betaFeedback

WorksMathematics

The relations of a Lie subalgebra considered by Tao: a complete presentation

Abstract

Let g be the Lie algebra over a field of characteristic 0 generated by D_i, E_i (i ≥ 1), subject to [D_i,D_j] = [E_i,E_j] = 0 and [D_i,E_j] = [D_j,E_i]. Let h be the subalgebra generated by the elements [D_i,E_j] and E_i. On MathOverflow (question 464808), T. Tao asked whether the obvious relations [D_i,E_j] = [D_j,E_i], [E_i,E_j] = 0 and [E_i,[D_j,E_k]] = [E_k,[D_j,E_i]] generate all relations of h. We prove that they do. The proof has four steps: (1) a polarisation argument reduces the problem to multilinear components; (2) we give a presentation of the ideal generated by the E_i; (3) an excess filtration, whose associated graded algebra we compute explicitly, reduces injectivity to an equality of dimensions; (4) that equality follows from the Hilbert series of g, which is given by Eulerian numbers. The Hilbert series in step 4 is equivalent to known results. The multilinear components of the enveloping algebra of the ideal generated by the E_i coincide with the homology of the Losev–Manin spaces: their Betti numbers are due to Losev and Manin (Michigan Math. J. 48 (2000)), and the algebra structure was presented by Dotsenko, Shadrin and Tamaroff (Comm. Math. Phys. 399 (2023)). The paper explains this relation precisely. It also gives an independent, self-contained derivation, using a PBW basis of U(g) obtained from Bergman’s diamond lemma and a sign-reversing involution. By-products: h is a semidirect product of a free Lie algebra and an abelian Lie algebra; the elements [D_i,E_j] (i ≤ j) freely generate a free Lie subalgebra of g; the multilinear components of g have dimensions given by Eulerian numbers (equivalent to known results). We were unable to find the affirmative answer to Tao's question or the freeness statement in the literature. Independent computer checks are included in the separate code archive.

Introduction

Throughout, k\mathbb{k} is a field of characteristic 00 (for instance R\mathbb{R}), and N={1,2,3,…}\mathbb{N}=\{1,2,3,\ldots\}. The following question was asked by T. Tao on MathOverflow in February 2024 [5].

Let g\mathfrak{g} be the Lie algebra over k\mathbb{k} generated by DiD_i, EiE_i, i∈Ni\in\mathbb{N}, subject to

[Di,Dj]=[Ei,Ej]=0,[Di,Ej]=[Dj,Ei](i,j∈N).(1)[D_i,D_j]=[E_i,E_j]=0,\qquad[D_i,E_j]=[D_j,E_i]\qquad(i,j\in\mathbb{N}). \tag*{(1)}

Let h⊂g\mathfrak{h}\subset\mathfrak{g} be the Lie subalgebra generated by the elements [Di,Ej][D_i,E_j] and EiE_i. These elements satisfy

[Di,Ej]=[Dj,Ei],[Ei,Ej]=0,[D_i,E_j]=[D_j,E_i],\qquad[E_i,E_j]=0,
[Ei,[Dj,Ek]]=[Ek,[Dj,Ei]],[E_i,[D_j,E_k]]=[E_k,[D_j,E_i]],

the second line following from the Jacobi identity. Tao asked whether (*) and (**) generate all relations of h\mathfrak{h}.

In a comment on the question [6], YCor reformulated it as follows. Let l\mathfrak{l} be the Lie algebra with generators FijF_{ij}, EiE_i (i,j∈Ni,j \in\mathbb{N}) and relators

Fij=Fji,[Ei,Ej]=0,[Ei,Fjk]=[Ek,Fij].(2)F_{ij}=F_{ji},\qquad[E_i,E_j]=0,\qquad[E_i,F_{jk}]=[E_k,F_{ij}]. \tag*{(2)}

There is a natural homomorphism θ:l→g\theta:\mathfrak{l}\to\mathfrak{g}, Fij↦[Di,Ej]F_{ij}\mapsto[D_i,E_j], Ei↦EiE_i\mapsto E_i, whose image is h\mathfrak{h}. The question asks whether θ\theta is injective.

