WorksPhysics and Astronomy
Pulsar timing response and observational constraints on continuous-spin gravity
Abstract
Continuous-spin particles form the most general massless integer-helicity irreducible representations of the Poincaré group, characterized by a dimensionful continuous-spin scale set by a nonzero Pauli–Lubanski invariant. A single continuous-spin representation contains an infinite tower of integer helicities that mix under Lorentz boosts. Since continuous-spin effects are controlled by at gravitational-wave angular frequency , nanohertz pulsar timing arrays are naturally sensitive to ultralow values of . Starting from the gauge-invariant worldline coupling of linearized continuous-spin gravity, we derive the one-way pulsar timing redshift response and the overlap reduction function of an isotropic stochastic background for arbitrary integer helicity. We show that while photon propagation is modulated across all helicities, only the vector modes () perturb the four-velocity of a static observer, and that the tensor modes () smoothly recover the Hellings–Downs correlation of general relativity as . Modeling an unpolarized background in the solar-system barycentric frame and jointly fitting the NANOGrav 15-year data with pulsar red noise, we obtain the upper limits and under uniform and log-uniform priors, respectively. Under the uniform prior, we obtain , which brings the spectral index closer to the canonical value expected for circular SMBHBs than standard General Relativity.
Introduction
Pulsar timing arrays (PTAs) time ensembles of Galactic millisecond pulsars over decadelong baselines to search for nanohertz gravitational waves [3, 4, 5] [1, 2]. In general relativity (GR), an isotropic, unpolarized stochastic gravitational-wave background (SGWB) induces a characteristic quadrupole-dominated inter-pulsar correlation described by the Hellings–Downs (HD) curve [6, 7]. In 2023, the NANOGrav, EPTA/InPTA, PPTA, and CPTA collaborations independently reported evidence for a nanohertz common-spectrum process with HD-like spatial correlations [8, 9, 10, 11]. Because non-Einsteinian polarizations, modified dispersion relations, and background anisotropies all reshape this pattern [12, 13, 14, 15, 16, 17, 18, 19, 20], PTA cross-correlations have rapidly become a powerful probe of gravitational physics in the ultralow-frequency regime [21, 22, 23, 24, 25, 26].
From a symmetry perspective, fixed-helicity states do not exhaust the massless unitary irreducible representations of the four-dimensional Poincaré group. Wigner’s classification also admits massless continuous-spin particles (CSPs), for which the Pauli–Lubanski invariant takes a nonzero value (in mostly-minus signature), defining a dimensionful continuous-spin scale [27, 28]. For integer spin, a single CSP contains an infinite tower of helicity states that mix under Lorentz boosts at finite , analogous to the spin projections of a massive particle even though the states remain strictly lightlike, and decouple into independent fixed-helicity modes as . Although soft theorems and the Weinberg–Witten theorem tightly constrain interacting massless particles [29, 30] and CSPs were long regarded as non-interacting, Schuster and Toro showed that CSPs admit consistent soft-emission amplitudes and constructed a local gauge field theory on an auxiliary four-vector space [31, 32, 33, 34], complementing related higher-spin and BRST formulations [35, 36, 37, 38, 39, 40]. Gauge-invariant couplings of this field to worldline matter currents [41] have recently enabled concrete predictions for continuous-spin quantum electrodynamics, atomic transitions, and photon thermodynamics [42, 43, 44, 45].
In the gravitational sector, a linearized theory of continuous-spin gravity with continuous-spin scale and a smooth GR limit () was recently formulated, and the time-delay signature of its modes was evaluated for an idealized laser interferometer [46]. In this framework, deviations from fixed-helicity dynamics enter through the dimensionless parameter and become more pronounced at lower frequencies . Nanohertz gravitational waves (– nHz, or – eV) therefore probe continuous-spin scales roughly ten orders of magnitude smaller than ground-based interferometers.
At nonzero , astrophysical sources may in principle radiate scalar (), vector (), and higher-helicity () states alongside the tensor () modes. Determining how a PTA responds across the entire helicity tower is thus essential both for understanding the infrared structure of continuous-spin gravity and for characterizing non-tensor polarization correlations. In this work, we derive the one-way pulsar timing redshift response and the isotropic SGWB overlap reduction function for arbitrary integer helicity from the worldline matter coupling, correcting a trace coefficient in the massive-particle worldline current of Ref. [46] to ensure exact recovery of GR in the limit, and extract closed-form ultraviolet and infrared scaling laws across all helicities. Focusing on an unpolarized background, which continuously connects to GR, we then carry out a Bayesian analysis of the NANOGrav 15-year (NG15) data set, jointly sampling , the common-background spectrum, and 134 intrinsic pulsar red-noise parameters.
The rest of this paper is organized as follows. In Sec. II, we present the worldline coupling of continuous-spin gravity and derive the one-way pulsar timing response. We then compute the overlap reduction functions for an isotropic stochastic background and analyze their asymptotic and numerical behaviors in § 1. § 1.1 is devoted to the Bayesian MCMC analysis of the NG15 data set and the resulting constraints on . Finally, we summarize our conclusions in § 1.2. Throughout this paper, we adopt the metric signature and use natural units with unless otherwise stated.
Matter coupling and pulsar timing response of continuous-spin gravity
Worldline matter coupling
In the Schuster–Toro formulation, an integer-helicity CSP is described by a gauge field defined over spacetime and an auxiliary four-vector space [33, 34, 41]. Expanding the free field in plane waves of null wave four-vector (), integer helicity , complex mode amplitude , and helicity wave function gives [41, 46]
With an auxiliary null frame vector and transverse circular-polarization vectors satisfying , , and (all other inner products vanishing), the helicity wave functions take the form [41]
Linear coupling to a conserved matter source is governed by the interaction action [34, 41]
where denotes the derivative of the Dirac distribution with respect to its argument and is the regulated auxiliary measure defined in Appendix A of Ref. [41].
