betaFeedback

WorksPhysics and Astronomy

Linearity of the co-moving velocity

Abstract

The co-moving velocity is a new variable in the description of immiscible two-phase flow in porous media. It is the saturation-weighted average over the derivatives of the seepage velocities of the two immiscible fluids with respect to saturation. Based on analysis of relative permeability data and computational modeling, it has been proposed that the co-moving velocity is linear when plotted against the derivative of the average seepage velocity with respect to the saturation, the flow derivative. I show here that it is enough to demand that the co-moving velocity is characterized by an additive parameter in addition to the flow derivative to be linear. This has profound consequences for relative permeability theory as it leads to a differential equation relating the two relative permeabilities describing the flow. I present this equation together with two solutions.

Introduction

The description of immiscible and incompressible two-phase flow in porous media at scales large enough so that the porous medium may be seen as a continuum, has been a challenge for a long time. In 1936 Wyckoff and Botset [1] proposed a generalization of the Darcy equation [2] by splitting it into two independent Darcy-type equations, one for each fluid, based on the idea that each fluid will experience, is the matrix and the other fluid together acting as an effective porous matrix. This reduces the effective permeability for each fluid by a factor, the relative permeability. It is then assumed that the two relative permeabilities depend only on the saturation. If I assume steady-state flow and that there are no continuum-scale gradients in the saturation, the theory is complete as described. This theory has a dominating position in all practical calculations.

The assumption that the relative permeabilities only depends on the saturation is the weak part of the theory. It is fairly accurate in a window of capillary numbers. However, outside this window, the pressure gradient enters and the theory loses its predictive power. For example Tallakstad et al. found that the average flow rate through a model porous medium

PoreLab, Department of Physics, Norwegian University of Science and Technology, NO–7491 Trondheim, Norway.

E-mail: [email protected] over a rather wide range of capillary numbers depends on the pressure drop across it to a power around two [3, 4]. In their experiment, they controlled the flow rates of the two immiscible fluids entering the porous medium, measuring the pressure drop and the saturation. But how to construct two generalized relative permeabilities from this information?

Hansen et al. [5, 6] recognized that the problem is that knowing the flow velocity of each fluid makes it possible to find the combined average flow velocity, but the opposite is not. The combined average flow velocity must be accompanied by a second independent velocity in order to calculate the two separate fluid velocities from the average flow velocity. This would be the co-moving velocity. Roy et al. [7] measured the co-moving velocity from relative permeability data using multiple sources and calculated it in a dynamic pore network model, finding that it would produce a straight line when plotted against the derivative of the average flow velocity with respect to the saturation — the flow derivative in the terminology of Hansen et al. [8] — necessitating only two parameters, one setting the scale and one determining the slope. They observed this linear behavior in the co-moving velocity plots generated from the relative permeability data, When the dynamic pore network model went outside the limits of relative permeability theory and into the non-linear flow regime first observed by Tallakstad et al. [3, 4], the linearity of the co-moving velocity was still in place, but the two parameters would now depended on the pressure gradient. Hansen et al. [8] constructed a statistical mechanics for immiscible two-phase flow in porous media under steady-state conditions that would explain why the derivative of the average flow velocity with respect to the saturation would be the natural variable for the co-moving velocity. Pedersen and Hansen [9] then presented an interpretation of the co-moving velocity by exploring the geometry of the space of variables describing the flow.

The last paper so far addressing the co-moving velocity is Alzubaidi et al. [10] who measured it for a wide range of contact angles using lattice Boltzmann computations on the reconstructed pore spaces of North Sea Sandstone and Bentheimer sandstone, but in the linear flow regime. In addition, they used experimental flow data on Bentheimer sandstone [11]. Their surprising conclusion was that the parameters characterizing the co-moving velocity are insensitive to the contact angle.

Three mysteries can therefore be identified concerning the co-moving velocity: 1. why is it linear in the flow derivative and 2. why is it still linear when the average flow rate becomes non-linear, and 3. why is the value of the parameters insensitive to the contact angle, at least in the linear regime.

The aim of this note is to address the first and second of these points. Is the linearity a result of some underlying mechanism that has to do with the detailed physics of immiscible two-phase flow, or is it rooted in the mathematical structure of the problem [9]? The robustness of the linearity (point two above) hints at the latter as the linear and the non-linear flow regimes are quite different. It is this viewpoint I will take in this note.

