betaFeedback

WorksPhysics and Astronomy

A buoyancy-drag model with a time-varying drag coefficient for evaluating bubble front penetration depth

Abstract

To evaluate and control bubble front penetration depth hB{{h}_{B}} induced by ablative Rayleigh-Taylor instability (ARTI) from a weakly nonlinear phase to a self-similar phase, we first propose an improved buoyancy-drag (BD) model with a time-varying drag coefficient. The coefficient incorporates the influence of multiple physical mechanisms, including non-steady ablation, preheating, and other mechanisms during this phase. The model is validated through simulations under various conditions, demonstrating improved accuracy compared to the classical BD model and the self-similar growth. Furthermore, the model suggests controlling hB{{h}_{B}} by suppressing the "most dangerous mode", which is influenced by initial perturbations and ablative acceleration history, thus offering novel insights for target manufacturing and pulse optimization near the ignition threshold.

Intruduction

Inertial confinement fusion (ICF) aims to achieve high-gain ignition[1, 2], which remains a significant challenge primarily due to the influence of hydrodynamic instabilities[3, 4]. Among these instabilities, ablative Rayleigh-Taylor instability (ARTI) is particularly important, as it can evolve from a linear phase into a nonlinear phase during the acceleration phase. Nonlinear ARTI can lead to interpenetration or mixing between the hot, low-density ablator and the cold, dense ablator or fuel, forming bubbles that penetrate the implosion shell. It is recognized that the appearance of bubbles is one of the main reasons degrading yield-over-clean (YOC) in early ignition experiments conducted during the National Ignition Campaign (NIC)[5, 6, 7] and has recently been implicated in target gain discrepancies[8, 9] among shots with similar targets and lasers. Previous studies have demonstrated that target defects and laser imprint[10, 11] could evolve into a highly nonlinear phase[12, 13], even a self-similar phase[14, 15, 16, 17]. However, a unified growth model for evaluating and controlling multimode ARTI from the weak nonlinear phase to the self-similar phase in real space is still lacking.

The theories of ARTI in various phases can be summarized as follows. In the linear phase, a single mode grows exponentially until reaching an amplitude about 1/10 to 1/5 of its wavelength. The linear growth rate shapes like γ≃Atkg−βkva\gamma\simeq\sqrt{A_tkg-\beta k v_a}[18, 19], where vav_a, gg, kk, AtA_t and β\beta are the ablative velocity, acceleration, perturbation wave number, Atwood number, and a factor that depends on the heat conduction power index ν\nu, respectively. In the nonlinear phase, a single mode achieves a terminal velocity, UB=CgAtλU_B=C\sqrt{gA_t}\lambda[20], where CC is a factor dependent on dimensions and λ\lambda represents perturbation wavelength. For a full spectrum of perturbation modes, Hann[21] proposes that nonlinear behavior initiates when the cumulative amplitude of modes within a wave packet becomes comparable to a wavelength. The evolution of the wave packet could be approximated as a single mode, which has been validated experimentally[17]. Furthermore, Hann’s weakly nonlinear theory for broadband ARTI[22], which incorporates γ\gamma into a classical second-order expansion, demonstrates that ablation can effectively suppress the nonlinear growth rate. Since high-order expansions are inadequate for resolving the evolution of highly nonlinear ARTI, based on Hann’s work, Dimonte[23] has proposed a method to derive the self-similar coefficient necessary for evaluating the bubble front penetration depth hBh_B during the subsequent self-similar phase. Nevertheless, the calculated self-similar coefficient varies due to non-steady ablation and complex physics inherent to ICF, indicating that the system is transitioning towards a self-similar phase. To evaluate hBh_B in this phase, the classical buoyancy-drag (BD)[24, 25] model, which can be derived from Layzer’s potential flow model[26], provides a valuable framework.

Originally proposed by Young[27] as a forcing equation for bubble dynamics, the BD model is adaptable due to several coefficients with physical connotations. In scenarios where At=1A_t=1, Layzer’s model simplifies to a form: (mass + added mass) ×\times acceleration = buoyancy − drag, detailed as follows,

(1+E)dVBdt=(1+E)g−CdRVB2,(1)(1+E)\frac{dV_B}{dt}=(1+E)g-\frac{C_d}{R}V_B^2, \tag*{(1)}

where, VB=dhBdtV_B=\frac{dh_B}{dt} represents the bubble velocity, RR relates to hBh_B; and an exponential term EE, applicable only in the linear phase with small amplitude, is omitted during the nonlinear phase. While both inertia and buoyancy are volumetric, drag is proportional to the cross-sectional area, incorporating a drag coefficient relevant to CdC_d. The added mass associated with bubble shapes arises from the movement of the penetrated fluid. Several extended models have been proposed, including modification of the transport process in the simulations to evaluate spikes at the interface of the hot spot[28] and incorporation of an ablative stabilization term[29] to better capture the dynamics of bubbles influenced by radiative shocks. However, these models with constant drag coefficient often inadequately calculate hBh_B from a weakly nonlinear phase to a self-similar phase, as this phase is influenced by diverse physical mechanisms[30, 31, 32, 33, 34], such as non-steady ablation, non-local electron heat transport, hot electron preheating, and self-generated magnetic fields.