For a point particle following worldline with tangent and einbein , the matter current admits the Fourier representation [41, 46]
where is the momentum-space worldline kernel. Gauge invariance of under Schuster–Toro gauge transformations requires to satisfy the continuity condition up to terms proportional to that integrate to total -derivatives [41, 46]. Recovering linearized GR as further requires , matching the trace-reversed gravitational coupling under the measure [41]. We note that the finite- worldline ansatz written in Sec. III.C of Ref. [46] carries a trace coefficient , expanding to rather than the GR kernel in their Eq. (44). Because identically, rescaling the exponential trace term preserves worldline gauge invariance exactly. We therefore adopt the minimal gauge-invariant worldline kernel with the corrected trace coefficient,
whose limit smoothly reproduces the GR current of Ref. [46]. For null trajectories () and static massive observers coupled to modes, the term drops out, leaving the interferometer tensor time delay of Ref. [46] unaffected. In the GR limit , the trace coefficient is essential specifically to prevent an spurious scalar force and redshift response for (see Eq. (18) below), while at finite it simultaneously fixes the velocity coupling of massive observers to the vector modes .
We now generalize the helicity projection of Ref. [46] to arbitrary integer helicity. Substituting Eqs. (1) and (4) into Eq. (3) and integrating over produces , setting and giving
For each plane-wave mode , integration over defines the worldline helicity coupling coefficient
in terms of which the single-mode interaction action reads
With the shorthand at fixed wave vector, both the perturbed particle motion and the pulse redshift are determined by and its derivative .
For and , the on-shell worldline kernel (5) reads
When Eqs. (2) and (9) are inserted into Eq. (7), the exponential phases and motivate the auxiliary four-vectors
We factorize the mode function (2) as ; for , absorbing the constant sign by redefining the complex mode amplitude allows us to write and uniformly for all . Equation (7) then splits into three integrals:
with . Each term follows in closed form from the generating integral of the Schuster–Toro formalism [41], which for an arbitrary four-vector reads
where denotes the Bessel function of the first kind of order . Applying the differential operator () to Eq. (12) brings down under the integral; using together with and [47] yields
In terms of the helicity projection integral
Eqs. (12) and (13) immediately give
The first two terms in Eq. (11) evaluate directly to and , while the identity rewrites the third integral as a directional derivative at ,
yielding the coupling coefficient for arbitrary integer helicity:
To express Eq. (15) explicitly in terms of Bessel functions, we introduce the dimensionless invariants
where and give from Eq. (10)
Because satisfies and , the subtraction terms evaluated at depend sensitively on . For the scalar mode (), expanding about the origin gives
and eliminating via Eq. (17) yields
For the vector modes (), expanding gives and
leading to
For tensor and higher helicities (), the factor causes both and its first derivative to vanish at , leaving only the first term of Eq. (15):
Equation (18) provides a direct physical check of the trace coefficient in Eq. (5). Since , vanishes as when , whereas an uncorrected coefficient would leave an scalar coupling (and hence a nonvanishing scalar redshift response for a static observer) in the GR limit.
One-way frequency response and timing residuals
Using the single-mode coupling , we vary the worldline action to obtain the linear perturbations to the photon four-momentum and the observer four-velocities, from which the one-way pulse frequency shift follows. Combining the free worldline action for a particle of mass ( for photons, for massive observers) [41, 46] with Eq. (8) gives , with Lagrangian
Variation with respect to the einbein enforces the perturbed mass-shell constraint
Under worldline variations to first order in in a constant- gauge, the canonical four-momentum
obeys the Euler–Lagrange equation ,
Evaluating the right-hand side along the unperturbed straight worldline (where and are constant) and integrating via gives the canonical-momentum perturbation
with integration constants canceling between reception and emission in a one-way timing link for an intrinsically steady clock. Comparison of Eq. (25) with the linearization of Eq. (23) isolates the tangent-vector perturbation:
comprising a term along the wave four-vector and a derivative term arising from the velocity dependence of the coupling.
Because the photon frequency measured by an observer with four-velocity () equals the invariant contraction [46, 48], linearizing about an unperturbed null ray of four-momentum (, , , constant einbein ) and observer velocity yields the fractional shift
At an emission or reception event , evaluating Eq. (25) on the photon () gives the photon-momentum contribution
which is invariant under affine reparameterization by the quadratic homogeneity of , while evaluating Eq. (26) on the massive observer (, ) gives the observer-velocity contribution
The sum of Eqs. (28) and (29) expresses the single-mode local frequency shift at as
with directional response coefficient
To evaluate Eq. (31) explicitly in the observer rest frame , we align the gravitational wave along :
Parameterizing the photon four-vector in spherical angles as with and , we have , , and ; Eqs. (16) and (17) at then give
The dimensionless Bessel argument in Eq. (32) admits a direct physical interpretation in terms of Wigner’s ISO(2) little-group kinematics. Since for , it measures the ratio of the continuous-spin scale projected transverse to the photon trajectory () to the rate at which the gravitational-wave phase varies along the photon path (). For head-on propagation (, ), the vanishing transverse projection eliminates little-group mixing (). Conversely, for nearly co-propagating waves and photons (, , corresponding to pulsars near with ), prolonged phase coherence causes the helicity-mixing argument to grow large within a narrow collinear region , where and the helicity tower mixes strongly even when .