The linearity of the co-moving velocity when plotted against the flow derivative is a strong statement that has profound consequences. It is the aim of this paper to find a necessary and sufficient criterion for linearity.

I will claim that it is sufficient to demand that two parameters with dimensions of velocity are necessary to characterize the seepage velocity of each fluid, vwv_w and vnv_n, where the subscripts refer to the wetting and non-wetting fluids. This does not exclude additional dimensionless parameters. Fix the pressure gradient and do a wetting saturation sweep. When the wetting saturation is at a minimum, which I will assume to be for Sw=0S_w = 0, the wetting seepage velocity defines the initial level vw0v_w^0 (which may be zero). Likewise, when the non-wetting saturation is a minimum, which I will assume to be for Sn=1−Sw=0S_n = 1 - S_w = 0, the non-wetting fluid will be flowing at its initial level vn0v_n^0 (which may be zero). The second parameter I will call the range. It is for the wetting fluid the difference between seepage velocity at Sw=1S_w = 1 minus vw0v_w^0. I will call it Δvw\Delta v_w. Likewise, I define Δvn\Delta v_n for the non-wetting seepage velocity. The two seepage velocities may then be written

vw=vw0+Δvwuw(Sw),(1)v_w = v_w^0 + \Delta v_w u_w(S_w), \tag*{(1)}
vn=vn0+Δvnun(Sn),(2)v_n = v_n^0 + \Delta v_n u_n(S_n), \tag*{(2)}

where uw(Sw)u_w(S_w) and un(Sn)u_n(S_n) are dimensionless functions of the saturation. Note that the two parameters vw0v_w^0 and vn0v_n^0 are additive. In the flow regime where one may define the relative permeabilities krw(Sw)k_{rw}(S_w) and krn(Sn)k_{rn}(S_n), I have

uw(Sw)=krw(Sw)Sw,(3)u_w(S_w) = \frac{k_{rw}(S_w)}{S_w}, \tag*{(3)}
un(Sn)=krn(Sn)Sn.(4)u_n(S_n) = \frac{k_{rn}(S_n)}{S_n}. \tag*{(4)}

As I am working with the seepage velocities and not the Darcy velocities, I need to divide the relative permeabilities by the saturation.

I will then demonstrate that two parameters with dimensions of velocity being necessary to characterize the seepage velocity of each fluid lead to one parameter with dimension of velocity characterizing the co-moving velocity.

A necessary and sufficient criterion for the co-moving being linear in the flow derivative is then that the parameter with dimension of velocity is additive.

In the next section, I review the central concepts surrounding the co-moving velocity. I provide a concrete example in order to illustrate the concepts in a concrete way, namely that of Corey relative permeabilities with indices both equal to two. I then go on to analyse the average seepage velocity in Section 3. By using the Euler homogeneity theorem combined with the assumption that two parameters with dimensions of velocity in addition to non-dimensional parameters describe the average seepage velocity, I derive a general functional form for it. I continue with the example from Section 2 to illustrate the manipulations. In Section 4 I analyse the co-moving velocity using the method used for the average seepage velocity. Having two parameters with dimensions of velocity needed for the average seepage velocities, this leads to only one dimensional parameter being needed for the co-moving velocity. Assuming then that this parameter is an added constant, a mild assumption, the Euler homogeneity theorem forces the co-moving velocity to be linear. I also here use the previously introduced concrete example to illustrate the theory. In Section 5 I explore the consequences of this linearity for relative permeability theory. In particular, I present an equation combining the two relative permeabilities and provide two solutions of the equation. Finally, I conclude in Section 6.

Central concepts

I assume a porous medium sample having an area AA transversal to the flow direction and a porosity ϕ\phi. The sample is uniform. I inject under steady state conditions a volumetric flow rate QwQ_w of the (more) wetting fluid and a volumetric flow rate QnQ_n of the (less) wetting fluid. I assume the fluids to be well mixed in the sample so that there are no sample-scale gradients in the saturation. The total average flow rate is

Qt=Qw+Qn.(5)Q_t = Q_w + Q_n. \tag*{(5)}

I now consider a cut through the porous sample orthogonal to the flow direction. It has an area AA. The sub-area of the transversal area AA that cuts through the pores is Ap=ϕAA_p = \phi A. The sub-area of the pore area AA that cuts through the wetting fluid is Aw=SwApA_w = S_w A_p and the sub-area that cuts through the less wetting fluid is An=SnApA_n = S_n A_p.