In this paper, to evaluate hBh_B from a weakly nonlinear phase to a self-similar phase, we propose an improved BD model with a time-varying drag coefficient, which encompasses the influence of various physical mechanisms. We employ radiation-hydrodynamic simulations to validate the model in ICF. The model suggests controlling hBh_B by suppressing the "most dangerous mode", which is influenced by initial perturbations and ablative acceleration history. This approach offers novel insights for target manufacturing and pulse optimization near the ignition threshold, particularly as the National Ignition Facility (NIF) seeks to enhance the maximum target gain through improved target quality[35].

The paper is organized as follows. In Section II, we propose an improved BD model with a time-varying drag coefficient. Validations of the model and its further application in guiding the control of hBh_B are presented in Section III. Finally, we draw our conclusions in Section IV.

The improved buoyancy-drag model with a time-varying drag coefficient

The classical BD model with a constant drag coefficient cannot accurately evaluate the bubble evolution from a weakly nonlinear phase to a self-similar phase. We propose an improved BD model with a time-varying drag coefficient, which involves the influence of multiple physical mechanisms through γ\gamma and UB20U_B^{20} in this phase.

The classical BD model has been well applied to weakly nonlinear phase and its subsequent phases[36, 37], particularly in describing the dynamics of bubble forcing, as illustrated in Figure 1. Various drag coefficients are utilized throughout these phases, typically expressed as follows[25],

Forcing of a bubble

Figure 1. Forcing of a bubble with the red indicating low-density fluid and the blue representing dense fluid. λB\lambda_B represents bubble wavelength.

D∼CdρBρS+ρBhBλBD \sim C_d \frac{\rho_B}{\rho_S+\rho_B}\frac{h_B}{\lambda_B}

where ρB\rho_B and ρS\rho_S denote the bubble density and spike density.

In the context of steady ablation, early experimental results have shown that the average hB/λBh_B/\lambda_B and ρB/ρS\rho_B/\rho_S[17] remains invariant, thus DD is approximately constant from the weakly nonlinear to self-similar phases. Consequently, we can use the specific self-similar behavior to derive the expression for DD within this steady-ablation scheme. The derivation of self-similar behavior, dominated by bubble competition[14, 15, 16], was based on established research: Hann’s theory[21] suggests representing a full mode spectrum with a dominant mode; Fermi’s nonlinear transition[26] theory indicates that a single-mode perturbation experiences exponential growth during the linear phase until it reaches terminal velocity UB=CAtgλB20U_B=C\sqrt{A_tg\lambda_B^{20}}; and Birkhoff’s approach[38] obtains the self-similar evolutions of the dominant bubbles by seeking λB\lambda_B that maximizes hBh_B. The self-similar coefficient is expressed as follows,

αab=ΞCπ4(ln⁡(UB,0⟨hk0⟩γk0)−1)−1=ΞCπ4(ln⁡(CπkB,0⟨hk0⟩Ξ)−1)−1,(2)\alpha_{ab}=\frac{\Xi C\sqrt{\pi}}{4}\left(\ln\left(\frac{U_{B,0}}{\langle h_{k0}\rangle\gamma_{k0}}\right)-1\right)^{-1} =\frac{\Xi C\sqrt{\pi}}{4}\left(\ln\left(\frac{C\sqrt{\pi}}{k_{B,0}\langle h_{k0}\rangle\Xi}\right)-1\right)^{-1}, \tag*{(2)}

where

Ξ=γk0AtkB0g=1−βkB,0Atgva\Xi=\frac{\gamma_{k0}}{\sqrt{A_tk_{B0}g}}=1-\beta\sqrt{\frac{k_{B,0}}{A_tg}}v_a

is the linear growth rate of ARTI normalized with that of classical RTI and ⟨hk0⟩\langle h_{k0}\rangle represents the initial perturbations at the onset of acceleration. If ⟨hk0⟩\langle h_{k0}\rangle is sufficiently small to remain in the linear phase initially, as indicated by the positive denominator in equation (1), this coefficient could be derived[23] and validated by simulations[14]. To get the self-similar growth of hBh_B,

hB=αabAt(∫g dt)2,(3)h_B=\alpha_{ab}A_t\left(\int\sqrt{g}\,\mathrm{d}t\right)^2, \tag*{(3)}

from Youngs’s BD model[27],

dVBdt=Atg−DVB∣VB∣hB,(4)\frac{\mathrm{d}V_B}{\mathrm{d}t}=A_tg-D\frac{V_B\lvert V_B\rvert}{h_B}, \tag*{(4)}

we first derive the expression of the time-varying drag coefficient by substituting equation (2) into (3),

