’t unphysical. This one is characterized here as ‘1-band.’ Panel f’s SED looks like it has an IR excess at the two longest detections, IRAC-3 and -4. However, the error bar and departure from the photosphere at IRAC-3 combine to make the IR excess insignificant given the limits we have set. But, viewed in context with the significant excess at IRAC-4, the shape of the SED suggests that the IRAC-3 excess may be real. This one is characterized as ‘1+band,’ meaning that technically there is only a significant IR excess at one band, but, in context, there may be a real excess at the second-to-last detection in the SED. The last two panels are both more unusual. Panel g is both strangely shaped and has a lot of scatter in the SED, suggesting either source confusion or intrinsic variability. This SED on its own doesn’t seem stellar. Panel h has an SED that more or less goes straight up in the IR; it’s characterized here as “straightup.” This particular SED is reasonably well-populated; many of the “straightup” SEDs are less-well-populated, and many have long-wavelength counterparts (as this one does).

Figure 14 collects four of the ‘yes?’ disks and four of the unambiguous ‘yes’ disks just as examples of the diversity of shapes and scatter and embeddedness. Plots like these will be provided for all of the YSO candidates in our final catalog delivery to IRSA.

Disk Reconciliation

L. Venuti et al. [107] placed their YSOs in bins of disk-bearing, disk candidate, or disk-free. The stars that we have in common are, in most cases, in the same bins in both analyses. In the few cases where they don’t agree, most commonly, we now have filled in missing Spitzer measurements (enabling classification not possible before), or cleaned up source confusion (which may have removed Spitzer fluxes previously assigned to a source). For example, there are three sources very close together: J180414.57-242221.1, J180414.63-242221.7, and J180414.70-242219.5. All three are legitimate, separate sources – Gaia, PASTAR?RS, VVV, and VPHAS all resolve the three sources here. All three of them have multiple literature identifications as YSOs. But once this source confusion is taken into account, IR flux is difficult-to-impossible to apportion properly to J180414.63-242221.7. It previously had some flux assigned that likely is actually due to J180414.57-242221.1, so the disk assessment was incorrect before.

Spatial Distribution of Disks on the Sky

The distribution of stars with and without disks on the sky is somewhat difficult to assess. The source density of YSOs and candidates is very high in several areas, but fades rapidly as a function of distance from those concentrations. Figure 15 plots the 6 different SED disk categories on the sky – confident disks (‘yes’), less confident disks (‘yes?’), possible disks, less confident no disks (‘no?’), confident no disks (‘no’), and no information.

Location on the sky of YSOs and candidate YSOs for the six different SED disk categories

Figure 15. Location on the sky (in decimal degrees, J2000) of YSOs and candidate YSOs, for the 6 different SED disk categories. From left to right, top to bottom: confident disks (‘yes’), less confident disks (‘yes?’), possible disks (largely 1-band), less confident no disks (‘no?’), confident no disks (‘no’), and no information. Black circles in each panel are the approximate locations of NGC 6530 (left) and the Hourglass Nebula (right). Concentrations of YSOs can be seen by eye in at least 4 of the 6 panels here, as is residual texture reflecting where there are more data (e.g., more disks in NGC 6530), or less data (e.g., more ‘no data’ in the Hourglass).

Concentrations of YSOs can be seen by eye in most of the panels in Figure 15. We expect that members with disks should, on average, be younger and therefore more clustered than stars without disks. However, selection effects could be a complication here – the limitations of, e.g., having no infrared data past 2 μ\mum in the Hourglass can be seen in the distribution of targets with no information.

Looking at the distribution of the objects on the sky as a function more explicitly of SED slope (as opposed to binned like in Figure 15) reveals no new information. There is a clear clump of steeply positive slopes in the heart of the Hourglass, but no other structure jumps out by eye, much like Figure 15. Further restricting this kind of analysis to only the best-populated SEDs or just the most confident disks/no disks similarly does not produce much new information.

Properties of the Final Catalog

Properties of the Final Catalog

Final Catalog

Our final, complete merged catalog of the 3019 YSOs and candidates is in an electronic table accompanying this article and delivered to IRSA. A list of the columns can be found here in the Appendix, and includes photometry and cross-IDs from the other catalogs merged here. An entire set of plotted SEDs is also in the IRSA delivery and can be viewed there in RA order or in disk confidence order.

Source Numbers

There are 3019 YSOs or YSO candidates listed in the literature in our region that have survived the merging process. To reiterate some critical points from above, as seen in Table 1, there are data from ∼50\sim50 different origins incorporated here. Note that not all of these original catalogs cover our whole region (there are more covering NGC 6530, for example), nor are they to similar sensitivity or spatial resolution.

Table 2 includes the numbers of sources per origin catalog that appear in our final merged catalog and the final list of literature-selected YSOs and candidate YSOs as a guide to how common or rare that catalog’s information is in our final catalog of literature YSOs. The rows where the number of sources and the number of YSOs are the same are the papers where their data tables consist solely of YSOs or candidates.

SED points

Table 1 also indicates that there are ∼80\sim80 different possible measurements that could appear in the SEDs, plus additional measurements such as LxL_x, vsin⁡iv\sin i, or ProtP_{\rm rot}. Note, though, that this does not necessarily mean ∼80\sim80 distinct wavelengths; a few surveys use exactly the same filters. For example, AllWISE, CatWISE, and unWISE all have the same WISE-1 and WISE-2 bands; CatWISE and unWISE use more data than AllWISE, but they use the same data as each other, so the points from those catalogs are not entirely independent. Several other catalogs use very similar but not exactly the same filters; Pan-STARRS grigri is similar but not the same as VPHAS grigri.

Figure 16 has a histogram of the number of points or limits in the SED for all of the literature YSOs or candidate YSOs. The median of this distribution is 30 points or limits in the SED, and the maximum number of points or limits any star has is 55. About 75% of them have more than 20 points or limits, so the SEDs in general are very well defined. At the other extreme, however, there are 210 targets with no measurements in their SED at all – they are X-ray only sources, whose nature is unknown (but whose YSO nature is suspected). They could, however, be active galactic nuclei (AGN), seen through the Galaxy.

Figure 16. Left: Histogram of number of points in the SED for all of the literature YSOs or candidate YSOs. The median is 30 points; ∼75% have more than 20 points in the SED. At the other extreme, 210 (not shown here) have no points in their SED – they are X-ray only. Right: Histogram showing the number of YSO tags per source, effectively highlighting those that have multiple YSO tags. Seventy-five percent have 5 or fewer YSO tags. There are 110 sources that at least 12 papers have identified as YSOs, and 302 sources that at least 10 papers have identified as YSOs.

Additional complicating factors can be seen in Figure 17. There are more literature surveys available on the East side of our region, in NGC 6530 (∼271.1∘\sim271.1^\circ, −24.3∘-24.3^\circ), so in general, there are more YSOs & candidates, and more points per SED, in the East half of our region. In regions of very bright nebulosity and high source surface density (in the heart of the Hourglass, ∼270.92∘\sim270.92^\circ, −24.38∘-24.38^\circ) there are distinctly fewer points on average available in any given SED, just because source confusion and high surface brightness both limit catalog completeness.