I can then define the seepage velocities. The seepage velocity of the wetting fluid is

vw=QwAw(6)v_w = \frac{Q_w}{A_w} \tag*{(6)}

and the less wetting fluid,

vn=QnAn(7)v_n = \frac{Q_n}{A_n} \tag*{(7)}

The combined average seepage velocity of the fluids is given by

vt=QtAp=Swvw+Snvn,(8)v_t = \frac{Q_t}{A_p} = S_w v_w + S_n v_n , \tag*{(8)}

where I in the last expression have use equations (5)–(7).

The co-moving velocity is defined as [5]

vm=Sw(∂vw∂Sw)p+Sn(∂vn∂Sw)p,(9)v_m = S_w \left(\frac{\partial v_w}{\partial S_w}\right)_p + S_n \left(\frac{\partial v_n}{\partial S_w}\right)_p , \tag*{(9)}

where the subscript pp means keeping the pressure gradient pp fixed. By taking the derivative of equation (8), I find that the co-moving velocity may be written

vm=(∂vt∂Sw)p+vn−vw=vt′+vn−vn,(10)v_m = \left(\frac{\partial v_t}{\partial S_w}\right)_p + v_n - v_w = v_t' + v_n - v_n , \tag*{(10)}

where I have defined vt′=(∂vt/∂Sw)pv_t' = (\partial v_t/\partial S_w)_p.

Equations (8) and (9) constitute the mapping (vw,vn)→(vt,vm)(v_w,v_n) \to(v_t,v_m). The inverse mapping, (vt,vm)→(vw,vn)(v_t,v_m) \to(v_w,v_n), is

vw=vt+Sn(vt′−vm),(11)v_w = v_t + S_n(v_t' - v_m) , \tag*{(11)}
vn=vt−Sw(vt′−vm).(12)v_n = v_t - S_w(v_t' - v_m) . \tag*{(12)}

Roy et al. [7] and Alzubaidi et al. [10] observed the co-moving velocity being linear when plotted against vt′v_t',

vm=a(p)+b(p)vt′.(13)v_m = a(p) + b(p)v_t' . \tag*{(13)}

It is important for the derivation in the next section to note that vt′v_t' is a control parameter in this expression in accordance with [8]. Hence, it does not depend on anything, but other functions will depend on it.

I refrain in the following from writing the pressure gradient explicitly as it does not enter the discussion explicitly before § 5.

An example

In order to illustrate these manipulations, I will consider a concrete example. Suppose

vw=vw0+ΔvwSw,(14)v_w = v_w^0 + \Delta v_w S_w , \tag*{(14)}
vn=vn0+ΔvnSn.(15)v_n = v_n^0 + \Delta v_n S_n . \tag*{(15)}

Hence, I have set uw(Sw)=Swu_w(S_w)=S_w and un(Sn)=Snu_n(S_n)=S_n in equations (1) and (2). According to equations (3) and (4) this corresponds to using the Corey relative permeabilities with indices both equal to two. The parameters vw0v_w^0, vn0v_n^0, Δvw\Delta v_w, and Δvn\Delta v_n all have dimensions of velocity.

The average seepage velocity, equation (8), is then

vt=vt0−4ΔvtCSw(1−CSw),(16)v_t = v_t^0 - 4\Delta v_t C S_w(1-C S_w) , \tag*{(16)}

where

vt0=vn0+Δvn,(17)v_t^0 = v_n^0 + \Delta v_n , \tag*{(17)}

and

Δvt=(vn0−vw0+2Δvn)24(Δvw+Δvn)(18)\Delta v_t = \frac{(v_n^0-v_w^0+2\Delta v_n)^2}{4(\Delta v_w+\Delta v_n)} \tag*{(18)}

have dimension of velocity. The parameter

C=Δvw+Δvnvn0−vw0+2Δvn(19)C = \frac{\Delta v_w+\Delta v_n}{v_n^0-v_w^0+2\Delta v_n} \tag*{(19)}

is non-dimensional.