Theorem 1.1. The homomorphism θ:l→g\theta:\mathfrak{l}\to\mathfrak{g} is injective. Equivalently, the relations (∗)(*) and (∗∗)(**), together with the axioms of a Lie algebra, generate all relations among the elements [Di,Ej][D_i,E_j] and EiE_i of g\mathfrak{g}.

Along the way we obtain the following structural information.

Corollary 1.2. (1) The Lie algebra h≅l\mathfrak{h}\cong\mathfrak{l} is a semidirect product L⋊aEL\rtimes\mathfrak{a}_E. Here aE\mathfrak{a}_E is the abelian Lie algebra with basis (Ei)i∈N(E_i)_{i\in\mathbb{N}}. The algebra LL is a free Lie algebra with free generators YW=ad⁡(Ej1)⋯ad⁡(Ejr)[Da,Eb]Y_W=\operatorname{ad}(E_{j_1})\cdots\operatorname{ad}(E_{j_r})[D_a,E_b], indexed by finite multisets W={j1,…,jr,a,b}W=\{j_1,\ldots,j_r,a,b\} of size at least 2; the element YWY_W depends only on WW. (Corollary 10.1.)

(2) In particular the elements [Di,Ej][D_i,E_j], i≤ji\leq j, freely generate a free Lie subalgebra of g\mathfrak{g}. This answers affirmatively a further question raised by YCor [6]. (Corollary 10.2.)

(3) Fix n≥2n\geq2. Consider the span of the brackets in g\mathfrak{g} in which every index 1,…,n1,\ldots,n occurs exactly once and DD's occur exactly aa times. This subspace has dimension equal to the Eulerian number A(n−1,a−1)A(n-1,a-1), the number of permutations of n−1n-1 letters with a−1a-1 descents. In total its dimension is (n−1)!(n-1)! (summed over aa). (Corollary 10.4.) This statement is equivalent to known results on the homology of Losev–Manin spaces [4, 3]; see § 11.

Status of the question and relation to prior work

As of November 16, 2026 the MathOverflow question has no answer. The comments on it contain the reformulation above and partial observations. We searched for a later resolution (MathOverflow, arXiv, zbMATH Open, Crossref, OpenAlex, OEIS and general web search; Google Scholar and MathSciNet were not searched directly). We were unable to find an answer to the question, nor the freeness statement of Corollary 1.2(2), in the literature.

Part of the machinery is, however, known in an equivalent form. Write the defining relators of the ideal of g\mathfrak{g} generated by the EiE_i (§ 4) in its enveloping algebra and restrict to multilinear components. One obtains exactly the relators of the twisted associative algebra tHyperCom of Dotsenko, Shadrin and Tamaroff, which they show to be the homology of the Losev–Manin spaces [3 Prop. 2.4.2]. The Betti numbers of these spaces are Eulerian numbers [4 Thm. 2.3]. Consequently, the Hilbert series of U(g)U(\mathfrak{g}) and of g\mathfrak{g} (Corollary 8.3, Proposition 9.1) and Corollary 1.2(3) follow from these known results. § 11 gives the precise statement. Our proofs of these facts (Sections 7–§ 9) are independent of [4, 3] and serve to keep the paper self-contained. The remaining results are Lemmas 5.4 and 6.1, Theorem 1.1, and Corollaries 10.1 and 10.2. We were unable to find them in the literature, but we make no stronger claim about them.

Outline of the proof

  • In § 3 a polarisation argument reduces Theorem 1.1 to the multilinear components, where each index occurs at most once.

  • In § 4 we show that g≅t⋊aD\mathfrak{g}\cong\mathfrak{t}\rtimes\mathfrak{a}_D, where t\mathfrak{t} is the ideal generated by the EiE_i. We give an explicit presentation of t\mathfrak{t} in which l\mathfrak{l} appears as the algebra defined by the “small” generators and relations.

