betaFeedback

WorksMathematics

Direct and Indirect Competition in a Two-Prey-One-Predator System : Global Dynamics, Chaos, and the Paine Conjecture

Abstract

This paper studies the global dynamics of a three-dimensional Lotka-Volterra system of two prey, with direct competition between them, and one predator. Under a symmetry assumption, the rescaled parameter space is sorted into four generic categories, which yield a complete classification of the global dynamics into 56 meaningful subcases. We determine the existence and stability of the boundary and positive equilibria, including global asymptotic stability and bistability of boundary equilibria, and necessary and sufficient conditions for local asymptotic stability of the positive equilibrium. We identify regimes of periodic solutions and chaos, including a period-doubling route to chaos. We further show that the parameters of Gilpin's chaotic dynamics fall within some cases. Biologically, we introduce the notion of extensive negative competition, which, together with trade-off competition and apparent competition, interprets the interactions among the three species. Our classification shows that the full system largely tracks the dynamics of the prey-only subsystem, and these competition mechanisms explain the differences between them, clarifying how predator-mediated interactions alter competitive outcomes and facilitate prey persistence, thereby providing mathematical support for Paine conjecture.

Introduction

In this work, motivated by [6, 5, 10], we consider the following two-prey-one-predator models with direct competition between the prey in the Lotka-Volterra functional response,

dU1ds=rˉ1U1(1−U1K1)−aˉ12U1U2−aˉ13U1V,dU2ds=rˉ2U2(1−U2K2)−aˉ21U1U2−aˉ23U2V,dVds=V(aˉ31U1+aˉ32U2−D).(1)\begin{aligned} \frac{dU_1}{ds} &= \bar{r}_1 U_1\left(1-\frac{U_1}{K_1}\right)-\bar{a}_{12}U_1U_2-\bar{a}_{13}U_1V,\\ \frac{dU_2}{ds} &= \bar{r}_2 U_2\left(1-\frac{U_2}{K_2}\right)-\bar{a}_{21}U_1U_2-\bar{a}_{23}U_2V,\\ \frac{dV}{ds} &= V\left(\bar{a}_{31}U_1+\bar{a}_{32}U_2-D\right). \tag*{(1)} \end{aligned}

Here, all parameters are positive, and two prey obey the logistic growth rule with intrinsic birth rates rˉi\bar{r}_i and environmental capacities KiK_i for i=1,2i=1,2. The coefficients aˉi3\bar{a}_{i3} and aˉ3i\bar{a}_{3i} are the rate of consumption of UiU_i and measure the contribution of the basal resource UiU_i to the growth of consumer VV, respectively. The direct competition between U1U_1, U2U_2 are aˉ12\bar{a}_{12}, aˉ21\bar{a}_{21}, and the mortality of VV is presented by DD.

With the rescaling,

u1=U1/K1,u2=U2/K2,v=V/D,u_1 = U_1/K_1,\qquad u_2 = U_2/K_2,\qquad v = V/D,
t=Ds,r1=rˉ1D,r2=rˉ2D,t = Ds,\qquad r_1 = \frac{\bar r_1}{D},\qquad r_2 = \frac{\bar r_2}{D},
a12=aˉ12K2D,a31=aˉ31K1D,a13=aˉ13,a_{12} = \frac{\bar a_{12}K_2}{D},\qquad a_{31} = \frac{\bar a_{31}K_1}{D},\qquad a_{13} = \bar a_{13},
a21=aˉ21K1D,a32=aˉ32K2D,a23=aˉ23,a_{21} = \frac{\bar a_{21}K_1}{D},\qquad a_{32} = \frac{\bar a_{32}K_2}{D},\qquad a_{23} = \bar a_{23},

we have a simpler model with 8 parameters,

{u˙1=r1u1(1−u1)−a12u1u2−a13u1v,u˙2=r2u2(1−u2)−a21u1u2−a23u2v,v˙=v(a31u1+a32u2−1),(2)\begin{cases} \dot{u}_1 = r_1u_1(1-u_1)-a_{12}u_1u_2-a_{13}u_1v,\\ \dot{u}_2 = r_2u_2(1-u_2)-a_{21}u_1u_2-a_{23}u_2v,\\ \dot{v} = v(a_{31}u_1+a_{32}u_2-1), \tag*{(2)} \end{cases}

where  ˙\dot{\ } means ddt\frac{d}{dt}.

In the past decades, extensive research has examined the dynamics of the Lotka-Volterra-type predator-prey equation, which serves as a prototype for more complex functional responses. Moreover, three-species models serve as a crucial bridge between simple two-species interactions and the highly complex ecological communities found in the real world. It is well known that predation and competition, interactions between species, are the primary drivers of population regulation and evolutionary pressure [22, 14]. Hence, it is interesting and important to investigate the global dynamics of system (1.2).