The flow derivative may be written

vt′=vw0−vn0−2Δvn+2(Δvw+Δvn)Sw=Δvt 4C (2CSw−1).(20)v_t' = v_w^0-v_n^0-2\Delta v_n+2(\Delta v_w+\Delta v_n)S_w=\Delta v_t\,4C\,(2C S_w-1) . \tag*{(20)}

I invert this expression with respect to SwS_w, finding

Sw=12C(1+4Cvt′Δvt).(21)S_w = \frac{1}{2C}\left(1+\frac{4C v_t'}{\Delta v_t}\right) . \tag*{(21)}

I express vtv_t in terms of vt′v_t' to find

vt=vt0−Δvt+vt′216C2Δvt.(22)v_t = v_t^0-\Delta v_t+\frac{v_t'^2}{16C^2\Delta v_t} . \tag*{(22)}

Combining equation (9) with equations (14) and (15) gives the co-moving velocity

vm=−Δvn+(Δvw+Δvn)Sw.(23)v_m=-\Delta v_n+(\Delta v_w+\Delta v_n)S_w . \tag*{(23)}

which becomes

vm=vn0−vw02+vt′2(24)v_m=\frac{v_n^0-v_w^0}{2}+\frac{v_t'}{2} \tag*{(24)}

when expressed in terms of the variable vt′v_t'. With reference to equation (13), I find that

a=vn0−vw02,(25)a=\frac{v_n^0-v_w^0}{2}, \tag*{(25)}
b=12.(26)b=\frac{1}{2}. \tag*{(26)}

Parameter aa has units of velocity whereas bb is non-dimensional.

Dimensional analysis of the average velocity

My assumption is that the seepage velocity of the two fluids vwv_w and vnv_n each need two parameters with dimensions of velocity, level and range, see equations (1) and (2). Combining equation (8) with these two equations will generate two parameters with dimensions of velocity vt0v_t^0 and Δvt\Delta v_t that will be functions of the four parameters vw0v_w^0, vn0v_n^0, Δvw\Delta v_w, and Δvn\Delta v_n.

The average seepage velocity vtv_t must be invariant under change of units. This means that if I divide the two parameters vt0v_t^0 and Δvt\Delta v_t, and the flow derivative vt′v_t' by a velocity scale v0v_0, the relation between them stays unchanged. In other words, they obey

vtv0=vt(vt0v0,Δvtv0,vt′v0).(27)\frac{v_t}{v_0}=v_t\left(\frac{v_t^0}{v_0},\frac{\Delta v_t}{v_0},\frac{v_t'}{v_0}\right). \tag*{(27)}

This defines vtv_t as an Euler homogeneous function of order one in (vt0,Δvt,vt′)(v_t^0,\Delta v_t,v_t'). I take the derivative with respect to 1/v01/v_0 and set it equal to one. This gives

vt=(∂vt∂vt0)Δvt,vt′vt0+(∂vt∂Δvt)vt0,vt′Δvt+(∂vt∂vt′)vt0,Δvtvt′.(28)v_t=\left(\frac{\partial v_t}{\partial v_t^0}\right)_{\Delta v_t,v_t'}v_t^0+\left(\frac{\partial v_t}{\partial\Delta v_t}\right)_{v_t^0,v_t'}\Delta v_t+\left(\frac{\partial v_t}{\partial v_t'}\right)_{v_t^0,\Delta v_t}v_t'. \tag*{(28)}

I set

(∂vt∂Δvt)vt0,vt′=f,(29)\left(\frac{\partial v_t}{\partial\Delta v_t}\right)_{v_t^0,v_t'}=f, \tag*{(29)}

and

(∂vt∂vt′)vt0,Δvt=g,(30)\left(\frac{\partial v_t}{\partial v_t'}\right)_{v_t^0,\Delta v_t}=g, \tag*{(30)}

so that equation (28) becomes

vt=(∂vt∂vt0)Δvt,vt′vt0+fΔvt+gvt′.(31)v_t=\left(\frac{\partial v_t}{\partial v_t^0}\right)_{\Delta v_t,v_t'}v_t^0+f\Delta v_t+gv_t'. \tag*{(31)}

Both ff and gg are homogeneous functions of order zero in (vt0,Δvt,vt′)(v_t^0,\Delta v_t,v_t'). The parameter vt0v_t^0 sets the level. It is therefore an added constant. This means that

(∂vt∂vt0)Δvt,vt′=1.(32)\left(\frac{\partial v_t}{\partial v_t^0}\right)_{\Delta v_t,v_t'}=1. \tag*{(32)}