Location on the sky of YSOs and candidate YSOs, colored by number of points in the SED and number of YSO tags

Figure 17. Location on the sky (in decimal degrees, J2000) of YSOs and candidate YSOs, where the color of the point corresponds to the number of points in the SED (top) or the number of YSO tags (bottom). There are more literature data available on the East side of our region, around NGC 6530 (∼271.1∘\sim271.1^\circ, −24.3∘-24.3^\circ, indicated by the large black circle on the left; see Figure 1), so there are generally more points per SED and more YSO tags. There are generally fewer points per SED and YSO tags in the heart of the Hourglass (∼270.92∘\sim270.92^\circ, −24.38∘-24.38^\circ, indicated by the large black circle on the right; see Figure 1), where high surface brightness and high source surface density both limit catalog completeness.

YSO Tags

Just looking at the literature, 25 different papers explicitly identified YSOs (Table 1). As described above, we discarded YSO candidates that were identified in only [82] or [14]. While there are many YSOs or candidates that are identified in more than one paper, there are also many others that are identified in only one paper. An approach one could take would be to simply retain only those YSOs that were identified in more than one or two papers as ‘more reliably YSOs.’ There is some implicit bias in this because as seen in Figure 17, there are more surveys (and therefore more tags) in NGC 6530 and fewer tags in the Hourglass. Additionally, different methods of searching for YSOs reach different kinds of targets – for example, using positions and proper motions (PPM) prior to Gaia was limited to optically brighter stars, and searches using Spitzer will easily reach relatively faint IR excess sources that may be entirely hidden from existing optical surveys.

Table 3 lists, for each journal article, the number of objects that were identified as YSOs or YSO candidates (“tagged YSOs”). It also lists the number of those sources that were also identified in at least one other paper, and the number of those sources that were only identified in that paper. Figure 16 includes a histogram of the number of sources as a function of how many times they were tagged as YSOs. There are 110 YSOs that have at least 12 papers that identify them as YSOs, and 302 that are identified in at least 10 papers, so even sight unseen, those seem likely to be legitimate YSOs. Roughly two-thirds of the sample have two or more YSO tags. If one assumes that identification by two or more studies indicates YSO legitimacy, then that two-thirds of the list is more likely to be legitimate YSOs. One-third have four or more YSO tags.

ReferenceTotal tagged YSOTotal tagged YSO in ≥2Total tagged YSO in ≥3Total tagged YSO only once
M. E. van den Ancker et al. (1997) (PPM)9692864
H. Sung et al. [98] (Hα)7465609
G. Rauw et al. [86] (X-rays)105878418
F. Damiani et al. [20] (X-rays)88487181413
L. Prisinzano et al. [82] (optical)9269268320 (403 dropped)
J.-L. Zhao et al. [118] (PPM)5959570
J. I. Arias et al. [5] (NIR)4439365
L. Chen et al. [17] (PPM)14711010037
L. Prisinzano et al. [81] (opt spec; with disks)9090900
L. Prisinzano et al. [81] (opt spec; members)33228825644
D. L. Kumar & B. G. Anandarao [56] (MIR)22115513965
C. B. Henderson & K. G. Stassun [42] (periods)2902902900
MYStIX: M. S. Povich et al. [78]; P. S. Broos et al. [11]; G. Romine et al. [92]; M. C. Ramírez-Tannus et al. [85] (X-rays+MIR)214515811117564
C. P. M. Bell et al. [8] (optical)66165164410
P. J. Castro [14] (X-rays)1303130310080 (47 dropped)
V. M. Kalari et al. [52] (optical)19515312342
L. Prisinzano et al. [84] (opt spec)61659556221
F. Damiani et al. [21] (PPM)910687650223
N. J. Wright et al. [116] (PPM)7767747342
M. A. Kuhn et al. [54] (MIR, PPM, variab)46643427631
R. J. Jackson et al. [50] (PPM)43942942610
C. Ordenes-Huanca et al. [74] (variab)3613613360

Table 3. Numbers of YSO tags

In contrast, however, one-third of the YSOs/candidate YSOs have just one paper identifying them as a YSO (only ∼15%\sim15\% of which have no points in their SED). As can be seen in Table 3, the majority of those single-tagged YSOs (∼500\sim500) come from the aggregate of MYStIX studies ([78, 11, 92, 85]), with another ∼200\sim200 from [21]. The former is a comprehensive multi-wavelength effort; the latter uses Gaia and Chandra data. These studies are therefore unlikely to contain many spurious sources. Nonetheless, these single-tagged YSOs also often seem to be outliers in a variety of optical and infrared color-color and color-magnitude diagrams. Some of that comes from the fact that those studies, particularly the MYStIX ensemble, is often reaching fainter objects than most of the other work, and so the photometry may be more uncertain. Further study is needed.

Figure 18 shows the JHKsJHK_s color-color diagram for the YSO sample with the number of YSO tags indicated. The empirical zero-age main sequence (ZAMS) ([75]) is shown in the figure, along with the [66] T Tauri locus and a reddening vector (following the reddening law from [46] and [63]). The stars with the most YSO tags appear in this diagram in a location consistent with slightly reddened ZAMS stars. This doesn’t mean that they are likely contaminants, just that their NIR colors are affected by reddening but not affected by IR excesses (they could have IR excesses >2 μ>2\ \mum). Many of the most reddened stars are identified in just a few papers, most commonly those reaching faint sources and using mid-IR or X-rays to identify YSOs, both of which can more easily penetrate dust than some of the other YSO identification methods. Many of the stars that have near-IR excesses (those near the T Tauri locus and those reddened from that locus) are YSOs identified based on IR excesses. Most of the earliest papers (particularly those using pre-Gaia positions and proper motions) find stars near where early type stars are expected to fall in this diagram – between 0 and 0.5 in H−KsH-K_s, and 0 and 0.5 in J−HJ-H. A Gaia color-magnitude diagram of these stars has the most-tagged YSOs clustered about a ∼6\sim6 Myr isochrone, with a long tail up to the brightest stars (identified most often in early position and proper motion studies), and considerable scatter among the fainter, single-tagged sources.

JHKs color-color diagram for the YSO sample

Figure 18. A plot of J−HJ-H vs. H−KsH-K_s for the YSOs. The point colors correspond to the number of stars in the bin, as indicated. The thick, solid line is the ZAMS ([75]); the dashed line is the [66] T Tauri locus. A reddening vector (following the reddening law from [46] and [63]) are shown, and the dash-dot lines are reddening vectors extending roughly from the extremes of the ZAMS relation. The YSOs with the most literature tags are clumped above the ZAMS. Many of the most reddened stars are identified in just a few papers, typically using mid-IR or X-rays to identify YSOs.

Figure 19 looks at the correlation between number of papers identifying the target as a YSO and the number of points in the SED. There does seem to be a correlation in that the more papers there are identifying the source as young, the more points there are in the SED, which makes sense if one assumes that the papers that identify YSOs also publish additional photometry. However, as can also be seen in Table 1, that is not necessarily the case. The most populated bins in Figure 19 are, in fact, YSOs tagged in just one paper, with ~25-30 points in their SED. Many of these stars come from MYSTIX or [21], and their SEDs are populated by large or all-sky catalogs.

Figure 19. A plot of the number of papers tagging the star as a YSO against the number of points in its SED. The point colors correspond to the number of stars in the bin, as indicated. It is roughly the case that the more papers there are identifying the YSO, the more points there are in the SED, but there are a lot of YSOs that are only tagged in one paper whose SEDs are well-populated from large catalogs.