Some early works should be mentioned [11, 12, 13, 1, 4, 5, 10, 16]. The Paine conjecture (often called the keystone species hypothesis) [12] suggests that an ecosystem’s species diversity is directly related to its top predators. It has been suggested [11, 12] that, in some communities, although a particular trophic level would, in isolation, be unstable due to competition, predation from other levels can lead to a stable system. You can see that the system (1.2) is the simplest case with multiple prey for verifying the Paine conjecture. However, system (1.2) without direct competition between prey, that is a12=a21=0a_{12}=a_{21}=0, it was shown that [16] u1u_1-u2u_2-vv can coexist if the apparent competition between u1u_1 and u2u_2 is not extreme. That is, for each prey uiu_i, the ratio of the birth rate rir_i to the consumption rate by vv is almost the same. Moreover, the positive equilibrium is globally asymptotically stable if it exists [16]. Therefore, this top-down regulation is dependent not only on predation but also heavily on competition among prey.

Numerical simulations [13, 1] of the two-prey-one-predator models (1.2), using some parameter values, illustrated and supported the Paine conjecture. In addition, periodic solutions or complex dynamics of (1.2) were also found in [4, 5]. Mathematically, Hsu [10] gave a theoretical analysis of the two-prey-one-predator models by assuming that the predator VV can survive in the u1u_1-vv and u2u_2-vv subcommunities. However, the parameters of numerical simulations of (1.2) exhibit interesting and complex dynamics [13, 1, 4, 5] that fall outside the range of Hsu’s results. So it is important to know what dynamics the system (1.2) will exhibit if Hsu’s assumptions do not hold.

Biologically, the model (1.2) can be regarded as a unified framework that includes both the resource competition mechanism like the classical R∗R^* rule and the predator-induced interaction mechanism associated with the P∗P^* rule [7], as well as the predator-mediated apparent competition [10]. However, we refer to the direct competition between prey species as negative competition rather than resource competition. Resource competition, the interaction between two consumers competing for a limiting resource, induces competitive exclusion, and only one winner emerges. However, there could be a win-win outcome in the negative competition for prey for (1.2). Moreover, the P∗P^* rule describes predator-mediated competition, assuming each prey species has a Pi∗P_i^*, the predator level at which the prey can just survive. A smaller Pi∗P_i^* usually indicates a greater tolerance for predators and an advantage in apparent competition. Parameters a13a_{13} and a23a_{23} in (1.2) represent this competition mechanism.

Building on the above distinction between negative competition and apparent competition, we further introduce the concept of extensive negative competition. Classical negative competition captures only the direct, pairwise suppression that one prey exerts on the other through the competition coefficients a12a_{12} and a21a_{21}. In the three-species system (1.2), however, the effective pressure felt by a focal prey species is jointly shaped by the other prey and by the shared predator: consumption by the predator directly reduces the focal prey, while the other prey species both competes for the same growth potential and channels a common predation pressure onto the focal species. Extensive negative competition therefore extends the pairwise notion of negative competition to the combined effect of the other prey and the predator on a focal prey species, which is measured through the joint combinations of the parameters (ri,ai3,aij)(r_i, a_{i3}, a_{ij}), i,j=1,2i, j = 1, 2. This unified viewpoint allows the direct (prey-prey) and the indirect (prey-predator) pathways of suppression to be described within a single framework, and it is this concept, together with trade-off competition and apparent competition, that we use to interpret the parameter-dependent transitions of the system and the differences between the full system and its prey-only subsystem. We will see that the interaction of these three competitive mechanisms produces a wide variety of dynamic behaviors, including competitive exclusion, coexistence, bistable states, periodic oscillations, and complex dynamics. Alternatively, other three-species models have long been of considerable importance. In [17], Hsu et al. discussed the intraguild predation model, including a specialist predator, an omnivorous predator, and a prey. The parameter space is divided into four categories, and the global dynamics in each case are analyzed in detail. Various results are obtained and proved, including species extinction, global stability, bistability, and periodic solutions. It is also fully discussed that, within a certain parameter range, the system can generate periodic solutions via Hopf bifurcation and enter a chaotic state via period-doubling bifurcation. The research methods, calculation methods, and key theories in this paper primarily follow the comprehensive research model established in [17].

Our investigations, while retaining all direct and indirect competition parameters from (1.1), conduct a comprehensive study of the dynamic changes arising from fluctuations in these parameters. However, we do not analyze a single parameter, as interactions among species in an ecosystem are unlikely to be influenced by a single factor. Our investigation found that establishing the following parameter relationships better reveals the complex dynamic changes. We use the relationship between r1a23r_{1}a_{23} and r2a13r_{2}a_{13} to represent the apparent competition, use the relationships between (r1a23r_{1}a_{23} and a12a13a_{12}a_{13}) and (a21a13a_{21}a_{13} and r2a13r_{2}a_{13}) to represent the negative competition, use the relationships between (r1a23r_{1}a_{23} and a21a13a_{21}a_{13}) and (a12a13a_{12}a_{13} and r2a13r_{2}a_{13}) to represent the trade-off competition, and use the inequality (6.3) to represent the extensive negative competition between prey. However, given the extensive existing research on apparent competition, we will focus our main investigation on negative competition, trade-off competition, and extensive negative competition to study the global dynamics of (1.2). Because these negative-competition pathways are in fact mediated by the predator through the consumption terms a13a_{13} and a23a_{23}, we consistently treat negative competition in its extensive form introduced above, so that the classification below simultaneously encodes the direct prey-prey suppression and the predator-mediated indirect effects. This makes the extensive negative competition term the natural counterpart of apparent competition in our analysis. This interpretation provides a biological mechanism underlying the observed parameter-dependent transitions between different dynamical regimes. We will not presuppose any results; rather, we will present all results in full, providing rigorous mathematical proofs and numerical analyses to verify their credibility.

