betaFeedback

WorksPhysics and Astronomy

CP Violation Problem

Abstract

The strong CP violation problem has a long history emanating from its discovery 60 years ago in the decay of neutral kaons and subsequent experimental and theoretical studies over several decades. We review herein experimental data that observe indirect CP violation of the order of ∼10−3\sim10^{-3}, as well as the discovery of direct CP violation of the order of ∼10−6\sim10^{-6}. Despite improved experimental methods over the past half a century, the original CP violation numbers have remained the same. Verification of the CP violation in the decay of charged kaons was also observed. Data reflecting CP violation in the decays of BB and DD mesons have become very important and are also discussed in this review. The question of CP violation only with the participation of ssˉs\bar{s}, ccˉc\bar{c}, and bbˉb\bar{b} quarks in the framework of the Standard Model or beyond it and its small magnitude remains open.

Introduction

New particles, called K-mesons, or kaons, were discovered in cosmic rays in the late 1940s and were then studied more intensively at charged-particle accelerators beginning in 1954. These are the charged K±K^{\pm} mesons (which form a particle / antiparticle pair) and the neutral K0K^0 meson (formed by a strange quark and a down antiquark); with its antiparticle Kˉ0\bar{K}^0. Kaons have zero spin and a mass approximately 970 times that of an electron. Since they participate via strong interactions, they are identified as hadrons, but with zero baryon charge. They also are assigned a new quantum number, strangeness SS, namely $S = 1 for K0K^{0} and S=−1S=-1 for Kˉ0\bar{K}^{0}, characterizing their behavior in strong interaction processes.

Until 1956, the law of conservation of parity was considered fundamental, as was the law of conservation of energy and momentum. However, Lee and Yang’s suggestion of spatial parity non-conservation in weak interactions [1] was confirmed in 1957 by Wu et al. in studying the beta decay of Co60\mathrm{Co}^{60} nuclei at NBS (now NIST) [2].

An important result of the study of K0K^{0} mesons was the discovery of CP parity violation, or T parity violation, according to the CPT theorem [3, 4]. Here, PP is a spatial inversion - parity, that is, a mirror image of the coordinates, replacing vector signs with the opposite ones for polar vectors r⃗→−r⃗\vec{r} \to-\vec{r}, as well as momentum p⃗→−p⃗\vec{p} \to-\vec{p}, while for pseudovectors, the angular momentum and spin do not change. CC is the charge conjugation parity, with the replacement of particles by their corresponding antiparticles, i.e., a change in the electric charge, hypercharge, baryon and lepton charges and, as a consequence, a change in the sign of the magnetic moment. In this case, the spatial coordinates, momentum, and spin of the particle do not change. TT denotes time reversal, t→−tt \to-t, that is, the reversibility of movement, with a corresponding change in the signs of momentum and spins. These parities are conserved in gravitational, electromagnetic and strong interactions but are violated in the weak interaction. The CTP theorem states that all quantum field theories must be symmetric under a combined transformation of P, C, and T which has been verified (see below).

CP Parity

Neither K0K^{0} nor Kˉ0\bar{K}^{0} have a certain CP parity, but they do have negative spatial parity PP. The action of the operators CC, PP, and CP on the wave functions K0K^{0} and Kˉ0\bar{K}^{0} can be written in the following form:

C∣K0⟩=−∣Kˉ0⟩,C∣Kˉ0⟩=−∣K0⟩,P∣K0⟩=−∣K0⟩,P∣Kˉ0⟩=−∣Kˉ0⟩,CP∣K0⟩=∣Kˉ0⟩,CP∣Kˉ0⟩=∣K0⟩\begin{aligned} C|K^{0}\rangle&= -|\bar{K}^{0}\rangle,\qquad C|\bar{K}^{0}\rangle= -|K^{0}\rangle,\\ P|K^{0}\rangle&= -|K^{0}\rangle,\qquad P|\bar{K}^{0}\rangle= -|\bar{K}^{0}\rangle,\\ CP|K^{0}\rangle&= |\bar{K}^{0}\rangle,\qquad CP|\bar{K}^{0}\rangle= |K^{0}\rangle \end{aligned}

where it is possible that antiparticles K0K^{0} and Kˉ0\bar{K}^{0} are transitioning from one to the other. Thus, from the states K0K^{0} and Kˉ0\bar{K}^{0} it is possible to construct linear combinations having definite CP parity values. These are

∣K10⟩=12(∣K0⟩+∣Kˉ0⟩),|K^{0}_{1}\rangle= \sqrt{\frac{1}{2}}\left(|K^{0}\rangle+ |\bar{K}^{0}\rangle\right),

with CP parity +1+1, which can decay into two pions, and the orthogonal superposition

∣K20⟩=12(∣K0⟩−∣Kˉ0⟩),|K^{0}_{2}\rangle= \sqrt{\frac{1}{2}}\left(|K^{0}\rangle- |\bar{K}^{0}\rangle\right),

has CP parity −1-1, that can decay into two pions only as a result of a CP violating process such as the weak interaction. K10K^{0}_{1} and K20K^{0}_{2} are not particle – antiparticle pairs and thus may have different decay channels. The resulting CP parities of K10K^{0}_{1} and K20K^{0}_{2} are:

CP∣K10⟩=+∣K10⟩,CP|K^{0}_{1}\rangle= +|K^{0}_{1}\rangle,
CP∣K20⟩=−∣K20⟩.CP|K^{0}_{2}\rangle= -|K^{0}_{2}\rangle.

Let us consider the conservation of combined CP-parity in the decays of KK-mesons into 2 and 3 pions. 2π2\pi and 3π3\pi systems with orbital momentum l=0l = 0 are eigenstates of the CP-operator. The operator P is equivalent to replacing π+π−\pi^{+}\pi^{-} with the acquisition of the wave function of the multiplier (−1)l(-1)^{l}.

P∣π+π−⟩=P∣π+⟩ P∣π−⟩ (−1)l=+∣π+π−⟩.P|\pi^{+}\pi^{-}\rangle= P|\pi^{+}\rangle\ P|\pi^{-}\rangle\ (-1)^{l} = +|\pi^{+}\pi^{-}\rangle.

The operator CC turns π+\pi^{+} into π−\pi^{-} and π−\pi^{-} into π+\pi^{+}, that is, it is also equivalent to replacement π+π−\pi^{+}\pi^{-} mesons

C∣π+π−⟩=(−1)l∣π+π−⟩=+∣π+π−⟩C|\pi^{+}\pi^{-}\rangle= (-1)^{l}|\pi^{+}\pi^{-}\rangle= +|\pi^{+}\pi^{-}\rangle

for l=0l = 0. And the eigenvalue of the CP operator of the 2π2\pi system is equal to +1+1:

CP∣π+π−⟩=(−1)2l∣π+π−⟩=+∣π+π−⟩.CP|\pi^{+}\pi^{-}\rangle= (-1)^{2l}|\pi^{+}\pi^{-}\rangle= +|\pi^{+}\pi^{-}\rangle.

The CP parity of a system of three pion state depends on the orbital state L⃗\vec{L} of the 3π3\pi which is the sum of the orbital momentum vectors l⃗\vec{l} of π+π−\pi^{+}\pi^{-} pair and the orbital momentum l⃗′\vec{l}^{\prime} of π0\pi^{0} relative to the center of mass of this pion pair, that is, L⃗=l⃗+l⃗′=0\vec{L} = \vec{l} + \vec{l}^{\prime} = 0 (l⃗′=−l⃗\vec{l}^{\prime} = -\vec{l}).

P∣π+π−π0⟩=P∣π+⟩ P∣π−⟩ P∣π0⟩ (−1)L=(−1)∣π+π−π0⟩,P|\pi^{+}\pi^{-}\pi^{0}\rangle= P|\pi^{+}\rangle\ P|\pi^{-}\rangle\ P|\pi^{0}\rangle\ (-1)^{L} = (-1)|\pi^{+}\pi^{-}\pi^{0}\rangle,
C∣π+π−π0⟩=∣π+π−π0⟩ (−1)L=(+1)∣π+π−π0⟩,C|\pi^{+}\pi^{-}\pi^{0}\rangle= |\pi^{+}\pi^{-}\pi^{0}\rangle\ (-1)^{L} = (+1)|\pi^{+}\pi^{-}\pi^{0}\rangle,
CP∣π+π−π0⟩=(−1)∣π+π−π0⟩CP|\pi^{+}\pi^{-}\pi^{0}\rangle= (-1)|\pi^{+}\pi^{-}\pi^{0}\rangle

for L=0L = 0. In the result, the eigenvalue of the CP operator of the 3π3\pi system is equal to −1-1.

Since 2π2\pi and 3π3\pi systems are eigenvalues of the CP operator at zero orbital momentum, we assume in above relations that this momentum equals zero.

The states K10K_1^0 and K20K_2^0 have fixed CP parity values, without, however, having fixed strangeness. We can write the following.

∣K0⟩=12(∣K10⟩+∣K20⟩),\lvert K^0\rangle= \sqrt{\frac{1}{2}}\left(\lvert K_1^0\rangle+ \lvert K_2^0\rangle\right),
∣Kˉ0⟩=12(∣K10⟩−∣K20⟩).\lvert\bar{K}^0\rangle= \sqrt{\frac{1}{2}}\left(\lvert K_1^0\rangle- \lvert K_2^0\rangle\right).

That is K0K^0 and Kˉ0\bar{K}^0 are superpositions of the states K10K_1^0 and K20K_2^0. Since CP(K10)=+1CP(K_1^0) = +1, while conserving the combined parity, with an average lifetime of the 2π2\pi decay is τ(K10)≈0.9×10−10\tau(K_1^0) \approx0.9 \times10^{-10} s. Correspondingly, CP(K20)=−1CP(K_2^0) = -1 and decays to 3π3\pis with with a lifetime τ(K20)≈5×10−8\tau(K_2^0) \approx5 \times10^{-8} s due to the smaller phase volume of the decay products. Due to the low energy release in 3π3\pi decays, their probabilities are approximately three orders of magnitude lower than the probabilities of 2π2\pi decays. Since 50% of the K0K^0 meson consists of the K10K_1^0 component, its decays into 2π2\pi are observed near the target. At a greater distance from the target, decays of the K20K_2^0 component are observed in 3π3\pi mesons.