  • In § 5 an excess filtration of t\mathfrak{t} is introduced. Its associated graded algebra is dominated by an explicit Lie algebra ttop⁡\mathfrak{t}^{\operatorname{top}} (Lemma 5.4). If dim⁡t=dim⁡ttop⁡\dim\mathfrak{t}=\dim\mathfrak{t}^{\operatorname{top}} in a multilinear degree, then θ\theta is injective there.

  • In Section 6 we determine ktop\mathfrak{k}^{\mathrm{top}} completely (Lemma 6.1) and compute its Hilbert series.

  • In Sections 7–9 we compute the Hilbert series of g\mathfrak{g}, hence of k\mathfrak{k}, independently. We use a quadratic Gröbner basis of U(g)U(\mathfrak{g}), obtained from Bergman’s diamond lemma [2], and count normal words by a sign-reversing involution. A generating-function identity shows that the two Hilbert series agree, which proves the theorem. Alternatively, the Hilbert series of g\mathfrak{g} can be deduced from [4, 3]; see § 11.

The proof is self-contained apart from Bergman’s diamond lemma [2 Theorem 1.2] and the Poincaré–Birkhoff–Witt (PBW) theorem (which is derived from the diamond lemma in [2 §3]). § 11 discusses the relation to the work of Losev–Manin and Dotsenko–Shadrin–Tamaroff. § 12 reports independent computer checks: exact rational arithmetic up to multilinear degree 8, and a modular computation, which is rigorous over Q\mathbb{Q}, in degree 9.

Conventions and standard facts

Multisets and gradings

A multiset TT of indices is a finitely supported function N→Z≥0\mathbb{N} \to\mathbb{Z}_{\ge0}, and ∣T∣|T| denotes its size. We write T+iT+i for TT with one more copy of ii, and A+BA+B for the sum of multisets. A multiset is a set if all multiplicities are ≤1\le1.

All Lie algebras below are generated by elements carrying an index content (a multiset), and all defining relations are homogeneous for it. Hence they are graded by the monoid of multisets. A component of content SS is called multilinear if SS is a set. We also use two further gradings, the DD-degree and the EE-degree: DiD_i has bidegree (1,0)(1,0) and EiE_i has bidegree (0,1)(0,1).

Every permutation π\pi of N\mathbb{N} induces automorphisms of all algebras considered (Di↦Dπ(i)D_i \mapsto D_{\pi(i)}, and so on), because all defining relations are invariant under renaming indices. Such an automorphism maps the component of content SS isomorphically onto that of content π(S)\pi(S). Consequently, the dimension of a multilinear component depends only on ∣S∣|S| and on the bidegree.

Multilinear Hilbert series

Let MM be a graded vector space of this kind with finite-dimensional components. Its multilinear Hilbert series is the formal power series

HM(x)=∑n≥0xnn!∑a,b≥0dim⁡M[n](a,b)yazb∈Q[y,z][[x]],H_M(x)=\sum_{n\ge0}\frac{x^n}{n!}\sum_{a,b\ge0}\dim M_{[n]}^{(a,b)}y^a z^b\in\mathbb{Q}[y,z][[x]],

where [n]={1,…,n}[n]=\{1,\ldots,n\} and M[n](a,b)M_{[n]}^{(a,b)} is the component of content [n][n] and bidegree (a,b)(a,b). We only use spaces in which the dimension of the content-SS component depends only on ∣S∣|S|.

Lemma 2.1 (exponential formula). Let M,M1,…,MkM,M_1,\ldots,M_k be graded spaces as above, with M∅=0M_{\varnothing}=0.

(1) HM1⊗⋯⊗Mk=HM1⋯HMkH_{M_1\otimes\cdots\otimes M_k}=H_{M_1}\cdots H_{M_k}, where content and bidegree are additive on tensor products.