From equation (31) we have that

(∂vt∂vt0)Δvt,vt′=(∂∂vt0)Δvt,vt′[vt0+fΔvt+gvt′]=1+(∂f∂vt0)Δvt,vt′Δvt+(∂g∂vt0)Δvt,vt′vt′.(33)\left(\frac{\partial v_t}{\partial v_t^0}\right)_{\Delta v_t,v_t'}=\left(\frac{\partial}{\partial v_t^0}\right)_{\Delta v_t,v_t'}\left[v_t^0+f\Delta v_t+gv_t'\right] =1+\left(\frac{\partial f}{\partial v_t^0}\right)_{\Delta v_t,v_t'}\Delta v_t+\left(\frac{\partial g}{\partial v_t^0}\right)_{\Delta v_t,v_t'}v_t'. \tag*{(33)}

where I have used equation (32). This gives

(∂f∂vt0)Δvt,vt′Δvt+(∂g∂vt0)Δvt,vt′vt′=0,(34)\left(\frac{\partial f}{\partial v_t^0}\right)_{\Delta v_t,v_t'}\Delta v_t+\left(\frac{\partial g}{\partial v_t^0}\right)_{\Delta v_t,v_t'}v_t'=0, \tag*{(34)}

for all choices of Δvt\Delta v_t and vt′v_t'. I conclude that neither ff nor gg depends on vt0v_t^0, and we may write vtv_t as

vt=vt0+f(vt′Δvt)Δvt+g(vt′Δvt)vt′,(35)v_t = v_t^0 + f\left(\frac{v_t'}{\Delta v_t}\right)\Delta v_t + g\left(\frac{v_t'}{\Delta v_t}\right)v_t', \tag*{(35)}

where ff and gg both are functions of the dimensionless single variable (vt′/Δvt)(v_t'/\Delta v_t).

I note that the dimensional analysis just performed does not generate any constraints on the two functions ff and gg apart from both being functions of the non-dimensional variable (vt′/Δvt)(v_t'/\Delta v_t).

The example: average velocity

Here I calculate ff and gg, equations (29) and (30) for the example given in § 2.1. By using equation (22) I find

f(vt′Δvt)=−1−116C2(vt′Δvt)2,(36)f\left(\frac{v_t'}{\Delta v_t}\right) = -1 - \frac{1}{16C^2}\left(\frac{v_t'}{\Delta v_t}\right)^2, \tag*{(36)}

and

g(vt′Δvt)=18C2(vt′Δvt).(37)g\left(\frac{v_t'}{\Delta v_t}\right) = \frac{1}{8C^2}\left(\frac{v_t'}{\Delta v_t}\right). \tag*{(37)}

Combining these two expressions with equation (31) recovers equation (22). I note that even if I set vw0=vn0=0v_w^0 = v_n^0 = 0, vt0=Δvnv_t^0 = \Delta v_n is still non-zero.

Dimensional analysis of the co-moving velocity

The three velocities, vwv_w, vnv_n and vtv_t each contain two dimensional parameters of which one is an added constant. The definition of the co-moving velocity (9) contains the derivatives of vwv_w and vnv_n with respect to the saturation. Hence, the two parameters vw0v_w^0 and vn0v_n^0, defined in equations (1) and (2) disappear when the co-moving velocity is expressed as a function of the saturation SwS_w. Only the parameters Δvw\Delta v_w and Δvn\Delta v_n appear, i.e.,

vm=vm(Δvw,Δvn,Sw).(38)v_m = v_m(\Delta v_w,\Delta v_n,S_w). \tag*{(38)}

I now express the co-moving velocity using the flow derivative vt′v_t' rather than the saturation SwS_w. As vt′v_t' has the dimensions of velocity, there will now only be one parameter with this dimensionality, the parameter aa. Hence, we have

vm=vm(a,vt′).(39)v_m = v_m(a,v_t'). \tag*{(39)}

The co-moving velocity must be invariant with respect to a change of velocity scale v0v_0. This was e.g., used in the analysis in Roy et al. [7], as it was the basis for using the relative permeability data. This means that vmv_m obeys the scaling relation

vm(a,vt′)v0=vm(av0,vt′v0).(40)\frac{v_m(a,v_t')}{v_0} = v_m\left(\frac{a}{v_0},\frac{v_t'}{v_0}\right). \tag*{(40)}