We organize this work as follows. In § 2, we recall results for classical two-species competition systems and establish the local stability of boundary equilibria of (1.2). In § 3, we classify all parameters into four generic categories with a total of nine subcases under the assumption C1=r1a23>C2=r2a13C_{1}=r_{1}a_{23}>C_{2}=r_{2}a_{13}, which means the apparent competition of u1u_1 is superior to that of u2u_2 [6, 8]. Five global dynamics of (1.2) are confirmed from these 9 categories. In particular, one case needs to be considered in more detail; it is presented in Table 3. In § 4, for the other 4 categories, we present a table for each category, as we explore and classify the complicated subcases in detail. There are 84 subcases, and the corresponding global results are discussed individually. Finally, some numerical computations and biological implications are given. In particular, we highlight how extensive negative competition, together with trade-off and apparent competition, provides a unified biological interpretation of the transitions among coexistence, exclusion and bistability, and how it underpins the mathematical support for the Paine keystone-species conjecture.

References

  1. [1]N. F. Cramer and R. M. May, Interspecific Competition, Predation and Species Diversity : A Comment, Journal of Theoretical Biology, 34:289–293, 1972.pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/5062748
  2. [3]H. I. Freedman, S. Ruan, and M. Tang, Uniform persistence and flows near a closed positively invariant set. Journal of Dynamics and Differential Equations, 6(4):583–600, 1994.DOI
  3. [4]K. Fujii, Complexity-Stability Relationship of Two-Prey-One-Predator Species System Model: Local and Global Stability Journal of Theoretical Biology, 69:613–623, 1977.pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/564430
  4. [5]M E Gilpin. Spiral Chaos in a Predator-Prey Model. The American naturalist, 113(2):306–308, 1979.DOI
  5. [6]Robert D Holt. Predation, apparent competition and the structure of prey communities. The American naturalist, 12(2):197–229, 1977.pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/929457
  6. [7]R. D Holt, J. Grover, and D. Tilman, Simple rules for interspecific dominance in systems with exploitative and apparent competition. The American Naturalist, 144: 741–777, 1994.DOI
  7. [8]R. D Holt and G. A. Polis. A theoretical framework for intraguild predation. The American naturalist 149:745–764, 1997.DOI
  8. [9]R. D. Holt and M. B. Bonsall. Apparent Competition. The Annual Review of Ecology, Evolution, and Systematics 48:447–471, 2017.
  9. [10]S B Hsu. Predator-mediated coexistence and extinction. Mathematical Biosciences, 54(3-4):231–248, 1981.DOI
  10. [11]G. E. Hutchinson, The Paradox of the Plankton, The American Naturalist, 95:137-145, 1961.DOI
  11. [12]R. T. Paine, Food Web Complexity and Species Diversity, The American Naturalist, 100:65–75, 1966.DOI
  12. [13]J. D. Parrish and S. B. Saila, Interspecific competition, predation and species diversity, Journal of Theoretical Biology, 27:207-220, 1970.pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/5465638
  13. [14]R. Solé, Revisiting Leigh Van Valen’s “A New Evolutionary Law” (1973). Biological Theory 17 (2):120–125, 2022.DOI
  14. [15]R. R. Vance. Predation and resource partitioning in one predator-two prey model community. The American naturalist, 112:797-813, 1978.DOI
  15. [16]Y. C. Yang, J. J. Lin and T. H. Yang, Global Dynamics of a One-Predator-Two-Prey Model and its Traveling Wave Solutions, Mathematics in Applied Sciences and Engineering, 6(3):203-302, 2025. https://doi.org/10.5206/mase/21285
  16. [17]S. B. Hsu, S. Ruan and T. H. Yang. Analysis of three species Lotka-Volterra food web models with omnivory. Journal of Mathematical Analysis and Applications, 426: 659–687, 2015.DOI
  17. [22]L. Van Valen, A new evolutionary law. Evol Theory, 1:1–30, 1973.

Paper details

vlnc:W_p9zsqyd4
Version
v1 · latest
Published
Fresh — added to the Hub within the last 30 days
Added
License
CC BY 4.0
Usage

views · 0

downloads · 0

A view counts once per browser per day, a download each time the PDF is requested.

  • Mathematics

Not recorded for this paper

View statement
Looking for related papers…
Contents