The inter-conversion of K0K^0 and Kˉ0\bar{K}^0 mesons in the vacuum is their oscillation between two superimposed states K0↔Kˉ0K^0 \leftrightarrow\bar{K}^0. Being a process with a ΔS=2\Delta S = 2 change in strangeness, (S=1S = 1 for the K0K^0 meson and S=−1S = -1 for the Kˉ0\bar{K}^0 meson), this can only occur through weak interactions between the quarks from which the K0K^0 mesons are formed: K0=sˉd↔sdˉ=Kˉ0K^0 = \bar{s}d \leftrightarrow s\bar{d} = \bar{K}^0.

As a result of these transformations, K0K^0 and Kˉ0\bar{K}^0 do not have fixed mass and lifetime. The allowed region in the mK0−mKˉ0m_{K^0} - m_{\bar{K}^0} could be obtained from uncertain of determination of δ\delta [5]:

−4×10−19 GeV<mK0−mKˉ0<+4×10−19 GeV (0.5% C.L.).-4 \times10^{-19}\ \mathrm{GeV} < m_{K^0} - m_{\bar{K}^0} < +4 \times10^{-19}\ \mathrm{GeV}\ (0.5\%\ \mathrm{C.L.}) .

The kaon states with fixed mass and lifetime are short-lived KS0K_S^0 and long-lived KL0K_L^0 mesons.

The difference between the masses of KL0K_L^0 and KS0K_S^0 is due to the weak interaction that causes K0↔Kˉ0K^0 \leftrightarrow\bar{K}^0 transitions; this mass difference is very small [5]:

ΔmK=m(KL0)−m(KS0)=(3.510±0.018)×10−12 MeV.\Delta m_K = m(K_L^0) - m(K_S^0) = (3.510 \pm0.018) \times10^{-12}\ \mathrm{MeV} .

In the presence of CP invariance, we can consider: ∣KS0⟩≡∣K10⟩\lvert K_S^0\rangle\equiv\lvert K_1^0\rangle and ∣KL0⟩≡∣K20⟩\lvert K_L^0\rangle\equiv\lvert K_2^0\rangle.

Let us assume that at an initial t=0t = 0 there exist pure K0K^0 mesons in the vacuum, e.g., produced in reaction π−p→K0Λ\pi^-p \to K^0\Lambda in the absence of K‾0\overline{K}^0 mesons. Then after time tt there will be the following beam:

12[(K0+K‾0)e−i(m1−Γ1/2)t+(K0−K‾0)e−i(m2−Γ2/2)t].\frac{1}{2}\left[(K^0+\overline{K}^0)e^{-i(m_1-\Gamma_1/2)t}+(K^0-\overline{K}^0)e^{-i(m_2-\Gamma_2/2)t}\right].

If K10K^0_1 and K20K^0_2 are stable, Γ1=Γ2=0\Gamma_1=\Gamma_2=0, the probabilities of finding

PK0(t)=14∣e−im1t+e−im2t∣2=cos⁡2(ΔmK2t),P_{K^0}(t)=\frac{1}{4}\left|e^{-im_1t}+e^{-im_2t}\right|^2=\cos^2\left(\frac{\Delta m_K}{2}t\right),
PK‾0(t)=14∣e−im1t−e−im2t∣2=sin⁡2(ΔmK2t).P_{\overline{K}^0}(t)=\frac{1}{4}\left|e^{-im_1t}-e^{-im_2t}\right|^2=\sin^2\left(\frac{\Delta m_K}{2}t\right).

and after time τ=π(m2−m1)=π/ΔmK\tau=\pi(m_2-m_1)=\pi/\Delta m_K (oscillation period) there would be no K0K^0 mesons in beam, since:

PK0(τ)=cos⁡2(ΔmK2τ)=cos⁡2π2=0,P_{K^0}(\tau)=\cos^2\left(\frac{\Delta m_K}{2}\tau\right)=\cos^2\frac{\pi}{2}=0,
PK‾0(τ)=sin⁡2(ΔmK2τ)=sin⁡2π2=1.P_{\overline{K}^0}(\tau)=\sin^2\left(\frac{\Delta m_K}{2}\tau\right)=\sin^2\frac{\pi}{2}=1.

Such oscillations, which are superimposed by exponential decay due to Γ1,2≠0\Gamma_{1,2}\ne0, are observed experimentally. It is possible to observe them, for example, in semileptonic decays of neutral kaons that satisfy the rule ΔQ=ΔS\Delta Q=\Delta S. This rule is due to the fact that during the transition s→us\to u the strangeness and electric charge of the quark increase by one.

K0(ds‾)→π−(du‾)l+νl,K0(ds‾)↛π+(ud‾)l−ν‾l,K^0\left(\frac{d}{\overline{s}}\right)\to\pi^-\left(\frac{d}{\overline{u}}\right)l^+\nu_l,\qquad K^0\left(\frac{d}{\overline{s}}\right)\nrightarrow\pi^+\left(\frac{u}{\overline{d}}\right)l^-\overline{\nu}_l,
K‾0(sd‾)→π+(ud‾)l−ν‾l,K‾0(sd‾)↛π−(du‾)l+νl.\overline{K}^0\left(\frac{s}{\overline{d}}\right)\to\pi^+\left(\frac{u}{\overline{d}}\right)l^-\overline{\nu}_l,\qquad\overline{K}^0\left(\frac{s}{\overline{d}}\right)\nrightarrow\pi^-\left(\frac{d}{\overline{u}}\right)l^+\nu_l.

Here l≡e, μl\equiv e,\ \mu. The sign of the charged lepton indicates the strangeness of K0K^0 or K‾0\overline{K}^0. Oscillations can be measured by recording the numbers of electrons and positrons arising from Ke3K_{e3} decays; such experiments make it possible to determine ΔmK\Delta m_K. Reactions with ↛\nrightarrow are prohibited by the rule ΔQ=ΔS\Delta Q=\Delta S and have not been observed experimentally.

The K0K^0-meson, arising as a result of the strong interaction, at some distance from the initial production point is practically transformed due to the weak interaction into K‾0\overline{K}^0 and therefore turns out to be capable of causing nuclear reactions, for example, K‾0p→Λπ+\overline{K}^0p\to\Lambda\pi^+ characteristic of K‾0\overline{K}^0 and prohibited for K0K^0 due to the preservation of strangeness in strong interaction. In 1955, Pais and Piccioni predicted oscillations in a beam of neutral KK mesons within the framework of the regeneration effect [6]. Regeneration consisted of the use of an absorber, positioned at a distance determined by τS\tau_{S} and τL\tau_{L} to demonstrate the superposition of K0K^{0} and Kˉ0\bar{K}^{0}. Let us take a pure beam K0K^{0} in vacuum (equal of parts KS0K^{0}_{S} and KL0K^{0}_{L}). After, e.g., t≈10τSt \approx10\tau_{S}, the intensity of KS0K^{0}_{S} was reduced by a factor of e−t/τS=e−10≈4.5×10−5e^{-t/\tau_{S}} = e^{-10} \approx4.5 \times10^{-5} (0.5 m for the 1 GeV kaons). The 6.2 GeV proton synchrotron at Lawrence Berkeley National Laboratory (LBNL) with a beam π−\pi^{-} of 1.1 GeV was used for the experiment.

A beam of neutral K-mesons decays in flight so that the short-lived KS0K^{0}_{S} disappears, leaving a long-lived pure beam KL0K^{0}_{L}. If this beam passes through matter, K0K^{0} and Kˉ0\bar{K}^{0} interact with nuclei in different ways. With K0K^{0}, quasi-elastic scattering on nucleons occurs, while Kˉ0\bar{K}^{0} can produce hyperons. Due to the different interactions of these components, the quantum coherence between the two particles is lost. The resulting beam contains various linear superpositions of K0K^{0} and Kˉ0\bar{K}^{0}. Each superposition is a mixture of KS0K^{0}_{S} and KL0K^{0}_{L}, so KS0K^{0}_{S} is restored when a beam of K-mesons passes through the substance of the regenerator, as was observed in the above experiment. Anomalous regeneration of KS0K^{0}_{S} was obtained in Ref. [7].

The problem of time reversal in quantum mechanics has been discussed since the 1930s [8].

In 1964, Christenson, Cronin, Fitch, and Turlay discovered CP violation in an experiment at the Brookhaven National Laboratory (BNL) AGS accelerator [9] through the decay of the neutral KL0K^{0}_{L} meson to 2π2\pi mesons in spite of the main decay channel to 3π3\pi. In fact, there are two K-mesons: K10→π+π−K^{0}_{1} \to\pi^{+}\pi^{-} with CP=+1CP = +1 (while CP=+1CP = +1 for the state), that is, the even state, and K20→π+π−π0K^{0}_{2} \to\pi^{+}\pi^{-}\pi^{0} with CP=−1CP = -1, i.e., the odd state.

The long-lived KL0K^{0}_{L} has a probability of approximately 0.2% decaying into 2π2\pi with CP parity violation, which is small, but is, however, an important discovery for fundamental physics [5]:

Γ(KL0→π+π−)Γ(KL0→all)=(2.03±0.04)×10−3.\frac{\Gamma(K^{0}_{L} \to\pi^{+}\pi^{-})}{\Gamma(K^{0}_{L} \to\text{all})} = (2.03 \pm0.04) \times10^{-3}.

CP violation in mixtures of neutral mesons K0↔Kˉ0K^{0} \leftrightarrow\bar{K}^{0} is an indirect violation of CP parity, in contrast to direct violation at different decay rates of a particles and antiparticles and interference between direct and indirect violation of CP parity. There is no strict identification of KS0K^{0}_{S} with K10K^{0}_{1} and KL0K^{0}_{L} with K20K^{0}_{2}. Instead, the states KL0K^{0}_{L} and KS0K^{0}_{S} are defined as follows:

∣KL0⟩=(1+∣ϵ∣2)−1/2(∣K20⟩+ϵ∣K10⟩)=[2(1+∣ϵ∣2)]−1/2[(1+ϵ)∣K0⟩−(1−ϵ)∣Kˉ0⟩],\lvert K^{0}_{L}\rangle= \left(1 + \lvert\epsilon\rvert^{2}\right)^{-1/2}\left(\lvert K^{0}_{2}\rangle+ \epsilon\lvert K^{0}_{1}\rangle\right) = \left[2\left(1 + \lvert\epsilon\rvert^{2}\right)\right]^{-1/2}\left[(1+\epsilon)\lvert K^{0}\rangle- (1-\epsilon)\lvert\bar{K}^{0}\rangle\right],
∣KS0⟩=(1+∣ϵ∣2)−1/2(∣K10⟩+ϵ∣K20⟩)=[2(1+∣ϵ∣2)]−1/2[(1+ϵ)∣K0⟩+(1−ϵ)∣Kˉ0⟩].\lvert K^{0}_{S}\rangle= \left(1 + \lvert\epsilon\rvert^{2}\right)^{-1/2}\left(\lvert K^{0}_{1}\rangle+ \epsilon\lvert K^{0}_{2}\rangle\right) = \left[2\left(1 + \lvert\epsilon\rvert^{2}\right)\right]^{-1/2}\left[(1+\epsilon)\lvert K^{0}\rangle+ (1-\epsilon)\lvert\bar{K}^{0}\rangle\right].