For the static-observer terms in Eq. (31), setting gives and hence , while , , and imply , so that identically for every . Differentiating Eqs. (18)–(20) with respect to the contravariant tangent prior to setting , and using together with the small-argument Bessel expansions, yields
Equation (33) reflects an angular-momentum selection rule in the observer rest frame. Because is rotationally invariant about , a linear spatial velocity perturbation carrying azimuthal spin weight cannot be excited by modes, while the gauge subtractions in Eq. (18) cancel any longitudinal velocity perturbation for , leaving only the vector modes to induce a transverse velocity perturbation of a static observer. Contracting Eq. (33) with and using gives the nonvanishing vector observer-velocity contribution,
Substitution of , , and into Eq. (31) reduces the directional response to
Evaluating at () via Eqs. (18)–(20) together with Eqs. (33)–(34) yields the local frequency-shift coefficients across the entire helicity tower:
Every response carries the azimuthal phase ; only receives contributions from both the photon-momentum and observer-velocity perturbations, whereas all and responses arise solely from the photon-momentum perturbation.
Following standard PTA antenna-pattern conventions [7, 49], we factorize the antenna response into its azimuthal phase and polar profile via
giving
Despite the divergence of as , every is continuous and bounded across . At head-on incidence , for all , while in the collinear limit at fixed , whereas . Conversely, at any fixed , taking () gives , which reproduces the standard GR circular-polarization antenna patterns , while all non-tensor profiles vanish pointwise on as well as in the norm (the narrow collinear region subtending a vanishing solid angle ).
For pulsar at distance along unit sky vector from Earth (placed at the spatial origin), radio pulses propagate along with and directional cosine relative to . Relating the pulsar emission event to the Earth reception event for a stable intrinsic spin frequency gives the one-way fractional frequency shift
where and , with pulsar phase , yielding the Earth- and pulsar-term phase factor [7, 49, 50].
In terms of the pulse redshift , the timing residual accumulates as [7] [2]
We adopt the two-sided Fourier convention (), where the dimensionless parameter entering the antenna patterns across all frequencies is defined as the positive quantity (reducing to for ). This definition ensures that the odd Bessel and observer-velocity contributions in do not flip signs at negative frequencies, guaranteeing . Absorbing the overall redshift sign, the plane-wave integration measure, and the prefactor of Eq. (39) into the plane-wave amplitude , the reality of then implies the standard circular-polarization reality condition . Summing over propagation directions and helicities then gives the frequency-domain redshift
where and is the azimuthal angle of around . With , in the short-wavelength regime [7, 51] the rapidly oscillating pulsar phase averages out of distinct-pulsar cross-correlations () while doubling each zero-lag autocorrelation (). Retaining the coherent Earth-term timing residual gives
Angular correlations of a stochastic continuous-spin background
Multipole expansion of the overlap reduction function
Consider a zero-mean, stationary, homogeneous, and isotropic stochastic continuous-spin background [7, 52, 53]. Because a rotation by about transforms , statistical isotropy requires a rotationally invariant two-point function that is diagonal in helicity:
where angular brackets denote ensemble expectation, is the Kronecker delta, is the Dirac distribution on , and is the polarization power spectral density of helicity .
Substituting Eq. (46) into the cross-correlation of two distinct pulsars () separated by angle and using Eq. (47), we define the Earth-term overlap reduction function () as
normalized by so that summing the two tensor helicities () recovers the standard HD normalization at . The Earth-term timing-residual cross-correlation then factorizes into source spectrum and detector geometry:
Exploiting the azimuthal factorization , we convert the two-dimensional sky integral (48) into an exact Legendre series via spherical-harmonic projection and SO(3) orthogonality [15, 16, 54, 55, 56, 57]. In the reference frame , expanding in the Condon–Shortley spherical harmonics (),
where is the associated Legendre function [47], motivates defining the one-dimensional multipole projection integral for and :
Azimuthal integration yields , forcing for and giving, for and ,
If we write for the single nonvanishing azimuthal component, the conjugation identity for contributes at most an overall sign , so that .
A rotation mapping to a general wave direction transforms via Wigner matrices [54]. Because any residual rotation about produces opposite helicity phases that cancel in , averaging over in Eq. (48) is equivalent to integrating over with normalized Haar measure (). Combining the Wigner orthogonality relation [54]
with the spherical-harmonic addition theorem , where denotes the Legendre polynomial of degree , reduces the sky average to
Substitution of together with the normalization factor from Eq. (48) yields the Earth-term angular correlation series for arbitrary integer helicity:
Several structural properties follow directly from Eq. (54). First, azimuthal spin weight imposes the multipole selection rule , forbidding a monopole () for all and both monopole and dipole () for . Second, since depends solely on , opposite helicities share identical spatial correlations, . Third, the manifest non-negativity of the Legendre weights guarantees, by Schoenberg’s theorem [58], that the inter-pulsar correlation matrix on is positive semi-definite for every helicity and every scale ratio . Finally, as , gives for , so the unpolarized tensor correlation resums to the GR Hellings–Downs curve [6, 49, 57],
with for distinct pulsars and unit diagonal entries once the pulsar term is added.
| Sector | range | Observer | UV () | IR behavior () |
| Scalar () | ||||
| Vector () | ||||
| Tensor () | (); | |||
| Higher () | (); | |||
| Higher () | (); |
Table 1. Summary of multipole selection rules, static-observer velocity perturbation , and Earth-term ultraviolet and infrared asymptotic behaviors ( for , unpolarized sum for ; entries without explicit refer to zero lag ) across the continuous-spin helicity tower.
At intermediate coupling , the zero-lag correlation for exhibits a non-monotonic peak (e.g., for ) before entering the universal asymptotic decay. For , the infrared asymptotics require .