D=14(1αab−2ss+2−2),(5)D=\frac{1}{4}\left(\frac{1}{\alpha_{ab}}-\frac{2s}{s+2}-2\right), \tag*{(5)}

where g∼tsg\sim t^s, (s≥0s\geq0), and s=0s=0 and a constant Ξ\Xi means steady ablation. Consequently, the improved BD model is articulated using equation (3) with equation (1) and (4). If DD is calculated with a constant gg while hBh_B evolves with a time-varying gg, hBh_B would be underestimated for s>0s>0 due to a larger DD.

In the context of non-steady ablation, various physical mechanisms, such as ablation, non-local electron heat transport, hot electron preheating, and self-generated magnetic fields, influence the growth of ARTI through the two factors of γ(t)\gamma(t) and UB(t)U_B(t)[34, 39]. Consequently, the history of ablative acceleration and related physical processes can be incorporated through variations in γ(t)\gamma(t) and UB(t)U_B(t) as indicated in equation (1).

As illustrated in Figure 2, to evaluate hBh_B, determining the initial dominant perturbation is essential for calculating DD and initiating equation (4). Given that the spectrum of initial multimode perturbations in ICF may consist of several wave packets, based on Hann’s study, we conceptualize these spectrums as a combination of distinct wave packets, each centered around its respective dominant wavelength. The wave number of the dominant perturbation can be extracted from the simulated areal density distribution,

The calculation process of our model

Figure 2. The calculation process of our model. Here, the subscript ‘nl’ represents the onset of nonlinearity.

kB0=∫ρk02Y2 dk/(∑ρk02Y2).k_{B0}=\int\rho_{k0}^{2}Y^{2}\,dk\Big/\left(\sum\rho_{k0}^{2}Y^{2}\right).

However, ⟨hk0⟩\langle h_{k0}\rangle is notably small, ranging from 10−810^{-8} to 10−5 cm10^{-5}\,\mathrm{cm}, necessitating alternative methods for its determination. The perturbation velocity at the onset of acceleration is taken as vk0=U−⟨U⟩v_{k0}=U-\langle U\rangle[40] and the initial perturbation amplitude is expressed as ⟨hk0⟩≈vk0/γ\langle h_{k0}\rangle\approx v_{k0}/\gamma, where UU represents local fluid velocity and ⟨U⟩\langle U\rangle denotes mass weight mean fluid velocity. With these initial perturbations, as well as data from one-dimensional simulations, especially va(t)v_a(t), At(t)A_t(t), g(t)g(t) and β(t)\beta(t), the calculated hBh_B during nonlinear phase can be validated through following simulations.

Validation and application of the model via simulations

Simulation setup

In this study, we employ the two-dimensional Eulerian radiation-hydrodynamic code FLASH[41] to validate the improved BD model represented by equation (4), which can guide the control of hBh_B in ICF. The key simulation setup is as follows. The lengths of the simulation domain in the XX and YY directions are denoted as Lx=[−100 μm,100 μm]L_x=[-100\,\mu\mathrm{m},100\,\mu\mathrm{m}] and Ly=[−400 μm,2000 μm]L_y=[-400\,\mu\mathrm{m},2000\,\mu\mathrm{m}], respectively, with a spatial resolution of 0.52 μm0.52\,\mu\mathrm{m}. The laser pulse a), vertically irradiating the planar target, is a square pulse with a rise time of 0.1 ns0.1\,\mathrm{ns} and a peak intensity of 25 TW/cm225\,\mathrm{TW}/\mathrm{cm}^{2}. The CH planar target is set with a density of 1 g/cc1\,\mathrm{g}/\mathrm{cc} and a thickness of 90 μm90\,\mu\mathrm{m}. For the seeding sources of multi-mode velocity perturbations adjacent to the surface, we define them as Vp(x)=∑Vpkcos⁡(mkLx+ψk0)V_p(x)=\sum V_{pk}\cos(m_kL_x+\psi_{k0}), kL=2π/Lxk_L=2\pi/L_x, where mm is an integer ranging from 4 to 10, ψk0\psi_{k0} is a random phase uniformly distributed between zero and one, Vpk=Vpk0e(−mkLx∣y−y0∣)V_{pk}=V_{pk0}e^{(-m_kL_x|y-y_0|)}, Vpk0=F(mkLx)−2V_{pk0}=F(m_kL_x)^{-2}, and FF is a constant. Table I displays the information of non-ideal simulation, which encompass the process of laser energy deposition, electron heat conduction, and heat exchange between electrons and ions, while excluding radiation transport effects. For case 1 at t=3.4 nst=3.4\,\mathrm{ns}, Vp(x)V_p(x) has been loaded onto the target and a shock wave propagates through the rear interface of the target at Y=0 μmY=0\,\mu\mathrm{m}, leading to the rapid growth of perturbations.