The laws of nature would be the same for matter and for antimatter. Most phenomena are CC- and PP-symmetric, and also CP-symmetric for electromagnetic, strong, and gravitational interactions. The weak interactions violate the CC- and PP-symmetric as well as some CP-symmetry of unknown nature with the supposition of a superweak interaction. At the same time, the Universe is made chiefly of matter, rather than consisting of equal parts of matter and antimatter, as might be expected.

Matter-Antimatter Problem

The Universe is made chiefly of matter, rather than consisting of equal parts of matter and antimatter, as might be expected. In order to create an imbalance in matter and antimatter from an initial balance, the special conditions must be satisfied.

In 1967, Sakharov showed that CP violation was one of the necessary conditions for the almost complete destruction of antimatter at the early stage of the development of the Universe in the first seconds following the Big Bang [10, 11]. The Big Bang should have produced equal amounts of matter and antimatter that would have resulted in the Universe being filled with radiation due to complete matter-antimatter annihilation. Our Universe is filled with a large number of relic photons formed as a result of partial matter-antimatter annihilation as is recorded by radio telescopes as the observed Cosmic Microwave Background, the 2.72548±0.000572.72548 \pm0.00057 K radiation that fills the entire Universe. Obviously, not all of the matter was annihilated into photons; about one of every billion quarks survived and is the origin of the Universe that exists today. This leads to some questions: how could some matter survive the primordial annihilation; why did matter survive instead of antimatter; and where and when did the corresponding antimatter disappear? Sakharov’s hypothesis is that after the Big Bang, the physical laws acted differently for matter and antimatter, that is, the CP symmetry was violated.

It can be shown that to create the current imbalance between matter and antimatter, the Sakharov conditions must be satisfied; that is, violation of the baryon number, violation of symmetry CC, violation of CP symmetry, and the interaction process is outside of that allowed by thermal equilibrium. Baryon number violation is a necessary condition for producing an excess of baryons over antibaryons. One of its conditions is the violation of CP symmetry in the extreme conditions of the first seconds after the Big Bang. Since our Universe is not a sea of photons without other matter, immediately after the Big Bang different physical laws than now exist now were in effect for matter and antimatter: that is, for one, CP symmetry was violated. However, breaking the CC symmetry was also necessary so that interactions that produced more baryons than antibaryons were not balanced by interactions that produced more antibaryons than baryons. Breaking of CP symmetry was necessary – otherwise an equal number of left baryons and right antibaryons would be produced, as well as an equal number of right baryons and left antibaryons. These interactions had to be outside of the limitations of thermal equilibrium; otherwise, CPT symmetry would have compensated for the processes of decreasing or increasing the baryon number.

CP Violation in Standard Model

In 1973, in their attempt to find an explanation for the violation of the CP in the decay of neutral kaons using the idea of Cabibbo concerning the mixing of two generations of quarks, Kobayashi and Maskawa predicted the existence of a third generation of quarks. As a result of their work, the bottom bb quark was discovered in 1977 [12], and the tt quark in 1995 [13, 14].

Possible CP violation is associated with complex weak coupling constants because of the CP-odd interaction of participating particles. The CP violation appears naturally in united gauge theories with spontaneous symmetry breaking. This mechanism is possible through the complex vacuum expectation value of the Higgs field presented in the Standard Model (SM) (Figure 1). The simplest model of CP breaking through the Higgs field coupling results in a complex phase in the Cabibbo-Kobayashi-Maskawa mass matrix (CKM) [15, 16].

Image not extracted

Figure 1. The Standard Model of elementary particles, taken from Ref. [5].

The interaction of quarks in the SM with charged gauge bosons W±W^{\pm} is described by:

L=−g22uˉiγμ(1−γ5)VijdjWμ±+h.c.L=-\frac{g}{2\sqrt{2}}\bar{u}_{i}\gamma^{\mu}(1-\gamma_{5})V_{ij}d_{j}W_{\mu}^{\pm}+h.c.

where gg is the weak interaction constant, uiu_i and djd_j is the fields of quark states of three generations, W±W^{\pm} is the fields of vector charged bosons, and VijV_{ij} is the quark mixing matrix, that is, the CKM matrix:

V=(c12c13s12c13s13e−iδ−s12c23−c12s23s13eiδc12c23−s12s23s13eiδs23c13s12s23−c12c23s13eiδ−c12s23−s12c23s13eiδc23c13).V=\begin{pmatrix} c_{12}c_{13} & s_{12}c_{13} & s_{13}e^{-i\delta}\\ -s_{12}c_{23}-c_{12}s_{23}s_{13}e^{i\delta} & c_{12}c_{23}-s_{12}s_{23}s_{13}e^{i\delta} & s_{23}c_{13}\\ s_{12}s_{23}-c_{12}c_{23}s_{13}e^{i\delta} & -c_{12}s_{23}-s_{12}c_{23}s_{13}e^{i\delta} & c_{23}c_{13} \end{pmatrix}.

Here cij=cos⁡θijc_{ij}=\cos\theta_{ij}, sij=sin⁡θijs_{ij}=\sin\theta_{ij} and a single phase δ\delta in the interval [0,2π][0,2\pi] [5]. The CKM matrix uses three Euler angles θ12\theta_{12}, θ13\theta_{13}, and θ23\theta_{23} and a CP violating phase δ\delta with values:

θ12=(13.04±0.05)∘,θ23=(2.38±0.06)∘,θ13=(0.201±0.011)∘,δ=(0.201±0.011)∘.\begin{aligned} \theta_{12} &= (13.04 \pm0.05)^\circ,\\ \theta_{23} &= (2.38 \pm0.06)^\circ,\\ \theta_{13} &= (0.201 \pm0.011)^\circ,\\ \delta&= (0.201 \pm0.011)^\circ. \end{aligned}

In the case of two generations of quarks, the mixing matrix is parameterized by a single Cabibbo angle θ12=θc=13.02∘\theta_{12}=\theta_c=13.02^\circ:

V=(cos⁡θcsin⁡θc−sin⁡θccos⁡θc)V=\begin{pmatrix} \cos\theta_c & \sin\theta_c\\ -\sin\theta_c & \cos\theta_c \end{pmatrix}

there is no possible mechanism for CP violation. The presence of a third generation of quarks, for example, the tt quark, would be a necessary condition for violation of the CP parity.

The standard CKM matrix parametrization given above is derived from the original CKM:

V=(VudVusVubVcdVcsVcbVtbVtsVtb)V=\begin{pmatrix} V_{ud} & V_{us} & V_{ub}\\ V_{cd} & V_{cs} & V_{cb}\\ V_{tb} & V_{ts} & V_{tb} \end{pmatrix}

reduced to the four indicated parameters determined from the experiment. The matrix for the generation of NN quarks, or flavors 2N2N, contains N2N^2 complex numbers or 2N22N^2 real parameters. In SM of three-quark generation 3×33 \times3 matrix VV contains 9 complex numbers or 18 real parameters. The unitarity condition:

VV∗=1,VV^{*}=1,

for the N×NN \times N-matrix (where V∗V^{*} is the conjugate transpose of VV) requires N2N^2 real parameters to be specified. Indeed, from

∑kVikVjk∗=δij\sum_k V_{ik}V_{jk}^{*}=\delta_{ij}

for the diagonal components with i=ji=j there are NN restrictions and N(N−1)N(N-1) for i≠ji \ne j, i.e., outside the diagonals (12N(N−1)\frac{1}{2}N(N-1) for Re(VikVjk∗)Re(V_{ik}V_{jk}^{*}) and Im(VikVjk∗)Im(V_{ik}V_{jk}^{*})). So, the number of parameters remaining is N+N(N−1)=N2N+N(N-1)=N^2. From the N2N^2, the remaining parameters 2N−12N-1, are not physically significant, because one phase can be absorbed into each quark field (i.e., the mass and weak eigenstates), but the matrix is independent of a common phase. So, the total number of free parameters, independent of the choice of the phases of base vectors, is

N2−(2N−1)=(N−1)2.N^2-(2N-1)=(N-1)^2.

Of these, 12N(N−1)\frac{1}{2}N(N-1) are rotation angles, i.e., quark mixing angles. The remaining 12(N−1)(N−2)\frac{1}{2}(N-1)(N-2) are the complex phases that cause CP violation. In the SM case (N=3N=3), three mixing Euler angles are indicated above (θ12\theta_{12}, θ13\theta_{13} and θ23\theta_{23}) and one complex phase CP violating δ\delta.

The CKM matrix describes the probability of transition from flavour quark to another one, ∣Vij∣2|V_{ij}|^2, with experimental elements [5]:

(∣Vud∣∣Vus∣∣Vub∣∣Vcd∣∣Vcs∣∣Vcb∣∣Vtb∣∣Vts∣∣Vtb∣)=(0.97435±0.000160.22501±0.000680.003732−0.000085+0.0000900.22187±0.000680.97349±0.000160.04183−0.00069+0.000790.00858−0.00017+0.000190.04111−0.00068+0.000770.999118−0.000034+0.000029).\begin{pmatrix} |V_{ud}| & |V_{us}| & |V_{ub}| \\ |V_{cd}| & |V_{cs}| & |V_{cb}| \\ |V_{tb}| & |V_{ts}| & |V_{tb}| \end{pmatrix} = \begin{pmatrix} 0.97435 \pm0.00016 & 0.22501 \pm0.00068 & 0.003732^{+0.000090}_{-0.000085} \\ 0.22187 \pm0.00068 & 0.97349 \pm0.00016 & 0.04183^{+0.00079}_{-0.00069} \\ 0.00858^{+0.00019}_{-0.00017} & 0.04111^{+0.00077}_{-0.00068} & 0.999118^{+0.000029}_{-0.000034} \end{pmatrix}.