Distances

Distances

Distances, even using Gaia data, can be complicated. Numerous papers discuss the strengths and weaknesses of different Gaia-derived distances. We noted in a previous paper (L. M. Rebull et al. [90]) that particularly in the case of young stars, most of the Gaia distance estimates may not be terribly reliable much past 2 kpc. The Lagoon nebula is at ∼1250 pc (L. Prisinzano et al. [84]), so it should be close enough for most if not all of the legitimate members, but separating them from the background could be difficult.

Figure 20 is a histogram of distances for the YSO catalog, and for comparison, the entire assembled catalog, scaled as if it was the same size as the YSO catalog. Just two distance values are shown – the geometric distance as derived by C. A. L. Bailer-Jones et al. [6], and that obtained by inverting the (positive) parallax. The YSO catalog is strongly biased towards much closer sources than the ensemble distribution; the most common value is at ∼1250 pc, as expected, regardless of which distance one uses.

Figure 20. Histogram of distances obtained from Gaia DR3, both from C. A. L. Bailer-Jones et al. [6] (black lines) and simply inverting the parallax (blue lines). The solid lines are the YSOs; the dotted lines are the entire catalog we assembled in this region, scaled as if it had the same total number of sources as the YSO catalog (it actually has ∼211,000 sources). There is a long, flat tail out past 8000 pc. The arrow at the top is placed at 1250 pc, the best available distance estimate for the Lagoon Nebula. The YSO catalog is strongly biased towards distances centered on ∼1200 pc, as expected if they were all true members of the Lagoon.

However, the structure near ∼5200 pc is interesting. If that ∼5200 pc peak is real, it presumably is a result of galactic structure behind the Lagoon Nebula. In the ensemble catalog, the Bailer-Jones distances are entirely responsible for that peak; the distribution of YSO candidates is fairly flat between ∼3000 and ∼6000 pc, and then falls off. The inverted parallaxes have no such peak, and instead have a slightly broader distribution at ∼1250\sim1250 pc. While there is a very long, flat tail, with a handful of YSOs out past 8 kpc (using either distance estimate), three-quarters of the YSOs with Bailer-Jones distances >4>4 kpc (creating that bump) are tagged as YSOs in at most 2 articles (∼45%\sim45\% are tagged in just 1 paper). If the objects with reported distances >4,000>4{,}000 pc are really at those distances, they are significantly less likely to be true members of the Lagoon SFR, but it is unclear if those distances are accurate.

We have included the distances in our final catalog, but have not used the distances to exclude YSOs from our final catalog. Future Gaia data releases may permit better distance-based exclusions.

Reddening

In subsequent analyses, we will plot against (V−Ks)0(V-K_{\mathrm{s}})_0 as a proxy for mass, so we would like to be able to deredden stars reasonably reliably. Reddening here is both patchy and occasionally substantial, so this is not a small problem. Because of the rich literature, we have spectral type estimates for 928 stars, biased towards things that are likely YSOs, and from there we can attempt to explore constraints on reddening. Most of these spectral types (805) come from L. Venuti et al. [107]. Another 86 come from M. C. Ramírez-Tannus et al. [85]: 70 from their own spectroscopy, and 16 OB stars for which they compiled literature spectral types (their Table 5). Ten come from J. I. Arias et al. [5] and one from L. Venuti et al. [106]. For the remaining 26 stars, we adopted the spectral type listed in SIMBAD (M. Wenger et al. [112]); these originate in L. Prisinzano et al. [83] (15 stars), Å. Wallenquist [110] (5), M. F. Walker [109] (2), and R. O. Gray & R. F. Garrison [38], A. Sota et al. [97], M. C. Ramírez-Tannus et al. [85], and J. Maíz Apellániz et al. [59] (one each). The source of each adopted spectral type is given in the catalog (column sptysrc; see Table 5).

Finding a measured VV in the literature is relatively rare, but since these SEDs are in general very well defined in the optical, we can with reasonable confidence interpolate a value for VV. Therefore, as in other of our papers (e.g., L. M. Rebull et al. [88]), we interpolated a value for VV using points near 0.55 μm0.55\ \mu\mathrm{m}, omitting Hα\alpha. To check the accuracy of this, for the stars where we do have measurements at VV, we can compare the interpolated and measured values of VV, and find that they are in general in good agreement; see Figure 21. We take this as confirmation that is is valid to interpolate values for VV in cases where there is no measured VV.

Figure 21. Comparison of (V−Ks)(V-K_{\mathrm{s}}) for stars where both VV and KsK_{\mathrm{s}} are observed explicitly (xx-axis), and where KsK_{\mathrm{s}} is observed, but where VV is interpolated from the points near 0.55 μm0.55\ \mu\mathrm{m} in the SED (yy-axis). A 1:1 line is overplotted. There is, in general, good agreement. We take this as confirmation that is is valid to interpolate VV for cases where there is no measured VV.

Next, we know that there will be a range of reddening corrections. Figure 22 compares the (V−Ks)(V-K_{\mathrm{s}}) values (where KsK_{\mathrm{s}} is observed, but where VV is interpolated from the points near 0.55 μm0.55\ \mu\mathrm{m} in the SED) to the expected (V−Ks)0(V-K_{\mathrm{s}})_0 values given the spectral type or the spectral type range available in the master catalog assembled here, and the colors from M. J. Pecaut & E. E. Mamajek [75]. The quantization arises because the types are quantized, and thus the colors are as well. For the bulk of the distribution, there is roughly a 1:1 relationship, though there is a net offset due, presumably, to an overall extinction contribution. There is clearly an additional population for which there is substantial reddening, where the observed (V−Ks)(V-K_s) is very different from the expected (V−Ks)0(V-K_s)_0 based on spectral type (or spectral type estimate). Stars with and without IR excesses are scattered throughout this diagram; the ‘hook’ structure on the right contains both stars with and without IR excesses, as does the structure that runs parallel to the 1:1 relationship.

Figure 22. Comparison of (V−Ks)(V-K_s) for stars where VV is interpolated from the points near 0.55 μ\mum in the SED (and KsK_s is observed) and the (V−Ks)0(V-K_s)_0 expected based on the spectral type. A 1:1 line is overplotted. There is typically at least some reddening, and sometimes substantial reddening.

We would like to be able to work with stars for which no spectral type estimate is available. We can also use the placement of the stars on a J−HJ-H vs. H−KsH-K_s diagram to estimate reddening, by shifting them back along the reddening law derived by R. Indebetouw et al. [46] to the expected JHKsJHK_s colors for young stars from M. J. Pecaut & E. E. Mamajek [75] or the T Tauri locus from M. R. Meyer et al. [66], then converting to E(V−Ks)E(V-K_s) via AK=0.114AVA_K=0.114A_V (J. A. Cardelli et al. [13]). The difficulty is that, in this region, sometimes this procedure results in a very different reddening estimate than can be obtained by a comparison to spectral types. Figure 23 compares the E(V−Ks)E(V-K_s) obtained from the placement in the JHKsJHK_s diagram and that from the observed KsK_s, interpolated VV, and colors assumed from the spectral type. The values are not completely uncorrelated, but we expected there to be more of a correlation than this. There are sometimes objects where the spectral type mandates much larger corrections than the placement in the JHKsJHK_s diagram suggests, which we expected, since disk excess can affect JHKsJHK_s, but there are also some stars where the JHKsJHK_s placement would be bluer (suggests a much larger correction) than the spectral type mandates.