(2) HT(M)=1/(1−HM)H_{T(M)}=1/(1-H_M) for the tensor algebra T(M)=⨁k≥0M⊗kT(M)=\bigoplus_{k\ge0}M^{\otimes k}.

(3) HSym⁡(M)=exp⁡(HM)H_{\operatorname{Sym}(M)}=\exp(H_M) for the symmetric algebra.

Proof. (1) A tensor of contents S1,…,SkS_1,\ldots,S_k has content S1+⋯+SkS_1+\cdots+S_k, which is a set SS if and only if the SiS_i are disjoint sets with union SS. Hence (M_1\otimes\cdots\otimes M_k)_S=\bigoplus_{S=S_1\mathbin{\mathaccent\cdot\cup}\cdots\mathbin{\mathaccent\cdot\cup}S_k}\bigotimes_i(M_i)_{S_i}. Counting ordered decompositions of [n][n] with prescribed block sizes gives multinomial coefficients, which is exactly the product of exponential generating functions. (2) follows from (1) by summing over kk. (3) The multilinear part of Sym⁡k(M)=(M⊗k)Sk\operatorname{Sym}^k(M)=(M^{\otimes k})_{\mathfrak{S}_k} of content SS is the space of coinvariants of ⨁(S1,…,Sk)⨂iMSi\bigoplus_{(S_1,\ldots,S_k)}\bigotimes_iM_{S_i}, the sum running over ordered decompositions into nonempty blocks. The group Sk\mathfrak{S}_k permutes these summands freely. The coinvariants are therefore isomorphic to the sum over unordered set partitions, and their series is HMk/k!H_M^k/k!. □\square

Free Lie algebras and enveloping algebras

We use the following standard facts. For a set XX, L(X)\mathcal{L}(X) denotes the free Lie algebra on XX.

(F1) Every map X→L(X)X \to\mathcal{L}(X) extends uniquely to a derivation of L(X)\mathcal{L}(X). More generally, let φ:L(X)→m\varphi:\mathcal{L}(X) \to\mathfrak{m} be a homomorphism. A φ\varphi-derivation is a linear map δ:L(X)→m\delta: \mathcal{L}(X) \to\mathfrak{m} with δ[u,v]=[δu,φv]+[φu,δv]\delta[u,v]=[\delta u,\varphi v]+[\varphi u,\delta v]. Such a δ\delta is determined by its values on XX.

References

  1. [1]Jörgen Backelin and Ralf Fröberg, Koszul algebras, Veronese subrings and rings with linear resolutions, Rev. Roumaine Math. Pures Appl. 30 (1985), no. 2, 85–97.
  2. [2]George M. Bergman, The diamond lemma for ring theory, Adv. Math. 29 (1978), no. 2, 178–218.DOI
  3. [3]Vladimir Dotsenko, Sergey Shadrin, and Pedro Tamaroff, Generalized cohomological field theories in the higher order formalism, Comm. Math. Phys. 399 (2023), no. 3, 1439–1500, doi:10.1007/s00220-022-04577-6, arXiv:2112.06015.DOI
  4. [4]A. Losev and Yu. Manin, New moduli spaces of pointed curves and pencils of flat connections, Michigan Math. J. 48 (2000), no. 1, 443–472, doi:10.1307/mmj/1030132728, arXiv:math/0001003.DOI
  5. [5]Terry Tao, Relations in a certain Lie algebra, MathOverflow, question 464808, February 24, 2024, https://mathoverflow.net/q/464808.
  6. [6]YCor, comments on [5], February 24–27, 2024 (UTC), https://mathoverflow.net/posts/comments/1207321. The reformulation and the question about the elements [Dᵢ, Eⱼ] are in this first comment.

Paper details

vlnc:W_pd7vw64m
Version
v1 · latest
Published
Fresh — published within the last 30 days
License
CC BY 4.0
Usage

views · 0

downloads · 0

A view counts once per browser per day, a download each time the PDF is requested.

  • Mathematics

OpenAI Codex, Anthropic Claude

View statement
Looking for related papers…
Contents