Hence, vmv_m is also an Euler homogeneous function of order one in the parameter aa and the variable vt′v_t'. Taking the derivative with respect to 1/v01/v_0 and setting v0=1v_0 = 1 gives

vm(a,vt′)=(∂vm∂a)vt′a+(∂vm∂vt′)avt′.(41)v_m(a,v_t') = \left(\frac{\partial v_m}{\partial a}\right)_{v_t'}a + \left(\frac{\partial v_m}{\partial v_t'}\right)_a v_t'. \tag*{(41)}

I define

(∂vm∂a)vt′=c(vt′a),(42)\left(\frac{\partial v_m}{\partial a}\right)_{v'_t}=c\left(\frac{v'_t}{a}\right), \tag*{(42)}
(∂vm∂vt′)a=b(vt′a),(43)\left(\frac{\partial v_m}{\partial v'_t}\right)_a=b\left(\frac{v'_t}{a}\right), \tag*{(43)}

where c(vt′/a)c(v'_t/a) and b(vt′/a)b(v'_t/a) are homogeneous functions of degree zero. Hence,

vm(a,vt′)=c(vt′a)a+b(vt′a)vt′.(44)v_m(a,v'_t)=c\left(\frac{v'_t}{a}\right)a+b\left(\frac{v'_t}{a}\right)v'_t. \tag*{(44)}

I must have that

(∂c∂vt′)a=∂2vm∂vt′∂a=∂2vm∂a∂vt′=(∂b∂a)vt′.(45)\left(\frac{\partial c}{\partial v'_t}\right)_a=\frac{\partial^2v_m}{\partial v'_t\partial a}=\frac{\partial^2v_m}{\partial a\partial v'_t}=\left(\frac{\partial b}{\partial a}\right)_{v'_t}. \tag*{(45)}

I now introduce a variable xx defined as

x=vt′a,(46)x=\frac{v'_t}{a}, \tag*{(46)}

so that equation (45) is reduced to the equation

dc(x)dx+xdb(x)dx=0.(47)\frac{dc(x)}{dx}+x\frac{db(x)}{dx}=0. \tag*{(47)}

I note that if the parameter aa is additive, the function cc is

c(x)=1,(48)c(x)=1, \tag*{(48)}

i.e., a constant. From equation (47) I then have that the function b(x)b(x) is also a constant. Combining this result with equation (33) gives the final result,

vm(a,vt′)=a+bvt′.(49)v_m(a,v'_t)=a+bv'_t. \tag*{(49)}

Hence, the co-moving velocity vmv_m is linear in vt′v'_t if and only if aa is an additive constant. The assumption that aa is an additive constant makes it possible to identify it. From equation (10) I have that

a=vm(a,0)=[vn−vw]vt′=0.(50)a=v_m(a,0)=\left[v_n-v_w\right]_{v'_t=0}. \tag*{(50)}

This identification is only possible if vt′=0v'_t=0 falls within the physical range of the parameters; in other words, vtv_t has a minimum in the range 0≤Sw≤10\le S_w\le1. If there is no such minimum, it is still possible to define aa, but it will not have the simple physical interpretation given in equation (50).

The example: co-moving velocity

The co-moving velocity in the example is given in equation (23). In order to calculate aa according to equation (46), I set vt′=0v'_t=0 in the equation (21) giving the corresponding saturation Sw=1/2CS_w=1/2C. I use the equations for vwv_w and vnv_n, (14) and (15) together with the definition of CC, equation (19),

a=[vn−vw]vt′=0=vn0−vw0+Δvn−12C(Δvw+Δvn)=vn0−vw02.(51)a=\left[v_n-v_w\right]_{v'_t=0}=v_n^0-v_w^0+\Delta v_n-\frac{1}{2C}\left(\Delta v_w+\Delta v_n\right)=\frac{v_n^0-v_w^0}{2}. \tag*{(51)}

We see that vw0v_w^0 and vn0v_n^0 appear in the expression in spite of equation (38). This is so since switching from SwS_w to vt′v'_t as control variable reintroduces them.

Consequences for relative permeability theory

The generalized Darcy equations that forms the core of relative permeability theory are

vw=−KkrwμwϕSwp(52)v_w=-\frac{K k_{rw}}{\mu_w \phi S_w}p \tag*{(52)}
vn=−KkrnμnϕSnp(53)v_n=-\frac{K k_{rn}}{\mu_n \phi S_n}p \tag*{(53)}

where μw\mu_w and μn\mu_n are viscosities, KK the permeability and krw(Sw)k_{rw}(S_w) and krn(Sw)k_{rn}(S_w) are the relative permeabilities. The saturations appear in the denominators since vwv_w and vnv_n are seepage velocities.