Figure 23. Comparison of E(V−Ks)E(V-K_{\mathrm{s}}) for stars where the reddening is estimated from the placement in the JHKsJHK_{\mathrm{s}} diagram (xx-axis) and the E(V−Ks)E(V-K_{\mathrm{s}}) calculated from the observed KsK_{\mathrm{s}}, interpolated VV, and colors assumed from the spectral type. A 1:1 line is overplotted. There is somewhat of a correlation, but one would like something better.

Another way to compare these methods can be found in Figure 24. The left histogram has the E(V−Ks)E(V-K_s) for stars where the reddening is estimated from the placement in the JHKsJHK_s diagram; this can be done for a very large fraction of the entire catalog, but here is only shown for the stars with spectral types. There is no clear peak to this distribution, unless one counts the peak at 0, which is what happens when the routine fails to converge at all, or fails to converge on a positive AVA_V. The other two panels are E(V−Ks)E(V-K_s) for stars where the reddening comes from a comparison to expected colors for their spectral type (or spectral type range). The distribution for those where both VV and KsK_s are observed, the middle panel, has a mode at E(V−Ks)∼1.25E(V-K_s)\sim1.25. The distribution in which KsK_s is observed but VV is interpolated from the SED is about the same, but may be slightly higher. The median for E(V−Ks)E(V-K_s) (observed VV) is ∼1.39\sim1.39 and the median for E(V−Ks)E(V-K_s) (interpolated VV) is ∼1.40\sim1.40. Given all the uncertainties here, these are probably identical.

Figure 24. Comparison of E(V−Ks)E(V-K_{\mathrm{s}}) for stars where the reddening is estimated from the placement in the JHKsJHK_{\mathrm{s}} diagram (left), the E(V−Ks)E(V-K_{\mathrm{s}}) calculated from the observed VV and KsK_{\mathrm{s}} (middle) and colors assumed from the spectral type, and the E(V−Ks)E(V-K_{\mathrm{s}}) calculated from the interpolated VV and colors assumed from the spectral type (right). The left hand plot xx-axis is truncated for ease of comparison with the other two plots; there are two stars that would be far to the right in this histogram, at E(V−Ks)=13.1E(V-K_{\mathrm{s}})=13.1 and 21.7. See the text for more discussion.

Note that there are two stars that would be far to the right in the JHKsJHK_s histogram, at E(V−Ks)=13.1E(V-K_s)=13.1 and 21.7. These stars are J180419.08-241545.1 and J180422.23-242215.7, respectively. The latter, J180422.23-242215.7, is slightly easier to understand; its spectral type is M5-M8III from M. C. Ramírez-Tannus et al. [85]. Its SED suggests it is very embedded, with a substantial IR excess; the near-IR could be affected by IR excess, all of which likely explains why the E(V−Ks)E(V-K_{\mathrm{s}}) from JHKsJHK_{\mathrm{s}} is so large. The former, J180419.08-241545.1, is confusing. L. Venuti et al. [107] says it is an F7.5 star. It has very different JHKsJHK_{\mathrm{s}} measurements from 2MASS and UKIDSS; 2MASS seems most consistent with the rest of the SED. The optical measurements from more than one catalog (PanSTARRS, VVV, VPHAS, Gaia, H. Sung et al. [98]) all agree with each other and pull away from what would be a Wein-shaped extension from the 2MASS peak of the SED. Assuming that KsK_{\mathrm{s}} is on the photosphere (which may not be a good assumption), there appears to be an IR excess at 3-4 μ\mum; if 3-4 μ\mum is instead on the photosphere, there is an IR excess

by 8 μm8\,\mu\mathrm{m} that extends to at least 24 μm24\,\mu\mathrm{m}, the longest wavelength point we have for this star. There is an apparently MYStIX-only source within 3′′3^{\prime\prime}, so source confusion may be important too. More information is needed to understand what is happening with this object.

In general, for stars in this catalog that need to be dereddened for this or our other future analysis, we took the spectral type correction where we could, and fell back to that from the JHKsJHK_s diagram when we had no other choice.

YSO Reliability and Completeness

Because of the wildly inhomogeneous constituent catalogs that we have merged to create this final catalog, it’s very hard if not impossible to assess completeness in a statistically rigorous fashion in terms of brightness, wavelength, or even spatial coverage. Only some of the catalogs we merged cover our entire field. However, our catalog is complete in terms of published literature between ∼\sim1997 and ∼\sim2024, which is what we set out to do. It combines data over ∼4\sim4 orders of magnitude in wavelength to create well-populated SEDs.

Specifically because we have so many points delineating the SEDs after all the catalog merging, we had hoped that we would be able to make a better assessment in many cases of the YSO nature of these sources. For example, if a source was identified as a YSO based only on, say, near- and mid-IR (2MASS+IRAC) data, contamination from, e.g., background asymptotic giant branch (AGB) stars or star-forming background galaxies is far more likely than if we have optical+NIR+MIR data to constrain the SED.

It turns out, however, that (as discussed above) discarding the YSO candidates that were identified in only L. Prisinzano et al. [82] or P. J. Castro [14] likely was among the most significant things we could have done to clean the list of the most questionable YSOs.

The simplest filter that could be easily imposed to make the catalog more reliable but less complete is to restrict the list to have at least 2 or 3 YSO tags before accepting it as a YSO. Table 4 shows the sample sizes for several different subsets of the data. If one drops the YSOs from the list that have only one YSO tag, then one loses 36% of the catalog (1098 sources). If one drops those with just one or two YSO tags, then one loses 1098+661 sources, 58% of the sample. These that would be so dropped include, e.g., X-ray sources without any other counterparts, sources that have well-populated but stellar SEDs (no IR excess), and sources with SEDs that honestly are quite strange looking (may be stars, may be something else), all of which sounds like it could be appropriate. However, it also drops several hundred that have very well-populated stellar SEDs with clear IR excesses, including some IRAS sources, suggesting that such a filter would also discard obvious YSOs.

DescriptionNumberNotes
YSOs in catalog3019
YSOs tagged in just 1 paper109836% of catalog
YSOs tagged in just 2 papers66122% of catalog
YSOs tagged in just 3 papers2538% of catalog
YSOs tagged in just 4 papers1184% of catalog
YSOs tagged in just 5 papers1445% of catalog
YSOs tagged in 6 or more papers74525% of catalog
SED points ≤10\le1037112% of catalog
SED points >10>10 and ≤20\le2039513% of catalog
SED points >20>20 and ≤30\le3086729% of catalog
SED points >30>30 and ≤40\le4089930% of catalog
SED points >40>4048716% of catalog
IR excess: no data53718% of catalog
IR excess: unambiguous no disk (1.x or “no”)109736% of catalog
IR excess: possibly no disk (1.x or “no?”)1605% of catalog
IR excess: 1 band (3.x)1936% of catalog
IR excess: possibly disk (4.x or “yes?”)2528% of catalog
IR excess: unambiguous disk (5.x or “yes”)78026% of catalog; (252+780)/3019 is 34% of catalog
Bailer-Jones distance exists220273% of catalog
Bailer-Jones distance <2<2 kpc140664% of those with distances
Bailer-Jones distance <2<2 kpc & 3 YSO tags91442% of those with distances
Bailer-Jones distance <2<2 kpc & IR excess 4 or 547922% of those with distances
Bailer-Jones distance <2<2 kpc, 3 YSO tags, & IR excess 4 or 535816% of those with distances
YSOs selected via PPM158252% of sample; 1029 (65% of the PPM sample) have more than 3 YSO tags
YSOs selected via Hα\alpha742% of sample; 60 (81% of the Hα\alpha sample) have more than 3 YSO tags
YSOs selected via other optical methods128142% of sample; 1010 (79% of the ‘other optical’ sample) have more than 3 YSO tags
YSOs selected via X-rays228476% of sample; 1169 (51% of the X-ray sample) have more than 3 YSO tags
YSOs selected via IR228076% of sample; 1131 (50% of the IR sample) have more than 3 YSO tags
YSOs selected via variability81527% of sample; 600 (74% of the variability sample) have more than 3 YSO tags

Table 4. Subsamples and Fractions

There are so many catalogs in this merged collection that adding a requirement for a certain minimum number of points in the SED is not a very stringent requirement, but it does exclude the X-ray-only objects. Only 12% of the catalog has 10 or fewer points in the SED, leaving 88% of the catalog intact.