The verification of unitarity of CKM matrix indicates:

∣Vud∣2+∣Vus∣2+∣Vub∣2=0.9985±0.0007|V_{ud}|^2+|V_{us}|^2+|V_{ub}|^2=0.9985 \pm0.0007

in excellent agreement with unitarity.

It is known experimentally that s13≪s23≪s12≪1s_{13} \ll s_{23} \ll s_{12} \ll1, and it is convenient to present this hierarchy using the Wolfenstein parametrization [17]:

λ=s12=∣Vus∣∣Vud∣2+∣Vus∣2,\lambda= s_{12} = \frac{\lvert V_{us}\rvert}{\sqrt{\lvert V_{ud}\rvert^2 + \lvert V_{us}\rvert^2}},
Aλ2=s23=λ∣VcbVus∣.A\lambda^2 = s_{23} = \lambda\left\lvert\frac{V_{cb}}{V_{us}}\right\rvert.
Aλ3(ρ+iη)=s13eiδ=Vub∗.A\lambda^3(\rho+ i\eta) = s_{13}e^{i\delta} = V_{ub}^{*}.

The Wolfenstein parametrization corresponds to an expansion in λ\lambda:

V=(1−12λ2λAλ3(ρ−iη)−λ1−12λ2Aλ2Aλ3(1−ρ−iη)−Aλ21)+O(λ4).V = \begin{pmatrix} 1 - \frac{1}{2}\lambda^2 & \lambda& A\lambda^3(\rho- i\eta) \\ -\lambda& 1 - \frac{1}{2}\lambda^2 & A\lambda^2 \\ A\lambda^3(1 - \rho- i\eta) & -A\lambda^2 & 1 \end{pmatrix} + O(\lambda^4).

This approximation on the order of λ3\lambda^3 has a better than 0.3% accuracy. The CP violation rates correspond to the parameters ρ\rho and η\eta. Wolfenstein parameters are the following [5]:

λ=0.22501±0.00068,\lambda= 0.22501 \pm0.00068,
A=0.826−0.015+0.016,A = 0.826^{+0.016}_{-0.015},
ρˉ=0.1591±0.0094,\bar{\rho} = 0.1591 \pm0.0094,
ηˉ=0.3523−0.0071+0.0073.\bar{\eta} = 0.3523^{+0.0073}_{-0.0071}.

The unitarity constraint on the CKM matrix can be written as ∑kVikVjk\sum_k V_{ik}V_{jk} for i≠ji \ne j is a constraint on three complex numbers, one for each kk, which form the sides of a triangle in the complex plane. There are six choices of ii and jj, three of which are independent, and six unitary triangles. The deviation areas of these triangles from equality determine the degree of CP violation. The most commonly used unitarity triangle arises from

VudVub∗+VcdVcb∗+VtdVtb∗=0.V_{ud}V_{ub}^{*} + V_{cd}V_{cb}^{*} + V_{td}V_{tb}^{*} = 0.

If we assume that real parts of VudV_{ud}, VcbV_{cb}, and Vtb>0V_{tb} > 0 and real part of Vcd<0V_{cd} < 0 (see Wolfenstein matrix for −λ-\lambda). So:

∣Vud∣∣Vub∗∣−∣Vcd∣∣Vcb∣+∣Vtd∣∣Vtb∣=0.\lvert V_{ud}\rvert\lvert V_{ub}^{*}\rvert- \lvert V_{cd}\rvert\lvert V_{cb}\rvert+ \lvert V_{td}\rvert\lvert V_{tb}\rvert= 0.
1−∣VudVubVcdVcb∣−∣VtdVtbVcdVcb∣=0.1 - \left\lvert\frac{V_{ud}V_{ub}}{V_{cd}V_{cb}}\right\rvert- \left\lvert\frac{V_{td}V_{tb}}{V_{cd}V_{cb}}\right\rvert= 0.

We can put this relation in the complex plane and interpret it as a unitarity triangle (see Figure 2). Here,

Image not extracted

Figure 2. The unitarity triangle.

ρˉ=ρ(1−λ2/2+⋯ ),\bar{\rho} = \rho(1-\lambda^2/2+\cdots),
ηˉ=η(1−λ2/2+⋯ ),\bar{\eta} = \eta(1-\lambda^2/2+\cdots),

The angles are

α=arg⁡(−VtdVtb∗VudVub∗)=(84.1−3.8+4.5)∘,\alpha= \arg\left(-\frac{V_{td}V_{tb}^{*}}{V_{ud}V_{ub}^{*}}\right) = \left(84.1^{+4.5}_{-3.8}\right)^\circ,
β=arg⁡(−VcdVcb∗VtdVtb∗)=(22.6−0.1+0.5)∘,\beta= \arg\left(-\frac{V_{cd}V_{cb}^{*}}{V_{td}V_{tb}^{*}}\right) = \left(22.6^{+0.5}_{-0.1}\right)^\circ,
γ=arg⁡(−VudVub∗VcdVcb∗)=(65.7±3.0)∘.\gamma= \arg\left(-\frac{V_{ud}V_{ub}^{*}}{V_{cd}V_{cb}^{*}}\right) = (65.7 \pm3.0)^\circ.

The amplitude of the CP violating asymmetry is proportional to sin⁡2β=0.709±0.011\sin2\beta= 0.709 \pm0.011 [5].

Within the framework of the SM using the CKM matrix, calculations of CP violating effects were carried out in the kaon system, as well as in systems with BB and DD mesons, where these effects are greater and were also discovered experimentally. Violation of the CP symmetry in decays of BB mesons was observed in 2001 in the BaBar experiment at SLAC and in experiments at the KEK facility.

As for the baryon number, there is no experimental evidence of the violation of this number. The violation of such conservation in the SM is possible outside the framework of perturbation theory. Baryon number breaking is possible within the framework of supersymmetry or Grand Unification Theory (GUT).

Discovery of Indirect CP Violation

Figure 3, taken from Ref. [9], presents a general overview of the detector system of the experiment carried out at Brookhaven National Laboratory. Spark chambers were located in each arm of a two-arm spectrometer; these record the trajectories of particles before and after the deflecting magnet. Cherenkov scintillation counters triggered the spark chambers when a coincidence was detected, and the resulting tracks were photographed and recorded on film. The detector system was installed in the beam of the K0K^{0} meson beam line at the Brookhaven synchrotron at a distance such that the K10K^{0}_{1} mesons had already decayed so that only the K20K^{0}_{2} mesons remained in the beam. The angle between the arms was chosen for optimal determination of the kaons that decay into two charged pions. Helium gas filled the volume where this decay occurred to minimize the detection of three-particle decays of K20K^{0}_{2} mesons by rescattering. In this case, the vector sum of the momenta of the two detected particles must be oriented in the direction of the beam of K20K^{0}_{2} mesons, and the missing mass of the decay particle, calculated from the data on the decay products, must coincide with the mass of the K-meson. 56 desired events were recorded with a background of 11 events. From these data it follows that the fraction of the decay of K20K^{0}_{2} into two pions in relation to all decay modes involving charged particles is equal to 2×10−32 \times10^{-3}. This was the first evidence of the violation of parity in the CP system in the kaon system. Almost six months were spent searching for an alternative CP violation, but to no avail. Thus, their conclusion that they obtained indirect CP violation (Figure 3) in the mixing of neutral kaon states (K0↔Kˉ0K^{0} \leftrightarrow\bar{K}^{0}).

Image not extracted

Figure 3. Plan view of the detector arrangement, taken from Ref. [9].

Direct and Indirect CP Violation

CP violation for quarks with a charge of −1/3-1/3 corresponds to the strange ss quark that is a constituent of kaons and the beauty bb quark that is a constituent of BB-mesons. However, CP violation was also predicted for quarks with charge of +2/3+2/3, corresponding to the charm cc-quark that is a constituent of the DD-meson. The weak force appears to act not on a quark state, as identified by the flavor of the quark, but on a quantum mixture of two types of quark for indirect CP violation in contrast to direct CP violation in the pure quark state.

In agreement with the tenants of Wolfenstein superposition, [18] which was first postulated in 1964, any of several superweak interactions are possible. A direct consequence of this manifests itself only in the mixing ΔS=2\Delta S = 2 between K0K^0 and Kˉ0\bar{K}^0 with the absence in ΔS=1\Delta S = 1. A consequence of this assumption could be the possibility of correlations between the decay amplitudes of K0K^0. Let

η+−=A(KL0→π+π−)A(KS0→π+π−),η00=A(KL0→π0π0)A(KS0→π0π0).\eta^{+-} = \frac{A(K_L^0 \to\pi^+\pi^-)}{A(K_S^0 \to\pi^+\pi^-)}, \qquad\eta^{00} = \frac{A(K_L^0 \to\pi^0\pi^0)}{A(K_S^0 \to\pi^0\pi^0)}.

In this case, the decay amplitude of the CP-odd combination K20K_2^0 combination to a 2π2\pi final state might differ from zero, corresponding to a direct violation of CP ϵ\epsilon. However, η+−=η00=ϵ\eta^{+-} = \eta^{00} = \epsilon in the case of indirect CP violation. There are two decay amplitudes, one is the I=0I = 0 and the second is found among the I=2I = 2 states and final states. As the Clebsch-Gordan coefficients projecting, the I=0I = 0 and I=2I = 2 states for the π+π−\pi^+\pi^- and 2π02\pi^0 final states are different, we have:

ϵ′=i1/2 Im(A2A0)ei(δ2−δ0),\epsilon^\prime= i\sqrt{1/2}\, Im\left(\frac{A_2}{A_0}\right)e^{i(\delta_2-\delta_0)},

here A0,2A_{0,2} and δ0,2\delta_{0,2} are the amplitudes and the strong phases of the 2π2\pi final isospin states I=0,2I = 0, 2. Then, there exists direct CP violation, determined by complex parameter ϵ′\epsilon^\prime, which states that there is possible K20→2πK_2^0 \to2\pi in the absence above equality, i.e.:

η+−=ϵ+ϵ′,η00=ϵ−2ϵ′,\eta^{+-} = \epsilon+ \epsilon^\prime, \qquad\eta^{00} = \epsilon- 2\epsilon^\prime,

Modern experimental data, taken from Refs. [5], are the following:

ϵ≡∣ϵ∣=(2.228±0.011)×10−3,\epsilon\equiv|\epsilon| = (2.228 \pm0.011) \times10^{-3},
Re(ϵ)=(1.66±0.02)×10−3,Re(\epsilon) = (1.66 \pm0.02) \times10^{-3},
Im⁡(ϵ)=1.57,\operatorname{Im}(\epsilon)=1.57,
Re⁡(ϵ′)=(2.5±0.4)×10−6,\operatorname{Re}(\epsilon')=(2.5\pm0.4)\times10^{-6},
∣η00∣=(2.220±0.011)×10−3,\lvert\eta^{00}\rvert=(2.220\pm0.011)\times10^{-3},
∣η+−∣=(2.232±0.011)×10−3,\lvert\eta^{+-}\rvert=(2.232\pm0.011)\times10^{-3},
∣η00/η+−∣=0.9950±0.0007,\lvert\eta^{00}/\eta^{+-}\rvert=0.9950\pm0.0007,
ϵ+ϵ′=(2.232±0.011)×10−3,\epsilon+\epsilon'=(2.232\pm0.011)\times10^{-3},
ϵ−2ϵ′=(2.221±0.011)×10−3,\epsilon-2\epsilon'=(2.221\pm0.011)\times10^{-3},
Re⁡(ϵ′/ϵ)=(1.65±0.26)×10−3,\operatorname{Re}(\epsilon'/\epsilon)=(1.65\pm0.26)\times10^{-3},
ϕ+−=(43.51±0.05)∘,\phi_{+-}=(43.51\pm0.05)^\circ,
ϕ00=(43.52±0.05)∘.\phi_{00}=(43.52\pm0.05)^\circ.