casepulse⟨hk0⟩≈vk0/γ\langle h_{k0}\rangle\approx v_{k0}/\gammakB0k_{B0} (103 cm−110^{3}\,\mathrm{cm}^{-1})independent variable
1a)2.332.43
2b)2.332.431→21\to2:pulsea)→^{a)}\to pulseb)^{b)}
3c)102.94
4d)102.943→43\to4:pulsec)→^{c)}\topulsed)^{d)}
5a)6.622.331→51\to5:random
6a)10.42.261→61\to6:deliberate
7a)232.321→71\to7:deliberate
8a)16.002.73
9a)16.804.958→98\to9:deliberate
10a)14.302.179→109\to10:deliberate
11c)10.002.943→11:ϵ=0.06→ϵ=0.043\to11: \epsilon=0.06\to\epsilon=0.04
12c)10.002.943→12:ϵ=0.06→ϵ=0.13\to12: \epsilon=0.06\to\epsilon=0.1

Table I. The information of simulation cases with perturbations, where ‘deliberate’ represents modifying the initial perturbations with FF and mm, while ‘random’ denotes modifying the initial perturbation with random phase and ff represents the flux-limited value.

Validation of the model

We conduct detailed validation of the model through simulations, focusing on the bubble competition mechanism, ablative stabilization effects, applicability in non-steady ablation, and the sensitivity of DD to initial perturbations and ablative acceleration history. In comparison to Figure 3(a), the multi-mode velocity perturbations in Figure 3(b) lead to significant deformation of the planar target, exhibiting nonlinear characteristics at t=10 nst=10\,\mathrm{ns}. The low-density fluid penetrates the dense fluid, resulting in the formation of bubbles, whereas the dense fluid penetrates the low-density fluid, forming spikes. The interface between the bubbles and the spikes is defined as the outer edge of the accelerated shell, represented by the average position with 1/e1/e of the peak density near the coronal region. The bubble front is expressed as Y=min⁡(min⁡(∇Yρ(X,Y)))Y=\min\left(\min\left(\nabla_Y\rho(X,Y)\right)\right), and the spike front is denoted by Y=max⁡(max⁡(∇YTe(X,Y)))Y=\max\left(\max\left(\nabla_YT_e(X,Y)\right)\right), where TeT_e represents the electron temperature.

Distribution of density $\rho$ and its spatial distribution and Fourier spectrum

Figure 3. Distribution of density ρ\rho for cases with (b) and without (a) velocity perturbations at 10 ns, where the red, white and green lines represent the spike front, the boundary between the spikes and the bubbles and the bubble front, respectively. The spatial distribution (c) and Fourier spectrum (d) of ρ\rho in XX after summed in YY. The black solid lines correspond to the initial perturbations with their spectrums bounded by two gray lines in (d). The colors and the line styles are the same in (c) and (d). The dominant perturbation wavelengths at t=10t = 10 ns are identical as those of the initial, demonstrating that bubble competition drives the evolution of the bubble front.

Figure 3(c) and 3(d) illustrate the evolution of bubbles in both real and spectral space to validate the bubble competition. The black solid lines represent the initial perturbations, with their spectrums bounded by two gray lines in Figure 3(d), at the onset of acceleration (t=3.4t = 3.4 ns). From t=3.6t = 3.6 ns to t=6.2t = 6.2 ns, the initial perturbations with smaller wavelengths exhibit faster growth. Upon entering the nonlinear phase at t=6.2t = 6.2 ns, the initial perturbations with larger wavelengths begin to dominate due to competitive interactions among bubbles, leading to the phenomenon where one bubble expands while its neighbors shrink. Although perturbations with wavelengths exceeding the initial perturbation wavelengths emerge due to bubble merging, bubble competition continues to dominate the evolution, as the amplitude of perturbations, outside the range bounded by two grey lines, remains smaller than that of the initial perturbations. Consequently, relating drag coefficient DD to the initial perturbations is justified.

In the context of steady ablation, we validate the ablative stabilization of equation (3). hBh_B calculated by equation (3) without ablation is larger than that obtained from simulations, while the calculated hBh_B from equation (3) with ablation aligns well with the simulation results under various laser pulses in Figure 4(a) and (b). As the distance hshh_{sh} traveled by the ablation front increases, the effects of accumulated ablative stabilization become more pronounced.