Analytical ultraviolet and infrared scaling laws
Before turning to numerical evaluations, we extract closed-form asymptotic scaling laws from Eqs. (40)–(42) and (54) that govern the high-frequency ultraviolet () and deep infrared () limits across the entire helicity tower. Under the change of variables , for which , , and , Parseval’s identity in Eq. (54) expresses the zero-separation Earth-term correlations as exact one-dimensional integrals; in particular, for ,
In the ultraviolet regime (), naive pointwise expansion of at fixed would suggest and hence sky-averaged power scaling as for . For , however, the resulting -integrand behaves as at large , diverging toward the collinear region () where and Bessel oscillations regulate the integral. Consequently, this collinear region dominates the sky average, lifting all correlations to and generating logarithmic terms for . Asymptotic expansion of Eq. (56) and the corresponding integrals for yields
where is the Euler–Mascheroni constant, so that the full tensor autocorrelation satisfies . Averaging over an isotropic pulsar sky thus enhances the leading continuous-spin correction to the tensor sector by relative to fixed-angle interferometer links [46].
In the deep infrared regime (), the helicity modes exhibit three distinct asymptotic behaviors depending on . For the scalar mode (), the bounded oscillatory piece in Eq. (40) decays as away from , leaving so that the sky correlation approaches a positive monopole-plus-dipole limit,
For the vector modes (), rewriting Eq. (41) as shows that the observer-velocity perturbation dominates once ; since is a pure dipole, Eq. (54) reduces to the quadratically growing dipolar correlation
For tensor and higher-helicity modes (), the static-observer velocity perturbation vanishes and rapid Bessel oscillations suppress the sky integral. Evaluating Eq. (56) via Mellin–Barnes contour integration reveals that parity in the -expansion eliminates all even negative powers of , so that the term vanishes identically, yielding the asymptotic expansion
valid when the continuous-spin parameter satisfies . For the tensor sector (), Eq. (64) gives at . At , the integral weight of is distributed across the backward hemisphere (; e.g., accounting for 95.3% of the integral at ), where oscillates rapidly with an effective angular wavenumber and shifts the dominant multipoles from out to . Table I summarizes the multipole selection rules, observer-velocity perturbations, and asymptotic scalings across all helicity sectors.
Numerical behavior across helicities and continuous-spin scales
Figure 1–Figure 3 display the numerical evaluation of Eq. (54) for () and the unpolarized pairs () at three representative scale ratios, , , and , corresponding to the ultraviolet (), intermediate (), and deep infrared () regimes. Figure 1 directly illustrates the three helicity regimes established analytically in § 1 B. At (blue curves), little-group mixing is confined to the narrow collinear region , so the tensor correlation closely tracks with mild zero-lag damping ( versus 0.5), whereas all non-tensor correlations remain suppressed in accordance with Eqs. (57)–(61). At (green curves), the three infrared behaviors are clearly separated. The scalar correlation () approaches the positive monopole-plus-dipole limit ((62)), reaching at and 0.40 at . The vector correlation () is dominated by the observer-velocity dipole term ((63)), reaching at , far above the and 1.2 curves of zero-lag amplitudes 0.068 and 0.189. All correlations undergo the suppression of Eq. (64), dropping to for and – for , so that the green curves lie nearly flat along zero on the vertical scale of the panels. Because correlations vanish in both the and limits, their amplitude varies non-monotonically with and peaks at , which explains why the intermediate (orange) curves have larger peak
Figure 1. Earth-term overlap reduction functions across continuous-spin regimes (blue), (orange), and (green) for helicities . Here is shown for and the unpolarized sum is shown for , with the GR Hellings–Downs curve (black dashed) overlaid in the panel. Vertical scales differ among panels to accommodate the wide dynamic range across .
Figure 3. Amplitude suppression and angular-shape deformation of the tensor correlation for compared with GR (black dashed). The left panel shows the unnormalized Earth-term correlation , while the right panel displays the normalized correlation alongside .
Figure 2. Earth-term angular correlation functions for different helicities at (defined as in Figure 1). The black dashed curve is the Hellings–Downs curve of general relativity. For visibility, the curves for are multiplied by 10, 50, and 200, respectively, as indicated in the legend.
magnitudes than those for and in the panels.
Figure 2 compares the angular correlation functions for through at , rescaling by factors of 10, 50, and 200. Under the normalization of Eq. (39), prior to rescaling, the lower-helicity modes () attain comparable zero-lag amplitudes (0.244, 0.189, and 0.191), whereas the higher-helicity amplitudes drop rapidly (, , and ) because is strongly suppressed for . On this scale, the multipole structure of each helicity is directly visible. Because for all , the polar profile satisfies across (and is strictly positive for ), ensuring that the scalar Earth-term overlap reduction function remains strictly positive at all separations. At , partial cancellation between the photon-momentum and observer-velocity dipole terms in Eq. (41) suppresses the harmonic of , producing a curve with two zero crossings similar to . The pure dipole at is shown in Figure 1. For , the correlation curves exhibit 2, 3, 4, and 5 zero crossings on , with the first zero crossing shifting progressively toward smaller angles (). The multipole selection rule in Eq. (54) makes the angular correlation function orthogonal to all Legendre polynomials of degree below , requiring at least sign changes over . The numerical curves at attain this lower bound.
Because our NG15 data analysis in § 1.1 focuses on the tensor sector (), Figure 3 separates overall amplitude damping from purely geometric distortion in as varies with frequency (with explicit factors of and restored hereafter).