Following Roy et al. [7], I define a velocity scale

v0=−Kμwϕp(54)v_0=-\frac{K}{\mu_w\phi}p \tag*{(54)}

which is the seepage velocity of the wetting fluid at saturation Sw=1S_w=1. I may then write the generalized Darcy equations as

vw=krwSwv0(55)v_w=\frac{k_{rw}}{S_w}v_0 \tag*{(55)}
vn=krnSnMv0(56)v_n=\frac{k_{rn}}{S_n}Mv_0 \tag*{(56)}

where I have defined the viscosity ratio M=μw/μnM=\mu_w/\mu_n. The average velocity, equation (8), is then given by

vt(p,Sw)=[krw(Sw)+Mkrn(Sw)]v0(p).(57)v_t(p,S_w)=[k_{rw}(S_w)+M k_{rn}(S_w)]v_0(p). \tag*{(57)}

I now combine equations (55) and (56), with the co-moving velocity, equation (10) using equation (13). I also make a change in notation by setting a→av0a\to av_0, as in Roy et al. [7]. The resulting equation is

(1−b)ddSw[krw+Mkrn]−krwSw+MkrnSn=a.(58)(1-b)\frac{d}{dS_w}[k_{rw}+M k_{rn}]-\frac{k_{rw}}{S_w}+\frac{M k_{rn}}{S_n}=a. \tag*{(58)}

A simplified version of this equation was used in Alzubaidi et al. [10] to determine the non-wetting relative permeability when the krwk_{rw}, a=0a=0 and bb are known.

It is also possible to find analytic solutions to equation (58). I give an example in the following. Picchi and Battiato [12] suggested the semi-empirical form (note that their viscosity ratio is the inverse of the definition I use)

krw=krw0Sw2,(59)k_{rw}=k_{rw}^{0}S_w^2, \tag*{(59)}
krn=krn0Sn2[1+2SwMSn],(60)k_{rn}=k_{rn}^{0}S_n^2\left[1+\frac{2S_w}{M S_n}\right], \tag*{(60)}

where krw0k_{rw}^{0} and krn0k_{rn}^{0} are the end point relative permeabilities. Setting

b=12,(61)b=\frac{1}{2}, \tag*{(61)}

and

a=krn0(62)a=k_{rn}^{0} \tag*{(62)}

solves equation (58).

By solving for the saturation for which vt′=0v_t'=0, using equations (59) and (60), I find that

[vn−vw]vt′=0=krn0.(63)[v_n-v_w]_{v_t'=0}=k_{rn}^{0}. \tag*{(63)}

According to equation (28) this is equal to aa, as found solving equation (58) directly, leading to (62).

The Corey empirical relative permeabilities

krw=krw0swμw,(64)k_{rw}=k_{rw}^{0}s_w^{\mu_w}, \tag*{(64)}
krn=krn0snμn,(65)k_{rn}=k_{rn}^{0}s_n^{\mu_n}, \tag*{(65)}

are, on the other hand, not solutions to equation (58), except when μw=μn\mu_w=\mu_n, they are solutions, but with a=0a=0. In that case I find

b=1−1μw.(66)b=1-\frac{1}{\mu_w}. \tag*{(66)}

The example I gave in § 2.1 was based on the Corey relative permeabilities with exponents μw=μn=2\mu_w=\mu_n=2. The non-zero aa that was found, equation (25), came from the assumption that vw0v_w^0 and vn0v_n^0 were non-zero. The generalized Darcy equations (52) and (53) assumes vw0v_w^0 and vn0v_n^0 are both zero.

Discussion and Conclusion

I have in this paper shown that the co-moving velocity is of the form given by equation (13) given that two conditions are in place: 1. the average seepage velocity is characterized by two parameters with dimensions of velocity, allowing for additional dimensionless parameters, and 2. the necessity of an additive velocity scale aa in the co-moving velocity. Both assumptions are weak and does not hinge on any further restrictions on the constitutive law for vtv_t, linear or non-linear. Equation (58), which is the combination of the relative permeability constitutive laws (52) and (53) with the linear equation for vmv_m, (10), leads to a relation between the two relative permeabilities: knowing one, gives the other one.