These phases are for η+−=∣η+−∣eiϕ+−\eta^{+-}=\lvert\eta^{+-}\rvert e^{i\phi_{+-}} and η00=∣η00∣eiϕ00\eta^{00}=\lvert\eta^{00}\rvert e^{i\phi_{00}}, summing CPT invariance [5]. An estimate of the phases ϕ+−\phi_{+-} and ϕ00\phi_{00} was given by Bell and Steinberger in 1965 [19] indicating their equality to the phase ϕϵ\phi_\epsilon and taking into account the CPT theorem with the above-mentioned ΔmK\Delta m_K and ΓS=1.11×1010 s−1\Gamma_S=1.11\times10^{10}\ \mathrm{s}^{-1} they are equal ϕϵ=43.5∘\phi_\epsilon=43.5^\circ in agreement with the experimental values mentioned above. Experimental confirmation of the approximate equality η+−≈η00\eta_{+-}\approx\eta_{00} was obtained in the 1970s [20, 21, 22].

Re⁡(ϵ′/ϵ)=16(1−∣η00η+−∣2)=16(1−R),\operatorname{Re}\left(\epsilon'/\epsilon\right)=\frac{1}{6}\left(1-\left\lvert\frac{\eta^{00}}{\eta^{+-}}\right\rvert^2\right)=\frac{1}{6}(1-R),

where RR is the so-called double ratio:

R=Γ(KL0→π0π0)Γ(KS0→π0π0)Γ(KL0→π+π−)Γ(KS0→π+π−).R=\frac{\Gamma(K_L^0\to\pi^0\pi^0)}{\Gamma(K_S^0\to\pi^0\pi^0)} \frac{\Gamma(K_L^0\to\pi^+\pi^-)}{\Gamma(K_S^0\to\pi^+\pi^-)}.

After the discovery of indirect CP violation [9], further experiments were carried out to find direct CP violation (see Figure 4). There are two possible manners of violation of the CP: in the first, the long-lived kaon is a mixture of two quantum states, mainly CP-odd with just a small amount of CP-even; in the second, CP violation in decay of K0K^0 when the actual quark reactions underlying the particle transformations. In the decay of the neutral kaon, a strange quark disappears with creation of pions composed of only up- and down-quarks – CP violation via this route is called a direct one.

Image not extracted

Figure 4. The indirect and direct modes of CP violation.

Direct CP violation necessitates that the probabilities of the decays of particles and antiparticles do not coincide; indirect CP violation in the processes of mixing of neutral mesons means that the probabilities of the direct and reverse processes are unequal. Additionally, interference is also possible when mixing the direct and indirect mechanisms of CP violation. While direct CP violation does not depend on the time from meson formation, the other two mechanisms are time-dependent. If the asymmetry changes with time, for example, in the decays B0→2πB^{0} \to2\pi or B0→2KB^{0} \to2K, then the CP violation depends on time.

CERN and Fermilab Experiments

In the NA31 experiment performed at CERN [23, 24], the decay channels of the neutral and charged kaons were simultaneously recorded both near the dipping volume and far from it (KL0K_L^0). This made it possible to avoid the background from the interaction of neutrons in the regenerator and to minimize the difference in the geometries of the decay lengths of which differ by approximately three orders of magnitude. The energies of neutral and charged particles were measured by two calorimeters filled with liquid argon. A detailed description of the detectors in this experiment is given in Refs. [23, 24]. The short and long-lived kaons were born in collisions of protons of the 450 GeV Super Proton Synchrotron (SPS) with two targets, one of which (KL0K_L^0 target) was located at a large distance (about 100 m) from the decay volume, and the other (KS0K_S^0 target) close to it. The trigger for launching the selection process to isolate decays into charged pions was triggered on the basis of data from the scintillation hodoscope located between the second wire chamber and the electromagnetic calorimeter. The trigger for isolating decays into neutral pions was launching by a hodoscope placed in liquid argon. The main problems of this experiment were related to the lack of a spectrometer to measure charged tracks. In this case, about 40% of the decays to 2π2\pi were lost.

A characteristic of another experiment E731 (Fermilab) [25, 26] was the simultaneous use of two almost parallel KL0K_L^0 beams, one of which, before the decay volume, passed through a B4_4C regenerator, where (due to the difference in the scattering of the nuclei K0K^0 and K‾0\overline{K}^0) coherent regeneration of the KL0K_L^0 component occurred. A magnetic spectrometer was used to record the tracks of charged particles. Neutral decays were recorded using an electromagnetic calorimeter containing 804 glass cells. Photomultipliers recorded Cherenkov light from electrons and positrons generated in glass by photons or high-energy electrons. The trigger of charged decays was launched as a result of coincidences of signals in two opposite quadrants of the scintillation hodoscope. Compared with the NA31 experiment, it is clear that in the E731 experiment, the background from KL0→3π0K_L^0 \to3\pi^0 in the neutral decay mode is significantly lower due to the closer location of the decay volume to the detectors. There is also less background in charged mode from a detector with better resolution to measure the momentum of charged particles. At the same time, the result of the E731 experiment strongly depended on the correct accounting of the efficiency of decay detection performed by Monte Carlo simulation. The results of these experiments are the following. NA31 (CERN) Re⁡(ϵ′/ϵ)=(2.30±0.65)×10−3\operatorname{Re}(\epsilon'/\epsilon)=(2.30 \pm0.65) \times10^{-3} and E731 Re⁡(ϵ′/ϵ)=(0.74±0.61)×10−3\operatorname{Re}(\epsilon'/\epsilon)=(0.74 \pm0.61) \times10^{-3}. From a comparison of these experiments it is clear that they do not agree with each other (with a confidence level of less than 10%). Experiment NA31 indicates the possibility of direct CP violation ≈10−3\approx10^{-3}, while the result of experiment E731 is compatible with zero. Therefore, there was no clear conclusion about a direct violation of the CP invariance at that time, and further more accurate measurements were required.

The theoretical calculations obtained for the ϵ′/ϵ\epsilon^{\prime}/\epsilon ratio up to the 1980s ranged from 0.002 to 0.02 [27, 28, 29]. Theoretical consideration of this problem continued in the 1990s with a decrease in the calculated ϵ′/ϵ\epsilon^{\prime}/\epsilon to 10−410^{-4} [30, 31, 32] with an indication of the reduction of the so-called loop “penguin” diagrams [33]. However, these diagrams are highly sensitive to possible contributions from unknown particles and therefore provide excellent probes for new sources of CP violation. The known source of CP violation, which is governed by the CKM matrix in the quark sector, is insufficient to account for the huge excess of matter over antimatter in the Universe; new sources of CP violation are necessary to solve this problem.

The NA48 experiment was significantly improved compared to the previous NA31 experiment with the participation of new institutions in the collaboration. The goal was to improve the precision of ϵ′/ϵ\epsilon^{\prime}/\epsilon to 10−410^{-4}. Significant changes were made to the beam system and the detector. The NA48 experiment at CERN [34] [35] had made separate runs with long- and short-lived kaons, KL0K_L^0 and KS0K_S^0, produced on two different targets by protons from the same CERN SPS beam. The four modes of decay in the KL0K_L^0 and KS0K_S^0 beams reduced the systematic uncertainties in the measurement of decay probabilities by having them occur in the same decay volume simultaneously and almost collinearly. Unlike NA31 the KL0K_L^0 beam was produced by a ten-times more energetic (450 GeV) proton beam impinging on a beryllium target. The protons for the KS0K_S^0 beam were produced by the free protons in the KL0K_L^0 target that collide with a silicon monocrystal. Unlike NA31, a magnetic spectrometer was used for the measurement of charged decays with better accuracy. Although the generation of the decays KL0→2πK_L^0 \to2\pi required an intense initial beam of protons, a much less intense beam of protons was sufficient to create the KS0K_S^0 beam when creating two-pion decays, which is approximately 5 orders of magnitude lower than the intensity of the beam for generating KL0SK_L^0S, which approximately corresponds to the square of the indirect violation parameter ∣η+−∣|\eta^{+-}|.

The simultaneous generation of two kaon beams ensured their equal sensitivity to variations in the intensity of the primary proton beam within 10%. Free protons (those not interacting with the target KL0K_L^0) were directed to a curved silicon crystal below the KL0K_L^0 beam axis. This was a small fraction of protons (≈10−5\approx10^{-5}) due to its collision near the decay volume with the target KS0K_S^0. The two-pion decays of this beam were decays due to the large difference in the lifetimes KL0K_L^0 and KS0K_S^0 and the low probability of such decays for KL0K_L^0. The decay volume was 6 m from the KS0K_S^0 target. Here, the KS0K_S^0 and KL0K_L^0 beams exited from two apertures in the last collimator into the general decay region. To identify decays in the beam KS0K_S^0 a “beam tagging station” consisting of different scintillators was used. The triggers for recording decays K0→2π0K^0 \to2\pi^0 worked based on the analog summation of signals from the group of cells of a liquid krypton calorimeter.