While the left panel shows the rapid monotonic drop in overall amplitude and zero-lag correlation , the right panel isolates angular shape via the normalized correlation
compared with . Moderate values () shift the zero-crossing angles and make the negative minimum deeper than that of the HD curve, whereas produces multiple oscillations at intermediate angular separations. For , rapid Bessel oscillations across the backward hemisphere (§ 1 B) shift the dominant Legendre weights in from the GR quadrupole , which accounts for 62.5% of , to higher multipoles , with accounting for 85.4% of . A continuous-spin tensor background therefore suppresses low-frequency timing power while distorting the angular dependence of inter-pulsar correlations toward higher multipoles.
Analysis of the NANOGrav 15-year data set
Bayesian likelihood and MCMC framework
We now test the continuous-spin tensor model against the public timing data from the 67 millisecond pulsars in the NG15 SGWB analysis [8, 59, 60], assuming an unpolarized background (, ) in the solar-system barycentric (SSB) frame; because the peculiar velocities of the SSB and Galactic pulsars relative to the cosmic rest frame are only , giving , boost-induced helicity mixing is negligible. Following the standard NG15 protocol [8, 61], we adopt the JPL DE440 solar-system ephemeris [62] to refer pulse arrival times to the SSB, the TT(BIPM2019) time standard, and the observing span , expanding stochastic processes on harmonic frequencies () with the first 14 frequencies modeling the common gravitational-wave background and the first 30 frequencies modeling intrinsic per-pulsar red noise.
Within the linear timing-model and Gaussian-process framework [63, 64], the concatenated timing-residual vector across all 67 pulsars is modeled as
where is the timing-model design matrix with linear parameter offsets , and are the Fourier design matrices for intrinsic red noise and the common background with zero-mean Gaussian coefficients and , and denotes white noise of covariance . White-noise parameters (EFAC, EQUAD, and ECORR) are fixed to their NG15 single-pulsar noise-run values [60, 61], while all red-noise and common-background hyperparameters are inferred jointly.
In the short-wavelength regime, combining the coherent Earth-term correlation with the equal diagonal pulsar-term contribution yields the full tensor correlation matrix at frequency :
where index pulsars separated by angle , is the Kronecker delta, and . By Parseval’s identity, the diagonal autocorrelation entries () of Eq. (67) equal
We model the common-background one-sided timing-residual power spectral density , which is related to in Eq. (49) by , as a power law referenced to [7, 8, 53],
with dimensionless strain amplitude and spectral index , alongside an independent power law for each pulsar’s intrinsic red noise [60]. In the Fourier-basis Gaussian-process representation [63], cosine and sine basis functions at frequency share the inter-pulsar covariance blocks
assembled across into . Integrating over (with block-diagonal covariance ), , and yields the total residual covariance [65]
Analytic marginalization over the deterministic timing offsets [63, 64, 66] projects onto the orthogonal complement of the column space of via an orthonormal basis matrix (, ), giving the marginalized Gaussian log-likelihood for the 137-dimensional hyperparameter vector (134 pulsar red-noise parameters plus , , and ),
where . Equation (72) uses a -matrix projection onto the null space of . In practice, we evaluate the equivalent marginalized likelihood using the Woodbury matrix identity, as implemented in enterprise [61, 66, 67].
| Parameter | Prior distribution |
| [eV] | |
Table II. Sampled model parameters and their prior distributions ( indexes pulsars).
Table II lists the prior distributions , where denotes a uniform distribution on and the red-noise and common-spectrum priors follow standard NG15 conventions [8, 61]. For , we consider both uniform and log-uniform priors. We sample the 137-dimensional posterior via Markov chain Monte Carlo (MCMC) [68, 69] using PTMCMCSampler [61, 70]. Convergence is assessed using the rank-normalized split- and effective sample size (ESS) statistics [71], with thresholds of , bulk ESS , and tail ESS .
Posterior constraints, spectral degeneracies, and comparison with massive gravity
Figure 4 shows the marginalized one- and two-dimensional posteriors of , , and . The marginalized density remains compatible with the GR limit , concentrating below with a broad maximum near (median ). The 95% credible upper limit is
Figure 4. Marginalized one- and two-dimensional posterior distributions of , , under the uniform prior on . The vertical dotted line in the upper-left panel marks the 95% credible upper limit ; inner and outer contours in the two-dimensional panels enclose 68% and 95% credible regions, respectively.
which corresponds to . The marginalized common-background spectral parameters are constrained to and (68% credible intervals). Across the 14 NG15 Fourier bins (from to ), setting spans down to , showing that the joint likelihood is sensitive to all frequency bins.
The joint posteriors in Figure 4 show a strong positive correlation between and , alongside a moderate anticorrelation between and . In the standard GR analysis, NG15 favors a relatively shallow spectral index [8], below the canonical SMBHB prediction [72, 73]. In continuous-spin gravity, increasing suppresses the low-frequency timing response through , while a larger enhances the underlying low-frequency background power, partially compensating for this suppression. This explains the positive correlation and allows steeper background spectra, including , for . Since the best-constrained frequencies (3–10 nHz) lie below the reference frequency nHz, increasing also tends to lower the inferred amplitude at , contributing to the observed anticorrelation.
The posterior distributions under the log-uniform prior on is plotted in Figure 5. The 95% upper limit is
Figure 5. Same with Figure 4, but under the log-uniform prior on . The vertical dotted line in the upper-left panel marks the 95% upper limit, .
which corresponds to pc. The log-uniform prior assigns greater weight to smaller continuous-spin scales, leading to a smaller upper limit than the uniform prior.