Relationship between $h_B$ and $h_{sh}$

Figure 4. The relationship between hBh_B and the distance, hshh_{sh}, traveled by the ablation front that is also the interface between the bubble and the spike for (a): case 1 and (b): case 3. The symbols are obtained from simulations, and the dashed and solid lines are calculated using equation (3) without and with ablation, respectively. The insets are laser pulses used in simulations.

In the context of non-steady ablation, the calculated hBh_B corresponds to the simulation results under two different pulses, as depicted in Figure 5(a) and (b). It is evident that equation (2) does not provide better predictions than equation (3) due to the non-linear relation between hBh_B and hsh∼(∫gαt)2h_{sh} \sim\left(\int\sqrt{g\alpha t}\right)^2. Additionally, resolution effects introduce errors (±0.04 μm\pm0.04\ \mu\mathrm{m}), leading to reduced confidence in hBh_B before hsh≤50 μmh_{sh} \le50\ \mu\mathrm{m}.

Relationship between $h_B$ and $h_{sh}$ in non-steady situations

Figure 5. The relationship between hBh_B and hshh_{sh} in non-steady situations for (a): case 2 and (d): case 4.

The time-varying drag coefficient DD is influenced by the initial perturbations and ablative acceleration history as seen in equation (1) and (4). For the same acceleration gg, hBh_B increases as DD decreases due to a reduced drag force. Figure 6(a) illustrates the dependence on ⟨hk0⟩=vk0/γ\langle h_{k0}\rangle= v_{k0}/\gamma, where the onset of nonlinearity is indicated by the beginning of the solid fitting lines. Cases with larger ⟨hk0⟩\langle h_{k0}\rangle transition into the nonlinear phase earlier and achieve greater hBh_B simultaneously. The impact of ⟨hk0⟩\langle h_{k0}\rangle becomes increasingly important for longer acceleration times^{13}, during which bubbles can progress through several generations. This underscores the necessity for stringent requirements in ⟨hk0⟩\langle h_{k0}\rangle for high compression ignition schemes.

Relationship between $h_B$ and $t$

Figure 6. The relationship between hBh_B and tt. (a) with different initial perturbation amplitudes vk0/γv_{k0}/\gamma for case 1, 5, 6 and 7; (b) with different initial perturbation wavelengths λ0=2π/kB,0\lambda_0 = 2\pi/k_{B,0} for case 8-10.

Figure 6(b) presents the dependence on the perturbation wavelengths λ0\lambda_0, which remain unstabilized. The cases with shorter λ0\lambda_0 exhibit larger hBh_B because they enter nonlinear phase earlier. However, the sensitivity diminishes for cases with wavelength differences of less than 6 μ\mum under this simulation setup. This indicates that effective control of hBh_B through perturbation wavelength requires exceeding a threshold value in wavelength differences.

To access the sensitivities of DD to ablative acceleration history, we modify the magnitude of local heat fluxes near the maximum temperature gradient by adjusting ff. Figure 7 illustrates that until hsh>150h_{sh} > 150 μ\mum, hBh_B with different ff gradually diverges. The calculated hBh_B aligns with the simulation results, increasing as ff decreases. If the drag force remains constant, gg increasing with ff leads to increasing perturbations, which contrasts with the trend shown in Figure 7. Thus, the elongation of bubbles at lower ff can be contributed to the decreasing drag force with a smaller DD.

Figure 7. hBh_B varying with YshY_{sh} for case 12, 3 and 11.

Application in controlling bubble front penetration depth

Although the model has been validated only in two-dimensional simulations, the various bubble growth observed in three-dimensional simulations can be incorporated in DD through UBU_B, which varies with distributions of vorticity and has different CC across different dimensions. Therefore, this model could be suitable for describing the evolution of bubbles in real situations. Following the validation of equation (3), we will further explore strategies for controlling hBh_B. To illustrate this control strategy, we will consider self-similar growth as an example.

Equation (2) indicates that maintaining αab\alpha_{ab} below its maximum value can effectively control hBh_B. In the classical self-similar regime, which is dominated by bubble competition, the self-similar coefficient lacks an extremum due to ∂αb∂kB<0\frac{\partial\alpha_b}{\partial k_B}<0[23]. However, ∂αab∂kB=0\frac{\partial\alpha_{ab}}{\partial k_B}=0 exists within the context of ARTI, leading to the establishment of the “most dangerous mode” kαk_\alpha characterized by the maximum αab\alpha_{ab}, as illustrated by the blue arrow in Figure 8. Different from the “classical most dangerous mode” kγk_\gamma, determined by the maximum γ\gamma, kαk_\alpha depends on both initial perturbations and ablative acceleration history. This result indicates that it may be more reasonable for pulse optimization with our improved model instead of time-integrated γ\gamma[42, 43] as value function.