The world average result is the following [36]:

Re(ϵ′/ϵ)=(1.68±0.20)×10−3,Re(\epsilon'/\epsilon) = (1.68 \pm0.20) \times10^{-3},
Γ(K0→π+π−)−Γ(Kˉ0→π+π−)Γ(K0→π+π−)+Γ(Kˉ0→π+π−)=2Re(ϵ′)=(5.3±0.6)×10−6,\frac{\Gamma(K^0 \to\pi^+\pi^-) - \Gamma(\bar{K}^0 \to\pi^+\pi^-)}{\Gamma(K^0 \to\pi^+\pi^-) + \Gamma(\bar{K}^0 \to\pi^+\pi^-)} = 2Re(\epsilon') = (5.3 \pm0.6) \times10^{-6},
Γ(K0→π0π0)−Γ(Kˉ0→π0π0)Γ(K0→π0π0)+Γ(Kˉ0→π0π0)=−4Re(ϵ′)=(−10.6±1.02)×10−6.\frac{\Gamma(K^0 \to\pi^0\pi^0) - \Gamma(\bar{K}^0 \to\pi^0\pi^0)}{\Gamma(K^0 \to\pi^0\pi^0) + \Gamma(\bar{K}^0 \to\pi^0\pi^0)} = -4Re(\epsilon') = (-10.6 \pm1.02) \times10^{-6}.

The recent data [5] are given above in Section VI.

Let us summarize the above. The NA48 experiment at CERN had made separate runs with long- and short-lived kaons. Both runs at CERN used simultaneous beams of long- and short-lived kaons and took data on charged- and neutral-pion production by both kaon beams at the same time. Installed on CERN’s highest intensity proton beamline, it uses a large and sophisticated detector. Some of the CERN protons go to make long-lived kaons, and the remaining particles are diffracted by a crystal and used to make a parallel beam of short-lived kaons. In this way, the two varieties of kaons are clearly differentiated, even though they eventually decay in the same way.

A detailed description of the selection of events in this and previous experiments is given in [36, 37]. These reviews describe the beams, detectors, and analysis methods used in CERN experiments, which made significant contributions to their results and established new standards for precision measurements.

The final measurements of ϵ′/ϵ\epsilon'/\epsilon made by the most precise experiments, KTEV, NA48, NA31, and E731, together with the average value are given in Figure 5, taken from [5]. In contrast to the significant improvements of the NA48 experiment over the previous NA31 experiment at CERN, the KTeV experiment [38, 39] followed the approach of the previous E731 experiment, also at Fermilab. Both beams were formed by collision of 800 MeV protons with a common production target; sweeping magnets removed the charged particles from the beams. A common absorber increased the proportion of neutral kaons relative to neutrons in the beams. A plastic regenerator that promoted the formation of KS0K_{S}^{0} in one of the beams was moved to block the other neutral beam. The beams diverged from each other and were completely separated in the decay volume. The spectrometer, consisting of four drift chambers, including sensitive wires and a large dipole magnet, was filled with helium. The electromagnetic calorimeter consisted of 3100 cells of cesium iodine (CsI) crystals. The trigger system included scintillation hodoscope signals for decays into charged pions and a summation of the energy release in the calorimeter during decays into neutral pions. The analysis of selected events included fitting the experimental data to curves obtained via Monte Carlo simulation of models for these processes.

Image not extracted

Figure 5. The comparison of the results of different experiments, taken from Ref. [5].

Using a subset of data collected in 1996–1997, the collaboration found [40, 41]:

Re(ϵ′/ϵ)=(2.80±0.41)×10−3.Re(\epsilon'/\epsilon) = (2.80 \pm0.41) \times10^{-3}.

The final result of the KTeV experiment is it follows [42]:

Re(ϵ′/ϵ)=(1.92±0.21)×10−3,Re(\epsilon'/\epsilon) = (1.92 \pm0.21) \times10^{-3},

A detailed description of the experiments NA31 and NA48 at CERN and KTeV at Fermilab is given in [36, 37]. The data on ϵ′/ϵ\epsilon^{\prime}/\epsilon obtained in these experiments made it possible to unconditionally establish for the first time the presence of direct CP violation in the decays of neutral kaons. Given the most accurate result of the NA48 experiment (with the first indication of direct CP violation in experiment NA31), the contribution of other experiments is extremely important to a complete picture of the discovered phenomenon. Detailed reviews are devoted to the violation of CP in neutral kaon decays [11] [36, 37, 43, 44, 45, 46].

In addition to obtaining new experimental results, theoretical research on the problem continued. The topics of Lorentz and CPT violation were discussed in Refs. [47–49]. They referenced the possibility of spontaneous CPT breaking that arises in string theory considering the SM extension (SME) taking into account this effect in the neutral meson system [47, 48]. However, Lorenz symmetry breaking, although leading to the CPT violating terms, cannot lead to the CPT violation in experimentally interesting K−KˉK-\bar{K} and analogous systems [49]. At the same time, any indication on CPT violation is absent up to now.

Alternative Research

Beginning in 2001, a large number of CP violating processes in B-meson and D-meson decays have been discovered in B-factory experiments; these include the BaBar experiment at the Stanford Linear Accelerator Center (SLAC) [50], the Belle Experiment at the High Energy Accelerator Research Organization (KEK) [51], and the Large Hadron Collider Beauty Collaboration (LHCb) at CERN [52]. These experiments investigated the time-dependent CP asymmetry in the decays of B0→J/ψK0B^{0} \to J/\psi K^{0}, where J/ψJ/\psi is a particle made of the charm and anti-charm quarks and was simultaneously discovered in 1974 by experimental groups at both SLAC and BNL confirming the existence of the charm quark cc. Such final states provide a means to measure one of the angles (β\beta) of the unitarity triangle (see above) with a negligibly small theoretical uncertainty. The difference between two distributions, i.e., B0B^{0} and Bˉ0\bar{B}^{0}, in Figure 6 and Figure 7 is a clearly visible indication that matter and antimatter are different.

Image not extracted

Figure 6. Measurement of B0→J/ψK0B^0 \to J/\psi K^0 decays from the BaBar Collaboration [53]. The word “tags” used here means that the initial-state tagging procedure was used to count the number of particles and antiparticles. The solid (dashed) curves represent the fit projection in Δt\Delta t for B0B^0 (Bˉ0\bar{B}^0) tags.

Image not extracted

Figure 7. Measurement of B0→J/ψK0B^0 \to J/\psi K^0 decays from Belle Collaboration [54]. The parameter qq has discrete values q=+1q = +1 when the tag-side BB-meson is more likely to be a B0B^0 and q=−1q = -1 when it is more likely to be a Bˉ0\bar{B}^0. So, they found 560 events with q=+1q = +1 flavor tags and 577 events with q=−1q = -1, observed Δt\Delta t distributions for B0B^0 (open circles) and Bˉ0\bar{B}^0 (filled circles).

BaBar Collaboration obtained [50, 53, 55, 56], respectively:

sin⁡2β=0.34±0.20(stat)±0.05(syst),\sin2\beta= 0.34 \pm0.20(\mathit{stat}) \pm0.05(\mathit{syst}),
sin⁡2β=0.59±0.14(stat)±0.05(syst),\sin2\beta= 0.59 \pm0.14(\mathit{stat}) \pm0.05(\mathit{syst}),
sin⁡2β=0.741±0.067(stat)±0.034(syst),\sin2\beta= 0.741 \pm0.067(\mathit{stat}) \pm0.034(\mathit{syst}) ,
sin⁡2β=0.722±0.040(stat)±0.023(syst).\sin2\beta= 0.722 \pm0.040(\mathit{stat}) \pm0.023(\mathit{syst}) .

The study of decay B0→J/ψKB^0 \to J/\psi K is not the only possibility to obtain the angle β\beta with a small theoretical uncertainty. There are many BB meson decays with other final states that were also investigated by the Belle and BaBar Collaborations [57, 58]. In the SM, other modes, such as B0→J/ψϕB^{0} \to J/\psi\phi, measure the same angle, β\beta, with comparable theoretical precision. The ϕ\phi meson is a vector meson formed of a ss- and sˉ\bar{s}-quarks. The existence of the ϕ\phi meson was first proposed by Sakurai in 1962 as a resonance state between the K0K^{0} and Kˉ0\bar{K}^{0} [59]. It was discovered later by Connolly et al. at the Alternating Gradient Synchrotron (AGS) at BNL [60].

The consideration via a loop transition, i.e., penguin diagrams, is very sensitive to possible contributions from unknown particles, provided there are probes for new sources of CP violation [61]. The measurement of CP violation in pinging modes is experimentally very desirable, due to the extremely low rates of the final states of interest and the difficulty in separating these from various sources of background. The favorable conditions of the BB factories (e.g. high luminosity etc.) make them ideal laboratories in which to perform these measurements. The data obtained show that the angle β\beta in the penguin diagram differs by 2.7σ2.7\sigma compared to the measurement of the same angle in the SM. However, testing if the modern data agree with the SM prediction, the research for penguin-dominated modes continues. The b→sqˉqb \to s\bar{q}q (where q=b,s,dq = b, s, d) penguin decays have the same CKM phase as the decays at tree level b→scˉcb \to s\bar{c}c suppressed by λ2\lambda^{2}. Therefore, decays such as B0→ϕK0B^{0} \to\phi K^{0} provide sin⁡2β\sin2\beta measurements in the SM. The main interest in these modes is not simply to measure sin⁡2β\sin2\beta, but to search for new physics beyond SM (BSM). The mass of these particles that appear virtually is expected to exceed hundreds of GeV, and either their decay or creation by the method of lost energy is sought.

The registration of CP violation in charm decays was also performed by the LHCb Collaboration. There are many other experiments sensitive to the BSM supposition, including a BsB_s system with a small angle.

βs=arg⁡(−VtsVtb∗VcsVcb∗).\beta_s = \arg\left(-\frac{V_{ts}V_{tb}^{*}}{V_{cs}V_{cb}^{*}}\right).

This angle can be measured via time-dependent CP violation in Bs0→J/ψϕB_s^{0} \to J/\psi\phi analogically to β\beta in B0→J/ψK0B^{0} \to J/\psi K^{0}. Since the J/ψϕJ/\psi\phi final state is not a CP eigenstate, an angular analysis of the decay products was performed to separate the CP-even and CP-odd components, which gave opposite asymmetries. The comparison of the LHCb results, including Bs→J/ψK+K−B_s \to J/\psi K^{+}K^{-} and Bs→J/ψπ+π−B_s \to J/\psi\pi^{+}\pi^{-}, for

2βs=0.039±0.022(stat)±0.006(syst)2\beta_s = 0.039 \pm0.022(stat) \pm0.006(syst)

and the current world average,

2βs=0.040±0.0162\beta_s = 0.040 \pm0.016

with the SM prediction

2βs=0.03726−0.00077+0.000782\beta_s = 0.03726^{+0.00078}_{-0.00077}

indicates an excellent agreement. LHCb also measured [62]:

sin⁡2β=0.717±0.013(stat)±0.008(syst).\sin2\beta= 0.717 \pm0.013(\mathit{stat}) \pm0.008(\mathit{syst}) .