It is instructive to contrast this continuous-spin bound with nanohertz constraints on a massive graviton of mass , which also induces frequency-dependent PTA correlations [13, 17, 24, 74, 75]. Freely propagating massive gravitons obey the dispersion relation and propagation threshold
below which oscillatory plane waves become evanescent; requiring the lowest NG15 frequency bin nHz to propagate () immediately yields [23, 24]. In contrast, continuous-spin gravitational waves remain strictly massless and luminal () at all frequencies [34, 46], so no sharp dispersion cutoff exists. Instead, continuous-spin gravity suppresses timing power through a smooth, frequency-dependent damping factor , which decreases monotonically. At the 95% upper limit (), timing power in the lowest four frequency bins (where ) is suppressed by . In a joint Bayesian fit, this low-frequency deficit is partially compensated by steepening the common-background spectral index , until the combination of residual power at intermediate frequencies and higher-multipole spatial correlation distortions () excludes larger continuous-spin scales. Together, the absence of a hard dispersion cutoff and this spectral degeneracy allow eV to exceed the massive-gravity threshold energy eV by nearly an order of magnitude.
Conclusions
In this work, we derived the one-way pulsar timing redshift response and the overlap reduction function of an isotropic stochastic background in linearized continuous-spin gravity for all integer helicities . From the Legendre expansion (54), we obtained closed-form ultraviolet and infrared scaling laws governed by . We find that while photon propagation is modulated across every helicity, rotational symmetry in the observer rest frame restricts the velocity perturbation of a static observer to the vector modes (). For , collinear helicity mixing within lifts all correlations to and produces enhancements for . For , the vector correlation grows quadratically as an dipole, the scalar correlation () approaches a constant monopole-plus-dipole form, and all correlations decay as while their dominant multipoles shift to . In the limit , all non-tensor responses vanish and the tensor sector smoothly recovers the GR Hellings–Downs curve.
In a Bayesian analysis of NG15 data, fitting the frequency-dependent tensor correlation matrix under a uniform prior on yields the 95% credible upper limit . With the log-uniform prior, the 95% upper limit is . Continuous-spin damping suppresses the lowest Fourier bins (), producing a low-frequency turnover in the timing spectrum that induces a strong positive correlation between and the common-background spectral index , which brings steeper background spectra, including the canonical of circular SMBHBs, into closer agreement with the NG15 data.
Although a strong-field calculation of binary radiation in continuous-spin gravity remains an open problem, helicity correspondence [32, 41, 46] suppresses non-tensor emission from non-relativistic binaries when . If relativistic or primordial sources generate appreciable scalar or vector radiation, the spatial correlation functions derived here, in particular the monopole-dominated correlation and the dipolar correlation at large , allow direct searches for non-tensor continuous-spin polarizations in PTA data. Because continuous-spin effects depend on , nanohertz observations probe values of roughly five orders of magnitude smaller than millihertz space-based interferometers and ten orders of magnitude smaller than ground-based () detectors [46]. Longer-baseline observations with the International Pulsar Timing Array and the Square Kilometre Array will improve sensitivity at the lowest frequencies and across angular multipoles, helping to separate finite- angular distortion from the common-background spectral slope . that of Ref. [76], while our theoretical derivation additionally covers all non-tensor helicities (, , and ), closed-form asymptotic scaling laws, and the trace correction to the massive-particle worldline kernel in Eq. (5). This correction also ensures the proper GR response limit, as only the modes retain the standard tensor response when , while the responses of all other helicities vanish.
The numerical difference between our uniform-prior upper limit and the limit reported in that work arises primarily from the choice of prior. Reference [76] adopts a log-uniform prior extending several decades below eV, where the likelihood approaches its nonzero GR limit. Lowering the cutoff assigns more prior probability to the region eV. In contrast, our uniform prior on is independent of any nonzero lower cutoff and directly probes the scale at which the NG15 likelihood begins to decrease.
The results difference between our log-uniform-prior limit and the limit reported in that work may mainly arising from the treatment of pulsar autocorrelations(and partially from the slight difference in prior boundaries). Our analysis retains the full frequency-dependent autocorrelation , which is expected to induce a strong positive correlation between and . Furthermore, inspecting the publicly released implementation and MCMC chains of Ref. [76] indicates that their likelihood evaluation adopts the standard convention commonly hardcoded in some PTA software interfaces, whereas our Eq. (67) retains the full frequency-dependent autocorrelation . Under a comparable log-uniform prior, our full-covariance analysis yields eV (Figure 5).
Acknowledgements
This work is supported by the 2115 Talent Development Program of China Agricultural University, and the High-performance Computing Platform of China Agricultural University. The Large Language Model was used to check some calculations and to assist with editing the manuscript.