Assuming a goal of having a very reliable catalog of YSOs, one could also impose a requirement of having an IR excess. This necessarily excludes those YSOs which no longer have disks, but it does ensure that the YSOs still in the catalog are more likely to be young. If one selects only the most reliable IR excess stars, or the likely IR excess stars, then one retains just 34% of the full catalog. If one requires detection at any band redward of 2 μm2\,\mu\mathrm{m}, such that any estimate of the photosphere is possible, regardless of whether or not there is a significant excess, then 18% of the catalog is dropped.

Distances are complicated, as discussed above, but for the sake of argument, if one requires a distance from C. A. L. Bailey-Jones et al. (2021a), then one is left with 73% of the catalog, necessarily the less embedded of the sample (though it also drops the X-ray sources without counterparts, of course). A further restriction down to <2<2 kpc leaves 64% of those with distances (47% of the whole catalog). Including additional restrictions of at least 3 YSO tags and an IR excess leaves just 358 YSOs, but at least nominally, they could be the most reliable YSOs.

YSOs selected by PPM prior to Gaia tend to be the optically brighter and higher mass stars. There are not many YSOs selected via Hα\alpha but those also tend to have an IR excess. MYStIX used combinations of X-rays and IR excess to identify YSOs, and they are largely responsible for the large numbers of X-ray and IR-selected YSOs in Table 4. Unsurprisingly, variability seems to be a good way to find YSOs; most of the YSOs identified via variability are also tagged as young via other methods.

Final Thoughts

We have assembled a reasonably complete, cleaned catalog of literature-identified YSOs in the Lagoon Nebula. Future surveys such as the Roman Galactic Plane Survey (R. Galactic Plane Survey Definition Committee 2025) will observe this region with high spatial resolution and sensitivity, and the Lagoon Nebula is also a prime target of interest for time-domain young star science with Vera C. Rubin Observatory’s Legacy Survey of Space and Time (Rubin LSST; [10]); rather than being limited to analysis using only the data from within a given survey, this catalog will enable future work to be more easily linked to prior analyses.

This catalog enables us to better exploit the time series data from this region and investigate periodic variability in a companion paper ([89]). The catalog and disk classifications compiled here are also being used in another work by our team (Venuti et al., in preparation) that aims to determine how the inner disk properties and their evolutionary timescales in the Lagoon Nebula are impacted by the presence of stellar companions, with information on stellar multiplicity being extracted from Gaia astrometric and Gemini speckle imaging data.

Acknowledgments

Tremendous thanks to the NITARP (https://nitarp.ipac.caltech.edu) 2019 IDYL team (D. Strasburger, M. Bechtel, D. Mattern, and R. Swanson and their students) for their work on an early version of this catalog.

  • This research has made use of the NASA/IPAC Infrared Science Archive (IRSA), which is operated by the Jet Propulsion Laboratory, California Institute of Technology, under contract with the National Aeronautics and Space Administration.

  • This publication makes use of data products from the Wide-field Infrared Survey Explorer (WISE), which is a joint project of the University of California, Los Angeles, and the Jet Propulsion Laboratory/California Institute of Technology, funded by the National Aeronautics and Space Administration.

  • This work is based in part on archival data obtained with the Spitzer Space Telescope, which was operated by the Jet Propulsion Laboratory, California Institute of Technology under a contract with NASA.

  • This publication makes use of data products from the Two Micron All Sky Survey (2MASS), which is a joint project of the University of Massachusetts and the Infrared Processing and Analysis Center/California Institute of Technology, funded by the National Aeronautics and Space Administration and the National Science Foundation.

  • Herschel is an ESA space observatory with science instruments provided by European-led Principal Investigator consortia and with important participation from NASA.

  • This research made use of data products from the Midcourse Space Experiment (MSX). Processing of the data was funded by the Ballistic Missile Defense Organization with additional support from NASA Office of Space Science.

  • The Pan-STARRS1 Surveys (PS1) and the PS1 public science archive have been made possible through contributions by the Institute for Astronomy, the University of Hawaii, the Pan-STARRS Project Office, the Max-Planck Society and its participating institutes, the Max Planck Institute for Astronomy, Heidelberg and the Max Planck Institute for Extraterrestrial Physics, Garching, The Johns Hopkins University, Durham University, the University of Edinburgh, the Queen’s University Belfast, the Harvard-Smithsonian Center for Astrophysics, the Las Cumbres Observatory Global Telescope Network Incorporated, the National Central University of Taiwan, the Space Telescope Science Institute, the National Aeronautics and Space Administration under Grant No. NNX08AR22G issued through the Planetary Science Division of the NASA Science Mission Directorate, the National Science Foundation Grant No. AST–1238877, the University of Maryland, Eotvos Lorand University (ELTE), the Los Alamos National Laboratory, and the Gordon and Betty Moore Foundation.

  • This work is based in part on data obtained as part of the UKIRT Infrared Deep Sky Survey (UKIDSS).

  • The VVV is based on data products from observations made with ESO Telescopes at the La Silla Paranal Observatory under programme ID 179.B-2002

  • The VPHAS catalogue is based on data products from observations made with ESO Telescopes at the La Silla Paranal Observatory under public survey programme ID, 177.D-3023

  • This research has made use of the SIMBAD database, operated at CDS, Strasbourg, France [112].

  • This work was partially supported by the National Aeronautics and Space Administration (NASA) under grant No. 80NSSC21K0633 issued through the NNH20ZDA001N Astrophysics Data Analysis Program (ADAP).

  • Generative AI tools were used in preparing this work. Gemini (Google) was used to suggest rewording of individual paragraphs. Claude (Anthropic; Claude Opus 5.5), used through the Claude desktop app (Cowork), was used to debug and cross-check the IDL code used to assemble the catalog, to check the catalog against the pipeline outputs, to format the machine-readable table, to locate bibliographic records, and to draft or suggest wording for parts of the text (e.g., the provenance of literature spectral types and descriptions of catalog columns). All AI-assisted text, code changes, and table contents were reviewed, verified, and revised by the authors, who take full responsibility for the content of this paper.

Author Contributions

Author Rebull worked with her NITARP (https://nitarp.ipac.caltech.edu) 2019 team to assemble an initial version of this catalog. Author Rebull then continued to redo, re-merge, re-work, and refine the catalog several times, then did the analysis and wrote the paper. Co-authors Cody and Venuti helped resolve source confusion issues with the catalogs used in their Lagoon papers, and commented on the manuscript.