References [63, 64] indicate that CP parity violation is evident in the ratio of measured yields for the decays of the B+B^+ and B−B^- mesons, which are a particle and antiparticle pair. The decay of the B−B^- meson through the 3π3\pi channel is more intense than that of the B+B^+ meson. During these decays, large amounts of energy are released owing to the heavy mass of the B mesons in comparison to the relatively light pions; the decay energy is carried away predominantly by the kinetic energy of the pions. These decays play an important role in the production of intermediate resonances that decay into pion pairs with a lifetime of the order of 10−2410^{-24} sec. Concurrently, the VubV_{ub} element of the CKM matrix responsible for direct b→ub \to u transitions is very small, so the contribution from the corresponding tree amplitudes is comparable to the contribution of loop diagrams (such as the penguin diagram). Tree and loop diagrams interfere (amplifying or compensating each other), depending on the imaginary part of the CKM matrix, which has a different sign for particles and antiparticles.

The effect of direct CP violation can manifest itself more strongly if one observes not just the integral number of decays but the difference at a number of discreet points of the phase volume. Dalitz diagrams have been constructed for the two-dimensional distribution of m2(π+π−)m^2(\pi^+\pi^-) pairs of daughter particles, on which resonance bands are visible. It can be seen that the nature of the intermediate states is different for the B+B^+ and B−B^- mesons and in some areas of these diagrams the CP asymmetry, that is, the ratio of the difference in the yields B+B^+ and B−B^- to their sum, reaches 80% with the prevalence of the yield of B−B^- mesons.

The issue of counting the number of particles and antiparticles is solved by the initial state tagging procedure. To register CP violation when mixing neutral mesons, it is necessary to establish the flavor of the particle that was born initially; i.e. was it a particle or an antiparticle? The period of quark-antiquark oscillations is small (≈\approx nsec) compared to the lifetime of a meson.

CP violation was also predicted for DD mesons, which includes a representative of the second type of quark with a charge of +2/3+2/3, i.e., a charmed cc-quark [65]. The latest publication of the LHCb Collaboration reports that it was possible for the first time to establish accurately the CP violation for DD mesons. The asymmetry AA of the decay of the DD meson in relation to Dˉ\bar{D} was studied in two different channels, in π+π−\pi^{+}\pi^{-} and K+K−K^{+}K^{-}. The difference between these depends on the unequal determination of the decay products of the two channels; the difference in asymmetries in these decay channels reduces the detection effect, leaving only CP violation. The result was symmetry violation [66]:

ΔACP=ACP(D0→K−K+)−ACP(D0→π−π+)\Delta A_{CP}=A_{CP}(D^{0}\rightarrow K^{-}K^{+})-A_{CP}(D^{0}\rightarrow\pi^{-}\pi^{+})

is

ΔACP=(−18.2±3.2(stat)±0.9(syst))×10−4\Delta A_{CP}=(-18.2\pm3.2(stat)\pm0.9(syst))\times10^{-4}

for π\pi tagged D0D^{0} meson in the reaction D∗(2010)+→D0π+D^{*}(2010)^{+}\rightarrow D^{0}\pi^{+}.

ΔACP=(−9±8(stat)±5(syst))×10−4,\Delta A_{CP}=(-9\pm8(stat)\pm5(syst))\times10^{-4},

for μ\mu tagged D0D^{0} meson in the reaction Bˉ→D0μ−νˉμX\bar{B}\rightarrow D^{0}\mu^{-}\bar{\nu}_{\mu}X.

Combining these with previous LHCb results leaded to

ΔACP=(−15.4±2.9)×10−4.\Delta A_{CP}=(-15.4\pm2.9)\times10^{-4}.

Where the uncertainty includes both statistical and systematic contributions. It differs from zero by more than 5σ5\sigma.

A long-term study of the rare decay of the BB meson into a lepton pair has established a violation of lepton invariance favoring its decay into an electron-positron pair rather than decay into a μ+μ−\mu^{+}\mu^{-} pair. This is not consistent with universality within the SM framework; the experimental ratio of the decay probabilities is Rk=(B0→μ+μ−)/(B0→e+e−)=0.846±0.044R_{k}=(B^{0}\rightarrow\mu^{+}\mu^{-})/(B^{0}\rightarrow e^{+}e^{-})=0.846\pm0.044 (LHCb) compared to the expectation of unity. At the same time, the values of the decay rate of B0B^{0} in a pair of muons Bs→μ+μ−B_{s}\rightarrow\mu^{+}\mu^{-} were calculated within the SM framework:

Bth(Bs)=(3.56±0.30)×10−9,B_{th}(B_{s})=(3.56\pm0.30)\times10^{-9},
Bth(B)=(0.10±0.01)×10−9.B_{th}(B)=(0.10\pm0.01)\times10^{-9}.

The experimental value obtained by the LHCb collaboration from Ref. [67] is equal to

B(Bs0)=(3.09−0.13−0.11+0.46+0.15)×10−9.B(B_{s}^{0})=(3.09^{+0.46+0.15}_{-0.13-0.11})\times10^{-9}.

No significant signal for B0→μ+μ−B^0 \to\mu^+\mu^- decay was found with an upper limit of B(B0)<0.26×10−9B(B^0) < 0.26 \times10^{-9}. The world average [5]:

Bexp⁡(Bs)→(3.01±0.35)×10−9B_{\operatorname{exp}}(B_s) \to(3.01 \pm0.35) \times10^{-9}

is consistent with the SM, with the current uncertainties.

The rare decay (KS→μ+μ−)(K_S \to\mu^+\mu^-) was investigated in Ref. [68] as a sensitive probe of the short-distance region. SM predictions for the short-distance contribution improved by a few percent. As the CP violating effect is small, ≈10−3\approx10^{-3} any other corrections should be taken into account to assure accurate extraction ϵ\epsilon and ϵ′\epsilon' from the experimental data.

Reference [69] considered the CP violating asymmetry in the energy of the charged pions in the decay KL0→π+π−π0K_L^0 \to\pi^+\pi^-\pi^0 in terms of two parameters that were determined by studying the corresponding time-dependent asymmetry in the decay of the neutral kaons with fixed initial strangeness. The measure of the conserving CP asymmetry provides a test of Chiral Perturbation Theory (χ\chiPT) and gives information on the final-state interaction of the three pions.

Fleischer provided a review [70] on CP violation in B decays with respect to recent development and future perspectives. He indicated that these processes provide a powerful tool to probe new physics beyond the Standard Model (BSM). The review of recent data on the decays of BB is also given by Malami in [71].

Higher-order electroweak contributions to indirect CP violation in neutral kaons were calculated in [72]. The authors wrote that the theoretical calculation of ϵK\epsilon_K had historically large perturbative errors arising from charm-quark corrections. These errors were larger than expected higher-order electroweak corrections. Recently, a simple reparameterization of the effective Hamiltonian reduced perturbation errors, making higher-order electroweak calculations justified. They presented the leading logarithmic electroweak contribution of O(1%) to ϵK\epsilon_K.

Starting in 2012 the KOTO Collaboration using the J-PARC 30 GeV Main Ring at KEK, investigated rare decay KL→π0ννˉK_L \to\pi^0\nu\bar{\nu} due to direct CP violation [73]. They obtained the upper limit of

BR(KL→π0ννˉ)<5.1×10−8 (90% C.L.)BR(K_L \to\pi^0\nu\bar{\nu}) < 5.1 \times10^{-8}\ (90\% \ \mathrm{C.L.})

This mode directly breaks CP symmetry and is highly suppressed in the SM. Moreover, the theoretical uncertainty of this decay is only a few percent; these features make this decay one of the best probes to search for BSM physics. They concluded that the number of observed events is statistically consistent with the background expectation. The agreement of theory in the SM framework with this experimental result could be an indication that BSM physics is unnecessary here.

An analogous search was undertaken by the NA62 Collaboration at CERN to perform the first search for the rare K+→π+ννˉK^{+} \to\pi^{+}\nu\bar{\nu} decay channel [74]. They obtained an upper limit of

BRexp(K+→π+ννˉ)<14×10−10 (95% C.L.).BR_{exp}(K^{+} \to\pi^{+}\nu\bar{\nu}) < 14 \times10^{-10}\ (95\% \ \mathrm{C.L.}).

This value agrees, within uncertainties, with the prediction of the SM:

BRtheor(K+→π+ννˉ)<10×10−10 (95% C.L.),BR_{theor}(K^{+} \to\pi^{+}\nu\bar{\nu}) < 10 \times10^{-10}\ (95\% \ \mathrm{C.L.}),

ruling out any need to resort to BSM theories. The kaons were created by a 450 GeV proton beam from the CERN SPS that impinged on a beryllium production target. A 270-meter-long detector, using a combination of triggers, made it possible to select kaon decays needed to calculate the background and search for the desired decay channel. The current theoretical and experimental conditions allowed for the first detection of the “golden modes” of this ultra-rare K decay channel with a statistical uncertainty of 3.5σ3.5\sigma. The current theoretical and experimental conditions concerning the ’golden modes’ of K→πννˉK \to\pi\nu\bar{\nu}, are taken from [5] and are summarized in Figure 8.

Image not extracted

Figure 8. Summary of current situation for the “golden modes” K→πννˉK \to\pi\nu\bar{\nu}, taken from [5]. The red ellipse shows the prediction 1σ1\sigma of SM with input from the CKM fitter [75]; the green (yellow) region corresponds to the NA62 (BNL787/949) 1σ1\sigma measurement; and the dashed orange line marks the upper bound 90% C.L. KOTO [76]. The black shaded region shows the Grossman and Nir [77] exclusion.