Plot of normalized amplitude versus $k$

Figure 8. Variation of αab\alpha_{ab} and γ\gamma with kk. The arrows represent the “most dangerous mode”. The initial value is taken as follows: β1/(Atg)va=10−2 μm1/2\beta\sqrt{1/(A_tg)}v_a=10^{-2}\,\mu\mathrm{m}^{1/2}, Z=⟨hk0⟩/C(π)Z=\langle h_{k0}\rangle/C(\sqrt{\pi}).

In the context of target defects or laser imprint, modes that initially exist in the nonlinear phase are unlikely to persist as

the dominant mode during the nonlinear phase, as they will not exhibit a self-similar manner. Instead, these modes primarily influence the vorticity, which in turn affects the UBU_B of λ0\lambda_0 smaller than 10 μ\mum$[39]. Therefore, based on ⟨hk0⟩\langle h_{k0}\rangle generated by the current quality of the target and beam, we can suppressing kαk_\alpha as shifting from case 8 to 9 shown in Figure 5(b). This approach may elucidate target gain differences among shots with similar targets and provide novel insights for target manufacturing and pulse optimization near ignition threshold.

Conclusions

Prior research has demonstrated that target defects and laser imprint could evolve into a highly nonlinear, or even self-similar phase. In ICF, which typically involves non-steady ablation and various physical mechanisms, we first propose an improved BD model with a time-varying drag coefficient for evaluating and guiding the control of hBh_B in real space. The coefficient incorporates multiple physical mechanisms through γ\gamma and UBU_B. The model is validated through simulations under various conditions, demonstrating improved accuracy compared to the classical BD model and the self-similar growth. Furthermore, the model suggests controlling hBh_B by suppressing the "most dangerous mode", which is influenced by initial perturbations and ablative acceleration history. This approach may elucidate the differences in target gains among shots with similar targets and lasers and provide novel insights for target manufacturing and pulse optimization near the ignition threshold.

Acknowledgments

This work is supported by the supported by the National Key R and D Projects (Grant No. 2023YFA1608402), Strategic Priority Research Program of the Chinese Academy of Sciences (Grant No. XDA25010200), and Nature Science Foundation of China (Grant No. 12375242).

Data Availability Statement

Data available on request from the authors.