Facility: IRSA

Data Table

The full primary data table appears as a machine-readable version in the electronic version of the journal and in more than one format in the delivery to IRSA. The table here describes the form and content of the data table.

References

  1. [2]Akari Team. 2020a, AKARI/IRC Point Source Catalogue,, NASA IPAC DataSet, IRSA181 doi: 10.26131/IRSA181DOI
  2. [3]Akari Team. 2020b, AKARI/FIS All-Sky Survey Bright Source Catalogue,, NASA IPAC DataSet, IRSA180 doi: 10.26131/IRSA180DOI
  3. [4]Arias, J. I., Barbá, R. H., Maíz Apellániz, J., Morrell, N. I., & Rubio, M. 2006, MNRAS, 366, 739, doi: 10.1111/j.1365-2966.2005.09829.xDOI
  4. [5]Arias, J. I., Barbá, R. H., & Morrell, N. I. 2007, MNRAS, 374, 1253, doi: 10.1111/j.1365-2966.2006.11217.xDOI
  5. [6]Bailer-Jones, C. A. L., Rybizki, J., Fouesneau, M., Demleitner, M., & Andrae, R. 2021a, AJ, 161, 147, doi: 10.3847/1538-3881/abd806
  6. [7]Bailer-Jones, C. A. L., Rybizki, J., Fouesneau, M., Demleitner, M., & Andrae, R. 2021b, VizieR Online Data Catalog: Distances to 1.47 billion stars in Gaia EDR3 (Bailer-Jones+, 2021),, VizieR On-line Data Catalog: I/352. Originally published in: 2021AJ....161..147B CDS
  7. [8]Bell, C. P. M., Naylor, T., Mayne, N. J., Jeffries, R. D., & Littlefair, S. P. 2013, MNRAS, 434, 806, doi: 10.1093/mnras/stt1075DOI
  8. [9]Benjamin, R. A., Churchwell, E., Babler, B. L., et al. 2003, PASP, 115, 953, doi: 10.1086/376696DOI
  9. [10]Bonito, R., Venuti, L., Ustamujic, S., et al. 2023, ApJS, 265, 27, doi: 10.3847/1538-4365/acb684DOI
  10. [11]Broos, P. S., Getman, K. V., Povich, M. S., et al. 2013, ApJS, 209, 32, doi: 10.1088/0067-0049/209/2/32DOI
  11. [12]Capak, P. 2019, Spitzer Enhanced Imaging Products (SEIP) Source List,, NASA IPAC DataSet, IRSA3 doi: 10.26131/IRSA3DOI
  12. [13]Cardelli, J. A., Clayton, G. C., & Mathis, J. S. 1989, ApJ, 345, 245, doi: 10.1086/167900DOI
  13. [14]Castro, P. J. 2013, PhD thesis, University of Delaware
  14. [15]Chambers, K. C., & et al. 2017, VizieR Online Data Catalog: The Pan-STARRS release 1 (PS1) Survey - DR1 (Chambers+, 2016),, VizieR On-line Data Catalog: II/349. Originally published in: 2016arXiv161205560C; 2016arXiv161205240M; 2016arXiv161205245W; 2016arXiv161205244M; 2016arXiv161205242M; 2016arXiv161205243F CDS
  15. [16]Chambers, K. C., Magnier, E. A., Metcalfe, N., et al. 2016, arXiv e-prints, arXiv:1612.05560, doi: 10.48550/arXiv.1612.05560
  16. [17]Chen, L., de Grijs, R., & Zhao, J. L. 2007, AJ, 134, 1368, doi: 10.1086/521022DOI
  17. [18]Chen, T. X., Schmitz, M., Mazzarella, J. M., et al. 2022, ApJS, 260, 5, doi: 10.3847/1538-4365/ac6268DOI
  18. [19]Churchwell, E., Babler, B. L., Meade, M. R., et al. 2009, PASP, 121, 213, doi: 10.1086/597811DOI
  19. [20]Damiani, F., Flaccomio, E., Micela, G., et al. 2004, ApJ, 608, 781, doi: 10.1086/420779DOI
  20. [21]Damiani, F., Prisinzano, L., Micela, G., & Sciortino, S. 2019, A&A, 623, A25, doi: 10.1051/0004-6361/201833877DOI
  21. [22]Denis Team. 2020, Deep Near-Infrared Survey of the Southern Sky (DENIS) Catalog,, NASA IPAC DataSet, IRSA478 doi: 10.26131/IRSA478DOI
  22. [23]Di Francesco, J., Johnstone, D., Kirk, H., MacKenzie, T., & Ledwosinska, E. 2008, ApJS, 175, 277, doi: 10.1086/523645DOI
  23. [24]Di Francesco, J., Johnstone, D., Kirk, H., MacKenzie, T., & Ledwosinska, E. 2009, VizieR Online Data Catalog: Submillimeter-Continuum SCUBA detections (Di Francesco+, 2008),, VizieR On-line Data Catalog: J/ApJS/175/277. Originally published in: 2008ApJS..175..277D doi: 10.26093/cds/vizier.21750277
  24. [25]Doi, Y., Takita, S., Ootsubo, T., et al. 2015, PASJ, 67, 50, doi: 10.1093/pasj/psv022DOI
  25. [26]Drew, J. E., Gonzalez-Solares, E., Greimel, R., et al. 2014, MNRAS, 440, 2036, doi: 10.1093/mnras/stu394 Drew, J. E., Gonzales-Solares, E., Greimel, R., et al. 2016, The VST Photometric Halpha Survey of the Southern Galactic Plane and Bulge (VPHAS+). Second VPHAS data release (DR2)..., VizieR On-line Data Catalog: II/341. Originally published in: VPHAS+ survey, (2016)
  26. [27]Egan, M. P., Price, S. D., Kraemer, K. E., et al. 2003, VizieR Online Data Catalog: MSX6C Infrared Point Source Catalog. The Midcourse Space Experiment Point Source Catalog Version 2.3 (October 2003), VizieR On-line Data Catalog: V/114. Originally published in: Air Force Research Laboratory Technical Report AFRL-VS-TR-2003-1589 (2003)
  27. [28]Eisenhardt, P. R. M., Marocco, F., Fowler, J. W., et al. 2020, ApJS, 247, 69, doi: 10.3847/1538-4357/abf72a
  28. [29]Epchtein, N., Deul, E., Derriere, S., et al. 1999, A&A, 349, 236
  29. [30]Fazio, G. G., Hora, J. L., Allen, L. E., et al. 2004, ApJS, 154, 10, doi: 10.1086/422843DOI
  30. [31]Feigelson, E. D., Townsley, L. K., Broos, P. S., et al. 2013, ApJS, 209, 26, doi: 10.1088/0067-0049/209/2/26DOI
  31. [32]Gaia Collaboration, Brown, A. G. A., Vallenari, A., et al. 2018, A&A, 616, A1, doi: 10.1051/0004-6361/201833051
  32. [33]Gaia Collaboration, Vallenari, A., Brown, A. G. A., et al. 2023, A&A, 674, A1, doi: 10.1051/0004-6361/202243940