The parameter a=[vn−vw]vt′=0a=[v_n-v_w]_{v_t'=0}, equation (28) may be given a straight-forward physical interpretation when vt=0v_t=0 falls within the physical range of the parameters. However, the second parameter, bb is not. It typically takes on a value around 0.6–0.8 and seems quite insensitive to the contact angle between the fluids and the matrix as shown by [10]. It is an open question why.

Declaration — The author declares no conflict of interest.

Acknowledgement — The author thanks R. T. Armstrong, C. F. Berg, S. Berg, E. G. Flekkøy, J. E. McClure, B. Hafskjold, H. Pedersen, T. Ramstad, S. Roy, and S. Sinha for countless discussions. This work was partly supported by the Research Council of Norway through its Centres of Excellence funding scheme, project number 262644.

References

  1. [1]R. Wyckoff, H. Botset, The flow of gas-liquid mixtures through unconsolidated sands, Physics 7(9), 325 (1936). DOI 10.1063/1.1745402DOI
  2. [2]H. Darcy, Les fontaines publiques de la ville de Dijon: exposition et application des principes à suivre et des formules à employer dans les questions de distribution d’eau, vol. 1 (Victor Dalmont, 1856)
  3. [3]K.T. Tallakstad, H.A. Knudsen, T. Ramstad, G. Løvøll, K.J. Måløy, R. Toussaint, E.G. Flekkøy, Steady-state two-phase flow in porous media: statistics and transport properties, Physical review letters 102(7), 074502 (2009). DOI 10.1103/PhysRevLett.102.074502DOI
  4. [4]K.T. Tallakstad, G. Løvøll, H.A. Knudsen, T. Ramstad, E.G. Flekkøy, K.J. Måløy, Steady-state, simultaneous two-phase flow in porous media: An experimental study, Physical Review E 80(3), 036308 (2009). DOI 10.1103/PhysRevE.80.036308DOI
  5. [5]A. Hansen, S. Sinha, D. Bedeaux, S. Kjelstrup, M.A. Gjennestad, M. Vassvik, Relation between seepage velocities in immiscible, incompressible two-phase flow in porous media, Transport in Porous Media 125, 565 (2018). DOI 10.1007/s11242-018-1139-6DOI
  6. [6]J. Feder, E.G. Flekkøy, A. Hansen, Physics of flow in porous media (Cambridge University Press, 2022)DOI
  7. [7]S. Roy, H. Pedersen, S. Sinha, A. Hansen, The co-moving velocity in immiscible two-phase flow in porous media, Transport in Porous Media 143(1), 69 (2022). DOI 10.1007/s11242-022-01783-7DOI
  8. [8]A. Hansen, E.G. Flekkøy, S. Sinha, P.A. Slotte, A statistical mechanics framework for immiscible and incompressible two-phase flow in porous media, Advances in Water Resources 171, 104336 (2023). DOI 10.1016/j.advwatres.2022.104336DOI
  9. [9]H. Pedersen, A. Hansen, Parameterizations of immiscible two-phase flow in porous media, Frontiers in Physics 11, 116 (2023). DOI 10.3389/fphy.2023.1127345DOI
  10. [10]F. Alzubaidi, J.E. McClure, H. Pedersen, A. Hansen, C.F. Berg, P. Mostaghimi, R.T. Armstrong, The impact of wettability on the co-moving velocity of two-fluid flow in porous media, arXiv preprint arXiv:2309.00362 (2023). DOI 10.48550/arXiv.2309.00362
  11. [11]S. Zou, R.T. Armstrong, J.Y. Arns, C.H. Arns, F. Hussain, Experimental and theoretical evidence for increased ganglion dynamics during fractional flow in mixed-wet porous media, Water Resources Research 54(5), 3277 (2018). DOI 10.1029/2017WR022433DOI
  12. [12]D. Picchi, I. Battiato, Relative permeability scaling from pore-scale flow regimes, Water Resources Research 55(4), 3215 (2019). DOI 10.1029/2018WR024251DOI

Paper details

vlnc:W_p3t7rqt6
Version
v1 · latest
Published
Fresh — added to the Hub within the last 30 days
Added
License
CC BY 4.0
Usage

views · 0

downloads · 0

A view counts once per browser per day, a download each time the PDF is requested.

  • Physics and Astronomy

Not recorded for this paper

View statement
Looking for related papers…
Contents