References

  1. [1]H. Abu-Shawareb, R. Acree, P. Adams, J. Adams, B. Addis, R. Aden, P. Adrian, B. Afeyan, M. Aggleton, L. Aghajan, et al., “Lawsn criterion for ignition exceeded in an inertial fusion experiment,” Physical review letters 129, 075001 (2022).
  2. [2]H. Abu-Shawareb, R. Acree, P. Adams, J. Adams, B. Addis, R. Aden, P. Adrian, B. Afeyan, M. Aggleton, L. Aghaian, et al., “Achievement of target gain larger than unity in an inertial fusion experiment,” Physical Review Letters 132, 065102 (2024).
  3. [3]V. Smalyuk, C. Weber, O. Landen, S. Ali, B. Bachmann, P. Celliers, E. Dewald, A. Fernandez, B. Hammel, G. Hall, et al., “Review of hydrodynamic instability experiments in inertially confined fusion implosions on national ignition facility,” Plasma Physics and Controlled Fusion 62, 014007 (2019).DOI
  4. [4]A. Casner, “Recent progress in quantifying hydrodynamics instabilities and turbulence in inertial confinement fusion and high-energy-density experiments,” Philosophical Transactions of the Royal Society A 379, 20200021 (2021).DOI
  5. [5]S. Haan, J. Lindl, D. Callahan, D. Clark, J. Salmonsen, B. Hammel, L. Atherton, R. Cook, M. Edwards, S. Glenzer, et al., “Point design targets, specifications, and requirements for the 2010 ignition campaign on the national ignition facility,” Physics of Plasmas 18, 051001 (2011).
  6. [6]J. Lindl, O. Landen, J. Edwards, E. Moses, N. team, et al., “Review of the national ignition campaign 2009-2012,” Physics of Plasmas 21, 020501 (2014).DOI
  7. [7]O. Hurricane, D. Callahan, D. Casey, P. Celliers, C. Cerjan, E. Dewald, T. Dittrich, T. Döppner, D. Hinkel, L. B. Hopkins, et al., “Fuel gain exceeding unity in an inertially confined fusion implosion,” Nature 506, 343–348 (2014).DOI
  8. [8]L. Divol, A. Pak, B. Bachmann, K. Baker, S. Baxamusa, J. Biener, R. Bionta, T. Braun, D. Casey, C. Choate, et al., “Thermonuclear performance variability near ignition at the national ignition facility,” Physics of Plasmas 31, 102703 (2024).DOI
  9. [9]A. Pak, “Overview of principal degradations arising from capsule target perturbations in inertial confinement fusion implosions,” Tech. Rep. (Lawrence Livermore National Laboratory (LLNL), Livermore, CA (United States), 2023).
  10. [10]V. Goncharov, O. Gotchev, E. Vianello, T. Boehly, J. Knauer, P. McKenty, P. Radha, S. Regan, T. Sangster, S. Skupsky, et al., “Early stage of implosion in inertial confinement fusion: Shock timing and perturbation evolution,” Physics of plasmas 13, 012702 (2006).DOI
  11. [11]D. Liu, T. Tao, J. Li, Q. Jia, and J. Zheng, “Mitigating laser imprint with a foam overcoating,” Physics of Plasmas 29, 072707 (2022).DOI
  12. [12]V. Smalyuk, O. Sadot, J. Delettrez, D. Meyerhofer, S. Regan, and T. Sangster, “Fourier-space nonlinear rayleigh-taylor growth measurements? format?? 3d laser-imprinted modulations in planar targets,” Physical review letters 95, 215001 (2005).DOI
  13. [13]A. Casner, L. Masse, S. Liberatore, P. Loiseau, P. Masson-Laborde, L. Jacquet, D. Martinez, A. Moore, R. Seugling, S. Felker, et al., “Probing the deep nonlinear stage of the ablative rayleigh-taylor instability in indirect drive experiments on the national ignition facility,” Physics of Plasmas 22, 2056032 (2015).DOI
  14. [14]H. Zhang, R. Betti, R. Yan, D. Zhao, D. Shvarts, and H. Aluie, “Self-similar multimode bubble-front evolution of the ablative rayleigh-taylor instability in two and three dimensions,” Physical review letters 121, 185002 (2018).
  15. [15]H. Zhang, R. Betti, R. Yan, and H. Aluie, “Nonlinear bubble competition of the multimode ablative rayleigh–taylor instability and applications to inertial confinement fusion,” Physics of Plasmas 27, 122701 (2020).DOI
  16. [16]D. Martinez, V. Smalyuk, J. Kane, A. Casner, S. Liberatore, and L. Masse, “Evidence for a bubble-competition regime in indirectly driven ablative rayleigh-taylor instability experiments on the nif,” Physical Review Letters 114, 215004 (2015).pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/26066443
  17. [17]O. Sadot, V. Smalyuk, J. Delettrez, D. Meyerhofer, T. Sangster, . f. R. Betti, V. Goncharov, and D. Shvarts, “Observation of self-similar behavior of the 3d, nonlinear rayleigh-taylor instability,” Physical review letters 95, 265001 (2005).pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/16486364
  18. [18]H. Takabe, K. Mima, L. Montierth, and R. Morse, “Self-consistent growth rate of the rayleigh–taylor instability in an ablatively accelerating plasma,” The Physics of fluids 28, 3676–3682 (1985).DOI
  19. [19]R. Betti, V. Goncharov, R. McCrory, P. Sorokin, and C. Verdon, “Self-consistent stability analysis of ablation fronts in inertial confinement fusion,” Physics of Plasmas 3, 2122–2128 (1996).DOI
  20. [20]V. N. Goncharov, “Analytical model of nonlinear, single-mode, classical rayleigh-taylor instability at arbitrary atwood numbers,” Physical review letters 88, 134502 (2002).pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/11955101