  33. [35]Gilmore, G., Randich, S., Worley, C. C., et al. 2022, A&A, 666, A120, doi: 10.1051/0004-6361/202243134DOI
  34. [36]Glimpse Team. 2020a, GLIMPSE II Archive,, NASA IPAC DataSet, IRSA219 doi: 10.26131/IRSA219DOI
  35. [37]Glimpse Team. 2020b, GLIMPSE 3D Archive,, NASA IPAC DataSet, IRSA216 doi: 10.26131/IRSA216DOI
  36. [38]Gray, R. O., & Garrison, R. F. 1989, ApJS, 69, 301, doi: 10.1086/191315DOI
  37. [39]Griffin, M. J., Abergel, A., Abreu, A., et al. 2010, A&A, 518, L3, doi: 10.1051/0004-6361/201014519DOI
  38. [40]Gutermuth, R. A., Megeath, S. T., Myers, P. C., et al. 2009, ApJS, 184, 18, doi: 10.1088/0067-0049/184/1/18DOI
  39. [41]Gutermuth, R. A., Megeath, S. T., Myers, P. C., et al. 2010, ApJS, 189, 352, doi: 10.1088/0067-0049/189/2/352DOI
  40. [42]Henderson, C. B., & Stassun, K. G. 2012, ApJ, 747, 51, doi: 10.1088/0004-637X/747/1/51DOI
  41. [43]Herbig, G. H. 1957, ApJ, 125, 654, doi: 10.1086/146338DOI
  42. [44]Howell, S. B., Sobeck, C., Haas, M., et al. 2014, PASP, 126, 398, doi: 10.1086/676406DOI
  43. [45]HSA. 2020, Herschel High Level Images,, NASA IPAC DataSet, IRSA79 doi: 10.26131/IRSA79DOI
  44. [46]Indebetouw, R., Whitney, B. A., Kawamura, A., et al. 2008, AJ, 136, 1442, doi: 10.1088/0004-6256/136/4/1442DOI
  45. [47]IRAC Instrument Team, & IRAC Instrument Support Team. 2021, IRAC Instrument Handbook,, NASA IPAC DataSet, IRS A486 doi: 10.26131/IRSA486DOI
  46. [48]IRSA. 2022a, Gaia Source Catalogue DR3,, NASA IPAC DataSet, IRSA544 doi: 10.26131/IRSA544DOI
  47. [49]IRSA. 2022b, Finder Chart Service,, NASA IPAC DataSet, IRSA540 doi: 10.26131/IRSA540DOI
  48. [50]Jackson, R. J., Jeffries, R. D., Wright, N. J., et al. 2022, MNRAS, 509, 1664, doi: 10.1093/mnras/stab3032DOI
  49. [51]Jansen, F., Lumb, D., Altieri, B., et al. 2001, A&A, 365, L1, doi: 10.1051/0004-6361:20000036DOI
  50. [52]Kalari, V. M., Vink, J. S., Drew, J. E., et al. 2015, MNRAS, 453, 1026, doi: 10.1093/mnras/stv1676DOI
  51. [53]King, R. R., Naylor, T., Broos, P. S., Getman, K. V., & Feigelson, E. D. 2013, ApJS, 209, 28, doi: 10.1088/0067-0049/209/2/28
  52. [54]Kuhn, M. A., de Souza, R. S., Krone-Martins, A., et al. 2021a, ApJS, 254, 33, doi: 10.3847/1538-4365/abe465DOI
  53. [55]Kuhn, M. A., de Souza, R. S., Krone-Martins, A., et al. 2021b, Spitzer/IRAC Candidate YSO (SPICY) Catalog,, NASA IPAC DataSet, IRSA556 doi: 10.26131/IRSA556DOI
  54. [56]Kumar, D. L., & Anandrao, B. G. 2010, MNRAS, 407, 1170, doi: 10.1111/j.1365-2966.2010.16964.x
  55. [57]Lang, D. 2014, AJ, 147, 108, doi: 10.1088/0004-6256/147/5/108DOI
  56. [58]Lucas, P. W., Hoare, M. G., Longmore, A., et al. 2008, MNRAS, 391, 136, doi: 10.1111/j.1365-2966.2008.13924.xDOI
  57. [59]Maíz Apellániz, J., Barbá, R. H., Fernández Aranda, R., et al. 2022, A&A, 657, A131, doi: 10.1051/0004-6361/202124364
  58. [60]Marocco, F., Eisenhardt, P. R. M., Fowler, J. W., et al. 2020, CatWISE2020 Catalog,, NASA IPAC DataSet, IRSA551 doi: 10.26131/IRSA551DOI
  59. [61]Marocco, F., Eisenhardt, P. R. M., Fowler, J. W., et al. 2021, ApJS, 253, 8, doi: 10.3847/1538-4365/abd805DOI
  60. [62]Marton, G., Calzoletti, L., Perez Garcia, A. M., et al. 2017, arXiv e-prints, arXiv:1705.05693, doi: 10.48550/arXiv.1705.05693DOI
  61. [63]Mathis, J. S. 1990, ARA&A, 28, 37, doi: 10.1146/annurev.aa.28.090190.000345DOI
  62. [64]Meisner, A. M., Lang, D., & Schlegel, D. J. 2017a, AJ, 153, 38, doi: 10.3847/1538-3881/153/1/38DOI
  63. [66]Meyer, M. R., Calvet, N., & Hillenbrand, L. A. 1997, AJ, 114, 288, doi: 10.1086/118474DOI
  64. [67]Minniti, D., Lucas, P., & Vvv Team. 2017, VizieR Online Data Catalog: VISTA Variable in the Via Lactea Survey DR2 (Minniti+, 2017), VizieR On-line Data Catalog: II/348. Originally published in: Astron. Astrophys., 537, A107 (2002)
  65. [68]MIPS Instrument MIPS Instrument Support Teams. 2021, MIPS Instrument Handbook,, NASA IPAC DataSet, IRSA488 doi: 10.26131/IRSA488DOI
  66. [69]Mizusawa, T. F., Rebull, L. M., Stauffer, J. R., et al. 2012, AJ, 144, 135, doi: 10.1088/0004-6256/144/5/135DOI
  67. [70]MSX Team. 2019, MSX6C Infrared Point Source Catalog,, NASA IPAC DataSet, IRSA9 doi: 10.26131/IRSA9DOI
  68. [71]Murakami, H., Baba, H., Barthel, P., et al. 2007, PASJ, 59, S369, doi: 10.1093/pasj/59.sp2.S369DOI
  69. [72]Neugebauer, G., Habing, H. J., van Duinen, R., et al. 1984, ApJL, 278, L1, doi: 10.1086/184209DOI
  70. [73]Neugebauer, G., Habing, H. J., van Duinen, R., et al. 2019, IRAS Point Source Catalog v2.1 (PSC),, NASA IPAC DataSet, IRSA4 doi: 10.26131/IRSA4DOI
  71. [74]Ordenes-Huanca, C., Zoccali, M., Bayo, A., et al. 2022, MNRAS, 517, 6191, doi: 10.1093/mnras/stac3049
  72. [75]Pecaut, M. J., & Mamajek, E. E. 2013, ApJS, 208, 9, doi: 10.1088/0067-0049/208/1/9DOI
  73. [76]Pilbratt, G. L., Riedinger, J. R., Passvogel, T., et al. 2010, A&A, 518, L1, doi: 10.1051/0004-6361/201014759DOI
  74. [77]Poglitsch, A., Waelkens, C., Geis, N., et al. 2010, A&A, 518, L2, doi: 10.1051/0004-6361/201014535DOI