The world’s leading program for the decay of K mesons is HIKE [78]. The program investigates several ultra-rare “golden” kaon decays, which are very clean from the theory of SM. The measurement of BR(K+→π+ννˉ)BR(K^{+} \to\pi^{+}\nu\bar{\nu}) with 5% precision (corresponding to the accuracy of the SM calculations) refers to the phase 1 of the program, while the phase 2 corresponds to the first observation of decays of K+→π0l+l−K^{+} \to\pi^{0}l^{+}l^{-} with a precision exceeding 5%. Being essentially free of hadronic uncertainties, they allow for precise tests of the SM. Their suppression in the SM leads to sensitivity to new BSM physics. HIKE will use high-intensity K+K^{+} and KLK_{L} beams and collect the world’s largest decay samples K+K^{+} and KLK_{L}, using triggers and detectors that are better than NA62 and other previous experiments. As a result, HIKE will significantly improve the previous of measurements. In addition to the rare gold modes, HIKE and KOTO-II will measure many other K+K^{+} and KLK_{L} decays, including radiative ones.with high precision.

The CP violating processes observed so far fit well into the framework of the SM. However, surprises cannot be ruled out when studying such processes with the need to search for alternative sources of CP violation with access to new physics. This problem is discussed in [77]. A measurement of time-dependent CP violation in the decays of the B0B^0 and Bˉ0\bar{B}^0 mesons to the final states J/ψ(→μ+μ−)KS0J/\psi(\to\mu^+\mu^-)K_S^0, ψ(2S)(→μ+μ−)KS0\psi(2S)(\to\mu^+\mu^-)K_S^0, and J/ψ(→e+e−)KS0J/\psi(\to e^+e^-)K_S^0 with KS0→π+π−K_S^0 \to\pi^+\pi^- (the J/ψJ/\psi meson was discovered in 1974 by two groups of experimentalists at SLAC and BNL, confirming the existence of charm quark cc) was considered in Ref. [62]. In agreement with their statement, the CP violation parameters obtained represent the most prestigious single measurement of the CKM angle β\beta to date and were more precise than the current global average.

The existing experiments indicate that the CP violation is too weak compared to what is required to explain the matter-antimatter asymmetry. The magnitude of the CP violation effect will be proportional to the function of all three mixing angles and the δ\delta known as the Jarlskog invariant [5]:

JCPCKM=c12c132c23s12s13s23sin⁡δ=(3.12−0.12+0.13)×10−5.J_{CP}^{CKM}=c_{12}c_{13}^{2}c_{23}s_{12}s_{13}s_{23}\sin\delta=(3.12^{+0.13}_{-0.12})\times10^{-5}.

The quark sector cannot explain the baryon asymmetry of the Universe while the mixing angles are small. An analysis of this asymmetry, ΔACP\Delta A_{\mathrm{CP}}, taking into account the direct CP violations discovered in D0→K−K+D^{0} \to K^{-}K^{+} and D0→π−π+D^{0} \to\pi^{-}\pi^{+} decays [79] and searching for CP violation in the radiative charm decays of the D0D^{0} meson, is given in [80]. The recent results are reported at “the 2024 International Workshop on Future Tau Charm Facilities,” Shanghai, China, 14-18 January 2024, https://indico.pnp.ustc.edu.cn/event/91/ and at “22nd Conference on Flavor Physics and CP Violation,” Bangkok, Thailand, 27-31 May 2024, https://indico.cern.ch/event/1291023/.

An open question remains to understand the participation of heavy quarks during CP violation in the weak interaction, whereas spatial parity violation (PP-violation) is characteristic of all weak interaction processes. In contrast to PP parity violation in weak interaction, CP parity violation does not exceed a fraction of a percent. Finally, further explaining the CP violation BSM, that is, within the framework of new physics, is an important task in studies of this problem [81–83]. One of the fundamental problems of modern physics is the explanation of the source of CP violation in the weak interaction. The first evidence for direct CP violation in beauty to charmonium decays was given in Ref. [84].

Acknowledgments

One of us, N.P., thanks Dr. Wilhelm Czaplinski for collaboration. I.S. thanks Dr. Valery Kubarovsky for useful comments. This work was supported in part by the U. S. Department of Energy, Office of Science, Office of Nuclear Physics, under Award No. DE–SC0016583.

References

References

  1. [5]S. Navas et al. [Particle Data Group], “Review of Particle Physics,” Phys. Rev. D 110, 030001 (2024).
  2. [6]A. Pais and O. Piccioni, “Note on the decay and absorption of the Theta0,” Phys. Rev. 100, 1487 (1955).DOI
  3. [7]L. B. Leipuner, W. Chinowsky, R. Crittenden, R. Adair, B. Musgrave, and F. T. Shively, “Anomalous regeneration of K-10 mesons from K-20 mesons,” Phys. Rev. 132, 2285 (1963).
  4. [8]E. Wigner, “Grupp[r]ntheorie und ihre Anwendungen auf die Quantenmechanik der Atomspektren,” (Friedr Vieweg und Sohn, Braunschweig, 1931); Nachr. Gesell. Der Wissen, Math.-Phys. Klasse 5, 546 (1932).
  5. [9]J. H. Christenson, J. W. Cronin, V. L. Fitch, and R. Turlay, “Evidence for the 2π decay of the K₂⁰ meson,” Phys. Rev. Lett. 13, 138 (1964).
  6. [10]A. D. Sakharov, “Violation of CP Invariance, C asymmetry, and baryon asymmetry of the universe,” Pisma Zh. Eksp. Teor. Fiz. 5 (1967), 32 (1967) [JETP Lett. 5, 24 (1967); Usp. Fiz. Nauk 161, 61 (1991) [Sov. Phys. Usp. 34, 392 (1991)].
  7. [11]N. Popov and I. Strakovsky, “Neutrino Mass: Past, Present, and Future,” (NOVA Science Publishers, 2021).DOI
  8. [12]S. W. Herb et al. [E288 Collaboration], “Observation of a dimuon resonance at 9.5-GeV in 400-GeV proton-nucleus collisions,” Phys. Rev. Lett. 39, 252 (1977).DOI
  9. [13]S. Abachi et al. [D0 Collaboration], “Observation of the top quark,” Phys. Rev. Lett. 74, 2632 (1995).DOI
  10. [14]F. Abe et al. [CDF Collaboration], “Observation of top quark production in pp collisions,” Phys. Rev. Lett. 74, 2626 (1995).
  11. [15]N. Cabibbo, “Unitary symmetry and leptonic decays,” Phys. Rev. Lett. 10, 531 (1963).
  12. [16]M. Kobayashi and T. Maskawa, “CP violation in the renormalizable theory of weak interaction,” Prog. Theor. Phys. 49, 652 (1973).
  13. [17]L. Wolfenstein, “Parametrization of the Kobayashi-Maskawa Matrix,” Phys. Rev. Lett. 51, 1945 (1983).DOI
  14. [18]L. Wolfenstein, “Violation of CP invariance and the possibility of very weak interactions,” Phys. Rev. Lett. 13, 562 (1964).
  15. [19]J. S. Bell and J. Steinberger, “Weak interactions of kaons,” in Proceedings of Oxford Int. Conf. on Elementary Particles, September 1965, Eds. T. R. Walsh, A. E. Taylor, R. G. Moorhouse and B. Southworth (Ruserford High Energy Lab., Chilton, Didicot, 1966) pg. 195.
  16. [20]M. Holder et al. “On the decay K_L → π⁰π⁰,” PhysLett. B 40, 141 (1972).
  17. [21]M. Banner, J. W. Cronin, C. M. Hoffman, B. C. Knapp, and M. J. Shochet, “Measurement of η⁰⁰/η⁺⁻,” Phys. Rev. Lett. 28, 1597 (1972).DOI
  18. [22]J. H. Christenson, J. H. Goldman, E. Hummel, S. D. Roth, T. W. L. Sanford, and J. Sculli, “Measurement of the phase and magnitude of η⁰⁰,” Phys. Rev. Lett. 43, 1209 (1979).DOI
  19. [23]H. Burkhardt et al. [NA31 Collaboration], “First evidence for direct CP violation,” Phys. Lett. B 206, 169 (1988).
  20. [24]G. D. Barr et al. [NA31 Collaboration], “A New measurement of direct CP violation in the neutral kaon system,” Phys. Lett. B 317, 233 (1993)DOI
  21. [25]L. K. Gibbons et al. [E731 Collaboration], “Measurement of the CP violation parameter Re(ε′/ε),” Phys. Rev. Lett. 70, 1203 (1993).pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/10054317
  22. [26]L. K. Gibbons et al. [E731 Collaboration], “CP and CPT symmetry test from the two pion decays of the neutral kaon with the Fermilab E731 detector,” Phys. Rev. D 55, 6625 (1997).
  23. [27]J. R. Ellis, M. K. Gaillard, and D. V. Nanopoulos, “Lefthanded Currents and CP Violation,” Nucl. Phys. B 109, 213 (1976).
  24. [28]F. J. Gilman and M. B. Wise, “The ΔI = 1/2 rule and violation of CP in the six quark model,” Phys. Lett. B 83, 83 (1979).
  25. [29]B. Guberina and R. D. Peccei, “Quantum Chromodynamic effects and CP violation in the Kobayashi-Maskawa Model,” Nucl. Phys. B 163, 289 (1980).
  26. [30]G. Buchalla, A. J. Buras, and M. K. Harlander, “The anatomy of ε′/ε in the Standard Model,” Nucl. Phys. B 337, 313 (1990).
  27. [31]M. Ciuchini, E. Franco, G. Martinelli, L. Reina, and L. Silvestrini, “An Upgraded analysis of ε′/ε at the next-to-leading order,” Z. Phys. C 68, 239 (1995).DOI
  28. [32]A. J. Buras, M. Jamin, and M. E. Lautenbacher, “A 1996 analysis of the CP violating ratio ε′/ε,” Phys. Lett. B 389, 749 (1996).DOI
  29. [33]J. M. Flynn and L. Randall, “The electromagnetic penguin contribution to ε′/ε for large top quark mass,” Phys. Lett. B 224, 221 (1989) [erratum: Phys. Lett. B 235412 (1990)].DOI
  30. [34]J. R. Batley et al. [NA48 Collaboration], “A precision measurement of direct CP violation in the decay of neutral kaons into two pions,” Phys. Lett. B 544, 97 (2002), and references therein.

Paper details

vlnc:W_p447hk22
Version
v1 · latest
Published
Fresh — added to the Hub within the last 30 days
Added
License
CC BY 4.0
Usage

views · 0

downloads · 0

A view counts once per browser per day, a download each time the PDF is requested.

  • Physics and Astronomy

Not recorded for this paper

View statement
Looking for related papers…
Contents