  21. [21]S. W. Haan, “Onset of nonlinear saturation for rayleigh-taylor growth in the presence of a full spectrum of modes,” Physical Review A 39, 5812 (1989).
  22. [22]S. W. Haan, “Weakly nonlinear hydrodynamic instabilities in inertial fusion,” Physics of Fluids B: Plasma Physics 3, 2349–2355 (1991).DOI
  23. [23]G. Dimonte, “Dependence of turbulent rayleigh-taylor instability on initial perturbations,” Physical Review E—Statistical, Nonlinear, and Soft Matter Physics 69, 056305 (2004).pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/15244930
  24. [24]L. Baker and J. Freeman, “Heuristic model of the nonlinear rayleigh-taylor instability,” Journal of Applied Physics 52, 655–663 (1981).DOI
  25. [25]G. Dimonte, “Spanwise homogeneous buoyancy-drag model for rayleigh-taylor mixing and experimental evaluation,” Physics of plasmas 7, 2255–2269 (2000).DOI
  26. [26]D. Layzer, “On the instability of superposed fluids in a gravitational field,” Astrophysical Journal, vol. 122, p. 1 122, 1 (1955).DOI
  27. [27]J. Hansom, P. Rosen, T. Goldack, K. Oades, P. Fieldhouse, N. Cowperthwaite, D. Youngs, N. Mawhinney, and A. Baxter, “Radiation driven planar foil instability and mix experiments at the awe helen laser,” Laser and Particle Beams 8, 51–71 (1990).DOI
  28. [28]V. Rana, H. Lim, J. Melvin, J. Glimm, B. Cheng, and D. Sharp, “Mixing with applications to inertial-confinement-fusion implosions,” Physical Review E 95, 013203 (2017).DOI
  29. [29]C. Huntington, A. Shimony, M. Trantham, C. Kuranz, D. Shvarts, C. Di Stefano, F. W. Doss, R. Drake, K. A. Filippo, D. Kalantar, et al., “Ablative stabilization of rayleigh-taylor instabilities resulting from a laser-driven radiative shock,” Physics of Plasmas 25, 052118 (2018).DOI
  30. [30]J. Li, R. Yan, B. Zhao, J. Zheng, H. Zhang, and X. Lu, “Mitigation of the ablative rayleigh–taylor instability by nonlocal electron heat transport,” Matter and Radiation at Extremes 7, 055902 (2022).DOI
  31. [31]J. Li, R. Yan, B. Zhao, J. Wu, L. Wang, and S. Zou, “Effect of hot-electron preheating on the multimode bubble-front growth of the ablative rayleigh–taylor instability,” Physics of Plasmas 31, 012703 (2024).DOI
  32. [32]D. Zhang, J. Li, J. Xin, R. Yan, Z. Wan, H. Zhang, and J. Zheng, “Self-generated magnetic field in ablative rayleigh–taylor instability,” Physics of Plasmas 29, 072702 (2022).DOI
  33. [33]C. Walsh, J. Chittenden, K. McGlinchey, N. Niasse, and B. Appelbe, “Self-generated magnetic fields in the stagnation phase of indirect-drive implosions on the national ignition facility,” Physical review letters 118, 155001 (2017).DOI
  34. [34]C. Walsh and D. Clark, “Nonlinear ablative rayleigh-taylor instability: Increased growth due to self-generated magnetic fields,” Physical Review E 107, L013201 (2023).DOI
  35. [35]A. Pak, A. Zylstra, K. Baker, D. Casey, E. Dewald, L. Divol, M. Hohenberger, A. Moore, J. Ralph, D. Schlossberg, et al., “Observations and properties of the first laboratory fusion experiment to exceed a target gain of unity,” Physical Review E 109, 025203 (2024).DOI
  36. [36]M. El Rafei and B. Thornber, “Numerical study and buoyancy–drag modeling of bubble and spike distances in three-dimensional spherical implosions,” Physics of Fluids 32, 124107 (2020).DOI
  37. [37]D. L. Youngs and B. Thornber, “Buoyancy–drag modelling of bubble and spike distances for single-shock Richtmyer–Meshkov mixing,” Physics D: Nonlinear Phenomena 410, 132517 (2020).DOI
  38. [38]G. Birkhoff, “Taylor instability. appendices to report la-1862,” Tech. Rep. (Los Alamos National Lab.(LANL), Los Alamos, NM (United States), 1955).DOI
  39. [39]R. Betti and J. Sanz, “Bubble acceleration in the ablative rayleigh-taylor instability,” Physical review letters 97, 205002 (2006).
  40. [40]J. Peebles, S. Hu, W. Theobald, V. Goncharov, N. Whiting, P. Celliers, S. Ali, G. Duchateau, E. Campbell, T. Boehly, et al., “Direct-drive measurements of laser-imprint-induced shock velocity nonuniformities,” Physical Review E 99, 063208 (2019).DOI
  41. [41]B. Fryxell, K. Olson, P. Ricker, F. X. Timmes, M. Zingale, D. Lamb, P. Mac-Neice, R. Rosner, J. Truran, and H. Tufo, “Flash: An adaptive mesh hydrodynamics code for modeling astrophysical thermonuclear flashes,” The Astrophysical Journal Supplement Series 131, 273 (2000).
  42. [42]T. Tao, G. Zheng, Q. Jia, R. Yan, and J. Zheng, “Laser pulse shape designer for direct-drive inertial confinement fusion implosions,” High Power Laser Science and Engineering 11, e41 (2023).
  43. [43]G. Zheng, T. Tao, Q. Jia, R. Yan, and J. Zheng, “Optimizing doping parameters of target to enhance direct-drive implosion,” Plasma Physics and Controlled Fusion 64, 105003 (2022).DOI

Paper details

vlnc:W_nya6ym72
Version
v1 · latest
Published
Fresh — added to the Hub within the last 30 days
Added
License
CC BY 4.0
Usage

views · 4

downloads · 0

A view counts once per browser per day, a download each time the PDF is requested.

  • Physics and Astronomy

Not recorded for this paper

View statement
Looking for related papers…
Contents