  75. [78]Povich, M. S., Kuhn, M. A., Getman, K. V., et al. 2013, ApJS, 209, 31, doi: 10.1088/0067-0049/209/2/31DOI
  76. [79]PPSC Team. 2024a, Herschel PACS Point Source Catalog: 70 microns,, NASA IPAC DataSet, IRSA573 doi: 10.26131/IRSA573DOI
  77. [80]PPSC Team. 2024b, Herschel PACS Point Source Catalog: 160 microns,, NASA IPAC DataSet, IRSA575 doi: 10.26131/IRSA575DOI
  78. [81]Prisinzano, L., Damiani, F., Micela, G., & Pillitteri, I. 2007, A&A, 462, 123, doi: 10.1051/0004-6361:20065623DOI
  79. [82]Prisinzano, L., Damiani, F., Micela, G., & Sciortino, S. 2005, A&A, 430, 941, doi: 10.1051/0004-6361:20040432DOI
  80. [83]Prisinzano, L., Micela, G., Sciortino, S., Affer, L., & Damiani, F. 2012, A&A, 546, A9, doi: 10.1051/0004-6361/201219853DOI
  81. [84]Prisinzano, L., Damiani, F., Carniani, V., et al. 2019, A&A, 623, A159, doi: 10.1051/0004-6361/201834870DOI
  82. [85]Ramírez-Tannus, M. C., Poorta, J., Bik, A., et al. 2020, A&A, 633, A155, doi: 10.1051/0004-6361/201935941
  83. [86]Rauw, G., Nazé, Y., Gosset, E., et al. 2002, A&A, 395, 499, doi: 10.1051/0004-6361:20021230DOI
  84. [87]Rebull, L. M. 2015, AJ, 150, 17, doi: 10.1088/0004-6256/150/1/17DOI
  85. [88]Rebull, L. M., Stauffer, J. R., Hillenbrand, L. A., et al. 2022, AJ, 164, 80, doi: 10.3847/1538-3881/ac75f1DOI
  86. [89]Rebull, L. M., Venuti, L., & Cody, A. M. 2026, AJ, submitted
  87. [90]Rebull, L. M., Anderson, R. L., Hall, G., et al. 2023, AJ, 166, 87, doi: 10.3847/1538-3881/ace32fDOI
  88. [91]Rieke, G. H., Young, E. T., Engelbracht, C. W., et al. 2004, ApJS, 154, 25, doi: 10.1086/422717DOI
  89. [92]Romine, G. F., Feigelson, E. D., Getman, K. V., Kuhn, M. A., & Povich, M. S. 2016, ApJ, 833, 193, doi: 10.3847/1538-4357/833/2/193DOI
  90. [93]Sagar, R., & Joshi, U. C. 1978, MNRAS, 184, 467, doi: 10.1093/mnras/184.3.467DOI
  91. [94]Saito, R. K., Hempel, M., Minniti, D., et al. 2012, A&A, 537, A107, doi: 10.1051/0004-6361/201118407DOI
  92. [96]Skrutskie, M. F., Cutri, R. M., Stiening, R., et al. 2006, AJ, 131, 1163, doi: 10.1086/498708DOI
  93. [97]Sota, A., Maíz Apellániz, J., Morrell, N. I., et al. 2014, ApJS, 211, 10, doi: 10.1088/0067-0049/211/1/10DOI
  94. [98]Sung, H., Chun, M.-Y., & Bessell, M. S. 2000, AJ, 120, 333, doi: 10.1086/301450DOI
  95. [99]Taylor, M. 2005, in Astronomical Society of the Pacific Conference Series, Vol. 347, Astronomical Data Analysis Software and Systems XIV, ed. P. Shopbell, M. Britton, & R. Ebert, 29
  96. [100]Tothill, N. F. H., Gagné, M., Stecklum, B., & Kenworthy, M. A. 2008, in Handbook of Star Forming Regions, Volume II, ed. B. Reipurth, Vol. 5, 533, doi: 10.48550/arXiv.0809.3380DOI
  97. [101]Trilling, D. E., Bryden, G., Beichman, C. A., et al. 2008, ApJ, 674, 1086, doi: 10.1086/525514DOI
  98. [102]UKIDSS Consortium. 2012, VizieR Online Data Catalog: UKIDSS-DR6 Galactic Plane Survey (Lucas+ 2012),, VizieR On-line Data Catalog: II/316. Originally published in: 2008MNRAS.391..136L; 2012yCat.2316....0U
  99. [105]van den Ancker, M. E., The, P. S., Feinstein, A., et al. 1997, A&AS, 123, 63, doi: 10.1051/aas:1997306DOI
  100. [106]Venuti, L., Cody, A. M., Rebull, L. M., et al. 2021, AJ, 162, 101, doi: 10.3847/1538-3881/ac0536DOI
  101. [107]Venuti, L., Cody, A. M., Beccari, G., et al. 2024, AJ, 167, 120, doi: 10.3847/1538-3881/adf165
  102. [108]Walker, M. F. 1957, ApJ, 125, 636, doi: 10.1086/146337DOI
  103. [109]Walker, M. F. 1961, ApJ, 133, 1081, doi: 10.1086/147113DOI
  104. [110]Wallenquist, Å. 1939, Annals of the Bosscha Observatory Lembang (Java) Indonesia, 5, E1
  105. [111]Weisskopf, M. C., Brinkman, B., Canizares, C., et al. 2002, PASP, 114, 1, doi: 10.1086/338108DOI
  106. [112]Wenger, M., Ochsenbein, F., Egret, D., et al. 2000, A&AS, 143, 9, doi: 10.1051/aas:2000332DOI
  107. [113]Werner, M. W., Roellig, T. L., Low, F. J., et al. 2004, ApJS, 154, 1, doi: 10.1086/422992DOI
  108. [114]Wright, E. L., Eisenhardt, P. R. M., Mainzer, A. K., et al. 2010, AJ, 140, 1868, doi: 10.1088/0004-6256/140/6/1868DOI
  109. [115]Wright, E. L., Eisenhardt, P. R. M., Mainzer, A. K., et al. 2019, AllWISE Source Catalog, NASA IPAC DataSet, IRSA1 doi: 10.26131/IRSA1DOI
  110. [116]Wright, N. J., Jeffries, R. D., Jackson, R. J., et al. 2019a, MNRAS, 486, 2477, doi: 10.1093/mnras/stz870DOI
  111. [117]Wright, N. J., Jeffries, R. D., Jackson, R. J., et al. 2019b, VizieR Online Data Catalog: Catalogue of members of NGC 6530 (Wright+, 2019), VizieR On-line Data Catalog: J/MNRAS/486/2477. Originally published in: 2019MNRAS.486.2477W
  112. [118]Zhao, J.-L., Chen, L., & Wen, W. 2006, ChJ&A&A, 6, 435, doi: 10.1088/1009-9271/6/4/06DOI

Paper details

vlnc:W_nxajef9n
Version
v1 · latest
Published
Fresh — added to the Hub within the last 30 days
Added
License
CC BY 4.0
Usage

views · 0

downloads · 0

A view counts once per browser per day, a download each time the PDF is requested.

  • Physics and Astronomy

Gemini (multiple versions), Claude

View statement
Looking for related papers…
Contents