References
References
- [3]R.S. Foster, D.C. Backer, Astrophys. J. 361, 300 (1990). doi:10.1086/169195
- [4]F.A. Jenet, G.B. Hobbs, K.J. Lee, R.N. Manchester, Astrophys. J. Lett. 625, L123 (2005). doi:10.1086/431220DOI
- [5]G. Hobbs, et al., Class. Quant. Grav. 27, 084013 (2010). doi:10.1088/0264-9381/27/8/084013DOI
- [6]R.W. Hellings, G.S. Downs, Astrophys. J. Lett. 265, L39 (1983). doi:10.1086/183954DOI
- [7]M. Anholm, S. Ballmer, J.D.E. Creighton, L.R. Price, X. Siemens, Phys. Rev. D 79, 084030 (2009). doi:10.1103/PhysRevD.79.084030DOI
- [8]G. Agazie, et al., Astrophys. J. Lett. 951(1), L8 (2023). doi:10.3847/2041-8213/acdac6DOI
- [9]J. Antoniadis, et al., Astron. Astrophys. 678, A50 (2023). doi:10.1051/0004-6361/202346844DOI
- [10]D.J. Reardon, et al., Astrophys. J. Lett. 951(1), L6 (2023). doi:10.3847/2041-8213/acdd02DOI
- [11]H. Xu, et al., Res. Astron. Astrophys. 23(7), 075024 (2023). doi:10.1088/1674-4527/acdfa5DOI
- [12]K.J. Lee, F.A. Jenet, R.H. Price, Astrophys. J. 685, 1304 (2008). doi:10.1086/591080DOI
- [13]K. Lee, F.A. Jenet, R.H. Price, N. Wex, M. Kramer, Astrophys. J. 722, 1589 (2010). doi:10.1088/0004-637X/722/2/1589DOI
- [14]S.J. Chamberlin, X. Siemens, Phys. Rev. D 85, 082001 (2012). doi:10.1103/PhysRevD.85.082001DOI
- [15]C.M.F. Mingarelli, T. Sidery, I. Mandel, A. Vecchio, Phys. Rev. D 88(6), 062005 (2013). doi:10.1103/PhysRevD.88.062005DOI
- [16]J.R. Gair, J.D. Romano, S.R. Taylor, Phys. Rev. D 92(10), 102003 (2015). doi:10.1103/PhysRevD.92.102003DOI
- [17]Q. Liang, M. Trodden, Phys. Rev. D 104(8), 084052 (2021). doi:10.1103/PhysRevD.104.084052DOI
- [18]Q. Liang, M.X. Lin, M. Trodden, JCAP 11, 042 (2023). doi:10.1088/1475-7516/2023/11/042DOI
- [19]N. Anil Kumar, M. Kamionkowski, Phys. Rev. Lett. 133(15), 151401 (2024). doi:10.1103/PhysRevLett.133.151401
- [20]N. Cordes, A. Mitridate, K. Schmitz, T. Schröder, K. Wassner, Class. Quant. Grav. 42(1), 015003 (2025). doi:10.1088/1361-6382/ad9881DOI
- [21]A. Afzal, et al., Astrophys. J. Lett. 951(1), L11 (2023). doi:10.3847/2041-8213/acdc91. [Erratum: Astrophys. J. Lett. 971, L27 (2024)]DOI
- [22]R.C. Bernardo, K.W. Ng, Astron. Astrophys. 691, A126 (2024). doi:10.1051/0004-6361/202449483DOI
- [23]Y.M. Wu, Z.C. Chen, Y.C. Bi, Q.G. Huang, Class. Quant. Grav. 41(7), 075002 (2024). doi:10.1088/1361-6382/ad2a9bDOI
- [24]S. Wang, Z.C. Zhao, Phys. Rev. D 109(6), L061502 (2024). doi:10.1103/PhysRevD.109.L061502DOI
- [25]J.H. Han, Z.C. Zhao, arXiv:2604.23384 [gr-qc] (2026)arxiv.org/abs/2604.23384
- [26]R.C. Bernardo, K.W. Ng, Phys. Rev. D 109(10), L101502 (2024). doi: 10.1103/PhysRevD.109.L101502DOI
- [27]E.P. Wigner, Annals Math. 40, 149 (1939). doi:10.2307/1968551DOI
- [28]X. Bekaert, E.D. Skvortsov, Int. J. Mod. Phys. A 32(23–24), 1730019 (2017). doi: 10.1142/S0217751X17300198DOI
- [29]S. Weinberg, Phys. Rev. 135, B1049 (1964). doi:10.1103/PhysRev.135.B1049DOI
- [30]S. Weinberg, E. Witten, Phys. Lett. B 96, 59 (1980). doi:10.1016/0370-2693(80)90212-9DOI
- [31]P. Schuster, N. Toro, JHEP 09, 104 (2013). doi:10.1007/JHEP09(2013)104DOI
- [32]P. Schuster, N. Toro, JHEP 09, 105 (2013). doi:10.1007/JHEP09(2013)105DOI
- [33]P. Schuster, N. Toro, JHEP 10, 061 (2013). doi:10.1007/JHEP10(2013)061DOI
- [34]P. Schuster, N. Toro, Phys. Rev. D 91, 025023 (2015). doi:10.1103/PhysRevD.91.025023DOI
- [35]X. Bekaert, J. Mourad, JHEP 01, 115 (2006). doi:10.1088/1126-6708/2006/01/115DOI
- [36]V.O. Rivelles, Phys. Rev. D 91(12), 125035 (2015). doi:10.1103/PhysRevD.91.125035DOI
- [37]V.O. Rivelles, Eur. Phys. J. C 77(7), 433 (2017). doi:10.1140/epjc/s10052-017-4927-1DOI
- [38]X. Bekaert, J. Mourad, M. Najafizadeh, JHEP 11, 113 (2017). doi:10.1007/JHEP11(2017)113DOI
- [39]M. Najafizadeh, Phys. Rev. D 97(6), 065009 (2018). doi:10.1103/PhysRevD.97.065009DOI
- [40]B. Bellazzini, S. De Angelis, M. Romano, JHEP 05, 166 (2025). doi:10.1007/JHEP05(2025)166DOI
- [41]P. Schuster, N. Toro, K. Zhou, JHEP 04, 010 (2023). doi:10.1007/JHEP04(2023)010DOI
- [42]P. Schuster, N. Toro, Phys. Rev. D 109(9), 096008 (2024). doi:10.1103/PhysRevD.109.096008DOI
- [43]P. Schuster, G. Sundaresan, N. Toro, Phys. Rev. D 111(5), 056019 (2025). doi: 10.1103/PhysRevD.111.056019DOI
- [44]A. Reilly, P. Schuster, N. Toro, Phys. Rev. D 113(1), 015028 (2026). doi:10.1103/1fm8-swI8
- [45]A. Reilly, A. Russo, P. Schuster, N. Toro, Phys. Rev. D 113(7), 075037 (2026). doi:10.1103/tkk2-1j69DOI
- [46]S. Kundu, P. Schuster, N. Toro, Phys. Rev. D 113(7), 076017 (2026). doi:10.1103/47wt-skjwDOI
- [47]NIST Digital Library of Mathematical Functions. https://dlmf.nist.gov/ (2026). Release 1.2.8 of 2026-09-15
- [48]R.M. Wald, General Relativity (Chicago Univ. Pr., Chicago, USA, 1984). doi: 10.7208/chicago/9780226870373.001.0001DOI
- [49]J.D. Romano, B. Allen, Class. Quant. Grav. 41(17), 175008 (2024). doi:10.1088/1361-6382/ad4c4cDOI
- [50]F.B. Estabrook, H.D. Wahlquist, Gen. Rel. Grav. 6(5), 439 (1975). doi:10.1007/BF00762449DOI
- [51]C.M.F. Mingarelli, A.B. Mingarelli, J. Phys. Comm. 2(10), 105002 (2018). doi:10.1088/2399-6528/aae06dDOI
- [52]B. Allen, J.D. Romano, Phys. Rev. D 59, 102001 (1999). doi:10.1103/PhysRevD.59.102001DOI
- [53]J.D. Romano, N.J. Cornish, Living Rev. Rel. 20(1), 2 (2017). doi:10.1007/s41114-017-0004-1DOI
- [54]D.A. Varshalovich, A.N. Moskalev, V.K. Khersonskii, Quantum Theory of Angular Momentum: Irreducible Tensors, Spherical Harmonics, Vector Coupling Coefficients, 3nj Symbols (World Scientific Publishing Company, 1988). doi:10.1142/0270DOI
- [55]J. Gair, J.D. Romano, S. Taylor, C.M.F. Mingarelli, Phys. Rev. D 90(8), 082001 (2014). doi:10.1103/PhysRevD.90.082001DOI
- [56]R.C. Bernardo, K.W. Ng, Phys. Rev. D 107(4), 044007 (2023). doi:10.1103/PhysRevD.107.044007DOI
- [57]B. Allen, Phys. Rev. D 110(4), 043043 (2024). doi:10.1103/PhysRevD.110.043043DOI
- [58]I.J. Schoenberg, Duke Math. J. 9(1), 96 (1942). doi:10.1215/S0012-7094-42-00908-6DOI
- [59]G. Agazie, et al., Astrophys. J. Lett. 951(1), L9 (2023). doi:10.3847/2041-8213/acda9aDOI
- [60]G. Agazie, et al., Astrophys. J. Lett. 951(1), L10 (2023). doi:10.3847/2041-8213/acda88DOI
- [61]A.D. Johnson, et al., Phys. Rev. D 109(10), 103012 (2024). doi:10.1103/PhysRevD.109.103012DOI
- [62]R.S. Park, W.M. Folkner, J.G. Williams, D.H. Boggs, Astron. J. 161, 105 (2021). doi:10.3847/1538-3881/abd414DOI
- [63]L. Lentati, P. Alexander, M.P. Hobson, S. Taylor, J. Gair, S.T. Balan, R. van Haasteren, Phys. Rev. D 87(10), 104021 (2013). doi:10.1103/PhysRevD.87.104021DOI
- [64]R. van Haasteren, Y. Levin, Mon. Not. Roy. Astron. Soc. 428, 1147 (2013). doi:10.1093/mnras/sts097DOI
- [65]S.J. Chamberlin, J.D.E. Creighton, X. Siemens, P. Demorest, J. Ellis, L.R. Price, J.D. Romano, Phys. Rev. D 91(4), 044048 (2015). doi:10.1103/PhysRevD.91.044048DOI
- [66]R. van Haasteren, M. Vallisneri, Phys. Rev. D 90(10), 104012 (2014). doi:10.1103/PhysRevD.90.104012DOI
- [67]J.A. Ellis, M. Vallisneri, S.R. Taylor, P.T. Baker. ENTERPRISE: Enhanced Numerical Toolbox Enabling a Robust Pulsar Inference SuitE (2020). doi:10.5281/zenodo.4059815DOI
- [68]W.K. Hastings, Biometrika 57, 97 (1970). doi:10.1093/biomet/57.1.97DOI
- [69]R. van Haasteren, Y. Levin, P. McDonald, T. Lu, Mon. Not. Roy. Astron. Soc. 395, 1005 (2009). doi:10.1111/j.1365-2966.2009.14590.xDOI
- [70]J.A. Ellis, R. van Haasteren. PTMCMCSampler: Official release (2017). doi: 10.5281/zenodo.1037579
- [71]A. Vehtari, A. Gelman, D. Simpson, B. Carpenter, P.C. Bürkner, Bayesian Anal. 16, 667 (2021). doi:10.1214/20-BA1221DOI
- [72]E.S. Phinney, arXiv:astro-ph/0108028 (2001)DOI
- [73]G. Agazie, et al., Astrophys. J. Lett. 952(2), L37 (2023). doi:10.3847/2041-8213/ace18bDOI
- [74]R.C. Bernardo, K.W. Ng, Phys. Rev. D 107(10), L101502 (2023). doi: 10.1103/PhysRevD.107.L101502DOI
- [75]Q. Liang, I. Obata, M. Sasaki, JCAP 10, 097 (2024). doi:10.1088/1475-7516/2024/10/097DOI
- [76]C. Ambasht, O. Bitcon, T. Trickle, NANOGRav Collaboration, arXiv:2611.14613 [hep-ph] (2026)arxiv.org/abs/2611.14613




